Special Meeting, February 1 (PDF, 25.91 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING
5:45 p.m., Monday, February 1, 2010
A Special Meeting of City Council was held at 5:45 p.m. on Monday, February 1, 2010 in
Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus, Piening,
Stone and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, City Attorney Halversen, Assistant
to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. There was a quorum present to conduct
business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Presentation by Greg Fender of Local Government Services regarding City’s
Options related to Cable Television Franchise
Mayor Cronin announced that Greg Fender of Local Government Services was present to
inform the City Council about the requirement from the State of South Carolina that the City
consent to the franchise agreement it has negotiated with Comcast Cable; he noted that the City
has sixty-five (65) days in which to pass an ordinance either consenting to or refusing the
agreement.
Mayor Cronin reviewed Mr. Fender’s credentials as having worked with the Georgia Municipal
Association for many years where he became their expert on the Georgia franchise laws,
particularly cable franchise; he has also worked with the states of South Carolina, Mississippi,
Arkansas and Texas as they negotiated franchise agreements. Using his twenty plus (20+)
years’ experience, Mr. Fender has also worked with seventy-five (75) municipal authorities in
South Carolina as they work through the franchise process.
Administrator Tucker explained that the City had received the certified letter from the Secretary
of State on December 23, 2009 – just as the City was closing for the holiday season. After the
new year, she began her research about the letter – what it meant and what the City should do;
she also worked with City Attorney Halversen, who had researched the new South Carolina law.
Mr. Fender stated that he intended to review the following areas related to franchise and
franchise fees:
• Changes with franchising authority for local governments in South Carolina;
• Background and history on what has occurred across the United States that has
impacted South Carolina legislation;
• Information on the background on franchise fees and compensation for the use of public
rights-of-way by private companies; and
• Information on the City’s rights under the South Carolina cable act.
Mr. Fender began his comments by stating that, “historically, franchising rights for cities have
always been vested in federal law.” Before 1984, cable companies were of the opinion that they
were at the mercy of the cities for obtaining a franchise renewal; they had no expectation of
continuing to operate. On the other hand, during the 1970s, there was the advent of the
Special City Council Meeting
February 1, 2010
Page 2 of 6
specialty channels, such as ESPN, HBO, C-Span, etc, that made cable more desirable to the
populace as these channels were seen an adding to quality of life. Because Congress was
requesting that the cable companies make more of an investment to the nation’s infrastructure,
the cable companies wanted more assurance that their franchise agreements would be
approved. The result was the 1984 Cable Act that established a process for local governments
and cable companies to follow in terms of negotiating franchise renewals; under this law, a
cable operator must submit its request for renewal three (3) years in advance of the expiration
date so that negotiations can begin. Before 1984, the maximum that a cable company would
pay for use of the right-of-way was three percent (3%) of gross revenue; cities lobbied that the
value of the rights-of-way had increased and the law was amended to allow for a maximum of
five percent (5%) of gross. Subsequent to that act, the cable companies decided to pass that
franchise fee along to the customer, creating the impression that the local governments were
imposing a tax on the consumer. Mr. Fender argued that the majority of cable users across the
United States do pay the full five percent (5%) franchise fee and that all cable companies create
their budgets anticipating a five percent (5%) franchise fee.
The 1992 Cable Act revamped parts of the 1984 Act; this act enabled local governments to
regulate cable television rates and mandated that cable companies had to itemize their bills; as
a result, some consumers learned that they were paying for services they had not ordered. In
addition, the cable companies were allowed to identify, through the itemization, the municipal
franchising authority for the first time.
Subsequent to a landmark federal case, known as the Dallas versus the FCC case, the Fifth
Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that franchise fees were not a tax but a rent for the use of a right-
of-way. If the cable company passes that cost of rent on the right-of-way on to the consumer
and collects that rental income, the cable company must include the franchise fee collected in
the total company revenue then apply the five percent (5%) to that revenue total for payment to
the governing entity. The Federal government stat ed that, unless the City specifically excludes
the franchise fee from the calculation of gross revenue, it must be included.
