Special Meeting, June 6 (PDF, 26.59 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS AND MEANS COMMITTEE SPECIAL MEETING
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, June 6, 2011
The special meeting of the Ways and Means Committee was held at 5:45 p.m.,
Tuesday, June 6, 2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of
Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli,
Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus, Piening, Thomas and Stone, Mayor Cronin, City
Administrator Tucker, City Treasurer Suggs, City Attorney Halversen and Assistant to
the Administrator Dziuban. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Review of FY 12 Operating and Capital Budgets
Administrator Tucker began by reviewing the assignment given to staff as she
understood it from the joint meeting of the Planning Commission and City Council as:
develop a fiscal plan to include in the FY 12 budget to implement a portion of the parking
plan discussed in the meeting to give residents some relief from the impact of beach
access parking. The first stage was to install parking nodes in the 40- and 60-foot-wide
street extensions along Palm Boulevard in the area of the island from Breach Inlet to 10
th
Avenue and to make the remaining streets in that area open to residential or owner
parking only. The goal was to implement before the next beach season, meaning the
budgetary impact had to be considered quickly.
Staff held inter-departmental meetings to assign and review portions of the task as
necessary for accomplishment. Staff examined the implementation of the concept.
Building Department Director Kerr was tasked with contacting the regulatory agencies
and discussing expenses with engineering and design firms and projecting construction
costs. Police Chief Buckhannon was tasked with considering enforcement and
implementation. City Treasurer Suggs was tasked with creating a budget as the puzzle
pieces were identified, which have been incorporated into the draft budget before the
Committee tonight. Attorney Halversen, who is present tonight, was tasked with
exploring all legal documents associated with the properties on Ocean Boulevard and
the street extensions to determine if any legal obstacles existed to the implementation of
the plan.
Administrator Tucker called the Committee’s attention to photographs (attached to the
historical record of this meeting) that included “people markers” indicating the proposed
lengths and widths of the project for visual reference.
Administrator Tucker stated that if the Ways and Means Committee approved of the
work presented at tonight’s meeting, the Committee should then recommend this version
of the budget for public hearing and second reading at the June City Council. Also, an
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee Special Meeting would be scheduled in the
interim because elements of this version of the budget impact state ATAX.
Director Kerr reviewed what he had learned about the physical elements of the project
and what they would require in terms of permitting, bidding and construction. He spoke
with three (3) engineering firms: Civil Site Environmental, Seamon & Whiteside, and
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 2 of 8
Thomas & Hutton. He requested their estimates for design cost, which all estimated
could be replicated to some degree among the four chosen street extensions. He also
requested estimates for the actual construction of the parking areas. It was determined
that the parking nodes would need to be permitted by two (2) agencies. The South
Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Controls Offices of Coastal Resource
Management (OCRM) would need to issue a land disturbance permit. Director Kerr
contacted OCRM and reported that the agency indicated that issuance of the permit was
likely because they were primarily concerned with lot disturbance and impervious
surface changes. This project would include pervious surface. The South Carolina
Department of Transportation (SCDOT) would need to issue the second permit. Chief
Buckhannon confirmed with SCDOT that encroachment permits would be necessary for
any signage changes and for the “driveway” off any road. Director Kerr summarize that
the City believes it would need three (3) permits from two (2) agencies to execute and
they all look favorable.
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the OCRM permitting process
typically has a public comment period.
Director Kerr indicated that the OCRM permitting process will also require topographical
information for each site, which will create additional expense at each site.
To compare “apples to apples,” the three firms from which the Director requested bids
were given an expected task and a sketch. Each was asked to include an estimate for
grading and clearing six inches of sand shell base with a timber border for the rough
dimensions of a one hundred twenty (120) foot axis and a four (4) foot wide walking path
on the edge in additional sand shell. The cost estimates include a fence, which can be
removed should it be determined that the “cons” outweigh the “pros.” Costs also
included an asphalt driveway access, parking stops throughout the area, signage,
grassing the disturbed areas and a twelve percent (12%) construction contingency.
Costs of the parking meters were obtained outside of the engineers’ estimates.
Mayor Cronin clarified the sequence as needing to complete the design work and
topographical surveys before submitting the permit applications. Director Kerr affirmed
this. Director Kerr estimated that OCRM would take six (6) weeks to two (2) months to
respond to the permit application.
Councilmember Stone queried whether public hearings would be required. Director Kerr
replied that to execute the project, portions of the City’s existing code would need to be
modified, which would require a public hearing. Also, the OCRM permit would have a
public hearing. Administrator Tucker also reminded that if the Committee moved forward
with this version of the budget, another public hearing on this budget draft would occur
before the June City Council meeting.
