April 4 (PDF, 30.56 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Monday, April 4, 2011
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Comm ittee was held at 5:30 p.m., Monday, April 4,
2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Loftus, Chair Bettelli, Administrator
Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon and City Clerk Copeland. A quorum was
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to approve the minutes of the regu-
lar MEETING OF March 2, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Loftus seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Having reviewed the minutes of the March meeting, Arnold Karig of 5102 Palm Boulevard com-
mented that he did not think space was available to accommodate a multi-use path between
41
st and 51st Avenue like the one being requested by the City in its requests for use of CTC and
Transportation Sakes Tax funds.
Administrator Tucker commented that an ASSHTO (American Association of State Highway and
Transportation Officials) bike path would be a continuation from the road to the existing bike
path assuming space would allow; at the very least, the Administrator noted that the existing
path is in poor condition and in need of repair.
Before moving on to Old Business, Councilmember Loftus commented that he had expected the
alarm ordinance discussed at the March City Council meeting to be on the agenda; he indicated
that Mr. Karig had made remarks at the meeting that Council agreed should be included.
Administrator Tucker stated that she, too, had thought it should be on the agenda, but a review
of the Council minutes indicated that City Council had sent the ordinance to the Planning
Commission for further discussion. The Administrator pointed out that this ordinance had origin-
nated with the Public Safety Committee and that to amend the agenda to discuss it would be
well within the Committee’s purview.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to amend the agenda to discuss the alarm
ordinance under Old Business : Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Old Business
Discussion of Ordinance 2011-04
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 2 of 9
Administrator Tucker recalled that the concern expressed had been that the installing alarm
company be aware of and responsible for registering the alarm with the City rather than the
property owner. Mr. Karig had noted that the property owner would have no reason to know
that he/she was required to register the alarm with the city and that, frequently, the homeowner
could be the alarm system installer. In case s where the homeowner installs the alarm, he/she
would not know about the registration requirem ent until a situation arose when a false alarm
occurs and he/she is ticketed for not registering the alarm.
Chief Graham suggested that the ordinance be changed to read “the installer” as the party
required to register the alarm, thereby, includi ng the property owner who installs the system
himself.
Councilmember Loftus expressed his opinion that, since the alarm companies are required to
purchase a business license to install alarms on the island, the responsibility for educating the
company about the City’s ordinance requirements falls to the Building Department.
Chief Buckhannon reported that, in the sixteen (16) years that the ordinance has been in the
City code, he does not remember anyone paying a fine. Typically, when a ticket is written, the
homeowner can pay for the alarm registration and have the ticket dismissed.
Administrator Tucker summarized the discussion stating that the staff would review the
ordinance and the internal processes to devise a better way to educate the installation com-
panies and property owners. Staff will have the recommendations in place before the ordinance
comes before City Council for Second Reading.
Review of FY12 Capital and Operating Budgets for Fire and Police Departments
Prefacing the discussion, Administrator Tucker explained that she, the City Treasurer and the
individual department managers had met and analyzed the operating budgets after the Ways
and Means March meeting and before the budget workshop for April 19. The staff chose to look
at recent history rather than just the prior y ear’s or year-to-date expenditures; actual expendi-
tures through February are misleading for budget purposes, because the City has yet to get into
the tourist season which puts a strain on City resources. In the analysis process, they had
looked at the most recent five (5) years audited financial statements and addressed each line
item that was five hundred dollars ($500) greater than the five (5) year average.
Police Department
Lines 67 through 74 all relate to employee compensation and were not addressed for the pur-
pose of this analysis.
Printing and office supplies 15,420
The analysis shows that this number is as close as possible
Memberships and dues 1,295
No change
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 3 of 9
Meetings and seminars 1,500
Included here is a conference attended by Ch ief Buckhannon on the Police Department software
Vehicle fuel and oil 116,000
Analysis on-going; amount will stay the same or possibly be reduced
Vehicle maintenance 27,000
No change; the police vehicles must be k ept in top repair in order to be reliable
Electricity and gas 22,000
The increase in this item is attributed to co rrecting the SCE&G equipment problem that, previous-
ly, afforded the City with much lower than anticipated charges. The number could change in that
the City will receive one (1) billing reflective of actual charges before the budget is passed.
