March 9 (PDF, 395.6 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
March 9, 2011
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on March 9, 2011 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Bev
Ballow, David Cohen, Ron Denton, Pete Doherty, Diane Oltorik, Noel Scott and Don
Smith; the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present, as well. The press had been
notified of the meeting, and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and the
Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman David Cohen called the meeting to order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The next item on the agenda was the review of the minutes of the February 9, 2011
meeting. Ms. Oltorik explained that during the miscellaneous business discussion, Ms.
Ballow inquired about the appropriateness of the Planning Commission making
recommendations to improve participation in the recycling program in the City. Mr. Kerr
explained that he would add these comments to the minutes. A motion was made and
seconded to approve the minutes as amended and the vote was and unanimous in
favor of the motion.
RECOMMENDATION ON RADIO TOWER ORDINANCE
Mr. Kerr explained that the existing ordinance allows the construction of
communications towers when specific conditions are met. He stated that there were
two sets of criterion, one that allowed staff approval of towers up to one-hundred feet
(100’) and a second that allow the Board of Zoning Appeals to grant a Special
Exception for a tower up to one-hundred and sixty feet (160’) tall. He explained that
ordinance being considered would add new provisions that would allow the construction
of a tower for public service uses for governmental purposes up to two-hundred feet
(200’) in height. He added that these provisions would be added to the section that
could be approved by the Zoning Administrator.
Mr. Kerr explained that the City Council had been working with Charleston County on
radio reception issues and it appeared that a possible solution to the issues would
include a taller tower at the 41
st Avenue cellular tower site. He explained that
representatives from the tower owner, Crown Castle, were present to answer technical
questions regarding the site.
Ms. Oltorik explained that she had been aware of the problems with the public safety
radio system for several years and she felt that this change was necessary to improve
their system.
Planning Commission minutes
March 9, 2011
Page 2
Mr. Denton explained that he would like to know if the problems with the public safety
communications system could be fixed with a tower lower than 200 feet. Mr. Keith
Powell, with Crown Castle, addressed the Commission and explained that while there
were several different alternatives to improve radio transmission, the taller tower at the
site on 41
st Avenue appeared to be the most desirable.
Mr. Cohen explained that he was concerned about the tower being able to be approved
at the staff level and asked why it was not under the Board of Zoning Appeals section.
He added that he was also concerned that subsection (11)(c) would allow a commercial
entity to partner with any governmental agency and get approval for new towers up to
two-hundred feet (200’) in height.
Mr. Kerr explained that he did not believe that changing the approval process to the
Board of Zoning Appeals would add much protection. He stated that if the Board of
Zoning Appeals found that a 200-foot tall tower for the City at the 41
st Avenue site met
the criteria spelled out in the ordinance, he did not see how the Board could defend not
approving the identical tower for a different governmental agency.
Mr. Jonathan Yates, attorney for Crown Castle, arrived and explained that he had
helped draft the City’s original communications tower ordinance and he had worked on
this amendment with the City Attorney. He explained that they drafted the ordinance to
allow two-hundred foot (200’) tall towers only for public service uses and only for
governmental agencies.
Mr. Kerr explained to Mr. Yates that the Commission has expressed concern about the
fact that any governmental agency could get a tower approved and then any
commercial carriers would be allowed to collocate on the tower. He asked if it would be
acceptable to narrow the list of governmental agencies to include only the City and the
County. Mr. Yates answered, yes, that he thought that would be reasonable.
Mr. Doherty made a motion to recommend the approval of the ordinance, with the
condition that the list of governmental agencies that would be allowed to construct a
two- hundred foot (200’) tall tower be limited to the City of Isle of Palms and Charleston
County. The motion was seconded and the vote was unanimous in favor of the motion.
DISCUSSION OF PARKING MANAGEMENT PROGRAM AND PUBLIC FORUM
Mr. Cohen explained that the City held a forum recently and he asked for general
discussion from the Commission about their impressions of the forum.
