Special Meeting, February 8 (PDF, 20.53 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SPECIAL MEETING OF CITY COUNCIL
5:30 p.m., Monday, February 8, 2010
A Special Meeting of City Council was held at 5:30 p.m., Monday, February 8, 2010 in Council
Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Is le of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the
meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy, Loftus, Piening, Stone
and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tu cker, City Attorney Halversen, Planning and
Building Director Kerr, Planning Commission Chair Denton, Assistant to the Administrator
Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. There was a quorum present to conduct business.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Second Reading of Ordinance 2010-03 – An Ordinance Granting Consent to
Application for Franchise for Cable Service and Setting Franchise Fee.
At Mayor Cronin’s request, Administrator Tucker informed the audience that Council’s action
tonight was in response to a change in state law regarding cable franchise agreements. In the
past, individual municipalities have negotiated franchise agreements with cable providers; under
the new law, the state negotiates the agreement and the local municipalities set the franchise
fee up to a maximum of five percent (5%). The franchise fee represents the rent the
municipality charges the cable provider for the us e of the City’s rights-of-way; at a previous
meeting, Council had first reading on an amended ordinance granting consent to the state to
negotiate cable franchise agreements and leaving the franchise fee for the Isle of Palms at three
percent (3%).
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to waive the reading and to approve
Second Reading of Ordinance 2010-03 – An Ordinance Granting Consent to
Application for Franchise for Cable Service and Setting Franchise Fee;
Councilmember Duffy seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 7 to 2 with
Councilmember Piening and Mayor Cronin cast the dissenting votes.
3. Consideration of Planning Committee Recommendations for new Zoning Districts
and Associated Requirements for Each
Mayor Cronin invited Building Director Kerr to the podium to present the Planning Committee
recommendations.
Director Kerr stated that tonight’s presentation was a conceptual plan developed by the
Planning Commission after several years’ consideration of issues referred to it by the City
Council. Should the Council decide there is merit in the concept, before implementation, there
would be a considerable amount of Administrative time in legal drafting, the creation of new
maps, advertising and postings, public hearings and several readings before City Council.
The Director explained that the Planning Commission has spent considerable time discussing
the issues of maximum house size, requirements for floor-to-area minimums, rental occupancy
and, specifically, from a joint Council – Planning Commission workshop held in the fall,
establishing new occupancy limits of twelve (12) persons for new rental units. He noted that the
Commission has consistently been unable to find a “one size fits all” solution to the entire island.
Special City Council Meeting
February 8, 2010
Page 2 of 5
Director Kerr noted that, outside of Wild Dunes, the existing zoning code is structured so that
the zoning criteria are identical, with only small differences, like setbacks; the primary
differences are the minimum lot size to create new lots, which occurs most infrequently. In all
zoning districts on the island the floor-to-area ra tio, occupancy limits and lot coverage limits are
identical; it was these similar criteria that the planning Commission saw as obstacles when
looking at the lots on Forest Trail versus the lots on Ocean Boulevard.
The Planning Commission did not concur with the Council’s proposal that occupancy for all
rental units be limited to twelve (12) persons and, instead, has developed a zoning strategy
intended to mirror the way the island has “naturally developed.” In general the first row, or
oceanfront, consists of large lots with large houses and has a high percentage of rental units.
The second and third rows are among the smallest lots on the island and have been under a lot
of pressure for development in the past ten (10) years. The lots that are one thousand feet or
more (1,000+ ft.) from the ocean, generally, are larger, have smaller homes and have a higher
percentage of fulltime residents. The proposed scheme follows this pattern and establishes it
into requirements that will maintain the pattern into the future.
Director Kerr noted that two (2) residential zoning districts are presently on the island, SR1 and
SR2; SR1 is, by and large, the oceanfront and waterway while SR2 is the smaller lots in the
middle of the island.
The Planning Commission’s proposal has three (3) districts defined as follows:
1. Ocean District – Oceanfront properties and Waterway Island;
2. 2
nd Row District – Properties that are less than one thousand feet (1,000 ft) from
the ocean, but not oceanfront; and
3. Waterway District – all other properties.
Specific recommendations for each district include the following;
1. Ocean District – Maximum house size – 7,000 sq. ft.
Floor-to-area ratio – 40%
Lot coverage – 40%
Maximum occupancy – 2/bedroom + 2, or 1/250 sq. ft.; 24 max
(currently there is no maximum occupancy)
2. 2
nd Row District – Maximum house size – 5,000 sq. ft
Floor-to-area ratio – 40%
Lot coverage – 40%
Maximum occupancy – 2/bedroom + 2 or 1/250 sq. ft.; 16 max
3. Waterway District – Maximum house size – 5,000 sq. ft.
Floor-to-area ratio – 35%
Lot coverage – 30%
Maximum occupancy – 2/bedroom, 1/250 sq. ft.; or 12 max
The changes are primarily in the proposed Waterway District because the majority of fulltime
residents live in this area of the island, and the Planning Commission thought that, with the
larger lots, the area was open to large development the way the ordinance now reads,
therefore, in need of limits.
Special City Council Meeting
February 8, 2010
Page 3 of 5
Director Kerr concluded his prepared comments stating that he and the City Administrator had
agreed that the Planning Commission needed input and feedback from City Council prior to
investing time and money into legal drafts and new maps, hence, this meeting.
In response to comments from Mayor Cronin, Director Kerr stated that there would also be three
(3) ordinances presented to Council at the February meeting related to the workshop in the fall;
the ordinances concern rooftop decks, maximum occupancy and lot vegetation.
Mayor Cronin thanked the Planning Commission for the time and thought that had gone into the
zoning proposal presented tonight and opened the floor to questions from Councilmembers.
