RecordWell Data

Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting — Agenda Packet

Town of Bluffton · Beaufort County · Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee · meeting of Feb 13, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Bluffton

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting Thursday, February 13, 2025 at 6:00 PM Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC AGENDA I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES a. January 9, 2025, Minutes IV. PUBLIC COMMENT V. OLD BUSINESS VI. NEW BUSINESS a. Presentation from Center for Public Safety Management (CPSM). Jarrod Burguan VII. DISCUSSION VIII. ADJOURNMENT NEXT MEETING DATE: Thursday, March 13, 2025 Page 1 Town of Bluffton, SC Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting Agenda February 13, 2025 “FOIA Compliance – Public notification of this meeting has been published and posted in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the Town of Bluffton policies.” In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Bluffton will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. The Town of Bluffton Council Chambers are ADA compatible. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Bluffton ADA Coordinator at 843.706.4500 or adacoordinator@townofbluffton.com as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Executive Session – The public body may vote to go into executive session for any item identified for action on the agenda. *Please note that each member of the public may speak at one public comment session and a form must be filled out and given to the Town Clerk. To submit a public comment online, please click here: https://www.townofbluffton.sc.gov/FormCenter/Town-15/Public-Comment-60 Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per speaker. Page 2 Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes Theodore D. Washington Municipal Building, Henry “Emmett” McCracken Jr. Council Chambers, 20 Bridge Street, Bluffton, SC January 09, 2025 I. CALL TO ORDER Vice-Chair Frazier called the meeting to order at 6:00 pm. II. ROLL CALL PRESENT Bill O'Toole Vice-Chair Michael Frazier Reginald Howard George Bailey Chairwoman- Jennifer Morrow ABSENT Tabor Vaux Mayra Rivera-Vazquez III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES a. October 10, 2024, Minutes: Vice-Chair Frazier asked for motion to approve: George Bailey made motion, Reggie Howard seconded, all in favor. b. November 14, 2024, Minutes: Vice-Chair Frazier asked for motion to approve: George Bailey made motion, Chairwoman-Morrow seconded, all in favor. IV. PUBLIC COMMENT: None V. OLD BUSINESS: None VI. NEW BUSINESS a. Approval of November 2025 Meeting Date Change proposed by Chief Babkiewicz: Bill O’Toole moved to approve with changes. Vice-Chair Frazier seconded, all in favor. VII. DISCUSSION a. Operation Christmas Child, Chief Babkiewicz briefed the committee on the successful outcome of Operation Christmas Child (150 boxes filled and sent out around the world, as well as locally). b. Chief Babkiewicz briefed the committee on the success of Shop with a Cop as well as the Bluffton PD annual Christmas Party. c. Chief Babkiewicz updated the committee on the Flock Camera program. The chief advised that the policy regarding the cameras and their use has been posted. He advised that the department is working with CIP on abatement locations on the cameras, for future camera Page 3 Section III. Item # a. Town of Bluffton, SC Law Enforcement Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes January 9, 2025 install locations. He also updated the committee regarding the training that all users of the system must complete prior to utilizing the system. The chief closed with he is hoping to have all the cameras in place by the end of February. VIII. ADJOURNMENT Chairwoman-Jennifer Morrow made a motion to adjourn. Seconded by: Reggie Howard. All were in favor and the meeting adjourned at 6:28 pm. Page 4 Section III. Item # a. 08 Fall POLICE OPERATIONS AND DATA REPORT BLUFFTON POLICE DEPARTMENT, BLUFFTON, SOUTH CAROLINA DRAFT CENTER FOR PUBLIC SAFETY MANAGEMENT, LLC 475 K STREET NW STE 702 • WASHINGTON, DC 20001 WWW.CPSM.US • 716-969-1360 Exclusive Provider of Public Safety Technical Services for International City/County Management Association CENTER FOR PUBLIC SAFETY MANAGEMENT, LLC Page 5 Section VI. Item # a. i THE ASSOCIATION & THE COMPANY INTERNATIONAL CITY/COUNTY MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION (ICMA) The International City/County Management Association (ICMA) is a 109-year-old, non-profit professional association of local government administrators and managers, with approximately 13,000 members located in 32 countries. Since its inception in 1914, ICMA has been dedicated to assisting local governments and their managers in providing services to their citizens in an efficient and effective manner. ICMA advances the knowledge of local government best practices with its website, www.icma.org, publications, research, professional development, and membership. CENTER FOR PUBLIC SAFETY MANAGEMENT (CPSM) The ICMA Center for Public Safety Management (ICMA/CPSM was launched by ICMA to provide support to local governments in the areas of police, fire, and Emergency Medical Services. The Center also represents local governments at the federal level and has been involved in numerous projects with the Department of Justice and the Department of Homeland Security. In 2014, as part of a restructuring at ICMA, the Center for Public Safety Management (CPSM) spun out as a separate company and is now the exclusive provider of public safety technical assistance for ICMA. CPSM provides training and research for the Association’s members and represents ICMA in its dealings with the federal government and other public safety professional associations such as CALEA, PERF, IACP, IFCA, IPMA-HR, DOJ, BJA, COPS, NFPA, etc. The Center for Public Safety Management, LLC, maintains the same team of individuals performing the same level of service that it had for ICMA. CPSM’s local government technical assistance experience includes workload and deployment analysis using our unique methodology and subject matter experts to examine department organizational structure and culture, identify workload and staffing needs, and identify industry best practices. We have conducted more than 400 such studies in 46 states and provinces and more than 275 communities ranging in population size 3,300 (Lewes, DE) to 800,000 (Indianapolis, IN). Thomas Wieczorek is the Director of the Center for Public Safety Management. Leonard Matarese serves as the Managing Partner for Research and Project Development. Dr. Dov Chelst is the Director of Quantitative Analysis. Page 6 Section VI. Item # a. ii CENTER FOR PUBLIC SAFETY MANAGEMENT PROJECT CONTRIBUTORS Thomas J. Wieczorek, Director Leonard A. Matarese, Director, Research & Project Development Dov Chelst, Ph.D. Director of Quantitative Analysis Shan Zhou, Data Analyst Jarrod Burguan, Public Safety Consultant – Team Leader Wayne Hiltz, Public Safety Consultant Craig Junginger, Public Safety Consultant Dennis Kouba, Senior Editor Page 7 Section VI. Item # a. iii CONTENTS Tables ........................................................................................................................... viii Figures ............................................................................................................................ x Section 1. Executive Summary .................................................................................... 1 General Observations ........................................................................................................................... 2 Recommendations ................................................................................................................................ 3 Patrol .................................................................................................................................................... 4 Investigations Division ........................................................................................................................ 4 Special Operations Division ............................................................................................................... 5 Support Services ................................................................................................................................. 6 Section 2. Methodology ............................................................................................. 10 Section 3. Community Overview ............................................................................... 11 Demographics .................................................................................................................................. 11 Law Enforcement Services .................................................................................................................. 12 Bluffton PD Mission, Vision, and Core Values ................................................................................ 12 Uniform Crime Reports ..................................................................................................................... 13 Section 4. Administration ............................................................................................ 17 Accreditation .................................................................................................................................... 20 Strategic Planning ............................................................................................................................ 21 Succession Planning ........................................................................................................................ 21 Department Policy Manual ............................................................................................................. 22 Professional Standards ......................................................................................................................... 23 PSB Staffing ........................................................................................................................................ 24 Internal Affairs Training ..................................................................................................................... 24 Policy ................................................................................................................................................. 24 Complaint Process ........................................................................................................................... 24 Complaint Investigations ................................................................................................................. 26 Discipline ........................................................................................................................................... 27 Early Warning System (EWS) ............................................................................................................ 30 Use of Force .......................................................................................................................................... 31 Policy ................................................................................................................................................. 32 Reporting Responses/Supervisor Responsibilities .......................................................................... 32 Duty to Intercede and Report ........................................................................................................ 33 Emergency Management .................................................................................................................. 34 Phases of Emergency Management ............................................................................................. 35 Page 8 Section VI. Item # a. iv Policy / SOP ....................................................................................................................................... 35 EOC Locations, Staffing, and Working Groups ............................................................................. 36 Section 5. Patrol ........................................................................................................... 39 Patrol Overview, Staffing ..................................................................................................................... 39 Division Management ..................................................................................................................... 39 Beat Structure ................................................................................................................................... 39 Staffing ............................................................................................................................................... 40 Scheduling ........................................................................................................................................ 40 Minimum Staffing .............................................................................................................................. 42 Patrol Deployment and Workload ..................................................................................................... 42 Rule of 60 – Part 1 ............................................................................................................................. 43 Rule of 60 – Part 2 ............................................................................................................................. 44 Call and Event Analysis ....................................................................................................................... 55 Traffic Enforcement .......................................................................................................................... 61 Out-of-Service-Activities .................................................................................................................. 62 Response Times .................................................................................................................................... 63 Section 6. Investigations Division ............................................................................... 68 Criminal Investigations Unit (CIU) ........................................................................................................ 68 Policy / Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) ............................................................................ 68 Staffing ............................................................................................................................................... 69 Case Intake ....................................................................................................................................... 71 Workload Demand .......................................................................................................................... 72 Case Management ......................................................................................................................... 74 Training .............................................................................................................................................. 75 Technology ....................................................................................................................................... 75 FBI UCR/NIBRS Crime Reporting ...................................................................................................... 75 Crime Scene Investigations / Forensics ............................................................................................. 79 CSI Policy / SOP ................................................................................................................................ 81 CSI Training ........................................................................................................................................ 81 CSI Case Management Data ......................................................................................................... 84 CSI / Forensics Summary .................................................................................................................. 84 Domestic Violence Detective, Victim / Witness Advocate ............................................................ 85 Community Mental Health .................................................................................................................. 86 Section 7. Special Operations ................................................................................... 89 School Resource Officers (SRO) ......................................................................................................... 89 Staffing ............................................................................................................................................... 89 Operating Agreements ................................................................................................................... 90 Page 9 Section VI. Item # a. v Policy / SOP ....................................................................................................................................... 90 Training .............................................................................................................................................. 91 Workload ........................................................................................................................................... 91 Annual or Semi-annual Review ...................................................................................................... 92 Rotation Schedule ............................................................................................................................ 92 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 93 Crossing Guards ................................................................................................................................... 93 Police Explorers ..................................................................................................................................... 94 Staffing / Participants ....................................................................................................................... 94 Policy ................................................................................................................................................. 95 Activities ............................................................................................................................................ 95 Funding .............................................................................................................................................. 95 Community Service Assistants ............................................................................................................ 96 Critical Incident Tactical Response .................................................................................................... 97 Mutual Aid ............................................................................................................................................. 98 Special Events ....................................................................................................................................... 99 Special Events and Personnel ......................................................................................................... 99 Officer Overtime ............................................................................................................................. 100 Workload ......................................................................................................................................... 100 1033 Program ...................................................................................................................................... 100 Equipment Management ............................................................................................................. 100 Continued Participation ................................................................................................................ 100 PIO/Social Media ............................................................................................................................... 101 PIO Responsibilities ......................................................................................................................... 101 Training ............................................................................................................................................ 102 PIO Team ......................................................................................................................................... 102 Policy ............................................................................................................................................... 102 Social Media Presence .................................................................................................................. 102 Section 8. Support Services ...................................................................................... 103 Personnel / Recruitment / Retention ................................................................................................ 103 Hiring Process .................................................................................................................................. 103 Pre-Employment Background investigations .............................................................................. 104 Retention ......................................................................................................................................... 105 Hiring Bonuses ................................................................................................................................. 106 Recruiting ........................................................................................................................................ 107 Training ................................................................................................................................................ 108 Training Policy ................................................................................................................................. 108 Page 10 Section VI. Item # a. vi Entry Level Training ......................................................................................................................... 109 Training Records ............................................................................................................................. 109 Weapons Qualifications ................................................................................................................ 109 Training Calendar ........................................................................................................................... 110 Department Training ...................................................................................................................... 110 Briefing Training ............................................................................................................................... 111 Career Development Training ...................................................................................................... 111 New Sergeant Training .................................................................................................................. 112 Professional Training for Executives .............................................................................................. 112 Field Training Officer Program (FTO) ................................................................................................ 112 Field Training Manual ..................................................................................................................... 114 Field Training Coordinator / Duties ............................................................................................... 114 Field Training Officer Selection ..................................................................................................... 114 Field Training Officer’s Duties ........................................................................................................ 115 FTO Records .................................................................................................................................... 115 FTO Program Outcomes ................................................................................................................ 116 Records ............................................................................................................................................... 116 Records Staffing and Work Schedule .......................................................................................... 116 Records Policies .............................................................................................................................. 117 Workload Demand ........................................................................................................................ 117 Training ............................................................................................................................................ 118 Online Access to Police Reports, Online Reporting ................................................................... 118 Records Management System ..................................................................................................... 119 Payment Options ........................................................................................................................... 120 Records Unit Area .......................................................................................................................... 120 Records Retention .......................................................................................................................... 120 Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) ............................................................................................. 121 Property and Evidence ..................................................................................................................... 122 Policy ............................................................................................................................................... 123 Facilities / Security .......................................................................................................................... 123 Processing ....................................................................................................................................... 124 Evidence Destruction ..................................................................................................................... 124 Staffing /Work Schedule ................................................................................................................ 125 Property and Evidence Management System ........................................................................... 125 Storage, Inventory Control ............................................................................................................ 126 Audits ............................................................................................................................................... 127 Quartermaster .................................................................................................................................... 128 Page 11 Section VI. Item # a. vii Equipment Storage and Tracking ................................................................................................ 129 Grant Funding ................................................................................................................................. 129 Equipment Issuance ....................................................................................................................... 129 Facility .................................................................................................................................................. 130 Facility Overview ............................................................................................................................ 131 Emergency Operations Center (EOC) ........................................................................................ 132 Fleet ..................................................................................................................................................... 132 Take-Home Vehicles ...................................................................................................................... 133 Leasing of Vehicles ........................................................................................................................ 133 Vehicle Maintenance .................................................................................................................... 133 Retention Schedule ....................................................................................................................... 134 Cleaning of Vehicles ...................................................................................................................... 134 Communications / Dispatch ............................................................................................................. 134 Response Times ............................................................................................................................... 135 Dispatch Times ................................................................................................................................ 136 Information Technology .................................................................................................................... 138 RMS .................................................................................................................................................. 138 Technology Replacement ............................................................................................................ 138 IT Committee .................................................................................................................................. 138 Associated Technology ................................................................................................................. 139 Training ............................................................................................................................................ 139 Section 9. Summary .................................................................................................. 140 Section 10. Data Analysis ......................................................................................... 142 Workload Analysis .............................................................................................................................. 142 Out-of-Service Activities .................................................................................................................... 164 Deployment ........................................................................................................................................ 169 Response Times .................................................................................................................................. 179 All Calls ............................................................................................................................................ 180 High-Priority Calls ............................................................................................................................ 185 Appendix A: Call Type Classification ............................................................................................... 187 Appendix B: Uniform Crime Report Information ............................................................................. 190 Page 12 Section VI. Item # a. viii TABLES TABLE 3-1: U.S. Census Data (Town, County, State, and US) ............................................................... 12 TABLE 3-2: Reported Crime Rates in 2021 and 2022, by Jurisdiction .................................................. 14 TABLE 3-3: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Rates, by Year ......................... 16 TABLE 4-1: Department Staffing .............................................................................................................. 20 TABLE 4-2: Citizen Complaints, 2018–2022 ............................................................................................. 26 TABLE 4-3: Citizen/Internal Complaint Investigation Adjudications, 2018–2022 ................................ 27 TABLE 4-4: Complaints vs. Police Contacts, 2022 ................................................................................. 27 TABLE 4-5: BPD Progressive Discipline Matrix ......................................................................................... 29 TABLE 4-6: Example of a Standardized Progressive Discipline Matrix ................................................. 30 TABLE 4-7: EWS Matrix Example ............................................................................................................... 31 TABLE 4-8: Uses of Force, 2021–2023 ....................................................................................................... 34 TABLE 5-1: BPD Patrol Division Staffing .................................................................................................... 40 TABLE 5-2: BPD 28-Day Patrol Work Cycle Example ............................................................................. 41 TABLE 5-3: Events per Day, by Initiator ................................................................................................... 55 TABLE 5-4: Events per Day, by Category ............................................................................................... 56 TABLE 5-5: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Month ................................................................................. 58 TABLE 5-6: Primary Unit’s Average Occupied Times, by Category and Initiator .............................. 59 TABLE 5-7: Extra Patrol Call Types and Average Time .......................................................................... 60 TABLE 5-8: Average Number of Responding Units, by Initiator and Category .................................. 60 TABLE 5-9: Calls and Work Hours by Beat, per Day .............................................................................. 61 TABLE 5-10: Activities and Occupied Times by Description ................................................................ 63 TABLE 5-11: Average Response Time Components, in Minutes, by Category .................................. 64 TABLE 5-12: Average Response Time Components, by Beat .............................................................. 65 TABLE 5-13: Average and 90th Percentile Response Times, by Priority .............................................. 66 TABLE 6-1: Criminal Investigations Division Authorized Staffing Levels at Present ............................. 69 TABLE 6-2: Criminal Investigations Unit Case Assignment, 2021–2023 ................................................ 73 TABLE 6-3: FBI UCR Reported Part 1 Crimes in Bluffton, 2021–2023* .................................................... 73 TABLE 6-4: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Clearance Rates, 2021 .......... 77 TABLE 6-5: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Clearance Rates, 2022 .......... 77 TABLE 6-6: Sample Training Matrix for Dedicated Crime Scene Investigators .................................. 82 TABLE 8-1: Background Investigations, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 ......................................................... 104 TABLE 8-2: Sworn Personnel Employment Activity, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ...................................... 105 TABLE 8-3: City of Bluffton and BPD Demographics, 2024 ................................................................. 107 TABLE 8-4: South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy Attendance and Completion, 2012 through 2024 ......................................................................................................................................................... 109 TABLE 8-5: FTO Program Outcomes, 2022–2024 .................................................................................. 116 TABLE 8-6: FOIA Requests, 2022–2024YTD ............................................................................................ 122 TABLE 8-7: FOIA Fee Schedule .............................................................................................................. 122 TABLE 8-8: Property and Evidence Items Processed, 2021–2023 ...................................................... 126 TABLE 8-9: Average Response Times, by Priority ................................................................................. 135 Page 13 Section VI. Item # a. ix TABLE 10-1: Events per Day, by Initiator ............................................................................................... 144 TABLE 10-2: Events per Day, by Category ........................................................................................... 146 TABLE 10-3: Calls per Day, by Category .............................................................................................. 148 TABLE 10-4: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Months ............................................................................ 149 TABLE 10-5: Calls per Day, by Category and Month .......................................................................... 151 TABLE 10-6: Primary Unit’s Average Occupied Times, by Category and Initiator .......................... 153 TABLE 10-7: Average Number of Responding Units, by Initiator and Category .............................. 155 TABLE 10-8: Number of Responding Units, by Category, Community-initiated Calls ..................... 157 TABLE 10-9: Calls and Work Hours by Beat, per Day .......................................................................... 159 TABLE 10-10: Calls and Work Hours per Day, by Category, Summer 2023 ...................................... 161 TABLE 10-11: Calls and Work Hours per Day, by Category, Winter 2024 .......................................... 163 TABLE 10-12: Activities and Occupied Times by Description ............................................................ 164 TABLE 10-13: Activities and Workload per Day, by Month ................................................................ 165 TABLE 10-14: Activities per Day, by Day of Week ............................................................................... 166 TABLE 10-15: Activities per Hour, by Hour of Day ................................................................................ 168 TABLE 10-16: Average Response Time Components, by Category ................................................. 182 TABLE 10-17: 90th Percentiles for Response Time Components, by Category ................................ 183 TABLE 10-18: Average Response Time Components, by Beat .......................................................... 184 TABLE 10-19: Average and 90th Percentile Response Times, by Priority .......................................... 185 TABLE 10-20: Call Type, by Category ................................................................................................... 187 TABLE 10-21: Reported Crime Rates in 2021 and 2022, by City ........................................................ 190 TABLE 10-22: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Rates, by Year ................... 192 TABLE 10-23: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Clearance Rates, 2021 .... 193 TABLE 10-24: Reported Bluffton and South Carolina Crime Clearance Rates, 2022 ...................... 193 Page 14 Section VI. Item # a. x FIGURES FIGURE 3-1: Reported Bluffton Violent and Property Crime Rates, by Year ...................................... 14 FIGURE 3-2: Reported Bluffton and South Carolina Crime Rates, by Year ........................................ 15 FIGURE 4-1: Bluffton Police Department Organizational Chart (July 2024) ....................................... 17 FIGURE 5-1: Bluffton Patrol Zones ............................................................................................................ 40 FIGURE 5-2: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Summer 2023 .................................................................. 45 FIGURE 5-3: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 ............................................. 45 FIGURE 5-4: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 ...................................................... 46 FIGURE 5-5: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Summer 2023 .................................................................. 47 FIGURE 5-6: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 ............................................. 48 FIGURE 5-7: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 ...................................................... 48 FIGURE 5-8: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Winter 2024 ..................................................................... 49 FIGURE 5-9: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 ................................................ 50 FIGURE 5-10: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 ........................................................ 50 FIGURE 5-11: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Winter 2024 ................................................................... 51 FIGURE 5-12: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 .............................................. 52 FIGURE 5-13: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 ....................................................... 52 FIGURE 5-14: Percentage Events per Day, by Initiator ......................................................................... 55 FIGURE 5-15: Percentage Events per Day, by Category ..................................................................... 57 FIGURE 5-16: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Month ............................................................................. 58 FIGURE 5-17: Average Response Time Components, by Beat ............................................................ 65 FIGURE 8-1: BPD Training Hours by Month, 2023 .................................................................................. 111 FIGURE 8-2: FTO Program Chain of Command .................................................................................. 113 FIGURE 8-3: Bluffton Law Enforcement Center ................................................................................... 130 FIGURE 8-4: BPD Sub-Station .................................................................................................................. 131 FIGURE 8-5: Average Response and Dispatch Processing Times for High-priority Calls, by Hour .. 137 FIGURE 10-1: Percentage Events per Day, by Initiator ....................................................................... 144 FIGURE 10-2: Percentage Events per Day, by Category ................................................................... 145 FIGURE 10-3: Percentage Calls per Day, by Category ...................................................................... 147 FIGURE 10-4: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Month ........................................................................... 149 FIGURE 10-5: Calls per Day, by Category and Month ....................................................................... 150 FIGURE 10-6: Primary Unit’s Average Occupied Times, by Category and Initiator ........................ 152 FIGURE 10-7: Number of Responding Units, by Initiator and Category ............................................ 154 FIGURE 10-8: Number of Responding Units, by Category, Community-initiated Calls ................... 156 FIGURE 10-9: Percentage Calls and Work Hours, by Beat ................................................................. 158 FIGURE 10-10: Percentage Calls and Work Hours, by Category, Summer 2023 ............................. 160 FIGURE 10-11: Percentage Calls and Work Hours, by Category, Winter 2024 ................................ 162 FIGURE 10-12: Activities per Day, by Month ........................................................................................ 165 FIGURE 10-13: Activities per Day, by Day of Week ............................................................................. 166 FIGURE 10-14: Activities per Day, by Hour of Day ............................................................................... 167 FIGURE 10-15: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Summer 2023 ............................................................ 170 Page 15 Section VI. Item # a. xi FIGURE 10-16: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Summer 2023 ............................................................ 170 FIGURE 10-17: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Winter 2024 ............................................................... 171 FIGURE 10-18: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Winter 2024 ............................................................... 171 FIGURE 10-19: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 ....................................... 173 FIGURE 10-20: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 ....................................... 173 FIGURE 10-21: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 .......................................... 174 FIGURE 10-22: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 .......................................... 174 FIGURE 10-23: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 ................................................ 176 FIGURE 10-24: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 ................................................ 176 FIGURE 10-25: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 .................................................... 177 FIGURE 10-26: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 ................................................... 177 FIGURE 10-27: Average Response Time and Dispatch Processing, by Hour of Day, Summer 2023 and Winter 2024 ..................................................................................................................................... 180 FIGURE 10-28: Average Response Time by Category, Summer 2023 ............................................... 181 FIGURE 10-29: Average Response Time by Category, Winter 2024 .................................................. 181 FIGURE 10-30: Average Response Time Components, by Beat ........................................................ 184 FIGURE 10-31: Average Response Times and Dispatch Processing for High-priority Calls, by Hour ................................................................................................................................................................. 185 FIGURE 10-32: Reported Bluffton Violent and Property Crime Rates, by Year ................................ 191 FIGURE 10-33: Reported Bluffton and South Carolina Crime Rates, by Year .................................. 191 Page 16 Section VI. Item # a. 1 SECTION 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Center for Public Safety Management, LLC (CPSM) was commissioned to review the operations of the Town of Bluffton Police Department (BPD). While our analysis covered all aspects of the department’s operations, particular areas of focus of this study included identifying appropriate staffing of the department given the workload, community demographics, and crime levels; the effectiveness of the organizational structure; and efficiency and effectiveness of division/unit processes. Special emphasis and attention was applied to the department’s policy and operational practices. We analyzed the department workload using operations research methodology and compared that workload to staffing and deployment levels. We reviewed other performance indicators that enabled us to understand the implications of the service demands on current staffing. Our study involved data collection, interviews with key operational and administrative personnel, focus groups with line-level department personnel, on-site observations of the job environment, data analysis, comparative analysis, the development of alternatives and recommendations, and engagement with key town stakeholders. Based upon CPSM’s detailed assessment of the Bluffton Police Department, we conclude that the department is doing an outstanding job—considering the challenges of policing in today’s environment—with a staff dedicated to the department's mission of providing quality police service. Throughout this report, we will strive to allow the reader to look inside the department to understand its strengths and challenges. We sincerely hope that all parties constructively utilize the information and recommendations contained herein to improve the operations of the Bluffton Police Department to provide an even higher level of service to the community. As part of this Executive Summary, we offer general observations identifying some of the department's more significant issues. We also list key recommendations for consideration; we believe these recommendations will enhance organizational effectiveness. Often, these types of recommendations require a substantial financial commitment. It is important to note that this report will examine specific sections of the department and offer a discussion of our observations and recommendations for each. The list of recommendations is extensive. Should the Bluffton Police Department choose to implement any or all recommendations, it must be recognized that this process will not take just weeks or even months to complete but perhaps years. The recommendations are intended to form the basis of a long-term improvement plan for the town and department. Though lengthy, this list of recommendations is standard in our operational assessments of agencies nationwide and should not be interpreted as an indictment of the department. While all the recommendations are important, we suggest the police department leadership, in conjunction with the Town Manager and community members, decide which recommendations should take priority for implementation. § § § Page 17 Section VI. Item # a. 2 GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Overall, the CPSM consultants were impressed with the Bluffton Police Department and its people. Although a number of recommendations for improvement are outlined in this report, the core of the organization and the capacity to manage policing challenges are in place. The following are some summarized highlights from the report: ■ The Bluffton Police Department is a generally well-staffed police department and possesses the capacity to handle most of the day-to-day challenges that face the organization. ■ The organization is having a difficult time maintaining full staffing. One reason for this is that the culture of policing in South Carolina appears to support a “free agent” style of policing wherein officers may move from agency to agency several times in their career. Although this is not unheard of in other places it appears to happen more in this region and contributes to some of the staffing challenges. It should be noted that the staffing shortages in BPD are impacting select specialized functions and not necessarily the core patrol and investigative functions. ■ Overall, the department is efficiently deployed and is addressing most areas of policing that an agency of this size category handles. ■ The men and women of the agency are professional and committed to the policing profession and the Bluffton community. ■ The department should adjust its policy management practices; this is outlined later in this report. However, overall, the policies that were reviewed meet industry standards in most cases. ■ BPD should adopt a data-driven approach to proactive policing practices as well as crime reduction strategies. ■ The community appears committed to providing the department the necessary equipment to be successful in carrying out its duties. ■ Bluffton is a very nice community that enjoys a very low crime rate but also has high expectations of the service provided by the police department. § § § Page 18 Section VI. Item # a. 3 RECOMMENDATIONS Administrative (See pp. 17-23) 1. CPSM recommends that BPD maintain an up-to-date operational chart and department assignment list. 2. CPSM recommends that BPD reorganize the department organizational chart so that functions are housed where there is a natural nexus to other department functions. 3. CPSM recommends that BPD eliminate at least one management position (captain or lieutenant) and reclassify it as an operational position (officer or corporal). 4. We recommend that BPD pursue and complete the development of a department succession plan. 5. We recommend that BPD engage its legal counsel for a review of all critical policies recently updated through the department’s current review process. 6. We recommend that BPD involve legal counsel in all policy updates going forward. 7. We recommend that BPD consider purchasing a policy subscription service to replace its current policy manual and internal policy process. Internal Affairs (See pp. 23-31) 8. CPSM recommends consideration be given to creating a Professional Standards/Internal Affairs Unit that reports directly to the Chief of Police regarding I/A issues. 9. CPSM recommends that the person in the IA assignment be rotated every three years. 10. CPSM would recommend that every sergeant in the organization be sent to internal affairs training. 11. CPSM would recommend the department add both Transfer and Demotion to the ways an employee can be disciplined. 12. CPSM recommends that all policies, especially those involving citizen and personnel complaints, be reviewed annually. 13. When the department is faced with an employee’s discipline that rises to anything that results in monetary loss, Education Based Discipline (EBD) should be considered. Use of Force (See pp. 31-34.) 14. The Use of Force policy should be reviewed annually for any changes in law or altering any way that force is used. 15. CPSM recommends adding additional language to the reporting requirements. 16. Policy should also be reviewed to ensure the threshold of reporting is appropriate based upon best practices. Emergency Management (See pp. 34-38) 17. Collateral duties such as FTO coordinator are incompatible with the Emergency Manager’s present role, and should be transferred to a supervisor in the Patrol Division. Page 19 Section VI. Item # a. 4 18. Review and revise SOP 011, Natural Hazards, to more appropriately align responsibilities for emergency preparedness with the department’s current staffing model. 19. Consideration should be given to incorporating non-government organizations such as the Red Cross into the EOC Logistics working group to enable a timelier response in establishing food and shelter services at disasters. 20. Consideration should be given to ensuring that biennial dynamic practical exercise training, as called for in policy, be conducted for all EOC disciplines. 21. Consideration should be given to transitioning the Emergency Manager position from a commissioned officer to that of a career civilian position. Patrol (See pp. 39-67) 22. CPSM recommends that Bluffton PD management engage in strategic decision-making regarding patrol officer-initiated workload. 23. CPSM recommends periodic reviews of call load data to determine whether scheduling changes should be made. This review should be done twice per year, during summer and winter. 24. We recommend that BPD take steps to realign its patrol workforce to bring patrol staffing closer to 60 percent of its sworn workforce. 25. CPSM recommends that BPD take steps to ensure an accurate collection of data of all patrol officer and sergeant workload. 26. CPSM recommends that BPD management carefully track “directed patrol” activity to ensure it is meeting department and community objectives. 27. We recommend that BPD and Bluffton engage local Traffic Engineering departments (City/County/State) and establish a mechanism that would enable police concerns to be routed to Engineering for potential solutions when appropriate. 28. We recommend that BPD engage in a data-driven strategic approach to traffic enforcement. 29. We recommend that BPD work to ensure that all legitimate patrol officer work is accurately captured in CAD in order to improve future workload assessments. Investigations Division Criminal Investigations Unit (See pp. 68-79) 30. A comprehensive review of SOP 024, Criminal Investigations, should be conducted to ensure that the policy meets current department practices and operating needs. 31. As part of a comprehensive review of the Criminal Investigations policy, SOP 024. II. C. should be amended to reflect after-hours call-out procedures to include the identification of the types of incidents that warrant call-outs. 32. Consideration should be given to developing a rotational schedule for the detective assignment and move away from its status as a permanent assignment, which is the case at present. 33. Consideration should be given to the development of a CID training matrix to identify both required and desirable training courses as a guide to ensure that CID personnel training opportunities are properly prioritized and met. Page 20 Section VI. Item # a. 5 34. Consideration should be given to conducting a technology needs assessment and developing a priority list for acquisition as funding permits. 35. To ensure accuracy and consistency, responsibility for FBI UCR NIBRS reporting should be transferred to the Records Division. Training of personnel will be required. As well, if additional staff are required, a part-time hire may be necessary. 36. Department command should review crime and crime clearance rates on a quarterly or semi-annual basis to allow for an accurate assessment of the effectiveness of the department’s investigative efforts and practices. The review should include both individual detective as well as cumulative department data. Crime Scene Investigation (See pp. 79-85) 37. A policy focused on crime scene investigation should be developed; it should include detailed responsibilities for patrol officers and detectives, as well as factors to be considered in seeking mutual aid for the processing of complex crime scenes. 38. Develop a training matrix specific to crime scene investigations. 39. Consideration should be given to acquiring a CSI-specific software program to include tracking of future CSI efforts and rates of success of such efforts. Community Mental Health (See pp. 86-88) 40. The Community Mental Health SOP should be amended to clarify the mandatory training schedule and eliminate the existing conflict in policy. Special Operations Division SROs (See pp. 89-93) 41. Develop a training matrix that identifies SRO-related training specific to the functions of a BPD SRO, and utilize that listing to prioritize these courses over others of less importance as it relates to the specific function of this position. 42. A department policy delineating the purpose of the SRO program and the roles and responsibilities of the SROs should be developed to guide operations. Those roles and responsibilities outlined in the Town’s contractual agreement with Beaufort County School District should serve as the framework for such a policy. Police Explorer Program (See pp. 94-96) 43. The department, without delay, should develop a SOP to guide the administration and operations of the Police Explorer Program. 44. Consideration should be given to utilizing Police Explorers as an alternative staffing source, in limited roles, at events such as 5k runs and parades. Compensation would be provided to the Explorer Post to support the post’s activities. Community Service Assistants (See pp. 96-97) 45. CPSM strongly urges BPD management to examine the process by which CSAs issue parking citations to include the technology in use, the need for an address of the vehicle’s registered owner information to be added to the citation, and court appearance requirements when citations have been paid by the violator. Page 21 Section VI. Item # a. 6 Critical Incident Tactical Response (See pp. 97-98) 46. Develop an active shooter policy to provide direction for all personnel responding to such an incident. Mutual Aid (See pp. 98-99) 47. Review the now 13-year-old mutual aid policy to ensure that it remains accurate in guiding current operations. 48. Examine whether additional mutual aid agreements are warranted for SLED and/or adjacent counties, cities, and towns. Special Events (See pp. 99-100) 49. CPSM recommends the department consider creating a part-time civilian position that could handle the responsibilities connected to special events. 10-33 Program (See pp. 100-101) 50. CPSM recommends the department continue to return existing equipment if it is not meeting its needs and at some point have discussions regarding future participation. PIO/Social Media (See pp. 101-102) 51. In addition to the scheduled training, CPSM recommends the PIO also attend some type of annual conference training. 52. CPSM recommends the department consider implementing a PIO team of approximately 2-3 officers who could assist with handling PIO responsibilities. 53. CPSM recommends the department policy be modified to allow the PIO to conduct media interviews without the prior authorization of the Chief of Police. Support Services Personnel and Recruitment (See pp. 103-108) 54. CPSM recommends the Town continue to move forward with plans to provide a hiring bonus for new and experienced recruits. 55. CPSM recommends that all hiring backgrounds for sworn personnel positions be outsourced to a private investigation company that specializes in background investigations. 56. The department should target its recruitment efforts towards woman and hire more females to fulfill the 30X30 initiative, thus making the department more representative of the population it serves. Training (See pp. 108-112) 57. CPSM recommends the section of policy regarding the training advisory committee be removed or the department create such a committee to match policy. 58. CPSM recommends the department utilize the already existing module in its case management system for the tracking of training or purchase a training tracking software package. Page 22 Section VI. Item # a. 7 59. CPSM recommends the department develop a training plan for each specialty position in the department. 60. CPSM recommends the department consider modifying its policy for qualification on firearms and rifles to twice a year. FTO Program (See pp. 112-116) 61. Since the FTO function is more Patrol-centric, CPSM recommends the FTO Program Manager responsibility be transferred to one of the Patrol Lieutenant positions. *At the time of this review, BPD had some dynamic management challenges that created the current structure. 62. CPSM recommends the department develop a standardized process for the selection of FTOs because of the impact an FTO can have on the department. 63. It is recommended that the department consider completing an annual performance evaluation on each FTO to ensure they are performing up to the program’s standards. 64. CPSM recommends that a one-year cap be put on the FTO position after appointment; however, upon receiving a satisfactory review, the FTO can be extended for an additional year. 65. CPSM recommends that the department define the amount of experience required for the FTO position. Records (See pp. 116-121) 66. CPSM recommends the department ensure that the SOP and the procedure manual for Records are reviewed and updated annually. 67. Consideration should be given to implementing an online reporting option for select crimes. 68. Consideration should be given to implementing an online service that enables citizens to access traffic accident reports to free up employees’ time for other duties. 69. Eliminate the acceptance of cash for department transactions at the public counter to remove an unnecessary risk to the Town, BPD, and its staff. 70. The department should consider placing a payment kiosk in the lobby of the station. 71. CPSM recommends that the department conduct an ergonomic study of the two employees’ work stations. FOIA (See pp. 121-122) 72. If delays begin occurring due to an increasing number of FOIA requests, the department should add an additional FTE to the unit. 73. The department should purchase software that enables tracking of FOIA requests to be done more easily and efficiently than manually logging them. 74. CPSM recommends the Records Unit track the amount of time spent on fulfilling FOIA requests to determine in the future if additional personnel are needed. Property and Evidence (See pp. 122-128) 75. CPSM would recommend creating an SOP defining ONLY how the P&E room operates. Page 23 Section VI. Item # a. 8 76. CPSM recommends the policy be reviewed annually for changes in law and procedure. 77. CPSM encourages the department to have the P&E technician attend classes provided by IAPE, and as well attend conferences and local training regarding P&E. 78. CPSM would encourage the department to continue to ensure the auditing of the P&E is completed as stated in the policy. 79. CPSM recommends that the technician develop a purging pattern and cycle to reduce the intake deficit. 80. CPSM recommends the department purchase a key locker that requires a key fob or key card entry to provide a record of who opens it to obtain the keys. 81. CPSM recommends the department put a computer and bar code machine in the processing area to expedite the process and avoid redundances. 82. It is imperative that the bar scanning device is repaired to allow the technician to be more efficient. 83. CPSM recommends the department consider creating two secure rooms within the storage area to store narcotics and weapons. 84. It is recommended that a new safe be purchased or the current safe be repaired. 85. CPSM recommends the department install an alert monitor on the refrigerator. 86. The department should ensure that a weapons destruction is conducted at least once a year, and that when that takes place, the technician is escorted by two armed officers. 87. CPSM recommends the department assign an armed officer to accompany the technician when transporting narcotics. 88. CPSM recommends the technician become IAPE-certified. Quartermaster (See pp. 128-130) 89. CPSM recommends that a key (fob/card) entry be installed on the door to the quartermaster’s office. 90. For reliable accountability and tracking of the department’s equipment and inventory, CPSM recommends the agency purchase asset tracking software. 91. CPSM recommends the agency take advantage of grant opportunities such as the Patrick Leahy Bulletproof Vest Partnership offered by the Bureau of Justice. Facility (See pp. 130-132) 92. CPSM recommends the Town begin considering the options available to enlarge the department’s workspace to better accommodate the needs of the department’s expected growth. 93. CPSM recommends consideration be given to allowing the civilian employees who must drive their personnel vehicles to work be allowed to park in the rear parking lot. Fleet (See pp. 132-134) 94. It is recommended that the department purchase a fleet management system to effectively track maintenance and repairs for its police vehicles. Page 24 Section VI. Item # a. 9 Communications / Dispatch (See pp. 134-137) 95. CPSM would encourage the department to form an advisory board of those agencies contracting with Beaufort County Communications. 96. CPSM urges the department to review its CAD call priorities and limit Priority 1 calls to those involving life-safety or in-progress calls. (Recommendation No. 97.) 97. CPSM would recommend the department initiate a conversation with the county’s communication manager about the reasons for the excessive time on P-1 calls. IT / Technology (See pp. 138-139) 98. CPSM recommends consideration be given to forming and implementing an IT Committee. § § § Page 25 Section VI. Item # a. 10 SECTION 2. METHODOLOGY Data Analysis CPSM used numerous sources of data to support our conclusions and recommendations for the Bluffton Police Department. Information was obtained from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, Part I offenses, along with numerous internal information sources. UCR Part I crimes are defined as murder, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, larceny-theft, and larceny of a motor vehicle. Internal sources included data from the computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system for information on calls for service (CFS). All data, analysis, and recommendations, especially for patrol operations, are based upon CPSM’s examination of 37,251 CAD events during the period of May 1, 2023, through April 30, 2024, which are those calls handled by the department’s patrol officers. Of those 37,251 calls noted, 10,175 were community-initiated calls requiring service, and 13,167 were calls initiated by Bluffton police officers. Interviews This study relied extensively on intensive interviews with personnel. Remote (Zoom meetings), on-site, and in-person interviews were conducted with people throughout the organization and the town. Focus Groups A focus group is an unstructured group interview in which the moderator actively encourages discussion among participants. Group discussion permits greater exploration of topics. For the purposes of this study, focus groups were held with a representative cross-section of employees within the department. Document Review CPSM consultants were furnished with numerous reports and summary documents by the Bluffton Police Department. Information on planning, personnel staffing, deployment, monthly reports, annual reports, operations manuals, evaluations, training records, and performance statistics were all reviewed by project team staff. Follow-up emails and phone calls were used to clarify information as needed. Operational/Administrative Observations Numerous observations were conducted over the course of the evaluation period. These included observations of general patrol operations, investigations, and administrative services such as records, property and evidence, professional standards, and administrative functions. CPSM representatives engaged in all facets of department operations from a “participant observation” perspective. Staffing Analysis In virtually all CPSM studies, we are asked to identify appropriate staffing levels. That is the case in this study as well. This report will discuss workload, operational and safety conditions, and other factors to be considered in establishing appropriate staffing levels. Staffing recommendations are based on our comprehensive evaluation of all relevant factors. Page 26 Section VI. Item # a. 11 SECTION 3. COMMUNITY OVERVIEW The Town of Bluffton is located near the southern tip of South Carolina, near the border with Georgia. Located in the center of Beaufort County, Bluffton is affectionately known as the “Heart of the Lowcountry.” The Town is part of the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Port Royal, South Carolina Metropolitan Statistical Area and is among the fastest-growing municipalities in the state. Bluffton was incorporated in 1852 as a one-square-mile town located on a bluff above the May River. The Town has experienced significant growth since 1998 and today encompasses approximately 54 square miles. According to the U.S. Census, Bluffton’s population was only 738 in 1990; by 2000, it had grown to just 1,275. At that point, exponential growth occurred. The 2010 census indicated the population had grown more than 800 percent to 12,530. By 2020, it was officially 27,716; in 2023, the population was estimated to be 35,243 people. The original downtown area still exists and is a very charming southern community that attracts visitors and residents with its mix of business, retail, and restaurants. It should be noted that the square mileage of the Town is considered to be accurate in terms of the patrol area that Bluffton PD is responsible for. However, the patrol area may be larger due to the fact that unincorporated Beaufort County has several areas in and around Bluffton. Those county “pockets” would make for an overall larger area for patrol purposes since BPD units frequently drive through them to other Bluffton patrol areas. The population numbers, on the other hand, may be lower as the census figures do not separate county areas that are called “Bluffton” from the Town. If the population of those county areas were deducted from the Town’s population total, then the official “residents” of the Town of Bluffton would be lower than reported here. The department and the Town did not have a revised population number for the residents within Town boundaries. We observed a community that is a mix of residential developments and commercial developments. However, it was difficult to always distinguish what was official Town area and what areas were considered Bluffton but were actually county areas. Bluffton has a “council-manager” form of government. The Town Council has five members: a mayor, a mayor pro-tempore, and three council members. Demographics Select demographic data from the U.S. Census is noted in the following table. The table shows data from the Town of Bluffton compared to Beaufort County, the State of South Carolina, and the United States. As one can see, Bluffton’s growth is significant and makes the community an outlier when compared to other communities. It is rare to see communities grow in both population as well as land area, as is the case in Bluffton. It is worth noting that Bluffton is statistically better in many categories such as owner-occupied housing, income, education, and poverty levels versus the county-state-national averages. At the same time, Bluffton is a somewhat more expensive community to live in, with higher median housing and rent prices. The population density is also significantly higher than the state and national averages and will continue to increase as the population grows. Page 27 Section VI. Item # a. 12 TABLE 3-1: U.S. Census Data (Town, County, State, and US) Bluffton, SC Beaufort County South Carolina United States Population 2020 27,718 187,106 5,118,422 331,464,948 Estimated Population 2023 35,243 198,979 5,373,555 334,914,895 White 77.10% 79.10% 68.90% 75.50% Black / African American 8.60% 16.70% 26.30% 13.60% Hispanic 13.10% 11.20% 6.60% 19.10% Two or More Races 6.10% 2.10% 2.20% 3.00% Asian 0.80% 1.50% 2.00% 6.30% Owner-Occupied Housing 82.30% 75.50% 70.90% 64.80% Median Housing Value $390,290 $377,900 $216,200 $281,900 Median Gross Rent $2,050 $1,435 $1,065 $1,268 High School Grad., age 25+ 96.80% 93.60% 89.30% 89.10% Bachelor’s Degree 46.50% 43.40% 30.60% 34.30% Median Household Income $99,575 $81,260 $63,623 $75,149 Persons in Poverty 5.50% 10.00% 14.00% 11.50% Land Area 2010 51.3 Sq. Mi 576 Sq Mi 30,064 Sq Mi 3,531,905 Sq Mi Land Area 2020 51.97 Sq Mi 576 Sq Mi 30,064 Sq Mi 3,533,038 Sq Mi 2010 Population Sq. Mile 244.2 281.5 153.9 87.4 2020 Population Sq Mile 533.3 324.8 170.3 93.8 LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES The Town of Bluffton is served by the Bluffton Police Department (BPD). The BPD has primary jurisdictional responsibilities over all incorporated areas within the Town limits. There are unincorporated areas of Bluffton and neighboring jurisdictions, such as Hilton Head Island, and which are patrolled by the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Department. There are also nearby and neighboring police departments that are within the general vicinity of the Town of Bluffton. Although these departments have their own geographic patrol responsibilities, they are all seen within the Town limits on a regular basis, and because these agencies share the same radio channel for primary dispatch operations, they often assist one another on calls. BPD provides all necessary daily police operations to the community, including patrol, school resource officers, and investigations. Some services, such as dispatching, crime scene processing, and special operations (SWAT), are delivered on a regional model. Bluffton PD Mission, Vision, and Core Values Our Mission is to protect and serve the Town of Bluffton with Professionalism, Excellence, Integrity, Dignity, and Respect, with an emphasis on Community Policing and Enforcing the law to enhance the quality of life for all. Page 28 Section VI. Item # a. 13 Vision The Bluffton Police Department will strive to be innovative, progressive, and transparent. We are committed to serving our team and the community with integrity, courage, and professionalism. Core Values The Core Values of BDP make up the acronym S.H.I.E.L.D.: Serving with Compassion Honor Integrity Excellence Leadership Dedication Uniform Crime Reports While communities differ from one another in population, demographics, geographical landscape, and socio-economic characteristics, comparisons to other jurisdictions can be helpful in illustrating how crime rates in Bluffton measure up against those of other South Carolina communities as well as the nation overall. The FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program assembles data on crime from police departments across the United States; the reports are utilized to measure the extent, fluctuation, and distribution of crime. For reporting purposes, criminal offenses are divided into two categories: Part 1 offenses and Part 2 offenses. For Part 1 offenses, representing the most serious crimes, the UCR index is split into two categories: violent crimes and property crimes. Violent crimes include murder, rape, robbery, and aggravated assault. Property crimes include burglary, larceny, and motor vehicle theft. Crime rates are expressed (indexed) as the number of incidents per 100,000 population to allow for comparison. The following tables and figures include the most recent information that is publicly available at the national level. This includes crime reports for 2013 through 2022 and clearance rates for 2021 and 2022. In comparing Bluffton data with other South Carolina jurisdictions, one can see that BPD reports both violent crime property crime rates that are significantly lower than other comparable South Carolina communities and that are significantly lower than the U.S. average for all communities. These reported numbers would indicate that Bluffton is a very safe community. § § § Page 29 Section VI. Item # a. 14 TABLE 3-2: Reported Crime Rates in 2021 and 2022, by Jurisdiction Municipality State 2021 2022 Population Crime Rates Population Crime Rates Violent Property Total Violent Property Total Beaufort SC 13,293 361 3,588 3,949 13,003 331 3,084 3,415 Goose Creek SC 45,901 292 1,732 2,024 46,665 289 1,830 2,119 Hanahan SC 29,582 260 1,312 1,572 22,320 403 1,470 1,873 Hardeeville SC 9,332 536 2,004 2,540 9,995 240 2,651 2,891 Moncks Corner SC 13,108 526 2,647 3,174 13,906 618 2,855 3,473 Mount Pleasant SC 95,657 98 1,104 1,202 93,951 128 1,366 1,493 Orangeburg SC 12,335 2,067 5,934 8,002 12,307 1,739 5,753 7,492 Port Royal SC 14,970 307 1,283 1,590 13,430 261 1,266 1,526 Summerville SC 54,438 244 1,977 2,221 51,423 369 2,738 3,108 Walterboro SC 5,303 1,263 6,713 7,977 5,432 957 7,493 8,450 Bluffton SC 30,519 85 737 822 36,064 69 613 682 South Carolina 5,190,705 533 2,605 3,138 5,282,634 519 2,456 2,975 National *332,031,554 396 1,933 2,329 332,403,650 380 1,954 2,334 Note: *We used national crime and clearance rates for 2021 as estimated in the FBI’s report The Transition to the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS): A Comparison of 2020 and 2021 NIBRS Estimates. The following figure visually represents the violent and property crime rates for Bluffton from 2013 through 2022. