RecordWell Data

_01052026-10591

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charleston Design Review Board Minutes January 5th , 202 6 4:30 p.m . A meeting of the Design Review Board was held at 4: 30 p.m. on Monday , January 5 , 202 6 , at 2 George Street and adjourned at 8:21 p.m. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media. Board members present : Eri n Stevens, Chair , William “Bill ” Eubanks, Adriana Carson, Ashley Jackrel , Ben Whitener, Lucas Boyd, and Stephanie Tillerson (joined at 4:41 p.m.) Staff members present : David Meeks , Brad Thomas, and Patrick Carlson, recording Chair called the meeting to order at 4: 30 p.m., introduced Board members and Staff, and explained protocol for the meeting. Applications The following applications were considered: (NOTE: Unless otherwise remarked, Chair voted all items, Copy of complete staff comments/recommendations are attached. Copies of all recusals/letters/emails/petitions mentioned during this meeting are on file.) 1. 2875 Savannah Hwy. – TMS # 3 08-00-00-001 | DR B202 5-0002 92 Requestin g approval for the demolition of an office/laboratory building from the 1930s, a former USDA building. Owner : Clemson University Applicant : Mosley /Aaron Bowman Nei ghborhood/Area: West Ashley Presenter: Aaron Bowman and Craig Bennett, Jr. Project Detail: Mr. Bowman said the main research office /laboratory building was originally constructed in 1936. It was primarily used for office space and research projects that were eventually developed in the adjacent greenhouses and fields. He said it was a concrete structure with terracotta tile walls with multiple ceiling sections in varying states of failure. The building was likely designed by an internal United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) team and was set within a parcel of land surrounded by property owned by Clemson University. The facility was used by the USDA for over six decades to conduct agricultural research using state and federal resources. The new facility center was constructed in 1999 on the north side of Savannah Highway and USDA relocated to that property in 2003. Clemson began negotiations to acquire the property between 2010 and 2014. The General Services Administration (GSA) began the process of disposing of the site in 2015 and initiated a Cultural Resources investigation. That report identified the district as eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places because of the farming and research that had been conducted on the site. However, Mr. Bowman said the report did not mention the physical structures as part of that cultural significance and said the story focused on the farming and research work that had been taking place since the 1930s. In 2018, Clemson renewed its efforts to acquire the property and developed a memorandum of agreement to mitigate adverse impacts to the site, including a comprehensive report documenting the history of the site, develop a public website displaying the findings from that report, and place a historic marker on the property. These efforts were completed in 2020, and the team wa s now requesting demolition at the local level. Mr. Bennett said he was a structural engineer and taught at Clemson. He said the roof was in poor condition with collapsing dormers and a missing roof membrane that had worsened the state of the interior spaces. He said the age of the concrete and foundation w ere nearing the end of its lifespan and recommended demolition . Mr. Bowman said the story was about the farming that took place on the site and the building was merely a witness to that history and not the author of the narrative in question. Bill asked if Clemson University had conducted a feasibility study on the adaptive reuse of the building. The applicant team said they were not aware of any study. Ashley asked for clarification concerning the National Register of Historic Places classification. Mr. Bowman said the area was eligible for listing as a historic district not just the building or specific site. Ashley asked if the dormers were functional. Mr. Bowman said the dormers opened into the attic space. Stephanie asked if the building was in imminent danger. Mr. Bennett said if the goal was preservation, then the entire roof would need to be demolished and most of the interior surfaces would need to be redone. Public Comment: Erin said the DRB received 51 online comments that were all in opposition to the project and had been distributed to the board prior to the meeting. Lisa Jones said she was the Director of Advocacy for the Historic Charleston Foundation. She said the building was an important part of regional and national history, suppor ted the City ’s past order for Clemson to secure the structure and craft a preservation plan , and asked the City to add the property to the landmark overlay list . Anna-Catherine Alexander said she worked with the Preservation Society of Charleston and that the building had endured decades of deferred maintenance-especially since 2019. She asked the board to thwart the demolition efforts and asked Clemson University to lead by example through adaptive reuse. Ruth Miller said she gave tours throughout downtown Charleston and that the most memorable artifacts of any history included the buildings. She envisioned a museum showcasing the labs and research conducted throughout the building ’s history and asked the DRB to help preserve the story of the site and deny the request. Donna Jacobs said Clemson should consider its origins as an agricultural school when they look at the site and she did not believe that the building could not be brought up to standard. She said West Ashley was worthy of large-scale preservation efforts and asked the Clemson team to utilize its renowned engineering and preservation teams to accomplish this task. Charlie Smith said the building represented important context that should not be