20261119_bpcrecs.docx
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
City of Isle of Palms
Recommendation 8 to IOP City Council:
Support Southern Groin and Dewees Inland Dredging Studies
Date: November 18th, 2026
The Beach Preservation Committee (BPC) recommends to the Isle of Palms City Council to fund both Foth Olsen proposals for designing and permitting of a groin at the South end of the island and for testing, investigating and permitting the dredging of Dewees Inlet.
Rational:
Several studies have now concluded that a long groin at the Southern end of the Isle of Palms is needed to slow erosion at the South end of the island.
In the Alternatives Study, coastal engineering firm Foth Olsen recommended a Southern groin as one of their priority actions for the city to take and estimated that it would slow erosion at the two most Southern reached by as much as 25% and 50%.
While the construction cost will likely be around $4M, the BPC estimates that it will save the city around $2M in future renourishment efforts at each renourishment cycle.
Foth is qualified to do this work and is already knee-deep in the relevant analysis. The cost of around $350,000 after negotiations with Foth appears to be justified.
The city and WDCA need to understand whether dredging Dewees Inlet is a viable alternative to expansive offshore dredging.
Mobilization cost will be about 33% less than off-share mobilization.
The cost of the pumped sand is about 20% less per cubic yard than offshore sand.
In addition, and very importantly, we need to understand whether dredging the inlet will limit the very negative implications of the periodic shoal attachment that causes extreme erosion at Ocean Club and Beachwood East beaches.
The cost of this study is estimated to be less than $500,000 after negotiations with Foth.
Experts estimate that Dewees Inlet could be a 700,000 cubic yard source of beach quality sand for Wild Dunes every 3-6 years.
For the IOP Beach Preservation Committee
Dietmar Ostermann
Chairman
Dostermann62@gmail.com
+1.972.672.4424
BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
City of Isle of Palms
Recommendation 9 to IOP City Council:
Design Alternatives Study for Wild Dunes Hard Structures
Date: November 18th, 2026
The Beach Preservation Committee (BPC) recommends to the Isle of Palms City Council to request a proposal for a design alternatives study from Foth Olsen for designing and simulating hard structure alternatives for the beaches in front of Ocean Club and Beachwood East.
Rational:
The beach erosion at Ocean Club and Beachwood East is the worst on IOP.
Re-nourishment alone is very expansive and hard to afford for both, IOP and WDCA.
Foth Olsen’s Alternatives Study has indicated that the erosion could be slowed significantly by building hard structures in both hot spots. The present value of T-groins and breakwaters versus renourishment needs further analysis. T-groins and breakwaters stabilize shorelines by dissipating waves, reducing sand volume loss, extending expensive renourishment intervals and protecting high value infrastructure.
The Alternatives study stopped short of recommending a certain structure solution and indicated more study needs to be done.
The BPC and WDCA would like to see that alternative designs being developed and simulated that anticipate the erosion rate reduction, construction cost, environmental impact and visual impact for homeowners and beach goers. Those design alternatives should include the number of groins, their length, the material used and the shape.
The BPC is envision a design alternatives study, not a permit application or construction drawing.
For the IOP Beach Preservation Committee
Dietmar Ostermann
Chairman
Dostermann62@gmail.com
+1.972.672.4424
BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
City of Isle of Palms
Recommendation 10 to IOP City Council:
Process Changes in the Interaction between the BPC and IOP’s City Council
Date: November 18th, 2026
The Beach Preservation Committee (BPC) recommends to the Isle of Palms City Council to optimize the process by which the BPC interacts with the Council:
Going forward, the City Administrator and the Council representative on the BPC are required to resent the views and recommendations of the BPC to Council whenever Council is discussing a topic related to IOP’s beaches.
Rationale:
Advisory Role: Council established the BPC to provide citizen advice on beach-related issues.
Information Gaps: Council has recently discussed beach matters without full awareness of the BPC's relevant context for recommendations.
Representation: Both the City Administrator and the BPC Council representative have recently not conveyed the BPC’s positions developed through detailed reviews and discussions.
Proactive Alignment: City administration should notify the BPC of upcoming Council beach agenda items and request written rationales for BPC recommendations. This preserves context, avoids duplicate consultant costs, and prevents conflicting advice.