Mr. Scott addressed the Commission and read a recap of what speakers at the forum
advocated (see attached “Exhibit 1” for details). Mr. Scott explained that he supported a
Planning Commission minutes
March 9, 2011
Page 3
plan for limiting the amount of public parking to the amount required to comply with
OCRM’s guidelines for beach management plans to qualify as having beaches with “full
and complete public access”. He explained that he believed that these guidelines could
be met by establishing three or four parking spots at each beach access path and
making all other areas of the island unavailable to visitor’s parking.
He added that he believed that it was critical that the plan be extremely simple to
execute and administer. He showed an example of an honor box for taking payment to
park and stated that he believed a beach services officer could monitor the areas of
visitor parking and enforce the requirement that they pay to park.
He handed out aerial photographs of many of the beach accesses that he had overlaid
with a sketch to show possible parking areas.
He added that he thought there was merit in the ideas of providing parking for golf carts
and bikes, providing shuttle buses or trolleys to redistribute visitors, and opening up
parking on Ocean Boulevard.
Ms. Oltorik distributed a written analysis of the public speakers’ comments/e-mails and
a written proposal to accommodate beach visitor parking (see attached “Exhibit 2” for
details).
She explained that she supported the idea of limiting visitor parking to parallel spaces
on the ocean side of Palm Boulevard and Ocean Boulevard from the commercial district
to 6
th Avenue. She added that she believed that this would have the effect of more
evenly distributing the beach traffic throughout the island and that she believed that the
number of spaces available to the public would generally be equal to what is being
currently used. She explained that she thought that theses areas were more correctly
characterized for beach visitors and that this approach was in keeping with the City’s
Comprehensive Plan.
She also explained that she believed that the public parking lots in the commercial area
could be modified to accommodate approximately one-hundred (100) more vehicles,
which she thought should be done.
She stated that she thought that it was reasonable to require beach visitors to pay to
park.
She stated that she believed that this approach would have the effect of keeping beach
visitors out of the neighborhoods and still provide ample opportunity for visitors to have
access to the beach.
Planning Commission minutes
March 9, 2011
Page 4
Ms. Ballow distributed her thoughts on the information gathered so far (see attached
“Exhibit 3” for details). She stated that in the short term, she believed that the City
should continue to pursue the installation of signs at the intersections, as they have
already been doing. She stated that in addition to these signs, the City should clarify
and unify the signs prohibiting parking closer than four feet from the pavement on Palm
Boulevard. She stated that the existing signs were unclear and sometimes conflicting.
She added that she felt that additional parking enforcement in these areas could
improve things.
She stated that she liked the idea of limiting parking to the ocean side of Palm
Boulevard and maybe ultimately moving the roadway away from the ocean to allow
more space to park on the ocean side of the roadway.
She explained that she supported the idea of smaller parking lots, where feasible and
she supported the idea of charging to park during the tourist season at peak hours (9
a.m. to 6 p.m.), just as the front beach area is currently regulated.
She also supported the general idea of not reducing the number of spaces currently
used by the public, but spreading them out to different areas of the beach.
Mr. Pete Doherty explained that he had summarized the e-mails following the public
forum and he had taken an inventory of what areas were available to visitor’s parking
and identified their characteristics in terms of when they were available, how much it
cost to use the areas and other criteria (see attached “Exhibit 4” for details).
He added that he believed improved signage could help, including the typical blue
parking signs to direct traffic to appropriate areas. He added that he supported the
concept of opening up Ocean Boulevard to parking.
He explained that he supported the idea of a payment structure to park that supported
car pooling. He explained that this provision could follow the concept of the HOV lanes,
where cars with multiple passengers received a benefit, which in this situation could be
a reduced parking charge.
He added that he felt that regardless of the direction that the Planning Commission
chooses, he believed that it was very important to come up with a fully detailed plan of
how the new parking system would work.
Mr. David Cohen explained that he saw potential conflict with many of the ideas that
have been expressed and the City’s Beach Management Plan. He quoted a section of
the plan that reflected a City goal of providing open access to the public and he
Planning Commission minutes
March 9, 2011
Page 5
questioned whether a plan of reducing the spaces that were available supported that
stated goal.
