DRB Public Comment
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 5, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
PUBLIC COMMENT
JANUARY 5, 2026
A meeting of the Design Review Board (DRB) will be held on Monday, January 5, 2026 at
4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street.
The following written comments will be provided to the board members on the deadline date and
also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the
meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard.
Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/drb. Please check the website on
the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items.
For additional information, please contact:
Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781
A. APPLICATIONS
1. 2875 Savannah Hwy.
West Ashley | Council District 5 | TMS #308-00-00-001 | DRB2025-000292
Requesting approval for the demolition of an office/laboratory building from the 1930s,
a former USDA building.
Owner: Clemson University
Applicant: Mosley/Aaron Bowman
51 Comments Submitted:
• Justin Ferira
Submitted to Staff
See attached.
• Michael Gravely
Submitted to Staff
See attached.
• Chad Husselbee
Submitted to Staff
See attached.
• 48 Comments Submitted on Innovate Site in Opposition:
First
Name
Last
Name
Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
Shellie Horgan 2251 N Marsh
Dr. Mount
Pleasant, SC
29466
This structure is important for the future
generations. We must keep Charleston’s history,
while keeping it preserved. Please SAVE this
structure.
Dec 29
2025
11:26PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 2
Meghan Lee 512 Sarah
Street,
Charleston, SC,
29407
Please don’t tear down this building!! It’s
important to keep not only for its role in global
20th century agricultural science, but as a
perfect opportunity for creative and intentional
use. The historic significance, architecture, and
character are so special — they gesture to an
important moment in history and this state’s
significant role in it. Not to mention, we love to
see it — it makes us feel like we are in a specific
and special place (as Charleston is!) and
connected to its unique history. It’s an important
and unique landmark for West Ashley, which we
hope will continue to be developed with thought
and care, protecting its marshes and local
historical landmarks like this one. I would love to
see this building restored and have long
wondered why it has not been. (We noticed the
nearby greenhouses were recently fixed and
were so happy to see them in use!)
Dec 30
2025
1:10PM
Megan Johnson 2640 Kingsfield
St, Mt Pleasant
SC 29466
Charleston has always understood that
preservation is not nostalgia. It is stewardship.
The USDA Vegetable Lab on Savannah Highway
tells a story of science, agriculture, and the quiet
work that shaped South Carolina’s economy,
communities, and food systems. It represents a
chapter of innovation, research, and contribution
that should not be erased. Please consider
protecting this site as part of Charleston’s living
history. Once places like this are gone, they’re
gone forever, and another glass box or parking
lot will never hold the meaning, character, or
connection to our past that this property does.
Preserving the Clemson/USDA Vegetable Lab
honors the people, the work, and the legacy that
helped sustain our region.
Dec 30
2025
4:33PM
Caroline Parker Brookbank
Avenue,
Charleston, SC
It is criminal and appalling that Clemson 's
intentional neglect has resulted in a request to
demolish this historically significant property. A
very dangerous precedent to set. This building
needs to be preserves at all costs. It's historical
importance and relevancy is irreplaceable and
essential to the community.
Dec 30
2025
5:17PM
Ashton Finley 22 Beverly Road Please deny the demolition request for the
Clemson/USDA Vegetable Laboratory Building
at 2875 Savannah Highway. This building is
eligible for inclusion on the National Register of
Historic Places due to its architectural
significance and it's historic significance. It is
structurally sound enough for adaptive reuse.
This building has been owned by the current
owners for nearly a decade, and during that
time they allowed the building to decay.
Dec 30
2025
5:23PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 3
Demolition-by-neglect of West Ashley's historic
resources should not be rewarded with
demolition permits. West Ashley's historic
buildings and cultural resources are worthy of
preservation. Ashton Finley Save Historic West
Ashley
McKenna Kerr 14 Brockman
Drive Charleston,
SC 29412
Clemson has held ownership for 10+ years and
has neglected it, now just to want to demolish it.
This building is historically significant and an
important piece of our historic fabric. We need
buildings like this around!
Dec 30
2025
7:04PM
Lucy Orton 514 Mansfield
Dr. Charleston sc
29407
Please don’t tear down that historical building!
It’s way too important in Charleston to connect
the beauty and history to agricultural roots.
Dec 30
2025
7:06PM
Victoria Bock 108 Live Oak
Ave 29407
This is a significant piece of American history,
and represents the Lowcountry’s iconic role in
food production and culture. Clemson should
not be allowed to let a building of this caliber
fall into disrepair, then try to demolish it. I’m
sure they could use it as a project for their local
historic preservation and architecture grad
school students, finding grants and donors to
fund the project. It could become the next home
a of a gardening or native plant nonprofit. The
possibilities are endless. Demolition should not be
one of them.
Dec 30
2025
7:09AM
Stephanie Morris 2968 Vincent
Astor Drive Johns
Island, SC 29455
Please don’t destroy our history. Fix it. We need
to conserve our history for future generations.
This could also be a place people visit to learn!
Dec 30
2025
8:18AM
Wiley Becker 44 Rutledge
Avenue
Oppose demolition by neglect due to precedent
setting by an applicant with means to maintain
and restore, the historic building and scientific
purpose, and prominence as a landmark nearing
the ACE Basin.
Dec 30
2025
8:43AM
Rutledge Young 107 Waterfront
Plantation Drive.
CHS. 29412
I have driven by the Clemson Experiment Station
building for many years and walk the
Greenway past its back. It’s a beautiful sight to
see compared to much of the rest of 17 South. Its
colonial style and unique setting should be
preserved and recycled. Too much of our history
is being destroyed .Clemson has the funds to do
this. I oppose demolition.
Dec 30
2025
9:58AM
Lauren Smith 9690 Godwin
street Ladson sc
The building is historical for Charleston farms
and is a landmark that I have enjoyed seeing
over the years. It lets me know where I am and
gives Charleston the character it’s known for. It
should not be demolished.
Dec 30
2025
12:22PM
Matt Brady Prefer not to say I oppose the demolition of this building. While I
recognize that not every historic structure can be
preserved indefinitely, demolition should not be
approved where long term neglect has
materially contributed to the building’s current
Dec 30
2025
12:37PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 4
condition. Public institutions with substantial
resources should not be rewarded for demolition
by neglect, particularly when alternatives such
as stabilization, adaptive reuse, or transfer have
not been fully explored. Approving demolition
under these circumstances would set a concerning
precedent.
Louise Britton 1111 William
Battle Ct., Edisto
Island, SC 29438
Every time I drive into Charleston from my home
on Edisto Island I admire this historic building
and the surrounding green space. We need to
preserve these historic sites that represent South
Carolina's important agricultural past and
present. The building should be restored and
treasured, not torn down, and the trees, fields
and open spaces around it preserved as well.
Dec 31
2025
1:11PM
Mary Traveland 204 N Galloway
Ave, Mesquite,
TX 75149
This beautiful, historical building needs to be
preserved, NOT demolished. It is important to
the city, the region, and can still be highly useful
in its current state. Please respect and preserve
this bit of Charleston's history in a time when so
much has been lost.
Dec 31
2025
1:27PM
Margaret Peery 1224 Village
Creek Lane, Apt
D5, Mt. Pleasant,
SC. 29494
I do not think this building should be demolished.
Clemson knew about the historical importance of
this building when they purchased the property.
I'm sure they can come up with a plan for
change that incorporates this building in the
design.
Dec 31
2025
1:39PM
Mary King 1504 Center St
Mt Pleasant SC
This is an historic structure and site. Clemson was
well aware of this when they purchased the
property. I vehemently oppose demolition. The
building has significant architectural details ,
agricultural and historic significance. DO NOT
ALLOW CLEMSON TO DEMOLISH. Shame on
them.
Dec 31
2025
1:42PM
Ralph Herda 14 Gadsden St
Charleston S C
Very opposed, find a way to
preserve/protect/repurpose the structure. It has
charm, beauty, historical importance and the
land parcel is large enough to make a solution
not unreasonable. KEEP IT. FIND A WAY.
Dec 31
2025
2:02PM
Paige Lewis 507 Stinson
Drive, Charleston
I oppose the application to demolish the
agricultural building at 2875 Savannah
Highway. The building in question is an historic
building for its Colonial Revival architecture, as
well as its use in developing agriculture for the
state and the country. I've always admired that
building and appreciated that it had been
preserved, including after Clemson University
purchased it. The University purchased the
historic building knowing of its condition at the
time and its historic significance and should seek
to preserve it for future use.
Dec 31
2025
2:28PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 5
Judy Anderson 31 Orne Street,
Marblehead, MA
01945
To Clemson University : Please do not demolish
this 1930s property. The building could be
preserved and the grounds could be used for
farm-to-table programs, consistent with its
historic function, and beneficial to the community.
Dec 31
2025
3:30PM
Susan Hansz 1743CentralPark
Road Charleston
29412
I have seen so many changes in our Charleston
communities that do not meld well with the area.
I have often passed the building at 2875
Savannah Highway and appreciated the
architectural and structural integrity. But recently
I was made aware not only of its remarkable
site, but also some of the historical significance
that has occurred on this property and in this
building. I do not know what Clemson has caused
to demolish such a structure, but I feel that the
land surrounding it should be sufficient to do
whatever they feel is necessary other than
destroying this property. And I hope that they
will allow a bit of landscape to benefit the
structure.
Dec 31
2025
3:35PM
April Chafin 3321
Middleburry Ln
Charleston SC
29414
The colonial revival style is a historically
important part of America.s history. There are
too many buildings of this era being torn down. I
oppose drastic changes to this building, and it's
property. Please uphold the importance of the
building.
Dec 31
2025
3:57PM
Christine Yriart 2428 Vaucluse
Road,
Charleston, SC
29414
Stop destroying the historic structures and filling
in of wetlands, etc. that make Charleston unique.
It is not worth the money from developers for this
city to lose it's unique character that make it so
special. Whether it is destruction of wetlands or
buildings, the end result is the same. If wetland
destruction, demolishing historic structures or
overbuilding does not stop, Charleston will soon
look like Atlanta and wouldn't that be sad!
Dec 31
2025
4:22PM
Lawren Lee 907 Belleview
Circle West
Do not demolish the vegetable laboratory off
Savannah Hwy. It holds a large piece of
Charleston history. It should be preserved as
such.
Dec 31
2025
8:26AM
Charles Andrus 31 Laurens St.,
Apartment 1402,
Charleston, SC
29401
To the Design Review Board, Clemson
University is reportedly considering the
demolition of a building it inherited from the U.S.
Dept of Agriculture - a structure that holds
genuine historical and scientific significance. I
believe this moment calls not for erasure, but
preservation and recognition. This
building was home to pioneering horticultural
research that helped shape modern plant
breeding and beyond. Among the many fine
scientists who worked there was my father, C.
Fred Andrus, a internationally recognized
horticulturalist whose collaborative research had
Dec 31
2025
8:40PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 6
lasting agricultural impact. His contributions were
recognized not only with an honorary doctorate
from Clemson University itself, but at a 2002
ceremony in Toronto, Canada where he was
inducted into the American Society of
Horticultural Sciences Hall of fame alongside
figures such as Luther Burbank and George
Washington Carver. Rather than tearing
the building down, Clemson - possibly in
partnership with the USDA - should begin a
process to repurpose it as a museum, archive, or
public educational space honoring the early
scientists who worked there. Once a
building like this is gone, so too is the chance to
connect future generations with the people and
ideas that helped feed the world. I urge
Clemson and state leaders to pause demolition
plans and explore preservation before this
history is lost forever. Respectfully,
Charles Andrus Charleston, SC
Mary
Frances
Hummel Shadow Ferry Dr Just leave the building standing. If it needs
repairs, fix it. We have too much development in
Charleston now. Mayor Riley did an outstanding
job as mayor for years protecting our historical
sites and history. Cogswell need to work on
taking care of what we have instead of building
more that we don't need. He needs to take care
better care of our city. Clean up the litter that's
getting out of hand and protect, restore and
repair our historical sites.
Jan 1
2026
2:34PM
Melanie LaRocca 153 Hampton
Circle, Bluffton,
SC 29909
Due to its historic significance, and that the
structure is doing no harm to persons or
property, please keep the building in tack.
Jan 1
2026
10:48AM
Laura Dubato 2406 Lilytree
Drive ,
Charleston SC
29414
This shouldn’t be demolished, it has historical
significance. Charleston has no problem building
new things that don’t help our city. We need to
honor the past too!
Jan 1
2026
11:39AM
State
Senator
Ed
Sutton 13 Leichester Rd I respectfully urge the Design Review Board to
deny Clemson University’s request to demolish
the historic building at 2875 Savannah Highway.
Constructed in 1936–1937 as the nation’s first
experimental vegetable breeding laboratory,
this Colonial Revival structure holds clear
regional and national significance and has been
deemed eligible for listing on the National
Register of Historic Places. Despite decades of
deferred maintenance, a recent structural
engineer’s report confirms the building remains
structurally sound, making demolition
unnecessary and premature. Approval of this
request would reward demolition by neglect, set
a troubling precedent, and further erode the
Jan 2
2026
1:27PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 7
irreplaceable historic fabric of West Ashley, a
community that is fully deserving of preservation
and thoughtful reinvestment. Adaptive reuse
remains a viable and responsible alternative
that honors both Charleston’s history and sound
planning principles, and the Board should
require that path rather than allow the
permanent loss of a landmark that once played
a pivotal role in feeding America during the
Great Depression.
Heather Russell 1597 Seabago
Drive,
Charleston, SC
29414
This is an important historic structure and site. It
is important to maintain this building due to the
significance to our area. Clemson was aware of
the historical nature of this building upon
securing the property it sits on and should be
required to maintain the building for further
generations.
Jan 2
2026
7:39AM
Aaron Russell 1597 Seabago
Drive,
Charleston, SC
29414
This is a historic building and everything should
be done to preserve this building for future
generations to learn about the significance of
this building and the work done inside of it.
Jan 2
2026
7:41AM
Lesa Watts 947 White Point
Court Charleston,
SC29412
We need to protect this historic building and site
and should not allow demolition of this building.
Jan 2
2026
9:22AM
Francine Dionne 1070
Northbridge
Drive Charleston
SC 29407
This is a historic building and in relatively good
repair. It does need some updating, renovation
but the basic structure is good. Needs to stay.
