Public Hearing, July 26 (PDF, 16.73 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC HEARING
6:45 p.m., Tuesday, July 26, 2011
The Isle of Palms City Council held a Public H earing at 6:45 p.m. on Tuesday, July 26, 2011 in
Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the hearing were Councilmember Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus, Piening, Stone
and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, City Attorney Halversen, Director Kerr,
Assistant Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Ordinance 2011-08 – An Ordinance Amending Title 5, Planning and Development,
Chapter 4, Zoning, Article 1, General Provisions, Section 5-4-15, Beach Regula-
tions, of the City of Isle of Palms Code of Ordinances to Provide for Designated
Parking on Beach Accesses.
After reading the title of the ordinance into the record, Mayor Cronin stated that this ordinance
and a companion ordinance were on the City Council agenda for Second Reading, but he
intended to move to defer action on these ordinances to give Councilmembers time to digest the
input received from residents at this Public Hearing. In addition, he asked that citizens limit their
comments to two (2) minutes.
The Mayor then asked Building and Planning Director Kerr to review the components to the
ordinance for the Public Hearing.
By way of background, Director Kerr related that this ordinance was a by-product of a joint work-
shop between the Planning Commission and City Council in May, 2011 to discuss island-wide
parking issues. As a result of the workshop, the City staff was charged with investigating one
(1) section of the concepts discussed, i.e. establishing new, small parking lots at existing beach
access rights-of-way. To accomplish that task, two (2) sections of the City Code would need to
be amended; this Public Hearing is on the one (1) ordinance that falls under the Zoning section
of the Code.
The Director explained that the current Zoning Code prohibits driving on beach accesses except
in special situations, i.e. public safety access to the beach, access approved by City Council.
This amendment would give City Council the authority to establish public parking at designated
parking areas within the beach accesses. In addition, this amendment provides for a second
(2
nd) action to be taken by City Council to des ignate the specific access(es) to be opened to
public parking.
John Ferrell, 702 Ocean Boulevard, read from a prepared statement, a copy of which is
attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Beth Ferrell, 810 Ocean Boulevard, stated that she was “strongly opposed” to the proposed
parking nodes; she stated that the island has a long history of putting residents first, but this
action will only serve to make the island “a haven for more day-trippers.” Ms. Ferrell said that
the quality of the island and the quality of life of residents should not be sacrificed for day-
trippers. She commented that day-trippers should park in designated areas. In her opinion, the
parking nodes would only move the problem from Carolina to Ocean Boulevard, which is no
Public Hearing
July 26, 2011
Page 2 of 4
solution to the parking problems. The existence of the parking nodes would generate more
traffic, more trash and environmental problems; Ms. Ferrell said that “these access pads” cannot
be installed in the beach access without encroaching on the “fragile dune area.” Additionally,
Ms. Ferrell did not think the plan was fiscally responsible; she opined that the cost of
construction and upkeep would not be offset by revenues. She also remarked that the presence
of the parking nodes would adversely impact t he property values of Ocean Boulevard – again
reducing revenues to the City through property taxes.
Melinda Mitchell, 702 Ocean, commented that the island has two (2) types of day-trippers who
come to the island; they are the good day-tripper who do not cause problems and the bad day-
tripper who do not know or ignore the rules and r egulations thereby causing a lot of problems.
Ms. Mitchell suggested that “bad” day-trippers should be forced to park in the Commercial
District only, and day-tripper parking in the residential areas should be by annual parking pass
only. In acquiring an annual pass, the day-tri pper would sign an agreement to follow the
island’s rules and regulations; if the island’s rules are violated by an annual pass holder, the City
could revoke the pass forcing the day-tripper to park in the commercial lots. In addition, Ms.
Mitchell suggested zoned permit parking capping the number of day-trippers allowed to park in
a specific area.
Will Millman, 408 Ocean Boulevard, noted that he has been a resident of the island for twenty-
five (25) years. He reported that he had spoken to the Ways and Means Committee on June 21
to express his opposition to any paid visitor parking on Ocean Boulevard. He re-stated the fact
that Ocean Boulevard is zoned SR-1, single-family residential, not commercial; he expressed
his understanding that Council would be meeting to change that zoning. He commented that
day-visitors should be parking in the County parking lot and “not on any residential street.” He
concluded by saying that “we have elected you [Councilmembers] to maintain our quality of life
and our property values, not to destroy them.”
