Community Services and Land Use Committee — Agenda Packet
Beaufort County · Beaufort County · Community Services Committee · meeting of Feb 12, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Beaufort County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Community Services and Land Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, February 12, 2024
3:00 PM
AGENDA
COMMITTEE MEMBERS:
ALICE HOWARD, CHAIR YORK GLOVER, VICE-CHAIRMAN
GERALD DAWSON PAULA BROWN
THOMAS REITZ JOSEPH PASSIMENT, EX-OFFICIO
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION OF THIS MEETING HAS BEEN PUBLISHED, POSTED, AND DISTRIBUTED IN
COMPLIANCE WITH THE SOUTH CAROLINA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES- November 13, 2023, November 23, 2023- Workshop, December 11, 2023-
Special Called Meeting,
6. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD- 15 MINUTES TOTAL
Anyone who wishes to speak during the Citizen Comment por tion of the meeting will limit their
comments and speak no longer than three (3) minutes. Speakers will address Council in a respectful
manner appropriate to the decorum of the meeting, refraining from the use of profane, abusive, or
obscene language. In a ccordance with Beaufort County's Rules and Procedures, giving of a speaker's
time to another is not allowed.
7. ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR REPORT - Chuck Atkinson, Assistant County Administrator
Development, and Audra Antonacci-Ogden, Assistant County Administrator Community Services
AGENDA ITEMS
8. PRESENTATION BY THE TECHNICAL COLLEGE OF THE LOWCOUNTRY
9. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY BEAUFORT
COUNTY WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY ROAD, HILTON HEAD
ISLAND (FISCAL IMPACT: Beaufort County will receive $30,250 from the Buyer. 70% of the funds from
1
County Council Agenda – Beaufort County, SC
the sale will be deposited into the Rural and Critical Bond Fund (4500 -80-0000-47010) to be used
towards future acquisitions by the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program 30% of the funds will
be reimbursed to the Town of Hilton Head)
10. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO PURCHASE (1) NEW 36 PASSENGER BUS MODEL: STARCRAFT ALLSTAR
XL (FISCAL IMPACT: $188,760.00)
11. ADJOURNMENT
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html
2
Community Services and Land Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, November 13, 2023
3:00 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Chair Howard called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
PRESENT
Chair Alice Howard
Vice-Chair York Glover
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member York Glover
Council Member Alice Howard
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
Council Member Joseph F. Passiment
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
Council Member Thomas Reitz
ABSENT
Council Member Mark Lawson
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Chair Howard led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. FOIA
Committee Chair Howard noted that public notification of this meeting had been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion to Amend : It was moved by Council Member Passiment, seconded by Council Member
Cunningham, to amend the agenda to remove item number 12.
3
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
The Vote - The motion to amend was approved without objection.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, seconded by Council Member Tabernik, to approve
the agenda as amended.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, seconded by Council Member Brown, to approve
the minutes of September 11, 2023.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
6. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the comments.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=144
1. Dennis Ross
7. UPDATE FROM ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATORS
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full update.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=378
Assistant County Administrator Antonacci-Ogden introduced Caroline Fermin, the new Office of Veterans
Affairs Director.
Director Fermin provided an overview of how the Office of Veterans Affairs works to support veterans in
the County, including through public engagements, like the Veterans Day Parade and Wreaths Across
America, and outreach events in various parts of the County. Director Fermin highlighted the Office ’s
assistance with end-of-life planning by creating quarterly briefings to identify and explain the benefits to
which veterans are entitled.
Council Member Reitz and Director Fermin discussed the timing and location of the outreach events.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover and Director Fermin discussed how veterans gaining access to their benefits
could help boost the local economy.
Assistant County Administrator Atkinson introduced Mark Davis, Deputy Director of the Planning and
Zoning Department, to provide an update on the Greenspace Program and Robert Merchant, Director of
the Planning and Zoning Department, to provide an update on the Lady’s Island Plan.
Deputy Director Davis provided an overview of the Green Space Program’s application process and the six
application types. Deputy Director David also explained how complete applications are added to the
Green Space Advisory Committee’s quarterly meeting agenda, where the Committee can review and
weigh the appl ications against the adopted program and make recommendations to the Community
Services and Land Use Committee. Deputy Director Davis also highlighted the Out-of-County application
addendum for applications with property beyond the County’s geographic boundaries.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover and Deputy Director Davis discussed funding requirements for applications
outside the County, including the 300% match requirement. ACA Atkinson added that the 300% match
could be an in-kind match.
Council Member Tabernik asked about the Green Space Program’s current funds, and ACA Atkinson
commented on the amount received from each deposit.
Council Member Cunningham asked if staff could provide a breakdown of the funding received from
tourists. ACA Atkinson replied that staff could do that and would provide quarterly updates.
4
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Director Merchant provided an update on the Lady’s Island Plan, including the agreement for the county
to develop a staff working group and reach out to planning firms. Director Merchant also noted efforts to
create a holistic plan, as there are unresolved transportation concerns with Sea Island Parkway and access
to Beaufort High School.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover commented on Woods Memorial Bridge traffic issues.
8. BEAUFORT CONSERVATION DISTRICT ANNUAL REPORT
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full report.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=2088
Hilary Gallop, an Education Coordinator with the Beaufort Soil and Water Conservation District, provided
an overview of the Conservation District’s Board of Commissioners, functions, and education outreach
programs, including eco -camp. Ms. Gallop explained the Conservation District’s partnership with USDA
NRCS and payouts from the conservation stewardship and environmental quality incentives programs.
Ms. Gall op also explained the Conservation District’s collaboration with The Nature Conservancy on
assessing the needs and challenges of Beaufort County farmers.
9. DISCUSSION ON FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES STAFF HAS IDENTIFIED FOR THE COASTAL COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (CCDC) WORKFORCE HOUSING
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=2878
Interim County Administrator Robinson provided an overview of the Workforce Housing Workshop during
the 1:30 p.m. Community Services Committee meeting . Interim County Administrator Robinson also
explained the different funding resources and availa ble fund balance. Interim County Administrator
Robinson added that TIF Districts, the regional housing trust fund, and the Coastal Community
Development Corporation could be utilized to develop workforce housing.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover asked about a potential partnership with Habitat for Humanity.
10. DISCUSSION REGARDING POSSIBLE DEVELOPMENT MORATORIUM AND CURRENT ZONING ALONG HWY
170
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=3301
Director Merchant explained the existing zoning for the Beaufort County and Jasper County areas along
Highway 170 and the limits provided by Jasper County’s moratorium. Director Merchant noted that Jasper
County’s zoning allows for one-acre lots.
Council Member Bartholomew asked about the objective of a potential moratorium. Director Merchant
discussed Hilton Head Island’s past moratorium during the construction of the Cross Island Parkway and
the importance of determining a clear objective. ACA Atkinson noted that County approval is already
required for upzoning and that upzoning could be denied without a moratorium.
Council Member Cunningham commented that a moratorium should be established for a specific reason.
Council Member Reitz commented that a moratorium may signal Beaufort County’s support for Jasper
County and limits on growth.
Committee Chair Howard commented that Beaufort County’s T2Rural Zoning is more stringent than what
Jasper County has in place and that there might not be a strong enough reason to put a moratorium in
place.
5
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Committee Vice-Chair Glover asked about the county’s relationship with Jasper County and Hardeeville,
as development in other counties and municipalities can create issues in Beaufort County, like increased
traffic. ACA Atkinson noted that the staff has good working relationships with all the municipalities.
11. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF AN ORDINANCE FOR A ZONING MAP AMENDMENT/REZONING REQUEST
FOR 57 ACRES (R200 004 000 0301 0000, R200 004 000 0302 0000, R200 004 000 0300 0000, R200 004
000 0063 0000) LOCATED AT 1, 2, 3, 4 BENNETT POINT DRIVE FROM PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT
(PUD) TO T2 RURAL (T2R)
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=4397
Director Merc hant discussed the fifty -seven acres in the northern part of Lady’s Island, the original
approval for 179 single -family lots, and the conservation easement on the property. Director Merchant
explained the request to change the zoning to match the character and ensure compatibility with future
development in the area.
Council Member Passiment and Director Merchant discussed which portions of the fifty -seven acres
would be rezoned.
Motion: It was moved by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, seconded by Council Member Reitz, to
recommend approval of an ordinance for a zoning map amendment/rezoning request for 57 acres (R200
004 000 0301 0000, R200 004 000 0302 0000, R200 004 000 0300 0000, R200 004 000 0063 0000) located
at 1, 2, 3, 4 Bennett Point Drive from Planned Unit Development (PUD) to T2 Rural (T2R).
Discussion: County Attorney Keaveny noted that the motion language needs to articulate the reasoning
for the motion.
Motion: It was moved by C ommittee Vice-Chair Glover, seconded by Council Member Bartholomew, to
accept the recommendation presented since the application 1) is consistent with and furthers the goals,
and policies of the Comprehensive Plan and the purposes of this Development Code. In areas of new
development, a finding of consistency with the Comprehensive Plan shall be considered to meet the
standards below, unless compelling evidence demonstrates the proposed amendment would threaten
the public health, safety, and welfare if the land subject to the amendment is classified to be consistent
with the Comprehensive Plan , 2) is not in conflict with any provision of this Development Code, or the
Code of Ordinances , 3) addresses a demonstrated community need , 4) is compatible with existing and
proposed uses surrounding the land subject to the application, and is the appropriate zone and uses for
the land, 5) would not adversely impact nearby lands, 6) would not result in adverse impacts on the natural
environment—including, but not limited to, water, air, noise, storm water management, wildlife,
vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment, and 7) would result in development
that is adequately served by public facilities (e.g., streets, potable water, sewerage , stormwater
management, solid waste collection and disposal, schools, parks, police, and fire and emergency medical
facilities).
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
12. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE A MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF BEAUFORT AND THE FRIENDS OF
WHITEHALL PARK
This item was removed from the agenda.
13. RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT THE PASSIVE PARKS DEPARTMENT PRIVATE
BUSINESS USE POLICY, APPLICATION AND FEE SCHEDULE
Please watch the video stream available on the County's website to view the full discussion.
6
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/281301?ts=4873
Passive Parks Director Stefanie Nagid explained how businesses have been utilizing passive park
properties for private engagements, such as eco-tours and staged photography sessions, without getting
prior approval or compensating the County. Director Nagid noted that these engagements occupy space
that is supposed to be available for the public and could negatively impact the conservation value of the
parks. Director Nagid also explained that the existing policy has been revised to address instances where
private businesses utilize passive parks.
Council Member Bartholomew and Director Nagid discussed enforcement of the proposed policy ,
including cooperation with municipalities and the Sheriff’s Office Environmental Crimes Unit.
Council Member Tabernik asked about the timeline and how business es will be notified. Director Nagid
replied that the item would be included on the County Council’s December 11 agenda and, if approved,
would be in effect on December 12, 2023. Director Nagid added that there would be a press release and
that the Passive Parks Department is already in touch with several businesses.
Council Member Cunningham asked about the number of people that would qualify as an event, and
Director Nagid said there is no set threshold as it depends on the intent . Council Member Cunningh am
also asked about the turnaround time for the existing facility rental application, and Director Nagid said it
is a couple of days.
Council Member Cunningham expressed concerns about the application process, the $100 fee, and the
types of activities the policy would apply to.
Director Nagid outlined how the passive park properties are purchased for conservation or cultural and
historical values and the potential problems with being unable to manage how businesses are using the
parks. Director Nagid also explained that if a business plans routine visits, only one application and
schedule for use would have to be submitted.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, seconded by Council Member Cunningham, to
recommend approval of a resolution to adopt the Passive Parks Department Private Business Use Policy,
Application, and Fee Schedule.
Discussion: Council Member Cunningham commented that there seems to be a lot of gray area in this
proposal and asked for further explanation to be provided during the December 11 County Council
meeting.
Council Member Dawson noted that the overwhelming concern is that passive parks are being used for
profit.
The Vote - Voting Yea: Committee Chair Howard, Committee Vice-Chair Glover, Council Member
Cunningham, Council Member Dawson, Council Member McElynn, Council Member Passiment, Council
Member Reitz, and Council Member Tabernik . Voting Nay: Council Member Bartholomew and Council
Member Brown. The motion passed by 8:2.
14. ADJOURNMENT
Adjourned: 4:38 p.m.
Ratified:
7
Item 5.
Community Services and Land Use Committee Affordable
and Workforce Housing Workshop
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, November 13, 2023
1:30 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Chair Howard called the meeting to order at 1:33 p.m.
PRESENT
Chair Alice Howard
Vice-Chair York Glover
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Gerald Dawson (arrived late)
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
Ex-Officio Joseph F. Passiment
Council Member Thomas Reitz (arrived late)
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
ABSENT
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Mark Lawson
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Chair Howard led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. FOIA
Committee Chair Howard noted that public notification of this meeting had been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Passiment, sec onded by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, to
approve the agenda.
8
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
5. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
No citizen comments.
6. DISCUSSION AFFORDABLE AND WORKFORCE HOUSING: WHERE ARE WE, WHERE DO WE WANT TO
GO, AND HOW DO WE GET THERE
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by Interim
County Administrator Robinson.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=53
Interim County Administrator Robinson commented that workforce housing will be one of the major focus
areas in Beaufort County’s strategic plan, as the County needs to find a sustainable solution that carries
workforce housing well into the future. Mr. Robinson also introduced the speakers for the workshop,
including Wendy Zara, Chair of the Beaufort Jasper Housing Trust , and Jeremy Cook, an attorney with
Haynsworth Sinkler Boyd.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by Wendy
Zara, Chair of the Beaufort Jasper Housing Trust.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=172
Wendy Zara provided an overview of the creat ion of the Beaufort Jasper Housing Trust, the partnership
with Community Works, the decision to incorporate as a 501c3, and the loan provided to a developer for
workforce housing development.
Council Member McElynn confirmed with Ms. Zara the loan amounts provided by the Beaufort Jasper
Housing Trust and Community Works to the developer. Counc il Member McElynn and Ms. Zara also
discussed the rate provided for the loan.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by Dana
Totman, Interim Executive Director of the Beaufort Jasper Housing Trust.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=443
Dana Totman provided an overview of his background and interest in addressing affordable housing
issues.
Need workforce housing, senior housing, and home repair. The needs are different in various parts of
the county (rural versus more populated). Needs are different through Beaufort and Jasper County.
Looked at the applications – requests for proposals last May. 5 or 6 entities that responded. Beaufort-
Jasper would provide loans of 500 tho usand, and Community Works would provide loans of 1
million/1.5 million. Ultimately, a couple dropped out, and others are still in the works – Carrington
Manor one is proceeding – 62 senior units; home ownership project in Hilton Head ; and rental
workforce development in Okatie that involves a partnership with a hospital and private developer.
That would be around 180/200 affordable homes combined. Also , some geographic diversity and
seniors/young people.
Relationship with Community Works – should they decide not to fund a project or to create different
parameters that affect our 500-thousand-dollar loan? Need to spend time with Community Works to
examine the applications closely & to work with the Board on making the financial decisions.
How do we develop the appropriate criteria and some uniformity for the applications ? Need to
provide informed guidance on how to best spend and make our investments going forward.
Important to have good working relationships with the different layers of government – state and
federal.
9
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
8 board members, 9 seats as one is vacant. Serving as a part -time interim staff. Not enough – need
more capacity – whether it is more board members or staff. Need to up capacity to fulfill requirements
and demands to create a fully functioning and impactful non-profit.
