November 9 (PDF, 36.43 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Tuesday, November 9, 2010
The Public Safety Committee held its regular meeting in the Public Safety Building at 5:30 p.m.
on Tuesday, November 9, 2010 with Councilmembers Bergwerf and Loftus, Chair Bettelli, City
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Lieutenant Wright, City Attorney Halversen,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland attending. There was a quor-
um present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regu-
lar meeting of the October 12, 2010 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf se-
conded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments
Suzanne Bland, Executive Director of the Mid-Atlantic Chapter of the National Multiple Sclero-
sis (MS) Society, addressed the Committee regarding the Challenge Walk MS scheduled for
March 4-6, 2011, which is in its eleventh year. The event will involve two hundred persons and
a fifty-mile (50-mile) walk over three (3) days with the goal of raising three hundred seventy-five
thousand dollars ($375,000). Ms. Bland described that average walker as a forty-eight (48)
year old female with an income in excess of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) per
year. On the first day, walkers will travel from historic Charleston to Fort Moultrie; on the se-
cond day, they walk through Mount Pleasant ending at Patriots Point; and the third day the
walkers will take approximately four and a half (4½) hours walking ten (10) miles through the
Isle of Palms ending in Wild Dunes around noon. She explained that support arrangements
that have been made to assist the walkers that are made up of volunteers from throughout the
area, and, as a result of those arrangements, Ms. Bland does not anticipate requiring assis-
tance from the City’s public safety personnel. In the area covered by the Mid-Atlantic Chapter,
approximately eight thousand (8,000) people are impacted with MS, and they rely on the MS
Society to educate people and to fund research.
Responding to Lieutenant Wright’s question, Ms. Bland stated that the walkers would not have
staggered start, but all the faster walkers will be in the lead. The Lieutenant also was interest-
ed in knowing if volunteers would be stationed at the points where walkers will cross Palm
Boulevard; she answered that volunteers would be posted at those locations, but she was
open to any suggestions the City’s Police Department had to offer.
Councilmember Loftus complimented Ms. Bland on her presentation to the Committee.
Administrator Tucker asked for clarification on the indication of “Rest Stop 2 – Isle of Palms
Recreation Dept” that appears on the Sunday route information because the Recreation De-
partment is staffed by part-time personnel for the few hours that it is open on a Sunday. Ms.
Bland explained that the rest stops, typically, ar e small spaces where a tent could be erected
where medical and other support, as well as port-a-potties, can be provided for the walkers.
Since the Recreation Center is in the heart of a residential neighborhood, the Administrator
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 2 of 9
pointed out that sensitivity exists among the neighbors to the presence of port-a-potties; there-
fore, delivery and pick-up of the port-a-potties should be timed close to the beginning and end
of the event. The Administrator advised Ms. Bland to coordinate with Director Page regarding
the placement of the port-a-potties and noted that all businesses contracted to assist with the
event must have valid Isle of Palms’ business licenses.
Lieutenant Wright asked for additional information regarding the use of the Citadel Beach
House; Ms. Bland explained that the “Final Mile Celebration” – all participants walk the final
mile together - will begin at the Citadel Beach House after all have shared lunch. Ms. Bland
explained that the walkers would leave the Cit adel Beach House, cross Palm Boulevard and
proceed through the main gates into Wild Dunes and to the Pavilion; event volunteers would be
used to block traffic as they cross the street.
Responding to a query from Administrator Tucker, Ms. Bland stated that she was working with
the Wild Dunes Community Association for their formal approval for the event, but stated that a
verbal approval had been given.
Referring to a statement earlier in Ms. Bland’ s presentation, Councilmember Loftus asked
whether the event had taken place in Charleston in 2009 or whether 2010 was the first year in
Charleston. Ms. Bland responded that 2010 was the first year in Charleston and that the Chap-
ter has signed a two-year (2-yr.) contract with Wild Dunes; if the event is approved by the
Committee tonight, they would be making a similar request a year from now.