Telephone and cable 34,992
No change
Water and sewer 5,500
No change
Non-capital tools and equipment 1,500
Reduce by $500 to the approximate 5–year average
Maintenance and service contracts 41,805
The addition of $7,520 for the annual maintenance on the dispatching radio equipment generated
the increase in this line item
Administrator Tucker reported that the five (5) year analysis was complicated by the fact that the
Police and Fire Departments do not have five (5) years of experience in the Public Safety
Building. Research into maintenance contracts for the City’s elevators is on-going; a couple of
the issues the staff has confronted are that the elevators came online at varying times and they
are not from the same manufacturer.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the City wa s required to have the manufacturer service
the elevators, and the Administrator replied that no such requirement existed. The city could
possibly see some cost savings if they were all under one (1) contract, so efforts are being pur-
sued for a global contract.
Councilmember Loftus inquired of Chief Buckhannon the date for the planned move of dispatch
activities to the County-wide consolidated disp atch center; Chief Buckhannon replied that the
date had been pushed back to July 2013 because of delays in breaking ground on the new
facility.
In addition, Councilmember Loftus asked for clarification of “hood maintenance;” he was told
that the maintenance is for the hoods on the stoves in the Public Safety Building. Because the
Public Safety Building was constructed to serve the City in a disaster, these specific hoods were
necessary, and they must have monthly inspections and be properly maintained under state
regulations.
Machinery and equipment repair 6,000
No change
U n i f o r m s 1 6 , 5 1 5
Reduced by $1,500 based on analysis
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 2,000
No change
Medical and lab supplies 4,500
Reduced by $1,000 based on analysis; includes costs associated with medical tests related to
hiring
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 4 of 9
I n s u r a n c e 6 1 , 7 2 3
No change
Rents and leases 2,600
No change
Employee training 8,980
No change
Professional services 5,750
Reduced by $1,500 based on analysis
Miscellaneous and contingency 3,750
No change
Canine Kennel Expenses 1,000
No change
The staff review of the Police Department Operating budget resulted in a new increase of seven
hundred forty-five dollars ($745).
Fire Department
The same five (5) year analysis was performed on the Fire Department expenditures, and the
Administrator highlighted the changes.
As in the Police Department, the first eight (8) lines relate to employee compensation and no
changes were made to those line items.
Printing and office supplies 7,000
Reduced by $1,000 based on analysis
Memberships and dues 2,000
No change
Meetings and seminars 1,500
Reduced by $15,00 based on analysis; includes Fire Inspector dues
Vehicle fuel and oil 35,200
As before, on-going evaluation; ex pected to stay the same or go down
Vehicle maintenance 50,000
No change. This equipment must be kept in top condition to be able to respond immediately.
Electricity and gas 32,000
Increased by $1,500 based on resolution of SCE&G problem
Telephone and cable 37,284
No change
Water and sewer 9,000
No change
Non-capital tools and equipment 6,500
No change
Maintenance and service contracts 36,592
No change. Administrator Tucker commented th at up to $1,000 was included as a contribution to
the Sullivan’s Island training facility; this money is used to make the small repairs that occur when
the City fire personnel are training there – th e amount used varies from year-to-year depending
on circumstances.
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 5 of 9
Councilmember Bergwerf asked about the housekeeping for the Fire Department; Chief
Graham indicated that the living quarters are cleaned by the personnel on duty and that only the
common areas are cleaned by an outside vendor.
Administrator Tucker commented that a bid will go out for cleaning City Hall that will go into
effect July 1, 2011. A similar process took place shortly after the City took occupancy of the
Public Safety Building, and the vendor at the Public Safety Building has not changed. The
Administrator noted that the vendor for City Hall and the Public Safety Building are different.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the City could get a more competitive price if it were to
bundle the City buildings under one (1) contract.
