William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor IRAC - Special Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · General · meeting of Apr 22, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/22/2024 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY GATEWAY
CORRIDOR INDEPENDENT REVIEW
ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING
Monday, April 22, 2024, 1:00 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 1:00 PM. Those present were: Mayor Alan
Perry, Chairman; Diederik Advocaat; Edward C. Warren, Jr.; Charles P. Walczak, PE; and
Willie Young. Absent was: Herbert Ford, Alternate.
2. Approval of the Minutes
a. Meeting Minutes of April 10, 2024 will be approved at the next regular meeting.
Mr. Advocaat stated he had appeared remotely at the April 10, 2024, meeting; however,
he had technical issues with his microphone and was unable to pose questions or
comments. Therefore, he would like his points to be recorded. Point 1: At the last
meeting, there was no discussion or opinion made concerning the bridges - one span vs.
two spans. If you have a 1 span, 11 lane bridge, is that technically feasible or make
sense? Point 2: The on-grade bypass option needs to be given serious consideration. It
is less obtrusive environmentally, has less impact on Stoney, can be a quick connection
to the Cross Island Parkway, has the lowest cost option, and cuts the commute time.
Point 3: The grading matrix produced in my opinion is really comparing apples and
oranges, and you cannot add numbers and come to a conclusion. Point 4: The bike lane
- a cost/benefit analysis should be done, its usage, and whether funds for a bike lane can
be better allocated elsewhere. Point 5: The adaptive management system - you are still
working in clusters at the end of 278, there has to be a way these 2 can be connected
during peak hours to create a better flow, and disabling the Windmill Harbour light during
peak hours should be explored. Point 6: I question whether the bow tie alternative would
actually work, and should be tested in your simulation models. Point 7: What is the cost
picture for the elevated bypass, does it makes sense at all, and has it been discussed
with SCDOT as a potential solution, and what is their opinion? Point 8: The $425M which
has been mentioned as a number, which is a 50% increase. Where does that come from
and how is that put together. All these points I would like Lochmueller to consider, take
them into account, and where applicable, add onto the simulation models.
3. Unfinished Business
Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager - Community Development, thanked everyone for
their appearance on such a short notice. He explained that at the last meeting Lochmueller
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/22/2024 Page | 2
had presented 4 viable Alternatives to advance for additional evaluation. A comparative
assessment was presented for each of those Alternatives, and the Committee asked for
additional information related to cost, and property impact to both public and private lands.
Lochmueller has developed that additional information, along with a third element relating to
the construction period, based on their professional opinion of the project. He turned the
presentation over to Nate Nohren and his Lochmueller team, with Brad Strader and Brian
Kinzelman available remotely.
Mr. Colin clarified for the Committee that with regard to Mr. Advocaat's points, the matter of
additional funding for this project is not within the scope of work for Lochmueller.
a. Additional Details on Property Impacts, Cost, and Construction Period for
Alternatives.
Nate Nohren, Project Manager for Lochmueller, introduced his team joining the meeting
remotely: Kate Swinford and Michelle Romaine, Traffic Engineering Leads; Chad Costa,
Chief Environental Engineer; Lorne Jackson, Chief Roadway Engineer. He noted this
meeting is designed to present the additional information requested at the April 10
meeting, which included delineating between public and private parcels, providing high
order of magnitude cost estimates as well as estimates for the construction duration, and
a matrix incorporating everything provided.
Mr. Nohren presented slides of the Alternatives, which slides are a part of the
presentation contained in the agenda packet. He briefly outlined on the slides Alternative
#1, Alternative #2, Alternative #3, and Alternative #4. He pointed out the travel time
comparison when compared to 2045 No Build for each Alternative completed in Synchro
for the Hilton Parkway corridor between Moss Creek and Indigo Run. Questions from the
Committee members were answered by Mr. Nohren, Mr. Jackson, and Mr. Colin.