Responding to Councilmember Bettelli’s query, Ron Denton, Chair of the Planning Commission,
stated that Waterway Island was included in the Ocean District because of the size lots and not
because it was considered to be a large rental area. He indicated that to put Waterway Island
into one of the other districts would immediately put the homes into non-compliance.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to reject the proposed zoning scheme;
Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Councilmember Thomas expressed his opinion that the proposal should be rejected because he
had understood from attending a previous meeting that Council requested the Planning
Commission to develop a vision of the island as a family-oriented, residential community and
that allowing twenty-four (24) persons in a house went against that vision.
Councilmember Duffy read into the minutes the Vision Statement from the City’s
Comprehensive Plan as follows:
Isle of Palms has developed into a premier barrier island residential community with a variety of
housing styles, commercial uses and recreational fac ilities. Despite the extensive development of
the island, the natural resources that make Isle of Palms such a wonderful place to live and visit
remain intact and in good conditi on. Measures that will enhanc e the existing character of the
island as a quality place to live, and protect th e environment both on and around the island, must
be taken to guide development and preserve the quality of life for generations to come.
He continued his comments stating that, in his opinion, the Planning Commission’s proposal did
not build a residential island and that the argument that the proposed scheme followed the
pattern of natural development was baseless. Councilmember Duffy stated that he wanted to
know more about the data analyzed by the Planning Commission for it to decide to eliminate the
SR1 zoning district. As Chair of the Public Works Committee, he referred to the drainage
problems on the island and the fact that drainage was impacted by development as was the
entire infrastructure of the island, but the impact on the infrastructure has not been discussed.
Councilmember Bergwerf stated that she lived in an area with a depth of six (6) homes that,
according to the proposed zoning scheme, would fall into of three (3) zoning districts; in her
opinion, the scheme was too complicated and would not control growth.
Special City Council Meeting
February 8, 2010
Page 4 of 5
Councilmember Loftus asked for the Director to detail the re-zoning process and the expense to
the City to accomplish it. Director Kerr stated that he estimated the cost to be approximately
one thousand dollars ($1,000) before legal expenses; signage could be handled in one of two
ways – three (3) very large signs on major thoroughfares alerting the public to the changes at a
cost of two hundred fifty dollars ($250.00) each or sixty to seventy (60-70) little signs, costing six
dollars each ($6.00/ea) that would delineate each time someone goes from one district into
another. In addition to the signs, there would be advertising expense of approximately four
hundred dollars ($400.00) and the legal expense to draft the ordinances; new maps would be
generated by the Council of Governments (COG) at no cost to the City.
Mayor Cronin voiced concern that there would be unintended consequences created in the 2
nd
Row District that would contain lots that are now both in the SR1 and SR2 zoning districts based
on minimum lot size. He also thought it would be extremely controversial to begin re-zoning the
core of the island and that the same basic results could be attained through other means.
Councilmember Piening thanked the Planning Commission for the work they had put into this
re-zoning proposal, but stated that he could not support it because he did not think it supported
his view of the Isle of Palms as a residential community. He reflected on the fact that the people
who had elected him wanted their personal property rights protected and would not think that
was happening if a structure advertising an occupancy of sixteen (16), but housing twenty (20),
were built next door.
Councilmember Bettelli echoed his thanks to the Planning Commission, but expressed his
dislike for these wholesale changes. He voiced agreement with the Mayor that the desired
results could be reached in another manner. In addition, Councilmember Bettelli noted that very
few septic tank permits were being issued as a result of changes in testing; therefore, he
thought the capacity of the City’s sewage system should be considered.
After thanking the Planning Commission for their efforts, Councilmember Loftus reflected on the
fact that his first foray into City government had been on the Planning Commission when there
were twelve hundred ten (1,210) rental units on the island and today there are seventeen
hundred nine (1,709) rental licenses. He referenced the Comprehensive Plan as it discusses
rental units that fit into neighborhoods; he voiced the opinion that this proposal violated the
Comprehensive Plan in terms of neighborhood capacity. He stated that he was an advocate of
growing residents not rentals.
Councilmember Buckhannon remarked that this was not the first time that the Planning
Commission had come before the City Council with a proposal only to be “shot down;” he
opined that there needed to be more collaboration between the City Council and the Planning
Commission.
Call for the Question: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Bergwerf commented that the message had clearly been sent to the Planning
Commission about what the island’s residents want and there was no need for more meetings.
Special City Council Meeting
February 8, 2010
Page 5 of 5
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to limit all new rental licenses
issued by the Isle of Palms to a maximum occupancy of ten (10) persons; to
“grandfather in” the occupancy limits of all existing rental licenses as long as the
license is kept current, but, if the license lapses, the new occupancy regulations
would apply; and, to apply for a rental license, the applicant must have a
Certificate of Occupancy at the time of the application; Councilmember Loftus
seconded.
Councilmember Bettelli called a point of order that this item was not on the agenda; therefore, a
vote could not be taken.
Councilmember Duffy countered that, since the new zoning scheme had addressed changing
occupancy maximums, the motion did fall within the parameters of the agenda. Mayor Cronin
asked if Councilmember Duffy were implying that this motion fell within the Planning
Commission’s recommendations as stated on the agenda.
Responding to the Mayor’s request for counsel, Attorney Halversen stated that there would be
no problem with discussing the issues, but a motion on such a detail should be on an agenda
for a future meeting.
Mayor Cronin stated that Councilmember Bergwerf’s motion would be worded for inclusion in
the February Council meeting.
4. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:55
p.m.; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted;
Marie B. Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.