April 5 (PDF, 38.17 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Monday, April 5, 2010
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, April 5,
2010 in the Training Room of the Public Safety Building located at 30 J.C. Long Boulevard, Isle
of Palms, South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Loftus,
Chair Bettelli, City Administrator Tucker, Police Chief Buckhannon, Fire Chief Graham,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of March 10, 2010 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and
the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Gary Griffin
, of WEZL radio station and the representative of the “Ride to the River,” was
present at the meeting to request approval for the motorcycle ride to traverse the Isle of Palms
in its annual ride to raise funds for the North Charleston Recreation Center. The ride is
scheduled for Sunday, May 2, and, depending on the weather, there can be anywhere from
three hundred to six hundred (300-600) riders. The proceeds from the ride will be used to
purchase equipment, uniforms and trophies for a youth baseball tournament put on every year
by the North Charleston Recreation Department. Mr. Griffin informed the Committee that this
would be the seventh (7
th) year that the ride has taken place and that the ride has not been on
the Isle of Palms in the past three (3) years. Both Sullivan’s Island and Mount Pleasant public
safety offices have been contacted, but Mr. Gri ffin reported that they have not responded to his
requests. He further explained that the ride will begin about 1:15 p.m. from the North
Charleston Coliseum, and the riders should arrive on the island about 2:15 p.m. The route will
take the riders across the Ben Sawyer Bridge onto Highway 703, across Breach Inlet, down
Palm Boulevard and turning left onto the Connector. The ride will be fully escorted by the
Charleston County Motor Squad; the motor squad will stop traffic at all intersections along the
route and re-open the intersections once the last rider has passed through.
Chair Bettelli asked Chief Buckhannon about his concerns for such an event passing through
the island on a beautiful Sunday afternoon when there will already be considerable traffic
generated by the day-trippers leaving the island over the Connector. Chief Buckhannon
responded that the time frame Mr. Griffin was referring to was, generally, the time that the
exodus from the beach begins; Chief Buckhannon stated that traffic has been known to back up
three to five (3-5) miles on a busy Sunday afternoon exodus.
Lee Gerard with the Charleston County Motor Squad stated that he had accompanied this ride
several times and that traffic would be blocked for no more than ten minutes (10 min); he noted
that the ride would be very organized in order to impact the communities as little as possible.
Chair Bettelli expressed full support for the cause the ride assists, but, even without events,
traffic can become snarled on a beautiful, sunny and warm day for people leaving the island.
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 2 of 10
Councilmember Loftus commented that the number of day-trippers continues to increase; he
expressed that he, too, thought the ride was for a good cause, but the timing for the Isle of
Palms was terrible.
Mr. Gerard asked if reversing the route would make any difference to the Committee, and
Councilmember Loftus said that it would not.
Chair Bettelli stated that the consensus of the Committee was that they could not support the
planned route through the Isle of Palms at the time of day and time of year proposed.
Ryan Buckhannon
, 23 Twenty-seventh Avenue, reported to the Committee that one (1) of the
City’s firefighters had been seriously injured recently in a motorcycle accident in Columbia; he is
facing a long recovery period. He stated that he and the management of the Acme Cantina are
planning a fundraiser for firefighter Dan Mills on Saturday, April 24 from 2 to 6 p.m., and he was
present to request that the Committee give permission for the closure of Pavilion Drive
Extension. In order to make the event a family one, they are planning to have a twenty-two foot
(22 ft) long fire truck air slide for the children; activities will be fire-related, such as a fire wings
eating contest. He stated that a request has already been submitted to SCDOT and he talked
with Chief Buckhannon about the event. The only property impacted was the Mims’ property,
and he has placed a call to them as well.
In response to Councilmember Loftus’ questions, Mr. Buckhannon stated that he anticipated
having the road closed from noon until 8 p.m., and parking could be in the Acme parking lot and
the City lot.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to amend the agenda to include the
closure of Pavilion Drive for a portion of the day on April 24, 2010; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to approve the closing of Pavilion Drive
Extension from noon until 8 p.m. on Saturday, April 24, 2010; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Mr. Buckhannon stated that he would have the balance of the information, the responses from
the Mims’ family and SCDOT, for the Ways and Means Committee on April 20. He indicated
that tickets for event would be fifteen dollars ($15.00), which would pay for the barbecue, and
there would also be drink specials from Acme Cantina.
