April 19 (PDF, 68.77 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS and MEANS COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, April 19, 2011
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was held at 5:45 p.m. on Tuesday,
April 19, 2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy,
Loftus, Piening, Stone and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of March 15, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Financial Statement – Treasurer Debbie Suggs
A. March Financial Statement
Treasurer Suggs commented that the financial statement before the Committee was through the
month of March, which is seventy-five percent (75%) of the way through the fiscal year.
General Fund revenue through March 31 was a sixty-nine percent (69%) of budget; in addition,
the City received the final Property Tax payments for January and February from Charleston
County in the amount of eight hundred sixteen thousand dollars ($816,000). With this collec-
tion, the FY11 revenue attributed to property taxes has been met. Through nine (9) months of
the fiscal year, General Fund expenditures are at sixty-eight percent (68%) of budget, and all
departments, except General Government are below budget. The Treasurer reminded Council
that the reason that General Government is over the nine (9) month target is that an annual debt
service payment has been made that is charged to that department.
In addition, Treasurer Suggs explained that expenses are low presently, but will catch up by
year’s end with seven (7) payrolls still to be paid, bi-annual payments for property and liability
insurance, as well as two (2) quarterly payments for Workers Compensation.
Councilmember Loftus asked for clarification on the disparity between the budget of over one
million dollars ($1,000,000) and collections year-to-date of only eighty-six thousand dollars
($86,000) for Other Licenses revenue. Treasurer Suggs stated that revenues from insurance
licenses and franchise fees make up that budget line, and the funds are, typically, received at
the end of the fiscal year.
At the end of March, the City had three hundred ninety-one thousand dollars ($391,000)
invested with BB&T and approximately two million dollars ($2,000,000) invested with the Local
Government Investment Pool (LGIP); the total cash represents twenty-nine percent (29%) of
annual General Fund expenditures.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 2 of 10
B. Tourism Schedules
State ATAX – Payments are made quarterly; therefore, the City should be receiving the March
quarter before the next meeting. Revenue is nine and a half percent (9.5%) greater than the
same period in FY10.
Municipal ATAX – Collections for FY11 continue to trend ahead of FY10.
Charleston County Pass-through – Payments are re ceived semi-annually, so the information is
the same as February.
Hospitality Taxes – Collections year-to-date are nine percent (9%) greater than FY10.
C. Projects Status
Beach Restoration – Expenditures since the February meeting were for post-project monitoring,
permitting and the consulting services of Chris Jones from October 2010 through March 2011.
53
rd-57th Avenue Drainage – Page 1 reflects the change orders approved at the February
meeting, and, on page 2, expenditures for legal fees , technical support from Civil Site Environ-
mental and the first (1st) pay application from Eadie’s Construction.
Administrator Tucker stated that work has been completed at the check-in area of Wild Dunes
and the landscaping has been restored; work is continuing in the parking lot and on Marsh
Island.
City Hall Renovation – The most recent expenditures are for phones, the fourth (4
th) pay appli-
cation to Wilson and Associates and painting.
5. Old Business – None
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to reorder the agenda to discuss
an item of Miscellaneous Business before New Business; Councilmember Loftus
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Mayor Cronin reported that the Public Works’ ice maker has broken; it was purchased in 1998
and is determined to be beyond repair. Director Pitts has secured three (3) bids for
replacement; the lowest was three thousand forty-six dollars ($3,046), including sales taxes.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to approve an amount not to exceed
thirty-one hundred dollars ($3,100) from the Capital Projects Fund to replace the
ice maker for the Public Works Department; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Before proceeding with New Business and the Budget Workshop, Mayor Cronin and Council
agreed to break for a light meal at 6:05 p.m. The meeting resumed at 6:30 p.m.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 3 of 10
6. New Business
Budget Workshop for FY 2011-2012 Operating and Capital Budgets
Administrator Tucker stated that the packets for the meeting included the following:
1) The proposed FY12 budget;
2) The City’s debt schedule;
3) The Fund balance schedule; and
4) The Ten-year Capital Plan.
Copies of all of the documents are attached to the historical record of the meeting.
