March 3 (PDF, 27.15 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
8:30 a.m., Thursday, March 3, 2011
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 8:30 a.m. on Thursday,
March 3, 2011 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Stone, Chair Loftus, City Administrator
Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. Mayor Cronin’s
absence was excused, and a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Loftus called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 3, 2011 as submitted; Chair Loftus seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizen’s Comments
Report from the Farmers Market Ad Hoc Committee by Jon Regan Walters
Mr. Walters explained that the Committee had been asked to determine the feasibility of a
farmers market for the Isle of Palms. The problems the Committee identified were as follows:
• Competition for established island businesses, particularly the Red and White and
• Drawbacks to every location suggested.
Members of the Committee agreed that the island did not have the year-round population
density to support a farmers market from spring to fall, the period farmers markets typically
operate. The Committee then considered variations on a farmers market but were unable to
identify an island need to be met; in addition, the costs associated with establishing a farmers
market and the administrative costs could not be justified as being in the best interest of the
City. The Committee concluded that a farmers market was not feasible for the City.
Chair Loftus extended the Real Property Commi ttee’s thanks for the time expended by the ad
hoc committee for examining the possibility of a farmers market on the island.
4. Comments from City Tenants – None
5. Old Business
A. Update on Beach Restoration
Administrator Tucker reported that the monitoring document, a summary of which has been
presented to the Wild Dunes Community Association and City Council, has been completed,
but the City is not yet in receipt of a copy; two (2) persons outside the City have requested to
see the document.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 2 of 7
Responding to Councilmember Stone’s query, Administrator Tucker stated that the document
is the scientific support in narrative form of the information contained in the PowerPoint presen-
tation made to Council; it is an official document that can be referred to in the future to track the
status of the beach.
When asked about the process to view the report, the Administrator indicated that this, and all
previous reports, are posted to the City’s website or linked to the site where it appears –
typically, Coastal Science and Engineering (CSE) generates an electronic version of the report.
Councilmember Stone inquired about a timeline for future action; the Administrator responded
that the project and associated permit have been designed to have triggers built in for action;
therefore, the answer to the question of action is when one (1) of the triggers is activated.
On the subject of the permit, Administrator Tucker commented that the City will not have a
permit in-hand until CSE, in collaboration with the City, have responded to the public
comments. These comments will then be judged by the permitting agencies to determine if the
actions to be taken adequately mitigate the issues set forth in the public comments.
B. Consideration of Recognition via Engraved Bricks
Administrator Tucker asked that this item be kept on the agenda because the staff has not
made any significant progress in identifying an area because the staff has been focused on
budgets. The Administrator reported that, coincidentally, the engraver is on the island today to
engrave the bricks that have been sold over the past year.
6. New Business
A. Review of FY 2011-2012 Marina Operating Budget
Assistant Dziuban explained that the Marina Oper ating Budget is different from departmental
budgets in that revenue estimates are available and that she will review changes to FY11.
Marina Revenues
Interest income 4,500
Based on past 12 months’ actual.
Marina store lease income 81,000
Current rent $5,500/month plus approximat ely $15,000 for additional rent provision.
Marina operations lease income 167,000
Annual base rent of $150,000 plus approxim ately $17,000 for additional rent provision.
Marina restaurant lease income 77,916
Current rent is $6,493/month. Additi onal rent provisions suspended until 2013.
Marina Waverunner lease income 19,836
Current rent is $1,653/month.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 3 of 7
Marina Fund Transfers In
Transfers in for Debt Service – State ATAX 177,431
For FY12 – 1/3 of total marina debt service.
Transfers in for Debt Service – Hospitality Tax 177,431
For FY12 – 1/3 of total marina debt service.
Transfer in from Municipal ATAX for Waverunner dock repair 25,000
100% of cost to design and permit a replacement dock for watersports amenities. This is a re-
budget of funds included in the FY11 budget, because City will not proceed before dredging.