Administrator Tucker added that the accident was not Firefighter Mills’ fault and that the other
driver had no insurance.
Debbie Jones
, 813 Ocean Boulevard, commented about the March Public Safety Committee
meeting where Chief Graham had indicated that radio communications for the public safety
departments would not improve without a tower being erected on the island. She asked if the
existing water tower had been considered to eliminate the need for another tall structure; Chief
Graham informed Mrs. Jones that the water tower was not tall enough. Chair Bettelli explained
that the Charleston County Council had hired a consultant to determine whether the
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 3 of 10
improvements suggested by Motorola would actually solve the communication problems being
experienced all over the county and that the City would not know anything certain until those
consultants made their report to County Council.
Mrs. Jones then noted that she recalled that a bike rack would be placed at the Public Safety
Building at a cost of four hundred seventy dollars ($470), but that seven hundred dollars ($700)
had been approved to include the installation. She related that retired or out-or-work
contractors or engineers, who live on the island might be willing to donate their time to install the
rack, or that, possibly, the firefighters could do the work thereby saving the City the cost of
installation.
4. Old Business
A. Update on Public Safety Building
Administrator Tucker reported that, according to the latest report from David Johnson of
Cole+Russell, approximately forty (40) items listed on the warranty list have been completed
and there are task completion dates for some of the items yet to be completed. Other than the
one (1) major problem related to the siding, the other items that have been identified are
relatively small. She reported that Chief Buckhannon has been working with Cole+Russell to
resolve problems with the lights in Rooms 243 and 244.
B. Update on Civil Engineering for 41
st Avenue/Palm Boulevard Intersection
Assistant Dziuban stated that the City has executed both the contract with Sanders Brothers
and Notice of Award pursuant to Council action in March. The Notice to Proceed has not been
issued because SCDOT has not issued the permit although they have verbally committed to do
so. Ms. Dziuban noted that all parties were aware of the time sensitivity of the project. Later in
the week a meeting is scheduled with IOP Water and Sewer, Sanders Brothers, Thomas and
Hutton, departments within the City, as well as representatives from Charleston County to
discuss the possibility of County participation in the project; the County has reviewed the City’s
plans and expressed interest in the project.
Councilmember Loftus voiced his understandi ng that SCDOT had approved the project;
Assistant Dziuban stated that Administrator Tucker had spoken with Thomas and Hutton today
asking that they gently maintain the sense of urgency with SCDOT.
C. Update on Digital Radios
Chief Graham reported that a meeting had taken place with the consultant, Kimball and
Associates, hired by Charleston County to validate the Motorola proposal on March 15. The
consultants are expected to be on the island this week to see firsthand the problems that exist.
She stated her understanding that the consultants would make their report to Charleston County
Council within a couple of months; but, with the weather heating up, the radio problems are
increasing. She stated that she anticipates a difficult summer since the radio problems will not
be resolved.
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 4 of 10
Councilmember Loftus asked the Chief what the time line was for handling the radio issues; she
responded that she fully expects it to be two years (2 yrs) before phases one and two of
Motorola’s plan are completed.
5. New Business
A. Consideration of Request from Sea Cabins for Lifeguard
Administrator Tucker provided history on this issue as follows:
• Two (2) seasons ago, Charleston County Parks and Recreation Commission (PRC) had
requested permission from the City to extend their lifeguarded area to the south side of
the pier;
• Since, from time to time, water-related or medical emergencies occur on the south side
of the pier, the City thought the PRC request was a good one to provide assistance to
emergency responders and granted their request;
• In the letter that approved the expanded area, the City had cautioned that “the
placement of the lifeguard stand not block the surf camera” that is located on one of the
Sea Cabins structures;
• The surfing club has a “surf cam web cam” that covers the south side of the pier where
they have surfed for many years.
• In the season that the City granted this expansion of the guarded area, a conflict arose
between the lifeguards and the surfers and kayakers, because the surfers and kayakers
had, in recent years, used that area of the beach for those activities and those activities
were in direct conflict with the training Charleston County provided for the lifeguards.
• In addition, Administrator Tucker noted that the City and State have regulations that
surfing and kayaking are not to take place in areas near swimmers; the same regulation
is taught to the lifeguards. (Chief Buckhannon distributed copies of the regulations.)
• Due to the conflict between the lifeguards and the surfers and kayakers and the fact that
this put Charleston County PRC outside of its property line – if one were to extend the
property line out onto the beach, the City with drew its approval of having that section
guarded and returned to original guarded area.