He explained that he thought an online reservation system could be used to give visitors
a parking pass to a certain area. He explained that this would minimize the amount of
searching visitors have to do, as their reservation would have a clear area designated
for them. And it would allow for the City to spread the parking areas out as they
determined was appropriate. He also thought that the City had to answer the question
of what does a visitor get when they pay to park that they do not get now and he
thought that an online reservation service provided the visitor with a service that they
are not currently given, a guaranteed area to park.
Mr. Don Smith handed out his written ideas about the goals in revising the parking on
the island (see attached “Exhibit 5” for details). He explained that he felt that the City
had an obligation to provide adequate and affordable parking to beach visitors. He
explained that he felt that the Commission should support ideas that minimized the
potential for accidents and injuries due to the expected increase in traffic and he thought
that the Commission should look for ways to minimize the impact beach traffic had on
the neighborhoods within the City.
He explained that he supported the idea of allowing parking only on the ocean side of
Palm Boulevard and Ocean Boulevard and in the commercial district. He explained that
this configuration allowed visitors to walk directly to the beach without crossing roads
while keeping the traffic out of the areas of many of the neighborhoods. He added that
he felt that this approach would comply with the standards outlined by OCRM for a
Beach Management Plan.
He stated that he thought that the City should only pursue the removal of obstructions in
situations where the demand in the area required removal.
The group generally discussed some of the ideas presented. They agreed that there
appeared to be agreement on the ideas of limiting parking to the ocean sides of Palm
Boulevard and Ocean Boulevard. They also agreed that there appeared to be
agreement that charging a fee to beach visitors seemed to be reasonable.
Mr. Smith asked what the next steps would be for the Commission. Mr. Kerr answered
that he thought that the group needed to agree on the concepts they wanted to pursue
and then present those concepts to City Council to see if there would be general
support. He added that if the Planning Commission and the City Council appear to be
aligned in a general direction, he thought the next step would be to get input from the
public on the ideas.
Planning Commission minutes
March 9, 2011
Page 6
Mr. Doherty stated that he felt it would be beneficial for Mr. Kerr to create an e-mail of
bullet points that he felt that the Commission were generally in agreement with to
canvass the Commission members with to see if where there is consensus. The group
generally agreed and Mr. Kerr explained that he would do this.
MISCELLANEOUS BUSINESS
Ms. Oltorik explained that she had a scheduling conflict with the next date and asked if
the member would consider moving the meeting up one week to April 6
th at 4:30. The
group agreed to make this schedule change.
The Commission asked that at the next meeting Mr. Kerr bring a projector so that they
can look at aerial images of the areas used for parking. Mr. Kerr stated that he would
do this.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7:10 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
David Cohen, Chairman.
Parking for the People
Please note:
The following is not necessarily the views of Noel Scott but of a collection of quotations and
more of an attempt to address concerns of the speakers and e-mailers from the Isle of Palms
parking forum.
Dick Watson, former commission member and retired attorney so eloquently said "Mr. Mayor,
members of City Council, members of the Planning Commission, You were not elected and you
were not sworn to look out for the interest of the rest of the State of South Carolina. Your job
is to look out for the interest of the residents of the Isle of Palms."
Starting with Jim Owens who we all know does not want parking on Palm, then to Guy Taylor
who said "If you decide to have parking on Ocean Boulevard Street, look at Palm Boulevard
down there" indicating Palm's problems and back to Dick Watson who said "Please don't
continue letting the rest of the State of South Carolina use our residential streets as a parking
lot" and then Danny Austin agreed with Dick. Eddie Brown then said "I want to say me to"
referring to former speakers. Jay leigh said "I agree with 85 to 90 % of what everybody else has
said". Donald lauseng said IIparking in our yards has got to go". Rosalie at 3405 Palm asked
"Would you like to live in a parking lot?" Jimmy Carroll wants to ('make it more attractive for
people to go to the front beach and park", Rolf Gobian said IICould not agree more with what
the other people said". Bobby Simmons said "I do like the idea of people parking more in the
commercial district'( and John Crouch said "I think the commercial district needs to be enforced
as the heart of the town". Jim Edwards said III think that if the Planning Commission and we as
citizens of the lOP work together we can provide a solution that will respect the property rights
of all of us."