Jan 2
2026
9:29AM
Avery Edwards 3627 Franklin
Tower Dr.
While I have lived in Charleston over 35 years, I
grew up on Hilton Head and would regularly
travel to the city on Highway 17. This building is
an absolute landmark, announcing that
Charleston is nearby. I cannot imagine the
roadside without it.
Jan 2
2026
11:48AM
Brittany Lavelle
Tulla
231 King Street Documenting the history of the USDA laboratory
was an honor, and I thank Clemson University for
the opportunity to research and share such a
powerful and significant story. I strongly oppose
its proposed demolition for numerous reasons,
including concerns about demolition by neglect,
the irreversible loss of a site integral to historic
scientific advancements in agricultural research,
the missed opportunity for creative preservation
through adaptive reuse, and setting a dangerous
precedent for the treatment of other historic
properties by institutions. I would like to
specifically address the application’s statement
that this building “does not exhibit unique
historic, architectural, or aesthetic features.” As
an intact two-story Colonial Revival-style
building, the former USDA laboratory stands as
a distinctive and historically significant
Jan 3
2026
7:20PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 8
architectural resource representing federally
sponsored construction during the New Deal era.
It was the first of nine experimental laboratories
established across the United States in the late
1930s and intentionally reflects Charleston’s
architectural character. Many of the other
laboratories built nationwide at this time under
the same federal program were erected with
varying designs more typical of government
facilities, making the lab’s architectural character
both regionally complementary to Charleston’s
architectural heritage and historically significant
as a unique application of Colonial Revival in
federal scientific architecture. Through its
preserved footprint, setting, and overall design,
the building powerfully conveys its significant
role in USDA research during a pivotal era in
American agricultural history - far from lacking
uniqueness - and its removal would result in the
total loss of historic integrity for the entire
property, emphasized by the site’s confirmed
eligibility by the SHPO. Character-defining
features at the exterior, for example, include the
building’s symmetrical façade, equidistant
dormers featuring arched windows, paired
central interior chimneys outlined in brick dentils,
and a molded cornice with an unadorned frieze.
Despite deterioration, much of the interior
finishes and floor plan remain. I urge DRB to
deny the demolition of this historic resource.
Cindy Wofford 8 elliott St Apt C
Charleston
It is difficult to understand why Clemson would
highlight the historic property in question on its
website and then propose its removal. Clemson
was aware of the history and significance of the
building when it purchased the property. DENY
their request at your upcoming meeting.
Jan 3
2026
7:47AM
Mary Casey 25 Wentworth
Street
Demolition by neglect should not be tolerated or
tacitly encouraged by granting permission to
demolish this significant building and its ancillary
structures. This property has an important history
in terms of function and is also a prime example
of colonial revival architecture. These buildings
comprise a unique local story and should be
preserved. Shame on Clemson.
Jan 3
2026
10:44AM
Hannah Adams 50 George St 2875 Savanah Hwy is a wonderfully intact
example of Colonial Revival style architecture
that has suffered from ownership neglect over
the past few decades. Its historical significance
comes from the period of the Great Depression,
when the site was used as a federally-funded,
cutting-edge vegetable breeding laboratory to
stimulate durable vegetable production and
Jan 4
2026
1:43PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 9
help feed the country. Most of these operations
took place in the structure under threat, and they
are entirely salvageable, with any damage
being a result of neglect and abandonment for
two decades. In 2015, the site was nominated
for the National Register, which also highlighted
the importance of its contribution to food
production in a time of great need across the
country. Its historical significance and
architectural purity should be heavily considered
in this decision.
Heather Sheldon 1387 Camp
Road
Without ANY proper infrastructure
improvements, there is NO PLACE for hundreds
more people driving down Savannah Highway
each day. There have been near 10000 new
units built in West Ashley and John's Island since
the moratorium expired. NEITHER of these towns
has ANY REPRESENTATION. No Mayor. Just the
Peninsula greed seeping into the formerly
nature-focused lands they're destroying, for
profit and greed. Our towns are worth more
than another zero at the end of Developer
Mayor's bank account.
Jan 4
2026
3:05PM
Matthew Dailey 4415 Lord
Proprietors Rd.
Meggett SC
29449
Why does Clemson get to allow a historic
building to fall into disrepair and then simply
demolish it because they acted irresponsibly? Is
that the standard in Charleston? Would a
private citizen be given this right? ABSOLUTELY
NOT. Make them restore the building. They have
the money and a historic preservation dept.
Jan 4
2026
3:35PM
Zachary Aument 105 America St This application is immensely saddening for
Charleston, South Carolina and our nation. As
one of the first national buildings to study native
plants it is a piece of our state and national
heritage that, if this application is approved will
be lost forever. As a frequent rider of the
Greenway, the historic lab building is a
landmark that I and my children look forward to.
Furthermore, to have Clemson University - the
only Architecture school in the state - propose
this solution is truly disheartening. They have an
active satellite campus in the city that has a
robust preservation department. Perhaps those
students could learn about preservation by
surveying and recreating the lab instead of
allowing it to fade into eternity.
Jan 4
2026
7:34PM
Christy Siegling 820 Armsway
Street, Mt. P
Oppose Demo! There were opportunities all
along to maintain (or improve) condition. Owner
Neglect for years should not be the path to
demo approval.
Jan 4
2026
8:19AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 10
Kinsale Pearson -- As a native South Carolinian who has driven by
this property many times, I vehemently oppose
this demolition. This is a textbook example of
demolition by neglect, and approving demolition
is a statement to the public that the sure-fire
way to demolish any important historic building
is to purchase and let sit and decay for years.
This is a stunning building and a great example
of a Colonial Revival structure. Not only is the
structure itself important, the history of the
structure is important. This is from the 1930's,
and holds an important role in USDA research. It
is an emblem of American agricultural history
and the property, building, and land that it is on
is meaningful. To approve demolition would set
a standard to others that the way to approval
of demolition of historic & beautiful buildings is
to purchase and let decay for years.
Jan 4
2026
11:00AM
Emily Bell 1125 Village Ct
SE Atlanta, GA
30316
As a graduate of Clemson University’s
architecture school, I am appalled by the
university’s hand in citing demolition due to their
own neglect - on any property at all - much less
on such a fascinating and agriculturally
significant structure. This move is one of glaring
contrast to any kind of stewardship to the state
of South Carolina, its past, or its future - values
for which the Clemson I know claims to stand. The
university has always been a wellspring of
creative solutions; it’s past time to tap into that
for this property. I hope the board rejects this
application if Clemson doesn’t rescind it
immediately as they so should, shamefully.
Jan 4
2026
11:40AM
Jean Stoll 205 21st St,
Grottoes, VA
24441
Thabk you for the opportunity to submit a
comment regarding TMS #308-00-00-001,
DRB2025-000292: the requested demolition of
a historic USDA building from the 1930s. I lived
in Charleston for two years as a Clemson
University graduate student in their historic
preservation masters degree program, and
remember this site and building. While I do not
know the full scope of the project, I urge the
owner, Clemson University, to thoughtfully
consider rehabilitation of this building. Reuse of
existing buildings is the most environmentally
friendly construction method. Rehabilitation of
this historic building would also demonstrate
Clemson's commitment to their own programs in
Charleston: architecture and historic
preservation. I urge Clemson and this
deliberative body to favor sustainability and
character over near-term goals which may or
may not serve the city in the long term.
Jan 4
2026
11:56AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 11
Max Kuller 2nd Bend Rd
Harleyville SC
This proposed demolitions would take away not
just this beautiful, historic building, but would
completely disrupt the lovely land on which it
sit’s upon. While it would be lovely to see the
interior fully restored and used, the building
maintains a large graceful presence as is,
connecting with the lot on which it occupies in a
symbiotic way that is quite beautiful. It is not
hard to take ourselves back to the early days of
the breakthrough vegetable lab as it sits today.
Please don’t let this building be demolished. It
has been neglected for years, but that should
certainly not be a reason to allow its destruction.
There is so much potential for rebirth, and one
with potential for an incredible homage to the
buildings past. Thank you.
Jan 4
2026
12:32PM
Mary Cooper 60 Rutledge Ave
Charleston SC
29401
DENY request to demolish because this building
is An important historic structure: This 89-year-
old, Colonial Revival-style structure is historic in
its architecture as well as its context. A significant
historic site: The site was deemed eligible for
listing on the National Register of Historic Places
in 2015 due to its historical significance. Clemson
purchased the property in 2019 understanding
its unique nature and character. An historically
and culturally important use: As the first of its
kind in the world, the building served as an
anchor for the first research station established
through the Bankhead-Jones Act to bolster
agricultural research, breeds, and innovation
post-World War I. Important to the city and
the region: Much of the research conducted in
and around this building was aimed at
developing new varieties of crops that could fill
in gaps after the Lowcountry rice and cotton
industries collapsed. This site was associated with
the improvement of produce
Jan 5
2026
9:13AM
Tom Gaman PO Box 276,
Inverness, CA
94937
Please do not allow destruction of the historic
USDA Experiment Station at 2875 Savannah
Hwy. I visit the area often and walk the
greenway, as my daughter lives nearby and I
am sure there are suitable uses for the restored
building. It is a valuable part of the cultural and
economic history of West Ashley.
Jan 5
2026
11:26AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 12
2. 725 Wappoo Rd.
West Ashley | Council District 7 | TMS #350-01-00-078 | DRB2025-000293
Requesting approval for the demolition of a small outbuilding on the school campus and
older than 50 years of age.
Owner: Charleston Co School District
Applicant: Tony Giuliani
No Comments Submitted
3. 2274 Clements Ferry Rd.
Cainhoy | Council District 1 | TMS #267-00-00-148 | DRB2025-000251
Requesting conceptual approval for a new 3-story storage building.
Owner: Holly McAlhany
Applicant: Holly McAlhany
No Comments Submitted
4. 2275 Henry Tecklenburg Dr.
West Ashley | Council District 7 | TMS #309-00-00-055 | DRB2025-000279
Requesting preliminary approval for a youth learning center which includes a learning
center building, a maintenance building, and a 9-hole youth golf course.
Owner: Essex Farms A Partnership
Applicant: LS3P
No Comments Submitted
5. 350 Grand Oaks Blvd.
West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS #301-00-00-052 | DRB2025-000294
Requesting conceptual approval for a multi-family development with 6 buildings with 380
units and 36 townhouses, some separate garages and a clubhouse.
Owner: Bees Resources LP
Applicant: Middleburg Communities
81 Comments Submitted on Innovate Site in Opposition:
First
Name
Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
William Falta 200 Pine
Terrace
Court,
Charleston
29414
The proposed development of 380 apartment
units and 36 townhomes is too massive a scale to
be built between Grand Oaks Blvd and West
Ashley Circle given the substantial increase of
traffic and congestion on a daily basis especially
in light of existing "rush hour" issues . My family
is firmly opposed to this proposal.
Jan 1
2026
2:34PM
Michael Laskavy 509
Hainsworth
Drive,
Charleston
SC 29414
This area cannot support further development.
Those of us who live in Grand Oaks are already
dealing with increased traffic getting in and out
of the subdivision, increased wildlife incursions
into property due to loss of habitat, and
increased flooding concerns. Additionally, many
of us enjoy the local wildlife, which will suffer
devastating impacts due to habitat loss. We are
Jan 1
2026
8:12AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 13
already seeing an increase in dead animals due
to car hits (a deer ran across GO Blvd. just this
past week right in front of my car trying to get
from one side of the property to the other; if I
had hit it, it would have resulted in the animal's
death as well as serious damage to my car).
Developers don't live here, they just take their
money and go ruin another area. Grand Oaks is
built out. At what point will the DRB and Council
say, "Enough"?? Our quality of life is being
destroyed by greed and thoughtlessness. Please
DENY this project!!
Robert Frederick 110 Sugar
Magnolia
Way
I understand the term "wetlands" has been
redefined by Trump Administration but this
proposed site should not be developed. It is
entirely to large a project at this site with Long
Savannah being developed behind it. Natural
storm water conservation beats out retention
ponds every time. Lawsuits will be abundant if
flooding occurs like in ShadowMoss. We also
have insufficient access to the existing
neighborhood from Bees Ferry. Our two lane
neighborhood roads are also not sufficient to
handle the proposed influx. I cannot attend this
public meeting because of the absurd timing in
relation to normal working hours and after school
care of children. This has been a constant
grievance with the public that has been totally
ignored to this date.
Jan 1
2026
9:31AM
Caitlin Crosby 123 Dorothy
Drive
Dear Charleston City Council: Please do not
approve this area to be developed into
residential space. The Grand Oaks community is
already in the process of undergoing so much
development and change and it has already
begun. Between the Long Savanna project taking
off, and the Somerset Division in the works, there
is going to be continuous construction in this quiet
and safe neighborhood. The area proposed for
residential development is wetlands, and in the
summer months and after tropical systems or
heavy rain it stays very wet for months because
it’s the natural catch all for rainwater which
prevents flooding in and round the neighborhood
entrance. In addition, we have an incredible
biodiversity of wildlife and native trees and
plants that are major contributors to why people
love to live here. I have lived here for 5 years
and it’s what drew me to this area as a biologist.
Another concern is traffic exiting the
neighborhood. Putting the proposed residential
development directly at the entrance of the
neighborhood is going to cause an incredible
Jan 1
2026
11:59AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 14
amount of traffic and we do not have the
infrastructure in place to support it. The Glenn
McConnell expansion is barely able to handle
the existing traffic in the morning and evening as
it, and the housing in the already approved
residential projects in and around the
neighborhood has not been factored in yet.
Please listen to your constituents and do not let
this land become residential property. We have
a vibrant and diverse community in Grand Oaks
and we want to preserve as much of the trees,
wildlife and community as we can. Thank you.
Beth Griffith 102 Dorothy
Drive
Please stop building - we can not accommodate
more traffic. I know this application handles size
and the other details about the site and not
approval however anything you can do to pass
our opposition would be appreciated
Jan 2
2026
11:01AM
Lucy Curtis 402 Blue
Dragonfly
Drive
Charleston,
SC 29414
NO to anymore apartment or townhomes in
Grand Oaks!!! I am so tired of seeing all of this
and Not one person has any solutions for traffic!
