Regular Meeting, June 22 (PDF, 68.59 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City Council Meeting
7:00 p.m., Tuesday, June 22, 2010
The regular meeting of the City Council was held at 7:00 p.m., Tuesday, June 22, 2010, in the
Palmetto Room at the Recreation Center, 24 Twenty-eighth Avenue, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Present for the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon, Duffy,
Loftus, Piening, Stone and Thomas, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, Assistant City
Attorney McCullough, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
Following a brief invocation, the Mayor led the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance, and the
City Clerk called the roll.
2. Approval of Previous Meetings’ Minutes:
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the Public
Hearing and the regular meeting of May 25, 2010 as submitted; Councilmember
Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizen’s Comments - None
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to re-order the AGENDA to address Item
9 at this point in the meeting to allow Howard Chapman, CARTA Executive
Director, who was attending tonight’s meeting, to get to another meeting;
Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
9. Introduction of New Bills, Resolutions and Proclamations
Resolution to Approve and Support FY11 CARTA Budget
Mayor Cronin asked Administrator Tucker to read the resolution into the minutes of the meeting;
a copy of the resolution is attached to the historical record of the meeting. The Administrator
noted that the word “amended” was picked up inadver tently from a previous year’s version of
the resolution; the budget being approved tonight was not an amended budget. A copy of the
corrected proclamation is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the amended
proclamation as read; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Mayor Cronin confirmed that ridership had exceeded four million in 2009, and, year-to-date
2010, ridership is up nine percent (9%) over 2009.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Reports from Standing Committees
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 2 of 9
A. Ways and Means Committee
In Mayor Cronin’s absence, Vice Chair Duffy had chaired the meeting of June 15, 2010; he,
therefore, gave the June Committee report. Councilmember Duffy conveyed Treasurer Suggs’
preliminary evaluation of the City’s year-end financial position as one with a potential surplus of
three hundred to four hundred thousand dollars ($300,000-400,000) and commented to the fact
that the anticipated year-end surplus was indicative of the fact that the City’s money was well
managed. Councilmember Duffy noted that tourism revenues were trending better than the
fifteen percent (15%) decline estimated for the FY10 budget year. Councilmember Duffy
announced that the City had been awarded sixty-eight thousand dollars ($68,000) for Sparrow
Drive drainage, one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for the 52
nd-57th Avenue Drainage
Project and an additional twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) in carryover funding for the Lauden
Street drainage by the Charleston County Transportation Commission.
1. Approval of an Amendment of the Civil Site Environmental Contract in the
amount of $33,880 for the expanded scope of design and engineering for
the 52
nd-57th Avenues Drainage Project.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to approve the amendment to the Civil
Site Environmental Contract in the amount of $33,880; Councilmember Bettelli
seconded.
Councilmember Stone asked whether the cost would come from the FY10 budget; Mayor
Cronin responded that the expense would be paid from the reserves the City has set aside for
the project.
Administrator Tucker thanked the City’s residents who had approached City Council about the
feasibility of expanding the scope of the project, which will result in more efficient drainage for all
of the area being addressed.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
2. Award of a contract to Bobcat in the amount of $42,708.76 for 4 budgeted
ATVs (3 for the Fire Department and 1 for the Police Department).
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to approve the contract award in the
amount of $42,708.76 to Bobcat for 4 ATVs; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Approval for the purchase of Victim Advocate’s camera and a portion of
the accessories in the amount of $1,727.67 from the FY10 budget.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to approve the purchase of the
purchase of the Victim Advocate’s camera and a portion of the accessories in the
amount of $1,727.76 from the FY10 budget; Councilmember Bettelli seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 3 of 9
The next Ways and Means Committee meeting will be at 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, July 20, 2010.
B. Public Safety Committee
From the meeting of June 9, 2010, Councilmember Bettelli reported that representatives of
Motorola, Crown Castle and Charleston County had attended the meeting to discuss again the
proposed two hundred thirty (230) foot tower to be erected on the island. The City Administrator
and the members of the Committee made it clear that such a tower was not wanted on the Isle
of Palms and that they should again review t he problems and the possible resolution with an
antenna on the Mount Pleasant side of the Connector; they agreed to do additional research
and come before the Committee at a later date with the results. Some problems from the punch
list continue to be handled at the Public Safety Building; the plumbing problem that will require
digging through the floor in the lobby area will be scheduled now that the Disaster Preparedness
Expo has been held. On the request from Sea Cabins to expand the lifeguarded area of the
beach to south of the pier, the Committee chose to take no action. The Committee approved
the purchase of the four (4) ATVs and the Victims Advocate’s camera and a portion of the
accessories from the FY10 budget. A discussion was held regarding traffic enforcement on 21
st
Avenue; Chief Buckhannon was asked to request the placement of additional 25 mph signs on
21
st Avenue and to step up enforcement of speeding on that street. The Committee provided its
input for the CTC funding requests and concurred with the Public Works Committee that the
projects should be the 52
nd-57th Avenue Drainage Project, improvements to and expansion of
the 21st Avenue handicapped parking area and paving Ca ssina Drive. Councilmember Loftus
had suggested adding language to the CTC request stating the City’s need and support for the
widening of the IOP Connector to four (4) lanes to US Highway 17.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to send a letter supporting
improvements to SC 517 between the IOP Connector bridge and US Highway 17 to
the proper governing authorities; Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Mayor Cronin commented that getting people safely off the island was an important issue at all
times, not just on holidays and in the event of evacuation from a storm. The Mayor noted that
he had spoken with the Mayor and City Administrator for Mount Pleasant on this subject in the
past, but they had many other road projects that were not funded that took priority and that,
through this letter, the City could demonstrate the urgency it feels in tackling this project.
