Minutes
Town of Awendaw · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Awendaw
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF AWENDAW
6971 Doar Road | P.O. Box 520 | Awendaw, SC 29429
843.928.3100 | www.townofawendawsc.org
townadministrator@townofawendawsc.org
Rebecca Vance | Interim Town Administrator
Takeya White | Clerk & Vivienne Haven | Treasurer
Chris Crolley | Mayor
Town Council
Paul Brown | Wendy Helms
Grace Gasper | Rodney Porcher
Kent Prause | John Timmons
Town of Awendaw Board of Zoning Appeals Public Hearing
APPROVED Meeting Minutes
November 2, 2026, 6:00 PM
6971 Doar Road, Awendaw, SC 29429, US
A.
Call to Order
Chairman Gary Freeman called the Board of Zoning Appeals Public Hearing to order at 6:00 PM on
Monday, November 2, 2026.
1. P
rayer, Pledge of Allegiance & Civility Pledge
Chairman Freeman led the prayer and Pledge of Allegiance. Vice-Chair John Brubaker read the
Civility Pledge.
B. R
oll Call
Present: Chairman Gary Freeman, Board Member Scott Jones, Vice-Chair John Brubaker, Board Member
Steve Wood; Board Member Josh Spencer; Planning Manager Daniel O'Hara and Town Clerk Takeya
W
hite (staff).
Clerk's note: A board member recorded as "Spencer" appears later in the recording but was not on the
opening roll call. Attribution of those motions and votes should be verified before the minutes are
adopted.
C. A
pproval of November 2nd Agenda
Motion to approve the November 2nd agenda was made by Board Member Wood and seconded
by Board Member Brubaker. No Discussion. Motion Passed unanimously.
D. Appro
val of Minutes – None
Although the agenda listed no minutes, Chairman Freeman called for corrections to the August 3rd
Meeting Minutes. None were offered.
Motion to approve the August 3rd meeting minutes as submitted was made by Board Member
Jones and seconded by Board Member Wood. No Discussion. Motion Passed unanimously.
Chairman Freeman noted that case rulings, minutes, and records are available for public review at Town
Hall during normal business hours.
E. Administration of the oath
Chairman Freeman explained that the Board of Zoning Appeals is a quasi-judicial body with jurisdiction
over appeals, variances, and special exceptions. He said a two-thirds vote is required to grant a variance
and that the notice was posted 15 days earlier in the Post and Courier and on the property, in
compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and S.C. Code § 6-29-760. He said an applicant who is
denied may appeal to circuit court within 30 days after the decision is mailed (S.C. Code § 6-29-820). All
testimony and written materials are considered evidence.
SETTLED 1696
Page 1 of 8
APPROVED
1. S
wearing in of the Applicant – [Time Stamp: 0:08:08/1:23:36]
Chairman Freeman administered the oath to the applicant, Ms. Dorcas Rhodes & Mr. Joe
Morgan, property owner.
2. Swearing in of the Public
Chairman Freeman administered the oath to members of the public wishing to speak, who
affirmed "I do." He also swore in Planning Manager O'Hara.
F. New Business - [Time Stamp: 0:08:08/1:23:36]
Motion to proceed with new business was made by Board Member Brubaker and seconded by
Board Member Wood. No Discussion. Motion Passed unanimously.
1. Application #2610-02: The applicant is requesting an eleven-square-foot variance from the
Town of Awendaw's maximum allowable sign area of 32 square feet, pursuant to § 153.281 (Sign
Characteristics) of the Town of Awendaw Zoning Code.
a. Statement of matter to be heard – Chairman Freeman
Chairman Freeman stated that the Board would take testimony and then approve,
approve with conditions, or deny Application #2610-02.
b. Presentation by the applicant – Dorcas Rhodes (5-minute limit)
Applicant Dorcas Rhodes said she is opening an ice cream shop, "Awe So Sweet," at 5103
N. Highway 17. She is not seeking a roadside sign, only one attached to the building. She
said the building previously carried a sign on an existing structure, and the new sign is
designed to fit it. She said an ice cream cone element adds height and takes the sign
beyond 32 square feet. She said other nearby businesses have visibility from the road and
described her request as "nothing flashy."
c. Presentation by Zoning Administrator (5-minute limit) - [Time Stamp: 0:12:17/1:23:36]
Planning Manager O’Hara reviewed the staff report. The property is zoned Planned
Development under Ordinance 2014-01 (adopted May 1, 2014), and the Planned
Development guidelines require all signage to follow the Town's guidelines for size and
location. The Town's sign requirements date to 2000 and are unchanged. The guidelines
granted no sign variance. The proposed sign is approximately 42.2 square feet, requiring
about 10.2 square feet of relief. The Planning Commission must still approve the sign's
design, and a sign permit is still required under § 153.276. He stated that the timing of the
shop's opening does not by itself establish hardship. He noted that the applicant bears the
burden of proof under Restaurant Row Associates v. Horry County, that S.C. Code § 6-29-
800(A)(2) requires a finding of unnecessary hardship, and that the Board must issue
written findings of fact and conclusions of law. Staff made no recommendation. Chairman
Freeman allowed staff to continue past the 5-minute time limit.
d. Public testimony - [Time Stamp: 0:20:07/1:23:36]
Three speakers testified in favor, and no one spoke in opposition.
