RecordWell Data

Historic Preservation Review Committee Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Review Committee · meeting of Oct 6, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Historic Preservation Review Committee Meeting Monday, October 06, 2025 at 4:00 PM Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC AGENDA I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. PUBLIC COMMENT IV. OLD BUSINESS V. NEW BUSINESS 1. 2 Blue Crab Street (Lot 52): A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and a 2-story attached carriage house at 2 Blue Crab Street, Lot 52. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). (COFA-09-25-019925)(Staff - Charlotte Moore) 2. 4 Blue Crab Street (Lot 51): A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and an attached carriage house at 4 Blue Crab Street, Lot 51. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). (COFA- 09-25-019927) (Staff - Charlotte Moore) 3. 6 Blue Crab Street (Lot 50): A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and a 2-story attached carriage house at 6 Blue Crab Street, Lot 50. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). (COFA-09-25-019928) (Staff - Charlotte Moore) 4. 8 Blue Crab Street (Lot 49): A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and a 2-story attached carriage house at 8 Blue Crab Street, Lot 49. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in Page 1 Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Review Committee Meeting Agenda October 06, 2025 the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). (COFA-09-25-019929) (Staff - Charlotte Moore) VI. DISCUSSION VII. ADJOURNMENT NEXT MEETING DATE: Monday, October 13, 2025 “FOIA Compliance – Public notification of this meeting has been published and posted in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the Town of Bluffton policies.” In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Bluffton will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. The Town of Bluffton Council Chambers are ADA compatible. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Bluffton ADA Coordinator at 843.706.4500 or adacoordinator@townofbluffton.com as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Executive Session – The public body may vote to go into executive session for any item identified for action on the agenda. *Please note that each member of the public may speak at one public comment session and a form must be filled out and given to the Town Clerk. To submit a public comment online, please click here: https://www.townofbluffton.sc.gov/FormCenter/Town-15/Public-Comment-60 Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per speaker. Page 2 PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS FOR COFA-09-25-019925 Town of Bluffton Department of Growth Management 20 Bridge Street P.O. Box 386 Bluffton, South Carolina 29910 Telephone 843-706-4522 OLD TOWN Plan Type: Apply Date: Plan Status: Plan Address: 2 Blue Crab Street BLUFFTON, SC 29910 Historic District Hold 09/05/2025 Plan PIN #:Case Manager: R610 039 000 1232 0000Charlotte Moore Plan Description: A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and an attached carriage house at 2 Blue Crab Street. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). STATUS (09.24.2025): Concept Plan scheduled for October 13, 2025 HPRC meeting. Staff Review (HD) Submission #: 1 Recieved: 09/05/2025 Completed: 10/05/2025 Reviewing Dept. Complete Date StatusReviewer Approved with Conditions10/05/2025Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewer Review Matthew Michaels Comments: Comments may be provided at time of building permit review. Approved with Conditions10/05/2025Growth Management Dept Review (HD) Charlotte Moore Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 1 of 3Page 3 Section V. Item # 1. 1. Ownership/Applicant Authorization: The owner is shown as Pat Mason on the application, but Beaufort County records show Blue Crab Bluffton LLC. Update the application to show the correct property owner and provide written and signed authorization that William Court is serving as the agent/applicant. 2. Setbacks: Show the front and rear yard setback on the Composite Site Plan and the individual Site Plan. 3. Building Type: “Single Family Residential” is shown as the proposed building type, which is not a building type per the Unified Development Ordinance. Identify the building type, which must be one that is permitted in the NG-HD District (UDO Sec.5.15.5.C.). The specific building types established by district for the Old Town Bluffton are intended to “perpetuate the character that makes Bluffton distinctive” (UDO Sec. 5.15.1.C.). If an Additional Building Type is selected, identify why. 4. Carriage House / Square Footage: As Old Town Bluffton is regulated by a form-based development code, the garage/bonus room is a carriage house and must comply with the carriage house building-type requirements of UDO Sec. 5.15.8.F. An attached carriage house “must be clearly incidental to…and distinguished from the principal building form.” Provide the individual square footage (footprint and total) for both the main structure and the carriage house. The carriage house is an ancillary structure, and it should be better differentiated from the main structure. Related to square footage, explain why the “storage room” on the second floor of the main structure is unconditioned. 