Council Member Passiment: does Community Works want to end its relationship with the housing trust,
and would the trust deal with that by expanding the membership and staff to replace what Community
Works is currently doing? Totman: that is generally accurate; they are in Greenville . So, providing
adequate support to the board and stakeholders with an interest in affordable housing is hard & they
want to end the relationship. In the original bylaws/IGA was the idea that the trust would incorporate and
become a 501c3, hire its own staff and have different approaches to how it is administered. Zara: It was
a mutual decision on the part of the Housing Trust and Community Works; they realized that the Housing
Trust, to move forward faster, needed to have its own staff. Did not have a person on the ground locally
that could be responsive quickly to questions. Passiment: money already expended for the first project –
the million from community works, how will that money be handled? Zara: the loan has not closed, so the
money has not been spent yet; we will continue to close the loan; going forward, we may have our own
contract with Community Works to do the underwriting and service the loans.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover: talk about different categories and the areas being vast. What would be the
approach to address the needs of rural areas? Totman: much of the funds from the federal and state
governments are skewed toward non -rural areas – projects of a certain scale may require water and
sewer. The strategies for rural areas – need to work with local officials, and home repairs may be
important; want people in the community to articulate their needs – can be harder because not of a large
scale, but people have needs in the rural areas , so need to work with the local officials to develop the
appropriate response.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by Jeremy
Cook, an attorney with Haynsworth Sinkler Boyd.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=1706
This is a growing area of need across the state. Need for affordable, attainable & safe housing. Part of
a long-term strategic plan. Need to determine the approaches you are willing to consider and support,
like whether the County is willing to incur debt to provide these kinds of services (issuance of general
obligation bond; would need additional mi lls to pay the debt – so would need to raise taxes). Is the
County willing to issue general obligation bonds to provide attainable housing?
Discussed what other cities have done – Charleston, Greenville to address affordable housing.
Council Member McElynn and Mr. Cook discussed the source of funding – it would be general dollar funds
and would not have to be limited to ad valorem taxes.
Can issue general obligation bonds without a referendum – up to 8% of your assessed value. Would
raise whatever taxes are needed to pay it back.
Multi-county parks would designate certain properties with the parks ; the county decides how the
money is distributed. Would allow credits to be given for specific projects.
Tax increment financing – TIFs. Used most successfully in areas where there is not yet development,
or there is underdevelopment – would be either developed or redeveloped. If already fully developed,
it may be an incremental increase, but not a lot of increase left to come. TIF is a tool the County and
City of Beaufort have used before. It can be a very successful tool , particularly in an area that is
undervalued.
o Provided an overview of the City of Beaufort’s TIF --- had a Boundary Street TIF.
Committee Chair Howard mentioned that you could use the previous year's funds from the
accommodation tax – don’t think that is possible for us, which surprised me. Cook: you would have to
show you are satisfied with the 15% test. Could see that being the case, but have not seen that.
10
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Council Member Tabern ik: when discussing the 15% of using a tax , there were a lot of hoops to jump
through. Is there any way that would be relaxed? Cook: this is brand new, so reasonable to think that we
would get broader and deeper in the use of that. When new tools are opened to local governments,
sometimes there is a natural reticence to set parameters/restrictions.
Development of Workforce Housing Bill that allows the use of revenue from local accommodations
tax for the development of workforce housing.
Council Member Passiment asked about the City of Greenville – they put up money that was then used to
get a larger loan. When we established the housing trust, each of the entities put up a sum of money and
pledged a sum of money over a ten-year period. Could we leverage that to borrow money? Leverage our
portion in the same manner as the City of Greenville. Cook: who is that money going to today? Passiment:
right now, it sits with the housing trust. The money that is there could we use the money Beaufort County
contributed to leverage a much larger loan. Cook: would need to think about what that would look like
going forward. It sounds like it would be the same model as Greenville.
Council Member Dawson: when we look at the consideration of applicants applying for affordable homes
and consider the percentage the application would be required to match. At 60% medium income, there
is a 60% required match. At 80%, there is a 20% required match. Included in the backup materials. Keaveny
refers to Greenville County’s multi -county park project. Cook: those we decisions made by Greenville
County – just an example and would not limit what Beaufort County could do. Keaveny: can set
parameters however we want to.
Committee Vice-Chair Glover: Assumes they will get with the administration to give some suggestions for
Beaufort County to move forward – various approaches and the best approach to move forward. Will
depend on expertise to guide me. Cook all in on that. Present all the options but want to tailor them to
make sure they are a good fit for the Council – interested in getting feedback on options going forward.
Explaining what they have seen work and helping figure out what would work for Beaufort County.
Council Member McElynn mentioned water and sewer, and a lot of places where we may need to build
workforce housing do not have water and sewer. You made a connection of how to provide water and
sewer in addition to engaging in building workforce housing. Would you be able to clarify the connection
between water and sewer development and workforce housing ? Cook: talking specifically about the TIF
because water and sewer would qualify for that. Would look at the impediments to property being
developed. Could also do general obligation bonds to extend water and sewer lines.
Council Member Dawson: availability of water and sewer. If water and sewer are prohibited (found mostly
in rural parts of the county) and the only source is a private well. To confirm, would the construction of
the home not be prohibited because water and sewer are not applicable? Cook: you don’t have to have
water and sewer (could have a well and septic tank), but water and sewer infrastructure itself could be
financed through some of the things we have talked about.
Interim County Admin istrator Robinson: will come to Council for guidance during the staff’s strategic
planning process.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by Hank
Amundson, Special Assistant to the County Administrator.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=3668
A couple of updates – focused on quick options that would involve land contribution or where the
public entity buys or previously owns the property – could contribute it through a long-term land lease
or transfer it with covenants and restrictions.
Current projects: Buckwalter Parkway and Ribaut Road (TCL Properties)
11
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
o Buckwalter: earlier this year, the Council authorized the administrator to put this property
under contract. Informed that there were no residential dwelling units on that property. This
is where the bulk of the work has gone. The town of Bluffton is in favor of this project.
Partnered with Beaufort Memorial Hospital because they need workforce housing. To
establish residential dwelling units, collaborated with the Town to get units and more medical
office offerings.
Have plans. The town has a partnership with Woda Cooper. Staff requested 120 units.
Will go to the town council and ask the town to contribute the units. Then the County
could partner with them on the portion of land that would be for affordable housing.
Mix between 40, 60, and 80% AMI. Ask for the County to a long -term lease, would
have to figure out how the ownership structure works – would get a medical office
and affordable housing.
Would be apartments with 120 total units.
Committee Vice -Chair Glover: if we move forward with developmen t, it would be environmentally
sensitive, right? Amundson: Absolutely. A lot of moving parts engaged Ward Edwards to do site planning.
Have a revisit of the wetlands delineation map currently going on. Committee Vice -Chair Glover and
Amundson also discussed the time horizon that would need to be negotiated in terms of the transfer of
the property. Woda Cooper company would own and operate the rental portion and their mission is
affordable housing. So, could work with a longer time horizon for the affordable housing offering.
o TCL Properties: The hospital would make a proposal to re-develop the properties. It would be
dedicated to medical employees. The other one would be open even though it’s adjacent to
the actual medical office – to be managed by Woda Cooper, it is open to everyone. Will be
bringing a proposal – would be some attached and detached to fit within the neighborhood.
Still determining the number of units.
Initial re-development planning under previous leadership was met with resistance
from the neighborhood.
Beaufort Memorial Hospital is interested in a dedicated medical housing facility.
Beaufort Memorial Hospital is finalizing a proposal to present to the Council that
would redevelop the properties into a mix of attached and detached workforce units.
Preliminary discussions with the City of Beaufort showed favorable support.
Please watch the video stream available on the County’s website to view the overview provided by County
Attorney Brittany Ward.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/280792?ts=4251
Took over to discuss Justice Square (Wilmington/King Street).
This property was approved for sale in October 2022. Have been working with the developer
Wheeler & Wheeler. Last week, they got their final approval from the City of Beaufort’s HRB.
Presented the proposed conceptual plan. Justice Place will be a renovation of the historic jail;
the cottages of Justice Square will be 12 to 14 single-family homes (300k price range); Justice
Park will be workforce housing (39+ units).
Committee Chair Howard: Do you know the length of time? Ward: due to state and federal funding , it
would be a year , and then construction will start then. Will be done in phases. Single-family homes –
planning to do six (Council approved 7 to be built) prior to starting affordable housing. Construction on
the remaining single-family homes is contingent on all the affordable housing units being built. Howard:
what are the terms for how long it must remain affordable housing? Believe it was 25 years. SRDP was at
30. And maybe 35.
Glover: would be rental units? Yes.
12
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Passiment: Would the renovation of the jail be for apartments? Ward: Yes , they will be condo units. Not
sure when those will be completed.
Glover: 30 years would be the minimum I would want to support.
Robinson: It may be beneficial for the county to hire someone to work on workforce housing projects full-
time. The Committee agreed that would be helpful.
7. ADJOURNMENT
Adjourned: 2:53 p.m.
Ratified:
13
Item 5.
Special Called Meeting of the Community Services and Land
Use Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, December 11, 2023
3:30 PM
MINUTES
Watch the video stream available on the County's website to hear the Council’s discussion of a specific topic or
the complete meeting. https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/285341
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Chair Howard called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
PRESENT
Chair Alice Howard
Vice-Chair York Glover
Council Member David P. Bartholomew
Council Member Paula Brown
Council Member Logan Cunningham
Council Member Gerald Dawson
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
Council Member Joseph F. Passiment
Council Member Thomas Reitz
Council Member Anna Maria Tabernik
ABSENT
Council Member Mark Lawson
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Chair Howard led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. FOIA
Committee Chair Howard noted that public notification of this meeting had been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act.
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Passiment, seconded by Council Member Tabernik, to
approve the agenda.
14
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
5. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD
No citizen comments.
6. RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO FUND DUE DILIGENCE AND NEGOTIATE TERMS OF ACQUISITIONS FOR THE
FOLLOWING PROPOSED GREEN SPACE APPLICATIONS:
A. CONSERVATION EASEMENT APPLICATION: HALF MOON ISLAND ROAD, LOBECO; POLITICAL
JURISDICTION - UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT COUNTY; GEOGRAPHIC REGION – NORTHERN
B. CONSERVATION EASEMENT APPLICATION: GREGORIE NECK ROAD, YEMASSEE; POLITICAL
JURISDICTION - UNINCORPORATED JASPER COUNTY; GEOGRAPHIC REGION – OUTSIDE OF COUNTY
C. FEE SIMPLE APPLICATION: ULMER ROAD, BLUFFTON; POLITICAL JURISDICTION - UNINCORPORATED
BEAUFORT COUNTY; GEOGRAPHIC REGION – SOUTHERN
D. FEE SIMPLE APPLICATION: MITCHELVILLE ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND; POLITICAL JURISDICTION -
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD; GEOGRAPHIC REGION – SOUTHERN
Mike McShane, Chairman of the Green Space Advisory Committee, commented that the Green Space
Advisory Committee received five applications , and four are being recommended for due diligence and
negotiations, as the fifth application was incomplete. Mr. McShane noted that the Green Space Advisory
Committee and County C ouncil are not obligated to move beyond due diligence for the properties with
this authorization.
Please watch the video stream on the County’s website to view the full discussion of Application A.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/285341?ts=166
Mr. McShane briefed the Committee on the conservation easement proposal for Half Moon Island Road,
including how the U.S. Department of Defense committed to equally matching the funds supplied by the
County to acquire the easement.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, seconded by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, to
recommend approval to fund due diligence and negotiate terms of acquisition for the conservation
easement application for Half Moon Island Road, Lobeco.
Discussion: Council Member Cunningham asked if the U.S. Department of Defense would split the due
diligence costs and easement purchase. Mr. McShane replied that the County could save money on due
diligence costs if it could accept some of the work conducted by the U.S. Department of Defense.
Council Member Tabernik asked about the differences between a conservation easement and a fee
simple. Mr. McShane explained that a qualified third party holds a conservation easement, and ownership
of the land remains privately held, with the easement enforcing the negotiated terms and restrictions.
Mr. McShane added that fee simple means taking clear ownership of the property.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
Please watch the video stream on the County’s website to view the full discussion of Application B.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/285341?ts=443
Mr. McShane briefed the Committee on the conservation easement proposal for Gregorie Neck Road ,
including the significant water resource on the property . Mr. McShane commented on the 300% match
requirement since the property is located outside of Beaufort County and noted that the requirement had
been exceeded due to the property's value.
15
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, seconded by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, to
recommend appr oval to fund due diligence and negotiate terms of acquisition for the conservation
easement application for Gregorie Neck Road, Yemassee.
Discussion: Council Member Bartholomew asked about engagement with Jasper County. Mr. McShane
said that Jasper County is aware and supportive of the proposal.
Council Member Cunningham asked about the entity that would hold the conservation easement. Mr.
McShane replied that it would be The Nature Conservancy.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
Please watch the video stream on the County’s website to view the full discussion of Application C.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/285341?ts=664
Mr. McShane briefed the Committee on the fe e simple acquisition proposal for Ulmer Road, noting that
the owner applied.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, seconded by Council Member Tabernik, to
recommend approval to fund due diligence and negotiate terms of acquisition for the fee simple
application for Ulmer Road, Bluffton.
Discussion: Council Member Cunningham asked if the previous property assessments would be used to
reduce costs. Mr. McShane replied that the County Council would have to accept the appraisal and that
updates could be added.
Council Member Bartholomew asked if a conservation appraisal was neede d since the previous
assessments were focused on commercial aspect s. Mr. McShane replied that there are legitimate
differences between the types of appraisals and that they need to determine how the appraisal process
moves forward.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
Please watch the video stream on the County’s website to view the full discussion of Application D.
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/285341?ts=765
Mr. McShane commented that the Town of Hilton Head made the application for the Mitchelville Road
property and that there are still some aspects that need to be resolved, such as the legal description.
Motion: It was moved by Co uncil Member Reitz, seconded by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, to
recommend approval to fund due diligence and negotiate terms of acquisition for the fee simple
application for Mitchelville Road, Hilton Head Island.
Discussion: Council Member Cunningham asked if there was interest in the property being developed and
if there would be matching funds. Mr. McShane replied that moving forward with due diligence would
allow the Green Space Advisory Committee to engage with the Town of Hilton Head and see if there are
any opportunities for matching funds. Mr. McShane added that the property owner is aware that an
application had been submitted for the property since the application allows someone to apply even if
they are not the owner.
Attorney Charles Huston commented on the fee simple application for Mitchelville Road. Mr. Huston
noted that the property does not have fee simple title, which is needed to consider purchasing the
property. Mr. Huston added that the minority heirs want to purchase the property and that the matter is
before the South Carolina Court of Appeals.
Mr. McShane commented that the Green Space Advisory Committee is aware of the heir’s property issue
and that part of due diligence would be ensuring that the County could acquire or create an easement.
16
Item 5.
County Council Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Mr. McShane added that the litigation would need to be resolved before the Green Space Advisory
Committee comes forward with a recommendation and that he would be willing to provide regular
progress updates.
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
7. EXECUTIVE SESSION
PURSUANT TO S.C. CODE SECTION 30 -4-70 (A) (2): DISCUSSION OF NEGOTIATIONS INCIDENT TO
PROPOSED CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS AND PROPOSED SALE OR PURCHASE OF REAL PROPERTY
(76 May River Rd.)
