Historic Preservation Commission Meeting - SPECIAL MEETING — Agenda Packet
Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of May 19, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting - SPECIAL MEETING
Monday, May 19, 2025 at 5:00 PM
Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers,
20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC
AGENDA
I. CALL TO ORDER
II. ROLL CALL
III. NOTICE REGARDING ADJOURNMENT
The Historic Preservation Commission will not hear new items after 9:30 p.m. unless authorized by
a majority vote of the Commission Members present. Items which have not been heard before
9:30 p.m. may be continued to the next regular meeting or a special meeting date as determined
by the Commission Members.
IV. PUBLIC COMMENT
V. OLD BUSINESS
VI. NEW BUSINESS
1. 4 Tabby Shell: A request by Joseph DePauw (DePauw Architects), on behalf of owners, Steve
and Jill Duncan, for review of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District, to allow
enclosure of an existing screen porch to create a Carolina room of approximately 204 SF on
the Main Residence located at 4 Tabby Shell Road, Lot 4, in the Tabby Roads Development.
The property is located in the Old Town Historic District and is zoned Neighborhood General-
Historic District. (COFA-03-25-019649) (Staff - Charlotte Moore)
VII. DISCUSSION
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
Page 1
Town of Bluffton, SCHistoric Preservation Commission Meeting - SPECIAL MEETING Agenda May 19, 2025
“FOIA Compliance – Public notification of this meeting has been published and posted in compliance
with the Freedom of Information Act and the Town of Bluffton policies.”
In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the
Town of Bluffton will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of
disability in its services, programs, or activities. The Town of Bluffton Council Chambers are ADA
compatible. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation
should contact the Town of Bluffton ADA Coordinator at 843.706.4500 or
adacoordinator@townofbluffton.com as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the
scheduled event.
Executive Session – The public body may vote to go into executive session for any item identified for
action on the agenda.
*Please note that each member of the public may speak at one public comment session and a form must
be filled out and given to the Town Clerk. To submit a public comment online, please click here:
https://www.townofbluffton.sc.gov/FormCenter/Town-15/Public-Comment-60
Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per speaker.
Page 2
4 Tabby Shell Road – Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission
HISTORIC PRESERVATION
COMMISSION
STAFF REPORT
Department of Growth Management
MEETING DATE: May 19, 2025 (Special Meeting)
PROJECT:
COFA-03-25-019649
4 Tabby Shell Road, Lot 4 (Tabby Roads Development)
Enclosure of an Existing Screened Porch
APPLICANT: Joe DePauw (DePauw Architects)
PROPERTY OWNERS: Jill and Steve Duncan
PROJECT MANAGER: Charlotte Moore, AICP, Principal Planner
APPLICATION REQUEST: The Applicant requests that the Historic Preservation
Commission approve the following:
A Certificate of Appropriateness -Historic Distric t to allow enclosure of a n
existing screened porch to create a Carolina Room of approximately 204 SF
at the Main Residence located at 4 Tabby Shell Road , Lot 4 (Parcel R610 039
000 1184 0000) in the Tabby Roads Development. The property is in Old Town
Historic District and is zoned Neighborhood General -Historic District (NG -
HD).
INTRODUCTION: The existing screened porch enclosure is in the rear, southeast corner of
the existing residence and is located underneath the main roof mass . Enclosure of the
patio to a conditioned space will increase the square footage of the house from 1,166
square feet to 1,370 square feet , which is less than the 1,800 square foot maximum
permitted for a Vernacular House building type. To properly condition the enclosed space,
a small mini-split system would be installed in the side yard and screened.
As shown on Page A101 of Attachment 5, the walls on the rear (south) and left (east)
elevations would primarily consist of double -hung, clad wood windows. While casement
windows are used elsewhere, they include a simulated sash bar and are similar in
appearance to the proposed double -hung windows. The windows will be surrounded by
Hardie trim and panels that would include 1x4 Hardie sticking beneath the windows . On
the left elevation, the existing screen door would be replaced by a wood casement door
beneath a transom window.
This project was presented to the Historic Preservation Review Committee (HPRC) for
conceptual review at the April 7, 2025 meeting. HPRC comments are provided as
Attachment 6. It was suggested that the door/transom window combination be changed to
Page 3
Section VI. Item #1.
May 19, 2025 Page 2
4 Tabby Shell Road - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission
an 8’ -0” door. The reasoning for maintaining this configuration is explained by the
Applicant in Attachment 2.
As the mini -split system was a late addition to the plans, screening details must be
provided to ensure compliance with UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.9.
REVIEW CRITERIA & ANALYSIS: In its review of this COFA -HD application, Town Staff and
the Historic Preservation Commission are required to consider the criteria set forth in
Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Section 3.18.3 (COFA-HD, Application Review
Criteria), applying the standards and guidelines of UDO Sec. 5.15, Old Town Bluffton
Historic District. The intent of the standards and guidelines is, in part, to provide guidance
and ensure consistent development without discouraging creativity or forcing the
replication of historic models.
The applicable criteria of UDO Sec.3.18.3 are provided below followed by a Staff Finding
based upon review of the application submittals to date.
1. Section 3.18.3.B. Consistency with the principles set forth in the Old Town
Master Plan.
a. Finding. The application is consistent with the principles set forth in the Old
Town Master Plan. The Old Town Master Plan states that “The built
environment, in particular the historic structures scattered throughout Old
Town, should be protected and enhanced. While it is of great importance to
save and restore historic structures, it is just as important to add to the built
environment in a way that makes Old Town more complete.”
