Special Meeting, January 18 (PDF, 35.44 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SPECIAL MEETING
Of
CITY COUNCIL
7:00 p.m., Tuesday, January 18, 2011
The City Council of the City of Isle of Palm s held a Special Meeting on Tuesday, January 18,
2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Be rgwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus,
Piening, Stone, Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, City Attorney Halversen,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. Invited guests were Allen
O’Neal, Charleston County Administrator, Dickie Schweers, District 2 County Council Represen-
tative, Bill Tunick, Walt Smalls and Donnie Giacomo, from Charleston County, Kevin Henry and
Keith Powell representing Crown Castle and Greg Malcolm and Greg Saylors of Motorola.
1. Mayor Cronin called the Special Meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Discussions with Charleston County Regarding Options for Improving Reliability
of 800 Radio System
Mayor Cronin commented that the City has been in discussions with Charleston County for quite
some time about the persistent and erratic comm unications problems experienced by the City’s
public safety personnel since the activation of the digital radio system. The Mayor stated that
the issue remains one of great concern to the island and that he was hopeful that Council would
have all of its questions and concerns resolved as a result of this meeting. Mayor Cronin then
asked that Administrator Tucker provide background on the City’s communications systems that
have led to this meeting.
Administrator Tucker recounted that initially the island communities had used VHF radios to
communicate with one another; the City had its ow n dispatch systems and communicated using
walkie-talkies. Having experienced a major natural disaster in the Charleston area, the need for
inter-operability, the ability for any local government in the county to be able to communicate
with any other local governments via radio, became evident. As the majority of entities in the
County were in agreement, a County-wide analog radio system was established. As with any
change, problems occurred with the analog system , but the problems were infrequent, typically
occurred at the same time of year and predictable at certain locations, such as with a “dead
space” for cell phone reception. In general, the analog system provided mostly reliable
communications and, in the instances where the communications were not reliable, the users
knew how to anticipate them.
The Administrator continued that, when the conver sion to digital was made, the City experi-
enced communication problems from the onset. In itially the problems were thought to be hard-
ware related, and considerable time was spent sending the radios to the shop for adjustments,
but the problems continued and were compounded by their unpredictability.
More in-depth investigation into the digital system ensued, and the findings were that the digital
system, as configured today, does not offer the reliability necessary for “public safety personnel
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 2 of 9
to communicate adequately and consistently in all situation and the inability to predict when and
where the system is going to fail.”
Charleston County, Motorola and Crown Castle committed to identifying and resolving the prob-
lems more than two (2) years ago, and the City has been in discussion with the County since
that time to determine what the best decision is to correct the problems, to have reliable radio
communications and to ensure the safety of public safety personnel, residents and visitors to
the Isle of Palms.
As the lead entity, Charleston County has spear-headed the project, and tonight the full body of
City Council will have the opportunity to ask questions, hear the presentation by the County’s
staff and tower and communications experts. Administrator Tucker noted that the Public Safety
Committee has had multiple meetings with Charleston County personnel, Motorola and Crown
Castle where they reported on the progress being made and possible solutions.
Administrator Tucker introduced Charleston County Administrator Allen O’Neal, who thanked
the City for the opportunity to appear before Council and introduced County Council member
Schweers and the members of his staff who were present to respond to the City’s queries, and
the representatives of Crown Castle and Motorola who were present as well.
Walt Smalls, Assistant Administrator for General Services for Charleston County, began the
PowerPoint presentation (copy attached to historical record of the meeting) by stating that, in
November 2010, County Council authorized the County staff to sign a contract with Motorola in
the amount of eleven million thirteen thousand dollars ($11,013,000) to correct the deficiencies
with the digital radio system. The Motorola contract has three (3) phases, but Phase III has not
yet been funded by County Council and has no timeframe. In addition to the Motorola contract,
the County signed lease agreements for tower space with Crown Castle, Verizon, The American
Tower Corporation and the State Ports Authority (SPA). L.R. Kimball, an independent consul-
tant, evaluated and validated the Motorola proposal to solve the problems; Kimball will also
perform project management and implementation for Phases I and II.
Mayor Cronin commented that the report from Kimball that validated the Motorola proposal has
not been released to the general public and asked if the City could get a copy. Mr. Smalls
responded that the City would receive a copy of the engineering portions of the Kimball report.
