February 8 (PDF, 36.76 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Tuesday, February 8, 2011
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:30 p.m. on Tuesday,
February 8, 2011 in the Training Room of the Public Safety Building, 30 J.C. Long Boulevard,
Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and
Loftus, Chair Bettelli, City Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was present to con-
duct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 11, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
A. Update on Public Safety Building
Chief Graham reported that a plumber and electrician have been found that will be the first con-
tact if, and when, problems occur for the life of the building.
B. Consideration of Amendment to the City’s Alarm Ordinance
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban stated that the Committee had been presented with the
staff’s recommendations for changes to the alarm ordinance related to false alarms and failure
to respond to notification of an alarm. The Assistant noted that the City policies referenced in
Section 7-4-4(g) and 7-4-5((f) had been stricken from the ordinance since the Police Depart-
ment policies have changed. The fines have been in creased from fifty dollars ($50) to one hun-
dred dollars ($100.00) for the fourth, fifth and sixth false alarms and from one hundred dollars
($100.00) to two hundred dollars ($200.00) for the seventh and subsequent false alarms. At the
end of the ordinance are exemptions to the false alarm penalties and the penalties for failure to
respond of one hundred dollars ($100.00) for the first violation and two hundred dollars
($200.00) for each subsequent violation. In addition, Assistant Dziuban indicated that both
chiefs have reviewed and approved the changes, but the amendment has not been through le-
gal review.
Chair Bettelli suggested that there should be a window of time, possibly thirty (30) minutes, for
the property owner/manager to respond to the not ification of a false alarm; Councilmember
Loftus commented that he did not want the ordinance to be punitive for the property
owner/manager who cannot logistically arrive on the scene in thirty (30) minutes. Chief Graham
stated that the Department was asking for a commitment by phone that the property
owner/manager was en route.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 2 of 9
Another question from Councilmember Loftus was how the property owners/managers would be
notified of the ordinance changes. Chief Graham responded that the City could incur a one-time
charge to mail the notification to them or the changes could be noticed with the renewals that
are sent out each December. Chief Buckhannon commented that the notice could also be
posted on the website, in the newsletter or the press, as well as notifying the various alarm com-
panies that service residences on the island; the Chief stated that the island has approximately
four hundred fifty (450) alarms.
Responding to Councilmember Loftus’ question about the number of times any residence had a
fourth, fifth or sixth false alarm in 2010, Chief Buckhannon stated that the instances are rare, but
they do occur – probably fewer than ten (10) instances per year.
Chief Graham related that two (2) ladders and two (2) pumpers with a total of nine (9) personnel
respond to every alarm; therefore, the Chief stated that her goal with this amendment was to get
a confirmation from the property owner/manager within thirty (30) minutes that he/she would be
on-scene in an hour.
Administrator Tucker noted that the amendment would give the City a tool to have a penalty to
use at the discretion of the Fire Department; the amendment intends to address the issue of the
property owner/manager being notified and refusing to respond.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to forward the recommendations for an amend-
ment to the City’s alarm ordinance to the City Attorney for review; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded.
The Administrator commented that she would inform the City Attorney of Councilmember Loftus’
concerns and that the City Attorney may have alternate language to address them.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of Amendment to the City’s Short-term Rental Business
License Application
Chair Bettelli informed the members of the Committee that no action was required from the
Committee for the recommended changes to be incorporated into the application.
Assistant Dziuban explained that a requirement for working smoke detectors in all sleeping
areas, areas used as sleeping quarters and all areas of egress would be incorporated into the
rental application from this point forward.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the application forms were completed filled out when re-
turned to the City; in his opinion, the City should not accept any applications that were incom-
plete. The Councilmember also suggested that line A.8. should indicate a cell phone number
since just about everyone has a cell phone that they carry with them constantly; Councilmember
Bergwerf suggested that the application have a space for two (2) numbers, one (1) of which
would specify cell number. Assistant Dziuban assured the Committee that their recommenda-
tions would be heeded.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 3 of 9
5. New Business
A. Consideration of an Amendment to the Zoning Ordinances to Allow for a
200 foot Communications Tower
Administrator Tucker stated that this amendment was the result of the Special Meeting of City
Council where Charleston County staff members and representatives of Motorola and Crown
Castle made a presentation explaining the options available to the City regarding a communi-
cations tower. At the January City Council meeting, staff was charged with proceeding with an
amendment to the City’s zoning ordinances to allow for a two hundred (200) foot tower for public
safety purposes. City Attorney Halversen us ed several sources in crafting the amendment
including ordinances from Folly Beach and York County, as well as the Crown Castle consult-
ants and Building and Planning Director Kerr.
