October 12 (PDF, 12.88 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE ISLE OF PALMS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
October 12, 2011
The Isle of Palms Planning Commission met in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207
Palm Boulevard on October 12, 2011 at 4:30 p.m. Members attending included Bev
Ballow, David Cohen, Ron Denton, Pete Doherty, Diane Oltorik, Noel Scott and Don
Smith; the Director of Planning Douglas Kerr was present, as well. The press had been
notified of the meeting, and the agenda for the meeting was posted in City Hall and the
Building Department to comply with the Freedom of Information Act.
Chairman David Cohen called the meeting to order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The next item on the agenda was the review of the minutes of the September 14, 2011
meeting. Ms. Oltorik made a motion to approve the minutes and Mr. Scott seconded
the motion.
Mr. Denton explained that the first paragraph on page 3, regarding Ms. Oltorik’s
comments were not accurate and he stated that he had no issue with the comments
being deleted. Mr. Smith made a motion to delete the paragraph in question. The
motion seconded and approved by unanimous vote. Mr. Cohen called for a vote on the
original motion and the vote was unanimous in favor of approving the amended
minutes.
DISCUSSION OF PARKING MANAGEMENT
Mr. Cohen started by stating that comments are circulating among citizens about the
direction of the Planning Commission. He clarified that everything that has happened
so far was just discussion and the group had not formulated a recommendation.
Mr. Kerr explained that he had included a copy of the request for qualifications that was
submitted to City Council for the purposes of hiring a consultant to assist with parking.
He explained that he felt that this document did a good job of summarizing the issues
and laying out an expectation of what a final work product could be which will be helpful
to the Planning Commission as they work through the process.
He explained that also in the packet were the comments from City Council members at
their Ways and Means meeting, which included good comments on their expectations of
how the Planning Commission might address the issues of parking. He stated that
Council members had expressed an interest in seeing several different scenarios, as
opposed to just one recommendation, which he thought would be useful. He added that
interest Council had expressed an interest in a series of meetings focused on individual
areas, as opposed to larger public hearing meetings.
Planning Commission minutes
October 12, 2011
Page 2
The group discussed the idea of having a series less formal meetings focusing on
different areas.
Mr. Denton presented the Commission with a method of quantifying the concerns
related to parking. He handed out a matrix and explained that this could be used as a
tool to evaluate what the Planning Commission’s objectives are in addressing parking
and assign priorities to the objectives. The exercise would include identifying the
objectives and then each Commissioner putting a numeric priority of each objective and
then tallying the individual priorities to come up with a number that represents the
overall priorities of the Commission. An additional step would be to then compare each
identified solution and grade how well that solution addresses the identified priorities.
The final product of this exercise would be a grade for each solution, which would be
useful in making recommendations to City Council.
Mr. Denton also presented a series of maps that showed the various parking scenarios
on the island. The first series of maps showed the number of spaces included in the
current Beach Management Plan for the City. The next series of maps showed the
absolute minimum number of spaces that would comply with OCRM’s minimum
standards for a Beach Management Plan. The final series of maps showed areas where
parking is consistently problematic, in his opinion.
The group expressed their appreciation for all of the work Mr. Denton had done and
agreed that the maps would be extremely useful going forward. The group discussed
the matrix and how that might be used in the future to help prioritize. Mr. Kerr explained
that he had distributed a short list of objectives and identified alternatives and the tools
described by Mr. Denton could be used to expand that list.
Mr. Kerr explained that since the last Planning Commission meeting, the managers of
the City staff had met and held a similar exercise to the one conducted by the Planning
Commission of identifying all alternatives and then narrowing down the list to all of the
alternatives that are worthy of future consideration. He explained that two lists, the
Planning Commissions alternatives and the staff’s alternatives, had a lot of similarities,
but that there were also some ideas that the Commission had not yet explored.
He went through the list of all ideas that the staff had strong agreement as viable
alternatives and he noted that a new idea was to use some type of electronic, real-time
notifications to give beach visitors information about the likelihood of easily finding
space. He stated that this could be done with an electronic road sign or the internet
(like Twitter or similar services). It could be similar to the highway signs that relay
messages like: “from this point to a parking area expect a one hour delay”.
Planning Commission minutes
October 12, 2011
Page 3
He also noted that the staff agreed that additional study would be useful. He added that
the staff believed that keeping things similar to how they currently, with only minor
modifications should be considered, which was contrary to the Commission’s position.
The group agreed that they had been presented with a lot of information and that at a
future meeting the group would discuss points individually and decide whether or not to
add new concepts to the existing list of concepts being considered.
Mr. Scott expressed an interest in moving this process forward with input from the
public. The group generally discussed how to move forward. Mr. Smith expressed his
opinion that he liked the idea of a series of smaller, less formal meetings to focus on the
three different areas identified by the Planning Commission. Mr. Scott expressed
concerns about trying to divide the issue into different areas, because all of the parking
issues are interrelated. After some discussion on the issue, the group agreed that it
would be beneficial to have a series of smaller meetings at locations outside of the
typical meeting sites.
Administrator Tucker explained that she thought that it would be more useful to have
focus group meetings as opposed to traditional public forum meetings. She explained
that the staff hears comments from residents who are not interested in talking at public
meetings, either because of time constraints or intimidation; and she feels that the
Commission would hear more from these residents at a focus group meeting. She
added that this approach would hopefully minimize the feeling that residents have that
ideas are being sprung on them, because they would have been more involved in the
process. The group generally agreed with the concept, but expressed concerns about
how to identify who should be a member of the group.
After discussing various meeting options, the group agreed to hold a series of three
drop-in events at various venues around the community to solicit input from the
residents. Each meeting would be focused on a particular area of the City and would
hopefully have residents from that area, but all meetings would be open to anyone who
would like to attend. The dates that were tentatively identified were November 9
th,
November 30th and December 14th. The time for each meeting was set for 5:30p.m. to
8:00p.m.. Mr. Kerr explained that he would develop a handout for the meetings and
displays for the rooms to spur conversation.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7:10 p.m.
Respectfully submitted, David Cohen, Chairman.
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.