Design Review Board Meeting (Agenda Meeting Packet) - Cancelled
City of Beaufort · Beaufort County · meeting of Jun 8, 2023 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Beaufort
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING AGENDA
The City of Beaufort
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
Thursday, June 8, 2023, 2:00 P.M.
City Hall, Council Chambers, 2nd Floor – 1911 Boundary Street, Beaufort, SC
Please click the link below to join the webinar:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86971549780?pwd=TUhwRUFQS3VKbGxYU0owQVkycHQ0UT09
Passcode: 016351 Meeting ID: 869 7154 9780 Call in Phone#: 1+929-205-6099
STATEMENT OF MEDIA NOTIFICATION:
"In accordance with South Carolina Code of Laws, 1976, Section 30-4-80(d), as amended, all local
media were duly notified of the time, date, place and agenda of this meeting."
Note: A project will not be reviewed if the applicant or a representative is not present at the meeting.
I. Call to Order
II. Review of Minutes:
A. Minutes of April 13, 2023 Meeting
III. Applications:
A. Beaufort Senior Apartments, PIN R122 029 000 0625 0000, 1556 Salem Road.
Applicant: Michael Riley, Architect (23-02 DRB.3)
The applicant is requesting site plan approval for a 154-unit senior apartment building including
(88) 1-bedroom units, (66) 2-bedroom units with on-site parking.
IV. Discussion
V. Adjournment
Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes – April 13, 2023
CALL TO ORDER 00:00:31
A regular meeting of the Design Review Board was held in-person on Thursday, April 13, 2023 at 2:00
PM.
ATTENDEES 444
Members in attendance: Benjie Morillo (Chair), Kimberly McFann (Vice-Chair), Erik Petersen, Clinton
Hallman, and Bill Suter.
Staff in attendance: Curt Freese (Community and Economic Development Director); Jeremy Tate and
Maria Short (Meadors Architecture) attended virtually.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES 00:00:50
Motion (0:01:01): Mr. Hallman made a motion to approve the February 9, 2023 minutes as
submitted; seconded by Mr. Suter. The motion passed (5-0).
All Design Review Board Meeting minutes are recorded and can be found on the City’s we bsite at
http://www.cityofbeaufort.org/AgendaCenter. Audio recordings are available upon request by contacting the City Clerk, Traci
Guldner at 843-525-7024 or by email at tguldner@cityofbeaufort.org
APPLICATIONS
A. Battery Creek Apartments, PIN R120 029 00A 0409/0410/0411/0412/0413 0000, 25 Old Jericho
Road
Applicant: Ryan C. Lyle, Andrews Engineering (23-01 DRB.3) 00:01:29
The applicant is requesting preliminary approval for an 83-unit four-story building with a pool
and pool cabana.
Motion 1 (1:45:02): Ms. McFann made a motion to defer the application, ask city staff to seek
an opinion from the city attorney regarding the application of Beaufort Code sections 9.8.2 and
4.3.2.B as they apply to the project presented with special consideration to its location next to
property that is not in the city of Beaufort and also to request that before it comes back here,
staff amend the recommendations, specifically staff comments 3b, 4a, and 6a to clarify what
staff’s position is as to these matters. The Board requests that they get back to us and at least
DRAFT
obtain the city attorney’s opinion within 60 days and get back to us as soon as possible
thereafter; seconded by Mr. Hallman. Motion passed (5-0).
5 DISCUSSION
Curt Freese, the Community and Economic Development Director, discussed the format of the
staff reports. Mr. Freese and the Board discussed rescheduling the DRB work session that was
cancelled as well as completion of the required 6-hour Board training. Mr. Morillo noted that
the Board should discuss any master plan that the city might have regarding future plans and
development as well as the code change meetings held by City Council.
6 ADJOURNMENT 01:54:40
Motion 1 (1:54:40): Ms. McFann made a motion to adjourn; seconded by Mr. Hallman. Motion
passed unanimously (5-0). Meeting adjourned at 2:19 PM.