U n i f o r m s 2 2 , 0 0 0
Reduced by $1,000 based on analysis
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 4,000
Reduced by $1,000 based on analysis
Medical and lab supplies 16,000
Reduced by $1,000 based on analysis
I n s u r a n c e 7 8 , 9 5 1
No change
Rents and leases 2,500
No change
Employee training 14,000
Reduced by $3,000 based on analysis
Professional services 3,000
Reduced by $1,160 based on analysis
Miscellaneous and contingency 6,500
Reduced by $500 based on analysis
Volunteer Fire Points 4,000
No change
Administrator Tucker explained that the Capital Budgets on the following pages are presented in
a different format from what the Committee has seen before; in the new schedules, the FY12
capital expenditures are shown with their funding source. No changes have been made to the
Police Department’s Capital Budget since the last version was presented to the Committee; the
Administrator noted that the expenditures under Facilities Maintenance were included in the
operating budget and here due to the dollar amounts.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether purchasing one (1) out of three (3) patrol vehicles
through tourism funds was typical for the City; the Administrator indicated that it was and stated
that vehicles had been purchased from the Victims and Narcotics funds in the past.
Administrator Tucker commented that more police calls are generated by tourists in season than
other times of the year; therefore, the City could make a legitimate case for the use of tourism
funds.
On the Fire Department Capital Budget, the Administrator pointed out that fifty percent (50%) of
the capital leases for equipment are to be paid from tourism funds. Like the Police Capital
Budget, no changes have been made to the figures since the Ways and Means meeting, and
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 6 of 9
the schedule illustrates the source of funding for these expenditures. Lines 84 through 76 are
routine, cyclical replacements and are represented on this schedule due to the costs.
Councilmember Bergwerf questioned that the replacement boat for the Fire Department was on
the capital budget for fifty thousand dollars ($50,000); Administrator Tucker recounted that Chief
Graham indicated, at the previous meeting, that she has looked at Pioneer and Key West boats,
both of which are on state contract pricing, as possible replacements at a cost of forty thousand
dollars ($40,000), but the Committee did not move to reduce the cost estimate on the budget.
Chair Bettelli asked Chief Graham whether she wa s confident that she would not exceed forty
thousand dollars ($40,000) in replacing the boat, and she stated that she was.
Councilmember Loftus expressed that he could not support spending that much for a boat in
these economic times and that lower cost alternatives must exist. He remarked that the City
should be able to get a boat that would serve its needs through state surplus or some type of
government seizure, possible a used boat could be retro-fitted. Chief Graham related that she
had contacted the federal group about seized equipment and had been told that they will be
receiving a shipment from government agencie s, but the condition of the equipment was
unknown, and, typically, the motors are not in working condition.
Chair Bettelli commented that, when amortizing forty thousand dollars ($50,000) over twenty
(20) years, which is how long he present boat has be in use, the cost is quite low; he added that
the committees have not yet seen revenues and that the responsibility of City Council was, to
the best of its ability, to meet the needs of the City and its residents, which cannot be accom-
plished with the existing boat.
Chief Graham noted that a new boat should be a commercial grade boat, not a sport boat.
Administrator Tucker indicated that the staff proposed purchasing the boat through tourism
funds which were tracking well ahead of what was projected for the FY11 budget.
According tom Chief Graham, repairs in the neighborhood of six thousand dollars ($6,000)
would be required to keep the existing boat in service, and she and the Administrator agreed
that such repairs were not cost effective.
Administrator Tucker suggested that the boat could be removed from the City’s FY12 capital
budget and could be purchased from State Accommodations taxes; the possibility exists that
funds may be available not.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to reduce the boat purchase in the Fire Depart-
ment Capital Budget to $40,000; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Loftus stated that he was not in favor of spending this amount for a boat when
he was confident that lower cost alternatives were available, but agreed that providing public
safety for the residents and tourists was critical.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 7 of 9
Administrator Tucker noted that the final pages were a reiteration of expenses by funding
source. The Administrator explained that a portion of every ticket paid goes to a Victims Fund
and is returned to the City for victims or crime; t he City only provides custodial services for the
Fire 1% Fund because all of the decisions are made by the Fire Department personnel.
5. New Business
A. Discussion of Livability Court Request for Home Detention Ordinance
Chair Bettelli reported that he and the city Administrator had received an email from the
Livability Court judge asked that the City consi der home detention as a method of punishment.