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Passiment, seconded by Council Member McElynn, to enter
into an executive session to discuss negotiations incident to proposed contractual arrangements and
proposed sale or purchase of real property (76 May River Road).
The Vote – The motion was approved without objection.
8. MATTERS ARISING OUT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Cunningham, seconded by Committee Vice -Chair Glover, to
authorize the Interim County Ad ministrator to negotiate and enter into a contract to purchase 76 May
River Road on terms that are consistent with the terms that were discussed in the executive session.
The Vote – Voting Yea: Chair Howard, Vice-Chair Glover, Council Member Cunningham, Council Member
Dawson, Council Member Passiment, Council Member Bartholomew, Council Member McElynn, and
Council Member Reitz. Voting Nay: Council Member Brown and Council Member Tabernik. The motion
passed by 8:2.
9. ADJOURNMENT
Adjourned: 4:05 p.m.
Ratified:
17
Item 5.
Beaufort Mather Campus │ Bluffton New River Campus
Hampton Campus │ Culinary Institute of the South │ Online
18
Item 8.
Technical College of the Lowcountry provides learning opportunities that advance workforce development,
promote economic development and ensure attainment of student learning goals – effectively increasing the
employability of all citizens of the Lowcountry and, ultimately, enhancing the quality of life for us all.
WHAT WE DO EVERYDAY:
HIGHER EDUCATION
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
QUALITY OF LIFE
19
Item 8.
MEASURABLE IMPACT:
91% of our students are
Lowcountry residents. Almost
18% are Active Duty Military or
dependents of Active Duty
Military.
TARGETED
Approx. 4000 Students
73% of our students are Beaufort
County residents. 12% are from
Jasper County; 6% from Hampton
County; and 4% from Colleton
County
LOCAL
94%
Graduate
Placement
94% of our graduates are placed
in a job related to their field of
study or are continuing their
studies and furthering their
education.
RELEVANT
Total Annual
Economic Impact
$129.3 million
FY 17/18
The college’s value to the Lowcountry is
larger than simply it’s economic impact.
Whether it is money invested in
operations, construction or a student’s
education, for every $1 dollar invested an
average of $10.10 in benefits will accrue to
society in the Lowcountry.
QUANTIFIABLE
20
Item 8.
ARTHUR E. BROWN REGIONAL WORKFORCE TRAINING CENTER
Bluffton New River Campus
21
Item 8.
WORKFORCE CENTER IMPACTS:
BY THE NUMBERS
50,000 Square footage
850 Additional students (Workforce)
102 Or an estimated 12% from outside of the Lowcountry such as Transitioning Military
4 plus New workforce training programs
$26MM Total project cost
$20MM Construction cost
4 yrs. Time from funding to doors open
$5.7MM Total annual economic impact
22
Item 8.
CONSTRUCTION SUPPORT REQUEST:
Objective: To secure Construction Cost support by June 30, 2024, so that the Arthur E. Brown Regional
Workforce Training Center is open and operational by end of year 2027.
Total Construction Cost $20,000,000
$10,000,000 State Approved Appropriations 2023 Legislative Session
$ 2,500,000 College Commitment
Remaining Need $ 7,500,000 Request to Beaufort County
23
Item 8.
INVESTMENT ADDING VALUE TO INVESTMENT:
Compound Investment – Education, training and jobs for Beaufort County.
24
Item 8.
REFERENCES & RESOURCES:
TCL Financial Transparency:https://www.tcl.edu/about-tcl/consumer-information/transparency/
TCL Strategic Plan: https://www.tcl.edu/strategic-plan/
2023 State of the College report: https://www.tcl.edu/about-tcl/2023-state-of-the-college/
President’s contact information:
Dr. Richard Gough
E: rgough@tcl.edu
P: 843-525-8247
25
Item 8.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO
EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY
WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee, February 12, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Brittany Ward, County Attorney (5 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
This is a new item for Committee/Council
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Parcel #R510 005 000 0329 0000 was co-purchased through the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program
on January 29, 2013 by Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island as part of a series of parcels
along Beach City Road adjacent to Mitchelville Freedom Park. At the time of acquisition, Parcel 0329 was 1.22
acres and cost $280,921, with a 70/30 respective cost share between the County and Town.
In early 2023, a property boundary discrepancy was brought to County staff’s attention whereby the adjacent
neighbor’s driveway was constructed on the co-owned County/Town property. A survey was completed on
August 4, 2023 to designate the 0.11 acre encroachment. An appraisal was completed on September 20, 2023
and provided a compensation opinion of $30,250 for the 0.11 acre encroachment area. The original
acquisition cost of the 0.11 acre encroachment area was $25,329, therefore the current appraised value is an
acceptable value for conveyance.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Beaufort County will receive $30,250 from the Buyer. Seventy percent of the funds from the sale will be
deposited into the Rural and Critical Bond Fund (4500-80-0000-47010) to be used towards future acquisitions
by the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program. Thirty percent of the funds from the sale will be
reimbursed to the Town of Hilton Head Island.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval as submitted
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify, or deny approval of an ordinance authorizing the interim county administrator to
execute the necessary documents to convey a portion of property owned by Beaufort County with TMS No.
R510 005 000 0329 0000, located on Beach City Road, Hilton Head Island.
Beaufort County Code of Ordinances Section 26-36 (attached) governs Council’s consideration of this matter.
If approved, move forward to County Council for 1st reading on February 26, 2024.
26
Item 9.
Created: 2024-02-01 10:45:35 [EST]
(Supp. No. 50, Update 4)
Page 1 of 1
Sec. 26-36. Resale, swap, condemnation or lease of acquired property.
There may be instances where property acquired under the RCLPP for its conservation value(s), and possibly
to mitigate the impacts of development, may not be suitable or needed for county ownership in the future. In such
cases, the county council may request the RCLP board to evaluate and make a recommendation on selling,
swapping or leasing the property, in whole or in part.
(a) In those instances, the RCLP board shall be guided by the following:
(1) To ensure that the resale, swap or lease of the property, in whole or in part, will not have an
adverse impact on the conservation value(s) of the property, which can be assured through the
placement of a conservation easement or other appropriate instruments on the sold, swapped or
leased property if necessary.
(2) To ensure that the development of the property for use(s) permitted under a conservation
easement will be carefully monitored by the easement holder.
(b) Additionally, the following will apply:
(1) Any RCLPP property considered for sale, swap or lease shall require appropriate action by a two-
thirds majority of the county council following prescribed procedures for sale, swap or lease of
county-owned land.
(2) If all or part of a RCLPP property is sold, swapped or condemned, the county and any c o-owners
will be entitled to respective ownership ratio compensation of any net proceeds, after payment
of all closing expenses.
(3) Any RCLPP property sold, swapped or condemned will have the county's portion of any proceeds
deposited into the land preservation fund for use in future RCLPP acquisitions.
(4) Any RCLPP property leased by the county will have any proceeds deposited into the passive parks
fund for use in management and maintenance of RCLPP passive parks.
( Ord. No. 2019/47, 10-28-2019 ; Ord. No. 2019/48, 10-28-2019 )
27
Item 9.
THIS PROPERTY LIES IN F.E.M.A. ZONE X
COMMUNITY NO. 450250, PANEL: 0456G, DATED: 3/23/2021
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION = NO MINIMUM ELEVATION
,,
ADDRESS: 282 BEACH CITY ROAD
MAP: 5 PARCELS: 10H & 329DISTRICT: 510
SCALE :DATE : 1" = 40'
HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
LOT A & TAX PARCEL 329, BEACH CITY ROAD,
BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA
8/04/2023
BOUNDARY RECONFIGURATION OF:
d.b.a. Sea Island Land Survey, Inc.
DWG No. :FILE No :
Fax (843) 689-3871
05608.15 4-05608.15
E-mail: admin@nandinainc.com
Hilton Head Island,
SC 29926
Tel (843) 681-3248
PREPARED FOR: ANDRE J. WHITE, AJJLA WHITE
FAMILY TRUST, & THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISAND
NOT VALID UNLESS EMBOSSED.
EXCEEDS THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SURVEY AS SPECIFIED THEREIN;
PRACTICE OF LAND SURVEYING IN SOUTH CAROLINA, AND MEETS OR
AND BELIEF, THE SURVEY SHOWN HEREON WAS MADE IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE MINIMUM STANDARDS MANUAL FOR THE
I HEREBY STATE THAT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE, INFORMATION,
CLASS "A"
ALSO THERE ARE NO VISIBLE ENCROACHMENTS OR PROJECTIONS OTHER
THAN SHOWN.
10 Oal Park Drive, Unit C1,
PROPERTY AREA TAX PARCEL 329: 1.11 AC. 48,529 S.F.
PROPERTY AREA LOT A: 0.61 AC. 26,559
28
Item 9.
APPRAISAL REPORT
OF
TAX PARCEL 329 BEACH CITY ROAD
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SC 29926
&
VALUE OF THE EASEMENT/ACQUISITION
PREPARED FOR
ANDRE WHITE
AS OF
09/11/2023
PREPARED
BY
WILLIAM R. COBIA, SRA
COASTAL PROPERTY APPRAISALS
29
Item 9.
September 20, 2023
RE: PARCEL 329 BEACH CITY ROAD & DRIVEWAY EASEMENT/ACQUISITION
Dear Mr. White,
In accordance with your request, I have made a personal inspection of the above referenced property and
prepared an appraisal for the purpose of estimating the just compensation for the proposed acquisition of
the 0.11+/- acre portion of parent parcel Tax Parcel 329. I understand the intended use of this appraisal is
to aid in negotiations to acquire this portion from the parent parcel of the subject property. The intended
users of this appraisal are Mr. Andre White, appropriate officials with the Town of Hilton Head Island
and appropriate members of Beaufort County. Use of this appraisal by anyone other than those listed as
intended users is prohibited. My conclusions of highest and best use and market value of the property, as
well as the just compensation for the proposed acquisition, are based on conditions existing in the market
as of September 11, 2023.
Submitted herewith is the appraisal report containing the pertinent information gathered during my
investigation. My opinion of the just compensation for the acquisition of the release is:
Thirty Thousand Two Hundred Fifty Dollars: ($30,250)
The preceding estimated just compensation is subject to the standard assumptions and limiting conditions
summarized in the attached report. This appraisal report has been prepared in conformance with my
interpretation of the "Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice" (USPAP) published by the
"The Appraisal Foundation", as well as South Carolina State Law.
It is noted that the real estate market is constantly changing, and numerous events, including but not
limited to, actions by the Federal Reserve, outcomes of elections, changes in the tax code, events overseas,
natural disasters, new or changing governmental regulations, development of public infrastructure, hiring
and layoffs by major area employers, and changes in the lending environment can have profound impacts
on values of real estate. As such, the reader is cautioned that the value of the subject property will almost
certainly change over time, and that I have no opinion of value of the subject property other than as of the
stated effective date(s) of valuation.
30
Item 9.
A digital copy of the report has been provided. If you have any questions or desire additional information,
then please do not hesitate to contact me.
Respectfully Submitted,
Coastal Property Appraisals
___________________________
Mr. William R. Cobia, SRA
SC Appraiser # AB .3490 CG
31
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 1
LIMITING CONDITIONS AND ASSUMPTIONS
This appraisal is made subject to the following Assumptions and Limiting Conditions:
1. It is assumed that the legal description as obtained from public records or as furnished is correct and
no responsibility is assumed for matters of a legal nature. No opinion is rendered as to title, as it is
assumed to be good, marketable, and in fee simple unless otherwise noted and discussed.
2. The information contained in this report as obtained from sources deemed reliable. However, no
warranty is given as to its accuracy. Competent management and responsible ownership are assumed.
3. The property is appraised as though free and clear of any or all liens or encumbrances except as noted
herein.
4. Any plot plans, sketches, drawings, or other exhibits in this report are included only to assist the
reader is visualizing the property. I have made no survey for this report and assume no responsibility
for its presentation within.
5. Possession of this report or a copy thereof does not carry with it the right of publication nor may it
be used for any purpose by any but the applicant without the previous written consent of the appraiser
and the applicant and then only with proper identification.
6. The appraiser herein by reason of this appraisal is not required to give future consultation, testimony
or be in attendance in court with reference to the property in question unless arrangements have been
previously made.
7. The distribution, if any, of the total valuation in the report between land and improvements applies
only under the existing program of utilization. The separate allocations for land and improvements
must not be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and are invalid if so used.
8. The appraisers assume, and the user of this report agrees, that the appraisers have no liability for
existing physical condition of the building and all parties agree that the purpose of this appraisal is
to estimate value as though the superstructure is structurally sound. Likewise, it is assumed and all
parties agree that the appraisers have no responsibility for subsurface or hazardous waste conditions,
including asbestos.
9. Unless otherwise noted herein, it is assumed that there are no encroachments, zoning or other
violations of any regulations affecting the subject property. The appraisers assume, and the user of
this report agrees that the appraised value is prepared as though no encroachments, liens or other
violations of any regulations affecting the subject property exist, unless otherwise noted.
10. The value estimates reported herein apply to the entire property and any proration or division of the
total into fractional interest will invalidate the value estimate unless such proration or division of
interest is set forth in the report. No statement as to the value in use to the property owner has been
made. Only the value of the property, if exposed for sale on the open market, has been estimated.
32
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 2
11. Neither all nor any part of the contents of this report shall be conveyed to the public through
advertising, public relations, news, sales, or other media, without the prior written consent and
approval of the author; this pertains particularly to valuation conclusions, the identity of the appraiser
or firm with which the appraiser is associated with and any reference to the Appraisal Institute or to
the SRA designation.
12. This appraisal will not take into consideration the possibility of the existence of asbestos, PCB
transformers, or other toxic, hazardous, or contaminated substances and/or underground storage tanks
(hazardous materials), or the cost of encapsulation or removal thereof. Should the client have concern
over the existence of such substances on the property, the appraisers consider it imperative for the
client to retain the services of a qualified, independent engineer or contractor to determine the
existence and extent, if any, of any hazardous materials, as well as the cost associated with any
required or desirable treatment or removal thereof.
13. Client agrees to defend, indemnify and hold harmless Appraiser from any damages, losses or
expenses, including attorneys’ fees and litigation expenses at trial or on appeal, arising from
allegations asserted against Appraiser by any third party that, if proven to be true, would constitute a
breach by Client of any of Client’s obligations, representations or warranties made in this Agreement,
or any violation by Client of any federal, state or local law, ordinance or regulation, or common law
(a “Claim”). In the event of a Claim, Appraiser shall promptly notify Client of such Claim, and shall
cooperate with Client in the defense or settlement of any Claim. Client shall have the right to select
legal counsel to defend any Claim, provided that Appraiser shall have the right to engage independent
counsel at Appraiser’s expense to monitor the defense or settlement of any Claim. Client shall have
the right to settle any Claim, provided that Appraiser shall have the right to approve any settlement
that results in any modification of Appraiser’s rights under this agreement, which approval will not
be unreasonably withheld, delayed or conditioned.
14. Neither party shall under any circumstances be liable to the other party for special, exemplary,
punitive or consequential damages, including, without limitation, loss of profits or damages
proximately caused by loss of use of any property, whether arising from either party’s negligence,
breach of the Agreement or otherwise, whether or not a party was advised, or knew, of the possibility
of such damages, or such possibility was foreseeable by that party. In no event shall Appraiser be
liable to Client for any amounts that exceed the fees and costs paid by Client to Appraiser pursuant
to this Agreement.
