County Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
Beaufort County · Beaufort County · County Council Meeting · meeting of Feb 26, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Beaufort County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
County Council Meeting
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, February 26, 2024
5:00 PM
AGENDA
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
JOSEPH F. PASSIMENT, CHAIRMAN LAWRENCE MCELYNN, VICE CHAIR
DAVID P. BARTHOLOMEW PAULA BROWN
LOGAN CUNNINGHAM GERALD DAWSON
YORK GLOVER ALICE HOWARD
MARK LAWSON THOMAS REITZ
ANNA MARIA TABERNIK
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND INVOCATION- Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - January 22, 2024, February 5, 2024 (Special Called County Council Meeting), &
February 12, 2024.
6. ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
CITIZEN COMMENTS
7. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD - 15 MINUTES TOTAL
Anyone who wishes to speak during the Citizen Comment portion of the meeting will limit their
comments to AGENDA ITEMS ONLY and speak no longer than three (3) minutes. Speakers will address
Council in a respectful manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting, refraining from the use of
profane, abusive, or obscene language. In accordance with Beaufort County's Rules and Procedures,
giving of a speaker's time to another is not allowed.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
8. LIASION AND COMMITTEE REPORTS
1
County Council Agenda – Beaufort County, SC
PUBLIC HEARINGS AND ACTION ITEMS
9. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA
10. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE
THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY
WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND (FISCAL
IMPACT: Beaufort County will receive $30,250 from the Buyer. 70% of the funds from the sale will be
deposited into the Rural and Critical Bond Fund (4500 -80-0000-47010) to be used towards future
acquisitions by the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program 30% of the funds will be reimbursed
to the Town of Hilton Head)
11. APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PROVISION OF FUNDS TO LOWCOUNTRY AREA
TRANSPORTATION STUDY (LATS) FOR BEAUFORT COUNTY ’S PORTION OF THE LOCAL MATCH FOR THE
NORTHERN TRANSIT STUDY, THE SC 315/46 AND BLUFFTON PARKWAY EXTENSION STUDY, AND THE
BLUFFTON PARKWAY FROM SC 170 TO US 278 AT THE BLUFFTON PARKWAY FLYOVER STUDY; AND
FURTHER TO AUTHORIZE THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATO R TO EXECUTE MEMORANDUMS OF
UNDERSTANDING WITH LOWCOUNTRY COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF THE
REGIONAL STUDIES (FISCAL IMPACT: The match for the Bluffton Parkway’s study will come from Bluffton
Transportation Impact Fees account 2300 -30-0000-51160 with a balance of $7,331,998.85. The match
for the SC315/SC 46’s study and the Northern Transit Study will come from Road Use Fee funds
professional services account 2342-30-0000-51160 with a balance of $1,558,409.65)
CITIZEN COMMENTS
12. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD- 15 MINUTES TOTAL
Anyone who wishes to speak during the Citizen Comment portion of the meeting will limit their
comments and speak no longer than three (3) minutes. Speakers will address Council in a respectful
manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting, refraining fr om the use of profane, abusive, or
obscene language. In accordance with Beaufort County's Rules and Procedures, giving of a speaker's
time to another is not allowed.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
13. PURSUANT TO S. C. CODE SECTION 30-4-70(A)(2) TO RECEIVE LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE ADVICE RELATES
TO PENDING LITIGATION (SCRATCH GOLF, LLC V BEAUFORT COUNTY AND BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL)
14. PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SEC. 30-4-70(A)(2): DISCUSSION OF PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS
AND MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE.
15. PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SECTION 30-4-70(A)(2): DISCUSSION OF MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-
CLIENT PRIVILEGE (INQUIRIES AND INVESTIGATIONS PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SECTION 4-9-660)
END OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
16. MATTERS ARISING OUT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
17. ADJOURNMENT
2
County Council Agenda – Beaufort County, SC
CONSENT AGENDA
Items Originating from the Finance, Administration, and Economic Development Committee
1. THIRD READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING FIFTEEN PERCENT OF FY24 GROSS STATE
ACCOMMODATIONS TAX REVENUE TO DEVELOPMENT OF WORKFORCE HOUSING (FISCAL IMPACT: If
approved, Council will be appropriating and committing fifteen percent of fiscal FY24’s gross state
accommodations tax revenue to the development of workforce housing. The County and Council will
need to satisfy, by subsequent action, all the requirements of the South Carolina Code of Laws before
these funds are expended)
Vote at First Reading by Title only on January 22, 2024 - 10:1
Vote at Public Hearing and Second Reading on February 12, 2024 - 10:1
Items Originating from the Public Facilities and Safety Committee
2. SECOND READING OF AN ORDIN ANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO ENTER
INTO A LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (SCDOT)
FOR PROPERTY LOCATED UNDER THE CROSS ISLAND PARKWAY ADJACENT TO THE BROAD CREEK BOAT
LANDING PARCEL 552 010 000 0650 0000 (FISCAL IMPACT: N/A)
Vote at First Reading on February 12, 2024- 11:0
Public Hearing to be held at third reading on March 11, 2024
END OF CONSENT AGENDA
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html
3
County Council Meeting
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, January 22, 2024
5:00 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Passiment called the meeting to order at 5:00PM
PRESENT
Chairman Joseph F. Passiment
Vice-Chairman Lawrence McElynn
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member York Glover
Council Member Alice Howard
Council Member Mark Lawson
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
Council Member Thomas Reitz
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND INVOCATION
Chairman Passiment led the Pledge of Allegiance and Council Member Brown gave the invocation.
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
Chairman Passiment stated that public notice of this meeting had been posted, published and
distributed in compliance with the SC Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion to Amend: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, seconded by Council Member Howard to
add first reading by title only of an ordinance appropriating 15% of the state
2% accommodations tax funds a-tax funds for workforce housing for workforce housing subject to review
4
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
by the state accommodations tax committee and in compliance with the requi rements of the sc code of
laws.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
Motion to Amend: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, seconded by Council Member
Tabernik to change the title of item number 12 removing Finance, Administration, and Economic
Development Committee and replace it with Public Facilities and Safety Committee.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
Main Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to
approve the agenda as amended.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Reitz, Seconded by Council Member Howard to approve the
minutes from January 8, 2024.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
6. ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
Interim County Administrator John Robinson recognized Denise Christmas for her outstanding work as
interim Deputy County Administrator and stated she has stepped back from that position and is not the
county's full time Chief Financial Officer.
Mr. Robinson then recognized employees Mark Sutton, construction manager; and Amber Black,
Workforce Development Specialist in HR then gave an update on the Daufuskie Island Ferry.
To listed to the full update please click on the link below.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
7. APPROVAL OF THE 2023 ANNUAL AUDIT PRESENTED BY MAULDIN & JENKINS, LLC, CPA FIRM
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Lawson, Seconded by Council Member Brown to approve the
2023 Annual Audit as presented by Mauldin & Jenkins, LLC, CPA Firm.
The Vote - Motion approved without objection.
8. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the comments.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
1. Debbie Roberson
2. Denise Gilbert
3. Skip Hogland
9. LIASION AND COMMITTEE REPORTS
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full report
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
10. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Bartholomew to
approve the consent agenda.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
5
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
11. TIME SENSITIVE ITEM FROM THE JANUARY 22ND SPECIAL CALLED FINANCE, ADMINISTRATION, AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE MEETING - APPROVAL OF THE APPOINTMENT OF TOMMY
HARMON, JR. TO THE BEAUFORT MEMORIAL HOSPITAL BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR A FIRST TERM OF 4
YEARS WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE OF 2028 & THE REAPPOINTMENT OF EUGENE RICHARDSON
LABRUCE, TO THE B EAUFORT MEMORIAL HOSPITAL BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR A SECOND TERM OF
FOUR-YEARS WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE OF 2028
Motion: it was moved by Council Member Howard, Seconded by Council Member Brown to approve the
appointment of Tommy Harmon, Jr. and the reappointmen t of Eugene Richardson LaBruceo to the
Beaufort Memorial Hospital Board of Trustees.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
12. TIME SENSITIVE ITEM FROM THE JANUARY 22ND PUBLIC FACILITEIS AND SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING
- APPROVAL OF AN ORDINANCE FOR A 2024 TRANSPORTATION SALES AND USE TAX REFERENDUM
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Tabernik
to approve first reading of an ordinance for a 2024 Transportation Sales and Use Tax Referendum.
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
Motion to Amend: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member
Bartholomew to include language in Section 2.3 stating that all proceeds of the sales and use tax and all
proceeds of any bonds payable shall be held by the County until County Council has approved the
allocation and expenditure for the projects and preparations of the projects as further identified here.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew, Council Member Brown,
Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member Lawson, Council Member
Tabernik, and Council Member Reitz. Voting Nay: Chairman Passiment, Council Mem ber Glover, and
Council Member Howard. The motion passes 9:2.
Motion to Amend: it was moved by Council Member Howard, Seconded by Council Member
Bartholomew to include language creating a citizens committee.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
Main Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Tabernik
to approve first reading of an ordinance for a 2024 Transportation Sales and Use Tax Referendum with
the approved amendments.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Brown, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member
Glover, Council Member Howard, Council Member Lawson, and Council Member Tabernik. Voting Nay:
Council Member Reitz. The motion passes 10:1
13. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF HAWKERS AND PEDDLERS LICENSE FEES
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Glover, Seconded by Council Member Howard to approve the
Hawkers and Peddlers License Fees.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
14. PUBLIC HEARING AND SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE
PURCHASE OF TAX MAP SERIAL NUMBER TMS R600-036-000-0013-0000 AND ALSO KNOWN AS 76 MAY
RIVER ROAD
6
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Howard to
approve second reading of an ordinance authorizing the Interim County Administrator to execute the
necessary documents and to provide funding for the purchase of tax map serial number tms r600 -036-
000-0013-0000 and also known as 76 May River Road.
Chairman Passiment opened the floor for public hearing.
No one came forward.
The Chairman closed the public hearing.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
15. RECONSIDERATION OF COUNCIL'S ACTION ON FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING
FUNDS FROM THE STATE 2% ACCOMMODATIONS TAX FUND AND FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE
APPROPRIATING FUNDS FROM THE STATE 2% ACCOMMODATIONS TAX FUND
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Bartholomew to
rescind the vote that council took on December 11, 2023 in which council awarded $150,000 to Workforce
Housing from the State A-Tax Committee recommendation.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Glover to approve
first reading of an ordinance appropriating funds from the state a-tax funds as recommended by the state
a-tax committee in compliance with the requirement of SC Code of Laws.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice -Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Dawson, Council Member Glover, and Council Member Lawson. Voting Nay: Council
Member Brown, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Howard, Council Member Tabernik, and
Council Member Reitz. The motion passes 6:5
15.a Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Cunningham to
approve First Reading by title only of an ordinance appropriating 15% of the State 2% Accommodations
Tax funds for workforce housing subject to review by the State Accommodations Tax Committee and in
compliance with the requirements of the SC Code of Laws.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Brown, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member
Glover, Council Member Howard, Council Member Lawson, and Council Member Tabernik. Voting Nay:
Council Member Reitz. The motion passes 10:1.
16. APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE
NECESSARY DOCUMENTS AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE PURCHASE OF TAX MAP SERIAL NUMBER
TMS R600-021-000-0078-0000 AND ALSO KNOWN AS BARRELL LANDING ORR
Motion made by Council Member Howard, Seconded by Council Member Cunningham.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
17. APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT THE PASSIVE PARKS DEPARTMENT BUSINESS USE POLICY,
APPLICATION AND FEE SCHEDULE
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Glover, Seconded by Council Member Howard to approve a
resolution adopting the Passive Parks Department Use Policy, Application and Fee Schedule.
The Vote - motion was approved without objection.
18. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD- 15 MINUTES TOTAL
7
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the comments.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/295383
1. William Smith
19. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 6:53PM
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY: _____________________________________
Joseph F. Passiment, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
__________________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
Ratified:
8
Item 5.
Special Called County Council Meeting
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, February 5, 2024
9:30 AM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/296421
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Passiment called the meeting to order at 9:30AM
PRESENT
Chairman Joseph F. Passiment
Vice-Chairman Lawrence McElynn
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member York Glover
Council Member Alice Howard
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
Council Member Thomas Reitz
ABSENT
Council Member Mark Lawson
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Chairman Passiment led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
Chairman Passiment stated that public notice of this meeting had been posted, published and
distributed in compliance with the SC Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, seconded by Council Member Howard to approve
the agenda.