How about more restaurants and shops? My
question is have you filled all of the apartments
that were built on Glenn McConnell and Bees
Ferry? As a homeowner in Grand Oaks we do
not want any more apartments or townhomes!
How about you use your money and efforts to
fix the traffic?!?
Jan 3
2026
6:08PM
Kathryn Wilson 225
Brambling
Lane
Development is too dense. I am not opposed to
all development however this one is too dense
for an area already severely congested with
traffic. Also - a deeper tree line needs to be
left in tact between the development line and
Grand Oaks / Brambling Lane. Stop the clear
cutting!!! Stop making everything ugly !
Developers need to improve roads before they
build.
Jan 3
2026
6:58PM
Sheryl Tuttle 10
Drummond
court
I have lived in Shadowmoss for the past 35
years. I am begging the board to not approve
this development. It is so crowded over here. The
roads cannot handle anymore developments.
Please please do not approve this development.
Jan 3
2026
7:00PM
Julie Mylin 383 Cabrill
Dr
I am strongly opposed to adding additional units
to the area of Grand Oaks and West Ashley
Circle. Unfortunately as soon as the Glenn
McConnell road project was completed it is
obvious 3 lanes in both directions was not wide
enough. Adding additional units to an already
congested area is unacceptable. We need to be
concerned about our roadways and truthfully we
need a stop all new construction for homes and
Multifamily developments.
Jan 3
2026
7:58PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 15
Cynthia Smart 301 Steele
Magnolia
No more traffic is needed in this area. Past
development has already maxed out the
infrastructure. Please don’t make it worse by
adding the proposed structures.
Jan 3
2026
10:48AM
Shawn Finch 190 Gazania
Way
Charleston
SC
You Council members need fired ASAP. Stop the
over building of West Ashley. We don't need
anymore apartments, Townhouses, storage
Facilities or anything else. How about a Park
instead. Why are you even having a public
meeting if you have no authority on what goes
there. Nice move having the meeting at 4:30pm
when most people are at work. Leave the trees
alone and stop taking away the beauty of West
Ashley because you are turning it into North
Charleston concrete jungle.
Jan 3
2026
10:57PM
william holland 122 evening
shade dr
The traffic around Harris Teeter is already very
heavy. More development is going to make it
worse with no improvements to Bees Ferry or
Grand Oaks Blvd. If it is not already zoned for
this concentration of housing, it should not ve
approved. Zoning is there for a reason, NOT to
make exceptions every time a developer wants it
changed. We vote. The developer probably
lives somewhere else.
Jan 4
2026
1:34PM
Lynn Veatch 809 Bent
Hickory Rd.,
Charleston
SC 29414
Grand Oaks Blvd is heavily congested making
entry and egress very slow. The addition of 380
apartments and 36 townhouses will further slow
traffic and limit emergency services to the Grand
Oaks community.
Jan 4
2026
1:58PM
Mark Bell 2 Brook
Hollow Ct.
Charleston,
SC 29414
Stop throwing buildings up whenever and
wherever. The infrastructure doesn't support
what we have now.
Jan 4
2026
2:01PM
Sarah Cantrell 827 Bent
Hickory Rd
The infrastructure of Grand Oaks Blvd, Bees
Ferry, and Glenn McConnell cannot support 400
more residential units. The residents of West
Ashley need more green space, not more homes.
Jan 4
2026
2:18PM
Charise Cassetta 258 Larissa
Drive,
Charleston,
SC 29414
Please please please do not approve this
project!! Bees Ferry is already too overloaded
with new developments and retail buildings that
have been added in the last five years. The
rapid development has not done anything to
alleviate the traffic and infrastructure. Getting
out of Grand Oaks is already a challenge. Log
Savannah is already under construction. Why do
we need to approve and build more
developments in this area? Please do not
approve! Let's put a pause on developments for
a few years and let what is already in the works
complete and see how infrastructure is then.
Jan 4
2026
3:34PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 16
Ruth Freedenberg 343 Cabrill
Drive
Congestion overload!!! It's already a nightmare
to exit onto Bees Ferry and then Glenn
McConnell. With the building going on here, it is
evident that traffic is not taken into account. No
infrastructure for public transportation which
should have been planned for decades ago.
Very discouraging situation. If I was not retired,
I would leave Charleston as it is a nightmare to
get anywhere.
Jan 4
2026
4:04PM
Meghann Wheeler 509 Blue
Dragonfly Dr.
Charleston
SC 29414
Grand Oaks Blvd is already overly congested
with traffic at peak times; adding this volume of
homes would only serve to exacerbate and
already stressed area. Wildlife has also recently
been displaced in this area with the Long
Savanna development, which will further stress
the wildlife in the area. There are too many
cons, nowhere near enough pros to move
forward with this plan.
Jan 4
2026
4:34PM
Lilia Pelfrey 703 Bent
Hickory Rd
It is IMPOSSIBLE TO BELIEVE the plans to do
more building in an already literally imposible to
handle the every day heavy loaded traffic!
Please reconsider NOT to do more building in
this already saturated community
Jan 4
2026
5:03PM
Pamela Ingram 1036 Tyron
Circle,
Charleston,
SC
The scale and mass are way too large for the
area. Buildings need to be no more than 2 stories
high, or else they will dwarf the homes that are
off of Grand Oaks Blvd. I’m also concerned
about light pollution from taller buildings. There
also needs to be more green space (particularly
areas left natural, including the wetlands area),
as well as a natural area buffer fronting Grand
Oaks Blvd. The garages and trash area should
not be visible from Grand Oaks Blvd. The area is
too small for the number of buildings proposed.
The developer MUST provide access to WA
Circle so that all of the traffic is not utilizing
Grand Oaks Blvd. This comment is off-topic, but
the notice was insufficient. It was placed during a
holiday week with the sign barely visible to
drivers-it was parallel to Grand Oaks Blvd. and
could only be read by stepping into the street.
At minimum, there needs to be a sign on each
side of the road, in the driver’s line of sight
(perpendicular to the road).
Jan 4
2026
5:10PM
Olivia H West Ashley I respectfully oppose the proposed development
at 350 Grand Oaks Blvd. Housing development
in this area of West Ashley is occurring at a
pace that exceeds the capacity of existing
infrastructure, particularly traffic and roadway
systems. Continued density without corresponding
infrastructure improvements will further strain the
area and reduce overall quality of life for
Jan 4
2026
5:23AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 17
residents. Additionally, there appears to be little
emphasis on conservation or long-term
environmental stewardship. West Ashley needs a
more measured approach to growth that
prioritizes infrastructure readiness, environmental
protection, and the future livability of the
community for our children.
Eric Wilhelm 1706 N Elgin
Ct,
Charleston
SC 29414
Infrastructure along Bees Ferry and Grand Oaks
is already stressed from numerous projects, such
as this one, over the last decade. In addition, an
area prone to flooding and heavy rainfall puts
existing buildings and houses at risk of major
damage if forests and wetlands are removed for
such a project. I heavily oppose such a project
without major improvements to both infrastructure
and drainage.
Jan 4
2026
5:23PM
Nancy Huber 337
Weeping
Willow Way
Our neighborhood not only doesn't need this
development but Grand Oaks can't handle all
the traffic it will bring. When I moved in GO 5
years ago I always said it took me 5 minutes to
get out of the neighborhood. Now it takes 10
minutes at times. If this development is
approved, we'll never be able to get out. And
one of the reasons I purchased in GO was the
beautiful entrance driving into the neighborhood.
Please please please don't approve this
development.
Jan 4
2026
5:43PM
Wendy Stimpson 902
Lansfaire Dr,
Charleston
This will add to the overcrowding in the area.
Traffic is already terrible. It will destroy the
beautiful entrance to Grand Oaks. It will have to
be renamed to No Oaks.
Jan 4
2026
5:45PM
Leyna Hanson 401
Matuskovic
Dr
I am very much so opposed to any further single
family, multi family or affordable housing
developments along Bees Ferry Rd. Over the
past few years I have seen the area grow at an
unbelievably astonishing rate. There seems to be
zero interest in supporting that growth with any
proper infrastructure being put in place. Traffic
is a huge problem already in this area. Mon thru
Fri, it can take me a full hour to get to the
downtown area...I live 12 miles away from my
job, an hour to get there is incomprehensible. The
widening of Glenn Mcconnell absolutely will not
accommodate the growth that is coming to this
area...it doesn't support the growth the area has
already seen. I can not think of a single positive
impact adding yet another multi family housing
development would bring to this area. Is the
addition of Long Savannah not enough?? Not
every open area of land needs to be developed
in order to make some money. What about the
environmental impacts, like flooding? How about
Jan 4
2026
5:54PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 18
the all of wildlife that is being displaced and
forced to become a nusance to some because the
animals have lost their homes? The greed that
drives these decisions is not surprising anymore,
but it never fails to disappoint. NO MORE
DEVELOPMENT ALONG BEES FERRY ROAD!!
Aislinn Mcilvenny Dorothy
Drive
Current infrastructure cannot handle this growth.
As things are now, it is extremely difficult to even
get out of grand oaks, onto bees ferry, then
Glenn McConnell during rush hour. That many
additional homes will make it near impossible.
Jan 4
2026
5:57PM
Devin Moore 1028 Tyron
Circle,
Charleston,
SC 29414
Do not approve this housing project. Grand Oaks
is already more than crowded. The coming Long
Savannah project will be adding thousands of
people and cars to the area already. As it is, I
often cannot leave my own neighborhood without
waiting through multiple traffic light cycles
because of backups at the Bees Ferry / Grand
Oaks intersection due to the current high traffic
levels. The last thing we need is an additional
380+ residences & the associated cars on Grand
Oaks Blvd. Residential saturation along the Bees
Ferry corridor is already astoundingly high. The
growth is out of control. We need an incredibly
large amount of infrastructure development
before adding any more residents to our
neighborhood. We don't even have permanent
traffic lights at the Bees Ferry / Grand Oaks
intersection yet - they're still the temporary lights
hanging on cables. I most strongly oppose the
development at 350 Grand Oaks Blvd. and
sincerely hope this does not progress any further.
Mark me down as a "NO" vote on this - in fact,
make that "HELL NO".
Jan 4
2026
5:57PM
Caroline Perez 2104 Fife
Lane
This area of West Ashley is becoming over
developed with housing and the road
infrastructure does not support it. The traffic is
bad enough it will worsen with the addition of
more apartments and townhomes.
Jan 4
2026
6:14AM
Richard Kazzi 862 Rue
Drive
Charleston,
29414
Please consider the negative impact that this
massive development will have on our Grand
Oaks neighborhood, on our quality of life. The
increase in traffic that this development will
bring to our neighborhood cannot be supported
by current infrastructure. Respectfully, Rick
Kazzi
Jan 4
2026
6:23PM
Bonnie Walton 210 Summer
Rain Ct.
Please do not allow this construction to happen. It
is one of the last wooded areas around Grand
Oaks. Traffic is already terrible leaving the
neighborhood and we will also see an influx of
traffic with the development of Long Savannah.
Please leave it as woods.
Jan 4
2026
6:34PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 19
Pamela Morgan 3464 Forest
Glen Drive
We have elected officials who would look out
for the best interest of our community. So far
they have not done their jobs because we have
been overrun by apartments. The traffic is
nothing less than complete deadlock all hours of
the day, night and week with no relief in sight.
And now you want to build 380 more
apartments? That is pure insanity and a sure fire
way to get voted out come election time.
Jan 4
2026
6:34PM
Tracy Lyles 1497 Ashley
Garden Blvd
More apartments are NOT needed in our area.
Traffic is a huge contributing factor to my
opinion. It should not 10+ minutes to get out of
Grand Oaks and down Glenn McConnell. The
traffic is terrible all day - there is no time that
travel is easy. Charleston must get our
infrastructure under control before we add more
housing. I have lived in Grand Oaks for 20
years. I have worked on Johns Island, North
Charleston and now James Island during this
time. It routinely takes me 30-40 minutes to get
to work every morning (I leave my house around
6:45 each morning) and an hour to get home
each day. The beauty of this area is also being
destroyed with every new housing complex. It is
no longer peaceful. Please reconsider adding
housing to this area. We don’t need more people
here.
Jan 4
2026
6:36PM
Rhiannon McPherson 6050 Postell
Dr Ravenel
SC
The infrastructure can't handle the additional
apartments and townhomes. The local schools are
over populated. Additional homes, townhomes,
apartments, and other living unit neighborhoods
must be denied until appropriate upgrades can
be made to the roads, the flooding, the lights,
traffic, and schools. This addition will only cause
detriment to current residents in the
neighborhood and those who have to travel thru
for school and work.
Jan 4
2026
6:36PM
Samantha Briggs 732 Bent
Hickory
Road,
Charleston,
SC 29414
I strongly oppose allowing the proposed
apartments and townhouses to be built on this
property without first addressing the inadequate
road infrastructure serving the Grand Oaks
subdivision. Our community is already
experiencing a significant residential expansion,
with many new homes currently under
construction. As it stands, we already face
ongoing traffic congestion and safety concerns
on the limited roads leading in and out of the
neighborhood. Adding high density housing
without improving these access points will only
worsen an already strained situation. Before
any additional residents are approved, the
roads in and out of Grand Oaks must be
Jan 4
2026
6:36PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 20
expanded and improved to ensure the safety of
current homeowners, future residents, and daily
commuters. This is not just an inconvenience issue,
it is a public safety concern. In the event of an
emergency, first responders need reliable and
efficient access to our community. Currently,
limited entry and exit routes create delays that
could be life threatening. Likewise, in the case of
a large scale emergency or evacuation, there is
no safe or sufficient travel path to accommodate
the residents who already live here, let alone
additional population. Development should be
done responsibly and in phases. Infrastructure
improvements must come before increased
density, not after. For the safety, accessibility,
and well being of our community, road
expansion and traffic planning should be
completed prior to approving any additional
housing on this property.
Michael Frederick 416 Blue
Dragonfly Dr
Charleston
SC 29414
I am opposed to further housing development
with the current infrastructure that exists around
Grand Oaks Blvd, Bees Ferry Road and Glenn
McConnell. The current infrastructure cannot
handle the amount of traffic already present,
further development of new housing will only
compound the problem and safety of drivers and
pedestrians present in the area.