The above citizen(s comments indicate that, for the most part( the speakers at the parking
forum want to either limit parking on Palm or have no parking at all on Palm. The City of the Isle
of Palms, however( has an obligation to maintain full and complete access to the beach as a
requirement of the Beach Front Management Program and can not deviate from the required
parking access.
Mary Ann luttrell indicated that smaller designated pay parking areas for maybe 10 cars would
be in order. Guy Taylor also spoke of parking at the beach access rights of way. Danny Austin
spoke of providing six or seven spaces. Eddie Brown said IIwe should put in angled parking on
EXHIBIT 1
the accesses going to the beach" and John Walters said "1 like what people said about smaller
lots" .
To accommodate both the Beach Front Management Program and the above speakers, there
are 53 equally spaced beach access points from 57TH Avenue to Breach Inlet which would not
show bias to anyone resident. Also there is easy access on the inland side again not showing
bias to anyone resident. The minimum number of designated spaces at these beach access
points would ultimately be determined by the City's Beachfront Management engineer, Chris
Jones to assure full but minimum compliance of the Beach Front Management Act. The forum
speakers have indicated they would like intrusive street parking kept to a minimum. Guy Taylor
indicated he would like to see more handicap parking and Jay Leigh would like to see golf cart
parking. Golf cart, handicap and bicycle parking would be convent in the areas shown in the
pass out, would allow direct access from the avenues and would accommodate the inland lOP
residents to beach access.
To alleviate Bea Love's fears of visitors infiltrating the inland neighborhoods and to eliminate
Mark Tidwell and Carolina Boulevard's parking problems, an island wide parking by permit only
(other than designated pay spaces) would be implemented.
Eddie Brown says to provide parking and pay for it. Jay Leigh said "pay for parking is not a bad
thing". Jimmy Carroll also agrees with pay parking and making Palm parking premium parking.
Mark Tidwell said "Everyone should have access but I'm sorry, it's not free"
If pay parking is to be implemented at the beach access points and put in place in the next two
years, the process must be kept as simple as possible. Daily, weekly or annual passes will
require expensive administrative costs and if passes are provided and a space is not available it
would also provide angry visitors. As Eddie Brown indicated, when the designated spaces are
full, the spaces are full. A first come, first serve basis has no administrative cost. Small honor
boxes as shown in the passout for designated spaces can be attached to the existing beach
access sign posts and screened with shrubbery again keeping things simple with one city
employee picking up the money and writing tickets.
If we are to accommodate Bobby Simmons, Jimmy Carroll, Eddie Brown and others in funneling
traffic into the commercial areas where the existing lots are rarely at full capacity, John Adams
says a shuttle or trolley running from the City and County lots up and down Palm and Ocean
would redistribute the beach goers to less crowded beach areas when street parking is not
available.
If a parking program is to be implemented in the next two years the financial aspects as well as
the physical parking space obstructions and the intrusions to property owners must be kept at a
EXHIBIT 1
minimum. Other phases of the program could include bike and pedestrian lanes, landscaping,
restrooms and other improvements.
EXHIBIT 1
~__._----~..
blD'J
C(}ItV\ V'" ~',
March 9, 2011 PC M~ _-.,
To: Planning; Commission mem;ers and Zoning Administrator /)
From: Diane Oltorik . ,< _._ _._._--~
Subj, I. My lDUl1ysis ofpublie forum speak commentsi"".l ~. rJ, ,fi" AJ f2..' ~/LJ ~ -;J'f