Administrator Tucker asked what the estimated costs of Phase III were; Mr. Smalls stated that
the estimates were in the neighborhood of six to seven million dollars ($6,000,000-7,000,000).
Councilmember Stone asked what the initial investment to change to the digital system had
been and was told that the cost had been seventeen million dollars ($17,000,000).
Mr. Smalls remarked that Charleston County had executed the contract with Motorola on
December 9, 2010 and had executed the contract with Kimball on January 4, 2011. The pre-
construction conference is scheduled for January 25, 2011 where the specifics of the project will
be reviewed.
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 3 of 9
Responding to Councilmember Thomas’ question about whether vendors other than Motorola
had been asked to submit proposals; Mr. Smalls noted that Motorola was a sole source vendor
to maintain consistency in hardware and eliminate a potential problem of compatibility. Mr.
O’Neal added that Motorola is the company in the forefront of digital communication in the
public safety arena.
The leases with Crown Castle for tower space at Folly Beach, Six Mile Road and Highway 17 at
Sewee will be finalized on January 26, 2011.
Mayor Cronin asked whether the existing tower at Six Mile was to be used or a new tower
erected. Mr. Smalls explained that, at that location, the existing one hundred ninety-foot (190
ft.) tower would be expanded to a two hundred ninety-foot (290 ft.) tower with simulcast capabil-
ities.
Continuing with the presentation, Mr. Smalls reported that Phase I of the contract with Motorola
focuses on the east of the Cooper River area, Folly Beach and North Charleston. Included in
the contract are considerations for the Isle of Palms that include the following:
• Should the City decide against a tower, the equipment can be used elsewhere in the
County;
• Should the City decide to proceed with a tower, the equipment cost is included in the
contract; or
• Should the City delay its decision about a tower, Motorola will re-mobilize at the
appropriate time to construct the tower at no additional costs.
In the fall of 2010, the City suggested the Motorola engineers look at the existing tower site at
41
st Avenue to determine whether it could be used to satisfy the island’s need for a tower to
resolve its communication problems. On Decem ber 1, representatives of Charleston County,
Motorola engineers, representatives of Crown Castle, who owns the tower, IOP’s Chief Graham
and representatives of Wild Dunes met at the 41
st Avenue site for a review. Keith Power, of
Crown Castle, presented the results of that study indicating that the location is as good, or
better, than other locations considered on the island because the tower would be locate closer
to the most densely populated area of the island. In addition, the presence of other leases on
that tower requires that the tower’s height be increased from approximately one hundred twenty
(120) feet to one hundred ninety (190) feet, but the tower would not require a light since it would
be under the two hundred (200) foot threshold for tower lights. Mr. Powell noted that Crown
Castle would need to lease additional land from Wild Dunes Property Management and relocate
a water and sewer line to accommodate the footprint necessary for the taller tower. The
location is in a flood zone; therefore, the structure housing the equipment and backup generator
would have to be elevated as it is currently.
Councilmember Stone questioned why the existing height of one hundred twenty (120) feet was
not sufficient to meet the communication needs of the island. Greg Malcolm, engineer for Moto-
rola, explained that, at present, Verizon, T-Mobile, Cingular and others lease space on the tower
and do not leave enough vertical “real estate” to accommodate the County’s antennas; the
County will add five (5) antennas to the tower, three (3) to transmit and two (2) to receive, that
are eighteen or nineteen (18 or 19) feet each.
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 4 of 9
Mayor Cronin noted that the majority of the towers being proposed exceed two hundred (200)
feet, and Mr. Malcolm commented that he would prefer to see a tower two hundred thirty (230)
feet tall on 41
st Avenue, but he did think the proposed one hundred ninety (190) feet would be
satisfactory. Mr. Malcolm explained that, in recent years, towers have been constructed lower
to the ground to overcome interference and to provide better in-building coverage.
Councilmember Stone questioned whether the extended tower at 41
st Avenue as proposed
would be a “guaranteed fix” to the City’s radio communications; Mr. Malcolm answered that the
coverage maps included in the presentation illustrate the “guaranteed coverage predictions”
provided in the proposal to Charleston County. Mr. Malcolm commented that the maps show
“extremely good coverage for this area for both on-street and in-building.”
