Community Services and Public Safety Committee — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Community Development and Public Services Committee · meeting of Mar 18, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/18/2024 Page 1 of 4
Town of Hilton Head Island
COMMUNITY SERVICES & PUBLIC SAFETY
COMMITTEE MEETING
Monday, March 18, 2024, 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Chair Becker called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m.
Committee Members Present: Chair Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Alex Brown, Ward 1; Patsy
Brison, Ward 2, Steve Alfred, Ward 5
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Approval of the Minutes
Regular Meeting Minutes of February 12, 2024
Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Regular Meeting Minutes of February 27, 2024
Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Appearance by Citizens
Pamela Martin Ovens addressed the Committee thanking Bryan McIlwee for eliminating
the use of rodenticide on Town property and stating that hopefully the Solid Waste and
Recycling consultant, A. Goldsmith Resources, LLC (AGR) will be able to answer
Councilmembers questions at today’s meeting.
Carl Braden addressed the Committee regarding his disappointment with a pedestrian
access gate closure between Bradley Circle and Driessen Beach Park that he uses
regularly for walking and bike riding.
Presentation of the Hilton Head Island Fire Rescue Annual Report- Chris Blankenship,
Fire Chief
Chief Blankenship conducted a presentation and summary of the item. Highlights
included a total of 9,560 incidents including 7,032 EMS calls, 2,284 Fire calls, 62 HazMat
calls and 168 Rescues for an average of 26 incidents per day. The top three busiest days
for 2023 were January 7, August 19, and September 9. The busiest day is Saturday, the
busiest month is July and the busiest station is 5 which is located at the front gate of Hilton
Head Plantation.
This past year there were 39 fires within a structure with 74% of them being confined to
the object or the room of origin. The total property that Fire Rescue saved was over $152
Billion with a total combined loss of approximately $2 Million in property. Chief
Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/18/2024 Page 2 of 4
Blankenship touched on the most frequent responses addressed which are elderly and
assisted care facilities in Hilton Head. Most EMS patient calls are for those 65-84 years
old followed by 85+. A major highlight that Chief Blankenship spoke of is that Fire Rescue
has a 50% cardiac arrest save rate whereas the national average is 26% and that has
helped them save 7 individuals under cardiac arrest that survived in 2023. There were
CIP highlights, staffing updates, community outreach & recruitment updates,
accomplishment highlights, and upcoming initiatives that everyone can expect to see.
Members of the Committee had questions, comments, and brief discussion regarding the
presentation by Chief Blankenship. After that discussion, the committee thanked the Chief
and his team for the presentation of the annual fire rescue report and spoke of their
willingness to continue to support them in any way they can.
Unfinished Business
Consideration of a Resolution to Support the Solid Waste and Recycling Analysis for
Hilton Head Island- Bryan McIlwee, Director of Public Projects and Facilities
Mr. McIlwee stated that before the committee was a resolution to support the Solid Waste
and Recycling Analysis for Hilton Head Island.
There is an initiative in the Town of Hilton Head Island 2023-25 Strategic Action Plan to
Identify strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities & Threats (SWOT) of Hilton Head Island
Solid Waste and Recycling (Attachment 2).
Staff procured A. Goldsmith Resources, LLC (AGR), an expert consultant in the field of
solid waste and recycling, and the preparer of the recently updated Beaufort County Solid
Waste Management Plan (2022-2041), to conduct this assessment.
On May 2, 2023, Town Council unanimously approved a Resolution supporting the
proposed approach and scope of services outline to complete the SWOT assessment.
On January 8, 2024, the Community Services and Public Safety Committee was
presented with the findings of the SWOT analysis provided by Abby Goldsmith. The
committee requested an explanation of select current practices and the inclusion of
possible near-term actions as outlined below:
1. Describe multifamily solid waste and recycling collection.
2. Provide examples of solid waste and recycling in a POA.
3. Clarify what is recyclable.
4. Include grant funding as an opportunity.
5. Add possible near-term actions.
Pending Committee recommendation, next steps are as follows:
•Present findings of the Solid Waste and Recycling Strength, Weaknesses
•Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) assessment to full Town council in May.
•Council approval of a Resolution supporting the SWOT assessment.