5. Materials/Dimensions/Operations: In Section 5 of the application (Materials), for each element, provide the required materials, dimensions and operations. This information must also be shown on the architectural plans and be consistent. Some materials are not permitted per the UDO, including boral, powder-coated aluminum and composite. Your narrative, which is required with the Final Plan submission, must provide reasoning why these alternative materials are proposed and how they are the same or better in appearance and performance as permitted materials. 6. Photos: Photos were not provided as required for a Concept Plan Review (COFA Application). 7. On-street Parking: At the pre-application meeting, we discussed removal of the proposed on-street parking spaces. Was the plan not updated, or is it the intent to provide them? 8. Screening Wall: A brick wall is shown on the east side of the house, but details are not provided. If the wall extends across property lines, an easement may be necessary that also identifies the party/parties responsible for maintenance. It appears that the wall exceeds the permitted height in the front yard; per UDO Sec. 5.15.6.K., wall height cannot exceed 42 inches and posts can be taller. Is the wall intended to serve as screen for the service yard? Consider moving the service yard farther into the property or in the rear. 9. Foundation Height: The main structure foundation is 2’-4”. UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.1.c. requires residential structure to have a “first finished floor height raised a minimum of three (3) feet above average adjacent sidewalk grade.” 10. Roofline: The left elevation, which will be visible from Wild Spartina, shows a variety of rooflines that is inconsistent with UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F., which states that “[r]ooflines shall be simple [and] correspond to the major massing of the building;…complicated rooflines are to be avoided.” 11. Double Porch Detail: Show the interior elevations of the porch that are not visible. 12. Windows: Fixed windows are not permitted as shown on the right ground floor elevation. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.I.3.b. Consider changing this window to match the adjacent dining and kitchen windows. 13. Shutters: Some windows that can accept shutters do not have them. 14. Gutters: Gutters are indicated on the application but not shown. 15. Second Concept Plan Review: Given the number of comments, a second Concept Plan review will be required. 16. Final Submission: At the time of Final Plan submission, provide a landscape plan showing foundation plantings and 75% tree canopy coverage at maturity (UDO Sec. 5.3.) and architectural details of the railings and balusters, door and window schedules, floor sections, corner board/pilaster trim detail and sections through the eave and wall depicting the material and dimensions (Applications Manual). A response to all Concept Plan comments must be provided. Approved with Conditions10/05/2025HPRC Review Charlotte Moore Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 2 of 3Page 4 Section V. Item # 1. 1. This is the same model home four times in a row with very slight roof form differences and a nominal difference in siding application. The chimney is in two different locations, but it is prominently in the same location twice. All have the exact same porch including the front door – window – bedroom door arrangement. Each home should take on a more unique character to provide variety on the streetscape. Use the porch detailing to further separate these homes. Vary column spacing, column design, handrails, door design, fenestration, etc. to create variety along the streetscape. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.3.a.: “Buildings shall incorporate interruptions and variety into the wall plane to create interest and variety in the streetscape while still maintaining a consistent architectural style and connection to its surroundings. Examples include but are not limited to offsets, recessed entrances, arcades, awnings and canopies, bay windows, roof overhangs, expression lines, shadow lines, porches and balconies.” 2. Modify the front porch column spacing to comply with UDO 5.15.6.H.1.a: “Columns and porch posts shall be spaced no farther apart than they are tall as measured from the centerlines of the columns (“o.c”).” 