RecordWell Data

Design Review Board Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Design Review Board · meeting of May 28, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board Meeting Tuesday, May 28, 2024, 2:30 PM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers 1. Call to Order 2. Adoption of the Agenda 3. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of 5/14/2024 4. Unfinished Business 5. New Business a. DRB-000797-2024 - 81 Union Cemetery - Port Royal Facility - Final 6. Appearance by Citizens 7. Board Business 8. Staff Reports 9. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Page 1 of 57 Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 57 Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 5/14/2024 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING Tuesday, May 14, 2024, 3:00 PM Minutes 1. Call to Order Chairman Foss called the meeting to order at 3:03 PM. Present were: Cathy Foss, Chairman; Todd Theodore; Annette Lippert; John Moleski; Ryan Bassett; Tom Parker; and Judd Carstens, Vice-Chairman, who arrived at 3:00 PM. No member was absent. 2. Adoption of the Agenda There being no changes to the agenda, a motion by Mr. Theodore was made to adopt the agenda as presented, and the motion was seconded by Mr. Parker. The motion passed 6-0-1, with Mr. Carstens not yet having arrived at the meeting. 3. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 9, 2024 There being no changes to the Minutes, a motion was made by Mr. Theodore to approve the Minutes of the meeting of April 9, 2024, and seconded by Mr. Bassett. The motion was passed by a vote of 5-0-3, with Mr. Carstens not having arrived at the meeting, and Ms. Lippert and Mr. Moleski absent from the April 9 meeting. 4. Appearance by Citizens Public comments concerning unrelated agenda items were to be submitted electronically via the Open Town Hall Portal. None were received, and no one spoke at the meeting. 5. Unfinished Business a. DRB-000715-2024 - 11 Lemoyne Avenue - Alteration Alexis McIlwee, Principal Planner, presented the application, which had been seen previously, from Katie Burzon for the proposed hotel conversion into a Spark by Hilton. The alteration involves changes to the color scheme on the building, doors, and railings. The sign will be presented for sign review separately. Ms. McIlwee noted that applicant does not have a representative present at the meeting, but Staff has no issues and recommends approval as submitted with the colors noted but no color chips provided. Since the colors submitted have not been approved before, the Committee members requested a review of the Town's color chart provided by Sherwin-Williams. The agenda item was moved to the end of the agenda to allow time for Staff to bring the Sherwin- Williams color chart to the meeting. Page 3 of 57 Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 5/14/2024 Page | 2 A continuation of this item occurred at 4:49 PM, at which time the Sherwin-Williams color chart was reviewed for overall building color, railings, doors, and trim, and Mr. Parker returned to the meeting. Ms. Lippert moved to approve the application as presented with the provided conditions: with the A/C to match the building color. The motion was seconded by Mr. Moleski, and the motion was passed unanimously. 6. New Business a. DRB-000699-2024 - Michael Anthonys - Conceptual Review Alexis McIlwee, Principal Planner, presented the application for conceptual review on behalf of Michael Anthonys, an existing restaurant located on 2 halves of an existing 2- story building, which proposes to change the interior envelope that is not necessarily visible from New Orleans Road. Michael Anthonys is a rental tenant, so no changes are requested to the facade of the overall building, which also has multiple units and businesses. Additonally, the landlord does not want to make major changes. Staff recommends conceptual approval with proposed plantings, color board and lighting and landscape plans, connections and details as needed to be provided at final review. Mr. Carstens arrived at the meeting during Staff presentation. Brent Robinson, Architect, outlined the project with existing photos and completed as-built drawings to fully explain the modifications, enclosures, stairway relocation, and proposed addition for storage room. Questions and comments from the Board members were addressed by Mr. Robinson. Mr. Parker made a motion to approve the conceptual as submitted, with Staff recommendations for additional plantings between the 2 stairs, and the following conditions: that colors and materials to match the existing building; the roof color to be submitted; miscellaneous details provided for back stairs, handrails, walkways, and patio area; and color and style on storage room doors to be provided. The motion was seconded by Mr. Theodore, and the motion passed unanimously. b. DRB-000696-2024 - Wells Fargo on Mathews Drive - Sign System Mr. Parker recused himself for DRB-000696-2024 and DRB-000703-2024. Alexis McIlwee, Principal Planner, presented the application for a refresh of the signage system for Wells Fargo located at 75 Mathews Drive, including directional signs, front building signs, and main frontage signs. The overall recommendation from Staff is approval with conditions: Staff approves signage E12 and E13; with signage labeled E01, E02, E03, E04, E05, and E06 the Staff recommends the red be changed to previously approved Sundried Tomato, and white be changed to previously approved Interactive Cream, with smaller directional signs approved as-is. She pointed out the yellow and red are trademark colors for Wells Fargo. Kevin Liller appeared on behalf of applicant, and noted his company is participating in a 4-5 year Wells Fargo roll-out for signs at 80 locations around the country, with 20 in SC. Page 4 of 57 Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 5/14/2024 Page | 3 He noted this is a like-for-like