Included in the amendment is the limitation of a tower/antenna constructed by governmental en-
tity for the purposes of public safety not to exceed a height of two hundred (200) feet. Other
conditions included in the amendment are as follows:
• The communications tower/antenna shall meet the approval conditions defined earlier in
the ordinance;
• Reasonable efforts shall be made to reduce the fall zone;
• The tower/antenna shall have the capacity to accommodate a minimum of four (4)
commercial carriers; and
• The tower/antenna shall meet the wind speed standards.
The Administrator noted that Crown Castle, the tower owner, has assured the City that the type
of tower that will be erected would telescope down, rather than fall over, should it ever be
compromised. The tower would accommodate, at a minimum, the four (4) commercial carriers
who have space on the tower at 41
st Avenue currently.
Should the Committee approve the amendment in it s current form, it can go forward to City
Council at the February meeting for First Reading; from there the amendment would go to the
Planning Commission for their review and recommendation and back to City Council for a pub-
lic hearing and Second Reading.
Chair Bettelli pointed out that that tower will be under that two hundred (200) foot limit that re-
quires it to be lighted.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend to City Council approval of the
amendment to the City’s zoning code to allow for communications tower for the
purposes of public safety not to exceed 200 hundred feet in height;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Loftus suggested that the City Administrator offer space on the City’s tower at
41
st Avenue to the commercial carriers presently on the water tower; Administrator Tucker said
she would look into that possibility.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 4 of 9
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Discussion of 3 rd Avenue Right-of-Way Parking
Chair Bettelli reported receiving an email from an island resident about the sight limitations at
Third Avenue; Councilmember Loftus added that the way people park creates blind spots.
Chair Bettelli asked for Chief Buckhannon to study the problem and to come back to the Com-
mittee with a recommendation.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that a similar pr oblem exists as one leaves the beach at the
intersection of 9
th Avenue and Carolina Boulevard; she reported that a large bush obstructs a
driver’s line of sight for vehicles approaching from the right.
Chief Buckhannon commented that he would look at both intersections and noted that the De-
partment is currently involved in getting the rights-of-way cleared.
C. Review of FY12 Capital Budget and Long-range Plans for the Fire and
Police Departments
By way of introduction, Administrator Tucker stated that the annual budget process begins with
a look at capital budgets and the long-range plan; the Administrator explained that staff looks at
the life expectancy of equipment to determine when it will need to be replaced as well as the
refinements made the previous year, and, at times, staff will add a new item or an item that has
been overlooked in prior years. Administrator Tucker commented that one (1) reason the City
has survived the economic downturn as well as it has can be attributed to good long-range
planning.
Police Department
Replace patrol cars (3 in FY12 – purchased in FY06) 69,000
Administrator Tucker that the City has developed a rotation cycle that works well in that vehicles
are replaced before the maint enance costs become burdensome.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked how many vehicles were in the Police Department; Chief
Buckhannon stated that there are twenty-one (21) patrol cars, one (1) truck for the beach
services officers, one (1) truck for animal control, a bobcat and one (1) low-speed vehicle. The
Councilmember commented that she was unaccustom ed to officers taking their vehicles home
because that adds mileage to them; she wanted to know whether consideration was given to
eliminating that “perk.” Chief Buckhannon responded that the majority of departments in the
area have the same policy of allowing officers to take their vehicles home; the City has learned
that the vehicles last longer and are kept in better condition when the officers can drive them
home. The Chief noted that vehicles that make up a fleet are driven twenty-four (24) hours a
day and do not last as long; additionally driving the vehicles to and from home is a benefit in lieu
of higher pay.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 5 of 9
Chair Bettelli remarked that, at one time, the City had limitations on the distance the vehicles
could be driven to and from home, but had changed that policy to be more competitive with
neighboring departments.
Replace VHS in-car camera systems with digital (4 in FY12) 13,600
This is the City’s continuing effort to go to di gital. Councilmember Loftus questioned that three (3)
patrol cars were planned, but four (4) cameras; Chief Buckhannon stated that the cameras were
not on the same rotation schedule as the vehicles.
Replace mobile data terminals (patrol laptops) (2/year) 4,500
Chief Buckhannon explained that these laptops are not like a laptop one would purchase for an
office or home; they are constructed to endure the di fficulties of being in a police vehicle, i.e. they hold
up to being dropped from a few feet and having coffee spilled on them.
Chair Bettelli questioned that the price of the laptops had not been reduced as a result of the
City’s purchase of a software licensing agreem ent in this fiscal year; Chief Buckhannon ex-
plained that the agreement was for the Microsoft Office, not the basic operating system.
Replace body armor (4 or 5 sets per year) 3,120
Routine annual expenditure.
