July 11 (PDF, 26.89 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
ACCOMMODATIONS TAX ADVISORY COMMITTEE
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, July 11, 2012
The regular meeting of the Accommodations Tax Advisory Commi ttee was held at 11
a.m. on Wednesday, July 11, 2012 in Counc il Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm
Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Caroli na. Attending the meeting were Committee
members Burgis, Covington, Russell, Nels on, Kruesi and Chair Ferencz, City
Administrator Tucker, City Treasurer Suggs, A ssistant to the Administrator Dziuban and
City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct business; Ms. Miller’s absence
was excused.
1. Chair Ferencz called the meeting to or der and acknowledged th at the press and
public had been duly notified of the me eting in accordance with the Freedom of
Information Act.
2. Approval of Previ ous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mr. Burgis moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of April 4, 2012 as submitted; Ms. Russell seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
Administrator Tucker was pleased to welcome Mary Alice Kruesi who was attending her
first meeting.
Chair Ferencz acknowledged that the Agenda for this meeting was very full and sug-
gested that Items E and F under New Business be postponed to the next meeting.
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to postpone the items noted above to the
next meeting; Ms. Russell seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
On a related subject, Chair Ferencz re marked that, since this ATAX Committee was
moving in a different direction from pas t Committees and was more of a working
committee, it would benefit from meeting more frequently so she recommended that the
ATAX Committee begin to meet every other month – making the next meeting date
September 5, 2012.
MOTION: Ms. Kruesi moved to hol d ATAX Committee meetings bi-
monthly effective immediately; Mr . Covington seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 2 of 8
4. Quarterly/Preliminary Year -end Financial Statement – Treasurer Suggs
Treasurer Suggs directed attention to the Balance Sheet and repeated that the reports
being reviewed at this meeting are prelim inary and unaudited year-end figures; the only
substantial change to the figures present ed here will be the June quarter’s state ATAX
payment. Cash in the bank at June 30, 2012 totalled nine hundred seventy-one
thousand dollars ($971,000); in excess of eight hundr ed thousand dollars ($800,000)
was held at the Local Government Investment Pool (LGIP) where the interest rate was
twenty-nine hundredths percent (0.290%).
Revenues since the April meeting were composed of interest and the proceeds from the
sale of two (2) patrol vehicles that had been purchased with ATAX funds.
The review of the expenditure s since the April meeting i ndicated that the following
accounts had exceeded their budget as follows:
Beach Barrel & Trash Pickup, etc. $930.00
Police Department – Body Armor 13.71
Beach Trash Barrels 335.29
MOTION: Mr. Nelson moved to approve payment of the accounts over-
budget as detailed above; Ms. Kru esi seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
The Treasurer referred to the schedule that details the ATAX income quarter-by-quarter
over two (2) years. Revenues for the Ma rch 2012 quarter were fourteen percent (14%)
greater than the same quarter 2011.
On the blue schedule, the preliminary and unaudited balance in State ATAX for June
30, 2012 are predicted to be one million one hundred sev enty thousand dollars
($1,170,000), which is a fifty-two thousand nine hundred dollars ($52,900.00) surplus.
This surplus can be attributed primarily to projects that di d not occur, i.e. the parking
nodes on Ocean Boulevard, the purchase of the mobile radio repeater and payments for
supplementary personnel in the Fire Depa rtment on summer weekends. Also some
items, like the beach walkover, were re-budgeted for FY13.
Responding to the Chair’s inquiry, the projected deficit for t he ATAX fund for FY12 was
four hundred thirty-five thousand dollars ($435,000).
5. Old Business
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 3 of 8
A. Summary Report of Ways and Means/Council Meetings’ Response to
ATAX Committee’s Request for 2012-2013 Budget Recommendations -
Sandy Ferencz
Chair Ferencz reminded the Committee that they had been proactive in their approach
to the FY13 budget as they included projects. Attached to the historical record of the
meeting are a synopsis of Chair Ferencz’s impresssions from a ttending the April and
May Ways and Means Committee meetings and copi es of the relevant portions of the
minutes from those two (2) meetings.
With the reductions to the ATAX FY13 budget, the fund balance will be reduced by only
twenty-nine thousand dollars ($29,000) as opposed to th e three hundred fourteen
thousand dollars ($314,000) as proposed by the ATAX Committee. Chair Ferencz
stated that Council is composed of true fiscal conservatives who want the ATAX
Committee to actively seek out ways to “put more heads in beds,” but who want those
efforts to stay within the range of annual income. She added that she inferred that
Council wants the ATAX Committee to follow the spending guidelines of the state, but to
keep the fund balance available for emergency spending while continuing to provide the
services necessary to ensure that all visitors to the island have a positive experience.
At the April meeting, the Committee had ch arged the City Treasurer with contacting the
TERC Committee to get a rulin g on the City’s being allowed to reserve ATAX funds as
disaster emergency fund, in hopes that the City could build reserves while staying
compliant with the two-year pol icy. The City’s request to hold funds longer than two (2)
years, specifically to recover from a natural disaster, was denied.
