Community Services and Public Safety Committee — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Community Development and Public Services Committee · meeting of Apr 8, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island
Community Services & Public Safety Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/08/2024
Page 1 of 4
Town of Hilton Head Island
COMMUNITY SERVICES & PUBLIC SAFETY
REGULAR MEETING
Monday, April 8, 2024 – 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m.
Committee Members Present: Chair Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy
Brison, Ward 2, Steve Alfred, Ward 5
Adoption of the Agenda
Ms. Brison moved to remove Item 6.b from the agenda and place it on the upcoming
May meeting agenda. She explained she did not feel the resolution, as written, along with
supporting documentation were ready to move forward. Mr. Brown seconded. After
discussion Mr. Brown withdrew his second. Ms. Brison stated she was not
withdrawing her motion. Chair Becker asked for a second to Ms. Brison’s original
motion. Motion failed for lack of a second.
Mr. Alfred moved to approve the agenda as presented. Mr. Brown seconded. Motion
carried 3-1 (Brison opposed).
Approval of the Minutes
Special Meeting Minutes of March 19, 2024
Mr. Alfred moved to approve the special meeting minutes of March 19, 2024, as
presented. Mr. Brown seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Appearance by Citizens
Citizens who signed up to speak during this time expressed the need to wait until the agenda
item they desired to speak on was discussed by the Committee.
New Business
Consideration of a Resolution Adopting a Beach Parking Fee Schedule – Josh Gruber,
Deputy Town Manager
Josh Gruber conducted a presentation. The Community Services and Public Safety
Committee has been discussing the establishment of paid parking for many of the Town’s
publicly accessible beach parks. At the time, staff has recommended that the Committee
review the various policy questions that will need to be addressed within a resolution setting
forth a rate schedule and other related matters that will need to be implemented as part of
its Beach Parking Master Plan.
Town of Hilton Head Island
Community Services & Public Safety Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/08/2024
Page 2 of 4
Mr. Gruber provided a recap of the December 18th Community Services and Public Safety
meeting, the Committee reviewed several policy questions and provided feedback to staff.
Additional information was requested to continue these discussions and develop additional
policy recommendations. This additional information included defining the overall purpose
for the program, recommending a maximum daily rate, evaluating both current and future
budget implications to refine potential parking rates, address Coligny Beach area employee
parking concerns, and evaluate resident beach parking passes.
During the discussion, Mr. Gruber stated that to commence PCI Municipal Services’ (PCI)
management of the Town’s Beach Parking Program, Town Council approved a Fiscal Year
2024 Budget amendment that included an operational budget of $366,965 and a Capital
budget of $502,765, for a combined expenditure of $869,730. A copy of this Ordinance was
enclosed as Attachment 1. For the upcoming Fiscal Year 2025 budget, PCI has submitted
a proposed operating budget of $598,789 and a recurring Capital budget of $25,000, for a
total combined expenditure of $623,789. A copy of that information was enclosed as
Attachment 2. In addition to these expenses, staff is recommending that the current $15.00
fee for Island Resident Beach Parking Passes be made free of charge and the revenue that
had previously been generated from this fee be replaced with revenues generated
exclusively from beach parking fees. This change will add an additional $115,000 in yearly
expenses to the Beach Parking Management Program. Items of interest during this
discussion were staffing levels, which include three full-time, five part-time and three
seasonal. Other comments regarding coverage were discussed and the future plan is for
the Town Facilities. Mr. Gruber stated that Islanders Beach Park is expected to have full-
time manned facilities and the other parks will be more of a patrolled model. Questions were
also raised regarding license plate recognition systems, and a representative from PCI was
present to explain the status and all locations except for Alder Lane are in place and will be
functional with power soon. Lastly, there was discussion of where funding would be sourced
from. Mr. Gruber stated that at the time a parking fee was to be utilized from a proposed
parking fee however, going forward if a parking fee is not adopted the revenue generated
would be sufficient to sustain this program. If revenue is not achieved, then the Town would
need to seek alternative ways as services are outweighing revenues currently. Additionally,
there were questions regarding the definition of a resident, which was clearly defined by Mr.
Gruber.
To financially support these combined expenses, the Town would need to consider adoption
and implementation of an updated parking fee rate structure that will generate a sufficient
amount of revenue to cover these costs. Staff is therefore recommending two separate
options be considered. The first option would charge $5.00 per hour at all identified beach
parking areas that contain publicly available parking spaces except for Chaplin Community
Park during the youth recreational sports season, and Coligny Beach Park year-round. The
second option would be to charge $5.00 per hour at all identified beach parking areas that
contain publicly available parking spaces except for Chaplin Community Park during the
youth recreational sports season, but inclusive of Coligny Beach Park year-round. If this
option is preferred, staff would make an additional recommendation that concerns regarding
the availability of employee parking within the Coligny Beach area be addressed through
the dedication of employee-only restricted parking at the site of the former Wild Wing Café.
