Special Meeting, July 20 (PDF, 69.26 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
JOINT MEETING
CITY COUNCIL and PLANNING COMMISSION
7 p.m., Tuesday, July 20, 2010
The joint meeting of the City Council and the Planning Commission was held at 7 p.m. on
Tuesday, July 20, 2010 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms,
South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf, Bettelli, Buckhannon,
Duffy, Loftus, Stone and Thomas, Planning Commission members Ballow, Campbell, Cohen,
Denton, Oltorik, Scott, and Watson, Mayor Cronin, City Administrator Tucker, Building and
Planning Director Kerr, Assistant City Attorney McCullough, Assistant to the Administrator
Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland. Westy Westmoreland of SCE&G and Dave Stevens of Civil
Site Engineering were present as invited guests.
1. Mayor Cronin called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Consideration of Granting Easement to SCE&G for Augmentation of Distribution
System
Mayor Cronin explained that SCE&G needs to add a fourth circuit to the sub-station behind City
Hall to improve reliability of service to the north end of the island. In order to do that, SCE&G
will need to run the circuit from the sub-station to a switchbox to be constructed in the parking
lot behind City Hall and then take the line under 13
th Avenue to a switchbox in the parking area
of the Building Department. From there the line would run along 13 th to Palm, along Palm to
and the Connector and then bore under the Connector to connect behind the Red and White.
The easements the City would grant are along the lot line on 13 th Avenue and in the parking lot
for the pad-mounted switchbox.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to grant easements to SCE&G as
requested per the documents provided; Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Councilmember Duffy asked Mr. Westmoreland how many utility poles would be eliminated by
this work; Mr. Westmoreland stated that there would be no poles removed, but the work will set
up the undergrounding of lines around City Hall and save the City sixty to eighty thousand
dollars ($60,000 – 80,000) in that endeavor.
Councilmember Loftus inquired as to the amount of time needed for this project, and Mr.
Westmoreland said the work would take only a couple of months. Councilmember Loftus
indicated to Mr. Westmoreland that the work should not begin until the heavy tourist season has
ended; Mr. Westmoreland agreed and added that he did not see much of an impact to traffic
since all of the work was to be done on one (1) side of Palm Boulevard and out of the roadway.
According to Mr. Westmoreland, SCE&G would like to begin as soon as possible so as to
complete the work prior to the end of the year.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 2 of 8
2. Presentation of Parking Plan by the Planning Commission
Mayor Cronin explained that the Planning Commi ssion has been studying the parking issues on
the island from various angles and perspectives; he added that he is of the opinion that traffic is
a topic that the City will be dealing with for the balance of the year.
Copies of the PowerPoint presentation and the handout distributed to City Council are attached
to the historical record of the meeting, as well as the legal opinion offered by Dick Watson.
Ron Denton, Chair of the Planning Commission, stated that the purpose of this meeting for the
Planning Commission members was to get feedback from City Council on the work they have
done thus far for them to know how to proceed. Based on the outcome of tonight’s meeting, the
Commission looks to having meetings with the public to get their input on concepts that the
Commission and City Council have developed, and with SCDOT who will have be a determining
factor in any final plan.
Mr. Denton thanked Dave Stevens, a former member of the Planning Commission, for his
engineering assistance and Dick Watson for free legal advice.
Mayor Cronin interrupted Mr. Denton to allow Mr. Watson to review the information he
researched from the South Carolina Code of Laws.
Mr. Watson stated that the inspiration for his research had been a question posed by Ms. Oltorik
regarding the City’s right to act independently of SCDOT because the streets were on the Isle of
Palms. Mr. Watson referred to the information in his email to Council quoting the code, and he
turned to Section 56-5-930, reading it into the minutes as follows:
“Subject to the limitation prescribed in Section 56-5-930, the provisions of this chapter
shall not be deemed to prevent local authorities with respect to streets and highways
under their jurisdiction and within the reasonable exercise of the police power from
(1) Regulating the standing or parking of vehicles;
(2) Regulating traffic by means of police officers or traffic-control signals; , , , “
In Mr. Watson’s opinion, “under their jurisdiction” would include rights-of-way, i.e., the City’s
police have jurisdiction over the streets and highw ays on this island, whether or not they are
DOT rights-of-way.