3. The dormers on the front elevation lack sufficient scale. They are too widespread, which creates an uncomfortable, unfinished appearance. Restudy the spacing of these dormers in conjunction with the columns. Consider three dormers with a tighter relationship or a single larger dormer. Vary the design from 6 Blue Crab. 4. The window in the dormer on the left carriage house elevation appears to go into the roof. 5. The chimney floating in the middle of the front roof forms is uncomfortable and lacks intention. Flip the chimney to the side property line or provide alternate venting solutions for the fireplace. 6. Consider folding shutters on the left side ground floor elevation for the two outer shutters to avoid an inconsistent appearance with other shutters on the same elevation. 7. Consider adding gable vents on front and right elevations; the other two elevations have windows in those areas to help with that empty space. 8. Review the window muntin designs for consistency. There is a mix of 4-lite and 6-lite windows that do not relate well to each other. 9. UDO 5.15.8.F “An attached [carriage house] structure must be clearly incidental to, smaller than, and distinguished from the principal building form.” The garage element is not distinguished from the principal building form. Redesign the carriage house to provide definition between these two forms that is more than just “glueing” the garage onto the rear of the house. The relationship of the carriage house and porch is haphazard. It does not appear consideration was given to how these two forms interact. Approved with Conditions09/30/2025Watershed Management Review Samantha Crotty Comments: 1. Comments may be provided at time of building permit/stormwater permit submittal. Approved09/16/2025Transportation Department Review - HD Mark Maxwell Comments: No comments Plan Review Case Notes: 10/06/2025 Page 3 of 3Page 5 Section V. Item # 1. PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS FOR COFA-09-25-019927 Town of Bluffton Department of Growth Management 20 Bridge Street P.O. Box 386 Bluffton, South Carolina 29910 Telephone 843-706-4522 OLD TOWN Plan Type: Apply Date: Plan Status: Plan Address: 4 Blue Crab St Street BLUFFTON, SC 29910 Historic District Active 09/08/2025 Plan PIN #:Case Manager: R610 039 000 1231 0000Charlotte Moore Plan Description: A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and an attached carriage house at 4 Blue Crab Street. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). STATUS (09.24.2025): Concept Plan scheduled for October 13, 2025 HPRC meeting. Staff Review (HD) Submission #: 1 Recieved: 09/08/2025 Completed: 10/05/2025 Reviewing Dept. Complete Date StatusReviewer Approved with Conditions10/05/2025Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewer Review Matthew Michaels Comments: Comments may be provided at time of building permit submission. Approved with Conditions10/05/2025Growth Management Dept Review (HD) Charlotte Moore Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 1 of 3Page 6 Section V. Item # 2. 1. Ownership/Applicant Authorization: The owner is shown as Pat Mason on the application, but Beaufort County records show Blue Crab Bluffton LLC. Update the application to show the correct property owner and provide written and signed authorization that William Court is serving as the agent/applicant. 2. Setbacks: Show the front and rear yard setback on the Composite Site Plan and the individual Site Plan. 3. Building Type: “Single Family Residential” is shown as the proposed building type, which is not a building type per the Unified Development Ordinance. Identify the building type, which must be one that is permitted in the NG-HD District (UDO Sec.5.15.5.C.). The specific building types established by district for the Old Town Bluffton are intended to “perpetuate the character that makes Bluffton distinctive” (UDO Sec. 5.15.1.C.). If an Additional Building Type is selected, identify why. 4. Carriage House / Square Footage: As Old Town Bluffton is regulated by a form-based development code, the garage/bonus room is a carriage house and must comply with the carriage house building-type requirements of UDO Sec. 5.15.8.F. An attached carriage house “must be clearly incidental to…and distinguished from the principal building form.” Provide the individual square footage (footprint and total) for both the main structure and the carriage house. The carriage house is an ancillary structure, and it should be better differentiated from the main structure (on the eastern elevation, the wall is recessed only one foot from the main structure wall). Related to square footage, explain why the “storage room” on the second floor of the main structure is unconditioned. 5. Materials/Dimensions/Operations: In Section 5 of the application (Materials), for each element, provide the required materials, dimensions and operations. This information must also be shown on the architectural plans and be consistent. Some materials are not permitted per the UDO, including boral, powder-coated aluminum and composite. Your narrative, which is required with the Final Plan submission, must provide reasoning why these alternative materials are proposed and how they are the same or better in appearance and performance as permitted materials. 