March 2 (PDF, 24.05 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
4:00 p.m., Wednesday, March 2, 2011
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 4:00 p.m. on Wednesday,
March 2, 2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were C ouncilmembers Stone and Thomas, Chair Duffy, City
Administrator Tucker, Director Pitts, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk
Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Duffy called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Thomas moved to approve the minutes of the regu-
lar meeting as submitted; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Jim Owens, 2805 Palm Boulevard, asked whether the City had an ordinance prohibiting land-
scapers from blowing leaves and grass clippings into the streets; Administrator Tucker re-
sponded that the City had no ordinance requiring that such debris be vacuumed. However,
blowing the leaves or clippings into the storm drains violates the City’s storm water ordinance;
the problem is that the person much be caught in the act to be charged.
Mr. Owens recalled that he had come before the Committee in the past about overgrowth along
the City’s sidewalks and, shortly thereafter, a ”chain gang” appeared on the island to perform
the work. He inquired about which entity was responsible for maintaining the sidewalks.
Administrator Tucker stated that the sidewalks are under the purview of SCDOT; the City’s
Public Works personnel do trim when the workload affords the time. When the City has asked
for assistance from Charleston County, they have sent teams of prisoners on work release to
trim the sidewalks. The Administrator commented that, if Mr. Owens had specific areas in mind,
he could report them, and the City would try to have them trimmed. Mr. Owens wondered
whether the City could arrange for prisoners to come to the island on a regular basis to keep the
sidewalks trimmed.
4. Department Reports for February 2011
Director Pitts reported that personnel had cut and removed a tree felled by a wind storm from
Myrtle and 19
th Avenue. He noted that the Caterpillar scoop had dropped a valve in the engine,
so personnel have been picking up debris by hand, and, to-date, work is on schedule. The
equipment is under warranty; the engine is in Columbia, but Director Pitts does not yet know
whether the engine will be repaired or replaced. In February, Charleston County completed the
storm water work on 27
th and 28th Avenue, and Eadie’s is continuing to restructure the ditches.
Since this meeting is so early in the month, the data needed to complete the garbage reports is
not yet available, but the reports will be on the City’s website tomorrow.
Administrator Tucker emphasized that the reports and graphs for the Public Works Department
were posted each month; she believes that the majority of people are not aware that the website
is updated, at least, weekly or that departmental reports are posted each month.
Public Works Committee
March 2, 2011
Page 2 of 6
5. Old Business
Update on Drainage Projects
Administrator Tucker announced that the contract for the 53
rd to 57 th Avenue Drainage Project
was signed by the City this week and is in the hands of the vendor for final execution.
According to Civil Site Environmental, work w ill begin on the components of the project that are
in the high tourist areas of Wild Dunes. In addition, the Administrator reported that she had
reconciled the funding balance for the project with Charleston County regarding the CTC and
Transportation Sales Tax grants awarded over the year, and the City’s balance agrees with that
of Charleston County. Administrator Tucker stated that she expects mobilization very shortly.
Director Pitts reported that Charleston County had used their new camera to inspect covered
section of the Sparrow Lane ditch and found that it has deteriorated to the point that the piping
has separated. The easiest solution is to slip-line the pipe, and Charleston County is in the
process of getting quotes.
6. New Business
A. Discussion of SCE&G Communications Poles
Westy Westmoreland of SCE&G was present to explain the program and to answer questions
and/or concerns of the Committee.
Administrator Tucker explained that this activity is related to the work being done around City
Hall to provide improved service delivery to the nor th end of the island. In order for the system
to function most efficiently, SCE&G needs a communications tower that would relay information
about a problem anywhere along the grid; this communication would identify the problem quickly
enough to eliminate a crew from coming to the island for an identification and another crew to
come to the island for repairs – one step would be eliminated. The Administrator explained that
this transmission system will require a one hundred foot (100 ft.) tower located on Thirteenth
Avenue.
Mr. Westmoreland stated that SCE&G has a lot of work happening on the Isle of Palms. The
most recent work around City Hall was to bring a fourth circuit onto the island, reducing the
num-ber of customers served per li ne. According to Mr. Westmoreland, the real benefit to the
island was that, in certain situations, should service be lost to Wild Dunes or 41
st to 57th Avenue,
SCE&G can shed load from one circuit to pick up service reducing the length of an outage.
The program brought before the Committee today was another reliability project; Mr.
