October 12 (PDF, 34.82 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Tuesday, October 12, 2010
The Public Safety Committee held its regular meeting at 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, October 12, 2010
at the Public Safety Building, 30 J.C. Long Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina. Attending
the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf and Loftus, Chair Bettelli, City Administrator Tucker,
Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon and City Clerk Copeland. There was a quorum
present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
Councilmember Loftus indicated that a correction needed to be made to Item 1; “Chair Loftus”
should read “Chair Bettelli.”
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of September 9, 2010 as corrected; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Buzzy Bramble identified himself as a member of the Men’s Auxiliary for the VFW and stated
that he was seeking the Committee’s approval for the VFW to hold a turkey shoot using Daisy
BB guns on Wednesday, November 17 through Friday, November 19, 2010. Mr. Bramble
explained that the event would be a fundraiser for the VFW to fund something special for
service men over the holidays. He described the area of the VFW that would be used, how it
would be set up and the safety precautions they have prepared. If approved, the VFW was also
asking that the event be advertised on the Connector boards.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked Chief Buckhannon if the event was legal; Chief Buckhannon
responded that “discharging a firearm in the City is not legal.” The Chief added that the Daisy
BB gun firing a projectile is considered a firearm.
After a period of discussion, Chair Bettelli asked that the VFW withdraw its request for this year,
that it devise a detailed plan with drawings of the setup and the distances involved to present for
next year and that a group from the VFW meet with the Chiefs to ensure their concerns are
covered. Administrator Tucker suggested that VFW research how Mt. Pleasant handles the
turkey shoots in the City, because Mt. Pleasant has the same ordinance. The Administrator
also recalled that the City has not approved requests for turkey shoots in the past because they
are counter to the City’s ordinance.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to reorder the agenda to go to Item B under
New Business asking for permission to close a portion of Cross Lane;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 2 of 9
5. New Business
B. Consideration of Request for Closure of Cross Lane on Saturday, October
30, 2010 from 1 p.m. to 7 p.m.
Steve Bryant, 213 Forest Trail, distributed a sketch of the Forest Trail/Cross Lane area for the
Committee members’ reference. Mr. Bryant noted that they had gotten permission from City
Council last year for this reason; he described the event as a neighborhood gathering and fund-
raiser for East Cooper Community Outreach (ECCO).
In answer to Councilmember Loftus’ inquiry, Mr. Bryant indicated that four (4) homes are on
Cross Lane, one (1) that is vacant.
Councilmember Loftus stated that he was completely behind events that create a sense of
community.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the closure of Cross Lane
as presented; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Chief Buckhannon asked what would be used to block the road; Mr. Bryant said that they had
coordinated with the Police Department to use cones that the Fire Department had picked up
after the event. Chief Buckhannon suggested that the same be done this year, but he asked
that the Fire Department wait until sundown to pick up the cones.
Administrator Tucker suggested that the Chair consider re-ordering the agenda to consider item
A under New Business at this time; she explained that Director Page was attending the meeting
particularly for this discussion.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to reorder the agenda to consider Item B under
New Business, a request from the Charleston Running Club; Councilmember
Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
A. Consideration of a Request for Prediction Run from Charleston Running
Club to be held at 7 p.m. on Saturday, August 6, 2011.
Administrator Tucker noted that no one from the Running Club was present, and she speculated
that Mr. Baxter, who initiated the request, had not been notified of the meeting change.
Chair Bettelli stated that this event is not included in the City’s list of approved annual events.
Administrator Tucker noted that the Committee has begun “to realize that, when you open the
door to events here, it becomes an event per week.” The Administrator related that she had
communicated with Recreation Director Page for her comments on the Prediction Run as it
would impact the City’s annual Beach Run bas ed on the similarity and timing. Reasoning
behind establishing the list of approved events was twofold; the first reason was the frequency
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 3 of 9
of requests coming to the City, and the second reason was that, as the events grow, the drain
on the City’s resources grows. The Administrator concluded that she had requested that the
Recreation Director attend to express her opinion on the event.
Director Page stated that, as scheduled, the Prediction Run would take place only two (2)
weeks after the IOP Beach Run, which she described as unique because it is the only one (1).
She noted that the Beach Run had been moved to July from October because people confused
it with the Connector Run; she voiced the opinion that the Prediction Run would “take away”
from the IOP Beach Run.
Councilmember Loftus asked the Director whether she could support the Prediction Run if the
Running Club chose a date that provided for more separation from date of the IOP Beach Run,
maybe in the off-season. She stated that she would not be opposed if it were not close to the
City’s event.
Chair Bettelli agreed with the Director that the IOP Beach Run was unique and expressed the
opinion that “any beach run belongs to the City no matter when it’s held. . .” The Chair then
quoted from the e-mail request as follows:
“We charge an entry fee to cover costs, and any additional cash goes to support the
Running Club’s activities.”