Discussion regarding concerns of employers providing their employees with parking for
Town of Hilton Head Island
Community Services & Public Safety Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/08/2024
Page 3 of 4
those working in the Coligny Beach area if parking fees were implemented was discussed
in length. At the time some members of the Committee were in favor and others were not.
Solutions of merchant validation was discussed as a suggested incentive. Other thoughts
were to implement a survey to collect efficient data to provide information to alleviate any
unintended issues that could arise.
The draft Beach Parking Management Ordinance has previously been considered by the
Committee and was forwarded to the Town Council with a recommendation that it be
adopted. However, to make sure that all issues associated with this program have been
addressed at the time of the Ordinance’s adoption, the Resolution setting forth the proposed
beach parking rates and addressing other ancillary issues should be recommended for
adoption as well. This would allow for concurrent adoption of both the Ordinance setting for
the framework for the beach parking program and the Resolution setting forth the necessary
rate structure to fully implement this program. Staff is therefore requesting that the
Community Services and Public Safety Committee consider each of the proposed policy
considerations that are identified in this Memorandum.
Chair Becker asked for public comment.
Lee Lucier addressed the Committee stating paid beach parking has been discussed for
many years and all the parties involved still cannot decide on what the real goal is that needs
to be addressed.
Jack Daly addressed the Committee regarding his involvement in the Circle-to-Circle
initiative set forth by the Town previously and that he feels that the Coligny area is not ready
for charged parking in that area.
Jay Wendl addressed and shared with the Committee statistics from the Hilton Head Island-
Bluffton Chamber of Commerce regarding visitors to Hilton Head Island and how he feels it
correlates to the proposed parking resolution.
David Martin addressed the Committee as the owner of Piggly Wiggly regarding the need
for an overflow parking lot and getting back to sharing our Island with others.
Melinda Tunner addressed the Committee with her thoughts on what problem the parking
policy is trying to solve and charging for parking in all areas except one could cause
problems down the road.
Rusty Jaquiss addressed the Committee and feels that there is not enough information to
implement the parking plan at this time.
Ashley Phillips addressed the Committee that she feels there are too many cars in the area,
not enough spaces, and the possibility of using trolly’s from Honey Horn to deal with the
traffic in the area.
There was much discussion made by the Committee regarding the agenda item and their
thoughts on the presented resolution. Discussion included maximum daily charges, resident
beach parking passes, employee parking considerations, the fiscal impacts, parking rates
and recreations supports/beach parking considerations. After a lengthy discussion, the
Committee felt that there was a need for additional information from PCI about parking and
data such as financial information regarding the costs of services for PCI to separate the
cost for Islanders and Coligny Beach Parks and additional services possibly at Chaplin Park
Town of Hilton Head Island
Community Services & Public Safety Committee
Meeting Minutes
4/08/2024
Page 4 of 4
and receive a copy of the report that Mr. Wendl referenced from the Chamber of Commerce
and potential future projections that could assist them in recommending a policy.
Mr. Alfred moved to forward the resolution to Town Council for review and
consideration of approval. Mrs. Becker seconded. Motion failed 2-2 (Brison and
Brown opposed).
Consideration of a Resolution Adopting Environmentally Friendly Landscaping and Grounds
Maintenance Practices/Integrated Pest Management Policy – Bryan McIlwee, Director of
Public Projects and Facilities
Bryan McIlwee presented to the Committee a resolution for consideration to recommend
adoption by Town Council to adopt an environmentally friendly landscaping and grounds
maintenance practices/Integrated Pest Management Policy.
Due to the late hour, Ms. Brison made a motion to continue the agenda item to the next
meeting on May 20, 2024. The motion failed by lack of a second.
Chair Becker asked for public comment.
Pamela Martin Ovens addressed the Committee about her thoughts on the use of pesticides
and not using chemicals that are poisonous to humans and wildlife. She wants the new IPM
to reflect the wishes of the people who live on Hilton Head Island.
Kim Konte addressed the Committee about her overall thoughts on the proposed Integrated
Pest Management program and the potential conflict of interest she sees with the third-party
contractor hired.
Trevor Konte addressed the Committee about his views on stopping using Round-Up and
other known pesticides to protect them and Hilton Head Island.
Bryan McIlwee responded to public comments and to questions from the Committee.
The Committee asked questions and made comments regarding the presentation of the
draft Integrated Pest Management Policy. Members of the Committee had concerns about
the types of chemicals that were proposed to be used, providing the public with advance
notice of when the chemicals were used, and the policy revisions that were presented at
today's meeting and hidden comments from one of the Town’s contractors on the draft
policy. After a lengthy discussion of their concerns with staff, they decided that more
information is needed to be able to make an informed decision about the policy.
Mr. Brison moved to continue this matter to the May 20 th Committee meeting for
further discussion to allow Staff to provide the Committee with additional
information. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 3-1 (Becker opposed).
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 1:22 pm.
Approved: August 19, 2024
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov.
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.