Old Town Bluffton Historic District is a locally designated historic district . The
proposed enclosure has been designed to be sympathetic to the architectural
character of the neighboring structures.
b. Finding. The Old Town Master Plan initiatives also include the adoption of a
form-based code that included architectural standards for structures located
within the Old Town Bluffton Historic District. These standards are included in
Article 5 of the UDO. The enclosure will be in conformance with those standards
if the conditions noted in #2 of this Section are met.
c. Finding. The Old Town Master Plan initiatives also promote preservation and
protection of the legacy of the Old Town Bluffton Historic District through
additions to the built environment which make Old Town more complete. The
enclosure will not deviate from these principles.
Page 4
Section VI. Item #1.
May 19, 2025 Page 3
4 Tabby Shell Road - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission
2. Section 3.18.3.C. The application must be in conformance with applicable
provisions provided in Article 5, Design Standards.
a. Finding. Town Staff finds that if the condition s noted below are met, the
proposed enclosure will be in conformance with applicable provisions provided
in Article 5:
1) (UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.9) Provide screening details for the mini-split system
to ensure compliance with the UDO.
3. Section 3.18.3.D. Consistency with the nature and character of the surrounding
area and consistency of the structure with the scale, form and building
proportions of the surrounding neighborhood.
Finding. The proposed enclosure complies with this condition.
4. Section 3.18.3.F. The historic, architectural, and aesthetic features of the
structure, including the extent to which its alteration or removal would be
detrimental to the public interest.
Finding. If the conditions #2 of this report are met, the proposed plans are
sympathetic in design to the neighboring non -historic resources; therefore, the
enclosure will have no adverse effect on the public interest.
5. Section 3.18.3.H. The application must comply with the applicable
requirements in the Applications Manual.
Finding. The Certificate of Appropriateness Application has been reviewed by Town
Staff and has been determined to be complete except for the applicable items in #2.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: It is the charge of the HPC to assess and interpret the
standards and guidelines set forth in the U DO as they pertain to applications using the
review criteria established in the UDO and to take appropriate action as granted by the
powers and duties set forth in Section 2.2.6.E.2. Town Staff finds that with the condition
noted below , the requirements of Section 3.18.3 of the Unified Development Ordinance
have been met and recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission approve the
application with the following condition:
1. Provide screening details for the mini -split system to ensure compliance
with UDO Sec. 5.15.5.F.9.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION ACTIONS: As granted by the powers and duties
set forth in Section 2.2.6.E.2, the Historic Preservation Commission has the authority to
take the following actions with respect to this application:
Page 5
Section VI. Item #1.
May 19, 2025 Page 4
4 Tabby Shell Road - Certificate of Appropriateness Historic Preservation Commission
1. Approve the application as submitted by the Applicant;
2. Approve the application with conditions; or
3. Deny the application as submitted by the Applicant.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Location and Zoning Map
2. Cover Letter
3. Final Application
4. Photos-Existing Conditions
5. Final Plans
6. HPRC Comments
7. Tabby Roads HARB Approval
Page 6
Section VI. Item #1.
LOCATION & ZONING MAP
4 Tabby Shell Road
Neighborhood General-HD District
Page 7
Section VI. Item #1.
April 8, 2025
Growth Management Service Center
20 Bridge Street
Bluffton, SC 29910
Re: Final COA-HD Submission
COFA-03-25-019646
A Porch Enclosure for the Duncan Residence
4 Tabby Shell Road
Bluffton, SC 29910
Charlotte,
In support of our Final COA-HD submission for the Porch Enclosure for the Duncan
Residence, we are providing the following project narrative.
Narrative Introduction
We are proposing to enclose the existing screened porch with framed walls
and windows to create a conditioned Carolina Room.
Zoning & Building Type
The property is zoned Neighborhood General-HD and the property has
platted setbacks. While the extents of the building footprint will not change
as a result of the proposed renovations, we are increasing the conditioned
footprint (excluding porches) from 1,166 sq. ft. to 1,370 sq. ft. The home will
continue to comply with the Vernacular House Building type (1,800 sq. ft.
maximum footprint, 1.5 story massing, and 1,600-2,800 sq. ft. size range).
Materials
The walls of the newly enclosed Carolina Room will be finished with a panel
detail above and below the new windows. As shown on sheet A501, the panels
will be of Hardiepanel with the sticking of Hardietrim. The panel finish allows
for a clean connection to the existing siding and a nod to the history of the
room as a screened porch. The new windows will be double hungs to
complement the existing windows.
Page 8
Section VI. Item #1.
In addition, we are providing the below responses to the comments received during
HPRC review:
1. Suggest changing the 3' x 8' instead of 6'-8" plus transom above to match
existing conditions
a. The design was originally considered with an 8’-0” door, but the
decision to use a 6’-8” door and transom combination was multi-
faceted. (1) The door is in the back of the home, well removed from
the front porch, so it will not be viewed in context with the front door.
(2) The door and transom combination with flanking tall double hung
windows is a traditional construction pattern. (3) There is a sizeable
step down into the porch. Using the door and transom combination,
we can bring the windows in Carolina Room to the height of the
existing windows. (4) There are cost efficiencies to the door and
transom combination, which are important to the feasibility of the
project. This has already received final approval from the Tabby Roads
HARB.