Chair Bettelli explained that the list of City -sponsored events was full, and this one would not
be added to that list. The Challenge Walk is scheduled for the off-season on the island, and
Administrator Tucker stated that she was unaware of a conflict with a City-sponsored event.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to approve the request for Challenge Walk MS
to be held March 4-6, 2011; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Administrator Tucker informed Ms. Bland that the City would need a Certificate of Insurance
naming the City as “additional insured;” Ms. Bland assured the Administrator that it would be
forwarded to her.
Ms. Bland assured the Committee that the Isle of Palms would be promoted, and a link to the
City’s website could be added to the Challenge Walk website.
4. Old Business
A. Update on Digital Radio Tower
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 3 of 9
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that she, Assistant Dziuban and the City’s Chiefs
had met with Bill Tunick, Walt Smalls, Donnie Jacomo and Allen O’Neal of Charleston County
regarding the digital radio system. The Administrator listed the following points of interest that
came from the meeting:
• The County is clearly committed to Motorola;
• The County is not contemplating falling back to an analog system; and
• The County is committed to solving the problems with the system with Motorola.
Administrator Tucker explained that the contract the County is expected to approve in Novem-
ber is structured in such a way as to take pressure off the City to make a decision on a tower;
the equipment required for a tower on the island will be included in the initial phase of the con-
tract. Should the City decide to proceed with a tower at either the present water tower location
or the Recreation Center, the equipment would be available; should the City decide to delay a
decision to allow for a re-evaluation of the system at a later date, the equipment would be
available; should the City decide against a to wer on the island, the equipment would be allo-
cated to a later phase of the County’s plan. During the course of the meeting, Charleston
County indicated that the radio user fees would be increased, but the amount or the time frame
for the increase was not yet available. The Charleston County staff did agree to attend a meet-
ing with the IOP City Council to provide a comp rehensive review of the radio situation and the
County’s plan for its improvement; at that time, City Council can pose their questions to the
Charleston County staff. The County staff did ask for that meeting to be delayed until January
2011 to give them time to inform the Charleston County Council.
Administrator Tucker related that she had asked the County to charge Motorola with evaluating
the tower at 41
st Avenue behind Fire Station 2 to determine whether it could be raised, thereby
eliminating the need to erect a second tower on the island. The Administrator explained that
other municipalities have been able to increase the height of existing towers rather than con-
struct an additional one.
In addition, the Administrator explained that the City has responded to the Freedom of Infor-
mation request from The Post and Courier regarding the digital radio situation; the newspaper
has also contacted Mount Pleasant, Folly Beach and Charleston County, as well.
Administrator Tucker stated that one (1) piece of new information that she agreed was a good
strategy for Charleston County was that, in light of the focus on the failures of the 800-digital
radio system both here and in other municipalitie s across the country, they have focused their
attention to the areas where the system has worked well, why it has worked and the differ-
ences between those places and the places where the system has not worked, such as the
number of towers, the geography, etc.
Councilmember Loftus questioned his understanding that the City would have an opportunity to
determine how the system works without a tower on the island before making a decision on a
tower; the Administrator stated that would be true if that was the decision of Council.
Administrator Tucker did suggest that Council delay its decision until after hearing the County’s
presentation in January, but she noted that she expected that the County would encourage the
City to choose a tower site.
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 4 of 9
The Administrator confirmed that the City was not being pressured to make a final decision at
this time, but could delay a decision, still be a part of the Charleston County system, and still
potentially have an improved circumstance base d on other improvements to the system. If
those improvements do not resolve the communica tion problems on the island, the City could
decide at that time for the placement of a tower on the island since the Charleston County con-
tract provides for the purchase of the equipment for an Isle of Palms tower.
Councilmember Loftus inquired about the antici pated completion date for Phase One of the
County Plan that originally included the Isle of Palms; Assistant Dziuban recalled that the
County expected thirteen (13) months, but added that they thought the timeline was somewhat
aggressive because it did not contain any contingency.
Assistant Dziuban informed the Committee that, should the City delay its decision to test the
effects of the other improvements, then decide to proceed with a tower on the island, the City
could experience financial consequences related to mobilization and demobilization that would
be avoided if a tower were to be constructed along with the other towers in Phase One.
