RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Nov 17, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT NOVEMBER 17, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. ONE-MOTION ONE-VOTE C. PUBLIC HEARINGS – OLD BUSINESS D. PUBLIC HEARINGS – NEW BUSINESS 4. 57 Hasell St. Ansonborough| Council District 8 |TMS# 457-11-01-050 Zoned: DR-1 | BZA2026-002596 Request Appeal for Reconsideration of variances granted from Sec. 54 -301 allowing the subdivision of the existing parcel into two parcels (Lots A & B) resulting in the existing building on Lot B having a north side setback of 0’ and a rear setback of 4’ (6 ’ and 25’ required) and to allow the construction of a two-family dwelling unit on the proposed Lot A with a lot area of 4342sf per unit (4500sf required). Owner: Michael Furlong Applicant: Hadden Powell 12 Comments Submitted to Innovate in Support 3 Comments Submitted to Staff in Opposition (see attached) First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date Submitted Charles & Martha McLendon 49 Laurens St. We stand firmly in opposition to any variance or zoning change related to 57 Hasell street and Maiden Lane that would permit parcels zoned STR to be used commercially. Nov 15 2026 Victoria De la Maza 51 Laurens St. Victoria de la Maza stands firmly in opposition to any variance or zoning change related to 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane that would permit parcels zoned STR to Nov 16 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 2 be used commercially. We ask that the BZA and the City deny commercial encroachment in our fragile residential neighborhood. We ask that our neighbors' appeal of the BZA's October 6 2026 decision be granted. John Nuss 58 Anson St. I have been a resident of Ansonborough for over 50 years and would like to voice my opinion in opposition to the proposed subdivision of this property as this would allow irreparable harm to the neighborhood in allowing commercial development on currently zoned STR property at 57 Hasell Street and 6 Madien Lane. We are a small neighborhood increasingly subjected to commercial transgressions into it. To allow this would start the decay of a small vibrant neighborhood with rich history for the Charleston community. Nov 16 2026 Marcia Guthrie 12 George St. I strongly oppose any variance, zoning change, or other approval related to 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane that would permit parcels zoned for Residential (STR) use to be converted to or used for commercial purposes. I respectfully ask the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) and the City of Charleston to protect the integrity and residential character of our fragile neighborhood by denying any request that would allow commercial encroachment into these residentially zoned areas. I further respectfully request that the appeal of the BZA's October 6, 2026 decision, filed by my neighbors, be granted. Our neighborhood's residential character, quality of life, and established zoning protections deserve to be preserved and respected. Allowing commercial uses to encroach upon residential parcels risks changing the nature of our neighborhood and undermining the protections intended to preserve it. Please respect our neighborhood and uphold its residential character. Deny commercial encroachment at 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane and grant our neighbors' appeal. Thank you for all of your hard work. Nov 16 2026 John Burquard I oppose the variance/zoning change to 57 Hassel Street and 6 Maiden Street that would allow parcels to be used commercially. I ask that the appeal of the October 6 decision be granted. Nov 16 2026 John Egan 58 Hasell St. My wife and I own property at 58 Hasell Street which looks upon the subject 57 Hasell Street property. We are opposed to any Nov 16 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 3 zoning change that would expand use of 57 Hasell Street and the adjoining 6 Maiden Lane property (both owned by the Andrew Pinckney Hotel) for commercial purposes. We believe that the BZA decision of October 6 furthers the commercialization of these properties. We ask that the BZA's decision granting the variances be reversed. Lisa Jones 40 East Bay St. To: Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning From: Lisa Jones, Director of Advocacy Date: November 16, 2026 Re: 57 Hasell Street - Request for Reconsideration and De Novo Hearing Dear Members of the Board: Historic Charleston Foundation (HCF) respectfully submits the following comments regarding the appeal of the October 6, 2026 decision concerning 57 Hasell Street. HCF believes the matter should be heard de novo because the full implications of the application were not adequately understood during the original hearing. The central issue extends well beyond variances and subdivision mechanics to the broader question of commercial encroachment into the historic residential core of Ansonborough. HCF has a longstanding connection to Ansonborough and has invested decades of effort in preserving the neighborhood's historic character, residential integrity, and sense of place. Ansonborough's significance is not derived solely from its individual historic structures, but from the historic relationship between residences, gardens, streets, lot configurations, and the predominance of residential land use that has defined the neighborhood for generations. The preservation of that character remains a core concern of our organization. At the October 6 hearing, the application was presented primarily as a request involving subdivision and setback relief associated with redevelopment of the property. However, subsequent review has revealed that the requested subdivision was not merely a technical adjustment. By creating a new lot containing the remaining nonconforming commercial structure and establishing a new lot configuration, the proposal fundamentally altered the relationship between commercial and residential uses on the site. The resulting configuration effectively shifts a substantial portion of what has historically been understood as residentially zoned property Nov 16 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 4 toward a future commercial orientation and creates conditions that facilitate additional commercial activity immediately adjacent to historic residential properties. HCF believes these broader land-use implications were not fully appreciated or discussed during the original hearing. The record further demonstrates that several of the affected neighbors did not have a meaningful opportunity to present evidence regarding the practical consequences of the subdivision, including the loss of separation between residential and commercial activity, the creation of a zero-setback condition adjacent to residential property, and the cumulative effect of expanding commercial influence within a historically residential neighborhood. These considerations are directly relevant to whether the