Community Services and Land Use Committee — Agenda Packet
Beaufort County · Beaufort County · Community Services Committee · meeting of May 13, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Beaufort County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Community Services and Land Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, May 13, 2024
3:00 PM
AGENDA
COMMITTEE MEMBERS:
ALICE HOWARD, CHAIR YORK GLOVER, VICE-CHAIRMAN
GERALD DAWSON PAULA BROWN
THOMAS REITZ JOSEPH PASSIMENT, EX-OFFICIO
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES- April 8, 2024 and October 9, 2023
6. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD- 15 MINUTES TOTAL
Anyone who wishes to speak during the Citizen Comment porti on of the meeting will limit their
comments and speak no longer than three (3) minutes. Speakers will address Council in a respectful
manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting, refraining from the use of profane, abusive, or
obscene language. In acc ordance with Beaufort County's Rules and Procedures, giving of a speaker's
time to another is not allowed.
7. ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR REPORT- Charles Atkinson
AGENDA ITEMS
8. PRESENTATION OF FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT 2023 ANNUAL REPORT - Barney Forsythe, President,
Friends of Fort Fremont
9. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM ADMINISTRATOR
TO EXECUTE A VOLUNTEER SERVICE AGREEMENT WITH THE FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT TO ALLOW THEM
TO PROVIDE VOLUNTEER SERVICES TO BE PERFORMED AT THE FORT FREMONT PRESERVE AND HISTORY
CENTER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE COUNTY - Stefanie M. Nagid, Passive Parks Department Director
1
County Council Agenda – Beaufort County, SC
10. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE RECOMMENDATION TO THE
GOVERNOR OF SOUTH CAROLINA FOR THE NOMINATION OF THE BEAUFORT COUNTY “CAROLINA
BRIGHT” ESTUARY SYSTEM INTO THE NATIONAL ESTUARY SYSTEM
11. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE
TO THE PROCUREMENT BY THE APPLICANT OF FEE SIMPLE REAL PROPERTY LOCATED ON HILTON HEAD
ISLAND, KNOWN AS THE MITCHELVILLE TRACT (PIN# R510 005 000 0007 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE FINAL
VALUE AS DETERMINED BY A NEW APPRAISAL AFTER THE COMPLETION OF AN UPDATED PLAT,
RESOLUTION OF ALL LEGAL ISSUES/CLAIMS, CONTINGENT UPON FULL LEGAL DES CRIPTION, AND SHALL
REQUIRE THAT ANY FUNDS RECEIVED FROM GRANTS, PRIVATE, FEDERAL, OR STATE FUNDING BE USED
SOLELY TO REIMBURSE THE EXPENDITURE OF THE GREEN SPACE PROGRAM (FISCAL IMPACT: TBD – Final
amount is unknown until staff completes and reviews neces sary due diligence in accordance with the
Green Space Advisory Committee’s recommendation and Green Space Program guidelines) - Mike
McShane, Chairman of the Green Space Advisory Committee
12. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION TO ESTABLISH BEAUFORT COUNTY’S
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PRIORITY LIST - Audra Antonacci – Ogden, Assistant County Administrator
13. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 38 ENVIRONMENT,
ARTICLE VI SINGLE USE PLASTIC BAGS SECTION 38-161, PURPOSE; SECTION 38-162 DEFINITIONS; SECTION
38-163 REGULATIONS; AND SECTION 38 -164 EXEMPTIONS OF THE BEAUFORT COUNTY CODE OF
ORDINANCES - Brian Hulbert, Deputy County Attorney
14. ADJOURNMENT
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html
2
Community Services and Land Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, April 08, 2024
3:00 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/301976
COMMITTEE MEMBERS:
ALICE HOWARD, CHAIR YORK GLOVER, VICE-CHAIRMAN
GERALD DAWSON PAULA BROWN
THOMAS REITZ JOSEPH PASSIMENT, EX-OFFICIO
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Vice-Chairman Glover called the meeting to order at 3:00pm.
PRESENT
Committee Vice-Chairman York Glover
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member Thomas Reitz
Ex-Officio Joseph Passiment
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
ABSENT
Committee Chair Alice Howard
Council Member David Bartholomew
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Mark Lawson
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Vice-Chairman led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. FOIA
Committee Vice-Chairman public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
3
Item 5.
Community Services and Land Use Committee – Beaufort County, SC
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to approve
the agenda.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES- March 11, 2024
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Brown, Seconded by Council Member Reitz to approve the
minutes of March 11, 2024.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
6. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD- 15 MINUTES TOTAL
Anyone who wishes to speak during the Citizen Comme nt portion of the meeting will limit their
comments and speak no longer than three (3) minutes. Speakers will address Council in a respectful
manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting, refraining from the use of profane, abusive, or
obscene language. In accordance with Beaufort County's Rules and Procedures, giving of a speaker's
time to another is not allowed.
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific
topic or the complete meeting https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/301976?ts=115
1. Jesse White
2. Teresa White
3. Joyce Gibbs Ham
7. ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR REPORT- Audra Antonacci – Ogden, and Charles Atkinson
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific
topic or the complete meeting https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/301976?ts=607
AGENDA ITEMS
8. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL FOR FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE
BEAUFORT COUNTY 2040 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN TO ADD THE BEAUFORT COUNTY LONG -TERM
RESILIENCE STRATEGY AS AN APPENDIX
Motion: It was moved by Ex-Officio Passiment, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to recommend
approval to council for first reading of an ordinance amending the Beaufort County 2040 comprehensive
plan to add the Beaufort County long-term resilience strategy as an appendix.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
9. CONSIDERATION OF AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING MAP FOR 86.16 ACRES (R100 028 000
0264 0000) LOCATED AT 98 JENNINGS ROAD FROM T2 RURAL (T2R) TO C3 NEIGHBORHOOD MIXED USE
(C3NMU)
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, Seconded by Council Member Tabernik to deny
consideration of an ordinance amending the zoning map for 86.16 Acres (R100 028 000 0264 0000)
located at 98 Jennings Road from T2 Rural (T2R) to C3 Neighborhood Mixed Use (C3NMU).
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
4
Item 5.
Community Services and Land Use Committee – Beaufort County, SC
10. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION TO NAME THE PORT ROYAL LIBRARY
FACILITY IN HONOR OF THE FORMER TOWN OF PORT ROYAL MAYOR, SAMUEL E. MURRAY
Motion: made by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Dawson recommend
approval to council of a resolution to name the Port Royal Library facility in honor of the former Town of
Port Royal Mayor, Samuel E. Murray.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
11. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION RECOGNIZING FAIR HOUSING MONTH
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, Seconded by Council Member Reitz to recommend
approval to Council of a resolution recognizing Fair Housing Month.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
12. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS AND PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE FEE
SIMPLE PURCHASE OF REAL PROPERTY IDENTIFIED AS TAX MAP SERIAL NUMBERS R100-026-00A-0260-
0000 and R100-026-00A-0261-0000 AND ALSO KNOWN AS BOUNDARY STREET LOGAN
Motion: It was moved by Ex-Officio Passiment, Seconded by Council Member Brown to recommend
approval to Council of a resolution authorizing the Interim County Administrator to execute the
necessary documents and provide funding for the fee simple purchase of real property identified as tax
map serial numbers R100-026-00a-0260-0000 and R100-026-00a-0261-0000 and also known as
Boundary Street Logan .
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
13. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO UNDERTAKE DUE DILIGENCE AND DISCUSSION/NEGOTIATIONS FOR THE
PROPOSED FEE SIMPLE PURCHASE OF REAL PROPERTY KNOWN AS WALLACE CREEK
Motion: It was moved by Ex -Officio Passiment, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to recommend
approval to undertake due diligence and discussion/negotiations for the proposed fee simple purchase of
real property known as Wallace Creek.
The Vote: It was approved without objection.
14. ADJOURNMENT
Committee Vice-Chairman adjourned the meeting at 4:48pm.
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html
Ratified:
5
Item 5.
Community Services and Land Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, October 09, 2023
4:00 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/273977
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Chair Howard called the meeting to order at 4:02 pm.
PRESENT
Chair Alice Howard
Vice-Chair York Glover
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
ABSENT
Council Member Paula Brown
Ex-Officio Joseph F. Passiment
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Mark Lawson
Council Member Thomas Reitz
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Chair Howard led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. FOIA
Committee Chair Howard noted that public notification of this meeting had been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Committee Vice-Chairman Glover, seconded by Council Member Tabernik, to
approve the agenda.
The Vote - The motion was approved without objection.
6
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
5. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
No citizen comments.
6. UPDATE FROM ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR CHUCK ATKINSON
Assistant County Administrator Atkinson introduced Beaufort County Library Director Amanda Dickman.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the full presentation.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/273977?ts=152
7. PRESENTATION BY THE COASTAL COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (CCDC) WORKFORCE
HOUSING FUNDING
Alan Wolf, Chairman of the CCDC/President of the Serg Restaurant Group & Carletha Frazier, Program
Manager for CCDC
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the full presentation.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/273977?ts=988
Motion: It was moved by Council Member McElynn, seconded by Council Member Bartholomew, to send
this agenda item forward to the full council for placement on the agenda for further discussion and
consideration.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
8. UPDATE ON DISCUSSIONS WITH THE CITY OF BEAUFORT REGARDING THE LADY'S ISLAND VILLAGE
CENTER MASTER PLAN
Robert Merchant, Director of Planning and Zoning, discussed the planning work needed for improvements
to the cross-section of Sea Island Parkway and SC 802 and the village center along the Sea Island Parkway
corridor. Director Merchant asked the Committee about other elements they would like to see in the
Village Center Master Plan to make it a more holistic plan.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the full presentation.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/273977?ts=2394
9. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
ENTER INTO A MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT WITH THE TOWN OF PORT ROYAL FOR MAINTENANCE
OF COUNTY OWNED PROPERTY KNOWN AS CHERRY HILL PARK (R112 032 000 0637 0000, R112 032 000
0008 0000 and R112 032 000 0064 0000)
Passive Parks Director Nagid provided an overview of the proposed Memorandum of Agreement between
Beaufort County and the Town of Port Royal for Cherry Hill Park’s grounds and park maintenance. Director
Nagid also explained that there would be no fiscal impact to the County, as a donation was received from
the seller that is being put toward hazard tree removal and bush hogging on the property and developing
a conceptual plan for the property.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the full presentation.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/273977?ts=2900
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, seconded by Council Member Tabernik, to
recommend approval of a re solution authorizing the Interim County Administrator to enter into a
Memorandum of Agreement with the Town of Port Royal for maintenance of county -owned property
known as Cherry Hill Park (R112 032 000 0637 0000, R112 032 000 0008 0000, and R112 032 000 0 064
0000).
