RecordWell Data

agenda (opens in a new tab)

City of Cayce · Lexington County · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Cayce

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

M ,ffOR CAYCE E LISE PARTIN a 11e1v kind qf city CITY OF CAYCE ilf Al'OR PR O-Tt~lt )AMES E . JENKINS CoU,\'Cll M t~IIBERS T ARA S. AL ~IOND E vA Co m.Ev T1~\0TliY M. ) AMES City of Cayce Regular Council Meeting Tuesday, September 1, 2015 CITY MANAGER R EBECCA VANCE 6:00 p.m . - Council Chambers - 1800 12th Street www.cityofcayce-sc .gov A SSISTANT C!n-M ANAGER SHAUN M. G REENWOOD I. Call to Order A. Invocation ·and Pledge of Allegiance B. Approval of Minutes August 4, 2015 Regular Meeting August 19, 2015 Special Meeting II. Public Comment regarding Items on the Agenda Ill. Ordinances and Resolutions A. Approval and Presentation of Resolution recognizing Council Member Tim James B. Discussion and Approval of Ordinance 2015-07 Amending the City's Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement - Second Reading C. Discussion and Approval of Ordinance 2015-08 Amending Section 103 .5 "Fees" of the International Property Maintenance Code to Set a Fee Schedule Relating to the Removal of Unsafe Structures - F irst Reading D. Discussion and Approval of Ordinance 2015-09 Amending Section 6.6 Table 2 ("Schedule of Uses and Off-Street Parking Requi rements fo r Commercial , Industrial & Development Districts ") of the Zoning Ord inance of the City of Cayce - First Reading E. Discussion and Approval of Ordinance 2015-1 O Adopting Five Year Update to The City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan - First Reading F. Consideration and Approval of Resolution Approving Financing Terms for Utility Department Vehicle Lease Purchases IV. Other A. Discussion and Approval of Hospitality Tax Fund Request Application Amendment - Native American Cherokee River Fest V. City Manager's Report 1800 TWELFf ll STREET • POST 0f'FI CE Box 2004 • CA\'CE, Sourn CAROLINA 291 71-2004 T EL. (803) 796 -9020 • FAX (803) 796 -90 72 WEBSITE ADDRESS: www .ci1y ofcayce -sc.go v VI. Committee Matters A. Approval to enter the following approved Committee Minutes into the City's Official Record Beautification Board - July 14, 2015 Cayce Housing Authority-April 14, 2015 Cayce Housing Authority-June 16, 2015 Events Committee - June 11, 2015 Events Committee - July 16, 2015 Planning Commission - May 18, 2015 Planning Commission - July 20, 2015 B. Appointments and Reappointments Beautification Board - One (1) Position Beautification Foundation - One (1) Position VII. Council Comments VIII. Executive Session A. Receipt of legal advice relating to claims and potential claims by the City and other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege B. Discussion of employment of Economic Development Consultant C. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements with McKay Public Affairs IX. Possible Actions by Council in follow up to Executive Session X. Adjourn SPECIAL NOTE: Upon request, the City of Cayce will provide th is document in whatever form necessary for the physically challenged or impaired. ITEM I. B. ilfA l'OR CAYCE ELISE PARTIN a IIC\V kind q/ Ci 0, . CITY OF CAYCE MAl 'OR PR O-TE,11 )MIES E . JENKINS COU,\'C/l M t"M/Jt'RS T ARA s. AL\\ 0:-lO Ev,, CORLEY T1~\0TIIY M . J,\ ,\\E S CITY OF CAYCE Regular Council Meeting August 4 , 2015 Cm' MA NAGER REBE CCA VA:,ICE A sstSTAA 'T Cm · M t1N1IGUi S HAUN M. G REENWOOD The August Regular Council Meeting was held this evening at 6 :00 p.m . in Council Chambers . Those present included Mayor Elise Partin, Council Members Tara Almond , Eva Corley and James Jenkins , City Manager Rebecca Vance , Assistant C ity Manager Shaun Greenwood and Municipal Clerk Mendy Corder. Municipal Treasurer Garry Huddle , City Attorney Danny Crowe , Director of Utilities Blake Bridwell , and Chief Charles McNair were also in attendance . Mayor Partin stated that Council Member James was not able to attend the meeting since he was out of town transitioning into his new job but will attend the September 1 , 2015 Council Meeting . Mayor Partin asked if members of the press and the public were duly notified of the Council Meeting in accordance with the FOIA . Ms. Corder confirmed they were notified . · Call to Order Mayor Partin called the meeting to order. Council Member Almond gave the invocation. Mayor Partin introduced Mr . D.uane Johnson to lead the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance . Mr. Johnson served with the United States Army for two years during Vietnam in 1966 & 1967 . After leaving the military , Mr. Johnson went to work in Forensics with the FBI in Maryland . Upon retiring from the FBI , he and his wife returned to Cayce in 2000 , where his wife has been a resident for over 50 years and Mr . Johnson 's father had also resided for many years . Mr. Johnson is now ret ired from the Lexington County Sheriffs Department. Approval of Minutes Council Member Corley made a motion to approve the July 7 , 2015 Regular Council Meeting minutes and the July 15 , 2015 Council Strategic Planning Session minutes as written . Council Member Almond seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote . Presentations A. Presentation by Ms. Stephanie Schroeder re Flood Insurance Rates 1800 T WELFTH STREET • POST O FFICE Box 2004 • C,WCE, SOUTH CAROLINA 29 1 71-2004 T EL. (803) 796-9020 • FAx (803) 796-9072 \\'EBS ITE ,\DORESS: \\'WW.Cityofcayce-sc.gov City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 2 Ms. Schroeder stated that she and her husband purchased a home in Riverland Park in 2010. She stated that part of the mortgage she signed stated that they were buying a house in a special flood hazard area. She stated she is currently paying $1,200 a year for flood insurance but that price is predicted to increase in a few years to $7,000 annually. She explained that the Federal government is taking away the subsidies for the rates and it is not possible for her and her family to pay the increased rates. Mayor Partin stated that the Riverland Neighborhood Association was meeting that week and stated City staff would give Ms. Schroeder the contact information for her Federal Legislators so she could share that information with her neighbors and contact her Legislators. Mayor Partin explained that Ms. Schroeder's Federal representatives were the ones who could make an impact on the issue. Public Comment Regarding Items on the Agenda Ms. Corder advised that no one had signed up for Public Comment. Resolutions A. Consideration and Approval of Resolution Approving Intergovernmental Mutual Aid Agreement for the Three Rivers Greenway Ms. Vance explained that the City had entered into this agreement in the past and there were not any changes to the agreement but Lexington County has a new Sheriff so each entity involved needs to re~approve the agreement with the new Sheriff listed. Council Member Almond made a motion to approve the Resolution approving an intergovernmental mutual aid agreement for the Three Rivers Greenway. Council Member Jenkins seconded the motion whi~h was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Other A. Discussion and Approval of the City of Cayce's Unsafe Structure Program Guidelines Mr. Greenwood stated that at the request of City Council, staff has compiled guidelines on how the International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) will be used to address the demolition of unsafe structures within the City limits. He stated that the guidelines summarize the required notices to home owners and time frames specified in City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 3 the IPMC. Additionally, the guidelines specify the process and authority for the City to place a lien on the property when demoliti9n becomes necessary. Mr. Greenwood stated that staff created a flow chart for Council that lists the time frame and details of the process. He explained that Mayor Partin recommended adding a box to illustrate if the property owner files an appeal and the Board grants the appeal then the building is declared safe and all enforcement action stops. Mr. Greenwood stated that Mayor Partin also asked that st~ff clarify that when it states that the building will be repaired to say that it will be repaired by the owner, not the City. He explained that under this program the City will not be doing any repairs to the properties. Mr. Greenwood stated that once a property owner has been notified that they have a violation and the structure has been deemed unsafe they will be given a chance to either repair it themselves or hire someone to repair it to bring it up to code. If the owner does not remedy the situation, staff .will have to proceed with getting voluntary condemnation and demolition or begin the process of the City demolishing it and putting a lien on the property. Mr. Greenwood explained that the list was created by a committee consisting of the Building Official, Fire Marshal and the Lieutenant over Codes Enforcement. He stated that they did a City-wide assessment and have created a list of properties that are ranked according to their current state of disrepair. He stated that the enforcement efforts will target the worst structures first and will continue down the list until all budgeted funds are expended. Mr. Greenwood explained that the structures on the list are categorized by the number one, two or three. The number one properties are mostly uninhabited, have structural issues and are unsafe. The structures numbered two or three could potentially be repaired and may not have to be demolished. He explained that staff will go down the list until the money that Council appropriated towards the program is expended. He stated that if Council appropriates funds towards the program again next year then the list will be reassessed. Ms. Vance stated that with the International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) the City has the ability to tear down buildings that the Building Inspector declares a nuisance or unsafe. She explained that there has not been any funding allocated towards tearing unsafe structures down in years. She stated the program is not a new Ordinance but the City actually has funding in the current budget to follow through with the demolition of unsafe buildings. She explained that it is ultimately up to the Building Inspector to determine if a building is unsafe. Mr. Greenwood stated that Cities with a demolition program typically seek to recover attorney and legal fee costs through a lien on the property. He explained that under the International Property Maintena~ce Code there is a system for establishing City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 4 fees so staff can create fees for the various things that have to be done legally. He stated he will bring back the proposed fees to Council in September and explained it will require a Public Hearing since new fees are being established. Council Member Almond asked if a lien can be renewed once the time period expires. Mr. Crowe explained that the lien does not expire and continues on until the property is sold. Council Member Jenkins asked what recourse the City has if someone is notified that their property is unsafe and they do nothing to remedy the situation. Mr. Greenwood explained that the property owner can be fined if they do not take any action and eventually the property can be demolished. Council Member Jenkins asked if staff would notify the bank when they put a lien on a property. Mr. Crowe stated that staff is going to make an effort to identify the title holders as well as any mortgage holders of the property. He stated that it might be beneficial to notify the mortgage holders srnce they might have an interest in taking over the property. Mayor Partin explained that any appeals will go before the Consolidated Board of Appeals. She explained that there are currently three open positions on the Board that need to be filled. The Board reviews citizen appeals to ensure building codes, property maintenance codes and fire codes are properly interpreted and implemented fairly. She stated members who serve on this Board must be either an Engineer, Contractor, Architect or Design Professional. She explained that this Board needs to have all the open positions filled and be active before the new demolition program can start. Mr. Greenwood explained that staff _has added the tax map number to each property on the list so there will not be any mistakes when identifying the property. This change will be part of the official guidelines. He stated that some of the addresses on the buildings were not correct so the tax map number was added to ensure that there is no mistaking which property is in question. Council Member Almond made a motion to approve the Unsafe Structure Program guidelines. Council Member Corley seconded the motion. Council Member Jenkins asked if staff was asking for approval just for the guidelines or approval of the guidelines and approval to move forward with the program. Ms. Vance explained that staff was asking for both so there is no confusion among staff or the residents. Council Member Almond amended her motion to approve the guidelines and authorize staff to move forward. Council Member Corley amended her second which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 5 City Manager's Report Ms. Vance stated that staff has appHed for a FEMA Pre-Disaster Mitigation Grant to fund the purchase of a new generator and needed electrical work in the Public Safety building. She explained that the Public Safety buildings serve as the Emergency Operations Center during an emergency. Also City Hall's server backs up to Public Safety's server so it is integral that the building be operational at all times. Ms. Vance stated that the Fire Department experienced significant flooding in June. She stated that most of the repairs have been completed and the new windows for the front of the building were installed that week. She stated that the new windows are a vast improvement and invited Council to ride by and look at them when they are in the area. She commended Ms. Corder for coordinating the repairs and improvements to the Fire Department and thanked the Fire Department staff for patiently dealing with the current conditions in their building. Ms. Vance stated that Mr. Greenwood recently received his ICMA Credentialed Manager Accreditation. She stated that she and Mr. Greenwood are both credentialed managers and explained that there are very few in the state. Mayor Partin congratulated Mr. Greenwood and stated that the City is very thankful and blessed to have such well trained and educated staff: Ms. Vance stated that staff is working on three different items to tackle some of the code enforcement issues in the City. She explained that staff is moving forward with the demolition program and she and Mr. Greenwood are meeting with Public Safety staff to discuss the enforcement of the Property Maintenance Code and the logistics of the enforcement. She stated that Mr. Greenwood plans to have a presentation for Council regarding the Rental Registry Ordinance at the September 16, 2015 Special Council Meeting. She stated at that point Council will have to decide how stringently they want staff to enforce the Ordinance. For example, some municipalities inspect rental property annually. Ms. Vance explained that Phase II 6f the Riverwalk was damaged during the recent heavy rains. Part of the sidewalk was washed away and the pilings under a bridge were seriously undermined. She explained that either the bridge will need to be replaced or improvements will need to be made to the pilings and the riverbanks on either side of the bridge to secure it. She asked that the public please be patient while the City is working to repair the damage a~d make the Riverwalk safe for everyone. Committee Matters A. Approval to Enter the Following Approved Committee Minutes into the City's Official Record City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 6 Council Member Jenkins made a motion to approve entering the following Committee minutes into the City's official record: Beautification Board - June 9, 2015 Council Member Almond seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. B. Appointments and Reappointments Mayor Partin stated that Ms. Kim Well's term expired on the Beautification Foundation in July and she would like to serve again. She has served on the Foundation since 2010 and consistently attends the meetings. Council Member Jenkins made a motion to reappoint Ms. Wells to the Beautification Foundation. Council Member Corley seconded the mo.tion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Mayor Partin reminded the assembly that there are open positions on the Accommodations Tax Committee, the Beautification Board, the Events Committee, and the Public Safety Foundation. She stated. anyone interested could contact Ms. Corder to request a potential member application. Council Comments Council Member Almond congratulated Mr. Greenwood for earning his ICMA certification. Council Member Jenkins also congratulated Mr. Greenwood. Mayor Partin stated that the Cayce West Columbia Life magazine is currently requesting nominees for the "Best of Cayce West Columbia". She asked the assembly to visit their web page and nominate Cayce businesses. Mayor Partin stated that the Congaree Bluegrass Festival is October 3 and 4, 2015 and will be held at the Historic Columbia Speedway this year. She explained that on October 3rd there is an admission cost but will be free to all Cayce residents with proof of residency. She stated that October 4th will be a Bluegrass Gospel music celebration and free to all. Mayor Partin stated that Ms. Addy Cullum, daughter of Lexington County Council Member Todd Cullum, is a rising sophomore at Brookland-Cayce High School and recently won a National High School Varsity Intermediate Horse Reining Championship. She stated that Council is ·proud of her for representing the City so well. Executive Session A. Receipt of legal advice relating to claims and potential claims by the City City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 7 and other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege B. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements with SCOOT for mast arms on Knox Abbott Drive C. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements For the use of TIF Funds related to Phase I of Knox Abbott Drive Pedestrian Safety and Traffic Calming Project D. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements for City Hall repairs E. Discussion of negotiations incident to a contractual arrangement for repairs in Riverwalk Phase II F. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements for funding for utility projects Council Member Jenkins made a motion to move into Executive Session. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Possible Actions by Council in follow up to Executive Session Item IX. B. Council Member Almond made a motion to approve and authorize the City Manager to sign a contract with SCOOT for mast arms for Knox Abbott Drive. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Item IX. C. Council Member Corley made a motion to approve an agreement with Standard Capital Partners for reimbursements of improvements to the right-of-way on Knox Abbott Drive and authorize the City Manager to sign a memorandum to use up to $100,000 in TIF Funds for this project. Co.uncil Member Almond seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Item IX. D. Council Member Jenkins made a motion to approve and award a contract for repairs of City Hall per the RFP with MAR Gonstruction and to authorize the City Manager to sign the contract and have change order authority up to 10% of the bid amount. Council Member Almond seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. City of Cayce Minutes of 08/04/15 Regular Council Meeting Page 8 Item IX. E. Council Member Almond made a motion to approve an agreement with the River Alliance for repairs in Riverwalk Phase II and authorize the City Manager to sign said agreement. Council Member Jenkins seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. · Item IX. F. Council Member Corley made a motion to move forward with an engineering study for waterline improvements in Edenwood. Council Member Jenkins seconded the motion which was unanimously approved ~y roll call vote. Adjourn There being no further business, Council Member Corley made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Council Member Jenkins seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. The meeting adjourned at 7:55 p.m. Elise Partin, Mayor ATTEST: Mendy C. Corder, Municipal Clerk IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON A MATTER APPEARING ON THE MEETING AGENDA, PLEASE COMPLETE THE INFORMATION BELOW PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING.* THANK YOU. COUNCIL MEETING SPEAKERS' LIST Date of Meeting August4,2015~~~~~~~- Name Address Agenda Item *Appearance of citizens at Council meetings - City of Cayce Code of Ordinances, Sec. 2-71. Any citizen of the municipality may speak at a regular meeting of the council on a matter pertaining to munic ipal services and operation, with the exception of personnel matters, by notifying the office of the city manager at least five working days prior to the meeting and stating the subject and purpose for speaking. Additionally, during the public comment period as specified on the agenda of a regular meeting of the council , a memb er of the public may speak on a matter appearing on the meeting agenda, with the exception of personnel matters by signing a speakers list maintained by the city clerk prior to the start of the public comment period. At the discretion of the mayor or presiding officer , the length of time for any speaker's presentation may be limited and the number speakers also may be limited. JlfA 1tJR CAYCE ELI SE PARTIN (l ae,v ki nd qfc io 1 CITY OF CAYCE Jl!dl'OR P RO-TE.II j A.111:S E. ) EKKINS CowvcJL Afr .llBERS T ARA 5. /\L.\I OND Ev,\ CORLE\' T l~IOTHY M. j ,\,\IES City of Cayce Special Council Meeting August 19, 2015 Cm· lvfANAGER R EBECCA VANCE AsstSTANT Cm· M 11NAGER SHA UN M . G1m:N11·00D A Special Council Meeting was held this afternoon at 5 :00 p.m. in Council Chambers. Those present included Mayor Elise Partin , Council Members Eva Corley , Tim James and James Jenkins , City Manager Rebecca Vance and Assistant City Manager Shaun Greenwood . Municipal Clerk Mendy Corder and City Attorney Danny Crowe were also in attendance. Mayor Partin asked if members of the press and the public were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the FOIA. Ms. Corder confirmed they were notified . Call to Order Mayor Partin called the meeting to order and Council Member James gave the invocation . Mayor Partin led the assembly in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance . She announced that Council Member Almond's daughter was getting married therefore Council Member Almond was unable to attend the meeting . Public Comment Regarding Items in the Agenda Ms. Corder stated no one had signed up for public comment. Ordinances and Other A. Discussion and Approval of Ordinance 2015-07 Amending the City 's Regulations for Council E xpense Reimbursement - First Reading Council Member James made a motion to approve the Ordinance amending the City's Regulat ions for Council Expense Reimbursement. Council Member Corley seconded the motion . Council Member James suggested changing the section of the Ord inance that states that the City will pay for a cell phone or smart phone if used primarily (more than 75% of the time) for City business. Coun cil Member Jam es stated that it would be very difficult for anyone to know how much time they spend on business call s and it would be an administrative nightmare for staff to try to keep up w ith it. He stated that he believes the City wants a Mayor that is easily contacted so the City should in cur the cost for the Mayor 's cell phone . He suggested changing the Ordinance to state that the City will pay the costs of a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor . Council Member James e xplained that any out -of-state travel for Council is approved along with the City 's annual budget th erefore it is not ne cessary to state in the Council E xpense Reimbu rsement Regulations that out-of- state travel for a member of Council mu st be approv ed by a majority vot e of Council. H e stated that any out-of - 1soo T IVELFTII S TREET • Posr O FFICE Box 2004 • CAYCE, Sourn (,\RO LI N,\ 29 1 71-2004 TE L. (803) 796 -9020 • FAX (803) 796-9072 WEBSITE ADDRESS: www.ci 1yo fcayce - sc.gov City of Cayce Minutes of 09/19/15 Special Council Meeting Page 2 state travel that has not been approved in the budget should come before Council for approval but anything previously approved would not. Council Member James made a motion to amend his previous motion to include the two amendments to the Regulations. Council Member Corley amended her second which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. B. Discussion and Approval of Hospitality Tax Fund Request - Improvements to Electrical in Granby Gardens Park - Staff Request Ms. Vance explained that staff is requesting to be allowed to utilize up to $30,000 of Hospitality Tax Funds for new electrical installation and upgrades to Granby Gardens Park. She stated additional lighting would be added, receptacles replaced throughout the park and new LED lights will be placed in the median in front of the park. She stated this park is highly utilized for Cayce special events and these upgrades are a necessity in continuing to hold concerts and special gatherings in this recreational facility. Ms. Vance stated that a contractor will need to be hired to do the work so the City will get three bids for the project. Council Member Jenkins made a motion to approve staffs request to utilize up to $30,000 of Hospitality Tax Funds for electrical upgrades in Granby Gardens Park. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Committee Matters A. Appointments and Reappointments Mayor Partin stated that the Consolidated Board of Appeals currently has four open positions. The City has received three potential member applications. Council Member James made a motion to appoint Mr. Lawrence Gardner, Mr. Craig Kirby and Mr. Erskine Suber to the Board. Council Member Jenkins seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Mayor Partin explained that members who serve on this Board must be either an Engineer, Contractor, Architect or Design Professional. She stated that she has two people that she is contacting to see if they might be interested in filling the last open position on the Board since all the open positions have to be filled and the Board be active before the new demolition program can start. Ms. Vance explained that Mr. Greenwood confirmed that the demolition program can start as long as the Board has a majority of the positions filled. Council Comments City of Cayce Minutes of 09/19/15 Special Council Meeting Page 3 Council Member Jenkins thanked staff for doing a good job and stated he was glad that the employees were being safe and there were no safety issues. Executive Session Council Member James made a motion to move into Executive Session. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. A. Receipt of legal advice relating to claims and potential claims by the. City and other matters covered by the attorney-client privilege B. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements as it pertains to the ETMF water tank C. Discussion of negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements as it pertains to construction of Riverland Park Reconvene After the Executive Session was concluded, Council Member James made a motion to reconvene the Regular meeting. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Mayor Partin announced that no vote was taken in Executive Session other than to adjourn and resume the Regular meeting. Possible Actions by Council in follow up to Executive Session VI.C. Council Member James made a motion to authorize the City Manager to utilize TIF Funds for construction of the new park in Riverland Park. Council Member Corley seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. Adjourn Council Member Corley made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Council Member James seconded the motion which was unanimously approved by roll call vote. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 6:02 p.m. Elise Partin, Mayor ATTEST: Mendy Corder, Municipal Clerk IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON A MATTER APPEARING ON THE MEETING AGENDA, PLEASE COMPLETE THE INFORMATION BELOW PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING.* THANK YOU. COUNCIL MEETING SPEAKERS' LIST Date of Meeting August19,2015~~~~~~~ Name Address Agenda Item * Appearance of citizens at Council meetings - City of Cayce Code of Ordinances , Sec. 2-71. Any citizen of the municipality may speak at a regular meeting of the council on a matter pertaining to municipal services and operation. with the exception of personnel matters. by notifying the off ice of the city manager at least five working days prior to the meeting and stating the subject and purpose for speaking. Additionally . during the public comment per iod as specified on the agenda of a regular meeting of the council. a member of the public may speak ~ma matter appearing on the meeting agenda, with the exception of personnel matters by signing a speakers list maintained by the city cle rk prior to the start of the public comment period. At the discretion of the mayor or presiding officer , the length of time for any speaker's presentation may be limited and the number speakers also may be limited. Resolution Recognizing Council Member Tim James Whereas, Timothy M. “Tim” James graduated from Brookland-Cayce High School, earned a Bachelor’s Degree in Criminal Justice and is a graduate of the Federal Bureau of Investigation National Academy, the FBI-Carolina Command College, the JFK School of Government at Harvard University and the Municipal Association of South Carolina’s Municipal Elected Official Institute of Government; and Where as, as a young boy he was a Cayce Explorer with Cayce Public Safety and in 1983 he began his career in law enforcement as a dispatcher and jailer with the Cayce Department of Public Safety. He rose through the ranks to serve as Chief of Police for the City of Cayce and Director of the Cayce Department of Public Safety, managing law enforcement and fire suppression services for the City and establishing a reputation as an innovative law enforcement administrator; and Where as, deeply dedicated to his community as a lifelong resident of Cayce, he was elected to serve on Cayce City Council in 2010 and his daughters, Taylor and Megan, are now being reared in his hometown and attend the same schools that their father did; and Where as, an active member of Trinity Baptist Church, Tim James has served the congregation in several leadership capacities, including Chairman of Deacons; and NOW , THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Cayce City Council, in Council Session duly assembled, joins in expressing its heartfelt appreciation and gratitude to Tim James for his many years of service, leadership and friendship to the City of Cayce, its Council, staff and its citizens. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that we extend our best wishes to Tim and wish him well in his future endeavors as he becomes Vice President and Director of Public Safety for Ocean Reef Community Association in Florida. ADOP TED this 1st day of September, 2015. _______ _______________________________ Elise Partin, Mayor ATTEST: _______ _________________________________ Mendy Corder, Municipal Clerk ITEM III. A. ________________________________________________________________________ Memorandum ________________________________________________________________________ To: Mayor and Council From: R ebecca Vance Date: A ugust 27, 2015 Sub ject: Approval of Second Reading of an Ordinance Amending the City’s Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement _________________________________________________________ ISSU E Approv al is needed for the Second Reading of an Ordinance amending the City’s regulations for Council expense reimbursement. BACKGRO UND/DISCUSSION Aft er reviewing the City’s regulations for Council expense reimbursement, it was determined that two amendments needed to be made to the Ordinance to address Meals and Other charges. The Ordinance needs to be amended to address the reimbursement of Council members for meals with third parties when the purpose of the meal is within the Council member’s official duties. The Or dinance also needs to be amended to add all costs to the section titled “Other” as it deals with the costs of a cell phone or a smart phone for the Mayor. These amendments clarify these two sections and make it easier to administer. Counci l voted at the August 19, 2015 Special Council meeting to amend the Out-Of-State Travel section in the Regulations to delete the sentence stating out-of-state travel for a member must be approved by a majority vote of Council since all travel is approved in the budget process and therefore would not need additional approval. Any travel that was not previously budgeted and approved would have to come before Council for approval. RECOM MENDATION Staf f recommends Council approve the Second Reading of an Ordinance Amending the City’s Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement. ITEM III. B. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA COUNTY OF LEXINGTON CITY OF CAYCE ) ) ) ) ) ORDINANCE Amending the City’s Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement WHEREAS, the Council, by Ordinance dated January 5, 2010, amended Section 2-39 of the City Code relating to City Council expenses and also adopted certain Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement; and WHEREAS, Council now wishes to amend two portions of the Regulations to clarify the allowance of reimbursement of expenses for a cell phone for the Mayor and to address reimbursement of a member’s expenses for meals for the member and third parties incurred in the performance of the member’s official duties, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and Council of the City of Cayce, in Council, duly assembled, that: The Regulations for Council Expense Reimbursement, adopted by Ordinance dated January 5, 2010, are hereby amended to (1 ) Add, under the paragraph heading “Meals”, a new subparagraph 4 to read as follows: 4. Meals for a member (or members) and a third party or third parties shall be reimbursed when the purpose of the meal is within the member’s performance of official duties. (2) Change the first sentence of sub paragraph 1 under the paragraph heading “Out-of-State Travel” to read as follows: 1. Out-of-state travel for a member that is not included in the City’s Annual Budget must be approved by a majority vote of Council. (3) Change subparagraph 2 b under the paragraph heading “Other” to read as follows: b. Costs for a cell phone or smart phone, with the exception of a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor. (4) Add, under the paragraph heading “Other”, a new subparagraph 3 to read as follows: 3. All costs for a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor shall be reimbursed. This Ordinance shall take effect on the date of second reading approval by Council. DONE IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED, this ____ day of ________________, 2015. ________________________________ Elise Partin, Mayor ATTEST: _________________________________ Mendy C. Corder, Municipal Clerk First reading: _______________________ Second reading and adoption: _______________ Approved as to form: _________________________ Danny C. Crowe, City Attorney 2 REGULATIONS FOR COUNCIL EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT The following regulations apply to requests by a Council member (including the Mayor) for reimbursement of expenses pursuant to the requirements of City Code section 2-39. The member shall be reimbursed only for their own individual reasonable actual allowable expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties as set forth below. Although requests for reimbursements of Council member expenses are submitted to the City Manager as a matter of procedure, the City Manager will review requests only for compliance with the facial requirements of Section 2-39 or these regulations. The Council member submitting a request for reimbursement is and remains responsible for determining whether a particular expense is appropriate for submittal for reimburse- ment. TRANSPORTATION Transportation cost incurred in the performance of official travel will be reimbursed as follows: 1. P ersonal Car – Subject to the mileage range restriction below, actual mileage to and from meetings to support the member’s official duties. The mileage rate will be the same as that allowed by the IRS for business travel. 