In September 2005, Texas was the first state to eliminate the cities’ rights to franchise video
services because the cable industry had developed a voice-over internet protocol, and the cable
company had only to go to the state public service utilities commission to be certified to provide
telephone services. AT&T and Verizon lobbied that, since the cable industry was invading the
telephone industry, they wanted to be allowed to offer video services but not be forced to
negotiate individual franchise agreements with each governmental entity. AT&T and Verizon
prevailed, allowing them to negotiate franchise agreements with the state.
South Carolina passed a similar law in May 2006 that states, when a local franchise agreement
expires, the incumbent operator goes to the Secretary of State’s office to re-apply for the
franchise. In South Carolina, cities have a constitutional right to the franchising authority; the
cable company must seek the governmental entity’s permission or authorization for the
application submitted to the Secretary of State authorizing the cable company to obtain a
franchise with the state. The law stipulates passage of an ordinance with two (2) readings in a
sixty-five (65) day period of time.
Special City Council Meeting
February 1, 2010
Page 3 of 6
The application asks the following three (3) questions:
• What is the franchise fee? If the entity does not respond, the franchise fee
automatically goes down to two percent (2%).
• How many PEG channels does the entity currently have? (PEG channels are public
education and government access channels.)
• Does the entity approve of the application? If an entity does not approve, it must
have a valid reason for doing so.
Mr. Fender reflected that one (1) decision before City Council was on the approval of the
franchise agreement between the State of South Carolina and Comcast Cable. He stated that
he was an advocate for local governments charging the full value for the use of their rights-of-
way, which, in this case, is five percent (5%).
Mr. Fender reported that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) figures from 2008
indicate that thirty-two percent (32%) of American households use satellite dishes for television
while sixty-eight (68%) have cable television. A key point to remember is that satellite providers
do not use rights-of-way, but they do pay the federal government “huge” licensing fees.
Mr. Fender repeated that City Council was not imposing the fee on the citizens, but was
imposing the fee on the company for the use of the public right-of-way. He added that, in
coastal communities, it is difficult to calculate the franchise fees based on population because of
the seasonal fluctuations; should the City increase its franchise fee to the five percent (5%)
maximum, the increased revenue would be approximately fifty-two thousand dollars ($52,000)
annually. One important fact to remember about franchise fees is that they are returned to the
community for use by the community for its citizens.
Concluding, Mr. Fender suggested that the Council look at the issue nationally since Comcast is
present in almost every major city in the country; he indicated that, in the Comcast budget
process, they are building into their pricing the assumption of a five percent (5%) franchise fee.
When any community has a lower franchise fee, they are helping Comcast with their profit
margins. He reported that all seventy-five (75) governmental entities he has worked with have
increased their franchise fee to five percent (5%). Mr. Fender added that increasing City
revenues in this manner lessens the City’s reliance on property tax revenues.
Mayor Cronin thanked Mr. Fender for his time to educate the Council on this subject and added
that the local municipalities – Charleston, Edisto, Mount Pleasant, Goose Creek - with whom Mr.
Fender has worked, have approved a franchise fee of five percent (5%).
The Mayor noted that the budget for Franchise Fee revenue for the current budget year is
seventy-eight thousand dollars ($78,000) and that, last year, the City collected seventy-eight
thousand two hundred forty-five dollars ($78,245). He reported that there has been a growing
trend over recent years for the consumer to bu y more services from the cable companies, and
the cable rates are continually rising.
Councilmember Loftus asked Mr. Fender if the City could ask other cable vendors to service the
island to create competition. Mr. Fender responded that any vendor could enter the market at
any time, but it is not financially viable for multiple vendors to be in a small market due to the
Special City Council Meeting
February 1, 2010
Page 4 of 6
costs involved. He noted that, under the new law, the local governments could no longer grant
or negotiate franchises; if another cable company wanted to enter this market, it must apply to
the Secretary of State.
Councilmember Loftus suggested, hypothetically, that, if he had a one hundred dollar ($100)
cable bill and the franchise fee was three percent (3%), his total bill should be one hundred
three dollars ($103.00), but, if the franchise fee were five percent (5%), the total bill would be
one hundred five dollars ($105.00). Mr. Fender said that the bill could increase, but it was also
possible that Comcast would not pass along the full five percent (5%) to the consumer due to a
recent price increase.
