RecordWell Data

Public Planning Committee — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Public Planning Committee · meeting of Mar 14, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Thursday, March 14, 2024, 10:00 AM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Adoption of the Agenda 3. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of February 8, 2024 4. Appearance by Citizens: Citizens who wish to speak on the matters being discussed during the meeting may do so by submitting the Request to Speak form no later than the day prior to the meeting. 5. Unfinished Business a. Consideration of a Resolution Supporting the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment - Missy Luick, Director of Planning 6. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Page 1 of 174 Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page1 of 7 Town of Hilton Head Island PUBLIC PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING Thursday, February 8, 2024, 10:00 AM Minutes Call to Order Chair Ames called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m. Committee Members Present: David Ames, Chair, Ward 3; Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Patsy Brison, Ward 5, Glenn Stanford (Via Zoom), Ward 6 Adoption of the Agenda Ms. Becker moved to amend the agenda by moving item 5.b under New Business to Executive Session. Mr. Stanford seconded. Ms. Brison stated she would be voting against the motion because she has reviewed the materials and is ready to proceed. Motion carried 3-1 (Brison opposed). Approval of the Minutes Regular Meeting Minutes of January 11, 2024 Ms. Brison moved to approve. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 4-0. Appearance by Citizens Jay Sudowski addressed the Committee regarding the timing of the proposed changes in the Short-Term rental maximum occupancy regulations. He noted he submitted a FOIA request regarding issues and questioned the need for such changes. Patricia Courtney addressed the Committee stating that amendments regarding parking and/or occupancy are tying to fix a problem that has not been identified. Elizabeth Petro addressed the Committee and thanked them for removing the item regarding the proposed amendments to the Short Term Rental regulations from New Business. Lee Stevens addressed the Committee for taking on the issue of parking and.or occupancy in regards to short-term rentals and asked that all loopholes be considered. New Business Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend the Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan to Incorporate a Housing Impact Analysis - Missy Luick, Director of Planning Page 3 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page2 of 7 Ms. Luick conducted a presentation and provided background in regard to Act 57. The Town of Hilton Head Island was instrumental in the passage of Act 57 of the 2023 South Carolina General Assembly Legislative Session. This Act allows local governments to utilize a portion of its state or local accommodations taxes, or both, to be utilized in the development of qualified workforce housing as a tourism related expenditure. A key component of Act 57 necessary for the Town to utilize up to 15% of Accommodations Tax revenue for workforce housing is the requirement to complete a Housing Impact Analysis which must be adopted by ordinance as an amendment to the Town’s Comprehensive Plan Housing Element. As part of this process the planning commission must solicit input for this analysis from homebuilders, developers, contractors, and housing finance experts when developing this element. The Town worked with Together Consulting, our housing consultant, to draft the Town’s Housing Impact Analysis. In addition to researching and compiling the data required for the Housing Impact Analysis from local, state, and national sources, our housing consultant also received information and data from the Hilton Head Area Realtors, Hilton Head Island Homebuilders Association, and local builders and developers. Housing Impact Analysis (HIA) required by Act 57: If local governments opt to use ATAX for workforce housing needs, they will be required to prepare a Housing Impact Analysis (as outlined in Section 6-4-12 in the Act) prior to the second reading of the ordinance allowing such usage. This Analysis will help to define the actual needs in their communities and how these funds will help solve the local workforce housing needs. This Housing Impact Analysis serves as a foundational tool to inform decision-making and policy formulation. By dissecting these components, we gain a holistic understanding of our community's housing landscape and can implement targeted solutions to meet the diverse needs of our residents. Act 57 Key Points: •For the purposes of the Act, workforce housing means “residential housing for rent or sale that is appropriately priced for rent or sale to a person or family whose income falls within thirty percent (30%) and one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the median income for the local area, with adjustments for household size, according to the latest figures available from the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).” •Expenditures of both state and local ATAX are capped at fifteen percent (15%) of the local government’s annual collections. •The provisions of this Act are no longer effective after December 31, 2030. •A Housing Impact Analysis must be completed and adopted prior to second reading of an Ordinance to Town Council for approval. Page 4 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page3 of 7 •Town must update (amend) its Comprehensive Plan to include/adopt the Housing Impact Analysis as a part of its housing element. The Housing Impact Analysis required by Act 57 must include: •Cost of developing, construction, rehabilitating, improving, maintaining, or owning single-family or multifamily dwellings. •An analysis of the relative impact of the ordinance on low- and moderate- income households. •The following housing cost information is required as part of the Housing Impact Analysis: •Reasonable estimates of the effect of housing costs, either in a brief summary or worksheet demonstrated by computations in dollar amounts. •If the local government determines that it is not possible to make an estimate expressed in dollar amounts, then the analysis must include a statement setting forth the reasons for the local government's determination. •The analysis must include descriptions of both the immediate effect and the long-term effect of the ordinance on housing costs. The local government shall provide copies of the Housing Impact Analysis to: •The Department of Revenue, •The Tourism Expenditure Revenue Committee, and •As an ordinance to the members of the legislative body of the local government. The Department of Revenue may not disburse any ATAX revenue for workforce housing unless and until the local government has provided the housing impact analysis to the parties listed. Procedural steps that must be taken: 1. Complete a Housing Impact Analysis. 2. Distribute the Housing Impact Analysis to the required entities. 3. Update/Ratify the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. a) Share the Housing Impact Analysis with the Planning Commission. (Solicit input from homebuilders, developers, contractors, and housing finance experts.) b) Adopt an Ordinance incorporating the Housing Impact Analysis into the Comprehensive Plan. The Housing Impact Analysis has five areas of focus outlined below: 1. Employment Analysis: The Employment Analysis assesses the current job market, growth projections, and employment trends within Hilton Head Island. This chapter also highlights how area employees are housing cost burdened. Households are considered cost-burdened if they spend over 30% of their household income on housing. Households are considered extremely cost-burdened if they spend over 50% of their household income on housing. In May 2022, a US Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment and Page 5 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page4 of 7 Wages study indicated the following averages for Hilton Head Island employment sectors. Workers in the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort, SC Metropolitan Statistical Area had an average (mean) hourly wage of $22.21 in May 2022, 25 percent below the nationwide average of $29.76. In this chapter we pulled wages from the Bureau of Labor Statistics for the top employment sectors for Hilton Head. •Based on these wages and 30% rule of thumb, rents would need to be below $964.50 to be considered affordable. •The current median rent is $1,330. 2. Housing Market Analysis: The Housing Market Analysis Chapter highlights the current cost of housing on the Island looking at both single family and condo/villa prices. In addition to national real estate data, the Hilton Head Area Realtors and Hilton Head Island Area Homebuilders Association helped to provide data sources for this section. The Hilton Head Area Realtors 2022 Year-end Market Trend Analysis indicated a significant increase in median sales costs on the Island in both single family attached and detached showing between 15-20% increases depending on what type of housing. With these accelerated increases in pricing, housing affordability has taken a direct hit. Recent data from May 2023 indicated historical housing affordability continuing to decline significantly on the Island. The chart below shows a continual trend as housing becomes less affordable based on average incomes on the Island. The lower the number the less affordable the community. 3. Housing Market Conditions: The Housing Market Conditions Chapter highlights various factors related to increased housing costs. •This chapter also focused on the Town’s housing costs versus other rapidly growing South Carolina markets. Several of these communities compete for the same employment sectors and employees. Hilton Head was by far the most expensive housing market. •This chapter goes into detail on the rapid growth in housing prices over the last few years on the Island. •The chart on the left shows overall housing types (condos, townhomes and single-family ownership) with a trend of almost doubling the median sale price from 2020 to 2023. If we just look at single family homes, the median home price is over $1M. 4. Construction & Development Costs: The Construction/Development Chapter highlights specific development costs impacting housing affordability. Construction costs have significantly increased the cost of housing over the past few years along with other development Page 6 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page5 of 7 factors including but not limited to the availability of developable land, insurance costs and mortgage rate increases. The following development costs were analyzed: Land Costs: •Over 70% of the land is in a planned unit development (PUD), minimizing the availability of land for developments, not to mention affordable land. For example, a recent search on Land Watch for vacant lots for sale on the Island showed one .11 acre lot Mid-Island for $359,000. •Developers indicated land cost can be as much $25,000/door for an apartment development on Hilton Head Island where available, developable land is scarce. Construction Costs: •The average price per square foot was $541. Rate.com research indicated a $261/sq. ft. increase from $279/sq. ft. to $540/sq. ft. from August 2021 to August 2023. •This means for a 1,000 square foot house, construction pricing grew from $279,000 to $540,000, not accounting for land, fees, insurance, and taxes. Development Fees: •On Hilton Head, assuming a $20M development with approximately 50 dwelling units, 2,500 sq. ft/unit on 2 acres, the Town’s fees could be as much as $360,927 and does not include planning fees estimated at $7,218.55 per unit in development fees. •Other fees such as permit fees for the Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County impact fees (water and sewer etc.) can cost over $3,000/unit. Insurance Costs: •A June 2023 article in the Island Packet indicated some insurance costs have increased by 500% from 2022. Several insurance policies for Island properties have doubled or tripled in the past two years. Mortgage Rates: •Increased mortgage rates continue to limit affordable home buying opportunities for families. Since August 2023, interest rates have risen to as high as 8% depending on the loan type, the amount of down payment provided and varying credit score between 580-800. 5. Solving the Housing Crisis: The Solving the Housing Crisis Chapter highlights past, current, and future strategies the Town has implemented or will consider to address the growing demand for affordable workforce housing. •The adoption of the Finding Home, Workforce Housing Framework in 2022 was a key step in addressing not only the need to preserve and produce more workforce housing but also outlined priority strategies and Page 7 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page6 of 7 action items for the town and council to help move the needle on meeting the community’s housing needs. •With the Adoption of the Housing Impact Analysis, the Town will have the authority to utilize up to 15% of its state and local Accommodation Tax (ATAX) to support critical action steps and strategies that will increase the production and preservation of workforce housing on the Island. Public Review Timeline: Housing Impact Analysis – Comprehensive Plan •December 17, 2023: Legal ad posting •January 17, 2024: Planning Commission Public Hearing •February 8, 2024: Public Planning Committee •February 20, 2024: Town Council Brief •March 5, 2024: Town Council 1st Reading •March 19, 2024: Town Council 2nd Reading Members of the Committee had questions, comments and discussion regarding: it was noted that the Town of Hilton Head Island is a leader on this subject and other communities will look at how the Town handled the issue moving forward; and the need to implement as many tools as possible to complete the project. Ms. Brison moved to move the item forward to Town Council for consideration of approval. Mr. Stanford seconded. Chair Ames asked for public comment. There was none. Ms. Becker explained her reason for opposition to the proposed ordinance was that she does not believe government should play a role in development of a housing component. Chair Ames called for a vote on the motion. Motion carried 3-1 (Becker opposed). Executive Session Consideration of an Ordinance to amend Title 10, Chapter 2 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island to amend Parking and/or Occupancy Regulations for Short-Term Rentals and Short-Term Rental Properties - Missy Luick, Director of Planning At 10:40 a.m. Ms. Brison moved to go into Executive Session for the reasons stated above. Ms. Becker seconded. Action from Executive Session At 11:40 a.m. Council returned to the dais and Chair Ames moved to end the Executive Session and return to the regular meeting. Mr. Stanford seconded. Motion carried 4-0 Chair Ames stated there was no action to take as a result of Executive Session. Adjournment Page 8 of 174 Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning Committee Meeting Minutes 2/8/2024 Page7 of 7 The meeting was adjourned at 11:41 a.m. Approved: The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov Page 9 of 174 Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex One Town Center Court  Hilton Head Island  South Carolina  29928 www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND Public Planning Committee TO: Public Planning Committee FROM: Katie Kabala, Customer Service Manager VIA: Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager- Community Development VIA: Missy Luick, Director of Planning VIA: Brian Eber, Development Services Program Manager CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager DATE: March 14, 2024 SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution Supporting the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment. RECOMMENDATION: Consideration of a Resolution Supporting the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment. BACKGROUND: The Hilton Head Island Town Council held a two-day strategic plan workshop on January 24-25, 2023, to discuss and identify priorities for inclusion in the 2023-2025 Strategic Action Plan. This workshop led to the establishment of a Growth Management Strategy, including a Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment, within the top 15 priority projects. SUMMARY: Our Plan, the Town’s Comprehensive Plan, identified 7 core values for the Town of Hilton Head Island including: •Relentless Pursuit of Excellence •Redefining Environmental Sustainability •Revitalizing and Modernizing the Economy •Fostering an Inclusive Multi-dimensional Community •Building a Connected and Collaborative Community Fabric •Expanding to Embrace an Integrated Regional Focus, and •Creating “Right-Sized” Infrastructure To best serve the community in the pursuit of these ideals, the Town must be aware of the current conditions as well as future projections of each of these segments. The Conditions and Trends Assessment was initiated by the Strategic Action Plan and managed through the Community Development Department and their consultants MKSK Page 10 of 174 Page 2 of 4 and Kimley-Horn. The assessment acts as a user manual for the Town and organizes a baseline of critical data to identify major trends and communicate the information through a consolidated assessment. The analysis will help leadership better understand the emerging trends to prepare policy that is timely, and data driven. The Conditions and Trends Assessment is a statistical assessment that provides a community snapshot in ten topic areas including: •Demographics •Workforce •Economics •Real Estate •Natural and Cultural Environment •Housing •Governance •Community Engagement •Systems •Land Use These ten topic areas are in line with our core values detailed in Our Plan which include: •Cultural Resources •Natural Resources •Population •Housing •Community Facilities •Economic Development •Land Use •Transportation •Priority Investment Assessment in Action The Assessment provides community benchmark information and statistics from which to evaluate and assess the overall health of the community. The assessment will be used as a building block for Town leadership to make data-driven decisions related to future community plans, community development strategies, public policies, and strategic actions. The purpose of the Conditions and Trends Assessment is to present an objective view of the Town’s most significant data points and trends in 2023. The use of this information – for planning, prioritizing, budgeting, etc. – should be considered through subsequent, future-focused conversations. As a living document, the Conditions and Trends Assessment will be updated regularly to reflect the ongoing evolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island. Page 11 of 174 Page 3 of 4 The report and dataset are designed to enhance the community’s shared understanding of current and emergent issues. This work will help inform the findings and recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan, Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. This assessment will be used by the Town in several ways including: •Provide a common starting point oAdd context to community conversations with respect local and regional trends oConnect key information; share source data and resources oRemove the mystery on community needs, gaps, or opportunities •Inform future plans and studies oProvide base set of findings to help initially focus and direct work oAccelerate the data assembly process with ready-made resources, tables, maps, and other resources oUncover pressing or emergent issues, opportunities, and/or needs oSynchronize data across multiple planning efforts, departments, and community partners •Sort priorities oEstablish an urgency of need based “root cause” issues oSequence projects and policy based on connections oIdentify “points of leverage” for issues outside the Town’s purview oJustify expenditures in terms of capital and time •Measure progress oTake a moment-in-time “snapshot” of the Island across multiple trends oMeasure progress or movement against this benchmark oEvaluate policy effectiveness oQuantify short and long-term impacts of major projects Insight Becomes Strategic Conversation The document includes a robust Future Strategies chapter that includes possible implementation actions in response to the trends outlined within the assessment. The potential steps are broken down by topic area and include a note on related topic trends as well as a suggested time frame for discussion. Again, the use of this information, for planning, prioritizing, budgeting, should be considered through subsequent policy and program strategic conversations. Next Steps Once approved, the Conditions and Trends Assessment will be included on the Town of Hilton Head website on the Master Plan landing page as a resource document. The Conditions and Trends Assessment gathered a wealth of information that both supported what is already seen in the community such as demographic changes and other areas gave some insight into potential threats to the island including environmental issues. The information brings attention to the complexity and interconnectivity of the decisions that Page 12 of 174 Page 4 of 4 Town Council and Town staff are responsible for making. The factual and trend analysis information provided in the assessment will help support the Town of Hilton Head Island in future policy and decision making. This is the second presentation of the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Proposed Resolution 2. Conditions and Trends Assessment (Version 4.1) 3. Presentation Page 13 of 174 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA RESOLUTION NO. _________________ A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, ADOPTING THE CONDITIONS AND TRENDS ASSESSMENT. WHEREAS, the Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan is required to be adopted in accordance with Section 6-29-520, and 6-29-530 of the Code of Laws of South Carolina; and WHEREAS, Our Plan was adopted on October 20, 2020 as the Town of Hilton Head Island’s 2020 to 2040 Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, Our Plan includes the following core values: Relentless Pursuit of Excellence, Redefining Environmental Sustainability, Revitalizing and Modernizing the Economy, Fostering an Inclusive Multi-dimensional Community, Building a Connected and Collaborative Community Fabric, Expanding to Embrace an Integrated Regional Focus, and Innovative Approach to Create 'Right-sized' Infrastructure; and WHEREAS, Our Plan includes the following elements: Cultural Resources, Natural Resources, Population, Housing, Community Facilities, Economic Development, Land Use, Transportation, Recreation, and Priority Investment and adopted appendices; and WHEREAS, the Town of Hilton Head Island Strategic Plan for 2023-2025, adopted June 6, 2023, identified conducting a Conditions and Trends Assessment as a top strategy for 2023 to provide updated statistics in order to help identify newly emerging trends and assist with the implementation of the Town’s Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, Public Planning Committee reviewed and discussed the proposed Conditions and Trends Assessment on January 11, 2024; and WHEREAS, Public Planning Committee recommended the adoption of the proposed Conditions and Trends Assessment on March 14, 2024; and WHEREAS, the Conditions and Trends Assessment represents a cumulation of input from the public and Town Council that provides a community snapshot through the use of statistics in ten key topic areas to help leadership better understand emerging trends and prepare targeted policy affecting Hilton Head Island. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT, AND HEREBY IT IS, RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AS FOLLOWS: (1) The Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment is hereby adopted. Page 14 of 174 (2) The Town Manager is hereby authorized and empowered to take such actions as may be necessary to develop, implement, and carry into action the strategies and tactics that have been identified within the adopted Conditions and Trends Assessment. MOVED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF _____________, 2024. THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ____________________________ Alan Perry, Mayor ATTEST: ______________________________________ Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: __________________________________ Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Introduced by Council Member: ____________________________ Page 15 of 174 FALL 2023 | DRAFT 4.1DRAFT 4.1 Page 16 of 174 Atlantic Ocean Atlantic Ocean Calibogue SoundCalibogue Sound May RiverMay River B road Creek B road Creek J a r v i s C r e e k J a r v i s C r e e k Skull Creek Skull Creek Port RoyalPort Royal SoundSound Marshland Public Parks Privately Conserved Land Town-Owned Property Roadways 3 Miles MID ISLAND MID ISLAND TRACT PARKTRACT PARK (FUTURE)(FUTURE) CHAPLIN CHAPLIN COMMUNITY PARKCOMMUNITY PARK CROSSINGS CROSSINGS PARKPARK Beach City RdBeach City Rd N LOWCOUNTRY LOWCOUNTRY CELEBRATIONCELEBRATION PARKPARK JARVIS CREEK JARVIS CREEK PARKPARK Sea Pines Forest Preserve Whooping Crane Conservancy Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge Marshland RdMarshland Rd Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy Gumtree RdGumtree Rd Squire Pope RdSquire Pope Rd Pope AvePope Ave ISLANDERS ISLANDERS BEACH PARKBEACH PARK FOLLY FIELDFOLLY FIELD BEACH PARKBEACH PARK DRIESSENDRIESSEN BEACH PARKBEACH PARK HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD ISLANDISLAND AIRPORTAIRPORT Main StMain St HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD HOSPITALHOSPITAL HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD SCHOOLSSCHOOLS COLIGNYCOLIGNY BEACH PARKBEACH PARK PINE ISLAND PINE ISLAND BEACHBEACH FISH HAUL FISH HAUL BEACH PARKBEACH PARK MITCHELVILLEMITCHELVILLE BEACH PARKBEACH PARK US 278US 278 Bluffton PkwyBluffton Pkwy Audubon Preserve Greenwood DrGreenwood Dr Lighthouse RdLighthouse Rd William Hilton Pkwy / US 278William Hilton Pkwy / US 278 S Forest Beach DrS Forest Beach Dr TOWN TOWN HALLHALL PINCKNEY ISLAND BULL ISLAND 2 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 3 Page 17 of 174 Atlantic Ocean Atlantic Ocean Port RoyalPort Royal SoundSound Marshland Public Parks Privately Conserved Land Town-Owned Property Roadways CONTENTS INTRODUCTION & EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................4 TOPIC AREA FINDINGS .................................................14 A. DEMOGRAPHICS .................................................. 14 B. WORKFORCE ........................................................22 C. ECONOMICS ..........................................................30 D. REAL ESTATE .......................................................38 E. NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT ..........46 F. HOUSING ...............................................................56 G. GOVERNANCE ...................................................... 64 H. COMMUNITY ......................................................... 72 I. SYSTEMS ................................................................82 J. LAND USE ............................................................. 92 STRATEGIES ..................................................................110 SOURCES AND RESOURCES ......................................134 2 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 3 Page 18 of 174 Acknowledgments This report was compiled through the collaborative work of dozens of community organizations, the Town of Hilton Head Island Staff, and elected officials. Thank you to all those parties who dedicated their time and information to this important work. The Planning Team would like to specially thank these individuals: Town Council Alan Perry, Mayor David Ames, Mayor Pro-Tem Alex Brown Patsy Brison Tamara Becker Steve Alfred Glenn Stanford Town of Hilton Head Island Staff Marc Orlando, Town Manager Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager- Community Development Missy Luick, Director of Planning Katie Kabala, Customer Service Manager Nicte Barrientos, Planner-Economic Development Shea Farrar, Principal Planner Zenos Morris, Director of Built Environment Bryan McIlwee, Director of Public Projects & Facilities Matthew Carey, GIS Administrator Kris Kronlein, Senior GIS Analyst 4 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 5 Page 19 of 174 An Important Moment. . . In 2023, the Town of Hilton Head Island staff initiated a process to better understand and document the critical conditions and trends that are – or will – have an impact on the community over the next 20 years. This effort is an informing component for major, forthcoming plans and studies and an objective inventory of available data and research. The 2020s mark the start of a new era for the communities of the Island. This analysis will help leadership better understand these emerging trends and prepare policy that is timely and data-informed. Why now? This is an inflection point. Community leaders have identified this moment as an important time to pause and better understand the implications and connections of various data. Through this analysis, the team has assessed the position of the Town across multiple measures and contextualized the potential impact of present and emerging trends. These are documented in the report through ten topical chapters including: demographics, workforce, economics, real estate, environment, housing, governance, community, systems, and land use. This is the time to pause and better understand the moment. This is an opportunity to consider the future of the community through forthcoming planning efforts while also determining which trends to reinforce and which trends to mitigate. This report will do four things: • Collect and organize a baseline of critical data. Through an investigation of available sources and existing research the planning team has assembled a comprehensive database organized around ten topics. • Identify major trends. The findings from the analysis are curated and presented through the report as critical trends. This work is supplemented by a database containing all information collected through analysis. • Clearly communicate the information. This report focuses on key findings and is presented in a clear, graphically rich format. • Consider “next steps. ” The final section of the report presents future strategies and actions to be considered as an outgrowth of the analysis. The report and data will also be leveraged by forthcoming plans and studies including the Growth Framework and District Plans. The Conditions and Trends Assessment will be used by the Town through future planning processes to establish a data-informed approach to decision making. The research can be repeated on a regular basis to mark progress on key community goals. The process was initiated by the Town Manager and managed through the Community Development department and their consultants MKSK and Kimley Horn. 4 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 5 Page 20 of 174 USER GUIDE The Conditions and Trends Assessment provides a snapshot of the Town of Hilton Head Island from multiple angles. The report and dataset are designed to enhance the community’s shared understanding of current and emergent issues. This work is pre-policy and is intended to level the conversation with respect to planning. HOW WILL THE ASSESSMENT BE USED? The assessment provides the community with benchmark information and statistics from which it can evaluate and assess the overall health of the Town and its systems. The report is a collection and distillation of this comprehensive database of information, research, and primary data sources. The findings and analysis identify major trends and provide a baseline of critical information. This report will be used as a building block for Town leadership to make data- driven decisions through future community plans, development strategies, public policies, and strategic actions. This assessment will be used by the Town in several ways including: Provide a common starting point ... • Add context to community conversations with respect local and regional trends • Connect key information; share source data and resources • Remove the mystery on community needs, gaps, or opportunities Inform future plans and studies ... • Provide base set of findings to help initially focus and direct work • Accelerate the data assembly process with ready-made resources, tables, maps, and other resources • Uncover pressing or emergent issues, opportunities, and/or needs • Synchronize data across multiple planning efforts, departments, and community partners Sort priorities ... • Establish an urgency of need based “root cause” issues • Sequence projects and policy based on connections • Identify “points of leverage” for issues outside the Town’s purview • Justify expenditures in terms of capital and time Measure progress ... • Take a moment-in-time “snapshot” of the Island across multiple trends • Measure progress or movement against this benchmark • Evaluate policy effectiveness • Quantify short and long-term impacts of major projects 6 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 7 INTRODUCTION: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Page 21 of 174 WHO WILL USE THE ASSESSMENT? The purpose of the Conditions and Trends Assessment is to present an objective view of the Town’s most significant conditions and trends in 2023. The use of this information – for planning, prioritizing, budgeting, etc. – should be considered through subsequent, future-focused conversations. The document includes a robust strategies chapter (p. 112) that includes possible implementation steps in response to the trends outlined within the report. There are several intended users for the information including: The general public • Move from notional to knowledge-based community conversations • Build a common understanding of community conditions • Provide a starting point for reviewing Town policy and Town actions • Feed the general curiosity about the position and direction of the Island Town Council • Provide real information compared to perceptions or political influences • View and understand impacted issues or trends from a regional to Island-wide scale • Build a comprehensive understanding interconnecting or causal factors • Assign indicators to track the progress of major policies or projects The Town Manager and Senior Staff • Establish planning and capital priorities that address major community needs or issues • Assist in capital project identification and budgeting • Craft public/private partnering opportunities based on shared opportunities • Prioritize future planning efforts Town Planners and Development Partners • Provide a factual background to specific issues • Develop priming “common knowledge” base for consultants in various areas of concentration • Establish a starting point for Town planning efforts • Inspire and influence action through applications of the findings Updating information and measuring progress The Conditions and Trends Assessment is a broad dataset that complements the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. It will be regularly updated as data is refreshed and new data is made available. Major resources and datasets used to build the report include the US Census, American Communities Survey, Bureau of Labor Statistics, along with dozens of additional resources. This assessment will be updated in concert with the Town’s decennial comprehensive plan. Senior planning staff will oversee these updates in conjunction with the Town’s Comprehensive Planning process. To learn more about the data used to build the Conditions and Trends Assessment, refer to the Sources and Resources chapter on page 134. 