The Administrator added that, long before the County Park existed, the City had a designed
swimming area that was guarded, and, during that period of time, any kind of hard device that
could injure a swimmer was not allowed in that area.
Now Sea Cabins, that enjoyed the summer of a guarded beach, is once again appealing to the
City to reconsider expanding PRCs jurisdictional area to the south side of the pier.
Administrator Tucker expressed her opinion that conflicts would again occur if this request were
granted because PRC has made it clear that they must give consistent instructions to the
lifeguards.
Responding to Councilmember Loftus’ question, Chief Buckhannon stated that the guarded
area would extend to the end of Sea Cabins, or approximately three hundred feet (300 ft).
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 5 of 10
Councilmember Bergwerf commented that, according to the code, surfers are not to be within
two hundred feet (200 ft) of the pier; Administrator Tucker agreed that was correct. Chief
Buckhannon commented that the existence of the web cam on Sea Cabins presents a
conundrum, because it serves to invite people to come to surf, but the lifeguards tell the surfers
they cannot surf in the area advertised. Sandy Stone noted that there was a disclaimer on the
web cam’s website.
Councilmember Bergwerf added that safety is key and that area of the beach is the most
crowded.
Chair Bettelli pointed out that, although the lifeguards are employees of Charleston County, the
City that is often blamed for the problems that arise out of the conflicts between these two
factions.
When asked by Councilmember Loftus whether C harleston County would be inclined to place
lifeguards south of the pier, Administrator Tucker replied that she thought they would do so, but
would have the expectation that the City would support their actions of running off the surfers
and kayakers.
Chair Bettelli added that one (1) reason the City chose to remove the lifeguards from this area
south of the pier was that the problems that arose were beginning to place a negative face on
the island since the City was deemed to be “the bad guy.” Councilmember Bergwerf interjected
that these lifeguards were enforcing a law that has been on the books for years prohibiting
kayaking and surfing within two hundred feet (200 ft) of the pier; Administrator Tucker agreed
and added that they were enforcing their own set of training standards and operating
procedures.
Chair Bettelli asked whether there had been any accidents involving surfers and swimmers;
Chief Graham responded that there had been, but not in this area of the beach. Chief Graham
added that people who go to the County Park area of the beach go there because lifeguards are
there. She asked that, if the Committee were to agree to this Sea Cabins’ request, that a
request be made to the County that the Fire Department/EMS be notified any and every time
there is any type of emergency in their guarded area.
Another area of concern, when the City withdrew its support for this area of the beach to be
guarded, was that Charleston County PRC was going out of its boundaries because they were
stepping out of the extended property lines of the park itself and as to whether or not, when they
did that and acted with authority, they truly had the authority if it turned out to be a court matter.
Chair Bettelli questioned that Sea Cabins was making this request for the safety of its guests,
and, if so, possibly, Sea Cabins should hire their own lifeguard.
The Chair commented that, as a rule, the surfers were a very careful group who did not
endanger swimmers.
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 6 of 10
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to defer a decision on expanding the
guarded areas of the beach until the May meeting; Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Consideration of Award of Contract to Lifeguard Medical Solutions in the
amount of $2,837.50 for one (1) AED with wall-mounted storage box,
replacement batteries and replacement pads for youth and adults.
Chief Graham stated that this item was overlooked when the Public Safety Building was being
outfitted; AED devices, like the one being requested, are located in City Hall, marina and the
Recreation Center.
Chair Bettelli asked the Administrator whether this purchase could be paid from the Public
Safety Building Contingency Fund; she answered in the affirmative. She commented that there
are portable devices on the truck, but, if they are on a call, that leaves the building without this
life-saving and easy to use device.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to approve the contract award to Lifeguard
Medical Solution in the amount of $2,837.50 for one (1) wall mounted AED with
accessories and fund from the Public Safety Building Contingency Fund;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Review of Operating and Capital Budgets for the Fire and Police
Department for FY 2010-2011
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the Budget Workshop was scheduled for
Tuesday, April 20 as part of the Ways and Means Committee meeting; therefore, her goal
tonight was to focus on the changes from the first review and the highlights. She directed the
Committee’s attention to page one where they were seeing the revenue side of the budget for
the first time. She indicated that lines 42 through 46 were of special interest because, for the
first time, several full-time, permanent employ ee salaries were being paid from accommodation
tax funds in order to balance the budget. The Administrator explained that this action is a direct
result of the economic conditions the City is experiencing and that, once the economy turns
around, these salary expenses will be transferred back to the General Fund. The specifics of
these “Transfers-in” are as follows:
From Municipal Acc Fees $152,411
Salary and Benefits for 1 Patrol Officer and 2 Firefighters
From Hospitality Taxes 102,473
Salary and Benefits for 1 Patrol Officer and 1 Firefighter
From State ATAX 9,326
Salaries for additional summer weekend part-time fire personnel
From Victims Fund 30,023
Salary and Benefits for ½ of Victims’ Advocate/Detective position
From Municipal Acc Fees 81,307
½ expense for Temp Labor in the Public Works Department
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 7 of 10
Overall, the FY11 Revenue Budget is projecting an increase of 3.4% over the FY10 budget.
