RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Meeting — Minutes

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Planning Commission · meeting of Mar 18, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIONCHAIR: JASON CAVALIER, DISTRICT 1T. YOKIMA CURETON,DISTRICT 2LYNETTE HINSON,DISTRICT 3JUDIANNA TINKLENBERG,DISTRICT 4 VICE-CHAIR: MICHELLE RICHARDS, DISTRICT 5 SHEILA HINSON,DISTRICT 6 FRANCES LIU,DISTRICT 7 SECRETARY: AIMEE SHOLAR MINUTES Lancaster County Planning Commission March 18, 2025, 6:00 p.m. Chairman Cavalier called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. 1. ROLL CALL: Quorum is present (7 Commissioners)Commissioners Present:Jason Cavalier, Dist. 1 Judianna Tinklenberg, Dist. 4T. Yokima Cureton, Dist. 2 Michelle Richards, Dist. 5 Lynette Hinson, District 3 Sheila Hinson, Dist. 6 Frances Liu, Dist. 7 Staff Present: Allison Hardin, Development Services Director Matthew Blaszyk, Planner Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician Sherrie Simpson, Clerk to Council The following press were notified of the meeting by email in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act: The Lancaster News, Kershaw News Era, The Rock Hill Herald, The Fort Mill Times, Cable News 2, Channel 9, and the local Government Channel. The agenda was also posted in the lobby of the County Administration Building for the required length of time, and was published on the County website. PRAYER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: T. Yokima Cureton THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY OF PROCEEDINGS. IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. 2. APPROVE AGENDA Chairman Cavalier called for a motion to approve the agenda. Motion to Approve by Shelly Richards; 2ndby Sheila HinsonCalled vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. 3. APPROVE MINUTESa. February 18, 2025, Regular MinutesChairman Cavalier called for a motion to approve February 18, 2025 Regular Minutes as written. Motion to Approve with correction of scrivener’s error page 1 (replace “Chairman Deese” with “Secretary Aimee Sholar) by Sheila Hinson; 2ndby Shelly Richards.Called vote: 6:0. Motion approved unanimously. Commissioner Cureton Abstained.b. March 6, 2025 Workshop Minutes Chairman Cavalier called for a motion to approve March 6, 2025; Workshop Minutes as written. Motion to Approve with correction of scrivener’s error page 1 (replace “Chairman Deese” with “Chairman Cavalier”) by Frances Liu; 2ndby Sheila Hinson. Called vote: 6:0. Motion approved unanimously. Commissioner Cureton Abstained.4. CITIZEN’S COMMENTS [see Sign-In sheet attached] Chairman Cavalier opened the floor to comments from the public. None had signed to speak; the floor was closed to general comment.5. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS FOR RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL a. CU-2024-2612 Cogito Academy Deferred from 2/18/2025 Application by Cameron Gill/True North K8 and Joseph Camposeo for a Conditional Use Permit for a charter school (“Cogito Academy”) to be located on 22.0 acres off Shiloh Unity Road (TM 0049-00-082.00). Staff Presentation: Matthew Blaszyk, Planner, presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Conditional Approval per staff review comments Questions to staff: Y. Cureton: Were any emails received other than those provided? (No)Y. Cureton: Has Applicant made any effort to reach out to the neighborhood? (Applicant responds below) Comment from applicant(s):Cameron Gill (Charlotte) and Roddy Jordan (Greenville): 401C(3) Public Charter School planned. Happy to answer questions. [staff provided applicants with a copy of citizens email comment] Questions from Commissioners:Y. Cureton: Has Applicant made any effort to reach out to the neighborhood? Cameron Gill: We have been working with the School District regarding their temporary location at Pleasant Dale Baptist property (S. Potter Road). School Board conducted interest surveys and open enrollment (for temporary site). In 6 days, 200 families enrolled. J. Tinklenberg: Concerned about the blind curve where turn-in to the site. Cameron Gill: Road improvements on Shiloh Unity from SCDOT review include a right turn lane, and a westbound left turn. William Heintz (Engineer): Site triangles for the ingress/egress are clear of the curve. There is a 4-way intersection at western driveway, with stop signs at 3 of the points. F. Liu: Expressed concern about danger to students walking. Cameron Gill: We do not foresee pedestrian crossing Shiloh Unity Road; there is connectivity with the subdivision community (Granite Falls) to the south for pedestrians. North of Shiloh Unity is the Lancaster Speedway and scattered large-acre lots. J. Cavalier: Has there been analysis of the timing of traffic for racetrack events? Cameron Gill: the track operates only on Saturdays, from March to October. For a good portion of that time school is not in session; and we do not anticipate having events on Saturday, so there should be no conflict. We’ve met with the Speedway owners and we are all on the same page. PUBLIC HEARING: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) None signed in. See attached comment letter from G. Evans. Chairman Cavalier closed public hearing and called for a motion on item CU-2024-2612Motion to approve by Yokima Cureton; 2ndby Sheila Hinson. Discussion: F. Liuexpressed concerned about access on the blind curve. People don’t obey traffic laws, especially student drivers. Applicantclarifies that the proposed school is K-8, not K-12Y. Cureton expressed concern about racetrack event traffic impacting school events on weekends. The track