Historic Preservation Commission Meeting — Minutes
Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of Jul 2, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting
Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20
Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC
July 02, 2025
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Goodwin called the meeting to order at 6pm.
II. ROLL CALL
PRESENT
Chairman Evan Goodwin
Vice Chairman Joe DePauw
Commissioner Carletha Frazier
Commissioner Debbie Wunder
Commissioner Lisa Sulka
ABSENT
Commissioner Jim Hess
Commissioner Tim Probst
III. ADOPTION OF MINUTES
1. June 11, 2025 Minutes
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to adopt the minutes as written.
Seconded by Commissioner Frazier.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
IV. PUBLIC COMMENT
Nicki Graziani, Historic Bluffton Foundation - Ms. Graziani spoke on behalf of the Historic Bluffton
Foundation, in support of the demolition of the structure located at 34 Thomas Heyward St.
V. NEW BUSINESS
There were technical difficulties when staff tried to present the Old Business item, 15 Meriwether
Ct.
Commissioner Frazier made a motion to move 89 Bridge Street before Old Business.
Seconded by Commissioner Sulka.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
1. 89 Bridge Street: A request by Amanda Denmark (Pearce Scott Architects), on behalf of
owners, Jamie and Allyn Oliver, for approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic
District to allow the conversion of an existing single-family residence into a bookstore with an
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes July 02, 2025
associated icery located at 89 Bridge Street Old Town Bluffton Historic District and zoned
Neighborhood Conservation-Historic District (NCV-HD). (COFA-03-25-019642) (Staff-Sam
Barrow)
Chairman Goodwin recused himself.
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The commissioners asked for clarification on the
finish being used on the windows.
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to approve the application with the following conditions:
1. Identify window and door finish material to be used to show compliance with UDO Sec.
5.15.6.I.
2. Provide a landscape plan to show the minimum 75% tree canopy lot coverage
requirement has been met (UDO 5.3.3.G.1).
Seconded by Commissioner Frazier.
Voting Yea: Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner Wunder,
Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
VI. OLD BUSINESS
1. 15 Meriwether Court: A request by BFL Builders, Owner and Applicant, for approval of a
Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District, to allow construction of a 2-story single-family
residence of approximately 1,637SF and an attached 2-story Carriage House of approximately
840SF located at 15 Meriwether Court (Lot 1) in the Landon Oaks Development. The property
is in Old Town Historic District and is zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District. (COFA-01-
25-019522)(Staff - Charlotte Moore)
Chairman Goodwin returned to the dais.
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The commissioners asked for clarification on trees
shown on the survey and if they were on the lot or the adjacent lot. The Commission had
questions about the lack of a retaining wall. The commissioners shared their worries over the
age of the survey and the information being presented being inaccurate. The Commission also
had concerns about the size and mass of the structures in relation to the lot and the
surrounding buildings.
The applicant requested to table the item.
Vice Chairman DePauw made a motion to table the item. Seconded by Commissioner Sulka.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed. The item was tabled.
VII. NEW BUSINESS
1. 5 Lawton Street: A request by Ansley Manuel (Manuel Studio), on behalf of James W. Jeffcoat
Revocable Trust, Owner, for the review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-HD (Demolition) to
allow the demolition of a non-contributing storage shed located at 5 Lawton Street in Old
Town of Bluffton, SC Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes July 02, 2025
Town Bluffton Historic District within the Neighborhood Center - Historic District (ND- HD)
zoning district. (COFA-03-25-019646) (Staff - Charlotte Moore)
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The Commission had no questions.
Commissioner Wunder made a motion to approve the application as submitted.
Seconded by Vice Chairman DePauw.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed.
2. 34 Thomas Heyward Street: A request by Jason Alexander, Applicant and Property Owner, for
review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District (Demolition), to allow the
demolition of an existing house located at 34 Thomas Heyward Street (Parcel R610 039 00A
0023 0000) in the Old Town Bluffton Historic District. The house, known as the Nellie and
Leroy Brown Cottage, is a Contributing Resource to the Old Town Bluffton Historic District and
is zoned Neighborhood Conservation-Historic District (NCV-HD). (COFA-04-25-019719) (Staff-
Glen Umberger)
Staff presented. The applicant was present. The Commission questioned if all other
alternatives have been considered. The commissioners asked for clarification on what plans
the applicant had regarding the property if the structure is demolished. The commissioners
stated they would like to see documentation from a restoration contractor to verify there
were no other options.
Commissioner Sulka made a motion to postpone a decision by 60 days.
Seconded by Commissioner Wunder.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and the motion passed. No action was taken.
VIII. DISCUSSION
1. Historic District Monthly Update. (Staff)
Staff reviewed the monthly report. The Commissioners had no questions
IX. ADJOURNMENT
Commissioner Frazier made a motion to adjourn.
Seconded by Commissioner Sulka.
Voting Yea: Chairman Goodwin, Vice Chairman DePauw, Commissioner Frazier, Commissioner
Wunder, Commissioner Sulka
All were in favor and motion passed. The meeting adjourned at 7:49pm.
Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.