The Committee was directed to Page 6 of the budget to review the proposed FY11 Police
Department Operating Budget.
Police Department Operating Budget
Salaries – Supervisors & employees $1,309,193
According to the Administrator, a change that is universal to all operating budgets is a decrease
in the pool for performance-based wage adjustments from four percent to three and one-half
percent (4%-3.5%).
Group health insurance 242,352
The original draft of the FY11 budget reflected an increase of ten percent (10%), but the City has
been informed that the group has been moved into the modified pool and will have an increase of
five percent (5%).
Based on questions raised at the last meeting about placeholders for general amounts of
money, Administrator Tucker assured the Committee that she would present to them at this
meeting the types of expenses that occur and are paid from these undesignated funds. For the
Police Department, the types of expenses paid in years past include small carpentry jobs,
electrical and phone repairs/wiring changes, fire extinguisher maintenance, typewriter repairs,
interior painting, computer network maintenance, lock repairs, hurricane shutter repairs and
plumbing repairs. The Administrator pointed out that these are general repairs that come up
throughout the year, but cannot be anticipated.
Councilmember Loftus asked to be provided with the past twelve (12) months’ actual fuel usage
by department that he thought would be helpful for the workshop.
Fire Department Operating Budget
Salaries – Supervisors & employees $1,377,738
The three (3) additional firefighters have been eliminated.
The same universal changes apply to the Fire Department that applied to the Police
Department. For the unspecified general maintenance for the Fire Department, in the past
these funds have paid for HVAC, plumbing and elec trical repairs, typewriter maintenance, fire
extinguisher maintenance, fire boards, AED repairs/maintenance and bay door repairs.
Police Department Capital Budget
Administrator Tucker turned to page 37 of the budget to review the Police Department Capital
Budget; she explained that this page displays how capital expenditures will be paid from the
various City funds.
Fire Department Capital Budget
The same depiction of how Fire Department capital expenditures are distributed to City funds
follows on paid 38 of the budget.
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 8 of 10
Councilmember Loftus asked how many miles we re on the Ford F-150 truck that was to be
replaced; Chief Graham stated that she did not know, but would have the information for the
workshop.
D. Consideration of Award of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 - None
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department
After Chief Graham reported that the Department had responded to a possible fire on Goat
Island, Chair Bettelli asked whether flyers coul d be distributed to Goat Island residents asking
that they notify the Fire Department in advance of burning yard debris; Chief Graham responded
that she would look into doing that. During the month of March, the Department responded to
fifty (50) calls, twenty-seven (27) of which were EMS calls. Fire Inspector Hommel officially
assumed his duties on March 9; during the mont h, he inspected twenty-seven (27) businesses
and found one hundred (100) violations. Currently there are thirteen (13) active volunteers.
Captain Tetor applied for and received a grant from Lowe’s for one hundred fifty-six (156)
smoke detectors that will be provided to and installed for island residents at no charge.
Councilmember Loftus stated that he would be interested in seeing a year-to-year comparison
of fire inspections as a regular part of the monthly report.
Police Department
Chief Buckhannon reported that, as a result of the Hurricane Disaster Drill, he, Lieutenant
Wright, Sergeant Usry and Detective Sergeant Caldwell had taken the NIMS level 300 course
and he had taken the level 700 course. The Chief, Sergeant Meekins and Detective Tarr had
attended the Wild Dunes Community Association annual meeting on March 14 where they had
distributed information on various topics and listened to citizens’ concerns. During the month of
March, the Department had received thirty-eight hundred thirty-two (3,832) calls, of which
twenty-four hundred sixty-two (2,462) were for the Police Department. In March, two hundred
seventy-eight (278) traffic stops were made t hat resulted in one hundred seventy-two (172)
tickets being issued. One hundred forty-nine (149) reports were written during the month; of
that number, fifty-seven (57) arrests were made, and twenty-two (22) of those arrests were for
underage possession of alcohol. The Animal Control officer wrote eight (8) citations, and the
Livability Officer issued five (5) citations.