2. The new door is called out as a sliding door in the renovation plan but shown
as a swinging door in the same drawing and elevation. The door is also called
out as 3’x8’ in the plan but shown in the elevation and schedule at 6’x8’ with
transom. Suggest that the door be 3’x8’ to match existing conditions.
a. See notes above.
3. The infill framing detail has a callout for hardiplank lap siding; only panel and
trim are shown in the elevation.
a. The detail has been revised to remove the stray note. Only
Hardiepanel and Hardietrim will be used.
4. The plan identifies casement windows; however, the elevation and narrative
show double hung windows “to match existing windows.” The existing
windows shown in the same elevation have hinge markers, suggesting
casement function. Clarification needed.
a. The existing windows are casements with a simulated sash bar to
mimic double hung windows. The previous owner was seeking an
energy efficient goal and casements have a tighter air seal. The
current owners prefer the operation of a true double hung for this
room. As it is a built-in porch this is a good opportunity to provide this
very slight difference in appearance. This has already received final
approval from the Tabby Roads HARB.
5. The window head detail calls out hardie panel above the head trim; the
elevation shows trim instead of panel.
a. The panels above the windows removed by the change to the door-
transom combination. This detail has been revised.
Page 9
Section VI. Item #1.
6. In the plan, elevations, and details, 1x4 hardie trim is specified, but the
elevations show a smaller vertical mull trim between windows.
a. The window on the left elevation where this was true has been
changed to match the other window mulls with 1x4 hardietrim stiles.
We look forward to the HPC’s review. If you require additional information about the
project ahead of the meeting, please let me know.
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Lydia DePauw, AIA
Principal, DePauw Architects
Page 10
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 11
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 12
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 13
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 14
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 15
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 16
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 17
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 18
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 19
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 20
Section VI. Item #1.
Page 21
Section VI. Item #1.
10'-0" ACCESS EASEMENT
3'-0" ACCESSORYSTRUCTURE SETBACK
1A101SITE PLAN3/16" = 1'-0"
VICINITY MAPSITE
7'-6" BUILDING SETBACK
7'-6" BUILDING SETBACK
EXISTING ALLEY GRADING TO REMAIN
EXISTING ABOVERAINWATERSTORAGE BARRELSCOPE OF WORK
EXISTINGSTORAGEEXISTINGPAVILIONEXISTINGPORCH
SCREENED PORCHTO BE ENCLOSED204 SQ. FT.
NEW EQUIP.ENCLOSURE
2'-10"GROUND CONTACTTR. 5/4x6'S W/ 1" GAPGROUND CONTACTTR. 4x4 POSTSET POST INCONCRETE6" OF # 57 STONEIN FILTER CLOTH
EXTERIORINTERIORTR. 2x6 TOP CAP- SLOPE TO DRAINTOWARDSINTERIOR OF YARD
2A101SERVICE ENCLOSURE1" = 1'-0"
A101SITE PLANSHEETPROJECT NO.CONTACTDATE
C COPYRIGHT 2025 DePAUW ARCHITECTS LLCTHIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF THE ARCHITECTAND IS NOT TO BE REPRODUCED IN WHOLE OR INPART BY ANY MEANS OR METHOD WITHOUT THEEXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT.ANY UNAUTHORIZED REPRODUCTION OR REUSE OFTHESE DOCUMENTS WILL RESULT IN LEGAL ACTION.
REVISIONS
NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONA PORCH ENCLOSURE FORTHE DUNCAN RESIDENCE
4.28.20254 TABBY SHELL ROADTABBY ROADSBLUFFTON, SC 299102502LRD
BUILDING CODES:INTERNATIONAL RESIDENTIAL CODE:2021(ALL CODES WITH SOUTH CAROLINA MODIFICATIONS)
DRAWING INDEX:SHEET #SHEET DESCRIPTION
4/23/2025 FORREVIEWARCHITECTURALAS101SITE PLAN■ AD101DEMOLITION PLANS■ A101RENOVATION PLANS■ A501DETAILED SECTIONS■ STRUCTURAL