6. Photos: Photos were not provided as required for a Concept Plan Review (COFA Application). 7. On-street Parking: At the pre-application meeting, we discussed removal of the proposed on-street parking spaces. Was the plan not updated, or is it the intent to provide them? The Site Plan (P.02) and Sheet A2.1 do not match. 8. Screening Wall: A brick wall is shown on the east side of the house, but details are not provided. If the wall extends across property lines, an easement may be necessary that also identifies the party/parties responsible for maintenance. It appears that the wall exceeds the permitted height in the front yard; per UDO Sec. 5.15.6.K., wall height cannot exceed 42 inches and posts can be taller. Is the wall intended to serve as screen for the service yard? 9. Foundation Height: The main structure foundation is 2’-4”. UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.1.c. requires residential structure to have a “first finished floor height raised a minimum of three (3) feet above average adjacent sidewalk grade.” 10. Rear Double Porch Detail: Show the interior elevations of the porch that are not visible. 11. Windows: Fixed windows are not permitted as shown on the left ground floor elevation. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.I.3.b. Consider changing this window to match the adjacent kitchen windows. 12. Porch Facia: The front and rear porch appear to have two fascia boards with a space in between—it’s not clear why. What is the material? Porch ceiling material must be identified. 13. Second Concept Plan Review: Given the number of comments, a second Concept Plan review will be required. 14. Final Submission: At the time of Final Plan submission, provide a landscape plan showing foundation plantings and 75% tree canopy coverage at maturity (UDO Sec. 5.3.) and architectural details of the railings and balusters, door and window schedules, corner board/pilaster trim detail and sections through the eave and wall depicting the material and dimensions (Applications Manual). A response to all Concept Plan comments must be provided. Approved with Conditions10/05/2025HPRC Review Charlotte Moore Comments: 1. Modify the front porch column spacing to comply with UDO 5.15.6.H.1.a: “Columns and porch posts shall be spaced no farther apart than they are tall as measured from the centerlines of the columns (“o.c”).” 2. The small nib of hipped roof of the front elevation should be eliminated or further extruded into an appropriately scaled element. Consider simplifying the main roof mass so that the fascia matches. 3. Review the window muntin designs for consistency. There is a mix of 4-lite and 6-lite windows that do not relate well to each other. 4. Change the lower roof of the garage to a shed roof to match the roof over the man door. 5. Per UDO 5.15.8.F.: “An attached [carriage house] structure must be clearly incidental to, smaller than, and distinguished from the principal building form.” The garage element is not distinguished from the principal building form. Redesign the carriage house to provide definition between these two forms that is more than just “glueing” the garage onto the rear of the house. The relationship between the carriage house and porch appears haphazard and more consideration is necessary regarding how these two forms interact. Approved with Conditions09/30/2025Watershed Management Review Samantha Crotty Comments: 1. Comments may be provided at time of building permit/stormwater permit submittal. Approved09/16/2025Transportation Department Review - HD Mark Maxwell Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 2 of 3Page 7 Section V. Item # 2. No comments Plan Review Case Notes: 10/06/2025 Page 3 of 3Page 8 Section V. Item # 2. PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS FOR COFA-09-25-019928 Town of Bluffton Department of Growth Management 20 Bridge Street P.O. Box 386 Bluffton, South Carolina 29910 Telephone 843-706-4522 OLD TOWN Plan Type: Apply Date: Plan Status: Plan Address: 6 Blue Crab St Street BLUFFTON, SC 29910 Historic District Void 09/08/2025 Plan PIN #:Case Manager: R610 039 000 1230 0000Charlotte Moore Plan Description: A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and a 2-story attached carriage house at 6 Blue Crab Street, Lot 50. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). STATUS (09.29.2025): Concept Plan scheduled for October 6, 2025 HPRC meeting. Staff Review (HD) Submission #: 1 Recieved: 09/08/2025 Completed: Reviewing Dept. Complete Date StatusReviewer Revisions Required10/06/2025HPRC Review Charlotte Moore Comments: 1. This is the same model home four times in a row with very slight roof form differences and a nominal difference in siding application. The chimney is in two different locations, but it is prominently in the same location twice. All have the exact same porch including the front door – window – bedroom door arrangement. Each home should take on a more unique character to provide variety on the streetscape. Use the porch detailing to further separate these homes. Vary column spacing, column design, handrails, door design, fenestration, etc. to create variety along the streetscape. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.3.a.: “Buildings shall incorporate interruptions and variety into the wall plane to create interest and variety in the streetscape while still maintaining a consistent architectural style and connection to its surroundings. Examples include but are not limited to offsets, recessed entrances, arcades, awnings and canopies, bay windows, roof overhangs, expression lines, shadow lines, porches and balconies.” 2. Modify the front porch column spacing to comply with UDO 5.15.6.H.1.a: “Columns and porch posts shall be spaced no farther apart than they are tall as measured from the centerlines of the columns (“o.c”).” 3. The dormers on the front elevation lack sufficient scale. They are too widespread, which creates an uncomfortable, unfinished appearance. Restudy the spacing of these dormers in conjunction with the columns. Consider three dormers with a tighter relationship or a single larger dormer. Vary the design from 2 Blue Crab. 4. The window in the dormer on the left carriage house elevation appears to go into the roof. 5. Review the window muntin designs for consistency. There is a mix of 4-lite and 6-lite windows that do not relate well to each other. 6. UDO 5.15.8.F “An attached [carriage house] structure must be clearly incidental to, smaller than, and distinguished from the principal building form.” The garage element is not distinguished from the principal building form. Redesign the carriage house to provide definition between these two forms that is more than just “glueing” the garage onto the rear of the house. The relationship of the carriage house and porch is haphazard. It does not appear consideration was given to how these two forms interact. Revisions RequiredGrowth Management Dept Review (HD) Charlotte Moore Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 1 of 2Page 9 Section V. Item # 3. 1. Ownership/Applicant Authorization: The owner is shown as Pat Mason on the application, but Beaufort County records show Blue Crab Bluffton LLC. Update the application to show the correct property owner and provide written and signed authorization that William Court is serving as the agent/applicant. 2. Setbacks: Show the front and rear yard setback on the Composite Site Plan and the individual Site Plan. 3. Building Type: “Single Family Residential” is shown as the proposed building type, which is not a building type per the Unified Development Ordinance. Identify the building type, which must be one that is permitted in the NG-HD District (UDO Sec.5.15.5.C.). The specific building types established by district for the Old Town Bluffton are intended to “perpetuate the character that makes Bluffton distinctive” (UDO Sec. 5.15.1.C.). If an Additional Building Type is selected, identify why. 4. Carriage House / Square Footage: As Old Town Bluffton is regulated by a form-based development code, the garage/bonus room is a carriage house and must comply with the carriage house building-type requirements of UDO Sec. 5.15.8.F. An attached carriage house “must be clearly incidental to…and distinguished from the principal building form.” Provide the individual square footage (footprint and total) for both the main structure and the carriage house. The carriage house is an ancillary structure, and it should be better differentiated from the main structure. Related to square footage, explain why the “storage room” on the second floor of the main structure is unconditioned. 5. Materials/Dimensions/Operations: In Section 5 of the application (Materials), for each element, provide the required materials, dimensions and operations. This information must also be shown on the architectural plans and be consistent. Some materials are not permitted per the UDO, including boral, powder-coated aluminum and composite. Your narrative, which is required with the Final Plan submission, must provide reasoning why these alternative materials are proposed and how they are the same or better in appearance and performance as permitted materials. 6. Photos: Photos were not provided as required for a Concept Plan Review (COFA Application). 