6 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 7 Page 22 of 174 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF FINDINGS The Conditions and Trends Assessment presents findings across ten broad topic areas. Each section features the most important data points related to the topic along with the long-term implications for the Town and community. This executive summary is a collection of the most important findings from the assessment. Each point includes a page reference to the related section where more information and sources are provided. » Population growth has stalled, but demographic shifts continue to drive socio-economic change. • After tremendous growth through the 1970s, ‘80s, and ‘90s, Hilton Head Island’s population began to plateau; between 2000 and 2020 it only grew by 11% compared to 55% across the region. • The two fastest growing segments were households over 65, which were up 50% (3,500 units), and persons living alone are up 57% (1,900 units). Households with children decreased 35%, with 1,200 fewer units. • The African American segment has decreased by 400 residents (or 15%) from 2000. The median age for African American residents, 61, is three years older than the overall Island median of 58. SHARE OF RESIDENTS OVER 65 37% This segment increased from 24% in 2000, the only growing age segment Demographics Population, households, change by season /day, citizen age, diversity Read more on p. 14 » Competition for labor pre-dated the COVID-19 Pandemic but was drastically accelerated through these two years of disruption. • Mainland economic growth is exacerbating this challenge as the Island’s workforce is traveling through similarly paying and more proximate job centers on their way to work on the Island. • Hiring challenges on the Island are growing—housing costs are rising, and with more employment opportunities emerging in Beaufort and Jasper Counties, crossing the bridge to Hilton Head Island each day is becoming less desirable to workers. • Other regions in the Lowcountry have more land available to accommodate greater job growth, increasing by 30–40% since 2000, while the Island’s employment has only grown by 7% in the same time frame. Workforce Labor force makeup, participation, commuting, wages Read more on p. 22 LOCAL JOBS FILLED BY NON-LOCALS 63% Nonresidents hold the majority of jobs on the Island, increasing 12% since 2002 8 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 9 INTRODUCTION: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Page 23 of 174 » Regional economic growth has diversified and solidified the Town’s local economy, but this broader growth is stressing regional systems – transportation, infrastructure, labor demands, housing, and others – on which the Town depends. • The Town is unique among peer communities for its year-round population and relatively diverse local economy. Tourism and hospitality, however, drive all major sectors and have set records following the disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. • The local economy has since recovered and job growth over the next ten years is expected to be a continuation of recent trends. In the five years leading up to the pandemic, approximately 550 jobs were added. • According to a 2021 Tourism Impact Report from the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton Chamber of Commerce, visitor expenditures generated a net total local revenue of $23.4 million in the region through the accommodations tax, the hospitality tax, and beach preservation fees. Economics Businesses, employment, tourism, pipeline projects Read more on p. 30 TOTAL VISITORS, 2021 3.1m Visitor levels returned to and exceeded pre-pandemic levels in 2021, up 16.5% from 2019 FUTURE ISLAND JOB GROWTH +5% Jobs growth is expected through 2030, adding 1,000 new jobs OFFICE REAL ESTATE SQUARE FOOTAGE BUILT SINCE 2010 <1% Much of the office space on the Island is aging and new product is not being delivered » Major shifts in retail and office demand have impacted the rent potential for existing, older real estate. • Very little new inventory has been added in the previous two decades. As buildings age, the redevelopment pressures are increasing, but unevenly depending on access, location, ownership, and additional factors. • Between April 2022 and March 2023, there were 153 building permits issued for new structures. Nine were accessory structures, ten were commercial structures and the remaining 134 were single family homes. • Almost 85% of the retail inventory was built prior to 2000, with limited renovations. Real Estate Retail, office, and residential property type and value Read more on p. 38 8 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 9 Page 24 of 174 » Home values are accelerating at their fastest rates ever and pulling even modest residential real estate properties to record highs. • Diminishing affordability means more Island workers are non-local and are liable to join other jobs centers growing around the region. • The average home cost tipped over $724,000 in 2022, outperforming the county average by more than $200,000, as well as every other community in the region. In May of 2023 that cost rose to $768,000. • This intense growth in value followed national trends, but the acceleration in the Lowcountry was much greater. About half of the Island’s nearly 34,000 housing units are defined as “vacant,” meaning without a year-round occupant. YEAR-TO-YEAR INCREASE IN HOME VALUE, 2021 TO 2022 +33% Fastest year-to-year increase in history, 20% increase in 2020 SHORT-TERM RENTAL PROPERTIES COMPARED TO ALL PROPERTIES 1 in 5 Just over 7,000 properties are actively permitted as short-term rentals » Short-term rentals are a relatively new and fast- emerging use across the Town. • The trend is impacting unit values and driving new trends in small-scale redevelopment. • Short-term rental properties have quickly surpassed hotels and resorts in number of units. These properties, however, have also strained existing neighborhoods and infrastructure with increased parking demand, nuisance management, and other issues. Housing Permitting, home values, short-term rentals, new development and redevelopment Read more on p. 56 » Sea level rise makes the Island more vulnerable in major storm and hurricane events. • The secondary impacts of the changes – saltwater intrusion, high heat days, insurance and financing, and others – can be reasonably predicted. • Because flooding will increase in coastal areas as sea levels rise, it is likely that insurance rates will increase. More frequent storms could lead to an increase in the deductible for wind damage in homeowner’s insurance policies, or much higher premiums for communities like Hilton Head Island. • As sea levels rise, many of the coastal wetlands and salt marshes may turn to open water and alter the ecosystems where many shellfish, birds, and fish reside. Environment Ecology, hydrology, geography, climate change, parks Read more on p. 46 SEA LEVEL RISE 2ft Potential sea level rise by 2050 10 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 11 INTRODUCTION: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Page 25 of 174 NATURALLY OCCURRING AFFORDABLE UNITS ~2k Estimate is based on existing properties with "affordable" rent and US Census cost-of-living estimates » Housing affordability for lower-wage residents is reaching an inflection point. • The small share of the existing and naturally occurring affordable housing is not protected from redevelopment and has been the target for recent development proposals. Losses in the category are not likely to be made up in a new locations in the Town given the scarcity and cost of land. • Naturally occurring affordable housing (NOAH) units are housing units at affordable price points that are not protected by income restrictions or state and federal subsidies. These units are “unrestricted,” meaning there is little to no protection for them to stay affordable in perpetuity. • The Island has around 2,000 NOAH units and just under 400 protected, income-restricted units. TOWN FACEBOOK FOLLOWERS 38k Total followers of the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Government facebook page have grown steadily since its launch » The Town’s record of transparency and commitment to community engagement are a national best practice. • This growing relationship between residents and leadership will be critical as the Town manages challenging planning and development questions through the coming decade. • The Our Future and Our Plan community engagement process was two years long and involved the Town Council, a community vision process consultant, a vision project management team of diverse community leaders, and the broader community. • Direct communication from the government though multiple digital platforms allows timely communications to residents and visitors in hurricane events and other emergencies. Governance Timeline of key events, staffing, service capacity, tax revenues, strategic planning Read more on p. 64 TOWN RESIDENTS PER STAFF 246:1 Growth in Town staffing has not kept pace with the increase in population, visitors, and jobs since 2012 » The Town’s staffing is small compared to similarly sized, tourism-based communities. • Hiring, amidst rising housing costs, has been a challenge for administrators and public safety officers. • The Town provides critical services, like fire and safety, which includes fire rescue, emergency medical services, and emergency management. • The Town outsources services like law enforcement, which is currently served by the Beaufort County Sheriff ’s Office. Other services are privatized like recreation and park management. *Ratio does not include Fire Rescue Personnel 10 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 11 Page 26 of 174 » Cultural and historical assets are critical to the Island’s unique story but are under increasing threat from development pressure and a general decrease in native population. • The Town has several initiatives to preserve Gullah culture, including the Gullah-Geechee Land and Cultural Preservation Task Force, the Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhoods Community Development Corporation, and other initiatives. Community Engagement culture, civic infrastructure, Town planning processes, communication networks Read more on p. 72 » The pathways network is a key amenity but is also ready for its next round of investment and upgrades to improve safety and access. • Rental bikes are affordable and widely accessible. Over 30 rental shops within the Town provide nearly 15,000 bikes for rent. Rental users, however, are less-likely to regularly bike at home. • The Town’s pathways provide critical multi-modal connections to neighborhoods and destinations while contributing to the creation of Complete Streets throughout the Island. • In 2022, the Town initiated the Corridors Plan to serve as a guide for future pathways projects establish base references for issues to do with vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian traffic. MILES OF PUBLIC PATHWAY 72 The Town's pathway network is extensive and one of the most comprehensive in the nation Systems Water infrastructure, roadway and pathway network, healthcare, service provision Read more on p. 82 PEAK DAILY USAGE OF WATER (GALLONS) 26m Total gallons of water sourced from point sources (wells, bulk, etc.) » The explosive growth on the mainland is putting pressure on below-ground water resources supplied by the Floridian Aquifer. • The Hilton Head PSD has lost 11 drinking water wells to saltwater intrusion into the Upper Floridan freshwater aquifer from 2000 to 2023. As a response, the Island’s Public Service Districts are exploring new methods to secure point sources including very deep wells into the Cretaceous aquifer. • Intrusion can have serious consequences for communities that rely on the aquifer for their water supply, as the increased salinity can make the water unusable for drinking, irrigation, and other purposes. 12 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 13 INTRODUCTION: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Page 27 of 174 » Transit can play an important role in addressing multiple community issues like labor, housing cost, and congestion. • A regional issue in scope, the Town has a large stake in expanding the frequency and coverage of the existing system to better connect workers with jobs. • Access to public transportation is proven to be a leading driver of increasing economic mobility for under-served communities. • Palmetto Breeze’s “Ride Free - New Job Pass” provides a free, 7-day transit pass for any rider starting a new job. Initiatives such as these are centered around utilizing public transportation as a catalyst for lowering poverty rates, driving down housing costs, and increasing workforce mobility. • A transit development plan prepared for the Lowcountry Council of Governments in 2018 identified higher areas of need along and northwest of Beach City Road (including Hilton Head Hospital) and the south end of the Island extending southwest of Pope Avenue. THE BREEZE TROLLEY STOPS 21 The Breeze Trolley currently serves 21 stops around the Island, with opportunities for expansion toward the airport » The decreasing developable acreage and increasing community scrutiny is driving up the cost of projects at all scales. • With fewer large lots available, major subdivision projects (greater than 5 acres) are increasingly rare. • Infill projects - development within existing subdivisions or smaller lots - and major redevelopment proposals are occurring more regularly. • This will continue to increase the value and susceptibility for change of the Town’s older commercial properties. UNDEVELOPED LAND ON THE ISLAND (ACRES) 1,500 Out of the total 21,862 acres of land above mean high tide. 28% of undeveloped property is Town-Owned Land Use Development trends and patterns, constraints, and tools Read more on p. 92 12 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 13 Page 28 of 174 14 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 15 Page 29 of 174 TOPIC A DEMOGRAPHICS Demographics is an assessment of the make-up of a population with respect to age, race, ethnicity, household makeup, education, tenure, and other measures. In many ways, a community’s demographics are its destiny. Understanding the Island as a collection of individuals, families, and neighborhoods is the critical first step to holistic and inclusive community planning; it helps define not just who the community is, but who it is becoming. All places are changing. Even in a community like Hilton Head Island, where the population has begun to plateau, movement is continual. There are trends related to the age of residents, makeup of households, diversity of neighborhoods, and so on. These movements can play out quickly. Whatever shape the Island’s future community takes, it may have different needs or expectations compared to yesterday’s and today’s residents. It will require new investments in infrastructure and supportive services. This section explores several key trends related to demographics and their connection to other community systems. KEY TRENDS 1 The full-time resident population of the Island is plateauing amid intense regional growth. 2 Households are getting smaller, older, and are less likely to include school-age children. 3 The number of people on the Island can vary significantly from its full-time population based on the time of day or the time of year. 4 The average age on the Island is getting older and the 55+ segment is driving a modest increase in population. 5 The Town is a relatively diverse community, but there has been a long-term decrease in the overall share of African American residents. 6 The Hispanic community is growing at the fastest rate of any ethnic segment, both locally and regionally. 7 Foreign-born residents are a growing segment and mostly from Latin America. 14 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 15 Page 30 of 174 37,660 Total Full-Time Residents After tremendous growth through the 1970s, '80s, and '90s, Hilton Head Island’s population began to plateau; between 2000 and 2020 it only grew by 11%. By comparison, Beaufort County’s population grew by 55%, with places like Bluffton (2,074%) in Beaufort County and Hardeeville (317% ) in Jasper County growing at a much faster rate than the Island during the same 20-year period. The broader Savannah metropolitan area also grew by 45% between 2000 and 2020, with an increase of 70,000 additional residents. Hilton Head Island’s population dynamics are more complicated than a simple measure of full-time residents, however. The amount of people on the Island at any given moment varies greatly depending on a number of factors, including the tourist season and the number of workers who live off-Island. Such fluctuations mean that the Island’s daytime population increases by roughly one-third on average as people commute in for work. The completion of the James F. Byrnes Bridge in 1956 transformed access to the Island and facilitated massive growth, both in terms of full-time residents and seasonal tourists. Source: Esri, Forecast based on linear regression adjusted for reasonable land use projections ISLAND POPULATION CHANGE SINCE 1960 1 38,100 Forecast 37,660 37,212 ~300 11,344 33,862 23,694 +750% +345% +100% +42% +1% +1% +10% +1% 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 1.2% Town Growth Rate (2010 to 2020) 2,546 39,100 Forecast 16 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 17 TOPIC A: DEMOGRAPHICS Page 31 of 174 REGIONAL POPULATION CHANGE, 2000 TO 2020 KEY POPULATION CHANGE Source: Esri DAYTIME POPULATION CHANGE BY INFLOW AND OUTFLOW OF WORKERS +14k The Island population increases by 33% during the average weekday (excluding visitors) 102% 80% 100% 63% 46% 47% -8% -15% -16% 43% 77% 92% 8% Source: Esri ~40% Increase ~20% Increase No Change ~40% Decrease This map shows the relative change in population during the day caused by the influx of workers on top of the population of full time residents. A negative score shows an area with a net decrease in daytime population. 16 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 17 Page 32 of 174 SHARE OF FIRST-TIME VISITORS, 2020 13% A 2020 survey indicated a significant share of tourists were visiting the Island for the first time. 2 Households are getting smaller and older, and are less likely to include school-age children. • While the total number of households did increase 24% over this period, the makeup of these households is smaller and older. Family sizes on the Island are decreasing faster than in the county and the state. • Between 2000 and 2020, the average household size decreased 4.3%, compared to 1% for other areas of Beaufort County. • The two fastest growing segments were households over 65, which were up 50% (3,500 units), and persons living alone are up 57% (1,900 units). Households with children decreased 35%, with 1,200 fewer units. 3 The number of people on the Island can vary significantly from its full-time population based on the time of day or the time of year. • The daytime population measures the net gain in workers coming over the bridge each morning. This number varies with time of year, but on average there are 53,000 people on the Island during the day. • Tourism is another major variable. More than 3.1 million people visit throughout the year, with higher-volume seasons starting in March and ending in September. • On any given day, there are 8,500+ visitors on the Island, or one visitor for every five full-time residents. The visitor count does not include second home owners. • The Island exceeded pre-pandemic visitor numbers in 2021 after a dip in total visitor numbers in 2020. It is on track to level out around 3 million total visitors in 2023. HOUSEHOLD SIZE 2.2 4% decrease in household size TOTAL VISITORS, 2021 3.1m Visitor levels returned to and exceeded pre-pandemic levels in 2021, up 16.5% from 2019 YEAR TOTAL VISITORS 2018 2,617,764 2019 2,669,889 2020 2,607,800 2021 3,126,856 2022 3,089,346 JAN-JUN 2023 1,537,256 2025 (ESTIMATED) 3,522,400 Source: Town of Hilton Head Island VISITOR TRENDS, 2018–2025 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 DAYTIME POP . 47,672 49,609 50,014 47,905 48,911 WORKERS 23,482 24,363 23,239 21,854 21,585 VISITORS* 5,412 6,120 7,160 6,869 8,575 RESIDENTS (NON-WORKING) 18,778 19,126 19,615 19,182 18,751 Source: Town of Hilton Head Island DAYTIME POPULATION TRENDS, 2017–2021 *Estimates based on yearly visitor averages 18 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 19 TOPIC A: DEMOGRAPHICS Page 33 of 174 4 The average age on the Island is rising and the 55+ segment is driving a modest increase in population. • The median age for Island residents is increasing quickly, moving from 46 in 2000 to 58 in 2020. During this period, people over 55 drove a population increase, adding just over 9,000 new residents. Every other segment decreased in size. • The 65 and over segment alone added 6,500 new residents, an 80% increase. This is consistent with regional trends, as Beaufort County’s population grew by 175% in this older segment. • The county tracked increases in all other age segments; this was not the case for the Island. The under-18, or school-age, population is decreasing. This segment lost 13% of its share from 2000, and the decline is reflected in public school enrollment. • The public school system lost 400 students from 2012 to 2022, and is experiencing its largest loss among younger students below second grade. SHARE OF RESIDENTS OVER 65 37% This segment increased from 24% in 2000, the only growing age segment 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 0 to 5 5 to 9 10 to 14 15 to 19 20 to 24 25 to 34 35 to 44 45 to 54 55 to 59 60 to 64 Over 65 Hilton Head Island Beaufort CountySource: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2020 Censuses AGE OF RESIDENTS BY SEGMENT (2020) 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 0 to 5 5 to 9 10 to 14 15 to 19 20 to 24 25 to 34 35 to 44 45 to 54 55 to 59 60 to 64 Over 65 Hilton Head Island Beaufort County 10% 30% 50% 70% 2000 2010 2020 10% 30% 50% 70% 2000 2010 2020 CHANGE IN SHARE OF POPULATION BY MAJOR AGE SEGMENT Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2020 Censuses +13% 65 and over -7% 18 to 64 -5% 18 and under Under 18 18 to 64 Over 65 2000 2004 2008 2010 2014 2018 2022 2026 Forecast 18 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 19 Page 34 of 174 5 The Town is a relatively diverse community, but there has been a decrease in the overall share of African American residents. • Eight out of ten residents on the Island identify as white, but the share of this segment decreased from 2000 to 2020, from 85% to 79%, despite moderately increasing in absolute numbers. • The number of residents identifying their race as “other” or as “two or more races” increased significantly over this period, growing from 6% to 13% of the Island’s total. • The African American segment lost population over this period, decreasing by 400 residents (or 15%). The median age for African American residents, 61, is three years older than the overall Island median of 58. CHANGE IN AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION, 2000 TO 2020 -400 The overall share of African American residents decreased from 8% to 6% AFRICAN AMERICAN RESIDENTS ISLAND OVERALL DIFFERENCE MEDIAN AGE 61 58 +3 BELOW POVERTY LINE 16% 7% +9% MEDIAN FAMILY INCOME $53k $86k -$ 33k TOTAL POPULATION 2020 2,192 37,661 SHARE DECREASE FROM 8% TO 6%, 2000 TO 2020 POPULATION 18 AND UNDER 8% 13% -5% MULTIPLE INDICATORS FOR AFRICAN AMERICAN RESIDENTS COMPARED TO ISLAND AVERAGE Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2020 Censuses The Gullah Geechee Community “A century ago, Hilton Head Island was dominated by the Gullah Geechee people. Because of years of geographic and social isolation, their distinct culture reflects their West African roots in many ways, including language, crafts, foodways, storytelling, traditions, farming, fishing, and relationship to the land.” - The Gullah Geechee Culture Preservation Project Report, 2019. Click to read more about the Gullah Geechee community and the recommendations from the report. Credit: The Gullah Museum 20 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 21 TOPIC A: DEMOGRAPHICS Page 35 of 174 6 The Hispanic community is growing at the fastest rate of any segment, both locally and regionally. • Mirroring trends across the region and the country overall, the share of Island residents of Hispanic or Latino ethnicity rose by 28.2% between 2000 and 2020 from 3,934 to 5,045. • According to the Island Packet, the Beaufort County School District is now home to the third-largest Hispanic student population in South Carolina, with more than 6,000 students concentrated mostly on Hilton Head Island and in Bluffton. • Hispanic students now make up almost half of the Island’s public school population. The growth was even faster, however, across the region, where Hispanic and Latino residents grew by 187%, nearly doubling in size as a segment. • At Hilton Head Island Middle and High Schools, about one in every three students is multilingual and developing fluency in English. Less than a third of those students met language proficiency targets in 2020, lagging at least 11 percentage points behind their peers across South Carolina. 7 Foreign-born residents are a growing segment and mostly from Latin America. • The region has also attracted a large number of foreign-born residents from 2000 to 2020. Just under 12% of residents on Hilton Head Island were not born in the United States, with two- thirds of this group migrating from Latin America. • Europe was the second-largest region of origin, representing 18% of the total foreign-born population. 2012 2013 2014 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 ENROLLMENT BY RACE IN HILTON HEAD ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS (2012 TO 2021) Source: SC Department of Education student headcounts 0 250 500 3X Population increase in overall Hispanic community Hispanic 54% White 33% African American 9% Other 4% STUDENTS SHARE IN 2021 Multilingual classrooms like the one pictured above are more common with the increase in English as a Second Language students. Credit: Drew Martin and the Island Packet STUDENTS LEARNING ENGLISH IN SCHOOL 1 in 3 Hilton Head Island public schools has increased its English as a Second Language (ESL) resources and offerings to meet the rising need INCREASE IN HISPANIC POPULATION, 2000 TO 2020 28% The overall share of the Hispanic population rose 11.6% from 2000 to 2010, and 15.8% from 2010 to 2020 20 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 21 Page 36 of 174 22 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 23 Page 37 of 174 TOPIC B WORKFORCE Workforce refers to the size, composition, and productivity of an area’s labor pool. It can include full-time, part-time, and contract workers. The scale and composition of an area’s workforce can have a significant impact on its overall productivity and economic potential. Hilton Head Island’s economy relies largely on the tourism industry, which represents a significant proportion of the local labor force. The tourism industry on the Island is supported by the region’s location and abundance of recreation, resorts, and beaches. Other notable workforce categories on the Island include retail services, professional services, and healthcare. Generally, the workforce on Hilton Head Island is diverse and reflective of the area’s distinctive economic and demographic characteristics, but there is a growing dependence on the larger region to meet the local workforce demands. Each year, more workers commute from off-Island. While wages have increased, they’ve not kept pace with the rise in housing costs. The divergence is forcing local employers to work harder to source labor and considering the long-term impacts of the scarcity. KEY TRENDS 1 Competition for labor is intensifying as the region experiences strong job and population growth. 2 Recent Island worker shortages have impacted local businesses. 3 Unemployment rates have been and continue to be low when compared to the region. 4 Median annual earnings have been increasing over the last decade, most notably for high school graduates, who experienced a 76% increase in earnings during that time. 5 Higher education facilities on or near Hilton Head Island will continue to add to the workforce with high-demand local industry skills. 6 Residents have comparatively higher levels of educational attainment than the overall populations of Jasper and Beaufort Counties. 7 One in five resident occupations are in the food preparation and serving industry. 8 Commuting for Island residents decreased by almost 10% over the last decade while the share of residents that work from home has steadily increased. 22 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 23 Page 38 of 174 18,000 19,000 20,000 21,000 22,000 23,000 21,400 Total Island Jobs in 2021 The Town of Hilton Head Island is part of a dynamic and evolving region that has experienced significant job growth over the last 20 years. While the COVID-19 global pandemic and related economic shutdowns dealt a temporary setback to the Island’s job growth, the total employment in the Town quickly recovered and exceeded pre-COVID totals. Now topping 21,000 employees, the number of jobs is forecast to increase. The total jobs picture in the larger Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA), which includes Beaufort and Jasper counties, has increased by nearly 24% during period between 2000 and 2022. The region’s growth in most job industries, with healthcare, education, retail trade, and construction posting the strongest increases. Although tourism continues to be an important driver of growth in the region, its economic profile has become more diverse over time. With comparatively ample land for development on the mainland, the overall Savannah and Charleston MSAs have both experienced comparatively stronger economic growth as a result of their rapidly expanding job bases during the same period. CHANGE IN TOTAL ISLAND PRIVATE-PRIMARY JOBS, 2002 TO 2021 Source: US Census Bureau, Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics +3% Island job growth from 2000 HILTON HEAD ISLAND The Lowcountry boasts strong hospitality and food service industries, which influenced the Technical College of the Lowcountry to open the Culinary Institute of the South in Bluffton in order to support training and development for these workforce sectors. Credit: Culinary Institute of the South 1 NATIONAL RECESSION FORECAST COVID-19 24 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 25 TOPIC B: WORKFORCE Page 39 of 174 2 Recent Island worker shortages have impacted local businesses. • Recent shortages of Island workers have led to a delayed opening for tourist season, reduced hours of operation, and business closures. • Hiring challenges on the Island are growing—housing costs are rising, and with more employment opportunities emerging in Beaufort and Jasper Counties, crossing the bridge to Hilton Head Island each day is becoming less desirable to workers. • Limited non-residential development on the Island tends to impede new job growth. The limited developable land going to non- residential uses leaves less opportunity to create workforce housing, driving workers to other emerging job markets. • Other regions in the Lowcountry have more land available to accommodate greater job growth, increasing by 30–40% since 2000, while the Island’s labor force has only grown by 7% in the same time frame. • Despite this, the Island had a 96% average labor force participation rate from 2000 to 2021, a slightly higher measure when compared to the Hilton Head Island MSA (95%) as well as the Charleston (95%) and Savannah (94%) MSAs. This shows residents are employed, but do not fill the labor needs of the Island. 