Westmoreland stated that SCE&G always strives to reduce the outage time for its customers
and to reduce the number of customers affected by an outage. He explained that the Number
One circuit runs from the substation behind City Hall to 41
st Avenue; the Number Three circuit
runs from 41 st Avenue to the end of the island, servicing Dewees, Capers and Bull Islands –
approximately seventy percent (70%) of the load on the island. The new project is to put remote
switching devices that would enable communication with the SCE&G system from Columbia or
Charleston or whatever area was dispatching; SCE&G wants to put one (1) device at 30
th and
Public Works Committee
March 2, 2011
Page 3 of 6
one (1) at 41 st Avenue. Mr. Westmoreland said that the City would not notice any difference at
the 41 st Avenue location because existing switching is there and they will only be adding
communications capabilities. The 30 th Avenue location was selected because it is half way on
the Number One circuit; 41 st Avenue is where the two (2) circuits tie. He explained that, should
a problem occur between City Hall and 41 st Avenue, SCE&G can tie those circuits and pick up
the customers in areas that are not faulted.
Mr. Westmoreland informed the Committee that presently SCE&G can only isolate the “fault,”
i.e. a tree falls on a line or the underground cable fails, which may be as small as six feet by four
feet (6 ft. x 4 ft.) yet disrupts service for all cust omers on that circuit, by dispatching technicians
and line staff to the island to locate it as best they can between two (2) switches. They can turn
the breaker on that will feed up to that problem area and close the switch at 41
st Avenue which
will back feed up to the bad area, reducing the number of customers affected - the switching
could take two to three (2-3) hours. With automated switches at 30
th and 41st Avenues, if a fault
occurs between 13th and 30th Avenue, the switch at 30 th could be opened and the switch at 41 st
could be closed and back feed to 30 th Avenue; the number of people affected is dramatically
reduced and the action takes minutes instead of hours. The process is illustrated in a drawing
identified as Exhibit A attached to the historical record of the meeting.
According to Mr. Westmoreland, the only way to communicate with these switches is via radio
signals, and, because of the distance across Hamlin Sound, towers are required on which to
mount the antenna. The location selected is next to the substation on 13
th Avenue and is shown
by a red dot on an aerial photograph marked as Exhibit B attached to the historical record of the
meeting. With the structures already in place at the end of 13
th on Hamlin Creek, the pole will
not be obvious to observers and is far away from residences, yet close to the substation.
In responding to Administrator Tucker’s question, Mr. Westmoreland stated that the complica-
tion with locating the antenna on the water tower is that the line must come back, hopefully
underground, to the substation behind City Hall.
In a project that is currently on the drawing board that would bring another circuit to the island,
the tower being discussed at this meeting would come down to be replaced by a structure
referred to as a riser (see Exhibit D) on which the antenna would be placed. Mr. Westmoreland
explained that the structure is called a riser because it is the location where the underground
cables rise up.
Administrator Tucker commented that this SCE&G communications tower would be problematic
for the City because there is no provision in the Ci ty’s Code of Ordinances for a utility tower of
this height. In discussions with Mr. Westmoreland, he and the Administrator checked the City’s
franchise agreement with SCE&G to determine if it contained language specific to poles, and
such language is included that suggests SCE&G might be able to move forward. Before
advising the Committee about Mr. Westmoreland’s project, the Administrator has asked the City
Attorney to review the franchise agreement and determine that SCE&G would be allowed to
construct this tower under the terms of that agreement.
Chair Duffy asked what the time frame was for the switch project, and Mr. Westmoreland stated
that SCE&G has funds available, and the job could be completed in three (3) months.
Public Works Committee
March 2, 2011
Page 4 of 6
Administrator Tucker asked whether this new communications tower would create interference
with existing signals on the water tower or the new communications tower on 41
st; Mr.
Westmoreland said that they have never had any issues.
Mr. Westmoreland stated that the franchise agreement is an ordinance; he expressed confi-
dence that the agreement contained the language needed for the pole.
Administrator Tucker indicated to the Committee that they are not expected to act on this pole
today.
Before leaving, Mr. Westmoreland stated that survey work was being done currently as SCE&G
prepares to underground the lines to Dewees Island.
B. Discussion of CTC and Transportation Sales Tax Requests
Administrator Tucker explained that this has been the source of funds for the 53
rd to 57th Avenue
Drainage Project, which has been generously supported since 2004; the City has received five
hundred fifty thousand dollars ($550,000) from CTC funds and three hundred thousand dollars
(300,000) from the Transportation Sales Tax funds. Other things that the City has received
funding for in the past have been the re-surfacing of the bike path on Waterway Boulevard, the
21
st Avenue parking expansion for handicapped parking, 21 st Avenue sidewalk improvement,
the 41st Avenue and Palm Boulevard bike path and improvements at 41 st Avenue for the three-
way stop. The Administrator suggested the engineering for the 44 th to 52nd Drainage project as
the primary request for 2012; she reminded the Committee that this project was an item in the
long-range plan for Public Works.
