Pickens County Council Committee of the Whole Meeting — Minutes
Pickens County · Pickens County · Mid Month Meeting · meeting of Oct 19, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Pickens County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL AS A WHOLE REPORT
1
Committee of the Whole Meeting Report – October 19, 2020
Council Members:
Roy Costner, Chairman
Chris Bowers, Vice Chairman
Wes Hendricks, Vice Chairman Pro-Tem
Carl Hudson
Trey Whitehurst
Ensley Feemster
Staff in Attendance:
Ken Roper, County Administrator
Meagan Nations, Clerk to Council
Les Hendricks, Contract Attorney
The Committee of the Whole met in the Main Conference Room, at the Pickens County Administration Facility, on
Monday, October 19, 2020, immediately following the special-called meeting. All members of the committee were
in attendance, with Chairman Roy Costner presiding.
WELCOME AND CALL TO ORDER:
Chairman Roy Costner called the Committee of the Whole meeting to order.
COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE:
Chairman Roy Costner stated the meeting will begin with Log No. 151 – AN ORDINANCE NO. 590 AMENDING THE
UNIFORM ORDINANCE FOR FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICTS (AS PREVIOUSLY ENACTED BY ORDINANCE NO. 404, AS
AMENDED BY ORDINANCE NO. 405 AND ORDINANCE NO. 571) TO CONSOLIDATE CERTAIN EXISTING FEE PAYOR FIRE
PROTECTION DISTRICTS THROUGH THE CREATION OF A NEW UNIFIED FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT; AND OTHER
MATTERS RELATING THERETO.
AN ORDINANCE NO. 590 AMENDING THE UNIFORM ORDINANCE FOR FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICTS (AS PREVIOUSLY
ENACTED BY O RDINANCE NO. 404, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE NO. 405 AND ORDINANCE NO. 571) TO
CONSOLIDATE CERTAIN EXISTING FEE PAYOR FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICTS THROUGH THE CREATION OF A NEW
UNIFIED FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT; AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING THERETO. – Log No. 151
Mr. Roper stated first reading of this Ordinance was on September 14, 2020, second reading was on
October 5, 2020 and the public hearing/third reading is scheduled for November 2, 2020. He stated
these are the legal requirements for passing this ordinance. Mr. Roper stated discussion on this issue
took place during the Committee of the Whole meetings on September 21 st and this evening, October
19th. He stated the Emergency Services Board has also discussed this at their meeting on October 15,
2020. He state d we have had some newspaper coverage, Facebook live video, set up the FREE room,
fire fee survey online and in paper form in the FREE room. He stated Billy Gibson spoke of this issue at
the Conservative of the Upstate meeting on October 8 th, and there wer e three public fire fee meetings
at three different fire stations in October. Mr. Roper advised that Staff has communicated more on this
proposal than anything else he can think of in memory. Mr. Roper discussed the survey results to
Council, stating 75 ci tizens took the survey.
Councilman Carl Hudson stated when will we know the exact fee schedule for the new fire fees based
on the square footage of these homes.
Mr. Roper stated we will not know the fee at this point, because that is determined in the annual
budget. He stated this ordinance, as it exists now, does not address this. He stated in the spring, the
way we have proposed this, Council will look at expens es that they deem appropriate and they will set
the fee. He stated the way that would break down is something Council will decide.
Councilman Carl Hudson stated that could have a big input on the public’s support for this.
COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL AS A WHOLE REPORT
2
Committee of the Whole Meeting Report – October 19, 2020
Vice Chairman Chris Bowers stat ed if we go by the Berkeley County model that staff presented a couple
of months ago, we do have an idea of what the fire fee schedule would be like.
Councilman Whitehurst stated he likes the idea of having the fee schedule in the ordinance as a base.
He stated we can put a base in there of a neutral number.
Chairman Costner states all the ordinance does is change the structure, and when we get to the
budgeting process, we will look at the numbers based on the square footage.
Councilman Carl Hudson state d before moving forward on third reading and public hearing, he would
like to know some numbers. He stated if we do not inform the public without them not knowing a
ballpark of what the fee will be, we will not get support for it.
After much more discussion between Council and the Administrator, Vice Chairman Chris Bowers made
a motion that we move this out of Committee, taking in the amendments that are noted in red,
addressing the city issues for Liberty, Six Mile, Central and Eas ley, as it is stated in this amended
ordinance, and to also add the amendment titled “Fee Schedule”, making note that this would be a
sample of what this current year levied fees would be. Chairman Costner seconded the motion and
carried unanimously (6 -0).
Vice Chairman Chris Bowers made a motion that we move this out of Committee for third reading,
taking in the amendments that are noted in red in the ordinance , addressing the city issues for
Liberty, Six Mile, Central and Easley, as it is stated in this amended ordinance, and to also add the
amendment titled “Fee Schedule”, making note that this would be a sample of what this current
year levied fees would be. Chairman Costner seconded the motion and carried unanimously (6 -0).