Discussion ensued about whether SCDOT or Beaufort County has reviewed the
Lochmueller plans. Mr. Colin reminded the Committee that a part of the scope for
Lochmueller was a provision to refrain from any communication with the County or
SCDOT during the engineering evaluations and assessments until the Committee
identifies Alternatives to be advanced, at which point any design modifications would then
be shared with both the County and SCDOT for consideration. He also raised the issue of
where additional funding would come from above the original project cost for the deficient
bridge and funding sources from the State Infrastructure Bank, grant, and referendum,
leaving a current deficit of $100M+. While there have been communications, he noted
none were specifically about SCDOT vetting all of the engineering solutions. Mr. Colin
indicated he would like to have the benefit of this meeting's results and the Committee's
position so that he can schedule further conversations this week.
Mr. Nohren concluded his presentation with slides detailing the additional right of way
required for each Alternative, with estimated cost ranging from $426M to $575M, and
estimated construction duration ranging from 36 to 48 months, with the resulting scoring
and ranking. A lengthy discussion followed concerning the scoring system and matrix,
how impact was determined for additional right of way acreage needed, difficulties and
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/22/2024 Page | 3
delays that could result, whether a sufficient right of way exists in Stoney to
accommodate a larger paved roadway, and the review being made Lochmueller's
structural engineers of the seismic study,with the initial analysis indicating no feasible way
to retrofit an existing bridge to meet SEE requirements.
Mr. Colin stated that after the last meeting when Lochmueller presented its evaluation
and comparative assessment of the alternatives, the goal was to identify an Alternative
that would be the preferred Alternative to put through the VISSIM model so they could
then perform the deeper analysis and evaluation, and they could move beyond the
current study area, as well, to look at the full end-to-end that was requested down to Sea
Pines Circle and to Wilborn and Indigo Run. Therefore, with the additional information
presented today as requested plus construction duration, they would like the Committee
to weigh in on the Alternative or Alternatives to continue to move forward and advance.
He asked for the Committee's feedback at this time. Each Committee member stated their
current choices and reasoning involved, but no clear consensus was reached.
Discussion continued among the Committee members and Mr. Nohren concerning
keeping a 4-lane bridge, and Mr. Nohren indicated the analyses done by them and other
studies reviewed, indicate this is not practical. Mayor Perry noted there are questions
concerning whether the State Infrastructure Bank, the State House, or other source would
grant the additional funding for the Alternative chosen, and conversations with these
entities needed to be held soon. Mr. Colin agreed that with a potential shortfall in the
current funding, and the failure of the Committee to narrow down the Alternatives for
Lochmueller to proceed into the VISSIM model, it would be appropriate to share the
Alternatives presented by Lochmueller with Beaufort County officials and SCDOT to
determine feasibility and funding availability. The Committee members indicated their
support for that plan, with Mr. Colin to schedule meetings and report back soon.
4. Appearance by Citizens
No citizens have requested to appear before the Committee regarding items not on the
agenda. No comments were received through the Open Town Hall Portal.
A citizen remarked that the traffic lights are not synchronized nor optimized at Spanish
Wells and Squire Pope Road intersections. He also mentioned that cost/value for benefit
gained in minutes should be a consideration.
Christopher Cliffe noted he had attended 32 committee meetings since November 2018
chaired by David Johnson, 12 or more joint broadcasts of Beaufort County and the Town,
numerous Town Council meetings, and at no time during those meetings until recently has
cost come up as a determining factor. He questioned how the construction duration was
computed, where the idea of pedestrian and bike paths originated, whether construction
costs were based on 2022 numbers, and whether there were certain aspects of the bridge
that would be the Town's responsibility.
An Indigo Run resident stressed the need for a fair, transparent, and independent analysis
Town of Hilton Head Island William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory
Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/22/2024 Page | 4
free from political manipulation, but he questioned whether that is the case. He stated too
much attention is being placed on an oversize bridge and not enough on traffic lights, which
are the real cause of our congestion problems. Better and cheaper options, with less
community impact on the Gullah community, have been suggested and ignored. The
Town's decision will be one of the most consequential decision in years and will impact our
Town for decades.
Louise Miller Cohen, a native of Hilton Head Island, stated God had given her a job to keep
the Gullah Geechee culture alive on Hilton Head Island. All that is remaining is the land left
by their ancestors and passed down to the current generation. She expressed her gratitude
to everyone who feels their pain, and asked the members to put themselves in their shoes
and help them keep their land, their culture, and their community.
5. New Business
None.
6. Adjournment
The meeting was declared adjourned at 2:42 PM.
Approved:
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
June 12, 2024
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.