Police Chief Buckhannon reviewed the five (5) areas regarding implementation: 1)
residential parking requirements, 2) parking requirements within the nodes 3) personnel
structure to facilitate and enforce, 4) use of parking meters versus kiosks, and 5) data
base design to facilitate distribution of residential parking permits.
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 3 of 8
Related to residential parking, Chief Buckhannon reviewed the area of Breach Inlet
through 10
th Avenue and concluded and it would take one hundred nine (109) signs to
be able to adequately tell the motoring public that parking is only available for residents
with passes. SCDOT indicated to the Chief that this is something SCDOT had
embraced before and that they could embrace again, if the City follows the process for
encroachment permits. A minimum of two (2) signs per block would be required on
every street to allow for visibility at all intersections.
Related to parking within the nodes, signs would be required within all nodes indicating
that the area is pay-to-park. Chief Buckhannon evaluated where the meters would need
to be placed in the nodes or on a right-of-way. Chief Buckhannon opined that the meters
the City uses in Front Beach are becoming universal as he has observed their use in
Savannah, Mount Pleasant and the City of Charleston. Visitors are becoming familiar
with this type of meter. Chief Buckhannon indicated that the honor boxes like those in
use at Folly Beach were less costly up front, but much more labor-intensive as a two
staff members would need to check the boxes at least once an hour. The honor box
system would necessitate a policy and procedure related to fraud and risk, something
City auditors have advocated for in the past.
Regarding personnel, Chief Buckhannon projected that two (2) parking enforcement
officers would be required to enforce parking in the parking nodes and in all of the
residential areas from 10
th Avenue to Breach Inlet. A third (3rd) person would be a part-
time administrator of the residential parking permits. Even though the first
implementation would restrict parking to residents only in the area of 10
th Avenue to
Breach Inlet, all island residents would be eligible to receive a residential parking sticker.
Additionally, residents who live on the restricted streets will need to be able to acquire
temporary passes for guests for special occasions at their homes.
The staff person needed to administer the parking sticker would need to begin work two
to three (2-3) months in advance of implementation to help build a data base of eligible
residents. The Police Department would need to either hire an organization to set up a
data file or set up the data file internally. Residents would need to receive notification
that stickers and passes are available and instructions on how to receive them. This
staff person’s hours are likely to include weekends.
Chief Buckhannon believes that, for enforcement, a consistency in meter type is
important. Visitors should encounter the same kind of meter in these parking nodes as
on Front Beach; a variation in system types may become an issue in court cases.
Chief Buckhannon indicated that these were initial assessments and other logistical
issues still needed to be determined.
Committee Member Loftus queried whether increased ticketing could generate revenue
to offset some of the expenditures. Administrator Tucker indicated that parking ticket
revenue was in the budget.
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 4 of 8
Chief Buckhannon stated that he saw problems with allowing residents to park in the
parking nodes without paying. If a resident chose to, he or she would be able to park
and leave a car in the node indefinitely, effectively blocking visitor parking. Committee
Member Duffy stated that residents pay to park at Front Beach and the nodes should be
consistent with that policy.
Committee Member Bergwerf questioned the need for additional Beach Services
Officers to enforce parking in the resident-parking-only streets as officers already
enforce parking island-wide. Chief Buckhannon said the new arrangement would be
more labor intensive and more effective if executed by persons specifically assigned to
that function. Additionally, in the busy beach season, officers are better used for
answering the increased call volume.
Committee Member Loftus asked whether the data base could be built using existing
Building Department information. Chief Buckhannon said that the Police Department
already taps into the Building Department data base for basic information, but more
complex information will be needed.
Mayor Cronin commented that the issuing of residential passes will be very difficult,
particularly in the first few years of implementation.
Chief Buckhannon has consulted with Wild Dunes regarding their sticker program. An
essential consideration is the number of stickers available to each property owner or
resident. Some residents may have four or five cars.
Mayor Cronin gave an example of a scenario that is likely to cause confusion: an
immediately family member, such as a son or daughter, requesting multiple passing for a
gathering. Technically, this person is not the property owner.
Committee Member Loftus suggested that new technologies may help minimize the
difficulties of administrating this program.
Chief Buckhannon reported that Wild Dunes’ technology system to administer their
program cost fifty thousand dollars ($50,000).
Committee Member Bergwerf asked how many hurricane re-entry stickers are currently
issued to residents. The answer is two. Mayor Cronin acknowledged that this creates
some difficulties for families, but that some limit had to be imposed.
Councilmember Stone inquired whether the kiosk system being proposed would be
seasonal like those at the Front Beach. Chief Buckhannon indicated that the decision
would be a policy decision by City Council.
