September 20 (PDF, 30.28 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
WAYS AND MEANS COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, September 20, 2011
The regular meeting of the Ways and Means Committee for the City of Isle of Palms was held at
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, September 20, 2011 in C ouncil Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm
Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. In attendance for the meeting were Councilmembers
Bergwerf, Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus, Piening, Stone and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City
Administrator Tucker, City Treasurer Suggs, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City
Clerk Copeland. The absence of Councilmember Be ttelli was excused. A quorum was present
to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of August 16, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Financial Statements – Treasurer Suggs
A. August Financial Statement
The financial statement for discussion covered the second month of FY12; General Fund
revenues were at seven percent (7%) collected, and expenditures were at fourteen percent
(14%) of budget – the target through two (2) months is seventeen percent (17%). Budgeted
revenues year-to-date were running ten percent (10%) ahead of FY11. Departments running
ahead of budgeted expenditures were the Recreation Department, which has additional part-
time employees for the summer months, and the Beach Services Officers, who are only in the
City’s employ five (5) months of the year. As the year progresses, these are expected to be on
budget. The General Fund cash balance is in ex cess of two and a half million dollars
($2,500,000); approximately half a million dollars ($500,000) is in BB&T earning a quarter of a
percent (0.25%) interest and approximately two million dollars ($2,000,000) in the LGIP earning
slightly less than a quarter of a percent (0.2420%) interest.
B. Tourism Schedules
State Accommodations Taxes are paid quarterly, therefore, no collections yet for FY12.
Municipal Accommodations Tax collections fo r August were excellent at one hundred seventy-
six thousand dollars ($176,000), which is an increase of fourteen percent (14%) over FY11
year-to-date.
Charleston County Pass-through is paid semi-annually, so no collections until the first of 2012.
Hospitality Tax collections are running behind FY11, primarily because a large taxpayer made
only a partial payment in July and no payment in August.
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 2 of 9
C. Project Schedules
The Beach Restoration project paid invoices to Chris Jones for consulting and to Coastal
Science and Engineering for post -project monitoring and permitting of the remedial plan.
Spending on the project exceeds nine and a half million dollars ($9,500,000), and a balance of
approximately nine hundred thousand dollars ($900,000) remains in the project fund.
Administrator Tucker reported that the deadline for comments on the pending permit ended on
September 14, but the City has not yet learned whether any comments were received.
53
rd to 57th Avenue Drainage Project fund made a seventh (7th) pay application to Eadie’s for the
construction, as well as a small payment to Ci vil Site Environmental for project management. A
total of one million fifty thousand dollars ($1,050,000) has been spent on this project, and
available to spend is approximately one hundred forty-five thousand dollars ($145,000).
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the City expected to receive additional invoices;
Treasurer Suggs stated that balances on the construction contract and technical support
remain. Administrator Tucker added that Eadie’s is doing the punch-list items now and that, if
something outside of the scope of the original contract needs to be done, the City could incur
additional expense, but nothing is anticipated at this time. One (1) outside expense will be the
removal of the stain on the road, but it is not expected to be costly.
City Hall Renovation fund made its final payment to Liollio for the construction; the remaining
expenditures on the project are retainage to Liollio, issues related to the hurricane shutters, the
demolition of 1301 Palm and the relocation of electrical and computer wiring to the Public Works
Building.
In response to Councilmember Loftus’ request for an update on 1301 Palm, the Administrator
reported that the City has received three (3) estimates for the removal of the wiring and
computer connections from the old building to the Public Works offices. After reviewing the
estimates, staff is of the opinion that the City could save money if the components of the project
were to be priced separately; the City is currently awaiting the new estimates.
5. Old Business
Discussion of Request for Qualifications – Beach Access Parking
Mayor Cronin reported that, as Council had requested, staff has developed a draft of a proposal
for request for qualifications to seek consultants to make recommendations about beach access
parking. Before moving forward, the Mayor and staff want to confirm that it remains the will of
Council to continue with the process and to issue an RFP.
Councilmember Stone commented that he hesitated to go forward to seek bids without an
understanding of what the cost would be for the scope of the work; he suggested that a simpler
solution would be to bring residents, Councilmembers and members of the Planning
Commission together for open discussion and brainstorming on possible solutions to the parking
problems on the island.
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 3 of 9
In his opinion, many issues could be solved by stepped up enforcement of traffic regulations
currently on the books, i.e. line of sight at the perpendicular streets. In addition, Councilmember
Stone referenced other options that have been submitted, such as allowing parking on only one
(1) side of Palm Boulevard. He did not believe that spending money on a consultant to get
another opinion was the answer.