DRAFT
STAFF REPORT: 1556 Salem Road Site Plan/Senior Housing
DATE: June 8, 2023
GENERAL INFORMATION
Applicant: Mike Riley, Agent for Beaufort Senior Apartments
Site Location/Address: 1556 Salem Road/R 122 029 000 0625 0000
Applicant's Request: The Applicant is requesting site plan approval for a 154-unit senior
apartment building including (88) 1-bedroom units, (66) 2-bedroom units
with on-site parking in the T-5 UC district.
Current Zoning: T-4 N
ZONING DISTRICT INFORMATION
T-4 N
Max Density N/A
Min. Lot Size N/A
Min. Frontage Build Out 60%- 85 % min
Front Setback 0’ min/15’ max
Side Setback 0-15 max
Rear Setback 10’
Building Height: 4 stories
SURROUNDING ZONING, LAND USE AND REQUIRED BUFFERS
Adjacent Zoning Adjacent Land Uses Setbacks for Adjacent Zoning
/Buffer required if rezoned
North: T-4 N/T-5 UC Vacant/Commercial office N/A
South: T-4 N Townhouses N/A
East: T-3 N Single family homes/Uhaul N/A
West: T-5 UC Car dealership/Used Car dealer N/A
2
Background: The project has been in review for some time, and across three different Community
Development Administrations. The applicant first participated in a pre-design meeting on 12/8/2020
and a revision meeting on 3/2/2022. The applicant met with the city on 4/26/2022 and then attended a
pre-app meeting with the city on 11/2/2022. This application was deferred at the January 2023 DRB
meeting. The applicant met with city staff at the 2/28/2023 TRC meeting and had further informal
meetings in April. The current Staff has raised issues that heretofore were unaddressed through the last
2 plus years. The Applicant has made significant changes to the layout based on these comments
discussed in April.
Streets:
Salem road is a two-lane road, with a drainage ditch and no sidewalks. The applicant would build
sidewalk along their portion of the road, which would link to the County’s funded Salem Road sidewalk
project. Staff has asked the Applicant to verify traffic, as per the City’s code which requires a full Traffic
Impact Analysis for any project with 50 or more tips per hour. Thomas and Hutton Engineers verified
that the project would not generate more than 50 or more trips per hour, and thus the TIA is not
required.
Access:
The Applicant is proposing to build two entrance points at the center and North end of the property.
They have moved the proposed Southern entrance due to Staff concerns about visibility and safety on the
sharp curve. The Northern Entrance would be a shared access drive with the adjoining Northern
property.
Lots and Blocks:
While the property is zoned T-4N, a typical urban lot and block street pattern does not currently exist.
Moreover, due to the sharp curve, creek, and natural features to the South, an urban grid pattern cannot
continue Southward. There is a car dealership on the adjoining non-Salem side of this lot. An urban grid
could be built to the North of this property. In addition, the new layout creates a more urban pattern.
Heights:
A four-story bank building does exist two lots away along HWY 170. However, the adjoining properties
all are either one story commercial buildings, with two story houses across the street, and several of two
3
story fourplexes to the South. T4-N requires a 2-story height minimum per code. Upon Staff suggestion,
the applicant has stepped back the four-story height from the street, so the wings of each building are 4
stories, and the buildings along Salem are only three stories.
Future Land Use:
The Area is planned for Urban uses and development.
Zoning:
The zoning of the property T-4 N does not have a density limit, but does regulate a four-story maximum
height, and basic setbacks to the road. The use of multi-family senior housing is a permitted use in T-4 N
district.
Amenities: A community garden is planned for the Southwest corner next to the access point. There is
also a small gazebo in the center of the lot.