7
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Discussion: Committee Chair Howard recognized the Port Royal Town Manager, Van Willis, and confirmed
he did not have any objections.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
10. ADJOURNMENT
Committee Chair Howard noted that she and Council Member Tabernik met with County Attorney
Keaveny and Deputy County Attorney Hulbert to discuss a possible moratorium along Highway 170 .
Committee Chair Howard proposed adding the topic as a discussion item to the November 13 Community
Services and Land Use Committee meeting.
Adjourned: 4:52 p.m.
Ratified:
8
Item 5.
COMMITTEE MEETING
CITIZEN CO MENTS
DATE: .�
0
\')( 2.L\
PRINT PULL N.AJ- : Qi-ca "V l ,J,l Slio V1 (. C tu r b
AGEr-r._A ITEM/TOPIC. \ e\ • :C>'f'$vi c,,;_
9
Item 6.
10
Item 6.
11
Item 6.
12
Item 6.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
PRESENTATION OF FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT 2023 ANNUAL REPORT
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee
May 13, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Barney Forsythe, President, Friends of Fort Fremont (10 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
N/A
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
The Friends of Fort Fremont will present data and information about actions and activity during the 2023
calendar year from Fort Fremont Preserve and History Center.
FISCAL IMPACT:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Presentation Only
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Presentation Only
13
Item 8.
1 | P a g e
FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT
ANNUAL REPORT
January 1 through December 31, 2023
Summary
2023 was another highly successful year for the Friends of Fort Fremont (FFF). We
experienced a dramatic increase in the number of visitors and initiated several important
projects that will continue to enhance the visitor experience in the years to come. In
2024, we will build on the successes of 2023, working closely with the Beaufort County
Passive Parks Director, who remains an outstanding partner in achieving our shared
vision for Fort Fremont.
History Center (HC) Operations
In accordance with requirements of the Memorandum of Understanding between
Beaufort County and the Friends of Fort Fremont, the Operating Plan (OP) was updated
by a FFF committee headed by Fred Channels, approved by the Friends’s Board of
Directors, and submitted to Beaufort County. The OP provides procedures for the
operations and staffing of the HC. It is a “living document” that will be revised as FFF
continues to increase HC volunteers. Expansion and modification of the OP will reflect
changes necessary to perform our roles and duties in the best interest of our visitors,
FFF, and Beaufort County. The 2024 OP was reviewed and approved by Stefanie
Nagid, Beaufort County Passive Parks Director, on December 18, 2023.
Throughout the year, we continued to recruit and train volunteers to greet visitors,
provide docent-led tours, and conduct educational programs for children and adults. To
better enhance our volunteer program, we took a field trip to Fort Moultrie on Sullivan’s
Island to learn how that national park interprets the history of its fortifications. We also
conducted periodic after-action reviews of our HC operations to improve our service to
the public. In March, we added staffing on Sundays to existing Friday and Saturday
operations, which enabled us to increase public access to the HC. Year-to-date, we
totaled1,897 volunteer hours, hosting more than 6,000 visitors from 45 states,10
foreign countries and one (1) U.S. Territory. Compared to 2022, this is a 50 percent
increase in the number of visitors to the History Center. Twenty-nine percent of our
visitors came from states outside of South Carolina, 15 percent came from towns in
South Carolina outside of Beaufort/Port Royal/St. Helena/Fripp, and 56 percent were
from the local area.
During 2023, 17 docent-led tours were conducted for local organizations, school groups,
national bus tours, and attendees for a national tourist conference broken down by the
following categories:
14
Item 8.
2 | P a g e
• Local organizations including neighborhood associations, clubs, and family
reunions: 10
• School field trips and Cub Scout Packs: 4
• National bus tours: 2
• Conferences: 1
An app developed for Smart Phones enables visitors to download a self-guided walking
tour. This provides historical information about Fort Fremont when the HC is closed or if
people elect not to take a docent-led tour. During 2023, the app was downloaded 869
times.
Facilities and Grounds
Members of the Facilities Committee and others performed a total of 300 volunteer
hours during 2023. Under the direction of Ted Panayotoff, work concentrated on
general clean up, vegetation removal, clean-up of downfall, raking and disposal of
leaves, and other tasks. This makes the Fort look well cared for and attractive and
preserves the conditions of the concrete.
Education Outreach
Four school groups and cub scout packs visited the Fort and History Center throughout
2023. Under the direction of Kathy Agee, the Education Outreach Committee developed
tours, activities, and lessons for students--preschool through high school. Fort Fremont
volunteers, dressed as Coastal Artillery Corps soldiers, guided students on tours of the
gun batteries explaining their military significance. Other volunteers engaged students in
several age-related activities in the HC.
FFF volunteers participated in Penn Center’s Heritage Days. Students from several
Beaufort County elementary schools visited our exhibit. In addition to a brief history of
Fort Fremont’s role in the Spanish-American War and in protecting US’s coastline, the
students played games they would have enjoyed playing 125 years ago.
Community Outreach
FFF presented several programs to community groups to promote awareness of Fort
Fremont and provide education on the history of the Fort. A slideshow of the 2022
Annual Report was presented to the Beaufort County Council on August 12, 2023. In
addition, presentations were made to community groups including the Sail and Power
Squadron and the DAR. Special group tours were conducted for members of Dataw,
Oldfield, Belfair, and St. Helena Island communities and for the Leadership Beaufort
class.
FFF put on the first Fort Fremont Harvest Festival on November 5, 2023. The event
was held at the Fort Fremont Preserve and coordinated with Beaufort County. The goal
of the event was to attract diverse members of the community with particular attention to
15
Item 8.
3 | P a g e
families and children, and to educate the public on the history of Fort Fremont.
Marketing throughout the community attracted more than 300 people, 200 of which
visited the HC. The event included food and other vendors, music, and games for youth
and adults. History displays were set-up by FFF volunteers, Beaufort History Museum,
and the Historic Port Royal Foundation. The event was staffed by 34 FFF, Marine
Corps, and Junior League volunteers.
FFF participated in the Land’s End 4th of July parade and provided refreshments after
the parade.
FFF partnered with the Beaufort Garden Club to host an open house at the former Fort
Fremont Hospital, now the private home of Mrs. Cecile Dorr, who graciously opened her
house, decked out in Christmas trimmings circa 1910, for this holiday event. Over 140
people from the greater Beaufort County area attended.
Social Media
FFF continued to update and maintain our website, Facebook page, and TripAdvisor.
On our Facebook page, we are rated at 5 out of 5 stars for non-profit organizations. As
of December 31, 2023, we had 1,900 followers, which is a 19 percent increase from
December 2022. TripAdvisor lists Fort Fremont as number 2 of 18 things to do on St.
Helena Island. We continue to receive positive reviews on TripAdvisor.
During 2023, we expanded our presence on social media sites and email blasts to
publicize events adding The Chamber of Commerce, Beaufort City Weekly Update, and
SC Lowcountry and Resort Islands.
Marketing
Marketing efforts focused on increasing the number of visitors to the HC and promoting
FFF events. An advertisement was placed in the 2023 Beaufort Visitor's Guide and
several advertisements were developed for the FFF events including placement on the
Beaufort Main Street sign board and in “The Island News.” The Communications and
Marketing Committee under the direction of Marty Hupka maintained our website and
Facebook page, distributed flyers to area businesses and on social media, and
conducted email campaigns to area schools, neighborhood websites, and community
civic and historical organizations. We also distributed more than 5,900 rack cards to
South Carolina Welcome Centers, Beaufort Visitors’ Centers, and area attractions, such
as Hunting Island.
To attract national bus tours, FFF participated in the Accent East Conference sponsored
by the Greater Beaufort Convention and Visitor’s Bureau. We developed story boards
for display during the conference and hosted participants in a private guided tour of Fort
Fremont. A special edition newsletter was developed to promote amenities at the Fort
tailored to tour operators.
16
Item 8.
4 | P a g e
Four editions of the newsletter were published throughout the year. They were
distributed to FFF members and handed to visitors at the History Center.
Ordnance Delivery Table
On June 30, 2023, a Temporary Custody Agreement for an Endicott-era Ordnance
Delivery Table (table) was signed by Beaufort County, the Town of Sullivan’s Island, and
the Friends of Fort Fremont (Friends) to transfer custody of the table from the Town of
Sullivan’s Island to Beaufort County. This table has been removed from Sullivan’s
Island and is being restored/preserved. It will be mounted on a stand for temporary
display on the back patio at the history center until it can be safely displayed on gun
emplacement #1.
Carl Project
The FFF Board of Directors established the Carl Project Committee in 2023 and
provided the committee with a charter to enhance the visitor experience at Fort Fremont
by preserving the the area under Battery Jesup gun emplacement #1 to help the visitor
understand what the fort was like when it was active. The project is named in memory
of Carl Dorr, husband of Cecile Dorr, a longtime supporter of FFF. The initial task was
to develop a phased concept plan with key steps by January 1, 2024 and a detailed
implementation plan by July 1, 2024.
The committee’s first meeting was in August, and it was agreed that structural concerns
under gun emplacement #1 needed to be addressed before a phased plan could be
attempted. It was decided to create an RFP for a feasibility study to be performed by a
qualified engineering firm. The purpose of the study is to determine what must be done
to make the structure safe for work to be conducted under the gun emplacement and to
possibly allow visitors to enter the rooms. The RFP was completed in November and
sent to Bennett Engineering in December.
As a parallel effort, FFF is pursuing the development of a digital simulation of activity at
the fort when it was active. The History Department at the United States Military
Academy at West Point has a digital history center and has offered to host and assist
with research to create a digital simulation life at Fort Fremont. The committee created
a proposal to the West Point History Department and submitted it January of 2024. It is
anticipated that a group of cadets and faculty members will come to Beaufort in the
Summer of 2025 to begin the project.
Book Project
Acting on a suggestion from FFF volunteer Jon Bebbington, the FFF Board approved
the creation of a committee to explore writing a book about Fort Fremont. The book
committee envisions a coffee table style book with pictures and narratives that tells the
story of the fort and anticipates the book will take several years to research and write.