Councilmember Loftus updated City Council on discussions he had with Charleston County
Councilmembers Joe McKeown and Dickie Schweers to highlight the importance of this issue;
he urged members of Council to keep the subject before the decision-makers.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Committee also discussed the need for preparations should oil from the Gulf of Mexico oil
spill round Florida and make its way to the East coast beaches. Administrator Tucker related
discussion she had been in communication with the US Coast Guard and her hope that a
meeting would take place in the coming weeks with the public safety, mayors, administrators
and managers of the coastal communities and officials from DHEC and the Coast Guard.
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 4 of 9
Following the monthly reports from the Fire and Police Departments, Councilmember Bettelli
stated that the request had been made by residents on the south end of the island for the
annual July 4
th parade.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the request for the annual
4th of July parade for residents; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The next meeting of the Public Safety Commit tee will be at 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, July 13 in
Council Chambers.
In conjunction with the discussion of additional 25 mph signs on 21 st Avenue, Councilmember
Duffy asked if the Public Safety Committee could investigate having 25 mph established as the
speed on the island except for streets where an alternate speed limit is posted; Councilmember
Bettelli agreed to do that.
C. Public Works Committee
At the June 2 meeting, the focus of discussion was the 52
nd to 57 th Avenues Drainage Project;
Dave Stevens of Civil Site Environmental was present and reviewed the results of his study on
the feasibility of expanding the scope of the project. The basin being drained has increased by
two-thirds ( ⅔), but the outflow is better with the re-design and areas will dry quicker than with
the original design. According to the Director’s report, quantities of garbage declined again in
May, but the Director has not pinpointed the reasons why. The annual trimming of the palm
trees along Palm Boulevard is currently happening.
The next meeting of the Public Works Committ ee will be at 2 p.m. on Wednesday, July 7, 2010
in Council Chambers.
D. Recreation Committee
Councilmember Buckhannon noted that the Committee had not met in June, but the next
meeting will be at 4 p.m. on Wednesday, July 7. AJ Basketball Camp and Camp Summershine
were keeping the Recreation Center a hub of entertainment and activities.
Mayor Cronin thanked Director Page and her team for setting up the “mock” Council Chambers
for this meeting.
E. Personnel Committee
Councilmember Piening stated that the Personnel Committee had not met in June and that the
next meeting would be at 5:45 p.m. on Tuesday, July 6, in Council Chambers. The May Safety
Sweepstakes winners were announced as follows:
Recreation Department – Nick Bako Fire Department – Bill Pesature
Public Works – Willie Powell Police Department – Kraig Thompson
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 5 of 9
F. Real Property Committee
Councilmember Loftus stated that, at the June 3 meeting, Marina Manager Berrigan stated that
business had finally turned around having experienc ed a very strong May. A successful month
was also reported for Morgan Creek Grill. At this time, all of the original agreement signers in
the beach restoration project have responded to the amendment to the original agreement to
allow the City to go forward with actions to ease the areas of focused erosion on the north end
of the island; the City anticipates the work taking place before turtle season in 2011.
Councilmember Loftus reported that discussions are ongoing regarding the dredging of the
marina. The next meeting is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. on Friday, July 9.
5. Reports from City Officers, Boards and Commissions
A. Board of Zoning Appeals – no June meeting
B. Planning Commission – minutes attached
6. Reports from Special of Joint Committees - None
7. Petitions Received, Referred or Disposed of - None
8. Bills Already in Possession of Council
A. Second Reading of Ordinance 2010-08 – An Ordinance Amending Title 5,
Planning and Development, Chapter 4, Zoning, Article 9, Short-Term
Rentals, Section 5-4-202, Maximum Overnight Occupancy Permitted at
Short-Term Rental Residences Constructed, Altered or Reconstructed After
the Adoption of this Ordinance.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to waive the reading and to approve
for Second Reading Ordinance 2010-08; Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Councilmember Duffy stated his understanding as the intent of the ordinance being to ensure
that existing rental license holders should maintain that license going forward as a part of this
ordinance as was stated in the original version of the ordinance.