lost. West Ashley developed differently compared to the downtown peninsula and some of that development came from the work that was conducted on the site in question. Dr. Mark Farnham said he was a resident of West Ashley and spent the first 13 years of his career with the US Vegetable Laboratory working at the building and during that time never heard that the building was considered historically significant or worthy of rehabilitation. He said it had outlived its useful purpose and thought it should be taken down. Justin F erira said he served on the West Ashley Revitalization Commission and has spoken about restoring buildings in the past. He said the DRB cannot consider self-created deterioration as grounds for demolition and Clemson needed to listen to local zoning rules. Thomas Legare said his family owned Legare Farms on John ’s Island and had utilized the agricultural research conducted at the property in question to assist with growing crops. He said he respected the history of the area, but it was time to take down the building. He said he spoke on behalf of the president of the Charleston County Farm Bureau and said that organization supported the demolition. Staff Recommendation : Denial of demolition Board Comments/Action: Mr. Bowman said the building was vacant for some years and was in an advanced state of deterioration before Clemson acquired it. He said there had been no attempt to circumvent the systems of consideration, but when Clemson acquired the property, the intent was to demolish the building. He said the applicant team believed the story of the site had to do with the land and not the building and asked the DRB to approve demolition. Ashley said she did not tie the specific building to the ultimate significance of the site, especially when they were only talking about saving a foundation and some walls. Lucas said the building was not the story of the site, but it contributed to the story which provided some significance beyond its architectural and aesthetic features. Bill said aft er the City told Clemson that they would not support demolition in 2019, Clemson continued to let the building decline intentionally. Lucas said he did not find the structural report to support the applicant ’s case because the City had been involved in restoring far more deteriorated buildings in the past. He also said it was considered an important component of the visual gateway for the area and thought by these factors it was appropriate to support denial of the demolition. MOTION : Denial of demolition and a request to provide a restoration plan to the DRB by 8/29/26 MADE BY : WE SECOND : AC VOTE : FOR 4 AGAINST 2 Ben Whitener is recused. Ashley and Stephanie voted nay. 2. 725 Wappoo Rd. – TMS # 3 50-01-00-078 | DRB2025-0002 93 Requesting approval for the demolition of a small outbuilding on the school campus and older than 50 years of age. Owner : C harleston Co. School District Applicant : Tony Giuliani Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley Presenter: Tony Giuliani Project Detail: Mr. Giuliani said the building was built in the late 1950s to be used as an office for District 10 of the school system. It was still being used as an office through the end of January 2026, but they would be moving to another location. The applicant had ordered an asbestos report and found it in the flooring and around the windows in addition to lead paint. Upon further evaluation, it was concluded that the building was too small to be renovated into anything useful and requested demolition so they could improve the entry area for the affiliated school campus. Public Comment : Anna-Catherine Alexander said she worked with the Preservation Society of Charleston . She said the building was an example of mid-century architecture that was important to the development of West Ashley and asked the DRB to consider utilizing the building for the school in some way. Staff Recommendation : Denial of demolition Board Comments/Action: Mr. Giuliani said it would cost more to renovate the building compared to removal and there were plenty of other mid-century architecture styled school buildings in the region . Ben said he agreed with the applicant and did not think the building contributed to the adjacent street context. MOTION : Approve of demolition MADE BY: ST SECOND : BW VOTE : FOR 7 AGAINST 0 3. 2274 C le ments Ferry Rd. – TMS # 267-00-00-148 | DRB2025-000 251 Requesting Owner : Holly McAlhany Applicant : Holly McAlhany Neighborhood/Area: Cainhoy Presenter: Holly McAlhany and Todd Lucas on phone Project Detail: Lucas asked if there would be a potential encroachment into a window opening from the roof membrane on the southeast elevation. Mr. Lucas said if there was an intersection that had to be adjusted, they would be able to do so because the slope was only measured at a quarter of an inch. Public Comment: None Staff Recommendation : Conceptual approval Board Comments/Action: Bill said they could considerably simplify the landscape plan and utilize more massing to create a more effective visual. Erin said she would appreciate more detail about the anticipated vine plantings. Ben said they should reconsider the bracket and cornice features as well as study the opportunity to incorporate recesses and material changes along the main façade to create more interesting movements. MOTION : Conceptual approval with staff comments 1-7, and board comments: 1. Simplify landscape p lan 2. Study the cornice, brackets , and material intersections 3. Study materiality and consider an alternate to thin brick 4. Study and introduce plane changes in all elevations MADE BY : BW SECOND : WE VOTE : FOR 7 AGAINST 0 4. 2275 Henry Tecklenburg Dr. – TMS # 3 09-00-00-055 | DRB2025-0002 79 Requesting preliminary approval for a youth learning center which includes a learning center building, a maintenance building, and a 9-hole youth golf course Owner : Essex Farms A Partnership Applicant : LS3P Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley Presenter: Evan McElrath , John Winters Project Detail: Mr. Winters said they considered the previous DRB requests and had identified 13 native trees that could be saved and provided horizontal slat screening to cover an additional mechanical unit. Mr. McElrath said the floor plan and overall massing of the building had changed since conceptual approval; however, the elevations remained the same. Public Comment: Austin Doyle said he represented himself and his neighbors in the HOA at the nearby Marshside Towns at Carolina Bay . He said they loved the idea of a youth center and learning facility in the community but thought it could be placed in a better location. He said it was located on an accident-prone stretch of road and thought it would create additional unsafe traffic conditions. Staff Recommendation : Preliminary approval Board Comments/Action: Ben said to continue to keep the design simple if they were interested in adding railings. He said to monitor the height of the roof to ensure that the mechanical unit was shielded from the ground level. MOTION : Preliminary approval with staff comments 1-2, and final review by staff MADE BY : BW SECOND : WE VOTE : FOR 7 AGAINST 0 5. 350 Grand Oaks Blvd. – TMS # 3 01-00-00-052 | DRB2025-0002 94 Requesting conceptual approval for a multi-family development with 6 buildings with 380 units and 36 townhouses, some separate garages and a clubhouse Owner : Bees Resources LP Applicant : Middleburg Communities Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley MOTION : Courtesy review MADE BY : BW SECOND : AJ VOTE : FOR 7 AGAINST 0 Public Comment: Erin said that the DRB received 81 online comments that covered a variety of topics but were mostly against the proposed project. Dr. Frank Ricker said he lived in Grand Oaks and was concerned about the growing number of large buildings that were being built around the community by developers. Charlie Stricklin said he thought the proposed design was not attractive and did not match the surrounding community. Betsy Rice said the proposed development needed more design work to look appropriate and help blend with the existing community. 6. East corner of West Ashley Cir. and Glenn McConnell Pkwy – TMS # 3 05-08-00-060 | DRB2025-0002 91 Requesting conceptual approval for a new City of Charleston Fire operations/training complex Owner : City of Charleston Capital Projects Applicant : Billy Connell Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley Presenter: Chase Anderson, Billy Connell Project Detail: Mr. Anderson said he was a Senior Construction Project Manager for the City and had been working with the fire department and several outside firms for over a year to create a complete fire department headquarters and operations center in West Ashley. The center would provide space for the fire training division, equipment storage, fleet services, and administrative work. Mr. Connell said they had several stormwater requirements and Dominion Energy easements to work around but they believed they had come up with a functional plan that supported the fire department ’s needs. He said the fire training building would be a three-story building that would house indoor training and administrative spaces. The outdoor training grounds and classroom spaces would be located behind the training building and next to the area for fleet maintenance and technical service building, which would primarily be a warehouse that supported all the fire stations throughout the City . He said they considered the existing vernacular and historic precedence to inspire the design for the proposed training building and thought using bricks with glass, to help break up the massing, was an appropriate set of primary materials. Erin asked what materials would be used to construct the perimeter fence. Mr. Connell said they were not sure, but the goal was to create something more ornamental. Adriana asked if the hatched sections of the site plan sketch would be used for landscaping. Mr. Connell said it was intended to define concrete spaces for maneuvering larger vehicles. Public Comment: None Staff Recommendation : Conceptual approval Board Comments/Action: Ben said the training building was too similar to peninsular fire stations and reflected an architectural style that did not fit with the surrounding context in West Ashley. Bill said he believed that civic buildings needed to be good expressions of architecture that reflected their community and thought that the proposal was not a good fit for that area. Lucas said he thought it was an excellent building and was located appropriately for future development and presented a proper civic face to the public. MOTION : Deferral to restudy the architectural direction of the fire training building MADE BY: BW SECOND : ST VOTE : FOR 3 AGAINST 4 MOTION: Conceptual approval for site and Technical Services building with board comment: 1. Study architectural direction of fire operations/training building MADE BY: BW SECOND : ST VOTE : FOR 5 AGAINST 1 Lucas abstained. 7. 3688 Angel Oak Rd. – TMS # 279-00-00-665 | DRB2025-000247 Requesting preliminary approval for a new 1-story visitor ’s center/restroom building at the Angel Oak Preserve. Also included are trails, playground, enhanced landscape, and new parking lot Owner : Low Country Land Trust/Samanatha Siegel Applicant : Liollio Architects/Jay White Neighborhood/Area: Johns Island MOTION : Preliminary approval with final to go to staff MADE BY: BW SECOND : ST VOTE : FOR 7 AGAINST 0 Minutes 1. Approval of minutes from the 12/ 1 /25 meeting MOTION: Approval of minutes MADE BY: WE SECOND : ST VOTE : FOR 6 AGAINST 0 Ashley abstained. There being no further bus iness, t he meeting adjourned at 8:21 p.m. Patrick Carlson Clerk of Council ’s Office

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.