1. Lynn Vicary (8470 Doar Road) recounted the building's history as a small trucking
company and later the "Lowcountry Mermaid" shop, which displayed a mounted
sign. She said the new sign fits the existing bracket, does not extend beyond the
building, and complements the neighboring Village Barbecue signage. She said
restoring the neglected building benefits the community.
Page 2 of 8
APPROVED
2. Mr.
Tim Pennigener (7303 Awendaw Landing Road) stated that he was in support
like Ms. Vicary, and no one hates Ice cream.
3. Mr. Joe Morgan (Property Owner), spoke in support, and said the building had
been vacant since he purchased it in 2023. He said the sign fits the long-standing
bracket, and the shop would benefit the community
.e. Rebuttal by the applicant (3-minute limit)
Chairman Freeman noted that no one had opposed the request, so no rebuttal was
needed.
f. Questions by the Board
Board Member Wood, who identified himself as a civil engineer, observed that 32 square
feet equals one sheet of plywood. He asked where the sign ordinance appeared in the
packet, noting that the Planned Development guidelines refer to a "monument sign" of 32
square feet. Planning Manager O’Hara explained that the guidelines defer to the Town's
size and location rules in § 153.281, and he entered a printed copy of § 153.281(A) into
evidence. Board Member Brubaker also said the proposal reminded him of a well-regarded
sign in Charleston. He observed that Highway 17 is dangerous and that better visibility
helps, but he questioned whether the situation amounted to a hardship within the Board's
purview.
Board Member Jones asked about the mounting. Applicant Rhodes said the sign was
designed to fit existing framework, that a structural engineer had reviewed it, and that
reducing the size would require removing bolts from the block building. She said the sign is
three aluminum composite panels mounted to existing 2x6 wood backing, which is
anchored to angle iron and lead anchors in the masonry. Board Member Jones questioned
if there was a physical limitation to having to reconfigure the sign. Applicant Rhodes said it
would cause a problem with the structure of the building, and an engineer could back that
up. Chairman Freeman confirmed the sign would be bolted to the existing wood. In
response to his question, Applicant Rhodes said no other changes to the facade were
planned. Property Owner Morgan approached the dais to show the board a diagram of the
sign.
Motion to close the public hearing was made by Board Member Jones and
seconded by Board Member Brubaker. No Discussion. Motion Passed unanimously.
[Time Stamp: 0:36:05/1:23:36]
2. Board Deliberation - [Time Stamp: 0:36:53/1:23:36]
Chairman Freeman reviewed the nine variance criteria and asked members to address as many
as possible. Board Member Brubaker said his earlier comments overlapped with other members'
technical points. Board Member Spencer asked the applicant if it would be a significant
undertaking to reduce the size of the sign to fit the structure.
Board Member Spencer asked
whether reducing the design to fit would be a substantial
undertaking, since attaching steel to a block building is generally easy. Applicant Rhodes
answered that "anything can be done," but noted that neighboring businesses such as Terminix
and Tractor Supply have much larger signs. She estimated corporate signs at 60 to 120 square
feet.
Page 3 of 8
APPROVED
Chair
man Freeman asked if any other changes would be made to the outside façade of the
building. Applicant Rhondes stated that there would be no others.
Board Member Jones stated that Applicant Rhodes referenced other signs in the local
neighborhood and asked if any examples were submitted as evidence. Applicant Rhodes stated
that you could just drive by Tractor Supply and see the difference, and that they are certainly
larger than 32 square feet. Board Member Jones reminded her that it was evidentiary based, so
there would have to be an exhibit presented to show that.
Planning Manager O’Hara reported that the adjacent Village Barbecue sign at 5105 US Highway
17, in the same zone, was approved on August 10, 2022, as a 4-by-4-foot sign (about 16 square
feet) on posts. He also stated that the zoning application was submitted as proof positive to
support that claim and is available for review and consideration. Chairman Freeman confirmed
Planning Manager O’Hara’s findings.