Administrator Tucker commented that she expects the County’s presentation will be quite ex-
tensive and that the Charleston County staff will be well-prepared when they appear before the
IOP City Council.
Chief Graham noted that the primary reason Charleston County anticipates meeting the thir-
teen (13) month time frame is that plans are to utilize twice the number of power crews that
would be called for normally. The Chief reminded the Committee that a true test of the digital
radio system had to occur in the summer months when the radio interference from the ocean
was at its height.
Responding to Councilmember Bergwerf’s question about when Motorola would evaluate the
41
st Avenue tower, Chief Graham stated that Motorola had been asked to expedite the work.
Chair Bettelli expressed the opinion that “great strides” had been made on this issue, and he
thanked all who have been involved.
B. Update on the Public Safety Building
Administrator Tucker related her conversation earlier in the day with Dave Johnson of
Cole+Russell concerning the HVAC. Mr. Johnson indicated that the plan is to put a sensor in
the ceiling for each room so that the sensors a ppropriately tell the damper to close; the engi-
neers have determined that the damper is stayi ng open longer than it should and is allowing in
unconditioned air. The sensors installed originally are not operating properly; with a sensor in
each room, they will cause the damper to close. The other issue at-hand is architects and con-
tractors debating whether the HVAC was installed as designed and who will be responsible for
the fix. According the Mr. Johnson, another item being discussed is when it would be appro-
priate to remove the dehumidifiers that have been installed and the potential for baseline test-
ing regarding the air or mold that may be remaining. The Administrator commented that a few
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 5 of 9
small items remain on the punch list that need to be repaired, for instance, problems with the
stair handrail in the lobby, with the siding re-attachment and a slope in an approaching side-
walk.
C. Consideration of Abandoned Vessels Ordinance 2010-14
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that she had asked City Attorney Halversen to
attend the meeting to provide legal advice in Executive Session. The Administrator stated that
she wanted the Committee and interested citizens to be aware that passage of this ordinance
will not solve the problem of abandoned vessels in the dunes on the island that have been the
inspiration for the ordinance.
From discussions between Chief Buckhannon and Lieutenant Wright, Lieutenant Wright had a
couple of concerns regarding the ordinance to bring before the Committee; they are as follows:
• The notice required to be placed on the vessels for thirty (30) days would be suscepti-
ble to the weather, so an appropriate method of signage had to be devised;
• Clarification of the City’s responsibility for removal at the end of the thirty (30) days- re-
moval might be cost-prohibitive;
• Clarification of how and who would remove the vessels from the beach without damag-
ing the beach or the dunes;
• Negotiation with the vendor removing the vessels for reasonable daily storage rate to
be charged to the owner of the vessel; and
• Assurance that the City would not be responsible, in any way, for unclaimed vessels.
5. New Business
A. Consideration of Amendment to the City’s Alarm Ordinance
Chief Graham distributed a copy of the alarm ordinances from the City Code.
The Chief explained that when a fire alarm goes off, the Fire Department requires that some-
one must come to the location of the alarm to re-set it. Chief Graham related that several in-
stances have occurred recently when property owners could not be reached or refused to
come to the residence which means that fire personnel must remain at the scene for an indefi-
nite period of time and are unavailable for other emergencies that might occur. The ordinance
change that Chief Graham was seeking was to impose a fine of possible twenty-five dollars
($25.00) when the property owner is unreachable or refuses to come to the island to re-set the
alarm.
Lieutenant Wright noted that most alarms are both burglar and fire alarms and that the existing
ordinance refers to both and accords a property three (3) false alarms per calendar year with a
fine of fifty dollars ($50.00) for the fourth, fifth and sixth false alarm and one hundred dollars
($100.00) for any additional false alarms in a year . Alarm activations caused by natural disas-
ter, weather conditions, power failure, etc. are not considered false alarms.
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 6 of 9
Chief Graham read from Section 7.4.4(b) of the Code as follows:
All alarm businesses shall have personnel available to respond at the request of the Po
lice Department to any alarm location within thirty (30) minutes of notification.