Transfer in from Municipal ATAX for new dock design 50,000
100% of cost to design and permit replacement docks on Morgan Creek; design work in FY12
with construction to follow dredging.
Transfer in from Hospitality Taxes for dredging 100,000
1/3 of costs for dredging construction.
Transfer in from State ATAX for dredging 100,000
1/3 of costs for dredging construction.
Chair Loftus questioned the decreasing amount of debt service payments; Administrator
Tucker stated that the amounts are from the amortization schedule for the debt.
The Chair asked for clarification about which set of docks was referred to for design – the
Intracoastal side or the marina docks. Administrator Tucker commented that reconfiguration of
the docks was always part of the long-range plan for the marina, the reconfiguration of the
docks, and that, without consultation with engineers who do this type of work, she was unsure
whether the project would be the marina docks or all docks including the City docks on the
Intracoastal Waterway. The Administrator explained that the intent of reconfiguring the docks
would be to maximize the dock space, and some older docks need attention. Administrator
Tucker noted that she was unsure whether the City would get to the dock reconfiguration in
FY12, but indicated that she would prefer for funding to be in-place should the City be able to
move forward.
The Administrator recounted that the docks at the marina had not all been constructed at the
same time, but sporadically over the years. At the time the Intracoastal docks were built,
rumblings among the permitting agencies was that they not going to allow the development of
water front, and the City was concerned that, if the City did not have docks along the
Intracoastal, it would not be allowed to construct them later. The fact remains that permitting
agencies are more likely to allow for the repair and replacement of existing docks than they are
to permit new dock construction.
Assistant Dziuban commented that the notes on the budget could easily be changed if they
were confusing; Chair Loftus thought that to be a good idea because “Morgan Creek docks” to
him mean the City’s docks used by Morgan Creek Grill.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 4 of 7
Chair Loftus remarked that the City is at the beginning stages of enhancement and renovation
of the marina; therefore, he expressed the opinion that the plan for that should be established
before the City spends money on an engineering study. The Chair added that, in his opinion,
City Council should decide on the direction and support for an enhancement project before it
invests money on engineering; for the Chair, this inclusion in the budget is, at least, a year
premature. The Administrator agreed that any enhancement would have to be a collaborative
effort, for instance, a determination of what the City is willing to fund and what the tenants are
willing to fund and capable of funding.
Councilmember Stone indicated that, if the dredging were to take place late in 2011 and
marina management had successfully made its presentation to Council, the City could be ready
for engineering early in 2011.
Administrator Tucker asked whether the Marina Manager’s presentation should be on the
March City Council agenda, and Chair Loftus stated that he understood that to be the case.
MOTION: Chair Loftus moved to have the presentation of the Marina
Manager’s long range at the March 2011 City Council meeting; Councilmember
Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
General and Administrative
Debt service interest 147,294
Total interest due on Marina and Marina Bulkhead GO bonds per the amortization schedules.
Amortization of bond issue costs 6,969
Professional services 12,000
Based on actual.
Contracted services 300,000
Construction of marina dredging project.
Councilmember Stone sought confirmation that the City had no partners in the dredging pro-
ject; Administrator Tucker concurred. The Administrator reminded the Committee that the City
had met with the other interested parties for eight (8) months, but had not received a commit-
ment from them. Assistant Dziuban reported that the City has committed to keeping the other
parties informed as actions are taken by the City.
Chair Loftus questioned that “Water and sewer” expense had doubled from the FY10 actual
and asked for more information; he also wanted more information about the contingency for
“Maintenance and service contracts” that has gone from an actual of less than twenty-four
hundred dollars ($2,400) to ten thousand dollars in FY11 and FY12.
Chair Loftus inquired about the City including a line item for advertising for the marina;
Administrator Tucker responded that the City has, historically, paid for advertising the marina in
a major mariner magazine.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 5 of 7
The Administrator explained that ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in legal fees were generated
primarily by legal review of the contracts for the engineering design and permitting in FY11 and
for the dredging project in FY12.