Board Member Spencer wanted to clarify that there was no precedence set with building signs
larger than 32 square feet being permitted. Planning Manager O’Hara stated that no building
sign over 32 square feet had been approved on the stated property, and a variance granted on a
separate parcel was not currently before the Board.
Board Member Jones reiterated that in his deliberation that he was keeping the 9 approval
criteria in mind and also the fact that they are a quasi-judicial board. He wanted to be sure to
follow the rules of the board, and all elements had to be considered together in their decision
making.
Applicant Rhodes said the criteria seemed written for rezoning situations such as a daycare in a
neighborhood, whereas this property has long been commercial. She said the sign would not be
flashing or backlit, and that her request is minimal compared with neighboring signs. She also
mentioned a “grandfather rule.” Hearing no other deliberative points, Chairman Freeman
entertained a motion to close deliberations.
Motion to close board deliberation was made by Board Member Spencer and seconded by
Board Member Brubaker. Discussion: No further discussion; Motion Passed with no
opposition.
3. Call for Vote - [Time Stamp: 0:47:07/1:23:36]
A procedural motion to move forward to a vote was made by Board Member Spencer and
seconded by Board Member Jones.
Discussion: Chairman Freeman asked that as many of the 9 criteria be discussed to help with the
optimal decision.
Members then debated the criteria and the options before them.
Board Member Spencer stated that the possibility of greater profitability from a larger sign was
"a sticking point" for him. He thought that the larger sign would prove for a more profitable
business. Applicant Rhodes chimed in and Chairman Freeman asked if the public would refrain
from any further public comments.
Board Member Jones mentioned that the 9 criteria of approval have to be met in order to grant
the variance, and he didn’t see where a hardship was established.
Town Clerk White
advised Chairman Freeman that the board may want to take on the 9 Criteria
Page 4 of 8
APPROVED
of Ap
proval item by item, so there would be a clearer record of the vote.
Board Member Spencer led the charge and went over each item 1-9 by reading through each
critique.
a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of
property;
During discussion the board felt that item a was MET.
b. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity;
During discussion the board felt that item b was NOT MET.
c. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or unreasonable restrict the utilization of the property;
During discussion the board felt that item c was NOT MET.
d. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to
the public good, and the character of the zoning district will not be harmed by the granting of
the variance;
During discussion the board felt that item d was MET.
e. The Board of Zoning Appeals shall not grant a variance the effect of which would be to allow
the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district, to extend physically a
nonconforming use of land, or to change the zoning district boundaries shown on the official
zoning map;
During discussion the board felt that item e was MET.
f. The fact that property may be utilized more profitably, should a variance be granted, may not
be considered grounds for a variance;
During discussion the board felt that item f was NOT MET
g. The need for the variance shall not be the result of the applicant's own actions;
During discussion the board felt that item g was MET.
h. Granting the variance will not be contrary to the public or neighborhood interest nor will not
adversely affect other property in the vicinity, nor interfere with the harmony, spirit, intent, and
purpose of this article; and
During discussion the board felt that item h was MET.
i. Granting of the variance does not substantially conflict with the comprehensive plan or the
purposes of this article.
During discussion the board felt that item I was NOT MET
Planning Manager O’Hara advised t
hat a formal motion was required before further discussion.
He said the Board may approve, approve with conditions, deny, or defer for more information,
and that each motion must state the criteria on which it is based. He clarified that the Board
cannot waive the variance criteria. It must find whether each is met, but may approve with
conditions, such as Planning Commission approval, if it states which criteria it relies on.
Page 5 of 8
APPROVED
C
hairman Freeman then entertained a motion and a second to deny the request. [YouTube
Time Stamp: 57:22/1:23:02] Chairman Freeman then asked the board if anyone wanted to
make the motion and also second the motion.
Board Member Brubaker stated that he did not want to make that motion but he believed the
decision was incumbent.
A member of the public then requested to speak.
Planning Manager O’Hara called a Point of Order and advised the Chairman that the public
comment portion of the meeting was closed and that the board should focus on their vote.
[YouTube Time Stamp: 59:00/1:23:02] A motion to deny the variance was made by
Board Member Brubaker. The motion received no second and failed.
[YouTube Time Stamp: 59:20/1:23:02] A motion to approve the variance was made by
Board Member Wood. It received no second and failed.
Planning Manager O’Hara again clarified for the board that they must act, even if it were to
defer action or approve with conditions.
[Yo
uTube Time Stamp: 1:00:11/1:23:02] A motion to accept the variance with conditions
that the remaining conditions are attempted to be met was made by Board Member
Jones.