2. Air, Bus, Train: The actual cost as shown on the ticket or receipt is reimbursable. All commercial travel shall be at the lowest available fare and take advantage of available discounts by early bookings, return trip bookings, etc. First class air travel shall not be reimbursed. Out-of-state travel must be approved by Council before travel commences. 3. Taxi: The cost of a taxi shall be reimbursable if appropriate public transportation is not available or if the official duties made use of a private car or public transportation impractical. Taxi expenses must be supported by a receipt. 4. Rental Car: The lowest cost car possible shall be reserved at the destination. The full cost of the rental car to include insurance shall be reimbursable. A copy of the rental contract must be submitted 5. Passengers: Members riding as a passenger in a private car shall not be entitled to mileage reimbursement. 6. No member shall receive reimbursement for mileage within 15 miles of their official headquarters/residence. LODGING/REGISTRATION 1. When possible, the City will pay in advance for registration and hotel deposits for members requesting to attend meetings or seminars sponsored by the Municipal Association of South Carolina or other recognized and reputable entities providing educational or informational programs directly related to the performance of the members official duties. 2. The cost of lodging for a single room shall be reimbursed. A receipt must be presented with the reimbursement form. During conventions, seminars and similar activities, lodging should be in the convention/seminar headquarters hotel if available or the next most reasonably priced hotel on the recommended list. Lodging expenses incurred in excess of the amount charged at the headquarters/seminar hotel shall not be reimbursed unless lodging at the headquarters/seminar hotel is not available. 3. If a member requests to attend a conference or seminar and the room deposit is non-refundable, the member will reimburse the City for the amount of the un- refunded deposit if he/she decides to cancel and not attend the event. Exceptions include personal or family emergencies. 4. The cost for room upgrades or extended stays beyond the meeting dates shall not be reimbursed. 5. The cost of additional lodging services such as pay movies, room service (other than meals within the limitations for meal reimbursement), valet service, etc. shall not be reimbursed. The cost of laundry and dry cleaning is reimbursable if the official absence extends over more than seven calendar days. A receipt must be presented. 6. No reimbursement for overnight accommodations will be permitted within 15 miles of Cayce City Hall. 7. Tips and gratuity are not reimbursable by the City as approved expenses. OUT-OF-STATE-TRAVEL 1. Out-of-state travel for a member that is not included in the City’s Annual Budget must be approved by a majority vote of Council. Out of state travel may be approved only for the following described items: a. Exploration of possible funding sources for an approved/adopted business item before Council; b. A potential or new economic development issue known by Council by way of public or executive session when accompanied by a recommendation from the City Manager; c. Attendance at an approved educational meeting or seminar; or d. Other matters, now unforeseen, that the Council may consider appropriate. 2. Any out of state travel must have a planned itinerary and be preceded by local meetings among participating local or elected officials to determine if the out-of- state trip is actually required for furthering the purpose intended. Council members should consider using or involving appropriate City staff, such as the City Manager or a department head, as a travel and meeting participant. No more than one Council member should travel on any approved out of state trip. MEALS 1. When authorized to travel on official business whereby overnight lodging is required, the member shall be reimbursed up to a maximum of $75.00 per day for meals. 2. Meals included in registration costs will reduce the maximum daily amount for meal reimbursement. 3. The cost of alcoholic drinks shall be at the expense of the individual. 4. Meals for a member (or members) and a third party or third parties shall be reimbursed when the purpose of the meal is within the member’s performance of official duties. OTHER 1. Long distance telephone charges placed from an individual’s personal phone in the performance of official duties representing the City shall be reimbursed. Documentation of the charge must be presented. 2. Expenses not eligible for reimbursement: a. Charges for common personal or business communication applications such as access to internet, fax service to printers at the member’s residence, personal business or personal office. b. Costs for a cell phone or smart phone, with the exception of a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor. Costs for a cell phone or smart phone, with the exception of a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor if used primarily (more than 75% of the time) for City business. If a phone for the Mayor is not provided by the City, minutes charged for city business are reimbursable with appropriate documentation. 3. All costs for a cell phone or smart phone for the Mayor shall be reimbursed. if the phone is used primarily (more than 75% of the time) for City business. Formatted: Underline, Font color: Red Formatted: Font color: Red Formatted: Underline, Font color: Red Formatted: Underline CLAIMS 1. Any request for reimbursement of reasonable actual expenses shall be submitted to the City Manager on a signed expense reimbursement form provided by the City Manager and within 30 days after the end of the month in which the expense is incurred. All expenses shall be substantiated with receipts and the description of expenses sufficient to satisfy any City audit requirements. Reimbursement will be paid by the City Manager after reviewing the reimbursement form for completeness and accuracy. 2. E xpenses for spouses or guests of a member will not be reimbursed. 3. The auditor for the City shall audit annually the expense reimbursements for Council members and separately list each Council member and the amount of the member’s reimbursed expenses in the annual audit report. Any amounts paid to a Council member and subsequently determined by the auditor to be outside these regulations or any law or established practice shall be repaid to the City by the Council member or withheld from the member’s next paycheck as a debt owed to the City. Note: All requests for reimbursements and attachments are public records when submitted to the City Manager and are subject to disclosure pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). ________________________________________________________________________ Memorandum ________________________________________________________________________ To: Mayor and Council From: R ebecca Vance, City Manager Shaun Greenwood, Asst. City Manager Date: A ugust 24, 2015 Sub ject: Approval of an Ordinance amending Section 103.5 “Fees” of the International Property Maintenance Code to set a fee schedule relating to the removal of unsafe structures. ________________________________________________________________ ISSU E Counci l approval is needed for the First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 103.5 “Fees” of the International Property Maintenance Code to set a fee schedule relating to the removal of unsafe structures. BACKGRO UND/DISCUSSION Cit y Council recently adopted staff’s recommendation for policy guidelines related to the removal of dilapidated and unsafe structures throughout the City. In an effort to ensure that all associated costs can be charged against the property and can be ultimately recovered by the City, a fee structure needs to be inserted into the International Property Maintenance Code. Staff believes the suggested fees will cover the immediate costs of demolition and any ancillary costs related to the administration of the program. Additional fees can be added at a later date if they become necessary. In acc ordance with State Law, the establishment of new fees requires a Public Hearing. The Public Hearing for these fees is scheduled before the Second Reading at the September 16, 2015 Special Council Meeting. RECOM MENDATION Staf f recommends Council approve First Reading of an Ordinance amending Section 103.5 “Fees” of the International Property Maintenance Code to set a fee schedule relating to the removal of unsafe structures. ITEM III. C. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ORDINANCE ) Amending Section 103.5 “Fees” of the COUNTY OF LEXINGTON ) International Property Maintenance Code to ) S et a Fee Schedule Relating to the Removal of CITY OF CAYCE ) U nsafe Structures WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that it is in the interest of the City to establish fees associated with the inspection and removal of dilapidated and unsafe structures in accordance with the adopted International Property Maintenance Code, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and Council , of the City of Cayce, in Council duly assembled, that: Section 103.5 “Fees” of the International Property Maintenance Code is hereby amended to include the attached schedule of fees. This Ordinance shall take effect upon the second and final reading. DONE IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED, this _____ day of ___________, 2015. ________________________________ Elise Partin, Mayor ATTEST: ____________________________ Mendy C. Corder, Municipal Clerk First reading: ______________ Public Hearing held: _____________ Second reading and adoption: __________________ Approved as to form: ____________________________ Danny C. Crowe, City Attorney Property Maintenance Code Item/Description Basis Fee Board of Appeals Application for Appeal Per Application $ 150.00 Legal Fees Fees for Legal Services Charges incurred by the City for the related legal services of its retained attorneys Actual Charges Demolition Fees Fees for Demolition Services Fees for Lot Clearing Fees for Environmental Cleanup - Includes reseeding and any other measures required for proper soil stabilization or other stormwater requirements Charges incurred by the City for the Demolition services of the chosen Contractor Charges incurred by the City for the Lot Clearing services of the chosen Contractor Charges incurred by the City for Environmental Cleanup services Actual Charges Actual Charges Actual Charges Unsafe Structure Inspection Fees Fees for Inspection Services Preliminary Site Inspection Re-Inspection 1st Inspection Per Inspection Free $50. 00 Administrative Fees Condemnation Resulting in Demolition Per Property $250.00 Utility Fees Water and Sewer shutoff fees and Water Meter removal Per Property $50.00 ________________________________________________________________________ Memorandum ________________________________________________________________________ To: Mayor and Council From: R ebecca Vance, City Manager Shaun Greenwood, Asst. City Manager Layne West, Planning & Development Director Date: A ugust 25, 2015 Sub ject: First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 6.6 Table 2 (“Schedule of Uses and Off-Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial & Development Districts”) of the Zoning Ordinance. ________________________________________________________________ ISSU E Counci l approval is needed for the First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 6.6 Table 2 of the Zoning Ordinance. (“Schedule of Uses and Off-Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial & Development Districts”). BACKGRO UND/DISCUSSION Over the past four years, staff has been systematically working to ensure that excessive asphalt parking areas were not included in new developments. With the pending development of a new hotel and the potential for several others, staff conducted a review of the current Zoning Ordinance and discovered that the current parking requirements for hotels and motels is well outside of the industry standard. Prospective developments of this nature would have some onerous land use requirements placed on them with the current requirements. Plann ing staff did a survey of other South Carolina cities to discover their parking requirements. The results showed that Cayce is placing an undue burden on hotels and motels with the parking requirement of 1.5 spaces per rental unit. Hotel Parking Requirement Comparison Municipality Parking spaces required Moncks Corner 1 per room Summerville 1 per room + 1 per 3 employees Charleston 2 per 3 rooms North Charleston 2 per 3 rooms Goose Creek 1 per room + 1 per 3 employees ITEM III. D. Columbia 1 per room Lexington 1 per room Forrest Acres Does not allow hotels Irmo 1 per room Rock Hill 1 per 3 rooms +1 per employee Isle of Palms 1 per room + 1 per 3 employees Myrtle Beach .33 per room West Columbia 1 per room Planning staff recommended to the Planning Commission that the Ordinance requirement be changed from 1.5 spaces per rental unit to 1 space per rental unit. The Planning Commission considered the request for the amendment at its regular meeting on August 17, 2015. The amendment request was opened for Public Hearing. Members of the public were present but no one signed up to speak. No one spoke in opposition to the amendment request. The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend the requested amendment. RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission recommends Council approve first reading of an Ordinance to amend Section 6.6 Table 2 (“Schedule of Uses and Off-Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial & Development Districts”) of the Zoning Ordinance. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ) COUNTY OF LEXINGTON ) ) CITY OF CAYCE ) ORDINANCE Amending Section 6.6 Table 2 (“Schedule of Uses and Off- Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial & Development Districts”) of the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Cayce WHEREAS, the Council has determined that it is in the interest of the city to amend in understanding the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, and in the interest of the City in administering and enforcing the Zoning Ordinance, to amend Section 6.6 Table 2 (“Schedule of Uses and Off-Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial, & Development Districts”) of the Zoning Ordinance to reduce the required number of parking spaces for hotel and motels, WHEREAS, the Planning Commission met on August 17, 2015, held a public hearing to receive public comment on the proposed change, and voted to recommend the text amendment, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and Council , of the City of Cayce, in Council, duly assembled, that Section 6.6 Table 2 (“Schedule of Uses and Off- Street Parking Requirements for Commercial, Industrial & Development Districts”), Sector 72 (Accommodations and Food Services) of the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Cayce is hereby amended to read as follows: Sector 72: Accommodation and Food Services Accommodations 721 Hotels & motels 72111 N N P P P N N 1.0 per rental unit Bed and Breakfast Inns 721191 P N P P P N N 1.5 per bedroom Camps & recreational vehicle parks (Sec.7.11) 72121 N N N N S N S Not applicable Rooming & boarding houses, dormitories, group housing 72131 N N N P P N N 1.0 per bedroom Eating Places 7221-3 N P P P P P N 1.0 per 150 s.f. GFA Drinking Places 7224 N N P P P P N 1.0 per 150 s.f. GFA This Ordinance shall be effective from the date of second reading approval by Council. 1 DONE IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED, this ______ day of _________2015. ______________________________ Elise Partin, Mayor Attest: ______________________________ Mendy Corder, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _____________________ Second Reading and Adoption: ____________ Approved as to form: __________________________ Danny C. Crowe, City Attorney 2 ________________________________________________________________________ Memorandum ________________________________________________________________________ To: Mayor and Council From: Rebec ca Vance, City Manager Layne West, Director of Planning and Development Monique Ocean, Zoning Technician Date: Augus t 25, 2015 Subj ect: First Reading of an Ordinance to Adopt the Five Year Update to the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan ________________________________________________________________ ISSUE Council approval is needed for the First Reading of an Ordinance adopting the five year update to the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan. BACKGROUN D/DISCUSSION The exis ting Comprehensive Plan was adopted May 6, 2010, and is the long- range planning document that has helped guide the City over the last 5 years. In an effort to maintain its relevance and in keeping with State law, as contained in the South Carolina Local Government Comprehensive Planning Enabling Act of 1994 (S.C. Code section 6-29-310 et seq.), Staff conducted a Comprehensive Plan Five Year Update throughout 2015. Staff has used current information to make updates where needed. A summary of the changes is attached for your consideration. A copy of the redline version of the changes is also attached. The Plann ing Commission met on August 17, 2015, to hear Public Comment about the suggested changes. No members of the public were present at the meeting. The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend the updates. RECOMM ENDATION The Plann ing Commission recommends Council approve First Reading of an Ordinance adopting the five year update to the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan. ITEM III. E. Comprehensive Plan Summary of Changes Introduction • Explanation for 5 year review and update added Part I. Population Element • 2010 census information added to Population table • Building permit information for 2009 through 2013 added • 2010 population added • Racial Characteristics Table updated from current Census information • Racial Trends Table updated • Age Composition updated from current Census information • Age Group Trends Table updated • Median Annual Earning table updated • Educational Attainment levels table updated • Income Comparisons Table updated • Household and Family Income Table updated • Cayce Poverty Income Table updated • Conclusions updated Part II. Housing Element • Building Permit Table updated • Housing Trends information updated • Housing Composition information updated • Housing Affordability and Assistance information updated • Trends in housing units table updated • Housing Costs and Values Table for 2008 – 2012 added • 2010 Housing affordability information added to table • City of Cayce Household Characteristics table updated • Occupancy trends Table updated • State Rebate Program for Earth Craft Homes no longer exists Part III. Natural resources element • No Changes Part IV. Cultural Resources Element • No Changes Part V. Community Facilities Element • Number of water system customers updated • Sanitary Sewer System information updated • Wastewater Treatment Facilities table updated • Police protection information updated • Law Enforcement Profile table updated • ISO rating updated • Park and Recreational Facility Inventory updated • Park Standards for Cayce Table updated • Sanitation information updated • Educational Facilities • School Profile, Trends updated table added • Utility Goals CF-5 AMEC added Part VI. Transportation Element • Table 26 Average Daily Traffic updated • Table 27 Traffic Volume Counts updated • CMRTA name changed added • Information on bus route for Cayce updated • TIA requirements updated (Planning Commission action) • Side Walk Plan Map updated Part VII. Economic Element • Labor Force Trends table updated • Employment by Industry table updated • Employment and Labor Force information updated • Chart 6 Major Employment Sectors updated • Table 30 – Carolina Recycling removed • Year corrected in Conclusion #3 Part VIII. Land Use Element • No changes Part IX. Priority Investment Element • Priority Investment Schedule Table 36 updated • Fiscal Year 2008 – 2009 added to pie chart • Revenues and Expenditures pie chart for FY 2013 – 2014 added • TIA requirements updated (Planning Commission action) STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) ) COUNTY OF LEXINGTON ) ) CITY OF CAYCE ) ORDINANCE ADOPTING FIVE - YEAR UPDATE TO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WHEREAS, State law, as contained in the South Carolina Local Government Comprehensive Planning Enabling Act of 1994 (S.C. Code Section 6- 29-510 et seq.), requires, among other things, that the City review and, if desirable, update every five years the City’s Comprehensive Plan, including all planning elements and maps; and WHEREAS, the entire membership of the Planning Commission, at its meeting on August 17, 2015, has voted affirmatively to recommend to the Council adoption of the updated Comprehensive Plan created and attached hereto, with all of its planning elements and maps, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and Council , of the City of Cayce, i n Council, duly assembled, that the updated Comprehensive Plan document attached hereto, including all of its planning elements and its sidewalk plan map and land use map and soil map, is hereby adopted as The Five-Year Update to the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan. This Ordinance shall be effective from the date of second reading approval by Council. DONE IN MEETING DULY ASSEMBLED, this ______ day of _________2015. ______________________________ Elise Partin, Mayor Attest: ______________________________ Mendy Corder, CMC, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _____________________ Second Reading and Adoption: ____________ Approved as to form: __________________________ Danny C. Crowe, City Attorney 1 1 INTRODUCTION This document updates and supersedes all previous planning efforts by the City of Cayce, including the 2007 Plan update. It has been prepared in accord with the requirements of the Comprehensive Planning Act of 1994, as amended through 2007 and is intended to promote within the community public health, safety, morals, convenience, prosperity, general welfare, efficiency, and economy. As such, this Plan is to be used as a guide to the orderly physical, social, and economic growth and future development of Cayce. As per the requirements of the Planning Enabling Act of 1994, Sections 6-29 -310 through 6-29-960, this Plan represents not only a blueprint for future development, but the continuation of a process to guide the orderly development of the community. It is a product of the Cayce Planning Commission, with assistance from a 36 member Ad Hoc Committee, appointed by City Council. It is based, in part, on citizen input derived from an on-line questionnaire regarding community issues, problems, services, assets, opportunities, existing social, economic and environmental conditions, and future planning objectives and goals. Comprehensive planning started in Cayce in 1961, with the development of Cayce’s first Land Use Plan. It focused on the auto-oriented, suburban development trend beginning with the opening of Blossom Street Bridge in 1955. The principal recommendation of that plan was to develop zoning and subdivision regulations, which were developed and subsequently adopted soon thereafter. The plan was updated in 1975, with emphasis this time on annexation, the creation of a distinctive downtown, and more public park land acquisition. The 1975 Plan was actually titled City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan. The next update, in 1980, recommended that the City protect and enhance the Congaree River area and prepare for growth to the south. A subsequent update in 1988 projected most future growth to come through annexation, aided by the opening of the 12th Street Extension exit off the Southeastern Interstate Beltway. 2 The City again updated its Comprehensive Plan in 1994. This effort focused on creating a unique character and sense of place. The planning process that preceded the 1994 Land Use Plan Update was influenced by the work of a Blue Ribbon Land Use Planning Committee -- a group of individuals appointed by City Council -- to provide a cross section of input into the planning process. This group’s work paralleled the efforts of a group of citizens and professionals charged with creating a Strategic Plan for the community entitled Affirm Cayce's Tomorrow (ACT). These two documents served as the basis for the 1999 Plan, which provided the most detailed analysis of the community to date, covering the then required seven elements comprising a comprehensive plan: the economy, population, housing, natural resources, community facilities, cultural resources and land use. The Land Use Plan element of the Comprehensive Plan was reviewed, expanded and readopted in 2007, in the wake of newly proposed annexations. A five (5) year review and update of the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan was conducted in 2015 as required by the South Carolina Planning and Enabling Act of 1994. This document represents the City of Cayce Comprehensive Plan 2010 - 2020 updated in 2015. This Plan consists of nine elements, as required by the 1994 State Act, amended through 2007. (1) Population (2) Housing (3) Economic Development (4) Natural Resources (5) Cultural Resources (6) Community Facilities (7) Land Use (8) Transportation (9) Priority Investment Each of the above elements is addressed in detail as a separate part (chapter) in this document. 3 PART I. POPULATION ELEMENT This initial element of the Comprehensive Plan profiles the City's population. Here, population trends are established and forecast to the year 2020. Age, race and gender data are compiled and analyzed to determine characteristics unique to Cayce. And income distribution and educational attainment levels are studied from a land use planning perspective. Social characteristics are assessed to determine lifestyle and conditions responsible for the way of life in the City of Cayce. DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS AND PROJECTIONS Planning is for people. It follows therefore that an understanding of the p opulation is essential to the planning process. How many people are we planning for? What are the characteristics of the population and how should they be addressed? What might we expect in the way of future population and its characteristics? Historical Perspective Historically, Cayce experienced a steady increase in population and land area in all but one of the last decades since incorporation in 1914. Relatively slow growth occurred between 1920 and 1950. But with completion of the bridge over the Congaree River joining Columbia and Cayce in 1955 growth accelerated. The population more than doubled between 1950 and 1960, increasing nearly ten times that of the three previous decades. 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 YEAR 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Population 4 Between 1980 and 1990, the City’s population declined by 4.8%. This decline turned out to be temporary, as the 2000 census recorded the City’s population at an all-time high of 12,150 - an eight percent increase over 1990. By the 2010 Census, the City’s population had grown to 12,528 – a 3% increase over the 2000 population. Recent Trends and Projections Population gains by the City resulted, in 2005, in a revised population estimate by the South Carolina Department of Budget and Control of 12,414. While representing a gain of 264 persons, it fails to account for the residential building boom during the period from 2000 through 2005, and the city’s aggressive position on annexation, bringing in new development and developing areas. Between 2000 and 2008, the city issued 3,436 building permits, of which 3,331 or 97 percent were residential permits. These residential permits included 337 new dwelling units or approximately 10 percent. The remaining residential permits were for either renovations or additions to existing dwellings. During this period it lost 39 housing units from the existing inventory, according to demolition permits. These data confirm the addition of over 298 dwelling units, or an average of about 33 per year. This increase upped TABLE 1 POPULATION PROFILE, PROJECTIONS 1980 1990 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 City of Cayce 11,701 11,163 12,150 12,528 Low Estimate 12,414 12,680 12,950 13,200 High Estimate 12,740 14,780 19,000 19,360 West Columbia 10,409 10,588 13,064 13,446 14,988 NP NP Lexington Co. 140,353 167,611 216,014 235,221 262,391 274,800 294,510 Cayce % Co. .083 .067 .056 Source: Us Census, selected years. Low 2005 estimate represent US Census Estimates, 2006; County projections by SC Budget and Control. High projection by Vismor & Associates, based on building permits (See Table 9). 5 the City’s housing stock by 5.5 percent in 2008, bringing the total to 5733 units. Based on the number of residential building permits issued, water tap activity, and annexations since 2000, the state’s 2005 population estimate appears to be valid. The state estimate represents 0.4 percent annual average increase between 2000 and 2005 -- projected forward at the same low rate. But local building permit data belie this estimate, indicating a higher rate of growth (See Table 9, New Building Permits). If we assume 93 percent for all housing in the City is occupied, and assign 2.36 persons per occupied household (average household size computed by 2000 Census) - projected downward by 1.1 percent per annum by the U.S. Census - to the increased housing supply, we estimated the 2005 population to be 12,454, and the 2010 population to be 14,780, a 2.6 percent annual average increase between 2000 and 2010. This gave us two estimates: a low estimate by the State of less than one percent per annum and a high of nearly three percent per annum, based on local indicators. In reality, the future population, it was thought, would likely range between 11,701 11,163 12,680 13,20012,150 14,780 19,360 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 CHART 2 POPULATION TRENDS, PROJECTIONS CITY OF CAYCE (2005) Low Estimate High Estimate 6 the two, trending toward the higher estimate and projection. And for purposes of this report and for planning the future of Cayce, the higher projection was used. The underlying growth assumption in 2005 was based on (1) internal “infill” growth and (2) “outside” development demands for city water and sewer service, the supply of which is contingent on annexation. Between 2009 and 2013, the City issued 1,394 building permits of which 1,153 or 83 percent were residential permits. These residential permits included 161 new dwellings. The remaining residential permits were for renovations or additions to existing dwellings. During this period, the City lost approximately 19 housing units from the housing inventory, according to demolition permits. These data confirm an addition of 142 dwelling units or an average of 35.5 new dwellings per year. This figure is slightly lower than the average between 2000 and 2008 but this increase upped the City’s housing stock by 2.4 percent in 2013, bringing the total housing units to 5, 875. Between 2000 and 2005, the population was projected by the State to increase by an average of .4 percent each year and bring the 2010 population up to 12,680. According to the 2010 Census, the population increased by an average of .3 percent from 2000 to 2010. The 2010 Census reports the City’s population as 12, 528. The City’s population has increased by only 378 persons or 3 percent between 2000 and 2010 and did not reach the higher population estimate. The internal infill and outside development demands for City water and sewer service has not had a large impact on the population as previously thought. The infill growth has not occurred at projected rates and annexation requirements for water and sewer service have not been enforced to the fullest extent. DEMOGRAPHIC COMPOSITION In addition to numbers, it is essential to know the make-up of the population from a planning perspective. The principal components are race, age and gender. A discussion of each follows. 7 Racial Composition There has been a gradual change in the racial composition of the City over the last 30 years. From just over 15 percent of the population in 1980, the minority population increased to over 30 percent by 2010. TABLE 2 RACIAL CHARACTERISTICS/TRENDS 1980 1990 2000 2010 Change 1980 - 2010 # Whites % Whites 8,890 84.7 8,838 79.2 9,058 74.6 8,522 68 -368 -4% #African American %African American 1,725 14.7 2,170 19.4 2,734 22.5 3,150 25 1,425 83% #All Other Races % Other Races 76 .6 155 1.4 358 2.9 910 7 834 1097% Source: U. S. Census, Selected years. White 75% African American 22% Other 3% CHART 3 RACIAL DISTRIBUTION, 2000 White 68% African American 25% Other 7% CHART 3a RACIAL DISTRIBUTION, 2010 8 The African American population increased by over 80% percent. Other minorities, led by Hispanics and Asians, increased at an even higher rate (1097 percent). The number of whites increased between 1990 and 2000 but decreased during the following 10 years. Changing population characteristics have resulted in Whites making up less than 68 percent of the total in 2010, compared with nearly 85 percent 30 years earlier. There continues to be a gradual change in the racial composition of the City over the last 30 year. From just over 15 percent of the population in 1980, the minority population increased to over 25 percent by 2000. By 2010, the minority population has continued to increase to 32 percent. The African American population increased by nearly 83 percent. Other minorities increased at a higher rate of over 1000 percent adding 834 persons since 1980. While Whites still compose the majority population, trends point to a more diversified population in the future. From a general planning perspective these changes should have little impact on the future of the City. It is important however to maintain a racially balanced population as the City ponders future annexations so as not to invite interference or invalidation by the U.S. Justice Department. Age Composition The most noteworthy trends taking place in the age of City residents are (1) a decline in the number of young people under the age of 18, and (2) an increase in the number of elderly, 65 and older. 