The Chair noted that the event would not be supporting a charity.
Director Page suggested that the Running Club could hold the Prediction Run in conjunction
with the City-sponsored Beach Run; however, the Running Club would not receive any cash
proceeds from it.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to deny the request for the Prediction Run as
described, but encouraged the Charleston Running Club to combine efforts with
the IOP Recreation Department for a joint run; Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded.
Councilmember Loftus wanted to encourage a run on the island in the off-season to draw
people to island and to generate activity for local businesses.
Administrator Tucker commented that, if the Running Club coordinated with the Recreation
Department on a beach run, they would not be required to make a request through the Public
Safety Committee. If they want to hold an event in the off-season, separate from the Recreation
Department, they will need to get approval from the Public Safety Committee.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Old Business
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 4 of 9
A. Update on Digital Radio Tower
Administrator Tucker related that, based on comments made at the September City Council
meeting, she sent a letter to Charleston County Administrator explaining that she did not believe
that a one hundred eighty to two hundred thirty foot (180-230 ft.) tower on the Isle of Palms
would get approval. In the letter she asked that the radio staff at Charleston County investigate
alternatives that would provide the island with the service needed without the construction of a
tower on the island. From dialogue with Dickie Schweers and members of the Committee, the
Administrator has learned that the task was given to the radio staff, but she has not received a
response to her communication. Concerns expressed at City Council were the following:
• Council was not convinced that a tower on the island was the only solution to the
problem; and
• A zoning change would be required to construct a tower to the required height, and, in
the period for public comments, the Administrator thought little support would come from
the community.
Chief Graham noted that construction of a tower on the island was not just to boost the signal
on the island, but was to block the interference coming on shore from the ocean.
Councilmember Loftus complimented Administrator Tucker on the quality of the correspondence
with the Charleston County Administrator. He asked whether the City had been approached by
Charleston County in the initial phases of the digital upgrade to determine whether the City
wanted or needed a tower.
Chief Graham explained that, in 1997, the City had joined with Charleston County for the analog
radio system; the County upgraded to digital, and, in 2008, the City of Isle of Palms switched
over to the digital system. During testing of the digital systems in May of 2008, problems were
detected and reported to Charleston County. Imm ediately after switching, Mount Pleasant and
the Isle of Palms joined forces in seeking an answer to the problems. After multiple complaints,
the Chief learned that, if the problem was coming from inside a building, it was not a problem
with the radio system because the digital system had not been designed for in-building
coverage. Following meetings held all over Charleston County, Charleston County and
Motorola agreed that a problem existed with the digital communications system, and Motorola
brought various engineers to the area to determine the source of the problem. Several
approaches were made to “optimize the system” from tuning the radios to redirecting the signal
from towers. Chief Graham stated that the initial proposal from Motorola did not include a tower
at the Isle of Palms, and Motorola would not guarantee that the island’s problems would be
solved by the actions described in that proposal. When the County requested a solution to the
IOP problems, Motorola would only guarantee a solution with the placement of a tower on the
island because of the amount of interference from the ocean.
Chief Graham related that, prior to changing to digital, studies of radio frequencies had indicated
the need for a tower on the Isle of Palms. The Chief expressed the opinion that, had the City
not complained, but accepted the problems as inher ent to the digital system, the City would not
be facing the decision about a tower on the island.
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 5 of 9
Chair Bettelli also thanked the Administrator for her letter to the County; he expressed the
opinion that the letter might get the answers from Charleston County that the Committee had
been seeking for months – alternatives to a tower on the island.
Councilmember Loftus asked when Charleston County would be voting on the proposal from
Motorola; a meeting is scheduled for November when Charleston County Council will be asked
to approve the Motorola request and fund the contract.
Councilmember Bergwerf posed the question that was asked at City Council – Can the City go
back to analog? Chief Buckhannon commented that the solution was not that simple in that the
analog is being phased out in favor of digital and getting parts for it are a major concern.
B. Update on Public Safety Building
Administrator Tucker reported that Cole+Russell has tasked the mechanical engineers with
coming up with a recommended solution for the third floor; the “fix” is expected to be adding de-
humidifiers. The City continues to withhold m oney from Mashburn Construction, and assuming
that the anticipated solution is put in place, it will remain to be tested in the hot season before
being accepted.
C. Update on Abandoned Vessels
Administrator Tucker reported that Assistant City Attorney McCullough has drafted an
amendment to the existing code that clarifies that the “‘Hobie Cat’ style sailboats which are
operable and kept in good working condition” can be left on the beach overnight.
The two-page (2 page) memo relates to a new ordinance that outlines the manner in which the
City would deal with abandoned boats on private property; the Administrator noted that she had
a couple of changes she wanted to see in the proposed language and that Chief Buckhannon
might also have changes. If the Committee approves of the approach taken, then a new
ordinance and the amendment could be included in the agenda for the upcoming City Council
meeting.