Staff Comments
Analysis:
Section 9.8.3 Decisions/Findings of Fact: Following the public meeting, the Design Review Board may
approve, deny, or approve with conditions the application for a Major Development. No Major
Development shall be approved unless the following findings of fact can be made:
1. The plan is consistent with the adopted plans and policies of the City.
Staff believes the plan is partially consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
The plan is consistent with density, use and setbacks of the T4-N district, and the future land
use plan.
x (Or sections the Staff does not believe is consistent with the requirements of Section 9.8.3)
Staff has concerns that the scale of the building is too large for the surrounding area and does not
fit `the neighboring context. Per Section 4.3.2, “Monolithic massing that disrupts the predominant
building pattern of the neighborhood and corridor is strongly discouraged.”
a. Per Section 4.3.2.C.1, “New construction should complement the massing of neighboring
buildings by utilizing roof forms, architectural trim, differentiation of façade planes, and a
4
relationship of solids (siding and walls) to voids (window and door openings) that are
consistent with the patterns established in neighboring buildings.”
b. Per Section 4.3.2.C.2, “When large scale construction is proposed that is not consistent with
the predominant building height and lot width of the surrounding area, special attention
shall be paid to specific building design elements to articulate a building form that is
appropriate to the neighborhood context. These include the items listed in the paragraph
above, along with siting, setbacks, and façade treatments.”
2. The plan complies with all applicable requirements of this Code.
Staff believes the plan is consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
Staff believes the project complies with the major requirements of the code, and minor
architectural revisions would be appropriate at the Final approval.
3. There exists adequate infrastructure (transportation and utilities) to support the plan as
proposed.
Staff believes the plan is partially consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
The applicant is providing curb and gutter, sidewalks and urban amenities and scale as
required by the T-4 N district.
x. Staff has concerns that an urban block with infrastructure is not present on the property being
developed. There is no sidewalk, curb and gutter, or other urban infrastructure close by or
adjacent to this property.
4. The proposed plan conforms to the character of the neighborhood, considering the location,
type and height of buildings or structures and the type and extent of landscaping on the site.
Staff believes the plan is partially consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
The properties to the North are commercial in nature and should develop in an urban fashion
as per their urban transect zones. The Senior homes will establish an urban form in an
otherwise non-urban area as required by the Beaufort Code.
5
x. Staff has concerns that the scale of the building is too large for the surrounding area and does
not fit `the neighboring context. Per Section 4.3.2, “Monolithic massing that disrupts the
predominant building pattern of the neighborhood and corridor is strongly discouraged.”
a. Per Section 4.3.2.C.1, “New construction should complement the massing of neighboring
buildings by utilizing roof forms, architectural trim, differentiation of façade planes, and a
relationship of solids (siding and walls) to voids (window and door openings) that are
consistent with the patterns established in neighboring buildings.”
b. Per Section 4.3.2.C.2, “When large scale construction is proposed that is not consistent with
the predominant building height and lot width of the surrounding area, special attention
shall be paid to specific building design elements to articulate a building form that is
appropriate to the neighborhood context. These include the items listed in the paragraph
above, along with siting, setbacks, and façade treatments.”
5. The proposed plan conforms to the Building Design Standards in Article 4.
Staff believes the plan is consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
Applicant has demonstrated compliance with Section 4.6.3.C.1 and many of the architectural
standards of the Beaufort Code.
There are a number of architectural details and changes Staff has recommended to the Applicant,
that will be applicable at Final approval.
6.The application will not substantially lessen the value of adjoining or abutting property and will
not be detrimental to the use or development of adjacent properties or other neighborhood uses.
Staff believes the plan is partially consistent with this factor for the reasons below:
The surrounding properties have T-4N and T-5 UC zoning classifications, and expectations of
density.
Affordable senior housing is a pressing need for the Beaufort community, and this request will
serve to satisfy a portion of this need.
x. There could be concern as per Section 4.3.2 C 1 about establishing very urban densities at 37 units
per acre and 4 story heights adjacent to traditional suburban residential development.
6
FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends Conceptual approval of the Application at 1556 Salem Road, in that is satisfies
the findings and requirements of Section 9.8.3 the Beaufort Code found in pages 2-5 of this Staff
Report with the following recommendations:
The community garden and gazebo relocated to a central location behind the buildings.
The parking stalls on the center access point be removed and turned into tree lawn/open
space.
Screening along the perimeter be included, with opaque screening to the South.
Consideration of a reduction in total parking spaces
Consideration of specific architectural comments provided by Meadors for Final approval.
Consideration of whether the four-story wings are necessary for the success of the project,
and whether or not a three story product would be more in keeping with the area.
Staff would recommend the Applicant consider these recommendations and revise minor details
to move straight to a Final approval at a future DRB meeting.
60"CLR.
60"CLR.
60"CLR.
60"CLR.
4-20-2023VJTMTRCONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN
SCALE: 1:30015'30'60'
2018-078
SITE INFORMATION:SITE: 4.203 +/- ACRESDENSITY: 37.59 UNITS/ACREBUILDINGS: (2) 3/4 STORY APARTMENT BUILDINGSUNIT INFORMATION:UNIT MIX UNITS1-BR (A UNITS)= 882-BR (B UNITS)= 66TOTAL = 154
SITE INFORMATION:PARKING REQUIRED SPCS92 1BR @ 1 SP/U= 8866 2BR @ 1.5 SP/U= 99TOTAL = 187
SITE INFORMATION:PARKING PROVIDED SPCSSTANDARD PARKING SPACES = 142COMPACT PARKING SPACES (20%) = 36HANDICAP PARKING SPACES = 9TOTAL = 187
3- STORYBUILDING 3- STORYBUILDING
4- STORY END 4- STORY END
COMMUNITY AREASON FIRST FLOORCOMMUNITY AREASON FIRST FLOORSCREENING WALL
T/ FOURTH FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +32'-9"
T/ THIRD FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +21'-4 12"
T/ FIRST FLOOR FINISHELEV. = SEE CIVIL
T/ SECOND FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +10'-8 58"
B/ ROOF TRUSS BEARINGELEV. = +41'-9"T/ FOURTH FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +32'-9"
T/ THIRD FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +21'-4 12"
T/ FIRST FLOOR FINISHELEV. = SEE CIVIL
T/ SECOND FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +10'-8 58"
T/ FOURTH FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +32'-9"
T/ THIRD FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +21'-4 12"
T/ FIRST FLOOR FINISHELEV. = SEE CIVIL
T/ SECOND FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +10'-8 58"
B/ ROOF TRUSS BEARINGELEV. = +41'-9"T/ FOURTH FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +32'-9"
T/ THIRD FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +21'-4 12"
T/ FIRST FLOOR FINISHELEV. = SEE CIVIL
T/ SECOND FLOOR FINISHELEV. = +10'-8 58"
2018-0785-5-2023VJTBUILDING 100 - ELEVATIONS
SCALE: 332" = 1'-0"05'-4"10'-8"21'-4" 1BUILDING 100 - SOUTH ELEVATION 3/32" = 1'-0" BLDG. 200 MIRROR IMAGE
2BUILDING 100 - WEST ELEVATION3/32" = 1'-0" BLDG. 200 MIRROR IMAGE
BAARCHITECTURAL ANTI-FUNGAL FIBERGLASS SHINGLES (MIN. 30 YR) - COLOR GAF TIMBERLINE HDZ " PEWTER GRAY"HARDIE FIBER CEMENT PANEL VERTICAL SIDING W/ 8" EXPOSURE - PAINTED SHERWIN WILLIAMS SW7566"WESTLANDHIGH WHITE" - FLAT FINISHC
E
HARDIE FIBER CEMENT PLANK LAP SIDING W/ 8" EXPOSURE - PAINTED SHERWIN WILLIAMS SW7662 "EVENINGSHADOW" - FLAT FINISHD4'x8' FIBER CEMENT PANELS - PAINTED SHERWIN WILLIAMS "LATTE" (INSTALL TYVEK DRAINVENT RAINSCREENBEHIND ALL FIBER CEMENT PANEL LOCATIONS, TYP.)