Councilmember Loftus recommended asking the Planning Commission to develop two or three
(2-3) scenarios to be presented at an island-wide public hearing, and, based on public
feedback, Council and the Planning Commission could decide the course to set. He voiced the
opinion that best ideas had been presented and that they needed identification and
organization.
Councilmember Bergwerf thought the Planning Commission should be tasked with developing a
comprehensive parking plan and recalled that the Planning Commission has been ruminating on
parking initiatives for several years. The Councilmember indicated that the time to hire a con-
sultant would be after a comprehensive parking plan was in place.
In Councilmember Duffy’s view, having a plan from the Planning Commission should identify all
the data that a consultant would need to research.
Mayor Cronin summarized the discussion thus far being that the Committee wanted the
Planning Commission to devise a plan, possibly with several chapters, to address the differing
problems that exist on the island.
Councilmember Duffy reflected that the members of the Planning Commission know the parking
issues on the island, they know the constraints imposed by state and local regulations, and they
know the goals set forth in the City’s Compr ehensive Plan. He expressed the opinion that the
draft request established parameters from which to develop a plan, and that plan would define a
narrowed scope for consultants.
Councilmember Buckhannon stated that he thought more time spent with Council and the Plan-
ning Commission brainstorming on ideas would be productive. He stated that residents had
proposed some great parking solutions in emails since the concept of the parking nodes on
Ocean Boulevard had been put forth.
Councilmember Piening stated that Council’s job was to make the best decision for the com-
munity despite the fact that some residents may not be pleased, and he noted that this Council
had proven that, if a decision proved not to work, it would take a step back and re-examine.
Councilmember Loftus commented that the Committee needed “to give the Planning Commis-
sion a road map” of the direction in which to head, and he referenced the Wilbur Smith study of
the 41
st Avenue and Palm Boulevard intersection that presented three (3) different options. He
remarked that the Planning Commission should identify key points and develop separate
scenarios for managing them.
The Mayor recapped the discussion that the issue should be sent back to the Planning
Commission for additional consideration that would involve interaction with City Council and
Ways & Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 4 of 9
island residents. The Mayor added that the citizen involvement might be better accomplished if
parking was approached by the differing sections of the island, for example, residents of Ocean
up to the Front Beach area or residents of Palm from 41
st Avenue to 57th Avenue.
The Mayor commented that the draft was a very good work product from staff and that it could
prove to be useful to the Planning Commission as they begin further deliberations. He thanked
the staff for their hard work in developing the draft and the quality of the end product.
6. New Business
A. Recommendation from the Real Property Committee for Approval of up to
$30,000, if necessary, from the Marina Fund for GEL sampling and analysis
plan and initial sampling with subsequent testing.
Administrator Tucker commented that Jack Walker of GEL was in the audience to answer any
technical questions that Committee members might have; the Administrator added that this
issue is the direct result of the expanded scope of the project. She then turned the discussion
to Assistant Dziuban, who had handled the subject at the Real Property Committee.
According to Assistant Dziuban, the goal of this action is to keep the dredging project moving in
order to meet the dredging window for 2011-2012. With the expanded scope of moving into the
Intracoastal Waterway, the Corps of Engineers has communicated that the Waterway has not
been dredged in some time; therefore, spoil material must be tested to determine its
composition. The process could have two or three (2 or 3) steps, which are as follows:
1) The development of a sampling and analysis plan that must be approved by the
Corps of Engineers;
2) The collection of sediment samples and size testing; and, possibly,
3) The actual sediment testing for chemicals.
The Corps of Engineers does have an exemption to th e sediment testing which states that, if
eighty-five percent (85%) of the material is as large as, for example, a grain of sand, the
agencies will feel confident that more sophist icated chemical testing is unnecessary because
the larger grain size will not absorb the same kind of materials that the smaller, silt-like particles
will. The request for thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) is assuming that all three (3) steps
required, and the approval of the request will mean that the dredging project will not be put on
hold while staff seeks another funding approval from Council. If only steps one and two occur,
the cost will be approximately ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
Assistant Dziuban stated that the Real Property Committee designated the Marina Fund as the
funding source for this phase of the project.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve up to $30,000 from the Marina Fund
to finance the sampling and analysis plan from GEL and the possible sediment
testing; Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 5 of 9
Responding to a query from Councilmember Duffy, Assistant Dziuban stated that this testing
procedure was in the original GEL proposal as a potential alternate.
The Mayor asked Mr. Walker the probability of meeting the eighty-five percent (85%) exemption,
and Mr. Walker replied that the chances were better than fifty percent (50%) and closer to
seventy-five percent (75%).
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Recommendation from the Public Works Committee to make repairs to 21
st
Avenue storm drain and seek reimbursement from Charleston County
Stormwater Fees.
Administrator Tucker noted that this item was for informational purposes and that no Committee
action was necessary.