Jan 4
2026
6:49PM
Kristen Martin 149 Dorothy
Drive
Charleston
SC 29414
I have lived in Grand Oaks since 2007 and the
traffic getting in and out of the neighborhood
has increased greatly over this time. Any more
development of such a high density would
completely tax the current infrastructure and
greatly depress the quality of life for residents
as well as future home sale values. With the Long
Savanna project underway, the Bees
Ferry/Grand Oaks area is at maximum capacity
and I vehemently oppose any further high
density residential development.
Jan 4
2026
6:59PM
Ben Briggs 732 Bent
hickory Road
Charleston,SC
29414
The proposed addition of apartments and
townhomes to an area that is already
experiencing significant traffic congestion and
population density raises serious concerns.
Introducing high-density residential development
in a location where roadways, intersections,
parking, and public services are already
overburdened will inevitably exacerbate
existing traffic problems, increase safety risks,
and further strain emergency response
capabilities. Higher-density housing generates
substantially more daily vehicle trips than single-
family homes. Without corresponding and clearly
funded infrastructure improvements, this
Jan 4
2026
7:00PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 21
development will negatively impact mobility,
increase commute times, and diminish the overall
quality of life for current residents. In addition,
the increased demand on schools, utilities, and
public services must be carefully considered, as
these systems may not be equipped to
accommodate a rapid influx of new residents.
Given these conditions, the proposed
development is not appropriate in its current
form. Single-family homes would represent a
more compatible and measured approach to
growth, one that better aligns with the existing
character and infrastructure capacity of the
area. At a minimum, this project should be tabled
until comprehensive traffic, infrastructure, and
public safety studies are completed and
reviewed, and until concrete plans are in place
to address the documented impacts. Proceeding
without these safeguards would be irresponsible
and contrary to the long-term interests of the
community.
Kraig Keyes 2919
Limestone
Blvd
Charleston
SC 29414
Excessive housing development on Hwy 61 and
Bees Ferry / Paul Cantrell, combined with
inadequate transportation infrastructure, is
impacting the quality of life due to a lack of
meaningful long-range planning.
Jan 4
2026
7:23PM
Bruce Stimpson 902
Lansfaire
Drive,
Charleston,
SC 29414
The addition of 380 units and 36 Townhouses to
Grand Oaks is not a wise decision for the
following reasons: 1. This will increase the
already overwhelming traffic. It now takes
several traffic lights to get out to Bees Ferry. 2.
The flooding of Church Creek will increase due to
the lack of drainage possibilities. 3. The
addition of yet more housing to our West Ashley
will make it look more like Mount Pleasant.
Jan 4
2026
7:25PM
Tracy Dresnin 128 Fulmar
Place,
Charleston
I oppose for this location for development. It is
overcrowded enough and I do not want any
wildlife harmed.
Jan 4
2026
8:22PM
Pamela Knox 311 Grouse
Park,
Charleston
SC 294145
As a resident in the Grand Oaks Plantation
subdivision, I strongly oppose this project. The
residents of this subdivision have already been
subjected to major development since 2018 at
the intersection of Grand Oaks Blvd. and Bees
Ferry including the major shopping center at the
corner of this intersection with a Harris Teeter
grocery store as the anchor. With the Bees
Ferry/Glenn McConnell Blvd intersection being
the main feeder to 526, the traffic is already a
major issue on weekday mornings. This proposed
new development will make it nearly impossible
to get in and out of the Grand Oaks subdivision
in a reasonable amount of time during standard
Jan 4
2026
8:23PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 22
rush hour timeframes. We cannot continue to
increase the population in this small area without
major changes in the infrastructure. We also
need to keep in mind that there has been major
new residential development on & off Bees Ferry
in the direction of Savannah Highway, creating a
significant increase in traffic. Please rethink this
additional stress on an already overly
developed area.
Denise Gann 188 Larissa
Dr
If there is going to be development here, it
really should be for commercial use only. It
would be nice to keep some of the green space
and at least keep a barrier of trees along
Grand Oaks Blvd. Would prefer no
development, but please NO MORE APTS!!!
Jan 4
2026
8:24PM
Kathryn Cox 610
Summerfield
Court,
Charleston
SC 29414
This project will impact so much in our already
crowded neighborhood of Grand Oaks
Plantation. I've lived her 23 years and have seen
it grow so much and traffic can't even get out at
our light sometimes for 10 minutes as the light
favors Bees Ferry Road always. I do not want to
see this happen but unfortunately our voices
don't seem to matter anymore it's all about
revenue and the people just have to take it. I
am very sad with with all the condo/apartments
being built along Bees Ferry Road , how much is
too much and where will it en? The Savanna Long
is about to be developed behind us and they
never ran the Glen McConnell all the way to 165
as promised when I moved here. No roads to
handle these vehicles and people trying to get to
work and home, it's becoming a very dangerous
nightmare driving and getting around over here
now....
Jan 4
2026
8:32PM
Thomas Freund 1039 Tyron
Circle
I am writing to formally oppose the proposed
development at 350 Grand Oaks Boulevard due
to significant concerns regarding inadequate
infrastructure planning, existing and projected
traffic congestion, and irreversible environmental
impacts. The Bees Ferry Road and Ashley River
Road corridor is already operating beyond its
intended capacity. Daily congestion—
particularly during peak commuting hours—has
become a defining feature of this area, creating
safety concerns, emergency response delays,
and reduced quality of life for residents. These
issues are not hypothetical; they are currently
being experienced and will be substantially
worsened by additional density without
corresponding infrastructure investment. This
concern is magnified when considered alongside
the ongoing and planned development efforts in
Jan 4
2026
8:53AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 23
Ravenel, which will further strain the same road
networks and intersections. At present, there is no
clear, funded, or phased plan to meaningfully
address these cumulative impacts. Approving
new development without first resolving known
transportation deficiencies represents poor long-
term planning and places the burden of
congestion squarely on existing residents.
Equally concerning are the environmental
implications of this project. The proposed
development threatens to destroy valuable
habitat and green space that serve important
ecological functions, including stormwater
absorption, wildlife corridors, and natural
buffers along the Ashley River watershed. In a
region already vulnerable to flooding, erosion,
and habitat loss, preserving remaining
undeveloped land should be a priority—not an
afterthought. Once these ecosystems are
disturbed or removed, they cannot be
meaningfully replaced. The environmental costs
of this project extend beyond the immediate site
and will affect surrounding communities through
increased runoff, degraded water quality, and
loss of biodiversity. Growth in our region is
inevitable, but it must be responsible, well-
sequenced, and aligned with infrastructure and
environmental realities. Approving development
at 350 Grand Oaks Blvd without first addressing
transportation capacity and environmental
protection sets a troubling precedent and
undermines the long-term resilience of the West
Ashley and Ravenel communities. For these
reasons, I strongly urge decision-makers to deny
or delay approval of this development until
comprehensive traffic mitigation, infrastructure
improvements, and environmental safeguards
are clearly defined, funded, and implemented.
Thank you for the opportunity to submit this
comment and for considering the long-term
wellbeing of our community.
Jamie Nault 805 Paran
Oaks Dr
Since moving into Grand Oaks in 2023 there has
been continuous development, majority of which
have been high and medium density residential
developments. Multiple sets of town homes off of
Bees Ferry, apartments off of Bees Ferry and
Glen McConnell, request to rezone Story Brook
Farm for more town homes. The current
infrastructure has remained the same and traffic
is more and more of an issue. As a resident of
Grand Oaks, I am opposed to more
development on Grand Oaks Blvd. This will add
Jan 4
2026
9:15AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 24
to the worsening traffic problems and further tax
the current infrastructure and facilities.
Cheryl Leonard 2982
Winners
Circle
I live in Hickory Farms. For 3 years in a row we
experienced severe flooding in our
neighborhood due to over development beside
and behind our subdivision. We have yet to see
any of the promises as to what would be done
that we were given to prevent this from
happening again. 1 acre of wetlands absorbs
over a million gallons of water. This area on
Grand Oaks Blvd. Is a wetland. It also has ruins
of a house on the old plantation. Are we ever
going to stop overdevelopment? Other
neighboring communities have established
moratoriums on over development. Why can’t
Charleston? Please do not allow this excessive
development to move forward.
Jan 4
2026
9:18PM
Michelle Kanapaux 910
Lansfaire dr
charleston sc
29414
We have enough traffic. Add houses or
townhomes not apartments.
Jan 4
2026
12:51PM
Beth Mountz 2912
Amberhill
Way
I believe this is a disservice to this area. Traffic
and congestion is already at a high point and
adding more homes to this area is irresponsible
for the infrastructure that is currently in place as
well crowding this area more than it already is.
Charleston/West Ashley used to be so beautiful
and unique and we just keep building and
adding homes and traffic is excruciating. All of
these aspects need to be seriously considered
before adding more apartments/buidling more
homes.
Jan 5
2026
6:41AM
Kellie Dawson 18 Darcy
Court
The infrastructure in West Ashley cannot handle
any more large projects with multi family units to
this extent. The growth is getting completely out
of control. We need to start focusing more on
shopping and stores that the local people can
use so they do not have to travel. Investors are
coming in here and overcrowding West Ashley
and causing the liability to decrease. I am a
school teacher, and our schools are becoming
overcrowded. This construction will just cause
more problems.. as a taxpayer and voter I ask
that you reconsider this building permit.
Jan 5
2026
7:14AM
Emily Vogelgesang 584
Hainsworth
Dr,
Charleston,
SC 29414
Increased tree buffers will help lessen the blow
of the overall development to the neighborhood
aesthetic - suggesting an increase to 35 feet.
The back of the townhomes should be required to
match the current look of other townhomes in the
development to maintain overall character -
there wasn't an indication if a fence would be
allowed to go up and that should be made clear
Jan 5
2026
8:22AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 25
as part of the design review. Overall the color
choices should be adjusted to reflect the other
townhomes within Grand Oaks - either the brick
choice or the bright colors. Adding a big white
building does not match any existing homes or
townhomes in the stretch of neighborhood this is
going in. Additionally, the white is going to get
mildew and moldy quickly and not be
maintained properly as seen in other apartment
units throughout town. The development should
be limited to 3 stories - allowing 4 stories in this
developed of a neighborhood where nothing is
currently higher than 2.5 stories is ridiculous.
With the trees to be left as a buffer and
addition of palm trees, this height would much
quicker blend in to the surrounding than 4 stories
will. I appreciate the developers use of native
plants to maintain existing area character. The
wet ponds should be required to have more
landscaping planned around them than is
currently indicated as well as benches to reflect
the other ponds in the neighborhood. The
developer should plan to add trash cans around
their property with the increase in residents. Dog
poop stations as well. This should be a part of
the design review as they should match the
aesthetic. Due to the site location, the builder
should be required to add bigger turn lanes on
their property and increase the tree buffer on all
sides. The turn lanes will help alleviate traffic
issues this is going to cause by giving residents a
quicker opportunity to exit moving lanes of
traffic.
Careen Jensen 904
Lansfaire Dr.,
Charleston,
SC 29414
I am opposed to any development in the Grand
Oaks neighborhood. The proposed development
will cause more congestion. The traffic in and out
of Grand Oaks has already become a problem
with the existing development. When the Harris
Teeter shopping center was proposed, there was
supposed to be an access road connecting
Grand Oaks to the circle. That still has not
happened. Adding hundreds more vehicles to
the area will cause additional congestion, which
this area cannot handle. Please stop the
development of high density housing in this
corridor. The infrastructure cannot handle it.
Jan 5
2026
9:02AM
Christy Rullis 228
Brambling
Lane, 29414
My family and I live on Brambling Lane, which is
the closest road to the proposed subdivision. The
road infrastructure in West Ashley/Bees Ferry
Area cannot house all of these new residents.
The traffic is already horrendous trying to leave
Grand Oaks and get down Glen McConnell.
Jan 5
2026
9:03AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 26
We also worry about flooding if they will be
filling in the wetlands behind our houses. Enough
with all of this building and time to focus on
renovating some of the old abandoned buildings
in West Ashley and fixing up inside 526 a bit
more.
Mary Cooper 60 Rutledge
Ave
Charleston
SC 29401
DENY request to demolish because this building is
An important historic structure: This 89-year-old,
Colonial Revival-style structure is historic in its
architecture as well as its context. A significant
historic site: The site was deemed eligible for
listing on the National Register of Historic Places
in 2015 due to its historical significance. Clemson
purchased the property in 2019 understanding
its unique nature and character. An historically
and culturally important use: As the first of its
kind in the world, the building served as an
anchor for the first research station established
through the Bankhead-Jones Act to bolster
agricultural research, breeds, and innovation
post-World War I. Important to the city and the
region: Much of the research conducted in and
around this building was aimed at developing
new varieties of crops that could fill in gaps
after the Lowcountry rice and cotton industries
collapsed. This site was associated with the
improvement of produce
Jan 5
2026
9:13AM
Linda McDonald 6001
Sandlewood
Court
Bees Ferry is busy enough without additional
traffic and housing. Need to improve
infrastructure before adding more cars to the
road!
Jan 5
2026
9:14AM
Elizabeth Gray 544 Tribeca
Drive
As a resident of Grand Oaks since 2011 I
understand that land will be developed and
changes happen. I ask that this is not allowed to
happen because the infrastructure is not here to
support this community or what is already here. I
work 12 miles away and have to leave 1.25 hrs
ahead to make it on time. I wont be able to
make the commute with more traffic and it could
put my livelihood at risk. I already live here, this
doesn’t have to happen.
Jan 5
2026
9:23AM
Katie Register 2 Loch Carrun
Terrace,
29414
526 needs to be finished before any further
housing developments are added. It is a
nightmare getting anywhere.
Jan 5
2026
9:25AM
Erin Nichols 120 Fulmar
Place,
Charleston,
SC 29414
I live in The Landings at Grand Oaks, the
adjacent property. The traffic is already too
congested and the lights way too long due to
over developed land on Grand Oaks and Bees
Ferry. I worry about ground water, wildlife and
congestion. This area is wetlands and has
already been overdeveloped. Please deny any
Jan 5
2026
9:26AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 27
large housing/apartment complex or storage
facility.