•Implement Near-Term Actions
Abby Goldsmith, the consultant with AGR, provided the Committee with a review of the
Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats previously presented at the January
8, 2024, Community Services and Public Safety meeting. Strengths identified were
Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/18/2024 Page 3 of 4
demonstrated support from elected officials and the public, and noted existing resources
that the Town currently has. The weaknesses identified were that there is limited control
of recycling and solid waste, no consistent curbside collection, haulers are not always in
compliance with ordinance requirements, ordinance insistences, and no dedicated Town
Staff or funding for solid waste management and recycling to name a few. Opportunities
that Ms. Goldsmith identified were identified as the county paying for residential disposal
at Hickory Hill landfill, the county considering the development of a processing facility for
recyclables south of the broad, existing framework exists for Town-wide collection,
potential diversion from commercial and public facilities, and enhancing solid waste and
recyclable collection on beaches. Treats identified were demographic and geographic,
limited facilities, and recycling challenges.
Ms. Goldsmith also referenced the feedback from the January 8th meeting including an
explanation of select current practices and the inclusion of possible near-term actions to
be implemented. She described multifamily solid waste and recycling collection, provided
examples of solid waste and recycling in a POA, clarified what is recyclable, and included
grant funding as an opportunity. She also spoke with the committee about clarifying the
current ordinance to meet the Town’s needs regarding what can and cannot be accepted
for recycling at this time and other suggestions to aid in a more cohesive outcome for all.
During this time there was a lengthy discussion on how to achieve that goal.
Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager, answered a committee member's question
regarding why the Town has not entered into a contract directly with a facility. During this
lengthy discussion, Mr. Gruber stated that the current facility that recycling is taken to,
Hickory Hill, closes at noon on Saturdays, and if haulers do not pick up and dispose of
the waste before noon, the hauler is responsible for storage over the weekend. Currently,
State Law prohibits any new Class 1 facility from being open within a 75-mile radius of
any existing Class 1 facility. Hickory Hill will be the only disposable facility for the
foreseeable future unless they open a new facility.
Mr. McIlwee presented to the committee five-year term actions that are feasible to aid
once this resolution is approved by Town Council. Actions included coordinating with
Beaufort County to share approved SWOT and determine the County’s short, mid and
long term plans for solid waste and recycling; evaluate potential approaches and
associated costs to provide curbside solid waste and recycling for all of HHI residents;
establish a best in class recycling program at beach park facilities, incorporating outreach
and education for residents and visitors; establish a best in class recycling at HHI facilities,
incorporating outreach and education for residents and visitors; and lastly continue to
strengthen enforcement of reporting and recycling requirements for licensed haulers in
Town ordinance.
Members of the Committee had questions, comments, and discussions regarding the
agenda topic. During this time there was a question of how the disposal fee that is set by
the County and paid by Town residents could be eliminated and it was stated that the
Town has an option to contract with a private recycling facility and require licensed haulers
to use that facility. The other option would be contracting with a recycling facility in a
nearby state. Town Attorney, Curtis Coltrane stated that it is allowed, however, the cost
of getting materials from one location on Hilton Head to an alternative site could be costly.
Town of Hilton Head Island Community Services and Public Safety
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/18/2024 Page 4 of 4
Mr. Alfred moved to forward the proposed resolution to Town Council for review
and consideration of approval. Mr. Brown seconded. Motion carried 3-1 (Brison
opposed).
New Business
Consideration of an Ordinance Amending Title 9, Chapter 2, of the Municipal Code of Hilton
Head Island Titled Regulations and Requirements Relating to Smoking of Tobacco Products
by Adding a Definition for Electronic Smoking Devices and Prohibiting Their Use Consistent
with Exiting Smoking Regulations – Josh Gruber, Deputy Town Manager
Josh Gruber presented information and an ordinance to amend smoking regulations and
requirements allowing the Town to become more current with the prohibited use definition
of electronic smoking devices.
In 2009, the Town of Hilton Head Island adopted regulations to its municipal code that
prohibited smoking tobacco and tobacco related products indoors within publicly
accessible commercial businesses or other publicly accessible buildings. In the years
since the adoption of these regulations, new types of consumer products including
electronic smoking devices, commonly referred to as vaping, have been created and are
now widely in use. Because of this, the Town is proposing to update the definition section
of its existing smoking regulations to include electronic smoking devices within the
existing smoking regulations
On July 18, 2023, student representatives from the Lowcountry Alliance for Healthy Youth
made a presentation to the Town Council on the negative effects that electronic smoking
devices and vaping in general has had on teens and young adults. They requested that
the Town consider amending its code to include the use of electronic smoking devices
along with the Town’s existing smoking regulations. Following the receipt of this
information, staff was requested to prepare this proposed amendment for the Community
Services and Public Safety Committee’s review and consideration.
Members of the Committee had minimal comments, and all were supportive of amending
the ordinance for this matter.
Chair Becker called for public comment, and there was none.
Ms. Brison moved to forward the proposed ordinance to Town Council for review
and consideration of approval. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 11:37 a.m.
Approved: May 20, 2024
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.