33
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 3
EXTRAORDINARY ASSUMPTIONS
An Extraordinary Assumption is defined as “an assumption, directly related to a specific assignment, as
of the effective date of the assignment results, which, if found to be false, could alter the appraiser’s
opinions or conclusions.”
This appraisal is subject to the following extraordinary assumption:
I am making the Extraordinary Assumption that there are NO wetlands and the majority, if not all, 1.22
acres are developable.
As real estate appraisers, I am not qualified to perform a wetland delineation; therefore, I strongly advise
the Client to retain the services of a qualified environmental consultant if it is concerned about this issue.
Furthermore, if my assumption pertaining to wetlands is false, then it could impact the value(s) estimated
in this report.
34
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 4
PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION
The subject of this appraisal is a ± 1.22-acre lot located at 329 Beach City Road in an incorporated area
of Beaufort County, South Carolina and within the Town of Hilton Head Island. The property is best
described by the Beaufort County Tax Assessor’s Office as Parcel Identification Number R510 005 000
0329 0000. An aerial tax map showing the approximate location and configuration of the subject property
outlined and shaded in yellow is provided below.
35
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 5
I understand Mr. Andre White wishes to obtain a certain portion estimated to contain approximately 0.11
acres from an approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area. This portion of the property is being used
for a permanent driveway easement across and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of
Hilton Head Island. Currently this 0.11+/- acre portion which is located at the east corner extending
approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast corner and is mostly rectangular in shape. A plan
sheet showing the approximate location and configuration of the area to be released from the parent parcel
is provided on the following page. Upon completion of the proposed release, the subject property will be
similar to before the acquisition, and unaffected by the current driveway encroachment.
The physical, legal, and economic characteristics of the subject property both before and after the proposed
acquisition are described and analyzed in greater detail in later sections of this report.
Below is a map showing the approximate location of the proposed portion of Tax Parcel 329 to be sold to
the owners of Lot A.
36
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 6
HISTORY OF OWNERSHIP
Tax records indicate legal ownership of the subject property is vested in the name of the Beaufort County
and The Town of Hilton Head Island. The only recorded sale according to Beaufort County Records
occurred on January 24, 2013, for $350,000 and included an additional property identified by tax map
number: R510 005 000 010B 0000, an adjacent site to the west and containing 0.30 acres or 13,068 square
feet.
Furthermore, it is my understanding that the property is not listed for sale or under contract for sale. In
addition, I was not advised that any offers to purchase this 0.11+/- acre portion from the property have
been made.
CLIENT AND INTENDED USERS OF THE APPRAISAL
Mr. Andre White is my client. Intended users of this appraisal are Mr. Andre White, as well as appropriate
officials with Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. Use of this appraisal by anyone other
than the stated intended users above is prohibited, and not intended by the appraiser(s).
PURPOSE OF THE APPRAISAL
The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the just compensation for the proposed acquisition of the
0.11+/- acre portion of the parent site which currently serves as the driveway easement to Lot A, 282
Beach City Rd. However, at this time the driveway encroaches on the parent site, which is the subject of
the report.
INTENDED USE OF THE APPRAISAL
I understand the intended use of this appraisal is to aid in negotiations to acquire the 0.11+/- acre area
from a portion of the subject property. Any other use of this appraisal is prohibited and not allowed
without authorization from the appraiser(s).
REAL PROPERTY INTEREST APPRAISED
The fee simple interest of the property is appraised. The Fee Simple Estate is defined as “...absolute
ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate subject only to the limitations imposed by the
governmental powers of taxation, eminent domain, police power, and escheat.”
EFFECTIVE DATE OF VALUATION AND DATE OF REPORT
The effective date of value is September 11, 2023, which is also the date of my most recent official
inspection of the subject property.
The date of the report is September 20, 2023.
37
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 7
Subject Property Viewed from Beach City Road: Facing East
Subject Viewed Beach City Road: Facing South
38
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 8
Beach City Road: Facing East
Driveway Encroachment
39
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 9
TYPE OF VALUE CONSIDERED
This assignment involves estimating the market value of the subject property. Market Value is defined as
the most probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all
conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably, and
assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a
sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby:
1. Buyer and seller are typically motivated;
2. Both parties are well informed or well advised, & acting in what they consider their best interest;
3. A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market
4. Payment is made in terms of cash in United States dollars or in terms of financial arrangements
comparable thereto; and
5. The price represents a normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or
creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.
*This definition is specified in the regulations pursuant to Title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform,
Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA).
SCOPE OF WORK
The scope of work is the amount and type of information researched and the analysis applied in the
assignment. The appraiser is responsible for determining the appropriate scope of work in the appraisal
assignment given the client’s intended use and the nature of the problem to be solved.
The appraiser(s) made a personal inspection of the neighborhood, which consisted of driving most of the
major roadways and identifying its approximate boundaries. In addition, the appraiser lives and works in
the Bluffton/Hilton Head Region and travels through the subject neighborhood on a regular basis. Sources
of information pertaining to the local region and subject neighborhood included various online
publications, and my ongoing market observations and research.
Information pertaining to the subject utilized in this appraisal was limited to viewing the property from
the fronting roadways and/or adjoining properties, and reviewing aerial photographs (supported by
Google Earth), flood maps, deeds, plats, zoning, and/or other publicly available information.
In order to estimate the market value of the subject property both before and after the acquisition, I have
considered a Sales Comparison Approach, whereby sales of comparable properties are analyzed. It is
noted that I considered two other valuation methodologies, which are the Cost Approach and Income
Approach; however, typical buyers and sellers in this market do not consider these approaches to value
when analyzing vacant land. Therefore, I have not developed these two approaches to value, and their
exclusion does not limit the scope of this assignment.
40
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 10
Comparable sales were gathered, verified, and compared to the subject site to determine a reasonable
market value of the land. Sources of information pertaining to comparable sales included, local MLS
data, Costar data, public deed and tax records, plats and surveys, discussions with parties either involved
in or familiar with the sales, aerial photographs, online zoning, flood, wetland, and topographic maps, and
visits to the sale properties.
AREA/NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS
The map below depicts the subject’s location within Beaufort County, and the Savannah/Hilton Head
Island region. As shown, this location is roughly 15 radial miles east of Interstate 95, 8 radial miles east
of Old Town Bluffton, and roughly seventeen radial miles north of Savannah’s National Landmark
Historic District.
The subject property is located on the south side of Beach City Road just west of the Port Royal Sound
and bordering the 33-acre Town-owned Mitchelville Freedom Park. The location is close to the Hilton
Head Island Airport and surrounding residential development. It is approximately 2 miles east of Highway
278, which is the primary thoroughfare on Hilton Head Island. This neighborhood is loosely defined as
the Mitchelville Historic Gullah Neighborhood. In general, this neighborhood is firmly entrenched in the
growth stage of its economic life cycle. The subject neighborhood is shown on the following aerial
photograph.
41
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 11
42
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 12
Aerial Map
43
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 13
HILTON HEAD ISLAND REGIONAL ANALYSIS
The subject property is located on the northeast side of Fish Haul Road. This location is mid island and is
centrally located to serve all of Hilton Head Island. The property is approximately ten miles south-east of
Bluffton, and twenty miles east of Interstate 95. Beaufort County is located in the southeastern part of the
State of South Carolina and has been one of the fastest growing counties in the US. Located entirely
within Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, a barrier island, is a 42 square mile resort town with an
approximate year-round population of 40,000 people. Over 2.25 million visitors come to Hilton Head
Island each year and during the summer the population can swell to over 150,000. Hilton Head Island is
a primary city within the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort metropolitan area and has an estimated
overall population of over 220,000. A map showing the location of the subject property relative to other
areas of Beaufort County and the Hilton Head Island Region is provided on the next page.
According to the Chamber of Commerce Economic Outlook published in July 2023 The South Carolina
Leading Index (SCLI) fell in June to a value of 102.37. Unemployment claims were 25% higher than in
May and the number of issued housing permits fell 11.3% month-over-month. In conjunction, the
valuation of the permits fell 8.2 percent and the weekly manufacturing hours rose 2.4 percent. The DOW
Jones Composite Average was up 6.4 percent.
The Conference Board’s national Leading Economic Index decreased in June to 106.1. The Conference
Board notes that the elevated prices and hard-to-get credit are dampening economic activity.
On the following page is the Key South Carolina Indicators for the following sectors: Income;
Employment and Real Estate.
44
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 14
South Carolina’s total non-seasonally adjusted nonfarm employment rose by 8,500 net jobs to 2,313,200
in June, a 0.4 percent increase from May’s numbers. Below is a chart depicting the industry sector, the
timeline comparison, and the overall rate of change for those periods.
In June 2023, the number of building permits in South Carolina for new residential construction fell 11.3
percent to 3,778, which is down 9.4 percent from a year ago. The value for the permits fell 8.2 percent
month-over-month and was 6.7 percent lower than one year ago. Real estate closings were up 5%
compared to May, while the median sale price was up 1.7%. Total closings rose in four of the top six
MSA, with Charleston reporting the strongest gain at 7.7 percent.
45
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 15
NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS
The subject neighborhood is defined as the mid island submarket, and includes the area along Fish Haul
Road, Beach City Road and Mathews Drive, a minor thoroughfare, running north to south from Highway
278. This neighborhood has experienced significant growth in the past ten years, with further new growth
expected during the foreseeable future, inclusive of some re-development on strategically located sites.
Overall, this neighborhood is in the growth stage of its neighborhood life cycle.
Vehicular access to this neighborhood is good and is provided by a network of streets that run north/south
and east/west. Major traffic arteries in this neighborhood are Mathews Drive which run in a general
north/south direction, and Marshland Road, which runs in an east to west direction.
Development in this neighborhood consists primarily of older commercial buildings, including Port Royal
Plaza, a retail plaza with a mix of tenants, including Planet Fitness, Auto Zone and a variety of restaurants
and CVS pharmacy, interspersed with pockets of older and newer residential neighborhoods.
In summary, the subject neighborhood is centrally located within the Town of Hilton Head Island, has
good vehicular access, and is stable, with minimal new development occurring. Reasons for the lack of
new development include a general scarcity of available vacant sites, as well as the transitional nature of
various parts of the neighborhood, along with lands owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island and
Beaufort County. Much of these lands are owned for preservation and utilized for park or community
recreation. In my opinion, this neighborhood will maintain stable population levels with minimal new
development over the foreseeable future.
Hilton Head Island Parks
46
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 16
47
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 17
SITE DESCRIPTION
The following description is based on my review of information provided by the property owner, the
recorded plat, various online sources, and my property inspections. Photographs of the subject property
were provided earlier in this report.
Size/Shape: Based on my review of the recorded plat, the subject site consists of 1.22-acres, and is a
rectangular shaped site located on the southeast side of Beach City Road, just east of the Hilton Head
Island Airport and just west of the Port Royal Sound. The shape and configuration of the subject site is
depicted on the following excerpt from the recorded plat.
Frontage: Review of the plat shows the subject having ± 359.00 feet of frontage on the southeast side of
Beach City Road.
In this area, Beach City Road is a two-lane, minor roadway that runs in a east-west direction. Development
along this stretch of road is comprised of various older and newer residential communities, limited
commercial and recreational parks.
Access: The subject is afforded good vehicular access via one driveway on Beach City Road.
Topography: The subject property is generally level and at the grade of the fronting roadways and
adjoining properties. The subject is cleared and vacant and is currently used as preservation land by the
Town of Hilton Head and Beaufort County.
Elevations: Review of the Beaufort County GIS website shows the subject’s elevations ranging from 13
to 15 feet.
48
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 18
Flood Zone: According to Flood Map Community Panel Numbers 45013C0456G dated March 23,
20021, the site appears to be in Flood Zone X500, which is defined as area of 0.2% annual chance of
flood. An excerpt from these flood panels showing the subject property and its immediate surroundings
is provided below and on the following page.
Drainage: No problems with drainage were noted during the inspection.
Soil Types: A soil report was not provided for use in this appraisal. I am not qualified to render a technical
opinion regarding soil conditions; however, the presence of the existing improvements indicates the soil
is sufficient for commercial oriented development typical of the area. Therefore, I assume the load-
bearing capacity is sufficient to support any reasonably probable improvements. If the Client is concerned
about this issue, then I recommend a study by a qualified soils engineer.
Hazardous Materials: Please note the subject buildings were not constructed during a time period when
both asbestos and lead based paint were commonly used materials. For the purpose of this appraisal, I
assume there are no hazardous substances on or beneath the surface of the subject property. The
appraiser, however, is not qualified to detect such substances. The presence of substances such as
asbestos, lead based paint, urea-formaldehyde foam insulation, underground storage tanks or other
potentially hazardous materials may have an effect on the value of the property. The value estimate is
predicated on the assumption that there is no such material on or in the property that would cause a
loss in value. No responsibility is assumed for any such condition, or for any expertise or engineering
knowledge required to discover them. The client is urged to retain an expert in this field if desired.
49
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 19
Wetlands: I did not observe any inundated areas or vegetation characteristic of jurisdictional wetlands
during the inspection. Furthermore, virtually all the subject property has been cleared and remains vacant.
As a real estate appraiser, I am not qualified to determine how much, if any, of the property is a
jurisdictional wetland. Therefore, for the purpose of this appraisal, I have made the reasonable
assumption the subject property consists entirely of usable upland area. I reserve the right to change
my opinions of highest and best use and market value if I am provided with information that indicates
the subject contains a different amount of jurisdictional wetlands than that indicated in this report. If
the client is concerned about this issue, then I strongly advise it to retain the services of a qualified
expert to perform a wetlands delineation of the subject property.
Utilities: All major public utilities, including water and sewer, have been extended to the subject property.
Adequate police and fire protection are provided by the Town of Hilton Head Island.
Easements/Encroachments: Review of the recorded plat indicates there is a known encroachment, other
than typical utility. My research of a recent survey did reveal an existing driveway encroachment.
According to the survey, a certain portion estimated to contain approximately 0.11+/- acres from an
approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area is being used for a permanent driveway easement across
and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. Currently this 0.11+/- acre
portion which is located at the east corner extending approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast
corner and is mostly rectangular in shape encroaches on land owned by The Town of Hilton Head Island
and Beaufort County.
Comments: Overall, the subject site is rectangular in shape and contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres,
of which all is believed to be usable upland area. The subject has frontage on one public roadway, Beach
City Road. Vehicular access to the site is good. Topographically, the subject property is level with
elevations from 13 to 15 feet and cleared. All major public utilities are available, and I am not aware of
any adverse issues related to wetlands, soils, site conditions, or encumbrances that would negatively
impact the use of the property. Therefore, it is my opinion that the subject property is physically suitable
50
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 20
for a wide range of development types, including residential or commercial oriented uses. However, the
limitations and restrictions imposed by the zoning district limit the overall use. As previously noted, the
subject is currently committed to public park and recreation use and it’s likely to remain unchanged into
the foreseeable future.
ZONING: (PR – Parks and Recreation)
The subject property is zoned PR, Parks and Recreation in the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Unified
Development Ordinance. The PR District is intended to accommodate and manage the land uses allowed
on publicly held land used for active or passive recreation purposes, or publicly owned land preserved in
its natural state for public enjoyment. Development in this district shall be allowed and designed to
minimize, as much as possible, its impact on both the natural environment and the community. Permitted
uses in the PR District include but are not necessarily limited to: Public, Civic, Institutional, and
Educational Uses.