NOTES: ABANCHOR BOLTABVABOVEAFFABOVE FINISH FLOORASFABOVE SUB-FLOORA/CAIR CONDITIONERAHUAIR HANDLING UNITALUMALUMINUMAMSLABOVE MEAN SEA LEVELAPPROXAPPROXIMATEBDBOARDBFBI-FOLDBLKGBLOCKINGBLDGBUILDINGB.O.BOTTOM OFBODBASIS OF DESIGNBRGBEARINGBTWBETWEENCABCABINETCANTCANTILEVERCENCENTERCJCEILING JOISTCLCENTERLINECLOSCLOSETCLGCEILINGCMCASEMENTCOCASED OPENINGCOLCOLUMNCONCCONCRETECTCERAMIC TILEDBLDOUBLEDEMODEMOLISHDHDOUBLE HUNGDIADIAMETERDIMDIMENSIONDISTDISTANCEDNDOWNDRDOORDWDISHWASHERDWGDRAWINGEAEACHELEVELEVATIONELECELECTRICALEQEQUALEQUIPEQUIPMENTEXSTEXISTINGEXTEXTERIORFDFLOOR DRAINFDNFOUNDATIONFFFIRST FLOORFFEFINISH FLOOR ELEVATIONFINFINISHFIXFIXTUREFLUORFLUORESCENTFLRFLOORFRZFREEZERFRMGFRAMINGFTFEETFTGFOOTINGGAGAUGEGALVGALVANIZEGLGLASSGYPGYPSUMGWBGYPSUM WALL BOARDHBHOSE BIBBHDRHEADERHORIZHORIZONTALHTHEIGHTININCHINCLINCLUDEINSULINSULATIONINTINTERIORJSTJOISTJNTJOINT
KSKNEE SPACELAMLAMINATELLLIVE LOADLTLIGHTLINLINENMAMASONITEMASMASONRYMAXMAXIMUMMECHMECHANICALMEDMEDIUMMFRMANUFACTURERMIDMIDDLEMINMINIMUMMISCMISCELLANEOUSMULMULLIONN/ANOT APPLICABLEN.I.C.NOT IN CONTRACTNTSNOT TO SCALEOCON CENTEROHOVERHANGOPNGOPENINGOSBORIENTED STRAND BOARDPEMBPRE-ENGINEERED METALBLDGPLPLATEPNLPANELPNTPAINTPRPAIRPTPRESSURE TREATEDPVCPOLYVINLYCHLORIDEPVMTPAVEMENTPLYPLYWOODPWDRPOWDER ROOMRRISERR & SROD & SHELFRAGRETURN AIR GRILLREFREFRIGERATORREQ'DREQUIREDRMROOMRVRIDGE VENTSCHEDSCHEDULESECTSECTIONSFSQUARE FEETSHSHELFSIMSIMILARSPECSPECIFICATIONSFSQUARE FEETSTDSTANDARDSTLSTEELSTORSTORAGESYSSYSTEMTTREADT.O.TOP OFTRTRANSOMT & GTONGUE & GROOVETELTELEPHONETEMPTEMPORARY/TEMPERATURETHKTHICKTVTELEVISIONTYPTYPICALUCUNDER-COUNTERUNFINUNFINISHEDU.N.O.UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISEVBVAPOR BARRIERVERVERIFYV.I.F.VERIFY IN FIELDVERTVERTICALWDWOODW/DWASHER-DRYERWHWATER HEATER
ABBREVIATIONS:NOTICE TO PERMITTING AUTHORITY & BUILDING OWNER REGARDING CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATIONSERVICES:THE SEALING ARCHITECT AND THE FIRM OF RECORD HAVE NOT BEEN ENGAGED TO PERFORM THEMINIMUM CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION SERVICES, AS DEFINED IN SC CODE OF REGULATIONSCHAPTER 11-12.B(5).ARCHITECT OF RECORD IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR INTERPRETING THE INTENT OF THECONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS INCLUDING MAKING MODIFICATIONS AS MAY BE NECESSARY DURINGTHE CONSTRUCTION PHASE; AND THE ARCHITECT OF RECORD IS NO LONGER LIABLE FOR THE WORKWHERE CHANGES TO THESE DOCUMENTS HAVE BEEN MADE.GENERAL NOTES:THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENTS ARE TO BE USED FOR DESIGN INTENT AND IN COORDINATION WITHSUPPLEMENTAL ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS.SEE STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS FOR STRUCTURAL CONNECTION TECHNIQUES, CALCULATIONSREQUIRED BY CODE, CODE COMPLIANCE INSTRUCTIONS FOR WALL AND ROOF CONSTRUCTION, AND TIEDOWN REQUIREMENTS.WHEN ARCHITECTURAL DRAWINGS ARE IN CONFLICT WITH ENGINEERING DRAWINGS, THE GENERALCONTRACTOR SHALL REQUEST CLARIFICATION FROM THE ARCHITECT BEFORE PROCEEDING.CONTRACTOR WILL VERIFY ALL EXISTING CONDITIONS IN THE FIELD- ANY DISCREPANCIES WILL BE BROUGHTTO THE ATTENTION OF THE ARCHITECT.FOR DIMENSIONS NOT SHOWN OR IN QUESTION, THE CONTRACTOR WILL REQUEST CLARIFICATION FROMTHE ARCHITECT BEFORE PROCEEDING.THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENTS HAVE BEEN PREPARED SPECIFICALLY AND SOLELY FOR THE PROJECT NAMEDHEREIN. THEY ARE NOT SUITABLE FOR USE ON OTHER PROJECTS OR IN OTHER LOCATIONS WITHOUT THEPARTICIPATION OF THE ARCHITECT. REPRODUCTION IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. THE ARCHITECT SHALL BEDEEMED THE AUTHOR AND OWNER OF THESE DOCUMENTS AND SHALL RETAIN COMMON LAW, STATUTORYAND OTHER RESERVED RIGHTS, INCLUDING THE COPYRIGHT AS DEFINED UNDER SECTION 102 OF THECOPYRIGHT ACT (TITLE 17 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE).DIMENSION NOTES:ALL DIMENSIONS ARE TO EDGE OF SLAB, BLOCK, & FRAMING OR COLUMN CENTERLINE U.O.N.PLUMBING NOTES:G.C. TO COORDINATE ALL IN-SLAB ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING REQUIREMENTS WITH APPROPRIATESUBCONTRACTORS PRIOR TO PLACING SLAB. G.C./OWNER TO COORDINATE LOCATION OF EXTERIOR HOSEBIBBS.FOUNDATION NOTES:SEE STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS FOR SIZE, LAYOUT, AND SPACING OF STRUCTURAL MEMBERS &REINFORCING, AND CONNECTION DETAILS.SUPPORT REINFORCING DURING CONCRETE PLACEMENT PER IRC R506.2.4.FRAMING NOTES:SEE STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING DOCUMENTS FOR SIZE, LAYOUT, AND SPACING OF STRUCTURAL MEMBERS,AND CONNECTION DETAILS.