Chief Graham repeated that too frequently the Police Department cannot contact anyone or
persons refuse to respond to the request.
When queried by Councilmember Loftus whether the problem Chief Graham was referencing
was with commercial properties or with rental properties on the island, the Chief explained that,
for rental properties, problems occur when trying to contact property managers because the
alarms typically do not activate during the daily business hours. Lieutenant Wright pointed out
that no penalty exists for not coming to the location to deactivate the alarm.
When asked what other communities are handling the problem, Chief Graham answered that
Mount Pleasant does have a fine attached to their ordinance.
The Committee asked that Chief Graham research how similar communities are responding to
this issue and report to the Committee at the next meeting.
B. Consideration of Amendment to the City’s Short-term Rental Business Li-
cense Application
Chief Graham distributed copies of the Short-te rm Residential Rental Application with a pro-
posed change on page 3; the change is an addition of the following:
E.8. Smoke Detector Requirement Each rental unit shall have working smoke detec-
tors installed per the International Fire Code Chapter 9, as adopted by the South Caro-
lina Building Code Council. Each unit shall have a working smoke detector in all sleep-
ing areas, all areas of travel for egress fr om the rental and any areas used as sleeping
quarters. All smoke detectors need batteries replaced twice yearly.
The Chief reported that she has discussed this addition with Building Director Kerr and that he
agrees that the section should be added to the application. He noted that the application pro-
cess is a one-time occurrence; therefore, any change would apply only to new applicants.
Additionally, Chief Graham commented that she had also discussed with Director Kerr a way of
updating the information on the rental licenses from phone numbers to changes in the property
itself, because the Fire Department has found, frequently, that “information in the computer
does not match the property.” Chief Graham noted that an emergency phone number is not
required to be on the placards that are in the rental units.
Councilmember Loftus expressed his opinion that the new requirement and a request for an
emergency phone number should be added to the rental renewal making it a requirement for all
of the rentals on the island.
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 7 of 9
Chief Graham was asked to work with the Building Director to derive a system for maintaining
current information on rental units that can become a normal part of the licensing process.
7. Executive Session, to receive legal advice
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to re-order the Agenda to go into
Executive Session to receive legal advice related to the Ordinance 2010-14 at this
juncture in the meeting at 6:31 p.m.; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Public Safety Committee returned to regular session at 6:50 p.m.; Chair Bettelli reported
that the Committee had not taken a vote or any other action while in Executive Session.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend to Council First Reading of Or
dinance 2010-14; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Councilmember Loftus stated that he could not support this ordinance because he believes it is
a property rights issue; however, he wanted to make his feelings clear that, should this ordi-
nance be adopted, it would not allow the City to remove the vessels that generated the discus-
sions that led to this ordinance being drafted. The Councilmember thanked resident Jim Ow-
ens for bringing the issue to the City’s attention.
Chair Bettelli remarked that the ordinance does not affect property rights as it does not allow
the City to go onto private property without the owner’s permission.
VOTE: The motion PASSED on a vote of 2 to 1 with Councilmember Loftus
casting the dissenting vote.
C. Contracts in Excess of $10,000
1. Award of Contract to Herndon Chevrolet for 3 Chevrolet Impalas at State
Contract Pricing of $19,957/each, or $57,871.00.
Councilmember Loftus queried Lieutenant Wright about the mileage on the vehicles being re-
tired; Lieutenant answered between one hundred and one hundred twenty-five thousand
(100,000 and 125,000). Councilmember Loftus then asked if the Police Department needed to
replace all three (3) vehicles or could it get by with replacing only two (2) in light of current eco-
nomic conditions; Lieutenant Wright responded tha t, according to Capital Plan, the Department
was scheduled to replace four (4) vehicles in FY10, but had opted to replace only three (3) be-
cause the fourth has lower mileage.