AD VALOREM TAXES
The property is subject to ad valorem taxation by Beaufort County and is identified by the Beaufort County
Tax Assessor's Office as Tax Parcel Number R510 005 000 0329 0000. This office has estimated the
value of the subject property, as of December 31, 2021, at $600.
Land: $600.00
Improvements: N/A
DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY BEFORE ACQUISITION
Description of Subject Land
Size: Tax records indicate the subject property contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres.
Shape: The subject property is rectangular in shape.
Frontage: The subject property has roughly 359 feet of frontage on the southeast side of Beach City
Road.
Access: The subject property has open vehicular access along Beach City Road via one curb cut.
Topography: The site is relatively low lying and flat.
Elevations: My review of the Beaufort County GIS website indicates elevations of the subject property
to be 13-15 feet.
Flood Zone: The subject property is in Flood Zone C, which is NOT in a FEMA Flood Hazzard Area.
Map Number: 4500250085D. Map Date: September 29, 1986. FIPS: 45013. Flood Map Included.
51
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 21
Wetlands: I am NOT aware of, nor did I observe any wetland or low-lying area. No wetland delineation
study was made available to me. I am making the Extraordinary Assumption that there are NO wetlands
and the majority, if not all, 1.22 acres are developable.
As real estate appraisers, I am not qualified to perform a wetland delineation; therefore, I strongly advise
the Client to retain the services of a qualified environmental consultant if it is concerned about this issue.
Furthermore, if my assumption pertaining to wetlands is false, then it could impact the value(s) estimated
in this report.
Soils: A soil report was not provided for use in this appraisal. I am not qualified to render a technical
opinion regarding soil conditions. Therefore, it is assumed that the load-bearing capacity is sufficient to
support any reasonably probable improvements. This assumption is considered reasonable based on the
existence of improved properties in the immediate area. If the Client is concerned about this issue, then I
recommend a study by a qualified soils engineer.
Site Conditions: As appraisers, I am not qualified to determine the existence or extent of hazardous
contamination either on or below the surface of the property. For the purpose of this appraisal, I have
made the reasonable assumption that no significant hazardous contamination is present which would
impact the highest and best use, marketability, or value of the subject property. I reserve the right to revise
my opinions of highest and best use and market value if provided with independent engineering reports
that indicate significant hazardous contamination exists on the property and which include estimated costs
for its remediation to acceptable levels.
Adjoining Uses: Adjoining uses include larger, vacant tracts which are also owned by the Town of Hilton
Head Island and Beaufort County and utilized as designated park space. In addition, there is existing
residential development along Beach City Road.
Utilities: Officials with Beaufort County indicated that public water and public sewer service is available.
Easements/Encumbrances: There are typical utility easements for the area. However, there is an existing
driveway encroachment. According to the survey, a certain portion estimated to contain approximately
0.11+/- acres from an approximate 53,143 square foot or 1.22-acre area is being used for a permanent
driveway easement across and through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island.
This driveway encroaches on the parent property. Currently this 0.11+/- acre portion which is located at
the northeast corner extending approximately 148 linear feet south to the southeast corner and is mostly
rectangular in shape encroaches on land owned by The Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County.
Functional Utility: The subject consists of a rectangular shaped, 1.22-acre tract. The property has open
vehicular access along Beach City Road, which in this area is a town maintained paved road.
Topographically, the property is partially cleared with some wooded areas and is predominately situated
outside a 100-year flood plain. Public water and sewer are in the immediate area, and it appears the
subject site is afforded with public water and sewer.
52
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 22
DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION
The proposed acquisition is for the approximate 0.11+/- acre area, which is currently serving as a private
driveway to an adjacent site and is encroaching on the Town/County-owned property, which is the subject
of this report. This portion of the property is being used for a permanent access easement across and
through the lands of Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island. This permanent access
easement will remain in place as it currently exists. The actual dimensions of this portion of the property
is unclear, with the exception of the east and west side showing 148’ linear feet. I have estimated that the
north and south side are approximately 27’ linear feet.
DESCRIPTION OF THE REMAINDER
Upon the release of the approximate 0.11+/- acre portion, the remainder will be similar as the property
prior to the acquisition and there will be minimal to no affect.
IMPACT OF THE RELEASED ACQUISITION ON THE REMAINDER
As such, I believe the release of the approximate 0.11+/- acre portion will have a very limited impact on
the potential use of the remaining area. Furthermore, I do not believe the release of the approximate
0.11+/- acre portion will have any impact on the future use of the unencumbered area.
HIGHEST AND BEST USE
The Appraisal Institute defines Highest and Best Use as follows:
“...that reasonable and probable use that will support the highest present value, as defined, as of the
effective date of the appraisal”
It is also defined as:
“...that use, from among reasonable and probable legal alternate uses, found to be physically possible,
appropriately supported, financially feasible, and which results in the highest land value.”
The determination of highest and best use includes identifying the motivation of probable purchasers,
analyzing the supply and demand of various property types in the market, and considering limitations
imposed by zoning and the physical characteristics of the property.
Highest and Best Use of Subject Property As Though Vacant Before The Release
Physically Possible
As discussed, the subject site is rectangular in shape and contains a gross land area of 1.22 acres, of which
all is believed to be usable upland area. The subject has frontage on one public roadway, Beach City
Road. Vehicular access to the site is good. Topographically, the subject property is level with elevations
from 13 to 20 feet and cleared. All major public utilities are available, and I am not aware of any adverse
53
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 23
issues related to wetlands, soils, site conditions, or encumbrances that would negatively impact the use of
the property. Therefore, it is my opinion that the subject property is physically suitable for a wide range
of development types, including residential or commercial oriented uses.
Legally Permissible
The subject property includes areas zoned PR; Parks and Recreation in the Town of Hilton Head Island’s
Unified Development Ordinance. The PR District is intended to accommodate and manage the land
uses allowed on publicly held land used for active or passive recreation purposes, or publicly
owned land preserved in its natural state for public enjoyment. Development in this district shall be
allowed and designed to minimize, as much as possible, its impact on both the natural environment and
the community. Permitted uses in the PR District include but are not necessarily limited to: Public, Civic,
Institutional, and Educational Uses. Consequently, any legally permissible use, which is physically
possible, could be considered.
Financially Feasible
My research shows there is good commercial and residential demand in this part of Hilton Head Island,
which is evidenced by the development of various residential and revived commercial development. In
general, I do not believe this activity would be occurring if the broader market did not believe there was
adequate demand. Considering this activity, it is reasonable to assume residential or commercial
development would be feasible on the subject property under the current market conditions. However,
considering the limitations under its current zoning district a zoning variance would need to be obtained.
This is unlikely. Therefore, the feasibility would be limited to the permitted uses.
Maximally Productive
Considering its physical, legal, and economic characteristics, it is my opinion the highest and best use of
the subject is for continued park and recreation use.
Highest and Best Use of Subject Property As Though Vacant After The Release
The highest and best use of the subject property as vacant will not change as a result of the proposed
release.
VALUATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY BEFORE THE ACQUISITION
In order to estimate the market value of the subject property before the acquisition, I have relied upon a
Sales Comparison Approach, where sales and listings of similar tracts are compared to the subject property
based on a price per gross acre, which is how these properties are normally analyzed in this market. My
research revealed relatively few sales and listings of similar tracts, and I have focused on four sales
considered the most comparable to the subject property. Details of these transactions are summarized on
the following pages, while a map showing their locations relative to the subject is included later in this
section.
54
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 24
LAND SALE ONE
LOCATION: Legal Address: Por Marshland Plantation Adjacent to Mathews Dr
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
Tax Parcel Number: R510 008 000 0015 0000
GRANTOR: United General Holdings, LLC
GRANTEE: Town of Hilton Head
SALE DATE: August 10, 2023
SALE PRICE: $350,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 4268 Page: 154
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: General Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Transfer Fee Funds, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Liam Cronin of Engels and Volkers; public records, MLS
LAND AREA: 0.52 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: MF; Marsh Front Mixed Use – Intended Zoning: PR; Parks and Recreation
FLOOD ZONE: Zone AE
IMPROVEMENTS: None
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $673,077 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a square shaped 0.52-acre site located on the west side of
Mathews Drive, just south of the traffic circle and with a deeded access easement on Matilda Drive. According to
my sources, this property was purchased by the Town of Hilton Head Island for green space to be designated as
Park and Recreation land. This site affords views of the marsh.
55
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 25
LAND SALE TWO
LOCATION: 160 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 072A 0000
GRANTOR: Fairfield Square Hilton Head, LLC
GRANTEE: Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: October 08, 2020
SALE PRICE: $475,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3919 Page: 2593
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Limited Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records, 2015 MLS, Realist
LAND AREA: 1.83 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone X
IMPROVEMENTS: Improvements were razed following the sale
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $259,563 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 1.83-acre site located on the west
side of William Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of
Hilton Head Island for use as green space, park and recreation.
56
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 26
LAND SALE THREE
LOCATION: 166 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 073A 0000
GRANTOR: Williams, Edward N.
GRANTEE: The Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: October 07, 2020
SALE PRICE: $975,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3928 Page: 0565
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Full Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records
LAND AREA: 2.6 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: PR; Park and Recreation; Formally S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone X
IMPROVEMENTS: Improvements were razed following sale
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $375,000 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 2.6-acre site located on the west
side of William Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of
Hilton Head Island for use as green space. It appears that this property was previously zoned S; Stoney Mixed Use
at the time of sale.
57
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 27
LAND SALE FOUR
LOCATION: 192 William Hilton Parkway
Beaufort County, Hilton Head Island, SC
Tax Parcel Number: R511 007 000 074F 0000
GRANTOR: MEGR, LLC
GRANTEE: The Town of Hilton Head Island
SALE DATE: January 08, 2020
SALE PRICE: $114,000
DEED REFERENCE: Deed Book: 3826 Page: 2326
RECORDING INSTRUMENT: Limited Warranty Deed
FINANCING: Cash to seller, normal
INTEREST CONVEYED: Fee simple subject to normal matters of record
CONDITIONS OF SALE: Arm’s length, no special circumstances
INFORMATION SOURCE(S): Public records
LAND AREA: 1.07 acres (No Survey)
ZONING: S; Stoney Mixed Use
FLOOD ZONE: Zone AE
IMPROVEMENTS: None
UTILITIES: All major utilities were in immediate area and available
UNIT PRICE: $106,542 per acre
COMMENTS: This is the sale of an irregular shaped 1.07-acre site located on the west side of
William Hilton Parkway on the corner of Spanish Wells Road. This site was purchased by The Town of Hilton
Head for greenspace, park, and recreation.
58
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 28
The sales are compared to the subject property based primarily on the following criteria:
Zoning/Use: Properties either in the same or similar zoning district, which is a precursor to developmental
use or uses, as well as the actual intended use of the property were included.
Size: Smaller tracts tend to sell for higher unit prices when all other factors are held constant due to the
economic principle of diminishing marginal utility.
Topography: Properties with a higher percentage of wetlands and/or non-usable area relative to usable
area are considered inferior to those with a higher percentage of usable area.
My analysis of the comparable sales is provided as follows:
Sale One: This is the recent sale of a square shaped 0.52-acre site located on the west side of Mathews Drive, just
south of the traffic circle and with a deeded access easement on Matilda Drive. This site has views of the marsh.
According to my sources, this property was purchased by the Town of Hilton Head Island for green space to be
designated as Park and Recreation land.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar in terms of its location, and use. Superior in Zoning
Superior in View.
Superior in size.
Similar in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is superior to the subject due primarily due to zoning, view and size. A reasonable unit
value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should be far less than $673,077 per acre.
Sale Two: This is an older sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 1.83-acre site located on the west side of William
Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of Hilton Head Island
for use as green space, park, and recreation. This property is an interior property with no view amenity.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar to the subject in terms of its location, and use. Superior zoning.
Inferior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its larger size.
Similar to the subject in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is considered slightly inferior to the subject. Consequently, a reasonable unit value of
the subject property as indicated by this sale should therefore be slightly greater than $259,563 per acre.
Sale Three: This is an older sale of a mostly rectangular shaped 2.6-acre site located on the west side of William
Hilton Parkway, just north of Spanish Wells Road. This property was acquired by the Town of Hilton Head Island
for use as green space. This site has a view of the marsh.
In my opinion, this sale is:
59
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 29
Similar to the subject in terms of its location and use. Superior zoning.
Superior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its size
Similar to the subject in terms of its topography.
Overall, this sale is considered superior to the subject due primarily to its zoning and view. A reasonable
unit value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should therefore be less than $375,000 per acre.
Sale Four: This is an older sale of an irregular shaped 1.07-acre site located on the west side of William Hilton
Parkway on the corner of Spanish Wells Road. This site was purchased by The Town of Hilton Head for greenspace,
park, and recreation. This site has a view of the marsh, but is believed to be impacted by wetlands or soil conditions
which would limit development.
In my opinion, this sale is:
Similar to the subject in terms of its location, and use. Superior zoning.
Similar to the subject in terms of its size.
Superior in View.
Inferior to the subject in terms of its topography
Inferior to the subject in terms of its shape.
Inferior to the subject in terms of development potential.
Overall, this sale is considered inferior to the subject due primarily to its topography, shape and
development potential. A reasonable unit value of the subject property as indicated by this sale should be
significantly greater than $106,542 per acre.
My analysis of the comparable sales and listing is summarized in the following table.
60
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 30
COMPARABLE LAND SALE TABULATION
Subject Sale One Sale Two Sale Three Sale Four
Location Parcel 329
Beach City Rd
Por. Marshland
Rd
160 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
166 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
192 Wm. Hilton
Pkwy.
Sale Date N/A Aug. 10, 2023 Oct. 08, 2020 Oct. 07, 2020 Jan. 08, 2020
Sale Price N/A $350,000 $475,000 $975,000 $114,000
Gross Land Area 1.22 0.52 1.83 2.6 1.07
Usable Area 1.22 0.52 1.83 2.6 Unknown
% Usable 100% 100% 100% 100.0% >100.0%
Zoning PR MF S S S
Flood Zone C AE X X AE
Utilities All available All available All available All available All available
Price/Gross Acre N/A $673,077 $259,563 $375,000 $106,542
Comparison to Subject
Zoning PR Superior Superior Superior Superior
Size 1.22 Acres Superior Inferior Inferior Similar
Topography/View Landscape/Park Superior Inferior Superior Similar
Shape Rectangular Similar Similar Similar Inferior
Utilities All available Similar Similar Similar Similar
Overall Comparison: N/A Superior Slightly Inferior Superior Inferior
Based on my review of the comparable sales, I believe a reasonable unit value of the fee simple interest
subject property should be less than Sale #1 and Sale #3; greater than Sale #4 and slightly greater than
Sale #2. The leading indicator is Sale #2 with an average price per gross acre of $259,563. The current
market value of the fee simple interest of the subject property is calculated as follows.
1.22 Acres x $275,000 per Acre = $335,500
Estimated Value of the ± 0.11- acre portion to be released.
The value of the release portion is calculated as follows:
Unit Value Released Area Value of Released Portion
$275,000/Acre x 0.11 Acres = $30,250
The value of the remainder portion is calculated as follows:
Unit Value Remainder Area Value of Remainder Portion
$275,000/Acre x 1.11 Acres = $305,250
In addition, I have included a chart and plat map below itemizing the few transactions where the Town of
Hilton Head sold off a portion of Town-owned property to owners of abutting sites. The sales below are
61
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 31
part of a bulk sale including fourteen 0.010 +/- acre portions. These transfers result in a price per acre of
$310,500.