3 While unemployment rates on the Island fluctuate with economic cycles, they have historically been lower when compared to surrounding regions. • The Island’s unemployment rate as of 2021 is 3.1% lower than the Hilton Head Island, Savannah, and Charleston MSAs. • The all-time high unemployment rate on Hilton Head Island was 6.8% during the national recession; it peaked again during the COVID-19 pandemic, but recovered quickly. UNEMPLOYMENT RATE, 2021 3.1% The Island is nearing full employment, including the portion of residents that work off-Island LABOR FORCE PARTICIPATION 96% This measures those locals that can and do work (non-retired, non- minor, etc.); Up 7% from 2000 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% CHANGE IN UNEMPLOYMENT, 2000 TO 2021 Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2020 Censuses NATIONAL RECESSION COVID-19HILTON HEAD ISLAND SAVANNAH MSA 24 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 25 Page 40 of 174 4 Median annual earnings have been increasing on the Island over the last decade, most notably for high school graduates. • There has been a 33% increase in median annual wages across the Island over the last decade, with high school graduates experiencing a 76% increase in earnings. • All levels of educational attainment experienced some form of growth in earnings from 2010 to 2021. • While wages on the Island have increased, housing costs remain a challenge for many residents. The maximum monthly housing cost the average single worker can afford before being housing cost-burdened is $1,043. This measure is based on the standard recommendation of spending less than 30% of monthly earnings on housing costs. The median rent in the Town of Hilton Head Island is $1,330 according to the US Census 2022 American Communities Survey. 2010 2015 2020 2021 CHANGE Less than High School $ 18,926 $ 20,642 $ 25,920 $ 28,257 49% High School Graduate $ 21,308 $ 21,616 $ 33,807 $ 37,570 76% Some College $ 31,146 $ 31,667 $ 37,282 $ 37,149 19% Bachelor’s Degree $ 42,175 $ 40,242 $ 51,621 $ 56,893 35% Graduate Degree $ 54,375 $ 50,625 $ 56,154 $ 65,000 20% Overall Median $32,113 $30,551 $40,285 $42,059 31% MEDIAN EARNINGS BY EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT, HILTON HEAD ISLAND Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2021 Censuses Path to payroll: growing hiring challenges Hilton Head Island is facing significant workforce challenges. In 2016, the Island’s tourism-based economy relied on over 8,400 workers to keep businesses open. However, with the rising cost of housing and increased employment opportunities in nearby Beaufort and Jasper Counties, workers are being pulled off the Island. This shortage of workers has led businesses to delay opening for the tourist season, cut hours of operation, or shutter locations altogether. Credit: the island PaCket TOPIC B: WORKFORCE Median Household Income Median Rent Hilton Head $ 86,171 $ 1,330 Savannah, GA $ 46,149 $ 1,049 Hardeeville, SC $ 65,245 $ 1,196 COMPARATIVE INCOME AND RENT, 2020 Source: US Census Bureau, 2020 Census 26 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 27 Page 41 of 174 5 Higher education facilities on or near Hilton Head Island will continue to infuse the workforce with high-demand local industry skills. • Higher education institutions include University of South Carolina at Beaufort (USCB) and Technical College of the Lowcountry (TCL). The schools have a combined student population of over 8,000. • Many higher education opportunities in the area are geared toward the tourism industry, including USCB-Hilton Head’s Hospitality Management program and the Culinary Institute of the South, a subsidiary facility created by TCL to advance the hospitality and food service workforce in the region. 6 Residents have comparatively higher levels of educational attainment than the overall populations of Jasper and Beaufort Counties. • 52% of the residents of the Town of Hilton Head Island age 25 years or older had at least a bachelor’s degree in 2021, while the comparable figures were 42% for Beaufort County and 24% for Jasper County. • All three geographic areas have experienced strong increases in education attainment levels since the 2010 US Census. Degrees & Certificates Associate Degree in Culinary Arts Restaurant Cooking Skills Certificate Associate Degree and Certificate in Baking & Pastry Arts Associate Degree and Certificate in Hospitality & Tourism Management Partner Advocates The Sea Pines Resort SERG Group The Omni Hilton Head Oceanfront Resort The Sonesta Resort Hilton Head The Westin Hilton Head Island Resort & Spa US Foods Fat Patties CULINARY INSTITUTE OF THE SOUTH Source: Technical College of the Lowcountry Town of Hilton Head Island 24% 42% Jasper County, SC Beaufort County, SC 52% SHARE WITH A BACHELOR'S DEGREE OR HIGHER Source: US Census Bureau, 2021 Census 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Graduate or prof. degree, 23.1% Bachelor's degree, 29.5% Some college, 15.1% HS diploma, 18.3% Associates, 6.6% No diploma, 7.4% USCB Hilton Head campus features a nationally-recognized hospitality management program geared toward training the next generation of leaders in the Island’s largest industry. Credit: University of South Carolina at Beaufort 26 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 27 Page 42 of 174 Could traffic be worse? While inbound commuting pulls close to 15,000 workers across the bridge each day, the staggered start times of the hospitality economy decrease the peak-time pressure and congestion. Source: US Census Bureau, Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics RESIDENT OCCUPATION BREAKDOWN, 2021 Building Grounds & Maintenance 10% Management 6% Office & Admin Support 13% Personal Care & Services 5% Food Prep & Serving 20% Installation, Maintenance & Repair 4% Sales 12% 7 One in five resident occupations are in the food preparation and serving industry, making it the most common job. • Food preparation and serving accounts for more than 20% of the Island’s labor force. The average salary of a worker on the Island in this industry is $34,106. • The second most common occupations on the Island are in office & administrative support, a sector which employs 13% of the labor force. This is closely followed by the sales industry, which employs around 12%. • Office and administrative support occupations have an average annual salary of $47,880 on the Island, and sales occupations have average annual earnings of nearly $62,000. 8 Commuting for Island residents decreased over the last decade while the share that work from home has increased. • The majority of local workers live off-Island, totaling about 14,800 workers crossing the bridge each day to get to work. This number has increased by 26% from 2002, while the number of workers who live on the Island has decreased by 34%, for a total of roughly 8,400. • Approximately 28% of workers commute to work after 9:00 A.M., and for most it takes between 10 and 19 minutes to commute. • The tourism-based economy of the Island means that commuting hours for Island workers do not necessarily align with traditional business hours. • When compared to the surrounding regions, residents on the Island have shorter commutes. The mean travel time to work was estimated to be around 18 minutes in 2021, which was only a slight difference from the average mean time of 17 minutes in 2010. Over 80% of workers use personal means of transportation such as a car, truck, or van to commute to work. • Commuting has decreased by about 10% since 2010 while the work-from-home trend has increased from 7% in 2010 to 15% in 2021. 28 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 29 TOPIC B: WORKFORCE Page 43 of 174 WHERE ISLAND WORKERS LIVE, 2019 Source: US Census Bureau, Longitudinal Employer-Household Dynamics JASPER CO. HAMPTON CO. BEAUFORT CO. Bluffton Hardeeville Ridgeland Beaufort Savannah EFFINGHAM CO. GEORGIA SOUTH CAROLINA CHATHAM CO. BRYAN CO. 1,400 total workers 700 2,300 300 8,400* non-Island, county residents 250 300200 14,800 employed on-Island, live off-Island 26% increase 6,400 live on-Island, employed off-Island 56% increase 8,400 live and work on-Island 34% decline Note: increases measured from 2002 to 2020. INFLOW/OUTFLOW ANALYSIS, 2002 TO 2020 Source: US Census Bureau OnTheMap Tool LIBERTY CO. 28 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 29 Page 44 of 174 30 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 31 Page 45 of 174 TOPIC C ECONOMICS Economics is an examination of the individual and market forces that influence businesses, revenues, expenditures, and capital projects. This section provides insight on the local economic conditions on Hilton Head Island and the overall region. While some trends have remained consistent over the last two decades, there have also been significant changes within Hilton Head Island’s economy. COVID-19’s impact on the tourism industry, though brief, exposed vulnerabilities within this sector and underscores the need for economic diversification. This unique moment in time also set off a host of new local trends, with more residents working from home, a ratcheting up of real estate activity, and a broad increase in business activity. Meanwhile, maintaining and improving accessibility to the Island is an economic imperative. Economically, the Island is not an island. Commuting and spending patterns show a tight connection between the Town and the broader region. This section examines the dynamics of the local economy and breaks down major trends following the pandemic and other regional impacts. KEY TRENDS 1 After the pandemic-related disruption in 2020, tourism has bounced back and continues to drive the Island’s economy. 2 The number of applications for business licenses shot up after 2020, almost two-thirds of which have been for short-term rental properties. 3 Hilton Head Island Airport (HHH) has played a growing role in local economic development since its 2018 expansion. 4 The local economy has recovered since the shock from the COVID-19 pandemic and historic trends are expected to continue. 5 Tourism drives local revenues and has recovered and surpassed pre-pandemic levels. 6 Non-tourism related jobs grew the most over the last two decades. 7 Several capital projects planned in and around Hilton Head Island are expected to positively impact economic outcomes. 30 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 31 Page 46 of 174 $2.8 billion Economic Impact of Tourism After the COVID-19 disruptions in 2020, tourism has bounced back and continues to be Hilton Head Island’s leading economic driver. In 2021, Travel & Leisure’s World’s Best Awards named it America’s number one island; that same year the MSA saw a total gross domestic product of $9.2 billion. As one of the most popular visitor destinations in the South and a record high of over 3 million visitors in 2021, it is no surprise that industries supporting tourism host the largest shares of jobs on the Island. Along with retail trade, accommodation and food services account for more than one- third of the Island’s jobs. This share has been relatively stable over the last two decades. Destinations like the Sea Pines Resort draw in large amounts of visitors each year, driving economic prosperity and maintaining a strong workforce. 1 $5,000 $6,000 $7,000 $8,000 $9,000 $10,000 TOTAL REAL GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT FOR HILTON HEAD ISLAND MSA Source: Federal Reserve Economic Data, Millions of Chained 2012 Dollars (Annual)In billions of dollars $5 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 $6 $7 $8 $9 $10 GROWTH IN REGIONAL GDP , 2001 TO 2021 $3.3b The Island still dominates regional contributions to GDP , but more recent growth can be attributed to mainland development NATIONAL RECESSION COVID-19 32 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 33 TOPIC C: ECONOMICS Page 47 of 174 2 The number of applications for business licenses shot up after 2020, almost two-thirds of which have been for short-term rental properties. • Between 2010 and 2020, the number of business license applications submitted per year ranged from a low of 917 (in 2010) to a high of 1,362 (in 2016). • The past two years have been record breaking, with 2,742 applications in 2021 and 3,863 in 2022. Requests for licenses for short-term rentals (STRs) have primarily driven this growth. • Prior to 2021, applications for construction contractors and subcontractors were the most popular type, making up more than one-fifth in some years. Since 2021, they are the second most popular type after STRs. • Approximately 99% of requests for licenses have been approved since 2010, and the elevated number of applications is expected to continue. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island 2010 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Jan–Oct. 2023 NEW BUSINESS LICENSE APPLICATIONS PER YEAR, 2010 TO 2023 TOTAL BUSINESS LICENSES ISSUED NON-STR BUSINESS LICENSES STR BUSINESS LICENSES Managing the Short Term Rental Wave In an effort to manage the proliferation of short term rentals on the Island, the Town passed a rule requiring home owners to acquire a permit if they intend to list and rent their home through a short term rental portal like Airbnb or VRBO. The permits are annual and non-transferable, costing the homeowner $250. The Town can suspend or cancel short-term rental permits if a property is deemed a nuisance, if the owner neglects tax or fee payments, or if more than two convictions for town code violations related to short-term rentals happen within a year, among other conditions. 32 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 33 Page 48 of 174 3 Hilton Head Island Airport (HHH) has played a growing role in local economic development since its 2018 expansion. • The 2018 runway extension allowed HHH to accommodate larger airplanes traveling from further distances. Prior to the expansion, American Airlines was the only airline serving the Island; now the Island is also served by United Airlines and Delta Airlines. • Passenger volume nearly tripled between 2018 and 2019. After a sharp decline in 2020, the volume spiked to a record-high of almost 350,000 passengers in 2021. • While passenger counts in 2022 were down from the 2021 peak, the ~245,000 enplanements and deplanements was 10% more than in 2019. • HHH is planning a $53 million terminal improvement project that will add 43,000 square feet to the existing four-gate terminal that was built in 1956. The upgraded airport facilities will provide a more enjoyable experience for residents and visitors and will greatly increase daily flight traffic. 4 The local economy has recovered since the shock from the COVID-19 pandemic and historic trends are expected to continue. • The number of jobs on the Island has held relatively steady, with the exception of 2020 when the economy was interrupted by business closures due to the COVID-19 pandemic. • The local economy has since recovered and job growth over the next ten years is expected to be a continuation of recent trends. In the five years leading up to the pandemic, approximately 550 jobs were added. Flying in: The growing impact of Hilton Head Airport Expanded airline capacity at HHH was the driving force behind a 145% increase in passengers coming to and from the airport in 2021. Passenger totals reached almost 400,000, surpassing even pre-pandemic numbers. With the proposed new terminal to come—bringing three gates, an expanded waiting area, and additional parking—Hilton Head Island’s tourism industry will continue to boom in the coming years. Credit: Proposed Terminal Expansion, Beaufort County PASSENGER INCREASE, 2020 TO 2021 145% Total passengers in 2021 reached a record high for Hilton Head Island FUTURE ISLAND JOB GROWTH 5% Jobs are forecast to grow through 2030, adding 1,000 new jobs 34 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 35 TOPIC C: ECONOMICS Page 49 of 174 ACCOMMODATIONS TAX REVENUE, 2021 $69m Generated by spending on the Island and across the County 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 TOTAL AND PROJECTED JOBS ON ISLAND Source: Lowcountry Area Transportation Study; US Census; Kimley-Horn 22,400 21,408 19,063 203020212010 5 Tourism has recovered and surpassed pre-pandemic levels, driving local revenues. • According to a 2021 tourism impact report from the Hilton Head Island- Bluffton Chamber of Commerce, visitor expenditures generated a total of $69.17 million in tax revenue in Hilton Head Island through the accommodations tax, the hospitality tax, and beach preservation fees. • In 2021 the Visitor & Convention Bureau spent $1.82 million on destination marketing. For every dollar spent by the Bureau, an estimated return of $38.01 in local tax revenue was generated by visitor spending. From 2019 to 2021 the return grew by $22.11 per dollar spent, even as the Bureau’s annual spending decreased by $25,000. HILTON HEAD ISLAND TOURISM TRENDS Source: Hilton Head Island-Bluffton Chamber of Commerce and Visitor & Convention Bureau 2019 2021 2,000,000 2,200,000 2,400,000 2,600,000 2,800,000 3,000,000 3,200,000 2019 2021 TOTAL TOURISTS 0 500,000,000 1,000,000,000 1,500,000,000 2,000,000,000 2,500,000,000 3,000,000,000 2019 2021 TOURISM ECONOMIC IMPACT 2019 3.1m 2021 2,000,000 2,200,000 2,400,000 2,600,000 TOTAL VISITORS 2,800,000 3,000,000 3,200,000 2,000,000 2,200,000 2,400,000 2,600,000 2,800,000 3,000,000 3,200,000 2019 2021 TOTAL TOURISTS 0 500,000,000 1,000,000,000 1,500,000,000 2,000,000,000 2,500,000,000 3,000,000,000 2019 2021 TOURISM ECONOMIC IMPACT 0 $.5 $1.0 $1.5 TOURISM ECONOMIC IMPACT (IN BILLIONS OF DOLLARS) $2.0 $2.5 $3.0 B 2.7m $1.5b $2.8b 34 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 35 Page 50 of 174 6 Non-tourism related jobs grew the most over the last two decades. • While tourism has historically dominated the Island’s employment base, the overall total number of jobs in the industries most closely tied to tourism has declined in recent decades. • The management of companies and enterprises, finance and insurance, and healthcare sectors have had the most growth. • Construction is the industry that experienced the largest decline in jobs, driven by the slowdown in new development. 7 Several capital projects planned in and around Hilton Head Island are expected to impact economic output. • Major capital projects on Hilton Head Island and around the region have the potential to impact economic output as they work to improve access and movement around the region. • The Mid-Island District Redevelopment Plan is a 103-acre parcel at the center of the Mid-Island District. It is slated for cultural, commercial development, and industrial uses. • The 278 Corridor Project, proposed by Beaufort County and SCDOT, could reduce congestion and improve access to Hilton Head Island by replacing the mainland bridge to the Island. While funding has been identified for the project, the proposed single bridge is still being studied and negotiated between the Town and County. • While not directly impacting the Island, the proposed Jasper Ocean Terminal (JOT) is a marine container terminal that would be built on a 1,500-acre site along the north bank of the Savannah River and is anticipated to accommodate the forecasted cargo throughput into the region over the next 35 years. As a result, there is an industrial development boom happening in Jasper County. SECTOR SIZE & CHANGE, 2002-2019 Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2021 Censuses, Primary jobs only Public Admin and Education Finance and Insurance Construction Management Other Sectors Professional, Scientific, and… Other Services Arts, Entertainment, and… Real Estate Administration & Support Health Care and Social Assistance Retail Trade Accommodation and Food Services -5% -3% 18% -2% 13% -9% -13% -19% -36% 453% -55% 23% 3% 0 2,000 Public Admin & Education Finance and Insurance Construction Management Other Sectors Professional & Scientific Other Services Arts & Entertainment Real Estate Administration & Support Healthcare & Social Assistance Retail Trade Accommodation & Food Services 4,000 6,000 8,0002002 2019 36 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 37 TOPIC C: ECONOMICS Page 51 of 174 JOB CENTERS AND MAJOR PROJECTS KEY Town Parks Golf Courses Major Roads Jobs Cluster ESTABLISHMENTS 300+ jobs10 Hilton Head Airport Expansion This includes a new 3-gate terminal that will allow increased travel to the area as well as amenities to make traveling more comfortable. WHP Gateway Corridor Project The proposed increase in capacity and improvements will have an impact on commuting and mobility for residents and workers. Mid-Island 733 businesses 9,166 employees Shelter Cove 124 businesses 1,359 employees Coligny & Beach 221 businesses 2,409 employees Sea Pines Circle 467 businesses 5,656 employees EMPLOYER EMPLOYEES SERG GROUP RESTAURANTS 1,244 MARRIOTT VACATION CLUB INTL 580 SEA PINES RESORT 536 HILTON HEAD MEDICAL CENTER AND CLINICS 506 COASTAL RESTAURANTS AND BARS 500 BEAUFORT COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT 438 TOP ISLAND EMPLOYERS (2021) Source: Town of HHI Comprehensive Annual Financial Report The Jasper Ocean Terminal When completed in the 2030s, the Jasper Ocean Terminal would add a deepwater, 15-berth port system to the north side of the Savannah River and effectively double the capacity of the region’s overall port system. This project will have huge economic implications for the entire Lowcountry region. Source: Esri, Business Analyst Mid-Island District Plan The plan establishes a clear vision for commercial redevelopment in the area that will leverage a major public park investment at the Mid-Island Tract. TOTAL ESTABLISHMENTS / BUSINESSES (2023) 2,514 The retail trade as well as accommodation & food services have the largest numbers of establishments on the Island 36 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 37 Page 52 of 174 3838 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 39 Page 53 of 174 TOPIC D REAL ESTATE Understanding the dynamics, the real estate market helps to expose the present and emerging pressures playing out within, and working to change, a community. The Island’s market is unique in many ways and this section deals with the trends within this system. Large-scale development on Hilton Head Island has taken place over a series of waves starting in the 1960s. Each of these eras conveyed its own unique profile and mix of architecture and land uses. When picturing the Hilton Head Island market, one may think first about resorts and short-term rentals, restaurants, and boutiques catering to visitors. There is, however, a sizable and dynamic inventory of commercial properties that are not directly connected to the to the hospitality economy. The vitality of these segments will come under increasing scrutiny as the amount of undeveloped land decreases. This topic explores several of the key trends related to the real estate market on Hilton Head Island and how these dynamics shape the experience of residents, workers, and visitors on the Island. KEY TRENDS 1 Hilton Head Island’s real estate is mostly comprised of residential properties, and its stock has grown slowly in recent years. 2 A majority of the residential real estate inventory on the Island is locally owned. 3 Nearly all the development in the last year has been single-family homes. 4 Multifamily rental options on the Island are very limited. 5 Healthcare is the leading office tenant, occupying close to one-third of available square footage. 6 Nearly all new retail space over the last decade is hosted at Shelter Cove Towne Centre and Sea Turtle Marketplace. 7 Vacancy across retail and office properties is increasingly volatile and trending upward. 8 Peak and shoulder seasons for visitors are lengthening. 9 The market is growing for year-round residents and a longer visitor season. 38 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 39 Page 54 of 174 90.6 MILLION SQUARE FEET Total Island market real estate Residential properties account for 76% of the total Island real estate, or close to 69 million square feet. This segment grew by 7% from 2016 to today, adding an additional 2.8 million square feet of property across large- and small-scale projects. Commercial properties make up the balance of the market, accounting for 10.5 million square feet in 2023, a small decrease from 2016 in terms of both share and total. Commercial real estate is concentrated along William Hilton Parkway and Palmetto Bay Road. The opening of the existing four-lane bridge in 1982 kicked off the most booming decade of development on the Island. Approximately 40% of current retail, office, and hospitality space was built during this decade alone. More recently, infill residential development has been distributed across the Island, while non-residential development is heavily concentrated along William Hilton Parkway and Palmetto Bay Road. Almost 25% of office space and 20% of retail space is located within a half-mile of the area between Sea Pines traffic circle and Coligny Plaza. TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND HILTON HEAD ISLAND MSA UNITED STATES TOTAL CHANGE TOTAL CHANGE TOTAL CHANGE 2013 3.06M - 11.94M - 11,367.95M - 2014 3.11 1.6% 11.88 -0.5% 11,428.42 0.5% 2015 3.11 0.1% 12.13 2.1% 11,500.83 0.6% 2016 3.19 2.5% 12.16 0.2% 11,574.08 0.6% 2017 3.19 0.0% 12.78 5.1% 11,656.72 0.7% 2018 3.26 2.1% 12.96 1.4% 11,713.28 0.5% 2019 3.30 1.1% 13.18 1.8% 11,768.99 0.5% 2020 3.30 0.0% 13.22 0.3% 11,813.62 0.4% 2021 3.30 0.2% 13.34 0.9% 11,832.42 0.2% 2022 3.30 0.0% 13.44 0.7% 11,856.70 0.2% Total Change 7.9% 12.5% 4.3% TOTAL REAL ESTATE INVENTORY, 2013 TO 2022 Source: CoStar, Beaufort County Auditor While retail and office spaces boomed following the opening of the bridge, commercial construction has since slowed down. Credit: Hilton Head Properties 1 40 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 41 TOPIC D: REAL ESTATE Page 55 of 174 ALL REAL ESTATE RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL TOTAL SHARE TOTAL SHARE TOTAL SHARE TOTAL SQUARE FEET 90.6 M - 68.7M 76% 22.0M 24% LOCALLY-OWNED 51.8M 57% 41.3M 60% 10.5M 48% IN-STATE 56.4M 62% 43.4M 63% 13.0M 59% OUT-OF-STATE 34.1M 38% 25.1M 37% 9.0M 41% INTERNATIONAL 0.13M 0.2% 0.11M 0.2% 0.02M 0.1% REAL ESTATE TOTALS BY LOCATION OF OWNER, 2023 Source: Beaufort County Auditor 2 Most residential property is owned locally; commercial ownership is more commonly off-Island. • As of March 2023, approximately 57% of all square footage on the Island is locally owned, up from 55% in 2016. When broken down by property type, 60% of residential square footage versus 48% of commercial square footage is locally owned. • Both residential and commercial shares of locally owned properties are up from 2016, indicating the Island’s growing attractiveness for year-round residence. • Properties with international owners, nearly all of which are residential, make up less than 0.5% of the total square footage. The amount under international ownership declined by more than 50% between 2016 and 2023, likely influenced by the travel restrictions imposed at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Almost 25% of office space and 20% of retail space is located between Sea Pines traffic circle and Coligny Plaza. OFFICE REAL ESTATE SQUARE FOOTAGE BUILT SINCE 2010 <1% Much of the office space on the Island is aging and new product is not being delivered Source: Beaufort County Auditor South Carolina Georgia North Carolina Florida Ohio 62% 6% 3% 4% 4% 21% Other REAL ESTATE TOTALS BY LOCATION OF OWNER, 2023 40 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 41 Page 56 of 174 3 Nearly all the development in the last year has been single-family homes. • Between April 2022 and March 2023 there were 153 building permits issued for new structures. Nine were for accessory structures, ten were for commercial structures and the remaining 134 were single family homes. • There is a 166-unit timeshare resort awaiting permit approval that is proposed for the property formerly known as the Port Royal Racquet Club Tract at 15 Wimbledon Court. • There is approximately 4.5 million square feet of non-residential space in the regional pipeline. Nearly 85% of the square footage under development is industrial space in Jasper County in anticipation of the proposed Jasper Ocean Terminal port project. 4 Island multifamily rental options are very limited. • On the Island, there are five market-rate apartment rental communities—55 Gardner, 7 Lagoon, 90 Dillon, Sandalwood Terrace, Sylby Tub, and The Glen. Two are dedicated to senior housing, Hilton Head Gardens and Cedar Well Apartments. • Aquatera, where rent averages $3,174 for a 2 bedroom, and Water Walk at Shelter Cove, where rent averages $3,633 for a 2 bedroom, are the sole market-rate multifamily rental communities built in the last twenty years, completed within the past five years. • In the past decade, monthly rent has increased by nearly 40%, and in 2022, the average rent exceeded $2 per square foot for the first time, influenced by the introduction of Aquatera. NEW RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT, 2016 TO 2023 +2.8m Square footage in new residential units on the Island significantly outpaced commercial development 0% 20% 40% 1980 to 1989 1990 to 1999 2000 to 2009 Built after 2010 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 BEAUFORT CO.HILTON HEAD ISLAND HOUSING DEVELOPMENT & SALES CHANGE Sources: US Census Bureau, Zillow.comYEAR BUILTSALES CHANGE 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0% 1980 TO 1989 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 1990 TO 1999 2000 TO 2009 BUILT AFTER 2010 20% 40% Aquatera: The Future of Multifamily? With so little residential construction the past decade, the Aquatera multifamily development stands out for a number of reasons. The development has larger and more variable floor plans compared to existing multifamily products, and is fully amenitized with modern, luxury finishes. The associated escalation in rent is more in line with a similar process taking place in market-rate rental properties on the mainland in new developments like Buckwalter. Credit: Aquatera Hilton Head 42 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 43 TOPIC D: REAL ESTATE Page 57 of 174 +36% On-Island +48% Growing competition? While a significant share of the Hilton Head Island MSA’s office product is on-Island, rent demand growth is slowing. Off-Island product is newer and more proximate to the larger region. Less than 10k square feet of office properties have been completed in the last ten years, compared to 280k total in the MSA. Hilton Head Island MSA 5 Healthcare is the leading office tenant, occupying close to one-third of total office square footage. • The Town hosts approximately 1.8 million square feet of office space. Healthcare users account for 30% of the total office square footage. The next three most prevalent types of office tenants are in finance and insurance, professional services, and real estate. • Less than 10,000 square feet of on-Island office space has been completed over the last decade, making it the least active commercial real estate sector when compared with retail and hospitality. The limited addition of new space has resulted in a tightening of the market with an average vacancy of 4.3% over the last decade. 6 Nearly all new retail space is hosted at Shelter Cove Towne Centre and Sea Turtle Marketplace. • There is approximately 3.4 million square feet of retail space on the Island. • The amount of retail space per permanent resident increased over the last ten years, primarily due to plateauing population growth and the opening of Shelter Cove Towne Centre and Sea Turtle Marketplace, which represent nearly all the new retail space completed during this period. • Almost 85% of the retail inventory was built prior to 2000, with limited renovations. • Vacancy has remained relatively low over the last decade, ranging from 2.4% in 2015 to 7.1% in 2021, when more space was vacated than leased following the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Generally, the Island’s older retail properties have higher vacancy rates and lower rents than the newest spaces. SHARE OF REGIONAL OFFICE SPACE ON-ISLAND 40% Nearly half of the Hilton Head Island MSA office product is located on Hilton Head Island TOTAL RETAIL SQUARE FOOTAGE 3.4m Located on Hilton Head Island 42 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 43 Page 58 of 174 7 Vacancy across retail and office products is increasingly volatile and trending upward. • Following national trends, the vacancy rate among retail-oriented buildings on the Island has increased over the previous five years from 4.7% in 2017 to 7.1% in 2021. The COVID-19 pandemic had similar effects across the country. • 2022 numbers showed initial signs of a recovery, but rent demand for retail uses is also in decline, especially among older buildings on the Island. • The lack of newer office product (less than 10k square feet delivered from 2013) has flattened rent demand among the Island’s properties, but vacancy remains relatively low at 2% in 2021. This is consistent with the broader MSA; however, regional development of office properties picked up significantly over this period, adding 280k square feet from 2013. 4.7% $26.39 $25.61 $18.92 $18.19 $15.95 $14.85 $16.57 $16.00 $19.42 $17.55 $19.89 $19.62 3.2% 2.6% 3.1% 3.5% 3.5% 5.0% 4.4% 5.4% 7.1% 2017 2017 HHI HHI MSA 2018 2018 2019 2019 2020 2020 2021 2021 2022 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $30 VACANCY RATE 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8% Source: Costar RETAIL VACANCY RATES & RENT DEMAND COMPARISONS RENT DEMAND PER SQ FT PERCENT DECREASE IN RETAIL RENT, 2013 TO 2022 7.6% Rent for retail product has decreased by 7.6% on Hilton Head Island from 2013 to 2022. 