Chair Bettelli summarized that the new ordinance provides for posting the vessel in question,
giving the owner thirty (30) days to remove the vessel and, after that period of time, giving the
City the authority to remove the vessels and to charge the owner for the expense of removing it.
The Chair expressed that the ordinance as proposed contains all of the issues about which the
Committee had concerns.
Administrator Tucker added that this new ordinance is very similar to the ordinance the City has
regarding abandoned vehicles.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend the amendment and new
ordinance to City Council; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 6 of 9
Councilmember Loftus voiced support for the amendment clarifying Hobie cats on the beach,
but he explained that he was concerned about the ordinance as it relates to private property and
property rights. He offered a situation where an individual has his boat in his driveway as he
saves to replace the motor or another situation where an individual has a sailboat in his yard
that he is reconditioning; would these vessels be in violation of this ordinance since neither is
seaworthy?
Chief Buckhannon responded that the key phrase in the proposed ordinance is “that present a
health or safety concern;” since the vessels in Councilmember Loftus’ scenarios do not present
either condition, the owners would not be in violation.
Another scenario offered by Councilmember Loftus if the user of a sailboat as a focus of a
homeowner’s landscape; would that boat be considered landscaping or an abandoned vessel?
Chair Bettelli thought that such a boat would be considered landscaping; he described an actual
case in Mount Pleasant where an old truck with the hood up and filled with plants in a resident’s
yard was ruled to be a part of the landscaping for the property.
Councilmember Loftus asked that Chair Bette lli withdraw his motion and Councilmember
Bergwerf her second in order to act on the Ordinance 2010-13 and the memorandum outlining a
proposed ordinance on abandoned boats separately. Chair Bettelli and Councilmember
Bergwerf withdrew their motion and second as Councilmember Loftus had requested.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend Ordinance 2010-13, amending
the code on abandoned personal property, to City Council for approval;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Loftus expressed the need for more study and discussion on the memorandum
outlining an ordinance about abandoned vessels on private property; he state that his concern
was taking away property rights.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend the memorandum outlining an
ordinance on abandoned boats on private property to City council for approval;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1
with Councilmember Loftus voting against the motion.
5. New Business
C. Consideration of Request for Lower Speed Limit
Administrator Tucker commented that the City receives, from time to time, conflicting requests
concerning the speed limit on Palm Boulevard. SCDOT recently lowered the speed limit on
Palm from Breach Inlet to the Post Office to th irty-five miles per hour (35 mph) at the request of
the City, which is the speed limit on the bulk of the island. The Administrator stated that she
was in receipt of a request to make the speed limit on Palm Boulevard between 41
st Avenue and
57th Avenue thirty-five miles per hour (35 mph) to make it consistent along all of Palm
Boulevard. But, over time, the City has received conflicting requests for that particular stretch or
road; currently the stretch is posted at thirty-five miles per hour (35 mph) in some places and
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 7 of 9
thirty miles per hour (30 mph) in others. The Administrator was of the opinion that the persons
who want a consistent thirty-five mile per hour (35 mph) speed limit live primarily in Wild Dunes.
In addition, Administrator Tucker referred to a conversation she had with Arnold Karig, who was
present for the Public Safety Committee meeting, when he had expressed the opinion that the
speed limit on that stretch of Palm Boulevard should mirror the limit of the side streets.
Administrator Tucker concluded her comments reminding the Committee that Palm Boulevard is
an SCDOT road; therefore, they would make the final decision.
Chief Buckhannon agreed that the speed limit along Palm Boulevard is confusing, and, for that
reason, he has approached SCDOT about establishing an island-wide speed limit. He noted
that Waterway Boulevard is twenty-five miles per hour (25 mph), but the side streets are thirty
miles per hour (30 mph). The Chief commented that, along one section of Palm between 41
st
and 57th Avenues, the speed limit heading north differs from the speed limit heading south, so
he stated that he would like to see the speed limit consistent going in both directions for that
stretch of road.
Councilmember Loftus asked if speeding was more of an issue for the Police Department along
Palm Boulevard between 41
st and 57th Avenues; Chief Buckhannon replied that people do tend
to speed up a little in that area because there is less traffic.
With agreement from the Committee members, Chair Bettelli opened the meeting to comments
from the residents, in attendance, who live in and travel the area being discussed.
Councilmember Loftus interjected that the board of the Wild Dunes Community Association had
voted unanimously for a speed limit of thirty-five miles per hour (35 mph) for Palm Boulevard.
Mary Thomas
, 5813 Back Bay Drive, stated that she normally drove the speed limit; she also
reported that a new sign has been installed along Palm making the speed consistent traveling in
both directions.