MOTION: Councilmember Duffy moved to amend Section 5-4-202(a) to add the
words “and maintains going forward” following the date of June 22, 2010.
Mayor Cronin asked Director Kerr to address Councilmember Duffy’s proposed amendment,
and Director Kerr recounted that the first version of this ordinance did include such a provision
stating that the ability of a homeowner to keep his/her overnight occupancy above twelve (12)
persons was hinged on holding a current license at the date of ratification of Ordinance 2010-
08. The first version of the ordinance also had a companion ordinance defining the changes
necessary to the business license code relative to the short-term rental licenses. The second
version of overnight occupancy maximum did away with that provision and the date of
construction became the determining factor. The subsequent Planning Commission changes
tried to achieve a balance between the previous two (2) amendments, and, according to the
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 6 of 9
Planning Director, their intention was omit the requirement for maintaining a business license
because of the complications it entailed. Director Kerr stated that the intention of the Planning
Commission “was to take a snapshot of what the license status is as of tonight . . , so that if a
rental property allowed their (rental) license to lapse or if they went into foreclosure and it lapsed
or it was sold, that would be immaterial and they could go back to the high rental level.”
Director Kerr added that, if Council intended to put that language back into the amendment, the
companion ordinance must be reintroduced to define when the term “lapse” as it relates to
rental licenses.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked if Council could vote on the ordinance as is at this meeting, and
reintroduce and vote on the business license amendment as a separate issue. Director Kerr
stated, “The technical reading of the ordinance is that the licenses actually expire in eight (8)
days [June 30, 2010} . . . there is a caveat that says you have until September 1 to renew it
without penalty.” This type situation is what the companion ordinance clarified.
Mayor Cronin suggested that the ordinance have Second Reading tonight as the ordinance is
currently written and, at a later date, amend it and bring the companion ordinance back for
consideration.
Councilmember Duffy withdrew his amendment.
Councilmember Stone expressed his opposition to the ordinance for “numerous” reasons
beginning with his opinion that the number twelve (12) is arbitrary and the ordinance does not
take into consideration of the historic development of the community. Councilmember Stone
stated that he understood the intent of the ordinance “to stop the development of high density
rental properties, but (he) also saw it as a punishment to vacant lot owners.” Councilmember
Stone expressed the opinion that the ordinance represented an erosion in property rights, and
he stated that he did not understand factually what the need for the ordinance was since two
hundred (200) instances of noise violations were reported annually – with some percentage of
these infractions being attributable to residents. According to Councilmember Stone, of the
seventy-four (74) homes with a square footage exceeding five thousand (5,000) square feet
built in the last couple of years, only sixteen (16) are short-term rental residences.
Councilmember Stone described the passage of this ordinance as a knee-jerk reaction to a
perceived problem.
Councilmember Loftus expressed surprise at Councilmember Stone’s description of a “knee-jerk
reaction” when the City has been wrestling with short-term rental issues for six or seven (6 or 7)
years. Councilmember Loftus voiced his opinion that the focus should be on whether Isle of
Palms is a residential or rental community. Co uncilmember Loftus said that the time has come
to protect the individual neighborhoods and homeowners.
Councilmember Piening related that he had received a couple of e-mails following recent
meetings where the writers express shock that he was supporting this ordinance; he
commented that this was the single issue upon which he based his campaign when he ran for
City Council. Councilmember Piening said that he ran on the issue of mini-hotels because he
was “sick and tired of the cancer that they are putting into our residential community;” he also
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 7 of 9
wanted the record to reflect that he had no financial interest in the question. He then quoted
from a letter sent to all members of Council from an island resident as follows:
“Large parties at neighboring rentals, late-night parties, swimming pools shrieking
voices, outdoor speakers, excessive traffic and karaoke machines have been a true
invasion of our space.”
Councilmember Piening commented that Council has been told multiple times that few police
reports cite noise issues and the Livability Court cases indicate no real problem. Councilman
Piening continued by stating that many island residents are reluctant to call the police, but will
tell him that they voted for him to take care of the problem without their having to call the police.
In conclusion, he stated that the people who make the island their home have property rights
also.
