February 2 (PDF, 25.71 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
5:45 p.m., Tuesday, February 2, 2010
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 5:45 p.m., Tuesday, February 2,
2010 in Council Chambers of City Hall, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember s Bettelli and Thomas, Chair Piening, City
Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; Building
Director Kerr and Police Chief Buckhannon were also present at the request of the City
Administrator.
1. Vice-Chair Thomas called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act;
Chair Piening arrived late having been detained at work
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of January 12, 2010; Vice-Chair Thomas seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments - None
4. Old Business - None
5. New Business
A. Review of Capital Budgets for General Government and the Building
Department
Administrator Tucker noted that, once initial decisions on the capital budgets are made at this
meeting, the Committee will need to make a motion to take them before the Ways and Means
Committee. She stated that it would be April before the revenue budgets were available for
comparisons to expenditures; therefore, this budget would get another review at that time.
General Government – Capital Budget
City Hall renovation to include Building Dept, per PSB bond estimate $100,000
The funds for this project were included in the Public Safety Building bond; this figure represents
the amount expected to be spent in FY 11.
Structural repairs to correct problem with sagging 2nd floor 25,000
The structural engineers found this problem as they were inspecting the building for the
renovation project; as is evident, there are no structural supports in Council Chambers.
Roof Repair (flat areas and caps w/misc carpentry for rotten wood) 8,500
Structural engineers uncovered leaks in the roof, which are particularly noticeable on both
exterior stairs. It is thought that there would be economies of scale to have this work done along
with the renovation, but, with the limited funds av ailable, this item, and others, would be listed as
alternates on the bid and be done only if the bids were favorable.
Replace dune walkover at public restroom 80,000
The Administrator reported that no significant funds have been spent on the walkover in some
time; it needs rehabilitation or replacement. Estimates were based on the work done to the 21 st
Avenue walkover.
Personnel Committee
February 2, 2010
Page 2 of 5
Replace dune walkover at 41st Avenue 80,000
In addition to being in poor condition, the walkover needs to be widened; therefore, this walkover
would need to be replaced, not rehabilitated.
Councilmember Bettelli expressed the opinion that these two (2) dune walkover items should be
on either the Public Works capital budget or Real Property since one of those Committees
would likely handle the projects. The Administrator agreed that the project could be under
Public Works as was the 21 st Avenue walkover, but she remembered that the project had been
a part of the General Government capital budget. Councilmember Bettelli felt it would be
advantageous for the project to be on the budget of the department that would coordinate and
oversee; the Administrator agreed to remove them from General Government.
Replace windows at City Hall 32,000
As with the roof, this item would be bid as an al ternate with the building reconfiguration; many of
the windows are rotting and cannot be opened or closed properly.
Replace Connector message board (possibly with computerized model) 15,000
Replace Breach Inlet message board (possibly with computerized model) 15,000
Administrator Tucker stated that staff has not lo cated a vendor for a message board that fits the
City’s needs; therefore, the costs indicated ar e “guestimates.” The goal is to have electronic
message boards that could be remotely changed and hold an equivalent amount of information,
also, in the case of an emergency, residents could be informed quickly.
Replace exterior door on City Hall 16,000
As with the roof, this item would be bid as an alternate with the building reconfiguration; the doors
are rusted.
Replace HVAC equipment (Fy11 expense for Council Chambers) 12,000
The HVAC equipment servicing Council Cham bers has been in use since the building was
occupied in 1991.
Replace staff computers 3,600
Three (3) computers in General Government were purchased at the same time as the
Administrator’s computer which had to be replac ed very recently; theref ore, replacement of one
(1) or more can be anticipated.
Prioritizing the list, Councilmember Bettelli expr ess his opinion that electronic message boards
were a low priority. The rusting exterior doors have been discussed for several years. He
stated that he did not think they could be re-work ed since they were steel; therefore, they would
probably have to be replaced.
Administrator Tucker commented that it would be better to have the building renovations in the
budget and not to do them than to have a contractor who was going to give an advantageous
price for one of the alternate repairs and be delayed by the process of its being an unbudgeted
expense. She repeated the plan to bid these re pairs as alternates, and Councilmember Bettelli
said he would agree to leave them in the budget under those conditions. The message boards
were deferred to FY 12.
Personnel Committee
February 2, 2010
Page 3 of 5
General Government – Special Projects
The Administrator explained that these are not capital expenditures, but are listed because they
are of significant expense.
Undergrounding of utility lines 75,000
Administrator Tucker noted that this has been a pr iority of previous Councils; the purpose was to
have money available should the City decide to use money in the Non-Standard Service Fund to
do an undergrounding project
Councilmember Bettelli suggested that this be another low priority item as he anticipates a
tough budget year.