7. On-street Parking: At the pre-application meeting, we discussed removal of the proposed on-street parking spaces. Was the plan not updated, or is it the intent to provide them? 8. Screening Wall: A brick wall is shown on the east side of the house, but details are not provided. If the wall extends across property lines, an easement may be necessary that also identifies the party/parties responsible for maintenance. It appears that the wall exceeds the permitted height in the front yard; per UDO Sec. 5.15.6.K., wall height cannot exceed 42 inches and posts can be taller. Is the wall intended to serve as screen for the service yard? Consider moving the service yard farther into the property or in the rear. 9. Foundation Height: The main structure foundation is 2’-4”. UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.1.c. requires residential structure to have a “first finished floor height raised a minimum of three (3) feet above average adjacent sidewalk grade.” 10. Roofline: The left elevation shows a variety of rooflines that appears inconsistent with UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F., which states that “[r]ooflines shall be simple [and] correspond to the major massing of the building; [and]…complicated rooflines are to be avoided.” 11. Double Porch Detail: Show the interior elevations of the porch that are not visible. 12. Windows: Fixed windows are not permitted as shown on the right ground floor elevation. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.I.3.b. Consider changing this window to match the adjacent dining and kitchen windows. 13. Gutters: Gutters are indicated on the application but not shown. 14. Second Concept Plan Review: Given the number of comments, a second Concept Plan review will be required. 15. Final Submission: At the time of Final Plan submission, provide a landscape plan showing foundation plantings and 75% tree canopy coverage at maturity (UDO Sec. 5.3.) and architectural details of the railings and balusters, door and window schedules, floor sections, corner board/pilaster trim detail and sections through the eave and wall depicting the material and dimensions (Applications Manual). A response to all Concept Plan comments must be provided Approved with Conditions10/06/2025Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewer Review Matthew Michaels Comments: Comments may be provided at time of building permit review. Approved with Conditions10/06/2025Watershed Management Review Andrea Moreno Comments: Comments may be provided at time of building permit submittal/stormwater permit review. Approved10/06/2025Transportation Department Review - HD Mark Maxwell Plan Review Case Notes: 10/06/2025 Page 2 of 2Page 10 Section V. Item # 3. PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS FOR COFA-09-25-019929 Town of Bluffton Department of Growth Management 20 Bridge Street P.O. Box 386 Bluffton, South Carolina 29910 Telephone 843-706-4522 OLD TOWN Plan Type: Apply Date: Plan Status: Plan Address: 8 Blue Crab St Street BLUFFTON, SC 29910 Historic District Active 09/08/2025 Plan PIN #:Case Manager: R610 039 000 1229 0000Charlotte Moore Plan Description: A request by William Court of Court Atkins Group (Applicant) on behalf of Patrick Mason (Owner), for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District to allow the construction of a new 2-story main house and an attached carriage house at 8 Blue Crab Street. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District in the Tabby Roads development and zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD). STATUS (09.24.2025): Concept Plan scheduled for October 13, 2025 HPRC meeting. Staff Review (HD) Submission #: 1 Recieved: 09/08/2025 Completed: 10/03/2025 Reviewing Dept. Complete Date StatusReviewer Revisions Required10/03/2025Growth Management Dept Review (HD) Charlotte Moore Comments: 10/06/2025 Page 1 of 3Page 11 Section V. Item # 4. 1. Ownership/Applicant Authorization: The owner is shown as Pat Mason on the application, but Beaufort County records show Blue Crab Bluffton LLC. Update the application to show the correct property owner and provide written and signed authorization that William Court is serving as the agent/applicant. 2. Setbacks: Show the front and rear yard setback on the Composite Site Plan and the individual Site Plan. 3. Building Type: “Single Family Residential” is shown as the proposed building type, which is not a building type per the Unified Development Ordinance. Identify the building type, which must be one that is permitted in the NG-HD District (UDO Sec.5.15.5.C.). The specific building types established by district for the Old Town Bluffton are intended to “perpetuate the character that makes Bluffton distinctive” (UDO Sec. 5.15.1.C.). If an Additional Building Type is selected, identify why. 4. Carriage House / Square Footage: As Old Town Bluffton is regulated by a form-based development code, the garage/bonus room is a carriage house and must comply with the carriage house building-type requirements of UDO Sec. 5.15.8.F. An attached carriage house “must be clearly incidental to…and distinguished from the principal building form.” Provide the individual square footage (footprint and total) for both the main structure and the carriage house. The carriage house is an ancillary structure, and it should be better differentiated from the main structure (on the eastern elevation, the wall is recessed only one foot from the main structure wall). Related to square footage, explain why the “storage room” on the second floor of the main structure is unconditioned. 