Historic Preservation Commission Meeting — Minutes
Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of Sep 3, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting
Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20
Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC
September 03, 2025
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Goodwin called the meeting to order at 6pm.
II. ROLL CALL
PRESENT
Chairman Evan Goodwin
Vice Chairman Joe DePauw
Commissioner Carletha Frazier
Commissioner Jim Hess
Commissioner Tim Probst
Commissioner Debbie Wunder
Commissioner Lisa Sulka
III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES
1. August 6, 2025 Minutes
Commissioner Frazier made a motion to adopt the minutes as written.
Seconded by Commissioner Sulka.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and motion passed.
IV. PUBLIC COMMENT
Nicki Graziani, Historic Bluffton Foundation - Ms. Graziani spoke in favor of the demolition of 34
Thomas Heyward St after the assessment showed the poor condition of the structure.
V. PRESENTATIONS
1. Discussion of Town of Bluffton Historic Resource Survey Update and Presentation by Stantec,
Inc. (Staff - Glen Umberger)
Sandy Shannon with Stantec, Inc. presented. The Commission questioned how many
participants there are in the survey to date and who would be included in the interview
portion. There were questions as to how this survey differed from surveys done in the past.
VI. OLD BUSINESS
1. 27 Bridge Street: A request by Jason Broene (Court Atkins Architects), Applicant, on behalf of
Mike Nerhus and Jessical Foley, Owners, for approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness-HD
to amend an approved COFA-HD to allow the installed brick foundation to remain for the
house under construction at 27 Bridge Street in OId Town Bluffton Historic District, and zoned
Neighborhood Conservation-HD. (COFA-05-25-011989) (Staff - Charlotte Moore)
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes September 03, 2025
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The commissioners asked for clarification on what
was initially approved versus what was constructed. The Commission stated that what is being
proposed is not conforming. The Commission clarified that the foundation was installed
incorrectly prior to asking for the amendments. There was discussion if the material being
used is allowed.
Vice Chairman DePauw to approve the application with the following conditions:
1. The height of the privacy fence must be no taller than 6’-0” and shown as the
maximum height on the Landscape Plan.
2. The Town’s Stormwater and Watershed Management Division must approve the
revised Landscape Plan.
and the following determination,
1. The reconfigured brick foundation as discussed at the meeting, as well as the brick
type (the same or similar to the previously installed brick) are appropriate.
Seconded by Chairman Goodwin.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Hess, Commissioner
Probst
Voting Nay: Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
The vote was 4-3 and the motion passed.
2. 34 Thomas Heyward Street: A request by Jason Alexander, Applicant and Property Owner, for
review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District (Demolition), to allow the
demolition of an existing house located at 34 Thomas Heyward Street (Parcel R610 039 00A
0023 0000) in the Old Town Bluffton Historic District. The house, known as the Nellie and
Leroy Brown Cottage, is a Contributing Resource to the Old Town Bluffton Historic District and
is zoned Neighborhood Conservation-Historic District (NCV-HD). (COFA-04-25-019719) (Staff-
Glen Umberger)
Staff presented. The applicant was present. There was discussion regarding the possibility of
reconstruction of the structure and what materials were salvageable. The commissioners
emphasized the importance of preserving Bluffton's history.
Richardson LaBruce, attorney to the Commission, clarified that the application the
Commission would be voting on at this time, was only for the demolition of the structure.
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to enter executive session for Legal Matters Relating
to the Receipt of Legal Advice Covered by the Attorney-Client Privilege.
Seconded by Commissioner Frazier.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier,
Commissioner Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
The Commission returned to the dais. No action was taken in executive session.
Chairman Goodwin made a motion to deny the application as submitted.
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes September 03, 2025
Seconded by Commissioner Frazier.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder
All were in favor and the motion passed.
VII. NEW BUSINESS
1. 215 Goethe Road: A request by Phil Madhere, Applicant, on behalf of Miguel Loarca (Leonex
Construction Group), Owner, for approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness-HD to allow
construction of a three-story mixed use Main Street Building (approximately 2,775 SF) and
detached Carriage House (approximately 528 SF) located at 215 Goethe Road, Lot 7. The
property is within the Old Town Historic District and is zoned Neighborhood Core-Historic
District (NC-HD). (COFA-04-25-019686) (Staff -Charlotte Moore)
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The commissioners questioned if the ARB
approval was given and what point that would be needed. There were questions regarding
the height of the building in relation to the buildings on the adjacent properties. The
Commission asked for clarification on the material being used for the first floor. There was
discussion regarding the pitch of the porch shed roof and the windows on the north side
elevation of the building.
Vice Chairman DePauw made a motion to approve the application with the following
conditions:
1. All service yards, as well as meters visible from the public right-of-way must be
screened in compliance with UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F. The screen detail must be revised to
show a height no taller than 6’-0”.
2. Revise all plans (site, landscape and elevations) to be consistent.
3. Revise applicable plan sheets to show the main structure porch shed roof with a 3/12
pitch.
4. Remove the brackets on the rear elevation of the carriage house to prevent
encroachment into the access easement. The scale of this elevation should be re-studied
and submitted to HPRC for final approval.
5. Per the Applications Manual, written approval from the Board of Directors of the
Goethe Road Association.
6. Per Section 3.19 of the UDO, a Site Feature-HD is required for any signs proposed on
the site.
and the following determinations:
1. The use of galvanized wire for the balusters is an acceptable material.
2. The windows on the north elevation of the main structure should have vertical
proportionality.
3. At the lower level of the main structure, the wall section detailing must show board
and batten instead of brick, where applicable.
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes September 03, 2025
Seconded by Commissioner Hess.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
VIII. DISCUSSION
1. Carport UDO Amendments (WORKSHOP - NO ACTION): Discussion, Consideration and
Direction on Potential Amendments to the Town of Bluffton Code of Ordinances, Chapter 23,
Unified Development Ordinance, Article 5 – Design Standards - Accessory Buildings (Staff -
Angie Castrillon)
Staff presented. The Commission shared their concerns with allowing more structures on a lot
and how scale and size should be addressed. There was discussion regarding what kind of
height restrictions should be included.
This was a workshop. No action was taken.
2. Historic District Monthly Update. (Staff)
Staff reviewed the monthly report. The Commissioners had no questions.
IX. ADJOURNMENT
Commissioner Frazier made a motion to adjourn.
Seconded by Vice Chairman DePauw.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Hess, Commissioner Probst, Commissioner Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed. The meeting adjourned at 8:18pm.
Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.