9
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
5. EXECUTIVE SESSION
Motion: It was moved by Vice-Chairman McElynn, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to enter
executive session.
The Vote – Motion was approved without objection.
Council entered executive session at 9:31AM.
6. END OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
Council came out of executive session at 2:13PM
7. MATTERS ARISING OUT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
Motion: It was moved by Vice-Chair McElynn, Seconded by Council Member Bartholomew to enter into
a contract with Find Great People to recruit and hire the next County Administrator.
The Vote – Motion was approved without objection.
19. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 2:15PM
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY: _____________________________________
Joseph F. Passiment, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
__________________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
Ratified:
10
Item 5.
County Council Meeting
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, February 12, 2024
5:00 PM
MINUTES
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Passiment called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm.
PRESENT
Chairman Joseph F. Passiment
Vice-Chairman Lawrence McElynn
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member York Glover
Council Member Alice Howard
Council Member Mark Lawson
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
Council Member Thomas Reitz
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND INVOCATION
Vice Chairman Lawrence McElynn led the Pledge of Allegiance and gave the invocation.
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
Chairman Passiment noted that public notification of this meeting had been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Vice-Chairman McElynn, Seconded by Council Member Brown to approve the
agenda.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
5. ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
11
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Interim County Administrator John Robinson recognized Joshua Sudomerski from the Auditors Office for
his outstanding work.
To listen to the full update please click on the link below.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/297139
6. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
There were no citizen comments.
7. LIASION AND COMMITTEE REPORTS
Council Member's Howard, Tabernik, Brown, Reitz, and Dawson all gave a brief update of community
meetings they attended.
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full report
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/297139
8. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Howard to approve
the consent agenda.
The Vote - Motion approved without objection.
9. PUBLIC HEARING AND SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE FOR A 2024 TRANSPORTATION SALES AND
USE TAX REFERENDUM
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Glover to
approve public hearing and second reading of an Ordinance for a 2024 Transportation Sales and Use Tax
Referendum.
Discussion: Henry Moss stated he was there to assist and thanked Council Members for bringing this
forward.
Motion to Amend: It was moved by Council Member Howard, Seconded by Vice -Chairman McElynn to
amend the ordinance by deleting the last sentence in section 2.3 which reads - All proceeds of the Sales
and Use Tax and all proceeds of any bonds payable therefrom shall be held by the County until the County
Council has approved the allocation and expenditure of funds for the Projects or portions of the Projects,
as further identified herein.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
Discussion: Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/297139
Motion to Amend: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by council Member Glover
to amend the ordinance to include language that no member who sits on “a” council shall be appointed
to the citizens committee defined herein.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
Main Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Glover to
approve public hearing and second reading of an Ordinance for a 2024 Transportation Sales and Use Tax
Referendum as amended.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member Glover, Council Member
Howard, Council Member Lawson, and Council Member Tabernik. Voting Nay: Council Member Brown,
Council Member Reitz. The motion passes 9:2
12
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
10. PUBLIC HEARING AND SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING FIFTEEN PERCENT OF
FY24 GROSS STATE ACCOMMODATIONS TAX REVENUE TO DEVELOPMENT OF WORKFORCE HOUSING
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Howard to approve
public hearing and second reading of an ordinance appropriating 15% of FY24 gross State
Accommodations Tax Revenue to development of workforce housing.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Brown, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member
Glover, Council Member Howard, Council Member Lawson, and Council Member Tabernik.
Voting Nay: Council Member Reitz. The motion passed 10:1
11. PUBLIC HEARING AND SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING FUNDS FROM THE STATE
A-TAX FUNDS AS RECOMMENDED BY THE STATE A -TAX COM MITTEE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE
REQUIREMENT OF SC CODE OF LAWS
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Tabernik, Seconded by Council Member Cunningham to refer
public hearing and second reading of an ordinance appropriating funds from the State A -Tax Funds a s
recommended by the State A -Tax Committee in compliance with the requirements of SC Code of Laws
back to the Finance, Administration, and Economic Development Committee for further review.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Chairman Passiment, Vice-Chairman McElynn, Council Member Bartholomew,
Council Member Brown, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member
Howard, Council Member Tabernik, and Council Member Reitz. Voting Nay: Council Member Glover,
Council Member Lawson. The motion passes 9:2.
12. FIRST READING OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO ENTER
INTO A LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION (SCDOT)
FOR PROPERTY LOCATED UNDER THE CROSS ISLAND PARKWAY ADJACENT TO THE BROAD CREEK BOAT
LANDING PARCEL 552 010 000 0650 0000
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, Seconded by Council Member Howard to
approve first reading of an ordinance authorizing the Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease
agreement with SCDOT for property located under the Cross Island Parkway parcel number 552 010 000
0650 0000.
The Vote - The motion was approved without objection.
13. APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT THE MILITARY ENHANCEMENT PLAN FUND GRANT FROM THE
SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMEN T OF VETERANS’ AFFAIRS FOR THE AMOUNT OF $3,392,328 FOR THE
LAUREL BAY ROAD PATHWAY PROJECT
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Howard, Seconded by Council Member Bartholomew to
approve a resolution to accept the Military Enhancement Plan Fund Grand f rom the South Carolina
Department of Veterans' Affairs for the amount of $3,392,328 for the Laurel Bay Road Pathway Project.
The Vote - Motion was approved without objection.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Glover, Seconded by Council Member Cunningham to take
citizen comments prior to executive session.
The Vote - approved without objection.
14. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full comment.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/297139
13
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
1. Debbie Smith- Daufuskie Island Ferry System
15. EXECUTIVE SESSION
PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SEC. 30 -4-70(A)(2): RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE ADVICE RELATES
TO PENDING CLAIMS OR OTHER MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE (BARACCO V
BEAUFORT COUNTY)
PURSUANT TO S. C. CODE SECTION 30 -4-70(A)(2) TO RECEIVE LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE ADVICE
RELATES TO PENDING LITIGATION (HELMSMAN WAY CONDEMNATION)
PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SEC. 30 -4-70(A)(2): RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE ADVICE RELATES
TO PENDING, THREATENED, OR POTENTIAL CLAIMS WHICH ARE COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY -CLIENT
PRIVILEGE (HILTON HEAD ISLAND AIRPORT)
PURSUANT TO S. C. CODE §30-4-70(a)(2): RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES
TO MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY -CLIENT PRIVILEGE (CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND
POTENTIAL LITIGATION)
PURSUANT TO S. C. CODE §30-4-70(a)(2): RECEIPT OF LEGAL ADVICE WHERE THE LEGAL ADVICE RELATES
TO MATTERS COVERED BY THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE (S. C. CODE SECTION 8-13-1346)
Motion: It was moved by Vice-Chairman McElynn, Seconded by Council Member Brown to enter
executive session.
The Vote – Motion was approved without objection.
Council entered executive session at 5:54PM.
16. MATTERS ARISING OUT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
There were no matters arising out of executive session.
17. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 7:10PM
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY: _____________________________________
Joseph F. Passiment, Jr., Chairman
ATTEST:
__________________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
Ratified:
14
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
15
Item 5.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY
WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee, February 12, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Brittany Ward, County Attorney (5 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
This is a new item for Committee/Council
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Parcel #R510 005 000 0329 0000 was co-purchased through the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program
on January 29, 2013 by Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island as part of a series of parcels
along Beach City Road adjacent to Mitchelville Freedom Park. At the time of acquisition, Parcel 0329 was 1.22
acres and cost $280,921, with a 70/30 respective cost share between the County and Town.
In early 2023, a property boundary discrepancy was brought to County staff’s attention whereby the adjacent
neighbor’s driveway was constructed on the co-owned County/Town property. A survey was completed on
August 4, 2023 to designate the 0.11 acre encroachment. An appraisal was completed on September 20, 2023
and provided a compensation opinion of $30,250 for the 0.11 acre encroachment area. The original
acquisition cost of the 0.11 acre encroachment area was $25,329, therefore the current appraised value is an
acceptable value for conveyance.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Beaufort County will receive $30,250 from the Buyer. Seventy percent of the funds from the sale will be
deposited into the Rural and Critical Bond Fund (4500-80-0000-47010) to be used towards future acquisitions
by the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program. Thirty percent of the funds from the sale will be
reimbursed to the Town of Hilton Head Island.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval as submitted
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify, or deny approval of an ordinance authorizing the interim county administrator to
execute the necessary documents to convey a portion of property owned by Beaufort County with TMS No.
R510 005 000 0329 0000, located on Beach City Road, Hilton Head Island.
Beaufort County Code of Ordinances Section 26-36 (attached) governs Council’s consideration of this matter.
If approved, move forward to County Council for 1st reading on February 26, 2024.
16
Item 10.
Created: 2024-02-01 10:45:35 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50, Update 4)
Page 1 of 1
Sec. 26-36. Resale, swap, condemnation or lease of acquired property.
There may be instances where property acquired under the RCLPP for its conservation value(s), and possibly
to mitigate the impacts of development, may not be suitable or needed for county ownership in the future. In such
cases, the county council may request the RCLP board to evaluate and make a recommendation on selling,
swapping or leasing the property, in whole or in part.
(a) In those instances, the RCLP board shall be guided by the following:
(1) To ensure that the resale, swap or lease of the property, in whole or in part, will not have an
adverse impact on the conservation value(s) of the property, which can be assured through the
placement of a conservation easement or other appropriate instruments on the sold, swapped or
leased property if necessary.
(2) To ensure that the development of the property for use(s) permitted under a conservation
easement will be carefully monitored by the easement holder.
(b) Additionally, the following will apply:
(1) Any RCLPP property considered for sale, swap or lease shall require appropriate action by a two-
thirds majority of the county council following prescribed procedures for sale, swap or lease of
county-owned land.
(2) If all or part of a RCLPP property is sold, swapped or condemned, the county and any c o-owners
will be entitled to respective ownership ratio compensation of any net proceeds, after payment
of all closing expenses.
(3) Any RCLPP property sold, swapped or condemned will have the county's portion of any proceeds
deposited into the land preservation fund for use in future RCLPP acquisitions.
(4) Any RCLPP property leased by the county will have any proceeds deposited into the passive parks
fund for use in management and maintenance of RCLPP passive parks.
( Ord. No. 2019/47, 10-28-2019 ; Ord. No. 2019/48, 10-28-2019 )
17
Item 10.
THIS PROPERTY LIES IN F.E.M.A. ZONE X
COMMUNITY NO. 450250, PANEL: 0456G, DATED: 3/23/2021
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION = NO MINIMUM ELEVATION
,,
ADDRESS: 282 BEACH CITY ROAD
MAP: 5 PARCELS: 10H & 329DISTRICT: 510
SCALE :DATE : 1" = 40'
HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
LOT A & TAX PARCEL 329, BEACH CITY ROAD,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA
8/04/2023
BOUNDARY RECONFIGURATION OF:
d.b.a. Sea Island Land Survey, Inc.
DWG No. :FILE No :
Fax (843) 689-3871
05608.15 4-05608.15
E-mail: admin@nandinainc.com
Hilton Head Island,
SC 29926
Tel (843) 681-3248
PREPARED FOR: ANDRE J. WHITE, AJJLA WHITE
FAMILY TRUST, & THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISAND
NOT VALID UNLESS EMBOSSED.
EXCEEDS THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SURVEY AS SPECIFIED THEREIN;
PRACTICE OF LAND SURVEYING IN SOUTH CAROLINA, AND MEETS OR
AND BELIEF, THE SURVEY SHOWN HEREON WAS MADE IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE MINIMUM STANDARDS MANUAL FOR THE
I HEREBY STATE THAT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE, INFORMATION,
CLASS "A"
ALSO THERE ARE NO VISIBLE ENCROACHMENTS OR PROJECTIONS OTHER
THAN SHOWN.
10 Oal Park Drive, Unit C1,
PROPERTY AREA TAX PARCEL 329: 1.11 AC. 48,529 S.F.
PROPERTY AREA LOT A: 0.61 AC. 26,559
18
Item 10.
APPRAISAL REPORT
OF
TAX PARCEL 329 BEACH CITY ROAD
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SC 29926
&
VALUE OF THE EASEMENT/ACQUISITION
PREPARED FOR
ANDRE WHITE
AS OF
09/11/2023
PREPARED
BY
WILLIAM R. COBIA, SRA
COASTAL PROPERTY APPRAISALS
19
Item 10.
September 20, 2023
RE: PARCEL 329 BEACH CITY ROAD & DRIVEWAY EASEMENT/ACQUISITION
Dear Mr. White,
In accordance with your request, I have made a personal inspection of the above referenced property and
prepared an appraisal for the purpose of estimating the just compensation for the proposed acquisition of
the 0.11+/- acre portion of parent parcel Tax Parcel 329. I understand the intended use of this appraisal is
to aid in negotiations to acquire this portion from the parent parcel of the subject property. The intended
users of this appraisal are Mr. Andre White, appropriate officials with the Town of Hilton Head Island
and appropriate members of Beaufort County. Use of this appraisal by anyone other than those listed as
intended users is prohibited. My conclusions of highest and best use and market value of the property, as
well as the just compensation for the proposed acquisition, are based on conditions existing in the market
as of September 11, 2023.
Submitted herewith is the appraisal report containing the pertinent information gathered during my
investigation. My opinion of the just compensation for the acquisition of the release is:
Thirty Thousand Two Hundred Fifty Dollars: ($30,250)
The preceding estimated just compensation is subject to the standard assumptions and limiting conditions
summarized in the attached report. This appraisal report has been prepared in conformance with my
interpretation of the "Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice" (USPAP) published by the
"The Appraisal Foundation", as well as South Carolina State Law.
It is noted that the real estate market is constantly changing, and numerous events, including but not
limited to, actions by the Federal Reserve, outcomes of elections, changes in the tax code, events overseas,
natural disasters, new or changing governmental regulations, development of public infrastructure, hiring
and layoffs by major area employers, and changes in the lending environment can have profound impacts
on values of real estate. As such, the reader is cautioned that the value of the subject property will almost
certainly change over time, and that I have no opinion of value of the subject property other than as of the
stated effective date(s) of valuation.
20
Item 10.
A digital copy of the report has been provided. If you have any questions or desire additional information,
then please do not hesitate to contact me.
Respectfully Submitted,
Coastal Property Appraisals
___________________________
Mr. William R. Cobia, SRA
SC Appraiser # AB .3490 CG
21
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 1
LIMITING CONDITIONS AND ASSUMPTIONS
This appraisal is made subject to the following Assumptions and Limiting Conditions:
1. It is assumed that the legal description as obtained from public records or as furnished is correct and
no responsibility is assumed for matters of a legal nature. No opinion is rendered as to title, as it is
assumed to be good, marketable, and in fee simple unless otherwise noted and discussed.
2. The information contained in this report as obtained from sources deemed reliable. However, no
warranty is given as to its accuracy. Competent management and responsible ownership are assumed.
3. The property is appraised as though free and clear of any or all liens or encumbrances except as noted
herein.
4. Any plot plans, sketches, drawings, or other exhibits in this report are included only to assist the
reader is visualizing the property. I have made no survey for this report and assume no responsibility
for its presentation within.
5. Possession of this report or a copy thereof does not carry with it the right of publication nor may it
be used for any purpose by any but the applicant without the previous written consent of the appraiser
and the applicant and then only with proper identification.
6. The appraiser herein by reason of this appraisal is not required to give future consultation, testimony
or be in attendance in court with reference to the property in question unless arrangements have been
previously made.
7. The distribution, if any, of the total valuation in the report between land and improvements applies
only under the existing program of utilization. The separate allocations for land and improvements
must not be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and are invalid if so used.
8. The appraisers assume, and the user of this report agrees, that the appraisers have no liability for
existing physical condition of the building and all parties agree that the purpose of this appraisal is
to estimate value as though the superstructure is structurally sound. Likewise, it is assumed and all
parties agree that the appraisers have no responsibility for subsurface or hazardous waste conditions,
including asbestos.
9. Unless otherwise noted herein, it is assumed that there are no encroachments, zoning or other
violations of any regulations affecting the subject property. The appraisers assume, and the user of
this report agrees that the appraised value is prepared as though no encroachments, liens or other
violations of any regulations affecting the subject property exist, unless otherwise noted.
10. The value estimates reported herein apply to the entire property and any proration or division of the
total into fractional interest will invalidate the value estimate unless such proration or division of
interest is set forth in the report. No statement as to the value in use to the property owner has been
made. Only the value of the property, if exposed for sale on the open market, has been estimated.
22
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 2
11. Neither all nor any part of the contents of this report shall be conveyed to the public through
advertising, public relations, news, sales, or other media, without the prior written consent and
approval of the author; this pertains particularly to valuation conclusions, the identity of the appraiser
or firm with which the appraiser is associated with and any reference to the Appraisal Institute or to
the SRA designation.
12. This appraisal will not take into consideration the possibility of the existence of asbestos, PCB
transformers, or other toxic, hazardous, or contaminated substances and/or underground storage tanks
(hazardous materials), or the cost of encapsulation or removal thereof. Should the client have concern
over the existence of such substances on the property, the appraisers consider it imperative for the
client to retain the services of a qualified, independent engineer or contractor to determine the
existence and extent, if any, of any hazardous materials, as well as the cost associated with any
required or desirable treatment or removal thereof.
13. Client agrees to defend, indemnify and hold harmless Appraiser from any damages, losses or
expenses, including attorneys’ fees and litigation expenses at trial or on appeal, arising from
allegations asserted against Appraiser by any third party that, if proven to be true, would constitute a
breach by Client of any of Client’s obligations, representations or warranties made in this Agreement,
or any violation by Client of any federal, state or local law, ordinance or regulation, or common law
(a “Claim”). In the event of a Claim, Appraiser shall promptly notify Client of such Claim, and shall
cooperate with Client in the defense or settlement of any Claim. Client shall have the right to select
legal counsel to defend any Claim, provided that Appraiser shall have the right to engage independent
counsel at Appraiser’s expense to monitor the defense or settlement of any Claim. Client shall have
the right to settle any Claim, provided that Appraiser shall have the right to approve any settlement
that results in any modification of Appraiser’s rights under this agreement, which approval will not
be unreasonably withheld, delayed or conditioned.
14. Neither party shall under any circumstances be liable to the other party for special, exemplary,
punitive or consequential damages, including, without limitation, loss of profits or damages
proximately caused by loss of use of any property, whether arising from either party’s negligence,
breach of the Agreement or otherwise, whether or not a party was advised, or knew, of the possibility
of such damages, or such possibility was foreseeable by that party. In no event shall Appraiser be
liable to Client for any amounts that exceed the fees and costs paid by Client to Appraiser pursuant
to this Agreement.
23
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 3
EXTRAORDINARY ASSUMPTIONS
An Extraordinary Assumption is defined as “an assumption, directly related to a specific assignment, as
of the effective date of the assignment results, which, if found to be false, could alter the appraiser’s
opinions or conclusions.”
This appraisal is subject to the following extraordinary assumption:
I am making the Extraordinary Assumption that there are NO wetlands and the majority, if not all, 1.22
acres are developable.
As real estate appraisers, I am not qualified to perform a wetland delineation; therefore, I strongly advise
the Client to retain the services of a qualified environmental consultant if it is concerned about this issue.
Furthermore, if my assumption pertaining to wetlands is false, then it could impact the value(s) estimated
in this report.
24
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 4
PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION
The subject of this appraisal is a ± 1.22-acre lot located at 329 Beach City Road in an incorporated area
of Beaufort County, South Carolina and within the Town of Hilton Head Island. The property is best
described by the Beaufort County Tax Assessor’s Office as Parcel Identification Number R510 005 000
0329 0000. An aerial tax map showing the approximate location and configuration of the subject property
outlined and shaded in yellow is provided below.
25
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 5
I understand Mr. Andre White wishes to obtain a certain portion estimated to contain approximately 0.11
acres from an approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area. This portion of the property is being used
for a permanent driveway easement across and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of
Hilton Head Island. Currently this 0.11+/- acre portion which is located at the east corner extending
approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast corner and is mostly rectangular in shape. A plan
sheet showing the approximate location and configuration of the area to be released from the parent parcel
is provided on the following page. Upon completion of the proposed release, the subject property will be
similar to before the acquisition, and unaffected by the current driveway encroachment.
The physical, legal, and economic characteristics of the subject property both before and after the proposed
acquisition are described and analyzed in greater detail in later sections of this report.
Below is a map showing the approximate location of the proposed portion of Tax Parcel 329 to be sold to
the owners of Lot A.
26
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 6
HISTORY OF OWNERSHIP
Tax records indicate legal ownership of the subject property is vested in the name of the Beaufort County
and The Town of Hilton Head Island. The only recorded sale according to Beaufort County Records
occurred on January 24, 2013, for $350,000 and included an additional property identified by tax map
number: R510 005 000 010B 0000, an adjacent site to the west and containing 0.30 acres or 13,068 square
feet.
Furthermore, it is my understanding that the property is not listed for sale or under contract for sale. In
addition, I was not advised that any offers to purchase this 0.11+/- acre portion from the property have
been made.
CLIENT AND INTENDED USERS OF THE APPRAISAL
Mr. Andre White is my client. Intended users of this appraisal are Mr. Andre White, as well as appropriate
officials with Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. Use of this appraisal by anyone other
than the stated intended users above is prohibited, and not intended by the appraiser(s).
PURPOSE OF THE APPRAISAL
The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the just compensation for the proposed acquisition of the
0.11+/- acre portion of the parent site which currently serves as the driveway easement to Lot A, 282
Beach City Rd. However, at this time the driveway encroaches on the parent site, which is the subject of
the report.
INTENDED USE OF THE APPRAISAL
I understand the intended use of this appraisal is to aid in negotiations to acquire the 0.11+/- acre area
from a portion of the subject property. Any other use of this appraisal is prohibited and not allowed
without authorization from the appraiser(s).
REAL PROPERTY INTEREST APPRAISED
The fee simple interest of the property is appraised. The Fee Simple Estate is defined as “...absolute
ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate subject only to the limitations imposed by the
governmental powers of taxation, eminent domain, police power, and escheat.”
EFFECTIVE DATE OF VALUATION AND DATE OF REPORT
The effective date of value is September 11, 2023, which is also the date of my most recent official
inspection of the subject property.
The date of the report is September 20, 2023.
27
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 7
Subject Property Viewed from Beach City Road: Facing East
Subject Viewed Beach City Road: Facing South
28
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 8
Beach City Road: Facing East
Driveway Encroachment
29
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 9
TYPE OF VALUE CONSIDERED
This assignment involves estimating the market value of the subject property. Market Value is defined as
the most probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all
conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably, and
assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a
sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby:
1. Buyer and seller are typically motivated;
2. Both parties are well informed or well advised, & acting in what they consider their best interest;
3. A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market
4. Payment is made in terms of cash in United States dollars or in terms of financial arrangements
comparable thereto; and
5. The price represents a normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or
creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.
*This definition is specified in the regulations pursuant to Title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform,
Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA).
SCOPE OF WORK
The scope of work is the amount and type of information researched and the analysis applied in the
assignment. The appraiser is responsible for determining the appropriate scope of work in the appraisal
assignment given the client’s intended use and the nature of the problem to be solved.
The appraiser(s) made a personal inspection of the neighborhood, which consisted of driving most of the
major roadways and identifying its approximate boundaries. In addition, the appraiser lives and works in
the Bluffton/Hilton Head Region and travels through the subject neighborhood on a regular basis. Sources
of information pertaining to the local region and subject neighborhood included various online
publications, and my ongoing market observations and research.
Information pertaining to the subject utilized in this appraisal was limited to viewing the property from
the fronting roadways and/or adjoining properties, and reviewing aerial photographs (supported by
Google Earth), flood maps, deeds, plats, zoning, and/or other publicly available information.
In order to estimate the market value of the subject property both before and after the acquisition, I have
considered a Sales Comparison Approach, whereby sales of comparable properties are analyzed. It is
noted that I considered two other valuation methodologies, which are the Cost Approach and Income
Approach; however, typical buyers and sellers in this market do not consider these approaches to value
when analyzing vacant land. Therefore, I have not developed these two approaches to value, and their
exclusion does not limit the scope of this assignment.
30
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 10
Comparable sales were gathered, verified, and compared to the subject site to determine a reasonable
market value of the land. Sources of information pertaining to comparable sales included, local MLS
data, Costar data, public deed and tax records, plats and surveys, discussions with parties either involved
in or familiar with the sales, aerial photographs, online zoning, flood, wetland, and topographic maps, and
visits to the sale properties.
AREA/NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS
The map below depicts the subject’s location within Beaufort County, and the Savannah/Hilton Head
Island region. As shown, this location is roughly 15 radial miles east of Interstate 95, 8 radial miles east
of Old Town Bluffton, and roughly seventeen radial miles north of Savannah’s National Landmark
Historic District.