44 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 45 TOPIC D: REAL ESTATE Page 59 of 174 8 Peak and shoulder seasons for visitors are lengthening into a year-round market. • The off-season average daily rate nearly doubled over the past decade, while the peak season average grew by 75%. During the off- season between September 2021 and April 2022, the average daily rate was $208, compared with $291 during the 2022 peak season. • Approximately one-third of visitors rent villas or homes and another quarter own second homes on the Island, while hotels and resorts hosted approximately 18% of visitors in 2021. • The difference between average peak season and off-season occupancy rates have also narrowed over the past ten years, shrinking from a variation of more than 25% to one of 18% by 2022. 9 The market is growing for year-round residents and a longer visitor season. • While population growth has plateaued in recent years, the shift to a more permanent resident population will influence the real estate market. • Businesses supporting the flourishing tourism economy will continue to be in demand, but there is also a growing need for businesses offering services and goods that support residents’ everyday lives. • As aging properties become obsolete, especially those in key locations along William Hilton Parkway, they become more attractive for redevelopment. Managing short-term rentals Starting in 2023, all short-term rental properties are required to obtain a yearly permit from the Town. This includes any privately owned residential property used as a vacation home and rented to transient occupants for periods of less than 30 days. The purpose of the permit is to “minimize the adverse effects of rental uses on surrounding residential properties and neighborhoods, and to preserve the character, integrity, and stability of residential neighborhoods” (HHI Code of Ordinances, Sec. 10-2-10). Credit: Conde Nast Traveler LODGING TOTALS 36% rooms independently owned 24% rooms owned by other hotels and resorts Average Daily Rates, 2022 Off-season: $208 Peak-season: $291 40% hotel rooms owned by Marriott (e.g., Marriott Hilton Head Resort and Spa, Springhill Suites) ~7,000 short-term rental units ~5,400 hotel rooms across 30 properties Source: Kimley-Horn 44 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 45 Page 60 of 174 4646 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 47 Page 61 of 174 TOPIC E NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT The natural and cultural environment are at the center of the Island’s identity. This section presents trends within each critical system. This section focuses on the Island’s environment and large-scale phenomena like climate change. It also considers important information related to the cultural legacy of the Island’s early residents. Over centuries of settling and modern development, residents have learned to work with the Island’s unique systems and ecology. It can be a difficult task: a barrier island like Hilton Head Island moves with the wind, the tides, and time. Its systems, like its people, evolve. Leaders have found success when working with, rather than against, the Island dynamic. These ebbs and flows—like the tidal rhythm—are what make the Island so unique and so cherished. KEY TRENDS 1 Sea level rise will increase the pressure on Island systems and will require ongoing, proactive monitoring and management. 2 Secondary impacts of climate change affect multiple environmental and ecological systems. 3 Water quality is responding positively to pollution mitigation efforts. 4 The Island’s canopy cover percentage far outperforms similar communities and is growing. 5 Protection and conservation practices and programs have a direct, positive impact on wildlife. 6 The Island’s beach management and renourishment practices are critical long-term investments. 7 The Town has committed to providing best-in- class parks and recreation resources. 8 Cultural sites continue to be an important asset and underscore the urgent need for neighborhood preservation. 46 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 47 Page 62 of 174 2 feet Potential sea level rise by 2050 Source: National Hurricane Center CATEGORY 2 HURRICANE STORM SURGE UNDER 2050 CONDITIONS 1 William Hilton PkwyWilliam Hilton Pkwy Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy Pope AvePope Ave Atlantic OceanAtlantic Ocean Skull Creek Skull Creek In the next several decades, climate change could bring about a global sea level rise as temperature averages increase and polar and glacial ice recedes. As a coastal community, it will be critical for Hilton Head Island to actively monitor and manage this process as it impacts the Island’s systems both directly through storms and tides, and indirectly through insurance increases, saltwater intrusion, and other processes. Water, driven by storms or tides, can wreak havoc on the built environment and utility networks. Small increases in sea level can radically increase the impact of storm surge events. Just two feet of sea level rise (models vary between one and four feet) would greatly increase the levels of inundation (shown as grey on the map on the right) for a category 2 hurricane. While these events are relatively rare, Hurricane Matthew hit the Island in 2016 with category 2 wind gusts, causing widespread damage from wind and water. In preparing for future storms, the Town must be prepared for more inundation and related damage. Por t R o y a l S o u n dPor t R o y a l S o u n d Port Royal Sound Port Royal Sound Calibogue Sound Calibogue Sound B road Creek B road Creek Damage from the 2016 storm Hurricane Matthew. Credit: Island Club of Hilton Head KEY Areas of potential inundation by a category 2 storm surge under potential 2050 sea level conditions 48 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 49 TOPIC E: NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT Page 63 of 174 2 Secondary impacts of climate change affect multiple environmental and ecological systems. • “King Tide” is a non-scientific term describing the highest seasonal tides that occur each year. While predicted high tides in South Carolina for 2023 average approximately 5 feet, a King Tide event may bring tides of 7 feet or higher to shore. Rising sea levels may cause an increase in the frequency and severity of King Tide events. • Climate models predict lower levels of overall precipitation in the Carolinas through the next 50 years with the potential for punctuating drought events, especially in late summer. • With a changing environment comes questions surrounding utility resilience. In 2022, Beaufort County received a $300,000 grant from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Climate Program Office to fund a study of sea level rise impacts on groundwater and buried utilities such as water and electric. • Because flooding will increase in coastal areas as sea levels rise, it is likely that insurance rates will increase. More frequent storms could lead to an increase in the deductible for wind damage in homeowner’s insurance policies, or much higher premiums for communities like Hilton Head Island where storm damage is not just possible but likely. • Large storms and tides accelerate natural erosion processes, especially for coastal communities. Rapid erosion of coastlines poses a threat to beach front properties and tourism industries alike. • As sea levels rise, many of the coastal wetlands and salt marshes may turn to open water and alter the ecosystems where many shellfish, birds, and fish reside. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), high tide frequency in Charleston, SC, has gone from 0-2 days in 2000 to 5-10 days in 2020. Photo Credit: Collins Group Realty South Carolina’s sea level is rising about 1 to 1.5 inches every decade, and is predicted to rise between one and four feet over the next century. (NOAA) Photo Credit: WCIV 48 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 49 Page 64 of 174 IMPERVIOUS SURFACE COVERAGE 19% Land area covered in roads or buildings 3 Water quality is responding positively to pollution mitigation efforts. • The Island is covered by 13 watersheds, each draining to the ocean through a central creek system or artificial outfall. • By the time the Town was incorporated in 1983, large-scale development and the expansion of impervious surfaces had greatly reduced water quality, especially within Broad Creek and the Calibogue Sound. • The 2002 Broad Creek Management Plan sought to reverse pollution trends in one of the Island’s central natural resources. This plan identified two primary pollutant sources: bacteria leaching from failing septic systems and nutrient runoff from excessive fertilizer application. • The 2004 Master Sewer Plan kicked off a major capital works campaign to connect unserved parcels to the sewer network and to educate residents and golf course management on the costs of over-fertilization. • Water quality for the creek and sound has responded and improved based on ongoing monitoring. Impact of impervious surfaces Impervious surfaces—paved or built areas where water is prevented from percolating into the ground—cover nearly one-fifth of the Island. While this percentage is low compared to similarly developed communities, the EPA reports that when impervious surfaces reach 10% to 20% of a local watershed, surface runoff doubles. This is the level where both stream and wetland degradation begins, with freshwater wetland habitat suffering impairments once the imperviousness of its local drainage basin is impacted. The Town has begun to address this issue through the use of permeable paver technology, rainwater capture, special plantings, and other technologies. Wetlands and marshes like the one pictured here are increasingly threatened by excess storm runoff. Credit: The Island Packet Since 1958, the amount of precipitation during heavy rainstorms has increased by 27% in the Southeast. (NOAA) Photo Credit: The Island Packet 50 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 51 TOPIC E: NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT Page 65 of 174 4 The Island’s tree canopy cover percentage far outperforms similar communities and is growing. • The Lowcountry Maritime Forest is abundant and rich with species diversity. Common trees include the live oak, loblolly pine, slash pine, cabbage palmetto, southern red cedar, and magnolia. • The Island’s canopy coverage (the share of land covered by leafed- out canopy of a tree) is around 50% of the overall land area—nearly double the national average of 27%. • The Canopy Mapping and Potential Planting Area Study (completed by Green Infrastructure Center, Inc.) of 2022 identified an additional 300+ acres that could accommodate new plantings. This is an exceedingly low acreage given the size of the Island and reflects the existing canopy coverage on the Island. • Through its Tree Ordinance, the Town regulates individual tree removal in lands within its purview and promotes plantings. • Storms are an ongoing threat. The Island lost more than 120,000 trees during Hurricane Matthew in 2016. • Finally, diseases, infestations, and saltwater intrusion also impact the coverage total. ISLAND TREE CANOPY COVER 50% Half of the Island's land area is covered by trees TREE CANOPY COVERAGE Source: Green Infrastructure Center, Inc. KEY LAND COVER Tree Canopy Developed Pope AvePope Ave Atlantic OceanAtlantic Ocean Skull Creek Skull Creek Port Royal Sound Port Royal Sound Calibogue Sound Calibogue Sound B road Creek B road Creek William Hilton PkwyWilliam Hilton Pkwy Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy 50 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 51 Page 66 of 174 5 Protection and conservation practices and programs have a direct, positive impact on wildlife. • One of the most important wildlife protection initiatives in the Town is the Sea Turtle Protection Ordinance. From May to October the Town requires those with beach-facing properties to turn off exterior lights and close blinds or curtains to limit light leak onto the beach, which can disorient turtles as they make their return to the water. • According to nest monitoring data from SCDNR, Hilton Head Island’s sea turtle nests had a 93.5% success rate in 2022, up from 85% in 2009. Several groups of volunteers help to ensure the safety of the sea turtles on the Island’s beaches. Sea turtles are often considered keystone species in marine ecosystems, and protecting them can have positive effects on other species and the overall ecosystem. 6 The Island’s beach management and renourishment practices are critical long-term investments. • Hilton Head Island is transgressive much like moving desert dunes just at a far larger scale. The Island has moved slowly toward the mainland over the previous millenia. This means the Island’s beaches require some infrequent but proactive maintenance to ensure their longevity and health. • The Hilton Head Island Beach Renourishment Program is a recurring effort to maintain the quality and size of the beaches on the Island. The program involves dredging sand from offshore locations and placing it on the beach to combat erosion and storm damage. Funding is procured through a combination of federal, state, and local sources. • The most recent project took place in 2016 and added approximately 2.6 million cubic yards of sand to the beaches. These efforts are essential for preserving property values in the area and protecting the Island’s main tourist attraction. SEA TURTLE NESTS, 2022 423 According to preliminary data from South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) Beach Renourishment Program Starting in 1990, the Town has performed three major beach renourishment projects. Program totals: • 10.7 million cubic yards of sand placed • Shorefront is 200 yards wider than before 1990 • Construction costs to date: $60 million • Value of First Tier shorefront: $3 billion 52 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 53 TOPIC E: NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT Page 67 of 174 7 The Town has committed to providing best-in- class parks. • As of 2020, the Town owns 548 acres of public park space, which equates to roughly 14.5 acres per 1,000 residents. • The Town completed its newest park, Lowcountry Celebration Park, in December of 2020. The 10-acre site features an open pavilion and lawn, playground, perimeter walk, fitness stations, and more. • Park improvements have been guided by the 2020 Parks and Recreation Master Plan, which was completed in tandem with the recent Comprehensive Plan. • The Parks and Recreation Master Plan identified three major focus areas for park improvements on the Island: improvements at Chaplin Park and Crossings Park, a new racquets facility, and a proposed new park located on the Town-owned Mid-Island Tract. Proposed programming for these three projects can be found on the Town website, as well as in conceptual plans for the Mid- Island Tract. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island Parks and Recreation Master Plan Community Parks 4 PARKS, 141 ACRES Other Parks 2 PARKS, 11 ACRES Beach Parks 5 PARKS, 58 ACRES Sports Parks 4 PARKS, 90 ACRES 33% Special Use Parks 5 PARKS, 109 ACRES Neighborhood Parks 3 PARKS, 12 ACRES 25% 3% 3% 22% PUBLIC PARKS BY TYPE 14% 14.5 9.9 Island park acreage per 1,000 residents National Recreation and Parks Association standard 52 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 53 Page 68 of 174 8 Cultural sites continue to be an important asset and underscore the urgent need for neighborhood preservation. • Before Captain William Hilton’s arrival in 1663, Native Americans lived on the Island, and evidence points to the presence of people on the Island as early as 4,000 years ago. While little is known of these early civilizations, remnants of mysterious shell rings can still be found on the Island. • By 1860, there were 24 plantations on the Island. • When federal forces took control of the Island, General Ormsby Mitchel helped lay the foundations for Mitchelville, the first of 14 historic Gullah neighborhoods on the Island and the first self- governing town of formerly enslaved African Americans. • The Island has many opportunities to engage with history and culture. The Gullah Museum of Hilton Head is dedicated to maintaining the Gullah customs, traditions, language, stories, songs, and structures on the Island. The museum offers guided tours and hosts events and educational activities. Annual festivals, such as the Hilton Head Island Gullah Celebration, showcase the cultural traditions of the Gullah people. Other ways to engage include National Historic Sites and public art. • The Town has several initiatives to preserve Gullah culture, including the Gullah-Geechee Land and Cultural Preservation Task Force, the Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhoods Community Development Corporation, and other initiatives. The Town’s Office of Cultural Affairs features Gullah Heritage sites on their Cultural Trail Map, which can be found on the office’s website. Land and Cultural Preservation Task Force In 2017 the Town established the Gullah-Geechee Land and Cultural Preservation Task force in response to the significant loss of Gullah population. The task force works toward preserving Gullah culture and improving their quality of life. Specific areas of interest include solving issues related to the heir property, taxes and land use, and providing on-going educational opportunities. The task force is under the jurisdiction of the Planning Commission and consists of three Commission members, three Native Islanders, and three members from organizations that deal with Gullah Geechee or Native Island culture. The Task Force, pictured here, was celebrated for Black History Month. Credit: Town of Hilton Head Island. HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS ACREAGE 2,500 The 14 historic Gullah Geechee neighborhoods on Island make up a little over 2,500 acres, over 1,000 of which are still Gullah owned. Historic Mitchelville Freedom Park celebrates the location of the first freedmen community in the country, established on the northern part of the Island during the Civil War. 54 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 55 TOPIC E: NATURAL & CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT Page 69 of 174 Source: Planning Team Research and Analysis PARKS & HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS SQUIRE POPE BIG STONEY LITTLE STONEY JONESVILLE JARVIS OLD HOUSE CREEK SPANISH WELLS CHAPLIN GARDNER Jarvis Creek Crossings Chaplin Lowcountry Celebration MARSHLAND GRASSLAND BIG HILL MITCHELVILLE BAYGALL KEY HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS Town Parks (major parks labeled) Golf Courses FUTURE: The Mid-Island Tract This 100+ acre site will be home to the Island's newest park. The site will combine active and passive elements for residents and visitors that will integrate and celebrate the Historic Neighborhood’s vibrant culture. Lowcountry Celebration Park Opened in December 2020 and situated on a 10-acre site off Pope Avenue near the Coligny Beach parking lot, this is the Town's newest park. HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS 14 Clustered together on the north end of Hilton Head Island, they make up what have traditionally been called the Native Islander communities Mitchelville Beach & Barker Field Historic Sites Historic structures and sites help tell the rich cultural story on the Island and fuel the history and culture that continues today. 54 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 55 Page 70 of 174 56 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 57 Page 71 of 174 TOPIC F HOUSING Housing and neighborhoods are the essential building blocks of strong communities. A home is more than real estate; it is the foundation on which families, livelihoods, and a strong citizenry are built. By analyzing the products, sales activity, and development pressures, there’s an opportunity to better understand the critical trends that will impact the real estate market over the coming years. The housing market does not remain static. Within the market, movement can impact community issues like workforce development, affordability, transportation, and other areas. The Hilton Head Island housing market is quite unique. While the Island swells in its high tourism season, hosting more than 3 million visitors over the year, only about 40,000 people live on the Island full-time. At any given moment, there are more than 7,000 non-residents spending the night on the Island in hotels, villas, or more commonly, short-term rental properties. Trends like short-term rental expansion are impacting the housing market significantly. Coupled with a general increase in sales value and a fast-growing region, the Island’s housing market is under intense pressure. KEY TRENDS 1 The Island has a unique mix of housing types fueled by the hospitality and home rental markets. 2 A building boom through the ‘80s and ‘90s has given way to slower growth, especially after 2010. 3 Permits for all types of building are trending upward; residential projects are leading the way. 4 A hot—if temperamental—housing market soared upward through the COVID-19 pandemic. 5 The Island’s housing market is atypical as it includes a significant number of units that are occupied on a seasonal basis. 6 As the market pulls prices upward, housing costs are increasingly a burden 7 Naturally occurring affordable housing is under threat from redevelopment. 56 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 57 Page 72 of 174 34,665 Total housing units From 2000, the Town added just over 10,000 new dwelling units spread across multiple product types (single-family detached, duplex, apartment, etc.). The majority of these units were added in single-family detached homes and apartments / condo complexes with 20+ units. The Town has a relatively diverse set of housing products when compared to communities around the region. This is due in large part to the significant tourism demand and the popularity of villa rental properties, as well as larger scale condominium construction. Less than half of the dwelling units on the Island are single-family detached, compared to 80% in the town of Bluffton, or 62% in Beaufort County overall. 1 Source: US Census Bureau Single-Family Detached 16,590 units Townhome 2,542 units Complex 7,885 units, 20+ unit 48% 23% 7% 3% HOUSING BY PRODUCT TYPE Mobile Homes 1,193 units Middle Housing 6,455 units, duplex to 20 unit 19% 58 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 59 TOPIC F: HOUSING Page 73 of 174 2 A building boom through the ‘80s and ‘90s has given way to slower growth, especially after 2010. • Eight out of ten homes on Hilton Head Island were built between 1970 and 2000. • Hilton Head Island experienced a building boom in housing through the 1980s. Just under 40% of the Island’s housing stock was built during this decade alone. • New home builds began to fall through the 2000s, corresponding with slowing population growth overall. • Construction has taken off in the larger region during this same period. Close to 40% of Beaufort County homes were built after 2000. 3 Permits for all types of building are trending upward; residential products are leading the way. • Permits and building activity for residential, commercial, and multifamily projects have trended upward from low points after the 2008 National Recession. • The majority of permits were issued for major and minor remodels, especially for residential properties. • The COVID-19 pandemic did very little to dampen building activity. The average total permits between 2020 and 2022 was higher than the same period eight years previous (2012 to 2014). • The Island’s yearly average has increased by about 50 permits each year from 2012, with a total average over this period of 5,200 permits per year. AVERAGE YEARLY INCREASE IN BUILDING PERMITS, 2012 TO 2022 +50 The Town issued just under 60,000 building permits over this entire period, averaging 5,200 per year HOUSING UNITS BUILT IN THE 1980s 13k This accounts for over one third of the Island’s total housing stock 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% Built before 1950 1960 to 1969 1970 to 1979 1980 to 1989 1990 to 1999 2000 to 2009 Built after 2010 BUILD DATE FOR HOUSING UNITS Source: US Census Bureau BEAUFORT CO. 81% Built between 1970 and 2000 40% County housing built after 2000 HILTON HEAD ISLAND Built before 1950 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 1960 to 1969 1970 to 1979 1980 to 1989 1990 to 1999 2000 to 2009 Built after 2010 58 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 59 Page 74 of 174 4 A hot—if temperamental—housing market soared upward through the COVID-19 pandemic. • Home value and home sale averages across all housing types saw their largest year-over-year increase ever in the years following the COVID-19 pandemic. • In 2022, the average value of housing units on the Island jumped 33% compared to the year before, considerably higher than the previous record year-to-year increase of 20%—set the year before. • The average home value tipped over $700,000 in 2022, outperforming the county average by more than $200,000 as well as every other community in the region. This intense growth in value followed national trends, but the acceleration in the Lowcountry was much greater. • The Island’s housing market demonstrates a highly elastic relationship with national economic trends. Through the 2008 National Recession, home values dipped by as much as $200,000 and did not fully recover to pre-recession values until 2021. • Limited building of new construction is another contributing factor to rising values. While permit activity has been steady through the past decade, the majority of projects are renovations compared with new builds. This is capping supply and driving demand. • Short-term rental conversion is another factor, with out-of-town or corporate purchases increasing significantly over the last five years, pushing up value across all segments. 5 The Island’s housing market is atypical as it includes a significant number of units that are occupied on a seasonal basis. • About half of the Island’s nearly 34,000 housing units are defined as “vacant,” or without a year-round occupant. This includes short term rentals, seasonal homes, and units for rent or sale without an occupant. • Based on a 2023 estimate, one in every five units on the Island is actively listed on at least one rental platform. • Short-term rental properties have quickly surpassed hotels and resorts in number of units. These properties, however, have also strained existing neighborhoods with increased parking demand, nuisance management, and other issues. SHORT-TERM RENTAL PROPERTIES COMPARED TO ALL PROPERTIES 1 in 5 Around 7,000 properties are actively permitted as short- term rentals ACTIVE SHORT-TERM RENTAL LISTINGS Source: Town of Hilton Head Island YEAR-TO-YEAR INCREASE IN HOME VALUE, 2021 TO 2022 +33% Fastest year-to-year increase in history, 20% increase in 2020 60 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 61 TOPIC F: HOUSING Page 75 of 174 $100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 $800,000 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Home Value Change - 2000 to 2022 Bluffton Hilton Head Island Hardeeville Okatie Beaufort County HOME VALUE CHANGE (2000 TO 2022) Source: Zillow.com National Home Sale / Home Value Dataset 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 $300,000 $200,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 OKATIE BEAUFORT CO. BLUFFTON The 2022 Workforce Housing Framework The latest effort to develop the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Workforce Housing Framework began fall of 2022 as a result of troubling trends around workforce housing and general affordability. Town leadership committed to a process to develop the Framework through a collaborative process with the community and key stakeholders. The “Framework” is a structure around which policies and more specific actions can be affixed and expanded. As a result of the Framework, the Town Council agreed to devote $1 million in annual funding to address the housing issue programmatically and through tangible projects. NATIONAL RECESSION COVID-19 AVERAGE HOME VALUE, 2022 $700k $200k higher than the County average and a 33% increase from the previous year HARDEEVILLE HILTON HEAD ISLAND 60 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 61 Page 76 of 174 6 As the market pulls prices upward, housing costs are increasingly a burden. • Housing affordability is determined by the percentage of an individual’s gross pay that is absorbed by housing costs. An “affordable” unit should cost no more than 30% of that individual’s or family’s total income. Households are considered “cost burdened” when their housing costs exceed this figure. • On Hilton Head Island, 40% of households are cost burdened by their housing costs. This segment increased 30% from 2000. Half of all households with service economy incomes between $35,000 and $50,000 are housing cost burdened. • Despite its location and strong real estate market, the Island has managed to preserve an affordable workforce housing segment. This is a very small portion of the Town’s overall housing stock, but this housing segment is important to working families. "WHAT'S AFFORDABLE?" BY WORKER SEGMENTS Source: US Census Bureau, 2018 Workforce Housing Strategic Plan Services Estimated 7,000 jobs in 2020 Public Sector Estimated 600 total workers Healthcare Estimated 2,400 total workers $575 $975 $1,250 Median Rent 2020 US Census $1,330 HOUSING COST-BURDENED HOUSEHOLDS 40% The share of families paying more than 30% of their income on housing has increased 30% from 2000 NATURALLY OCCURRING AFFORDABLE UNITS ~2k Estimate is based on existing properties with "affordable" rent and US Census cost-of- living estimates 7 Naturally occurring affordable housing is under threat from redevelopment and short-term rental conversion. • Naturally occurring affordable housing (NOAH) units are housing units at affordable price points that are not protected by income restrictions or state and federal subsidies. These units are “unrestricted,” meaning there is little to no protection for them to stay affordable in perpetuity. • The Island has between 1,700 and 2,475 NOAH units and just under 400 protected, income-restricted units based on planning team analysis of existing unit pricing and rental patterns. • NOAH units are increasingly under threat of redevelopment. Large-scale replacements of affordable housing units may become more common with fewer undeveloped sites remaining on the Island. 62 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 63 TOPIC F: HOUSING Page 77 of 174 “I worry about what we’ll lose when we lose this first rung of the housing ladder. ” -Former Mayor John McCann From the 2022 Workforce Housing Framework HOUSING UNIT TOTALS BY TYPE Source: Planning Team Research and Analysis Income Restricted ~400 units, 1% of total NOAH ~2,000 units, 7% of total 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 Market Rate ~31,500 units, 92% of total Source: Planning Team Research and Analysis KEY NOAH PROPERTIES INCOME RESTRICTED 200 units10 units In 2022, eviction notices were issued to roughly 300 residents of the Chimney Cove Village apartment complex on Hilton Head Island. Residents were given 30 days notice before their leases would end early. Recently, the Town worked with developers and the start date of the new project was pushed back significantly to provide over a year’s notice time to current residents. LOCATIONS OF NOAH AND INCOME-RESTRICTED HOUSING Mobile Homes 1,193 units, 3% of all housing units 55% of affordable units While not depicted in the graphic because of their relative dispersal, mobile homes make up the majority of naturally occuring affordable units on the Island. This type is most common within the Island’s 13 historic Gullah neighborhoods. 62 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 63 Page 78 of 174 64 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 65 Page 79 of 174 TOPIC G GOVERNANCE Governance refers to the exercise of authority, decision making, and the distribution of power within a society or community. It includes the institutions, policies, and practices that guide the actions of government officials and ensure that they are acting in the best interests of the people they serve. One of the youngest incorporated communities in the state of South Carolina, the Town of Hilton Head Island is celebrating its 40th birthday in 2023. Over these four decades, change has been constant. Serving this dynamic place within its even more dynamic region has required community leaders to regularly evaluate the community priorities and evolve services as necessary. Overall, proficient governance is critical for the smooth and effective functioning of any organization, whether it be a government, a corporation, or a non-profit organization. Well-governed communities are realized over time and evolve along with their citizenry. This topic explores several of the key trends related to management of the Town, including its structure, pressures, fiscal health, and department planning. KEY TRENDS 1 The Town was formally incorporated in 1983 with a mandate from voters to “regulate the pace and character” of future development. 2 As a limited-services local government, the Town both administers services directly and partners with regional entities to serve residents. 3 Emerging community challenges and needs are driving more proactive planning processes and policies from the Town. 4 The Town’s annual strategic planning cycle uses best practices to link department-level operational plans and capital investments back to the Comprehensive Plan. 5 Following two disasters—Hurricane Matthew and the COVID-19 pandemic—revenues and community investments are now growing and focusing on “normal” expenditures. 