Mr. Watson then directed attention to Section 56-5-930 that, when paraphrased, states that
local authorities must have written approval from the SCDOT to “place or maintain any traffic-
control devices upon any state highway.” From his review, Mr. Watson contends that the
legislature “specifically reserved, to towns and muni cipalities, the right to regulate, govern, limit
parking within their jurisdiction.”
Mayor Cronin indicated that, historically, the state has wanted to regulate rights-of-way. Mr.
Watson stated that he had not found any cases where SCDOT had been challenged and a
written decision rendered.
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 3 of 8
According to Mr. Watson, on the subject of allowing residents free parking while charging
visitors to park, SCDOT said that an Attorney General’s opinion existed stating that such a
practice would be discriminatory. A few months after the State’s Attorney General’s report was
issued, the U.S. Supreme Court dealt with the same issue in Arlington, Virginia and decided that
if the municipality had a good reason, such as safe ty or traffic congestion, to discriminate in
parking that to do so was not a violation of equal protection.
Mr. Denton related that the Planning Commission had tackled the parking issue as a result of
updating the City’s Comprehensive Plan, its concern for the safety of residents and visitors and
anticipating the impact on the island of the anticipated growth along US17 North. The plan
being offered at this meeting is the Planning Commission’s effort to find a balance between
residents and day-trippers while still maintaining the residents’ quality of life and an access way
for emergency vehicles. The focus initially has been on Palm Boulevard because two-thirds ( ⅔)
of the island’s population has to pass down Palm to reach their ultimate destination.
Mr. Denton cited several issues of concern along Palm Boulevard, including
• Vehicles parked in an unorganized manner;
• Vehicles parked illegally – too near the road, fire hydrants and intersections;
• Vehicles parked in such a manner as to hi nder the sight-line for pedestrians crossing to
the beach; and
• Traffic congestion created by the search for a parking space that prevents emergency
vehicles from getting through or residents getting home from work.
The Planning Commission thought it prudent to implement a parking plan in phases. The first
step in Phase One is to request that vehicles park eight feet (8 ft) from the roadway on both
sides of Palm Boulevard from 21
st to 41st Avenues rather than four feet (4 ft) as indicated in the
State Code. Mr. Denton stated that people woul d have more room to maneuver as they
unpacked or packed up their cars and children would be further from the road, therefore, less
likely to run into the road.
In addition, the Planning Commission is recommending perpendicular parking on the non-ocean
side of Palm Boulevard; Mr. Denton admitted that the Commission had not reached a
consensus for parking on the ocean-side of Palm.
State law also mandates that vehicles not park within fifteen feet (15 ft) of an intersection; Mr.
Denton said that some signs are beginning to appear on the island informing drivers of this
requirement.
According to Mr. Denton, regulations exist for a sightline of three hundred fifty feet (350 ft) at an
intersection. In the opinion of the Planning Commission, the best mode of enforcement would
be the delineation of parking spaces by using wheel stops, for instance.
Because 21
st Avenue to 26 th Avenue is one (1) of the more congested areas, the Planning
Commission suggested using that stretch of Palm Boulevard as a test area for the proposals
being set forth. The Commission believes that people will see the benefits of safer and more
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 4 of 8
organized parking and safer beach access. By establishing this as the test area, the Planning
Commission and City Council could learn the benefits and drawbacks of the individual changes
that would provide a basis for generating an island-wide parking program.