In response to Councilmember Stone’s query about the new staff members, Chief
Buckhannon indicated that his intentions are like those for current Beach Services
Officers (BSOs) who work from approximately from St. Patrick’s Day to October.
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 5 of 8
Administrator Tucker clarified that, unlike the two (2) new BSOs, the thirty (30) hours-
per-week position to administrate the parking stickers will need to be year-round. New
residents will move to the island year-round and will need to be able to acquire stickers.
Chief Buckhannon stated that he foresaw “growing pains” at the beginning and the need
for many policy decisions.
Administrator Tucker called the Committee’s attention to the photographs distributed to
the Members and attached to the historical record of this meeting. The pictures are of
the four street extensions where the proposed nodes would be constructed. In the
pictures, City staff is standing on the sites in positions to indicate the width of the access
and the depth of the proposed node. The proposed depth of the parking nodes was
established by the Planning Commission in hopes of preventing the ocean-side
homeowners from being able to see them from their oceanfront porches. The proposed
street extensions are at 3
rd Avenue (40 foot wide), 4th Avenue (60 foot wide), 8th Avenue
(60 foot wide) and 9th Avenue (60 foot wide). The goal of the photographs is to illustrate
to the committee the existing topography and vegetation that would need to change at
these locations.
Administrator Tucker recounted that when these photographs were being made, she
parked her City vehicle illegally on Ocean Boulevard to execute the City business. Each
time, as soon as her vehicle was parked, another vehicle parked on Ocean Boulevard,
assuming it was legal by example.
Administrator Tucker distributed a one-sheet “Cost and Revenue Estimates” (attached to
the historical record of this meeting) that included all of the budget numbers from the
third draft of the budget that included the parking initiative. When the budget numbers
were developed, staff identified a cost of five-hundred two thousand two-hundred ninety
seven dollars ($502,297) for eight (8) parking nodes or two-hundred eighty thousand
five-hundred forty dollars ($280,540) for four (4) parking nodes. Based on these
numbers, staff determined that it was not affordable to complete all eight (8) in fiscal
year twelve (FY 12). It did seem feasible to construct four (4) in fiscal year twelve (FY
12) and the remaining four (4) in fiscal year thirteen (FY 13). The four (4) street
extensions identified for fiscal year twelve (12) were chosen based on highest utilization.
The Cost Estimate sheet reflects a planning and permitting number of twenty-six
thousand dollars ($26,000) that is the average of the three (3) quotes received. The
planning and permitting expenses remained the same for construction of four (4) or eight
(8) nodes.
The average of the three (3) estimates received for construction was three-hundred
thirty-four thousand dollars ($334,000) for eight (8) nodes and one-hundred sixty-seven
thousand ($167,000) for four (4) nodes.
One (1) kiosk per location is estimated to cost forty thousand dollars ($40,000) for four
nodes. The kiosk system offers an accounting advantage over “honor boxes” because
when it is services, staff remove a locked container of cash with a receipt indicated the
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 6 of 8
amount of cash in the container as opposed to removing uncontained cash without a
receipt.
The Police Department expects to require two (2) additional automated ticketing devices
at an estimated cost of eighty-five hundred ($8,500) for both. An estimated one hundred
eight (108) signs will cost three-thousand seven-hundred eighty ($3,780).
Staff solicited input from Public Works Department Director Pitts regarding ongoing
maintenance of the nodes. Maintenance costs will include service for the electronic
kiosks, property insurance, service and supplies for the additional ticketing devices, an
annual placement of sandshell, and weekly weeding and cleaning by staff. These costs
are estimated to be five-thousand eighty-two dollar ($5,082) per year for four (4) parking
nodes.
Administrator Tucker’s hope is that as the program is implemented, the residential
parking stickers will take the place of hurricane re-entry stickers. The estimated cost for
personnel and the database, as explained earlier by Chief Buckhannon, is sixty-five
thousand two hundred and sixty for four (4) parking nodes.
The total fiscal year twelve (FY 12) estimated cost for implementing the parking initiative
with four (4) nodes is three hundred ten thousand five hundred forty dollars ($310,540).
Thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) had previously been included in the fiscal year 12 (FY
12) budget draft, meaning that the new budget draft includes two-hundred eighty
thousand five hundred forty dollars ($280,540) of new expenditures related to the
parking initiative.
The revenue estimates were generated from the fiscal year 12 (FY 12) Front Beach
parking revenue estimate. This figure was divided by the number of Front Beach spaces
to determine a multiplier indicating revenue per space. The number of new expected
spaces is thirty (33), but that figure was reduced to account for required handicapped
parking. The Cost Estimate sheet included an additional reduction for free resident
parking in the nodes, but if the policy decision was to require all to pay to park in the
node to be consistent with Front Beach, that figure will be adjusted. The estimated total
revenue is forty-two thousand dollars ($42,000) or greater.
