Public Planning Committee — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Public Planning Committee · meeting of Mar 14, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 1 of 6
Town of Hilton Head Island
PUBLIC PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING
Thursday, March 14, 2024, 10:00 AM
Minutes
Call to Order
Chair Ames called the meeting to order at 10:00 a.m.
Committee Members present: David Ames, Chair, Ward 3; Tammy Becker, Ward 4;
Patsy Brison, Ward 5, Steve Alfred, Alternate
Committee Members absent: Glenn Stanford, Ward 6
Adoption of the Agenda
Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Approval of the Minutes
Regular Meeting Minutes of February 8, 2024
Ms. Becker moved to approve. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 4-0.
Appearance by Citizens
Keith Burns, President, Sea Pines Property Owners Association, addressed the
Committee with the results of a survey sent to Sea Pines property owners regarding
the Short-term Rental regulations regarding occupancy.
Unfinished Business
Consideration of a Resolution Supporting the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions
and Trends Assessment - Missy Luick, Director of Planning
Ms. Luick provided background and conducted a presentation regarding the item. The
Hilton Head Island Town Council held a two- day strategic plan workshop on January
24-25, 2023, to discuss and identify priorities for inclusion in the 2023- 2025 Strategic
Action Plan. This workshop led to the establishment of a G rowth Management Strategy,
including a Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and Trends Assessment, within the
top 15 priority projects.
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 2 of 6
Our Plan, the Town’s Comprehensive Plan, identified 7 core values for the Town of
Hilton Head Island including:
• R elentless Pursuit of Excellence
• R edefining Environmental Sustainability
• R evitalizing and Modernizing the Economy
• F ostering an Inclusive Multi-dimensional Community
• B uilding a Connected and Collaborative Community Fabric
• E xpanding to Embrace an Integrated Regional Focus, and
• C reating “Right-Sized” Infrastructure
To best serve the community in the pursuit of these ideals, the T own must be aware of
the current conditions as well as future projections of each of these segments.
The Conditions and Trends Assessment was initiated by the Strategic Action Plan and
managed through the Community Development D epartment and their consultants
MKSK and Kimley -Horn. The Assessment acts as a user manual for the Town and
organizes a baseline of critical data to identify major trends and communicate the
information through a consolidated Assessment. The analysis will help leadership better
understand the emerging trends to prepare policy that is timely, and data driven.
The Conditions and Trends Assessment is a statistical Assessment that provides a
community snapshot in ten topic areas including:
• Demographics
• W orkforce
• Economics
• R eal Estate
• Natural and Cultural Environment
• H ousing
• G overnance
• C ommunity Engagement
• Systems
• L and Use
These ten topic areas are in line with our core values detailed in Our Plan which
include:
• Cultural Resources
• Natural Resources
• Population
• Housing
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 3 of 6
• Community Facilities
• Economic Development
• Land Use
• Transportation
• Priority Investment
Assessment in Action
The Assessment provides community benchmark information and statistics from which
to evaluate and assess the overall health of the community. The Assessment will be
used as a building block for Town leadership to make data- driven decisions related to
future community plans, community development strategies, public policies, and
strategic actions. The purpose of the Conditions and Trends Assessment is to present
an objective view of the Town’s most significant data points and trends in 2023. The use
of this information – for planning, prioritizing, budgeting, etc. – should be considered
through subsequent, future-focused conversations. As a living document, the Conditions
and Trends Assessment will be updated regularly to reflect the ongoing evolution of the
Town of Hilton Head Island.
The report and dataset are designed to enhance the community’s shared understanding
of current and emergent issues. This work will help inform the findings and
recommendations for Town planning initiatives like the decennial Comprehensive Plan,
Capital Improvements Program, and Strategic Action Plan. This Assessment will be
used by the Town in several ways including:
• Provide a common starting point
o Add context to community conversations with respect local and regional
trends
o Connect key information; share source data and resources
o Remove the mystery on community needs, gaps, or opportunities
• Inform future plans and studies
o Provide base set of findings to help initially focus and direct work
o Accelerate the data assembly process with ready -made resources, tables,
maps, and other resources
o Uncover pressing or emergent issues, opportunities, and/or needs
o Synchronize data across multiple planning efforts, departments, and
community partners
• Sort priorities
o Establish an urgency of need based “root cause” issues
o Sequence projects and policy based on connections
o Identify “points of leverage” for issues outside the Town’s purview
o Justify expenditures in terms of capital and time
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 4 of 6
• Measure progress
o Take a moment-in-time “snapshot” of the Island across multiple trends
o Measure progress or movement against this benchmark
o Evaluate policy effectiveness
o Quantify short and long-term impacts of major projects
Insight Becomes Strategic Conversation
The document includes a robust Future Strategies chapter that includes possible
implementation actions in response to the trends outlined within the Assessment . The
potential steps are broken down by topic area and include a note on related topic trends
as well as a suggested time frame for discussion. Again, the use of this information, for
planning, prioritizing, budgeting, should be considered through subsequent policy and
program strategic conversations.