The Administrator then commented that the FY12 budget, as proposed, is a balanced General
Fund budget with no tax increase.
Global comments for the operating budgets were that the departmental budgets include a three
percent (3%) merit pool, do not create any new positions, include the cost estimates for the new
health insurance, eliminate the long-term disability costs which are now part of the health
insurance premium and contain an estimate of four dollars ($4) per gallon for fuel.
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that, since the March meeting, she and the
Treasurer had met with each department manager for a line-by-line analysis of expenditures.
The process involved calculating the average fo r each line using audited year-end financial
statements for a period of five (5) years; any expenditure in the FY12 budget that was at least
five hundred dollars ($500) greater than the five-year (5 yr.) average was further dissected and,
frequently, reductions were made. The FY12 budget included in the meeting packets reflects
those changes.
General Fund Revenue
In general, revenue is projected to be slightly less than in FY11; primary contributing factors are
the reduction to State-shared funds by the State legislature and the lower population reported
by the 2010 census.
Transfers-in from tourism funds will pay salari es in FY12, as in FY11, for beach services
officers, the livability officer, additional summer weekend personnel in the Fire Department, etc.
Administrator Tucker commented that, if necessary, the City could increase the millage by one
and sixty-four one hundredths percent (1.64%), the amount of the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
For the past couple of years, the City has avoided a millage increase to balance the budget.
Mayor Cronin reported that an issue being hotly debated in the State legislature as part of the
point-of-sale legislation is a condition that would allow this type of increase to accumulate for a
period of up to three (3) years, rather than just lose it if the local government does not enact the
increase for any given year.
Councilmember Buckhannon asked whether the City had set a precedent with the FY11 budget
of using tourism fund balances to balance the budget by paying salaries for staffing for the
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 4 of 10
Fire Department, two (2) Beach Services Officers and one (1) patrol officer previously paid from
the General Fund.
Administrator Tucker responded that, were these salaries to be moved back to the General
Fund, the budget would have to be re-balanced, and that re-balancing the budget could not be
done without adding the CPI increase to the millage rate. The Administrator explained that she
preferred not to fund salaries from tourism sources because these funds are not steady and are
not a guaranteed source.
Councilmember Piening remarked that the City would not need the level of staffing that it has
were it not for the tourists; he was clear in stating that the only other source of funds would be a
tax increase to residents. Administrator Tucker responded that staffing requirements, due to
public safety standards, would likely remain the same even if there were a reduction in tourism.
Councilmember Buckhannon said that another source of funds would be cutbacks to expenses;
Administrator Tucker responded that to reduce personnel would mean a reduction in services.
Councilmember Piening asked Councilmember Buck hannon if he were suggesting that the City
either reduce staff or raise taxes; to which Councilmember Buckhannon responded, “Neither.”
The FY12 revenue total is projected to be six tenths of one percent (0.6%) less than in FY11.
Mayor and Council
Administrator Tucker commented that the transition to the State Health Plan continues to be a
learning experience as enrollment continues. When the City was insured through SCLGAG,
elected officials could participate in the program at no cost to the City; they reimbursed the City
for the monthly premiums. Under the State Health Plan, all participants in the program must be
treated the same, i.e. elected officials the same as employees, and all participants must be
enrolled in the State Retirement System. In addition, the State Health Plan dictates out how
much the City must contribute toward the participant’s premium. For the City to continue to
allow elected officials to participate, the City will see an increase to the budget in premiums and
in the contribution to the State Health Plan. From polling other local governments, the staff
learned that all but one (1) do cover elected official and pay the premium expense.
Administrator Tucker said that staff needs to know whether the City wants to continue its pro-
gram of including elected officials, and, if so, who will want to participate and to what level. This
is especially important to know these things because the enrollment process is to be completed
and in the hands of the State Health Plan by May 1, 2011, as well as to make the appropriate
changes to the next version of the budget.
MOTION: Councilmember Piening moved to continue the policy of allowing
elected officials to participate in the City’s health insurance program and for the
City to pay the required premium expense; Councilmember Duffy seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 5 of 10
General Government
Administrator Tucker pointed out that the elevator maintenance for City Hall has been reduced
by half (½) by eliminating the twenty-four (24) hour emergency service provision that was insti-
tuted when the Police Department shared the building. The City Hall cleaning service will be bid
for a new contract beginning July 1, 2011. With the additional storage space afforded by the
City Hall renovation, two (2) off-site storage units were vacated reducing the expense in Line 60.
Councilmember Loftus remarked that using a five-year (5 yr.) average for advertising would
generate a misleading figure based on the successful efforts over the past two (2) years to
reduce the City’s advertising expense; the expense in FY10 was six thousand dollars ($6,000)
and, year-to-date in FY11, the expense is one thousand seventy-three dollars ($1,073). He
suggested reducing the FY12 budget to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) leaving a cushion for bid
notices/solicitations, and the City Administrator said the change would be made.
Councilmember Duffy commented to the amount budgeted for the digitizing of City records;
between FY11 and FY12, the project is costing twelve thousand five hundred dollars ($12,500).
He questioned whether the task had been priced out as a project, what the total cost would be
and in what fiscal year the project would be completed. The Administrator replied that the City
was using the same company that had digitized the Building Department’s records; they had
been found to be reliable and dependable with the City’s historical records and were charging
the City the same price today as when they started working with the City originally. The
Administrator assured Councilmember Duffy that the digitized records would be searchable.
When Councilmember Duffy queried if the City had fuel usage by department, Treasurer Suggs
reported that the City had the actual number of ga llons used per vehicle from the fuel system.
Councilmember Duffy acknowledged that the City could not control the price of gas, but could
control the mileage. Administrator Tucker said that three (3) factors impacted fuel costs; they
are (1) the price per gallon when purchased, (2) seasonality and (3) frequency of trips. When
the tourist season is at its height and servic es are in the highest demand, mileage and trip
frequency are almost impossible to control.
Police Department
No significant changes have been made in this budget.
Councilmember Duffy expressed the opinion that the general maintenance in the amount of four
thousand dollars ($4,000) for the Police Department seemed to be high for a building that was in
its second year of usage. Administrator Tucker recommended reducing the amount to three
thousand dollars ($3,000) to match the Fire Department.
For both the Fire and Police Departments, a proper estimate for electricity and gas in the Public
Safety Building remains a work-in-progress. Despite the equipment corrections SCE&G made
earlier in the year, the amount being billed is still in question.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 6 of 10
Fire Department
No significant changes have been made in this budget.
Public Works Department
The Public Works’ budget contains few changes from FY11.
Building and Planning Department
Having moved into their new space, the Building Department is now sharing City Hall expenses
as well as continuing to carry some level of expense for the old building.
Councilmember Bergwerf commented that the overtime proposed for FY12 appeared to be high
based on year-to-date. Treasurer Suggs explained that, for budget purposes, the overtime is
calculated as two percent (2%) of the salaries of those persons in the department eligible for
overtime; Councilmember Duffy suggested usin g one and one-half percent (1.5%) which equals
twenty-seven hundred ninety-one dollars ($2,791), which was acceptable to the balance of the
Committee.
When Councilmember Bergwerf questioned the electricity and gas estimate, Administrator
Tucker reminded the Committee that the Building Department is now paying half (½) for City
Hall and one hundred percent (100%) of the costs generated by the old building. The Treasurer
confirmed that the utility bills for City Hall are split fifty/fifty (50/50) and not apportioned by
square footage.
Recreation Department
This budget contains no significant changes over FY11.
Judicial and Legal
This budget contains no significant changes over FY11.
Parking Meter Department
This budget contains no significant changes over FY11.
The total FY12 operating budget is eight million, two hundred ninety-seven thousand three
hundred forty dollar ($8,297,340) and represents a decrease of six tenths of a percent (0.6%)
from the FY11 budget.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 7 of 10
Capital Project Fund Revenues
Grant Income $286,000
CTC & TST grants for 53rd-57th Avenue and 46th-52nd Avenue drainage projects
Grant Income 2,000
Recreation PARD grant
Interest Income 8,400
TOTAL $296,400
Transfer in from Gen Fund 6,216
Total Cap Proj Rev Net of Transfers $302,616
Municipal Accommodation Fee Fund Revenues
With all tourism-related revenue sources appearing to trend upward, the staff is confident in
estimating revenues to at or above the previous twelve months’ actual receipts. The County
Accommodations Taxes have been returned to their original 2009 levels, and staff has
estimated accordingly. Among the transfers out are fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) to increase
the reserve for future beach restoration efforts and approximately three hundred fifteen
thousand dollars ($315,000) to pay one hundred percent (100%) of the scheduled Beach
Restoration Debt service payment.
Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund Expenditures
The expenditures are listed by department, and the ma jority of expenditures are repeats of the
FY10 and 11 budgets. Included in General Government is fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) as
a placeholder for funds for the implementation of an on-street parking management program.
For the Police Department, funds are provided for four (4) in-car digital cameras and two (2)
mobile data terminals; the Fire Department sees a re-budget of funds for mobile radio repeaters
and funds to replace the Boat 1. In the Public Works Department, partial lease payments, signs
and the Charleston County Solid Waste Disposal fees are among the expenditures paid from
Municipal Accommodations Fees. On the Front Beach, the largest additions were five thousand
dollars ($5,000) each for sod and green spaces and road resurfacing/patching and sixty-seven
hundred dollars ($6,700) for an additional kiosk in the area of Sea Cabins.
The FY12 budget anticipates spending one hundred eighty-one thousand dollars ($181,000) of
cumulative surpluses from prior years. Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the
purposes of the accommodations taxes is to take care of tourists by providing services and
amenities and to get the money back into the community; if the fund balances were not spent,
the City would not be meeting the intended purpose for the money.
Hospitality Tax Fund Revenues
As collections have begun to rebound in FY11, Hospitality Tax revenues have been budgeted at
the level of actual FY11 collections, which is an increase of sixty thousand dollars ($60,000)
from last year. Unlike prior years, the FY12 budget does not reflect a transfer out to the marina
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 8 of 10
fund for debt service, but does include one-third ( ⅓) of the projected costs for dredging at one
hundred thousand dollars ($100,000).
Hospitality Tax Fund Expenditures
Expenditures are again reflected by department. For General Government, an addition of half
(½) of the cost for replacing the DOS-based court software at eight thousand dollars ($8,000)
has been included. Fifty-six thousand four hundred twenty dollars ($56,420) will be spent to
replace SCBA air packs, bunker gear, fire hose and appliances and two (2) gas meters for the
Fire Department.
The FY12 budget, as presented, will require spending approximately one hundred forty-four
thousand eight hundred dollars ($144,800) of cumulative fund balance from prior years.
Volunteer Fire 1% Fund Revenues
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the City only acts as custodian of this fund;
revenues are one percent (1%) of all island fire insurance policies, and the purposes for which
these funds can be expended is legislated.
State Accommodations Tax Fund Revenues
The revenues in the FY12 budget reflect the past twelve (12) months’ actual collections, which
are one hundred thirty-three thousand dollars ($133,000) higher than budgeted FY11.
Transfers out are basically the same with the exception of funding one-third ( ⅓) of the cost of
marina dredging.
State Accommodations Tax Fund Expenditures
Under General Government, a provision of fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the implement-
tation of an on-street parking management program is included. The balance of the cost of a
replacement boat, twenty-thousand dollars ($20,000), for the Fire Department is being paid from
this fund, and eighty thousand dollars ($80,000) has been added to the Public Works Depart-
ment for the repair/replacement of a dune walkover. The FY12 budget does not reflect any new
expenditures for the Police or Recreation Department or for the Front Beach and public rest-
rooms.
The FY12 budgets for the 2008 Beach Restoration Fund, the island-wide Beach Maintenance
Fund and Disaster Recovery Reserve Fund are basically unchanged from prior years. The
balance in the Disaster Recovery Reserve is one million eight hundred forty-one thousand
dollars ($1,841,000).
Very little activity takes place in the Federal and State Narcotics Funds.