Councilmember Stone asked whether the City or Morgan Creek Grill had paid legal fees for
amending their lease; as the Administrator recalled, the restaurant presented the Committee a
proposal crafted by their attorney at their ex pense, the City made a counter offer and the City
attorney created the final document.
Chair Loftus noted that, in FY10, “Miscellaneous” had actual expenses of twenty dollars ($20),
yet twenty-five hundred dollars ($2,500) had been budgeted for FY11 and FY12. He asked
that staff provide information on how the budget was tracking in FY11 in that expense item.
Marina Store
Councilmember Stone asked whether the City paid the water bill for the marina store;
Administrator Tucker replied that the City is required to perform back flow testing on much of
the infrastructure it uses and is confident the expense refers to that work.
Marina Operations
Assistant Dziuban noted that the FY12 budget is the same as the FY11 budget.
Marina Restaurant
The restaurant budget for FY12 is the same as for FY11.
Chair Loftus asked for more information on why a “Miscellaneous” expense of one thousand
dollars ($1,000) exists for the marina and the restaurant.
Marina Waverunner Operation
As presented, no changes exist between the budgets for FY11 and FY12.
Councilmember Stone asked for clarification about total advertising expenses for the marina of
fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000); he suggested that a portion could be the website. The
Councilmember followed up by questioning that the City should expending time and energy
toward the marina website or whether it should fall to the tenant.
Assistant Dziuban commented that the marina website is not separate from the City at this
time, rather it is a page on the City’s website. The marina’s page on the website is more of a
sub-section for visitors than a website maintained and updated by a vendor.
Chair Loftus remarked that the marina would be “smart” to have their own website; he stated
that the more often an entity comes up on search engines the more successful it will be.
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 6 of 7
Chair Loftus took a moment to compliment Administrator Tucker and the staff for the “excellent
job” they have done on the FY12 budget
B. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
Administrator Tucker stated that staff had received a call from a resident after the last meeting
recommending that the City should consider planting palm trees in the median in front of the
Methodist Church and along the Sea Oats’ fence on 41
st Avenue for beautification.
The Administrator commented that the area along the Sea Oats’ fence would be private
property.
Assistant Dziuban stated that she had taken the call and spoken with Chief Buckhannon about
the median in front of the church. The Chief expressed concerns about whether SCDOT would
be amenable to that suggestion; he also thought that palm trees in the median could impair the
line of sight for drivers as they round the curv e. Chair Loftus agreed that they could create a
“blind spot” for drivers.
Councilmember Stone asked whether funds were available in the Tree Fund for Palms at Sea
Oats. The Administrator stated that the City could approach the Sea Oats’ association indica-
ting that the City could provide the trees if they were interested.
Councilmember Stone reported that he had been approached by several residents about the
creating a “NO WAKE ZONE” from the Connector to the end of Waterway Island; he stated
that, at different times of the year, traffic is heavy and moves through that area at full speed,
which he believes has contributed to issues at the marina and at 26
th Avenue. The
Councilmember said he was going to enlist the aid of Senator Campsen, and he would like to
have the City’s support.
Administrator Tucker reported that, in general, NO WAKE ZONES are very controversial with
extremes on both sides of the issue. She not ed that the City’s primary mission should be to
protect its residents and property owners; therefore, if that is what the citizens want, Council
must be responsive to it. On the other hand, the City has mariners who do not live along the
NO WAKE ZONE who would have the opposite position. The Administrator noted that the City
receives complaints about the temporary NO WAKE ZONE every year.
Chair Loftus indicated that he hears as good many complaints about the temporary zone as
well; he said that, personally, he thinks that is too long an area to include in a NO WAKE
ZONE. The Chair stated that he would prefer that things stay as they are.
Next Meeting Date: 8:30 a.m., Thursday, April 7, 2011
8. Executive Session – not necessary
Real Property Committee
March 3, 2011
Page 7 of 7
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to adjourn the meeting at 9:14 a.m.;
Chair Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.