Ren Ruggiero 2178 Bees
Ferry Rd Apt
D Charleston
SC 29414
As a longtime resident of Bees Ferry Rd, I have
seen the increasing congestion in the Grand
Oaks area firsthand. It is already very difficult
to access the businesses at the intersection of
Bees Ferry and Grand Oaks due to the traffic
coming in and out of the subdivision. Our
neighborhood is growing too fast and the
development is unsustainable.
Jan 5
2026
9:27AM
Doug Lembo 316 Cabrill
Dr
As a resident living in Grand Oaks &
Shadowmoss for over 15 years I have seen the
area grow significantly. While the majority of
this is great news for home value and quality of
life, I have seen the negative side as well.
Specifically with removing natural
wetland/drainage in highly populated areas.
The flooding is astronomical and the more we
pave over these natural drainage areas the
worse it gets. The land behind Harris Teeter is
one of the few larger run off areas we have left
in this neighborhood. Building a giant townhome
complex will not only take that drainage away
but it will also remove a large area for wildlife
which has been dwindling as well. On top of all
this the minimal entrances and exits from grand
oaks got vehicles is already an issue, adding
additional cars right near the main exit will
increase an already frustrating traffic pattern
issue. Finally I’m all for capitalism and making
money for these applicants and even helping
house residents who may be trying to buy into
the area but there has to be a line of
demarcation. The building of homes behind
grand oaks (blue dragonfly and long Savanah)
is already going to bring hundreds and
eventually thousands of residents. Let’s leave
well enough alone and allow the current
residents to try and enjoy what we have without
the added stress of traffic/construction near the
exit and worst of all flooding in the surrounding
neighborhoods. Thank you for your time.
Jan 5
2026
9:30AM
Pamela Bright 310 Grouse
Park
Charleston,
SC 29414
I respectfully oppose the proposed development
of 350 new homes along Grand Oaks Blvd. due
to the significant and unresolved impacts it would
have on traffic congestion, community
overcrowding, and the loss of valuable
undeveloped land. Grand Oaks Blvd. extending
to Bees Ferry and onto Glenn McConnell,
already experiences substantial traffic volume,
particularly during peak morning and evening
hours. Residents routinely face delays, safety
Jan 5
2026
9:31AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 28
concerns, and limited accessibility for emergency
vehicles. Adding hundreds of additional
households would place an unsustainable burden
on an infrastructure that is already strained,
increasing commute times, accident risk, and
overall frustration for both current and future
residents. I personally commute 16 miles to work.
On an average my commute time to and from
work is over an hour. Why is it Charleston
County's goal to cover every inch of
undeveloped land?
Tim Jensen 904
Lansfaire Dr.,
Charleston,
SC 29414
I am opposed to this development effort as there
are already traffic problems in this area. Adding
apartments will only exacerbate this problem.
Jan 5
2026
9:35AM
LaDon Paige Hunt Club Run I respectfully ask that the design review board
not take this proposal under consideration. The
scale and density is too great. I believe that the
limited business district should be reserved for
something that would better complement the
surrounding area and not add to traffic
congestion and strain on our inadequate
infrastructure. There should be a moratorium on
development with the addition and with the
upcoming Long Savanna and multiple multifamily
projects that are already under construction
along Bees Ferry and Glen McConnell, the
infrastructure is not adequate to accept more
density. Please consider some other design that is
better for this community.
Jan 5
2026
9:39AM
Jeffrey Loope 222
Brambling
Lane
Charleston,
SC 29414
I am opposed to the potential development of
large apartment and townhome complexes that
is planned for the Grand Oaks neighborhood
behind Harris Teeter because the area is
already overcongested and lacking the
infrastructure needed to support such rapid
growth. Traffic delays, strained utilities, and
reduced emergency response times are already
everyday concerns for residents of West Ashley.
Adding hundreds to thousands more residents
without meaningful road improvements, drainage
solutions, or public service expansion will only
worsen quality of life, compromise safety, and
erode the character of our community.
Responsible growth should prioritize
infrastructure and long-term livability over
unchecked density in one of Charleston’s most
burdened corridors.
Jan 5
2026
9:41AM
Erin Scott 130 Fulmar
Place
I oppose this development. This area is already
overcrowded with too many developments along
Glen McConnell and Bees Ferry. This land should
remain open.
Jan 5
2026
10:07AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 29
Victoria Klvana 426 Blue
Dragonfly
Drive
We can not handle amount of people and traffic
that would be added
Jan 5
2026
10:08AM
Lester Klvana 426 Blue
Dragonfly
Drive
We can not handle more people and traffic Jan 5
2026
10:12AM
Lindsey Gill 302 Steele
Magnolia
Ave
There is NO infrastructure in place for this
additional housing. Do you propose a new road
out of the neighborhood that will NOT clog the
corner of Bees Ferry and Glen McConnell? Also
a tall apartment building is NOT coherent with
the style and look of Grand Oaks where this is
proposed. What ever happened to green space
and fresh air? This is not sustainable. What about
schools? What’s the plan there for all these
additional children and overcrowded classes
already?
Jan 5
2026
10:25AM
Paula Molnar 515 Ivy
Circle 29414
Opposed to further development. This particular
road / intersection is already struggling to
handle existing traffic of the area.
Jan 5
2026
10:39AM
Charles Privett 420
Sycamore
Shade street
There is not enough infrastructure at the Grand
Oaks entrances to support more traffic in and
out of the area. People are already blocking the
lanes coming out of Grand oaks. Additional
filling of wetlands in the bees ferry and church
Creek areas increase the risk of flooding, which
is already significant.
Jan 5
2026
10:58AM
Jennie Frederick 110 Sugar
Magnolia
Way
The current design is inappropriate for the area.
Too many buildings, too many units, too dense.
The buildings don't match size or style of the
neighborhood. We don't want more apartments.
Only single family townhomes or duplexes woul
d be appropriate in this space, to be harmonious
with surrounding neighborhoods design.
Jan 5
2026
11:05AM
Abby Spell 143 Cabrill
Drive,
Charleston,
SC 29414
There have been hundreds upon hundreds of
apartments built in the same area of West
Ashley over the past few years. We do not need
any more temporary housing. I have been a
homeowner in Grand Oaks since 2013. I
encounter cars speeding down Grand Oaks Blvd
and Ashley Gardens Blvd daily racing to their
apartments. We have lots of wildlife including
Bald Eagles, alligators, and deer that inhabit the
woods in the area. There is also trouble with
flooding and water in the area. A ton more
concrete is not good for the planet and not good
for our community. A better use of the space
would be a park or community center that
offered something for all the citizens of West
Ashley. We do not need any more apartments.
We need infrastructure improvements!!! The City
Jan 5
2026
11:12AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 30
of Charleston is not being responsible with its
over development.
Jennie Frederick 110 Sugar
Magnolia
Way,
Charleston,
SC 29414-
9000, USA
We opposed any development to the wetlands!
Our voices will likely fall on deaf ears, AGAIN.
Be advised, the public has become acutely
aware of abuse of power when it comes to new
development, and we are ending the public
service careers of elected officials that betray
the trust of their constituents.
Jan 5
2026
11:12AM
Kristie Davis 537 Tribeca
Drive
The infrastructure and the wetlands will not
support yet more construction here. Traffic has
become very dangerous not only for pedestrians
and bike riders, but for other drivers. It’s not
acceptable to wait 30 minutes in traffic to arrive
at hwy 526. Flooding is an ongoing issue, and
building on wetlands, exacerbates the problems
and devastate our natural environment. Wildlife
is affected by yet fewer resources and become
“nuisance “ to residents who then harm the
animals. Finally, we are held captive here in a
hurricane now due to over-construction of the
Charleston area. If there is an evacuation we
cannot get out due to the overpopulation and
highways that can no longer sustain it! We are in
danger, and many of our leaders, and the
developers do not care. It’s outrageous to think
we can sustain more homes and residents here in
Grand Oaks.
Jan 5
2026
11:17AM
Andrea Maxwell Grand oaks
resident
I oppose all aspects of this ridiculous project. The
area is rapidly being overdeveloped, with
negative increaing traffic, risk of flooding, and
lack of improvements to current infrastructure.
The Glenn McConnell widening is not enough to
accommodate the explosion in development. To
be clear: I strongly oppose this project. Should
it move forward: building height should be
limited to no more than three stories. Parking
must be included in or under the building. Green
space should be maximized, optimizing the
retention of trees to maintain the neighborhood
asthetic.
Jan 5
2026
11:26AM
Linh Smith 566 ivy cir Oppose Jan 5
2026
11:26AM
Kim Boerman 900
Lansfaire
Drive
Charleston
SC 29414
Dear Members of the City of Charleston Design
Review Board, I am writing to respectfully but
firmly oppose the proposed development of 380
apartments and 36 townhomes behind Harris
Teeter on Grand Oaks Boulevard. West Ashley
— particularly the Bees Ferry, Grand Oaks, and
Glen McConnell corridors — is already heavily
saturated with multi-family projects. Over the
Jan 5
2026
11:28AM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 31
past several years, our area has seen a dramatic
increase in apartment density without
proportional investment in roads, schools,
drainage, safety services, or quality-of-life
infrastructure. Adding hundreds more units to this
already stressed area would further strain an
environment that is simply not equipped to
absorb it. Traffic & Safety Grand Oaks
Boulevard was not designed to accommodate the
significant daily traffic generation that an
additional 400+ residential units will bring. The
Bees Ferry/Glen McConnell corridor is already
congested, with frequent backups, safety
concerns, and increased accident risk. This project
would unquestionably worsen those conditions for
residents, school buses, emergency vehicles, and
everyday commuters. Drainage & Flooding
West Ashley is known for flooding challenges,
and much of this area is already sensitive.
Covering more land with impervious surface
places neighborhoods at higher risk, increases
stormwater burden, and pushes water toward
existing homes. This puts residents, property
values, and insurance costs at risk. Schools &
Community Capacity Our local schools are
already at or over capacity. Rapid multi-family
expansion has not been matched with school
expansion, teacher support, or transportation
infrastructure. Approving another high-density
development ignores the reality of the impact on
families and students. Community Character
Grand Oaks is a well-established residential
community that families intentionally chose
because of its suburban neighborhood
environment. This project fundamentally changes
the scale, feel, and livability of the area.
Responsible development should complement a
community — not overwhelm it. The Right Project
in the Wrong Place This is not anti-growth; it is a
request for responsible, balanced, and thoughtful
growth. West Ashley needs infrastructure relief,
traffic solutions, stormwater improvements, and
community resources before more mass-density
housing is approved. Approving yet another
massive apartment complex disregards the lived
reality of residents who already bear the daily
impact of unchecked development. For these
reasons, I urge the Board to deny this proposal in
its current form and protect the integrity, safety,
and livability of the Grand Oaks and greater
West Ashley community. Thank you for your time
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 32
and consideration of the residents who call this
area home. Sincerely,
Pamela Lyons 406 Blue
Jasmine Ln
Charleston
SC 29414
This proposal is not in line with mass or scale in
this proposed location. We urge the board to not
approved this project as it will significantly ruin
the current aesthetics along GO Blvd.
Jan 5
2026
11:38AM
Jordan Woodard 508 Ivy
Circle
I strongly oppose the 380 apartment and 36
townhomes project. Traffic in this area is already
congested, with horrendous wait times at the
main traffic light. Adding this level of density
without major roadway and signal improvements
will negatively impact safety, commute times,
and emergency response access. This
development is not appropriate for the current
capacity of the area.
Jan 5
2026
11:48AM
Carlos &
Pamela
Bright 310 Grouse
Park,
Charleston
SC 29414
The proposed subdivision and apartments will
create undue strife on the existing residences of
Grand Oaks. The roads affected and the traffic
lights therein are already overburdened. Adding
an additional 400+ vehicles to these roads is
ignorant at best. The traffic signal at Grand
Oaks and Bees Ferry is timed incorrectly and
does not allow a good flow of traffic onto Bees
Ferry. On top of that the flow down Glenn
McConnell is backed up every morning and
evening. There is no way to direct this traffic
anywhere else. There is so much construction
going on in the area with no regard for the
quality of life for the current residents. Anyone
traveling this route to work is already dealing
with multi hour commutes. Adding these
additional cars to the mix will only exacerbate
the already miserable commute. The Grand
Oaks area/community is already mostly single
family homes and some townhomes and adding
the apartments to the area will create a mix that
we do not want. Apartments should be kept out
of the neighborhood. Let us have a peaceful
area that is filled with homeOWNERS and not
rentals with tenants flipping every year.
Jan 5
2026
11:48AM
suzann marchewka 108 Dorothy
dr
Someone needs to look out for the people who
already live in Grand Oaks and the population
growth. It seems as though those making
decisions are lining their pockets. Nothing new
there but a change from that mindset is sorely
needed.
Jan 5
2026
11:51AM
Natalie DiValentino Autumn
Chase
Magnolia
Lakes
Public Comment – Opposition to DRB Application
Re: Bees Resources LP / Middleburg Communities
– Multi-Family Development Design Review
Board Members, I am writing to formally oppose
the proposed multi-family development consisting
of six buildings with 380 apartment units, 36
Jan 5
2026
12:05PM
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 33
townhouses, separate garages, and a clubhouse.
While I understand the importance of growth,
this particular proposal raises serious concerns
about the long-term impact on our already
overburdened community. 1. Traffic & Roadway
Capacity Traffic conditions in this area are
already extremely challenging. Daily congestion
during peak hours has reached an unsustainable
level, and the addition of hundreds of new
residential units will only worsen this problem.