DICIPLINEFIRMLICENSE NO.PHONE NO.ArchitecturalDePauw Architects101468843-284-7848Structural---DESIGNERS OF RECORD:
MAIN HOUSEFIRST FLOOR:EXISTINGADDEDNEW TOTALHEATED & COOLED:1,166 SF204 SF1,370 SFCOVERED & ENCLOSED:395 SF(204 SF)191 SFSECOND FLOOR:HEATED & COOLED:720 SF0 SF720 SFCOVERED & ENCLOSED:0 SF0 SF0 SFTOTAL MAIN HOUSE:HEATED & COOLED:1,886 SF204 SF2,090 SFCOVERED & ENCLOSED:395 SF(204 SF)191 SF
FLOOR AREA CALCULATIONS:
Page 22
Section VI. Item #1.
N
REMOVE SCREEN FRAMES
REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW
REMOVE COLUMN
REMOVECOLUMNSREMOVE DOORREMOVESCREEN FRAMESREMOVECOLUMNSREMOVEDOORREMOVESCREENFRAMES
REMOVE COLUMNREMOVESCREEN FRAMES
STRUCTURALCOLUMN TO REMAIN1AD101FIRST FLOOR DEMO PLAN1/4" = 1'-0"3AD101DEMO LEFT ELEVATION1/4" = 1'-0"
2AD101DEMO REAR ELEVATION1/4" = 1'-0"
REMOVE:DETACH ITEMS FROM EXISTING CONSTRUCTION AND DISPOSEOF THEM OFF-SITE UNLESS INDICATED TO BE SALVAGED ORREINSTALLED.REMOVE & SALVAGE:DETACH ITEMS FROM EXISTING CONSTRUCTION, IN A MANNERTO PREVENT DAMAGE, AND STORE.REMOVE & REINSTALL:DETACH ITEMS FROM EXISTING CONSTRUCTION, IN A MANNERTO PREVENT DAMAGE, PREPARE FOR REUSE, AND REINSTALLWHERE INDICATED.EXISTING TO REMAIN:LEAVE EXISTING ITEMS THAT ARE NOT TO BE REMOVED ANDTHAT ARE NOT OTHERWISE INDICATED TO BE SALVAGED ORREINSTALLED.DISMANTLE:TO REMOVE BY DISASSEMBLING OR DETACHING AN ITEMFROM A SURFACE, USING GENTLE METHODS AND EQUIPMENTTO PREVENT DAMAGE TO THE ITEM AND SURFACES;DISPOSING OF ITEMS UNLESS INDICATED TO BE SALVAGED ORREINSTALLED.
1.UNLESS OTHERWISE INDICATED, DEMOLITION WASTE BECOMESPROPERTY OF CONTRACTOR.2.NOTIFY ARCHITECT OF DISCREPANCIES BETWEEN EXISTING CONDITIONSAND DRAWINGS BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH SELECTIVE DEMOLITION.3.STORAGE OR SALE OF REMOVED ITEMS OR MATERIALS ON-SITE IS NOTPERMITTED.4.UTILITY SERVICE: MAINTAIN EXISTING UTILITIES INDICATED TO REMAIN INSERVICE AND PROTECT THEM AGAINST DAMAGE DURING SELECTIVEDEMOLITION OPERATIONS.5.TEMPORARY SHORING: DESIGN, PROVIDE, AND MAINTAIN SHORING,BRACING, AND STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS AS REQUIRED TO PRESERVESTABILITY AND PREVENT MOVEMENT, SETTLEMENT, OR COLLAPSE OFCONSTRUCTION AND FINISHES TO REMAIN, AND TO PREVENTUNEXPECTED OR UNCONTROLLED MOVEMENT OR COLLAPSE OFCONSTRUCTION BEING DEMOLISHED. STRENGTHEN OR ADD NEWSUPPORTS WHEN REQUIRED DURING PROGRESS OF SELECTIVEDEMOLITION.6.REMOVE DEMOLITION WASTE MATERIALS FROM PROJECT SITE ANDDISPOSE OF THEM IN AN EPA-APPROVED CONSTRUCTION ANDDEMOLITION WASTE LANDFILL ACCEPTABLE TO AUTHORITIES HAVINGJURISDICTION. DO NOT ALLOW DEMOLISHED MATERIALS TO ACCUMULATEON-SITE. REMOVE AND TRANSPORT DEBRIS IN A MANNER THAT WILLPREVENT SPILLAGE ON ADJACENT SURFACES AND AREAS.
SELECTIVE DEMOLITION DEFINITIONSSELECTIVE DEMOLITION NOTES
SCREENED PORCHREMOVE SCONCES -SWITCH TO BE REUSED FORNEW RECESSED LIGHTINGREMOVE BEADBOARD CEILINGREMOVE LAP SIDING FROM WALLS
SCOPEOF WORK
SCOPEOF WORKSCOPE OF WORKAD101DEMOLITION PLANSSHEETPROJECT NO.CONTACTDATE
C COPYRIGHT 2025 DePAUW ARCHITECTS LLCTHIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF THE ARCHITECTAND IS NOT TO BE REPRODUCED IN WHOLE OR INPART BY ANY MEANS OR METHOD WITHOUT THEEXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT.ANY UNAUTHORIZED REPRODUCTION OR REUSE OFTHESE DOCUMENTS WILL RESULT IN LEGAL ACTION.