TOWN OF HHI EASEMENT SALE TABULATION
Subject Sale One Sale Two Sale Three Sale Four
Location Parcel 329
Beach City Rd
45A Folly Field
Rd
44A Folly Field
Rd
47A Folly Field
Rd
46A Folly Field
Rd
Sale Date N/A May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022 May 25, 2022
Sale Price N/A $3,105 $3,105 $3,105 $3,105
Gross Land Area 0.11 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010
Usable Area N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
% Usable 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Price/Gross Acre N/A $310,500 $310,500 $310,500 $310,500
62
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 32
63
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 33
64
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 34
65
Item 9.
Coastal Property Appraisals 35
66
Item 9.
2024/ ____
AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE INTERIM COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE
THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO CONVEY A PORTION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY
BEAUFORT COUNTY WITH TMS NO. R510 005 000 0329 0000, LOCATED ON BEACH CITY
ROAD, HILTON HEAD ISLAND
WHEREAS, Beaufort County (“County”) purchased real property and is the current fee simple
co-owner of the real property with TMS No. R510 005 000 0329 0000 and being recorded in the Office of
the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina on January 29, 2013, in Book 3210 Pages 2689-
2692; hereinafter referred to as the “Property”; and
WHEREAS, the County purchased the Property through the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation
Program for $230,263 per acre, at a 70/30 cost share with the Town of Hilton Head Island (“Town”); and
WHEREAS, adjacent to the Property is the real property with TMS No. R510 005 000 010H 0000
and is currently owned by the White Family (“Residents”); hereinafter the “Adjacent Property”; and
WHEREAS, the Residents private access d rive to the Adjacent Property was previously
constructed on a portion of the Property; and
WHEREAS, the Residents desire to purchase a portion of the Property to retain their existing
private residence access to the Adjacent Property in the most direct and accessible manner possible with no
potential user conflicts; and
WHEREAS, the County and the To wn desire to convey a 0.11 acre portion of the Property, as
illustrated in the survey for Tax Parcel 329 dated August 4, 2023 (Exhibit A), for the appraised value of
$30,250 to be deposited in the County Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program Fund (#4502).
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL , duly
assembled, does hereby authorize the Interim County Administrator to execute the necessary documents to
convey a portion of property owned by Beaufort County with TMS No. R 510 005 000 0329 0000 to Mr.
Andre White, of which the proceeds will be returned to the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program
land acquisition fund.
Adopted this _____ day of ________________, 2024.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
By: ______________________________________
Joseph Passiment, Chairman
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Sarah Brock, Clerk to Council
67
Item 9.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
REQUEST AUTHORIZATION TO PURCHASE (1) NEW 36 PASSENGER BUS MODEL: STARCRAFT ALLSTAR XL
($188,760)
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Community Services and Land Use Committee – February 12th, 2024
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Hank Amundson, Special Projects Director, Special Projects
(10 Minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
Asset 20336, a 2002 Freightliner FS65 Chassis bus with 76,279 miles, has surpassed its recommended service
life of 10 years or 125,000 miles. It is currently experiencing mechanical issues and has also been affected by
mold and mildew due to prolonged periods of inactivity and lack of maintenance. This bus is intended to be
used for transporting senior citizens and youth programs provided by Beaufort County Parks and Recreation.
To ensure the safety and presentability of transportation for these programs, it is necessary to replace the
bus. Replacing Asset 20336, Parks and Recreations can guarantee a reliable and well-maintained vehicle that
meets the needs of our community. Investing in a new bus will not only provide a safer mode of
transportation but also enhance the overall experience for our senior citizens and youth participants
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Purchase of One (1) New 36 passenger bus: Star Craft All Star XL
FISCAL IMPACT:
A quote has been provided from Model 1 in the amount of $188,760. The funding source for this item was
approved in the FY 2024 budget for Parks and Recreation account # 1040-80-1600-54000. $192,000 was
budgeted for FY 2024.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
The Beaufort County Fleet Manager recommends approving the purchase of a new 36-Passenger bus to
replace the existing one. This recommendation is based on the age and poor condition of the current bus.
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to either accept/deny the recommendation to approve the purchase of a 36 Passenger Bus.
Next Steps – None. Council action not required because purchase is within the Committee’s financial threshold
(≤ $200,000)
68
Item 10.
2023
STARCRAFT
Allstar XL 36’
PRICE PROPOSAL
CONTACT
Date Issued: 1/4/2024
Name: Karla Lynch
Phone: 470-373-7479
Email: klynch@model1.com
Prepared for
Beaufort County
Whether you need to fill a spot in your fleet or create an entirely new vehicle, your Model 1 experts have a single
top priority: you. With a clear understanding of your needs, we find ways to deliver — starting with deep relationships
all the way back at the manufacturer level. And with the nation’s largest inventory of commercial vehicles,
you’ll never be short on the best choices to make for your business.
SALES EXPERIENCE
550+ Years of Collective Bus
Sales Experience Servicing Over
1,500 Customers Annually
NATIONWIDE NETWORK
21 Full-Service Locations
Nationwide Partners with
25+ Top Manufacturers
COMPETITIVE PRICING
Volume Discounts
Fixed Contract Pricing
IN-HOUSE FINANCING
Seamless Transactions
Flexible Solutions
69
Item 10.
PRICE PROPOSAL
IMAGES & FLOORPLAN
70
Item 10.
SPECIFICATIONS
CHASSIS
⋅ 2023 International T/C Cummins ISB 240 HP
⋅ Hydraulic Brakes Air Suspension
⋅ Engine: 7.3 L
⋅ Fuel Type: Diesel
⋅ GVWR: 23,500
EXTERIOR
⋅ Exterior Color: White
⋅ Wheelbase: 276”
⋅ Front Destination Sign Window and Overhead Access Door
⋅ Side Destination Sign Window w/ Structure
⋅ Passenger Door 36” Electric
⋅ Double W.C. Doors w/ Windows
INTERIOR
⋅ 96” Wide Exterior Body
⋅ Yellow step nosing per step (4)
⋅ Driver Area: Grey padded vinyl
⋅ Walls and Ceiling: Grey FRP
⋅ Flooring: Gerflor Sirius Anthracite Grey
⋅ Ceiling Grab Rail on Both Sides
⋅ 1 ¼” Dual Entry Grab Rails Parallel to Entrance Steps (Both Sides)
⋅ Left Hand Entry Vertical Grab Rail – 1 ¼”
⋅ Stanchion and Modesty Panel at Entry Door & Behind Driver
A/C & HEAT
⋅ A/C System: TA77R90 Super 13 125K BTU, TA77 EVAP , R90 RM COND,
(2) 13 CID COMP
⋅ Heater: SMART Heater, 70K BTU - Floor Mounted
LIGHTING
⋅ Door activated Interior Lights
⋅ Surface Mount LED Entry Door Exterior Light
⋅ LED Mid-Ship Turn / Marker Lights
⋅ 4” Grommet Mount LED Exterior Lighting
PRICE PROPOSAL
ELECTRICAL
⋅ Intermotive Flex Tech Electrical System
AUDIO / VISUAL
⋅ Jensen AM/FM/MP3/USB/Sirius XM with clock & 4 speakers - PA ready
⋅ Handheld Mic & Clip Added to PA Ready Radio
⋅ Additional Speakers, Each (2)
⋅ Rosco back-up camera system w/ 7” rearview monitor/mirror combo
WHEELCHAIR ACCESSIBILITY
⋅ 34” x 54” Braun Century NCL 1000 wheelchair lift located in the rear of the unit
⋅ Intermotive Gateway Transit Fast Idle with lift interlock
⋅ Max Retractor Tie Down, Combo Lap/Shoulder (2)
⋅ Q-Straint Storage Pouch (2)
ACCESSORIES
⋅ Priority seating sign **Required for ADA Compliance**
⋅ Wheelchair Decal
SAFETY
⋅ Back-up alarm SAE type C 97 db(A)
⋅ Fire Extinguisher, First Aid Kit, Reflective Triangles
PASSENGER SEATING OPTIONS
⋅ 36 Ambulatory, 0 Wheelchair
⋅ 28 Ambulatory, 2 Wheelchair
SEATING
Passenger Seating:
⋅ Seat Fabric: Level 6 Duratex Jordan Blue
⋅ Mid high, Double Seat (15)
⋅ Econo Flip, Double (2)
⋅ Foldaway Seat, Double AM Benchback (1)
⋅ Seat Belt, Non-Retractable (36)
⋅ Seat belt loop – Each (34)
⋅ Anti-vandal grab handle on aisle seats (15)
Driver Seating: OEM Seating
71
Item 10.
Manufacturer Warranty Starcraft 5-year / 100,000 miles
Chassis Warranty See Attached
All vehicles come with warranty, but Model 1 offers more value without the added cost.
Our coverage and support come with each of our new vehicles — standard.
WE PROCESS ALL THE WARRANTY REGISTRATIONS
We register all of your bus parts for you, no more pesky warranty cards to fill out. This includes
all parts, wheelchair lift, electronics, HVAC, etc.
WE HANDLE ALL THE PAPERWORK
We administer and coordinate any warranty work. You make one call to our warranty department,
and they take it from there.
REPAIR FACILITIES NEAR YOU
When warranty work is needed, we use service repair facilities near the bus location. We have over
3200 authorized centers and growing. You will never have to drive far to get repairs completed.
NO MORE CLAIM FORMS
Model 1 handles all parts of the claim process, you will have no out of pocket expenses,
no reimbursements, and the service facility will be paid directly by us.
LONGER WARRANTY PERIOD
We have negotiated extended periods for the units we sell. Unprecedented 60 month/100,000 mile
bumper-to-bumper warranty on the Starcraft bus upfit.
WARRANTY
PRICE PROPOSAL
72
Item 10.
PRICING
DESCRIPTION AMOUNT
Bus Cost $188,760.00
FOB Beaufort, SC Included
Total $188,760.00
*Pricing does not include DMV, title, or licensing . This quote is valid for 30 days from date issued.
PRICE PROPOSAL
73
Item 10.
CTS-3306C
Printed in the USA Page 1 of 2 CTS-3306B Revised 4/2019
Public
OBTAINING SERVICE Return this vehicle to any IC Bus Dealer authorized to service this model vehicle and engine. DISCLAIMER NO WARRANTIES ARE GIVEN BEYOND THOSE DESCRIBED HEREIN. THIS WARRANTY IS IN LIEU OF ALL OTHER WARRANTIES, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED. THE COMPANY SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ALL OTHER REPRESENTATIONS TO THE USER/PURCHASER, AND ALL OTHER OBLIGATIONS OR LIABILITIES. THE COMPANY FURTHER EXCLUDES LIABILITY FOR INCIDENTAL AND CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, ON THE PART OF THE COMPANY OR SELLER. No person is authorized to give any other warranties or to assume any liabilities on the Company's behalf unless made or assumed in writing by the Company; and no other person is authorized to give any warranties or to assume any liabilities on the seller's behalf unless made or assumed In writing by the seller. RECORD OF OWNERSHIP Upon receipt of new vehicle by original owner, complete the following: I have read this Warranty Brochure and fully understand the warranty coverage, and the limitations and exclusions. I acknowledge that I have received a copy of the Owner's Limited Warranty and I accept the terms described herein. ________________________________ ____________________________________ Customer Signature Date ________________________________ ____________________________________ Owners Address City State/Prov Postal Code ________________________________ ____________________________________ Bus Model Vehicle Identification Number ________________________________ ____________________________________ Engine Number Engine Serial Number ________________________________ ____________________________________ Date Delivered to User (DTU) Odometer Reading at Delivery IMPORTANT: The information contained in this Warranty Policy explains the coverage provided on your new IC Bus brand vehicle. This policy should be kept in the vehicle for presentation to the Dealer when you request warranty services. Any provisions of this Limited Warranty that are prohibited or not enforceable in any jurisdiction shall be, as to such jurisdiction, ineffective to the extent of such prohibition or non-enforceability without invalidating the remaining provisions hereof, and any such prohibition or non-enforceability in any jurisdiction shall not invalidate or render non-enforceable any such provisions in any other jurisdiction. All claims under this Limited Warranty must be submitted in writing to an authorized IC Bus dealer within the warranty period as stated herein. If you have questions regarding this Limited Warranty, contact IC Bus Dealer. To locate nearest dealer, visit the IC Bus website, www.ICBus.com.
EFFECTIVE WITH VEHICLES BUILT JANUARY 02, 2018 OR LATER LIMITED WARRANTY FOR BUS MODELS TC SERIES (PC515) Integrated Cut Away Bus ID) IC Bus, LLC warrants to the original purchaser (the Purchaser) that IC Bus, LLC brand buses and component parts thereof are, at the time of purchase, free from defects in material and workmanship and will remain free from such defects under normal use after delivery to the Purchaser as provided herein. Warranty shall begin at the time of delivery unless otherwise approved by IC Bus, LLC. The delivery limitations as set forth herein shall run from the date of delivery to the Purchaser in the United States of America and Canada. The remedy available under this Limited Warranty is non-cumulative in nature and is limited to repair or replacement at IC Bus, LLC option of the bus or component parts thereof that are returned to locations approved by IC Bus, LLC transportation charges prepaid, and which IC Bus, LLC examination disclosed to its satisfaction to be defective. IC Bus, LLC, at its option, will repair or replace any part of this vehicle which proves defective in material and/or workmanship in normal use and service, with new or ReNEWed parts, for the first 12 months or unlimited miles, from new vehicle delivery date, regardless of distance traveled. Exceptions are listed below under What Is Not Covered. This warranty is automatically transferred to subsequent owners at no charge. Visit your local IC Bus Dealer for name and address change information. COMPONENT COVERAGE The components described below are given additional warranty coverage of variable time periods and distance traveled limitations, as shown in the Warranty Coverage Schedule. 1. Frame Side Rails and crossmembers 2. Cab/Cowl Structure. The Cab/Cowl is warranted against perforation due to corrosion, except for perforation caused by industrial chemicals and/or corrosion caused by use in a corrosive industrial environment. 3. Navistar Diesel Engine Coverage includes: Engine block, cylinder heads, internally lubricated components fuel pump, high pressure pump, turbocharger, water pump, air compressor, injectors/nozzles; electronic engine modules, engine relays, engine sensors and regulators required for electronic engine operation, and certain aftertreatment components. Excluding: attaching accessories (e.g., fan clutch, alternator, starter, etc.), and externally mounted electrical and filtration systems 4. Spicer front & rear axles and propeller shaft, when used with Allison transmission; excluding brakes, wheel ends axle shafts, controls & attachments. THE PROVISIONS HEREOF CONSTITUTE THE EXCLUSIVE AND COMPLETE WARRANTY BY IC BUS, LLC ON IC BUS BRAND BUSES AND COMPONENT PARTS THEREOF MANUFACTURED BY IT, OR APPROVED BUS BODY CONTRACT MANUFACTURERS AND IS IN LIEU OF ALL OTHER OBLIGATIONS OR LIABILITIES OF IC BUS, LLC WHETHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED. Note: The customer has 365 days and up to a maximum of 100,000 miles (160,000 km) from DTU (delivery to end user) to purchase an extended warranty on the unit. For extended warranty purchases between 181 and 365 days from DTU and <100,000 miles (160,000 km).
Remedies Under State or Provincial Law: Any suit for breach of this Limited Warranty must be initiated within one year after breach. Some States and Provinces do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages, so the above limitation or exclusion may not apply to the owner. This warranty gives the owner specific legal rights, and he may also have other legal rights which may vary by state or province.