Councilmember Duffy explained that capping the overnight occupancy in new rental
construction at twelve (12) people was a number that many people who live in the single-family
residential neighborhoods believe to be too high. He stated that there were two (2) purposes
associated with single-family residential di stricts, i.e. “(1) to discourage unwarranted
encroachment by prohibiting commercial uses and to prohibit other uses which would interfere
with the development or continuation of single family use and (2) to encourage the cessation of
non-confirming uses.” Councilmember Duffy ex pressed confidence that everyone present
would agree that short-term rentals are a commercial activity. Continuing, Councilmember
Duffy stated that the number twelve (12) was “a compromise resulting from the analysis of the
make-up of the island’s residents that show that ninety-three percent (93%) of the island’s thirty-
two hundred eighty three (3,283) residences – no condominiums, but single-family residential
homes – are five (5) bedrooms or less.” Therefore, in his opinion, the island has developed in
that fashion, which he believes supports the computation of two (2) people per bedroom plus
two (2) people or twelve (12) persons total. Another contributing factor to the maximum number
of twelve (12) persons is the idea that the Isle of Palms is a family-oriented island where the
family is defined as two (2) parents with two (2 ) kids; the number twelve (12) accommodates
that nicely with the grandparents with their two (2) children’s families of four (4) each and a
friend for the grandchildren. Councilmember Duffy concluded his comments by stating, “A vote
against this ordinance was a vote for mini-hotels.”
Councilmember Bettelli expressed offense at C ouncilmember Duffy’s thinking for him as he
related a conversation with another grandfather recently who was “thrilled that his family was
going to have a family reunion on the Isle of Pa lms and that they were going to have seventeen
(17) people.” Councilmember Bettelli voiced his support for the Livability Court and the job that
it is doing, but he also expressed his feeling sorry for those residents who were reluctant to call
the police who are on the island to protect them whether they are being robbed of their
possessions or robbed of their peaceful life. Councilmember Bettelli agreed with
Councilmember Stone that this ordinance was unnecessary and that the number twelve (12)
was arbitrary because no study had been done to support it.
Councilwoman Bergwerf supported Councilmember Duffy and the positions he had voiced.
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that the very large rental units would continue to be on
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 8 of 9
the island to accommodate family reunions. In Councilmember Bergwerf’s opinion,
development was the issue, not livability, because the City did not have the infrastructure to
support the demands of several thousand homes with seven or eight (7 or 8) bedrooms. The
Councilmember stated, “going forward, this (ordinance) gives reasonable, rational control.”
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 6 to 3 with Councilmembers
Bettelli, Buckhannon and Stone dissenting.
B. Second Reading of Ordinance 2010-09 – An Ordinance to Raise Revenue
and Adopt a Budget for the City of Isle of Palms, South Carolina, for the
Fiscal Year Beginning July 1, 2010 and Ending June 30, 2011.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to waive the reading of and to adopt
for Second Reading Ordinance 2010-09; Councilmember Piening seconded.
Mayor Cronin complimented the staff for the many hours of work they put in, as well as Council
for not only the hours spent in Committee and Council meetings but also for the time they spent
away from City Hall considering various options open to the City. The Mayor did express his
opinion that the budget was a document for which the City could be proud especially since it
does not contain a tax increase for the citizens.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Second Reading of Ordinance 2010-10 – An Ordinance Amending Title 6,
Health and Sanitation, Chapter 4, Smoking in the Workplace, Section 6-4-7,
Jurisdiction, Enforcement and Penalties of the City of Isle of Palms Code of
Ordinances to Provide for Minimum and Maximum Civil Fines in
Accordance with State Law and to Declare Violation as a Public Nuisance.
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to waive the reading and to approve
for Second Reading Ordinance 2010-10: Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and
the motion PASSED on a vote of 8 to 1; Councilmember Buckhannon voted
against the motion.
10. Miscellaneous Business
Discussion of Establishing a Joint Meeting with the Planning Commission
Receiving no objections from members of the City Council, Mayor Cronin set a joint meeting of
the Planning Commission with City Council for 7 p.m., Tuesday, July 20 following the meeting of
the Ways and Means Committee. The purpose of the meeting is to discuss the Planning
Commissions’ work product related to parking management.
Mayor Cronin announced that Bocce ball games had been scheduled for Thursday, June 24 at
the Recreation Center as part of the City’s Employee Wellness program.
City Council Meeting
June 22, 2010
Page 9 of 9
The Mayor noted the work put in by all of the Departments of the City to make the Disaster
Preparedness Expo the success that it was on Friday, June 18. He reported that citizens had
expressed their thanks to the City for the efforts put forth to put the valuable information before
the residents of the island.
Councilmember Bergwerf queried the Mayor about whether the issue of photography on the
beach had been referred to the Planning Commission. The Mayor responded that the
document from Mick Smith had been forwarded to the Commission; he noted that there was a
problem with the information provided by Mr. Smith in that the one (1) community that he
referenced as allowing photography on the beach required that approval be granted and a
permit be issued each and every time someone wanted to take photographs. Councilmember
Bergwerf admitted that such a process would be cumbersome, but she did think there had to be
creative thinking to work out a way for people to be allowed to take quality photographs on the
beach at the Isle of Palms.
11. Executive Session – not necesary
12. Conclusion/Adjournment
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 8:05 p.m.;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.