may not be open, but people do gather at the racetrack on Fridays. M. Richards stated that the addition of the turn lane should reduce danger at entrance, even if on a curve Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously.The item will go to County Council for consideration, and applicant will be notified of time and date. b. RZ-2025-0072 McDonald/Small Application by Carl Small to rezone 0.488 acres off Airport Road and Great Falls Highway (p/o TM 0086D-0C-001.00) from Medium Density Residential (MDR) to General Business (GB) District, in order to conjoin it to TM 0086D-0C-006.00 to resolve structures crossing boundary line Staff Presentation: Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician, presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: ApprovalQuestions to staff: none. Comment from applicant(s):Gary Pakozdy for McDonald Family Trust: Ms. Bryan summarized the project. We wish to purchase the property and demolish the cooler behind the old Piggly Wiggly. Thank you for your consideration; I am here to answer questions. Questions from Commissioners: no questionsPublic Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) None signed in Chairman Cavalier closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item RZ-2025-0072 Motion to approve by F. Liu; 2ndby Y. Cureton.Discussion: no discussion Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item will go to County Council for consideration, and applicant will be notified of time and date. c. RZ-2025-0191 Ingram/ Old Carter RoadApplication by Kenisha Ingram on behalf of Veterans United Realty of the Southeast LLC to rezone 0.73 acres located at 1754 Old Carter Street (TM 0086C-0M-003.00) from Manufactured Housing (MH) to Medium Density Residential (MDR) District in order to subdivide and build single-family homes. Staff Presentation: Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician, presented the applications consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Approval [see attachment: Breakdown of MH zoning in Old Carter Rd Neighborhood] Questions to staff:Y. Cureton: in the County, how many MH areas are left?J. Bryan: I do not have that information; however, all AR and RR zoning allows mobile homes, which is a vast amount of the County. There is very little that is specifically zoned MH. L. Hinson: I’m concerned with the price of housing; mobile homes are more affordable; was there anyone who complained or commented for this item?J. Bryan: no one has filed email comments. Lot sizes under an acre are not really conducive to mobile homes; a great number of these lots are under 1/3 of an acre, and do not have lot width requirement to accommodate a mobile home. F. Liu: Why do we require an acre? J. Bryan: I can’t answer that question; I can say that even our regulations for Mobile Home Parks, which is mainly what MH zoning is now used for, require larger lots areas than that for each mobile home. Another comment regarding locations for mobile homes - Allison has mentioned that in the new UDO, we are looking at opening more districts to allow mobile homes. J. Cavalier: Is the existing structure condemned? J. Bryan: I don’t think it has been condemned but it will be demolished since the property can’t be divided until it is removed. Comment from applicant(s): Kenisha Ingram (Columbia SC) : Mobile homes now are long, and cannot meet rear setbacks in these small lots. Questions from Commissioners: none Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) None signed in Chairman Cavalier closed public hearing and called for a motion on item RZ-2025-0191 Motion to approve by Y. Cureton ; 2ndby S. Hinson. Discussion: no discussion Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item will go to County Council for consideration, and applicant will be notified of time and date. 6. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS FOR PLANNING COMMISSION DECISIONa. SD-2024-1745 Silver RunDeferred from 2/18/2025Application by Broadstreet Homes Inc and Jerry Griffin Jr for a Preliminary Plat for 25.25 acres located off Silver Run Road (TM 0006-00-034.00) to develop a 44-lot single family residential community.Staff Presentation: Matthew Blaszyk, Planner, presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Questions to staff: F. Liu: notes that the entrance is not aligned with Rise Lane.M. Blaszyk: Public Works and SCDOT will review that issue at Civil Review process. SCDOT is abandoning the front portion Rise Lane, it will become a County Road. Applicants: Chris Hanson (Waxhaw NC) Skylar Brown (Charlotte NC) Chris Hanson:Broad Street Homes and sister company Synergy Steel are Lancaster-based companies, both will be heavily involved in both building and manufacturing components such as the steel beams and trusses. Both are invested in the community, building with Habitat for Humanity. We are local, and our reputation is important to us. We take staff concerns and community concerns seriously; you are not dealing with a faceless person out of state. There are site challenges, particularly since the site is narrow and there is topography, ; we understand there may be elevated construction costs as we develop due to such constraints, but we are not looking at simply maximizing density. We are staying well under requirements for density and paid attention to functional park space. We also have flexibility with construction design to accommodate topography challenges as they come up. Our revision has extended the road stub to the property line per staff review comment. Questions to Applicant: J. Tinklenberg: Looking at the grading plan, you are tying in right at property line. Looking