74
Item 10.
CTS-3306C
Printed in the USA Page 1 of 2 CTS-3306B Revised 4/2019
Public
Items Covered Months Miles/Km (000) WHAT IS NOT COVERED cont. REPAIRS: Maintenance-related items/repairs or those as a result of normal wear and tear, including tune-ups, brake/clutch lining, windshield wiper blades, tire balancing, lubrication and other similar procedures/parts required to keep vehicle in good working condition. To any part of the vehicle subjected to misuse, negligence, improper maintenance, improper operation, or which are the result of an accident. Fade, runs, mismatch or damage to paint, trim items, upholstery, chrome, polished surfaces, etc., resulting from environmental causes, improper polishes, cleaners or washing solutions, or chemical and industrial fallout. In which power train, propshaft and suspension sales guidelines (specifications) are not strictly adhered to by all owners and operators of this vehicle. OTHER: Vehicles sold and/or operated outside the United States and Canada. Vehicles/components that have had unauthorized alterations or modifications. Vehicles on which the odometer reading has been altered. Loss of time or use of the vehicle, loss of profits, inconvenience, or other consequential or incidental damages or expenses. Replacement of defective parts with parts other than those provided by IC Bus, LLC. This warranty does not apply, or include coverage for defects attributable to the following: (a) Damage resulting from: (i) misuse, abuse, accident, neglect, negligence, vandalism, fire, riot, war, or Acts of God; (b) (ii) Structural or other modifications or alteration without prior express written authorization by IC Bus, LLC; (iii) Repair or attempted repair by unauthorized persons; (iv) Replacement of original components with substitutes without prior express written authorization by IC Bus, LLC; (v) Failure to perform routine preventative maintenance as customarily accepted within the industry or failure to provide proof of such preventative maintenance having been performed; (vi) Exposure to corrosives, contaminants, chemicals, salt, irradiation or atmospheric or environmental conditions; (vii) Usage or loading in excess of recommended capacities or in non-standard applications, including off-road. (c) Fading or discoloration of paint, lettering or decals. Revised 4/1/2019 Telematics Data Disclosure Your Navistar vehicle may include an activated telematics subscription service. By accepting this Limited Warranty you consent to our collection and use of data from your vehicle as set forth at www.oncommandconnection.com on behalf of yourself and any vehicle operators and passengers. Navistar, Inc. or its affiliates will collect and send diagnostic and system data from your vehicle and use it for various purposes as further set forth in our Privacy Policy, posted at www.oncommandconnection.com, such as improving the uptime for your vehicle, improving our vehicles in the future, and reducing warranty events. If you choose not to allow Navistar to access your data, you may suspend your subscription at www.InternationalTrucks.com/Opt-Out
BASIC VEHICLE COVERAGE Basic Vehicle Warranty 12 Unlimited Towing (Non-Engine) 90 Days Unlimited BASIC CHASSIS / CAB COVERAGE Frame Side Rails 60 100/160 Cab/Cowl Structure 60 100/160 Cab/Cowl Perforation Corrosion 60 100/160 Brightwork, Chassis and Paint Corrosion (other than cab) 6 Unlimited Cab Paint Delamination 60 100/160 ENGINE * +Cummins Engines, Contact Cummins DRIVETRAIN** Spicer - 3 Part Drivetrain (Front & Rear Axles, Propeller Shaft, When Used With Allison Transmission Only) 48 50/80 Meritor Axles 48 75/120 * Emission Coverage: Refer to engine operators manual for emission coverage. **Drivetrain: Allison Transmissions products or Transynd lubricants and fluids are not covered under this warranty. For warranty information, see: www.allisontransmission.com/publications/ For specific Eaton/Fuller Warranty coverage, see supplier information: www.roadrangerwarranty.com For extended component warranty: www.roadranger.com/Roadranger/warranty/ExtendedWarranty/index.htm For Eaton Hybrid system warranty: www.roadranger.com/Roadranger/warranty/ExtendedWarranty/Hybrid/index.htm WHAT IS NOT COVERED AFTER THE FIRST 90 DAYS FROM DELIVERY TO USER (DTU): Correction of loose fasteners, squeaks, rattles and unusual noises. Towing (vehicles with non-engine failures only). Adjustments (e.g., headlights, brake/clutch adjustments, steering system adjustments, coolant levels). COMPONENTS / ITEMS: Warranted by their respective manufacturers (e.g., non Navistar brand engines, tires & tubes, Allison Transmissions, lubricants, etc.) Bodies, equipment and accessories installed by other than authorized IC Bus employees at IC Bus manufacturing plants. Front and rear axle alignment. Front & Rear axle coverage excludes brakes, wheel ends, axle shafts, controls & attachments.
75
Item 10.
5-7 40 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle
Preparer:
Base Model 189,437.00$
Startrans
-$
(677.00)$
Vehicle Length Lift Position WC Positions
Total #
Passengers
CDL
Required
40 Rear 2 36 Yes
QTY Vehices: 1
188,760.00$
Customer Info
Customer:
Address:
Contact:
Office Phone:
Mobile Phone:
E-Mail:
Karla Lynch
Base Model Price:
Options:
GEORGIA DOAS
99999 - SPD - SPD0000212 - 0005
FY 2023
Unpublished Options:
Total Contract Price: 188,760.00$
843-812-7572
todd.davis@bcgov.net
Beaufort County
Floorplan
120 Shanklin Rd. Beaufort, SC 29906
Todd Davis
Per Vehicle Price:
1/18/2024
76
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Solicitation Title/Event Name:
Public Mass Transit Vehicles and Related Options,
Equipment, and Accessories
Solicitation No/Event ID:
99999-SPD0000212
Solicitation Close/ Event End Date:
3/20/2023
Notice of Intent to Award Posting Date:
6/9/2023
Issuing Officer:
Billy Gilbert
Issuing Officer Contact Information:
404 657-4277; billy.gilbert@doas.ga.gov
The State intends to award a contract to the apparent successful offeror(s). The Notice of Intent to Award should
not be considered as a binding commitment by the State. Inquiries should be addressed to the Issuing Officer.
Although the State will provide the reason(s) an offeror was not successful in accordance with Georgia law, please
note that the reasons listed beside the names of the unsuccessful offeror(s) should not be interpreted as an
exhaustive list. NOTE: In the event any of the following is applicable, then all identified award amounts (if any)
are estimates only: (1) this is an open agency contract and/or (2) the state entity has identified primary/secondary
awardees. All protest mu st be submitted electronically via email at doas.protests@doas.ga.gov. Please
reference the Georgia Procurement Manual for the supplier protest process updated August 2020 :
http://doas.ga.gov/state-purchasing/law-administrative-rules-and-policies
APPARENT SUCCESSFUL OFFERORS
CATEGORY 1 COACH BUSES
FEDERAL TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION (FTA) CATEGORY 1 COACH BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA or
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
1-1A: 45 Ft
Surburban/
Commuter/Coach
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI D45CRT FTA $689,990.00 $704,689.22
1-1B: 45 Ft
Surburban/
Commuter/Coach
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI D45CRT Le FTA $778,990.00 $793,689.22
1-1C: 45 Ft
Surburban/
Commuter/Coach
Electric
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI D45CRT e LE FTA $1,342,990.00 $1,373,799.22
1-4C: 30 Ft
Surburban/
Commuter/Coach
Electric
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI D45RT E FTA $1,339,990.00 $1,370,799.22
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
77
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA or
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
1-5A: Any Length
Other Coaches-
(Specify Length)
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI D4520 FTA $708,990.00 $723,689.22
NON-FTA CATEGORY 1 COACH BUSES
1-1A: 45 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Van Hool, CX45 Non-
FTA $542,027.27 $552,564.55
1-1C: 45 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Van Hool, CX45E Non-
FTA $1,036,751.52 $1,047,288.80
1-3A: 35 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Van Hool, CX35 Non-
FTA $469,188.89 $479,726.17
1-3A: 35 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI J3500 Non-
FTA $569,990.00 $584,914.22
1-5A: Any Length
Other Coaches-
(Specify Length)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Van Hool, TDX25
(45-ft., double
decker)
Non-
FTA $895,000.00 $905,912.28
1-5B: Any Length
Other Coaches-
(Specify Length)
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI J4500 Non-
FTA $634,990.00 $650,049.22
1-5C: Any Length
Other Coaches-
Electric (Specify
Length)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Van Hool, TDX25E
(45-ft., double
decker)
Non-
FTA $1,316,850.51 $1,327,762.79
1-5C: Any Length
Other Coaches-
Electric (Specify
Length)
**Motor
Coach
Industries,
Inc.
MCI J4500 e Non-
FTA $1,166,990.00 $1,197,799.22
1-6C: Prison Coach
- All Seg Cell
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Van Hool, CX45-
Prison Coach
Conversion
Non-
FTA $652,609.00 $663,146.28
END OF CATEGORY 1 COACH BUSES
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
78
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 2 TRANSIT BUSES
FTA CATEGORY 2 TRANSIT BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
2-1B: 45 ft to 47 ft
Heavy Duty- Transit
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-BE
(Battery Electric) 45' FTA $1,214,117.00 $1,247,813.72
2-2A: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Transit
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS 40'
DIESEL FTA $696,321.00 $723,717.72
2-2A: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Transit
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XD40 FTA $534,900.00 $554,191.78
2-2B: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Transit
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-FC
(Fuel Cell) 40' FTA $1,221,779.00 $1,255,475.72
2-2B: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Transit
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XN40 FTA $598,990.00 $617,486.78
2-2C: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Electric
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-BE
(Battery Electric) 40' FTA $1,049,920.00 $1,083,616.72
2-2C: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Electric
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XE40 FTA $939,900.00 $969,841.78
2-2C: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Electric
**Proterra
Operating
Company,
Inc.
ZX5+ FTA $968,325.00 $1,030,362.03
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
79
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
2-3A: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Hometown
Manufacturing
Urban
FTA $461,162.00 $480,754.84
2-3A: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS 35'
DIESEL FTA $684,603.00 $711,999.72
2-3A: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XD35 FTA $529,900.00 $549,191.78
2-3B: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-FC
(Fuel Cell) 35' FTA $1,198,917.00 $1,232,613.72
2-3B: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XN35 FTA $594,990.00 $613,486.78
2-3C: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-BE
(Battery Electric) 35' FTA $1,038,402.00 $1,072,098.72
2-3C: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XE35 FTA $934,900.00 $964,841.78
2-3C: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
**Proterra
Operating
Company,
Inc.
ZX5+ FTA $974,218.00 $1,035,003.78
2-4A: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Hometown
Manufacturing
Urban
FTA $454,090.00 $473,682.84
2-4A: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC E-Z RIDER 32'
DIESEL FTA $633,783.00 $661,179.72
2-4B: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC E-Z RIDER CNG
32' FTA $716,511.00 $750,207.72
2-4C: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS EVO-BE
(Battery Electric) 32' FTA $1,029,283.00 $1,062,979.72
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
80
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
2-5A: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ARBOC Spirit of
Equess FTA $619,615.00 $638,430.48
2-5A: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Hometown
Manufacturi
ng, Inc.
View FTA $176,472.00 $192,411.81
2-5B: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ARBOC Spirit of
Equess FTA $536,249.00 $555,064.48
2-6A: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ARBOC Spirit of
Equess FTA $606,985.00 $625,800.48
2-6A: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Hometown
Manufacturi
ng, Inc.
View FTA $174,528.00 $190,467.81
2-6B: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ARBOC Spirit of
Equess FTA $524,473.00 $543,288.48
2-7A: 59 ft - 65 ft 0
ft Articulated Heavy
Duty : Transit
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XD60 FTA $849,990.00 $869,326.78
2-7B: 59 ft - 65 ft 0
ft Articulated Heavy
Duty : Electric
**New Flyer
of America
Inc.
Xcelsior XE60 FTA $1,420,990.00 $1,468,946.78
NON-FTA CATEGORY 2 TRANSIT BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
2-1A: 45 ft to 47 ft
Heavy Duty- Transit
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
ENC AXESS 45'
DIESEL
Non-
FTA $763,762.00 $791,158.72
2-3B: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Vicinity Motor
Corporation Classic
Non-
FTA $539,288.00 $560,291.41
2-3C: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Hometown
Manufacturing
Urban EV
Non-
FTA $970,253.00 $989,845.84
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
81
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
2-4B: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Vicinity Motor
Corporation Classic
Non-
FTA $501,729.00 $522,732.41
2-4C: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Hometown
Manufacturing
Urban EV
Non-
FTA $931,869.00 $951,461.84
2-5B: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Hometown
Manufacturi
ng, Inc.
View Non-
FTA $208,710.00 $224,649.81
2-6B: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty
Hometown
Manufacturi
ng, Inc.
VIEW Non-
FTA $204,390.00 $220,329.81
2-6C: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty -
Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. VMC Lightning Non-
FTA $582,058.00 $603,061.41
2-6C: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Medium Duty -
Electric
Hometown
Manufacturi
ng, Inc.
View EV Non-
FTA $404,223.00 $418,515.02
END OF CATEGORY 2 TRANSIT BUSES
CATEGORY 3 TROLLEY BUSES
FTA CATEGORY 3 TROLLEY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
3-1A: 40 Ft & >
Trolley Transit Bus
HF Front Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Villager FTA $197,199.68 $213,508.54
3-1B: 40 Ft & >
Trolley Transit Bus
HF & LF Rear Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Streetcar FTA $399,098.00 $417,612.15
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
82
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
3-2A: 35 Ft Trolley
Transit Bus HF Front
Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Villager FTA $194,499.68 $210,808.54
3-2B: 35 Ft Trolley
Transit Bus HF & LF
Rear Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Streetcar FTA $392,798.00 $411,312.15
3-3A: 30 Ft Trolley
Transit Bus HF Front
Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Villager FTA $191,799.68 $207,949.25
3-3B: 30 Ft Trolley
Transit Bus HF & LF
Rear Engine
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Streetcar FTA $383,348.00 $401,862.15
3-4A: 24 Ft- to 29 ft,
11 in Medium Duty
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Villager FTA $186,399.68 $202,549.25
3-5: < 25 Ft Trolley
Light Duty Transit
Vehicle- HF
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Carriage FTA $174,170.00 $184,766.94
NON-FTA TROLLEY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
3-1C: 40 Ft & >
Trolley Transit Bus
Rear Engine LF -
Electric
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Streetcar EV Non-
FTA $849,426.28 $867,940.43
3-2C: 35 Ft Trolley
Transit Bus LF Rear
Engine-Electric
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Streetcar EV Non-
FTA $842,946.28 $861,460.43
3-4B: 24 Ft- to 29 ft,
11 in Medium Duty -
Electric
HOMETOWN
MANUFACTU
RING INC.