Once approved, the Conditions and Trends Assessment will be included on the Town of
Hilton Head website on the Master Plan landing page as a resource document. The
Conditions and Trends Assessment gathered a wealth of information that both
supported what is already seen in the community such as demographic changes and
other areas gave some insight into potential threats to the island including
environmental issues. The information brings attention to the complexity and
interconnectivity of the decisions that Town Council and Town staff are responsible for
making. The factual and trend analysis information provided in the Assessment will
help support the Town of Hilton Head Island in future policy and decision making.
This is the second presentation of the Town of Hilton Head Island Conditions and
Trends Assessment.
Members of the Committee asked questions, made comments, and had discussion
regarding: affirmation the Assessment will help with the strategic plan workshop;
inquiry regarding the implementation plan and incorporation of the data for potential
strategies; confirmation the Assessment is a tool for planning and prioritizing;
confirmation this would be adopted for future considerations; a suggestion that current
actions should be labeled as potential first steps and future ones as potential strategies
and actions; discussion as to the intent of the use of the Assessment ; the need for
clarification of immediate priorities; concern the proposal is to adopt this as the plan for
the future; a suggestion the Committee recommend T own Council accept the
Assessment as opposed to adopting it; caution not to approve something as a finalized
document but as a provision of data that could be analyzed for future plans; the need
for further discussion regarding the strategies; comments regarding the capacity of the
Island and that it has limitations; a need for focus on residents as opposed to tourists;
a question as to the need to work with strategies to accommodate more people to
come to the Island; the need for statistics defining the results; a questions and concern
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 5 of 6
with committing to continued growth; the need to have statistics and demographic
information in order to make informed decisions; the view it is a planning document;
inquiry as to the timeline for updating the document; and confirmation the document
will be updated but the timeline has not been determined.
Chair Ames invited Curtis Coltrane to the podium to answer questions regarding
adoption or acceptance of the Assessment . Mr. Coltrane stated adopting something
creates policy which is authorization to execute the policy. He stated if they change it
to accept there is a question as to what is to be done with it after it is accepted. He
further stated that the task at hand is whether or not to approve that the item advance
to Council with the Committee’s recommendation of approval or rejection.
Members of the Committee asked questions, made comments, and had discussion
regarding: concern that if adopted is used they are recommending that it be their
implementation plan; confirmation the Condition Trends Assessment is a planning tool
which is information for the Strategic Action Plan; clarification the recommendations
would be potential strategies in future planning; and concern as to the Town Manager’s
authority if the resolution is adopted.
Curtis Coltrane confirmed if Town Council were to adopt the resolution, it would
empower the Town Manager to utilize the plan to bring items back to Council for review
and consideration.
Chair Ames asked for public comment.
Christopher Cliff addressed the Committee challenging the statistic within the
Assessment. He noted the baseline needs to be more accurate.
Heather Rath a ddressed the Committee regarding technical errors within the document
and the need for clarity of the statistics. She added there is a need for a definition of
“limited services government”.
Owen Ambur a
ddressed the Committee stating his opinion this is a working document
as opposed to a policy document which contains two different areas that need
addressed separately which are data and trends and recommendations and strategies.
Concluding further discussion Chair Ames asked for a motion.
Ms. Brison moved to recommend that the Town Council accept the conditions
and trends Assessment with the following amendments:
Page 113 – strike the word “strategies” and insert in lieu thereof potential
strategies”.
Page 114 – strike the phrase “current steps” and inset in lieu thereof the phrase
Town of Hilton Head Island Public Planning
Committee Meeting Minutes
3/14/2024 Page 6 of 6
“potential first steps”.
Page 115 – strike the phrase “future strategies and steps” and insert in lieu
thereof the phrase “potential future strategies and steps”.
And further to amend the draft resolution as follows:
In the seventh Whereas – strike the word “adoption” and insert in lieu thereof the
word “acceptance”.
And under the resolution clause in paragraph number (1) strike the word
“adopted” and insert in lieu thereof the word “accepted”.
In the second clause under the resolution language strike number (2) and insert
in lieu thereof the following sentence: “The Town Manager is authorized to use
the Conditions and Trends Assessment for future planning purposes.
Finally, to ask the Town Manager to have the Town Staff review the document in
light of the public’s comments to make any technical corrections.
(Ms. Brison’s notes and written words for the motion are attached as exhibit A.)
Mr. Alfred seconded.
Ms. Becker expressed concern over not being able to follow each change and
questioned if all were confident that the document would reflect the changes.
Motion carried 3-1 (Becker opposed).
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 11:05 a.m.
Approved: May 9, 2024
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s
website at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Exhibit A - Public Projects Facilities Meeting Minutes
March 14, 2024 - Council Member Brison's Motion on Item 5.a
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.