Jim Radley, 3801 Hartnett, identified himself as a member of the Carolina Surf Club and stated
that he and his wife had been day-trippers for two and a half (2½) years before moving to the
island. One (1) benefit they saw to the Isle of Palms was the accessibility of the beaches. A
solution he has seen work at Dewey Beach, Delaware is the annual parking pass; anyone could
purchase a parking pass for use from Memorial Day to Labor Day. He stated his understanding
that the parking nodes would be one hundred twenty (120) feet “in” from Ocean Boulevard;
having taken measurements using Google maps, Mr. Radley found that the closest house on
Ocean Boulevard was only seventy (70) feet from the street, but most houses are one hundred
to one hundred five (100-105) feet from the road – his point being that the parking nodes would
extend beyond the houses. Another point of in terest was that Ocean Boulevard ranges from
two hundred ninety to three hundred sixty (290-360) feet from the ocean; therefore, a one
hundred twenty (120) foot parking node consumes a lot of that space. In Mr. Radley’s opinion,
another manner of dealing with day-trippers is through parking kiosks, for example, at the end of
9
th Avenue with one (1) parking space where visitors could park while they get a parking pass.
He suggested that the number of day-trippers would diminish when they are required to pay-to-
park at a dollar ($1.00) an hour. As a surfer, he asked that pay-to-park begin at 10 a.m.
because surfers are out early in the day and off the beaches by 10 a.m.
Public Hearing
July 26, 2011
Page 3 of 4
Lucas Whitney, 403 Ocean, reported that he deals with lots of parking issues due primarily to a
vacant lot to one (1) side where day-trippers leave trash, relieve themselves, etc. Despite this,
he expressed opposition to the parking nodes primar ily because of the destruction of the sand
dunes which create a natural buffer in storm surges.
Wayne Jones chose not to speak, but say he was opposed to the nodes.
Wayne Barfield, 500 Ocean Boulevard, commented that “the Isle of Palms is not only known
nationally but internationally as one (1) of the most beautiful island communities anywhere,”
because many people have worked to preserve the character of the island. He stated that, “If
we start down the path of inserting commercial into, what is currently, a residential area, I think
we do start down the path of destroying part of what has made Isle of Palms Isle of Palms.” He
strongly encouraged the City Council not to follow that path.
Mary Ann Luttrell, 316 Charleston Boulevard, st ated that she also owns the property at 5
th and
Carolina indicating a long-term investment in the island. She noted that she had e-mailed
Councilmembers and thanked those who had responded to her comments. She stated that her
first (1
st) reaction to the proposed parking nodes was “feeling . . . heartsick at the notion of
putting a parking lot at the beginning of what I think is one (1) of the most beautiful beach paths
on the island;” she described the parking nodes as an “unenlightened approach to solving the
[parking] problem.” She agreed with a previous speaker that the nodes would only serve to shift
the parking problem from one (1) area to another. In her opinion, the City would be de-valuing
its natural value found in the marshes and marsh and beach views. Ms. Luttrell requested that
the City put together workshops with citizens, sim ilar to those for the Front Beach revitalization,
to draw the creativity of the citizens to solve the parking problems on the island.
Micheal Cervous, 415 Ocean, stated that he has resided on the island since the 1960s and is
directly affected by the parking issues. He expressed deep concern and strong opposition.
Willy McRae, owner of a lot on 6
th Avenue, described a public safety hazard in the parking
nodes as parents are weighed down with beach pr eparations, and the small child darts away
toward the beach to be hit by a departing vehicle that cannot see him/her.
Peter Zervos, 5th and Ocean, stated that he and his family have been associated with the island
since 1953. He expressed concern over who Councilmembers were representing – residents or
people who do not live on the island. He stated that the City does not owe anything to day-
trippers who come to island and damage it.
Eddie Brown, 901 Carolina, also had printed comments that are attached to the historical record
of the meeting.
Susan Burns, 3603 Palm Boulevard, noted that she has been a resident of the island for twenty-
eight (28) years. She stated that property values are good in the area of the island where she
resides and that, whatever is decided to be done for the Ocean Boulevard area, should be fair
to all of the island.
Public Hearing
July 26, 2011
Page 4 of 4
3. Conclusion/Adjourn
Mayor Cronin closed the Public Hearing at 7:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.