October 5 (PDF, 19.03 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
City Hall, 2nd Floor Conference Room
11:00 a.m., Wednesday, October 5, 2011
The regular meeting of the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee was held at 11:00 a.m.
on Wednesday, October 5, 2011 in the 2
nd Floor Conference Room of City Hall, 1207 Palm
Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Malcolm Burgis, Jimmy
Carroll, Sandy Ferencz, Margaret Miller and Chair Jimmy Ward, City Administrator Tucker and
City Clerk Copeland. The absences of Rick Linville and David Nelson were excused; a quorum
was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Ward called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Ms. Miller moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of
July 6, 2011 as submitted; Ms. Ferencz seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Financial Statement – Treasurer Suggs
Treasurer Suggs was absent due to an illness in the family, and Administrator Tucker presented
the reports in her absence. The Administrator pointed out that the schedule that projects the
end of year balance was not included because the Treasurer did not have sufficient time; the
schedule will be forwarded to Committee members when completed.
The first schedule the Administrator addressed was the legal sheet that depicts State Accom-
modations Tax revenues for the past three (3) years; total revenue for FY10 was approximately
six hundred seventy-five thousand seven hundred dollars ($675,700) while revenue for FY11
was approximately seven hundred forty-six thousand dollars ($746,000). Administrator Tucker
commented that FY11 may have been “one of the best performing ATAX fiscal years.”
From the balance sheet, the Administrator reported that the total cash assets are in excess of
one million dollars ($1,000,000) with approximately three hundred fifty-three thousand dollars
($353,000) in BB&T and over six hundred forty-six thousand dollars ($646,000) in the Local
Government Investment Pool (LGIP).
State Accommodations Taxes are paid quarterly; therefore the only revenue year-to-date is from
interest totaling three hundred eighty-six dollars ($386).
Expenditures discussed cover the period July through September 2011, and all are budgeted
expenditures. The larger expenditures were as follows:
Public Restroom Operations $20,737.17
Beach & Front Beach Trash Pickup, Hole fill-ins 37,230.00
July 4
th Fireworks, 2011 12,046.80
Early Payoff-2009 Mack Garbage Truck 48,752.92
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
October 5, 2011
Page 2 of 5
Lease Payment, FD Ladder Truck (25%) 20,528.17
Lease Payment, 2005 Garbage Packer (33.3%) 5,239.93
Lease Payment, Caterpiller (33.3%) 5,519.71
Lease Payment, 2010 FD Pumper Truck (25%) 10,095.77
Two (2) items brought to the Committee’s attention were the Isle of Palms Beach Run, Page 3
of 9, indicating that the event generates money for the City and it had a reclassification from
FY11 of approximately fifty-two hundred dollars ($5,200).
Ms. Ferencz questioned that forty-three percent (43%) of the annual budget for Public Restroom
Operations had been expended in the first quarter of the fiscal year; Administrator Tucker
replied that many expenditures to the City are seasonal in nature and even out as the year
progresses.
MOTION: Ms. Ferencz moved to approve the financial statement as presented;
Mr. Carroll seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. Old Business - None
Chair Ward expressed concern with addressing non-budgeted expenditures without the report
that the Committee typically received indicating the projected year-end balance; he stated that
the ATAX fund showed a “huge” deficit after Council had approved funding fifty percent (50%) of
the design and construction for the Ocean Boulevard parking nodes from ATAX. The
Administrator explained that City Council had put on hold any activity toward implementation,
and the parking issue has been volleyed back to the Planning Commission for more work.
Therefore no plans exist to spend the monies earmarked from ATAX for that purpose, and the
funds will serve to offset the projected deficit. Administrator Tucker remarked that revenues
being higher than expected would also help with the projected deficit.
Chair Ward indicated that he had been studying the year-end fund balance for FY11, which was
in excess of two million six hundred thousand dollars ($2,600,000), but is projected to be down
to one million one hundred thousand dollars ($1,100,000) for year-end FY12. The Chair asked
the Administrator if she should tell him what the projected fund balance for ATAX was for the
end of FY12.
Administrator Tucker again stated that she did not have that information at this time, but she
pointed out that, in the FY12 budget, fifty-three thousand dollars ($53,000) was available to
spend on unidentified projects. The Administrator added that knowing that the parking money is
not going to be spent means it could be added to that figure.
The Administrator informed the Committee that the City had ended FY11 with a surplus in the
General Fund of five hundred seventy-one thousand dollars ($571,000). Administrator Tucker
stated that, historically, things come up throughout the year that can be either under or over
budgeted projections or things anticipated to be done in the year are not done; the City’s
performance is normally to the positive according to the Administrator. The City’s policy of
carrying-over fund balance in tourism is unlike many local governments who spend one hundred
percent (100%) of the tourism funds they receive each year.
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
October 5, 2011
Page 3 of 5
6. New Business
A. 2012 Request for Spoleto Festival USA
Stephenie Steele, grant writer for the festival, was present to answer any questions members of
the Committee might have. Ms. Steele reported that Spoleto had an excellent season in terms
of box office receipts and attendance, but the fe stival is trying to find ways to compensate for
the significant loss of state funding, which appears to be permanent. She explained to the
Committee that typically non-profit, arts organizations get forty to fifty percent (40-50%) of their
funding from ticket sales, and the balance of the operating budget comes from private funding,
corporate sponsorships, and government and foundation funding; in addition, Spoleto has a
substantial endowment. Ms. Steele reported that government support had also decreased
significantly, making continued support from the Isle of Palms very important, and she thanked
the City for its support.