Local roads and intersections are not designed to
accommodate this level of increased volume, and
no meaningful mitigation strategy has been
presented that would prevent significant
degradation of safety and quality of life for
existing residents. 2. Wetland & Drainage
Concerns The site’s proximity to wetlands and
existing drainage systems presents major
environmental and infrastructure risks. Our
community has already experienced issues
related to stormwater management and
flooding. Further development at this scale
increases the likelihood of runoff, erosion, and
long-term drainage problems that could
negatively impact nearby properties and the
surrounding ecosystem. 3. Cumulative Strain
from Overdevelopment This project cannot be
evaluated in isolation. Numerous other
developments and high-density projects are
already underway or recently approved in the
surrounding area. Together, these projects are
placing severe strain on local resources, public
infrastructure, and community services. Even basic
necessities, such as finding parking at Harris
Teeter, have become increasingly difficult — a
small but telling indicator of how stretched this
area already is. Our community is growing
faster than its infrastructure can reasonably
support. Approving yet another large-scale
residential project without comprehensive
planning for transportation, environmental
protection, and resource capacity will further
compromise the livability of this area. For these
reasons, I respectfully urge the Design Review
Board to deny conceptual approval of this
application or, at minimum, require substantial
revisions and additional impact studies before
moving forward. Thank you for your time and
consideration. Sincerely, Natalie DiValentino
Resident of Grand Oaks Community: Autumn
Chase Magnolia Lakes
Design Review Board
Public Comment | January 5, 2026 Page 34
6. East corner of West Ashley Cir. and Glenn McConnell Pkwy.
West Ashley | Council District 2 | TMS #305-08-00-060 | DRB2025-000291
Requesting conceptual approval for a new City of Charleston Fire operations/training
complex.
Owner: City of Charleston Capital Projects
Applicant: Billy Connell
No Comments Submitted
7. 3688 Angel Oak Rd.
Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS# 279-00-00-665, 142 | DRB2025-000247
Requesting preliminary approval for a new 1-story visitor’s center/restroom building at
the Angel Oak Preserve. Also included are trails, playground, enhanced landscape, and
new parking lot.
Owner: Low Country Land Trust/Samantha Siegel
Applicant: Liollio Architects/Jay White
No Comments Submitted
ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do
not click links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or
have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish
Alert Button.
From: Justin Ferira
To: Meeks, David
Subject: Procedural Observations About DRB Application - re: Clemson Lab Demo Application
Date: Monday, January 5, 2026 1:42:01 AM
Dear Mr. Meeks,
I hope you are well. I wanted to take a moment ahead of today’s Design Review Board
hearing to introduce myself and to share a brief procedural observation in a collegial spirit.
First, I want to express my sincere appreciation for your service and for the work of the
Design Review Board. I know the Board is frequently asked to navigate complex and high-
profile matters, and I appreciate the care and professionalism with which you and the Board
approach those responsibilities.
By way of background, I grew up in West Ashley and previously served on the West Ashley
Revitalization Commission. Through that role, I came to appreciate the City’s efforts—
particularly with Councilman Shahid’s and Jacob Lindsey’s involvement—to place markers at
the gateways into West Ashley. I have long viewed the former research lab site as one of those
gateways, with the buildings carrying significance beyond their parcel boundaries.
I plan to speak briefly during that portion of today’s meeting on the historical merits of the
buildings and property. I did, however, want to flag two procedural considerations in
advance, particularly as they overlap with issues you personally have previously and
thoughtfully identified in Post & Courier reporting.
Demolition by Neglect – Self-Created Deterioration Excluded from Consideration of
Building Assessment:
I also noted—and agree with—your statement that “We are now looking into what we
can do to stop this demolition by neglect. These buildings need to be renovated and
used.” I understand the City has issued similar directives.
Procedurally, this raises the question of whether the current application presents
evaluable information for approval.
The Board may consider a building’s condition only where deterioration is not self-
created. Where damage results from an owner’s failure to maintain or stabilize—
particularly after municipal direction—such deterioration cannot lawfully support
demolition and instead compels denial or corrective action.
In that sense, it appears the application may be evaluable for denial, but not for
approval. Reliance on self-created deterioration or on a mischaracterized MOA could
place the Board in a position of being asked to rely on inaccurate or procedurally
compromised information, potentially warranting deferral, denial, or later appeal if
approved.
Limited MOA Scope & Potential Lapse of Agreement:
I noted your comments stating: “It was brought to our attention that Clemson never
notified the MOA that the City denied the demolition of the buildings. And also “It was
brought to our attention that Clemson never notified the MOA that the City denied the
demolition of the buildings.
From a procedural standpoint, it appears that the applicant may have overrepresented
the scope of what the MOA ever was from the start. it was a limited coordination
agreement that expressly preserved local zoning authority and did not grant demolition
rights or override Charleston’s review authority. It stated expressly it was “subject to
local zoning and local rules.” I have seen many outward references that it was intended
to accomplish more—but it undeniably and expressly noted it has no influence on local
processes nor should they feel directed by the MOA.
Additionally, the MOA appears it either may have naturally expired or lapsed
through noncompliance of reporting. If it was extended, the required annual January
updates were not provided. If it was not extended or updates not provided (as you
noted), per section V of the MOA, Clemson would be in default and non-compliant, and
the MOA not operative to even suggest they still have federal support. So continued
reliance on it would seem to misstate its operative status.
Again, the applicant must present accurate representation of the documents it
references for application and asks the DRB to rely upon.
Either scenario raises concerns about whether the MOA is being accurately
characterized for the Board’s consideration. And the application mischaracterizing a
zoning document as a basis for approval is grounds for denial or appeal.
I offer these thoughts respectfully and in appreciation of the care you bring to your role. Thank
you again for your service, and I look forward to today’s proceedings.
If you have any interest to speak to educate me on how I’m thinking about things correctly or
not, I welcome the chance to speak and am at . I appreciate your service. Thank you again for
your time.
Best,
Justin Ferira
Dear Ms. Stoner,
I am writing regarding Clemson University’s renewed request to demolish the historic
vegetable research laboratory at the West Ashley agricultural research campus, as detailed in
the recent Post and Courier articles: “Charleston blocked Clemson plans to raze parts of its
historic farm. Now it is accused of demolition by neglect” (Sept. 29, 2025) and “Clemson seeks
to demolish historic vegetable research lab in West Ashley” (Dec. 23, 2025).
I want to be very clear: I am extremely disappointed and frustrated by Clemson’s handling of
this property.
If Clemson wishes to present itself as a responsible steward of land entrusted to it. Then it has
a duty to care for what has been given to it — especially when that property holds clear
historic and civic significance. Allowing a nationally important building to deteriorate for
years, responding only after city enforcement action, and then returning with another
demolition request is deeply troubling.
Good stewardship does not mean neglect followed by convenience-driven demolition. If
Clemson is unable or unwilling to maintain and responsibly manage this historic asset, then
the university should seriously reconsider its presence on this site. That may mean selling the
land to parties who are willing to meet the responsibilities that come with ownership, or
reassessing internal priorities and budgets if funding for basic stabilization and repair cannot
be found.
I strongly hope — and fully expect — that this demolition request will be denied.
As a public university serving the people of South Carolina, and as an institution operating
within the City of Charleston, Clemson should be held to a higher standard. I had hoped for
better judgment, transparency, and accountability from those entrusted with overseeing this
property.
Thank you for your time and consideration. I urge Clemson to reconsider this course of action
and to pursue a solution that reflects genuine stewardship rather than irreversible loss.
ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click
links or open attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have
confirmed the content is safe. Forward any suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button.
From: Michael Gravely
Sent: Tuesday, December 23, 2025 6:15 PM
To: haselde
Cc: wwechte; Summerfield, Robert
Subject: Concern Regarding Proposed Demolition of Historic Vegetable Research Laboratory – West
Ashley
Supply Chain Management
The Citadel Oscar '27
Michael Gravely
Respectfully,
ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City of Charleston's systems. Do not click links or open
attachments unless you are expecting them from the sender and/or have confirmed the content is safe. Forward any
suspicious emails by clicking the Phish Alert Button.
From: Chad Husselbee
To: Meeks, David
Subject: DRB Public Comment Submission – Agenda Item #1 – 2875 Savannah Highway (January 5, 2026)
Date: Sunday, December 28, 2025 11:45:02 PM
Attachments: DRB Opposition – 2875 Savannah Highway – Agenda Item 1 – Husselbee.pdf.pdf
History- USDA Vegetable Lab Clemson webpage .pdf
2875 Final Report (corrected) .docx
Dear Mr. Meeks,
Attached please find my written public comment and opposition materials for inclusion in the
official record for the City of Charleston Design Review Board meeting scheduled for Monday,
January 5, 2026.
Property: 2875 Savannah Highway
Agenda Item: #1 – Demolition request by Clemson University
Meeting Date: January 5, 2026
Submitted by: Chad Husselbee
The primary opposition memorandum is submitted as a single PDF. Additional supporting files
and referenced exhibits are also attached for the Board’s consideration and incorporation into the
record.
I would also like to thank you and the members of the Design Review Board for the time and
attention devoted to this matter. The issues presented extend beyond a single property and raise
important considerations for historic preservation, public accountability, and stewardship of
nationally significant resources. I appreciate the Board’s careful review of this record and its role
in addressing matters of such importance.
Please confirm receipt of these materials and advise if anything further is required to ensure they
are properly distributed to Board members in advance of the meeting.
Thank you for your time and attention.
Respectfully,
Chad Husselbee
Supporting Documentation
Former USDA Vegetable Lab -
Historical Report - BVL - FINAL &
SHPO APPROVED.pdf | Powered
by Box
app.box.com
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email and any attachments may contain confidential or
privileged information. It is intended solely for the use of the recipient. Any unauthorized review,
use, disclosure, or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify
the sender and delete this message. Thank you.
INVESTIGATIVE REPORT ON THE LEGAL
ENFORCEABILITY OF ALLEGED BREACH
AT 2875 SAVANNAH HIGHWAY
Prepared for Submission to Federal and State Oversight Authorities
Date: September 16, 2025
Prepared for: MOA Signatories (GSA, Clemson University, SHPO, ACHP), DOJ,
Congress, Preservation Stakeholders, and Relevant Oversight Authorities
Prepared by: Independent Analysis Based on Provided Reports and Public Sources
Table of Contents
I. Executive Summary
II. Introduction and Factual Background
III. Timeline of Key Events
IV. Legal and Regulatory Framework
V. Precedent Analysis
VI. Gray & Pape Cultural Resources Study (2015)
VII. Breach and Concealment Analysis
VIII. Effect of the MOA on Findings
IX. Agency and City Evidence
X. Conclusions
XI. Remedies and Enforcement
XII. Recommendations and Anticipated Defenses (Expanded)
XIII. Policy Reform and Legislative Recommendations
XIV. Strengthening Legal and Regulatory Analysis (2024–2025 Context)
XV. Case Law Appendix
XVI. Certification
I. Executive Summary
This comprehensive report consolidates and expands upon analyses of the alleged
material breach of the 2018 Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) governing the
transfer of the former USDA Vegetable Laboratory at 2875 Savannah Highway from
the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) to Clemson University. The MOA was
premised on the approval of demolition by the City of Charleston’s Design Review
Board (DRB), which was denied in January 2021. This denial constituted a failed
condition precedent, collapsing the agreement’s foundation. Clemson concealed this
denial from MOA signatories, allowed the historic structures to deteriorate through
“demolition by neglect,” and colluded with GSA to script official responses,
misleading federal agencies, and Congress.
Evidence from FOIA responses confirms collusion, undermining federal oversight.
The City of Charleston enforced its demolition-by-neglect ordinance in August 2025,
mandating stabilization within 30 days and rehabilitation within one year,
validating the adverse effects of neglect. This is not a procedural loophole but a
violation of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), federal property disposal
laws, and potentially the False Claims Act (FCA). The 2015 Gray & Pape Cultural
Resources Study confirmed the property’s historic significance, proving Clemson’s
awareness prior to concealment.
Key implications include re-engagement of Section 106 review, potential property
reversion, FCA liability, and the need for legislative reforms to prevent transferees
from evading accountability through nondisclosure. Congressional oversight is
recommended due to misrepresentations and evidence of collusion. This report
merges insights from prior analyses, incorporates public sources, and calls for
immediate corrective action to preserve this historic site.
II. Introduction and Factual Background
The property at 2875 Savannah Highway, formerly the U.S. Vegetable Laboratory, is
a historic complex in Charleston County, South Carolina. Established in the early
20th century, it holds significance for agricultural research and architecture, as
documented in the 2015 Gray & Pape Cultural Resources Investigation, which
deemed it eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) due to its
association with USDA advancements and intact structures. A 2017 historic report
by Brittney Tulla, approved by the South Carolina State Historic Preservation Office
(SHPO), further affirmed its value.
In July 2018, the MOA was executed among GSA, Clemson University, SHPO, and the
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) to facilitate the property’s
transfer under Section 106 of the NHPA. The agreement was explicitly conditioned
on DRB approval for demolition, allowing Clemson to redevelop the site. GSA
conveyed the property in April 2019. However, Clemson’s September 2020
demolition permit application was denied by the DRB in January 2021. Clemson
withdrew the application but failed to notify signatories, violating MOA stipulations
for communication and reporting.
From 2021 to 2025, the structures were abandoned, leading to deterioration. In
August 2025, the city enforced its ordinance, requiring immediate stabilization and
a rehabilitation plan. FOIA records reveal Clemson drafted GSA’s responses,
constituting collusion. GSA admitted ignorance of the denial in July 2025, repeating
Clemson’s “repurposing” narrative. ACHP and USDA confirmed they were unaware,
believing the undertaking was complete. Congressional offices, including those of
Rep. Mace, Rep. Clyburn, and Sen. Scott, were misinformed about mitigation
completion.
This concealment prevented re-engagement under Section 106 and subverted the
MOA’s purpose, creating a legal paradox: the MOA assumed demolition, but city law
mandated preservation.
III. Timeline of Key Events
• 2015: Gray & Pape Cultural Resources Study, conducted with Clemson’s
involvement, confirms historic significance and NRHP eligibility.
• July 2017: Brittney Tulla Historic Report finalized and SHPO approved.
• July 24, 2018: MOA executed, premised on demolition approval.
• April 15, 2019: GSA conveys property to Clemson.
• September 17, 2020: Clemson files demolition permit.
• January 2021: DRB denies demolition; Clemson withdraws and fails to notify
signatories.
• 2021–2025: Structures deteriorate via demolition by neglect; photos show
serious decay.
• July 2025: GSA admits ignorance of denial, repeats Clemson-scripted responses.
• August 27, 2025: USDA contractor confirms nondisclosure would have triggered
action.
• August 28, 2025: ACHP confirms unawareness.
• August 29, 2025: City enforces ordinance: stabilization in 30 days, rehab plan in
12 months.