The subject property is located on the south side of Beach City Road just west of the Port Royal Sound
and bordering the 33-acre Town-owned Mitchelville Freedom Park. The location is close to the Hilton
Head Island Airport and surrounding residential development. It is approximately 2 miles east of Highway
278, which is the primary thoroughfare on Hilton Head Island. This neighborhood is loosely defined as
the Mitchelville Historic Gullah Neighborhood. In general, this neighborhood is firmly entrenched in the
growth stage of its economic life cycle. The subject neighborhood is shown on the following aerial
photograph.
31
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 11
32
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 12
Aerial Map
33
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 13
HILTON HEAD ISLAND REGIONAL ANALYSIS
The subject property is located on the northeast side of Fish Haul Road. This location is mid island and is
centrally located to serve all of Hilton Head Island. The property is approximately ten miles south-east of
Bluffton, and twenty miles east of Interstate 95. Beaufort County is located in the southeastern part of the
State of South Carolina and has been one of the fastest growing counties in the US. Located entirely
within Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, a barrier island, is a 42 square mile resort town with an
approximate year-round population of 40,000 people. Over 2.25 million visitors come to Hilton Head
Island each year and during the summer the population can swell to over 150,000. Hilton Head Island is
a primary city within the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort metropolitan area and has an estimated
overall population of over 220,000. A map showing the location of the subject property relative to other
areas of Beaufort County and the Hilton Head Island Region is provided on the next page.
According to the Chamber of Commerce Economic Outlook published in July 2023 The South Carolina
Leading Index (SCLI) fell in June to a value of 102.37. Unemployment claims were 25% higher than in
May and the number of issued housing permits fell 11.3% month-over-month. In conjunction, the
valuation of the permits fell 8.2 percent and the weekly manufacturing hours rose 2.4 percent. The DOW
Jones Composite Average was up 6.4 percent.
The Conference Board’s national Leading Economic Index decreased in June to 106.1. The Conference
Board notes that the elevated prices and hard-to-get credit are dampening economic activity.
On the following page is the Key South Carolina Indicators for the following sectors: Income;
Employment and Real Estate.
34
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 14
South Carolina’s total non-seasonally adjusted nonfarm employment rose by 8,500 net jobs to 2,313,200
in June, a 0.4 percent increase from May’s numbers. Below is a chart depicting the industry sector, the
timeline comparison, and the overall rate of change for those periods.
In June 2023, the number of building permits in South Carolina for new residential construction fell 11.3
percent to 3,778, which is down 9.4 percent from a year ago. The value for the permits fell 8.2 percent
month-over-month and was 6.7 percent lower than one year ago. Real estate closings were up 5%
compared to May, while the median sale price was up 1.7%. Total closings rose in four of the top six
MSA, with Charleston reporting the strongest gain at 7.7 percent.
35
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 15
NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS
The subject neighborhood is defined as the mid island submarket, and includes the area along Fish Haul
Road, Beach City Road and Mathews Drive, a minor thoroughfare, running north to south from Highway
278. This neighborhood has experienced significant growth in the past ten years, with further new growth
expected during the foreseeable future, inclusive of some re-development on strategically located sites.
Overall, this neighborhood is in the growth stage of its neighborhood life cycle.
Vehicular access to this neighborhood is good and is provided by a network of streets that run north/south
and east/west. Major traffic arteries in this neighborhood are Mathews Drive which run in a general
north/south direction, and Marshland Road, which runs in an east to west direction.
Development in this neighborhood consists primarily of older commercial buildings, including Port Royal
Plaza, a retail plaza with a mix of tenants, including Planet Fitness, Auto Zone and a variety of restaurants
and CVS pharmacy, interspersed with pockets of older and newer residential neighborhoods.
In summary, the subject neighborhood is centrally located within the Town of Hilton Head Island, has
good vehicular access, and is stable, with minimal new development occurring. Reasons for the lack of
new development include a general scarcity of available vacant sites, as well as the transitional nature of
various parts of the neighborhood, along with lands owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island and
Beaufort County. Much of these lands are owned for preservation and utilized for park or community
recreation. In my opinion, this neighborhood will maintain stable population levels with minimal new
development over the foreseeable future.
Hilton Head Island Parks
36
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 16
37
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 17
SITE DESCRIPTION
The following description is based on my review of information provided by the property owner, the
recorded plat, various online sources, and my property inspections. Photographs of the subject property
were provided earlier in this report.
Size/Shape: Based on my review of the recorded plat, the subject site consists of 1.22-acres, and is a
rectangular shaped site located on the southeast side of Beach City Road, just east of the Hilton Head
Island Airport and just west of the Port Royal Sound. The shape and configuration of the subject site is
depicted on the following excerpt from the recorded plat.
Frontage: Review of the plat shows the subject having ± 359.00 feet of frontage on the southeast side of
Beach City Road.
In this area, Beach City Road is a two-lane, minor roadway that runs in a east-west direction. Development
along this stretch of road is comprised of various older and newer residential communities, limited
commercial and recreational parks.
Access: The subject is afforded good vehicular access via one driveway on Beach City Road.
Topography: The subject property is generally level and at the grade of the fronting roadways and
adjoining properties. The subject is cleared and vacant and is currently used as preservation land by the
Town of Hilton Head and Beaufort County.
Elevations: Review of the Beaufort County GIS website shows the subject’s elevations ranging from 13
to 15 feet.
38
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 18
Flood Zone: According to Flood Map Community Panel Numbers 45013C0456G dated March 23,
20021, the site appears to be in Flood Zone X500, which is defined as area of 0.2% annual chance of
flood. An excerpt from these flood panels showing the subject property and its immediate surroundings
is provided below and on the following page.
Drainage: No problems with drainage were noted during the inspection.
Soil Types: A soil report was not provided for use in this appraisal. I am not qualified to render a technical
opinion regarding soil conditions; however, the presence of the existing improvements indicates the soil
is sufficient for commercial oriented development typical of the area. Therefore, I assume the load-
bearing capacity is sufficient to support any reasonably probable improvements. If the Client is concerned
about this issue, then I recommend a study by a qualified soils engineer.
Hazardous Materials: Please note the subject buildings were not constructed during a time period when
both asbestos and lead based paint were commonly used materials. For the purpose of this appraisal, I
assume there are no hazardous substances on or beneath the surface of the subject property. The
appraiser, however, is not qualified to detect such substances. The presence of substances such as
asbestos, lead based paint, urea-formaldehyde foam insulation, underground storage tanks or other
potentially hazardous materials may have an effect on the value of the property. The value estimate is
predicated on the assumption that there is no such material on or in the property that would cause a
loss in value. No responsibility is assumed for any such condition, or for any expertise or engineering
knowledge required to discover them. The client is urged to retain an expert in this field if desired.
39
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 19
Wetlands: I did not observe any inundated areas or vegetation characteristic of jurisdictional wetlands
during the inspection. Furthermore, virtually all the subject property has been cleared and remains vacant.
As a real estate appraiser, I am not qualified to determine how much, if any, of the property is a
jurisdictional wetland. Therefore, for the purpose of this appraisal, I have made the reasonable
assumption the subject property consists entirely of usable upland area. I reserve the right to change
my opinions of highest and best use and market value if I am provided with information that indicates
the subject contains a different amount of jurisdictional wetlands than that indicated in this report. If
the client is concerned about this issue, then I strongly advise it to retain the services of a qualified
expert to perform a wetlands delineation of the subject property.
Utilities: All major public utilities, including water and sewer, have been extended to the subject property.
Adequate police and fire protection are provided by the Town of Hilton Head Island.
Easements/Encroachments: Review of the recorded plat indicates there is a known encroachment, other
than typical utility. My research of a recent survey did reveal an existing driveway encroachment.
According to the survey, a certain portion estimated to contain approximately 0.11+/- acres from an
approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area is being used for a permanent driveway easement across
and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. Currently this 0.11+/- acre
portion which is located at the east corner extending approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast
corner and is mostly rectangular in shape encroaches on land owned by The Town of Hilton Head Island
and Beaufort County.
Comments: Overall, the subject site is rectangular in shape and contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres,
of which all is believed to be usable upland area. The subject has frontage on one public roadway, Beach
City Road. Vehicular access to the site is good. Topographically, the subject property is level with
elevations from 13 to 15 feet and cleared. All major public utilities are available, and I am not aware of
any adverse issues related to wetlands, soils, site conditions, or encumbrances that would negatively
impact the use of the property. Therefore, it is my opinion that the subject property is physically suitable
40
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 20
for a wide range of development types, including residential or commercial oriented uses. However, the
limitations and restrictions imposed by the zoning district limit the overall use. As previously noted, the
subject is currently committed to public park and recreation use and it’s likely to remain unchanged into
the foreseeable future.
ZONING: (PR – Parks and Recreation)
The subject property is zoned PR, Parks and Recreation in the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Unified
Development Ordinance. The PR District is intended to accommodate and manage the land uses allowed
on publicly held land used for active or passive recreation purposes, or publicly owned land preserved in
its natural state for public enjoyment. Development in this district shall be allowed and designed to
minimize, as much as possible, its impact on both the natural environment and the community. Permitted
uses in the PR District include but are not necessarily limited to: Public, Civic, Institutional, and
Educational Uses.
AD VALOREM TAXES
The property is subject to ad valorem taxation by Beaufort County and is identified by the Beaufort County
Tax Assessor's Office as Tax Parcel Number R510 005 000 0329 0000. This office has estimated the
value of the subject property, as of December 31, 2021, at $600.
Land: $600.00
Improvements: N/A
DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY BEFORE ACQUISITION
Description of Subject Land
Size: Tax records indicate the subject property contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres.
Shape: The subject property is rectangular in shape.
Frontage: The subject property has roughly 359 feet of frontage on the southeast side of Beach City
Road.
Access: The subject property has open vehicular access along Beach City Road via one curb cut.
Topography: The site is relatively low lying and flat.
Elevations: My review of the Beaufort County GIS website indicates elevations of the subject property
to be 13-15 feet.
Flood Zone: The subject property is in Flood Zone C, which is NOT in a FEMA Flood Hazzard Area.
Map Number: 4500250085D. Map Date: September 29, 1986. FIPS: 45013. Flood Map Included.
41
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 21
Wetlands: I am NOT aware of, nor did I observe any wetland or low-lying area. No wetland delineation
study was made available to me. I am making the Extraordinary Assumption that there are NO wetlands
and the majority, if not all, 1.22 acres are developable.
As real estate appraisers, I am not qualified to perform a wetland delineation; therefore, I strongly advise
the Client to retain the services of a qualified environmental consultant if it is concerned about this issue.
Furthermore, if my assumption pertaining to wetlands is false, then it could impact the value(s) estimated
in this report.
Soils: A soil report was not provided for use in this appraisal. I am not qualified to render a technical
opinion regarding soil conditions. Therefore, it is assumed that the load-bearing capacity is sufficient to
support any reasonably probable improvements. This assumption is considered reasonable based on the
existence of improved properties in the immediate area. If the Client is concerned about this issue, then I
recommend a study by a qualified soils engineer.
Site Conditions: As appraisers, I am not qualified to determine the existence or extent of hazardous
contamination either on or below the surface of the property. For the purpose of this appraisal, I have
made the reasonable assumption that no significant hazardous contamination is present which would
impact the highest and best use, marketability, or value of the subject property. I reserve the right to revise
my opinions of highest and best use and market value if provided with independent engineering reports
that indicate significant hazardous contamination exists on the property and which include estimated costs
for its remediation to acceptable levels.
Adjoining Uses: Adjoining uses include larger, vacant tracts which are also owned by the Town of Hilton
Head Island and Beaufort County and utilized as designated park space. In addition, there is existing
residential development along Beach City Road.
Utilities: Officials with Beaufort County indicated that public water and public sewer service is available.
Easements/Encumbrances: There are typical utility easements for the area. However, there is an existing
driveway encroachment. According to the survey, a certain portion estimated to contain approximately
0.11+/- acres from an approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area is being used for a permanent
driveway easement across and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island.
This driveway encroaches on the parent property. Currently this 0.11+/- acre portion which is located at
the northeast corner extending approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast corner and is mostly
rectangular in shape encroaches on land owned by The Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County.
Functional Utility: The subject consists of a rectangular shaped, 1.22-acre tract. The property has open
vehicular access along Beach City Road, which in this area is a town maintained paved road.