17
Item 8.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH THE FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT TO ALLOW THEM TO PROVIDE VOLUNTEER
SERVICES TO BE PERFORMED AT THE FORT FREMONT PRESERVE AND HISTORY CENTER FOR THE BENEFIT OF
THE COUNTY
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee
May 13, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Stefanie M. Nagid, Passive Parks Department Director (5 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
This is a new item for consideration.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Since 2019, the County and the Friends of Fort Fremont have been operating under two older agreements for
use and services of the Fort Fremont Preserve and History Center. Those two agreements are expiring in June
and Staff and the Friends wish to enter into a long-term volunteer services agreement for the Friends’
continued use and services to the County as volunteers, docents and operators of the History Center.
FISCAL IMPACT:
There is no fiscal impact to the County to enter into this agreement.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommend approval of the agreement as provided.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify or deny the agreement for volunteer services for the Friends of Fort Fremont.
If approved, the agreement will move forward to County Council on May 28, 2024 for final approval.
18
Item 9.
RESOLUTION 2024/__
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH THE FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT TO ALLOW THEM
TO PROVIDE VOLUNTEER SERVICES TO BE PERFOMRED AT THE FORT FREMONT
PRESERVE AND HISTORY CENTER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE COUNTY
WHEREAS Beaufort County has been a frontrunner among local governments in land
preservation since 1999 with the creation of the Rural and Critical Land Preservation Program; and
WHEREAS Beaufort County purchased the parcels comprising the Fort Fremont Preserve in
2004 and 2010 for a total of $5,930,000 through the County’s Rural and Critical Lands Preservation
Program; and
WHEREAS the Friends of Fort Fremont is a South Carolina Nonprofit Corporation in good
standing formed on September 21, 2009; and
WHEREAS The Friends of Fort Fremont mission is to preserve and promote the Fort Fremont
Preserve as an educational, historical, natural, and cultural resource of the Spanish-American War era;
and
WHEREAS Beaufort County has constructed a History Center to be used by the Friends of Fort
Fremont as an educational and interpretive facility; and
WHEREAS Beaufort County and the Friends of Fort Fremont recognize the value of the
successful interpretation of cultural and historic resources at Fort Fremont Preserve and the cooperative
relationship between the County and Friends.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, THAT THE COUNTY COUNCIL OF
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA authorizes the Interim County Administrator to execute
the necessary documents to enter into an agreement with the Friends of Fort Fremont to allow them to
provide volunteer services to be performed at the Fort Fremont Preserve and History Center for the
benefit of the County, attached hereto and incorporated herein as fully as if repeated verbatim.
Adopted this ____ day of ____________, 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY:
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
Sarah Brock, Clerk to Council
19
Item 9.
Page 1 of 6
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) AGREEMENT FOR VOLUNTEER
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT ) SERVICES ON PUBLIC PROPERTY
THIS AGREEMENT FOR VOLUNTEER SERVICES ON PUBLIC PROPERTY (“Agreement”) is entered
into on this ____ day of ______________, 20 24 (“Effective Date”) by and between Beaufort County, a political
subdivision of the State of South Carolina (“County”) and Friends of Fort Fremont Historical Park, Inc. ,
(“Friends”); collectively hereinafter referred to as the “Parties”.
WHEREAS, the County’s Rural and Critical Land Preservation Program (“RCLPP”) was created in order
to purchase real property deemed critical, to provide for the protection of natural resources, to protect property with
historic and cultural significance, to obtain property for regional or local passive recreation potential, to obtain
view-scapes or lands suitable for public use; and
WHEREAS, in 2004 and 2010 the County purchased real property known as Fort Fremont Preserve
(“Park”) with funding from the RCLPP making the property subject to the County’s Code of Ordinances, Chapter
91 Passive Parks (2018/53); and
WHEREAS, County desires to enhance the historical and cultural value of the Park by interpreting its place
in American History held in the late 19 th and early 20 th Century, and has constructed the Fort Fremont Preserve
History Center for the cultural and historical interpretation of the Park; and
WHEREAS, Friends is a South Carolina nonprofit corporation operating in good standing formed on
September 21, 2009 , and received 501(c)(3) status by the IRS on January 21, 2011 . A ll of Friends ’ officers,
members, and volunteers providing services hereunder are volunteers as defined in the Volunteer Protection Act,
42 USC 139§14501–14505 and are not compensated; and
WHEREAS, Friends’ mission is to preserve and promote the P ark as an educational, historical, natural,
and cultural resource of the Spanish American War era . In furtherance of its mission, Friends desires to provide
Services to the County; and
WHEREAS, the Parties recognize the public benefit of the successful implementation of this Agreement,
and Friends desire to serve as volunteers to support the County, the owner of the Park.
NOW, THEREFORE, for mutual consideration and public service, the Parties mutually agree as follows:
1. DEFINITIONS. For purposes of this Agreement, the terms are defined as follows:
a. “County” shall mean Beaufort County, a political subdivision of the State of South Carolina, and including
the Beaufort County Council and all Departments that fall within the structure of the Beaufort County
Government Administration.
b. “Friends” shall mean the Friends of Fort Fremont Historical Park, Inc. performing Services under this
Agreement and shall include all board members, officers, volunteers, and any other individual affiliated
with the nonprofit corporation.
c. “Park” shall mean real property located at 1124 Lands End Road, Saint Helena Island, SC 29920, consisting
of approximately 16.98 acres, generally known as the Fort Fremont Preserve and History Center ; and
includes the land, buildings, structures, and amenities that fall within the property boundaries.
20
Item 9.
Page 2 of 6
d. “Services” shall mean those services being provided by the Friends to the benefit of the Park and as
described in Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
2. TERM. The initial term of this Agreement shall commence on the Effective Date and end on June 30,
2030, unless terminated sooner pursuant to the provisions of th is Agreement. The term of this Agreement may be
extended for up to three (3) additional five (5) year periods (July 1 to June 30) upon the written request of the
Friends and written approval of the County.
3. FUNDING. This Agreement does not obligate the County to expend funds. Friends agrees to use its own
funding sources to provide the Services. County agrees to support improvements, maintenance, and operations of
the Park. Any endeavor involving reimbursement or contribution of funds between the Parties will be handled in
accordance with applicable County laws, regulations, policies and procedures.
4. COMMUNICATION and SUPPORT. In order to provide Services, Friends will maintain regular
ongoing communications regarding proposals and scheduling of plans for the Park and activities at the Park with
the County. Meetings may be scheduled between the parties, either in-person or via conference call, on an as needed
basis. All communications will be provided to the County’s Passive Parks Director from the President of the Friends
or designated representative when the President is not available.
5. ACCESS AUTHORIZATION. County hereby authorizes Friends to access the P ark while providing
Services, subject to the terms and conditions stated in this Agreement and the annual Operating Plan. Friends may
access the Park during regular park hours to provide Services so long as it does not conflict with any County plans,
events, or activities. This Agreement shall not infringe on the access rights of the County or any of its officers,
employees, or agents to any and all portions of the Park at any time or for any reason in carrying out County’s
responsibilities for the ownership, maintenance, and operation of the Park.
6. SERVICES GENERALLY. The Parties agree to the terms and conditions in this Section in order for
Friends to provide the agreed upon Services.
a. Friends shall provide Services in accordance with the terms and conditions of this Agreement and the
approved annual Operating Plan.
b. County shall be responsible for all exterior and interior maintenance and repair of buildings and/or
structures, janitorial services, an d trash removal on the P ark. County shall provide and pay for all utility
services necessary for the operation of the Park.
c. If permits are needed in order for Friends to complete a project, the County agrees to provide support by
seeking any permits that may be required. Friends are not authorized to represent the County as landowner
in order to obtain any permit.
d. Friends shall comply with all the laws, ordinances, rules, policies and orders of appropriate governmental
authorities affecting the cleanliness, occupancy, reservation and preservation of the P ark, including the
Beaufort County Passive Park Ordinance and the Beaufort County Passive Park Facility Rental Policy .
County shall be responsible for security and enforcement of rules and regulations of the Park.
e. Friends shall notify the C ounty immediately via email and phone call if while providing Service they
become aware of the presence of any structural or utility problems , or if vandalism is known to have
occurred at the Park.
7. ANNUAL OPERATING PLAN REQUIRED. On or before July 1 of each year, Friends shall submit to
the County an Operating Plan for the upcoming calendar year. The Operating Plan shall include, but is not limited
21
Item 9.
Page 3 of 6
to, proposed services, activities, functions, events, hours of operation, and programs that Friends propose to conduct
at the Park in support of the Service. The Operating Plan shall also include the name(s), credential(s), and cost(s)
of any known hired contractors for any proposed activities. The County reserves the right to request additional
information or documents after review and/or approval of the Operating Plan.
8. ANNUAL REPORT. On or before March 1 of each year, Friends shall submit to the County an Annual
Report for the previous year’s activities at the Park. The Annual Report shall describe tourist-related activities and
statistics, including but not limited to bus tours, school groups and services to other tour groups ; as well as a
summary of any activities, functions, events, or programs Friends conducted at the Park.
9. OUTREACH MATERIALS. Friends may create public outreach materials related to activities permitted
by this Agreement. Any public outreach material including, but not limited to, advertising or display materials shall
clearly identify the Park as a Beaufort County Passive Park and display the County seal. Prior to its use, any public
outreach materials shall be provided to th e County for written approval ; and Friends may only use the public
outreach materials after receiving the County’s written approval.
10. LIABILITY INSURANCE REQUIRED. At all times during any term of this Agreement, Friends shall
maintain no less than $1,000,000 in general liability insurance coverage (each occurrence) and no less than
$2,000,000 general liability insurance in the aggregate. The Friend’s insurance shall provide coverage to all
individuals associated with the Friends, including but not limited to, members and volunteers. Insurance carried by
the Friends shall include that it is the primary coverage for any and all claims made by Friends and its volunteers.
Beaufort County shall be named as an additional insured in Friends insurance policy and Friends shall provide
Beaufort County with proof of being named.