REVISIONS
NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONA PORCH ENCLOSURE FORTHE DUNCAN RESIDENCE
4.28.20254 TABBY SHELL ROADTABBY ROADSBLUFFTON, SC 299102502LRD
Page 23
Section VI. Item #1.
N
3A101RENOVATED LEFT ELEVATION1/4" = 1'-0"
2A101RENOVATED REAR ELEVATION1/4" = 1'-0"
NEW DOUBLEHUNG WINDOWSEXTEND EXISTINGCORNER BOARD1x8 SMOOTHHARDIETRIMCUT TO FITSMOOTHHARDIESOFFITPANELS W/ 1x4STICKING, TYP.
NEW DOORW/ TRANSOM
NEW DOUBLEHUNG WINDOWSEXTEND EXISTINGCORNER BOARD1x8 SMOOTHHARDIETRIMCUT TO FITSMOOTHHARDIESOFFITPANELS W/ 1x4STICKING, TYP.
1x8 BEAM TRIM TOALIGN W/ FACE OFCORNER BOARDS
1x8 BEAM TRIM TOALIGN W/ FACE OFCORNER BOARDS
2'-10"NEW MINI-SPLIT& ENCLOSURE 1AD101FIRST FLOOR RENOVATION PLAN1/4" = 1'-0"NEW DOUBLEHUNG WINDOWSNEW 2x6 WALL FRAMINGAROUND EXISTING COLUMN
NEW DOOR
GYP. BD. INTERIOR FINISH @ALL INTERIOR WALLS & CEILING
WINDOW SCHEDULEMARKTYPELABELHEAD JAMB HEIGHT(SEE NOTE 2)EXTERIORMATERIALEXTERIORFINISHADOUBLE HUNGELDH3272 3W±8'-0"ULTREX CLADSTONE WHITEBDOUBLE HUNGELDH3272±8'-0"ULTREX CLADSTONE WHITENOTE 1:SIZES ARE BASED ON MARVIN ELEVATE. IF A DIFFERENT MANUFACTURER IS SELECTED, G.C. ISTO COORDINATE. CONTACT ARCHITECT FOR ASSISTANCE IN SELECTING APPROPRIATEALTERNATE SIZES.NOTE 2:G.C. TO COORDINATE ALL NEW WINDOW/DOOR HEAD JAMB HEIGHTS TO ALIGN BOTTOM OFNEW INT./EXT. WINDOW & DOOR HEAD JAMBS.NOTE 4:G.C. TO PREPARE EXTERIOR OPENINGS PER ASTM E2112.NOTE 5:PROVIDE PRODUCTS TO MEET OR EXCEED DESIGN PRESSURE (DP) RATINGS AS REQUIRED BYTHE STRUCTURAL DESIGN CRITERIA FOR COMPONENTS & CLADDING CHART ON SHEET S100.NOTE 6:U-VALUE OF 0.30 AND MINIMUM SHGC OF 0.30 OR APPROVED EQUIVALENT AS SPECIFIED BYENGINEER TO COMPLY WITH ALL APPLICABLE ENERGY CODES, BUILDING CODES ANDREGULATORY REQUIREMENTS.NOTE 8:PROVIDE TEMPERED GLASS AS REQUIRED TO MEET IRC SECTION R308 FOR WINDOW GLAZING.NOTE 9:PROVIDE WOOD STRUCTURAL PANELS, IMPACT PANELS OR IMPACT RESISTANCE GLAZING FOROPENING PROTECTION AT ALL NEW WINDOWS, SKYLIGHTS AND DOORS IN ACCORDANCE WITHSECTION R301.2.1.2 OF THE 2018 IRC. FASTENING SHALL BE BY MEANS OF CORROSION RESISTANTMACHINE SCREWS FASTENED TO PERMANENTLY INSTALLED THREADED RECEIVERS LAGBOLTED INTO THE FRAMING. EACH VIBRATION-RESISTANT RECEIVER SHALL HAVE A MINIMUMWITHDRAWAL CAPACITY OF 490 POUNDS. SEAL AROUND EACH RECEIVER WITH A SUITABLESEALANT. ALL PANELS MUST BE PRECUT, LABELED AND STORED ON SITE.
DOOR SCHEDULEDOORNO.NOMINAL SIZE(SEE NOTES)LABELHEAD JAMB HEIGHT(SEE NOTE 2)MATERIALREMARKSWHTh1013'-0"6'-8" (R.O. 8'-8")1 34"ELOFD3068±8'-8"CLAD WOODNOTE 1:G.C. TO PREPARE EXTERIOR OPENINGS PER ASTM E2112.NOTE 2:PROVIDE PRODUCTS TO MEET OR EXCEED DESIGN PRESSURE (DP) RATINGS AS REQUIRED BY THE STRUCTURAL DESIGNCRITERIA FOR COMPONENTS & CLADDING CHART ON SHEET S100.NOTE 3:U-VALUE OF 0.30 AND MINIMUM SHGC OF 0.30 OR APPROVED EQUIVALENT AS SPECIFIED BY ENGINEER TO COMPLY WITHALL APPLICABLE ENERGY CODES, BUILDING CODES AND REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS.NOTE 4:PROVIDE TEMPERED GLASS AS REQUIRED TO MEET IRC 2018 SECTION R308 FOR DOOR GLAZING.NOTE 5:PROVIDE WOOD STRUCTURAL PANELS, IMPACT PANELS OR IMPACT RESISTANCE GLAZING FOR OPENING PROTECTION AT ALLNEW WINDOWS, SKYLIGHTS AND DOORS IN ACCORDANCE WITH 2018 IRC SECTION R301.2.1.2. FASTENING SHALL BE BY MEANSOF CORROSION RESISTANT MACHINE SCREWS FASTENED TO PERMANENTLY INSTALLED THREADED RECEIVERS LAG BOLTEDINTO THE FRAMING. EACH VIBRATION-RESISTANT RECEIVER SHALL HAVE A MINIMUM WITHDRAWAL CAPACITY OF 490POUNDS. SEAL AROUND EACH RECEIVER WITH A SUITABLE SEALANT. ALL PANELS MUST BE PRECUT, LABELED AND STOREDON SITE.