9 From 3,182 persons or nearly 26 percent of the total population in 1980, the under 18 age group dropped to 2,328 or 19 percent of the total by 2010. This contrast to a 77 percent increase in the elderly population (65 and older) and a total population increase for the period of eight percent. By 2010,the elderly population grew from 8.8 percent to 13 percent of the total. The more productive and procreative age group, between 18 and 64 increased slightly, by 4.25 percent, comprising the bulk of the population at about 68 percent. However, it is the shift from young to old that is of concern because of the obvious planning ramifications. At 3,182 persons or nearly 26 percent of the population in 1980, the under 18 age grouped dropped to 2,328 persons or under 20 percent of the total by 2010. The elderly population held an 80 percent increase between 1980 and 2010. The decline in the less than 18 age group may be attributed in large part by changes in child-bearing patterns. In 1957 the number of births per woman was 3.7. It fell to 1.8 by the mid-1970s, and with minor fluctuations has hovered around two per woman over the last 20 years, according to the 2000 U.S Census. This rate is slightly below the long-term replacement level. If not reversed, the decline of the young surely will show up in future population counts, if not off-set by annexation and/or in- migration. TABLE 3 AGE GROUP TRENDS 1980 1990 2000 2010 Change 1980-2010 # Under 18 % Under 18 3,182 26.9 2,503 23.0% 2,516 20.7 2,328 19% -854 -27% # 18-64 % 18-64 7,524 64.3% 7,097 63.0% 7,843 64.6 8,443 68% 919 12% # 65 & over % 65 & over 995 8.8% 1,564 14.0% 1,791 14.7% 1,757 13% 762 77% Median Age 29.8 34.2 36.1 36 21% Source. U.S. Census, Selected Years 10 That the City’s elderly population is increasing is not surprising. This is a national and state-wide trend. People are living longer and many are apparently staying in place as opposed to out- migrating to retirement and resort communities. The Country’s elderly population grew rapidly for most of the 20th century, from 3.1 million in 1900 to 35.0 million in 2000. Except for the 1990s, growth of the elderly has outpaced that of the total population. Moreover, the older population is on the threshold of a boom. According to U.S. Census projections in 2003, a substantial increase in the number of older people will occur during the 2010 to 2030 period, after the first Baby Boomers turn 65 in 2011. The elderly population is projected in 2030 to be twice as large as in 2000, growing from 35 million to 72 million, and representing nearly 20 percent of the total U.S. population. In the next 22 years, the State's elderly population will grow 200 percent faster than the total population, according to Census projections. The U.S. population continues to age. The median age (which divides the population into two groups, half younger and half older) rose from 22.9 in 1900 to 35.3 in 2000, and is projected to increase to 39.0 by 2030. The median age in Cayce was 43.2 years in 2000. The oldest-old population (those 85 and older) was 34 times as large as in 1900, compared with the population aged 65 to 84 that was only 10 times as large. The oldest-old population is projected to grow rapidly after 2030, when the Baby Boomers begin to move into this age group. There is every reason to believe Cayce’s elderly population will mirror or exceed national trends and projections, based on 2000 Census data. 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% 1980 1990 2000 Chart 5 Age Group Trends Under 18 18-64 64+ 11 Contrary to the notion that most elderly retired people migrate to places like Florida and the coast, 85 percent of elder Americans prefer to stay in their homes and never move, according to a survey by AARP. Aging in place is a trend that is here to stay says AARP. Only 13 percent of older people wish to move and the reason generally is to be closer to family as opposed to preference for a resort retirement community. With most older people electing to age in place, Cayce may expect its older population to stay home as well, which apparently has been the case. But staying home does not mean business as usual. A lifestyle change accompanies growing older. And the City should be responsive to the changing needs of its aging population. Two of the principal concerns of the elderly are (1) the environment and (2) housing. In response to these concerns the City should consider and this plan should address the following issues as they relate to the City's enlarging elderly population. Environmental Issues  Transportation - Make getting places easier. Focus on alternatives to private vehicular transportation, i.e. sidewalks, bikeways, and public transit. Require installation of easy to read directional signs, ramps and hand rails in all public buildings.  Social - Increase the variety, accessibility and attractiveness of places where people meet, whether by accident or appointment, including passive parks.  Safety - Focus on different ways to increase safety and crime prevention. 12 Housing Issues Few issues are more fundamental to the quality of life than where and how people live. Housing, one's most immediate physical environment, should be responsive to one's changing social, economic, and physiological characteristics. Housing can and should be made to do this by offering a broad range of options to address the full spectrum of shelter and service needs and the preferences of people throughout their lives. Unfortunately, most residential areas are devoted exclusively to single-family detached housing on fairly large lots. Alternatives to this lifestyle are needed to more fully address the changing needs and preferences of an aging population. Such alternatives should include the following, among others:  Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs)  Accessory Apartments  Shared Housing  Assisted Housing  Congregate Housing  Retirement Housing Projects, Subdivisions  Smaller Housing Units Also critical to the planning of environments and housing more suitable to the elderly population is proximity of housing alternatives to health care facilities and commercial services. Gender Composition As a general rule, the female population is larger than its male counterpart. In 2000, the female population in South Carolina accounted for 51.4 percent of the total. The City of Cayce by comparison had an even higher ratio of females. The City's female population increased gradually from 52.6 percent in 1980 to 53.7 percent of the total by 2000. 13 Nationally, the sexes are about evenly distributed in the pre-teen and teenage years, but with age the ratio generally becomes imbalanced on the female side. While the process is gradual, females at age 65 and over are in a definite majority position. This pattern is prevalent in the City of Cayce where in 2000, females 65 and over comprised 62 percent or nearly two-thirds of the elderly population. This trend has few physical planning implications, except for housing. More people, particularly elderly, of any one sex generally produce more one-person households, favoring smaller units and/or aggregate housing and care facilities. There are obvious social and financial ramifications however with gender imbalance, particularly for females. AARP conducted in 2008 a study entitled Poverty & Aging in America. The study concludes that: 1. “Six in Ten” older persons in poverty are women. 2. Forty-three percent of persons age 50+ living in poverty live alone. 3. Older women are less likely to be in the work force than men of the same age. 4. Total median financial assets of women over 50 in all income groups is approximately half that of men.” These conditions generally are mirrored in housing conditions and living standards, but also show up in health conditions, as persons in poverty or subsisting on low incomes are more likely to have poor health because of inadequate doctor care due to cost. SOCIAL CHARACTERISTICS Suffice to say, there is a positive correlation between land use and the quality of housing, income and education. Higher educated people generally command higher incomes and subsequently reside in higher quality homes and neighborhoods. And these neighborhoods generally reflect positively on the use of land. 14 In South Carolina, as elsewhere, higher education equates to increased earnings with each level of attainment, as illustrated in Table 4-Median Annual Earnings in South Carolina. In 2005 and again in 2010, persons with a high school diploma earned on average 38 percent more than those who do not finish high school. Going to college increased average incomes by 22 percent over those who do not attend. And each step above some college also will result in higher incomes, on average. Recent studies also establish a correlation between education, income and health. The government report, Health, United States, 1998, found that each increase in income and education has a perceptible impact on health. The near poor are, on average, healthier than those living in poverty; middle-income people are healthier than the near poor; and people with high incomes tend to be the healthiest. People with less education and less money TABLE 4 MEDIAN ANNUAL EARNINGS IN SOUTH CAROLINA BY EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT 2005 2012 Education Attainment Level Income % Increase By Education Level Income % Increase By Education Level < High School Graduate $17,510 -- $18,102 High School Graduate 23,315 33 $25,704 42 Some College/Associates Degree 28,527 22 $31,143 21 Bachelor’s Degree 39,635 39 $43,365 39 Graduate or professional degree 49,581 25 $54,018 25 Source: U. S. Census, 2005 American Community Survey, 2012 American Community Survey 15 are more likely to have jobs that do not offer health insurance, and that means less access to health care. Education lengthens life and enhances health. Less-educated adults have higher death rates for all major causes of death, including chronic diseases, infectious diseases and injuries. Education also governs smoking habits. The least educated are twice as likely to smoke as those with more education. Educational Profile Clearly educational attainment levels in Cayce have improved over time. But are they where they should be in this global economy, dependent on an educated and skilled labor market? Educational attainment levels (highest school level completed) of City residents 25 years and older improved greatly between 1990 and 2010. From one in four persons without a high school diploma in 1990, the number dropped to one in five by 2000 and barely changed in 2012. Noteworthy gains ,in 2000 and 2012, TABLE 5 CITY OF CAYCE EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT LEVELS (Persons 25 Years and Older) 1990 2000 2010 Numerical Change 1990 - 2010 Percent Change No. % No. % No. % >Less than 9 th grade 775 10% 393 05% 202 2% -573 -74% 9th – 12th, No Diploma 1,215 16% 1,169 15% 810 10% -405 -33% H.S. diploma, Some college 3,758 50% 4,240 54% 5,029 62% 1,270 34% Associate degree 515 07% 455 06% 761 9% 246 48% Bachelor/Graduat e degree(s) 1,238 17% 1,592 20% 1,296 16% 58 5% Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Census Tape STF3A, Selected Years. 16 also were recorded in the number of persons having attained at least a high school diploma, and the number of persons with bachelor and graduate degrees. By 2010, 10 percent of the 25 plus group have not finished high school and two percent have less than a ninth grade education. M uch of the credit for improved education attainment is due to ready access to educational facilities. In addition to containing two high schools – Brookland-Cayce and Airport – the City is situated geographically between Midlands Technical College and the University of South Carolina. Unfortunately, not everyone has taken advantage of the wealth of educational facilities in the community. With the improvement of educational attainment we may conclude from Table 4, incomes have risen accordingly. All of this translates into higher standards of living and improved quality environs. Income Profile TABLE 6 INCOME COMPARISONS 2000 2010 Cayce South Carolina % State Cayce South Carolina % State Median Household $35,850 $37,082 97% $42, 538 $44,623 95% Median Family $43,500 $44,227 98% $51, 772 $55,058 94% Per Capita $17,745 $18,795 94% $23,355 $23,906 98% Source. Ibid 17 As indicated previously, higher education generally produces higher incomes. And while both have improved since 1990, incomes in Cayce have fallen behind averages for the State. Median household, family and per capita incomes all lagged behind those for the State in 2000 and 2010. A closer look at incomes in Cayce reveals that over one-third of all households and one fourth of all families had, in 2000, incomes less than $25,000 a year. Another third had incomes less than $50,000 a year. Current studies show that, in 2010, the number of households and families with incomes greater than $25,000 has gone up. The number of households and families with $100,000 or more has also increased significantly. In 2000, of the lower income families, 10 percent were determined to have incomes below poverty status. This represents one-tenth of all families in Cayce. The poverty rate for individuals was even higher, at 17 percent. The poverty rate has increased since 2000. In 2010, 14 percent of families and 21 percent of individuals were determined to have incomes below poverty. TABLE 7 CITY OF CAYCE HOUSEHOLD AND FAMILY INCOME 2000 2010 Annual Income # Households % Households # Families % Families # Households % Households # Families % Families < $25,000 1,758 35% 777 25% 1,467 27% 632 22% $25,000 – 49,999 1,661 33% 953 32% 1,710 32% 701 24% $50,000- 99,999 1,372 27% 1,115 36% 1,578 29% 1,004 35% $100,000 plus 260 05% 234 07% 626 12% 553 19% Source. U. S. Census Bureau, Census 2000, SF3, Table P52, Census 2010 18 These data tell us a lot about living conditions in Cayce. While incomes have improved over time, due in part to increased educational attainment levels, they have not kept pace with the State, and much of the population remains burdened by poverty. CONCLUSIONS From the preceding, we may conclude: 1. that the City, with the exception of the 1980s, has enjoyed sustained population growth since incorporation in 1914; 2. that all indications and forecast foretell continued and accelerated population growth in the future, 3. that the racial composition of the community is becoming more diversified, with greater African- American, Asian, Hispanic and other minorities comprising an ever enlarging segment of the population; Table 8 CITY OF CAYCE POVERTY INCOME STATUS 2000 2012 CHANGE BETWEEN 2000 AND 2010 Families 308 10% 390 14% 82 26% With Children under 18 226 15% 601 21% 375 166% With Female Householder, no Husband 181 26% 248 32% 67 37% Individuals 2,032 17% 2,610 21% 578 28% Elderly (65 & older) 143 08% 198 11% 55 38% Related children under 18 484 20% 485 14% 1 .2% Source. US Census Bureau, 2008 – 2012 American Community Survey 19 4. that age composition is changing, with a rapidly growing elderly population and a declining number of young people; 5. that the gender composition is changing, with an enlarging female population, particularly elderly; 6. that educational attainment levels have improved over time, but further improvements are needed, as (in 2000) 20 percent of adults 25 or older still has not finished high school. As of 2012, improvements have occurred – 87 percent of the population possesses a high school diploma or higher education level; 7. that median family, household and per capita incomes in the community have slipped below State averages, albeit increased over time; and 8. that improved income and education attainment aside, poverty still exist for 14 percent of families in Cayce. To address these conditions, the following goals and strategies are established. POPULATION GOALS (PG) AND POLICIES PG-1: Grow the City through annexation, with the objective of forming a more logical and efficient service area. The future demographic and geographic size of the City will depend on economic development and annexation, as in the past. That the City has enacted a growth ordinance requiring annexation in exchange for sewer and water service clearly has aided in the expansion of its boundaries and its population. This is a critical policy, as annexed properties help build the city’s tax base. 20 Policy: In reshaping the future boundaries of the City, a policy concentrating on annexing areas currently receiving water and/or sewer service, and areas in proximity to existing water and sewer lines, is recommended. This will greatly reduce infrastructure cost, one of the major constraints to annexation and the cost to serve annexed areas, while producing a greatly expanded, efficient and logical municipal service area. Also, the City should move to annex the many isolated and surrounded unincorporated properties to enhance efficiency and better define its service area. Service is what cities are all about. Action: Develop an annexation marketing and/or incentive program to encourage annexation of unincorporated islands and/or inward unincorporated areas. Action: Examine opportunities for annexing large scale developments using the State’s 75 Percent Petition and Ordinance Method of Annexation. Action: Update and enforce existing annexation agreements between the City of Cayce and unincorporated property owners. PG-2: Grow the population through job development. Action: Accelerate economic development activity to expand job opportunities within the community (Refer to Part VII, Economic Development). PG-3: Grow the population through quality of life enhancements and resident recruitment. Studies have shown that, in addition to jobs, quality of life issues loom large in the decision making process of prospective new residents, e.g. good schools, good and affordable housing, safe neighborhoods, green communities, cultural and recreational opportunities, etc. These and other quality of life issues are assessed in various parts of this Plan. Their enhancement and promotion are essential to the growth of the community. 21 Action: Move comprehensively to address and enhance quality of life issues, as recommended throughout this Plan and summarized in the Priority Investment Element. Action: Develop a resident recruitment program, targeting younger families, college graduates and business entrepreneurs. Action: Expand the City’s Web site to include a strong resident recruitment element profiling the advantages of living in Cayce and quality of life inducements. PG-4: Create an “Age Sensitive” Community to meet and accommodate changes in age and gender composition of City residents. The focus here is on developing more facilities and programs, and providing more housing alternatives and opportunities for an enlarging elderly population. With the vast majority of the elderly staying put as opposed to migrating to retirement communities, retrofitting the community to better address the needs of the elderly is critical. Policy: In light of this situation, the following action is recommended to make the City more age sensitive. Implementation of such programs is recommended as an on-going activity, designed to: Action: Provide a diversity of housing alternatives. This should include apartments, townhouses, small and large single-family residences, modular homes, accessory apartments and condominiums, all available at a range of costs. Ideally, diversity should be found throughout the City, and in most neighborhoods. The ready availability of affordable housing alternatives in one's own neighborhood will enable older people to make adjustments without leaving their community and foregoing all the relationships they have established over time. 22 Action: Provide pedestrian and/or public transportation linkages. The environment within which a person operates needs to be viewed as a series of links from one place to another. If this environment is only partially accessible, then it is essentially inaccessible to someone who is age impaired. In the absence of adequate sidewalks, a resident in a well-designed assisted care housing project or neighborhood may be unable to reach a nearby park or other social or commercial outlet without a car. The ability of older persons to maintain their independence is dependent on linkages, as recommended by the Sidewalk Plan in the Transportation element of this report. Action: Adapt the environment to meet changing needs of the elderly. Universal design is a significant innovation within the housing sector; the same approach should be applied to the community at large in building design, site planning, and land uses. A long-term perspective should take into account the reuse and adaptability of schools to serve the needs of the elderly as senior centers or senior housing and converted back as necessary. Also, parks should be redesigned to emphasize passive recreation opportunities, more attuned to the needs of the elderly. PG-5 Raise the Educational Attainment of All Adults to or above that of a high school education. Dedication to improving education and subsequently improving earning power and the environment in which one resides is not the sole responsibility of the school district. It will take the combined efforts and support of the community, both financially and politically. Toward this end, the following action is recommended. Action: Initiate a campaign to emphasize the importance of education and parental involvement in the process, and 23 Action: Work with Midlands TECH and Lexington School District #2 to increase participation in adult education programs leading to GED diplomas. Provide incentives to encourage greater participation in adult education programs. 24 PART II. HOUSING ELEMENT The housing element is one of the principal components of a Comprehensive Plan. It is a measure of lifestyle, and an indicator of land use and environmental conditions. The City's housing stock is its habitat. It is therefore essential to study and plan for housing improvements, protection, and expansion to meet future demands as part of the comprehensive planning process. HOUSING TRENDS The U. S. Census reported 5,435 housing units in the City of Cayce in 2000. In 1990, the reported number of housing units was 4,654, an increase of 781 units or an annual average increase of about 78 per year. In 2010, the reported number of housing units in the City of Cayce was 5,834 – an increase of 399 units since 2000 or an average 0f 36 units per year. Since 2000, construction of new housing has continued to increase. The City issued 498 permits for new single family residential dwellings between 2000 and 2013, averaging 36 permits a year. It also issued 39 demolition permits during this period. This substantially higher rate of growth in new housing was the primary basis upon which a higher population forecast is based. TABLE 9 BUILDING PERMITS, 2000-2013 Year Issued Single- Family Multi- family Mobile Home Commercial Total 2000 541 (6) 15 1 14 571 2001 399 (8) 2 2 24 427 2002 276 (15) 1 1 16 294 2003 314 (14) 1 1 12 328 2004 305 (40) 3 3 14 325 2005 369 (46) 2 2 10 383 2006 344 (52) 1 1 12 358 2007 360 (96) 2 2 2 366 2008 379 (60) 2 2 1 384 2009 214(39) 0 2 61 277 2010 225(16) 1 3 41 270 2011 209(18) 1 1 54 265 2012 255(50) 1 2 37 295 2013 237(38) 1 1 48 287 Total 4427 33 24 346 4,830 Source: City of Cayce, Planning and Building Department, 12-2013 25 Although the housing stock has continued to increase with new single family homes since 2009, the higher population forecast has not been met. HOUSING COMPOSITION Single-family detached homes account for a majority of the housing in Cayce. In 1990, 2000 and again in 2010, they comprised 75 percent of the housing stock. The stability of the single-family market in Cayce is somewhat surprising because higher density alternatives such as apartments, townhouses, manufactured houses and condominiums have made significant inroads into the national housing market over the last 10 to 30 years. Yet, such housing accounts for only one quarter of the housing in Cayce, and less than one percent of the residential building permits issued since the 2000 Census. Furthermore, in 2013, single family detached homes still comprised 75% of Cayce’s housing stock. 161 new single family homes have been built between 2009 and 2013 with the construction of the Concord Park Subdivision. This is not to say multi-family and manufactured housing have not increased. The U.S. Census recorded a 23 percent increase in such housing between 1990 and 2000, with the addition of 245 units in 2000, the issuance of 44 multi-family and manufactured housing permits since 2000, and the annexation in 2008 of 195 multi-family units in “The Retreat“. No other multi-family housing units have been built since 2009 but multi-family developments may be on the rise. Otarre Pointe Apartments are scheduled to be completed in the Fall of 2015 and will bring 299 19% 6% 75% CHART 4 Housing Distribution, 2000 Multi Family Manufactured Single-Family 26 units. Developers are restructuring the Westwood Mobile Home Community to make it more appealing to prospective buyers. Most alternatives to single-family detached dwellings are driven by economics and changing lifestyles. Cayce’s future housing stock probably will reflect these changes in time, and the City will be challenged to provide alternatives to its predominately single-family housing stock. Future housing proposals are likely to be mixed use with varying densities and housing types, including small-lot cluster development, townhouses, patio homes, etc., particularly with the increasing demand for university housing and the push of the University toward and beyond the Congaree River to Cayce. Change rarely occurs without problems, however, particularly from a land use perspective. Juxtaposition of alternative housing in a single-family housing environment has not always produced favorable results. Alternative housing often is considered incompatible to single-family environs because of density, design and attendant traffic, particularly lower income housing. That these issues be addressed and resolved is essential to an orderly development process, environmental compatibility, and quality of life. While housing composition and lifestyles are changing, change need not be disruptive to those who have invested in a single-family lifestyle. If properly harnessed and planned, change in the housing market may be accommodated without compromising prevailing environmental conditions - single-family residential, historical or scenic natural areas. In addressing change, the city must remain cognizant of its impact on the “built environment”. It is critical to the future of the City that the impact is tempered to the extent possible to provide growth and affordable housing opportunities, often associated with such housing, while preserving the history and ambience of the community and its neighborhoods. 27 Clearly, "compatibility" is the key. Careful land use planning is needed to ensure that these inherent differences between housing types do not have a negative impact, perceived or in reality, on the built environment, if alternative housing projects are to play a more significant role in meeting future housing needs and preferences in Cayce. HOUSING AFFORDABILITY AND ASSISTANCE NEEDS The goal of the National Affordable Housing Act of 1990 is that "every American family be able to afford a decent home in a suitable environment". But what constitutes affordability? Table 10 TRENDS IN HOUSING UNITS Units in Structure 1990 2000 2010 Number % Number % Number % 1, Detached 3,547 75% 4,049 75% 4187 74% 1, Attached 49 1% 83 1% 58 1% Multi-Family 2 - 4 597 13% 474 9% 539 9% 5 - 9 178 4% 80 1% 228 4% 10 + 13 1% 439 8% 485 9% Manufactured homes 270 6% 310 6% 190 3% Total 4,654 100% 5,435 100% 5687 100% 28 According to the 2000 Census, housing values or the cost of housing in Cayce is modest by comparison with the County as a whole, but generally on par with the State average (Table 11). Seventy-four percent of owner- occupied housing in Cayce was valued in 2000, at less than $100,000 compared with 45 percent in the county. The City also had over twice the rate of homes valued at less than $50,000 than the county. Only two percent of the City's owner- occupied dwellings were valued above $200,000, compared with 13 percent in the county and statewide. The median value of housing in the City is 76 percent of that of the County and 85 percent of that of the State. On the surface, this would appear to put most of the housing in Cayce in the affordable category. Table 11 Housing Costs and Values, City of Cayce, 2000 Owner-Occupied Units Cayce South Carolina Lexington County Unit Value # Units Ratio Ratio Ratio Less than $50,000 365 12 13 05 $50,000 - 99,999 1,839 62 41 40 100,000 - 149,999 565 20 22 29 150,000 - 199,999 131 04 11 13 200,000 plus 58 02 13 13 Median value City of Cayce; $81,000 Median Value Lexington County: $106,3000 Median Value State of South Carolina: $94,900 Source. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Census, 2000. 29 In the 2008 – 2012 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimate, 33% of houses in the City were valued at less than $100,000. The rate of owner-occupied dwellings valu ed above $200,000 increased to 13% and the median value of housing in the City is 85% of that of the County and 86% of that of the State (Table 11a). Rental housing rates in Cayce, like owner-occupied housing values, generally are lower than those in the County and the State by about five percent, but are they affordable rates? Calculating Affordability Affordability is perhaps the most important factor driving the housing market. The market must be in tune with the marketplace if it is to meet the demand for housing in Cayce. This means matching housing costs with household incomes of existing and perspective householders. As a general rule, affordability is calculated by lending institutions on the basis of the "two and a half" rule. That is, affordability is based generally on housing costs not exceeding two and a half times gross household income. Using this measure, Table 12 establishes housing cost and rental ranges for households based on income ranges, generally at two and a half to one. The HUD formula or definition of affordability is similar to the above rule. “Affordable housing, defined in Section 6-29-1110 of the S. C. Code of Laws, as amended, means in the case of dwelling units for sale, Table 11.a Housing Costs and Values, City of Cayce, 2008-2012 Owner-Occupied Units Cayce South Carolina Lexington County Unit Value # Units Ratio Ratio Ratio Less than $50,000 217 7 14 11 $50,000 - 99,999 833 26 21 18 100,000 - 149,999 1325 42 20 27 150,000 - 199,999 387 12 16 17 200,000 plus 425 13 30 27 Median value City of Cayce; $115,600 Median Value Lexington County: $136,800 Median Value State of South Carolina: $134,100 Source. U.S. Census Bureau, 2008-2012 American Community Survey 30 housing in which mortgage amortization, taxes, insurance, and condominium or association fees, if any, constitute no more than twenty-eight percent of the annual household income for a household earning no more than eighty percent of the area median income, by household size, for the metropolitan statistical area as published from time to time by the U. S. Department of Housing and Community Development (HUD) and, in the case of dwelling units for rent, housing for which the rent and utilities constitute no more than thirty percent of the annual household income for a household earning no more than eighty percent of the area median income, by household size for the metropolitan statistical area as published from time to time by HUD.” As with most rules, there are exceptions. Some householders pay more than the rule, while some pay less. But the vast majority generally fall in line with the affordability ranges shown on the Housing Affordability Matrix, Table 12. Using the HUD formula for calculating housing affordability, in 2010, over 20 percent of the householders of owner occupied dwellings in Cayce pay in excess of 28 percent of household income for housing, and 34 percent of all renters pay in excess of 30 percent. However, not all of these households pay in excess of what they can afford. Eighty percent of median household income in the Columbia Metropolitan Statistical Area was $38,649 in 2010, compared with $42,538 in median household income in Cayce. Thus, over one-half of all households met the 80 percent income threshold, discounting household size. This being the case, it is estimated that 14 to 20 percent of all Cayce households qualify for housing assistance, based on the HUD definition of Table 12 Housing Affordability Matrix Household Income Range Affordable Purchase Price Range Affordable Rental Range (Monthly) Less than $10,000 Less than $25,000 Less than $167 $10,000-19,000 $25,000-49,999 $167-349 20,000-29,999 50,000-74999 350-499 30,000-39,999 75,000-99,999 500-649 40,000-49,999 100,000-124,999 650-834 50,000-59,999 125,000-149,999 835-1,164 60,000-74,999 150,000-199,999 1,165-1,499 75,000-99,999 200,000-249,999 1,500 or more 100,000-124,999 250,000-299,999 125,000 300,000 31 what constitutes housing affordability. The Cayce Housing Authority had on file in 2009 an active waiting list of 290 applications for assisted housing. HOUSEHOLD COMPOSITION Nationally, over the last several decades the number of households has increased at a higher rate than the population. The reason for this has been a sustained reduction in the size of households. In 2008, the U.S. Census reported the lowest ever average number of persons per household at 2.67 nationally. From 1970 to 2000, the average size of households in Cayce declined by 29 percent. The result is almost one fewer person per household in 2000 than 1970. Reduction in the average size of families was not as sharp, at 14 percent. Households include all persons who occupy a housing unit, but not all households are composed of families. A family by definition consists of a householder and one or more other persons living in the same TABLE 13 HOUSING AFFORDABILITY, 2000 (2010) Gross Rent/ Owner Costs As Percentage of Household Income # Rental Households % Rental Households # Owner Households % Owner Households Less than 15% 366 (161) 21% (08%) 1,255 (1272) 42% (39%) 15 to 19% 218 (334) 13% (10%) 580 (604) 19% (18%) 20 to 24% 246 (282) 14% (13%) 338 (369) 11% (11%) 25 to 29% 192 (195) 11% (09%) 274 (277) 09% (08%) 30 to 34% 134 (125) 08% (06%) 173 (222) 06% (07%) 35% or more 435 (893) 26% (43%) 349 (526) 12% (16%) Source. U. S. Bureau of Census, 2000; DP-4 Profile of Selected Characteristics; Source. U. S. Bureau of Census, 2006 – 2010 ACS 32 household who are related to the householder by birth, marriage or adoption. A household can also contain only one person. In the City of Cayce, 3,081 of 5,133 total households or 60 percent of all households are family households. The remaining 40 percent are non-family households, of which 29 percent are one-person households and 10.8 percent are comprised of householders 65 years and older, according to the 2000 Census. Shrinking household size would normally equate to a preference for smaller housing units. This seems not to be the case in Cayce. Fifty percent of all housing in the City has six or more rooms. This may change to smaller units in time however. Future households, as well as families, are projected to further decline in size, but at a slower rate, about 1.1 percent annually based on national trends and projections by the U.S. Census. This will produce in 2010, 2.31 persons per household; in 2015, 2.26 persons per household; and in 2020, 2.2 persons per household. Household downsizing is the result of a combination of things, including declining birth rates, an aging population and more one person households, increased divorces and separations, and delayed marriages. TABLE 14 HOUSEHOLD CHARACTERISTICS, CITY OF CAYCE 1970-2010 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Persons Per Family 3.34 3.17 2.98 2.89 2.91 Persons Per Household 3.30 2.74 2.49 2.36 2.34 1970-1980 1980-1990 1990-2000 2000-2010 Persons Per Household % Change -18% -09% -05% -01% 33 Future household composition is projected nationally to increase among four basic groups, as follows: Percent Elderly family households 25% Non-family households 30 Husband-wife family households 25 Single-parent family households 20 If we assume that national household projections offer reasonable estimates of probable trends in the City of Cayce, changes in the number of households by type may be extrapolated in the form of "internally generated" households i.e. households formed from the existing population base via marriage, divorce, separation, children leaving home, etc. Also, household growth will result from net in-migration i.e. households moving into the area. The composition of those moving into the City should differ significantly from internally generated households, as indicated by the following distribution pattern. Percent Elderly family households 05% Non-family households 23 Husband-wife family households 69 Single-parent family households 03 In summary, the Plan should take into account the projected growth of households and projected household composition to more accurately predict future housing needs in the community. OCCUPANCY CHARACTERISTICS The majority of housing in Cayce is owner-occupied. Home ownership increased by 13 percent between 1990 and 2000. Home mortgage issues in 2008 and 2009 aside, home ownership remains high in Cayce. In 2010, the number of rental occupied units continued to increase due to overall growth of the housing supply. The vacancy rate increased as well, from five to eight percent. 