11. TERMINATION.
a. Termination Due to Plans and Reports. This Agreement may be terminated with a thirty (30) day
written notice if Friends fails to provide an Operating Plan or Annual Report as required in this Agreement.
b. Mutual Termination. In addition to any other right to terminate as set forth in this A greement, the
Parties may mutually agree in writing to terminate this Agreement prior to the expiration of any term without any
notice required.
c. Termination With Cause. This Agreement may be terminated by the County for cause with ten (10)
days written notice of the breach of any terms.
d. Termination Without Cause. Upon a thirty (30) day prior written notice, any Party may terminate
this Agreement at the end of the Initial Term or during any Renewal Term for any reason.
e. Automatic Termination. This Agreement shall automatically terminate if at any time , during any
term, Friends has a lapse in liability insurance coverage, and the automatic termination shall apply regardless of the
length of time the lapse covers . This Agreement will automatically terminate if Friends loses its tax -exempt
§501(c)(3) status.
12. MISCELLANEOUS TERMS
a. Notices. All notices required under this Agreement shall be in writing. Notices shall be deemed
delivered when (a) personally delivered; (b) five (5) days after deposit in U.S. registered mail, postage prepaid,
addressed to the other party; or (c) receipt of email is acknowledged by the recipient by reply email or “read receipt”
is received by sender of notice. All notices shall be sent to the mailing address or email address shown below or to
such other address as may from time to time be designated by written notice.
22
Item 9.
Page 4 of 6
To the County:
Beaufort County, Passive Parks Director
124 Lady’s Island Drive
Beaufort, SC 29907
To the Friends:
Friends of Fort Fremont Historical Park, Inc.
P.O. Box 982
St. Helena Island, SC 29920
b. Default. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, in the event of a default by either
Party, the non -defaulting Party may seek any available remedy in equity or at law as a result of such failure to
perform, including but not limited to, any action for specific performance of obligations recited in this Agreement;
but the Parties mutually agree that the County shall not be forced to appropriate funding for the funds.
c. Relationship of Parties. Nothing contained in this Agreement nor any act of the County or Friends
shall be deemed or construed by the parties, nor by any third person, to create any other legal relationship between
the Parties, including, but not limited to, that of an employer/employee, third-party beneficiary, principal, agent,
limited or general partnership, joint venture, landlord/tenant, or other relationship. Friends’ officers, members,
volunteers, and agents and the methods utilized by Friends in providing Services and fulfilling its obligations under
this Agreement shall lie solely and exclusively with Friends. Friends’ officers, members, volunteers, and agents
shall not be considered agents or employees of the County for any purpose.
d. Indemnification. Friends agrees that to the fullest extent provided by law it shall indemnify, defend,
and hold harmless the County and its respective agents, employees, and volunteers, from and against any and all
claims, demands, lawsuits, or other actions that may arise out of this Agreement from the actions or negligence of
its employees, agents, or volunteers that may be the basis for such claim, demand, lawsuit, or other similar action.
e. Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire agreement between the Parties pert aining
to the subject matter contained herein and fully supersedes all prior written or oral agreements and understanding
between the Parties pertaining to such subject matter.
f. Captions and Recitals. The section headings appearing in this Agreement are fo r convenience of
reference only and are not intended to any extent for the purpose, to limit, or define the test of any section or any
subsection hereof. The recitals to this Agreement are incorporated into this Agreement by this reference.
g. Amendment or Modification. The terms and conditions of this Agreement may be renegotiated at
the conclusion of each respective term period and may result in an amendment or modification to the Agreement
only if agreed upon in writing by the Parties. This Agreement shall only be amended or modified in writing and
signed by both Parties.
h. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterparts, and all such executed
counterparts shall constitute the same agreement. The Parties agree that this Agreement may be communicated by
use of a fax or other electronic means, such as electronic mail and the internet, and that the scanned or photographed
signatures and initials to this Agreement shall be deemed valid and binding upon the Parties as if the original
signatures and initials were present on the Agreement.
i. Binding Nature and Assignment. This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of
the Parties and their respective successors, heirs, administrators, representatives, and assigns. However, the Parties
agree that any assignment of this Agreement must be approved in writing by the County.
j. Waiver. No waiver of any provision of this Agreement shall be effective unless in writing and
signed by the party waiving its rights. No delay or omission by either Party to exercise any right or remedy it has
under this Agreement shall impair or be construed as a waiver of such right or remedy. A waiver by either Party of
23
Item 9.
Page 5 of 6
any covenant or breach of this Agreement shall not constitute or operate as a waiver of any succeeding breech of
the covenant or of any other covenant.
k. Governing Law and Severability Clause. This Agreement is governed and interpreted in accordance
with the laws of the State of South Carolina. Any and all disputes between the Parties that may arise pursuant to
this Agreement shall be brought in the courts of the State of South Carolina in Beaufort County or, if it has or can
acquire jurisdiction, in the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina. If for some reason a court
finds any provision of the Agreement, or portion thereof, unenforceable, that provision of the Agreeme nt shall be
enforced to the maximum extent permissible so as to affect the intent of the Parties, and the remainder of this
Agreement shall continue in full force and effect.
l. Authority. The parties herein represent and warrant each to the other that they have all the
requisite power and authority to enter into this Agreement and perform their obligations under this Agreement.
WITNESSES BEAUFORT COUNTY
By:
Name: John Robinson
Title: Interim County Administrator
WITNESSES FRIENDS OF FORT FREMONT
HISTORICAL PARK
By:
Name: Barney Forsyth
Title: President
24
Item 9.
Page 6 of 6
Exhibit A
Park Use Terms and Conditions
1. The general public shall have access and use of the Park from dawn to dusk, Monday through Sunday, and
access and use of the History Center during the Friends operating hours , as stated in the approved annual
Operating Plan.
2. Friends shall keep the Park History Center reasonably s ecure and clean during their use of the Park, and
dispose of garbage, rubbish, and other waste generated by the Friends in a clean and safe manner.
3. Friends may support grounds maintenance of the Park through volunteer efforts including, but not limited
to (1) picking up of litter; (2) raking, weeding, and debris clean up during Clean Up Days, with prior written
notification to the County; and (3) assistance to the County for activities that benefit the Park when
requested by the County.
4. Friends will not deliberately or negligently destroy, deface, damage, impair, or remove any part of the Park,
or knowingly allow any person to do so while attending a Friends sponsored event at the Park.
5. Friends shall request County approval, via email, for use of the conference room at leas t two (2) business
days in advance of needed use, with the exception of scheduled History Center operating hours, as stated
in the approved annual Operating Plan.
6. Friends shall comply with the Beaufort County Passive Park Facility Rental Policy for use of the Park for
any activities considered an event. County shall not charge the facility rental fee to Friends, however Friends
may charge fees for event attendees for fundraising purposes.
7. Friends is authorized to use the Park for storage of artifacts and/or equipment as approved by County. Any
Friends property such as the diorama, displays, reference material and electromagnetic media stored on the
Park will be the responsibility of the Friends, the County is not liable for its loss or damage.
8. County reserves the right to relocate or remove any Friends property stored on the Park in order to meet the
needs of the County upon 24 -hour notice to the Friends via email, or immediately upon an emergency
situation.
9. Friends is authorized to purchase and sell interpretive, recreational and historic literature and materials to
visitors on the Park, at its own expense, and to retain and use the proceeds to pay the costs associated with
purchasing and selling the materials. All materials pu rchased and/or developed by Friends for sale or
display on the Park will receive final approval by the County.
10. Friends is authorized to apply for grants as well as seek in -kind and financial donations to support
preservation, promotional, and educational objectives for the P ark. Grant applications/proposals will be
approved by the County prior to the application submittal date.
11. Friends shall provide docen ts, greet visitors, provide orientation information, lead tours and answer
questions to the general public as described in the approved annual Operating Plan.
12. County retains management and decision -making authority on the P ark including, but not limited to ,
maintenance, security, repairs, and improvement projects.
13. Friends and County will mutually agree to a decorating plan for the History Center, including but not limited
to placement of the diorama, displays, signage, media and reference materials.
14. County retains final approval authority for any and all alterations or improvements on the P ark proposed
by the Friends. Any proposed contractors must provide proof of business license and insurance prior to any
work being performed.
15. Any and all approved structural alterations or improvements on the Park shall become the property of the
County, unless County has provided written approval to Friends to retain and remove an item. Friends shall
retain ownership of artifacts that have been donated to the Friends and a re not under ownership by the
County or other entity.
16. Friends agree not to change any locks on any door, mailbox, gate or otherwise. County will provide a 24 -
hour notice to Friends if a change to any lock is necessary.
25
Item 9.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO COUNCIL OF A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE RECOMMENDATION TO THE
GOVERNOR OF SOUTH CAROLINA FOR THE NOMINATION OF THE BEAUFORT COUNTY “CAROLINA BRIGHT”
ESTUARY SYSTEM INTO THE NATIONAL ESTUARY SYSTEM
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee May 13, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
(Councilman David Bartholomew)
(5 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The Pritchards Island Research and Living Shores Coalition requests that Council support their
recommendation to the Governor of South Carolina that the "Carolina Bight" estuary system be added as a
member of the National Estuary Program.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Pritchards Island Research and Living Shores Coalition requests Councils support in asking the Governor to
nominate the "Carolina Bight" estuary system to become a member of the National Estuary Program. Council’s
support is key in helping to unite the region in this voluntary, collaborative effort to develop an ecosystem
based management program.
FISCAL IMPACT:
There would be no direct fiscal impact on the County.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends Council support this endeavor and approve this Resolution.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
(Move forward to Council for Approval/Adoption or to not Approve on May 28, 2024)
26
Item 10.
RESOLUTION 2024 /
A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE RECOMMENDATION TO THE
GOVERNOR OF SOUTH CAROLINA FOR THE NOMINATION OF THE
BEAUFORT COUNTY “CAROLINA BRIGHT” ESTUARY SYSTEM INTO THE
NATIONAL ESTUARY SYSTEM.