101B2'-2"5'-8"5'-714"AB
2'-3"2'-1112"3'-214" B
B
CAROLINA ROOM
SCOPEOF WORK
SCOPEOF WORKSCOPE OF WORK
(4) 4" RECESSEDLED FIXTURES ONABANDONEDSCONCE CIRCUIT
EXISTING FANTO REMAIN
3'-214" B MINISPLITGATE4'-6"3'-1"3'-8"
2AS101
A101FLOOR PLANSSHEETPROJECT NO.CONTACTDATE
C COPYRIGHT 2025 DePAUW ARCHITECTS LLCTHIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF THE ARCHITECTAND IS NOT TO BE REPRODUCED IN WHOLE OR INPART BY ANY MEANS OR METHOD WITHOUT THEEXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT.ANY UNAUTHORIZED REPRODUCTION OR REUSE OFTHESE DOCUMENTS WILL RESULT IN LEGAL ACTION.
REVISIONS
NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONA PORCH ENCLOSURE FORTHE DUNCAN RESIDENCE
4.28.20254 TABBY SHELL ROADTABBY ROADSBLUFFTON, SC 299102502LRD
Page 24
Section VI. Item #1.
INSTALL FIRST LAYER OF 9" WIDESELF-ADHESIVE FLASHINGHORIZONTALLY AT HEAD DIRECTLY ONSHEATHING AND STOP AT WINDOWOPENING - FLASHING WILL OVERLAPFIRST LAYER OF VERTICAL SAF ATJAMBS. PRIME ALL SURFACES.BACKER ROD AND SEALANT1x4 HARDIETRIMINSTALL SECOND LAYER OF 6" WIDESAF HORIZONTALLY AT HEAD OVERWINDOW FLANGE - THIS FLASHINGWILL OVERLAP THE SECOND LAYER OFVERTICAL SAF AT JAMBS
ALUMINUM HEAD FLASHING WITHSIDE TURN-DOWNS - FLASHINGTERMINATION TABS AT ENDS OF HEADFLASHINGINSTALL THIRD LAYER OF 6" WIDE SAFHORIZONTALLY AT HEAD OVERWINDOW HEAD FLASHING - THISFLASHING WILL OVERLAP THESECOND LAYER OF HORIZONTAL SAFAT HEADSHEATHING, SEE STRUCTURAL
CONT. 20 OZ. COPPER FLASHING THELENGTH OF WINDOW SILL AND TIGHTAGAINST JAMBSBACKER ROD AND SEALANTWINDOW FLANGE OVER "ULTRA-LATH"1x4 HARDIETRIM APRON
INSTALL 9" WIDE SELF-ADHESIVEFLASHING - PRIME ALL SURFACES -EXTEND FLASHING INTO WINDOWOPENING TO THE TOP OF COPPERFLASHING - LAP FLASHING ONTO ZIPSHEATHING AND EXTEND LEG DOWNAND OVER ANOTHER LAYER OF SAFBELOWTYVEK DRAINWRAP WRB
EXTEND SAF UP 8" AT WALL JAMBS,TYP.PROVIDE PVC SLOPED SILL BETWEENSAF AND R.O.
NOTE: INSTALL SILL 'PAN' FLASHING PERASTM E 2112
APPLY "ULTRA-LATH", 112" WIDE BY THELENGTH OF THE WINDOW FLANGE TOWATERPROOF MEMBRANE UNDERSILL FLANGECONT. SEALANT BETWEEN LAP SIDINGAND TRIM
SHEATING, SEE STRUCTURALSEE A201-A302 FOR EXTERIOR SIDINGMATERIALCONT. SEALANT BETWEEN SIDING ANDTRIM
1x4 HARDIETRIM CASING
INSTALL FIRST LAYER OF 9" WIDESELF-ADHESIVE FLASHING VERTICALLYAT JAMB DIRECTLY ON SHEATHINGAND EXTEND INTO WINDOW TO ALIGNW/ FLASHING AT SILL - FLASHING WILLOVERLAP HORIZONTAL SAF AT SILL -PRIME ALL SURFACESINSTALL SECOND LAYER OF 6" WIDESAF VERTICALLY AT JAMB OVERWINDOW FLANGEBACKER ROD AND SEALANT
INTERIOR WINDOW TRIM AND WALLFINISHES BY G.C./OWNER
2CA501WINDOW SILL1" = 1'-0"
2BA501WINDOW JAMB1" = 1'-0"
1AA501WINDOW HEAD1" = 1'-0"
TYVEK DRAINWRAP WRB
SHEATHING, SEE STRUCTURAL
TYVEK DRAINWRAP WRB
NOTE: INSTALL SILL 'PAN' FLASHING PERASTM E 2112
SMOOTH HARDIEPANEL
SMOOTH HARDIEPANEL
EXISTING SIDING
2A501INFILL FRAMING @ EXISING PORCH SLAB1" = 1'-0"
EXISTING CMUFOUNDATION
EXISTING PORCH SLAB EDGE
CONT. METAL FLASHING SETTO BRICK IN SEALANT BED
SEE STRUCTURAL ENG. FORCONNECTION DETAILS
2x6 TR SILL PLATES - SEE STRUCT. FORCONNECTION DETAIL
RIGID FOAM INSULATION, TYP.