E
CB
G
B
G
CA
4'x8' FIBER CEMENT PANELS - PAINTED SHERWIN WILLIAMS "HONEY BLUSH" (INSTALL TYVEK DRAINVENTRAINSCREEN BEHIND ALL FIBER CEMENT PANEL LOCATIONS, TYP.)4'x8' FIBER CEMENT PANELS - PAINTED SHERWIN WILLIAMS "KILIM BEIGE" (INSTALL TYVEK DRAINVENT RAINSCREENBEHIND ALL FIBER CEMENT PANEL LOCATIONS, TYP.)BRICK VENEER #1 - CHEROKEE BRICK - 'SAPELO'GF
A
A1(b)A1(b)
B1(b) A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)
A1(b)
B1(b)
B1(b)
B2(b)B3(b) B3(b)B3(b)B3(b)A1(b)
124122120118116114109
123121119117115113
108
106
104
107
105
103
101 102
M.E.M.E.M.
E.
M.
M.
COMMUNITYAREAS
LEASING OFFICE& COMMUNITYAREAS
90'-612" 48'-3" 48'-2"234'-512"
2018-0784-27-2023VJTBUILDING 100 - FIRST FLOOR PLAN
SCALE: 332" = 1'-0"05'-4"10'-8"21'-4" 1BUILDING 100 - FIRST FLOOR PLAN3/32" = 1'-0"
A3.13
A1(b)A1(b)
B1(b) A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)
A1(b)
B1(b)
B1(b)
B2(b)B3(b) B3(b)B3(b)B3(b)A1(b)
A3(b)
A3(b)
B4(b)
224222220218216214209
223221219217215213
208
206
204
207
205
203
201 202
210
212
211
M.E.M.E.M.
M.
E.
2018-0784-27-2023VJTBUILDING 100 - SECOND FLOOR PLAN
SCALE: 332" = 1'-0"05'-4"10'-8"21'-4" 1BUILDING 100 - SECOND FLOOR PLAN3/32" = 1'-0"
A3.13
A1(b)A1(b)
B1(b) A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)
A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)
A1(b)
B1(b)
B1(b)
B2(b)A1(b) A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)A1(b)
A3(b)
A3(b)
B4(b)
324322320318316314309
323321319317315313
308
306
304
307
305
303
301 302
310
312
311
M.E.M.E.M.
M.
E.
2018-0784-27-2023VJTBUILDING 100 - THIRD FLOOR PLAN
SCALE: 332" = 1'-0"05'-4"10'-8"21'-4" 1BUILDING 100 - THIRD FLOOR PLAN3/32" = 1'-0"
A3.13
408
406
404
407
405
403
401 402A1(b)A1(b)
B1(b) A1(b)
A1(b)
B5(b)
A1(b)
B1(b)
M.
E.
2018-0784-27-2023VJTBUILDING 100 - FOURTH FLOOR PLAN
SCALE: 332" = 1'-0"05'-4"10'-8"21'-4" 1BUILDING 100 - FOURTH FLOOR PLAN3/32" = 1'-0"
A3.13
OLD SUBMITTAL
SITE INFORMATION:SITE: 4.243 +/- ACRESDENSITY: 36.8 UNITS/ACREBUILDINGS: (1) 4 STORY APARTMENT BUILDINGZONE: T4-NPARKING REQUIRED SPCS114 1BR @ 1 SP/U= 11442 2BR @ 1.75 SP/U= 74 TOTAL = 188PARKING PROVIDED SPCSTYPICAL SPACES= 158COMPACT SPACES (20% MAX)= 30 TOTAL = 188BICYCLE PARKING REQUIRED (188 X 0.5)= 9.4BICYCLE PARKING PROVIDED = 11
UNIT INFORMATION:UNIT MIX UNITS1-BR (A UNITS)= 1142-BR (B UNITS)= 42TOTAL = 156
SITE INFORMATION:LOT COVERAGE BUILDING :20.9+/- %IMPERVIOUS SURFACE : 56.0 +/-%MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE LOT COVERAGEIS 80% (70%+10%)
50 Park of Commerce Way Savannah, GA 31405 • 912.234.5300www.thomasandhutton.com
Source: City of Beaufort website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.