Assistant Dziuban related that this problem had been brought to the City’s attention by a citizen,
and the situation is that a drainage pipe has sunk, creating a large pool of standing water, and
needs to be raised. Chuck Jarman of Charleston County attended the Public Works Committee
and had provided the City with three (3) options to resolve the situation; they are as follows:
1) To wait until the spring of 2012 when Charleston County Public Works will be back
on the island in its routine cycle;
2) To go before Charleston County Council to make a special request for the work to be
done sooner, which may or may not be granted; or
3) For the City to arrange for the work to be done and apply for reimbursement from the
stormwater fees Charleston County has collected from residents of the island.
Mr. Jarman stated that the City has a bal ance of approximately fifteen thousand dollars
($15,000) in its stormwater fund; an initial bid for the 21
st Avenue repairs came in at under six
thousand dollars ($6,000). The Public Works Committee has agreed that the City should seek
bids for the work to be reimbursed from Charleston County Stormwater Fees.
Mayor Cronin commented that he understood that the residents of the island paid approximately
one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) each year in stormwater fees; Administrator Tucker
informed the Mayor and Ways and Means Committee members that the City has requested an
accounting of the stormwater fees collected from the Isle of Palms.
The Mayor reminded the Committee that the City had decided for Charleston County to admin-
ister the stormwater program for the City, but the City could choose to assume responsibility for
the program at some future date.
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 6 of 9
7. Miscellaneous Business
A. Update on Status of Property for Open Space
Administrator Tucker prepared a short PowerPoint presentation for this item on the agenda; a
copy is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
The Administrator started her presentation program by quoting from the City’s Comprehensive
Plan as follows:
Goal 3.4 – Promote the maintenance of green space throughout the island.
Administrator Tucker proceeded to give the history behind the City’s attempt acquire the lot
located at 3206 Palm Boulevard; the lot is centrally located on the island, remains untouched by
developers and has been owned by one (1) family since 1945. The acquisition of this property
is the City’s third (3
rd) attempt at using the Greenspace Funds allocated by Charleston County;
the other attempts were the purchase of property at 45 th and Palm and the property known as
the “7th Avenue triangle.”
When the property was appraised in 2011, it appraised at one million three hundred thousand
dollars ($1,300,000). In April of this year, City Council passed a resolution authorizing the
submittal of a grant application to the Greenbelt Fund which has a sum of four hundred seventy-
four thousand dollars ($474,000) earmarked for the acquisition of open space on the Isle of
Palms. Subsequently the application was submitted, and Charleston County Council approved
the funding application in its August 2011 meeting.
The vision for the property is to trim the vegetation, provide a pedestrian pathway and to provide
a virtually untouched space for quiet enjoyment. As is the case along Palm Boulevard, parking
would continue to be allowed in the right-of-way; the lot will not be turned into a parking lot or a
playground, and no City funds will be used in the acquisition.
Future steps are to continue to seek funds to pur chase the property. The City plans to submit a
Land and Water Conservation Fund application; the letter of intent will be issued in November
2011. The City has a successful track record with the source of funds; in the past, the City
received funds to help with the purchase of the Front Beach parking lots. A second source is
the South Carolina Conservation Bank, and the deadline for application is January 31, 2012. In
addition, the City is seeking donations from the community, and one (1) has been received.
At some point, the City hopes to amass enough funds to enter into negotiations with the owner
in hopes that they will accept less than the appraised value for the property.
The Administrator took time to discuss the allowable uses of Greenbelt Funds by coastal
communities, other than the acquisition of proper ty for open space, such as improvements to
boardwalks, foot bridges, unpaved trails and roadways and unpaved small parking lots. Some
residents have questioned the use of Greenbelt Funds to acquire this property rather than
improvements to beach access path; Administrator Tucker pointed out that other sources of
money are available for access path improvements, such as Community Development Block
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 7 of 9
Grant Funds used for 21 st Avenue improvements. In additi on, improvements to beach access
paths that the City owns would be subject to the same restrictions that will be placed on the
3206 Palm lot.
Councilmember Buckhannon inquired about the funding amounts to be sought from the sources
named; the Administrator responded that she did not know how much was available from
Conservation Bank because they are subject to donations from multiple sources and the state
legislature, as well. The previous application to the Land and Water Conservation Fund was for
one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000). She assured the Committee that she would be
applying for the maximum allowed, but Administrator Tucker did not think that the needed eight
hundred thousand dollars ($800,000) would come from these sources.
Councilmember Piening commented about the misinformation that is in the community and
asked whether the Administrator’s presentation could be put on the City’s website or included in
the next e-newsletter from the City.