Topographically, the property is partially cleared with some wooded areas and is predominately situated
outside a 100-year flood plain. Public water and sewer are in the immediate area, and it appears the
subject site is afforded with public water and sewer.
42
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 22
DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION
The proposed acquisition is for the approximate 0.11+/- acre area, which is currently serving as a private
driveway to an adjacent site and is encroaching on the Town/County-owned property, which is the subject
of this report. This portion of the property is being used for a permanent access easement across and
through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. This permanent access
easement will remain in place as it currently exists. The actual dimensions of this portion of the property
is unclear, with the exception of the east and west side showing 148’ linear feet. I have estimated that the
north and south side are approximately 27’ linear feet.
DESCRIPTION OF THE REMAINDER
Upon the release of the approximate 0.11+/- acre portion, the remainder will be similar as the property
prior to the acquisition and there will be minimal to no affect.
IMPACT OF THE RELEASED ACQUISITION ON THE REMAINDER
As such, I believe the release of the approximate 0.11+/- acre portion will have a very limited impact on
the potential use of the remaining area. Furthermore, I do not believe the release of the approximate
0.11+/- acre portion will have any impact on the future use of the unencumbered area.
HIGHEST AND BEST USE
The Appraisal Institute defines Highest and Best Use as follows:
“...that reasonable and probable use that will support the highest present value, as defined, as of the
effective date of the appraisal”
It is also defined as:
“...that use, from among reasonable and probable legal alternate uses, found to be physically possible,
appropriately supported, financially feasible, and which results in the highest land value.”
The determination of highest and best use includes identifying the motivation of probable purchasers,
analyzing the supply and demand of various property types in the market, and considering limitations
imposed by zoning and the physical characteristics of the property.
Highest and Best Use of Subject Property As Though Vacant Before The Release
Physically Possible
As discussed, the subject site is rectangular in shape and contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres, of which
all is believed to be usable upland area. The subject has frontage on one public roadway, Beach City
Road. Vehicular access to the site is good. Topographically, the subject property is level with elevations
from 13 to 20 feet and cleared. All major public utilities are available, and I am not aware of any adverse
43
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 23
issues related to wetlands, soils, site conditions, or encumbrances that would negatively impact the use of
the property. Therefore, it is my opinion that the subject property is physically suitable for a wide range
of development types, including residential or commercial oriented uses.
Legally Permissible
The subject property includes areas zoned PR; Parks and Recreation in the Town of Hilton Head Island’s
Unified Development Ordinance. The PR District is intended to accommodate and manage the land
uses allowed on publicly held land used for active or passive recreation purposes, or publicly
owned land preserved in its natural state for public enjoyment. Development in this district shall be
allowed and designed to minimize, as much as possible, its impact on both the natural environment and
the community. Permitted uses in the PR District include but are not necessarily limited to: Public, Civic,
Institutional, and Educational Uses. Consequently, any legally permissible use, which is physically
possible, could be considered.
Financially Feasible
My research shows there is good commercial and residential demand in this part of Hilton Head Island,
which is evidenced by the development of various residential and revived commercial development. In
general, I do not believe this activity would be occurring if the broader market did not believe there was
adequate demand. Considering this activity, it is reasonable to assume residential or commercial
development would be feasible on the subject property under the current market conditions. However,
considering the limitations under its current zoning district a zoning variance would need to be obtained.
This is unlikely. Therefore, the feasibility would be limited to the permitted uses.
Maximally Productive
Considering its physical, legal, and economic characteristics, it is my opinion the highest and best use of
the subject is for continued park and recreation use.
Highest and Best Use of Subject Property As Though Vacant After The Release
The highest and best use of the subject property as vacant will not change as a result of the proposed
release.
VALUATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY BEFORE THE ACQUISITION
In order to estimate the market value of the subject property before the acquisition, I have relied upon a
Sales Comparison Approach, where sales and listings of similar tracts are compared to the subject property
based on a price per gross acre, which is how these properties are normally analyzed in this market. My
research revealed relatively few sales and listings of similar tracts, and I have focused on four sales
considered the most comparable to the subject property. Details of these transactions are summarized on
the following pages, while a map showing their locations relative to the subject is included later in this
section.
44
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 24
LAND SALE ONE
LOCATION: Legal Address: Por Marshland Plantation Adjacent to Mathews Dr
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
Tax Parcel Number: R510 008 000 0015 0000
GRANTOR: United General Holdings, LLC
GRANTEE: Town of Hilton Head
SALE DATE: August 10, 2023
SALE PRICE: $350,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 4268 Page: 154
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: General Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Transfer Fee Funds, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Liam Cronin of Engels and Volkers; public records, MLS
LAND AREA: 0.52 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: MF; Marsh Front Mixed Use – Intended Zoning: PR; Parks and Recreation
FLOOD ZONE: Zone AE
IMPROVEMENTS: None
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $673,077 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a square shaped 0.52-acre site located on the west side of
Mathews Drive, just south of the traffic circle and with a deeded access easement on Matilda Drive. According to
my sources, this property was purchased by the Town of Hilton Head Island for green space to be designated as
Park and Recreation land. This site affords views of the marsh.
45
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 25
LAND SALE TWO
LOCATION: 160 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 072A 0000
GRANTOR: Fairfield Square Hilton Head, LLC
GRANTEE: Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: October 08, 2020
SALE PRICE: $475,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3919 Page: 2593
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Limited Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records, 2015 MLS, Realist
LAND AREA: 1.83 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone X
IMPROVEMENTS: Improvements were razed following the sale
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $259,563 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 1.83-acre site located on the west
side of William Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of
Hilton Head Island for use as green space, park and recreation.
46
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 26
LAND SALE THREE
LOCATION: 166 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 073A 0000
GRANTOR: Williams, Edward N.
GRANTEE: The Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: October 07, 2020
SALE PRICE: $975,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3928 Page: 0565
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Full Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records
LAND AREA: 2.6 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: PR; Park and Recreation; Formally S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone X
IMPROVEMENTS: Improvements were razed following sale
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $375,000 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 2.6-acre site located on the west
side of William Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of
Hilton Head Island for use as green space. It appears that this property was previously zoned S; Stoney Mixed Use
at the time of sale.
47
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 27
LAND SALE FOUR
LOCATION: 192 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 074F 0000
GRANTOR: MEGR, LLC
GRANTEE: The Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: January 08, 2020
SALE PRICE: $114,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3826 Page: 2326
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Limited Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records
LAND AREA: 1.07 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone AE
IMPROVEMENTS: None
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $106,542 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of an irregular shaped 1.07-acre site located on the west side of
William Hilton Parkway on the corner of Spanish Wells Road. This site was purchased by The Town of Hilton
Head for greenspace, park, and recreation.
48
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 28
The sales are compared to the subject property based primarily on the following criteria:
Zoning/Use: Properties either in the same or similar zoning district, which is a precursor to developmental
use or uses, as well as the actual intended use of the property were included.
Size: Smaller tracts tend to sell for higher unit prices when all other factors are held constant due to the
economic principle of diminishing marginal utility.
Topography: Properties with a higher percentage of wetlands and/or non-usable area relative to usable
area are considered inferior to those with a higher percentage of usable area.
My analysis of the comparable sales is provided as follows:
Sale One: This is the recent sale of a square shaped 0.52-acre site located on the west side of Mathews Drive, just
south of the traffic circle and with a deeded access easement on Matilda Drive. This site has views of the marsh.
According to my sources, this property was purchased by the Town of Hilton Head Island for green space to be
designated as Park and Recreation land.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar in terms of its location, and use. Superior in Zoning
Superior in View.
Superior in size.
Similar in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is superior to the subject due primarily due to zoning, view and size. A reasonable unit
value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should be far less than $673,077 per acre.
Sale Two: This is an older sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 1.83-acre site located on the west side of William
Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of Hilton Head Island
for use as green space, park, and recreation. This property is an interior property with no view amenity.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar to the subject in terms of its location, and use. Superior zoning.
Inferior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its larger size.
Similar to the subject in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is considered slightly inferior to the subject. Consequently, a reasonable unit value of
the subject property as indicated by this sale should therefore be slightly greater than $259,563 per acre.
Sale Three: This is an older sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 2.6-acre site located on the west side of William
Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of Hilton Head Island
for use as green space. This site has a view of the marsh.
In my opinion, this sale is:
49
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 29
Similar to the subject in terms of its location and use. Superior zoning.
Superior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its size
Similar to the subject in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is considered superior to the subject due primarily to its zoning and view. A reasonable
unit value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should therefore be less than $375,000 per acre.
Sale Four: This is an older sale of an irregular shaped 1.07-acre site located on the west side of William Hilton
Parkway on the corner of Spanish Wells Road. This site was purchased by The Town of Hilton Head for greenspace,
park, and recreation. This site has a view of the marsh, but is believed to be impacted by wetlands or soil conditions
which would limit development.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar to the subject in terms of its location, and use. Superior zoning.
Similar to the subject in terms of its size.
Superior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its topography
Inferior to the subject in terms of its shape.
Inferior to the subject in terms of development potential.
Overall, this sale is considered inferior to the subject due primarily to its topography, shape and
development potential. A reasonable unit value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should be
significantly greater than $106,542 per acre.
My analysis of the comparable sales and listing is summarized in the following table.
50
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 30
COMPARABLE LAND SALE TABULATION
Subject Sale One Sale Two Sale Three Sale Four
Location Parcel 329
Beach City Rd
Por. Marshland
Rd
160 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
166 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
192 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
Sale Date N/A Aug. 10, 2023 Oct. 08, 2020 Oct. 07, 2020 Jan. 08, 2020
Sale Price N/A $350,000 $475,000 $975,000 $114,000
Gross Land Area 1.22 0.52 1.83 2.6 1.07
Usable Area 1.22 0.52 1.83 2.6 Unknown
% Usable 100% 100% 100% 100.0% >100.0%
Zoning PR MF S S S
Flood Zone C AE X X AE
Utilities All available All available All available All available All available
Price/Gross Acre N/A $673,077 $259,563 $375,000 $106,542
Comparison to Subject
Zoning PR Superior Superior Superior Superior
Size 1.22 Acres Superior Inferior Inferior Similar
Topography/View Landscape/Park Superior Inferior Superior Similar
Shape Rectangular Similar Similar Similar Inferior
Utilities All available Similar Similar Similar Similar
Overall Comparison: N/A Superior Slightly Inferior Superior Inferior
Based on my review of the comparable sales, I believe a reasonable unit value of the fee simple interest
subject property should be less than Sale #1 and Sale #3; greater than Sale #4 and slightly greater than
Sale #2. The leading indicator is Sale #2 with an average price per gross acre of $259,563. The current
market value of the fee simple interest of the subject property is calculated as follows.
1.22 Acres x $275,000 per Acre = $335,500
Estimated Value of the ± 0.11- acre portion to be released.
The value of the release portion is calculated as follows:
Unit Value Released Area Value of Released Portion
$275,000/Acre x 0.11 Acres = $30,250
The value of the remainder portion is calculated as follows:
Unit Value Remainder Area Value of Remainder Portion
$275,000/Acre x 1.11 Acres = $305,250
In addition, I have included a chart and plat map below itemizing the few transactions where the Town of
Hilton Head sold off a portion of Town-owned property to owners of abutting sites. The sales below are
51
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 31
part of a bulk sale including fourteen 0.010 +/- acre portions. These transfers result in a price per acre of
$310,500.
TOWN OF HHI EASEMENT SALE TABULATION
Subject Sale One Sale Two Sale Three Sale Four
Location Parcel 329
Beach City Rd
45A Folly Field
Rd
44A Folly Field
Rd
47A Folly Field
Rd
46A Folly Field
Rd
Sale Date N/A May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022
Sale Price N/A $3,105 $3,105 $3,105 $3,105
Gross Land Area 0.11 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010
Usable Area N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
% Usable 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Price/Gross Acre N/A $310,500 $310,500 $310,500 $310,500
52
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 32
53
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 33
54
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 34
55
Item 10.
Coastal Property Appraisals 35
56
Item 10.