6 Fire Rescue maintains a strong and effective staff and fleet but is strained by the increasing cost of living. 64 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 65 Page 80 of 174 1983 Hilton Head Island becomes a town 1993 Town Fire and Rescue established 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2021 2022 1956 Completion of the James F. Byrnes Bridge transforms access to the Island. 1957 Sea Pines Plantation opens, becoming the first of HHI's family resorts 1983 The Town of Hilton Head is incorporated after referendum passes 60–40; Council-Manager form of government is established Ben Racusin elected first Mayor of Hilton Head Island 1985 & '87 Town adopts its first Comprehensive Plan, followed by Land Management Ordinance and Zoning Map 1982 Controversial development of prefabricated condominiums kicks off a campaign for incorporation 1 TIMELINE LEADING TO AND THROUGH INCORPORATION 1969 Beaufort County's Council push for industrial development attracts a chemical plant to be built on Victoria Bluff; Hilton Head Island Community Association is formed in opposition 1961 Spanish Wells and Port Royal Development 1990 Sea Turtle Protection Ordinance, First Beach Renourishment Project, and Town Water Management Plan are adopted “We needed greater impact in our own destiny.... ” -Ben Racusin Hilton Head's First Mayor Hilton Head Island was a place and community well before its formal incorporation in 1983. In fact, it was the wave of development on the Island that first initiated the campaign that led to incorporation. Much of the early, large-scale development occurred through the 1950s and ‘60s within master-planned communities, like Sea Pines, Spanish Wells, and Port Royal. Growth between these communities— specifically projects out of scale and character with past development—provided the impetus for incorporation in the early 1980s. Since its inception, the Town has taken a proactive approach to land regulation, environmental and cultural preservation, and strong town management practices. 66 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 67 TOPIC G: GOVERNANCE Page 81 of 174 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2021 2022 2018 & '20 Our Future Vision and Strategic Action Plan Our Plan: 2020 Comprehensive Plan 2019 Gullah Geechee Cultural Preservation Plan and Workforce Housing Strategic Plan are adopted 2022 Workforce Housing Framework, Mid-Island District Plan, and Short-Term Rental Ordinance are adopted 1995 Wetland Protection Ordinance is established 2010 Town adopts second Comprehensive Plan 2006 Congress establishes the Gullah Geechee Cultural Heritage Corridor National Heritage Area 1997 Cross Island Parkway Opens 2001 & '04 Tree City USA, Golden Acorn Award for Outstanding Forestry Program 2014 New Land Management Ordinance and Zoning Map based on the 2010 Plan is established 2 As a limited-services local government, the Town both administers services directly and partners with regional entities to serve residents. • The Town provides critical services, like fire and safety, which includes fire rescue, emergency medical services, and emergency management. • The nine boards and commissions on the Island provide guidance over areas such as zoning appeals, Gullah Geechee land and cultural preservation, and housing. • The Town outsources services like law enforcement, which is currently served by the Beaufort County Sheriff ’s Office. Other services are privatized, like recycling and waste management. TOWN RESIDENTS PER STAFF 283:1 Growth in Town staffing has not kept pace with the increase in population, visitors, and jobs since 2012 *Does not include Fire Rescue staff, which is the largest staff in most communities. Moment-in-time snapshot of totals from referenced governments, 2023. STAFF* RATIO PER RESIDENT RATIO PER VISITOR HILTON HEAD ISLAND 153 246:1 19.5k:1 BLUFFTON, SC 87 319:1 5.5k:1 ASPEN, CO 234 87:1 6.4k:1 OAK BLUFFS, MA 68 79:1 2.5k:1 Source: US Census Bureau, 2000 to 2020 Censuses, Town of Hilton Head, Think HHI and the Lowcountry. +11.2% Population +8.3% Visitors +3.9% Town staffing, 2012 to 2021 +5% Total jobs CHANGE IN TOWN STAFF & COMPARISONS TO SIMILAR COMMUNITIES 66 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 67 Page 82 of 174 3 Emerging community challenges are driving more proactive planning and policy from the Town. • The Town’s initial motivation for incorporation focused on the regulation and pace of development in areas outside of the current master-planned communities. • The Town initially limited its services to planning, permitting, and inspections, with the principal focus on managing growth and development. As the community has evolved, however, the Town has expanded its relatively tight purview to respond to new issues and trends. • The Town’s preliminary policy extensions focused heavily on environmental and wildlife protections for wetlands, sea turtles, and water quality. • In the 2000s, the community sharpened its focus on cultural preservation and its historic Gullah Geechee communities in multiple plans and policies. • Most recently, the issue of housing affordability and its relationship to other community issues, like the workforce, have manifested in several studies and policies, such as the Workforce Housing Framework. ADOPTED REPORTS, STUDIES & PLANS 13 The Town has advanced more than a dozen critical plans dealing with a wide range of community issues since 1999 Our Plan: Setting the community’s direction The Town completed its third Comprehensive Plan in 2020, entitled Our Plan. The plan builds off the Our Future visioning work completed in 2018 and sets the broad policy direction for the community for the next two decades. It recognizes that comprehensive planning is required in the state of South Carolina for incorporated communities. The plan covers a wide range of topics, including housing, economics, transportation, land use, and sustainability, while establishing goals for more specific action planning. Each year, the Town develops a Strategic Action Plan to operationalize the Comprehensive Plan. Credit: Our Plan Finding Home: A Workforce Housing Framework Short-Term Rental Permits Mid-Island District Plan Town of Hilton Head Corridors Plan Status of Gullah Geechee Top Priority Project Recommendations 68 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 69 TOPIC G: GOVERNANCE Page 83 of 174 The Town Mission The Town of Hilton Head Island’s mission is to promote the health and vitality of the community we serve through ethical and inclusive programs, policies, and actions. 4 The Town is mission-oriented and committed to regular strategic planning and capital investment. • Strategic planning is a best practice for proactive and responsive communities. • Each year, the Town revises its Strategic Action Plan to serve as a guide for staff in executing the designated Strategic Initiatives identified by the current comprehensive plan. The Strategic Action Plan encompasses all the initiatives that demand a substantial investment of administrative resources and helps to identify and prioritize capital improvement projects. • The Town’s Strategic Action Plan FY 2023-2025 identified 15 strategies and various initiatives. The plan broke these initiatives into policies, projects, and operational items. • The Capital Improvements Program for the Town is an ongoing process to identify, fund, and implement capital projects, like new parks and pathways, roadway improvements, and improvements to Town facilities and equipment. • In fiscal year 2022-23, there were 46 total projects, totaling $46.5 million, spent across seven different project categories: parks, roadways, pathways, fleet, facilities and equipment, beach, and land acquisition. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM INITIATIVES 46 $46.5 million in projects averaging $1M per initiative STRATEGIC PLANNING PURPOSE AND PROCESS Source: Town of Hilton Head Island Strategic Plan Development Reviewing progress, reflecting on ideals and priorities (Our Plan + Addl. Policy), setting annual priorities Budget Priorities Evaluating the action agenda based on Town budget planning (capital improvements, operating costs, etc.) Scheduling & Contracts Operationalizing the action agenda through specific scheduling (may span multiple years) and bidding Evaluation Achievements and progress reporting for external communication (the public) and internal action review The Role of Our Plan The Comprehensive Plan is the foundational policy guide for community development. The plan is a recurring reference and justification for specific action implementation. Strategy Identification Focusing action agenda to critical projects, policies, and programs pertinent to values Strategic Management Close oversight over implementation process of physical projects (CIP), and/or policy development 68 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 69 Page 84 of 174 5 Revenues and community investments have increased and returned to pre-pandemic “normals”. • With its 2023 budget totaling $119 million, the Town expenditure per capita for Hilton Head Island is just over $3,100 per resident. • If compared to the country’s 100 largest cities, the Town would rank 21st in spending per citizen. This level of investment has been enabled by strong growth in revenues and the Town’s ability to focus on non-emergency spending. • Hurricane Matthew in 2016 and the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 redirected significant portions of the Town’s expenditures to disaster recovery and crisis management. • The 2022-23 fiscal year expenditure plan represents a return to “normal” investments in critical community programs and a robust capital improvements campaign. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island$ in Millions 2012 0 20 30 40 50 60 10 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Property Tax Accommodations Tax Hospitality Tax GOVERNMENTAL TAX REVENUES BY SOURCE Parks $13.8m Roadways $8.15m Pathways $4.7m Beaches $2.85m Equipment $2.84m Facilities $3.5m Fleet $8.17m Housing $1.38m Land Acquisition $300k CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS BUDGET, 2022 Source: Town of Hilton Head Island RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES BY TAX MILLAGE As per the Beaufort County Treasurer’s Office, properties in Beaufort County, both residential and commercial, are subject to a standard assessment rate of 6% for taxation. However, owner-occupied legal residences may be eligible for a reduced 4% Special Assessment Ratio. The chart right shows how Island property is divided by the 4 and 6% tax millage brackets. 6% TAX MILLAGE 4% TAX MILLAGE* TOTAL PROPERTIES 27,886 13,209 SINGLE FAMILY 5,308 9,711 CONDO 11,217 2,835 TOWNHOUSE 598 471 OTHER (ALL OTHER LAND USES) 8,432 192 * Owner Occupied Legal Residences 70 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 71 TOPIC G: GOVERNANCE Page 85 of 174 6 The Fire Rescue Department prioritizes staffing needs in its strategic plan, underscoring housing affordability needs. • The Hilton Head Island Fire District and the Sea Pines–Forest Beach Fire Department were both established in 1969; the Hilton Head Island Rescue Squad was established in 1970. In 1993, these three departments were merged to form what is now Hilton Head Island Fire Rescue. The department’s core programs include emergency medical services, fire suppression and investigation, fire rescue 911 communications, domestic preparedness, hazardous materials mitigation, and public education. • One of the goals identified by Hilton Head Island Fire Rescue 2024 to 2026 Strategic Plan is to “create the appropriate staffing model to fulfill the needs of the department and best serve the community.” A major hurdle to achieving this goal is the rising cost of living on the Island. Based on the current entry-level firefighter and EMT salaries and the median rent on the Island, employees are spending over 30% of their monthly income on housing. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island 4 HQ 5 3 6 1 7 2 FIRE RESCUE STAFF PER 1,000 RESIDENTS 2.6 With average Island occupancy, including visitors, the Town maintains an above-standard ratio or staffing per resident FIRE STATION LOCATIONS FACILITY BUILT NOTES Headquarters 2001 The Fire Rescue Headquarters accommodates all administrative staff and houses the department’s maintenance facility. Station 1 2011 Station One operates with a minimum staffing of four firefighters. The station employs a split crew model, with two personnel addressing EMS calls on the medic unit while keeping the fire apparatus in service with the remaining two. All four staff members respond to fire-related calls on the fire apparatus, temporarily placing the medic unit out of service. Equipment at the station includes Engine-1, Medic-1, and Rescue-1. Station 2 2021 Built to withstand seismic activity, high winds, and storm surges, Station 2 maximizes elevation for additional staff during emergencies. The station houses a fire engine and EMS vehicle, operating on a split crew model for efficient responses to both EMS and fire-related calls. Station 3 2000 Using a cross-staffed model, all three personnel respond to either the engine for fire- related calls or the medic unit for EMS calls. Equipment at the station includes Engine-3 and Medic-3. Station 4 2005 With a minimum daily staffing of three firefighters, the station employs a cross-staffed model. The equipment includes Engine-4 and Medic-4. Station 5 2011 Station Five maintains a minimum daily staffing of four firefighters. Operating with a split crew model, two personnel respond to the medic unit for EMS calls, while the remaining two keep the fire apparatus in service. All four staff members respond to fire-related calls, temporarily placing the medic unit out of service. The equipment at the station includes Engine-5 and Medic-5. Station 6 2014 Station has a minimum daily staffing of seven firefighters. Four personnel respond to either the engine for fire-related calls or the medic unit for EMS calls. The equipment includes Engine-6, Medic-6, Truck-6, and Hazmat-2. Station 7 2003 Station Seven maintains a minimum daily staffing of three firefighters. The equipment includes Engine-7, Medic-7, and Battalion-1, which oversees daily shift personnel for all stations. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island 70 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 71 Page 86 of 174 72 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 73 Page 87 of 174 TOPIC H COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT The Town has involved its residents and stakeholders in creating a shared vision for the future of the Island, addressing major issues like utility provision, environmental and wildlife protection, transportation and Island access, and more recently, housing affordability and workforce support. Conversations within the communities of Hilton Head Island are what first initiated the Island’s steps toward incorporation. These discussions over what the place ought to look or feel like in the future set off a series of conversations that eventually culminated in the 1983 incorporation referendum. The actions of the early 1980s were the result of a community movement built around grassroots engagement and iterative conversation. As the community continues to grow—albeit more slowly— and evolve, the need for this ongoing dialogue remains. The community is quite active compared to its peers around the region and eager to contribute ideas to the wide range of Town-initiated and regional processes. This section provides an assessment of past community engagement efforts, a review of the communication practices and channels, an overview of the major audiences or segments within the community, and a highlight of the harder-to-reach communities on the Island. KEY TRENDS 1 The Hilton Head Island community is intensely engaged in planning efforts, far beyond its Lowcountry peers. 2 The Town is committed to facilitating community conversations through its engagement processes. 3 The Town uses multiple platforms to proactively communicate important messages. 4 The Island’s community tapestry make-up (an analytical model designed to categorizing communities) reveals a diverse and unique segmentation. 5 Some groups living on the Island are harder to reach than others when it comes to gathering community input. 6 The Island Recreation Association produces, provides, and coordinates public recreation programs through a unique, non-profit model. 72 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 73 Page 88 of 174 5,400+ Hours of conversation The Town’s community engagement effort leading to the adoption of Our Plan, the Town’s 2020 comprehensive plan, was deep and exhaustive. Outreach began in March 2017. In the span of nine months, there were over 4,500 hours of community engagement activities, which ultimately led to the adoption of Hilton Head Island’s Our Future, the vision and strategic action plan. This thorough assessment of the community’s values set the groundwork to pursue a second round of engagement in order to create the new comprehensive plan. In 2019, the Town developed eight work groups that met twice monthly for eight months. These groups were composed of eight to twelve diverse community members who worked to develop goals and strategies for the plan based on the values previously established. In concert with this effort, staff held seven public open houses, attended festivals and pop-up activities, and facilitated several online modes of engagement to keep the public informed and involved. These efforts culminated in the adoption of Our Plan in October 2020. Hilton Head Island’s recent engagement efforts fare well when compared to the rest of the Lowcountry. For example, Beaufort County’s comprehensive planning community engagement process reached 3,900 people, less than 1% of its total population. A community engagement session with young professionals for the Our Future initiative 1 The Town’s community engagement activities go beyond public hearings; specialized work groups focused on representation and inclusivity convene to participate in collaborative, interactive activities related to the planning process. Photo Credit: Our Plan COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 11% Total Island population reached during Our Plan community engagement 74 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 75 TOPIC H: COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT Page 89 of 174 2 The Town is committed to facilitating community conversations through its engagement processes. • The values for Our Future, the 2018 vision and strategic action plan, were derived from community discussions that started broad but gradually narrowed in on the emerging key themes and shared aspirations for the Island’s future. • The Our Future and Our Plan community engagement process was two years long and involved the Town Council, a community vision process consultant, a vision project management team of diverse community leaders, and the broader Hilton Head Island community. • The Town Council required transparency in the Our Future community engagement process. Our Plan identified transparency as a key idea for shaping excellence, one of the plan’s core values. • In October of 2022 the Town Staff convened 35 housing stakeholders to participate in a two-day workforce housing charrette. This community participation of public, private, and philanthropic groups led to the development of major components of the final Workforce Housing Framework strategy. PLAN NAME YEAR MID-ISLAND DISTRICT PLAN 2022 OUR PLAN - COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 2020 LOWCOUNTRY NATURAL HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN 2020 PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN 2020 HILTON HEAD ISLAND FIRE RESCUE 2019-2024 STRATEGIC PLAN 2019 WORKFORCE HOUSING STRATEGIC PLAN 2019 GULLAH GEECHEE CULTURAL PRESERVATION PROJECT REPORT 2019 OUR FUTURE VISION AND STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN 2018 RECENT ENGAGEMENT EFFORTS ORGANIZATION TYPE IMPACT / REACH COMMUNITY FOUNDATION FOR THE LOWCOUNTRY PHILANTHROPIC ORGANIZATION 445 active funds NEIGHBORHOOD OUTREACH CONNECTION LOW-INCOME SUPPORT RESOURCE 10,000 people served since 2008 THE DEEP WELL PROJECT EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE 170+ active volunteers LIFELONG LEARNING OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND CONTINUING EDUCATION 1,400+ members SECOND HELPINGS FOOD RESCUE & DISTRIBUTION 325+ volunteers FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF HILTON HEAD OLDEST CHURCH ON THE ISLAND 300+ members CONGREGATION BETH YAM JEWISH HOUSE OF WORSHIP 300+ members ACTIVE COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS STRATEGIC INITIATIVES 65 Each initiative identified for the 2023–25 fiscal year was informed by the community's input 74 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 75 Page 90 of 174 For Our Place Is welcoming, inclusive, values diversity, safe, and people focused. Is recognized as an excellent place to live, work, and visit. Preserves, values, and recognizes its history. Attracts businesses and residents who identify with and appreciate the Hilton Head Island community Ideals of Excellence and Core Values. Is recognized as a best-in-class destination where visitors are welcomed and the economic impact of tourism is valued. Protects the natural environment as a unique quality of our identity. For Our People Prioritizes the greater good. Attracts and maintains a diverse and multi-dimensional residential population, providing a competitive live-work option. Recognizes the benefit and value of arts, culture, recreation, healthy living, and education for the community. For Our Planning and Process Fosters a collaborative, transparent, and inclusive environment when resolving concerns or planning for the future. Considers sustainability as foundational to the Island’s development and redevelopment of environmental and economic projects and policies. Fosters a spirit of inspiration and leads by example. Uses innovation and learning to continually develop and apply best practices and standards for processes and projects. Continually adapts to the Core Values and Comprehensive Plan to meet the needs of the present and future. Environmental Sustainability Revitalize Economy Inclusive Community Connected Community Regional Focus Pursuit of Excellence'Right-sized' Infrastructure STRATEGIC ACTION PLAN CORE VALUES Source: Town of Hilton Head Island Strategic Action Plan, FY 2021-22. The Strategic Action Plan lays out in detail the activities the Town staff and associated agencies need to carry out in order to implement the Town Council’s policy directions. It is focused on all initiatives that are not capital improvement projects and require a significant investment of staff support, and helps ensure that staff have sufficient time and resources necessary to successfully meet expectations. HILTON HEAD ISLAND IDEALS OF EXCELLENCE Source: Town of Hilton Head Island Strategic Action Plan, FY 2021-22. The Ideals of Excellence are the foundational tools which uphold one of Hilton Head Island’s seven Core Values: the relentless pursuit of excellence. These ideals, set forth by the community, are statements of intention for the future growth and development of the Town. The Town’s intention is to be a community that... 76 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 77 TOPIC H: COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT Page 91 of 174 3 The Town utilizes multiple platforms to communicate important messages. • In February 2022, the Town released the MyHHI Mobile App, which lets community members report nonemergency issues to the Town. Not only does this let citizens directly connect with the Town administration, it is also used to spread emergency announcements. • Beyond the app, the Town has seven social media accounts with a combined total of over 46,600 subscribers / followers. The Town’s Visitor & Convention Bureau Facebook page, Visit Hilton Head, has 235,000 likes and 236,000 followers. • Direct communication from the government allows emergency communication to reach residents quickly, which is crucial during hurricane season when conditions are dangerous. • The 2020 comprehensive plan also identified transparency as a key idea for shaping excellence, one of its core values. Facebook 34,000 followers Active since 2015 NextDoor 1,453 neighbors Twitter 8,296 followers Active since 2009 Instagram 1,248 followers 105 posts YouTube 841 subscribers 50,000+ total views LinkedIn 2,272 followers SOCIAL MEDIA PRESENCE AND REACH AS OF JANUARY 2023 Source: Planning Team Research & Analysis MyHHI Mobile App The MyHHI Mobile App lets citizens report nonemergency issues to the Town via their smartphone, tablet, or computer. This immediate line of communication also allows the Town to alert the community in the event of natural disasters and emergency situations. TOWN FACEBOOK FOLLOWERS 38k Total followers of the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Government facebook page have grown steadiliy since its launch 76 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 77 Page 92 of 174 4 The Island’s community tapestry make-up reveals a diverse and unique segmentation. • The Community Tapestry model is designed to categorize neighborhoods and communities in the United States based on a combination of demographic and socioeconomic characteristics. This tool (developed by the Environmental Systems Research Institute) helps businesses tailor their marketing strategies and locate consumer markets based on spending patterns. • Hilton Head Island is relatively unique in that a majority of the population, 61.4%, fall into one segment. This segment, “Silver & Gold,” is made up of seniors with money to spend. They have retired to sunnier climates and have free time and resources. Implications of a large segment of this population are more on-Island healthcare needs and higher spending on luxury items and convenience services. • The next largest portion of the population, 7.8%, falls into the Emerald City segment. These young professionals are often renters and enjoy the cultural offerings of the community. This could mean there is an opportunity for more engagement in arts on the Island, as well as shared workspace offices for remote employees. • Following behind is the Bright Young Professionals segment at 5.4% of the population. These working families have median household incomes, home values, and rent averages close to US figures. They are potential homebuyers if affordable housing options are available, and their children make up large portions of the school system. TAPESTRY SEGMENTATION ISLAND'S SILVER & GOLD POPULATION 61.4% This segment is significantly larger on the Island than anywhere else in the country Silver & Gold Median Age: 63.2 Median Household Income: $72,100 Median Net Worth: $357,100 Average Household Size: 2.03 Emerald City Median Age: 37.4 Median Household Income: $59,200 Median Net Worth: $52,700 Average Household Size: 2.06 Bright Young Professionals Median Age: 33 Median Household Income: $54,000 Median Net Worth: $34,200 Average Household Size: 2.41 Other Tapestry Groups Metro Fusion Savvy Suburbanites In Style NeWest Residents Retirement Communities Up and Coming Families The Great Outdoors City Lights Golden Years Young and Restless Old and Newcomers Exurbanites Source: Esri Esri’s Tapestry Segmentation tool provides a detailed description of US neighborhoods based on their socioeconomic and demographic composition. The model uses a unique classification system that divides the U.S. population into distinct segments, each characterized by specific traits, behaviors, and preferences. The segmentation is based on a wide range of variables, including income, education, age, housing, and lifestyle preferences. The goal is to provide a more nuanced and detailed understanding of the diversity within communities. 61% 8% 5% 25% 78 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 79 TOPIC H: COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT Page 93 of 174 5 Some community groups on the Island are not being reached as often as others. • Some groups on the Island are harder to reach than others when it comes to gathering community input. Hard-to-reach groups include the native Gullah Geechee and Hispanic / Latino populations, as well as workers from the greater Beaufort County area who commute to the Island. • In a race and ethnicity breakdown of the 2018 Our Future vision & strategic action plan, only 3.3% of the community survey respondents were Hispanic / Latino, and 2.2% were Native Islanders. No data was collected regarding the number of respondents who work but do not live on Hilton Head Island. • The Hispanic population on the Island has grown more than 28% from 2000 to 2020 and does not show signs of slowing. Like any group, they have their own specific needs and hopes for the future of the Island that were not captured in proportion to their share of the population. • Conversely, the African American population has decreased by over 15% from 2000 to 2020. The Town must continue to engage this population in planning conversations in order to know what they need to reverse the trend of migration. HISPANIC & LATINO SURVEY RESPONDENTS 3.3% The percentage of survey participants for the Our Future plan who were Hispanic and Latino was significantly lower than the group's population on the Island (13.8%) Louise Cohen, director of the Gullah Museum of Hilton Head Island. Credit: Bailey Davidson Boys & Girls Club The Boys & Girls Club of Hilton Head Island has served children ages 6-18 with a host of educational and recreational programs on the Island since 1990. They currently serve 260 enrolled members in their facility, built in 1999 and funded completely through donations. The organization has a diverse membership of 42% Latino, 29% Caucasian, 28% African-American, and 1% Other. Additionally, 63% of Club members fall below the national federal poverty guidelines. The organization services the vital function of providing childcare after school and during the summer through their programming. Credit: Boys & Girls Club of Hilton Head Island 78 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 79 Page 94 of 174 6 The Island Recreation Association produces, provides, and coordinates public recreation programs through a unique, non-profit model. • In 1977, the Hilton Head Rotary Club recognized that the existing recreational programs provided by the county government were insufficient for the youth in the community. To address this issue, the Rotary Club decided to fund and build the Island Youth Center, to provide recreation programs for the youth. The Rotary Club also supported the center’s operation in its early years as it evolved into the Island Recreation Center. • By 1984, the demand for recreation had expanded to include residents of all ages, prompting the transformation of the Island Youth Center into the Hilton Head Island Recreation Association. • The Association’s Board of Directors played a crucial role in acquiring land and securing funding for the construction of the Island Recreation Center, which has been managed by the Association ever since. • In 1990, recognizing the growing recreation needs of the community, the Association partnered with the SHARE Senior Center to provide programs for the senior population. In 2013, SHARE was re-branded as Hilton Head Island Senior Center under the direction of the Island Recreation Association. • The renovations and expansion of the current Island Rec Center completed in January 2019, including a new gymnasium, classrooms, playground, fitness equipment, indoor walking track, renovated restrooms, pool restroom facilities, and other facilities. • The Association’s non-profit status is a unique model among municipal recreation programs which are typically managed directly by the Town. The non-profit is funded through a 35% grant from the Town of Hilton Head The balance is the responsibility of the Association’s Board to recover in order to deliver the best recreational services to residents and visitors alike. • The quasi-government status of the association allows for proactive and nimble program planning and the opportunity to fund-raise. This model has allowed the Association to invest in novel programs like its Carmines Family Recreation Scholarship Program. This scholarship program annually awards an average of over $280,000, supporting hundreds of families and children. The Association offer’s numerous adaptive recreation programs with more than 6,000 total participant visits in 2022. POOL AND FITNESS TOTAL MEMBERSHIPS 4,639 In 2022, there were more than 350,000 unique visits to the Hilton Head Recreation Center 2022 ASSOCIATION OPERATING BUDGET $2.9m Programs are co-funded through ongoing support from the Town of Hilton Head and through program fees and memberships 80 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 81 TOPIC H: COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT Page 95 of 174 Shifting Demographics and Recreation Programming The median age for Island residents is increasing quickly, moving from 46 in 2000 to 58 in 2020. During this period, people over 55 drove a population increase, adding just over 9,000 new residents. Every other segment decreased in size. The under-18, or school-age, population is decreasing. This segment lost 13% of its share from 2000, and the decline is reflected in public school enrollment. The school system lost 400 students from 2012 to 2022, and is experiencing its largest loss among younger students below second grade. As these changes occur, there will be rolling impacts to the types of recreation programs demanded and the volume of enrollees. The growth in popularity for sports like pickleball - a lower-impact a paddle sport combining elements of tennis and table tennis - have demonstrated the latent impact older recreation users can have on the Island’s facilities and recreational programming. The Association can expect these impacts in demand and preferences to increase through the coming decade with older users continuing to grow into the most common age segment. Credit: Rozel RECREATION FITNESS VISITS YOUTH (0-17) 45,000 ADULT (18-49) 108,426 SENIORS (50+) 94,972 RECREATION POOL VISITS YOUTH (0-17) 56,763 ADULT (18-49) 30,667 SENIORS (50+) 30,000 ISLAND RECREATION FITNESS & POOL Source: Island Recreation Association Annual Report, 2022 YOUTH PROGRAMS (SELECTION) After School Rec Club Kid’s Night Out Vacation Club E Sports Discovery Club Pre-School Swim Lessons All-Day Summer Camp ADULT PROGRAMS (SELECTION) Fitness Classes Swim Lessons Open Gym Pickleball Club Community Yoga SENIOR PROGRAMS / SENIOR CENTER PROGRAMS (SELECTION) Exercise Classes Book Club Dining Socials Craft Club Card and Board Games Painting for Fun ADAPTIVE RECREATION PROGRAMS Challenge Camp PEP Pockets Full of Sunshine ISLAND RECREATION CENTER PROGRAMMING 80 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 81 Page 96 of 174 82 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 83 HEADING: HEADING Page 97 of 174 TOPIC I SYSTEMS Without its network of visible and invisible infrastructure, modern life on Hilton Head Island would be impossible. The Island’s initial growth was predicated on reliable access to the mainland; the Town’s first bridge was completed in 1956. This spurred a wave of real estate development through the following decades. With many attracted by an oceanfront lifestyle and the Island’s natural beauty, it is ironic how central maintaining access to fresh water is to the life and sustainability of the Island today. Without access to deep wells into the Floridan aquifer, development on Hilton Head Island could never have achieved the scale it has today. However, the water cycle is both a limiting and enabling factor for growth on the Island, and the system is increasingly under threat from explosive growth on the mainland. A web of services and utilities are present on the Island, and each has its unique challenge of servicing a formerly disconnected community. The Town contracts out or plays a limited direct role in providing most of its services. The legacy of this limited-service government approach means the Town maintains very few of its own systems. While not uncommon for towns across the Lowcountry, it presents a challenge when regional direction clashes with the local vision. This topic explores the various infrastructure systems on the Island and the challenges that come with maintaining them. KEY TRENDS 1 Water use on the Island fluctuates significantly—reaching as high as 26 million gallons per day (MGD)—based on the season. 