change, non-illuminated letters, no font changes, no changes to electrical upgrades keeping existing lumen count, keeping the size, location, and mounting the same for primary building signs, including ground signs. The paint colors are trademark colors with most of the signs not clearly visible from any major road, so he has been asked to push these colors. He provided a metal color chip showing the trademark color Red being requested by Wells Fargo. While the yellow is a trademark color, he noted some flexibility on their part to switch to a preferred yellow for accents on directional and/or drive-thru entrance/exit signs. However, the Sundried Tomato color would appear to be too different to be acceptable, but he will relay all comments to them for a final decision. He indicated they would like to get closer to the trademark red than the Sundried Tomato color. Since the applicant has a seconded application, it was decided that the presentation for the second application would be heard and a decision on both would be made simultaneously. c. DRB-000703-2024 - Wells Fargo on Greenwood Drive - Sign System Mr. Parker recused himself for DRB-000696-2024 and DRB-000703-2024. Alexis McIlwee presented the application for a refresh of the signage system for Wells Fargo located at 1 Greenwood Drive, including directional signs, front building signs, and main frontage signs, similar to DRB-000696-2024. The overall recommendation from Staff is similar, as well, approved with conditions: Staff approves signage E19 and NE20; with signage labeled E01, E02, E03, E04, and E05 the Staff recommends the red be changed to previously approved Sundried Tomato, and signage E12, E-13 and E-18 with white be changed to previously approved Interactive Cream. She noted that one more review for this area would be needed, that being the Sea Pines Circle ARB. Mr. Liller appeared on behalf of applicant, and noted that again, this is a like-for-like change, non-illuminated letters, no changes to electrical upgrades keeping existing lumen count, keeping the size, fonts, location, and mounting the same for primary building signs, including ground signs. The paint colors red, white, and yellow are trademark colors with most of the signs not clearly visible from any major road, so he has been asked to push these colors. He provided a metal color chip showing the trademark color Red being requested by Wells Fargo. While the yellow is a trademark color, he noted some flexibility on their part to switch to a preferred yellow for accents on directional and/or drive-thru entrance/exit signs. However, the Sundried Tomato color would appear to be too different to be acceptable, but he will relay all comments to them for a final decision. The main difference between the Mathew Drive and Greenwood Drive sign systems is the monument sign at Greenwood Drive, with plans to powerwash the monument and directional signs, with some new directional signs. He indicated they would like to get closer to the trademark red than the Sundried Tomato color. Questions, concerns, and comments were addressed with the Board members, with the suggestion that the entire building be powerwashed and not just the monument sign. Ms. Page 5 of 57 Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board Meeting Minutes 5/14/2024 Page | 4 McIlwee reminded the applicant that the directional and smaller signs will still require a sign permit review. A motion was made by Ms Lippert to approve the conceptual review of both DRB- 000696-2024 and DRB-000703-2024 sign systems, with conditions as follows: for the directional signage, the background color should be more akin to the building color; the red needs to be toned down to a somewhat darker, more nature blending red; the yellow should be toned down, with Staff to provide samples for review; for areas where signage is a monument sign, it needs to be investigated whether the street number needs to be mounted per Fire Department request and a new layout provided; any white element on signage, whether letters or turns shall be building base color; the yellow proceeding strips shall be removed; it shall be verified if there is a totality limit per building/site on total square footage of signage; building signs and/or monument mounted signs, all wall elements need to be treated equally via cleaning; and the whole project should come back before the Board for final approval, including providing a copy of the Sea Pines Circle ARB approval. Mr. Theodore seconded the motion, and the motion was passed 6- 0-1 with Mr. Parker recusing himself. 7. Board Business A question was posed about whether continuing education is required for a board member whose term is expiring in June, and Ms. McIlwee is to determine an answer. 8. Staff Reports Ms. McIlwee reported 16 minors with 7 of the 16 being public storage upgrades, which will require Board review. Palmetto Breeze has requested a demo lighting on D'Allyon, and Ms. McIlwee will provide the address for any member who would like to check it out. She reported that Dunes House had completed a temporary awning replacement over the bar area, which she will suggest be painted the same as the building, and she will also be dealing with the umbrella colors at Zunzibar. 