Councilmember Loftus praised the Administrator for the presentation and suggested that it be
repeated at the September Council meeting in an effort to counter the rumors circulating about
the property. The Mayor agreed to add the presentation to the Council agenda.
B. Report on Emergency Repairs due to power surge to the HVAC on 3
rd Floor of
the Public Safety Building
According to the City Administrator, the primary reason for placing this item on the agenda was
to alert the Committee about it should a problem arise with insurance reimbursement since it is
a covered expense. The Committee was assured that the appropriate documentation had been
sent to the insurance carrier with the claim; the repairs have been made for approximately six
thousand dollars ($6,000). No action from the Committee was required.
C. Discussion for use of FY11 General Fund Year-end Gain
As Mayor Cronin foreshadowed last month, the bulk of the preliminary work by the auditors has
been completed, but the time has come in the audit process where the City needs to decide
how the FY11 year-end gain will be classified in order to close the books. The auditors plan to
have their work completed and to make their presentation at the October Council meeting.
Treasurer Suggs distributed an updated version of the June 30, 2011 financial statement
coversheet that shows a year-end gain in the General Fund of five hundred seventy-one
thousand dollars ($571,000) based on the following calculation
General Fund Revenues $7,933,000
Transfers + 463,000
Expenditures ( 7,825,000)
Gain $ 571,000 Preliminary Audited Results
Mayor Cronin reminded the Committee that the City has established the practice of maintaining
cash on-hand equal to approximately thirty percent (30%) of annual General Fund expenses
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 8 of 9
and transferring any balance to the Capital Projects Fund in an unreserved status to maintain a
balance of approximately one million dollars ($1,000,000). With the current budget in FY11, the
Capital Projects Fund will exceed one million dollars ($1,000,000), but will fall short in FY12 as
projected. If Council were to transfer the five hundred seventy thousand dollar ($570,000) gain
to the Capital Project Fund, the balance will exceed the one million dollar ($1,000,000) balance.
Another option for the FY11 gain would be to move all of the funds into the Capital Projects fund
and to use portion of it to pay off the debt on the 2009 pumper in the Fire Department; this
action would leave a residual balance of approximately one million dollars ($1,000,000) in the
Capital Projects Fund and paying off the truck years in advance of term.
Treasurer Suggs reported that the FY12 debt payment on the pumper was made August 1, and,
according to the terms of the lease, payoff is only allowed on the anniversary of the debt. The
Treasurer noted that she had proposed the early payoff to BB&T, the leaseholder, and received
approval from the lender to pay off the debt if Council so chooses. The City would save
approximately thirty-eight thousand dollars ($38,000) in interest.
Councilmember Stone inquired when this lease was due to be paid off and was told FY19.
Councilmember Stone remembered that certain capital acquisitions were deferred when the
FY12 budget was finalized; he, therefore, suggested putting the gain into the Capital Projects
Fund with a goal of buying, not leasing, future capital acquisitions. To further this discussion,
the Treasurer distributed copies of the 10-Year Capital Plan developed as part of the FY12
budgeting process. Discussion continued about capital purchases scheduled for the City to
make in coming years, including a Public Works truck in FY14 and a rescue truck for the Fire
Department in FY15.
Mayor Cronin commented that the gain could be held in the Capital Projects Fund with the
intention of paying off the pumper on the anniversary date in FY13 depending on how the
budget flowed for FY13. On the other hand, if a capital project came up in the spring for which a
sinking fund were needed, the funds would be available.
Councilmember Loftus inquired about the interest rate on the pumper; Administrator Tucker
reported that the rate is 3.89% with an outstanding balance of two hundred seventy-three
thousand dollars ($273,000).
Treasurer Suggs distributed the City’s debt schedule to Committee members. The Treasurer
noted that the pumper debt is serviced fifty percent (50%) from Capital Projects, twenty-five
percent (25%) from Municipal Accommodations Tax and twenty-five percent (25%) from
Municipal Accommodations Tax. The City has t he option of paying the pumper off completely
with the FY11 gain from the Capital Projects Fund or pay it off from the funds that support the
debt.
Mayor Cronin interjected that the specific decision does not have to be made in this meeting,
but the gain has to be transferred to close the FY11 books.
Ways and Means Committee
September 20, 2011
Page 9 of 9
Councilmember Duffy asked what the useful life of the pumper would after being paid off; he
stated that paying off early means that one (1) property owner has paid his full share for
something they may never use in the future. He noted that he continues to support the fact that
the City should reduce debt whenever possible, but contended that a good argument exists for
extending payments on real capital assets through the appreciable life so that it is equitable to
all of the taxpayers and residents.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to transfer the FY11 gain of approximately
$570,000 to the Capital Projects Fund as unassigned; Councilmember Duffy
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:03
p.m.; Councilmember Duffy seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.