Replace staff computers (9 computers/4 yr. average life = approx. 2/year) 1,800
Administrator Tucker stated that a replacement schedule of all City computers is being gener-
ated for the Council meeting.
Replace computer servers (3 yr. replacement) w/backup system 6,500
Councilmember Bergwerf asked if the servers to be replaced were older than three (3) years.
Chief Buckhannon stated that the servers being replaced are older than three (3) years and have
an older operating system that is being phased ou t; the City’s servers also operate twenty-four
hours (24 hrs.) a day seven (7) days a week.
Replace existing digital camera for investigations 1,200
The Administrator commented that a camera wa s purchased for the Victim’s Advocate, and the
purchase for FY12 would be for investigations.
As a photographer, Councilmember Bergwerf asked what kind of camera they were considering;
she thought they could find a less expensive camera that would meet their needs.
Councilmember Loftus questioned whether the two (2) departments, Investigations and Victims
Advocate, could share the camera purchased last year. Chief Buckhannon said the biggest
issue with sharing is the availability of the camera when it is needed; he said that the ideal situa-
tion would be for each of the two (2) investigators to have a camera in-hand upon arriving at a
crime scene to take photographs before anything could be disturbed waiting for a camera to
arrive.
Replace Animal Control Officer 4WD truck 24,000
Administrator Tucker directed the Committee’s a ttention to the vehicle information sheet for the
Police Department; this purchase would replace the 2006 Ford F150 with an excess of one
hundred twenty-nine thousand (129,000) miles.
Public Safety Committee
February 9, 2011
Page 6 of 9
Radar unit replacement 5,000
The radar units are on a four (4) year rotation, but the units to be replaced were purchased in
1995 and 1997.
Facility Maintenance
Pressure wash exterior (50% of PSB) 1,000
Administrator Tucker noted t hat City buildings wear better when pressure washed annually.
Elevator Maintenance (1.5 of 2 elevators in PSB) 3,330
Routine annual expenditure.
Based on her calculations, Councilmember Bergwe rf stated that the City spends in excess of
eighty dollars ($80.00) per week on elevator maintenance for the Public Safety Building, which
she thought was exceedingly high. After discussions, Chief Graham said that she would contact
the Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation to get a list of the companies who are
licensed on the elevators in the building. Chief Buckhannon noted that the current contract
should expire in September; Administrator Tucker said that the City could go out to bid on the
contract for elevator maintenance.
Generator maintenance (50% of PSB generator) 750
Routine annual expenditure.
HVAC maintenance (50% of annual contract) 1,500
Fire Department
Existing lease pmt. on ’03 95 ft. ladder truck (10 yrs.) 82,113
Existing lease pmt. on 75 ft. ladder (cost-$500K) (10 yrs.) 55,210
Existing lease pmt. on ’09 E-1 pumper (10 yrs.) 40,383
Regular recurring:
Replace SCBA air packs and cylinders 27,020
Replace 10 sets of bunker gear 15,000
Replace fire hose and appliances 11,000
Replace Boston Whaler rescue boat (City has owned since 1989) 50,000
Chief Graham noted that the boat gets frequent use and, in the prior year, its use had to be can-
celled due to problems with the boat; the existing boat was a recreational boat that was modified
for use by the Fire Department. The repl acement would be a like-replacement with a
commercial hull that is constructed for fire rescue use.
Councilmember Loftus express his opinion that the Department could locate a boat by another
manufacturer with the same specifications that would be less expensive, and the Chief agreed
to do more research before the next meeting.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 7 of 9
3 mobile radio repeaters (this will allow one (1) repeater per big truck) 36,000
Three (3) repeaters were included in the FY 11 budget, but have not been purchased because the
FCC is not yet releasing licenses; therefore, a port ion of the funds indicated here is a roll- forward
from the FY11 budget.
8 mobile data terminals (computers in vehicles) needed for consolidated dispatch 18,000
Chief Graham stated that her understanding is th at the in-vehicle computers will be a requirement
once the City transitions to t he Consolidated Dispatch Center; the general information on an
emergency call will be given via telephone, but the details will be relayed via computers to the
vehicles. The City Administrator added that the City hopes to get a grant to pay for the
computers, but thought it prudent to have a pl aceholder in the budget in case the grant does not
materialize. Chief Buckhannon stated that the City is scheduled to transition to the consolidated
dispatch system in 2012 after the tourist seasons ends.
Thermal imaging camera (City has 3 – goal is to have one (1) for each truck) 11,000
Safety harness system (10 individual sets – goal to outfit entire staff) 5,500
Chair Bettelli suggested moving this line item to Regular Recurring, but Chief Graham noted that,
once each firefighter has a suit, the City will not be purchasing them annually.