After Chief Buckhannon’s report, Councilmember Bergwerf expressed her concern over a letter
from an island visitor critical of the Police Department that was originally sent to the Chief and
member of City Council; the letter has now become public apparently through an action of a
member of Council. She voiced her opinion of t he lack of professionalism that was exhibited by
the person who “leaked” the letter before the Police Department had the opportunity to
investigate and respond.
Councilmember Loftus expressed agreement with Councilmember Bergwerf, as well as his
complete support for Chief Buckhannon and the members of the Police Department.
Councilmember Loftus stated that he had received a second email referring to the original
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 9 of 10
complaint the following day from Charlie Aikman, and the Councilmember read the following
from Mr. Aikman’s communication:
“ If we continue to treat visitors to the Island like this we will scare away our remaining
visitors. We are all very familiar with the Island’s speed traps but not this visitor refers to
‘noise traps.’ Even more disappointing, the writer describes himself as a third generation
law enforcement officer, yet he describes one of our isle of Palms police officers as
‘probably one of the rudest people I have ever encountered.’ Charleston has been voted
year after year as the friendliest City in the nation, maybe we can go for the honor of the
‘unfriendliest City in the nation!’ “
Councilmember Loftus condemned the member of C ouncil who distributed the original email
before the facts of the case were known.
Chair Bettelli voiced his support for the Police Department and asked the Chief if he wanted to
make any comments on the matter.
Chief Buckhannon stated that it was an ongoing investigation and that the officers involved had
made statements on the situation; he noted that policies and procedures would not change as a
result of this complaint. He stated that there were inaccuracies in the original email that have
been addressed and communicated to the complainant; at this time, the Chief is waiting to hear
back from him and to receive the information that was requested from him. In addition, Chief
Buckhannon commented that the Department takes every complaint seriously and, if it is found
that personnel have done something wrong, he wants to know about it to make the necessary
adjustments. Conversely, if it is found that t he officers did everything they were supposed to do
according to established procedures, Chief Buckhannon stated that he would report that to the
complainant as well. He also reported that, at times when enforcing the laws, officers may
appear rude from the standpoint of the other parties.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Discussion of Raccoons on the Island
Administrator Tucker stated that her goal was for Chief Buckhannon to explain how raccoon
complaints are handled and the City’s boundaries for dealing with the raccoon population.
Chief Buckhannon commented that the first step in responding to a raccoon complaint is to
determine what type of damage the raccoon is doing. If there is damage inside a home, traps
will be set to catch it; time is also spent to ascertain how the raccoon is entering the house and
to seal the entry. He stated the Isle of Palms Police Department does not capture raccoons
doing damage outside a residence. He stated that he had distributed a pamphlet at the Wild
Dunes Community Association meeting about how to deal with raccoons inside and outside the
home. If a raccoon is captured, it must be taken to a local veterinarian to be euthanized; state
laws will not allow the release of a captured raccoon back into the wild. If a raccoon is found to
have inflicted a bite upon another animal or a human, the incident must be reported to DHEC.
Public Safety Committee
April 5, 2010
Page 10 of 10
Councilmember Loftus noted that the numbers vary from year to year as to the numbers of
raccoons that are dealt with vary year to year; he asked if the Animal Control officers ever act to
cull the numbers of raccoons on the island. Chief Buckhannon responded that trapping of
raccoons is a reactionary process and that the numbers seem to be cyclical; he added that,
when construction was booming on the island, they received many more complaints about the
raccoons as they lost their habitat.
Chair Bettelli reminded the Committee members of the following upcoming events:
• Hazardous Household Materials Colle ction and Shred Event, City Parking
Lot, Saturday, April 10, 2010, 9 a.m. to noon
• Annual Yard Sale, Recr eation Center, Saturday, April 17, 8 am to noon
• Disaster Preparedness Expo, Public Safety Building, June 18, 5-7 p.m.
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, May 4, 2010
Councilmember Loftus asked that the meetings return to City Hall, primarily for ease of parking.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:05 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.