Based on the success of Phase 1, Phase 2 would involve implementation of the above-
mentioned changes on Palm Boulevard from 27
th to 41st Avenues. A later phase would consider
paying for parking; the Commission has researched a variety of ways this method is used
throughout the country – none of which included parking meters or kiosks along Palm
Boulevard. Mr. Denton stated that the most recent consensus from the Planning Commission
was to consider a whole-island parking requirem ent using passes, decals, etc., which could be
purchased on-line through the website. He noted that requiring people to pay to park anywhere
on the island where a legal parking space exists prevents parking from creeping into the
neighborhoods. He indicated that lessons learned on Palm Boulevard would be used on
Carolina, Ocean Boulevard, etc.
Mr. Denton commented that, by the time the parking plan were to enter its final phase, hopefully
the City would have generated revenue from fee parking to fund improvements such as major
roadway improvements throughout the island, bike and/or walking paths, special parking for golf
carts or electric vehicles, well-defined pedestrian crosswalks, etc.
The final page of the presentation was an engineering drawing of the area of Palm Boulevard
from 21
st to 26 th Avenues that illustrates the Plan as envisioned by the Planning Commission
including the perpendicular parking on the non-ocean side of Palm, the eight-foot (8 ft) no
parking zone adjacent to the road, as well as a proposed sidewalk and bike and walking paths
along the ocean-side. According to Mr. Denton, one obstacle that the Commission encountered
on the ocean-side of Palm was the mature landscaping that extends well into the rights-of-way
in many areas. Although no parking was the plan for the ocean-side of Palm, the Commission
has considered using the area across from the end of leader streets for golf cart parking.
Having completed the presentation, the Planning Commission and City Council began open
discussion.
Mayor Cronin initiated the discussion by asking Chief Buckhannon whether the City had
experienced any accidents in the 21
st to 26 th Avenue area involving pedestrians crossing the
road; Chief Buckhannon answered that no pedestrian-related accidents had occurred in the past
five (5) years. Mayor Cronin commented that, with safety being the primary factor, he was
surprised that the parking was moved to the non-ocean side of Palm Boulevard adding to the
number of pedestrians.
Defending his concept of parking only on the non-ocean side of Palm Boulevard, Mr. Stevens
suggested that the island be considered as a whole and that, from the Front Beach to the
marina, a pedestrian pathway could be constructed with a minimum number of road crossings to
be enjoyed by not just residents, but by everyone who visited the island. Mr. Stevens
envisioned massive pedestrian access to the island along the ocean-side of Palm Boulevard
that many locations do not have.
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 5 of 8
Mayor Cronin stated, and Mr. Stevens confirmed, that the right-of-way on the ocean-side is the
same depth as the right-of-way on the non-ocean side.
Councilmember Bergwerf questioned who would walk on the street when they could be walking
on the beach. She did offer full support for parking a minimum of eight feet (8 ft) from the road
and suggested that it be implemented immediately for the entire length of Palm, but expressed
reluctance to give up the parking on the ocean-side of Palm Boulevard.
With all of the parking on Palm proposed for the non-ocean side of the street, Councilmember
Bettelli asked if crosswalks were planned for every intersection on the street to ensure the
safety of pedestrians crossing to get to the beach.
According to Mr. Campbell, there is very little parking on the ocean-side of Palm beyond 26
th
Avenue, primarily due to intrusions into the right-of -way. He also indicated that the majority of
the parking in that stretch of the road is illegal par king, i.e. less than four feet (4 ft) from the
pavement. Mr. Campbell also contended that the City would actually lose only a few parking
spaces by disallowing parking on the ocean-si de of Palm because the City would have more
organized parking on the other side. Ms. Oltorik inserted the fact that forty (4) parking spaces
have been counted between 21
st Avenue and 32 nd Avenue; Ms. Ballow confirmed Mr. Oltorik’s
count.
Mayor Cronin recalled that parking counts are included in the City’s Beach Management Plan.