Digitize historical records (minute books, ordinances) 5,000
Administrator Tucker reported that, in previous capital budgets were fireproof cabinets to house
the City’s minute books; rather than continue that process, the City would like to begin digitizing
the minutes which could then be made available on-line.
Volume licensing for Microsoft Office (approximately $200/computer City-wide) 10,000
The Administrator commented that this item was the reason that she had asked Chief
Buckhannon to be present. She explained that al l of the City’s computers have individual
programs loaded onto them; each time a new computer is purchased, it comes with the most
recent version of the software. The City also pays for a new license each time a new computer is
purchased. The figure indicated here would be for a volume license that would allow the City’s
computers to all run on the same software vers ion; new computers would not be purchased with
pre-loaded software. Chief Buckhannon noted that this license was for the Microsoft Office
products – Word, Excel, Outlook, etc. This woul d be for fifty (50) licens es for Microsoft Office
Small Business Edition for a three-year (3-yr) peri od of time. This license would also allow all
members of City staff to switch to the most recent version of Microsoft Office, which would
eliminate instances of staff working on incompat ible documents produced on different versions of
software. When the City purchases new comput ers, they would not have pre-loaded software
saving the City that expense; the software would be loaded after the computer is delivered.
General Government – Facility Maintenance
Replace gray chairs in Council Chambers (½ every 2 years) 2,000
Replacement for damaged or discolored chairs.
In Councilmember Bettelli’s opinion, this was also a low priority purchase.
Replace office furniture 5,000
According to the Administrator, there are severa l pieces of office furniture that are wobbly,
particularly the City Treasurer’s desk.
Elevator maintenance 2,700
Must be done annually to ensure the City’s compliance with elevator regulations.
Pressure wash City Hall exterior 2,500
To remove the mold and mildew that form on the building.
Generator maintenance (twice per year) 2,400
Self-explanatory.
Exterior painting (entire building) 5,000
Another potential alternate to the building renovation bid.
Personnel Committee
February 2, 2010
Page 4 of 5
Councilmember Thomas questioned whether something should be added to the budget to
improve the rear entrance/exit where the pavement ends. Administrator Tucker noted that
periodically shell sand is brought in as fill; she explained that the City could run afoul of NPDES
regulations if it were to extend the pavement of the parking lot to the roadway. She added that
the cost of the shell sand did not warrant inclusion in the budget.
Administrator Tucker asked Director Kerr to come forward to present the Building Department’s
budget.
Building Department – Capital Budget
Replace staff computers $ 1,600
Director Kerr indicated that one (1) of the four (4) computers in the Building Department was
“ancient.”
Replace office furniture, furniture for new conference room 5,000
The furniture to be purchased would be for chairs to go with the conference table, chairs for an
audience (like those in Council chambers) and one (1) chair for the Building Official.
Facility Maintenance
Demolition of Building Department 10,000
This figure is in the current year’s budget, but the work will not take place until FY 11.
Rehabilitate former Building Dept site for overflow parking 10,000
A parking surface is anticipated for the site; in current year’s budget, but work done in FY 11.
Asbestos/lead survey 1,200
This figure is in the current year’s budget, but the work will not take place until FY 11.
Possible hazardous material removal 7,000
This figure is in the current year’s budget, but the work will not take place until FY 11.
Moving expenses 3,000
This figure is in the current year’s budget, but the work will not take place until FY 11.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the capital budgets for
General Government and the Building Department with the changes discussed;
Councilmember Thomas seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Review of Projects Greater than $250,000
Assistant Dziuban prefaced her discussion with the following information:
• This list is comprised of projects sugges ted by previous Councilmembers, staff and
citizens;
• The list was last reviewed in 2007; and
• The Committee will be asked to add and/or delete projects and to prioritize its top five (5)
projects.
The project list is attached to the historic record of the meeting; significant comments follow:
• Councilmember Bettelli expressed his opinion that SCDOT should be responsible for an
addition of a pedestrian lane on the Connector; he noted that the City’s only true jurisdic-
tion was to the middle of the bridge;
Personnel Committee
February 2, 2010
Page 5 of 5
• On the subject of the wireless mesh co mmunications system, Councilmember Bettelli
commented that the City of Charleston had tried such a system, and it did not work; he
thought this project should have a very low priority; and
• Chair Piening questioned the City’s responsibility to replace/reconfigure the marina
docks, as well as the suggested marina enhancement project in light of the lease
agreement now in place at the marina. He questioned whether the City would not
benefit financially from such an investment with the new lease structure.
The Personnel Committee prioritized the projects as follows:
1. Drainage project 54-57
th Avenue;
2. Marina dredging;
3. Disaster Recovery Fund increase;
4. Recreation ball field reconfiguration and lighting;
5. Marina dock replacement/reconfiguration.
6. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date; 5:45 p.m., Wednesday, March 3, 2010.
7. Adjourn
MOTION: Chair Piening moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:20 p.m.;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.