34 The fact that owner occupancy is relatively high and stable is a good sign, as it represents community vesting, which translates generally into better maintained homes and neighborhoods. HOUSING CONDITIONS Housing conditions fall generally into four categories: (1) standard (requiring no major modifications or improvements, (2) needing minor repair, (3) substandard (needing major repair), and (4) dilapidated. A substandard house is one with structural deficiencies and/or one without complete plumbing and/or kitchen facilities. Something as basic as plumbing and complete kitchen facilities are viewed in this day and time as standard components in all homes. Unfortunately, there is not an adequate measure for determining the extent to which these conditions exist in Cayce in 2009. The 2000 Census reported 38 homes without complete kitchen facilities and 17 dwellings without complete plumbing facilities. The U.S Census does not evaluate or statistically record the extent of substandard structures. In the absence of Census data and individual housing inspections, it is not possible to assess with a high degree of accuracy structural conditions of the City’s housing stock. However, there are some indices, in addition to the absence of plumbing, complete kitchen facilities, housing values, and visual inspection which may be used to evaluate and quantify housing conditions in the community. Table 15 Occupancy Trends Housing 1990 2000 2010 Number Percent Number Percent Number Percent Owner-Occupied 2,991 64 3,364 61 3245 56 Renter-Occupied 1,444 31 1,769 32 2109 36 Vacant 286 05 384 07 480 8 Source. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Census, General Housing Characteristics, Selected Years.+ 35 The U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) conducted a study and produced a publication May 2001, entitled: Barriers to the Rehabilitation of Affordable Housing, Volume I. This publication investigates and estimates the extent of substandard housing conditions nationally. The publication profiles and estimates the need for rehabilitation intervention by race of occupants, tenure, and age of housing. By applying the findings of this study to the City of Cayce, using 2000 Census data, we are able to estimate the number of substandard housing units in the City at that time, the severity of housing conditions and the need for rehabilitation, e.g. Minor, Moderate, or Major. While definitions of what constitutes needed repairs may vary, minor repairs include such things as painting, repairing shutters, replacing screens, etc.; moderate facilities, etc.; and major improvements extend to structural improvements. 3,0681,637 490 240 Chart 5 Rehabilitation Needs By Age of Housing Sound Minor Rehab Moderate Rehab Major Rehab 36 One of the key indicators used for determining housing conditions was “age of housing”. Older homes are more likely to pose fire hazards, have dangerous code violations, have lead paint, or be structurally deficient in some way. Four percent of Cayce’s housing stock, or 195 units were built prior to 1940. While this is not a condemnation of all older homes, it is an indicator of possible substandard conditions based on age. Where such housing exists, the potential for becoming substandard and the cost of maintenance generally are greater Of the 5,435 housing units reported for Cayce by the 2000 Census, we estimate 240 or 4.4 percent require major rehabilitation; 490 housing units or 9.0 percent need moderate rehabilitation; and 1,637 or about 30 percent can make do with only minor rehabilitation, based on age of housing (Table 16). Table 16 Estimated Rehabilitation Need, Occupied Housing, By Property Profile, 2000 Property Profile Minor Rehab. Moderate Rehab. Major Rehab. Total Rehab. % No. % No. % No. % No. Tenure Renter Occupied 30.4 538 12.3 218 5.6 99 48.3 855 Owner Occupied 30.6 1,029 8.7 293 4.3 145 43.6 1,467 Race White 30.5 2,763 8.7 788 4.1 371 43.3 3,922 Black & Other 30.0 899 19.1 572 7.9 237 57.0 1,708 Age of Unit 1980-2000 29.0 418 5.4 78 2.6 46 36.9 542 1970-1979 30.6 255 7.6 63 3.9 32 42.0 350 1940-1969 30.4 902 10.8 320 5.0 148 46.2 1,370 Before 1940 32.0 62 14.8 29 7.3 14 54.0 105 All 30.0 1,637 9.0 490 4.4 240 43.6 2,367 Source: HUD, Barriers to The Rehabilitation Of Affordable Housing, Volume I, Exhibit 2.2, May, 2001. Cayce Census data, 2000. Calculations by Vismor and Assoc. 37 Somewhat greater need for rehabilitation or degree of substandard conditions exist in rental housing, as opposed to owner occupied housing, 48.3 percent compared to 43.6 percent. Substandard housing conditions are among the highest for units occupied by African-Americans and other minorities than for units occupied by Whites. An estimated 54 percent of all housing built before 1940 (105 units) require some type of rehabilitation, about 10 percent more than the figure cited for all housing. Over seven percent of the pre-1940 housing stock is in need of major repair, compared with only 2.6 percent of all housing built after 1980. Additionally, most existing housing and buildings in the community were constructed without regard to “green building design” – incorporating efficiency and conservation of energy and water in the design, construction and operation of buildings. As such, they too, may be considered substandard by today’s standards. Green building design is intended to reduce environmental impact through energy-efficient materials, solar systems, and water conservation technique, including storm water management techniques. With emphasis on green building design, the city is challenged to assist in retrofitting its housing stock and ensuring green building design in new homes and subdivisions. In summary, housing conditions have improved over the last several Census surveys, based on plumbing and kitchen facility indicators, but there is still work to be done. The City has yet to meet the goal of the "National Affordable Housing Act of 1990", that every American family be able to afford a decent home in a suitable environment. HOUSING PROJECTIONS What does the housing industry hold in store for Cayce? Based on the population forecast (Table 1, High Estimate) and further projected declines in the size of households, the future looks positive 38 HOUSING FORECAST Forecasts, by Vismor and Associates, through the year 2020 show an increase of nearly 1,600 new housing units. This forecast is based on population growth projections primarily through annexation, development of tract property, and in-fill development. The increase should continue to outdistance population growth, based not only on decreasing household size, but construction of replacement housing lost from inventory over time (between ½ and one percent per decade). The City may be well on its way to reach this forecast. With construction of Concord Park Subdivision and in-fill development, the City’s housing supply is sure to increase. CONCLUSIONS From the preceding we may conclude that: (1) the housing market is changing and the City is challenged to adjust to these changes while protecting both its built and natural environment; (2) the size of households is shrinking, giving rise to potential changes in the size of housing, and accelerating the need for housing; TABLE 17 HOUSING FORECAST CITY OF CAYCE 2010 2015 2020 Total Additional Population 1,020 2,000 2,000 5,020 Household Size 2.31 2.26 2.20 Additional Housing Units 10% Vacancy Total New Units 442 +42 484 885 +88 973 910 +91 1,001 1,578 Source: Vismor & Associates, Inc. 39 (3) owner-occupancy is constant -- an indication of neighborhood stability; (4) housing values and conditions in the City generally are comparable to state averages but lower than County averages; (5) nearly one in five households is below poverty income level; (6) the net increase in housing has been greater since 2000, than in the previous two decades; (7) housing affordability is a problem for 14 to 20 percent of all householders in Cayce; and (8) technically 40 percent of all housing in Cayce requires some degree of repair, 4.4 percent of which requires major rehabilitation. However approximately 55 percent of all existing housing since 2000 has undergone some type of repair, therefore 20 percent may be a more realistic estimate. HOUSING GOALS (HG) AND POLICIES HG-1: Protect the “built environment” while accommodating a changing housing market. A changing housing market and annexation of developed residential areas will bring into the City a greater mix of housing. This, in turn, will heighten the need for more comprehensive development regulations and a full complement of development options (tools) to meet ever changing housing market forces. 40 Action: Amend Zoning Ordinance to include provisions for “development agreements”. Currently the City relies on zoning and land development regulations to assure orderly development. Its most effective tool for large scale residential projects is the Planned Development District (PDD) in the zoning ordinance. The PDD permits flexibility of development and ensures land use compatibility by requiring plan review and approval by the Planning Commission and City Council and rezoning, following a public hearing. An additional development tool, and one recommended for inclusion in the Zoning Ordinance, is a “Development Agreement”. This type of agreement, if required as a condition to development of large scale projects (greater than 25 acres) could be used to exact conditions acceptable to the City (Council) while providing greater flexibility and assurances to the developer. In addition, the process could be concluded without rezoning in some instances. Action: Amend the Zoning Ordinance to allow use of the PDD on large undeveloped tracts prior to a development proposal. This would institute complete land use flexibility for the developer/owner, but would subject all project proposals within the designated district to public hearings, and review and approval by the Planning Commission. Projects greater than 25 acres could be required, as a condition for approval, to enter into a contractual agreement with the City Council. Action: Amend the Zoning Ordinance to allow for “Cluster Development” Cluster developments are permitted within the PDD and would be permitted in a Contractual Agreement between the City and the Developer. It still may be helpful, however, to specifically detail in the Zoning Ordinance the standards and conditions for cluster development within the City. 41 HG-2: Increase the Supply of Affordable, Structurally Sound Low to Moderate Income Housing. Household poverty and substandard conditions in certain parts of the community indicate that financial assistance will be needed to meet the goal of the National Affordable Housing Act of 1990, that "every American family be able to afford a decent home in a suitable environment". Without getting into the need for and economic aspects of generating additional higher paying jobs and improving job skills and educational levels, the objectives of this goal are: (1) To increase the supply of new affordable housing, including public housing and (2) To renovate and make affordable existing housing in need of repair, including public housing. Policy: There are several strategies for expanding the supply and quality of affordable housing that can be applied within the City of Cayce. Given the scope of affordable housing needs, it is recommended to apply a combination of strategies for maximum effectiveness. In addition to pursuing multiple tools to encourage affordable housing, it is also important to work with adjacent local governments and regional entities in order to address housing needs on a regional scale. This regional approach helps to avoid concentrating low-income housing in a single community or neighborhood. Action: Initiate Voluntary Inclusionary Zoning “Inclusionary zoning” involves regulations that seek to encourage the development and maintenance of affordable housing within a given community. While mandatory set asides of affordable housing are not permitted under South Carolina law, incentives for affordable housing within new developments may be a valuable tool for increasing the stock of low-cost housing. The term inclusionary stands in contrast to exclusionary zoning regulations, which are sometime enacted by communities seeking to exclude low- income housing. 42 Another successful strategy for implementing inclusionary zoning is to provide options for developers to donate money to build affordable housing units or build affordable housing off site from their development. The most common alternatives to onsite construction are “in-lieu of fees” and land dedications. Also, developers are sometimes permitted to build affordable housing off-site or receive credit for excess affordable units built in previous projects. Retention of affordable housing stock is one of the most important elements of an inclusionary zoning program. Monitoring and compliance mechanisms are necessary in order to track affordable units within mixed-income developments. Requirements for long-term maintenance as affordable units can prevent owners and landlords from reselling or re-renting units at market rate. Most inclusionary zoning systems do allow for affordable units to be eventually converted to market-rates. Action: Provide Developer Incentives Developer Incentives provide a market-based mechanism for encouraging the construction of affordable housing. Many of these incentives may be included within an inclusionary zoning ordinance. Density bonuses are the most common form of compensation for affordable housing requirements. These bonuses allow developers to build at higher density than residential zones typically permit in exchange for the inclusion of affordable units within the development. Alternately, the developer may be permitted to purchase density credits by paying into a local housing trust fund. Design flexibility is another method of encouraging developers to offer affordable housing. It is important for affordable housing units to fit within the context of their surrounding neighborhoods. Mixed-income developments should strive to have assisted housing units be indistinguishable from market-rate units. One such regulatory tool is to require identical or similar exteriors while allowing variations in internal features in order to facilitate financial feasibility for developers. Also, it is important that design guidelines within a zoning ordinance do not add excessive costs to construction and maintenance of housing. 43 Another developer incentive is the provision of fee waivers, which reduce or waive the fees levied on new development projects where affordable housing is included. Regulations may be set up to reimburse permit fees to a builder upon certification that the dwelling unit is affordable. Tap-on fees for public utilities such as water and sewer may also be reduced for affordable housing developments. Fast track permitting provides another possible incentive for developers to include affordable housing. This system can expedite affordable housing developments to help reduce costs and time delays in the construction permitting process. Action: Cooperate With and Assist Affordable Housing Providers There are a number of agencies and programs operating within the community designed to assist low-to- moderate income families in obtaining decent housing, including rental assistance agencies and programs. Community Development Block Grant Program The Federal Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program was established in 1974 when a series of categorical assisted housing programs were effectively folded into a block grant directly to larger urban areas and to states for distribution to smaller places. The grants are restricted to benefiting lower income persons. Grants are not restricted to housing, but the fact that the source of initial funding superseded housing programs established a political claim in favor of housing uses. HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME) The HUD HOME program provides formula grants to States and localities that communities use—often in partnership with local nonprofit groups—to fund a wide range of activities that build, buy, and/or rehabilitate affordable housing for rent or homeownership or provide direct rental assistance to low-income people. 44 HOME is the largest Federal block grant to State and local governments designed exclusively to create affordable housing for low-income households. HOME funds are awarded annually as formula grants to participating jurisdictions. HUD establishes HOME Investment Trust Funds for each grantee, providing a line of credit that the jurisdiction may draw upon as needed. The program's flexibility allows States and local governments to use HOME funds for grants, direct loans, loan guarantees or other forms of credit enhancement or rental assistance or security deposits. Public Housing Program The City of Cayce established in the early 1980s a 5-member Public housing Authority. The Authority works in concert with the Columbia Housing Authority, which provides full-time staff assistance to the Cayce Housing Authority. Currently, the Authority operates and maintains 40 units of public housing on scattered sites throughout the community. The Authority maintains a two percent vacancy rate at its 40 units and a waiting list of 290 applicants. This places a premium on affordable housing. In response the Agency is dedicated to exploring all opportunities to increase the supply of affordable housing through acquisition of Section 8 vouchers, construction or renovation, as well as different options. Unfortunately all of this is dependent on the availability of federal funds. Assisted Ownership Programs The State Housing Authority offers up to $4,000 to assist eligible borrowers with down payments and closing cost. Habitat for Humanity builds new homes for low-to -moderate income persons with an investment of “sweat equity”. There are many other resources as well, all of which should be investigated and made available to low-to-moderate income families in Cayce. 45 Housing Trust Fund Housing Trust Funds are distinct funds established by legislation, ordinance, or resolution that dedicate sources of public revenue to support affordable housing. Housing Trust Fund programs are designed locally to address specific housing needs within the community. The Trust Fund program is administered in South Carolina by the State Housing Finance, and Development Authority. HUD Section 202 and 811 Programs These programs are designed to assist low income seniors and persons with disabilities. They offer interest-free capital advances to nonprofit organizations that will produce accessible housing, subsidiz e rents, and provide supportive services, which, in turn, will enable qualifying participants to live independently. These funds, including 650 million available in 2009, are available for funding construction, acquisition, and rehabilitation of multifamily developments. The program subsidizes the rents of senior citizens in a way that limits residents’ housing costs to 30 percent of their incomes. The funds will be invested primarily in smaller, newly constructed residences, typically group homes or condominium units. Policy: Scattered Site Policy for Affordable housing The Cayce Housing Authority recognized that the location of affordable assisted housing can create problems of community acceptance when built in project settings. It opted instead for locating its 40 units of public housing on scattered sites. A scattered site policy is further recommended for any additional or future assisted housing to make it more acceptable to the community and compatible with its surroundings, to wit:. 46 (1) Such housing should be located on "scattered sites", as opposed to concentrations or "project settings". (2) Such housing should be designed for compatibility to blend with its proposed surroundings. (3) Such housing should be geographically dispersed to provide for "location preference". Action: Rehabilitate Existing Substandard Housing The City has been actively involved over several years in the renovation and rehabilitation of structurally deficient homes, with assistance from the Community Development Block Grant Program as well as the HOME program. Continued participation in these programs is strongly recommended as a means of salvaging existing housing stock and improving housing conditions. Also, CLG (Certified Local Government) grants and Historic Rehabilitation Grants could prove helpful. Action: Initiate systematic code enforcement program, targeting substandard rental units. Deteriorating and neglected rental housing was one of the major land use issues cited in the Citizen Survey conducted for the Comprehensive Plan. HG-3: Protect and Maintain Existing Supply of Quality Housing. Most of the City's housing is structurally sound, secured in stable residential environs, and protected by zoning regulations. The goal here is to ensure the long-term maintenance of such conditions and environs. Action: Identify through the planning process all stable neighborhoods and apply and maintain appropriate protective residential zoning. Condition any change to such zoning on compliance with or 47 amendment of the Comprehensive Plan. This strategy establishes a definitive link between the plan and applicable zoning regulations. HG-4: Increase Development of Infill Housing and Make More Infill Sites Available By Razing Dilapidated Structures. Most vacant lots are located in fully facilitated neighborhoods, e.g. sidewalks, parks, street lighting, proximity to cultural resources, etc. These sites are also in receipt of all City services and infrastructure, and are primed for development. Additionally, most of Cayce’s seriously deteriorated and dilapidated dwellings are located in the same general areas, providing redevelopment and infill opportunities once they are removed. Currently, the City is issuing demolition permits for about five substandard dwellings a year, on average. This translates into a like number of additional infill sites per annum, which could be increased with stepped-up or more intensified inspections. Action: Waive or prorate water and sewer connection or tap fees on in-fill lots. Action: Accelerate inspection and removal of dilapidated dwellings and structures to rid the City of unwanted blight and create more infill sites for new housing. HG-5: “Green” the community’s housing stock, by retrofitting existing housing and ensuring in the development of future housing, energy and conservation design techniques. Action: Provide assistance for installation of “green” techniques, by making property owners and developers aware of the following incentive programs. 48 Corporate Tax Credit Biomass Energy Tax Credit Solar Energy Tax Credit (Corporate) Personal Tax Credit Energy Efficient Manufactured Homes Incentive Tax Credit Solar Energy Tax Credit (Personal) Production Incentive Biomass Energy Production Incentive Palmetto Clean Energy (PaCE) Program Sales Tax Exemption Sales Tax Cap on Energy Efficient Manufactured Homes Sales Tax Exemption for Hydrogen Fuel Cells State Loan Program Conser Fund Loan Program Action: Amend the Zoning ordinance to include conservation and green building design provisions. Action: Apply for grant from the 2009 Stimulus Fund to retrofit and make more energy efficient the city’s supply of public housing. 49 PART III. NATURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT This element of the Comprehensive Plan consists of an inventory and assessment of the community’s natural resources and consideration of their role in relation to the general welfare and future development of the community. Principal among the City's natural resources are wetlands, floodways, canopy trees, topography, soil composition, and climatic conditions. An assessment of each follows. GEOGRAPHIC PROFILE One of Cayce’s principal resources is its location. The city of Cayce is located in the eastern portion of Lexington County along the Congaree River. It is flanked on the north by the cities of West Columbia and Springdale, on the west by the towns of South Congaree and Pineridge and on the east by the Congaree River and City of Columbia. To the south lies a large expanse of unincorporated and relatively undeveloped land. The Congaree River was the primary reason for early settlement of the area. It provided a means of transportation, later enhanced by the construction of the Cayce Canal. This, in turn, led to the construction of a rail yard and rail transportation to move goods to and from the low-country via the canal to the upstate. The canal and rail yard aided in the exploitation of underlying granite deposits which led to the development of the Cayce quarry in 1896. The quarry remains active today. In addition to its earlier contribution to transportation, the river serves today as the water source for the City and recreation source for its citizens and visitors to the area. As such, the River is one of the driving forces of development. 50 CLIMATE Cayce has a temperate climate, characterized by ample rainfall in all seasons, short and usually mild winters and long warm summers. The total annual precipitation is about 47 inches and is fairly evenly distributed among the seasons. Snowfall is rare. In 60 percent of the winters, there is no measurable snowfall. The average relative humidity in mid-afternoon is about 50 percent. Humidity is higher at night and the average at dawn is about 90 percent. The prevailing wind is from the southwest. Average wind-speed is highest, eight miles per hour in spring. The average winter temperature is 48 degrees and the average summer temperature is 80 degrees. Climatic conditions are largely responsible for the physical, chemical and biological relationships of the soils, and their present state. They have also contributed to population and industrial movement from less hospitable temperatures in the northeast (Frost-belt region) to the more hospitable Sunbelt region. And managing climate changes, as well as reduction of dependency on fossil fuels, are among the foremost challenges to creating sustainable cities. TOPOGRAPHY The topography of the Cayce area consists of rolling sandhills drained by two major streams - Six Mile Creek and Congaree Creek - and the Congaree River. Certain areas are subject to periodic flooding from surface runoff and rising water levels. Topographic elevations range from 130 to 260 feet above sea level. MINERALS 51 The first mineral resource to be mined in the Cayce area was clay. First mined by prehistoric man to create pottery, the extensive deposits of high quality kaolinite clay were later mined by the Guignard family for the manufacture of bricks. The original buildings in Columbia were made of Guignard Bricks. After the city was burned in 1865, during the Civil War, it was raised from the ashes using Guignard bricks created from the clays of the Congaree. The brickworks continued to operate on the banks of the Congaree until they were moved in 1975. Granite from the area was first used to form stone tools. Commercial use of the granite started in 1896, when Captain John Ross began mining at what is now the Cayce Quarry. The quarry has been in continuous use since, and is now owned and operated by Martin Marietta Materials. Southeastern Concrete Products, dependent upon a source of high strength aggregate, located in Cayce in 1949, and is still in operation. FLOOD PLAINS Flood prone areas and floodways generally are avoided by developers, but encroachment over time and subsequent damage and disaster have led to the promulgation of federal and local legislation regulating development of such areas. A significant portion of the city and its urban fringe area are subject to flooding, according to Flood Insurance Rate Maps (See Appendix) prepared by FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency). The areas are roughly described as paralleling the Congaree River, Congaree Creek, Six Mile Creek and their tributaries. To date, these areas by-in -large have remained sparsely populated and developed, but could become more intensely utilized if more costly flood prevention practices are incorporated into the construction of new development. That these areas remain undeveloped in order to function naturally to drain the community of flood water and minimize damage or destruction of property and loss of life is critical to the future of the community. And their continued reservation is strongly recommended. Such a 52 recommendation is reinforced by the utility of these areas in replenishing ground water supply, helping protect water quality and their contribution as wildlife habitats and open space in parts of the city. Additionally, the intent of these regulations, as stated in model FEMA Codes, is to “protect human life and health, minimize property damage, encourage appropriate construction practices, and minimize public and private losses due to flood conditions by requiring that uses vulnerable to floods, including facilities which serve such uses, be protected against flood damage at the time of initial construction. They are further intended to minimize damage to public facilities and utilities such as water and gas mains, electric, telephone, and sewer lines, streets and bridges located in the floodplain, and prolonged business interruptions; and to minimize expenditure of public money for costly flood control projects and rescue and relief efforts associated with flooding”. To this end, the City should: (1) Expand its review of proposed development in flood prone areas to ensure that buildings are located on flood-free sites and that other structures do not encroach into the flood plain. (2) Develop a flood plain management program to include incentives and conservation agreements to preserve or limit the use of such areas to natural greenways, agricultural or outdoor recreation. WETLANDS The term wetlands means those areas that are inundated or saturated by surface or ground water at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances do support, a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions. Wetlands generally include swamps, marshes, bogs, and similar areas. The principal criteria for determining wetlands are (1) hydrology, (2) soils, and (3) vegetation. 53 Wetlands are considered by the state and federal governments to be important to the public welfare and interest. As such, they are protected by state and federal laws. Prerequisite to the development of such lands is a "jurisdictional determination" by the U.S. Corps of Engineers. The Corps has developed a wetlands map for general reference, included herein. But for specific sites, a determination of wetlands by the Corps should be secured. Based on their determination, a permit from the Corps may or may not be required to develop the property. Wetlands requiring a permit from the Corps are characterized as follows: (1) Wetlands which serve significant natural biological functions, including food chain production, general habitat and nesting, spawning, rearing and resting sites for aquatic or land species; (2) Wetlands set aside for study of the aquatic environment or as sanctuaries or refuges; (3) Wetlands the destruction or alteration of which would affect detrimentally natural drainage characteristics, sedimentation patterns, salinity distribution, flushing characteristics, current patterns, or other environmental characteristics. (4) Wetlands which are significant in shielding other areas from erosion or storm damage. (5) Wetlands which serve as valuable storage areas for storm and flood waters; (6) Wetlands which are ground water discharge areas that maintain minimum base flows important to aquatic resources and those which are prime natural recharge areas; 54 55 (7) Wetlands which serve significant water purification functions; and (8) Wetlands which are unique in nature or scarce in quantity to the region or local area. Where such conditions are found to exist, the Corps will evaluate each request for development on the basis of projected benefits to be derived from the proposed development in relation to the damage to the wetlands resource. Suffice it to say, wetlands restrictions by the federal government make development of wetlands tenuous at best. Where, in the past, development has been constrained principally by the simple presence of wetlands. It is further constrained by the need to plan around or mitigate the use and circumstances of development proposed for such areas. Clearly, the presence of wetlands should alert the City and the developer to the need for a "wetlands determination" before proceeding. Failure to secure a wetlands determination and permit, if required, could result in work stoppage, restoration of the project site to its original state, fines, or other compensatory action. As a factor responsible for influencing development, wetlands, perceived as a natural resource, pose a greater deterrent to development than ever before. CANOPY TREES One of the more important natural resources in any community is its large canopy trees. Areas void of a canopy are generally avoided by developers, particularly residential. Trees in the urban environment serve to protect and enhance property values, control erosion, moderate climate extremes, provide screens and buffers, promote traffic safety and contribute to community ambience and beautification. Promoting the planting of street trees, and regulating and monitoring the care and cutting of trees on public rights-of-way as well as private property are recommended as means of protecting and enhancing the environment. 56 Unfortunately, the City of Cayce does very little to advance tree preservation and planting. It does protect in proposed new developments canopy trees measuring 24” in diameter, referred to as “Significant Trees”, but exempts from protection trees on public streets and utility rights-of-way, trees on existing lots of record occupied by single-family or duple x dwellings, and pine trees. These regulations, while helpful, stop short of restricting or prohibiting the cutting of mature canopy trees once a subdivision is developed, or regulating the felling or pruning of trees in public rights- of-way, or promoting urban forestation, and the retention of urban wildlife habitats. Consequently, a more comprehensive approach to tree planting and protection is needed. SOILS There are two major soil associations in the Cayce area: the Congaree-Toccoa-Brogdon Association and the Lakeland-Blaney Association. The former is primarily a sedimentary soil associated with floodplains of major rivers and streams. They are found principally along the drainage channels of the Congaree River, Six Mile Creek, and Congaree Creek. These soils have limited development potential due to wetness. There are four basic hydrologic soil groups in the area, identified by the Natural Resource Conservation Service and shown on the following Map as Group A, B, C and D. Group A soils consist of sand or sandy loam types, with low run-off potential and high infiltration rates when thoroughly wetted with a high rate of water transmission. They are found principally in the 12th Street area, as illustrated on the Cayce Area Soil Map. 57 Group B soils constitute the prominent soils in the Cayce area. They support the bulk of development. These soils consist of loam or silt loam, with a moderate infiltration rate when thoroughly wetted. They are moderately well to well drained. Group C soils are found in relatively small pockets along 12th Street, south toward the interstate. They consist of sandy clay loam with low infiltration rates. Group D soils have high runoff potential. They are located principally in flood prone areas paralleling creeks and drainage ways. Ignoring soil limitations can be costly not only monetarily, but in lives as well. As a result, greater use of soils information is recommended prior to development, including: (1) Considering soil survey information as one of the criteria for making land use plans and decisions. (2) Consulting a soil survey before commencing any earth-moving or construction activities. (3) Requiring the use of soil surveys in any large scale land development or management project. 