For the IOP Beach Preservation Committee
Dietmar Ostermann
Chairman
Dostermann62@gmail.com
+1.972.672.4424
BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
City of Isle of Palms
Recommendation 11: Beneficial Use Sand Quality Analysis
Date: November 19, 2026
The Beach Preservation Committee of the city of Isle of Palms recommends the City Council seek an independent evaluation of Army Corp beneficial use sand quality by a coastal engineer. This is based on Chris Creed’s recommendation to confirm beach compatibility prior to acceptance of any beneficial use sand. We recommend this study is completed now, as it impacts groin cost/benefit analysis, budget implications (offshore source value of this sand is $0.5MM/year or $4MM over 8 years), and could influence project implementation pace.
Background:
A FOIA request was given to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) to obtain sand quality of the intracoastal dredged material that was delivered via pipe direct to the beach (6th – 9th Ave) by Cottrell. Sand from the dredge location was analyzed by USACE in 2023 and is said to represent future intercoastal projects.
USACE Intracoastal Beneficial Use Sand Quality from WC-4A:
Appears inconsistent with US Fish and Wildlife opinions, SCDES water quality and SCDES coastal sediment compatibility rules.
13% silt and clay
For every 150,000 cubic yards delivered, only 7%, or 10,500 cubic yards, is greater than 0.149mm grain size*
WC-4A Details:
87% fine; 13% silt
93% is less than 0.149mm grain size (passed through a #100 sieve size).
13% passed through a sieve size at 0.075mm
*Native Sand Quality (CSE): IOP south end native mean grain sizes between 0.15 and 0.25mm
Phase I Quick Pass Analysis Requested:
Review USACE grain size compatibility, regulatory compliance, and impacts on Foth beach alternative recommendations and budget impacts, if any
Estimate quantity of 150,000 cy delivered by USACE to be beach stable vs. expected to quickly wash away. Desktop calculation of the overfill factor (Ra), if USACE grain distribution data is sufficient or available.
List important considerations of USACE beneficial use sand that may need further analysis (ability of fine sand to sustain a normal beach slope, ability of fine sand placed below water line to move towards dunes versus downstream, potential downstream impacts, etc)
BEACH PRESERVATION COMMITTEE
City of Isle of Palms
Recommendation 12: Town Facilitation for South End Sand Fencing and Increased Vegetation
Date: November 19, 2026
The Beach Preservation Committee of the city of Isle of Palms recommends the City Council assist residents on the south end to enable a private pay option for sand fencing and increased vegetation, in accordance with ecological recommendations and equitable protection of the dune.
Background:
Based on the SCDES sand and vegetation permit, plus guidance from coastal experts Chris Creed (Foth & Olsen) and Nicole Elko, the Beach Preservation Committee recommends:
18” spacing of vegetation across the entire dune. Planting sea oat plugs at a maximum of 18” apart improves the ability to trap blowing sand, builds a dense underground root network, and helps survive harsh coastal winds before eroding. Plantings spaced greater than 18” apart, up to 36” apart, should use one-gallon plants, not the 2” containers IOP will receive.
Sand fencing at the bottom of all new dunes. Because a freshly built dune lacks deep root systems, it is highly vulnerable to wind erosion and foot traffic until plants can take hold. The 8” tall sea oats we will receive are too small to trap blowing sand initially, especially if planted at greater distances apart.
The Wild Dunes Association made up the financial shortfall for residents on the north end. However, a financial shortfall remains on the south end due to budget constraints. The result:
24” vegetation spacing rather than 18” on dune news, from Breach Inlet to ~8th Ave
NO sand fencing on any new dunes, except at beach paths
Some residents are interested in private pay to cover the financial shortfall for their property. The town’s contractor, Earth Balance, has ample crews and can take on additional work with no impact to the town’s funded project.
The recommendation:
The Beach Preservation Committee recommends:
Sand fencing is installed in January on the south end, or as soon as Marinex is complete, for both the town’s covered portion 8th thru the pier plus any resident who elects to private pay, to help prevent sand blowing and stabilize the dune for plantings after frost.
Council approve administrative resources to facilitate communication for a private pay option to create an equitable level of protection via sand fencing and 18” vegetation spacing
facilitate communication via: Beach Preservation Committee post on IOP social media, Forwarding Beach Preservation Committee email to residents, and/or other options to reach residents Breach Inlet to ~8th Ave
Facilitate communication with Earth Balance on residents who opt-in
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.