2ND AMENDMENT SANCTUARY PROPOSAL – Log No. 159
Mr. Hendricks presented an attorney client interoffice memorandum to Council. He stated one of the things
that was clear to himself was that this Council fully supports the Second Amendment. Mr. Hendricks stated
we have all sworn an oath to the Constitution of the United States and that is the law of the land. He stated
the U.S. Constitution does not mention local governments, instead, the 10th amendment reserves authority-
giving powers to the states. He stated the states then provide authority to locals. Mr. Hendricks stated that
South Carolina is a “home-rule state.” He explained that home-rule limits the degree of state interference
in local affairs and delegates power from the state to local government. He stated that power is limited to
specific fields, and subject to constant judicial interpretation. He advised regardless of whether a state is a
home-rule state or another form, state law supersedes local governing authority. Mr. Hendricks advised that
the Home-Rule act quotes, “all counties of the state have authority to enact regulations, resolutions and
ordinances, not inconsistent with the Constitution and general law of the State…” He st ated that South
Carolina expressed exclusive jurisdiction over gun rights, which is Section 23 -31-510, “Regulation of
ownership, transfer, or possession of firearm or ammunition. No governing body of any county,
municipality, or other political subdivision in the State may enact or promulgate any regulation or ordinance
that regulates or attempts to regulate: (1) the transfer, ownership, possession, carrying, or transportation
of firearms, ammunition, components of firearms, or any combination of these things;” Mr. Hendricks stated
the state has taking the regulations of firearms in South Carolina as its own jurisdiction. He stated there are
counties that have passed resolutions and ordinances. He stated the ordinances do different things, for
example, Anderson County delegates some responsibility to individuals in Anderson County to determine
whether or not the Second Amendment is applicable in certain laws. He stated one of the problems is that
creates a potential liability for the County. He stated a county ordinance providing the Sheriff discretion to
interpret state and federal laws and regulations potentially places liability on the Sheriff and the county,
both those aggrieved by enforcing the laws and by those wherein laws were not enforced. After more
discussion, Mr. Hendricks stated one means Pickens County Council can do to support the Second
Amendment for localities is to pass resolutions. He stated resolutions are non-binding, but offer a means to
provide a viewpoint of the current county council. With new county council members beginning in January
2021, the council may want to update their resolution that the new council either supports or does not
COMMITTEE OF COUNCIL AS A WHOLE REPORT
3
Committee of the Whole Meeting Report – October 19, 2020
support the second amendment.
Councilman Carl Hudson stated Pickens County Council has no control over the Sheriff of Pickens County.
He stated the Sheriff of Pickens County can enforce laws at his discretion. He stated we cannot tell the Sheriff
to enforce this law, or not enforce this law. He stated by passing an ordinance of the Second Amendment,
at least it lets the Sheriff know where we stand as a county government. He stated local people can have an
impact because when the Brady Bill was passed many years ago, Federal Government came out with very
strict rules about telling local law enforcement what they had to do. After more discussion, Councilman
Hudson stated Pickens County Council cannot tell the Sheriff of Pickens County how to do his job. He stated
he does not know how much liability we would have if we aren’t able to tell the Sheriff what to do. He stated
we are letting our Sheriff know if something comes along and it is not right, and you stand up against it, that
this is how we feel and where we stand on the Second Amendment.
Chairman Costner stated there is a lot of fear in the country right now and he understands the passion. He
stated his concern is that he is not voting on anything that is illegal. He stated the attorney stated it is not
illegal. Chairman Costner stated the law already exists, we are just voting on a law that already exists. He
stated if it is going to make people feel better, he is all for it.
Councilman Whitehurst stated he does not believe in doing stuff just for political show. He stated if we pass
this ordinance, it does not do anything for the Sheriff. He stated this ordinance does not carry any authority.
He stated the role of government is to do what government needs to do, not just to make someone feel
good. He stated the state has the authority over gun control in South Carolina, not the counties. He stated
we passed a resolution on support of the Second Amendment, which he strongly agreed with, but he does
not agree on passing something that we have no authority on.
After much more discussion, Councilman Carl Hudson made a motion to move out of Committee for second
reading, then recommit back to the Committee for further discussion. Motion was seconded by Vice
Chairman Chris Bowers and carried 5-1, with Councilman Trey Whitehurst opposed.
Councilman Carl Hudson made a motion to move out of Committee for second reading, then recommit
back to the Committee for further discussion. Motion was seconded by Vice Chairman Chris Bowers and
carried 5-1, with Councilman Trey Whitehurst opposed.
SOLAR FARM ORDINANCE – Log No. 132
No Action Taken by the Committee.
ADJOURN:
Hearing no further Committee business, Chairman Roy Costner called for a motion to adjourn.
Motion was made by Vice Chairman Chris Bowers , seconded by Councilman Wes Hendricks and carried
unanimously (6-0).
Source: Pickens County website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.