58 Lexington County GIS Soil Map, Cayce Area 59 CONCLUSIONS A summary review of the City's natural resources reveals that: (1) Climatic conditions have and will continue to influence development of the community. (2) Wetlands pose both a deterrent to the movement and development of areas south of the City, and as an asset, providing natural linear greenways along the Congaree River, Congaree Creek and Six Mile Creek, and significant amounts of large natural open space, much of it in the Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve . (3) Flood hazard conditions exist along major waterways in and out of City, constraining the movement of development, but providing much needed drainage channels. (4) Canopy trees constitute one of the City's most important resources, but not enough is being done to populate the streets or preserve their presence in the community. (5) Soils within the City generally are unsuited to septic tank usage because of wetness and, in some cases, building and street foundations. However, the City has overcome the wetness problem with a combination of regulations and improvements: it has a city-wide sewerage system, flood and wetlands regulations. NATURAL RESOURCE GOALS (NR) AND POLICIES NR - 1: Maintain and enhance natural wildlife areas in the city. Policy: Protect native plant and animal species in Cayce. Action: Pursue the designation of the City as a “Bird Sanctuary” to include protection of small mammals. 60 Action: Amend the City’s Land Development Ordinance to include provisions requiring assessment of plant and wildlife presence prior to development. NR-2: “Green” the Community. Action: Participate in the “Tree City” program. The Tree Town USA program is sponsored by The National Arbor Day Foundation in cooperation with the USDA Forest Service and National Association of State Foresters. To achieve the national recognition of being named a Tree Town USA, the Town must meet four standards: (1) Establish a Tree Board or Department; (2) Amend the Tree Protection Provision of the Zoning Ordinance to more comprehensively protect trees; (3) Establish an Annual Community Forestry Program; and (4) Schedule an Arbor Day Observance and Proclamation. NR-3: Protect Water Quality Inasmuch as the community depends on its water supply from the Congaree River and its tributaries, It behooves the City to take all necessary measures to ensure that the development of land and water resources proceeds in a manner consistent with Best Management Practices (BMPs), and permitting requirements designed to control run-off and protect water quality. The community’s water sources represent complex interactive systems providing not only water supply but multiple-use resources. As such, special consideration should be given to the planning and development of the riparian zone (area where land and water interface) of water-way corridors, including a requirement for buffer strips to retain adjacent land in an undisturbed or minimal use state. 61 Policy: Improve drainage and reduce storm water runoff. Action: Encourage residents to use rain gardens on their property to help reduce runoff. Action: Add maximum impervious surface requirements to the zoning ordinance. Policy: Coordinate with other local jurisdictions to ensure consistent water quality throughout the region. NR-4: Capitalize on the City's natural resources. Cayce’s central position in the larger Metro area and its abundance of natural resources in the midst of an urban environment make it an attractive place in which to live, work and visit. But not everyone know s that. The City needs to do a better job of promoting and marketing these unique attributes. Emphasize in promotional materials the natural aspects of the City as a means of capitalizing on its potential and enhancing growth and development opportunities. Two of the community’s most high profile natural assets -- the Riverfront walkway and the Congaree Creek H eritage Preserve – are difficult to find and use by virtue of their location, compounded by inadequate directional signage. Signage is not only limited but uninteresting and route directions are poorly marked. The only indication one has arrived at the Preserve is a gated parking lot, with an obscure sign marking the site. This is not the way to capitalize on the city’s natural resources. Action: Improve signage directing visitors to the Riverfront walkway and the Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve. Action: Improve linkage of Riverfront walkway with the City’s sidewalk network (see Transportation Element and Sidewalk plan). 62 Action: Establish “cultural information center” in high visibility location such as vicinity of State Street and Knox Abbott Drive or the intersection of 12 th Street Extension and I-77 to promote the Riverwalk Park, Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve and other historic and culturally significant sites and facilities in the community. Action: Prepare and distribute at public information outlets brochures for self guided tours of the city’s historical, cultural and recreational assets. NR-5: Maintain Proper Functioning of Wetlands and Flood Plains This may be accompanied by prudent enforcement of the City’s Flood Hazard Ordinance, and careful review and mitigation of all projects impacting wetlands and floodways. Policy: Prevent the fill and development of wetlands and floodplain areas where possible. Policy: Disallow development and impervious surfaces within 50 feet of creeks, rivers and wetlands. Action: Amend the Zoning Ordinance to require riparian buffer setbacks to protect all rivers, creeks and wetlands. Action: The SC Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism in a study of South Carolina Wetlands recommend the following action. 1. Public education efforts focusing on wetland values, potential losses due to various types of development, and how wetlands protection relates to overall water and land use goals. 2. Encouragement and support for private protection efforts by individual landowners or conservation groups. 63 3. Adoption of local wetland protection plans and policies which guide land use development and management including implementation of Best Management Practices. 4. Adoption of environmental impact statement (EIS) requirements for both public and private projects. 5. Close monitoring and enforcement of existing federal, state and local land and water regulations which directly or indirectly affect the use of wetlands. 6. Acquisition of specific wetlands. 7. Rehabilitation or restoration of damaged wetlands. 64 PART IV. CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT This element of the Comprehensive Plan focuses on cultural resources, which abound within and in proximity to the City of Cayce. But what constitutes cultural resources and why are they considered an integral part of the Comprehensive planning process? Webster’s Dictionary defines culture as “ the act of developing the intellectual and moral facilities esp. education; acquaintance with and taste in fine arts, humanities and aspects of science; the customary beliefs, social forms, and material traits of a racial, religious or social group .” In sum, this element is all about the local social order, and why it is what it is. And it starts with the history of the area. HISTORY It may be said that our culture is the product of our history. The City of Cayce was incorporated in 1914, but the larger area in which it is a part has been occupied for over twelve thousand years. As a result it contains many significant archeological sites. The first European exploration of the area occurred in 1540, when Hernando Desoto visited a large Indian village located on the banks of Congaree Creek. In 1718, the first inland fort in South Carolina was constructed at a site just north of the mouth of Congaree Creek on Old State Road. By 1725, this fort was converted into an Indian trading post. The trading post was frequently referred to in contemporary reports as the “Town of the Congarees.” It was established on the old Cherokee Trail, which was later improved to serve as a wagon trail between the Piedmont and the Coast. U.S. Highway 21 now follows the route of that ancient footpath. In 1730, the Congaree District was laid out as one of 11 districts in the central portion of the state to provide protection for Charles Towne against hostile Indians. The Congaree District, subsequently renamed Saxe Gotha in 1733, served as the principal inland buffer to raids from the vast Cherokee 65 population to the northwest, and from other marauding bands from as far away as New York State. The district was renamed Saxe Gotha in an attempt to lure hardy German immigrants for the frontier settlement. Saxe Gotha District was roughly 34 miles wide and contained 625,000 acres. The original town of Saxe Gotha lay along the west bank of the Congaree River in the area where Taylor Road intersects Old State Road. The Saxe Gotha Township was seven miles square, covering a territory currently occupied by the City of Cayce, West Columbia, Springdale, the Columbia Metropolitan Airport and south to Dixiana. In 1748, a new Congaree Fort was constructed on the north bank of Congaree Creek. In 1751, Friday’s Ferry was opened across the Congaree River at a point near the new fort, helping the settlement grow into one of the most important trading centers east of the Mississippi River, second only to Camden. In 1774, the town of Granby was formed on the banks of the Congaree River at a point just south of the existing railroad trestle. The name Granby came into use presumably to honor the marquis of Granby, then Commander-in-Chief of the British Army. This settlement was fortified during the American Revolution and was the site of several skirmishes. After the war, Granby became the seat of Lexington County with a courthouse and jail. Indigo and later cotton constituted the main products of the area. The Santee Canal Company was responsible for much of the riverboat trade. Granby’s existence was important but short. As late as 1807, Granby had nearly 200 more houses than the new capital city of Columbia across the river, but by 1837 the town was practically deserted. The development of Columbia and problems with mosquitoes were among the reasons for the town’s decline. As the population decreased, the county seat was relocated to the Town of Lexington in 1818. Existing structures were sold and their structural parts used to construct new buildings in Columbia. Today a cemetery and historical marker are the only reminders of the town of Granby. 66 The current name of Cayce is in honor of an old family of the area. The old Cayce house in which the family lived was built in 1765, about one-hal f mile from the Granby Ferry. W.J. Cayce operated the first store at this site known as “Cayce's Crossing.” HISTORIC AND ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES Over fifty archeologically significant sites have been identified in the area. Some of these sites are protected; most are not. Some of the more significant ones include the following. Congaree River and Preserve The State of South Carolina, with technical assistance from the National Park Service, in the late 1980s completed the first comprehensive assessment of the state’s rivers. The study entitled: South Carolina Rivers Assessment, assessed all rivers based on their resources and utility. The Study assigned one or more of fourteen different classifications to rivers, based on their attributes. The classifications included everything from Agricultural to Wildlife Habitats. The Congaree was classified as having 12 of the fourteen attributes, not all of which are present along the stretch of the river paralleling Cayce. Each attribute is classified based on degree of significance, from one to five with one being the highest. The stretch of the river contiguous to and paralleling Cayce is rated one in terms of 67 historical and cultural value, and one in recreational fishing. Its value as an urban river was assessed in the 1980s report as three, but the rating was based on the lack of river-related recreation and/or commercial development and support for riverfront revitalization. Since then things have changed, including the development of walking trails and other waterfront development, and the acquisition in 1997 of 627 acres of archeologically and historically significant land bordering the river. This acreage forms the Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve. It contains 12,000 years of history and pre- history imbedded in a pristine setting, documented by archaeological findings. The first Anglo-Saxon settlement at Fort Congaree was established in 1718 on the Congaree River. Later the Saxe Gotha Township was founded in 1731. Fort Granby was established during the Revolutionary War. Beginning in the early 1900s, clay was dug from pits for Guignard Brick Works; The pits now form several ponds, providing refuge to all kinds of wildlife. The site is facilitated for hikers with a 2.5 mile loop trail. The trail has been designated by the White House as a Community Millennium Trail, as it like dozens of others so designated reflects community history through natural settings. The Preserve includes and protects four archeological sites and a stand of Atlantic White Cedar trees. Part of the old Saxe Gotha and Manning Site locations are included in the preserve. The sites of Fort Congaree and the Confederate Earthworks are currently protected by deed restriction. 68 Guignard Brick Works In 1803, when Thomas Jefferson was President, the Guignard Brick Works was founded at a site on the river just north of present-day Knox Abbott Drive. Guignard Brick Works was the first brick manufacturing plant in the New World, manufacturing brick for almost every substantial building in the early history of Columbia. After Sherman’s Army sacked and burned Columbia, it was rebuilt with Guignard brick. The Liberty Life building, Columbia College, the interior of the State House, the YMCA and the old Confederate Printing Plant are examples of structures that were built using Guignard bricks. An exhibit in the Cayce Historical Museum commemorates the history of the Guignard Brick Works. The Guignard Brick Works was added to the National Register in 1995. Charles Pinckney House In 1790, Charles Pinckney, one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence, built his home, “Tacitus” at a site just south of the original Congaree Fort. This site lies just outside of the Cayce city limits. Other Historically Significant Buildings There are a number of other apparently historically significant structures remaining today, particularly in “Old Cayce”, though not designated at this time. Some of these buildings include Brookland-Cayce High 69 School, the old Cayce City Hall, the Women's Club building, and several residences such as those at 517 Holland Street and 668 Frink Street. ARTS AND ARCHIVES The location of Cayce within the larger Columbia metropolitan area puts at the fingertips of its citizens the greatly expanded collection of fine arts and higher education facilities within the area. Among them are the following. Cayce Historical Museum The City of Cayce established in 1991 a small Historical Museum on the City Hall Campus. It consists of a main museum building and several other buildings within the museum complex including an outside kitchen that was brought to the site from the Buff Plantation. It was built by a group of local citizens and donated to the City. The Cayce Historical Museum presents the legacy and history of the Old Saxe Gotha, Granby, and Cayce areas. The focal point of the museum is a reconstruction of the Trading Post established by James Chestnut and Joseph Kershaw at Granby Village in 1765. Granby was an important river trading market (established 50 years before Columbia in 1733) on the Congaree River. With the eventual growth of Columbia as the capital, Granby gradually declined as a community. The museum interprets the agricultural, social and cultural heritage of Old Saxe Gotha (1733), Granby, Cayce and West Columbia. Exhibits emphasize 70 periods of Colonial trade, agricultural development and transportation from the 18th century to the present. Native American artifacts displayed date back thousands of years to when Native Americans inhabited the land near the Broad, Saluda and Congaree Rivers. Six exhibit areas include a Trading Post Room, Saxe Gotha/Granby Room, Emily Geiger Room, Victorian Room, Cayce Room and Visitors Center -- emphasize peri ods of Indians, Colonial activity and trade, agricultural development and transportation in the area. The museum tells the story of Cayce’s past and the important role this area played in the development of the Midlands of South Carolina. From a trading post to a Revolutionary Fort to a prominent suburb of the state capitol, Cayce’s history is indeed long and colorful and fills an important niche in the story of South Carolina’s history. Since opening, the Cayce Museum has entertained and enlightened almost 25,000 visitors. In addition to local and statewide visitors, there have been visitors from 49 of the 50 states and from more than 25 international countries. This excellent cultural and educational facility is a source of pride for Cayce citizens who often bring out- of-state friends and relatives in to show off their local museum. The Visitors’ Center at the museum is used by historical groups in the Greater Columbia area and even statewide. The museum director gives lectures on the Revolutionary and the Civil Wars to visiting schools and historical groups complete with his own artifacts from those time periods. The visitor’s center occupies a portion of the museum and can hold up to 50 people. 71 South Carolina State Museum In addition to the Cayce Museum, the South Carolina State Museum is located just across the river in Columbia. It also includes a “hands-on” museum for children. The Museum has four large floors devoted to the disciplines of art, history, natural history and science/technology. It houses both long-term exhibits and five changing exhibit galleries. The Museum opened October, 1988, bringing to the citizens of the State the newest, and one of the finest, state museums in America. The State Museum has more than 70,000 artifacts in its collection, and it is still a very young institution. It is housed in its largest artifact, the former Columbia Mill. This former textile mill also is a world-first. When it opened in 1894, manufacturing cotton duck cloth (a canvas-like material), it was the first totally-electric textile mill in the world. It was also the first major industrial installation for the General Electric Corporation. It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The State Museum was voted one of the three top museums by Southeastern readers of Southern Living magazine, along with the High Museum in Atlanta and the Smithsonian Institution. Columbia Museum of Art The Columbia Museum, located across the River, is an adaptive re-use facility with over 20,000 square feet of gallery space. The Museum is designed to bring a wide range of traveling exhibitions to South Carolina, as well as to provide the necessary space for the proper presentation of its collection, which numbers over 7,000 objects. The building has well-designed workspaces, storage for collections, art studios, 150-seat public auditorium, art library, Museum shop and public reception spaces. The Columbia Museum of Art has exhibition galleries worthy of any of this country's great museums. Temporary exhibitions are presented in a flexible space that contains a minimum of 4,000-sq. ft. with the capability of expanding to nearly 7,000 sq. ft. When a smaller space is required, the balance is installed 72 with contemporary art from the Museum's collection. The Museum has 14 galleries offering to its visitors not only the display of its collection, but art related programs. From Art School classes for teens and adults, to programs specially designed for preschool children, people of all ages can find classes and workshops that inspire and enrich. The Museum supports almost 160 jobs in the Columbia area and generates local hospitality and tourism tax revenues of at least $80,000 per year. More than 6,250 people visit the Museum each month. These visitors spend almost $1.7 million on lodging and $1.6 million on food and beverages. LIBRARY The Cayce-West Columbia Branch Library, a 20,000 square foot building, was uniquely renovated from a multilevel department store by an award winning architect, Danny Shelley. The R.H. Smith Meeting Room is named in honor of a longtime benefactor of the Lexington County Library System. The 1,000 square foot room is frequently used for special events. The youth services department provides a variety of programs including: preschool story-time, daycare visits, a book discussion group “The Young Critics Club,” toddler-time, and creative dramatics “The CWC Players.” The branch is maintained by Lexington County and the operation funds are derived from local and state taxes. Local fund-raising also contributes funding, including support from the Friends of Library. The Lexington County Public Library System is responsible for and committed to providing timely , accurate, courteous, and useful information to the citizens, businesses and organizations of Lexington County and surrounding areas. The Library System is dedicated to encouraging children to develop a life- long interest in reading and learning; to offering current, high-demand materials for all ages; and to assisting patrons in meeting educational objectives. The library supports these commitments by providing materials, services, and a well trained and knowledgeable staff. 73 The importance of library services and facilities to local residents may be found in the following facts, extracted from the Annual Statistical Summary of S.C. Public Libraries, produced by the State Library, 2006. Of the 42 library systems in South Carolina, Lexington County Library ranks: (1) 5 th in population served, but (2) 5 th in collections, (3) 5 th in number full-time staff, (4) 4 th in circulation per capita, (5) 5 th in number of visits, and (6) 9 th in internet web stations. UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA Located across the Congaree is the State’s largest and most diversified University. The Columbia Campus of the University of South Carolina is home to more than 200 years of history and tradition, rising from a single building in 1805 on what would become the heart of the campus, the Horseshoe. The 11 buildings that now make up the Horseshoe frame a lush lawn that is an irresistible gathering place. The Columbia campus has more than 350 degree programs through its 14 degree-granting colleges and schools. Students have been awarded more than $11.4 million for national scholarships and fellowships since 1994; and faculty generated $206 million in funding for research, outreach, and training programs in fiscal year 2008. The University is in the process of expanding the Columbia Campus westward toward the Congaree River and the City of Cayce in support of its research initiatives in nanotechnology, health sciences, Future Fuels, the environment, and information and knowledge technologies. Three separate sites, each specializing in its own research area, will comprise this new innovation district, called Innovista. It will 74 initially cover 500,000 square feet spread over about six city blocks but is projected to grow to five million square feet, mixing University and private research buildings, parking garages, and commercial and residential units around a public plaza called Foundation Square. By creating space for residences, retail, restaurants, and recreation that will complement the research, Innovista will be a place to live, learn, and work. The westward move toward Congaree also includes the new baseball park, the “Greek Village” and student housing, and growth and development opportunities for the Cayce Community. RIVERBANK ZOO AND GARDENS Located about two miles west of the City on the Congaree is South Carolina's largest gated attraction – Riverbanks Zoo and Gardens. This cultural attraction, situated on 170 acres, averages 850,000 visitors each year. It is also a four-time winner of the Southeastern Tourism Society's Shining Example Award as the southeast's top tourist attraction and a two-time winner of the SC Parks Recreation and Tourism Governor's Cup Award as South Carolina's Leading Attraction. Riverbanks is an accredited member of the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA). The Zoo is home to over 3,000 animals, with extensive collections of mammals, birds , reptiles and fish. Recent additions to the Zoo include exhibits for African elephants, gorillas and koalas. The Birdhouse at Riverbanks (opened 2002) was given a Significant Achievement Award by the AZA as one of the best new zoo exhibits in the United States and features an incredible display of king, rockhopper and gentoo penguins. Riverbank also has a large botanical garden (70 acres) with more than 4,200 species of native and exotic plants. A trail system is available to visitors which allow them to explore several kilometers of bottomland and upland mixed hardwood forests and a myriad of native wildlife that call the Zoo and Garden home. 75 CONCLUSIONS We may conclude from the preceding that the City of Cayce is well endowed with historical resources due to its rich history, and equally endowed with cultural resources due to its location. We may also conclude that without proper stewardship, marketing and continuous exploration and preservation efforts, many of the community’s cultural resources will be compromised over time, under developed or underutilized, remain dormant, or lost altogether. CULTURAL RESOURCE GOALS (CR) It is paramount for the City to determine how to optimize the use of these resources as a development tool without compromising their value to the health and general welfare of the community and future generations. Toward a course of optimal use and development of these resources, the following goals are established. CR-1: Fully integrate the community's heritage into the economic development process. Promote the history of one of the state's oldest inland communities and the attributes that contributed to this settlement. Stress them as part of the economic development process. Action: Provide up-to -date cultural data to economic development agencies for inclusion in their community resource information packets. Action: Pursue the use of grants to improve tourist attractions. CR-2: Enhance and protect the community's historical resources. It is not enough to research, identify and restore historical artifacts, buildings, places and structures, or even protect them in place through acquisition, trust, ownership commitment or regulation (zoning) 76 although these actions are recommended. Surrounding areas also should be enhanced and regulated to the extent necessary to ensure compatibility and a proper setting for such uses. Action: Monitor all rezoning and development proposals to ensure compatibility with existing historical sites and structures, utilizing plan review and the public hearing process. CR-3: Continue to survey, list and record the community's archaeological and historical assets. Much has been done and much more must be done to preserve and study these sites, including Guignard Park, Cayce City Hall, Cayce Women’s Club, Old Cayce jail on Railroad Avenue. Efforts to increase the awareness of the archeological and historical significance of the area need to be examined, if the city of Cayce is to reap the potential economic benefits of the tourism industry in South Carolina. Action: Pursue grants and volunteers to continue research and identification of archeological and historic sites. CR-4: Transform local archaeological sites and artifacts into a “12,000 Year History Park” The seeds of a 12,000 year history or archeological park are in the minds of many forward thinking people in the community and are being nurtured by the River Alliance. To this end the Alliance has requested the National Park Service to create a Cultural Resource Study of the River region’s Congaree Creek. Action: Support and assist in the pursuit and future development of such a park with commitments of city staff and financial resources. 77 CR-5: Become a "Certified Local Government". Becoming a certified local government (CLG) or participating in the CLG program will qualify the community for additional funding for local preservation. This federally funded program is administered by the S.C. State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). It is designed to integrate federal, state and local preservation efforts in partnership. Participating local governments are eligible for federal grant funds amounting to 10 percent of the state's federal allocation for preservation. Certified local governments also receive technical help and training for their design review committees, participate in statewide preservation planning programs, and can comment on National Register nominations from their community before the nominations are considered by the State. Action: Apply to become a “certified local government”. CR-6: Build a Community center/auditorium. Action: Initiate feasibility study of building a community center/auditorium of sufficient size to meet multiple community functions. 78 PART V. COMMUNITY FACILITIES ELEMENT The purpose of this element of the Comprehensive Plan is to inventory and evaluate the presence of community facilities and the level of public services rendered in relation to current and projected needs of the City. COMMUNITY FACILITIES DEFINED Community facilities relate generally to infrastructure, which is defined as facilities that are necessary to support development and redevelopment, are publicly owned and/or serve the public health, safety and welfare. Infrastructure systems include transportation, energy, telecommunications, water supply, wastewater disposal, storm water management, open space and recreation, solid waste management, public health care, public education, higher education, arts, historic resources, public safety, justice, public administration, and public housing. For purposes of this study, community facilities are divided into the following categories and sub- categories:  Utilities  Public Safety  Recreation  Sanitation  Storm Water Drainage  Health Care  Education 79 From the above list it is obvious that not all community facilities are provided by or under direct control of the City governing authority (City Council). As a result, inter-agency cooperation and coordination are essential to the orderly extension and development of such facilities. The status and plans of each follows: UTILITIES The City of Cayce owns and operates water and sewer facilities and systems within and beyond the City limits. These systems and services are operated under the direct supervision of the Utilities Department. 80 Water System The City’s water system extends throughout the City and into much of the unincorporated urban area. The City has over 8,245 customers, and average daily consumption of approximately 2.8 MGD (Million Gallons per Day). The water plant has the capacity to produce 10 MGD, allowing sufficient reserve (approximately 72 percent of plant processing capacity) to serve future growth and population projections. Additionally the City has completed a 10 year Water and Sewer Infrastructure Plan to meet future growth demands. The City’s water supply comes from the Congaree River. Water rates are based on service location, business or residence, meter size and volume consumed. Rates outside the City are twice the amount of in-side rates. The imbalance helps off-set the loss of property taxes from outside customers receiving municipal water, and the added cost to operate and maintain municipal service beyond the corporate limits. The City has adopted a standing policy requiring annexation as a prerequisite to receiving municipal water. However, property owners not contiguous to the City and therefore not in a position to be annexed are not automatically excluded from receiving water service. They may execute an agreement to annex at such time as their property becomes contiguous, thus accommodating an immediate need for service and a commitment to annex at a future date. For various reasons this policy has been less than fully implemented and therefore less than fully effective. 81 Sanitary Sewer System Cayce’s sewer system is actually more extensive and serves more customers than its water system. This is highly unusual, as the cost to extend sewer lines and process sewage generally exceed the cost to deliver water. The reason lies in the fact that West Columbia and other water providers outside Cayce have water lines in several fringe areas, most notably the Kitty Wake Road area (previously the Anco Service area), Lake Francis, Laurel Hill, Indian River, Laurel Hill and Congaree Downs Subdivisions, and the Ramblin Road area. The City’s old wastewater treatment plant operated at about 60 percent capacity on dry days (January 2009). On wet days infiltration caused the system to be less efficient. A new plant capable of processing 25 MGD (million gallons per day) was completed in 2013. Such capacity would seem excessive in light of the City’s previous uses (January 2009) and current uses, but the new plant is not designed for exclusive use by the City of Cayce. It also receives and processes, as did the old plant, wastewater from the Town of Lexington and the Joint-Municipal Water and Sewer Commission. Agreements to process wastewater from these entities entitle them to up to 16 MGD. The remaining capacity will be reserved for the City of Cayce. The new plant is located next to the old plant on Old State Road and adequately positions the City to meet projected growth and development demands. Table 18 Wastewater Treatment Facilities 2009 Planned: On line 2013 2014 Treatment Plant Discharge Capac ity: MGD (Million Gallons per Day) 9.5 25.0 25.0 Annual Average Volume Wastewater Treated: MGD from all sources (1) 5.5 8.2 Approximate usage by Cayce: MGD 3.3 3.5 5.8 Reserve Capacity for all sources (1) 4.0 16.8 Approximate Reserve capacity for Cayce 5.5 Approximate MGD treatment to Town of Lexington and Joint -Municipal Water and Sewer Commission 16.0 (1) Includes City of Cayce, Town of Lexington, and Joint -Municipal Water and Sewer Commission Source: City of Cayce, Utilities Department, 2009, 2014 82 Sewer rates, like water rates, are based on service location, business or residence, meter size and volume consumed. Rates outside the City are twice the amount of in-side rates. The imbalance helps offset the loss of property taxes from outside customers receiving municipal sewer service, and the added cost to operate and maintain municipal service beyond the corporate limits. The City has adopted the same standing policy for sewer service as for water service, requiring annexation as a condition to the receipt of such service. PUBLIC SAFETY The City of Cayce has a Public Safety Department, including both police and fire fighters, cross-trained to maximize the use of departmental manpower and resources. The efficiencies of this system are readily apparent: one Chief instead of two, one department instead of two, one person trained to perform two jobs. The Public Safety Department also is responsible for the operation of Animal Services, which includes housing animals from the City of West Columbia. The Department is located in a building on the City Hall Complex. The building was designed initially for the Fire Department, but was expanded in 1983 to accommodate both fire and police when the two departments were joined, forming the Public Safety Department. It has since been rearranged and expanded internally to accommodate an enlarging staff, necessitated by an enlarging and expanded population and City limits. 