FINISH FLOORING AS SELECTEDOVER VAPOR BARRIER
3AA501
SILL GASKET
TYVEK DRAINWRAP WRBSHEATHING, SEE STRUCTURALSMOOTH HARDIEPANEL
1x4 HARDIETRIM
1x8 BEAM TRIM (SEE ELEVATIONS)
14" GAP (NO SEALANT)TR. BLOCKING
A501DETAILED SECTIONSSHEETPROJECT NO.CONTACTDATE
C COPYRIGHT 2025 DePAUW ARCHITECTS LLCTHIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF THE ARCHITECTAND IS NOT TO BE REPRODUCED IN WHOLE OR INPART BY ANY MEANS OR METHOD WITHOUT THEEXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT.ANY UNAUTHORIZED REPRODUCTION OR REUSE OFTHESE DOCUMENTS WILL RESULT IN LEGAL ACTION.
REVISIONS
NOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONA PORCH ENCLOSURE FORTHE DUNCAN RESIDENCE
4.28.20254 TABBY SHELL ROADTABBY ROADSBLUFFTON, SC 299102502LRD
Page 25
Section VI. Item #1.
PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS FOR COFA-03-25-019649
Town of Bluffton
Department of Growth Management
20 Bridge Street P.O. Box 386 Bluffton, South Carolina 29910
Telephone 843-706-4522
OLD TOWN
Plan Type: Apply Date:
Plan Status: Plan Address: 4 Tabby Shell Road
BLUFFTON, SC 29910
Historic District
Pending
03/14/2025
Plan PIN #:Case Manager: R610 039 000 1184 0000Charlotte Moore
Plan Description: A request by Joseph DePauw (DePauw Architects), on behalf of the owners, Steve and Jill Duncan, for review
of a Certificate of Appropriateness-Historic District, to allow enclosure of a screen porch to create a Carolina
Room of approximately 204 SF on the Main Residence located at 4 Tabby Shell Road (Parcel R610 039 000
1184 0000) in the Tabby Roads Development. The property is located in the Old Town Historic District and is
zoned Neighborhood General-Historic District (NG-HD).
STATUS: Scheduled for HPRC review on April 7, 2025.
Staff Review (HD)
Submission #: 1 Recieved: 03/14/2025 Completed: 04/03/2025
Reviewing Dept. Complete Date StatusReviewer
Approved with Conditions04/03/2025HPRC Review Charlotte Moore
Comments:
1. Suggest changing the 3' x 8' instead of 6'-8" plus transom above to match existing conditions
2. The new door is called out as a sliding door in the renovation plan but shown as a swinging door in the same drawing and
elevation. The door is also called out as 3’x8’ in the plan but shown in the elevation and schedule at 6’x8’ with transom. Suggest
that the door be 3’x8’ to match existing conditions.
3. The infill framing detail has a callout for hardiplank lap siding; only panel and trim are shown in the elevation.
4. The plan identifies casement windows; however, the elevation and narrative show double hung windows “to match existing
windows.” The existing windows shown in the same elevation have hinge markers, suggesting casement function. Clarification
needed.
5. The window head detail calls out hardie panel above the head trim; the elevation shows trim instead of panel.
6. In the plan, elevations, and details, 1x4 hardie trim is specified, but the elevations show a smaller vertical mull trim between
windows.
Approved with Conditions04/03/2025Watershed Management Review Samantha Crotty
Comments:
Comments may be provided at time of building permit submittal.
Approved04/03/2025Beaufort Jasper Water and Sewer
Review
Matthew Michaels
Comments:
Comments may be provided at time of Final Plan.
Approved04/03/2025Growth Management Dept Review
(HD)
Charlotte Moore
Comments:
No comments.
Approved03/19/2025Transportation Department
Review - HD
Mark Maxwell
Comments:
No comments
04/03/2025 Page 1 of 2
ATTACHMENT 6Page 26
Section VI. Item #1.
Plan Review Case Notes:
04/03/2025 Page 2 of 2
ATTACHMENT 6Page 27
Section VI. Item #1.
Habitat Architectural Review Board
Tabby Roads
Bluffton, SC
April 29, 2025
DUNCAN STEVEN M DUNCAN JILL M,
Lot 4, Tabby Roads
4 Tabby Shell Rd
Bluffton, South Carolina 29910
Dear Jill and Steve,
This letter shall serve as final approval with conditions for your request to enclose your porch and create a
Carolina Room. Plans within the following files titled are the basis for this approval:
25.03.13 Duncan Carolina Room_For Review.pdf & 25.04.28 Duncan Carolina Room_Service Yard.pdf
This approval is based upon the following items of clarification:
• Should Town of Bluffton Building Safety require a hand rail on the landing. Railing design must
be submitted for review and approval prior to installation.
We trust this approval will be satisfactory for your needs. If you have any questions concerning
any item contained herein, please contact us at your convenience.
Sincerely,
Robert Nurnberg
On behalf of Tabby Roads HARB
Page 28
Section VI. Item #1.
Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.