Villager EV Non-
FTA $412,862.40 $429,842.44
END OF CATEGORY 3 TROLLEY BUSES
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
83
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 4 LIGHT DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
FTA CATEGORY 4 LIGHT DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-1A: 18 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
9,500 GVWR Min HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarTrans Candidate
II/Ford Transit
Chassis
FTA $103,441.00 $113,768.31
4-1B: 18 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
9,500 GVWR Min HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Starlite/Ford Transit
Chassis
FTA $102,396.00 $112,723.31
4-2A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD FTA $99,684.00 $114,619.28
4-2A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $118,081.00 $140,634.06
4-2A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarTrans
Senator/Ford E350 FTA $100,874.00 $116,672.50
4-2B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Turtle Top Odyssey FTA $105,431.00 $120,366.28
4-2B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Universal FTA $119,111.00 $141,664.06
4-2B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E350 FTA $99,828.00 $115,626.50
4-3A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Turtle Top VanTerra FTA $101,330.00 $116,265.28
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
84
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-3A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion Crusader FTA $116,808.00 $139,361.06
4-3A: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Star Trans
Candidate II/Ford
E350
FTA $99,506.00 $115,304.50
4-3B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit LD FTA $105,529.00 $116,000.41
4-3B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Primetime FTA $117,838.00 $140,391.06
4-3B: 20 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF Narrow Body
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Starlite/Ford E350 FTA $99,370.00 $115,168.50
4-4A: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD FTA $105,636.00 $120,526.88
4-4A: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $120,912.00 $143,465.06
4-4A: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarTrans Senator
II/Ford E350 FTA $105,088.00 $120,794.92
4-4B: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
New England
Wheels Frontrunner FTA $184,040.00 $196,436.35
4-4B: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Universal FTA $121,942.00 $144,495.06
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
85
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-4B: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E350 FTA $104,043.00 $119,749.92
4-4C: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF - Electric
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $225,921.00 $248,474.06
4-5A: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD FTA $111,525.00 $126,415.88
4-5A: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $131,231.00 $153,784.06
4-5A: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E450 FTA $108,921.00 $124,596.29
4-5B: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Turtle Top Odyssey FTA $117,407.00 $132,297.88
4-5B: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Universal FTA $132,261.00 $154,814.06
4-5B: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Arboc Spirit of
Freedom/Chevrolet
4500
FTA $135,268.00 $155,073.04
4-6A: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD FTA $115,752.00 $153,558.04
4-6A: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $135,892.00 $130,701.15
4-6A: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarTrans Senator
II/Ford E450 FTA $115,425.00 $158,445.06
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
86
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-6B: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Turtle Top Odyssey FTA $120,362.00 $131,280.11
4-6B: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Universal FTA $136,922.00 $135,311.15
4-6B: 28 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E450 FTA $114,658.00 $130,513.11
4-7A: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD - All
Passenger
FTA $108,217.00 $123,107.88
4-7A: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Challenger FTA $118,337.00 $140,890.06
4-7A: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
Coach &
Equipment
Bus Sales,
Inc.
Ford E450 Phoenix FTA $92,680.00 $115,268.38
4-7A: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E450
All Passenger
FTA $105,781.00 $121,456.29
4-7B: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD - ADA FTA $111,768.00 $126,658.88
4-7B: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Universal FTA $128,492.00 $151,045.06
4-7B: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
Coach &
Equipment
Bus Sales,
Inc.
Ford E450 Phoenix FTA $99,330.00 $121,918.38
4-7B: GDOT
Cutaway Shuttle Bus
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E450
ADA Equipped
FTA $113,140.00 $128,815.29
4-8A: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion Defender FTA $168,654.00 $191,207.06
4-8A: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarTrans Senator II
HD/Ford F550 FTA $149,412.00 $165,267.11
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
87
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-8B: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Glaval Entourage FTA $169,684.00 $192,237.06
4-8B: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc.
StarCraft Allstar
XL/Ford F550 FTA $148,251.00 $164,106.11
NON-FTA CATEGORY 4 LIGHT DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
4-1A: 18 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
9,500 GVWR Min HF
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Collins DH MFSAB Non-
FTA $105,379.00 $126,413.02
4-4A: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF
Transportati
on
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(dba TESCO)
Chevrolet 3500 with
Pegasus Orion Body
Non-
FTA $104,209.00 $119,463.96
4-4C: 22 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
11,500 GVWR Min
HF - Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Transit
MD - EV Upfit (UES)
Non-
FTA $243,515.00 $257,600.03
4-5C: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR Min
HF - Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc.. Optimal EV S1 Non-
FTA $342,282.00 $354,247.14
4-8A: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
CLASSIC BUS
SALES, LLC Diamond Coach PT Non-
FTA $177,976.00 $191,503.25
4-8B: 33 Ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
19,500 GVWR Min
CLASSIC BUS
SALES, LLC Diamond Coach Non-
FTA $171,332.00 $185,334.25
END OF CATEGORY 4 LIGHT DUTY CUTAWAY
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
88
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 5 MEDIUM DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
FTA CATEGORY 5 MEDIUM DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
5-1: 28 ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
22,000 GVWR
Min HF Front
Engine Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit HD Ford
F550
FTA $128,879.00 $144,150.98
5-2: 30 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
22,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit HD Ford
F550
FTA $131,955.00 $147,226.98
5-3: 32 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
22,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turlte Top Terra
Transit HD Ford
F550
FTA $138,515.00 $153,786.98
5-4: 34 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit HD FCCC
S2C
FTA $175,507.00 $191,650.33
5-5: 36 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Terra Transit HD
FCCC S2C FTA $178,966.00 $195,109.33
5-5: 36 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Defender /
Conventional
Chassis
FTA $199,202.00 $223,662.59
5-5: 36 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
StarTrans Senator
II HD/Ford F650
Cutaway Style
Chassis
FTA $176,232.00 $192,087.11
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
89
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
5-6: 38 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit HD FCCC
S2C
FTA $185,466.00 $199,376.99
5-6: 38 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
StarTrans Senator
II HD/Freightliner
S/2 Cutaway Style
Chassis
FTA $182,932.00 $198,787.11
5-7: 40 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Champion
Defender /
Conventional
Chassis
FTA $203,755.00 $228,215.59
5-7: 40 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
StarTrans Senator
II HD/Freightliner
S/2 Cutaway Style
Chassis
FTA $189,437.00 $205,292.11
NON-FTA CATEGORY 5 MEDIUM DUTY CUTAWAY BUSES
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
5-3: 32 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
22,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
Marco Polo
Shuttle
Non-
FTA $189,932.00 $200,149.31
5-6: 38 Ft Medium
Transit Vehicle-
26,000 GVWR Min
HF Front Engine
Rail
Transportat
ion
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(dba TESCO)
Peterbuilt 536
with Pegasus
Atlas Body
Non-
FTA $170,190.00 $192,340.11
END OF CATEGORY 5 MEDIUM DUTY CUTAWAY
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
90
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
FTA CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
6-1A: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Rear
Entry
The Bus Center
Atlanta, LLC
2023 Chrysler
Voyager / Braun RE FTA $74,486.00 $78,387.73
6-1A: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Rear
Entry
Transportation
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(TESCO)
Chrysler Voyager
Rear Entry
(Chrysler Pacifica
Option)
FTA $67,065.00 $71,468.60
6-1B: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Side
Entry
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
BraunAbility/Chrysl
er Voyager FTA $78,895.00 $78,771.05
6-1B: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Side
Entry
Transportation
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(TESCO)
Chrysler Voyager
Side Entry (Chrysler
Pacifica Option)
FTA $70,359.00 $74,762.60
6-2A: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
T-350 HD 148" EL
High Roof XLT DRW
RWD U4X
FTA $95,932.00 $100,022.95
6-2A: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans
The Bus Center
Atlanta, LLC
Ram Promaster
Primetime Low
floor
FTA $121,732.00 $572,783.73
6-2A: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Mobility Trans
Gamechanger FTA $113,822.00 $118,720.30
6-2B: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Sunset Vans -
159RP Low Floor FTA $146,611.00 $145,980.96
6-2B: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc Driverge Transit FTA $102,195.00 $107,316.41
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
91
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
6-2C: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans-
Electric (Submit
Specifications)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Electric T-350 148"
EL High Roof RWD
W3X
FTA $103,502.00 $107,592.95
6-2C: Other
Modified ADA
Transit Vans-
Electric (Submit
Specifications)
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Mobility Trans
Gamechanger E
Transit
FTA $132,907.00 $135,583.30
6-3A: Other
Modified Non-
ADA Transit Vans
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
T-350 HD 148" EL
High Roof XLT DRW
RWD U4X
FTA $85,256.00 $89,346.95
6-3A: Other
Modified Non-
ADA Transit Vans
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
BraunAbility
Promaster FTA $155,939.00 $158,007.00
6-3C: Other
Modified Non-
ADA Transit Vans-
Electric (Submit
Specifications)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Electric T-350 148"
EL High Roof RWD
W3X
FTA $93,950.00 $98,040.95
6-3C: Other
Modified Non-
ADA Transit Vans-
Electric (Submit
Specifications)
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Forest River Van
Battery Electric FTA $104,980.00 $109,872.75
6-4A: GDOT OEM
ADA Mobility
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Mobility Trans
Gamechanger FTA $114,548.00 $119,446.30
6-4A: GDOT OEM
ADA Mobility
Coach &
Equipment Bus
Sales, Inc.
Ford E350
Metrolite FTA $90,560.00 $95,265.35
6-4B: GDOT OEM
ADA Mobility
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Mobility Trans
Gamechanger FTA $100,733.00 $105,631.30
6-4B: GDOT OEM
ADA Mobility
Coach &
Equipment Bus
Sales, Inc.
Ford E350
Metrolite FTA $82,390.00 $87,095.35
6-5A: GDOT
Shuttle Van
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD - All
Passenger
FTA $99,317.00 $103,127.30
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
92
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
6-5A: GDOT
Shuttle Van
The Bus Center
Atlanta, LLC Champion Crusader FTA $111,864.00 $115,932.23
6-5A: GDOT
Shuttle Van
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E350
All Passenger
FTA $95,320.00 $100,303.21
6-5A: GDOT
Shuttle Van
Coach &
Equipment Bus
Sales, Inc.
Ford E350 Phoenix FTA $84,270.00 $88,975.35
6-5B: GDOT
Shuttle Van
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
Turtle Top Terra
Transit MD - ADA FTA $107,827.00 $111,637.30
6-5B: GDOT
Shuttle Van
The Bus Center
Atlanta, LLC Champion Crusader FTA $122,169.00 $126,237.23
6-5B: GDOT
Shuttle Van
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Starcraft
Allstar/Ford E350
ADA Equipped
FTA $103,746.00 $108,729.21
6-5B: GDOT
Shuttle Van
Coach &
Equipment Bus
Sales, Inc.
Ford E350 Phoenix FTA $91,040.00 $95,745.35
NON-FTA CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
6-1A: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Rear
Entry
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
BraunAbility/Chrysl
er Voyager
Non
-
FTA
$67,443.00 $67,403.41
6-1B: OEM
Modified ADA
Mobility Modified
Mini-Van Side
Entry
The Bus Center
Atlanta, LLC
2023 Chrysler
Voyager / Braun SE
Non
-
FTA
$74,486.00 $78,387.73
6-3B: Other
Modified Non ADA
Transit Vans
Creative Bus
Sales, Inc
Braunability
Promaster
Non
-
FTA
$129,098.00 $133,186.00
END OF CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
93
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 7 OTHER MOBILITY VANS
FTA CATEGORY 7 OTHER MOBILITY VANS
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
7-2: Other Mobility
Van- Electric
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
E-T350 148" Med
Roof RWD W9C FTA $94,254.00 $98,344.95
7-2: Other Mobility
Van- Electric
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Ford Transit /
Driverge FTA $105,887.00 $109,788.73
7-2: Other Mobility
Van- Electric
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
FR Van E Transit FTA $104,680.00 $97,353.75
7-3: Other Mobility
Van (Conversion)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
T-350 HD 148"
Med Roof XL RWD
X2C
FTA $82,064.00 $84,314.46
7-3: Other Mobility
Van (Conversion)
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Ford Transit /
Driverge FTA $77,661.00 $81,562.73
7-3: Other Mobility
Van (Conversion)
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
Mobility Trans
X2C FTA $82,904.00 $82,752.30
7-4: Other Transit
Van (Conversion)
**ABC Bus,
Inc..
T-350 HD 148"
Med Roof XLT
RWD X2C
FTA $71,397.00 $75,487.95
7-4: Other Transit
Van (Conversion)
The Bus
Center
Atlanta, LLC
Ford eTransit /
Driverge FTA $99,811.00 $103,712.73
7-4: Other Transit
Van (Conversion)
Creative
Bus Sales,
Inc
Forest River Van
X2C Transit FTA $84,021.00 $86,085.75
7-4: Other Transit
Van (Conversion)
Master's
Transportat
ion, Inc
Ford Transit 7+1
Rear Lift Wood
Floor
FTA $75,669.00 $81,012.05
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
94
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
NON-FTA CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
Base Vehicle
Price Total Eval Cost
7-3: Other Mobility
Van (Conversion)
Transportat
ion
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(TESCO)
RAM Promaster Non-
FTA $78,618.00 $82,344.50
7-4: Other Transit
Van (Conversion)
Transportat
ion
Equipment
Sales
Corporation
(TESCO)
Ford Transit T350
SRW Van
Non-
FTA $72,120.00 $76,953.17
END OF APPARENT SUCCESSFUL OFFERORS
UNSUCCESSFUL OFFORERS
CATEGORY 1 COACH
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
REASON
1-1B: 45 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD C10M FTA *Non-Responsible
1-1A: 45 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD C10MS Double
Decker
Non-
FTA
*Non-Responsible
1-1C: 45 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD C10M Non-
FTA
*Non-Responsible
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
95
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
REASON
1-3B: 35 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD C8MS Double
Decker
Non-
FTA
*Non-Responsible
1-3C: 35 Ft
Surburban/Commut
er/Coach Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD C8M Non
FTA
*Non-Responsible
CATEGORY 2 TRANSIT
2-2C: 40 ft to 44 ft
11 Heavy Duty -
Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD K9MD FTA
*Non-Responsible
2-3C: 35 ft to 39 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD K8M FTA
*Non-Responsible
2-4B: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD K7M-ER FTA
*Non-Responsible
2-4C: 30 ft to 34 ft
11 in Heavy Duty -
Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD K7M FTA
*Non-Responsible
2-7B: 59 ft - 65 ft 0
ft Articulated Heavy
Duty : Electric
RIDE Coach
& Bus, a
d/b/a of BYD
Coach & Bus
LLC
BYD K11M FTA
*Non-Responsible
CATEGORY 4 LIGHT DUTY CUTAWAY
6-2C Other Modified
ADA Transit Vans-
Electric (Submit
Specifications)
LIGHTNING
eMOTORS
ZEV3 80kWh ADA
Passenger Vehicle
Non-
FTA Non-Responsive
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
96
Item 10.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO AWARD
Revised: 08/31/20 SPD-AP004
CATEGORY 6 OEM MOBILITY VANS
Line Item #/ Vehicle
Description Supplier Make/Model
FTA/
Non-
FTA
REASON
4-5C: 25 ft Light
Transit Vehicle-
14,200 GVWR
Min HF-
Electric
LIGHTNING
eMOTORS
ZEV4 PASSENGER
SHUTTLE
NON-
FTA Non-Responsive
*Supplier is non-responsible based on the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Federal Transit
Administration’s determination that supplier is a prohibited source of supply as the supplier is owned or
controlled by, is a subsidiary of, or is otherwise related legally or financially to a corporation based in China,
which has been identified as a nonmarket economy country, and is prohibited by 49 U.S.C. Section
5323(u)(1). Should the supplier’s status change, the State Purchasing Division reserves the right to re-open
it's award recommendation.
**Contingent on successful resolution of Contract Terms and Conditions exceptions.
Authorized Signature: ___________________________________________________________
END OF NOIA
DocuSign Envelope ID: D5565176-6AE6-4E1C-80F8-6D3A803AA6F5
97
Item 10.
Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.