Mr. Malcolm explained that Motorola has worked with the end-users and understands that one
source for the problems being experienced is the level of interference in the summer months
and in the fall when the area experiences temperature inversions and varying atmospheric
conditions over land and the ocean. To compensate for these issues, Motorola has raised the
noise floor to give additional protection on the coverage maps.
Island resident John Ghindea asked whether guywires would be required with a one hundred
ninety (190) foot tower; Mr. Powell answered that guywires would not be required because the
tower would be a self-supporting monopole, similar to the tower that is there now.
Greg Malcolm explained the coverage maps included in the presentation; he stated that the blue
areas indicate portable, on-street coverage areas with ninety-five percent (95%) reliability, while
the white spaces indicate reduced or no coverage areas. The white areas shown are not on the
island. Mr. Malcolm replied to Administrator Tucker’s query that the coverage maps assume
that the improvements have been made to the Six Mile tower, as well as the other changes
proposed for Mount Pleasant.
Councilmember Duffy asked Mr. Malcolm whether the proposed design was the optimal one
from an engineering perspective. Mr. Malcolm recalled that Charleston County and Motorola
had looked at the tower placement at the water tower originally and later at the Recreation
Center, but he repeated that the 41
st Avenue site actually provides better coverage to the
densely populated area of the island and better in-building coverage for the condominiums in
Wild Dunes. He also pointed out that with the 41
st Avenue location, the towers in this
constellation, including Mount Pleasant, Six Mile, the Sewee site and Awendaw, are
approximately eight (8) miles from each other. Fr om what is in place today, this constellation
represents two to three (2 – 3) additional sites in between existing ones that provide very good
in-building coverage and very good, or seamless, roaming; Mr. Malcolm stated that he was
“very happy with the design.”
Mayor Cronin asked whether interference was a natural occurrence or whether it was caused by
other people transmitting at or near the frequency range. Mr. Malcolm responded that the inter-
ference was likely attributable to both situations; the issue is that the interference is coming from
locations far enough away that a phenomenon referred to as ducting is happening in the transi-
tion months of the spring and summer when temperature inversions occur, i.e. the atmostphere
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 5 of 9
generates almost a cable for the signal to ride, which explains why the signals are coming from
Florida, for instance.
Mr. Malcolm commented that, if the engineers could isolate the one (1) particular transmitter or
site that was creating the interference, they could work to stop it, but the second best option is
to overpower it with signal, which is what Motorola is doing with the island tower. The Mayor
then asked whether the addition of systems along the East Coast would generate more
interference to the system; Mr. Malcolm expressed confidence that the new tower configuration
would provide more than sufficient protection.
Councilmember Loftus inquired whether the Ci ty would have guaranteed coverage in metal-
roofed residences; Mr. Malcolm stated that public safety personnel would have coverage based
on the maps. Mr. Malcolm added that part of Motorola’s contract with Charleston County is to
perform subjective audio tests – Motorola will go into buildings and on streets to test the signal –
at times of year when interference is at its highest levels. He did note that the closer a structure
is to the tower site, the stronger the signal will be; conversely, an interior room on the lowest
level of a 20 db structure, like The Villages in Wild Dunes, will experience a diminished signal.
At Councilmember Loftus’ request, Mr. Malcolm explained that a 6 db structure would be repre-
sented by a one-story residence; a 12 db building would be a two-story residence or a conveni-
ence store; and, at 20 db, the structure would have poured concrete walls and would describe
the high-rises in Wild Dunes.
County Councilmember Schweers asked Mr. Malcolm to locate Dewees Island on the coverage
map to demonstrate that all of the large buildings on the island would receive good coverage.
Referring to gaps in coverage on the maps, Administrator Tucker stated that, since the same
engineering would have been done when the digital system was first put in place, Motorola
could have informed the City that communica tion problems would occur. Mr. Malcolm
concurred and explained that the difference between then and now was that a 20 db noise floor
was not added to the equation because Motorola did not realize the level of interference coming
from the ocean. In preparing the upgrades proposed now, Motorola hired an independent
company to take measurements of the level of interference on two (2) separate occasions;
another change is to the audio quality based on the end-users’ requirements.