Replace staff computers (7 computers/4 yr. aver. Life = approx. 1.75/yr.) 1,800
Vent saw for cutting roofs (have 1, want 2 – 1 for each engine) 2,200
Chief Graham explained that this is a heavy-duty saw used for ventilation.
Two (2) 4-Gas meters w/calibration (tests for dangerous gases) 3,400
The meters detect explosive gases; t he City does not have any at this time.
Facility Maintenance
Generator maintenance (50% of PSB generator) 750
Generator maintenance – Station 2 1,100
Contribution to SIFD training facility maintenance 1,000
This is a new item to the budget; the City uses the Sullivan’s Island facility for training.
Elevator maintenance – Station 2 2,200
Elevator maintenance (50% of 1 elevator in PSB) 1,100
HVAC maintenance (50% of annual PSB contract) 2,500
HVAC maintenance – Station 2 2,000
Pressure wash exterior (Station 2 plus 50% of PSB) 1,800
D. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
6. Highlights of Department Reports
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 8 of 9
Fire Department
Chief Graham commented that the Department had responded to a fire on Ocean Boulevard on
January 9; the smoke detectors in the house alerted the tenants to the danger. In the month of
January, the Department responded to fifty-four (54) total calls; of that number twenty-six (26)
were EMS calls. Personnel conducted fifty-eight (58) fire inspections and found ninety-seven
(97) violations. Training in January included a demonstration by the Charleston County Rescue
Squad about the web-based motor vehicle informati on system, which is software that provides
information on alternative fuel vehicles and special features to responders in the field. On
January 19
th and 20 th, representatives for the Insurance Services Office (ISO) were on the
island for their Public Protection Classification evaluation; the City will receive the results in
approximately three (3) months.
Police Department
Chief Buckhannon alerted the Committee to a common email scam, in which an acquaintance
requests money via Western Union for an emergency, that appeared on the island in January;
he noted that any money sent via Western Union is lost forever. Officers found two (2)
businesses and three (3) homes with open or unsecured door in January. Dispatchers pro-
cessed thirty-three hundred ninety-one (3,391) calls in January, and twenty-one hundred
nineteen (2,119) were for the Police Department. Officers made one hundred ninety-eight (198)
traffic stops and wrote eighty-five (85) tickets. Of the ninety-one (91) reports written, fourteen
(14) arrests were made. A total of four hundred seventy-four (474) hours of training took place
in January with ninety-one percent (91%) focused on the field training of the new officers. For
January, two (2) noise violations were reported and one (1) citation was written; two (2)
warnings were issued for fireworks violations.
7. Executive Session – Not necessary
8. Miscellaneous Business
Councilmember Loftus recounted that an ordinance received First Reading in January allowing
2x3 sandwich board signs; he asked Chief Bu ckhannon whether he saw any public safety
implications related to it. Chief Buckhannon responded that he has not had any experience with
sandwich board signs, but he did not think the signs would be a problem on wide sidewalks like
on Front Beach.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked about the impact on the Police Department for enforcement
since the ordinance states that the signs cannot be left out overnight; the Chief commented that
enforcement of the ordinance would be under the Building Department. Administrator Tucker
interjected that the Police Department would record the violation and report it to the Building
Department for enforcement.
Jim Owens of 2805 Palm Boulevard remarked that he had arrived late and asked whether
Citizens’ Comments could be re-opened to allow him to ask question.
Public Safety Committee
February 8, 2011
Page 9 of 9
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to re-open Citizens’ Comments; Councilmem-
ber Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Mr. Owens asked the Chiefs whether the City maintained a data base of emergency contact
information on residents in the possibility that a resident, away from home for an extended time,
might have the home burglarized or even experi ence a fire creating the need for the emergency
information. Chief Buckhannon explained that the situation he was describing was the reason
the City had initiated the Special Patrol Request (SPR) program whereby residents can notify
the Police Department of an emergency contact when they plan to be away for any period of
time. During the resident’s absence, an officer will make additional patrols by the address and,
if requested, get out of the patrol car to walk around the residence to ensure that all is as it
should be.
Mr. Owens noted that a public forum is planned for Wednesday, February 23 about parking on
the island; he expressed concern about emergency vehicles getting access to properties when
vehicles are parked at meters along the streets. Mr. Owens then asked Chief Graham and
Chief Buckhannon to express how emergency vehicles will handle the proposed parking plan.
Chair Bettelli explained to Mr. Owens that Citizens’ Comments is not a question and answer
period and suggested that Mr. Owens speak to the Chiefs after the meeting.
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 2, 2011.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:05
p.m.; Chair Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.