Whereas, Beaufort County’s unique estuary, the “Carolina Bight,” comprises ten
rivers, two sounds, and 175,000 acres of salt marsh; and
Whereas, the “Carolina Bight” is a one-of-a-kind estuary providing an invaluable
habitat for wildlife while its tidal waters sustain a nutrient rich environment an d serve as
fish nurseries, seasonal stopovers for migratory birds, and breeding grounds for species
from oysters to sharks and marine mammals and reptiles; and
Whereas, two major U.S. Marine Corps installations and a Navy Support Facility
are located within the estuary system; and
Whereas, the “Carolina Bight” executes a crucial role in sheltering Beaufort
County and our people from storms and rising sea level, stabilizing shorelines, preventing
erosion, filtering our water, and storing carbon in our salt marsh at 10 times the rate of
tropical forests; and
Whereas, the estuary ecosystem of Beaufort County not only serves to provide
natural resiliency for our community it also provides valuable commercial, recreational,
and subsistence fishing for many while protecting our precious assets; and
Whereas, due to high tidal range, high salinity, abundance of salt marsh, and low
fresh water infiltration Beaufort County’s “Carolina Bight” is a unique estuary system of
national significance; and
Whereas, the Gullah Geechee community continues to have a close relationship
with the Sea Islands and waterways of the County as a pillar of their singular culture; and
Whereas, the National Estuary Program seeks to protect and improve waters,
habitats, and resou rces of the estuary; and the “Carolina Bight” is clearly a national
resource for study, research, and education.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the County Council of Beaufort
County, South Carolina that:
Beaufort County Council recommends the Governor o f South Carolina nominate
the “Carolina Bight” estuary system for inclusion in the National Estuary Program.
27
Item 10.
Adopted this ____ day of May 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By:
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
______________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
28
Item 10.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVE A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO
CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY THE APPLICANT OF FEE SIMPLE REAL PROPERTY
LOCATED ON HILTON HEAD ISLAND, KNOWN AS THE MITCHELVILLE TRACT (PIN# R510 005 000 0007
0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE FINAL VALUE AS DETERMINED BY A NEW APPRAISAL AFTER THE
COMPLETION OF AN UPDATED PLAT, RESOLUTION OF ALL LEGAL ISSUES/CLAIMS, CONTINGENT
UPON FULL LEGAL DESCRIPTION, AND SHALL REQUIRE THAT ANY FUNDS RECEIVED FROM
GRANTS, PRIVATE, FEDERAL, OR STATE FUNDING BE USED SOLELY TO REIMBURSE THE
EXPENDITURE OF THE GREEN SPACE PROGRAM
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee, Monday, May 13, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Mike McShane, Chairman of the Green Space Advisory Committee (10 -15 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
On December 11, 2023, the Community Services and Land Use Committee approved due diligence and negotiations
for the Mitchelville Tract (the “Property”). After this approval, staff undertook the necessary actions with the Town
of Hilton Head (the “Applicant”), and while county staff and the Applicant conducted their work on the property
with known/disclosed title issues, a consent order to quiet title and partition land by sale was filed on March 25,
2024. The consent order placed a court mandated deadline for purchase agreements to be made by April 30, 2024,
placing very specific restrictions/requirements on submissions. This prompted the Applicant to submit a purchase
agreement in accordance with the consent order. The consent order also states that the court shall hold a hearing no
later than May 14, 2024, to hear all purchase and sale agreements submitted. The consent order court action
prompted the Green Space Advisory Committee to consider making a recommendation on the application prior to
the completion of ongoing due diligence and negotiations. On April 26, 2024, the Green Space Advisory Committee
met, reviewed the consent order and existing due diligence, and recommended conditional approval for the
contribution of funds. The condition of their approval is for the contribution of funds not to exceed the final value as
determined by a new appraisal after the completion of an updated plat. The Committee’s recommendation also
included requiring all opportunities from funds acquired through other grant/partnership opportunities only be used
to reimburse funds contributed from the Green Space Program in order to leverage funds, as the applicant has not
explicitly included a matching contribution component as a part of their application. It has not been determined at
this time who will be responsible for applying for grant/collaboration funding opportunities and/or if ownership of
the parcel will dictate which governmental entity qualifies to apply for and receive said funding. As a part of the
program-required due diligence and discovery of matching/funding collaboration opportunities, which is a primary
requirement of the program (leveraging of funds), consideration of elements associated with government entity
ownership and land uses that would be allowed in perpetuity for the preservation procurement of the property is also
required. Because this application was received from another governmental entity and the property is located within
their municipal boundary, these items need to be known to allow for a complete application review and final staff
evaluation. Doing so will establish property operation requirements, program compliant land use restrictions, and
stewardship/maintenance plans for the property. Authorizing staff to complete the due diligence and negotiations
with the applicant will help facilitate a better understanding of the application and allow for a final staff evaluation.
This will also assist in achieving the program requirement of transparency and that the Green Space Program
operates in a fiscally responsible manner.
29
Item 11.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
The Mitchelville Tract is a 25 +/- acre property located in Historic Mitchelville on Hilton Head Island. It is heirs’
property, and the ownership is split among many parties. The Town of Hilton Head Island (the “Applicant”) applied to the
Green Space Program, requesting 100% funding, offering no municipal match/partnership contribution. The applicant,
through their application and discussions with staff and the Green Space Advisory Committee, have expressed an interest
in combining the parcel with the adjacent Fish Haul Creek Park to expand public access as a passive park. A preservation
outcome for this property would achieve several goals of the Green Space Program, including providing public access to
natural spaces and the waterfront, preservation of an intact natural habitat for plants and animals, protection of water
quality, preservation of an established maritime forest, environment and economic resilience, and protection of areas with
known historic and cultural significance.
FISCAL IMPACT:
TBD – Final amount is unknown until staff completes and reviews necessary due diligence in accordance with the Green
Space Advisory Committee’s recommendation and Green Space Program guidelines.
RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL:
Green Space Advisory Committee (GSAC) recommends approval with conditions. The recommendation is to recommend
proceeding with purchase of the Mitchelville tract to the Community Services and Land Use Committee, not to exceed
new appraisal on the property after completion of an updated plat, contingent on full legal description, and that any funds
received from grant, private, federal, or state would be reimbursed to the Green Space fund. The vote to approve the
motion was unanimous.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify, or deny a Resolution to expend funds (TBD) from the Green Space Program to contribute to
the procurement of a fee simple acquisition of the Mitchelville Tract located on Hilton Head Island.
30
Item 11.
Mitchelville road - FEE SIMPLE
Applicant – Town of Hilton Head Island
25 +/- 2 Acres
31
Item 11.
Mitchelville road - Fee SiMPle
32
Item 11.
1
RESOLUTION 2024/_____
RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVE A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO
CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY THE APPLICANT OF FEE SIMPLE REAL PROPERTY
LOCATED ON HILTON HEAD ISLAND, KNOWN AS THE MITCHELVILLE TRACT (PIN# R510 005 000
0007 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE FINAL VALUE AS DETERMINED BY A NEW APPRAISAL AFTER
THE COMPLETION OF AN UPDATED PLAT, RESOLUTION OF ALL LEGAL ISSUES/CLAIMS,
CONTINGENT UPON FULL LEGAL DESCRIPTION, AND SHALL REQUIRE THAT ANY FUNDS
RECEIVED FROM GRANTS, PRIVATE, FEDERAL, OR STATE FUNDING BE USED SOLELY TO
REIMBURSE THE EXPENDITURE OF THE GREEN SPACE PROGRAM
WHEREAS, the Mitchelville Tract (the “Property”) is one of the last remaining large,
undeveloped parcels of land located on Hilton Head Island and abuts an existing town owned park
that provides water access and recreation to the general public; and
WHEREAS, the Property is located in Historic Mitchelville on the shores of the Port Royal
Sound of Hilton Head Island, which has historic and cultural significance; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Council recognizes the need to preserve land that
provides scenic, natural, environmental, recreational, rural, and open space character which is
deemed essential to the County’s economic viability, environmental resilience, and overall quality
of life; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff received a Fee Simple Application from the
Town of Hilton Head Island requesting 100% funding from the Green Space Program which was
presented to the Green Space Advisory Committee at their December 6, 2023, meeting, where
the GSAC voted to recommend due diligence and negotiations to the Community Services and
Land Use Committee; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Community Services and Land Use Committee
authorized staff to engage in due diligence and negotiations during their December 12, 2023
meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff began conducting due diligence and negotiations
to further evaluate the property and application against the Beaufort County Green Space
Program Criteria to calculate the procurement benefits and overall value; and
WHEREAS, while Beaufort County and Town of Hilton Head staff undertook due
diligence and negotiations, a consent order to quiet title and partition land by sale was filed on
March 25, 2024 (“Exhibit A”), placing a court mandated deadline requiring all purchase
agreements be submitted by April 30, 2024, placing very specific restrictions and requirements
on submissions; and
33
Item 11.
2
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff presented the existing due diligence documents
and their evaluation to the Green Space Advisory Committee during their April 26, 2024
meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Green Space Advisory Committee reviewed the staff evaluation,
existing due diligence, and consent order, and voted to recommend conditional approval for the
grant of Green Space funds to contribute to the procurement of the Property, not to exceed the
final valuation as determined by a new appraisal after the completion of an updated plat,
contingent upon full legal description; and
WHEREAS, the Green Space Advisory Committee additionally recommended that all
funds acquired through other grant/funding opportunities be used solely to reimburse the Green
Space Program grant in order to leverage program funds, because matching funds were not
offered by the Town of Hilton Head or others; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council finds that it is in the best interest of the citizens and
residents of Beaufort County for the Interim County Administrator to execute the necessary
documents to contribute to funding for the procurement of a government owned fee simple
acquisition of real property for the purposes of purchasing development rights and providing public
passive recreation access.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Beaufort County Council, duly assembled, does
hereby authorize a Resolution authorizing the Interim County Administrator to execute the
documents necessary and to provide funds to contribute to the procurement by the Applicant of
fee simple real property located on Hilton Head Island, known as the Mitchelville tract (PIN# R510
005 000 0007 0000), not to exceed the final value as determined by a new appraisal after the
completion of an updated plat, resolution of all legal issues/claims, contingent upon full legal
description, and shall require that any funds received from grants, private, federal, or state funding
be used solely to reimburse the expenditure of the Green Space Program.
Adopted this ____ day of ____________, 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY:
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
34
Item 11.
Page 1 of 11
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
) FOURTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT ) CIVIL ACTION NO. 2020-CP-07-02301
)
GEORGIA HARRISON,
BARBARA HARRISON, JOYCE
ELLEN HARRISON, WILLIAM S.
HARRISON, III, STANLEY
ROBERTS, and DIANA
MENDHEIM, individually and as
agent and attorney in fact,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
STEPHANIE LORRAINE
KIRKLAND, GARY LAMONT
KIRKLAND, KEITA NICOLE
WHITE, CHERYL KIRKLAND,
WILLIAM CHARLES KIRKLAND,
PAULETTE KIRKLAND, PAUL T.