• September 2025: DRB staff confirms concealment and neglect; GSA misinforms
Congress.
IV. Legal and Regulatory Framework
Relevant statutes and regulations include:
• National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), 54 U.S.C. §§ 306108, 306101,
307103:
• Section 106: Requires federal agencies to assess effects on historic
properties before undertakings.
• Section 110: Mandates active preservation of properties under federal
control.
• Section 304: Protects sensitive information but does not excuse
nondisclosure of key facts.
• 36 CFR Part 800: Protection of Historic Properties.
• §§ 800.4–800.5: Identify and assess effects.
• § 800.9: Failure to implement mitigation triggers re-review or enforcement.
• False Statements Act (18 U.S.C. § 1001): Liability for misleading federal
statements.
• False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729–3733):
• § 3729(a)(1)(B): False statements material to claims.
• § 3729(a)(1)(G): Reverse false claims for concealing obligations (e.g.,
reversion).
• Qui tam provisions allow private suits.
• Federal Property Disposal Law (40 U.S.C. § 541 et seq.): Governs surplus
transfers; breaches justify reversion.
• Charleston Ordinance § 21-54: Enforces stabilization (30 days) and
rehabilitation (1 year) for neglected historic sites.
The MOA’s stipulations (I.A–B) tied mitigation to demolition; III & V required
notices and reporting; VI–VIII allowed amendments/termination for failed
conditions.
V. Precedent Analysis
Precedents affirm enforceability:
• Old Post Office, DC: GSA OIG found concealment as federal misconduct.
• Fort Hancock, NJ: Federal re-engagement after failed agreements.
• Courthouse Case: Accountability for concealment in local-federal collaborations.
• Crowley v. GSA (2022): Injunctive relief viable despite expired agreements.
These show that post-mitigation concealment does not eliminate obligations.
VI. Gray & Pape Cultural Resources Study (2015)
The study, conducted for GSA with Clemson’s input, confirmed the property’s
historic significance under NRHP Criteria A (agricultural history) and C
(architecture). It described intact laboratory buildings, greenhouses, and fields from
the 1930s–1950s, recommending mitigation if demolished. This proves Clemson’s
deliberate nondisclosure, not ignorance.
VII. Breach and Concealment Analysis
1. Failed Condition Precedent: DRB denial in January 2021 discharged
obligations.
2. Concealment During Active Term: Occurred while MOA was in force.
3. Violation of Stipulations: Ignored reporting/communication duties.
4. Demolition by Neglect: City enforcement and photos confirm.
5. Collusion with GSA: Clemson scripted responses; misled Congress.
GSA’s July 2025 admission that the MOA was “based solely on demolition” and
unawareness of denial transforms this into material misrepresentation, subverting
Section 106.
VIII. Effect of the MOA on Findings
The MOA’s premise failed, voiding the transfer. Remedies: Breach rescission, Section
106 re-engagement, reversion, FCA liability.
IX. Agency and City Evidence
Exhibits include:
• F: 2018 MOA.
• G: Gray & Pape Study (2015).
• P: Brittney Tulla Report (2017).
• H–R: Emails, permits, photos, enforcement notices, congressional responses.
Supporting documentation is available via public sources.
X. Conclusions
The concealment, coupled with collusion, constitutes a material breach and violation
of law. This failure of accountability warrants:
• Re-engagement of Section 106.
• Declaration of breach and potential reversion.
• FCA litigation.
• Policy reforms for independent disclosures.
XI. Remedies and Enforcement
Explicit Remedies:
• Property reversion under disposal law.
• Monetary damages for neglect-induced losses.
• Injunctive relief to prevent further disposal/demolition.
Jurisdictional Authority:
• Federal District Court (SC): MOA enforcement, injunctive relief, FCA.
• GSA OIG: Investigate collusion.
• ACHP: Section 106 re-engagement.
• City of Charleston BAR: Ordinance enforcement.
• Private Relator: Qui Tam under FCA.
Enforcement Pathways:
• DOJ/GAO review for congressional misrepresentations.
• Contract law: Failed condition precedent renders MOA unenforceable as written.
Anticipating Defenses: Claims of “mitigation complete” are flawed; steps were
conditioned on demolition, which failed amid concealment.
XII. Recommendations and Anticipated Defenses
(Expanded)
Recommended Actions
To ACHP & SHPO:
• Re-open Section 106 review: Advise GSA to re-engage due to new adverse effects
(demolition denial and subsequent neglect).
• Convene a Problem-Resolution Meeting within 15 days under 36 C.F.R. § 800.9.
• Recommend a standstill on property actions until review is complete.
• Coordinate with Charleston BAR deadlines (30-day stabilization; 1-year
rehabilitation) and invite ACHP observer participation.
To GSA (cc: OIG):
• Issue a breach determination: Acknowledge failed condition precedent and
concealment during the MOA’s active term.
• Begin corrective conveyance/reversion analysis under 40 U.S.C. § 541 et seq.
• Refer misstatement and collusion issues to the GSA Office of Inspector General.
• Preserve and produce all Clemson–GSA communications from 2018–2025.
To City of Charleston BAR/Legal:
• Integrate federal enforcement with City deadlines under Ordinance § 21-54.
• Invite ACHP/SHPO participation during compliance monitoring.
• Use BAR enforcement to ensure parallel federal remedies are honored.
To DOJ & GAO:
• Initiate a preliminary inquiry into False Claims Act exposure, including potential
reverse false claims by concealment.
• Review risks of false statements to Congress (2021–2025).
• Issue records preservation orders for all Clemson–GSA–Congress
correspondence.
Broader Remedies
1. Immediate review of Clemson’s nondisclosure by oversight authorities.
2. Formal breach declaration of the 2018 MOA.
3. Property reversion or corrective transfer to a preservation entity.
4. FCA liability evaluation and investigation.
5. Policy reforms: Require independent verification of MOA conditions; mandate
re-engagement for new facts; prohibit delegation to transferees.
Anticipated Defenses & Rebuttals
• Defense: “Mitigation steps are complete; MOA expired.”
Rebuttal: Mitigation was expressly conditioned on demolition approval. The
DRB denial (Jan. 2021) collapsed the MOA’s foundation, and concealment
occurred while the MOA was active. Expiry does not erase a breach.
• Defense: “We intended adaptive reuse.”
Rebuttal: Subjective intent cannot substitute for disclosure. The City’s August
2025 enforcement letter confirms demolition by neglect, the opposite of reuse.
• Defense: “No federal jurisdiction now.”
Rebuttal: Jurisdiction survives for:
• Property reversion under 40 U.S.C. § 541 et seq.
• False Claims Act liability (reverse false claim for concealment).
• Injunctive relief post-expiry, as affirmed in Crowley v. GSA (2022).
XIII. Policy Reform and Legislative
Recommendations
If Section 106 cannot be re-engaged despite contradictions, amend NHPA to:
• Require independent verification.
• Mandate automatic re-review for undermining facts.
• Close loopholes allowing concealment to “run out” MOAs.
Congressional action is essential to prevent recurrence.
XIV. Strengthening Legal and Regulatory
Analysis (2024–2025 Context)
1. Charleston Ordinance § 21-54 (Demolition by Neglect):
The City of Charleston’s Code of Ordinances, Section 21-54, defines ‘demolition
by neglect’ as the willful failure to maintain a structure to the point of
deterioration, decay, or damage. The ordinance authorizes the City’s Board of
Architectural Review to require stabilization within 30 days and rehabilitation
or reuse within one year. Failure to comply may result in fines or forced repair
action. 2008 Clemson University thesis highlighted enforcement weaknesses in
this ordinance. However, the August 2025 enforcement action shows that the
City has recently applied it, demonstrating renewed municipal willingness to
act. This strengthens the argument for closer federal-city coordination in
enforcement.
2. Case Law Developments (2024–2025):
Recent cases and legal opinions provide guidance, even if no exact precedent
matches the facts of this matter:
• Graton Rancheria v. Haaland (2024): Enforced strict Section 106
consultation obligations, confirming that failure to provide notice or adequate
engagement violates federal law.
• Crowley v. GSA (2022): Clarified that injunctive relief remains available
even after agreements expire, establishing precedent for re-engagement when
concealment undermines an MOA.
• False Claims Act Enforcement (2024–2025): DOJ reports and case law
confirm vigorous enforcement of the FCA, including concealment-based
‘reverse false claims.’ In FY 2024, FCA settlements and judgments exceeded
$2.9 billion, demonstrating the viability of FCA pathways for property transfer
concealments.
XV. Case Law Appendix
• Graton Rancheria v. Haaland (2024): Confirmed that failure to notify or
adequately consult under Section 106 violates federal law.
• Crowley v. GSA (2022): Established that injunctive relief may be available
against GSA even after agreements expire.
• DOJ False Claims Act Settlements Report (2024): Demonstrated vigorous FCA
enforcement, with $2.9 billion in recoveries, showing broad applicability of FCA
to concealment-based cases.
XVI. Certification
To the best of available knowledge, this report presents facts and analysis under
federal frameworks. Respectfully submitted on September 16, 2025.
Respectfully submitted,
Chad Husselbee
Prepared: September 16, 2025
OPPOSITION TO DEMOLITION REQUEST
2875 Savannah Highway – Former U.S. Vegetable Laboratory (Office/Laboratory Building,
1936)
Submitted to: City of Charleston Design Review Board
For Consideration at: Monday, January 5, 2026, at 4:30 PM
Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability
Agenda Item: #1 – Demolition Request by Clemson University
Submitted by: Chad Husselbee, Concerned Stakeholder and Advocate for Historic Preservation
Date: December 28, 2025
1. BOARD SUMMARY
This submission opposes demolition of the 1936 Office/Laboratory Building at 2875 Savannah
Highway, a contributing resource in a National Register-eligible historic district associated with
nationally significant USDA agricultural research. SHPO-approved evaluations, including
Clemson’s own commissioned historical report, confirm its integrity, significance, and viability,
directly contradicting the applicant’s claims of lacking unique features or being beyond repair.
The applicant’s structural assessment affirms sound masonry and concrete systems, while City
enforcement actions under Ordinance § 21-54 mandate stabilization and rehabilitation,
confirming feasibility and evidencing intentional demolition by neglect. This neglect, coupled
with concealment of prior DRB denial and collusion with GSA, has been referred to the GSA
Office of Inspector General (OIG) for investigation into the federal conveyance process. Contact
information for the assigned GSA Office of Inspector General investigator can be provided to the
Board upon request. Based on Board criteria, deny the request outright to preserve the status
quo amid ongoing federal scrutiny.
2. INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE OF REVIEW
This rebuttal addresses Clemson’s demolition request for the Office/Laboratory Building at 2875
Savannah Highway. It mirrors the applicant’s packet, responds directly to Board criteria, and
relies on professional cultural resource evaluations (e.g., 2015 Gray & Pape study), City
enforcement actions, Clemson’s own published historical documentation (including their Coastal
REC webpage and the 2020 SHPO-approved historical report prepared for them), and the
investigative report on MOA breaches. Evidence establishes a clear case of intentional
demolition by neglect, violating local and federal preservation laws.
3. FEDERAL REVIEW CONTEXT (PROCEDURAL CONSIDERATION)
The property is subject to ongoing federal scrutiny due to alleged breaches of the 2018 MOA
governing its GSA conveyance to Clemson. The MOA was conditioned on DRB demolition
approval, which was denied in January 2021—a fact Clemson concealed from signatories
(GSA, SHPO, ACHP), leading to misleading statements to federal agencies and Congress. This
concealment, combined with deliberate neglect, constitutes a material breach under NHPA
Section 106 and federal property laws, triggering potential re-engagement, reversion, and
liability. The matter has been referred to GSA OIG for investigation into the process, including
collusion (e.g., Clemson scripting GSA responses). Contact information for the assigned GSA
Office of Inspector General investigator can be provided to the Board upon request. Proceeding
with demolition is premature and inconsistent with prudent preservation; deferral is warranted
pending OIG resolution.
4. HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE OF THE U.S. VEGETABLE LABORATORY
Established in 1936 under the Bankhead-Jones Act as the nation’s—and world’s—first
permanent federal vegetable breeding laboratory (as affirmed on Clemson’s own Coastal REC
webpage: “THE FIRST OF ITS KIND IN THE WORLD”), the facility advanced research in
breeding, pathology, and entomology, producing over 160 vegetable varieties. Professional
evaluations, including the SHPO-approved 2020 historical report prepared for Clemson, confirm
eligibility under National Register Criterion A (1936–1980). The building was central to this
mission, housing core laboratories inseparable from the site’s significance—directly refuting
Clemson’s claim that history is limited to greenhouses and farmland.
5. ARCHITECTURAL INTEGRITY AND CONDITION
The two-story Colonial Revival structure retains integrity of location, design, materials,
workmanship, feeling, and association, as documented in SHPO-approved reports with pre-
vacancy photographs showing intact façades and minimal encroachment. Deterioration results
solely from Clemson’s post-2021 neglect, not inherent defects—evidenced by the 2015 Gray &
Pape study (conducted with Clemson’s input) and 2016 building assessment, both confirming
viability prior to abandonment. This counters Clemson’s portrayal of the building as a “shell with
liabilities,” as their own consultant noted good structural condition in primary elements.
.
6. STRUCTURAL VIABILITY AND REHABILITATION FEASIBILITY
Clemson’s consultant confirms sound brick walls, concrete floors, and interior elements;
deficiencies are confined to systems, roofing, and deferred maintenance—addressable issues.
City enforcement under Ordinance § 21-54 (August 2025) mandates stabilization within 30 days
and rehabilitation within one year, affirming repairability and classifying the deterioration as
intentional demolition by neglect. Precedents (e.g., 2008 Clemson thesis on Charleston’s
ordinance) highlight enforcement viability, inconsistent with demolition. Clemson’s failure to
maintain post-conveyance, despite awareness of significance (from their own reports),
evidences bad faith.
7. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD DEMOLITION CRITERIA ANALYSIS
7.1 Historic, Architectural, and Aesthetic Features
Contrary to Clemson’s claim of no unique features, the 1936 Colonial Revival building
exemplifies rare New Deal-era federal research architecture, central to a National Register-
eligible district. Clemson’s own webpage and 2020 historical report laud it as groundbreaking,
embodying agricultural innovation—demolition would erase this typology, as affirmed in Gray &
Pape and Tulla reports.