2024/ ____
AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE
THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY
BEAUFORT COUNTY WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY
ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND
WHEREAS, Beaufort County (“County”) purchased real property and is the current fee simple
co-owner of the real property with TMS No. R510 005 000 0329 0000 and being recorded in the Office of
the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina on January 29, 2013, in Book 3210 Pages 2689-
2692; hereinafter referred to as the “Property”; and
WHEREAS, the County purchased the Property through the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation
Program for $230,263 per acre, at a 70/30 cost share with the Town of Hilton Head Island (“Town”); and
WHEREAS, adjacent to the Property is the real property with TMS No. R510 005 000 010H 0000
and is currently owned by the White Family (“Residents”); hereinafter the “Adjacent Property”; and
WHEREAS, the Residents private access d rive to the Adjacent Property was previously
constructed on a portion of the Property; and
WHEREAS, the Residents desire to purchase a portion of the Property to retain their existing
private residence access to the Adjacent Property in the most direct and accessible manner possible with no
potential user conflicts; and
WHEREAS, the County and the To wn desire to convey a 0.11 acre portion of the Property, as
illustrated in the survey for Tax Parcel 329 dated August 4, 2023 (Exhibit A), for the appraised value of
$30,250 to be deposited in the County Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program Fund (#4502).
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL , duly
assembled, does hereby authorize the Interim County Administrator to execute the necessary documents to
convey a portion of property owned by Beaufort County with TMS No. R 510 005 000 0329 0000 to Mr.
Andre White, of which the proceeds will be returned to the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program
land acquisition fund.
Adopted this _____ day of ________________, 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: ______________________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Sarah Brock, Clerk to Council
57
Item 10.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
Recommend approval of a resolution authorizing the providing of funds to Lowcountry Area Transportation
Study (LATS) for Beaufort County’s portion of local match for the Norther Transit Study, the SC 315/46 and
Bluffton Parkway Extension Study, and the Bluffton Parkway from SC 170 to US 278 at the Bluffton Parkway
Flyover Study; and further to authorize the interim county administrator to execute memorandums of
understanding with Lowcountry Council of Governments for the management of the regional studies.
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Public Facility and Safety Committee – November 27, 2023
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Jared Fralix, Assistant County Administrator- Infrastructure
5 minutes
ITEM BACKGROUND:
LATS is the transportation planning entity for the region. They are working on various plans to guide
transportation improvements throughout the area. LCOG will manage the preparation of the regional
studies.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
If planning studies are completely within SCDOT’s network, guideshare funds can be used for the entirety of
the project. In the event there are some local roads within the project area, a 20% local match is required.
Currently, there are three planning studies that LATS is working on that involve local streets and a local match
is required. The plan is for the local match to be divided amongst the applicable jurisdictions for each study.
Beaufort County’s pro rata share for the Northern Transit Study will not exceed $25,000, for the SC 315/SC 46
study will not exceed $10,000 and for the Bluffton Parkway will not exceed $30,000.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The match for the Bluffton Parkway’s study will come from 2000 Bluffton impact fees professional services
account 2300-30-0000-51160 with a balance of $7,331,998.85.
The match for the SC315/SC 46’s study and the Northern Transit Study will come from Road Use Fee funds
professional services account 2342-30-0000-51160 with a balance of $1,558,409.65.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Recommend approval of a resolution to authorize the use of matching funds for Beaufort County’s portion of
the Local Match for three planning studies through LATS and authorize the Interim Administrator to execute
the Memorandums of Understanding (MOU) with LCOG for each of the three planning studies.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve/deny the recommended approval of a resolution the use of matching funds for Beaufort
County’s portion of the Local Match for three planning studies through LATS and to authorize the Interim
58
Item 11.
County Administrator to execute the Memorandums of Understanding (MOU) with LCOG for each of the
three planning studies.
59
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
MEMORANDUM of UNDERSTANDING
BETWEEN
Beaufort County and
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG)
Subject: SC 315/SC 46 Bluffton Parkway Local Match
The Lowcountry Council of Governments in cooperation with the Lowcountry Area
Transportation Study has identified completing a corridor study for SC 315/SC46 and the
Bluffton parkway extension as a priority in the 2045 in the Long Ragne Transportation Plan.
$450,000 was programmed in the Transportation Improvement Program to fund the study.
1. The purpose of this MOU is to engage the services of the Planning Department of the
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG) to manage the preparation of a study on
behalf of LATS.
2. Beaufort County, the City of Hardeeville, the Town of Bluffton and Jasper County will
serve as key stakeholders on the Advisory Committees created , providing input to the
project team.
3. Work will consist of, but not be limited to the following tasks:
a. Establish a project steering committee.
b. Data collection and map existing conditions
c. Interim findings
d. Prepare recommendations, policy, and regulations.
e. Implementation plan
f. Complete a draft and final document for review.
g. Complete final report
4. The total cost of the project is $200,000. The Federal share is $160,000 and local share is
$40,000. No single party will be held responsible for the lack of funding from another
entity. The local share is to be split between the four local entities:
a. Beaufort County will not exceed $10,000.
b. City of Hardeeville will not exceed $10,000.
c. Town of Bluffton will not exceed $10,000.
d. Jasper County will not exceed $10,000.
60
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
5. The completion date is estimated to be Spring 2024.
6. Beaufort County, the Town of Bluffton, City of Hardeeville and Jasper County will be
provided with all relevant documentation at the conclusion of the study.
7. This agreement will become effective upon the signature of both parties’ authorized
officials.
Signed:
Beaufort County Lowcountry Council of Governments
Date Date
61
Item 11.
RESOLUTION 2024/
A RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE THE PROVIDING OF FUNDS TO
LOWCOUNTRY AREA TRANSPORTATION STUDY (LATS) FOR BEAUFORT
COUNTY’S PORTION OF LOCAL MATCH FOR THE NORTHERN TRANSIT
STUDY, THE SC 315/46 AND BLUFFTON PARKWAY EXTENSION STUDY,
AND THE BLUFFTON PARKWAY FROM SC 170 TO US 278 AT THE
BLUFFTON PARKWAY FLYOVER STUDY; AND FURTHER TO AUTHORIZE
THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE MEMORANDUMS
OF UNDERSTANDING WITH LOWCOUNTRY COUNCIL OF
GOVERNMENTS FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF THE REGIONAL STUDIES
WHEREAS, Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) is the transportation
planning entity for the regional metropolitan planning organization (MPO); and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County is one of the jurisdictions within the MPO of which there
are seven (7) members (Beaufort County, Jasper County, Port Royal, City of Beaufort,
Hardeeville, Bluffton and Hilton Head; and
WHEREAS, the County desires to enter into Memorandums of Understanding (MOU) to
engage the services of the Planning Department of Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG)
to manage the preparation of regional studies on a Northern Transit Study, SC 315/SC 46 study,
and Bluffton Parkway from SC 170 to US 278 study on behalf of LATS; and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County is required to provide our pro rata share of the local match
for certain regional studies that LATS conducts; and
WHEREAS, the Northern Transit Study will look at and evaluate mass transit needs,
potential routes, and projects for the urbanized areas north of the Broad . The local share cost of
the study is $50,000 to be paid as follows:
1. Beaufort County will not exceed $25,000.
2. City of Beaufort will not exceed $12,500.
3. Town of Port Royal will not exceed $12,500.
WHEREAS, the SC 315/SC 46 and the Bluffton Pkwy Extension study will evaluate
needed roadway improvements in the Southern part of Beaufort and Jasper County The local share
cost of the study is $40,000 to be paid as follows:
1. Beaufort County will not exceed $10,000.
2. City of Hardeeville will not exceed $10,000.
3. Town of Bluffton will not exceed $10,000.
4. Jasper County will not exceed $10,000.
WHEREAS, the Bluffton Parkway from SC 170 to US 278 at the Bluffton Parkway
flyover will evaluate access management and corridor improvements throughout the parkway to
enhance safety and capacity withing the corridor . The local share cost of the study is $40,000 to
be paid as follows:
62
Item 11.
1. Beaufort County will not exceed $30,000.
2. Town of Bluffton will not exceed $10,000.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED at a duly called meeting of
Beaufort County Council, that the Interim County Administrator is hereby provided the authority
necessary to provide the local match ing funds for the aforementioned studies and to sign the
Memorandums of Understanding with LCOG related to each study.
Adopted this 26th day of February 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: _______________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
63
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
MEMORANDUM of UNDERSTANDING
BETWEEN
Beaufort County and
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG)
Subject: Bluffton Parkway Local Match
The Lowcountry Council of Governments in cooperation with the Lowcountry Area
Transportation Study has identified completing a corridor study for Bluffton Parkway from the
Flyover to SC 170 a priority in the 2045 Long Range Transportation Plan. $200,000 was
programmed in the Transportation Improvement Program to fund the study.
1. The purpose of this MOU is to engage the services of the Planning Department of the
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG) to manage the preparation of a study on
behalf of LATS.
2. Beaufort County and the Town of Bluffton will serve as key stakeholders on the
Advisory Committees created , providing input to the project team.
3. Work will consist of, but not be limited to the following tasks:
a. Establish a project steering committee.
b. Data collection and map existing conditions
c. Interim findings
d. Prepare recommendations, policy, and regulations.
e. Implementation plan
f. Complete a draft and final document for review.
g. Complete final report
4. The total cost of the project is $200,000. The Federal share is $160,000 and local share is
$40,000. No single party will be held responsible for the lack of funding from another
entity. The local share is to be split between the two local entities:
a. Beaufort County will not exceed $30,000.
b. Town of Bluffton will not exceed $10,000.
5. The completion date is estimated to be December 31st, 2024.
64
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
6. Beaufort County and the Town of Bluffton will be provided with all relevant documentation
at the conclusion of the study.
7. This agreement will become effective upon the signature of both parties’ authorized
officials.
Signed:
Beaufort County Lowcountry Council of Governments
Date Date
65
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
MEMORANDUM of UNDERSTANDING
BETWEEN
Beaufort County and
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG)
Subject: Northern Beaufort County Transit Study
The Lowcountry Council of Governments in cooperation with the Lowcountry Area
Transportation Study has identified completing a transit Study in Northern Beaufort County as a
priority in the 2045 in both the urban and rural Long Range Transportation Plans. $200,000 was
programmed in the Transportation Improvement Program to fund the study.
1. The purpose of this MOU is to engage the services of the Planning Department of the
Lowcountry Council of Governments (LCOG) to manage the preparation of a transit study
for the Northern portion of Beaufort County, the City of Beaufort and the Town of Port
Royal.
2. Beaufort County, the City of Beaufort and the Town of Port Royal along with Palmetto
Breeze will serve as key stakeholders on the Advisory Committees created , providing
input to the project team.
3. Work will consist of, but not be limited to the following tasks:
a. Establish a project steering committee.
b. Data collection and map existing conditions
c. Interim findings
d. Prepare recommendations, policy, and regulations.
e. Implementation plan
f. Complete a draft and final document for review.
g. Complete final report
4. The LCOG planning department successfully applied for federal funds to conduct the work
while local governments will supply the 20% local match. The total cost of the project is
$250,000. The Federal share is $200,000 and local share is $50,000. No single party will
be held responsible for the lack of funding from another entity. The local share is to be
split between the three local entities:
a. Beaufort County will not exceed $25,000.
66
Item 11.
Serving Beaufort Colleton Hampton Jasper Counties
Lowcountry Council of Governments
PO Box 98 634 Campground Road
Yemassee, South Carolina 29945
P: 843.726.5536 F: 843.726.5165
www.lowcountrycog.org
b. City of Beaufort will not exceed $12,500.
c. Town of Port Royal will not exceed $12,500.
5. The completion date is estimated to be December 31st, 2024.
6. Beaufort County, The Town of Port Royal and the City of Beaufort will be provided with all
relevant documentation at the conclusion of the study.
7. This agreement will become effective upon the signature of both parties’ authorized
officials.
Signed:
Beaufort County Lowcountry Council of Governments
Date Date
67
Item 11.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
SECOND READING OF AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING FIFTEEN PERCENT OF FY24
GROSS STATE ACCOMMODATIONS TAX REVENUE TO DEVELOPMENT OF
WORKFORCE HOUSING
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
County Council, February 12, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
John Robinson, County Administrator
5 minutes
ITEM BACKGROUND:
During its 2023 legislative session, the South Carolina General Assembly adopted (and the
governor subsequently signed into law) Act 57. This Act amended the South Carolina Code of
Laws to permit the use of state accommodations tax revenue and local accommodations tax
revenue for the development of workforce housing. The Act established several steps that a
governing body must satisfy before state accommodations tax revenue is expended on
workforce
Council has made the development and funding of workforce housing a priority. On January
22, 2024 Council approved by title only first reading of an ordinance appropriating fifteen
percent of FY24’s gross state accommodations tax revenue to the development of workforce
housing subject to review by the state a-tax committee and compliance with the all the
requirements of South Carolina Code of Laws. The proposed ordinance requires that these
steps be satisfied before these funds are expended.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
See above
FISCAL IMPACT:
If approved, Council will be appropriating and committing fifteen percent of fiscal FY24’s
gross state accommodations tax revenue to the development of workforce housing. The
County and Council will need to satisfy, by subsequent action, all the requirements of the
South Carolina Code of Laws before these funds are expended.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Council can approve the motion, deny the motion, modify it, or defer it.