ALLBRIGHT, CHRISTOPHER
KIRKLAND AND SHAWN
KIRKLAND,
Defendants.
_________________________________
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
CONSENT ORDER
This action was originally filed on November 24, 2020, to quiet title and
partition land by sale pursuant to the Clementa C. Pinckney Uniform Partition
of Heirs’ Property Act, codified at S.C. Code Annot. Section 15-61-310 et. seq.
The case was referred to the undersigned Master in Equity on April 21, 2021.
On October 20, 2021, the Defendants were notified by Order of their
rights to purchase all of the Plaintiff cotenants’ ownership interest in the
property that is the subject of this action (the “Property”) as allowed under the
Pinckney Act. The Defendants had until December 22, 2021 to pay their
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
Exhibit "A"
35
Item 11.
Page 2 of 11
apportioned prices into Court, and by that Order, if the Defendants failed or
refused to pay their apportioned prices into Court by December 22, 2021, then
the Property was to be partitioned by sale at a purchase price of not less than
$9,100,000.00 and the Plaintiffs were authorized by that Order, to enter into,
or ratify, a contract of sale of the Property for not less than that price. None of
the Defendants paid their apportioned prices into Court by December 22, 2021.
On December 22, 2021, Defendants filed their Motion for Relief of
Judgment and for Extension of Time to Tender Purchase Price and Right of
First Refusal. On January 20, 2022, the Court denied said motion. Thereafter,
Defendants filed a Motion for Reconsideration of the January 20, 2022 Order,
and the Court denied that Motion for Reconsideration on March 7, 2022.
On March 9, 2022, the Defendants filed a Notice of Appeal to the Court of
Appeals, which was assigned Case No. 2022-000277. That appeal was
dismissed on March 15, 2023 and the Remittitur filed on April 5, 2023.
Just prior to the Court of Appeals’ dismissal of Case No. 2022-000277,
the Defendants herein filed a new Notice of Appeal on March 13, 2023, seeking
the Court of Appeals’ review of my Order of November 7, 2022 that denied the
Defendants’ September 7, 2022 motion entitled “Defendants’ Motion For Stay
And Waiver of Supersedeas Bond Or In the Alternative A Nominal Bond
Pending Appeal” and of my Order of March 8, 2023 that denied the Defendants’
Motion For Reconsideration of the November 7, 2022 Order. That appeal was
assigned Case No. 2023-000438, and remains pending at the present time.
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
36
Item 11.
Page 3 of 11
Although this case is currently on appeal, the parties now appear before
this Court with a joint request for the Court to enter a Consent Order that
allows the Petitioners to move forward with negotiations to sell the Property to
a third party for the highest dollar amount that can be negotiated, with the
caveat that Defendants will have the right to match the specific terms and
conditions of the final agreement and acquire the Plaintiffs’ 98.82 percent
ownership interest according to the following timetable:
1. The Plaintiffs are free to (and encouraged to) proceed to negotiate a
final written agreement for the sale and purchase of the Property at
the highest price possible above $9,100,000.00, which will benefit
all heirs. Plaintiffs must provide copies of all purchase and sale
agreements for the sale of the Property (including all amendments,
exhibits and attachments) along with evidence of proof of funds
from each proposed purchaser, to Defendants, in the manner set
forth in Section 3 below, and to the Court no later than 4:00 pm
EDT on April 30, 2024. The Court shall thereafter hold a hearing
no later than May 14, 2024, regarding all purchase and sale
agreements for the sale of the Property submitted by the stated
deadline so the parties may state their respective positions on each
agreement to assist the Court with its approval of an agreement for
the sale of the Property(the “Approved Agreement”). While the
purchase price will be a primary factor the Court will consider, the
Court shall also consider other commercially reasonable factors
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
37
Item 11.
Page 4 of 11
including, but not limited to, the following: (1) cash v. non-cash
offer; (2) amount of earnest money; (3) length of due diligence
period, including reservation of right to extend due diligence
period; (4) timing, conditions and amount of any earnest money
becoming nonrefundable, (5) maximum time to close; and (6) proof
of funds acceptable to the Court; provided, however, that proof of
funds related to any purchase and sale agreement with a town,
municipality, governmental entity, or similar body may consist of a
sworn certification by the chief administrative officer, such as a
Town Manager or a County Administrator, that sufficient funds
have been allocated for the acquisition of the Property. No
purchase and sale agreement may be submitted to the Court for
consideration to which a town, municipality, governmental entity,
or similar body is a party that requires further approvals (including
full funding authorization, resolutions, ordinances, approvals and
allocated sourcing of the same) from the governing body; and any
submissions of the same shall be considered null and void. The
planned or intended use of the Property by a prospective purchaser
shall not be a factor in the determination of the Approved
Agreement. The Approved Agreement may provide that all parties
to this action will convey their undivided ownership interests in the
Property by limited warranty deed and that this Court will convey
the interests of any other claimants by Masters’ Deed. For
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
38
Item 11.
Page 5 of 11
avoidance of doubt, Defendants are not prohibited from presenting
Plaintiff with a purchase and sale agreement to purchase their
undivided interests in the Property.
2. Any purchase and sale agreement for the sale of the Property to a
third party negotiated by the Plaintiffs must contain provisions
that acknowledge that (a) the purchase and sale agreement is
subject to review and approval by the Court; and (b) the Court will
provide the Defendants an option to acquire the Plaintiffs’
undivided interests in the Property (the “Option”) on the same
terms and conditions set forth in such purchase and sale
agreement for a purchase price equal to 98.828122% of the
contract sales price for the Property; provided, however, (i) that
regardless of the due diligence period provided for in the Approved
Agreement, Defendants shall have a due diligence period that is
the greater of (A) the due diligence period provided in the Approved
Agreement, or (B) sixty (60) days from the date that Defendants
exercise the Option; (ii) that regardless of the length of time
between the end of the due diligence period and the date of closing
of the sale of the Property under the Approved Agreement (the
“Close Period”), Defendants shall have a Close Period that is the
greater of (A) the Close Period provided in the Approved Agreement,
or (B) fifteen (15) days; and (iii) that regardless of any proposed or
intended use of the Property stated in the Approved Agreement,
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
39
Item 11.
Page 6 of 11
Defendants shall have no restrictions regarding use of the Property
and any provisions of the Approved Agreement regarding
limitations on the use of Property are, as to the Defendants, null
and void and of no effect. Defendants must exercise the Option by
delivering written notice of such exercise to the Court and to
counsel for the Plaintiffs no later than 4:00 PM EDT on the date
that is ten (10) business days after the Court’s approval of the
Approved Agreement.
3. All purchase and sale agreements for the sale of the Property
negotiated by the Plaintiffs shall be submitted to the Court for final
approval and simultaneously shall be given to the Defendants by e-
mail and overnight delivery of a copy of the purchase and sale
agreement to the Defendants’ attorney Charles E. Houston to his
email address chouston@houstonlawfirm.net and overnight
delivery of a hard copy to his office address of The Houston Law
Firm, LLC, 1011 Bay Street, Suite 2A, Beaufort, SC 29902, and to
the Defendants’ consulting counsel, Earsa R. Jackson, at her email
to EJackson@clarkhill.com with a hard copy overnighted to Earsa
Jackson, Esq., Clark Hill, 901 Main Street, Suite 6000, Dallas, TX
75202. If Defendants timely exercise the Option, their written
notice of exercise of the Option shall be accompanied by evidence
acceptable to the Court of Defendants’ financial ability to close the
purchase of Plaintiffs’ undivided interests in the Property pursuant
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
40
Item 11.
Page 7 of 11
to the terms of the Approved Agreement. Upon the Court’s
approval of Defendants’ financial ability to close the purchase of
the Property, Plaintiffs must thereafter deal exclusively with
Defendants during the applicable due diligence period and Close
Period.
4. If the Defendants fail or refuse to timely exercise the Option, then
the Option shall conclusively be waived and discharged, and the
Plaintiffs shall proceed forward with the Purchaser under the
Approved Agreement on the same terms and conditions of the
Approved Agreement. Any modification of purchase price or any
terms of the Approved Agreement after the expiration of the Option
requires Court approval and restarts Defendants’ ten (10) business
day Option. At closing, the net sales proceeds representing the
Defendants’ undivided ownership interests in the Property will be
distributed to the Defendants by transmittal of such amounts to
the Defendants’ attorney’s Trust Account or to the Office of the
Clerk of Court for Beaufort County. Each party shall be
responsible for payment of its own attorney’s fees and costs
incurred related to this case and the sale of the Property, including
but not limited to broker, consulting, and attorney’s fees.
5. In exchange for the Plaintiffs’ agreement to allow the Defendants to
have the Option set forth herein, the Defendants agree that if and
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
41
Item 11.
Page 8 of 11
when a final purchase and sale agreement is reached for
conveyance of the Property to a third party at a price above
$9,100,000.00 and is approved by the Court, upon the timely
exercise of, or the expiration of, the Option, (a) all further claims
for relief remaining in this case are waived and ended and this
Consent Order shall bring this case to a close and end same at
such time, except as to supplementary proceedings as may be
necessary or desirable to facilitate the closing of the sale of the
Property under the Approved Agreement and the distribution of the
net proceeds of such sale, and to enforce the terms of this Consent
Order; (b) the Defendants shall immediately dismiss their pending
appeal to the Court of Appeals; and (c) Defendants waive any right
(i) to appeal regarding any matters in this case, and (ii) to file any
new actions regarding the Property. This agreement by all parties
to end the case and all appeals upon the Court’s approval of the
Approved Agreement and the timely exercise of or expiration of
Defendants’ Option is binding on all parties whether or not the
Defendants complete the purchase of the Plaintiffs’ 98.828122
percent ownership interests in the Property. For avoidance of
doubt, Plaintiffs, too, waive any right to appeal regarding matters
in this case.
6. Regardless of whether the Defendants’ Option is timely exercised or
expires, Plaintiffs and Defendants shall reasonably cooperate with
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
42
Item 11.