requested variances are detrimental to adjacent properties, the public good, or the character of the district. HCF believes the absence of this information contributed to a misapprehension of the true nature and consequences of the application. Of particular concern is the precedent established by the subdivision itself. While individual land-use decisions may appear modest when viewed in isolation, the cumulative effect of such decisions can gradually erode the residential character that makes historic neighborhoods like Ansonborough significant. HCF opposes actions that contribute to commercial creep into established residential historic districts, and we believe the subdivision approved at 57 Hasell Street presents precisely such a concern. The issue is that the reconfiguration of the property creates a pathway for the continued expansion of commercial activity into an area historically protected by residential zoning and residential land-use patterns. For these reasons, Historic Charleston Foundation respectfully requests that the Board grant reconsideration and hear this matter de novo. A new hearing would allow the Board to evaluate the application with the benefit of a complete record, including testimony regarding the land-use implications of the subdivision, the effects on surrounding residential properties, and the broader implications for the historic character of Ansonborough. Such a review is warranted to ensure that the Board's decision Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 5 is based on a full understanding of the proposal's consequences and its consistency with the public interest and preservation of Charleston's historic neighborhoods. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully submitted, Lisa Jones Jennifer Davis 5 Maiden Ln. I am strongly opposed to the BZA decision to grant variances at 57 Hasell Street. These concessions to the developer will cumulatively validate commercial encroachment into a residential neighborhood by allowing a non conforming commercial use on a property whose underlying zoning is residential. The BZA ruling is inconsistent with the City's position that encourages more residential housing to be built in residential neighborhoods. The decision does not support the greater good of the public nor the Ansonborough neighborhood as a whole. Immediately after the applicant's variances were approved by the BZA the applicant submitted a re-zoning request for the property to become commercial both on 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane. The developer and the Andrew Pinckney Hotel's intention for commercial expansion is blatantly clear. I am of the belief that the BZA staff and board was not made aware at the time of their consideration that this was the intent of the Andrew Pinckney Hotel and the developer. I have lived on the corner of Maiden Lane and Hasell Street for 25 years. Maiden Lane is one of the last six remaining cobblestone streets in Charleston. In the video of the October 6th BZA meeting it was stated that Maiden Lane would be used as egress for deliveries for the Andrew Pinckney and their expanding event space. At no time was it mentioned that trucks are prohibited Maiden Lane due to its fragile nature. There is a large sign on the street. NO TRUCKS. I respectfully ask that the member of the Zoning Board of Appeals consider repercussions of their October 6th ruling and rescind all variances and protect the integrity of Ansonborough' residential neighborhood. Respectfully, Jennifer V H Davis 5 Maiden Lane. I am a 25 year resident of 5 Maiden Lane. My home is a generational home. My children and grandchildren have been raised here. This is our full time home and only home. Please help us keep our neighborhood livable. Nov 16 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 6 Cheryl & Peter Tague 54 Hasell St. We stand firmly in opposition to any variance or zoning change related to 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane that would permit parcels zone STR to be used commercially. We ask that the BZA and the City deny commercial encroachment in our fragile residential neighborhood in which we have personally invested our personal time and wealth in keeping up our historic homes for the benefit of the community. How dare overnight developers come in and take advantage of our neighborhood for their quick gain. We ask that our appeal of the BZA's October 6, 2026 decision be granted. Nov 16 2026 RuthAnn Brazill 55 Hasell St. I stand firmly in opposition to any variance or zoning change related to 57 Hasell Street and 6 Maiden Lane that would permit parcels zoned STR to be used commercially. We ask that the BZA and the City deny commercial encroachment in our fragile residential neighborhood. We ask that our neighbors’ appeal of the BZA’s October 6, 2026 decision be granted. Nov 16 2026 Steven Creedman 8 George St. I strongly support the appellants' request to reverse the Board's October 7, 2026 decision permitting the subdivision of the existing residential parcel at 57 Hasell Street into two separate lots, potentially facilitating the subsequent rezoning of the newly created Lot B for commercial use (CT). Ansonborough has a rich history dating to 1727 and remains one of Charleston's most treasured historic residential neighborhoods. Preserving its residential character and integrity is essential, not only for its current residents but for future generations. I believe the Board of Zoning Appeals has a vital responsibility to protect that character. Allowing the subdivision of residential property in a manner that facilitates subsequent commercial rezoning risks establishing a troubling precedent for further commercial encroachment into this historic neighborhood. I respectfully urge the Board to reverse its October 7 decision. Nov 16 2026 Hart Hagerty 43 Society St. Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I write in opposition to the commercial portions of the application for 57 Hasell Street. These include the Andrew Pinckney Inn's request to permit or expand commercial use on 50% of the tract, and the request to make 100% of 6 Maiden Lane commercial. I come from a generational Nov 16 2026 Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning Public Comment | November 17, 2026 Page 7 Charleston family, and I am raising my children in Ansonborough. Our neighborhood is zoned residential and is only two blocks wide and five blocks long. We cannot afford to lose another large parcel to commercial use. Thank you Sincerely, Hart Hagerty 43 Society Street I am writing in opposition to any variance or zoning change related to 57 Hasell and 6 Maiden Lane. I feel the plans need additional clarification and understanding of how this development will impact the neighbors directly next to the address in question. I ask the BZA and the City deny commercial encroachment into the Ansonborough neighborhood. Steve Peters 29 Hasell Street

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.