at adjacent homes backing up to this in Rosemont, I’m worried about impacts to those homes [given the steep grade]. Chris Hanson: in this plan we are just looking at slab-on-grade construction with the rough publicly available topography data. With more detailed data, we have the flexibility to adapt our plans to use basements to accommodate the grade as we find it. J. Tinklenberg: Will you do fencing or any other privacy amendments between the properties?Chris Hanson: right now a buffer is not required, but we can look at fencing if it needs to be added.S. Richards: I’m also very concerned with the topography, I’m an engineer. The roofs of the neighboring properties are going to be on a level with the basements. I’m concerned not only with the aesthetics for those moving in but the impact on those already there.Chris Hanson: We’re looking to Skylar and his team to come up with plans that will meet all those objectives. S. Hinson: When you say the streets will be privately maintained, do you mean the people that live there or the HOA?Chris Hanson: We will turn them over to the HOA to maintain. Y. Cureton: How many streets are we looking at? Chris Hanson: 3 streets total: the stub street, a main drive, and the circle around the park.Y. Cureton: Does the road connect to a main road, or another neighborhood?Chris Hanson: The stub allows future connectivity if the adjacent property is developed; the main drive enters/exits on Silver Run Road. J. Tinklenberg: What amenities are included with the park? Chris Hanson: We’ve found that the preferred option by residents is an open green space, perhaps with a walkway and some benches around the perimeter. We may consider a playground on a smaller lot, but we’ll determine that during the construction phase. F. Liu: You have the smaller park space and the larger park space across the street from each other? That concerns me if children are running back and forth across the road.Chris Hanson: The main park is the one-acre green space, not an active park area. F. Liu: Do you see any problem with the entrance offset from Rise Lane? Chris Hanson: Rise Lane is very narrow, with few homes; if that alignment needs to be met, we can do that within the constraints of our property boundary. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets)1. Brian Dentremont(Rise Lane) [Against the proposal]. We back up to this property. Concerned about traffic on Rise Land and Silver Run Road, as well as detrimental effect on Rosemont. Silver Run is over capacity, a curvy road. Everyone will use the cut-through Rosemont to get to Hwy 160, which is dangerous. Schools are already over capacity. Proposed road going to Rise Lane, will there be more houses there? No one is for this development 2. Jill Randolph (Vixen Lane, Rosemont): [Against the proposal]. The area is packed. Concerned about traffic, especially since a recent accident nearby where a child was hurt in Rosemont. Concerned by schools over capacity, police are understaffed, there is rampant overdevelopment. Worried about cracking foundations and damage to existing homes by construction. 3. Kirk Reed (Rosemont Drive): [Against the proposal] Resident since 2009, President of Rosemont HOA. There has been a lot of development in and around the community since then. The biggest problem is roads. Yellowstone Drive has been a particular problem. We’ve put in speed bumps at our own expense and a monitor that tells your driving speed. We also have a traffic counter to count the vehicles going through. In the past month we have had 20,000 vehicles cut through our neighborhood of 334 houses, going to 160 or out to Silver Run. In the last few years several developments have been built: Heritage Hall, Roseglen Townhomes, and now The Lodges with apartments, townhomes and single-family rentals. Regarding these new homes: what is the size and price point? How well do they fit with existing development? Regarding the grade differences, they say they’ll deal with it “down the road” but that’s not good enough. That’s our property next door. I ask that you not approve this project. 4. Billy Snipes (Stones Throw Lane): [ For the proposal] I live on a cut-through road, I understand the problem. That happens over time and can be addressed through other means. We’re talking about denying people’s development rights because of development. People speeding does not have to do with the new homes, it has to do with people cutting through. The developer is asking for well below the allowed density for this district, just as the land around it was developed when it had the opportunity to build. I ask for your approval of this project.5. Julie Griffin(Woodhurst Drive, Monroe NC) [For the proposal] Owner of the 25 acre subject property. I appreciate the opportunity to make our request. We are simply asking to develop this property with the existing zoning. Properties all around it have been developed in the same way, and it only makes sense to develop this as a neighborhood as well. It’s the logical and appropriate use. There have been requests to rezone it for even higher density development such as townhomes, and those requests were denied because they county determined that Medium Density Residential was the proper designation. We respect that decision. That is exactly what we are requesting, in fact we are asking for less than the allowed density. We elected to work with Broad Street Homes because they are a respected developer based right here in Lancaster County. Denying this request will devalue the land and will impact our financial security. This is the responsible and appropriate use for this property. Thank you for your consideration. 