9. Adjournment The meeting was declared adjourned at 4:54 PM. Approved: The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 6 of 57 1 DESIGNDESIGN TEAM/DRBTEAM/DRB COMMENTCOMMENT SHEETSHEET TheThe commentscomments belowbelow areare staffstaff recommendationsrecommendations toto thethe DesignDesign ReviewReview BoardBoard (DRB)(DRB) andand dodo NOTNOT constituteconstitute DRBDRB approvalapproval oror denial.denial. PROJECT NAME: 81 Union Cemetery DRB#: DRB-000797-2024 DATE: 5/28/2024 CATEGORY: Final Review RECOMMENDATION: Approval Approval with Conditions Denial APPLICATION MATERIAL DRB REQUIREMENTS Complies Yes No Not Applicable Comments or Conditions Demolition Plan if needed Existing Conditions match As-Built Dimensioned Details and of Sections Detail Illustrating Connection to Existing Structure New Building Details Match Existing Building Details ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN DESIGN GUIDE/LMO CRITERIA Complies Yes No Not Applicable Comments or Conditions Structure is designed to be appropriate to the neighborhood Promotes pedestrian scale and circulation Design is unobtrusive and set into the natural environment Utilizes natural materials and colors Avoids distinctive vernacular styles Design is appropriate for its use All facades shall have equal design characteristics Page 7 of 57 2 Avoids monotonous planes or unrelieved repetition Has a strong roof form with enough variety to provide visual interest Overhangs are sufficient for the façade height. Forms an details are sufficient to reduce the mass of the structure Human scale is achieved by the use of proper proportions and architectural elements Utilizes a variety of materials, textures and colors Incorporates wood or wood simulating materials Windows are in proportion to the facade Details are clean, simple and appropriate while avoiding excessive ornamentation Utilities and equipment are concealed from view Decorative lighting is limited and low wattage and adds to the visual character Accessory elements are designed to coordinate with the primary structure LANDSCAPE DESIGN DESIGN GUIDE/LMO CRITERIA Complies Yes No Not Applicable Comments or Conditions Treats the Landscape as a major element of the project Provides Landscaping of a scope and size that is in proportion to the scale of the development Landscape is designed so that it may be maintained in its natural shape and size Preserves a variety of existing native trees and shrubs Provides for a harmonious setting for the site’s structures, parking areas or other construction Location of existing trees and new trees provides street buffers, mitigation for parking lots, and an architectural complement that visually mitigates between parking lots and building(s) Shrubs are selected to complement the natural setting, provide visual interest and screen less-desirable elements of the project A variety of species is selected for texture and color Provides overall order and continuity of the Landscape plan Page 8 of 57 3 Native plants or plants that have historically been prevalent on the Island are utilized A variety of sizes is selected to create a “layered” appearance for visual interest and a sense of depth The location of existing mature trees is taken into account in placement of shrubs so as not to damage tree roots Proper spacing and location for plants to reach their mature size and natural shape while avoiding excessive or unnatural pruning Proposed groundcovers are evergreen species with low maintenance needs Large, grassed lawn areas encompassing a major portion of the site are avoided The adjacent development is taken into account in determining the most appropriate buffer so as not to depart too dramatically from the neighborhood Ornamentals and Annuals are limited to entrances and other focal points NATURAL RESOURCE PROTECTION DESIGN GUIDE/LMO CRITERIA Complies Yes No Not Applicable Comments or Conditions An effort has been made to preserve existing trees and under story plants Tree protection will be provided for any significant trees within 15’ of proposed work. Supplemental and replacement trees meet LMO requirements for size, species and number Wetlands if present are avoided and the required buffers are maintained Sand dunes if present are not disturbed COMMENTS & CONDITIONS 1. Staff recommends approval with the condition that the color and materials be submitted at the time of the meeting and are deemed acceptable. 2. This project will require a Building Permit prior to construction and a Major Development Plan approval. Please email CDIC@hiltonheadislandsc.gov following this approval. 3. Conceptual Review was approved with conditions on 3/12/2024 a. Add all required buffers to landscaping plan and bolster plantings for the side of the property that is adjacent to a residential use. b. Consider a mesh fence for the entrance gate of the facility to screen. c. Add some landscaping to the west property side to better screen the existing shipping containers. Page 9 of 57 4 d. Provide cut sheets on the light fixture selection. e. Provide a detailed color and material board for Final Submission. f. Garage doors to be a proposed darker color to the match the roof. Page 10 of 57 Page 11 of 57 Page 12 of 57 Page 13 of 57 Page 14 of 57 Project Narrative The Association of Landowners of Port Royal Plantation is proposing to construct a new metal maintenance facility structure at 81 Union Cemetery Road. Since purchasing an acre parcel in 2017, the goal has been to build a maintenance storage facility to protect and work on equipment. The purpose of the building will primarily be used as the main operational and storage area that the maintenance staff utilizes. It will store all the Association’s maintenance equipment and vehicles, which are currently being stored outside in the weather and elements. The new structure will also contain restrooms, a small office, and an employee lunchroom. The plan is to enhance the site with a metal building, paving, parking, landscaping, and storage. Page 15 of 57 Page 16 of 57 Page 17 of 57 Page 18 of 57 Page 19 of 57 Page 20 of 57 Page 21 of 57 Page 22 of 57 Page 23 of 57 Page 24 of 57 Page 25 of 57 Page 26 of 57 Page 27 of 57 Page 28 of 57 Page 29 of 57 Page 30 of 57 Page 31 of 57 Page 32 of 57 Page 33 of 57 Page 34 of 57 Page 35 of 57 Page 36 of 57 Page 37 of 57 Page 38 of 57 Page 39 of 57 Page 40 of 57 Page 41 of 57 Page 42 of 57 Ó Page 43 of 57 Ó Page 44 of 57 Ó Page 45 of 57 Ó Page 46 of 57 Ó Page 47 of 57 Page 48 of 57 Page 49 of 57 Page 50 of 57 Page 51 of 57 Page 52 of 57 Page 53 of 57 Page 54 of 57 Page 55 of 57 Page 56 of 57 Page 57 of 57

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.