Mayor Cronin suggested using the Recreation Department’s field lining equipment to delineate
the four-foot (4 ft) distance from the roadway for visitors looking to parallel-park along Palm
Boulevard. Chief Buckhannon reported that on a normal weekend, twenty to twenty-five (20-25)
tickets are written for parking less than four feet (4 ft) from the pavement in the area between
21
st and 26th Avenues on Palm Boulevard.
Director Kerr noted that the Planning Commission had studied the Beach Management Plan
prior to making this recommendation; he stated that the term used in the Plan is “full and
complete access.” Director Kerr repeated Mr. Campbell’s statement that few parking spaces
would be lost using the Planning Commission’s proposal and that the City would remain in
compliance with the Beach Management Plan whatever concept the Planning Commission were
to offer.
Mr. Denton indicated that he had envisioned parallel parking on Palm Boulevard at the lower
numbered avenues and perpendicular parking on the higher numbered avenues. Both Ms.
Ballow and Mr. Denton agreed that parking is very sparse in the area of 36
th Avenue, for
example.
Councilmember Bettelli suggested that, if an attempt was going to be made to delineate the
four-foot (4 ft) distance, the City should also mark beach access paths, because people park in
such a way as to block them and the crosswalks leading up to the access paths.
Councilmember Bettelli also voice opposition to parking or wheel stops being place on the non-
ocean side of Palm; he pointed out that there is gr ass growing in many of the areas that would
become parking.
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 6 of 8
Councilmember Bergwerf added that many residents are not going to appreciate people parking
in an area which many consider their front yards.
Regarding line of sight, Mayor Cronin suggested the addition of more signage saying “NO
PARKING HERE TO CORNER” to eliminate t hat problem. Some of these signs have been
installed, and none of those present had seen illegal parking where the new signs were placed.
Ms. Ballow pointed out that some of the City’s signs are contradictory, i.e., some say “NO
PARKING WITHIN 4 FEET OF THE ROAD” and others say “NO PARKING 4 FEET FROM THE
ROAD.” For first-time visitors to the island, one could easily end up parked very near the edge
of the road in Mr. Ballow’s opinion.
Councilmember Loftus thanked the Planning Commission for the work they had put into their
study of the parking issues on the island and for the work they have done on the parking plan
they set forth at this meeting. Councilmember Loftus stated that he did not want to begin with a
test area, but wanted to proceed with a comprehensive, island-wide program that would entail
free parking anywhere on the island for property owners who would be issued stickers/decals
and vehicles without the sticker/decal would be restricted in where they would be allowed to
park. He indicated that the proposed plan with a test area would drive visitors to park in
neighborhoods on the avenues. He proposed an annual fee for the stickers and suggested that
weekly renters could get passes from the rent al agencies when they check-in. Councilmember
Loftus voiced the opinion that anyone without a sticker would be required to pay to park and that
the revenues from the stickers/decals would pay for whatever needed to follow.
Ms. Ballow agreed that Councilmember Loftus had great ideas, but she stated that changes
should come about in stages and start with moving cars farther back from the road on Palm
Boulevard. Ms. Ballow noted that Sullivan’s Island was considering charging for parking; she
contended that, if Sullivan’s Island carried through with charging, parking on Isle of Palms would
become an even greater issue because people would come here to park for free rather than go
to Sullivan’s Island where they would be required to pay.
Mr. Watson commented that signs stating “NO PARKING EXCEPT BY PERMIT” could be
installed on the avenues to restrict parking only to residents once the stickers/decals had been
distributed. He indicated that residents are attending Planning Commission meetings wanting to
see action taken on parking because they were “suffering.”
Councilmember Loftus suggested that work begin immediately to develop a plan for
implementation with the inception of the 2011 tourist season in April. He suggested that the
property owner listing used for distributing hurricane re-entry stickers could be used to distribute
annual parking stickers; persons who wished to do so could purchase annual parking stickers,
on-line maybe, for the same price as annual parking decals for the City lots. Councilmember
Loftus maintained that this action would take unwanted cars out of the neighborhoods.