Councilmember Loftus suggested that the City cons ider a six and a half (6.5) year replacement
cycle for vehicles in hard economic times. Lieutenant Wright remarked that state contract pric-
ing is published once per year and that, generally, factories close one (1) week per year to
manufacture police vehicles. The Lieutenant also reminded the Committee that, if a vehicle is
ordered in November, it, typically, is not put on the road until March or April. Councilmember
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 8 of 9
Loftus stated that he would vote to support the motion to take it before Ways and Means, but,
at W&M, he plans to introduce the subject of lengthening replacement schedule.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to recommend to the Ways and Means Committee
to award a contract to Herndon Chevrolet for 3 Chevrolet Impalas at State con-
tract Pricing of $19.957/each or a total of $59,871; Councilmember Bergwerf se-
conded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
1. Award of Contract to Safe Industries for air packs in the amount of
$22,790.00.
Chief Graham explained this purchase represented the routine replacement of equipment for
the Fire Department, but, that the Department was changing the brand of air pack. The Chief
indicated that she had arranged to trade in eight (8) of the old ones for eight (8) new and was
buying four (4) additional air packs; the Department would then have twelve (12) in new packs.
Motion: Councilmember Bergwerf moved to recommend to the Ways and
Means Committee to award a contract to Safe Industries for air packs in the
amount of $22,790.00; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department Report – Chief Graham
Chief Graham related that the Department had responded to a brush fire at Sea Cabins on Oc-
tober 4 that had ignited in freshly laid pine straw that had blown into a light with a broken fix-
ture. In the month of October, the Department responded to a total of sixty-three (63) calls that
included thirty-four (34) EMS calls. The Fire Inspector conducted forty-six (46) inspections and
found a total of one hundred six (106) violations. Career personnel completed fourteen hun-
dred three and a half (1,403.5) hours of training while volunteers completed nearly four hun-
dred (400) hours of training. Chief Graham reported that hydrant flushing had been completed
in the month which required using over five hundred thousand (500,000) gallons of water.
On the Maintenance Report, Councilmember Loftus questioned that over one thousand dollars
($1,000) has been spent to replace a seat cover; Chief Graham explained that most of the
money had been spent in replacing the pump packing and that the entry should have shown
that expense first.
Councilmember Loftus complimented the Department on the public relations efforts put forth in
October.
Police Department Report – Lieutenant Wright
Lieutenant Wright began his comments by stating that nothing unusual had happened in the
month of October. Dispatchers received twenty-seven hundred thirty-three (2,733) calls, seven
hundred fifty-four (754) of which were for the Police Department. Officers made one hundred
sixty-six (166) traffic stops that resulted in sixty-six (66) tickets being issued.
Public Safety Committee
November 9, 2010
Page 9 of 9
Councilmember Loftus commented that he had been participated in Adopt a Highway through
the IOPNA; based on the volume of trash they picked up, he expressed the opinion that officers
should be writing more citations for littering. Lieutenant Wright explained that, often, an inci-
dence of littering will initiate a stop, but a more serious offense is found and becomes the inci-
dent that is reported; the Lieutenant added that an act of littering must be witnessed by the of-
ficer if the citation is to hold up in court.
Councilmember Loftus suggested that officers be rewarded for writing littering citations - maybe
eight (8) citations would earn an officer a restaurant gift card. Lieutenant Wright noted that to
do so would be tantamount to creating a quota syst em, but that he would speak to the officers
to be more vigilant about littering on the island.
In October, the Livability Sergeant wrote two (2) citations for business license violations and
four (4) warnings for roll-out cart violations.
Councilmember Loftus asked for the structure of the Livability Report could be changed to in-
clude the nature of the offense on the same page that indicates the addresses where the of-
fenses occur.
In addition, Councilmember Loftus commented that 3015 Waterway had an “unfounded” com-
plaint on October 8
th and a “founded” complaint on October 10 th. The Councilmember asked
Lieutenant Wright, when officers were dispatched to an address, whether they were informed
that officers had been sent to the same address recently, and the Lieutenant responded that
the dispatchers do related recent history to officers when dispatching them to a call.
Councilmember Loftus questioned two (2) complaints for 80 Forty-first Avenue on October 30;
Lieutenant Wright noted that the address is that of Morgan Creek Grill.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, January 11, 2011.
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to adjourn at 7:20 p.m.; Coun-
cilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.