7.2 Nature and Character of the Surrounding Area
Demolition would fragment the historic district, diminishing cohesion among contributing
resources (greenhouses, headhouse, landscape), whose value depends on the laboratory. The
active agricultural campus’s character is enhanced, not jeopardized, by preservation—refuting
Clemson’s assertion. Neglect has already harmed the area; approval would reward
noncompliance.
7.3 Historic or Culturally Important Use
For nearly 70 years, the building housed pivotal USDA research in pathology, horticulture, and
entomology, integral to the site’s mission—not peripheral, as Clemson claims. Evaluations (e.g.,
2020 report prepared for Clemson) affirm its primary role in national advancements, with history
tied directly to this structure.
7.4 Importance to the City
The site embodies Charleston’s agricultural, scientific, and educational heritage, enabling
interpretation (e.g., historic marker). Preservation offers public benefits; demolition erodes civic
identity. Clemson’s mitigation claims are undermined by MOA breach and neglect—City policy
favors rehabilitation.
8. PRIOR CITY DETERMINATIONS AND ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
City records document prior demolition denial (January 2021) due to merit and significance.
August 2025 enforcement requires immediate action, confirming reuse feasibility and City’s
preservation commitment—directly countering Clemson’s neglect-based arguments.
9. CONCLUSION AND REQUESTED ACTION
Under Board criteria, the building merits protection. Evidence of intentional neglect,
concealment, and federal breaches defeats Clemson’s points. DENY the request, or DEFER
pending GSA OIG investigation, stabilization, rehabilitation, and federal resolution.
10. INCORPORATION BY REFERENCE AND EXHIBITS
Incorporation by Reference: The SHPO-approved “Former USDA Vegetable Lab – Historical
Report – BVL – FINAL & SHPO APPROVED” (2020, prepared for Clemson), including
appendices; Clemson’s Coastal REC webpage history; 2015 Gray & Pape study; and the
Investigative Report on MOA Breaches (September 2025).
Exhibits (submitted separately): ● Exhibit A – SHPO-Approved Historical Report (Full). ● Exhibit
B – Clemson Webpage History PDF. ● Exhibit C – Investigative Report on Breaches. ● Exhibit
D – City Enforcement Records.
COASTAL RESEARCH &EDUCATION CENTER
(https://www.clemson.edu/) CAFLS (/cafls/index.html) Coastal Research & Education Center (/cafls/coastal/index.html)
About Us
/ / /
“THE FIRST OF ITS KIND IN THEWORLD”From the onset of World War I and through the 1920s, the role of American farmers
grew significantly. With much of Europe’s agricultural workforce called to war and
farmlands transformed into battlefields, Europe lost much of its farm production
during and after the war, creating an unprecedented increased demand in crop
production across the Atlantic.
As Europe recovered in the 1920s, American farmers were left with significant
inventory, resulting in falling prices for produce that only continued with the collapse
of the stock market in 1929. One of the responses by Congress was the Bankhead-
Jones Act of 1935 – an effort to help farmers efficiently grow sustainable and durable
crops for widespread distribution.
The Bankhead-Jones Act called for the U.S. Department of Agriculture to establish
nine research laboratories in major agricultural regions to “meet the necessity for
creating plants … adapted to growth under certain climatic conditions and soils. ”
Each research station was designed to focus on the agricultural concerns of its
respective region to collectively bolster America’s farming industry and contribute to
national agricultural research and innovation.
USDA Vegetable Lab building in 1945
History: USDA Vegetable Lab
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 1 of 6
The USDA vegetable breeding laboratory in Charleston County, South Carolina was
the first laboratory established under this act. In February of 1936, the USDA
purchased a 452-acre former phosphate mining property along Savannah Highway in
Charleston for the future U.S. Vegetable Breeding Laboratory’s experimental fields. A
few months later, a 3.2-acre parcel across the street previously owned by the
Agricultural Society of the United States was purchased for the laboratory’s buildings
from Charleston County.
The facility consisted of a small two-story, Colonial Revival-style structure with
laboratories for pathology, horticulture and entomology where scientists
experimented on the production of beans, corn, melons and cabbage to strengthen
the truck farming industry after the collapse of the rice and Sea Island cotton
industry in the Low Country.
Sprawling high ground with surrounding marsh, the property was also selected for its
representation of a typical Southeastern truck-farming area where scientists could
test vegetables and plants using a wide variety of soils, rainfall and temperatures that
existed throughout the southeast. These conditions included frost, extreme heat and
extended drought.The location also represented the South’s increasing role in
American truck farming, as the accessibility to larger farming tracts and the longer
growing seasons enabled the region to sustain cultivation when the northern climate
became unfit for growing. Northern markets, consisting of approximately 40 million
people, relied on the supply of fresh vegetables from Southern farmers.
The adjacent Truck Experiment Station, a state-run facility known today as Clemson’s
Coastal Research and Education Center, and the USDA federal complex were not
associated formally but would work together for decades to create more durable,
healthy and vibrant crops for national distribution.
Immediately after the land purchases in Charleston, Dr. E.C. Auchter from the USDA
joined members of independent and state-run plant-breeding stations from across
the Southeastern states for a two-day conference at the Francis Marion Hotel in
downtown Charleston to identify the most pressing issues to be addressed in the new
laboratory. The conference was the nation’s first biennial vegetable breeding
conference, which would continue in Charleston well into the late twentieth century.
The groundbreaking for the complex began the second week of March in 1936. The
proposed complex would center around a main laboratory structure estimated at
$30,000 and also include an auxiliary house with two greenhouse wings, storage
buildings and workers’ cottages.
The First ExperimentsBy the summer of 1936, an acre was dedicated to creating disease-resistant
tomatoes, ear-worm resistant corn and a half-acre for 35 varieties of zinnias.
Additional plants were harvested for later experiments, including cauliflower,
Southeastern territory represented by
the U.S. Vegetable Breeding Laboratory
in Charleston County (USDA, 1945)
1940s photograph showing USDA
laboratory complex (right) and Truck
Experiment Station (left) (USDA, 1945)
1950 photograph of Peggy Sullivan on
the front steps of Building 1
(USDA,1950)
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 2 of 6
cabbage, Brussels sprouts, collards, watermelon and radishes. The staff also
received 220 pounds of onion bulbs from the University of California to develop
onions resistant to mildew.
With the nearly 50 acres already cultivated for the laboratory’s first experiments,
local contracting firm Dawson Engineering was hired in the summer of 1936 to
construct the laboratory and accompanying structures. During the next six months,
Dawson Engineering constructed the multiple building complex that would become
the first USDA research facility to collectively have a laboratory, greenhouse and
experimental fields. As Dawson Engineering served as the complex’s construction
team, the laboratory and its auxiliary buildings were most likely designed by the
USDA’s architects.
By the time of the laboratory’s completion in early 1937, new crops of snap peas,
cabbage, watermelons, tomatoes and sweet corn were ready for testing. In addition
to these crops, the U.S. Division of Plant Exploration and Introduction sent several
new and “valuable and economic and ornamental plants showing promise of
usefulness” from foreign countries to the “new vegetable breeding project” in
Charleston for analysis.
Margaret “Peggy” Kanapaux Sullivan, a Charleston native with a biology and English
degree from the College of Charleston, served as a biochemist on the property until
1942, at which time she left for active duty as part of the WAVES (Women Accepted
for Voluntary Emergency Service). During her tenure at the laboratory, Sullivan
worked with other property scientists to create “winter hardy” cabbage, high-quality
snap peas, disease-resistant tomatoes and durable watermelons, which would take
years to master. Sullivan would later return after the war.
In 1938, Illinois horticulturist Charles Frederick Andrus joined Dr. Wade, Dr. Poole
and Sullivan as part of the laboratory’s staff and was tasked with further studying
diseases in beans, watermelons, tomatoes and cabbage. This marked the beginning
of Andrus’ 30-year employment at the laboratory, during which time he ultimately
would create several new breeds of watermelon and tomatoes.
The staff continued to breed severe weather and bacteria-resistant snap beans,
experimented with maintaining quality in flavor and durability through drying and
preserving seeds and even tested fertilizers and irrigation systems. They worked to
create more colorful and sweeter watermelon, bigger potatoes and redder tomatoes.
By 1943, Louisiana scientist Dr. James E. Welch was hired to test quick freezing and
dehydration qualities of crops to improve the “shipability” and preservation of
vegetables during a time of vast food rationing. Within the next year, Charleston's
Evening Post reported that the laboratory mastered the flavor-saving, quick-freeze
method and was prepared to help provide “more and better food” to Americans. By
1955 April 15,The Daily Times,
Salisbury, Maryland; (right) 1955 July
21,The Knoxville Journal, Knoxville, TN
1954 announcement for the Charleston
Gray Watermelon(USDA, 1954)
Building 1 North (primary) facade
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 3 of 6
1945 the staff consisted of scientists ranging in expertise from genetics, cytology,
pathology, physiology and chemistry in horticulture, vegetable composition and
related fields.
In the post-war period, the staff worked on creating more disease-resistant snap peas
with “more color,” cabbage with higher vitamin content and “greater penetration of
green color into the head,” darker green peas with a “more attractive appearance,”
larger ears of corn with greater resistance to earworm, larger tomatoes with “high
color” and resistance to cracking and watermelons with a “very attractive
appearance. ”
“A more prosperous South, a better-fedNorth”In 1949 the laboratory finalized a new watermelon breed called the Congo, which
was bred from what the Miami News called “a vastly superior specimen” from
Africa and made to have a sweeter taste and a tough rind for shipping. After its first
shipments, the Congo, often referred to as “the king of all watermelons,” was widely
distributed and replaced the popular Garrison and the Cannonball varieties.
As the 1950s dawned the Charlotte Observer reported that Charleston’s vegetable
breeding led to “a more prosperous South and a better-fed North,” crediting the
Congo watermelon and the Contender, a “fresh market” snap pea with great
tolerance to heat and drought, as examples of the national advances in vegetable
farming that could be traced to the complex.
Within the next three years, the laboratory introduced the Bush snap bean, followed
by the Homestead tomato and the Fairfax watermelon. By 1954, the Charleston Grey
(or Gray) Watermelon was introduced, a worldwide commodity for which Dr. Andrus
received the USDA Superior Service Award and was elected into the American
Society of Horticulture Hall of Fame in 2002.
Although Hurricane Gracie and the subsequent mildew destroyed much of the
cabbage crop in 1959, Dr. James C. Hoffman successfully introduced a new variety of
snap beans to the American farmer in 1960 called the Extender. The new bean
became known for its wide adaptability to climates.
Amidst persistent corn, tomato, cabbage and bean farming and testing, advances in
melons continued throughout the next decade. After a sixteen-year trial, the
Summerfield watermelon was released in 1969 and was a cross between the Fairfax
and the Blackstone. It was designed for superior wilt resistance, its large size and
high-quality flesh.
The laboratory produced new types of turnips and collards resistant to common
disease and cold with the adjacent Clemson University Truck Experiment Station in
1977 after a 15-year developmental stage and also started a new sweet potato
Building 2 Overview of greenhouse
complex, looking south
Building 1 and Building 2 - Facing
Southeast
Building 1 South Elevation - Facing
North
The text in this website is adapted
from U.S. Vegetable Breeding
Laboratory Former U.S. Department of
Agriculture (USDA) Southeastern
Vegetable Breeding Laboratory, A
History
(https://clemson.box.com/s/8qsmkvkz3xsaicm0n12bbavjuw3rc48w
and edited for clarity.
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 4 of 6
breeding program.
In 1980, a one-story warehouse was added to the complex to accommodate new
research that focused on weed science.
The laboratory often housed education and research groups to demonstrate the
experiments on ongoing research. In addition to local agricultural societies and
national scientists, students Folbert Bronsema and Sjaan VanEghmaal from the
University of Wageningen in Netherlands, for example, spent five months at the
laboratory in 1987 to learn how to breed flowers for their return to Holland. A chemist
from India and another Dutch student were also scheduled to spend months training
at the facility that year.
In 1990, USDA received $5 million to begin work on a new shared laboratory with the
Clemson Truck Experiment Station, known by the 1980s as the Coastal Research and
Education Center, yet construction of a new, 54,000 square foot, $20.5 million
facility did not begin until in 1999. In the meantime, the laboratory produced the
Charleston Greenpack, a pinkeye-type southern pea with significant field resistance
to disease and a vibrant green color, after a seven-year trial. The Charleston Belle, a
disease-resistant bell pepper, was also released in 1997.
By 2003, the new research facility was completed across the street with office space
for twenty scientists from both USDA and Clemson laboratories. Building 1 and
Building 2 were abandoned at this time and no new work has taken place on the site
since. At the former complex’s closure, the USDA’s Agricultural Research Service
reported that the laboratory developed and released more than 160 vegetable
varieties since its opening. Notables included the Charleston Gray, Congo,
Garrisonian, Graybelle, Fairfax, and Summerfield watermelons, Planters Jumbo and
Mainstream muskmelons, Charleston Green pack southern peas, Wade, Bonus,
Extender, and Provider snap bean, Homestead tomato, Charleston Hot pepper, and
Charleston Belle bell pepper.
In 2015, the original laboratory complex was deemed eligible for listing on the
National Register of Historic Places under Criterion A (Historic Events) for its national
associations with the USDA’s 1930s expansion of its research capabilities to assist
farmers in efficiency by producing goods across the country, developing new breeds
more adaptable to the region through the creation of pest-resistant strains that
allowed farmers to increase crop yields, and for its regional association with the
improvement of truck-farming produce in the southeast region of the United States
from 1936 through 1980.
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 5 of 6
Coastal Research and Education CenterCopyright © 2025 Clemson University
Coastal Research and Education Center | 2700 Savannah Hwy, Charleston, SC 29414
(843) 402-5399 (tel:(843) 4025399) | Email Us (mailto:rccstl@clemson.edu) | Page Update
Request (https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/communications/update-request.html)
https://www.clemson.edu/cafls/coastal/about/index.html 12/26/25, 8:01 PM
Page 6 of 6
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.