Minutes
Oconee County · Oconee County · meeting of Jul 22, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Oconee County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes
6:00 PM – July 22, 2024
Members in Attendance
Will Decker – At Large Bill Gilster – District 3
Tim Mays – District 5
John Eagar – At Large
Jim Henderson – District 1
Gwen Fowler -District 2
Members Absent
Thomas James – District 4
Staff
James Coley
Logan Gibbons
ITEM 1 – Call to Order – Mr. Eagar called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM.
ITEM 2 – Motion to approve the minutes from June 24, 2024 – Mr. Mays made a
motion to approve the minutes; seconded by Mr. Decker. Mr. Eagar called for a vote.
The motion passed 4/0/2. Ms. Fowler and Mr. Henderson abstained
ITEM 3 – Brief statement about rules and procedures – Mr. Eagar outlined the
proceedings of the meeting going forward:
Applicant will provide a presentation to state their request (5 minutes).
Staff will be asked to make any comments regarding the request.
The public is allowed to voice their approval or opposition to the proposed.
Please do not repeat opinions that have already been stated into the record (3-5
minutes).
Applicant rebuttal
Board members will discuss in detail.
Voting
ITEM 4. Variance application #SE24-000001 for new communications tower.
Variance application: #VA24-000010 Duke Power Co. is requesting a 60-foot
increase to the 250-foot Industrial/agricultural height restriction for cell towers.
TMS 137-00-01-001 with an address of 7805 Rochester Hwy Seneca SC 29672. Ref.
Sec. 32-136
Applicant Comments:
Stated Name: Sarah Spruill from Haynsworth Sinkler Boyd, representing Duke Energy.
Ms. Spruill confirmed that the board had received the application prepared by Duke
Energy.
Ms. Spruill stated that Duke Energy is sought to build a 310 ft tower next to the Oconee
nuclear site, therefore needed a 60ft variance. She stated the parcel is zoned CFD. She
further stated that the parcel is over 110 acres and that the fall zone for the tower is
wholly contained within the parcel.
Ms. Spruill stated that the tower is needed for Duke Operation and point to point
communication. The height is required because of the limitations in the surrounding
topography.
Ms. Spruill explained that Duke Energy had looked for alternatives including co-location,
stealth design, and others but would not adequately satisfy their need.
Ms. Spruill explained that with board approval of the application the county would be
able to use the tower for emergency services.
Ms. Spruill further stated that this tower is consistent with the comprehensive plan and
is in the best interest of the county. No traffic or access issues because the tower is
contained fully within the property.
Staff comments:
Mr. Coley explained that the application is complete and that the county has no
objections to the application.
Public comment:
Applicant rebuttal:
NA.
Board Questions/ Discussion:
Mr. Gilster questioned about the safety of the tower.
- Ms. Spruill called up Patrick Bernier, senior project manager with Duke Energy.
- Mr. Bernier explained that this tower was a similar situation to an earlier hearing
regarding the tower at Bad Creek. He explained the intention is to increase safety
of line workers during storm recovery, and day to day operations.
- Mr. Bernier confirmed Duke’s intention to have county 911 services on the tower.
- Mr. Bernier explained that similar to the Bad creek tower, this tower is designed
to break in half before falling to minimize damage.
Mr. Eagar questioned if Duke had any intention to open the tower up to public phone
wireless use.
- Mr. Bernier explained that they are open to leasing tower space to any wireless
companies, and was unware of any pending applications for this tower.
Mr. Henderson complimented the thoroughness of the application.
- Ms Spruill explained that the tower was extremely important to duke energy.
Consideration of SE24-000001:
1. Is in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan and consistent with the spirit,
purpose, and the intent and specific requirements of this chapter, to include the
definition and intent of the district in which the Special Exemption is being
requested
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
2. Is in the best interests of the County, the convenience of the community and the
public welfare
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Mays. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
3. Is suitable for the property in question, and designed, constructed, operated and
maintained so as to be in harmony with and appropriate in appearance to the
existing or intended character of the general vicinity.
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
4. Is suitable in terms of effects on highway traffic, parking and safety with adequate
access arrangements to protect streets from undue congestion and hazards.
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Gilster. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
5. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the proposed special exception be Approved.
a. Motion – Mr. Decker made a motion; seconded by Mr. Mays. No
Discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that variance request was approved
Consideration of VA24-000010:
6. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular
piece of property:
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Mays. No discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
7. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity:
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
8. Because of these conditions, the application of this chapter to the particular piece
of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the
property.
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Mays. No discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
9. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
uses or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by
the granting of the variance.
a. Motion – Mr. Gilster made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
10. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the proposed variance be Approved.
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion; seconded by Mr. Henderson. No
Discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that variance request was approved
Item 5. ***This application was withdrawn from the 07/22/24 Agenda*** Variance
application: #VA24-000011 Jim Anthony of Falls Park Subdivision is seeking relief
from the 100-foot minimum between a curve and intersecting road right of way.
TMS 039-00-01-014 with an address of 105 Jocassee Landing Dr. Salem SC 29676
Ref. Sec. 26-3 (e) (3)
Mr Eagar asked why the application was left in the agenda.
- Mr. Coley explained that because of public interest the application was left for
clarity.
ITEM 6. Variance application: #VA24-000012 Devin Moeser is requesting a 6-
foot variance to the front setback. TMS 271-01-01-137 with an address of 34 Ulster
Dr. Seneca SC 29678. Ref. Sec. 38-10.2
Applicant Comments:
Stated Name: Devin Moeser, Development Manager, Core Spaces
Mr. Moeser explained that they had built over 200 new student housing, in which the
layout was designed based on the original survey that had done for the property. Upon
completion of the development, a new as-built survey was done. Mr. Moeser pointed out
that open discovery of the violation, he had self-reported.
Mr. Moeser explained that the issue had originally occurred because the first surveyor
assumed incorrectly that the road right of way curved with the road, instead of being a
point to point linear line.
Staff comments:
Mr. Coley showed that Ulster rd has a 66ft road right of way which condenses into a 50ft
right of way. He explained, that although the violation was not originally caught, core
self-reported the issue.
Public comment:
Applicant rebuttal:
NA.
Board Questions/ Discussion:
Consideration of VA24-000012:
1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular
piece of property:
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity:
a. Motion – Mr. Mays made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by Mr.
Henderson. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
3. Because of these conditions, the application of this chapter to the particular piece
of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the
property.
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Gilster. No discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
4. The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent
uses or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by
the granting of the variance.
a. Motion – Mr. Henderson made a motion in the affirmative, seconded by
Mr. Gilster. No Discussion
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that the criterion did pass.
5. Mr. Eagar asked – Based on the evidence presented to the Board, do I hear a
motion that the proposed variance be Approved.
a. Motion – Mr. Decker made a motion; seconded by Mr. Mays. No
Discussion.
b. Vote
In-favor Opposed
6 0
Mr. Eagar noted that variance request was approved
ITEM 8- Adjourn – Mr. Mays made a motion to adjourn, seconded by Mr. Henderson.
Mr. Eagar called for a vote. Motion passed unanimously 6/0.
Source: Oconee County website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.