2 Saltwater infiltration poses a serious risk to long-term water extraction practices. 3 Wastewater recycling processes put treated water to use. 4 The Town’s efforts to manage stormwater have mitigated the potential increase of runoff by regulating development. 5 The Town administers very few direct services and utilities to residents. 6 The Island outperforms major indicators of health outcomes, despite an aging population. 7 Only 3% of the roads on the Island are owned and maintained by the Town, with the county and state planning for major regional projects. 8 The Island’s renowned public multi-use pathway network is well-positioned for expansion. 9 Seasonal transit services broaden access with room to grow. 82 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 83 Page 98 of 174 26 million Peak daily gallons of water usage 1 Hilton Head’s Public Service Districts divide the Island into three sections, but all three tap into the aquifers below the Earth’s surface. PUBLIC SERVICE DISTRICTS Source: Town of Hilton Head Island The Island’s source for potable water is groundwater drawn from the relatively shallow Floridan (<200 feet) and the very deep Cretaceous (>3,000 feet deep) aquifers. When islands like Hilton Head Island receive rainfall, this water infiltrates and charges a groundwater aquifer, but these unconfined sources are highly susceptible to saltwater intrusion and are not reliable long-term sources. The three Public Service Districts (PSDs) on the Island—Hilton Head, Broad Creek, and South Island—each maintain a series of deep wells that tap into confined aquifers far below the surface. On average, the three districts extract or serve a demand for 15 million gallons per day (MGD). However, peak demand can swell to 26 MGD and aligns with the high tourist season, from May to September, when the Island’s nighttime population pushes to its maximum. South Island PSD Capacity - 10.8 MGD Average demand - 6.6 MGD Remaining capacity in households - 9,347 Broad Creek PSD Capacity - 3.7 MGD Average demand - 1.8 MGD Remaining capacity in households - 5,702 Hilton Head PSD Capacity - 12.5 Average demand - 7 MGD Remaining capacity in households - 3,738 Mitigation Measures The Island’s PSD’s have taken several measures to diversify their water sources as the longevity of the Island’s main water source, the Upper Floridan Aquifer, is now compromised by saltwater intrusion. Mitigation Initatives: • Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Treatment Facility • Aquifer Storage & Recovery Facility • Groundwater hyrdogeologic modeling • Cretaceous well supply Credit: Town of Hilton Head Island Measured in million gallons per day (MGD) WASTEWATER AVERAGE DAILY DEMAND 6.4 MGD PEAK DEMAND 10.6 ROUGH CAPACITY 2.8 WASTEWATER CAPACITY Source: Hilton Head, Broad Creek, and South Island PSDs 84 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 85 TOPIC I: SYSTEMS Page 99 of 174 2 Saltwater intrusion poses a serious risk to the long-term water extraction practices. • The Hilton Head PSD has lost 10 drinking water wells to saltwater intrusion into the Upper Floridan freshwater aquifer from 2000 to 2023. • Saltwater intrusion occurs when the pressure in the groundwater system is reduced, either by excessive pumping or by natural causes, such as drought. When this happens, saltwater from the ocean or nearby coastal areas can flow into the freshwater aquifer, displacing the freshwater and increasing the salinity of the groundwater. • Only two of the utility’s four remaining Upper Floridan freshwater wells are currently unaffected by saltwater intrusion. • Saltwater intrusion can have serious consequences for communities that rely on the aquifer for their water supply, as the increased salinity can make the water unusable for drinking, irrigation, and other purposes. 3 Wastewater recycling processes put treated water to use. • Each of the Island’s three PSDs reclaims billions of gallons of treated wastewater each year. • Through a process of capture, treatment, and release, the districts are able to irrigate landscaping and golf courses across the Island and help nourish wetlands. FRESHWATER WELLS LOST TO SALTWATER INTRUSION 10 The Town has lost close to a dozen wells across its three PSDs, most recently in January 2023 RECYCLED WASTEWATER CAPTURED ANNUALLY (GALLONS) 2.2b gallons of water are recycled across the Island's three Public Service Districts for irrigation and wetland nourishment The Floridan Aquifer The Upper Floridan aquifer is a limestone, freshwater aquifer located 50 to 150 feet underground. It is one of the largest aquifers in the world, and stretches from the Beaufort area southward through the Florida Everglades. Groundwater from this aquifer requires little treatment. The PSD treats this water with chloramines directly at their well sites. Unfortunately, this aquifer has been impacted by saltwater intrusion. Credit: Hilton Head PSD 84 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 85 Page 100 of 174 OVERALL ISLAND IMPERVIOUS SURFACE 19% Includes all areas acting as infiltration funnels (parking lots, roofs, etc.) 4 The Town’s efforts to manage stormwater have mitigated the potential increase of runoff by regulating development flood risk and improving water quality by capturing pollutants at or near the surface. • Stormwater management refers to the proactive processes applied to control the discharge of rainwater back into the natural environment. • On Hilton Head Island, rain events and development projects that produce large areas of impervious surfaces can lead to large and sudden surface water runoff that is not able to naturally percolate into the soil. • Runoff can cause localized flooding, erosion, non-point pollutant discharge, and other issues. • Through its Stormwater Management Division, the Town regulates new development with respect to its impact on runoff and site retention. The water cycle So much of the life and activity on Hilton Head Island revolves around water and the water cycle. Without access to freshwater aquifers, the current scale of development on the Island may never have been possible. Above ground, managing water events is another crucial concern. In major storms or—much more rarely—hurricanes, stormwater management best practices can mitigate the risks to safety, property, and the overall health of waterways. The Town and its partner Public Service Districts have invested millions of dollars to ensure the health and resilience of these systems in the long term. Pervious parking areas, like the system picture above at Islanders Beach Park, allow rain water to percolate into the ground. This helps to re-charge ground water aquifers and minimize run-off. Credit: Town of Hilton Head Island Credit: HIltonHead.com 86 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 87 TOPIC I: SYSTEMS Page 101 of 174 Credit: Shelter Cove, Hilton Head Island 5 As a limited-services government, the Town administers few direct services to residents. • Public safety is maintained by the Beaufort County Sheriff ’s Office. While headquartered in Beaufort, a fully-staffed substation is located on the Island and includes an enforcement and investigative department. • In 2020, the County passed an ordinance to assess a special tax on property owners in the Town in order to raise the $4.4 million in revenue necessary to serve the Island. This controversial “special” assessment was the result of a study that showed rising costs to serve the Island and a need to address growing budgetary limitations. • The Town’s ten planned unit developments (PUDs) contract with South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) certified private security to provide law enforcement authority within their communities. • Some of the area’s electricity providers are Palmetto Electric Cooperative and Dominion Energy. Hargray Communications and Spectrum are among the local options for internet / phone / cable. • Over 17 years, Palmetto Electric has been working toward “underground” power distribution and to harden against storm events. It has converted just over 1,200 transformers and 115 miles from above-ground to underground systems. • Trash and recycling are managed by several private companies including: Republic Services, Capital Waste Services, and Waste Management. Businesses are required to use a private waste and recycling company. • The Hilton Head Island Convenience Center, run by Beaufort County, allows residents to drop off their trash and recycling up to three times a week per household. The Convenience Center is open 6 days a week, and closed on Wednesdays and holidays. • The Town provides other direct services not listed above, but can be found on the Town website. The Beufort County Sheriff’s Office maintains a substation at 70 Shelter Cove Lane on Hilton Head Island. In early 2015, fiber Internet infrastructure was installed on Hilton Head Island, providing residents with high-speed Internet access. Data shows that the average download speeds in the Town (157 MBPS) are currently higher than the statewide and national average, while average upload speeds (30 MBPS) are lower than the statewide and national average. Credit: New York Times 86 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 87 Page 102 of 174 6 The Island outperforms major indicators of health outcomes, despite an aging population. • The Hilton Head Regional Healthcare system maintains the Island’s 109 hospital beds. Hilton Head Hospital provides short-term acute care and provides services in orthopedics, cardiovascular health, stroke treatment, and more. • The top number of Medicare inpatients in 2022 were seen for ‘medicine,’ which encompasses less specific reasons including traumatic injury, allergic reactions, and other injuries, with an average length of stay of four days. The second largest number were seen for cardiology, with an average stay of three days. • In 2023 there are 150 physicians on the Island. Compared to the 2023 population, that is one physician for every 251 residents, and one for every 170 residents over age 44. These ratios out perform the state and national averages. 7 Only 3% of the roads on the Island are owned and maintained by the Town, with the county and state planning for major regional projects. • Of the 400 miles of roadways on the Island, the Town maintains only 14 miles. The longest, a segment of Arrow Road, runs for three- quarters of a mile from Helmsman Way to Archer Road. • Because of this division of ownership, the Town must collaborate with other entities, such as SCDOT and Beaufort County, to facilitate upgrades. For example, the Town has agreements with the state and county to remove disaster-generated debris. • Measuring from the entrance to William Hilton Parkway, the average daily traffic is 57,400 vehicles (or over 400,000 cars per week). Volumes have grown along with tourism and events, leading to some concerns about future levels of service. • SCDOT is proposing to make improvements to the US-278 corridor between Bluffton and Hilton Head Island, including the replacement of the Island’s existing gateway bridges. However, the multi-billion-dollar project has sparked a community conversation about the potential impact of the transportation project on community character. • The Town has initiated studies to develop its own standards for corridor development and to provide an alternative to the alignment of the roadway and the landing area of the state’s new proposed bridge. ROADWAY ROAD TYPE DISTANCE IN FEET ARROW ROAD Minor 4038 INDIGO RUN DRIVE Other 3727 NORTH MAIN STREET Non-arterial 3076 HONEY HORN DRIVE Non-arterial 2902 DUNNAGANS ALLEY Non-arterial 2778 CASTNET DRIVE Non-arterial 2736 SUMMIT DRIVE Non-arterial 2534 OFFICE PARK DRIVE Non-arterial 2273 HAIG POINT CIRCLE Non-arterial 2181 HOSPITAL CENTER BOULEVARD Non-arterial 2157 TOP 10 LONGEST TOWN-OWNED ROADS Source: Town of Hilton Head Island PHYSICIAN TO RESDIENTS RATIO HILTON HEAD ISLAND 1:251 SOUTH CAROLINA 1:398 UNITED STATES 1:335 Source: Association of American Medical Colleges State Physician Workforce Data Report, 2022 PHYSICIANS PER RESIDENTS, 2022 88 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 89 TOPIC I: SYSTEMS Page 103 of 174 Credit: The Island Packet Cross Island Parkway Tolls were removed from the CIP in 2021 with the expiration of the levy period. Per SCDOT , daily traffic counts across the CIP had reached an all-time high in 2023, with over 35,000 vehices a day for the month of July. WHP Gateway Corridor Project The SC Department of Transportation (SCDOT) and Beaufort County are undertaking the US 278 Gateway Corridor project to address roadway issues along US 278 from the intersection of Moss Creek Drive to the intersection of Spanish Wells Road. Working with SCDOT , the Town of Hilton Head Island and local design and transportation consultants are using local knowledge to create community-based solutions to enhance SCDOT’s preferred approach. This should aid the approximately 60,000 vehicles that use the corridor daily. Sea Pines Circle Traffic & Safety Hotspot Vehicular crashes cluster around the Sea Pines Circle area. The redesign of this intersection was an area of focus through the Corridors Planning Project. In 2022, peak midday and PM traffic caused consistent roundabout failure, where approaches from all four directions had queues in excess of 350 feet. ROADWAY CAPACITY USAGE AND PROJECTS Source: Planning Team Research and Analysis Hilton Head Airport Improvements The planned expansion of the airport's terminal will triple the internal capacity of the facility, providing three total gates and greatly expanding daily flight potential. 105% 96% 75% 71% 70% 65% 56% 49% 88% 87% 63% 54% 48% 46% 41% 109% KEY More Strained Less Strained Transporation Impact Analysis Found in Section 16 of the Town’s Land Managment Ordinance (LMO), a Transportation Impact Analysis (TIA) is a requirement for new development proposals. The intent of a TIA is to ensure that proposed developments, if approved, would not cause a street facility to fall below the Town’s adopted traffic service levels standards. 88 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 89 Page 104 of 174 MILES OF PUBLIC PATHWAY 72 The Island's pathway network is extensive and one of the country's most comprehensive 8 The Island’s renowned public multi-use pathway network is well-positioned for expansion. • Pathways are a signature feature of Hilton Head Island and are highly valued by residents and visitors. Trip Advisor ranks Hilton Head Island Bike Trails as the third most popular attraction on the Island. • The Island currently has over 70 miles of existing Town-owned pathways (some neighborhoods may benefit with improved direct access to these facilities). • The existing multi-use pathway network is extensive and interconnected, but there are opportunities to better connect to existing neighborhoods and improve safety. • Rental bikes are affordable and widely accessible. Over 30 rental shops within the Town provide nearly 15,000 bikes for rent. • The Island’s pathways provide critical multi-modal connections to neighborhoods and destinations while contributing to the creation of Complete Streets throughout the Island. • Current pathway routes are not intuitive or apparent due to missing connections and inconvenient access, and there is little adherence to best practices for pathway widths, horizontal curves, and queuing areas. • Minimal separation is provided in some areas between pathways and vehicles, including safety hazards from turning vehicles at driveways. Source: Town of Hilton Head Island Corridors Plan The design of pathways must go beyond establishing the bare minimum space requirements for various user groups. Pathways should be designed for safe usage, especially along highly- trafficked roadways. Island Schools There are five public and three private schools on the Island: Hilton Head Island Early Childhood Center, Hilton Head Island Elementary School, Hilton Head Island School for the Creative Arts, Hilton Head Island Middle School, and Hilton Head Island High School are all public schools. They are operated under the Beaufort County School District. There is a decreasing trend in enrolled capacity from the High School to the Elementary, with the High School at 98% usage, the Middle School at 85%, and the Elementary School at 63%. Credit: Hilton Head Island Elementary School 90 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 91 TOPIC I: SYSTEMS Page 105 of 174 The Breeze Trolley serves 21 stops around the Island, but its service is not evenly distributed. Aside from being a seasonal service that only operates from April to September, the trolley does not serve some key locations such as Hilton Head Island Airport. 9 Seasonal transit services broaden access, with room to grow. • Palmetto Breeze Transit services the Lowcountry, including public transportation on Hilton Head Island. • In addition to regional routes and central to mobility within the Town, the Palmetto Breeze Trolley service provides a highly efficient and sustainable alternative to car travel for employees, residents, and visitors on the island. According to the LRTA’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, in FY 2022 more than 48,000 passengers rode The Breeze Trolley, compared to nearly 27,000 in 2021. • Access to public transportation is proven to be a leading driver of increasing economic mobility for underserved communities. Palmetto Breeze’s “Ride Free - New Job Pass” provides a free, 7-day transit pass for any rider starting a new job. Initiatives such as these are centered around utilizing public transportation as a catalyst for lowering poverty rates, driving down housing costs, and increasing workforce mobility. • In 2023, the Palmetto Breeze Transit Service collected two industry awards for achievements in Transit Maintenance and Transportation Marketing. • A transit development plan prepared for the Lowcountry Council of Governments in 2018 identified higher areas of need along and northwest of Beach City Road (including Hilton Head Hospital) and the south end of the Island extending southwest of Pope Avenue. PALMETTO BREEZE TRANSIT SERVICE 8 The Island is currently serviced by eight regional routes that provide access to and from mainland locations REGIONAL EMPLOYMENT 1,730 The share of Hilton Head Island workers that live in Bluffton jumped from 7.6% in 2002 to 23.5%, or 1,730 people, in 2020 THE BREEZE TROLLEY STOPS 21 The Breeze Trolley currently serves 21 stops around the Island, with opportunities for expansion toward the airport 90 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 91 Page 106 of 174 92 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 93 Page 107 of 174 TOPIC J LAND USE Land is a community’s most important resource. Regulating the form, location, and aesthetics of development is one of a municipality’s primary responsibilities and the area where the community has the most control. This section examines the Town’s approach to this management, the opportunities presented by development and – now more commonly – redevelopment, and the current mix of land uses. The visionary work of a few planned developments in the early days of the James F . Byrne Bridge has shaped Hilton Head Island into the iconic destination that it is today. With raw development slowing down in recent decades and land availability becoming sparse, Hilton Head Island may face less of the explosive growth it witnessed in past decades, instead relying on incremental changes to meet the needs of its residents and visitors alike. This chapter explores the existing land use patterns and recent development trends on the Island. Land use and development on Hilton Head Island is regulated by a number of authorities, including the Land Management Ordinance discussed within this chapter. Zoning determines what types of development should occur on the Island and where it may be located; it is a critical component in shaping the character and productivity of the Town. While much of the land on the Island is already developed or under tight constraints that hinder development, there are many areas where the Town of Hilton Head Island can continue to grow and evolve. KEY TRENDS 1 About 7%, or 1,500 acres, of the Island’s total land area (above mean high tide) is undeveloped. Of that 1,500 acres, 28% (425 acres) is Town-Owned Property. 2 The Land Management Ordinance, in conjunction with several boards and commissions, regulates the character and desired development forms on the Island. 3 Redevelopment of aging retail centers and the addition of single-family homes are the biggest development trends on the Island. 4 Areas with the least amount of constraints to development are the biggest targets for growth and re-investment. 5 While the Island as a whole is dominated by Planned Development zoning districts, overall land use is more evenly distributed. 6 Older commercial properties are more susceptible to change or redevelopment in the near-term. 7 Housing density is slowly increasing but varies significantly across the Island’s neighborhoods. 92 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 93 Page 108 of 174 1,500 Acres of Undeveloped Land* Hilton Head Island covers 21,862 acres of land above mean high tide, but in 2023 the community is approaching “build out”. In this condition, the majority of large, unconstrained parcels have been developed or are entitled to be developed. Just over 1,500 acres, or less than 7% of the Island’s total land area is vacant or undeveloped land. This only considers properties that have never been developed and are considered ‘greenfield’ sites. The transition of land use across the Island has been shaped by several different key eras of settlement and development. Before the arrival of European settlers, Native Americans lived on Hilton Head Island seasonally. The first Europeans arrived in 1717 when the Island was sparsely populated. Following the Civil War, formerly enslaved people created a settlement on the Island with their own culture and economy, known as the Gullah-Geechee community, driven by new opportunity to own land. From the 1930s to the ‘50s, Charlie Simmons operated a ferry from Savannah to Hilton Head Island until the state ferry began operation in 1953. Development during this time was limited because the only way to reach the Island was via ferry or private boat. The James F . Byrne Bridge opened in 1956, making the Island accessible by car. Soon after, Charles E. Fraser began developing the Island’s first Planned Unit Development (PUD), Sea Pines, on the southern portion of the Island. The Bridge led to an increase of development on the Island, allowing for the addition of several PUDs, the Island’s first golf course, and the introduction of telephone service. The 1970s and ‘80s saw continued development and a dramatic increase in people: the Island added 10,000 residents between 1969 and 1982, and visitors increased by over 250,000 from 1975 to 1982. Four more PUDs were built as well as a hospital, and the bridge was expanded to accommodate more traffic. The Town of Hilton Head Island was finally incorporated in 1983 as a response to the rapid development of the Island. The Town’s chief goal was to create standards for development and implement strategies to manage growth. The population growth has been slowing down since 2000; as a result, development on the Island has taken on a new direction. 1 *Includes portions of undeveloped lots inside master planned communities such as Sea Pines or Wexford. 94 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 95 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 109 of 174 ALL BUILDING STRUCTURES BY YEAR BUILT Before 1960 1960–1980 1980–2000 After 2000 DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE LAST 5 YEARS: 2017–2022 The hotspots in red show greater concentrations of new construction within the last five years. These higher concentrations represent new residential subdivisions occurring within primarily historic neighborhoods. The maps depict the time at which all current structures on the Island (both residential and commercial) were built. Source: Planning Team Research & Analysis 94 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 95 Page 110 of 174 2 The Land Management Ordinance, in conjunction with several boards and commissions, regulates the character and desired development forms on the Island. • The Town’s Land Management Ordinance (LMO) is its instrument for guiding the development and use of land within the Town’s jurisdiction. It is the regulating power that enforces the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. • The LMO aims to promote public health, safety, and general welfare, while recognizing the rights of real property owners by adopting a comprehensive zoning ordinance for the Town and guiding administrative procedures and development standards. • Town Council votes on any amendments to the LMO, including text changes, rezoning of districts, and/or new PUD districts. In addition, a host of individuals and governing bodies influence land use decisions across the Island. There are several different boards and commissions, including the Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals, whose duties have direct land use implications. YEAR-ROUND POPULATION IN 1987 17k Slightly less than half of the Island’s population in 2023 BOARD / COMMISSION SIZE PURPOSE Planning Commission 9 members Prepares and updates Comprehensive Plan and reviews proposed zoning changes, public projects, conditional uses, street and development name changes, and traffic impact applications. Design Review Board 7 members Reviews the aesthetics of new development and renovations of existing developments in order to uphold Island character. Board of Zoning Appeals 7 members Reviews land use issues, including proposed variances from the Town’s LMO, special exception applications, and appeals of decisions made by an administrative official. Gullah-Geechee Land & Cultural Preservation Task Force 9 members Identifies and assists in the preservation of the Gullah-Geechee culture, which includes taxes, land use, heir property, and the general sustainability of the Gullah-Geechee community. Construction Board of Adjustments & Appeals 9 members Decides on appeals made against Building Official determinations as they pertain to interpretation of building and fire codes; also oversees variances from base flood elevations. William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Independent Review Advisory Committee 5 members Formed in 2023, this group plays a critical role in comprehensively reviewing the William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project. Source: Planning Team Research & Analysis BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND COMMITTEES 96 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 97 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 111 of 174 3 Redevelopment of aging retail centers and the addition of single-family homes are the biggest development trends on the Island. • Much of the significant recent residential development has entailed new single-family neighborhoods built within the Low to Medium Density Residential (RM-4) zoning district. • The minimal space left for new commercial development opportunities and an aging stock of existing buildings is leading to a critical redevelopment moment for the Island. The Towne Center at Shelter Cove highlights this trend, which is likely to continue into the next decade where traditional retail centers with are repositioned into more engaging and vibrant commercial districts. The Towne Center redevelopment transformed a traditional mall of over 350,000 square feet into an open air, pedestrian-friendly mixed-use center. In addition to completely reconfiguring the mall’s original footprint, existing roadways and parking areas adjacent to the marshland were converted into roughly 200,000 square feet of public space. • The Towne Center at Shelter Cove is an example of how the Mid-Island District Center Concept can be utilized in practice. These redevelopments aim to build upon the Island’s Lowcountry aesthetic, while also increasing access to public amenities and open space. 2013: Shelter Cove Mall 2023: Towne Center at Shelter Cove The Mid-Island District Center Concept The Town is taking proactive steps to prepare for and guide future redevelopment projects in areas - like Mid Island - where there is more susceptibility to change. The District Center concept includes a vertical mix of uses and a greater emphasis on the public realm. BEFORE AFTER 96 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 97 Page 112 of 174 4 Areas with the least amount of constraints to development are the biggest targets for growth and re-investment. • When considering constraints to development, or the edges within which development should be confined, several different criteria are taken into account, including cultural considerations, locations of public property, transportation access, and environmental factors. A Future Informed by Resiliency Planning A Resiliency Plan is a comprehensive strategy that outlines actions to help a community adapt to and mitigate the impacts of climate change. This type of plan equips the Town with a robust, scientifically-backed understanding of the dynamic elements that pose the highest risk to the Island. Resiliency is also tied to the growth of environmental liability, particularly as it pertains to real estate and the growing risk and price tag involved in financing and insuring both new and existing built assets on the Island. A Resiliency Plan would help the Town navigate the complicated and evolving environmental landscape. Credit: The Island Packet A. PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENTS The Town’s land area and zoning are primarily characterized by Planned Unit Developments. These areas operate under an approved master plan that governs their growth, aesthetics, circulation, and other community development considerations. While negotiations can occur between the communities and the Town, development opportunities (outside the district’s master plan) are not likely. B. HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS The Island’s historic neighborhoods are centers of cultural and historical significance. While development is by no means precluded, the opportunities must be pursued with special care and respect for existing sites and neighbors. C. TOWN OWNED PROPERTY Parcels owned by the Town may present an opportunity for certain, specific types of development, but in most cases these properties were purchased for the purpose of preservation. Funding source and restrictive covenants often limit devlopability of Town-Owned property. Only about 100 acres of the Town’s nearly 1,500 acres is undeveloped and permissive of future development. D. ACCESS TO ARTERIAL ROADS Access to major roadways is key for visibility and economic viability. Land farther than 750 feet from a major arterial roadway is considered constrained. E. HIGH RISK FLOOD ZONES High risk flood zones are established by FEMA and have associated insurance premiums. Areas at greatest risk of flooding have more obstacles to financing and construction. F. TREE CANOPY & SALT MARSHES Both salt marshes and mature tree canopy are environmental assets many on the Island hope to protect, and also factors that make development difficult or much more expensive. 