68
Item 1.
69
Item 1.
ORDINANCE 2024/________
AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING FIFTEEN PERCENT OF FY24 GROSS STATE
ACCOMMODATIONS TAX REVENUE TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF
WORKFORCE HOUSING
WHEREAS, Act 57 of the 2023 South Carolina General Assembly Legislative Session
amended S.C. Code of Laws §6 -4-5 et seq. , Allocation of Accommodations Tax Revenue, to
permit the County to dedicate and expend up to fifteen percent of its annual two percent
accommodations tax revenue for the development of workforce housing which must include
programs to promote home ownership; and
WHEREAS, the Act provides that prior to the expenditure of these funds for the development
of workforce housing, the County must satisfy several requirements as set forth in the Act; and
WHEREAS, Council is aware of the critical need for workforce housing in unincorporated
Beaufort County and has come to appreciate the difficulty in finding funds to satisfy this need; and
WHEREAS, in light of the tremendous need for workforce housing in unincorporated Beaufort
County and the general lack of funds to meet this need, Council desires to appropriate and to
commit (pursuant to Section 6 -4-10(4)(c)(ii)) fifteen percent of the gross state local
accommodations tax revenue (2%) it receives pursuant to Section 6 -4-5 et seq. for FY24 to the
development of workforce housing as set forth in Section 6-4-10(4)(b)(ix).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT Beaufort County Council does hereby
appropriate and commit fifteen percent of the state local accommodations tax revenue it receives
pursuant to Section 6-4-5 et seq. in FY24 to the development of workforce housing as permitted
by Act 57 and further directs that none of these funds may be expended until such time as Beaufort
County has satisfied all the requirements that are set forth therein.
Adopted this _______day of _________________ 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: ____________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
___________________________
Sarah Brock, JD
Clerk to Council
70
Item 1.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
An ordinance authorizing the Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease agreement with the South
Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for property located under the Cross Island Parkway adjacent
to the Broad Creek Boat Landing parcel R552 010 000 0650 0000.
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Public Facilities & Safety Committee Meeting January 22, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Jared Fralix, P.E., Assistant County Administrator, Infrastructure
(5 Minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
On May 7, 2002 Beaufort County and The Town of Hilton Head Island executed an Intergovernmental
Agreement associated with the construction of a boat ramp off Broad Creek. Recently, the Town of Hilton
Head Island and the County have been working with SCDOT to formalize use of the property located under
the Cross Island Parkway that has been in use for approximately 20 years. SCDOT requested a public interest
finding from FHWA so the County can lease the property gratis.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
SCDOT and the County have finalized a lease agreement for the property located under the Cross Island
Parkway associated with the Broad Creek Boat Landing parcel # R552 010 000 0650 0000 . SCDOT will lease
this property to the County at no cost (gratis).
FISCAL IMPACT:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval of an ordinance authorizing the Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease
agreement with the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for property located under the
Cross Island Parkway adjacent to the Broad Creek Boat Landing parcel R552 010 000 0650 0000.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve/deny an ordinance authorizing the Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease
agreement with the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for property located under the
Cross Island Parkway adjacent to the Broad Creek Boat Landing parcel R552 010 000 0650 0000.
An approval vote by Committee would move the item to full County Council for three readings and a public
hearing to approve the ordinance.
71
Item 2.
ORDINANCE 2024/_________
AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO ENTER
INTO A LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION (SCDOT) FOR PROPERTY LOCATED UNDER THE CROSS ISLAND
PARKWAY ADJACENT TO THE BROAD CREEK BOAT LANDING PARCEL R552 0 10 000
0650 0000
WHEREAS, Beaufort County (“County”) and the Town of Hilton Head Island (“Town”) entered
into an Intergovernmental Agreement on May 7, 2002 to construct a boat ramp off Broad Creek on parcel
# R550 010 000 0650 0000; and
WHEREAS, the County completed the boat ramp in the 2003 time frame and the public has been
utilizing the boat ramp and area under the Cross Island Parkway for approximately 20 years; and
WHEREAS, the South Carolin a Department of Transportation (“SCDOT”) has ownership
interests in the property located under the Cross Island Parkway adjacent to the County boat ramp on parcel
#R550 010 000 0650 0000. The County recently approached SCDOT about transferring ownership interests
to the County, but SCDOT needs to retain ownership for bridge /highway maintenance purposes. SCDOT
offered to lease the property gratis. More specific lease information is provided on attached Exhibit “A”;
and
WHEREAS, County Council finds that it is in best interest of the citizens and residents of Beaufort
County for the Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease agreement with the South Carolina
Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for property located under the Cross Island Parkway adjacent to
the Broad Creek Boat Landing parcel R552 010 000 0650 0000.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED that Beaufort County Council hereby authorizes the
Interim County Administrator to enter into a lease agreement with the South Carolina Department of
Transportation (SCDOT) for property located under the Cross Island Parkway adjacent to the Broad Creek
Boat Landing parcel R552 010 000 0650 0000.
ADOPTED this ______ day of _____, 20___.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: _______________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Sarah W. Brock,
Clerk to Council
72
Item 2.
Exhibit “A”
Final Lease SCDOT to Beaufort County January 2024
73
Item 2.
1 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) LEASE AGREEMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
This Lease Agreement is made this ________ day of _____________________, 2024, by
and between the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) (“Lessor”) and
Beaufort County, its successors and/or assigns (“Lessee”).
1. Lease and Use of Premises
a) Lessor hereby leases to Lessee and Lessee hereby leases from Lessor the following
described property (hereinafter referred to as “the Premises”) for use as parking:
ALL AND SINGULAR, all that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, situate ,
lying and being in the town of Hilton Head Island in Beaufort County, South
Carolina, containing approximately 2.05 acres and being shown on highway
plans for US Route 278, File 7.558, Sheets 13 & 32, Tract 41 and for Road
S-80 under File 7.558, sheet 16 as portions of Tracts 113, 114, 116, and 121,
and designated as “ Lease Area” on the attached Exhibit A, and also being
shown on “Dufuskie Island at Cross Island, Overall Site Plan prepared by
Davis & Floyd, dated October 2023; on the attached Exhibit B. Said property
being acquired by the South Carolina Department of Transportatio n by
General Warranty Deed from Plantation Land Company, Inc. dated August
5, 1994, and recorded on January 26, 1995, in Book 30042 at Page 325 in the
Office of the Register of Mesne Conveyances for Beaufort County. Adjacent
to TMS Number R552-010-000-0309-0000 and R552-010-000-0650-0000.
b) Restricted Use of Premises
1) Lessee’s use of the Premises shall be subordinate at all times to SCDOT’s use
of the Premises for Highway Purposes. As used herein, the term “Highway
Purposes” means the operation, use, maintenance, construction, or reconstruction
of the highway facilities, including but not limited to the piers, columns, and other
structural support of the highways and bridge facilities. Lessee shall use and
maintain the Premises at all times in a manner that will not interfere with the use
of the Premises and SCDOT facilities thereon for Highway Purposes.
2) Lessee shall use and manage the Premises exclusively for public purposes,
specifically as follows:
(i) to make parking available f or passenger vehicles for patrons of Cross
Island Boat Landing ; and to install and maintain a ferry embarkation dock
near, but not under the bridge on Premises;
(ii) for park and recreational uses; and
74
Item 2.
2 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
(iii) for pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicular access, ingress, and egress, including
walking, jogging, and biking paths and/or trails to other property of the Lessee
or to parking, park, and recreational uses on the Premises.
(iv) at no time shall any vehicle or recreational vehicle be used as living and/or
sleeping quarters while parked on the Premises. Lessee will be responsible for
operation, security, landscaping, trash, ice and snow removal and all
maintenance of the parking and recreational park facilities.
3) SCDOT has complete authority to require that the Lessee install approved
protective barriers at bridge piers and at low elevation structures of any bridge
affected by construction plans and improvements prepared and approved in
accordance with Paragraph 6) of this Section. SCDOT can regulate or prohibit the
type of machinery and use of the Premises in any manner necessary to insure
protection of highway structures.
4) Vehicular access to any portion of the Premises affected by construction plans
and improvements prepared and approved in accordance with Paragraph 6) of this
Section will be restricted by Lessee with fences, bollards or other means to prevent
regular use of vehicles larger than a passenger vehicle (16’ height limitation), but
to allow access by emergency vehicles, fire trucks and SCDOT’s maintenance
vehicles and trucks whenever necessary.
5) No use will be made o f the space within ten feet (10’ ) of any bridge pier or
column. To the extent any piers or columns are affected by construction plans and
improvements prepared and approved in accordance with Paragraph 6) of this
Section, said piers or columns shall be protected by Lessee, at no expense to
SCDOT, with protective devices suitable to and approved by SCDOT’s District Six
Engineering Administrator, or his or her designee (the “DEA”). No flexible
pavement will be utilized within five feet (5’) of any bridge pier or column.
Exceptions upon approval of SCDOT’s District Six Engineering Administrator or
designee may include:
(a) Install and maintain parking spaces as needed
(b) Install and maintain walkways, both surface and raised as needed
6) All construction plans and improveme nts to the Premises must be
preapproved by the DEA, who may be contacted as follows:
SCDOT District Six Engineering Administrator
6355 Fain Boulevard
North Charleston, SC 29406
843-740-1667(Office); 843-740-1663 (Fax)
Any outstanding issues with respect to plans, improvements, modifications, etc.
of the individual Premises that cannot be resolv ed by the DEA and the Lessee
shall be elevated to the Deputy Secretary for Engineering in Columbia. The
Deputy Secretary for Engineering shall review and make the final determination.
7) Unless approved by the DEA in accordance with Paragraph 6 of this Section,
the following modifications to the Premises shall not be allowed:
(a) Change in site grades or fill elevation;
(b) Trenching for drain structures; or
(c) Additional storm water drainage discharged into bridge ponds.
(d) Additional off-site storm water drainage from private parcels
8) Without the prior written approval of the DEA, the Lessee shall not do any
of the following on the Premises:
a) change or divert, or fill drainage under or around bridge structures;
b) mine, remove soil or any ground materials; or
75
Item 2.
3 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
c) install signs, displays or lighting.
d) additional off-site storm water drainage from private parcels
9) No flammable, explosive or hazardous materials of any kind shall be allowed
on the Premises.
10) The operation and use of the Premises by Lessee shall not permit
objectionable smoke, fumes, steam, vapor, or odors to rise above the grade line of
the highway.
11) The Premises shall be subject to the SCDOT’s superior right at all times:
a) E ntry for emergency inspections and/or repairs . If SCDOT, in its sole
discretion, determines that emergency inspection and/or repairs are
necessary in the interests of public safety, SCDOT, its agents, contractors,
and employees, shall have the right to enter the Premises without notice to
Lessee for the purposes of inspection and/or repair.
b) Entry for non- emergency situations . In cases other than such
emergencies, SCDOT, its agents, contractors and employees, shall have the
right to enter the Premises upon no less than 48 hours prior notice for any
reason including maintenance, repair and inspection of the Premises or the
highway or bridge facilities. Lessee shall remove or have removed at its own
cost any vehicles or other obstructions to such work.
c) Responsibility for damages or injuries . Except in the case of gross
negligence or willful misconduct, neither SCDOT, nor its agents or
employees, shall be held responsible for costs or damages to the Lessee, or
anyone claiming through Lessee, fo r damages to property or injuries to
persons arising from the work described in subparagraphs a) and b) directly
above.
2. Rental and Covenant to pay rent . Lessee shall pay SCDOT rent at the rate of $1.00
per year. As additional rent, Lessee shall be responsible for maintaining the Premises in
a safe, clean and attractive condition, to include without limitation regular mowing.
3. Term of Lease. The lease term will run for a thirty (3 5) year period beginning at
12:00AM on_____________________________, and ending at 12:00am on
____________________________, unless otherwise terminated in accordance with this Lease.
4. Security Deposit. There will be no security deposit required.
5. Condition of the Premises. The Lessee acknowledges that it has examined and knows
the condition of the Premises and that no representations as to the condition or repair of
the Premises have been made to Lessee by SCDOT. SCDOT makes no warranties or
representations as to the condition of the Premises or the fitness of the Premises for
Lessee’s intended use. Should the Premises be deemed to be unsuitable for parking at any
time during the term of this Lease by any governmental or regulatory authority through
no fault of Lessee, Lessee may immediately terminate this Lease without penalty.