Arnold Karig
, 5102 Palm Boulevard, stated that he c onsiders Palm Boulevard to be like any
residential street on the island; therefore, he believes the speed limit should be twenty-five miles
per hour (25 mph). He stated that, once drivers pass the entrance to Wild Dunes, they
accelerate; he noted that he had asked the Administrator to install a sign “Reduce Speed
Ahead” to notify drivers that the speed limit is lower. In Mr. Karig’s opinion, the speeding in that
section of Palm Boulevard was a serious problem.
Chair Bettelli charged Chief Buckhannon with contacting SCDOT to find out what speed limit
they would recommend for that the section of Palms Boulevard between 41
st and 57th Avenues.
Jim Owens
, 2805 Palm Boulevard, recommended that the City look into placing a STOP sign, a
YIELD sign or a solid white line at the intersection of 21 st Avenue and Palm Boulevard for
persons wanting to turn left from Palm onto 21 st Avenue. After relating an incident involving a
Beach Services Officer ticketing a car for parking closer than four feet (4 ft.) from the roadway,
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 8 of 9
incorrectly in Mr. Owens’ opinion, he suggested that all officers should be issued rulers to
ensure that tickets are warranted.
Mr. Owens concluded his comments by thanking the Committee for their work regarding the
abandoned catamarans; he added that the enforcement arm of DHEC has also gotten involved
in the issue.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
Chief Graham reported that on September 25, the Fire Department covered for the Awendaw
Fire Department as they worked a structure fire; while in Awendaw, they responded to one (1)
medical call. On the same day, Department personnel responded to a request from Sullivan’s
Island Fire Department for two (2) children in distress in the water; the children were on shore
when the IOP crew arrived.
For the month of September, the Department had a total of eighty-six (86) calls, and fifty (50) of
them were EMS calls. The Fire Inspector conducted one hundred twenty (120) inspections in
the month and found two hundred seventy-one (271) violations. Fifty-three (53) pre-incident
surveys were completed using the new software.
The Chief reported that the most significant expense to vehicle maintenance was the
replacement of six (6) tires on Tower 1. The quarterly preventative maintenance of Department
vehicles was completed in September.
Chair Bettelli inquired about the response time with Charleston County EMS; Chief Graham
stated that the response time has been more sluggish than the IOP Department is accustomed.
As a result, the City’s Department has made arrangements with the Mount Pleasant Fire
Department to respond to the Isle of Palms in life-threatening situations.
Councilmember Loftus reported hearing that the County’s response time has slowed and asked
whether she knew what has changed to cause the slower time. Chief Graham stated that the
two (2) spare trucks previously available in the busiest part of the day were taken out of service
as personnel were hired to fill positions vacated due to promotions. The Chief added that island
personnel have found issues with the way calls have been handled by the consolidated dispatch
center.
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
Chief Buckhannon highlighted a call on September 7 when a vehicle was stopped in Wild Dunes
with an invalid paper tag; the vehicle had been purchased two (2) years ago and had never
been registered. The driver was in possession of a forged bill of sale and had no insurance on
the vehicle; he was charged with Falsify DMV document, Failure to Display Tag and Operating
an Uninsured Vehicle.
Public Safety Committee
October 12, 2010
Page 9 of 9
In April, a Wild Dunes visitor reported the theft of a bicycle valued at twenty-three hundred
dollars ($2,300); on September 21, the bicycle was located on Craig’s List as for sale by an
island resident. IOP police contacted the seller by phone, returned the bicycle to the owner and
charged the seller with Petit Larceny.
Chief Buckhannon, Lt. Wright, Sgt. Caldwell, Sgt. Meekins and Sgt. Usry visited the monthly
Keenagers’ meeting where they gave a present ation entitled “Crime Prevention through
Environmental Design” followed by a question and answer period; approximately sixty-five (65)
people attended. The Chief reported that the Department has worked with Wild Dunes’ security
personnel and presented the programs several times in Wild Dunes, and police staff has
arranged to make this presentation to the rental companies and the Exchange Club.
During the month of September, IOP telecomm unicators received thirty-four hundred eighty-
nine (3,489) calls; twenty-five hundred five (2,505) were for the Police Department and one
thousand twenty-five (1,025) were service calls.
One hundred fifty-seven (157) traffic stops produced seventy-one (71) tickets.
Two (2) officers are attending Crime Prevention School.
The Livability Officer wrote five (5) citations for noise violations.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked Chief Buckhannon about the on-line survey that the Police
Department has on the website; the Chief reported that the Department had received one
hundred sixty-nine (169) responses. Some the comments from the survey will be included in
the Police Department report for October.
Councilmember Bergwerf inquired about the source of the survey; Chief Buckhannon
commented that the Department is required to su rvey residents every three (3) years as part of
the accreditation process.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, November 9, 2010.
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:01
p.m.; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.