98 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 99 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 113 of 174 POTENTIAL CONSTRAINTS TO DEVELOPMENT A. PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENTS (PUDS) E. HIGH RISK FLOOD ZONES B. HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS D. ACCESS TO ARTERIAL ROADS F. TREE CANOPY & SALT MARSHES C. TOWN OWNED PROPERTY 98 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 99 Page 114 of 174 5 While the Island as a whole is dominated by Planned Development zoning districts, overall land use is more evenly distributed. • Zoning districts are delineated areas that have specific regulations which govern the use, placement, spacing, and size of land parcels and buildings. The Town has 22 different zoning districts. • Island-wide, Planned Development (PD-1) zoning is most common and largest district, making up almost 70% of the total land area. • After PD-1, the next largest zoning district is Low to Moderate Density Residential (RM-4). This zoning district makes up 1,557 acres. While it constitutes just 7.5% of the Island’s total area, it makes up 24% of the land area outside of the major Planned Development areas. • The Land Management Ordinance (LMO) allows for up to four housing units per acre under RM-4 zoning, meaning the district has a maximum entitled capacity of over 6,200 housing units (based upon acreage) across the Island. There are currently 1,600 housing units within the zoning district, per census data from Esri Business Analyst. Additionally there is a net acreage bonus within RM-4, where properties five acres and above can develop at up to eight units per acre. This ‘ceiling of entitlement’ points to a high amount of housing that can be developed or redeveloped within areas that fall within the RM-4 zoning district. • The third largest zoning district Island-wide is Parks and Recreation (PR), with 189 properties adding up to 759 total acres. This constitutes about 5% of the total Island, but 12% of the land area outside of Planned Developments. • While there are 22 different zoning districts, the Town has only five general land use categories, which characterize how the land is currently functioning today. These categories are Commercial, Residential, Industrial, Public / Civic, and Other (which includes undeveloped and vacant land). • Residential is the largest land use on the Island, encompassing 58% of the Island’s total land area. LAND USE CATEGORY % LAND AREA PROPERTIES RESIDENTIAL 58% 19,314 PUBLIC / CIVIC 25% 687 UNDEVELOPED / OTHER 11% 1,860 COMMERCIAL 5% 600 INDUSTRIAL 1% 173 ISLAND-WIDE LAND USE Source: Town of Hilton Head Island ZONING DISTRICT ABBREVIATION % LAND AREA PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PD-1 69% LOW TO MODERATE DENSITY RESIDENTIAL RM-4 8% PARKS AND RECREATION PR 5% LIGHT COMMERCIAL LC 3% LIGHT INDUSTRIAL IL 2% RESORT DEVELOPMENT RD 2% MODERATE DENSITY RESIDENTIAL RM-12 2% REMAINING 15 ZONING DISTRICTS N/A 9% ISLAND-WIDE ZONING (TOP 7 BY LAND AREA) Source: Town of Hilton Head Island PORTION OF THE ISLAND’S TOTAL LAND AREA DESIGNATED TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENT ZONING 69% Which operate under the purview of private Master Plan agreements with limited involvement from the Town. Residential Breakdown (by land area) - 55% Single Family, 25% Residential Open Space, 15% Multifamily, 5% Mobile Home 100 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 101 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 115 of 174 Housing opportunities in undeveloped land? The majority Town-Owned and undeveloped property includes a restrictive covenant or was purchased with a funding source that precludes building. Roughly 100 acres, however, of Town-Owned land is not restricted by those restraints, presenting an opportunity for a community-serving development project like workforce housing. TOWN ZONING CC - Community Commercial CON - Conservation CR - Coligny Resort IL - Light Industrial LC - Light Commercial MED - Medical MF - Marshfront Mixed Use MS - Main Street MV - Mitchelville NC - Neighborhood Commercial PD-1 - Planned Development PR - Parks and Recreation RD - Resort Development RM-4 - Low to Moderate Density RM-8 - Moderate Density RM-12 - Moderate to High Density RS-3 - Single Family RS-5 - Single Family RS-6 - Single Family S - Stoney Mixed Use SPC - Sea Pines Commercial WMU - Water-Oriented Mixed Use KEY William Hilton PkwyWilliam Hilton Pkwy Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy Pope AvePope Ave Atlantic OceanAtlantic Ocean Skull Creek Skull Creek Calibogue Sound Calibogue Sound B r o a d C r e ek B r o a d C r e ek Port Royal Sound Port Royal Sound 100 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 101 Page 116 of 174 Extruded heights represent the unbuilt entitled additional housing capacity (via zoning entitlement) for non-PUD residential zoning districts ZONING DISTRICTS ENTITLED BUT UNBUILT UNITS RM-4 - LOW TO MODERATE DENSITY RESIDENTIAL >3,000 RD - RESORT DEVELOPMENT 2,000-3,000 MS - MAIN STREET 2,000-3,000 WMU - WATER ORIENTED MIXED-USE 2,000-3,000 RM-8 - MODERATED DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 1,000-2,000 ZONING DISTRICTS WITH MOST REMAINING ENTITLED HOUSING Source: Town of Hilton Head Island, ESRI Business Analyst Unbuilt capacity by zoning district One way to measure potential buildable housing capacity is to look at the zoning district allowances per code, subtracted by the amount of current housing units within those districts. The remainder is the number of entitled capacity that remains within each zoning district (based upon their total acreages). This is a broad, analytical exercise that doesn’t account for site specific development considerations and constraints, but is meant to give an overview of which zoning districts hold the most potential for residential growth as an order of magnitude, based on current entitlements. With much of the Island “built-out”, this is particularly relevant to long-term redevelopment scenarios under the existing zoning conditions. 102 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 103 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 117 of 174 TOWN LAND USE KEY Commercial Residential Industrial Public / Civic Other William Hilton PkwyWilliam Hilton Pkwy Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy Pope AvePope Ave Atlantic OceanAtlantic Ocean Skull Creek Skull Creek Calibogue Sound Calibogue Sound B r o a d C r e ek B r o a d C r e ek Port Royal Sound Port Royal Sound LAND USE CATEGORY % LAND AREA RESIDENTIAL 58% PUBLIC / CIVIC 25% UNDEVELOPED / OTHER 11% COMMERCIAL 5% INDUSTRIAL 1% Source: Town of Hilton Head Island 1/4 of Public/Civic land (7% of the total Island) is Town-Owned. Undeveloped represents about 7% of total Island land use, with the “other” category including land uses that do not fall within existing classifications. Residential Breakdown -55% Single Family, 25% Residential Open Space, 15% Multifamily, 5% Mobile Home 102 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 103 Page 118 of 174 Atlantic Ocean Atlantic Ocean Calibogue SoundCalibogue Sound May RiverMay River B road Creek B road Creek J a r v i s C r e e k J a r v i s C r e e k Skull Creek Skull Creek Port RoyalPort Royal SoundSound 3 Miles MID ISLAND MID ISLAND TRACT PARKTRACT PARK (FUTURE)(FUTURE) CHAPLIN CHAPLIN COMMUNITY PARKCOMMUNITY PARK CROSSINGS CROSSINGS PARKPARK Beach City RdBeach City Rd N LOWCOUNTRY LOWCOUNTRY CELEBRATIONCELEBRATION PARKPARK JARVIS CREEK JARVIS CREEK PARKPARK Sea Pines Forest Preserve Whooping Crane Conservancy Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge Marshland RdMarshland Rd Cross Island PkwyCross Island Pkwy Gumtree RdGumtree Rd Squire Pope RdSquire Pope Rd Pope AvePope Ave ISLANDERS ISLANDERS BEACH PARKBEACH PARK FOLLY FIELDFOLLY FIELD BEACH PARKBEACH PARK DRIESSENDRIESSEN BEACH PARKBEACH PARK HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD ISLANDISLAND AIRPORTAIRPORT Main StMain St HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD HOSPITALHOSPITAL HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD SCHOOLSSCHOOLS COLIGNYCOLIGNY BEACH PARKBEACH PARK PINE ISLAND PINE ISLAND BEACHBEACH FISH HAUL FISH HAUL BEACH PARKBEACH PARK MITCHELVILLEMITCHELVILLE BEACH PARKBEACH PARK US 278US 278 Bluffton PkwyBluffton Pkwy Audubon Preserve Greenwood DrGreenwood Dr Lighthouse RdLighthouse Rd William Hilton Pkwy / US 278William Hilton Pkwy / US 278 S Forest Beach DrS Forest Beach Dr TOWN TOWN HALLHALL PINCKNEY ISLAND BULL ISLAND Undeveloped Property Commercial Property - Bldg over 40 Years Old PROPERTIES SUSCEPTIBLE TO CHANGE 104 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 105 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 119 of 174 Atlantic Ocean Atlantic Ocean Port RoyalPort Royal SoundSound Undeveloped Property Undeveloped property is land that has not been built on or altered by public or private capital investments. This type of property is often the most desirable for development investment (compared to redevelopment) because it is a “blank slate”, with more straightforward understanding of cost and risk. This category includes both residential and commercially zoned undeveloped land. Properties in the category may have specific site characteristics the present challenges for development like environmental or political constraints. Commercial Property Pre-1983 Commercial properties built before 1983, and thus older than 40 years old, are properties that are reaching latter phases in the life cycle of typical commercial buildings. Major re- investment in the form of renovation, or even repositioning and reuse, become much more likely as owners and landlords seeks to keep buildings viable and attractive to the desires of the broader market. Buildings constructed before 1983 were also built before the Town was incorporated, therefore not subject to its building and site design standards. 6 Older commercial properties are more susceptible to change or redevelopment in the near-term. While there are many factors that can influence the likelihood of real estate changing from its current form or function, two main criteria can be broadly applied to highlight properties with a relatively high susceptibility to change in coming years. These criteria are undeveloped property and commercial property built pre-1983. Because of the complexities that permit change within the Planned Unit Developments (PUDs), this susceptibility analysis has been focused to the areas outside of the Island’s major PUDs. UNDEVELOPED LAND IN THE AREAs OUTsIDE OF MAJOR PLANNED DEVELOPMENTs COMMERCIAL PROPERTY BUILT PRE-1983 IN AREAs OUTsIDE OF PLANNED DEVELOPMENTs 1,114 acres 196 acres UNBUILT CAPACITY IN PLANNED COMMUNITIEs 300 acres TOTAL IsLAND LAND AREATOTAL IsLAND LAND AREA 22,000 acres SHARE OF UNDEVELOPED PROPERTY COMPARED TO ISLAND TOTAL Source: Town of Hilton Head Island, ESRI Business Analyst 104 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 105 Page 120 of 174 District Planning To best understand the Island’s land use dynamics, both currently and into the future, its important to note the eight planning sub- districts of the Island. Each of the areas share common characteristics with respect to land uses, neighborhood character, access and geography. The eight planning districts do not include the following master planned communities: Hilton Head Plantation, Palmetto Hall, Port Royal, Indigo Run, Spanish Wells, Wexford, Long Cove Club, Palmetto Dunes, Leamington, Shipyard, and Sea Pines. TOP 3 EXISTING LAND USES TOTAL ACRES ACRES SUSCEPTIBLE TO CHANGE % SUSCEPTIBLE TO CHANGE 1ST 2ND 3RD MARSHES 1,235 195 16% Single Fam. Vacant/Undevelop Mobile Home SKULL CREEK 1,203 337 28% Vacant/Undevelop Single Fam. Open Space MAIN STREET 665 54 8% Schools Office Retail/Serv/Sales MID-ISLAND 1,798 355 20% Vacant/Undevelop Airport Multi Family CHAPLIN 601 44 7% Park - Active Rec. Multi Family Single Family PARKWAY 576 61 11% Retail/Serv/Sales Multi Family Office FOREST BEACH 614 36 6% Multi Family Single Family Religious BRIDGE-TO-BEACH 755 224 30% Vacant/Undevelop Multi Family Retail/Serv/Sales Source: Town of Hilton Head Island GIS CHANGE SUSCEPTIBILITY 106 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 107 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 121 of 174 Skull Creek Current Commercial SF: 120,057 SF Current Housing Units: 1,366 337 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 150,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 1,000 Units Marshes Current Commercial SF: 122,446 SF Current Housing Units: 1,120 195 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 25,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 450 Units Main Street Current Commercial SF: 1,312,612 SF Current Housing Units: 549 54 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 310,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 175 Units Mid-Island Current Commercial SF: 2,349,514 SF Current Housing Units: 1,781 355 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 725,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 1,000 Units KEY Planning District Property Susceptible to Change DEVELOPABLE CAPACITY BY PLANNING DISTRICT 106 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 107 Page 122 of 174 Chaplin Current Commercial SF: 27,532 SF Current Housing Units: 2,134 44 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 85,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 150 Units Parkway Current Commercial SF: 1,446,360 SF Current Housing Units: 375 61 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Approx 250,000 SF Housing Units: Approx 75 Units Forest Beach Current Commercial SF: 293,589 SF Current Housing Units: 2,735 36 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Undefined* Housing Units: Undefined* *11 acres of Coligny Resort Zoning is susceptible to change and has no maximum commercial or housing unit restriction. Bridge-to-Beach Current Commercial SF: 1,581,646 SF Current Housing Units: 542 224 acres susceptible to change Developable Capacity (per Zoning of Parcels Susceptible to Change) Commercial SF: Undefined* Housing Units: Approx 850 Units *60 acres of Sea Pines Commercial Zoning is susceptible to change and has no maximum commercial square footage restriction KEY Planning District Property Susceptible to Change DEVELOPABLE CAPACITY BY PLANNING DISTRICT 108 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 109 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 123 of 174 KEY Remaining unbuilt lots # HILTON HEAD PLANTATION PALMETTO HALL PORT ROYAL REMAINING LOTS IN PLANNED COMMUNITIES INDIGO RUN INDIGO RUN - OAKVIEW INDIGO RUN - CROSSWINDS PALMETTO DUNES SHELTER COVE SHIPYARD WEXFORD LONG COVE CLUB LEAMINGTON SPANISH WELLS SEA PINES Source: Planning Team Research and Analysis PLANNED DEVELOPMENT TOTAL LOTS REMAINING CAPACITY SPANISH WELLS 190 7% HILTON HEAD PLANTATION 4,524 2% INDIGO RUN 1,880 4% LEAMINGTON 244 39% PALMETTO DUNES 1,193 3% PALMETTO HALL 573 8% PORT ROYAL 1,101 3% SEA PINES 5,890 3% WEXFORD 436 12% SHIPYARD 255 2% LONG COVE CLUB 573 7% 90 150 13 75 15 15 0 41 15 54 96 48 38 Unbuilt Capacity A majority of the Island’s land area is made up of Planned Developments, each of which are entitled to certain development rights. Those rights are legally binding agreements, specifying the maximum allowances for housing units within each respective community. Across all of the Island’s planned developments there are 690 single family housing units that have been entitled but not yet constructed. The breakdown of how many remain within each planned development can be seen in the accompanying map. 40Source: Town of Hilton Head Island GIS 108 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 109 Page 124 of 174 1960 0 0.6 0.9 1.2 1.5 1.8 0.3 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2019 2020 2021 HOUSING DENSITY THROUGH TIME (ISLAND-WIDE)Housing Units Per Acre Source: Town of Hilton Head Island GIS HOUSING DENSITY BY NEIGHBORHOOD / PLANNING DISTRICT PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS HOUSING UNITS PER ACRE A. SPANISH WELLS 0.6 B. INDIGO RUN 0.7 C. HILTON HEAD PLANTATION 1.3 D. PALMETTO HALL 0.8 E. PORT ROYAL 0.9 F. PALMETTO DUNES 1.5 G. LEAMINGTON 1.8 H. SHIPYARD 2 I. LONG COVE CLUB 1 J. WEXFORD 0.9 K. SEA PINES 1.4 11 22 33 44 55 66 77 88 AA BB CC EE FF GG HH II JJ KK Housing Density Housing Density is based upon total housing units per acre. A housing unit includes single family homes, condominiums, villas, townhomes, and apartments. For the Planning Districts and Planned Developments that include multifamily housing, the number of housing units within them is greater than their number of residential lots. DD PLANNING DISTRICTS HOUSING UNITS PER ACRE 1. MARSHES 0.9 2. SKULL CREEK 1.1 3. MAIN STREET 0.8 4. MID-ISLAND 1 5. CHAPLIN 3.6 6. PARKWAY 0.7 7. FOREST BEACH 4.5 8. BRIDGE-TO-BEACH 0.7 More Dense Less Dense Housing Units per Acre Source: ESRI 110 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 111 TOPIC J: LAND USE Page 125 of 174 7 Housing density is slowly increasing but varies significantly across the Island’s neighborhoods. • Housing density refers to the number of housing units (such as houses, apartments, or condominiums) within a specific area, often measured in terms of dwellings per unit of land area. It is a key indicator of how closely packed or dispersed residential structures are within a given region. • The built density on the Island increased dramatically through the 1980’s as most the Town’s planned communities began to develop. The planned communities such as Sea Pines or Spanish Wells are, generally speaking, less dense that development that has occured with the planning districts (or outside of a planned community). • Housing density is driven upwards by multi-unit projects and districts that are close to the beach tend to include more of these properties. The Island’s highest density — 4.5 dwelling units per acre — is inside the Forest Beach Planning District. HOUSING DENSITY VISUAL COMPARISON Source: Nearmap, 2023 imagery 4.5 DU / ACRE 1.1 DU / ACRE 1.4 DU / ACRE .7 DU / ACRE .9 DU / ACRE 3.6 DU / ACRE 7. FOREST BEACH 7. FOREST BEACH 2. SKULL CREEK2. SKULL CREEK K. SEA PINESK. SEA PINES 6. PARKWAY6. PARKWAY 1. MARSHES1. MARSHES 5. CHAPLIN5. CHAPLIN ISLANDWIDE RESIDENTIAL DENSITY, 2023 1.5 Densities have increased slowly from 2000, from 1.2 to 1.5. This is mostly driven by projects in the Island’s Planning Districts or outside of the Planned Communities 110 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 111 Page 126 of 174 112112 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 113 Page 127 of 174 STRATEGIES The purpose of this assessment is to present an objective view of the Town’s most important conditions and trends in 2023. The use of this information – for planning, prioritizing, budgeting, etc. – should be considered through subsequent, future-focused conversations. There are, however, specific steps the Town may consider as a prudent response to these trends. These strategies or steps might be incorporated into future Strategic Action Plans, Capital Improvement Programs, and/or Town Budgets. This section outlines those strategies and steps by topic and with respect to the key findings and considerations raised through the research. Across the ten chapters of this Conditions and Trends Assessment, many different issues are identified. The next step is to determine a course of action for addressing each of these trends to continue the success and maintain an excellent quality of life on Hilton Head Island. This action database focuses on policy and/ or research actions that will help the Town respond to trends, address community needs, and continue to build its understanding of important issues. This list does not represent a committment by the Town, but rather presents a non-exhaustive set of potential first steps. Leadership can then consider these strategies as it begins to craft policy in response to the trends presented throughout this report. TIME FRAMES Immediate: 0-1 year Short Term: 1-3 years Mid Term: 3-5 years Long Term: 5-10 years Continuous RELATED TRENDS Additional topic areas addressed by the potential step. 112 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 113 Page 128 of 174 CURRENT STEPS The Town is working with partners from around the community and the region to address key trends presented through this analysis. The actions presented below are no exhaustive, but represent several of the most critical “first steps”. A. Develop a comprehensive future land use plan for areas outside of the Town’s planned communities. Guided by a framework for conservation and growth, the future land use plan is an extension of the Our Plan Comprehensive Plan established by the Town in 2020. The map and supportive rationale should articulate “how” and “where” they community intends to conserve or consider change in land uses for the future. The plan should be based on a solid understanding of development constraints – environmental, cultural, political, etc. – and prescribe a land use pattern that is self-referential and aspirational. This may include new development types that leverage emerging market opportunities and seek to address key community needs. B. Pursue an in-depth analysis of climate change impacts and establish a resilience plan. The potential scope of climate change impacts and the necessary host of prudent, immediate Town actions should be studied further. A resilience plan is a comprehensive strategy that outlines measures and actions to help the municipality adapt to and mitigate the impacts of climate change and related sea level rise. It includes strategies to enhance infrastructure, protect natural resources, promote sustainable practices, and increase community resilience to climate-related hazards such as extreme weather events, sea-level rise, and temperature changes. The plan aims to ensure the municipality’s long-term sustainability, economic stability, and the well-being of its residents in the face of these growing challenges. C. Convene and lead the regional conversations on workforce development. Competition for labor will intensify through the 2020’s as regional growth continues. Given the increasing reliance on off-Island labor to meet it’s growing employment needs, the Town should consider initiating and leading a regional conversation on workforce development for the communities across the Lowcountry. D. Build on the success of the Town’s Workforce Housing Framework. The latest effort to develop the Town of Hilton Head Island’s Workforce Housing Framework began fall of 2022 as a result of troubling trends around workforce housing and general affordability. Town leadership committed to a process to develop the Framework through a collaborative process with the community and key stakeholders. The “Framework” is a structure around which policies and more specific actions can be affixed and expanded. As a result of the Framework, the Town Council agreed to devote $1 million in annual funding to address the housing issue programmatically and through tangible projects. E. Continue to support and expand programs that seek to maintain the cultural and demographic diversity of the Town. The African American population is decreasing in the Town. As a result, the living legacy of the Island’s native community is under threat. The Town has taken significant action to protect the cultural heritage exhibited through its historic neighborhoods and should continue to provide and widen pathways for native residents. 114 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 115 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 129 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Continue to lead regional conversations on growth A.1 Support regional long-term planning efforts Continuous Economics, Workforce, Land Use, Systems A.2 Lead regional advocacy efforts at a state and federal level Continuous Systems, Housing, Workforce A.3 Continue to lead project identification work through the Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP) Continuous Systems A.4 Create and launch a new resident experience survey Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement, Workforce, Governance A.5 Perform district level visitor surveys and counts Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement, Workforce, Economics A. Demographics Population, households, change by season/day, citizen age, diversity CONSIDERATIONS • The full-time resident population of the Island is plateauing amid intense regional growth. • Households are getting smaller, older, and are less likely to include school-age children. • The number of people on the Island can vary significantly from its full-time population based on the time of day or the time of year. • The average age on the Island is getting older and the 55+ segment is driving a modest increase in population. • The Town is a relatively diverse community, but there has been a long-term decrease in the overall share of African American residents. • The Hispanic community is growing at the fastest rate of any ethnic segment, both locally and regionally. • The Island’s population of foreign-born residents is increasing, largely from Latin America. STRATEGIES & STEPS FUTURE STRATEGIES & STEPS The following matrix organizes the strategies and steps by their relative topics, time frames, and potential partners. The time frame includes immediate-term tactics (0-1 year), short-term tactics (1-3 years), medium-term tactics (3-5 years), and long-term (beyond 5 years). (See the key on page 103) Partners refer to groups or organizations outside of the municipal government who’s involvement will help drive and complete the action. 114 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 115 Page 130 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Continue to support the Native Islander community A.6 Update land and demographic counts from the Gullah Geechee Culture Preservation Project Report Short Term: 1-3 years Natural and Cultural Environment, Community Engagement A.7 Audit efficacy and progress of existing programs Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement, Governance A.8 Proactively monitor tax vulnerable properties to ensure long-term family ownership (if this is the desire of the family.) Continuous Natural and Cultural Environment, Community Engagement A.9 Continue to support and collect oral history interviews of elderly Gullah citizens Mid Term: 3-5 years Natural and Cultural Environment, Community Engagement A.10 Prepare a comprehensive and detailed cultural preservation plan for the Island in general, but to include a focus on Gullah historic and cultural preservation Mid Term: 3-5 years Natural and Cultural Environment, Community Engagement, Land Use Continue to support the Spanish-speaking community A.11 Perform a accessibility study / audit of the Town’s physical and non-physical spaces for Spanish speakers Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement Workforce, Housing A.12 Perform a community specific census or survey targeting the bilingual and/or Spanish speaking community Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement A.13 Explore Town internship opportunities for dual-language students Mid Term: 3-5 years Community Engagement A.14 Foster alignment between local non-profits to inventory community services like the Island Recreation Association Mid Term: 3-5 years Community Engagement Improve opportunities for aging in place A.15 Explore a home accessibility revolving fund to support aging in place Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use, Housing A.16 Identify major gaps in proximity to healthcare facilities, clinics, pharmacies, and medical professionals to ensure easy access to healthcare services and regular check-ups Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use A.17 Work with partners to encourage and enable the availability of home healthcare services, telemedicine, and medical equipment rentals for convenient care at home Mid Term: 3-5 years - A.18 Work with regional transit partners to provide accessible and reliable public transportation options or specialized transportation services for older adults Mid Term: 3-5 years Systems, Land Use A.19 Promote walkable neighborhoods with pedestrian-friendly infrastructure and well-maintained sidewalks Continuous Land Use 116 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 117 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 131 of 174 B. Workforce Labor force makeup, participation, commuting, wages CONSIDERATIONS • Competition for labor is intensifying as the region experiences strong job and population growth. • Recent Island worker shortages have impacted local businesses. • Unemployment rates have been and continue to be low when compared to the region. • Median annual earnings have been increasing over the last decade, most notably for high school graduates, who experienced a 76% increase in earnings during that time. • Higher education facilities on or near Hilton Head Island will continue to infuse the workforce with high-demand local industry skills. • Residents have comparatively higher levels of educational attainment than the overall populations of Jasper and Beaufort Counties. • One in five resident occupations are in the food preparation and serving industry. • Commuting for island residents decreased by almost 10% over the last decade while the share of residents that work from home has steadily increased. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Engage local employers and institutions in an ongoing dialogue on labor issues B.1 Continue to build on the partnership with USCB and explore future opportunities for the site and program Continuous Economics, Real Estate B.2 Explore new programs that align with current or emergent jobs opportunities within the Island’s tourism and resort economy Mid Term: 3-5 years Economics B.3 Engage local employers in a round table discussion on workforce issues and conduct a detailed worker’s survey and census Immediate: 0-1 year Economics, Community Engagement B.4 Develop a long-term workforce development and maintenance strategic plan Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement B.5 Explore site or building opportunities for co-working facilities Long Term: 5-10 years Real Estate, Economics B.6 Launch an essential worker recruitment and retention task force Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement Improve regional and local transit frequency and access B.7 Develop a transit access and needs statement based on worker’s survey / census Immediate: 0-1 year Systems 116 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 117 Page 132 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS B.8 Explore the feasibility of an on-Island transit hub Long Term: 5-10 years Systems, Land Use, Real Estate B.9 Continue to advocate - through state and federal programs and forums - for funding maintenance and increases Continuous Systems, Governance B.10 Prepare case study analysis of similarly positioned communities who have achieved positive outcomes with respect to transit, i.e. Aspen, Colorado Short Term: 1-3 years Systems Expand workforce housing B.11 Continue to dedicate funding to acquire property to be made available to local groups to construct affordable housing units Continuous Real Estate, Housing B.12 Implement Housing Framework Plan Elements Mid Term: 3-5 years Real Estate, Housing, Governance B.13 Maintain a workforce housing database and dashboard Short Term: 1-3 years Housing 118 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 119 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 133 of 174 C. Economics Businesses, employment, tourism, pipeline projects CONSIDERATIONS • After the pandemic-related disruption in 2020, tourism has bounced back and continues to drive the Island’s economy. • The number of applications for business licenses shot up after 2020, almost two-thirds of which have been for short-term rental properties. • Hilton Head Island Airport (HHH) has played a growing role in local economic development since its 2018 expansion. • The local economy has recovered since the shock from the COVID-19 pandemic and historic trends are expected to continue. • Tourism drives local revenues and has recovered and surpassed pre-pandemic levels. • Non-tourism related jobs grew the most over the last two decades. • Several capital projects planned in and around Hilton Head Island are expected to positively impact economic outcomes. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Pursue a diverse local economy C.1 Maintain an inventory of available commercial space and vacant land that could accommodate new business growth. Continuous Real Estate C.2 Continue to engage with regional economic development partners Continuous Workforce C.3 Identify real estate limitations to small business scaling Short Term: 1-3 years Real Estate Continue to grow and evolve visitor industry C.4 Develop a Tourism Management Plan that outlines the Island’s tourism vision, goals, strategies, and action plans Short Term: 1-3 years - C.5 Define Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) with respect visitor numbers, economic impact, visitor satisfaction, and sustainability metrics Short Term: 1-3 years Natural and Cultural Environment C.6 Foster collaboration and partnerships among stakeholders, including local businesses, government agencies, non-profits, and tourism operators, to collectively address industry challenges and opportunities Continuous Community Engagement 118 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 119 Page 134 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS C.7 Promote sustainable tourism practices to mitigate the environmental impact of tourism on coastal areas and ensure long-term economic viability Continuous Natural and Cultural Environment C.8 Continue beach ambassador program Continuous Natural and Cultural Environment, Community Engagement Leverage key assets C.9 Support the implementation of the Hilton Head Island Airport Master Plan Mid Term: 3-5 years Systems, Real Estate C.10 Partner to develop a Economic Impact Assessment for HHI Airport Terminal expansions and upgrades Short Term: 1-3 years - 120 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 121 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 135 of 174 D. Real Estate Retail, office, and residential property type and value CONSIDERATIONS • Hilton Head Island’s real estate is mostly comprised of residential properties, and its stock has grown slowly in recent years. • A majority of the residential real estate inventory on the Island is locally owned. • Nearly all the development in the last year has been single-family homes. • Multifamily rental options on the Island are very limited. • Healthcare is the leading office tenant, occupying close to one-third of available square footage. • Nearly all new retail space over the last decade is hosted at Shelter Cove Towne Centre and Sea Turtle Marketplace. • Vacancy across retail and office properties is increasingly volatile and trending upward. • Peak and shoulder seasons for visitors are lengthening. • The market is growing for year-round residents and a longer visitor season. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Prepare for redevelopment D.1 Develop a redevelopment playbook Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use D.2 Study appropriately scaled blight mitigation programs for vulnerable commercial properties Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use D.3 Develop and maintain a commercial properties dashboard Continuous Land Use, Economics D.4 Launch a regular vacancy survey program with local property owners Continuous Community Engagement, Economics D.5 Conduct a comprehensive analysis of the retail market, including consumer demand, competition, and emerging retail trends Short Term: 1-3 years Economics, Land Use Increase the share of locally-owned property D.6 Evaluate existing zoning regulations and business licensing requirements to ensure they are conducive to attracting and retaining businesses Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use 120 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 121 Page 136 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS D.7 Identify properties with high susceptibility to change and develop metrics to proactively identify properties vulnerable to off-Island deed transfer / sale Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use, Community Engagement Continue to explore and develop public-private partnerships D.8 Develop a property acquisition schedule for key properties Continuous Governance, Community Engagement D.9 Explore the Community Development Corporation (CDC) tool as a mechanism for land management Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Governance 122 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 123 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 137 of 174 E. Natural & Cultural Environment Ecology, hydrology, geography, climate change, cultural resources, and parks CONSIDERATIONS • Sea level rise will increase the pressure on Island systems and will require ongoing, proactive monitoring and management. • Secondary impacts of climate change affect multiple environmental and ecological systems. • Water quality is responding positively to pollution mitigation efforts. • The Island’s canopy cover percentage far outperforms similar communities and is growing. • Protection and conservation practices and programs have a direct, positive impact on wildlife. • The Island’s beach management and renourishment practices are critical long-term investments. • The Town has committed to providing best-in- class parks and recreation resources. • Cultural sites continue to be an important asset and underscore the urgent need for neighborhood preservation. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Monitor and mitigate the impacts of climate change E.1 Pursue an in-depth analysis of climate change impacts and establish a resilience plan Immediate: 0-1 year Systems E.2 Develop and implement comprehensive coastal management plan that consider climate change, incorporating adaptive strategies for infrastructure, land use, and natural resource management Long Term: 5-10 years Systems, Land Use E.3 Incorporate Climate Resilience in Zoning and Building Codes Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Systems E.4 Develop a plan to expand green infrastructure, such as dunes and wetlands, to provide natural buffers against storm surges, erosion, and flooding Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use, Systems E.5 Monitor and communicate impacts to home and property insurance Continuous Community Engagement, Housing E.6 Implement strategies from Beaufort County’s Sea Level Rise Task Force Long Term: 5-10 years Land Use, Systems E.7 Engage with the State of South Carolina Resiliency Office Continuous Land Use, Systems, Governance 122 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 123 Page 138 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Monitor and mitigate the impacts of climate change E.8 Develop a heat island mapping and mitigation process Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use, Systems E.9 Perform a wildlife impact assessment Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use E.10 Perform a comprehensive tree census Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use Continue to improve the Island’s beach environment and experience E.11 Implement the Beach Master Plan Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Systems E.12 Develop a Beach Parking Master Plan Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Systems E.13 Adopt Beach Experience Regulations – Fishing, Tents, Smoking, Emergency Access Routes, Facility Hours of Operation, Parking Management, Boat Storage on Beach, etc. Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Systems, Community Engagement Protect and share the Island’s rich cultural history and landmarks E.14 Support the work of the Gullah-Geechee Land & Cultural Preservation Task Force in their mission to preserving Gullah culture and improving their quality of life Continuous Community Engagement E.15 Continue to support the work of the Office of Cultural Affairs Continuous Community Engagement E.16 Explore the Distinctive Destination status for the Island or specific sites through the National Trust for Historic Preservation Long Term: 5-10 years Community Engagement, Economics E.17 Develop an endangered sites or buildings list Mid Term: 3-5 years Community Engagement, Land Use Maintain and evolve the Town’s best-in-class parks system. E.18 Regularly perform a users survey for parks and recreational facilities to identify use patterns and needs Continuous Community Engagement, Land Use 124 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 125 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 139 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Monitor and manage short term rentals F.1 Perform annual audit and reporting on STR management processes and practices Continuous - Improve access to workforce housing F.2 Implement the Finding Home: Town of Hilton Head Island Housing Framework Immediate: 0-1 year Governance, Community Engagement F.3 Continue to support the Housing Action Committee Immediate: 0-1 year Community Engagement F.4 Distribute and regularly update an asked-rent survey to area renters and landlords Continuous Community Engagement, Workforce F.5 Develop an asset map of local groups and individuals involved directly on indirectly with housing security or affordability Immediate: 0-1 year Governance F.6 Create a displacement contingency plan for vulnerable households Short Term: 1-3 years Governance, Demographics F.7 Study a local tax abatement process for workforce housing projects Short Term: 1-3 years Governance, Real Estate F . Housing Permitting, home values, short-term rentals, new development and redevelopment CONSIDERATIONS • The Island has a unique mix of housing types fueled by the hospitality and home rental markets. • A building boom through the ‘80s and ‘90s has given way to slower growth, especially after 2010. • Permits for all types of building are trending upward; residential projects are leading the way. • A hot—if temperamental—housing market soared upward through the COVID-19 pandemic. • The Island’s housing market is atypical as it includes a significant number of units that are occupied on a seasonal basis. • Housing cost burdening is increasing as the market pulls prices upward. • Naturally occurring affordable housing is under threat from redevelopment. STRATEGIES & STEPS 124 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 125 Page 140 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS F.8 Explore and identify needed updates the Town’s Land Management Ordinance (LMO) Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use F.9 Explore a wetland banking program on Town-owned properties Mid Term: 3-5 years Land Use, Natural and Cultural Environment F.10 Develop and maintain a map and database of all naturally occurring affordable housing units Immediate: 0-1 year Land Use 126 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 127 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 141 of 174 G. Governance Timeline of key events, staffing, service capacity, tax revenues, strategic planning CONSIDERATIONS • The Town was formally incorporated in 1983 with a mandate from voters to “regulate the pace and character” of future development. • As a limited-services local government, the Town both administers services directly and partners with regional entities to serve residents. • Emerging community challenges and needs are driving more proactive planning processes and policies from the Town. • The Town’s annual strategic planning cycle uses best practices to link department-level operational plans and capital investments back to the Comprehensive Plan. • Following two disasters—Hurricane Matthew and the COVID-19 pandemic—revenues and community investments are now growing and focusing on “normal” expenditures. • Fire Rescue maintains a strong and effective staff and fleet but is strained by the increasing cost of living. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Scale Town operations to meet evolving needs G.1 Analyze current workloads and responsibilities to understand the gap between available staff and workload demands and develop a long-term strategic workforce plan that aligns staffing needs with organizational goals and future growth projections Short Term: 1-3 years - G.2 Review staffing practices from peer communities Immediate: 0-1 year Workforce G.3 Develop a key staff recruiting strategy Immediate: 0-1 year Workforce G.4 Explore stipend program for essential workers Mid Term: 3-5 years Workforce, Demographics Maintain strong fiscal performance G.5 Study disaster response funds for communities with similar vulnerabilities Short Term: 1-3 years Systems G.6 Analyze connections between land use and fiscal outcomes Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use, Economics 126 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 127 Page 142 of 174 H. Community Engagement Engagement culture, civic infrastructure, Town planning processes, communication networks CONSIDERATIONS • The Hilton Head Island community is intensely engaged in planning efforts, far beyond its Lowcountry peers. • The Town is committed to facilitating community conversations through its engagement process. • The Town uses multiple platforms to proactively communicate important messages. • The Town has a unique combination of tapestry communities that make the Island truly one of a kind. • Some groups living on the Island are harder to reach than others when it comes to gathering community input. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Continue to build and expand the Town’s ongoing community conversation H.1 Review the reach of Town messaging with respect to demographics and socio-economic categories Immediate: 0-1 year Demographics H.2 Train designated spokespersons to represent the town and communicate effectively with the media and the public during various situations Mid Term: 3-5 years Demographics H.3 Define key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the effectiveness of communication efforts, including reach, engagement, feedback, and sentiment analysis Short Term: 1-3 years Demographics H.4 Continually update the Town’s crisis communication plan to effectively communicate during emergencies, disasters, or critical incidents, ensuring the safety and well-being of the community Short Term: 1-3 years Systems H.5 Require major Town initiatives include a communications plan to outline messages, plan for outreach and engagement, and document the process Continuous Demographics 128 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 129 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 143 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Build bridges for harder-to-reach groups H.6 Develop an Island-wide civic infrastructure matrix Short Term: 1-3 years Systems H.7 Develop tailored outreach strategies for harder-to-reach communities Short Term: 1-3 years Demographics H.8 Institute minimum engagement metrics for policy advancement Continuous Demographics 128 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 129 Page 144 of 174 I. Systems Water infrastructure, roadway and pathway network, healthcare, service provision CONSIDERATIONS • Water use on the Island fluctuates significantly—reaching as high as 26 million gallons per day (MGD)—based on the season. • Saltwater infiltration poses a serious risk to long-term water extraction processes. • Wastewater recycling processes put treated water to use. • The Town’s efforts to manage stormwater have greatly reduced surface runoff. • The Town administers very few direct services and utilities to residents. • The Island outperforms major indicators of health outcomes, despite an aging population. • Only 3% of the roads on the Island are owned and maintained by the Town, with the county and state planning for major regional projects. • The Island’s renowned public multi-use pathway network is well-positioned for expansion. • Seasonal transit services broaden access with room to grow. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Secure long-term primary source water supply I.1 Support deep well drilling across Island water providers to secure long-term point source Long Term: 5-10 years Land Use I.2 Convene ongoing conversations between PSDs around long- term source water planning Mid Term: 3-5 years - I.3 Consolidate water capacity statistics into a single database and dashboard Short Term: 1-3 years - I.4 Develop water re-use / recycle best practices Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use I.5 Develop a community water conservation campaign Continuous Community Engagement I.6 Review current policies related to impervious surface coverage Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use Ensure access to high-quality healthcare and social services I.7 Conduct a thorough assessment of the healthcare needs and demands of the community to identify gaps and prioritize services accordingly Immediate: 0-1 year Demographics 130 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 131 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 145 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS I.8 Partner with existing healthcare providers, hospitals, clinics, and private practices to expand their services and reach on the Island Short Term: 1-3 years Demographics I.9 Utilize Town facilities to integrate tele-medicine and telehealth services to provide remote consultations, diagnosis, and treatment options Mid Term: 3-5 years Demographics, Real Estate Develop resilient infrastructure I.10 Develop acquisition strategy for flood susceptible property Long Term: 5-10 years Land Use I.11 Integrate future climate projections and scenarios into the design and planning of infrastructure to ensure it remains effective and functional under changing climate conditions Continuous Land Use I.12 Develop and support a redundancy plan for all critical infrastructure systems, ensuring that if one component fails, another can provide essential services to the community Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use Continually invest and improve mobility across the community I.13 Implement the recommendations from the Major Thoroughfare Corridors Plan (MCTP) Long Term: 5-10 years Land Use I.14 Develop a right-of-way acquisition strategy Short Term: 1-3 years Land Use 130 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 131 Page 146 of 174 J. Land Use Historic development trends and patterns, constraints to development, land use regulatory system CONSIDERATIONS • The Island has close to 1,500 acres of undeveloped land, which is about 7% of the total land area (above mean high tide) of the Island. This follows a history of much growth and development over the last half-century. • The Land Management Ordinance, in conjunction with several boards and commissions, regulates the character and desired development forms on the Island. • Redevelopment of aging retail centers and the addition of single-family homes are the biggest development trends on the Island. • Areas with the least amount of constraints to development are the biggest targets for growth and re-investment. • While the Island as a whole is dominated by Planned Development zoning districts, overall land use is more evenly distributed. • Housing density is slowly increasing but varies significantly across the Island’s neighborhoods. STRATEGIES & STEPS ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS Prepare a comprehensive land use strategy J.1 Map constraints to development or redevelopment based environmental and cultural factors Immediate: 0-1 year Natural and Cultural Environment, Economics J.2 Adopt a future land use map made up of development and conservation placeypes Immediate: 0-1 year Natural and Cultural Environment, Housing J.3 Prepare a schedule of Land Management Ordinance (LMO) amendments based on the direction provided by the future land use mapping process Short Term: 1-3 years - J.4 Continue to pursue a rational acquisition strategy for vulnerable or catalytic properties Continuous Natural and Cultural Environment, Housing, Workforce J.5 Work with property owners on short-term improvement strategies like façade improvements, use integration, landscaping, etc. Mid Term: 3-5 years - J.6 Convene members of the building community, Town review appointees, and staff for a work session focused on redevelopment Short Term: 1-3 years Economics, Governance, Community Engagement J.7 Develop a clear, community-driven architectural standard for Lowcountry development that reflects the character of the Island Short Term: 1-3 years Community Engagement, Real Estate 132 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 133 IMPLEMENTATION: STRATEGIES Page 147 of 174 ID POTENTIAL STEPS TIMEFRAME RELATED TRENDS J.8 Explore a form-oriented code system as a governing mechanism for focus area properties Short Term: 1-3 years Real Estate, Economics J.9 Utilize design standards to enforce more sustainable and resilient land use, including expanding provisions for stormwater management, vegetative buffers, and trees Short Term: 1-3 years Natural and Cultural Environment, Real Estate J.10 Pursue opportunities to expand pathways Mid Term: 3-5 years Systems, Natural and Cultural Environment 132 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 133 Page 148 of 174 134 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 135 Page 149 of 174 SOURCES & RESOURCES The conditions and trends summaries presented through the previous chapters were distilled from numerous data sources, plans, publications, and additional resources. This section presents an index of those resources along with additional links and connected information. All sources presented through the section are hyperlinked. The Conditions & Trends Database The source data and tables for the summarized conditions and trends topical series is organized into a single database. This can be accessed through the QR Code above. Data will be updated periodically based on new releases from their sources. Click for link to database TOPIC SOURCE Demographics U.S. Decennial Census 2000–2020 American Community Survey 2010–2020 Census Flows Mapper South Carolina Department of Education American Hospital Directory Hilton Head Regional Physicians Network HealthGrades.com CauseIQ County Health Rankings Esri 2017 Gullah Geechee Cultural Preservation Project Report TOPIC SOURCE Workforce American Community Survey 2000–2020 U.S. Decennial Census 2000–2020 Beaufort Regional Chamber of Commerce The Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Annual Financial Report The Island Packet Technical College of the Lowcountry Federal Reserve Economic Data 134 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 135 Page 150 of 174 TOPIC SOURCE Economics U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis Federal Reserve Economic Data The Town of Hilton Head Island Beaufort County, SC – HHH Airport Terminal Expansion Hilton Head Island Airport Lowcountry Area Transportation Study Hilton Head Island–Bluffton Chamber of Commerce & Visitor Convention Bureau American Community Survey 2000–2020 U.S. Decennial Census 2000–2020 TOPIC SOURCE Real Estate Air DNA American Community Survey 2000–2020 CoStar Beaufort County Auditor Zillow The Town of Hilton Head Island - Short Term Rental Permits TOPIC SOURCE Natural & Cultural Environment National Hurricane Center Green Infrastructure Center Our Plan Hilton Head Island South Carolina 2020-2040 SeaTurtle.org DeepRoot.com HiltonHeadIsland.com The Town of Hilton Head Island - Beach Renourishment Program The Island Packet South Carolina Department of Health Environmental Control 136 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 137 APPENDIX: SOURCES & RESOURCES Page 151 of 174 National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Environmental Protection Agency IOP Science National Weather Service Beaufort County, SC S.C. Sea Grant Consortium TOPIC SOURCE Housing American Community Survey 2000–2020 Zillow RedFin Department of Housing and Urban Development Caring.com Seniorly Senior Housing Net Affordable Housing Online PublicHousing.com Eviction Lab Our Plan Hilton Head Island South Carolina 2020-2040 TOPIC SOURCE Governance American Community Survey 2012–2021 The Town of Hilton Head Island Think HHI and the Lowcountry 136 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 137 Page 152 of 174 TOPIC SOURCE Community Engagement Our Plan Hilton Head Island South Carolina 2020-2040 Youtube Twitter Instagram Facebook LinkedIn Flickr Hilton Head Island–Bluffton Chamber of Commerce TOPIC SOURCE Systems Town of Hilton Head Island Hilton Head Public Service District Broad Creek Public Service District South Island Public Service District Beaufort County Sheriff ’s Office Palmetto Electric Cooperative Inc. United States Geological Survey South Carolina DOT BreezeTrolley.com University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute American Hospital Directory 138 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 139 APPENDIX: SOURCES & RESOURCES Page 153 of 174 TOPIC SOURCE Land Use HiltonHeadIsland.com ExploreHiltonHead.com Palmetto Dunes Property Owners Association Celebrate Hilton Head The Providence Group The Town of Hilton Head Island 138 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 139 Page 154 of 174 RELEVANT PLANS AND STUDIES • Strategic Action Plan, 2021 Details activities of staff and associated entities necessary to implement the policy directions, furthering the Town’s mission from the Our Plan (Comprehensive Plan) • Beach Management Plan, 2017 Analyzes Hilton Head beaches,their environmental constraints, and strategies for disaster planning and preserving public access • Our Plan (Comprehensive Plan), 2020 Serves as the policy planning framework, and guide for a resilient and successful future of Hilton Head Island • Fire Rescue Strategic Plan, 2019 Establishes the priorities and expectations of Hilton Head’s Fire Rescue Organization • Hazard Mitigation Plan, 2021 Required by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), it serves as the representation of the jurisdiction’s commitment to reduce risks from natural hazards • Mid-Island District Plan, 2022 Envisions a future for the Mid-Island District that combines park design with community planning • Mid Island Tract Master Plan, 2022 Aims to ensure that a park on the Mid-Island Tract serves the entire community, residents, and visitors • Office of Cultural Affairs Strategic Plan 2021 Aims to promote and support Hilton Head Island as a vibrant and diverse place that is celebrated for the ways arts and culture enrich the community • Parks & Recreation Master Plan Pt. 1, 2020 Evaluates Hilton Head Island’s access to public parks and makes recommendations to increase the level of service across the community over the next ten years 140 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 141 APPENDIX: SOURCES & RESOURCES Page 155 of 174 • Workforce Housing Strategic Plan, 2019 Aims to expand housing options for workers who serve the Hilton Head Island economy and community • Workforce Housing Framework, 2022 Recommendations for perserving and expanding workforce housing options on the Island • 2045 LATS Long Range Transportation Plan, 2022 Outlines the strategies for creating a resilient transportation system, accommodating both existing and future needs • Broad Creek Management Plan, 2023 Fulfills a recommendation from the 1999 Comprehensive Plan to manage and protect the most significant and vulnerable natural resource on the Island • Stoney Initiative Area Plan, 2023 Fills the gap in the Ward One Master Land Use plan regarding the Stoney Neighborhood • Chaplin Initiative Area Plan, 2002 Provides land use provisions with associated density and determines infrastructure services needed to accomplish the goals of the Chaplin area • Ward One Master Plan, 1999 Addresses the needs in equity in addressing the aspirations of the community for groups historically left out of the economic progress enjoyed by relative newcomers • Hilton Head Island Airport Master Plan Examines land use and facility requirements in line with sustainability and future airport development priorities 140 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 141 Page 156 of 174 BLUFFTONBLUFFTON SAVANNAHSAVANNAH HARDEEVILLEHARDEEVILLE PORT OF PORT OF SAVANNAHSAVANNAH SAVANNAH/HILTON HEAD SAVANNAH/HILTON HEAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORTINTERNATIONAL AIRPORT JASPER OCEAN TERMINAL JASPER OCEAN TERMINAL (UNDER DEVELOPMENT)(UNDER DEVELOPMENT) PALMETTO PALMETTO BLUFFBLUFF EXIT 5EXIT 5 EXIT 8EXIT 8 N e w R i v e r N e w R i v e r Savannah National Wildlife Refuge JONES ISLAND May River RdMay River Rd Okatie HwyOkatie Hwy Freedom PkwyFreedom Pkwy Buckwalter Pkwy Buckwalter Pkwy US 17US 17 US 17US 17 US 278US 278 US 17US 17 Savannah Ri v e r Savannah Ri v e r Islands ExpyIslands Expy JASPER COUNTY BEAUFORT COUNTY G E ORGI A SOUTH CAROLINA Lowcountry DrLowcountry Dr 95 95 ◄ ◄ Jacksonville, FL 135 MilesJacksonville, FL 135 Miles Charleston, SC 80 Miles Charleston, SC 80 Miles ►► 170 170 25 46 25 DAUFUSKIE ISLAND US 278US 278 142 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 143 Page 157 of 174 N e w R i v e r N e w R i v e r G E ORGI A SOUTH CAROLINA 46 Marshland Incorporated Cities and Towns Major Roadways PORT PORT ROYALROYAL Calibogue SoundCalibogue Sound Atlanti c Ocean Atlanti c Ocean M a y Ri ver M a y Ri ver Chechessee River Chechessee River Beaufort River Beaufort River William Hilton ParkwayWilliam Hilton Parkway Cross Island Parkway Cross Island Parkway DAUFUSKIE ISLAND BULL ISLAND PICKNEY ISLAND Port RoyalPort Royal SoundSound D A W S ISLAND Bluffton PkwyBluffton Pkwy US 278US 278 US 278US 278 N REGIONAL CONTEXT The Town of Hilton Head Island is part of a dynamic and fast- growing region. Investments in roads, ports, and airports are expanding the jobs market. Homebuilding − to support these jobs and a burgeoning retirement community − is occurring at similar rates. This map depicts the Island’s regional context and includes portions of Beaufort County, Jasper County, and the Savannah Metropolitan Area of Georgia. SAINT PHILLIPS ISLAND SAINT HELENA ISLAND OLD TOWN OLD TOWN BLUFFTONBLUFFTON 5 Miles HILTON HEAD HILTON HEAD ISLANDISLAND 142 | The Town of Hilton Head Island Master Plan DRAFT | version 4.1 DRAFT | version 4.1 Conditions & Trends Assessment 2023 | 143 Page 158 of 174 Report prepared by: Page 159 of 174 1 Page 160 of 174 Public Planning Committee March 14, 2024 2 Page 161 of 174 Understanding our Island 1. Collect and organize a baseline of critical data • Investigate available sources and existing research • Assemble a comprehensive database organized around ten topics 2. Identify major trends • Organize findings around critical trends. • Supplement with a database of all information 3. Clearly communicate the information • Focus on “need to know” information • Present in a clear, graphically rich format 4. Consider application and “next steps” • Introduce future strategies and actions to be considered • Leverage the work through forthcoming plans and studies 3 Page 162 of 174 Reflecting on our values • Relentless Pursuit of Excellence • Redefining Environmental Sustainability • Revitalizing and Modernizing the Economy • Fostering an Inclusive Multi-dimensional Community • Building a Connected and Collaborative Community Fabric • Expanding to Embrace an Integrated Regional Focus • Creating “Right-Sized” Infrastructure 4 Page 163 of 174 Topics and clusters Reporting through the CTA covers ten, broad topic clusters 5 Demographics Workforce Economics Real Estate Environment Governance Engagement Systems Housing Land Use Page 164 of 174 Connections to Our Plan chapters 6 Environment Systems Governance Demographics Workforce Economics Real Estate Land Use Engagement Housing Page 165 of 174 Putting the information to use Provide a common starting point • Add context to community conversations with respect local and regional trends • Connect key information; share source data and resources • Remove the mystery on community needs, gaps, or opportunities 7 The CTA will inform recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan, Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. The report will also … Page 166 of 174 Putting the information to use Inform future plans and studies • Provide base set of findings to help initially focus and direct work • Accelerate the data assembly process with ready-made resources, tables, maps, and other resources • Uncover pressing or emergent issues, opportunities, and/or needs • Synchronize data across multiple planning efforts, departments, and community partners 8 The CTA will inform recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan, Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. The report will also … Page 167 of 174 Putting the information to use Sort priorities • Establish an urgency of need based “root cause” issues • Sequence projects and policy based on connections • Identify “points of leverage” for issues outside the Town’s purview • Justify expenditures in terms of capital and time 9 The CTA will inform recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan, Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. The report will also … Page 168 of 174 Putting the information to use Measure progress • Take a moment-in-time “snapshot” of the Island across multiple trends • Measure progress or movement against this benchmark • Evaluate policy effectiveness • Quantify short and long-term impacts of major projects 10 The CTA will inform recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan, Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. The report will also … Page 169 of 174 Who will use the CTA? The General Public Town Council The Town Manager and Staff Town Staff and Development Partners • Move from notional to knowledge-based community conversations • Build a common understanding • Provide a starting point for reviewing Town policy • Feed the general curiosity • Provide real information • Create a “Big picture” view • Build an understanding of interconnecting or causal factors • Assign indicators; mark progress • Establish planning and capital priorities • Craft public/private partnering opportunities • Prioritize future planning efforts • Provide a ready- made factual background • Develop a priming set of key info • Establish a starting point for planning efforts • Inspire and influence action 11 Page 170 of 174 Building a culture of data-driven decision making • Continue to create valuable insights • Commit to continual growth • Improve program outcomes • Optimize operations and levels of service • Anticipate future trends and local impacts • Create actionable, real-time insights 12 Page 171 of 174 Insight fuels strategic thinking Study • Outline and analyze Reveal • Share information Connect • Attach to strategy Apply • Policy / Projects Evaluate • Indicators 13 • Information informs strategy and strategy reveals projects and policies • Key data reveal indicators to measure progress (ex. workforce housing units) • Moving indicators proves progress; fuel further investment or pivot in policy Page 172 of 174 Next steps • Support by Town Council • Publishing and sharing findings • Integrating work with ongoing and future planning processes 14 Page 173 of 174 Questions? • Thank you 15 Page 174 of 174

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.