Ms. Kruesi asked whether funds were availa ble for use in FY13 other than the items
identified in the budget; Treas urer Suggs informed her t hat the ATAX Committee has
fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for approved projects throughout the year. The funds
support applications brought before the Committee, like the rescue sleds on the Agenda
for today’s meeting.
Ms. Kruesi voiced the opinion that an off-s eason event would be an excellent way to
draw people to the island, but to hold an event that would reflect the proper image of the
island would require time and the talents of an experienced event planner. If the City is
fortunate enough to have a resident who woul d volunteer his/her time and talents that
would be wonderful, but if t hat is not the case, som eone should be engaged who has
the knowledge and the local co nnections to guarantee a successful event. Ms. Kruesi
suggested that the Committee needs to locate that resident who can provide the City
with the services needed, whether as a volunteer or for compensation. She added that,
if the Committee begins now to plan for a futu re event, it can also begin allocating the
funds needed to have a quality off-season event.
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 4 of 8
Chair Ferencz expressed her opinion t hat the Ways and Means Committee was less
inclined to support the ATAX Co mmittee’s proposal because it did not present a plan;
she was also in favor of assigning an ad hoc committee from ATAX to work on an off-
season event.
Chair Ferencz stated that t he Recreation Department had b een allocated funds for an
off-season event in this budget year, which c ould possibly serve as the seed money for
an event to be held at a later date.
Regarding a proposed timeframe for an o ff-season event, the consensus of the
Committee was the fall or win ter of 2013. The Committee thought that was sufficient
time to produce a quality, off-season event and to allocate the necessary funding.
B. Recreation Report – 2011-2012 Special Events – Director Page
Director Page noted that the ATAX Committee supports a number of events throughout
the year; they include the IOP Beach Run, the Connector Run, the Lowcountry Blues
Bash, the Easter Egg Hunt, t he Piccolo Spoleto Sand Scul pting Contest and the Front
Beach tree lighting. The B each Run attracts people from nineteen (19) states, and the
number of participants has increased over t he past three (3) years. The Director
attributes part of the su ccess and growth to the City’ s growing electronic media
presence. The Connector Run will not be held until October, but three hundred twenty-
nine (329) runners/walkers from eight (8) stat es have already registered. Five to six
hundred (500-600) people attend t he Blues Bash over the two (2) day event. The tree
lighting in 2011 was not as successful as hoped, so the Recreation Department has
decided to take a different approach involv ing the local restaurant s with entertainment
on the street. The sand sculpting event drew forty-eight (48) teams this year.
The FY12 budget includes funding for a summer arts production or event; the event was
a comedian/magician “Great Scott.” Direc tor Page was pleased with the turnout, but
believes that such an event would draw a bigger crowd in the spring or fall.
The Director remarked that the Recreation staff is considerin g a race starting on Front
Beach, going to Sullivan’s Island and return ing to Front Beach where there would be
some type of festival in January or February. She stated that this idea had come to her
at an earlier meeting of the ATAX Committee as the members discussed an off-season
event.
7. New Business
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 5 of 8
A. 2012-2012 ATAX Budget Presentation – Treasurer Suggs
The Treasurer drew attent ion to the schedule on which she had written “Ratified
5/22/12” and a sheet entit led “Reconciliation of FY13 Budg et . . .” The reconciliation
takes the budget as presented to the Committee in their April meeting, incorporates the
additions made by the Committee and the changes made by City Council to arrive at a
projected deficit for FY13 of twenty-nine thousand seven hundred dollars ($29,700).
B. Request from Charleston Sym phony Orchestra for $10,000 for
General Operating Expense for 2012-2013 Season
Alana Morrell, Director of Development, s poke to the Committee regarding the request
for funding, a copy of which is attached to the historical record of the meeting; she noted
that the Charleston Sym phony Orchestra (CSO) perfo rms before thirty thousand
(30,000) people each year through more than one hundred (100) concerts and events.
She reported that the CSO restructured in 2011 and has trimmed one million dollars
($1,000,000) from its budget; they ended the 2011-2012 season with a surplus. Ninety-
eight percent (98%) of previous subscri bers have renewed for the coming year, and
they are now seeking new sub scribers. The CSO relies on contributions from indivi-
duals, corporations, governm ent entities and other philan thropic groups to support
seventy percent (70%) of its annual budget.
Chair Ferencz asked whether the CSO was c onsidering a performanc e on the Isle of
Palms; Ms. Morrell responded that no plans we re “in the works,” but the CSO was open
to all suggestions.
The discussion centered on the fact that the CSO request would not “put heads in beds”
on the Isle of Palms; Chair Ferencz asked if there would be a medium for advertising
the island through the CSO. Ms. Morrell explai ned that the program book reaches thirty
thousand (30,000) people, and the subscription br ochures go to in ex cess of fifty thou-
sand (50,000) people. Initiati ves to reach outside of the state and through electronic
media are expanding to broaden awareness of the symphony.
