December 2 (PDF, 17.21 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Real Property Committee
Special Meeting
4:00 p.m., Friday, December 2, 2011
Conference Room, City Hall
The Real Property Committee held a Special Meeting at 4:00 p.m. on Friday, December 2, 2011
in the second floor Conference Room of City Ha ll, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Stone, Mayor Cronin and Chair Loftus,
City Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; Jack
Walker of GEL Engineering was also present. A quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Loftus called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of November 2, 2011 as submitted; Councilmember Stone seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Recommendation for Award of Contract to Marcol Dredging for Dredging of the
Isle of Palms Marina
Assistant Dziuban noted that the bid opening for the marina dredging project had been on
Monday, November 28, 2011 at 2 p.m.; three (3) co mpanies submitted bids for the project, and
there was great disparity between them. Jack Walker and Larry Setzler of GEL Engineering
checked the bids for compliance with the terms of the bid and for accuracy in the calculations in
order to make the recommendation on award of the contract. Assistant Dziuban reported that
the City has received only one (1) of the two (2) permits required to commence work on the
project; although staff is optimistic about receiving the Corps of Engineers’ permit by the Special
Council meeting of December 6, any motion for award of a contract should be contingent upon
receipt of the Corps’ permit.
At this time, Jack Walker reviewed the three (3) bids as follows:
1. Con-Mar Ltd, dba Marcol Dredging $ 423,510.00
North Charleston, South Carolina
2. Mobile Dredging and Pumping Company $ 1,566,084.00
Chester, Pennsylvania
3. Orion Dredging Services, LLC $ 1,251,486.90
Tampa, Florida
Mr. Walker pointed out that not only had the per-unit prices been quite different, but the
mobilization and demobilization costs for the out-of-state bidders made a significant difference
in the bids. He also reminded the members of the Committee that the GEL’s estimate for the
project had been between four hundred twenty-five thousand and four hundred forty thousand
dollars ($425,000-440,000). Mr. Walker informed the Committee members that Marcol had one
Special Real Property
December 2, 2011
Page 2 of 4
(1) qualifier in their bid, and it is a guarantee of twenty-eight thousand (28,000) cubic yards of
material to be dredged. Mr. Walker explained that the City will pay Marcol for this quantity of
spoil at a minimum; he commented that he and the City Administrator had done multiple
calculations indicating that, at Marcol’s per unit price, the City still comes out ahead paying for
the guaranteed minimum.
In addition, Mr. Walker indicated that a qualifier for all three (3) contractors was that they “would
dredge to the capabilities of [their] equipment,” which means that the equipment used has
limitations based on the mass of the material being dredged. He stated that the City could
choose to allow a dredger to stay in a particular location and to take smaller cuts to dig deeper
by paying an hourly rate to cut through particularly dense material. He stated that the typical
swipe of a ten to twelve (10-12) inch dredge is about a foot and a half deep, but the cutter head
can be raised to take six (6) inch cuts if necessary to get through dense material. The area
where the City could encounter dense materials is in the Waterway, not Morgan Creek.
Mayor Cronin inquired about how much material the City would be allowed to take to the spoil
site; Mr. Walker responded that the cover letter for the consent agreement states seventeen
thousand (17,000) cubic yards, while the actual agreement states twenty-two thousand
(22,000). With the discrepancy, Mr. Walker called the Corps office in Savannah who told him
that the City can dredge as much as it is willing to pay for; therefore, the City could deliver as
much as twenty-eight thousand (28,000) cubic yards of spoil material. Mr. Walker reminded
members of the Committee that the in-kind charge for the spoil site is one dollar fifty-one cents
($1.51) per cubic yard.
Mr. Walker explained that the calculation of the volume of spoil material delivered to the spoil
site is based on the difference in the hydrogr aphic surveys taken by GEL Engineering a couple
of months ago and the hydrographic survey tak en within fourteen (14) days of project
completion. He reported that they have computer graphics that model the topography of the
bottom before and after the dredging to compute the volume of material removed; these
calculations are very accurate according to Mr. Walker. Based on this data, GEL has calculated
that the dredging will remove approximately twenty-two thousand (22,000) cubic yards of
material. The Corps of Engineers will accept the measurements and calculations from GEL and
will not perform additional hydrographic surveys.
Chair Loftus asked Mr. Walker if the dredging project could exceed twenty-eight thousand
(28,000) cubic yards of spoil material; Mr. Walker responded that he thought it was very
unlikely. The area to be dredged has been surveyed three (3) times in the past five to six (5-6)
years, and the engineers are very familiar with the erosion and secretion cycles that occur there.