Page 9 of 11
each other to convey their undivided interests in the Property,
including cooperation related to the closing on the purchase and
sale of the Property, such as any necessary supplementary order in
this matter; the timely execution and delivery of limited warranty
deeds by all Plaintiffs and all Defendants to the ultimate purchaser
of the Property under the Approved Agreement, be that the
Defendants or the original contract purchaser; Master’s Deed
conveying to Defendants or to the original contract purchaser the
undivided interest in the Property held by any persons or entities
claiming any right, title, interest in, or lien upon the Property;
reasonable requirements of a national title insurance company to
obtain an ALTA Owner’s Policy of Title Insurance; cancellation and
satisfaction of record of any valid lis pendens affecting the
Property; and dismissal of this matter with prejudice.
7. In the event the sale of the Property under the Approved Agreement
does not timely occur, Plaintiffs must notify the Court and
Defendants of the same within forty-eight hours of the same.
8. For avoidance of doubt, all rights of the Defendants under this
Consent Order shall inure to any designee, joint venturer, or other
party the Defendants cooperate with to submit a purchase and sale
agreement for the Property.
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
43
Item 11.
Page 10 of 11
9. If any party violates any term or provision of this Consent Order,
and another party seeks to enforce compliance with this Consent
Order by supplementary proceedings in this matter, the prevailing
party shall be entitled to recover the reasonable costs of enforcing
compliance with this Consent Order, including, without limitation,
attorneys’ fees and court costs.
AND IT IS SO ORDERED this _____day of March, 2024.
s/
Marvin Dukes, III
Master In Equity and Special Circuit
Court Judge of Beaufort County
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
44
Item 11.
Page 11 of 11
WE CONSENT:
/s/ Thomas C. Taylor
Thomas C. Taylor (SC Bar No. 5499)
Law Office of Thomas C. Taylor, LLC
10 Pinckney Colony Road, Bldg. 400
Post Office Box 1808
Bluffton, South Carolina 29910
(843) 785-5050
tom@thomastaylorlaw.com
CO-COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS
March 22, 2024
/s/ Chester C. Williams
Chester C. Williams
Law Office of Chester C. Williams, LLC
17 Executive Park Road, Suite 2
Post Office Box 6028
Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29938
(843) 842-5411
firm@ccwlaw.net
CO-COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS
March 22, 2024
/s/ Charles E. Houston, Jr.
Charles E. Houston, Jr. (SC Bar No. 2663)
The Houston Law Firm LLC
1011 Bay Street, Suite 2A
Beaufort, SC 29902
(843) 684-0211
chouston@houstonlawfirm.net
COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANTS
March 22, 2024
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
45
Item 11.
Beaufort Common Pleas
Case Caption: Georgia Harrison , plaintiff, et al VS Stephanie Lorraine Kirkland ,
defendant, et al
Case Number: 2020CP0702301
Type: Order/Consent Order
So Ordered:
s/Marvin H. Dukes III #3069
Electronically signed on 2024-03-25 10:21:31 page 12 of 12
ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Mar 25 10:28 AM - BEAUFORT - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2020CP0702301
46
Item 11.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVE A RESOLUTION TO ESTABLISH BEAUFORT
COUNTY’S COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PRIORITY LIST
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee
May 13, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Audra Antonacci – Ogden, Assistant County Administrator – Community Services
5 minutes
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The Beaufort Couty Community Development Priority List is updated annually.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
The Beaufort County Development Priority List is updated annually and is provided to the
Lowcountry Council of Government as a pre-requisite for Community Development Block
Grant Program Applications. The SC CDBG Program is designed to provide assistance to
units of local government in improving economic opportunities and meeting community
revitalization needs, particularly for persons of low or moderate income (LMI). The annual
allocation from HUD for the program is administered by the SC Department of Commerce –
Division of Grant Administration.
FISCAL IMPACT:
None
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval of a resolution to establish Beaufort County’s Community
Development Priority List.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve a Resolution to establish Beaufort County’s Community Development Priority List
or motion to deny a Resolution to establish Beaufort County’s Development Priority List.
47
Item 12.
RESOLUTION 2024/___
A RESOLUTION ADOPTING PRIORITY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NEEDS
WHEREAS, every year the county is required to provide the Lowcountry Council of
Governments with a “Community Development Priority” list, as a prerequisite to applying for
federal Community Development Block Grant funds; and
WHEREAS, during the April 22, 2024 Beaufort County Council meeting Lowcountry
Council of Governments presented the SC CDBG Program; and,
WHEREAS, at the May 13, 2024 meeting of the Community Services Committee the
County’s priority community development needs were discussed and an opportunity for public
comment was provided;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Beaufort County Council, in meeting duly
assembled, does hereby affirm that the County’s priority community needs for 2024 are as
follows:
1. Provide new quantifiable public services and materials that will primarily benefit low
and moderate-income (LMI) individuals and are needed to prepare for, respond to, or
prevent the spread of coronavirus. These activities include but are not limited to:
a. After school programs.
b. Alterations or retrofitting of publicly owned facilities to facilitate compliance
with public health guidelines. (HVAC and air filtration improvements, expansion
of interior public spaces to facilitate social distancing, and equipment or public
improvements needed to expand or improve internet access).
2. Drainage improvements in low-and-moderate income neighborhoods as identified in
our capital improvement plan.
3. Funding for public facilities, transportation, recreation centers, and services; other
activities that strengthen existing quality of life (parking garage, event center, education
and workforce development, public health, and safety “pathways”).
4. Housing programs – Water and sewer hookups to replace failing septic systems and
wells in low-and-moderate income communities and/or neighborhoods; housing repair
for low-and-moderate income homeowners and for rental units occupied by low-and-
moderate income renters; programs to promote new affordable rental housing;
programs and policies to promote homeownership for low-and-moderate income
households; and incentives to promote affordable infill housing.
48
Item 12.
5. Streetscape improvements in all areas of the county that contain low-and-moderate
income communities and/or neighborhoods.
6. Improvements to public recreation facilities that benefit low-and-moderate income
citizens of the County.
7. Extend access and affordable options to digitally underserved areas through
coordination with Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and State Office of Resiliency.
8. Disaster Recovery – Provide recovery activities to low-income areas affected by
Presidentially declared disasters.
Adopted this ____ day of May, 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY: ______________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST: __________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
49
Item 12.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 38 ENVIRONMENT, ARTICLE VI SINGLE USE PLASTIC BAGS
SECTION 38-161, PURPOSE; SECTION 38-162 DEFINITIONS; SECTION 38-163 REGULATIONS; AND
SECTION 38-164 EXEMPTIONS OF THE BEAUFORT COUNTY CODE OF ORDINANCES.
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee May 13 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
(Deputy County Attorney Brian Hulbert)
(5 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The Keep Beaufort County Beautiful Board requests that Beaufort County Council pass an ordinance
to eliminate the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and polystyrene/plastic foam in order to
protect marine wildlife and local wildlife, in order to maximize the operating life of landfills and
lessen the economic and environmental costs of managing waste. If Council would like to take this
action it is best accomplished by amending our current Single Use Plastic Bag ordinance.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Amend the Single Use Plastic Bag ordinance to eliminate the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws
and polystyrene/plastic foam in order to protect marine wildlife and local wildlife, in order to
maximize the operating life of landfills and lessen the economic and environmental costs of
managing waste.
FISCAL IMPACT:
There would be no direct fiscal impact on the County.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff has no recommendation in relation to the proposed ordinance amendments.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
1) Move forward to Council for Approval/Adoption or to not Approve on May 28, 2024; or
2) Move forward to Council for Approval/Adoption or to not Approve at a future meeting after the
proposed amendments are forwarded to the municipalities in Beaufort County for comment and
concurrence in an attempt to have a uniform ordinance throughout Beaufort County; or
3) Forward to the municipalities in Beaufort County for comment and concurrence in an attempt to
have a uniform ordinance throughout Beaufort County and then bring back to the Community
Services and Land Use Committee for further discussion after receiving comments from the
municipalities.
50
Item 13.
ORDINANCE 2024/ ____
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 38 ENVIRONMENT, ARTICLE VI SINGLE USE PLASTIC BAGS
SECTION 38-161, PURPOSE; SECTION 38-162 DEFINITIONS; SECTION 38-163 REGULATIONS; AND
SECTION 38-164 EXEMPTIONS OF THE BEAUFORT COUNTY CODE OF ORDINANCES.
WHEREAS, Chapter 38, Article VI Single Use Plastic Bags was adopted on January 22,
2018 for the purpose of improving the environment of the county by encouraging the use of
reusable checkout bags and recyclable paper carryout bags and banning the use of single -use
plastic bags for retail checkout of purchased goods ; and
WHEREAS, The Keep Beaufort County Beautiful Board requests that Beaufort County
Council pass an ordinance to eliminate the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and
polystyrene/plastic foam in order to protect marine wildlife and local wildlife, in order to
maximize the operating life of landfills and lessen the economic and environmental costs of
managing waste; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council determines that in order to discourage and
decrease the use of certain carryout plastic bags, plastic straws and expanded polystyrene food
service products, it is necessary to regulate such use; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council determines that regulating and eventually
prohibiting the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and polystyrene/plastic foam take-
out food packing products and replacing them with food service ware that is locally recyclable
or compostable and restricting the use of polystyrene/plastic foam products that are not wholly
encapsulated or encased by a more durable material will further protect the county, its citizens
and visitors, its marine life and wildlife, and will support the county’s goal of reducing waste
and litter in an effort to attain a cleaner and healthier environment and reduce the economic
impact of non-recyclable waste; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council wishes to create a uniform standard regarding the
ban on the use plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and polystyrene/plastic foam products
throughout the county; it therefore finds it is the best interest of the county’s residents,
visitors, marine life and wildlife to eliminate the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and
polystyrene/plastic foam products by business establishments, thereby encouraging the use of
reusable carryout bags and recyclable products in an effort to eliminate non-biodegradable
waste and alleviate the economic impact of said products; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council wishes to amend the Single Use Plastic Bags
ordinance to eliminate the use of plastic carryout bags, plastic straws and polystyrene/plastic
foam products by business establishments, thereby encouraging the use of reusable carryout
bags and recyclable products in an effort to eliminate non-biodegradable waste and alleviate
the economic impact of said products.
51
Item 13.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL THAT:
Chapter 38 Environment, Article VI Single Use Plastic Bags which appears in Beaufort County
Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to reflect the language as depicted in exhibit A .
Adopted this _______ day of ________________ 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: ________________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
___________________________
Sarah w. Brock, JD, Clerk to Council
52
Item 13.