83 Four storage rooms have been converted to offices and multiple personnel have been crowded into space initially designed to accommodate far fewer officers and auxiliary personnel. In a word, conditions at the Public Safety Department are crowded, with no place else to expand within the existing building. This also includes the municipal court room, which is much too small to accommodate the over-flow crowds in attendance on “court days”. Future growth of the Department, brought on by future annexation, population growth and development unquestionably will stretch the Department and trigger the need for building expansion or replacement. Police Protection Currently, the Public Safety Department has a staff of 63; 44 of whom are crossed trained and certified fire and police officers; one of whom is police certified only; seven are fire certified only; and 11 are civilian personnel. This equates to 4.2 sworn police officers per 1,000 population. By way of comparison to cities of comparable size with Public Safety Departments, the number of sworn police officers to population is above average. 84 Current officer- to- population ratios notwithstanding, stretching the community through annexation has created a need for six patrol zones. Each zone is assigned a patrol officer working 12 hour shifts. With annexations east of the Congaree, in Richland County, and west of the Columbia Airport, routine patrols have become less efficient and more costly due to the added distance and time to patrol these areas. Continued annexations in these more remote outlying areas will trigger the need for additional personnel and equipment to maintain the current patrol schedule. Fire Protection and Emergency Medical Services The Public Safety Department has 7 Fire Fighters assisted by 44 Police Officers cross trained as Fire Fighters. They also handle EMS/First Responder Calls and Hazardous material responses. The availability and level of fire protection has a direct bearing on the security of life and property. It is also a matter of considerable importance in choosing a location for new development. In addition to saving lives and property, fire protection, or the level (class) of protection has a direct bearing on insurance Table 18 Law Enforcement Profile City of Cayce 2004 2009 Public Safety officers 48 52 Population residing within area of jurisdiction 12,680 12,528 Area of jurisdiction (square miles) 16.5 16.65 Number sworn police officers per 1,000 population, 4.2 4.2 Average number public safety officers for cities of comparable size (10,000-24,999) 55 50 Average number public safety officers per 1,000 population for cities of comparable size (10,000-24,999) 3.45 1.9 Law enforcement officers per square mile 2.9 3.1 Source: City of Cayce; U.S. Department of Justice; Bureau of Census; and Municipal Year Book, 2004, 2009, 2010. 85 premiums. Both fire and homeowner’s insurance premiums are predicated on the fire defenses and subsequent classification of a community by the South Carolina Insurance Service Office (ISO). To understand what this means in dollars and cents, we first need to explain the somewhat complicated and ever changing relationship between fire defenses and insurance premiums. The Insurance Service Office (ISO) inspects, grades, and ranks fire departments and defense areas from 1 to 10 on the basis of protection offered. One represents the best possible, with 10 signaling the absence of any protection. Insurance rates are then established to reflect the prevailing classification: the lower the classification, the lower the rates, theoretically. But there is a vast difference between theory and practice in today's insurance market. Premium differences once observed between classes no longer exist. The differences now generally are between groups of classes, grouped along the following lines: Major Class Groupings Characteristics Class 10 No recognized fire department or defense Class 9 Recognized fire department, but no recognized community water system Classes 4-8 Recognized fire department and community water system Classes 1-3 More complete and sophisticated systems, based on individual grading of suppression The City’s fire defenses were inspected and received a Class 5 rating by the ISO around the year 1989. The objective of the Department, like most other public safety or fire departments, has been and continues to be: to improve its Class rating and subsequently lower insurance premiums and improve fire protection. But with annexations across the River, on Bluff Road (The Retreat), and west of the Airport (Hunters Mill), it seems that the City may have actually jeopardized its Class rating and derailed any chance to improve its rating. Fire departments are required by ISO to be within 5 miles of homes and three miles of 86 commercial and/or industrial buildings. These two annexations are beyond ISO approved limits from the existing station in the Municipal complex off State Street. To address this concern, the Public Safety Department has entered into an Automatic Aid Agreement with Lexington County to respond to fire calls in Hunters Mill and a verbal Aid Agreement with the City of Columbia to respond to fire calls in The Retreat, located in Richland County. It also has Mutual Aid Agreements with Columbia, West Columbia, Lexington County, and the Irmo Fire District. How satisfactory these agreements are in meeting the 5-mile radius requirement of ISO may only be speculated. But continuation of annexation in these more distant locations will in time generate a need for new sub-stations and additional fire trucks to serve these areas, preserve the Department’s Class 5 rate, and/or improve its rate. In light of this situation, it is recommended that an ISO inspection be requested and status of the City’s fire defenses clarified. An ISO inspection will detail what needs to be done to retain or improve the current Class rating. The City’s fire defenses were inspected in August 2011 and received an improved class 4 rating, so it appears that the City’s new annexations have no adverse affect on the latest ISO rating. In addition to the above Aid Agreements, the Department has “paired-up” with the City of Surfside Beach to respond in the event of a catastrophe on the coast. In fact, all coastal communities have pairing arrangements with in-land Departments in the event of catastrophes. RECREATION The term recreation includes both active and passive activity. In Cayce, most passive recreational opportunities are available in parks owned and maintained by the City. The City does not conduct or staff active recreational programs. Most active recreational opportunities are available in parks and facilities owned or leased, operated and maintained by the Lexington County Recreation and Aging Commission. An inventory of City and County parks and facilities in the community are shown on Table 20. 87 Until 2011, Cayce’s parks were under the direction of the City’s Sanitation and Parks Department, which not only maintained the parks, but maintained all public grounds and buildings as well. Recreational Preferences There have been significant changes in recreation patterns and trends over the last several years due principally to societal changes, i.e. increased average income, more women in the work force, increased commuting time, increased average age, early retirement, greater health consciousness, more indoor recreation opportunities, higher education levels, delayed marriages and child bearing, change from industrial to high technology service and communications society, etc. Active recreation is more popular than passive recreation. Among the national trends of local interest are preferences for walking, swimming, visiting historic sites, and jogging. By 2040 the most popular activities nationally are expected to be sightseeing, walking, pleasure driving, picnicking, hiking, family gatherings, bicycling, photography, wildlife observation, visiting historic sites, and camping. A survey conducted in 1990 and updated through 2005 by the South Carolina Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism establishes the following trends in preferred outdoor activities. South Carolinians’ participation in recreational activities has been relatively stable over the past 15 years. During this period, there have been only minor variations in the percentage of population 12 and older who participate in various recreational activities. Walking for pleasure or exercise remains the activity in which the largest percentages of people participate. Following walking, recreational activities participated in by the largest number of people include attending outdoor sporting events, swimming or sunbathing, driving for pleasure (though not so much in the current economy), working out with weights, picnicking and visiting historical sites. Cayce’s Riverwalk Park and the 2.5 mile walking trail in the Congaree Preserve, both relatively new additions to the inventory of 88 recreation outlets in the community, enable the community help meet the number one preferred recreational activity in South Carolina – walking. Table 19 Top 20 Preferred Outdoor Activities Age 12 and older, South Carolina, 2005 % Participating 1. Walking for pleasure or exercise 83.2 2. Attending outdoor sporting events 63.4 3. Beach swimming/sunbathing 62.5 4. Driving for pleasure 58.2 5. Weights or exercise machines 57.1 6. Picnicking 53.4 7. Pool swimming 53.2 8. Visiting historical sites 52.1 9. Bicycling 42.8 10. Visiting a museum 38.4 11. Fresh water fishing 37.2 12. Visiting unusual natural feature 34.7 13. Playing basketball 34.5 14. Visiting a Zoo 34.1 15. Motor boating 34.1 16. Jogging/running 33.9 17. Watching wildlife 33.4 18. Lake/river swimming 28.0 19. Playing football/soccer 26.1 20. Playing baseball or softball 23.4 Source: S.C. Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism, State Comprehensive Recreation Plan, 2005. While the general pattern of recreational participation has been relatively stable, several activities have either increased or decreased in popularity. Respondents working out with weights increased from 43.2 89 percent in 1990 to 57.1 percent in 2005.Historical visitors climbed from 47 percent in 1990 to 52 in 2005. The largest decline was in volleyball, followed by baseball, softball, tennis, waterskiing, and picnicking. Existing Recreation Facilities and Program Opportunities In combination, the City of Cayce and the Lexington County Recreation and Aging Commission offer a wide variety of recreation programs and facilities for all ages, as shown on Table 20. Many of the preferred recreational outlets and activities identified on Table 19, including walking trails, ball fields, picnicking opportunities, visiting museums, visiting zoos, and attending outdoor sporting events are available within the community and/or the immediate vicinity. In addition to the parks and facilities listed on Table 20, recreational opportunities and facilities essentially surround the community. Three major County facilities just outside Cayce, but intended primarily for use by all tri-city residents, including Cayce residents, are the Tri-City Leisure Center, Howard Sports Complex, and B Avenue Ball Park, in West Columbia. The Leisure Center offers a variety of classes, programs and activities, including everything from pre - school to senior citizen programs. Amenities include a gymnasium, wellness center, senior center, multi- purpose rooms, racquetball courts and a walking area. The Howard Sports Complex includes ball fields for organized sports, picnic shelters and a walking trail. The B Avenue Ball Park also has ball fields and support facilities. The inventory of public recreational facilities and opportunities is complemented by numerous nearby private and commercial recreation resources, both within and in the immediate proximity of the community. 90 Table 20 Park and Recreation Facility Inventory, 2009 2014 Cayce Community Name Size (Acreage) Major Facilities present at Park Assessment/Planned Improvements City Parks Guignard 8.25 Passive park: walking trail, park furniture Excellent condition Glenwood 1.0 Picnic shelter, open-air basketball court, playground equipment Planned replacement of Basketball Ct., 3 picnic tables, adding 3 BBQ grills and water fountain, and replacing swing Andrew J Burnette (Lee St.) 0.5 Playground equipment Planned improvements to add picnic shelter and 2 picnic tables Total renovation completed Newman Boat landing 3.75 Boat ramp Planned addition benches and picnic tables Granby Gardens 12.65 Pavilion, playground equipment, landscaped area Planned improvements: New gazebo, replace playground equipment, add 2 BBQ grills and 8 ceiling fans for pavilion River walk 51.0 415 Restroom facilities, park furniture Excellent condition Churchill Gardens (planned) 3.5 Undeveloped site Planned for benches, picnic tables, grills and playground equipment Total Acreage 80.65 444.65 County Parks Cayce Memorial Park (M Avenue) 5.0 Lighted tennis courts (2), baseball fields (2), playground equipment, canteen and restrooms In need of major renovation; no longer used for organized sports – practice fields Henry C Moore Park (Dunbar Road) 8.0 Rec. building, gym, meeting rooms; baseball fields (3), soccer fields, tennis courts. Ball fields used mostly for practice. Tennis Courts to be removed. Consideration by County to clear and rebuild park Sunnyside 2.0 Playground equipment Excellent condition RECO Ball Field 3.0 Softball fields (2), canteen & restrooms Average condition; located on lease property Cayce Tennis Complex 18.0 23 Adult and 7 Quick Start Tennis Courts Planned opening: Opened Spring 2011 Total 36.0 Grand total 116.65 480.65 Source. City of Cayce, Sanitation and Parks Dept; Lexington County Recreation Commission, 2009, 2014. 91 Assessment The adequacy of parks and recreation facilities generally is determined by how abundant and accessible they are and how much they are used. As part of this Plan update, the adequacy of the current inventory of parks and recreation will be revisited using one of the most effective and accepted methods of assessment: that of relating park space to population, and comparing the results to "universal standards of adequacy". Unfortunately however, universal standards do not always reflect local situations alike, and must be modified accordingly. They may however be used as a general gauge for evaluating a system. The 2008 South Carolina Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP) includes "universal" space requirements for all types of parks. Of the four basic types generally provided at the local level, the aggregate area per 1,000 population is 13 acres (13:1). Application of this standard ratio to the Cayce community will produce a need for 273 park acres. This includes not only the City of Cayce (population 12,000), but the larger urban area of the Census County Division in which it is located (population 21,000). Based on the inventory of parks and facilities (Table 20,pg.87), in 2009, the Cayce community had a deficit of 40 acres, based on the amount recommended by the National Recreation and Park Association (Table 21,pg.89). But this deficit was misleading when nearby recreation facilities provided by the County for residents of the tri-city area are computed in the equation. Additionally, the number of parks and recreation opportunities available just across the river in Columbia combine to make Cayce one of the few communities in the state to meet or exceed National Recreation and Park Association standards, when accounting for all recreation outlets in the immediate vicinity. 92 Table 21 Application of National Park Standards To Cayce Park Inventory NATIONAL PARK STANDARDS: 13 acres* per 1,000 population Application of National Standards to Cayce: 12 (pop. 000) X 13.0 (acres) Acreage Recommended for Cayce Area = 156 2009 PARK ACREAGE CAYCE AREA 116 2014 PARK ACREAGE CAYCE AREA 480 2009 PARK ACREAGE DEFICIT 40 2014 PARK ACREAGE SURPLUS 324 * Note: Includes acreage for all community parks, i.e. Neighborhood 3 to 1, Playfields 3 to 1, Community 2 to 1, and Major Community 5 to 1. Source: National Recreation and Park Association, Recreation Park and Open Space Standards; Cayce Sanitation and Parks Department; Lexington County Recreation and Aging Commission, 2009, 2014. The additions of Riverwalk Phases III and IV have increased the acreage of Cayce Parks substantially and based on the inventory of parks and facilities, in 2014, the Cayce community has a surplus of 324 acres. When surveying more closely the distribution of Neighborhood parks and Playfields, there still appears to be an inequity in the distribution and a need for neighborhood parks in Broad Acres, The Avenues and Edenwood, even with the surplus of park acreage in 2014. Additionally, there is the matter of “condition.” Not all parks are up to standard. Burnette Park has received a total renovation but Churchill Park and Newman Boat Landing are scheduled for improvements, pending approval of grants from SC State Parks and Recreation. Also, Lexington County has tentative plans to improve conditions at Henry C. Moore Recreation Complex, starting with the removal of tennis courts in disrepair. 93 Finally, in the Citizen Survey regarding recreation, a majority of respondents indicated a need for more programs and classes, indicating that current offerings are both insufficient in number and variety. SANITATION The Sanitation Department is responsible for garbage, trash and recyclable collection and transfer. To accomplish this task, the Department has a staff complement of 17 sanitation workers, and a rolling stock consisting of five garbage trucks, one yard trash truck, one recycling truck, two roll-off trucks, five roll-off containers, one leaf machine, three pick-up trucks and two limb grabbers. Residents are provided with “roll carts” and recycling bins can be purchased for $10. Collections are scheduled once a week, twice a week during the summer months. Recycling is encouraged and promoted through the City’s website, E- letters, the Sunrise quarterly news letter and our newcomer packet. The Department’s vehicles and equipment, as well as vehicles used by other departments, are repaired and maintained by the City’s Garage. Replacement vehicles are purchased as needed, based on serviceability, not a replacement scheduled based on projected vehicle life. This enables the City to maximize investment in its vehicles and equipment by often extending the expected serviceable life, but can create financial planning and budgeting problems, which could jeopardize the procurement of needed replacements. STORM WATER DRAINAGE The responsibility for maintaining most storm water drainage channels within the city, existing or to be constructed for the purpose of providing release of excess waters from storm runoff, rests primarily with individual property owners, according to City Ordinance 6-7-82, Section 4, to wit: 94 “Any person owning or leasing a lot or parcel of land within the corporate limits of the city, which has an existing drainage channel lying within or contiguous to such parcel of land, shall be responsible for carrying out basic maintenance as prescribed and set forth in this article. If more than one abutting property owner is involved, the responsibility shall be held jointly between the owners, or as determined by the administrative official. For incidental drainage channels, the property owner shall maintain the channel in an attractive manner, including the cutting and removal of grasses, weeds and other brush along the border and otherwise removing excessive debris, sediment and other foreign objects, so as to maintain the proper function of the channel or swale. It shall be unlawful to place leaves, rocks, sticks, or other extraneous materials in a drainage channel which would in any way obstruct or alter the normal flow of water in that channel.” Storm water drainage was not carefully designed or well regulated during the development of Cayce’s older neighborhoods and many of the drainage channels have since been obstructed with unlawful materials, creating severe flooding conditions in several areas and neighborhoods. So much so, in fact, storm drainage was identified in the citizen survey as a major issue. To address this problem the City entered into an intergovernmental agreement with Lexington County 10- 23-07, authorizing the County to administer its Storm Water Management Ordinance within the corporate limits of Cayce. This ordinance is intended to control storm water runoff and post-construction storm water management in new development and redevelopment. Prior to this action and ongoing is the City’s participation in the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Phase II Storm Water Program. This program is designed to address water quality issues in smaller municipalities in South Carolina. The City completed as part of this program in 2004 an Illicit Discharge Detection and Elimination inventory and map, in which all outfalls were identified by location and owner or responsible entity. Approximately one-half were identified as being owned by the SC Department of Transportation and the other half by the City of Cayce. Unfortunately none of the action to date has resulted in relief from periodic storm water flooding. Part of the problem is in the assignment of responsibility. The City, SC Department of Public Transportation 95 (DOT), and private property owners are all responsible for repair and maintenance of the system, such as it is. There is no single responsible authority, making system improvements difficult at best. Then there is the problem of financing long overdue improvements. Already the City is committed financially to further study and implementation of its NPDES Phase II Storm Water Permit. But until a drainage flow plan and coordinated approach to system improvements under the leadership of the City are initiated, there will be little relief from periodic storm water flooding in the community’s older neighborhoods. MEDICAL FACILITIES AND SERVICES The City of Cayce is provided medical service principally from nearby Lexington Medical Center. Proximity to the City of Columbia and its three principal hospitals offer city residents expanded care opportunities and access to a full range of medical services. Lexington Medical Center is a 414-bed medical complex that anchors a comprehensive, county-wide health care network. That network includes six community medical centers at strategic locations throughout Lexington County, the largest extended care facility in the state, an occupational health center and affiliated physician practices. The stated mission of the Center is to provide quality health services that meet the needs of the community, growing as the community grows to serve it in the best way possible. The Center has a staff of over 5,900 members. The staff includes nurses, physicians from diverse medical and professional disciplines, technicians, therapists, education specialists, and hundreds of dedicated volunteers. Lexington Medical Center has long been associated with high-quality patient care, featuring high-tech diagnostic and therapeutic tools. It has over 30 state-of -the-art, fully equipped operating rooms, plus additional rooms for endoscopy and cystoscopy which allow surgeons to examine the most delicate tissues. In addition, the Center has the most powerful Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanner 96 available today, which uses intense magnetic fields to clearly image virtually any part of the body, and Special Procedures Suites to accommodate intricate vascular procedures. The Center is also the first area hospital to feature midwives and doulas to assist parents during delivery. In addition to a large nursery, it has a Special Care nursery to nurture the most delicate newborns. To ensure continuity in women's care, the Center provides education on a variety of topics such as menopause and breast cancer. It also offers a complete cardiac rehabilitation program , advanced laboratory services and one of S.C.'s largest emergency departments. For more than 25 years, Lexington Medical Center has been a leader in health education. Throughout the region, the Center sponsors health fairs, on-site health programs for companies, and trade shows - all emphasizing the importance of early detection when combating illness. Through its Health Directions Program, the Center provides a complete array of health and wellness classes including aerobics, weight management, and healthy cooking, plus ongoing seminars from smoking cessation to menopause. Educational programs such as these are intended to promote healthy lifestyles leading to longer lives. EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES Lexington School District 2 serves the City of Cayce and the larger tri-city area. The District has 16 schools, seven of which are located in Cayce, including the District’s two high schools: Airport and Brookland Cayce. Enrollment (135 day membership) at these schools has been relatively stable, declining only slightly between school year 2001-02 and 2007-08. Enrollment at the two high schools has been particularly stable. However, Taylor Elementary, on Anne Street, registered a loss of nearly one-quarter (22 percent) of its students during this period, which may be attributed to the aging neighborhood it primarily serves. The City’s other elementary school – Davis – is a technology magnet school for the entire District. The magnet school program is designed to improve student achievement through the integration of technology in the classroom. The school includes a technology lab which provides wireless capabilities and a 97 digital/audio and computerized publicity center. Being a magnet school may account for the stability of its membership, as it, like the two high schools, draws from throughout the District. Cyril B. Busbee Creative Arts Academy was one of ten schools in the state of South Carolina to be named as an award-winning Exemplary Writing School. However, the overall rating of the middle school was “poor” for the 2008 school year, according to the South Carolina Annual School Report Card. Both of the City’s high schools were rated in 2008 by the State as “average’, as was Taylor Elementary. Davis Elementary, on the other hand, was rated “poor”. Overall, these ratings translate into the need for improvements in the community’s educational system. To address this in part, the School District initiated in 2001 the Freshman Academy Program at Airport and Brookland-Cayce High Schools. The program targets students who have experienced limited academic success. It is designed to address the high failure rate of students in the ninth grade to improve their academic performance so they may be promoted to the 10th grade at the end of the term. TABLE 21 Cayce School Profiles, Trends School Grades 2001-02 Enrollment 2007-08 Enrollment Change Airport High 9-12 1,361 1,366 +5 Brookland-Cayce High 9-12 1,238 1,235 -3 Cyril Busbee Creative Arts Academy - Middle 6-8 377 399 +22 Davis Elementary K-5 385 392 +7 Taylor Elementary K-5 431 336 -95 Fulmer Middle 6-8 724 667 -57 Granby Alternative Center 1-12 Adult Ed 137 144 +7 Total K-12 4,653 4539 -114 Source. SC Department of Education and School District 2; 2009. 98 Between school years 2007-08 and 2013-14, enrollment (135 day membership) at these schools has been relatively stable, declining only slightly. Enrollment at Brookland-Cayce High School has registered a loss of almost one-fifth (19 percent). However, Taylor Elementary, on Anne Street, registered a gain of nearly one-fifth (19 percent) of its students during this period. Davis Elementary has registered a gain of nearly one-third (32 percent). In 2014, Cyril B. Busbee Creative Arts Academy’s overall rating was “average”, according to the South Carolina Annual School Report Card. Both of the City’s high schools were rated in 2014 by the State as “Good’, and Taylor Elementary was “Average”. Davis Elementary has not been rated for 2014. CONCLUSIONS From the preceding, it is obvious that the City is not the only community facility provider. It is just as obvious that the City has little if any control over the level or quality of many local services and facilities. It is also obvious that the City is not in a position to plan comprehensively for community facilities and services. Cooperation and coordination of and among the various facility providers are essential to an effective planning and orderly development process. Project concurrency also is an essential ingredient to an effective planning and development process. TABLE 21.a Cayce School Profiles, Trends School Grades 2007-08 Enrollment 2013-14 Enrollment Change Airport High 9-12 1,366 1,330 -6 Brookland-Cayce High 9-12 1,235 1,041 -194 Cyril Busbee Creative Arts Academy - Middle 6-8 399 304 -95 Davis Elementary K-5 392 578 +186 Taylor Elementary K-5 336 417 +81 Fulmer Middle 6-8 667 672 +5 Granby Alternative Center 1-12 Adult Ed 144 0 -144 Total K-12 4,539 4,342 -167 Source. SC Department of Education, and School District 2; 2009, 2014 99 COMMUNITY FACILITIES GOALS (CF) AND POLICIES Community Facility Goals CF-1: Coordinate the provision of community facilities to coincide with the projected needs of development. Policy: Toward this end a policy of concurrency is recommended. Also, impact statements should be required for large scale projects. CF-2: Facilitate infrastructure needs for new development in a fair and economical manner in relation to existing development and taxpayers. Action: Study feasibility of initiating “impact fees” to cover the cost of needed infrastructure in support of planned new development. Utility Goals CF-3: Maintain Quality Utility Services at Lowest Possible Rates. Action: Continue to monitor rates and cost of service for efficiency. Action: Monitor serviceability of utility lines. CF-4: Meet the Growing Utility Needs of the Community. Action: Plan for the expansion of utilities based on projected growth and development of the Community. CF-5: Eliminate Storm Water Flooding. 100 Action: Commit the City to responsibility for coordinating all storm drainage improvements and maintenance projects, including responsibility for coordinating improvements along DOT streets and highways and illicit discharge points, and inspecting private drainage channels and requiring and assisting property owners to clean and maintain these channels in accord with Section 4 of City Code 6-7-82. Action: Continue scheduled phase development and implementation of NPDES Storm Water Permit (study). This 3 year program is being developed by AMEC in conjunction with Lexington County and member cities of a consortium, including the City of Cayce. Action: Initiate study to document, prioritize and address storm water problems – engage residents in the process. Action: Expand and equip staff to assume additional responsibility for storm drainage improvements and maintenance once NPDES Storm Water study is complete. CF-6: Annex outside utility customers into the City. Policy: Enforcement of the City’s policy to require annexation/annexation agreement as a condition to receiving city water and/or sewer service. Action: Pursue annexation of currently facilitated water and sewer service customers located in unincorporated “donut areas” and outside areas strategically located to form a more logical service delivery area. Public Safety Goals CF-7: Maintain Optimum Response to Public Safety Calls. According to a majority of respondents to the Citizen questionnaire in support of this plan, the public safety Department is doing an excellent job in responding to emergency situations. 101 Action: Maintain full complement of qualified, crossed trained staff, and vehicle and equipment readiness to continue practice of optimum response. Action: Improve working conditions at the department by increasing storage, operational work space, and judicial (court) space. The feasibility of completely replacing the Public Safety building should be studied. CF-8: Ensure citizen readiness to respond to emergency situations. Action: Educate public on proper response to distress situations and assist in securing individual homes and apartments with fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, carbon monoxide detectors and ready access to emergency assistance. CF-9: Make Cayce a Safer Community ---in the Minds of the People, in the Streets, in the Neighborhoods, During the Day and During the Night. Action: Reduce the crime rate and fear of crime with increased presence of police in high crime areas. Action: Maintain a highly visible law enforcement presence on school grounds. This will help secure a safe environment conducive to an educational atmosphere and serve as a means of preventing criminal activity. CF-10: Improve the City’s ISO rating to Class 3, if economically feasible. Action: Call for an ISO inspection to determine what needs to be done to improve the City’s fire defenses to Class 3. Estimate cost of improvements based on results of the inspection; evaluate cost and benefits to determine proper course of action. 102 Parks and Recreation Goals CF-11 Maintain and Further Develop Quality Recreational Facilities and Promote their use. Action: Continue to pursue governmental grants for recreational programs and facilities. Action: Retain and nurture partnerships with non-profit organizations and other governmental entities. Action: Continually monitor and improve existing facilities as needed, including the addition of shade trees for park playgrounds, where needed. Action: Add to the community's park inventory by encouraging or requiring land development practices that reserve park space within or close to newly developed sites. This will ensure that park development keeps pace with residential development. The basis for requiring park and recreation space set asides is found in the following provision of Section 6-29-1120 of the South Carolina Code: "development regulations may provide for the dedication or reservation of land for recreation areas and other public services and facilities". Action: Extend Riverwalk Park to Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve. Action: Promote through better signage use of the City’s parks. Action: Work closely with County Recreation Department to better meet the needs of Cayce’s residents. 103 Health Services and Educational Goals CF-12: Provide Comprehensive Quality Healthcare Services which meet Community and Individual Needs and Expectations. CF-13: Empower all students to be problem solvers, users of technology, effective communicators, and life long learners in a rapidly changing global community, by providing challenging experiences in a safe, caring, supportive and cooperative environment. CF-14: Prepare students to contribute as productive and responsible citizens in a global society by ensuring innovative and challenging learning experiences. CF-15: Provide affordable, quality development child care to ensure that every child is ready to enter the first grade. CF-16: Provide a state-of-the-art safe and well maintained public school system, and ensure quality and equity in instructional programs. CF-17: Provide alternative training programs and opportunities for under-skilled persons outside the school system---to provide them with skills to participate in the work force. CF-18: Assist school district by providing volunteer municipal programs. 