Administrator Tucker asked whether performances at Kiawah and Mount Pleasant were
in return for the contributions that these municipal governments make to CSO or were
initiatives of the CSO performances. R ephrasing her comments, the Administrator
inquired about whether the City would receive free adv ertising space if the ATAX
Committee and Council were to approve the funding request. The Administrator added
that the Committee might be more interested in “a proposal from the symphony that
actually did outline some action item benefits to attracting Isle of Palms’ visitors in return
for some type of investment in the symphon y.” The City has had Spoleto performances
on the island in return for support of the event; there are venues on the island that
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 6 of 8
would be conducive to a production by CSO. In addition, Administrator Tucker voiced
her opinion that City Council would be more inclined to support an investment in CSO if
they could see an increase in visitation on the Isle of Palms because of it.
MOTION: Mr. Covington moved to pos tpone action by the Committee on
the CSO request until they come fo rward with an alternate proposal; Mr.
Burgis seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Request from General Government for IOP Brochure
Administrator Tucker ex plained that the City has had broc hures in the past that were
distributed by the Charleston Visitors Bur eau (CVB) and the various rental companies,
but the City’s brochures were produced in-house, not by a professional design team. In
addition, all General Government personnel wear multiple ha ts as a rule; therefore, a
project of this sort tends to take a ‘back burner.’
Assistant Dziuban spoke with per sonnel at Rawl Murdy, a local advertising firm, in an
effort to determine the cost of camera-ready artwork for a Spoleto advertisement. They
were willing to work with t he City, but focused on the big picture – determining how the
advertisement would be used and the goal of said advertising.
Ms. Russell queried about opport unities to work with other graphic artists or an art
student to produce a camera-ready ad, rather than going to a full service firm;
Administrator Tucker noted that the City has done this in the past with marginal
success. The Administrator noted that she has had informal dialogue with Perrin
Lawson of the CVB about the possibility that CVB has people on staff who could assist
the City.
According to Assistant Dziuban, Rawl Murdy to ld her that the City could set any kind of
budget and get what that would buy; s he was encouraged to know what the City
purpose and goal for the advertising would be before setting a budget.
Administrator Tucker indicated that the Cit y needs a brochure to have a presence in
visitors’ centers throughout the state, which was the original goal of the brochure; she
recommended that the City revi ew what the costs to pr oduce that brochure had been,
adding some amount to it and going back to Ra wl Murdy, or another firm, to see what
they could produce.
Ms. Kruesi commented that she is involved in advertising for her bus iness and that the
City needed to decide on the purpose for each individual project; for the visitors’
centers, she suggested a broc hure should indicate what t he island offers. She also
agreed that the media that serves to draw more people to Isle of Palms today is web-
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 7 of 8
based; therefore, the City might benefit from an attractive addi tion to the City’s website
to define the facilities and restaurants availabl e. In her opinion, an advertisement for
Spoleto or the symphony should ta rget these patrons to retu rn to the area in the off-
season. Concluding, Ms. Kruesi said that she could provid e the names of several firms
from which the City could get cost estimate s and would provide that information to the
City Administrator.
D. Request from the Fire Department for 2 rescue sleds
Chief Graham brought forward a water re scue sled that the Department has been
testing for several weeks and introduced Fire fighter David Mello; she explained that
they do water rescues throughout the year. At this time, the City does not own any of
these rescue sleds which attached easily to any jet ski and make for a more efficient
and a safer rescue. Mr. Mello demonstrated how the rescue sled is used and how it
makes water rescue safer for both the rescuer and the person being rescued – even if
that person is unconscious.
Responding to Chair Ferencz’s inquiry, Chief Graham stated that she had not been able
to find and test a quality product prior to passage of the budget.
In addition to the rescue sleds, the fundi ng request included VHF handheld radios with
speaker microphones for ease in communicating with the incident commander on shore.
Mr. Covington asked Mr. Mello about the cost and life span of the rescue sled; Mr. Mello
stated that the sleds cost less than one thousand dollars ($1,000) each, plus shipping,
and he did not know the lifespan.
MOTION: Mr. Covington moved to award the Fire Department $3,014.13
for the purchase of rescue sleds and VHF handheld radios; Ms. Kruesi se-
conded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Administrator Tucker informed the Committ ee that legislation on the Freedom of
Information Act passed recently stating t hat nothing can be added to an agenda once it
has been printed and posted; she urged Committee members to contact the Chair if
there was an item they wanted to discuss at an upcoming meeting.
Thanks to County Councilmember Schweers and County Administrator Taylor, the City
was given forty thousand dollars ($40,000) to offset the cost of additional Beach
Services Officers this season. The Administrator urged the Committee members to
thank these gentlemen.
ATAX Committee
July 11, 2012
Page 8 of 8
In the past month, Moody’s rating agency upgraded the City’s financial rating from Aa2
to Aa1; Administrator Tucker explained t hat this was like receiving the “Good House-
keeping Seal of Approval” for financial responsibility.
In conclusion, the Administrator congratul ated Perrin Lawson for twenty (20) years of
service to the Charleston Visitors Bureau and thanked him for bei ng a good steward for
the City of Isle of Palms.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Mr. Burgis moved to adj ourn the meeting at 12:38 p.m.; Mr.
Nelson seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.