Councilmember Loftus asked, if the Council chose not to increase the fee now, could it increase
the fee next year, and Mr. Fender said that it could increase at any time with passage of an
ordinance and notification to the Secretary of State.
Councilmember Stone asked if he were correct that there is no term attached to the state
agreement; Mr. Fender said the Councilmember was correct.
3. First Reading, by title only, of Ordinance 2010-03 – An Ordinance Granting
Consent to Application for Franchise for Cable Service and Setting Franchise Fee.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve Ordinance 2010-03 for
First Reading by title only; Councilmember Betttelli seconded.
Councilmember Stone repeated that the City Council was to approve the state’s franchise
agreement and to establish the Isle if Palms franchise rate. He looked to the City Administrator
for confirmation that the City was currently imposing a three percent (3%) fee; she agreed and
added that the maximum rate was five percent (5%). Councilmember Stone expressed his lack
of support for an increase to five percent (5%) because he did think it was a tax and he did not
see the need.
AMENDMENT: Councilmember Loftus moved to amend Ordinance 2010-03
to keep the franchise fee at three percent (3%); Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded.
Councilmember Bettelli called into question amending the ordinance when the primary motion
had stated that the ordinance would be approved “by title only.” After conferring with the City
Attorney, Mayor Cronin asked that all motions be withdrawn; Councilmember Loftus withdrew
the amendment and Councilmember Stone withdrew the primary motion.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve Ordinance 2010-03 for
First Reading and to maintain the franchise fee at three percent (3%);
Councilmember Buckhannon seconded.
Councilmember Buckhannon repeated and concurred with Councilmember Stone’s stance that
the franchise fee is a tax.
Special City Council Meeting
February 1, 2010
Page 5 of 6
Councilmember Piening expressed his opinion that the cable companies were going to charge
what they were going to charge whether the franchise fee is three percent (3%) or five percent
(5%); he added that the City should get the full value for its citizens.
Councilmember Duffy argued that the City was the people and the City did not need the money.
Mayor Cronin countered that the City’s costs, to a large extent, were people, and those costs
increase one or two percent (1-2%) every year causing the City to constantly be in need of new
revenue sources. He expressed his support to increase the franchise fee to be consistent with
the greater Charleston area.
Councilmember Loftus cited the many island residents on fixed incomes, the economic
recession and the recently reported SCE&G rate increase as reasons not to increase the
franchise fee.
Call for the Question: The motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to 2; Mayor Cronin
and Councilmember Piening cast the negative votes.
4. Personnel Committee Recommendation: Reclassify the position of Assistant Fire
Chief to that of Fire Inspector and approval of the job description.
Administrator Tucker reported that this was an action that has passed through both the Public
Safety and Personnel Committees that takes the position of Assistant Fire Chief, which is
already budgeted in the Fire Department, and changes that job classification and job description
to that of Fire Inspector. Chief Graham has believed that the Department would benefit from
having one (1) person licensed and assigned the responsibility for the inspections; other fire
personnel would accompany the inspector to increase frequency in the buildings and to get
training. Presently all inspections are being done under Chief Graham’s license. Having one
(1) person performing fire inspections would provide a consistency that has been lacking with
multiple persons doing the inspections. There is no cost change for this change, only a
reallocation of budgeted funds.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to approve the reclassification
of the position of Assistant Fire Chief to that of Fire Inspector and to approve the
job description; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Duffy expressed concern with the fact that there is inconsistency in the
inspections; he opined that inconsistency indicated a lack of procedures or a lack of
documentation and sharing of procedures.
Chief Graham stated that there were good procedures in place, but there were too many people
doing the job; she noted that the Department follows the state codes and Fire Marshall
recommendations. She noted that there are four (4) members of the Department who are
qualified to perform fire inspections at this time, and other personnel are always being trained.
Special Council Meeting
February 1, 2010
Page 6 of 6
In response to Councilmember Stone’s question about the Assistant Chief position, Chief
Graham replied that the position was not needed because she was seldom away from the
island, and there was a chain of command established in the Department in her absence.
Call for the Question: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
5. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:02 p.m.;
Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.