2. My proposal for solution for day-tripper parking ~~ - .
EXHIBIT 2
I - Paid Parking A. 1) good idea: 9; 2) Bad idea: 3;
II - Where to Have Paid Parking
A. Open up ocean side of Ocean, but only where sidewalks start (6th): 2; not at all: 2;
B. Palm Blvd: 1) ocean side: 1; 2) creek side: 0 ; 3) neither side: I;
C. Business district only: 1) current lots: 6; 2) parking garage: 3;
D. Buy a pit:ce of property and make a new pkg lot with trash and rest room facilities: 5;
III - Residential concerns for Quality of Life in General 6',
A. Visitors don't care: 3; visitors do care: 2;
B. Keep parking out of residential streets: 1) all the avenues: 5; 2) also Hartnett, Cameron, Chstn,
Carolina (plusPalm 10cean): 5
C. Free parking passes for residents and guests; 4;
D. Signage: 1) better & understandable: 5; 2) enforcement: 2;
E. Use shuttles: 1) various stops: 1 2) business district only: 0;
IV - How to Pay
A. Kiosks: I) good idea: 0 2) bad idea: 5;
B. Virtual only: 1;
C. Charge marc un street than lots: 2;
V - State requirements
A. We can conu'ol and manage: 1;
B. State rights of way control: 2;
VI - Safety concerns
A. Pedestrian injury: 5;
B. Room for city vehicles and emergency vehicles: 1;
C. Widen Palm Blvd: 1;
VII - Golf Can and Bike Parking - Where: 2;
VIII - Bike Lanes and/or Walking Paths:
A. 1) good idea; 1; 2) bad idea: 4;
IX - Obstructions: A. Take them down: 2; B. Build more of them: I;
X - More handicap spuces: 2;
/ }Jt.L it.lJ) V(j
£ /J7f})l-
EXHIBIT 2
TALKING POINTS - PC MEETING WEONESOA Y MARCH 9 - RE PUBLIC FORUM OF 2/23
1. parking only on Ocean side of Palm Blv~parallel
(a) what creek side residents look out their front door to vs. what ocean side residents look out their front
door to.
(b) residential character of Palm Blvd. Waterway side has 30% registered voters plus second horne
owners plus non-registered voter owners
© current # of blocks with most vehicles on high season weekends on creek side is from 2200 to 31st
(excludes ftrst block due to Lutheran Retreat Center> and on ocean side from, 21st to 31st
approximately 130 vehicles on creek side.
approximately 32 vehicles on ocean side
2. Assuming a loss of the ability for 130 vehicles to park on creek side in the most popular blocks would be
partly compensated for by epening up ocean side ofOcean Blvd from 6th ave.. (the beginning of the
sidewalk) up to Windjanuner"""This area of about 7 blocks, given the same parameters as above, could
accommodate about 23 vehicles.
3. Theeity lots and the county lot together could accommodate about 100 additional vehicles.!
4. Further, assumme.a pay to park pl~I believe ultimately vehicles would park further down Palm Blvd,
thus creating the "scale" or "spread ourphilosophy some public forum speakers talked about, thereby
compensating further for loss of parking on waterway side.
cause there is an asphalt
:r:::::::r.:~=-=:':'r.!""='=':=;~
6. Thq ocean side of Palm and the ocean side of Ocean ~e more correctly characterized as the tourist
access to our public beach, and ftt the philosophy of our Comprehensive Plan.
7. It would be asking for trouble to severely limit or altogether prohibit parking on Palm and/or Ocean. It
would have the effect of thumbing our noses at SCOOT. We believe that SC regs give us the right to
''regulate'' traffic in our municipality, and regulation means "control by rule, principle, or system", but lets
not ask for trouble.
8. I believe the overall effect of all of the above would be to reduce day visitor parking, keep day visitor
vehicles out of our neighborhoods, and provide ample opportunity for our visitors, thereby protecting the
quality of life for our citizens and being welcoming to our day visitors. This would be a good thing!
EXHIBIT 2
A. Langtenn best ideas gle_. from the m eef'lIg and c6ersaun:es :
1. .....- Palm BIwlID ..ftDIIh (VI '''1 side) 8 feet. And ... no parUtg on that side7
at aI.. Just it side.aIk and a bike paIh if Ie I I 1*(if ••)..