As a follow-up question, the Administrator asked whether there were any other pieces of data
that would be added to the mix to reduce the white, or non-coverage, areas, and Mr. Malcolm
stated that he was not aware of any. He commented that the 20 db noise floor has been
applied only to the coastal areas of Charleston County that are impacted by the system
upgrades.
Mr. Smalls returned to the presentation to review the timeline for Phases I and II that concludes
with final systems acceptance in mid-September 2012.
Mr. Tunick summarized the actions scheduled to be included in each phase as follows:
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 6 of 9
Phase I
• Addition of towers Highway 17 at Sewee and the Isle of Palms;
• Higher tower with simulcast upgrade at Six Mile Road;
• Higher tower at Folly Beach and the Isle of Palms; and
• Re-locate equipment from Summerville to a Verizon tower on Otranto Road.
Phase II (to occur simultaneously with Phase I)
• Higher towers on Johns Island and Edisto.
Phase III
• Upgrade McClellanville tower to simulcast capabilities;
• Additional towers between Awendaw and McClellanville and on Highway 165;
and
• Re-installation of Summerville tower.
Mr. Smalls concluded the presentation by stating that the County’s network increases from eight
(8) to sixteen (16) towers at the completion of all three (3) phases.
Councilmember Buckhannon expressed a degree of skepticism in accepting the proposed up-
grades as the solution to the island’s comm unication issues since the City had been given a
similar presentation in years past that caused the City to buy into the digital radio system.
Councilmember Stone asked Motorola for other lo cations in the country where like systems
were installed, whether these systems were working according to specifications and whether
other local governments had been resistant to the construction of two hundred (200) foot
towers. Greg Saylors, Senior Account Manager for Motorola for this geographical area,
answered that there are hundreds of similar, yet unique, systems across the country. On the
subject of the present tower requirements, Mr. Saylors explained that the need is primarily
rooted in the end-users’ requirements for the type of coverage and the required specifications;
Mr. Saylors indicated that in the original digital radio specifications from Charleston County, in-
building coverage was not included.
Councilmember Thomas inquired whether per formance guarantees were included in the
Motorola contract; Mr. Malcolm explained that the contract includes functional guarantees that
the system features will work, an extensive acc eptance plan will ensure the functionality of the
systems and a very in-depth coverage acceptanc e test plan for the system in included -
ultimately the expansion is about coverage and audio quality. As explained earlier, Mr. Malcolm
noted that Motorola engineers will be all over Charleston County, in buildings and on the streets,
in the hottest summer conditions to provide assurances that the coverage meets the contract
specifications that were set by the end-users; th is testing will also identify any problem areas
that may exist for public safety personnel.
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 7 of 9
Responding to Councilmember Duffy’s question about coverage testing in 20 db buildings, Mr.
Malcolm indicated that such testing was not a part of the contract, but could be done to provide
real data to the public safety personnel.
Councilmember Loftus noted that the island has forty-foot (40 ft.) tall houses with tin roofs and
asked what guarantees were going to be given to personnel that they will be able to communi-
cate in these structures in an emergency situation. Mr. Malcolm replied that the system would
function well “in the majority” of those homes; to which Councilmember Loftus emphatically
responded that majority was “not good enough” – “it must be one hundred percent (100%)!”
Mr. Malcolm stated the following:
“If you look at the industry standard for communications and reliability, you are not going
to see somebody that can guarantee that, yes, you can talk one hundred percent (100%)
of all of the buildings, one hundred percent (100%) of the dirt. It’s not . . . The laws of
physics and the atmospheric conditions and just anomalies that are going on . . . It’s not
going to happen. I mean, to increase the reliability from where it’s at to the next level
exponentially increases the number of sites and RF that have to go out there, and then
it becomes totally not cost effective at all. Believe me, as an engineer, I don’t like
something doesn’t work. I have been doing this for twenty-one (21) years now, and I
want to know that those guys, when they ri sk their lives, that they can communicate. . .