6. Rod Alvarado (Vixen Lane, Rosemont) [ Against the proposal] Please consider these impacts: the owners have rights, but the adjacent properties also have rights. Environmental Impact: impermeable surfaces will create runoff, and we will have issues with stormwater. Several streets backing up to it in Rosemont are directly downhill and will experience flooding due to the runoff. Economic Impact: the proposed lots and houses are much smaller than the existing homes, and will devalue surrounding homes. Public Safety: So much traffic passing through is causing concern to parents. Adding 44 new homes will mean 100 more cars. Schools are overcrowded. Fire department and police will be affected. The street is a narrow street with a blind corner and is very dangerous. Applicant rebuttal: The homes will be around 2500 square feet, the price comparison concern is not valid. With regard to the stormwater concerns, we are meeting all design requirements for the state and county for the discharge. Regarding the stub toward Rise Lane: we are required to provide stub out, but it’s unlikely development there would be able to obtain the necessary right-of-way to create additional access there. Allison Hardin: Regarding some of the issues raised: 1. Stub outs are required, but that does not mean there is development planned adjacent. 2. Park planning should take place now, not at Civil stage, especially if the location of the park needs to be reconsidered. 3. Matters that affect the safety of the neighborhood, such as road alignment or foot traffic for parks, needs to be done now.The current plan meets many UDO requirements, but you can address these design concerns now. Y. Cureton: Excited to see LC School District weighing in early. Was there more detail, or just this comment? Hardin: We do not have concurrency requirements, but we are working toward that. So the School District information is helpful but we cannot deny a plan just based on their comment. Denial must be based on UDO or safety issues. Chairman Cavalierpaused the discussion to call for a motion on item SD-2024-1745. Motion to approve by Y. Cureton; 2ndby L. Hinson. Discussion continued:Y. Cureton: If I understand, then saturation in school enrollment is in the middle?Hardin: We couldn’t deny it just on that basis. J. Tinklenberg: This project is in my district, I am familiar with all the problems. I can’t find many positives for this site. The topography does not work with the adjacent properties. Add to that the knowledge that the schools are at capacity. We have a responsibility to fix the problem. We don’t have to continue doing things the way they have been done in the past. This is not smart development. This parcel is left because it is not suitable for this type of development. F. Liu: For public safety, I went to look at this property. My GPS took me through Rosemont. Since there’s already a problem, I couldn’t in good conscience add 100 cars to that problem. Called vote: 0:7. Motion is denied unanimously. Planning Commission makes final decisions on Preliminary Plats. b. SD-2024-1442 Shadow MossApplication by Prestige Development & Site Works LLC and Michael McCarter for a Preliminary Plat for 52.235 acres located off Hilldale Drive (TM-0080-00-033.00) to develop a 100-lot single family residential community Applicant: Paul Carter, Eastlake Engineering: APPLICANT REQUESTS DEFERRAL TO APRIL 15, 2025. Chairman Cavalier called for a motion on item SD-2024-1442 Motion to continue to April 15, 2025 by Y. Cureton; 2nd by J. Tinklenberg. Called vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. Item is continued to April 15, 2025. 7. NON-HEARING ITEMS a. NRN-2025-0375 March Submittals New Road Names from E911 Addressing via Preliminary Plats and Civil Plans, pursuant to Sec. 6.4.11 of the Unified Development Ordinance Staff Presentation: Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician, presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendation: Approval. Questions to Staff: None. No public hearing is required. Chairman Cavalier called for a motion on item NRN-2025-0375. Motion to approve by S. Richards; 2nd by J. Tinklenberg. Discussion: no further discussion. Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously.The Planning Commission has final approval of new road names and road name changes. 8. OTHERa.CIP Overviewwith Jamie Privuznak [ see attached copy of slide deck]Discussion:J. Tinklenberg requested additional information about projects, and expressed dissatisfaction with the process. Planning Commission should be included earlier in the process to develop projects in line with Comprehensive Plan. This was already discussed last year, and we were assured we would be included earlier in the process.J. Privuznak clarified context of the non-funded projects list in the overall CIP and Budget cycle process, and stated she would supply additional project information. b. UDO Workshop Report: The Workshop was postponed and will be rescheduled. The consultants made a presentation for Council at the Committee of the Whole meeting. The Subcommittee will tackle Chapter 10: Definitions next.c. Board Member of the Year Nominations: After discussion of the annual nomination process for Board Member of the Year, Y. Cureton Nominated Judianna Tinklenberg, and the nomination was seconded by Shelly Richards. Commissioners agreed to continue the discussion at the next Workshop meeting (April 3rd, 2025). d. ADJOURN Motion to adjourn by Sheila Hinson; 2ndby Yokima Cureton. Motion approved by unanimous consent. Meeting adjourned at 8:29 p.m.

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.