Chair Loftus commented that add-ons are typically very expensive; Mr. Walker noted that, in the
apparent low bidder’s proposal, stand-by charges are quoted at three hundred seventy-five
dollars ($375) per hour. Mr. Walker explained that stand-by charges are, for example, if a
medical boat were to have to enter and depart the marina forcing the dredging to cease for a
period of time – these charges come into play for the time spent idling.
Administrator Tucker noted that Marcol is the company that dredged the last time for the City.
Special Real Property
December 2, 2011
Page 3 of 4
Mr. Walker recalled that, when the marina was dredged previously, the dredging did not go
close to the bulkhead because of concerns that it might fail; Marcol is aware that the dredging
will get as close to the bulkhead as it can safely do so. The material closer to the bulkhead is
expected to be denser since it has not been dredged for some time.
Mayor Cronin asked whether the apparent low bidder Marcol could meet the schedule GEL has
prepared; Mr. Walker assured him that Marcol could meet it since they have a plant in town
now.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to recommend to City Council the award of a
contract to dredge the Isle of Palms Marina to Con-Mar Ltd., dba Marcol Dredging,
subject to receipt of the necessary permits, in the amount of $423,510.00; Chair
Loftus seconded.
Chair Loftus asked what would happen if the City has not received the Corps permit by
December 6 when Council is expected to award the contract. Mayor Cronin indicated that
Council would award contingent upon the receipt of the permit; Mr. Walker added that the City
would not issue the Notice to Proceed until the permit is received.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Discussion of Proposals for 1301 Palm Boulevard and City Hall/Public Works
Parking
Administrator Tucker stated that this item was placed on the agenda to acquire a consensus of
agreement from the Committee on the way to proceed with these tasks; she reported that
everything has been done to proceed with the demolition of the building except for issuing the
RFP and awarding a contract. The Administrator voiced her concerns about the eyesore that
will result from the demolition “right in the center of town” and the need for something to be done
immediately to screen Public Works.
In the FY12 budget, funds were included for the reconfiguration of the City Hall parking lot and
for landscaping as well as funds for rehabilitation of 1301 Palm Boulevard. The Administrator
reported that she has discussed with the City’s Department Managers the best way to proceed
to accomplish the goal and cause the least amount of an undesirable visual; the staff agreed
that the first step should be to hire a landscape architect to review the surveys of 1301 Palm
and the ingresses/egresses to Public Works and City Hall to generate the best configurations for
parking, ingress/egress to Public Works, fencing and buffering. Administrator Tucker explained
that this course of action would not delay the demolition of the building; immediately after the
demolition, the installation of temporary chain link fencing will secure the Public Works area and
mask the area from view.
Since the landscape architect would be working at the same time that the RFP and bidding
process are happening for the building demolition, the bidding process for the landscaping could
proceed shortly thereafter in tandem with the budgeted expense of the City Hall landscaping.
The Administrator indicated that, through this process, another goal is to eliminate the ingress to
Public Works from Palm Boulevard, which is a safety hazard.
Special Real Property
December 2, 2011
Page 4 of 4
Administrator Tucker asked the committee for authorization for herself, Director Kerr, Director
Pitts and Assistant Dziuban to select a landscape architect; since the contract should be
approximately four thousand dollars ($4,000) for the landscape architect and the topographic
survey, it would not require Council approval.
In addition, the Administrator reported that the budget is being revised for this entire project to
include the funds identified in the FY12 budget for City Hall landscaping and parking lot reno-
vation and the funds identified for 1301 Palm site renovations to represent one (1) project. Until
the City enters into the bidding process, whether or not sufficient funds have been earmarked is
unknown.
Included in meeting packets were estimates from two (2) landscape architects with whom the
City is familiar and who frequently work on the island. The Administrator noted that these two
(2) people are often called upon to develop plans related to the NPDES stormwater program. In
a side note, Administrator Tucker stated that she particularly liked the work outline and goals of
the work Kelly Messier included with her proposal – they more closely match the tasks the
Administrator expected to be included. The Administrator added that the prices were
comparable, and she thought both persons could do the work to the City’s satisfaction.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to authorize the staff to proceed with
hiring a landscape architect to develop a landscaping and parking renovation plan
for City Hall and 1301 Palm Boulevard; Mayor Cronin seconded.
Chair Loftus stated that one idea from the parking plan was to install a drive-through kiosk,
similar to an ATM, at this location where visitors to the island could purchase parking passes;
he, therefore, was hesitant to see the site rehabilitated outside the scope of the island-wide
parking plan.
Councilmember Stone commented to the value to the City of the economy of scale to be gained
with one (1) larger project over two (2) small projects. He stated that he does not envision a
large paving project that would be problematic to revise at a later date.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 4:35 p.m.;
Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.