That WOI.Id give mom for a bike paIh ... "alking on the beec:b side. Requile aI
bellctlSiide psIdng to be perpa""'"(nose in) Thus no doors open tf.M.ds traIIc inc. bike
traftic... (later even - take contJoI over rigI'It&-oJ-way •
2.. Add smalliats where feasiNe. such as 1he post oIice property, the beadl co.·S 1riangIe'
and oIher areas they' and the ely may (MJL
3. Chm'ge for parking oIher than Jibe lots on Palm and Ocean. Daily passes bought at
local feIai1 ou8els C9M'them a cui) and the kiosks on front beach. addling a few at the PO lot
and R&W etc. Also make a seasonal and .. annual pass available1hrough City Hal and the
PWbktg.
THE PERMITTED PARKING HOURS SHOUlD BE RESTRICTED FROM , 9AM TO 6 PM, and
from May 1 thru OCtober (someIJWrg).
B. Middle period best ideas
1. Issue·residentiat paOOng permits for up to .. cars per resideldial full time addIess. (These
people Icars/ can park anywhere legal any time) ... (Not the same as a hurricane pass as that
aIows business owners and their employees back on). In season you have a party? Inform the
police dept. and you gel permitted. And install-no parking without. residential pennit" signs in
neighborhoods.
2. Check with any possibility of expanding the city'slots. EiIher be re-configuratio or actually
adding a second story.
C. THINGS V\E CAN AND SHOULD 00 NOW
1. Finish placing the signs15' from intersection from the cornetS. Everywhere. starting with
OCean and Palm and working back as time permits.
2 Most importantly replace aSh Palm B signs (and elsewhere) that say eiIher No Parking 4 ft
from pawment or No Parking Wthin .. ft from pavement. to read
NO paI1Qng closer than 4 feet from road.
Or words that make even f1lOfl! sense.
Increase police stIeet parking enforcement. ( I KNOW I see illegal cars ever; wee.tend day and
more on Palm without tickets orpolice presence. The comment '"whimsical" enfOicement may
not be totally accurate or fair but it is close. Suggest Cf:u1ciI discuss a safety study, and see if
the speed on Palm can be restricted to 25 mph for certain hours in season.
EXHIBIT 3
pol
Hen! .e some thoughts on less atlladive ideas:
1) ShuIIIe bus. Perhaps Carta can mme up willi a partneIShip idea to teny riders either from a
part( 8td ride smp in Mount Pleasant OR along Palm and OCean - a few designated stops IF
we reach M agteementto ban ALL parking cbing high season and times on Palm and OCean.
Only aIowiIlg paOOng on the lots. current and future). •
2) Pwchase empty lots 1hat exist on 0cJean. and Palm. I do not see this as a financial possibility.
If we do need to spend money which we of course wiD. Iwould want to see the Palm Blvd
road -.noved"' and bike path ereded.
3) IF lt1ete were fminHots"'. haw can you do resbooms? Porta-poIties. maybe. allDlher expense
that po ssibly can be cowred wiIh parting fees. but that is a pretty ugly thought - they smeU and
are an eyesore. On the other hand a bunch of parked cars is an eyesore..
4) Requiring property ownens to remove R.O.W. obstructions arJ'f time in the near fuIure. There
are some dId1es that might be dosed on Palm. (they aren't active for drainage anyway) and
same owvgrown R.'sO.W. in front d vacant lots that perhaps the city could dear to the tot fines.
- (everyllde bit hetps even if irs a drop in the bucket, like opening Ocean would be).
5) Reducing the number of parking spots on Patm. This would have to be arbitJary and
ittbitsic:4y not fair. Fnt and foA!most we have to be fair to a8 parties. and primarily to the
resident property owners.
6) Just the institution of pay10 part wiR do nothing for the tniIffic safety issue if we do nothing
else. If that is what we do. it wit put a lie to the idea that our primary interest is safely.
Finaly. we need to conlrol publicity better. to insure that 1) lhefads get out. and 2) that the
pubic gels informed and educated Ie what the city is doing..