Chair Duffy agreed that the first priority should be engineering for the next phase in solving the
island’s drainage needs; he thought the paving of Cassina Drive should next and some bike
path on the island. Administrator Tucker suggested improvements to the bike path between 41
st
and 57th Avenue to make it a multi-use path, a wider path that has designations for both bikers
and pedestrians. The Committee concurred with the options set forth by the Administrator.
The deadline for the requests for CTC and Transportation Sales Tax funds in March 18; the
Administrator stated that she would present these recommendations to the Public Safety Com-
mittee for their input as well.
C. Review of Operating Budget for FY 2011-2012
Assistant Dziuban commented that both the operating and capital budgets had been in meeting
packets; this version of the capital budget contains the changes made in February.
Wages and salaries 410,987
Overtime wages 7,652
FICA expense 32,026
Retirement expense 39,310
Workers Compensation 19,865
Wages include a 3% merit pool and othe r lines are factored of that increase.
Public Works Committee
March 2, 2011
Page 5 of 6
Employee health insurance 56,940
Reflects reduction in estimated premium with the State Health Plan.
Vehicle fuel and oil 96,400
Based on 12 months’ usage and an estimate $4/gallon for both diesel and unleaded.
Electricity and gas 73,000
Telephone and cable 7,440
Water and sewer 2,500
Based on most recent 12 months’ actual.
Maintenance and service contracts 5,930
Increased to reflect Public Works’ share of glob al firewall and anti-virus protection and cost of fuel
filters for fuel island.
L T D i n s u r a n c e - 0 -
Cost included in premium from State Health Plan.
Contracted Services 25,160
Reduction in number of truckloads going to 4B related to the ordinance disallowing plastic bags.
Overall, the operating budget for Public Works in FY12 as presented has a negligible change
from FY11.
Councilmember Stone questioned Director Pitts about the time frame that the City provided
twice a week garbage collections; the Director responded that the change starts the Monday
following Memorial Day through the Monday following Labor Day. Based on the
Councilmember’s calculations, wages, temporary labor and related costs compose sixty-seven
percent (67%) of the Public Works budget, and he asked whether that could be reduced in
some way. Councilmember Stone concluded that if all City budgets maintain the same, like the
Public Works budget, the City will need to draw from reserves in FY12 to balance the budget as
it did in FY11.
Councilmember Stone inquired about whether “justification (existed) for cutting back on some of
the double pick-ups.” Director Pitts responded that if personnel were reduced, overtime would
be necessary to get the work done; currently the Department uses five (5) temporary persons,
one (1) per truck.
Councilmember Stone re-phrased his question to a sk whether the twice weekly pickups were
the reason the City hires temporary workers; the Director stated that the City has eight (8) trucks
with one (1) driver, and the temporary labor is made up of men on the back of the truck.
Director Pitts remarked that the full-time employees in the Department are CDL drivers, but they
must aid the personnel on the back of the truck because the number of temporary helpers has
been reduced from eight (8) in years past to five (5). Chair Duffy added that one full-time
position had been eliminated last year.
Councilmember Stone noted that the tonnage has been getting lower each month, so he
thought that would relate to a reduction in staffing needs. Director Pitts countered that the
volume may be declining but the number of households to be serviced remains the same.
Public Works Committee
March 1, 2011
Page 6 of 6
Administrator Tucker commented that, if the personnel were not involved in a second garbage
collection during peak season, they would be expand on other work that is done only as time
allows, such as maintaining the beach accesses. The Administrator added that, “yes, the
biggest expense to the City of Isle of Palms is personnel, and that is because what the City
does for its residents is a service industry – that is what we do. A service industry requires
people; that is the most important part of what we do. . . We do not need someone on the
payroll that does not have multiple work tasks assigned to them, and most do.”
D. Consideration of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
Chair Duffy stated that the Public Works Director should communicate any concerns about the
potential parking plan and its impact on the servic es provided by the Public Works Department
to the City Administrator, to the Planning Commission and, ultimately, to City Council. Director
Pitts commented that the shuttle truck travels down the right-of-way, so parking there would
create a problem for his staff; the efficiency, i.e. the length of the route would be impacted.
Director Pitts reported that the yellow trash barrels have arrived and will get another coat of
paint before the palm tree stencil is applied; he stated that he has not heard from the Garden
Club about filling them in. Councilmember Stone suggested that the Director contact the
Exchange Club; he thought they would be willing to assist.
Next meeting date: 4 p.m., Wednesday, April 6, 2011.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to adjourn at 5:30 p.m.; Chair Duffy
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.