Ms. Steele stated that the City is treated more like a corporate sponsorship to the extent that the
City gets as much exposure as possible on the S poleto website, in email blasts and in printed
materials.
MOTION: Mr. Carroll moved to approve $15,000 for the 2012 Spoleto Festival
USA; Mr. Burgis seconded.
Ms. Ferencz inquired of Ms. Steele the level of support the festival receives from Kiawah and
the City of Charleston ATAX; Ms. Steele responded that the festival has not received support
from Kiawah and gets approximately one hundred twenty thousand dollars ($120,000) from the
City of Charleston. Ms. Steele commented that neither Mount Pleasant nor North Charleston
contribute.
Ms. Steele stated that she sees the Isle of Palms’ participation as a sign of what the City values
in the way of cultural attractions in the area.
During the discussion, Assistant Dziuban brought in the report with the projected year-end
deficit that had been distributed at the July meeting. Administrator Tucker stated that the
projected deficit for the FY11 budget was two hundred seven thousand five hundred sixty-seven
dollars ($207,567), and the actual year-end balance was forty-three thousand five hundred forty-
six dollars ($43,567) “to the good.” Not only were revenues higher than projected, but some
budgeted expenditures were deferred, such as the marina dredging project.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 4 to 1; Chair Ward cast the
opposing vote.
B. Request from Patriots Point Naval and Maritime Museum Foundation
Ron Plunkett, a resident of the island, attended the meeting representing the Patriots Point
Naval and Maritime Museum Foundation, which he stated is totally separate from the Patriots
Point Development Authority, whose members are appointed by the state. The foundation tries
to raise funds in support of the museum. The foundation’s first project was the handicapped
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
October 5, 2011
Page 4 of 5
elevator, which took three to four (3-4) years, and the second project was the Maritime
Education Center located in the bow of the USS Yorktown.
Mr. Plunkett explained that the foundation has hired a St. Louis’ firm to develop a master plan
for the Patriots Point Naval and Maritime Museum; the master plan is focused on the develop-
ment of the museum into a nationally prominent cultural destination. The master plan process
has three (3) phases; Phase One is nearing completion and provides key analysis and strate-
gies that are the basis for Phases Two and Three.
According to Mr. Plunkett, the Foundation is trying to raise a minimum of two hundred twenty-
five thousand dollars ($225,000) to pay for the study; they have raised forty to forty-five percent
(40-45%) of their goal. The Foundation is seeking a one-time donation of ten thousand dollars
($10,000) toward the study. Mount Pleasant has contributed twenty-five thousand dollars
($25,000), and the Foundation is anticipating a like amount from the City of Charleston.
MOTION: Mr. Carroll moved to approve $10,000 for the study to the Patriots
Point Naval and Maritime Museum Foundation; Mr. Burgis seconded.
Ms. Ferencz asked how the ten thousand dollar ($10,000) figure had been determined, and Mr.
Plunkett said it was generally based on population, but the Foundation was not trying to limit the
City’s contribution.
MOTION: Ms. Ferencz moved to approve $15,000 for the study, and Mr. Burgis
seconded.
Mr. Carroll withdrew his motion and Mr. Burgis withdrew his second to the original motion.
Administrator Tucker stated that, if the motion passes at the Committee level, the issue would
go before the Ways and Means Committee and, ultimately, City Council. Preparing Mr. Plunkett
for such an event, the Administrator posed a likely question about how a study would put “heads
in beds” on the Isle of Palms, because the expenditure of ATAX money should correlate to
people coming to stay on the island.
Chair Ward repeated his understanding that the Foundation’s goal was three hundred thousand
dollars ($300,000), that approximately forty percent (40%) of that had been acquired and that
the study could be accomplished with two hundred twenty-five thousand dollars ($225,000). Mr.
Plunkett confirmed that the Chair’s understanding was correct.
Ms. Ferencz expressed a clear understanding of the Administrator’s question, but she
countered that, without a study, there is no action.
Mr. Plunkett stated that the Foundation believes that, if the study can be completed and imple-
mentation started, a world-class exhibit will result drawing people to the area and putting “heads
in beds.”
Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee
October 5, 2011
Page 5 of 5
Administrator Tucker continued that there has been considerable news coverage of the fact that
Patriots Point in behind in its debt payments to the state; therefore, if ATAX funds were to be
spent, would they not be better spent to keep the doors open by contributing to pay off debt.
Mr. Plunkett expressed the belief that, if the plan can be implemented making Patriots Point a
world class destination, paying off the debt and generating future revenue “will take care of
itself.”
Ms. Ferencz encouraged Mr. Plunkett keep in mind when he speaks with the other committees
that, “if you don’t have a plan, you don’t raise money.” She voiced her opinion that an issue with
Patriots Point has been that there was no plan. She added that, although this money may not
put “heads in beds” immediately, it will eventually make the Patriots Point area tie into the
surrounding communities.
Vote: The motion PASSED on a vote of 4 to 1; Chair Ward opposed the motion.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 11:00 a.m., Wednesday, January 4, 2012
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Ms. Miller moved to adjourn the meeting at 11:48 a.m.; Mr. Carroll
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.