Bev
EXHIBIT 3
--------
--
lOP PLANNING COMMISSION
PARKING MANAGEMENT - PARKING LOTS LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
BEACH ACCESS PARKING WHEN SPACES COST PROS CONS
Avenues & Streets 365 In use Neighborhood & control$
.1-
Breach Inlet 365 $ In use
City Hall WE x Available Control
City lot - large 365 $ 5.00
-~-- -
In use none
City lot - small In use365 $ 5.00 none
City lot next to post office X Available Not prepared
County Park lot
-- $
365 $ 7.00 In use none
Front Beach - behind shops -_. 365 $ 5.00 In use none
Front Beach - kiosks 365
$1.00jhr In use none
Lot next to Pelican Cleaners X Usable Not prepared$
f-- --t--
Lot next to Red & White grocery X Usable Not prepared$
Lot on 4th street (7) X 7$ 7
Ocean Blvd. 0 Usable Obstructions$
Palm Blvd. 365 In use Safety & control$
------ +---~---
Post Office S Permission needed Usable$
Recreation center 7 $ Available Other weekend activities
L __
EXHIBIT 4
lOP PLANNING COMMISSION
PARKING MANAGEMENT • PUBLIC COMMENTS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10I
11
12
13;
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
COMMENTS
NAME RESIDE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 6
Anthony Wescott Ml. P No pay to park on Palm Blvd Never seen trash, urinating, changing Allow street parking Outer Banks no pay to park Parking $ just for revenue Safety not an issue Enforcement
Danny Austin lOP Set terms &conditions for visitors Look at Hilton Head restrictions Pay to park Parking @beach access Add more lots Acquire green space Enforcement Trash!
Donald H. Lauseng lOP Keep neighborhoods private Publis lots only Speeding
Eddie Brown lOP Designated parking areas, lots Stop visitors when all spaces are full 2nd level parking No parking on blvd, st, etc. Must pay for services Safety is an issue Enforcement Trashl
Janice Wages Ml.P Not pay to park
Jay Leigh lOP No additional pay to park Seasonal pass More signage Golf carts &bikes
Jimmy Carroll lOP High $ for day parking on streets Funnel visitors to Front Beach area Lower $ in lots Good beach access
John Q. Adams #1 lOP Ocean Blvd? Park on Palm @41st + No kiosks Property value Parking lots only Clarity of authority Park &Ride Need PR
John Q. Adams #2 lOP Island shuttle bus Handicap, senior, low income parking 2level parking No charge after 6 pm Beach Co. parking lots Enforcement
Lucinda Olasov #1 lOP More cones at crosswalks No paid parking on blvds More signage Public lots only
Mark Lindsay lOP Park &ride No street parking
Mary Ann Luttrell lOP Endgame? More small lots Pay to park All spaces full; stop! No street parking 4th street lot (?) Enforcement Trash!
Paul Drennen CHS? No pay to park on Palm Blvd Enforcement; parking &trash
Pearse Fitzpatrick Ml.P Keep rules to a minimum Don't have surf only; swim only areas Enforcement No pay to park on blvds Enforce set backs
Scott Morris lOP No parallel parking on Palm Blvd Pay for permit parking only Safety first
Susan Craig off island Foremost is quality of life Mini bus system from parking lots Pay to park Use traffic experts
~ -
m
><
~
-
OJ
=4 .a:.
GOALS IN REVISING DAY VISITOR PARKING ON lOP
• Provide ADEQUATE and AFFORDABLE parking for day visitors
• Minimize potential for injuries and accidents due to the significant increase in the number of
cars and pedestrians
• Minimize the impact on lOP neighborhoods
• Meet the parking requirements of the Beach Management Plan (BMP)
ONE POSSIBLE APPROACH
Allow parking for day visitors ONLY in the county lot, the city lots and on the ocean side of Palm
and Ocean Avenues
Remove incursions into the state right-of-way on a measured basis to add parking spaces as the
demand for beach parking increases over time
ADVANTAGES OF THIS APPROACH
• Visitors walk directly to the beach passing only one row of island houses
• Visitors do not need to cross any island roads
• No day visitor parking on any inland residential streets
• Visitors parking in lots and on Ocean Avenue are close to downtown businesses
• Meets the parking requirements of the BMP
EXHIBIT 5
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.