104 PART VI . TRANSPORTATION ELEMENT Urban development in general and economic development in particular are influenced perhaps more by transportation facilities than any other single element. The primary mode of transportation in Cayce, like all other communities in South Carolina, is the automobile. Public transportation is available on two fixed-route transit (bus) lines operated by Central Midlands Regional Transit Authority (CMRTA); and cab service is available from several companies operating out of Columbia. Travel service to places outside the community is available by air from the Columbia Metropolitan Airport, sharing a boundary with Cayce, and by Greyhound Bus lines and Am Track trains across the river in Columbia. AUTOMOBILE TRANSIT Transportation by automobile is sustained by the local street system. Responsibility for street maintenance is divided among the City, County and the State. Most major streets are on the state system and most subdivision and minor streets are the responsibility of the City Table 26 Class “C” Average Daily Traffic Volume Limits Street Classification Number Lanes Two Three Four Five Six Principal Arterial Divided Undivided 16,800 14,600 19,300 16,800 33,600 29,200 38,600 33,600 50,400 43,800 Minor Arterial Divided Undivided 12,400 10,800 14,300 12,400 24,800 21,600 28,600 24,800 37,200 32,400 Collector Divided Undivided 9,800 8,600 11,300 9,800 19,600 17,200 22,600 19,600 29,400 25,800 For Level “D” Service multiply “C” level limits by 1.15 For Level “F” Service multiply “C” level limits by 1.35. Source. SCDOT, 2006. 105 or County. Throughout the State, 65 percent of all streets and roads are on the State system for maintenance. The development and opening of new streets are regulated by the City. Streets are categorized by SCDOT and the Federal Department of Transportation into a hierarchy of “functional classification.” This system allows for evaluation and analysis of specific street segments within the overall functioning of the street network. Functional classification systems organize roadways based on accessibility and mobility. There is an inverse relationship between accessibility and mobility in transportation planning. At the top of the spectrum, Arterials provide the highest level of mobility due to their high travel speeds. However, these high travel speeds necessitate a restricted system of access points. At the other end of the spectrum, local streets provide the highest level of access to land, with numerous curb cuts and driveways. However, local streets must necessarily limit speed and mobility as a result of increased access. The capacity of City streets to serve existing and projected development is critical to the planning process. In evaluating that capacity, the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) categorizes all roadways on the basis of level of service (LOS). This defines streets and roads in terms of their service characteristics, ranging in levels from A to F. An “A” level of service roadway has free flow conditions with relatively low volumes and little or n o delays. The other end of the spectrum is an “F” LOS with stop and go operation and average signal delays greater than one minute. 106 All streets and roads in the Cayce urban area are designed to provide not less than a “C” level of service. Where traffic volumes exceed this designed service level, improvements are generally scheduled by the State. Typically, streets with an LOS of D, E or F are given top priority for improvements. Among the City’s major streets listed on Table 27, four meet the description of “four-lane undivided major arterial”: Knox Abbott, Charleston Highway, 12th Street, and Airport Boulevard. None of these streets exceeds the Class “C” average daily traffic volume limits established by SCDOT. As additional development occurs and the use of land intensifies, continuous monitoring will be required to remain alert to the need for street improvements. But much of the need may be anticipated through the local land use planning process, which is an integral part of any street planning exercise. The Columbia Area Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) includes three projects for the Cayce community in its FY-2006-2012 Study. One project includes improvements of the Airport Boulevard – I-26 I ntersection. The second includes an Airport Connector, directly linking Airport Boulevard with I-26, south of the existing interchange. The third project is for enhancing a small strip of State Street, between Frink Street and Lexington Avenue. It has been completed. No other street improvement or enhancement projects are planned at this time. This does not foreclose the need for improvements, including the need Table 27 Traffic Volume Counts, Selected Streets City of Cayce 2008 2013 Street Average Daily Traffic Average Daily Traffic Knox Abbott Drive 21,700 22,500 State Street 8,400 11,900 12th Street Knox Abbott to Naples Naples to Interstate 11,000 9,500 11,600 26,100 Frink Street 12th St. to Charleston Highway 12th St, to State St. 6,300 5,400 5,800 5,200 Airport Blvd: Charleston Hwy to I-26 13,700 11,900 Charleston Highway Knox Abbott to Williams St. Williams St, to I-26 26,800 13,300 23,900 32,400 Source. SC Department of Transportation, 2008, 2013. 107 to provide cul-de -sacs for streets in the Broad Acres neighborhood that end without any turning or maneuvering space. PEDESTRIAN AND BICYCLE TRANSIT The emphasis on transportation within the community is gradually shifting from sole reliance on the automobile to a more balanced combination of travel modes, including greater use in the future of mass transit, bicycles, and pedestrian walkways. Respondents to the Survey Questionnaire strongly suggested that greater emphasis be placed on pedestrian transit (adding sidewalks) and mass transit (improving the local bus system). Also smaller, more energy efficient automobiles are projected for the future. Moreover, the Columbia Area Transportation Study (COATS) recommends: (1) emphasizing pedestrian and bicycle features internal to land use developments; (2) raising public awareness campaigns to educate pedestrians and drivers about pedestrian and cyclist rights and responsibilities; and (3) incorporating bicycle/pedestrian needs into the design of future construction and expansion projects. Biking and walking, as complements to the local vehicular transportation system, provides numerous personal and social benefits, both in terms of a necessary means of travel, and for recreational opportunities. The personal benefits include healthy exercise and savings in transportation costs. Increased walking and biking also reduces vehicle miles traveled for personal automobiles, which reduces traffic congestion and the need for widening roads; this additionally creates less pollution. Pedestrian and bike activity also help support pedestrian oriented mixed-use districts and neighborhood commercial establishments, leading to a more vibrant community and increased quality of life. For some residents, biking or walking is a primary means of transportation, whether out of desire or necessity. And for others, having facilities present for walking, biking, or both adds a quality of life factor that may determine where a person chooses to live and work. The presence of a network of accessible and well-maintained sidewalks and biking facilities has shown to help communities attract new residents. The public input process for this 108 comprehensive plan update showed a citywide desire for more sidewalks and bicycle or multi-use trails, especially for routes that connect to parks, schools, open space, and other cultural amenities. Safety for pedestrians and cyclists represents a key challenge, given the high volume of traffic passing through the city’s street network. If facilities in the form of sidewalks, trails or bike lanes are not provided, then pedestrians and cyclists are forced to try and share busy roads with automobile traffic, which can often be dangerous. It is particularly important to ensure that safe routes to schools and parks are provided with sidewalks, crosswalks, and bicycle lanes. Renewed interest in pedestrian and bicycle transit stresses the need for transportation enhancements as a means to improve, expand and enhance such facilities in the City. Transportation Enhancements (TEs) are innovative, community-based projects that provide opportunities to expand transportation choices beyond traditional street and highway programs. Such projects enhance one’s travel experience by walking, bicycling, taking transit, or simply riding in a car. TE funds are available from SCDOT for retrofitting local streets and roads to accommodate bicycles and pedestrians, protect scenic vistas and the environment. These funds have been used in Cayce to improve sidewalks and streetscape part of State Street, and to expand the Riverwalk Trail. Greater use of these funds is needed to transition most neighborhood collector streets into enhanced multi-model passageways. Currently, sidewalks are limited principally to arterial streets, and not all of them. Also, there are a few sidewalks extending from local schools, and a few interior streets have sidewalks leading to nowhere and linking nothing, as gaps exist throughout the system. Future Sidewalk Planning As part of this plan, a survey of existing sidewalks was conducted. It was determined from the survey that there are many gaps in the city’s sidewalk network, and some sidewalks go nowhere. While it is not necessary that there be sidewalks on every street – there are several areas (including industrial areas) where pedestrians simply are unlikely to want to walk. There are numerous areas of the city where there is heavy foot traffic and sidewalks are either non-existent or incomplete. Other areas that lack adequate 109 pedestrian facilities may see an increase in foot traffic if they were provided. Also missing is adequate linkage to schools, parks, Riverwalk trail, and commercial areas. In short, the city has sidewalks, but not a system or network. Connectivity is missing. To address these inadequacies and provide for a connected network, the following criteria for improving existing or constructing new sidewalks is recommended: 1. Identification of quantifiable need as determined by: Obvious dirt foot paths, Existing sidewalk not compliant with Americans with Disabilities Act, and Evidence of pedestrian fatalities or injuries. 2. Near Schools . Not every school-aged child rides a bus to school. For kids that live near their school and walk to school, they must have a safe place to travel. Areas within ¼ mile of schools should be the highest priority for sidewalk improvements – ¼ mile is generally estimate as a 5-minute walk, a distance that people will usually choose to walk. 3. Bus Stops. For those who do not own cars or choose to use public transportation, sidewalks leading to bus stops are necessary for safe pedestrian travel. 4. Near Parks. People are likely to walk to parks if they are located within a short walking distance (5-minute walk from a park). 5. Commercial Corridors. Those who do not own cars will walk to commercial areas for their service needs, as well as some who enjoy walking from their home to retail or restaurants, if sidewalks are available. Areas with a lot of foot traffic and inadequate pedestrian walkways should be a high priority for sidewalks. 110 6. Along Residential Collector Streets. Movement through or to and from most residential neighborhoods is by way of collector streets. These streets carry enough traffic to warrant sidewalks for convenience and safety, and to link the various neighborhoods with the above locations and form an unbroken network of sidewalks throughout the community. Using the above criteria, a plan for extending existing sidewalks to create a connected sidewalk network linking most educational, social, recreational and commercial generators, and subsequently enhancing pedestrian safety and movement within the City is recommended and shown on the Sidewalk Plan Map. A word of caution, however. Sidewalk construction should be preceded by an impact analysis on the storm drainage system in those parts of the city subject to periodic flooding, so as not to exacerbate flooding. MASS AND PARA-TRANSIT Mass transit is provided in Cayce and the Columbia Metropolitan Area by the Columbia Midlands Regional Transit Authority (CMRTA). The *CMRTA was formed in 2002. It replaced SCANA as the responsible entity for providing mass transit service to the area. The *CMRTA provides fixed-route bus and para-transit services throughout the metropolitan Columbia area. Daily operations are contracted to a private company. The network includes 30 fixed routes, operating in a hub-and-spoke system centered on downtown Columbia. There is one route through Cayce and it extends through the community to Midlands Technical College. All routes operate on weekdays, 24 operate on Saturdays, and 14 operate on Sundays. Service is provided 365 days per year, excluding holidays. The route through Cayce terminates in downtown Columbia, at Laurel and Assembly, where transfers are available. In addition to mass transit, *CMRTA provides para-transit service. Dial-A-Ride Transit (DART) is *CMRTA’s para-transit (demand response transportation) service that is provided to individuals with disabilities who cannot use the fixed-route network. This service is provided to meet the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). DART provides curb-to-curb, advance reservation, shared ride 111 transportation service. A DART serves customer located within ¾ mile of a fixed route, and is available during the same operating hours as fixed-route service. There are no restrictions on the purpose or frequency of trips for DART customers. *CMRTA envisions the role of mass transit to be the travel mode of choice for a broader constituency by the year 2030. In its vision statement *CMRTA maintains the system “will provide a high degree of mobility for a diverse group of travelers. Excellent services will be available to traditional transit user groups, including those too young or old to drive, low income citizens, the disabled and those without access to an automobile. As a result of improvements in the quality, extent and efficiency of transit services, mass transit will also become the travel mode of choice for a broader constituency, including college students, suburban commuters, and families or individuals who choose a less automobile dependent lifestyle...” More intensive use of mass transit is conditioned on careful coordination of bus services and land use policies designed to reduce vehicular traffic. Public transit is most feasible in areas of dense development that create enough ridership demand. Strategic land use planning will create a pattern of high density residential, commercial and mixed-use nodes along major transportation corridors that will support transit services. Cayce should pursue Transit Oriented Development regulations for areas in which it wishes to increase density with the purpose of supporting mass transit. This would allow a mix of land use and higher density within walking distances of existing or future transit stops. It would also set requirements for developing pedestrian facilities, such as bus shelters, pedestrian signalization at intersections, and adequate sidewalks. As currently configured, the existing route alignment is not convenient for many riders, and this likely impacts ridership. *CMRTA was renamed to COMET in 2013. RAIL TRANSIT Rail service in the Metropolitan Area includes both passenger and freight. Amtrak has a station just across the river from Cayce in downtown Columbia, with daily stops between New York and Florida. CSX 112 Corporation and Norfolk Southern own and operate an extensive rail network through and within the Region, with approximately 308 route miles of railroad lines in the four counties. The lines are predominately single track, with no extended sections of double track. This limits rail line capacity, since trains must wait on sidings to pass each other. The capacity of single track depends on a number of factors including the number of sidings, the mix of trains using a segment, the track grade, curvature, speed limits in effect, and the method of dispatch control. AIR TRANSIT The Columbia Metropolitan Airport (CAE) shares boundaries with the City of Cayce. It occupies a 2, 600 acre site and contains more than 50 agencies and businesses. Air passenger and cargo service are provided by scheduled airlines, jet freight carriers, two fixed base operators, and various charter flights. Air operations are conducted on an 8,600' x 150' runway and an 8,000' x 150' runway. Annually, the airport serves more than 1.2 million passengers and processes more than 168,000 tons of air cargo. A major terminal renovation was completed in 1997. The airport was reestablished in 1962 as the Richland-Lexington Airport District. As such, it is a political sub-division of the state of South Carolina. The governing body of the Airport District is the Richland- Lexington Airport Commission, which consists of twelve members. Five members are representative of Richland County and are nominated by the Richland County Legislative Delegation. Five members are representative of Lexington County and are nominated by the Lexington County Legislative Delegation. Two members are representative of the City of Columbia and are nominated by the Columbia City Council. Commission members are appointed for four year terms. The airport contains a 108-acre foreign-trade zone (FTZ 127), which is an attractive economic development stimulus. A foreign-trade zone is a duty-free, quota-free, secure area in a Customs Port of Entry considered to be outside the U.S. Customs territory. Both domestic and foreign goods can be brought to an FTZ for assembly, manufacture, display, storage or processing without formal Customs entry. Duty payments are not required until the merchandise leaves the zone for domestic consumption. If re-exported, no duty payments are made. 113 CONCLUSIONS From the preceding we may conclude: 1. T hat the city’s street network is functioning properly, with no major trouble spots or recorded traffic volumes in excess of what the network is designed to handle; 2. That a network of sidewalks and bicycle paths is sorely lacking, Riverwalk Park notwithstanding. There are far too many gaps in the existing system of sidewalks to form a functioning network – one that links residential areas to educational, recreational, commercial and social generators; 3. That mass (bus) transit, with but one route, is inconvenient for many if not most riders; 4. That the city’s street network needs enhancing and retrofitting to better meet the need for alternatives to gasoline powered automobiles; and 5. That traffic circulation in the Broad Acres neighborhood is restricted by the absence of cul-de - sacs or other means of turning around at the end of many streets. TRANSPORTATION GOALS (TG) AND POLICIES New Development TG-1: Coordinate transportation and land use planning in new developments. 114 Action: Monitor new development for its impact on the level of service (LOS) of existing streets. Action: Allow the SC Department of Transportation to set thresholds for requirements on Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) reports. Action: Provide for flexible, negotiated traffic mitigation measures for large new developments that facilitate pedestrian, bicycle and mass transit access. Action: Support context-sensitive roadway design in order to ensure that transportation facilities are compatible with surrounding neighborhoods and activity centers. Action: Encourage street connectivity to enhance traffic flow. Action: Encourage the use of “neo-traditional” design standards, featuring grid-like street patterns and sidewalks. Discourage use of one-way-in and one-way-out cul-de-sac development, except where dictated by geographic conditions or safety concerns. Action: Discourage cul-de-sac and dead-end streets in new developments where natural features do not prevent street connectivity. Action: Require large new residential subdivisions to provide multiple entrances and exit points. Action: Limit the number of curb cuts and driveways allowed for development along major roadways. Existing Streets TG-2: Improve circulation, condition and safety of existing street system. Action: Continually monitor street system to ensure that it is functioning properly. 115 Action: Take corrective action to maintain and/or improve the existing street system. To this end, the City may have to assume greater involvement in the maintenance of local streets, not in the state highway maintenance program. Action: Provide cul-de-sacs or other appropriate turning configurations on all existing dead-end streets. Walking and Bicycling The Central Midlands Regional Vision Statement and Goals contained in the Columbia Area Transportation Study are herein restated and included as part of this Plan, as follows. Vision Statement. The Central Midlands region (Cayce) will be a place where people choose to make walking and/or bicycling a part of their everyday lives. Residents and visitors will walk and ride with confidence, safety, and security, as bicycling and walking become a routine part of our transportation system. TG-3: Goals of the plan include the following. 1. To provide a safe, efficient, and accessible transportation system to all residents and visitors, which allows them to walk and bicycle alongside other modes with independence and comfort. 2. To foster bicycle and pedestrian access and mobility in all transportation and development projects at local, regional, and state levels of government and in all project phases, including planning, design, construction, and maintenance. 3. To support and encourage the integration of transportation and land use decisions that result in the promotion of development patterns that allow bicycling and walking to be viable, everyday modes of travel. 116 4. To support and enhance healthy lifestyles and good stewardship of the environment by providing safe and convenient opportunities for bicycle and pedestrian travel, thereby increasing active living, while reducing auto emissions and fuel usage. 5. To identify opportunities, funding sources, and responsible public and private agencies/entities at the local, regional, and state levels so that bicycle and pedestrian projects and programs can be implemented. Policy. Expand the city’s system of sidewalks and bike lanes. Action: Link Riverwalk Park with sidewalk network in the City and eventually extend network to include the trail at the Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve. Action: Provide annual budgeting to go towards sidewalk and trail development and local matches for regional, state and federal trail grants. Action: Implement sidewalk plan along the following streets using the following construction priority list recommended by the Planning Commission and Ad Hoc Committee: 1. Naples St., from State St. to Lorick St. (approved for funding by SCDOT) 2. Frink St., from Haynes Lane to Taylor St. (approved for funding by SCDOT) 3. Axtel St., full distance 4. 12th St., Knox Abbott to Evergreen 5. Lafayette Avenue, from Charleston Highway to State St. 6. Julius Felder St., from Charlotte Avenue to Taylor Road 7. Taylor Road, from Frink St. to Julius Felder St. 8. Frink St., remainder of street without sidewalks (see Map) 9. North Eden Drive, from existing sidewalk to Charleston Highway 117 10. Dunbar Road, from Wilkinson St. to Reco Ball Field 11. Holland Avenue, between 10th and 11th Streets 12. 9th St., from Lafayette Ave. to Knox Abbott Drive 13. Wilkinson St., from Dunbar to Poplar St. Action. Reconstruct and/or improve existing sidewalks in disrepair and/or not compliant with the Americans Disabilities Act along the following streets, using the following priority schedule. 1. Dunbar Road, from Morlaine St. to Wilkinson St. 2. Knox Abbott, prioritize selected sections 3. Other Streets – maintain, monitor and prioritize for improvements, as needed. 118 PART VII. ECONOMIC ELEMENT This element of the Plan focuses on internal as well as external forces and conditions that shape the City's economy, and are responsible for the standard of living of its inhabitants. The local economy is not confined to the City limits. It is shaped to a large extent by what is happening in the County, the region, the State, and internationally. Therefore, this element looks beyond the City when assessing economic conditions, constraints and capabilities. EMPLOYMENT AND LABOR FORCE Lexington County's civilian labor force, which includes the City of Cayce (not seasonally adjusted), grew from 117,950 in 2000 to 133,280 by 2008. Unfortunately, this 13 percent increase did not translate into 13 percent more jobs, as the labor market was unable to fully absorb the increase. Unemployment grew during this period by 85 percent, from 2.7 to 5 percent. The larger Columbia metro labor market, of which Cayce is also a part, increased to 374,454 in December 2008. This increase was accompanied by an increase in the unemployment rate to 7.6 percent (seasonally adjusted) compared with 6.5 percent in Lexington County. Failure of the local economy to absorb growth of the labor market coupled with job losses, and the subsequent increase in unemployment has led in part to the enactment of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Stimulus Plan), which is designed among other things to create more jobs and lower the unemployment rate. By 2010, the labor Table 28 Annual Labor Force Trends Lexington County Year Labor Force Employment Unemployment Rate 2010 133,487 122,639 8.1 2008 133,280 126,655 5.0 2006 131,161 125,113 4.6 2004 124,748 118,660 4.9 2002 117,720 113,090 3.9 2000 117,950 114,810 2.7 Source. SC Employment Secur ity Commission. Not seasonally adjusted. 119 force increased but the unemployment rate continued to go up. An unemployment rate of 8.1 was reported for Lexington County in 2010. Major employment sectors in the Cayce labor market include Manufacturing, Retail Trade, Finance and Insurance, Services and Professional. The contribution of each of these sectors, as well as others, to the local job market and economy is illustrated on Table 29. The table shows the impact of the Service industry Table 29 Employment By Industry Sector City of Cayce 2000 2009 NAICS Code Industry Description Number # Employed Percent Number # Employed Percent Total Male Female Total Male Female 23 Construction 444 7.7 85.0 15.0 346 5.4 96.5 3.5 31-33 Manufacturing 519 9.0 78.0 22.0 469 7.0 73.1 26.9 42 Wholesale Trade 231 4.0 75.0 25.0 207 3.0 76 23 44-45 Retail Trade 731 12.7 45.0 55.0 914 14.0 56.0 44 48-49 Transportation/warehousing 320 5.5 67.0 33.0 524 8.0 66.8 33.2 51 Information 167 2.9 65.0 35.0 94 5.6 37.2 62.8 52 Finance/Insurance 478 8.3 45.0 55.0 335 5.2 28.7 71.3 54 Professional/Scientific etc. 533 9.2 49.0 51.0 583 9.0 58.8 41.2 61 Education/Health/Social Service 1,106 19.2 18.0 82.0 1,413 22.0 28.5 71.5 71-72 Art/Entertainment/Accommodation/ Food Service/Recreation 541 9.4 49.0 51.0 809 12.6 64 36 81 Other Services 266 4.6 53.0 47.0 245 3.8 62.9 37.1 92 Public Administration 431 7.5 49.0 51.0 411 6.4 57.2 42.8 Source. U.S. Census Bureau, American Fact Finder, 2000,2009-2013 Community Survey 120 on the local economy, which has been dubbed the major growth industry in the State and appears to be no less significant in Cayce. According to the 2000 Census, the Service industry was broad in scope and by far the largest employer in the community. It includes education, health and social services, which make up the largest sub- segment at 19.2 percent, followed by Art/Entertainment (9.4 percent), professional and scientific (9.2 percent), finance/insurance (8.3 percent), public administration (7.5 percent), information (2.9 percent) and other miscellaneous and lesser represented services (4.6 percent). According to the 2010 Census, the service industry continues to be the largest employer in Cayce (22 percent). According to the 2010 Census, manufacturing continues to be a major economic force in Cayce, ranked sixth (9 percent) among the 12 major sectors and accounting for a little below 1 in every 10 jobs. Retail and Wholesale trade jobs also contribute substantially to the local economy, accounting for 14 percent of all jobs. Construction accounts for 5.4 percent and Transportation/warehousing accounts for 8.0 percent of the work force. Most currently, females comprise 45.5 percent of persons 16 and over in the City’s labor force. A closer look at the make-up of the City's labor force (16 years and older) shows females dominating employment in the fields of education, health and social services, and comprising the majority of jobs in finance, insurance, real estate and information. Females also account for a majority of the labor force in management, professional and related occupations, service, sales and office jobs. Males, on the other hand, are more commonly employed 0% 20% 40% 60% CHART 6 MAJOR EMPLOYMENT SECTORS, CITY OF CAYCE, 2000 and 2009 121 in farming, production, maintenance and construction occupations but, the number of males in jobs, such as Professional/Scientific, and Art/Food services has increased over the last 10 years. EMPLOYMENT CHARACTERISTICS Statistically, and for analytical purposes, economic data are divided into two sectors: manufacturing and non-manufacturing. A discussion of each follows. Manufacturing Sector Since the industrialization of the South, manufacturing has driven the local economy, previously in the form of textiles. Neither textiles in particular nor manufacturing in general dominate the local economy as they once did. However, manufacturing remains important to the economic well being of the community. To illustrate the importance, studies have shown that the creation of 100 new manufacturing jobs can have the following impact on the local economy. • Create 68 new non-manufacturing jobs, • add one (1) retail establishment, • add to bank deposits, • add to retail sales, and • add to personal income. Additionally, 100 new manufacturing jobs will produce about 67 new families and add approximately 350 people and 80 school children. Manufacturing jobs have declined statewide despite intensive recruitment efforts by the state. From 27 percent of all non-farm jobs in 1986, manufacturing jobs dropped to just 12 percent across the State in 122 2008. For the same period, manufacturing jobs made up 8.4 of all non-farm jobs in the Columbia MSA labor market and 8.9 percent of the Cayce labor market. There have been no new industrial plants to locate in the Cayce community since 2000, but SCANA is in the process of relocating its primary operations from Columbia to the 12th Extension and I-77 interchange. This will add substantially to the development of 12th Street Extension as an “Industrial Corridor”. While new industrial development has been relatively dormant since the turn of the Century, the community has been successful in retaining most of its more entrenched industries, some dating to establishment as early as 1941. The community’s largest industries, in terms of employment, include Owens Electric Steel, SMI Joist Company and American Investors. The list of major industrial employers will soon be joined by SCANA. Although not all of the industries listed on Table 30 are located in the City of Cayce, the contribution of these manufacturers and others to the City’s economy is considerable. Local industries contribute directly through municipal utility revenues and indirectly with jobs and incomes. 123 Table 30 Profile Cayce Industrial Plants Name NAICS Established Employees Location American Investors, LLC 3241 1999 100 1839 Dunbar Rd. Aqua Seal Manufacturing 3241 1992 48 1144 Walter Price St. CMS Business Forms 3231 1984 7 918 Holland Ave. Carolina Lantern Inc. 3351 1992 30 903 Poplar St. Carolina Letterpress Inc. 3231 1990 6 1817 Middle St. Interstate Brands Corp. 3118 NA 13 1923 Edmund Rd. Javelyn Manufacturing 3152 1984 5 903 Poplar St. Krispy Kreme Donut Corp. 3118 1992 42 1200 Knox Abbott Drive Magnum Publications LLC 5111 1986 25 530 Knox Abbott Drive Martin Marietta Materials 2123 1894 42 2125 State St. Mobile Mini Inc. 3372 NA 10 1139 Walter Price St. Commercial Metal Corporation 3241 1962 400 310 New State Road Ronnie Brazell 3221 1985 2 202 Moss Creek Drive Rose’s Quality Paints 3255 1973 20 901 Frink St. Signs By Tomorrow 3399 1988 2 1900 State St. Sloan Construction 3241 1968 3 600 Taylor St. RECO 3323 1935 NA 1839 Old Dunbar Rd. Tube City LLC 2123 NA 43 310 New State Rd. WC Manufacturing 3362 1954 55 2028 Charleston Hwy. Wilbert Columbia Vault Co. 3279 1941 30 1741 Airport Blvd. Source. 2007 Harris South Carolina Manufacturers Directory, SC Chamber of Commerce, 2015 City of Cayce Business Licenses 124 Non-manufacturing Sector Evolution of the national, state and local economies has been dominated by growth in the non-manufacturing sector. Growth in this sector has accounted for most new jobs at the State and National levels. In Cayce, there were job losses in both sections from 1997 to 2002. But non- manufacturing jobs still increased in relation to manufacturing jobs, climbing from 75 to 79 percent of all jobs locally. Manufacturing jobs declined by 42 percent, while non- manufacturing jobs went from 2,870 to 2,821, declining by only two percent. Other noteworthy changes in the local economy include small increases in the number of professional, technical, administrative, health care, art, entertainment, food service and other service establishments. Unfortunately the growth of these establishments was not enough to offset the loss of manufacturing, wholesale, and retail establishments. 1312 922 2870 2821 1997 2002 CHART 8 City of Cayce Manufacturing/Non-manufacturing Jobs/ Trends Manufacturing Non-manufacturing 125 That the County’s job market is becoming increasingly service oriented is not surprising. The service industry has become the driving force of South Carolina’s economy. In fact, the service industry is projected by the S.C. Employment Security Commission to provide one of every two new jobs in the state. This projection likely will apply to Lexington County and Cayce as well, based on local development trends. The service sector is involved in one way or another in all aspects of business, including legal services, lodging, childcare services, education, health care and most business services in support of other industries in one way or another. Table 31 Economic Sector Trends City of Cayce, 1997-2002 1997 2002 NAICS Code Industry Description Number Establishments Number Employees Annual Payroll ($1,000) Number Establishments Number Employees Annual Payroll ($1,000) 31-33 Manufacturing 26 1,312 35,867 15 922 34,909 42 Wholesale Trade 21 589 18,915 19 219 9,298 44-45 Retail Trade 62 847 14,223 47 614 14,975 51 Information NA NA NA 9 154 4,914 53 Real Estate/leasing 14 40 814 13 35 912 54 Professional/Technical 18 161 4,402 27 169 7,407 56 Admin./Remediation 11 358 3,584 13 324 5,040 62 Health Care/Social Ser. 16 138 2,821 19 201 4,782 71 Arts/Ent./ Recreation 3 33 479 5 NA NA 72 Accommodation/Food Ser. 38 855 6,274 42 882 8,442 81 Other Services 24 266 3,537 28 212 6,127 Total 233 4,599 90,916 237 3,743 96,806 Source. U.S. Census Bureau, American Fact Finder, Selected years. 