Bo
ard Member Wood stated that he didn’t understand, because there were 9 parameters that
they are to appease and each of them would have to be a “yes” before the variance could be
approved, and they only met 5 of the 9 criteria that were met, so it’s not a clean-cut
deliberation. Unless they find that the applicant MET all 9 criteria, the board couldn’t grant the
variance. Board Member Brubaker explained that in order to approve the variance the board
has to make findings that all 9 criteria were met.
Bo
ard Member Brubaker said he would like to support the application but felt obliged to follow
the Board's rules. He said four of the nine criteria were not met, and that denial would be
unpopular, including with him.
The board again went into discussion. Board Member Wood and Board Member Jones discussed
that with the current motion, Applicant Rhodes would be approved if she could satisfy the
criteria for approval that was NOT MET, which were items b, c, f, and i.
Approval Criteria NOT MET:
b. T
hese conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity;
c. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or unreasonable restrict the utilization of the property;
f. T
he fact that property may be utilized more profitably, should a variance be granted, may
not be considered grounds for a variance;
i. Granting of the variance does not substantially conflict with the comprehensive plan or the
purpose
s of this article.
Page 6 of 8
APPROVED
B
oard Member Wood questioned how Applicant Rhodes could meet criteria b. Board Member
Jones stated that would be a question for an attorney. Chairman Freeman then pushed the
board forward in further discussion. After a few more minutes of discussion, Chairman Freeman
asked the board if any other board member wanted to entertain an alternative motion.
Planning Manager O’Hara stated for the record that, before another motion was made, the
Board should ensure it did not duplicate a previous motion.
He explained that the Board could make a motion to:
• Approve the variance with conditions;
• Approve the variance based on criteria a through i; or
• Defer action to allow Applicant Rhodes to submit further evidence at a predetermined
dat
e and time of her choosing.
C
hairman Freeman stated to Board Member Jones that he had made a previous motion to
approve with conditions that did not move forward. Board Member Jones was asked to please
address the criteria MET and NOT met within his motion. Board Member Jones stated that he
wanted the conditions to be as seamless as possible. He would like the conditions to be
appropriate for the applicant to make sure nothing blows back on the 9 Criteria of Approval. He
further stated that conditions have to be met, but it’s unfortunate that the board doesn’t have
any leeway outside of the 9 Criteria of Approval. Chairman Freeman then asked Board Member
Jones if he would please state that in a motion. [YouTube Time Stamp: 1:13:19/1:23:02]
Motion to approve the variance with conditions was made by Board Member Jones and
seconded by Board Member Wood. Chairman Freeman restated the motion as
conditional approval, with the applicant to address satisfactorily the criteria found NOT
MET criteria b, c, f, and i.
The Board continued discussion with Board Member Brubaker asking who the applicant would
go to get a sign off that they met the final criteria by the Planning Manager.
Planning Manager called a Point of Clarification for the record and let the board members know
that they could not issue a variance to the variance criteria. The applicant must prove that they
demonstrate in facts of findings, that they either meet all 9 criteria or the board would have to
demonstrate in fact those which they do or those which they do not meet. If the board felt that
some of the criteria were not applicable and still wish to approve with conditions, they may do
so.
The board continued further discussion and then called for a vote.
T
own Clerk White conducted a roll call vote. [YouTube Time Stamp: 1:19:34/1:23:02]
Board Member Spencer - Aye
Board Member Jones - Aye
Board Member Brubaker - Aye
Chairman Freeman - Aye
Board Member Wood – Aye
Page 7 of 8
APPROVED
Board
Member Jones asked for the criteria NOT MET be read out loud as a Point of Clarification.
It was clarified that the motion did not include item g, and it was expunged from the motion.
Motion carried unanimously
G. Old Business – None [YouTube Time Stamp: 1:22:22/1:23:02]
H. C
losing Remarks
Chairman Freeman announced that the next meeting will be held Monday, December 7, 2026, at 6:00
PM. That meeting will approve these minutes and hear any additional cases.
I. Adjournment
Chai
rman Freeman called for a motion to adjourn.
A motion was made by Board Member Brubaker and seconded by Board Member Spencer and
the meeting was adjourned.
The meeting adjourned at 7:23 pm
DRAFT Minutes Respectfully Submitted on Thursday, November 13th, 2026, by Takeya White
APPROVED AS AMENDED
Final Approval Date: 11.16.2026 Signature: Takeya White, CMC
Note: These meeting minutes are not verbatim. To watch the full meeting video, please visit the
town’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@TownOfAwendaw
Notice of Meeting: In accordance with S.C. Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, notice
of the time, date, place, and agenda of this meeting was provided, and the agenda was posted on the
bulletin board at Town Hall prior to the meeting.
Page 8 of 8
APPROVED
Source: Town of Awendaw website. First collected Nov 19, 2026.