Administrator Tucker has written a letter to SCDOT regarding these plans, but she has
not yet heard back. However, the Administrator speculates that if the City of Isle of
Palms patterns this program after the City of Charleston’s successful implementation,
SCDOT approval could be expected. The City confirmed that the streets in question in
the City of Charleston belonged to SCDOT.
Mayor Cronin asked if the revenue projections were seasonal or based on the fiscal
year. The projections are based on Front Beach parking which is seasonal. In the first
year of implementation, the fiscal year revenue will be less than the projection.
Committee Member Bergwerf called attention to the fact that the 3
rd Avenue street
extension was a forty foot (40 ft.) wide extension. She suggested making the first four
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 7 of 8
(4) nodes in street extensions that were all sixty feet (60 ft.) wide. The Mayor concurred
that this was worth consideration, and Administrator Tucker said the staff would re-
examine the choices of street extensions. In that case, Chief Buckhannon suggested
moving the emergency access path to a smaller street extension. The Mayor expressed
concern about an access path that included both a parking node and emergency access.
Fire Chief Graham remarked that the beach access at 5
th Avenue is one of the busiest
paths.
The Mayor observed that he liked the kiosks currently in use on the Front Beach due to
track record, turn over and consistency.
Committee Member Buckhannon asked about the natural buffers of vegetation and dune
currently in place at the street extensions. Administrator Tucker stated that the project
would require significant disturbance of the buffer in the street extensions. Although the
areas will recover, citizens tend to react when they observe the change of the
topography. The street extensions will need to be scraped down and pervious surface
would be placed. Administrator Tucker remarked that as little land as possible will be
disturbed, but that construction will be a function of the design.
Director Kerr summarized the initial design concept as including a forty feet (40 ft) of
parking area and a four foot (4 ft.) walking path to keep pedestrians as a distance from
cars, leaving sixteen feet (16 ft.) available for buffer, eight (8) feet on each side. He
opined that in a sixty foot (60 ft.) street extension, excavating forty-four feet (44 ft.) would
have a significant appearance.
Mayor Cronin remarked that this is a not a small project.
Committee Member Duffy queried if the City had requested information for neighboring
municipalities about their parking administration. Administrator Tucker answered in the
affirmative but reminded the Committee that the City of Charleston has an entire parking
department.
Mayor Cronin called the Committee’s attention to the Cost Estimate sheet that indicated
that, to execute this project, the City would be using one hundred forty-eight thousand
seven hundred sixty dollars ($148,760) in Municipal Accommodations Tax fund balance
and one hundred sixty-one thousand seven hundred eighty dollars ($161,780) in State
Accommodations Tax fund balance over and above what fund balance use was
budgeted in previous versions. Both funds will have fund balance remaining, and after
the first year’s cost, revenues will begin to be generated. Council Member Piening
remarked that monies from these funds are meant for projects such as these.
Council Member Bettelli hoped that adjacent property owners would be made aware of
the project well in advance. Administrator Tucker related that based on past experience,
regardless of the City’s efforts to inform citizens, some folks do not become aware until
construction begins.
Ways and Means Special Meeting
June 6, 2011
Page 8 of 8
Administrator Tucker remarked that for the initial year, the City might be out of
compliance with its Beachfront Management Plan. However, the intention to construct
all eight (8) nodes should bring the City back into compliance.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the draft budget as submitted at
tonight’s meeting; Committee Member Loftus seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: At 6:45 p.m. Committee Member Stone moved to go into executive
session to receive legal advice pertaining to the implementation of
phase one of parking plan; Committee Member Bergwerf seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Executive Session, to receive legal advice pertaining to implementation of
phase one of parking plan
The Committee came out of executive session at 7:20 p.m., and Mayor Cronin indicated
for the record that no decisions were made and no actions were taken during the
executive session.
Administrator Tucker thanked City Treasurer Suggs for her extensive work on this
budget draft.
Administrator Tucker also announced that she was in receipt of a resignation letter for
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban effective September 28, 2011.
In response to Committee Member Stone’s query, the Treasurer clarified that the
budgetary changes impacted the Municipal Accommodations Tax Fund and the State
Accommodations Tax Fund but not the Public Works Department budget. Administrator
Tucker remarked that in out years, there may be a Public Works budgetary impact.
4. Adjourn
MOTION: Committee Member Loftus moved to adjourn at 7:37 p.m.;
Committee Member Bettelli second and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.