126 Thirty-one of the “Big 50” (largest employers in the State) are non- manufacturing, including five located in the Columbia labor market: Palmetto Health, BlueCross-Blue Shield, Lexington County Health Services, BB&T, and First Citizens Bank Corporation. WORKER COMMUTING PATTERNS Lexington County exports more labor than it imports. Approximately 44 percent of the County’s workforce commutes outside the County for employment, the vast majority (88 percent), as expected, to Richland County. The county is also the recipient of a large influx of workers from Richland County. In fact, 65 percent of labor in-commuting to the County is from Richland County. The worker exchange with all other nearby counties is heavily weighted toward Lexington. The imbalance with Richland County is due primarily to Columbia’s historical position as the State Capitol, and growth emanating there from. Also, the presence of the University of South Carolina and Fort Jackson, and jobs at four of the five “Big 50” non-manufacturing industries located in Richland County help create the imbalance of worker exchanges. Worker exchanges with other nearby counties are indicative of the County’s growing industrial position in the region. Its position has been aided over time by its central location and enhanced access via interstates 26 and 77, and bridge construction better linking it to Columbia and Richland County. Worker exchange through commuting produces a net in-migration of 4,106 workers from all other places. TABLE 32 WORKER COMMUTING PATTERNS, LEXINGTON COUNTY County of Residence In-commuting From Out-commuting To Net Exchange Richland 18,860 44,237 -25,377 Saluda 1,591 218 +1,373 Aiken 1,428 613 +815 Newberry 1,386 606 +780 Orangeburg 1,110 520 +590 Calhoun 1,001 233 +768 All Other Places 3,443 3,834 -391 Total 28,819 50,261 -21,442 Source. Worker Commuting Patterns, SC Employment Securi9ty Commission, 2008. 127 Commuting patterns reveal a shift in the county’s position from a former “Bedroom County” in the larger Columbia Metropolitan Area to an integral and equal partner in the economic complex that is the Columbia Metropolitan Area. Table 34 Projected Job Growth, By Occupation, 2007-2016 Occupation Lexington County (%) South Carolina (%) Management occupations 21 17 Business and financial operations occupations 22 22 Computer and mathematical science occupations 29 23 Architecture and engineering occupations 16 15 Life, physical and social science occupations 21 15 Community and social services occupations 23 15 Legal occupations 28 21 Education, training and library occupations 21 16 Arts, design, entertainment, sports and media occupations 22 17 Healthcare practitioners and technical occupations 30 24 Healthcare support occupations 35 25 Protective service occupations 14 18 Food preparation and serving related occupations 15 13 Building and grounds cleaning and maintenance occupations 26 23 Personal care and service occupations 15 7 Sales and related occupations 26 19 Office and administrative support occupations 15 13 Farming, fishing and forestry occupations 14 16 Construction and extraction occupations 18 19 Installation, maintenance and repair occupations 16 17 Production occupations 5 10 Transportation and material moving occupations 10 11 Source. SC Department of Commerce, Labor Market Analysis Lexington County, 2009 128 EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES/PROJECTIONS According to the Employment Security Commission, future job creation will come principally from the service sector, followed by the wholesale and retail sectors, as shown on Table 33. Government jobs, construction, transportation and public utilities also are projected to add to the job market. The County also may benefit from job creation in the agricultural services sector, which is projected to add nearly 5,000 jobs statewide by 2010. No additional jobs are projected for the manufacturing sector. Instead, projections show further reductions in this sector. The County is projected by the South Carolina Department of Commerce to create a higher percentage of jobs in the future than the state as a whole in all but a handful of occupations, as shown by Table 34. This is an encouraging economic development forecast, not only for the County, but the City of Cayce as well. 129 Table 33 Projected job Growth, By Industry Industry Title 2000 2010 Base Employment Percent Employed Projected Employment Percent Employed Change Employment Percent Total, All Industries 1,968,330 100.00 2,267,870 100.00 299,540 15.2 Agricultural Services 12,590 0.64 17,460 0.77 4,870 38.7 Mining 1,830 0.09 1,820 0.08 (10) -0.5 Construction 113,060 5.74 126,940 5.60 13,880 12.3 Manufacturing 345,140 17.53 336,520 14.84 (8,620) (2.5) Transportation and Public Utilities 101,870 5.18 119,840 5.28 17,970 17.6 Wholesale and Retail Trade 440,480 22.38 496,630 21.90 56,150 12.7 Finance, Insurance and Real Estate 79,450 4.04 87,680 3.87 8,230 10.4 Services 731,580 37.17 910,240 40.14 178,660 24.4 Government 131,130 6.66 141,790 6.25 10,660 8.1 Source. SC Employment Security Commission. 130 CONCLUSIONS From the preceding, we know that: (1) The local economic base is changing, with manufacturing jobs declining, and service jobs generally on the increase; (2) Job creation since 2000 has not kept pace with growth of the local labor market, resulting in higher unemployment and job losses, accelerated by the economic downturn of 2008-09; (3) The number of retail and wholesale jobs and establishments declined between 1997 and 2002, and likely will continue to decline until the National economic crisis of 2008-09 is remedied and; (4) The future job market is heavily oriented toward service and retail occupations, the current economic downturn notwithstanding. ECONOMIC GOALS (EG) AND POLICIES EG-1: Develop and maintain a balanced economy of sufficient size and strength to ensure a sustainable quality of life. Realization of this goal starts with retaining the communities existing industries and businesses. Policy: Provide technical and financial assistance to existing industries and businesses, where needed, to help survive present economic conditions and adapt to a changing world economy. Policy: Encourage the provision of quality child care service for low-to-moderate income workers. Promote 131 provision of on-site child care by employers to aid employers. EG-2: Attract new business and industry to Cayce, with emphasis on manufacturing jobs. The significance of manufacturing jobs is in the multiplier effect on non-manufacturing jobs, retail sale s and establishments, bank deposits, and higher wages. It is undeniable that like uses (manufacturing) attract like uses (manufacturing). The City’s existing manufacturing base centered on 12th Street Extension and its position at the intersection of I-26 and I-77 should aid in attracting additional manufacturing companies, provided the proper emphasis is placed on recruiting and accommodating such development. Policy: Coordinate economic development activities with infrastructure and service providers, a nd community plans. Policy: Foster an entrepreneurial environment that encourages economic development. Action: 1. Create new marketing tools, including CD presentations, showing the movement of better paying jobs and higher quality life conditions within the community. 2. Provide business incentives to attract desired industries. 3. Craft and maintain zoning regulations designed to sustain and enhance existing business and industrial uses and identify and protect areas suitable for new and expanded business and industry from encroachment by interim land uses which would detract from, would be incompatible with, or would preclude their future industrial or business utility. 4. Recycle Race Track for major outdoor shows and exhibits. 132 Policy: Promote the development of planned industrial parks. Action: Continue to support and cooperate with the Greater Columbia Chamber of Commerce, West Metro Chamber of Commerce, the South Carolina Chamber of Commerce, the South Carolina Department of Commerce, Lexington County Economic Development Office and other regional business organizations engaged in economic development and recruitment. Action: Assist Economic Development Agencies by Prioritizing Community Industrial Recruitment Objectives. Setting priorities locally is critical to succeeding in the recruitment of preferred and compatible industry. The South Carolina Department of Commerce is the lead state agency for industrial recruitment, development and maintenance. The Central South Carolina Alliance is the regional conduit and the Lexington County Industrial Development Office is the local point agency for these duties. In their combined approach to economic development in general and the above goal in particular, it is recommended that their focus be on recruitment of industries for the Cayce Community that are (1) environmentally sound, and (2) pay high wages. Industry meeting these criteria would be a welcome addition to almost any community. Higher paying industries equate to higher standards of living. Environmentally sound industry generally is compatible with its surroundings and therefore unopposed by environmental groups. But what kinds of industries meet these criteria? 133 High Paying Industries Technology industries, emphasizing research and development (R&D), generally meet this criterion. In fact, the South Carolina Department of Commerce has assembled a list of technology industries based on their growth potential and above average wage scales. Included in this list are the following: SIC INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION 281 Industrial Inorganic Chemicals 282 Plastics materials and synthetic resins, synthetic rubber, cellulosic and other manmade fibers, except glass 283 Drugs 284 Soap, Detergents and Cleaning Preparations, Perfumes, Cosmetics and other Toilet Preparations 285 Paints, Varnishes, Lacquers, Enamels and Allied Products 286 Industrial Organic Chemicals 287 Agricultural Chemicals 289 Miscellaneous Chemical Products 348 Ordinance and Accessories except Vehicles and Guided Missiles 351 Engines and Turbines 353 Construction, Mining and Materials Handling Machinery 355 Special Industry Machinery, except Metalworking Machinery 356 General Industrial Machinery and Equipment 357 Computer and Office Equipment 359 Miscellaneous Industrial and Commercial Machinery & Equipment 361 Electric Transmission and Distribution Equipment 362 Electrical Industrial Apparatus 365 Household Audio and Video Equipment and Audio Recordings 134 366 Communication Equipment 367 Electronic Components and Accessories 369 Miscellaneous Electrical Machinery, Equipment & Supplies 371 Motor Vehicles and Motor Vehicle Equipment 372 Aircraft and Parts 376 Guided Missiles and Space Vehicles and Parts 379 Miscellaneous Transportation Equipment 381 Search, Detection, Navigation, Guidance, Aeronautical and Nautical Systems 382 Laboratory Apparatus and Analytical, Optical, Measuring and Controlling Instruments 384 Surgical, Medical and Dental Instruments and Supplies 385 Ophthalmic Goods 386 Photographic Equipment and Supplies 387 Watches, Clocks, Clockwork Operated Devices and Parts 737 Computer Programming and Related 739 Commercial research and laboratories 891 Engineering services That these industries are relatively high paying, job security and income are rarely employment issues. As a result, union membership is low to nonexistent in most workplaces. Environmentally Sound Industries This is an area in which the community must be very careful. Air quality standards enacted in 1999 limit ozone, an ingredient of smog, to 0.08 parts per million compared with the current standard of 0.12 parts per million. States and counties that do not meet the standards will have to implement rules to improve air quality or face losing federal funds. In addition to being mindful of industries impacting the state’s guidelines for air emissions, industrial recruiters should closely scrutinize chemical industries-SIC 28-and primary metal industries-SIC 33. While 135 it is unfair to categorically define industries on the basis of their environmental relationships, the inherent production process of many of these industries is such that the potential exist for environmental conflict. However, the real gauge here should not be industrial classification, but the track record and history of a given industry, particularly small chemical mixing plants and industries impacting air quality. Action: Assist with Development of Local Marketing Plans and Strategies. Following is a two point program designed to aid in the recruitment and/or expansion of industry and business in the Cayce Community. Product Development: Direct economic efforts to improving the City’s weaknesses and maintaining its strengths. Marketing Materials: Create or modify specific marketing collateral pieces such as proposal presentations, brochures, CDs, multi-media presentations, advertising copy, etc. EG-3: Strengthen the Business Climate and Enhance Aesthetics of Knox Abbott Drive. There have been a number of recommendations and efforts in the past to enhance the economic viability and aesthetics of Knox Abbott Drive. And conditions generally have improved, particularly of late with the application and enforcement of rigid sign regulations. But much remains to be done to improve the aesthetics, increase the drawing power, and intensify the development of the City’s prime “commercial corridor” and primary entrance. Action: Prepare Streetscaping Plan, to include placing utility lines underground, tree planting, highlighted crosswalks, decorative signage and more. Refer to City’s Master Plan Charrette for details Action: Prepare a marketing strategy, based on market survey results contained in the city’s Master Plan Charrette (May, 2009), to help attract new businesses. It will take more than physical improvements to fully realize the potential economic contribution of Knox Abbott Drive. 136 EG-4: Create New Economic Markets to Cash in on South Carolina's Emerging Recreation- Retirement Image. Action: Expand local economic development efforts to include tourist and retiree markets. The state has placed great emphasis on promoting South Carolina as a tourist destination and retirement place. With so much free advertising by the state, it should be relatively economical for the City to cash in on these initiatives and enjoy the benefits of an even broader based economy. Action: Develop a more aggressive tourism and retirement promotion program, together with educational programs for individuals involved in tourism, and the integration of infrastructure development in support of tourism including historic lodging facilities, specialty restaurants, etc. 137 PART VIII. LAND USE ELEMENT In many respects, the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan is the cumulative product of the preceding seven elements, as it is based in part on information developed in each. For organizational purposes this Element is divided into five components: An Existing Land Use Component, An Issues Component, A Goals and Policies Component, A Plan Map Component, and A Compliance Index Component. The Existing Land Use Component provides the background and physical base upon which the Plan is predicated. After all, we are not starting from scratch. We are starting with a “built environment”. It is critical to the planning process to survey, inventory and evaluate the existing use of land as a starting point. From the survey and analysis of existing land use, the land use Issues Component is developed. It identifies problems and issues which should be addressed by the Plan. The Goals and Policies Component provides direction and articulates a guide to future development. The Plan Map Component establishes and illustrates geographic goals and objectives designed to accomplish a planned physical order of the community. And the Compliance Index Component provides instructions on the use of the Plan as it relates to zoning, proposed zoning amendments and development proposals. It is designed to ensure plan compliance as a condition to proposed zoning and development changes. EXISTING LAND USE COMPONENT In order to plan for the future, we need to understand the past and the existing use of land produced by it. This will help determine future expectations and the degree of departure, if any, from established patterns of growth and intensity which may be applied in planning future development. 138 1999 Assessment of Existing Land Use The 1999 Comprehensive Plan described the status of Existing Land Use at that time as follows. “The existing land use indicates a pattern of typical auto-oriented suburban development. Major traffic arteries, particularly Knox Abbott Drive and Airport Blv d. /Edmund Road, are lined with individual stores, restaurants, and typical grocery store anchored shopping centers. Residential uses, while adequately protected from major traffic intrusions, are still subject to the negative effects of nearby commercial and industrial uses. Manufactured homes, while generally concentrated in the two existing manufactured home parks, can also be found intermingled with single family structures in certain parts of the City. Mobile homes are no longer permitted in areas other than manufactured home parks. Industrial uses, which are basically concentrated along the rail lines in the central portion of the City and near the Southeastern Beltway interchange south of the City, can be found scattered in residential areas, particularly in older portions of the City. Overall, the City suffers from all too frequent incompatible placements of uses and too heavy a pattern of strip commercial development. There is also the absence of a central-city area or downtown to be defined as the “heart” of the City. Meanwhile, land is available for new development and redevelopment, with major highway improvements and the river serving as stimuli for future land use”. 2009 Survey and Assessment of Existing Land Use What has changed, if anything, since the 1999 land use assessment? To answer this question, the community was resurveyed and existing land use and land use patterns and conditions reassessed as part of the 2009 Comprehensive Plan Update. From the survey, it is apparent that much of the City’s developable land west of the Congaree is essentially built-out, with few developable vacant tracts and lots remaining. Through annexation in recent years the 139 City has added large undeveloped acreage, but because of the potential to flood and the presence of wetlands, many of these tracts have only limited development potential. Overall, land use patterns have remained essentially unchanged since 1999. However, there have been changes to the boundaries of the City and in some areas of the City. Mixed use development is evident in a few areas of the community, but is not widespread. Most mixed use areas were developed prior to zoning. Existing Commercial Land Use Strip commercial development still lines Knox Abbott, Airport Boulevard and the Charleston Highway. It is also scattered along parts of Frink Street, and clustered at the end of State Street, site of a streetscaping project to improve the aesthetics and drawing power of the area. It achieved the first objective – improving aesthetics – but has yet to stimulate new commercial activity. Still, the unique historical ambience of the area may in time result in renewed commercial vitality. More recently, commercial development of the old Guignard Brickworks site, at the entrance to the Ci ty from Columbia, is taking shape. It could spur redevelopment of the property across Knox Abbott and in combination produce the making of a “city center” with major drawing power. New commercial development -Three Fountains – is also located in the far reaches of the City, at the intersection of Platt Springs Road and Emanuel Church Road, and contiguous to the Airport on Lexington Drive. For the most part, the City’s commercial establishments are stripped along its major arterial streets. As a result they have little if any cumulative drawing power. Even its shopping centers fail in this regard, as none contains combinations of stores that together increase the drawing power of the whole. The closest thing the city has to a cumulative drawing combination is Knox Abbott Drive with its multiple eating establishments. 140 Commercial development has remained relatively contained in established and zoned commercial areas, showing no signs of commercial encroachment into established residential areas over what had occurred earlier, prior the 1999 Plan. Existing Residential Land Use Residential development is contained in pockets throughout the City – some large, some small, some old, some new. Most single-family neighborhoods, while bordering on commercial or industrial uses or zones, are sufficiently insulated from the adverse impact of such uses. Each is associated with an element of tranquility, removed from the noisy, high volume peripheral street system. But internal pedestrian movement to schools, parks and outside commercial uses is hampered by the absence of sidewalks, or a sidewalk network in most neighborhoods. A noted exception is the newly developed Hunters Mill subdivision on Emanuel Church road, with extensive sidewalks throughout. Also street conditions are in disrepair in some neighborhoods where responsibility for maintenance is unclear. Housing conditions vary throughout the city, but the vast majority (56%, Table 16) is structurally sound and without need of rehabilitation. However, 13.4 percent of the city’s housing stock is in need of moderate to major rehabilitation. The majority of this housing may be found in the area behind City Hall complex on Poplar, Hart, Hopkins, Middle, Park and Pond Streets, and in a corner of the Broad Acres neighborhood, on Tree and Peach Streets. Storm drainage is a problem in several residential areas, based on water ponding and the absence of storm drainage systems, as indicated earlier, and echoed by Members of the Ad Hoc committee. Multi-family projects generally are located on the periphery of established single-family neighborhoods. Also most areas zoned for multi-family use are found on the edge of single-family neighborhoods. Most of these zoned areas do not contain multi-family uses however, but are occupied instead by small lot single- family homes previously judged to be acceptable areas for future high density multi-family development. The problem with this future development scenario is in property assemblage, making these locations, 141 with few exceptions, unattainable for multi-family development. Two noted exceptions are: (1) a large undeveloped tract next to Moss Creek subdivision, and (2) a smaller tract on Taylor Street next to the railroad. Mobile homes are restricted to mobile home parks in the City. There are two. Mobile home parks are permitted only in the RG-2 Zone, subject to approval as Special Exceptions by the Zoning Board of Appeals. The potential for future mobile home parks is limited not only by the above constraints to multi- family development in currently zoned RG-2 Districts, but also by perceived incompatibility. It is highly doubtful that, if proposed, such development would be acceptable to or considered compatible by neighboring single-family residents. And as Special Exceptions they would be exposed to public critique prior to judgment by the ZBA. Unfortunately, the history of mobile home maintenance and perceived land use incompatibility as a result thereof, has led to the enactment of location and development regulations that essentially preclude their future use in the City of Cayce. Existing Industrial Land Use The community’s industrial and support uses are located generally along and parallel with its major arterials and railroad lines. Older, “heavier” and often unenclosed industries are located closer in, along Frink Street and Old State Road. Newer, primarily enclosed, and “lighter” industries and businesses are found in peripheral and developing areas, on 12th Extension, and service roads paralleling the interstates. They are also found in park settings such as Overlook Business Park on Dixiana Road. Most new industrial and business uses have been classified and zoned M-1, Light Industrial. These districts include not only industrial uses, but warehousing, distribution, processing, office and some commercial uses, as permitted by the ordinance. As such they resemble a mixed use district but for the absence of residential development. The older industries are zoned M-2, Heavy Industrial. They permit industrial operations not generally considered compatible with residential or most other types of development. 142 Most undeveloped property zoned for future industrial development is zoned M-1. It is found in areas generally paralleling the interstate. Except for a small parcel at the intersection of Frink Street and 12 th Street Extension. No vacant tracts are zoned for “heavy” industry. This is not to rule out such development in the future however, as most undeveloped property in the city is zoned “Development”, meaning it is in a holding pattern pending rezoning to a more productive use. Summary Statement Existing Land Use In summary, Existing land use patterns and densities have changed relatively little since the last land use survey was conducted in 1999, but the community has greatly expanded in size and peripheral development, and structural conditions and residential environments generally have improved. ISSUES COMPONENT Many of the land use issues identified in earlier plans are still with us in 2009. Reassessed for continued applicability and expanded to reflect prevailing conditions and concerns, land use issues confronting the community in 2009 include the following:  Land Use Compatibility  Visual (physical) Image  Future size and shape of the City  Future housing composition  Orderly arrangement (plan) of development  Substandard housing conditions  Future composition and Economic Draw of Knox Abbott Drive 143 Issue: Land Use Compatibility Most new development within the City will be in the form of redevelopment, in-fill development, or recycling of buildings, except for vacant, recently annexed tracts that offer new development opportunities on the periphery of the built environment. Expansion of existing development in the City, particularly commercial, and high-density residential, in all probability, will raise the issue of land use compatibility. There are few places to go that are not already developed, except outward. Thus, there is potential for conflict whenever a property is redeveloped or recycled to a more economically advantageous use, or expanded in the direction of a different established use, and a zoning change is required. The strength and support for planning and zoning are based generally on the concept of land use compatibility. Home owners, land owners, environmentalists and the general public alike are concerned when development creates an incompatible situation, i.e. lowers property values, heightens traffic congestion, emits pollutants, alters accepted environmental conditions, scars the landscape, or lacks visual appeal. How this Plan responds to the juxtaposition of potentially incompatible land uses will determine the future landscape of the community. Not all land use is complementary to or compatible with its surroundings, existing or proposed. And any infringement by uses adversely impacting the prevailing environment generally is met by resistance from affected property owners. Land use incompatibility is a universal issue. It is no less an issue in the City of Cayce, surfacing every time a new use or project impacts an existing residential area or environmental resource. Where quality subdivisions, natural and cultural resources are threatened by "incompatible development" a policy to ensure stability should be adopted by the City. It is not enough that property be zoned residential or other appropriate protective zone designation. Zoning can break down over time and often does. But an adopted policy to guide the rezoning process in such matters will go a long way toward ensuring sustainability, particularly if it is part of the City's Comprehensive Plan. It would have the added clout of the state planning enabling act, which mandates that "regulations shall be in accordance with the (comprehensive) land use 144 plan". Any action to the contrary would require reevaluation of the Plan itself, and its call for land use stability. While such a policy may seem rigid, and it is, it should nonetheless be applied to those neighborhoods, subdivisions, and resources where stability and sustainability are of principal concern. Issue: Visual (Physical) Image There is a saying, "you don't get a second chance to make a first impression". This is true for cities as well. How the City is perceived to prospective residents, industries, businesses, and visitors is critical to its future well being. The ‘built environment” projects a visual image of the community and plays a major role in future development by attracting "like uses". Quality development generally attracts quality development and blight begets blight. This is not always true of course, but rarely does quality development take place in a blighted environment, unless major resources have been committed to renewal. The image of a community is tempered by a number of elements, both negative and positive. Based on survey observations in advance of this report and a sense of “self analysis” provided by respondents of the Citizen Survey in support of this Plan, they include in Cayce, to varying degrees, the following: Positive Elements Negative Elements River Walk Park Quality of business and service establishments Sense of Community Limited shopping and employment opportunities Abundant green space, including Congaree Creek Heritage Preserve Rundown and dilapidated buildings and dwellings Nice stable neighborhoods Inadequately maintained vacant lots Location next to Congaree River Junk and abandoned vehicles Abundance of public parks and playgrounds Poor street conditions, storm drainage and street lighting 145 The city’s most pressing negative elements may be addressed with a combination of stronger code enforcement, street improvements and enhancements, storm drainage improvements and targeted business recruitment and development. The positive elements need to be used and viewed as building blocks to further enhance the local environment. Issue: Future Size and Shape of the City It is important for the City to size and shape its boundaries to fully include its logical urban area. Failure to do so may result in population stagnation or worse, loss of population, weakened tax base, loss of state shared funds, and higher service costs and taxes to City residents. The City is also prevented from controlling development on its borders and ensuring land use compatibility of border properties and environs. The state's restrictive annexation laws notwithstanding, the City is challenged to selectively expand its corporate limits in order to keep pace with or ahead of the spiraling cost of governmental administration and services. The operative word here is “selectively”. Careful consideration should be given to the potential impact of annexation on the city’s resources and services. Will the annexed property produce enough revenue to pay for City services? Will the City be required to build new police or fire sub-stations, or build new parks in support of new annexations? Will the additional costs of servicing the annexed property be passed on to those already residing in the City or will the annexed area produce sufficient revenue to pay for services received? Will the annexations produce an illogical and/or inefficient City service area? What will be the net effect of annexation? These questions need to be framed and answered before annexations take place. Annexations should be driven by design to form a more logical, efficient community service area. 146 Issue: Future Housing Composition That local housing landscapes and preferences are changing is documented by this study. But such changes are not always viewed in a positive light, as the community strives to protect its existing inventory of single-family homes and project an image of "nice homes" (single-family) and neighborhoods. Housing preferences generally driven by costs include manufacture and multi-family. But these housing alternatives generally are considered incompatible with single-family environs and, therefore, restricted from most residential areas. Manufactured homes are restricted to manufactured home parks in Cayce, where there are two. The parks are restricted to a single zone district (RG-2) as special exceptions, subject to review and approval by the Cayce Zoning Board of Appeals. Multi-family housing is permitted in the RG-2 District as well, and also permitted in the RG-1 District. The restrictions placed on these housing alternatives indicate the difficulty in carving out space for such housing in a predominately “built single-family residential environment”, growing preferences for lower cost housing notwithstanding. Clearly, changes in the housing market, most of which have been precipitated by the need for lower cost housing and life-style changes, including household downsizing, emphasize the need to better reconcile differences in housing types in order to preserve the “single-family way of life” in the community while accommodating changes in the housing market. Issue: Orderly Arrangement (Plan) of Development This is the essence of land use planning---defining a framework for future development. As Cayce is not a new City and the planning process is not starting anew, the framework already exists. Future concerns have to do with expanding, refining and massaging existing development patterns in a manner that will perpetuate an orderly land use arrangement and promote land use compatibility. Also, as Cayce looks to the future and beyond its current city boundaries, it will need to focus on planning its unincorporated fringe 147 areas. Development of these areas is controlled by Lexington County. The vast majority of these lands are zoned Intensive Development or Restrictive Development. A few established subdivisions are zoned by streets, either Residential or Local. The affect of the Intensive and Restrictive Development Districts is to permit any and all land uses, subject to development standards contained in the Zoning Ordinance. This open ended approach to development leaves the Cayce community vulnerable to a variety of development that may be completely inappropriate and incompatible with neighboring development in Cayce and inconsistent with the community’s plans for the future. The difficulty for Cayce is that these areas are beyond its control. It must prevail on the County to do the “right thing”, as there is little assurance from the County Zoning Ordinance that Cayce’s interests are protected. What is needed and recommended for the City Plan is a less inclusive but flexible approach – one that will allow development proposals to meet changing market preferences, but ensure land use compatibility and an orderly land use arrangement. Issue: Substandard Housing Conditions Housing conditions have improved appreciably over time, but there is still ample evidence of poor and substandard housing in certain parts of the City, as noted earlier. The impact of these conditions is two- fold. They provide less than adequate housing, and they project negatively on the community. Continued participation in low income housing rehab programs and demolition of dilapidated houses and buildings are necessary to address this issue. Also continu ed help from private organizations such as Habitat for Humanity and local churches contribute greatly to the improvement of housing. Issue: Future Composition and Economic Draw of Knox Abbott Drive Knox Abbott Drive is the face of Cayce. How it looks and the composition of its business makeup largely defines how it and the community are perceived, either positively or negatively. 148 GOALS (LU) AND POLICIES COMPONENT This component establishes general goals, policies and actions directed by the Plan. Specific goals for various areas of the community are established in the Plan Map Component. General goals consist of the following:  Make Cayce a preferred location to live and

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Cayce website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.