The Victims Assistance Fund pays half (½) of the sa lary and benefits for the Victim’s Advocate;
the FY12 budget generally reflects the FY11 budget.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 9 of 10
On page 30, the Recreation Building Fund shows additional revenue in that the costs for and
revenue from the IOP Beach Run have be reclass ed to this fund from State ATAX. The Beach
Run has generated revenue in the past, and staff agreed that this was a good way to increase
this fund.
Marina Fund
Little expense is assigned to the marina because the leaseholders are responsible for the main-
tenance items that occur.
The Administrator noted that the City’s true expense for dredging the marina remains unknown
because, at this moment, no other stakeholders have come forward to participate in the project,
but that may change. The FY12 budget anticipates an expense of three hundred thousand
dollars ($300,000).
Under the heading “General and Administrative,” five thousand dollars ($5,000) is included for
advertising which a provision of the lease. Also included are legal fees applicable to the marina,
such as the review of the dredging agreements and engineering agreements.
For the Marina Store, the most significant figure is depreciation.
The City incurs no expenses from the Waverunner operation.
Total FY12 Marina Fund expenditures are approximately seven hundred thousand three
hundred dollars ($700,300) and anticipate a surplus of twenty-seven thousand three hundred
eighty-six dollars ($27,386).
The remainder of the budget documents is the FY12 Departmental Capital Budgets by proposed
funding sources and the Bonded Debt Service schedule.
Mayor Cronin distributed a schedule he had prepared that traced the changes in year-end
balances from FY06 through estimates for FY12 for the General Fund, the Capital Projects
Fund and three (3) tourism funds. The Mayor commented that two and a half million dollars
($2,500,000) is the comfort level for the auditor as it represents thirty percent (30%) of the
annual General Fund expenditures; the comfort level for the Capital Projects fund is one million
dollars ($1,000,000).
Focus was now directed to the Debt Analysis schedule that lists all City Debt with the terms,
principal and interest balances, sources of funds for payoff and whether or not early payoff is
possible. Mayor Cronin repeated Councilmember Loftus’ question about whether any debt
existed that the City could pay off with fund balances on hand that will benefit the City in future
years.
Councilmember Loftus stated that the City staff “has done a great job managing expenses this
year” yielding a surplus that he would like to use to reduce debt, possibly one (1) of the fire
trucks. His question was which truck; to which Mayor Cronin commented that the answer would
be based on how much the City wanted to spend.
Ways and Means Committee
April 19, 2011
Page 10 of 10
Treasurer Suggs confirmed that four hundred thousand dollars ($400,000) had been transferred
to the Capital Projects Fund at the end of FY10, and the forecast for FY11 is two hundred
thirteen thousand dollars ($213,000).
Councilmember Loftus explained that he understood that a portion of the FY10 gain would be
added to a portion of the FY11 gain to pay off debt which would eliminate the need for inclusion
of that debt service and interest in the FY12 budget.
Councilmember Stone expressed agreement with pay ing off the debt, but wanted the figures to
remain in the budget as a reserve to pay cash for or to reduce the amount of borrowing for a
future capital purchase.
The consensus of the Committee was to pay off the ninety-five foot (95 ft.) ladder truck;
Treasurer Suggs recommended that the payoff come from the same sources from which the
interest and principal payments would ordinarily be paid.
According to Administrator Tucker, the next step in the budget process is to have first (1
st)
reading of the budget with the changes discussed at this meeting at the April Council meeting
next week. The budget advertisement must be pub lished in the newspaper timely to hold the
Budget Public Hearing before the May Council meeting in order to have the Second Reading of
the FY12 budget at the May Council meeting.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Mayor Cronin stated that the Planning Commission would like to meet with City Council again to
discuss parking management; the proposed date is Wednesday, May 11. Council was in
agreement with the date and suggested meeting at 6 p.m.
Due to planned travels, the Ways and Means Committee rescheduled its May meeting to 5:45
p.m. on Tuesday, May 10, 2011.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to adjourn the meeting at 8:35
p.m.; Councilmember Duffy seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.