We do everything we can to make these sy stems work, and they are reliable, they are
safe, they are easy to use - all the things that goes into a radio communication network
so that they can do their jobs; the last thing they need to do when they come up on a
scene is worry about the communications – they have plenty of other things that they
need to be focused on.“
Mayor Cronin commented that Chief Graham has been very quiet through the meeting and
asked whether she had any comments; Chief Graham wanted to say for the record that she
“strongly believes that we (the City) needs this tower; we have had several close calls; we have
had issues where we did not get a call when we needed to go. I got probably well over a
thousand (1,000) documented, for lack of a better term, complaints where I have actually
documented situations where we had a problem, and I sent it in. And, for the thousand (1,000)
that I have sent in, I guarantee that there is probably well over a thousand (1,000) that I didn’t
send in, and that’s just Isle of Palms.”
Councilmember Stone re-phrased a question from earlier and asked, of the thousands of
Motorola systems in the field, how many ha ve required retrofits or have been designed with
these one hundred eighty and two hundred (180 and 200) foot towers. Mr. Malcolm commented
that he did not consider the proposed work to be retrofitting, but upgrades, additions and
enhancements to the Charleston County system. He noted that changes to a system are
required when population centers change, or communications needs change, or buildings are
added – these local governments may need additional channels or additional sites.
Councilmember Buckhannon complimented Charleston County and Motorola on their presenta-
tion and commented that he had learned that Motorola had built a system to specifications, but
those specifications might not have been complete.
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 8 of 9
John Ghindea, a resident of Sea Cabins, asked what would happen to communications if a
storm took down one (1) or more towers in the constellation; Mr. Malcolm responded that
communications would not be lost entirely – there would be mobile phones and, likely, on-street
coverage. The City could not expect to have the same level of coverage as before the storm,
but this is one (1) of the advantages of a simulcast system.
Debbie Jones, an island resident, commented that, despite the seventeen million dollar
($17,000,000) expenditure for the digital system, it is not reliable and asked whether guarantees
had been in the original contract. Mr. Malcolm stated that the contract did include coverage
guarantees, but in-building coverage had not been a requirement of the contract. She
expressed concern about the reliability of the systems even after the upgrades.
Dean Surrett of Dewees Island asked whether the RF estimates took into consideration the
Nextel re-banding that has been completed and how much of an impact that had on the system.
Mr. Malcolm remarked that they had one (1) site that was creating a lot of noise problems, but it
has been re-banded and helped the issue. Mr. Malcolm reported that a study had found that the
issue was the general noise floor rise, not a particular frequency.
Administrator Tucker asked about the budgetary impact to the City with respect to the per-radio
fees paid to Charleston County. Mr. Smalls indicated that Charleston County, at this time, plans
to absorb the additional costs for the balance of this fiscal year and will recommend to County
Council to do the same for FY12. The City should anticipate an increase per radio of
approximately eleven dollars ($11) in January 2013 for Phases I and II; the completion of Phase
III will bring another increase, but the amount is not yet known.
Chief Graham commented that the City would have the price increase whether or not the City
approved the tower recommendations for the island.
Councilmember Stone thanked the County for the presentation and stated that he now
understood that, had the system specifications originally been what they are today, the project
would have cost thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) not seventeen million dollars ($17,000,000).
Councilmember Duffy noted that this was a situation where the end-users should have been
more involved in the design phase.
Councilmember Bettelli, speaking as the Chair of t he Public Safety Committee, related that he
has met with the majority of the County, Motorola and Crown Castle representatives multiple
times in the past year or so where the City asked some hard questions; he expressed appreci-
ation for the answers provided at this meeting. He also thanked Chief Graham who brought the
problems to the forefront and has been involved from the beginning to identify the problem and
working toward a solution.
Mayor Cronin asked that Councilmembers deliber ate on the information they have received
from this presentation and be prepared to discuss the City’s options at the Council meeting on
Tuesday, January 25.
Special Council Meeting
January 18, 2011
Page 9 of 9
Administrator Tucker reminded the Council that, in order to proceed with the tower on 41 st
Avenue as discussed in this meeting, the City must amend the zoning ordinance to allow for a
tower of the height required. The ordinance will require two (2) readings; it must go through the
Planning Commission and a Public Hearing.
Charleston County Administrator O’Neal thanked Council for the opportunity to attend the
meeting and to respond to Council’s questions and concerns. He urged the Mayor and City
Administrator to feel free to contact him or Mr . Smalls with any additional concerns that might
arise. He added that he feels very responsible for where the County is on this matter and that
he believes that good decisions are being made.
3. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 8:22 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.