February 3 (PDF, 23.69 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
8:30 a.m., Thursday, February 3, 2011
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 8:30 a.m. on Thursday,
February 3, 2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Stone, Mayor Cronin, Chair Loftus, City
Administrator Tucker, Marina Manager Berrigan and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was pre-
sent to conduct business.
1. Chair Loftus called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of January 6, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to re-order the agenda to move to New Busi-
ness at time; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANI-
MOUSLY.
6. New Business
A. Update on Beach Restoration
Administrator Tucker stated that Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) has been asked to
attend the February Ways and Means Committee meeting to present the results of the most
recent monitoring and to update the Committee on the status of the permitting and engineering
phase of the focused erosion project. The Administrator related that a member of the
community has expressed interest in the new project and has requested copies of the
engineering designs; should the resident have n egative comments about the project, the public
comment period for the project has passed. In conclusion, Administrator Tucker noted that Tim
Kana of CSE would be speaking at the annual meeting of the Wild Dunes Community
Association that closely follows the Ways and Means meeting.
B. Status of Request for Proposals for Engineering Design and Permitting for
Marina Dredging
Administrator Tucker explained that the task of selecting a vendor to recommend for the
engineering design permitting for marina dredging had been a more laborious one (1) than she
had expected because the three (3) bidders were each well-qualified and had each submitted
comprehensive bid packages. The bidders were Applied Technology and Management (ATM),
Tidewater Environmental and GEL Engineering. In developing the bid analyses, the
Administrator compared the responses to the requirements of the RFP, thus ensuring that all
bidders met the bid requirements, and summarized the most important points. Clerk Copeland
checked references on the bidders and did get one (1) unfavorable reference for ATM. A like-
for-like comparison of costs was complicated by the fact that each bidder had included caveats
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 2 of 7
in different areas. In the end, Administrator Tucker recommended GEL Engineering for the
project based on their in-house capabilities, the City’s past experience with GEL as the
oversight engineer for the 2003 dredging project and GEL’s familiarity with the area and the
players.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to recommend that staff begin negotiations on
a contract with GEL Engineering for the engineering design and permitting of a
marina dredging project; Councilmember Stone seconded.
Chair Loftus asked whether staff had reviewed the contract from the 2003 project to ensure
that everything had been included in the RFP to avoid change orders that typically cost more
as add-ons than as contract inclusions. Administrator Tucker recalled that the change orders
in that project were initiated by the City, and she assured the Chair that the staff had carefully
reviewed the previous contract, but the possibility of unknowns still existed.
When queried, Marina Manager Berrigan said he had worked with the staff on the RFP and
that his primary concern was that the dredging get as close to the bulkhead as possible.
Chair Loftus asked whether other stakeholders had expressed interest in joining with the City;
the Administrator recalled that the Morgan Creek Harbor Association (MCHA) had asked to
speak at the January meeting and cancelled at the last minute. The City informed MCHA that
a contract for engineering design and permitting would likely be approved at this meeting, and
they declined to comment or attend the meeting.
Administrator Tucker stated that the biggest question at this point is what needs to be done at
the Goat Island spoil site and the cost associated with that work; the Administrator voiced
concern that the City could be forced to do the repairs to the site then be denied its use by the
Corps of Engineers.
As for the 26
th Avenue Canal dredging, Jack Walker, Senior Scientist for GEL Engineering,
reported that the residents have their permits and plan to dredge February 15 th-17th. They
have been given permission by the Corps to use a spoi l site south of the site previously used
by the City. Mr. Walker added that this site is huge and the City should investigate it.
When asked by the Administrator what additional costs would be incurred with this second site,
Mr. Walker estimated a ten percent (10%) increase in mobilization and demobilization with no
increase in dredging costs. Mr. Walker noted that whether the Corps of Engineers would hold
the City hostage on the Goat Island spoil site was unknown.
Administrator Tucker commented that no one knows who is responsible for the damages to the
Goat Island spoil site; Mr. Walker stated that the Corp has used that site two (2) times since the
City used it. Mr. Walker said he thought the cost estimates for the repairs were inflated; he
thought the repairs could be done for less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000).