5. Materials/Dimensions/Operations: In Section 5 of the application (Materials), for each element, provide the required materials, dimensions and operations. This information must also be shown on the architectural plans and be consistent. Some materials are not permitted per the UDO, including boral, powder-coated aluminum and composite. Your narrative, which is required with the Final Plan submission, must provide reasoning why these alternative materials are proposed and how they are the same or better in appearance and performance as permitted materials. 6. Photos: Photos were not provided as required for a Concept Plan Review (COFA Application). 7. On-street Parking: At the pre-application meeting, we discussed removal of the proposed on-street parking spaces. Was the plan not updated, or is it the intent to provide them? The Site Plan (P.02) and Sheet A2.1 do not match. 8. Service Yard: Is the brick wall on the west property line intended to serve as a screening wall for the service yard? 9. Foundation Height: The main structure foundation is 2’-0”. UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.1.c. requires residential structure to have a “first finished floor height raised a minimum of three (3) feet above average adjacent sidewalk grade.” 10. Rear Double Porch Detail: Show the interior elevations of the porch that are not visible. 11. Windows: Fixed windows are not permitted as shown on the left ground floor elevation. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.I.3.b. Consider changing this window to match the adjacent kitchen windows. 12. Second Concept Plan Review: Given the number of comments, a second Concept Plan review will be required. 13. Final Submission: At the time of Final Plan submission, provide a landscape plan showing foundation plantings and 75% tree canopy coverage at maturity (UDO Sec. 5.3.) and architectural details of the railings and balusters, door and window schedules, corner board/pilaster trim detail and sections through the eave and wall depicting the material and dimensions (Applications Manual). A response to all Concept Plan comments must be provided. Revisions Required10/03/2025HPRC Review Charlotte Moore Comments: 1. This is the same model home four times in a row with very slight roof form differences and a nominal difference in siding application. The chimney is in two different locations, but it is prominently in the same location twice. All have the exact same porch including the front door – window – bedroom door arrangement. Each home should take on a more unique character to provide variety on the streetscape. Use the porch detailing to further separate these homes. Vary column spacing, column design, handrails, door design, fenestration, etc. to create variety along the streetscape. Per UDO Sec. 5.15.5.3.a.: “Buildings shall incorporate interruptions and variety into the wall plane to create interest and variety in the streetscape while still maintaining a consistent architectural style and connection to its surroundings. Examples include but are not limited to offsets, recessed entrances, arcades, awnings and canopies, bay windows, roof overhangs, expression lines, shadow lines, porches and balconies.” 2. Modify the front porch column spacing to comply with UDO 5.15.6.H.1.a: “Columns and porch posts shall be spaced no farther apart than they are tall as measured from the centerlines of the columns (“o.c”).” 3. Review the window muntin designs for consistency. There is a mix of 4-lite and 6-lite windows that do not relate well to each other. 4. Change the lower roof of the garage to a shed roof to match the roof over the man door. 5. Per UDO 5.15.8.F.: “An attached [carriage house] structure must be clearly incidental to, smaller than, and distinguished from the principal building form.” The garage element is not distinguished from the principal building form. Redesign the carriage house to provide definition between these two forms that is more than just “glueing” the garage onto the rear of the house. The relationship between the carriage house and porch appears haphazard and more consideration is necessary regarding how these two forms interact. Approved with Conditions10/03/2025Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewer Review Matthew Michaels Comments: Comments may be provided at time of building permit submission. Approved with Conditions09/30/2025Watershed Management Review Samantha Crotty 10/06/2025 Page 2 of 3Page 12 Section V. Item # 4. Comments: 1. Comments may be provided at time of building permit/stormwater permit submittal. Approved09/16/2025Transportation Department Review - HD Mark Maxwell Comments: No comments Plan Review Case Notes: 10/06/2025 Page 3 of 3Page 13 Section V. Item # 4.

Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.