Administrator Tucker commented that she had passed the suggestion to the City Attorney for
research into the state laws regarding home detention. The research indicated that the City
would be required to enact a new ordinance, contract with an entity to monitor those sentenced
to home detention and incur additional expenses related to it.
Responding to Councilmember Bergwerf’s question, the Administrator stated that she had not
investigated the initial startup costs because neither she nor Chief Buckhannon recommends
the action. Chief Buckhannon mentioned that he had spoken with Charleston County and
learned that they had rejected the idea as well.
After brief discussion, the Committee agreed to take no action on the subject of home detention.
B. Discussion of Command Positions in Police Department
Chief Buckhannon stated that Friday, April 1 had been Lieutenant Wright’s last day with the City
and that he was looking into the best way to fill the vacancy. He commented that, at one time,
the City had another position between those of lieutenant and sergeant, and he was proposing
that the City return to that structure. The Chief indicated that he has the staff presently to fill two
(2) such positions that would share the lieutenant’s workload and report directly to him; these
would be new positions that would be filled by existing personnel – no increase in the number of
people in the Police Department.
Administrator Tucker stated that, should the Committee agree with the Chief’s proposal, he
would need to prepare the job descriptions for these positions with appropriate wage ranges to
present to the Personnel Committee for approval. Consequently, the current lieutenant’s posi-
tion would go away and be replaced with these two (2) new positions. Once the job descriptions
and pay ranges are approved, the Chief can begin reviewing applications.
Chief Buckhannon responded to Councilmember Loftus’ concern about budget impact by stating
that this change will be budget neutral; the Police Department will be eliminating one (1) salary
while increasing two (2) other salaries.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved for Chief Buckhannon to proceed
with the proposed command positions; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and
the motion passed unanimously.
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 8 of 9
C. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department
Chief Graham stated that personnel had reported a fuel spill at the marina on March 6
th that
turned out to be a situation where a crew had overfilled a tank leaking a small amount of fuel
into the water. On March 9
th, personnel responded to a tour bus fire on Front Beach emanating
from the engine compartment; on March 16 th, staff responded to an alarm activation at Sweet-
grass Pavilion that was the result of a sump pump that had shorted out and overheated. Isle of
Palms’ personnel assisted with the wild fires in Awendaw on March 23 rd and 24 th. During the
month, fire personnel installed several smoke detectors and assisted residents who had fallen in
their homes.
Pursuant to a request from the Committee to track EMS response times, Chief Graham offered
the Committee the first draft of a report to get their feedback on the format. Councilmember
Loftus suggested a separate column indicating when EMS originated their response from
Station 1 versus off-island; Chair Bettelli requested a column where the response time had been
computed.
Police Department
Chief Buckhannon reported that, on March 26 th, four (4) young ladies from Berkeley County
were picked up for steading merchandise from Front Beach businesses. The same day, a
report was made of a beer can being thrown at a car from partiers in Wild Dunes who turned out
to be five (5) nineteen (19) year olds found to in possession of both beer and liquor; they were
charged with underage possession. Four (4) juveniles between the ages of ten and fourteen
(10-14) were spray painting cars and signs; a total of fourteen (14) separate instances were
recorded. Two (2) of the young people were island residents and two (2) were from Mount
Pleasant.
During the month of March, the dispatchers responded to thirty-nine hundred (3,900) calls;
twenty-nine hundred fifty-five (2,955) were for the Police Department. A total of twelve hundred
twenty-seven (1,227) building checks were performed; four hundred twenty-nine (429) traffic
stops generated one hundred sixty-nine (169) tickets.
Administrator Tucker cautioned Committee members to keep their bicycles and golf carts locked
up as the City was seeing a rash of thefts and subsequent damage to the items.
In conclusion, Chief Buckhannon announced that the Police Department had received its third
(3
rd) accreditation from CALEA in Bethesda, Maryland on March 26 th. Chair Bettelli reported
that the Department had received “a wonderful report.”
7. Executive Session – Not needed
Public Safety Committee
April 4, 2011
Page 9 of 9
8. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, May 3, 2011 in Council Chambers.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:15 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.