Mayor Cronin asked if the Commission had determined how many stickers would be allowed
per household. How would extended families be handled?
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 7 of 8
Councilmember Bettelli expressed the opinion that no action should be taken without first
holding an island-wide meeting to get feedback and input from the residents of the island
because everyone involved in this conversation was doing so in their role as servants of the
residents of the City. He remarked that, by setting policies, this group was guessing what
citizens of the island wanted done to solve parking issues.
Councilmember Duffy commented that the parking issues should be approached from a
residential viewpoint – that it was something that residents have been complaining about for
years. He remarked that the Planning Commission had done an excellent job addressing the
major thoroughfare on the island, but he questioned the impact on the residential areas. He
stated that one (1) way to solve the problem was to create residential parking zones on the
island. Councilmember Duffy continued by sayi ng that individual property owners could be
issues a number of “guest” passes for evening-long to week-long visitors.
Mayor Cronin noted that a comprehensive parking plan would call for parking on Ocean
Boulevard that is presently not allowed on either side; therefore, the City has a blank sheet in
that area to create organized parking from the beginning. He expressed belief that this action
alone would eliminate pressure from the avenues.
Mr. Denton stated that the Planning Commission perceived their plan as one that would create a
revenue stream for future parking improvement s throughout the island. He described pay-to-
park concepts that the Commission discussed such as residential parking areas, NO PARKING
areas, tiered parking with the prime locations being the most costly, etc.
Councilmember Stone expressed his support for the Planning Commission’s phased-in program
as described in their handout to City Council while an island-wide comprehensive plan is being
developed. Although he anticipated little opposition from residents to these changes, he stated
that he was open to public meetings for input. Councilmember Stone mentioned that residents
who live on the ocean-side of Palm frequently compla in to him that they do not have a line of
sight to back out of their driveways; he believes that the eight foot (8 ft) setback would help
these residents and generally improve safety along Palm Boulevard.
Mayor Cronin noted that the City receives solicitations for grant money to put in increased areas
for accesses and walkways, etc; he suggested that these grants might be a source of funds for
a sidewalk on the ocean side of Palm to keep people out of the line of traffic. The Mayor
repeated his dislike of taking parking off the ocean-side of Palm, because he did think that was
the safer side on which to park.
Councilmember Bergwerf noted that Sullivan’s Island would be having a public meeting on
parking on Tuesday, July 27 – the night Isle of Pa lms has its City Council meeting; she stated
that her understanding of the Sullivan’s Island propos al was to contract out the kiosk-type sale
of five-dollar ($5) day stickers for legal parking anywhere on the island.
Mayor Cronin said that he had no indication that there would be problems in having DOT place
more of the “NO PARKING HERE TO CORNER” signs along the full length of Palm Boulevard.
Joint Meeting
July 20, 2010
Page 8 of 8
On the subject of a public forum on the Isle of Palms on parking, Mayor Cronin thought that a
meeting could be scheduled for September of October. Director Kerr suggested that the City
have specific proposals to put forth for discussion rather than random discussions on parking in
an effort to get clear direction from residents.
Councilmember Buckhannon suggested that each area of the island had unique parking issues
that would have to be addressed; he did not that think that a “one size fits all” approach would
be successful.
Mayor Cronin suggested holding another joint meeting in September with the Planning
Commission continuing its work in the interim; the timing for a public forum could be discussed
at that meeting.
Prior to closing the meeting, Mr. Scott thanked Dave Stevens on behalf of the Planning
Commission for the design work he had done for them to aid in their presentation.
Administrator Tucker reported that the meeting had been videotaped and would be shown on
Comcast Channel 60 the following evening at 6 p.m. and would be loaded onto the City’s
website.
The meeting was adjourned by Mayor Cronin at 8:43 p.m.
Respectfully submitted;
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.