6. Repairs, improvements, or modifications . The Lessee shall keep the Premises in a
good and safe state of repair. The Lessee shall make no repairs, modifications, or
improvements on the Premises without the prior written consent of the DEA.
.
7. Outdoor Advertising. No outdoor advertising shall be allowed on the Premises.
8. Responsibility for Claims . Lessee acknowledges its responsib ility for acts of its
employees and officials within the limits of the S.C. Tort Claims Act. Lessee shall reimburse
SCDOT for any and all damages to the highway and bridge facilities arising out of the use
of the Premises for Lessee’s purposes caused by the negligent or intentional acts of the City.
76
Item 2.
4 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
9. Insurance. The Lessee will obtain and keep in effect during the term of the Lease a
policy of Commercial General Liability insurance with minimum limits of liability of
$1,000,000.00 per occurrence and $2,000,000.00 in the aggregate to cover any and all
liability that the Lessee or Lessor may incur as a result of the Lessee’s occupancy of the
Premises and suc h policy shall name Lessor as an additional named insured. Proof of
insurance must be provided to the Lessor.
10. Taxes and Insurance. The Lessee agrees to pay all taxes, insurance, water and other
utilities imposed or charged upon the Premises or upon the Lessor and Lessee in respect
thereof. At the execution of this Lease there are no taxes due and owing on the Premises
for which the Lessee is responsible. If at any time during the term of this Lease any taxes
are assessed against the Premises for which Lessee is responsible , Lessor shall notify
Lessee upon receipt of such notice at the Lessor’s Property Management Office and Lessee
shall make payment for such taxes directly to the entity assessing the taxes and provide
the Lessor a copy of the paid receipt.
11. Compliance with Laws. The Lessee agrees to use the Premises for legal purposes only
and agrees to comply with all local, state and federal laws and ordinances governing the
use and occupancy thereof.
12. Default Remedies. If any rental installment shall be due and remain unpaid ten ( 10)
business days after the due date, or if default shall be made in any of the covenants and
terms of this Lease Agreement on the part of the Lessee, then it shall be lawful for the
Lessor to re -enter the Premises and to again have, possess and enjoy the same. Lessor
shall give Lessee writ ten notice of any default other than failure to pay rent and an
opportunity to cure the default within fifteen (15) days. If the default cannot be cured
within fifteen (15) days and Lessee promptly commences and diligently pursues a cure of
the default, L essor will grant Lessee a reasonable time to cure, not to exceed thirty (30)
days. If not cured, Lessor may terminate this lease.
13. Termination.
a) Either party may elect to terminate this Lease Agreement for “Just Cause” (as
hereinafter defined) at any time during the life of the Lease upon ninety (90) days written
notice given to the other party. The parties will incur no damages, liabilities, or
responsibilities by reason of such termination. “Just Cause” shall mean the need for major
structural repairs or major maintenance to be made to the bridge structure located within
the Premises.
b) Lessor shall also have the right to terminate this Lease Agreement purs uant to
the provisions of Paragraphs (6), (12), (16) (b).
c) Termination shall not operate to relieve Lessee from its responsibility for any
charges payable pursuant to this Lease or for any damages to the Premises or Lessor’s
improvements on the Premises.
d) In lieu of terminating for Just Cause, if the repairs can be made within six (6)
months, Lessee can agree to vacate the Premises until repairs are complete and rent shall
abate for an equal period and add the equal number of months onto the tail end of the
Lease.
14. Lessee’s Duty as to Condition of Premises upon Termination or Default.
a) Upon termination or default of the Lease, the Lessee shall vacate the Premises
and leave it in good and clean condition, free of vehicles and debris. Failure to clean and
clear the Premises will result in direct action for damages should Less or incur any
expenses for cleaning or clearing the Premises, including attorney’s fees and costs in
bringing such action.
b) Upon expiration or earlier termination of the Lease, Lessor may, at their option,
request the removal of any improvements made by the Lessee. If such request is made,
the removal shall be accomplished by the Lessee in a manner prescribed by Lessor at no
cost to the Lessor. If such request is not made, any modifications or improvements to the
Premises made by Lessee shall become the property of Lessor and shall be surrendered
77
Item 2.
5 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
to Lessor upon the expiration or prior termination of this Lease and Lessee shall not be
required to remove any modifications or improvements made to the Premises.
15. Assignment. The Lessee may not assign or sublet the Premises; provided, however,
the County may rent monthly and daily parking passes to the general public in compliance
with all applicable fede ral, state, and local laws. Charges for parking shall be limited to
an amount necessary to recoup the County’s cost of improvements, maintenance , security
and regulating/management of parking.
16. Lease Subject to Other Rights . This Lease is being made subject to any and all
existing public utility rights of user, reservations, easements, rights of way, control of
access, zoning ordinances and restrictions or protective covenants that may appear of
record or on the Premises, ot her than those hereby released. It is understood and agreed
by the parties hereto that Lessor holds Control of Access rights along the boundary line of
many of its properties. The Premises being subject to the Lessor’s superior right at all
times, Lessor retains the right to enter the Premises at any reasonable time for any reason
including maintenance of the Premises or its improvements on the Premises without any
liability or cause for complaint by Lessee, or anyone claiming through Lessee, and Lessor
shall not be held responsible for costs or damages to the Lessee, or anyone claiming through
Lessee, except to the extent caused by the willful conduct or gross negligence of Lessor, its
officers, employees, agents and contractors.
a) The Lessee shall not mine, remove soil or any ground materials from the subject
property other than in conjunction with work that is permitted in paragraphs 1 (b) (ii) and
by encroachment permit, without specific wri tten permission from the Lessor’ s local
District Engineering Administrator. Lessor shall have and retain all mineral and timber
rights to the land.
b) Lessee’s operation on the Premises shall not interfere in any way with the
Lessor’s use of the Premises for highway purposes and if such interference takes place,
Lessor shall have the right to immediately terminate this Lease without any liability to the
Lessee for such termination and Lessee shall compensate Lessor for any damages to
Lessor’s property by reason of Lessee’s operations.
17. Hazardous Waste. Lessee shall be responsible for the cleanup of any hazardous waste
contamination caused by their use of the premises without liability to the Lessor.
18. Relocation Benefits . Lessee acknowledges that Lessee will not qualif y for relocation
benefits upon the termination of this Lease.
19. Notices. Any notice by either party to the other shall be val id only if it is in writing
and delivered personally or by certified mail to the addresses shown below, unless the other
party is notified in writing of a new address:
20. Use of Generated Revenues . Lessee shall dedicate and expend any revenues
generated under this lease solely for maintenance and/or improvements to the Premises,
security, and/or regulation and management of parking on the Premises.
21. Entire Agreement. This Lease contains the entire agreement of the parties and no
representations, inducements, promises or agreements, oral or otherwise, between the
parties not stated herein, shall be of any force or effect.
If to Lessor:
South Carolina Department of
Transportation
955 Park Street
Columbia, SC 29202
Attn: Property Management
If to Lessee:
Beaufort County
104 Industrial Village Rd,
Beaufort, SC 29902
Attn: Pat Wilson
78
Item 2.
6 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
22. Applicable Law. This Lease shall be governed by and interpreted in accordance with
the laws of the State of South Carolina.
23. Severability. If any clause or provision of this Lease is illegal, invalid or
unenforceable, under present or future laws effective during the term hereof, then it is the
intention of the parties hereto that the remainder of this Lease shall not be affected thereby
and it is also the intention of both parties that in lieu of each clause or provision as similar
in terms to such illegal, invalid or unenforceable clause or provision as may be possible and
be legal, valid and enforceable; provided however, that both partie s must agree in writing
to such substitute language and provisions before such will become binding on either party.
24. Counterparts. This Lease may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of
which shall be deemed an original, but all of which toge ther shall constitute one and the
same instrument. Faxed signatures are acceptable with the understanding that the parties
will use their best efforts to promptly deliver original signatures to the other parties.
25. Non-discrimination Clause . The parties covenant that the use of these premises
pursuant to this Agreement shall in no way discriminate on the grounds of race, religion,
color, sex, age, disability or national origin.
REMAINDER INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
79
Item 2.
7 | Page
Lessee______ Date _______ Lessor______ Date ________ Lessor ______ Date ________
Signed, sealed and delivered SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF
in the presence of TRANSPORTATION
“LESSOR”
_______________________________ By: (L.S.)
Witness Christy A. Hall, PE, Secretary of Transportation
_______________________________ By: (L.S.)
Madeleine Hendry, Acting Deputy Secretary for
Finance and Administration
THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
)
) PROBATE
COUNTY OF RICHLAND )
Personally appeared before me _____________________________________________ and
made oath that s(he) saw the within named South Carolina Department of Transportation, by
its duly authorized officers, Christy A. Hall, PE, Secretary of Transportation and Madeleine
Hendry, Acting Deputy Secretary for Finance and Administration, sign, seal with its corporate
seal, and as its act and deed delivered the within written instrument, and that s(he) with
_____________________________________________ witnessed the execution thereof.
SWORN to before me this ______ ______________________________
day of __________________, 2024 Witness
_______________________________
Notary Public for South Carolina
_______________________________
Printed Name of Notary
My Commission Expires: ________
LESSEE SIGNATURE ON FOLLOWING PAGE
Witness
80
Item 2.
THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) PROBATE
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
Personally appeared before me _____________________________________________ and
made oath that s(he) saw the within named South Carolina Department of Transportation, by
its duly authorized officers, __________________________________, sign, seal with its corporate
seal, and as its act and deed delivered the within written instrument, and that s(he) with
_____________________________________________ witnessed the execution thereof.
SWORN to before me this ______ ______________________________
day of __________________, 2024 Witness
_______________________________
Notary Public for South Carolina
_______________________________
Printed Name of Notary
My Commission Expires: ________
Signed, sealed and delivered in the
presence of
BEAUFORT COUNTY
“LESSEE”
________________________________ By_________________________________(L.S.)
Witness
Its: _________________________________
81
Item 2.
Approx 2.05 Acres
Lease Area
Sheet 32 & 32A
File 7.558 S-80
Beaufort Co.
(Cross Island Expressway)S-80
EXHIBIT "__"A
25
SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
SCALE
0
FEET
50 25
SCALE
0
FEET
50COUNTY PREPARED
08/23/2023
DRAWING 809-105-00.
STANDARD SCDOT WITH COMPLIANCE IN DEEDS OF REGISTER THE TO SUBMITTED
BE SHALL PLAT WAY OF RIGHT RECORDABLE A CONSTRUCTION, OF COMPLETION UPON
ADDITIONALLY, 29201. SC COLUMBIA, STREET, PARK 955 HEADQUARTERS; SCDOT FROM
OBTAINED BE CAN WHICH OF COPY A PLANS, ENGINEERING TO REFERENCE DIRECT
IN IS AND AREA" "LEASE THE OF REPRESENTATION GRAPHIC A IS EXHIBIT THIS
AREA OF LEASE Approx - 2.05 AC File - 7.558
Beaufort
82
Item 2.
OWNER
THESE DRAWINGS AND THE DESIGN THEREON ARE THE PROPERTY OF DAVIS & FLOYD, INC. AND MAY NOT BE USED IN WHOLE OR IN PART WITHOUT WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ENGINEER / ARCHITECT AND ANY INFRINGEMENT WILL BE SUBJECT TO LEGAL ACTIONF:\Projects\2023\2023 Projects\J23707 Daufuskie Ferry at Cross Island Landing Ph 1\dwg\J22746_mst.dwg, 10/4/2023 11:53:06 AM, chris bates, pe
PROJECT TITLE
DRAWING TITLENO. RELEASEDCHECKEDDATE
PAGEOF
CHECKED
DESIGNED
JOB NO.
DRAWN
APPROVED
DATE
2712 BULL STREET, SUITE ABEAUFORT, SC 29902843-743-9135
Overall Site PlanBEAUFORT COUNTY
DAUFUSKIE ISLAND AT CROSS ISLAND
4C20015CABCAB
CABCAB
October 202303214100
PROJECT DATUM INFORMATION: HORIZONTAL DATUM: NAD83VERTICAL DATUM: NAVD88
003060 SCALE: 1" = 30'
R
Know what'sbelow.before you dig.Call
83
Item 2.
Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.