EXHIBIT A
PART I - GENERAL ORDINANCES
Chapter 38 - ENVIRONMENT
ARTICLE VI. SINGLE-USE PLASTIC BAGS, STRAWS, POLYSTYRENE/PLASTIC FOAM PRODUCTS
Beaufort County, South Carolina, Code of Ordinances Created: 2024-02-19 14:45:10 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50)
Page 1 of 5
ARTICLE VI. SINGLE-USE PLASTIC BAGS, STRAWS, POLYSTYRENE/PLASTIC FOAM
PRODUCTS.
Sec. 38-161. Purpose and intent.
This article is adopted to improve the environment of the county by encouraging the use
of reusable checkout bags and recyclable paper carryout bags and banning the use of single-use
plastic bags for retail checkout of purchased goods. Business establishments are encouraged to
make reusable bags available for sale, to make recyclable paper carryout bags available for
distribution and to continue offering bins for all recyclable products including, but not limited
to, plastic products. This article does not impose a tax on the use of plastic products of any kind
including, but not limited to, single use plastic bags.
This Chapter is adopted to improve the environment of the county by banning the use of plastic
carryout bags for distribution and use by food or grocery establishments, food providers,
retailers, stores, shops, sellers, vendors and other merchants for their customers to carry,
transport or store purchased goods or products; banning the use and distribution of plastic
straws; and banning the use and distribution of polystyrene/plastic foam products. Businesses
are encouraged to have reusable carryout bags available for sale and provide recyclable paper
carryout bags to customers; and are also encouraged to provide bins on the premises for all
recyclable products including, but not limited to, plastic and aluminum waste. This Ordinance
does not impose a tax on the use of plastic or polystyrene/plastic foam products of any kind
including, but not limited to, plastic carryout bags.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Sec. 38-162. Definitions.
The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, shall have the
meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a
different meaning:
Business establishment. Any commercial enterprise that provides carryout bags to its
customers through its employees or independent contractors associated with the business. The
term includes sole proprietorships, joint ventures, partnerships, corporations, or any other legal
entity, whether for profit or not for profit. Any food or grocery establishment, food provider,
retail or commercial enterprise that provides plastic carryout bags, single-use plastic products
(including but not limited to plastic straws) or polystyrene/plastic foam products to its
customers through its employees, agents or independent contractors associated with that
53
Item 13.
Created: 2024-02-19 14:45:10 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50)
Page 2 of 5
business. The term includes, but is not limited to, retailers, stores, shops, sellers, vendors,
warehouses, merchants or any other entity that sells goods and products that use and
distribute plastic carryout bags, single-use plastic products or polystyrene/plastic foam
products to their customers to be used on the business’ premises or to carry, transport or
stores purchased good or products purchased from the business establishment.
Customer. A person who purchases merchandise from a business establishment.
Disposable Food Service Ware. (Interchangeable with “to go containers” and “food
packaging materials”) Any product, including but not limited to bowls, containers, clamshells
containers, cartons, cups, cutlery, napkins, plates, straws, stirrers, trays, and other items
designed for one time use associated with prepared foods, including without limitation, service
ware for takeout foods and/or food from partially consumed meals prepared by food providers.
Polystyrene/plastic foam. A blown, expanded and extruded polystyrene (often called
Styrofoam) or other plastic foam processed by multiple techniques into consumer products.
The products generally include, but are not limited to, bowls, cups, clamshell containers, egg
cartons, coolers, ice chests, beach and pool toys, plates, shipping boxes and packaging, food
packaging trays.
Plastic carryout bag. A bag provided by a business establishment to a customer typically
at the point of sale for the purpose of a onetime use to transport purchases, which is
predominately made of plastic derived from either petroleum or a biologically-based source,
including compostable and biodegradable bags but excluding reusable carryout bags.
Reusable carryout bag. A carryout bag that is specifically designed and manufactured for
multiple reuse, and meets the following criteria:
(1) Displays in a highly visible manner on the bag exterior, language describing the bag's
ability to be reused and recycled;
(2) Has a handle; except that handles are not required for carryout bags constructed out
of recyclable paper with a height of less than 14 inches and width of less than eight
inches; and
(3) Is constructed out of any of the following materials:
(a) Cloth, other washable fabric, or other durable materials, whether woven or non-
woven; or
(b) Recyclable plastic, with a minimum thickness of 2.25 mils;
(1) Displays in a highly visible manner on the bag exterior, language describing the
bag's ability to be reused and recycled;
(2) Has handles which are stitched and not heat-fused; except for paper bags.
Handles are not required for carryout bags constructed out of recyclable paper with a height of
less than 14 inches and width of less than eight inches; and
(3) Is constructed out of any of the following materials:
54
Item 13.
Created: 2024-02-19 14:45:10 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50)
Page 3 of 5
(a) Cloth, other washable fabric, or other durable materials, whether woven or non-
woven;
(b) Recyclable plastic, with a minimum thickness of 4 mils; or
(c) Recyclable paper.
Single-use plastic carryout bag. A bag provided by a business establishment to a customer
typically at the point of sale for the purpose of transporting purchases, which is made
predominantly of plastic derived from either petroleum or a biologically based source. "Single-
use plastic carryout bag" includes compostable and biodegradable bags, but does not include
reusable carryout bags.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Sec. 38-163. Regulations.
(a) No person may provide single-use plastic carryout bags at any county facility, county-
sponsored event, or any event held on county property.
(b) No business establishment within the unincorporated county limits may provide single-use
plastic carryout bags to its customers.
(c) Business establishments within the county limits are strongly encouraged to provide
prominently displayed signage advising customers of the benefit of reducing, reusing and
recycling and promoting the use of reusable carryout bags and recyclable paper carryout
bags by customers.
(d) No person may provide plastic straws or polystyrene/plastic foam products at any county
facility or any event sponsored by the county or held on county property.
(e) No food or grocery establishment or food provider within the unincorporated areas of
Beaufort County may provide plastic straws, plastic food service ware or disposable food
service ware containing polystyrene/plastic foam to its customers.
(f) All Beaufort County facilities shall use recyclable or compostable products for disposable
food service ware.
(g) No business establishment within the unincorporated areas of Beaufort County can sell,
rent or provide any polystyrene/plastic foam products to its customers, except as
exempted in this Ordinance.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Sec. 38-164. Exemptions.
This article shall not apply to:
55
Item 13.
Created: 2024-02-19 14:45:10 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50)
Page 4 of 5
(a) Laundry dry cleaning bags, door-hanger bags, newspaper bags, or packages of multiple
bags intended for use as garbage, pet waste, or yard waste;
(b) Bags provided by pharmacists, physicians, dentists, or veterinarians to contain
prescription drugs or other medical necessities products;
(c) Bags used by a customer inside a business establishment to:
(1) Contain bulk items, such as produce, nuts, grains, candy, or small hardware items;
(2) Contain or wrap frozen foods, meat, or fish, whether or not prepackaged;
(3) Contain or wrap flowers, potted plants or other items to prevent moisture damage to
other purchases; or
(4) Contain unwrapped prepared foods or bakery goods; and
(d) Bags of any type that the customer bring to the store for their own use for carrying away
from the store goods that are not placed in a bag provided by the store;
(e). Trays made from polystyrene/plastic foam which are used to contain meats, fruits and
dairy products;
(f) Plastic straws that are necessary due to medical or physical conditions;
(g) Products made of polystyrene/plastic foam which are wholly encapsulated or encased by a
more durable material, including but not limited to surfboards, boats and life preservers;
(h) Any products purchased, prepared or packaged outside the unincorporated area of
Beaufort County that are delivered to or sold in the county;
(i) Any organization providing emergency services during a declared state of emergency or an
emergency situation where the immediate preservation of the public peace, health or
safety is involved;
(j) Bags used by 501(c)(3) organizations associated with schools, religious groups and
humanitarian organizations to distribute food, grocery products, clothing or other
household items;
(k) Meat and seafood trays, egg cartons, plastic lids used to contain foods and liquids, single-
use condiment packaging and carry out cutlery (spoons, forks, etc.);
(l) Items used for ready-to-eat foods by food and grocery establishments that are
predominantly made of paper, including: wax paper products, paper products with plastic
inserts/sections, and paper cups and bowls that are lined with plastic;
(m) Construction products made from polystyrene/plastic foam, if the products are used in
compliance with the Beaufort County Code and used in a manner preventing the
polystyrene/plastic foam from being released into the environment;
(n) Any packaging used by a food or grocery establishment that is required to comply with
South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control Retail Food
56
Item 13.
Created: 2024-02-19 14:45:10 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50)
Page 5 of 5
Establishment Regulation 61-25 and similar food safety regulations, or are required to
comply with any federal food safety laws and regulations, shall be exempt from the
provisions of this Ordinance.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Sec. 38-165. Penalties.
(a) Any business establishment that violates or fails to comply with any of the provisions of
this chapter after a written warning notice has been issued for that violation shall be
deemed guilty of a misdemeanor. The penalty shall not exceed $100.00 for a first violation;
$200.00 for a second violation within any 12-month period; and $500.00 for each
additional violation within any 12-month period. Each day that a violation continues will
constitute a separate offense.
(b) In addition to the penalties set forth in this section, repeated violations of this chapter by a
person who owns, manages, operates, is a business agent of, or otherwise controls a
business establishment may result in the suspension or revocation of the business license
issued to the premises on which the violations occurred. No business license shall be
issued or renewed until all fines outstanding against the applicant for violations of this
chapter are paid in full.
(c) Violation of this chapter is hereby declared to be a public nuisance, which may be abated
by the county by restraining order, preliminary and permanent injunction, or other means
provided for by law, and the county may take action to recover the costs of the nuisance
abatement.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Sec. 38-166. Effective date and review.
(a) The provisions of this article shall take effect eight months from the date county council
enacts the ordinance codified in this article provided that the same or a substantially
similar ordinance has been adopted by every municipality in Beaufort County. If the same
or substantially similar ordinance has not been adopted by every municipality in Beaufort
County on the date county council adopts this article, then this article shall take effect on
the date the last municipality does adopt such an ordinance.
(b) Provided this article takes effect, the county will implement a program to evaluate the
success of this article by soliciting input, including statistical data, from all parties and
organizations with an interest in this legislation. County council will review the evaluation
three years from the date this article goes into effect.
( Ord. No. 2018/5, 1-22-2018 )
Secs. 38-167—38-190. Reserved.
57
Item 13.
Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.