Administrator Tucker stated that the dredging area would begin where the IOP Marina
intersects with Dewees Inlet and extend to the private property line beside the Tidal Wave
docks.
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 3 of 7
Vote: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: Chair Loftus moved to go to Item 4 on the Agenda; Mayor Cronin
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Marina Manager’s Report – Brian Berrigan
Mr. Berrigan stated that for three (3) days last week the marina had done zero business; he
added that, had last year not been a good one, he would not be surviving. Mr. Berrigan said
that the store is “dying a slow death.” He indicated that he was not getting support from
islanders in the off-season; he commented that gas at the store was only two dollars ninety-six
cents ($2.96) a gallon when it was over three dollars ($3.00) across the street. Mr. Berrigan
asked for assistance from the City, maybe via the City’s website or newsletter, to boost
business at the marina and the marina store.
Mr. Berrigan voiced his opinion that a report of the payment status of tenants at the marina
should be removed from the Committee’s agenda; he stated that the City sends letters to
tenants who are late and collects late fees on delinquent payments – bringing attention to them
on the public record was unfair. In his opinion, public identification should only be made when
a tenant falls behind a couple or three (3) months.
Mr. Berrigan noted that he was very pleased that the City had selected GEL for the engineering
design and permitting for marina dredging; he was confident that they would do an excellent
job for the City.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to remove the Marina Rents Report from
future Real Property Committee agendas; Councilmember Stone seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Stone stated that he had wondered why the marina and the restaurant were
singled out for reports; he expressed the opinion that Committee should not meddle into
tenant’s business.
Mayor Cronin suggested that the marina and the restaurant be removed from the agenda and
replaced with Leaseholder Comments.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to remove reports from the marina
and Morgan Creek Grill from the Real Property Committee Agenda; Mayor Cronin
seconded.
Chair Loftus indicated that tenants should be notified each month before meeting agendas are
prepared giving them the opportunity to be on the agenda if they want to comment.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 4 of 7
5. Morgan Creek Grill Report – Carla Pope, Operations Manager
Administrator Tucker stated that Ms. Pope was out of town, but had emailed a question about
lights to be repaired and the fact that the marina dockmaster had been in discussions with
SCE&G about them.
Mr. Berrigan reported that the problem light on the restaurant has a voltage problem and that
the tallest and brightest lights were being replaced. The lights that are out in the restaurant’s
employee parking area were installed by the restaurant and are, therefore, the restaurant’s
responsibility. Mr. Berrigan agreed to discuss the lighting issues with Ms. Pope when she
returns.
6. New Business
A. Recognition of Past Council and Commission Members via Engraved
Bricks
Chair Loftus commented that he had asked that this be placed on the agenda for discussion
because he perceives the City’s engraved brick program to be an economical way to recognize
the contribution citizens have made to the City through their service. He noted that criteria
would need to be established, for instance, length of service, how far back in the City’s history
to go, recognizing Committee chair persons differently from members, etc., as well as a
location to use.
Mayor Cronin suggested that the staff make a recommendation about a location taking into
consideration future needs.
B. Review of FY 2011-2012 Marina Capital Budget and Long-Range Capital
Plan
Front Beach, including Public Restrooms, Parking Meters and Parking Lots
Replace/refurbish benches, trash receptacles, information kiosks $ 2,000
Routine annual expenditure.
Purchase a piece of public art honoring all past council members 7,500
Deferred from FY11.
Add 1 parking kiosk in high volume area at Sea Cabins 6,700
Administrator Tucker stated that Chief Bu ckhannon recommends purchasing a refurbished unit
to keep costs down.
Facility Maintenance
Replace street signs, parking signs, poles (approx. 75 signs) 2,500
Maintain public restrooms, plumbing, electrical, etc. 7,500
Annual parking lot maintenance (fill material, grading) 1,000
Maintain irrigation system for parking lots and Front Beach green spaces 2,500
Maintain electrical systems, landscape lighting, etc. 2,000
Resurfacing (patching) City-owned portion of Ocean Blvd. 5,000
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 5 of 7
Sidewalk and brick repair on City-owned portion of Ocean Boulevard 5,000
Resod and refurbish green spaces 5,000
All of the above items ar e routine annual expenditures
Mayor Cronin questioned the FY14 expenditure of sixty thousand dollars ($60,000) to rehabi-
litate the Breach Inlet boat ramp because it sees so little use. Administrator Tucker
commented that anywhere the City has water access the City should seek to keep it; she
indicated that no work had been done on that ramp in quite some time.
Chair Loftus suggested that the piece of public art be scrapped entirely and replaced by the en-
graved bricks that were discussed earlier; the members of the Committee agreed.
Beach Restoration and Monitoring
2008 Project post-project monitoring (each January and July through 2011) 65,331
Permitting requirement
2008 Project Administration 5,000
2008 Project sand fencing maintenance 5,000
2008 Project escarpment grading (4 times per year) 1,800
Address focused erosion as it occurs (FY12 project is underway) 600,000
Ongoing monitoring of shoreline/long term beach management 50,000
Establish reserve for future beach restoration management projects 100,000
Administrator Tucker pointed out that funds were placed in out years to address future shoals,
but the frequency was a “guess-timate” on staff’s part.
Chair Loftus asked whether the City would use all of the funds for the 2008 renourishment
project; the Administrator responded that, at this time, she did not know. Should any funds
remain, they would be returned to the stakeholders on a pro-rata basis, but those refunds could
not occur until the City is released by the permitting agencies.
Isle of Palms Marina
Design & permitting of new watersports/waverunner dock 25,000
This item was in the FY11 budget and deferred to FY12.
Design and permitting for new docks (permit process takes up to 1 year) 50,000
Part of the long-range plan for the marina.
Chair Loftus voiced his opinion that the restaurant elevator in FY13 should not be the City’s
responsibility. Administrator Tucker countered that the City owned the property and the
building; therefore, the elevator would be the City’s responsibility. The Administrator reported
that she had been in dialogue with the local Americans with Disabilities office because they
were requiring an assessment of all City-owned buildings to ensure compliance with the
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA); the task has been assigned to Director Kerr and is in
progress.
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 6 of 7
Chair Loftus indicated that he had experience with The ADA, and the fact that the restaurant
accommodates the handicapped by serving the same menu to them as they might get in the
area of the restaurant they cannot access makes the restaurant compliant. In his estimation,
no further accommodation, i.e. an elevator, is necessary. Members of the Committee agreed
that the placeholder for an elevator in FY13 should be removed.
Special Projects
Dredging (engineering, permitting in FY11, construction in FY13) 300,000
This represents the construction expense.
Mayor Cronin asked why permitting would be needed since the City ‘s dredging permit has not
yet expired; the Administrator replied that the City’s permit would need to be modified to
accommodate a greater depth.
C. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
7. Old Business
C. Presentation Relative to Electric Car Charging Stations
Mayor Cronin reported that the Isle of Palms has a large number of golf carts and is beginning
to see a number of low-speed vehicles despite the fact that these vehicles are not allowed on
Palm Boulevard. The Mayor reported that legislation is being proposed to allow local
government to determine whether these vehicles should be allowed on the roads. The Mayor
introduced John Poch, Executive Director of Plugin Carolina; a copy of Mr. Poch’s presentation
is attached to the historical record of the minutes of the meeting.
Mr. Poch stated that millions of dollars in grants are available through the Clean Cities Grant
and the Department of energy; the City would be ine ligible for grants involving tax credits since
the City has no tax liability. He proposed t hat charging stations should be as Level 2, 240
volts, and he expressed confidence that he could assist the City in acquiring funds for such
stations.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Marina Rents Report
Administrator Tucker indicated that Morgan Creek Grill continues to be behind; Mayor Cronin
recalled that Ms. Pope had stated that the restaurant would catch up in February. The
Administrator stated that, although not a requirement of the lease, the City does send letters to
tenants when they get behind with the rent.
Next Meeting Date: 8:30 a.m., Thursday, March 3, 2011.
Real Property Committee
February 3, 2011
Page 7 of 7
9. Executive Session – not needed
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:44 a.m.;
Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.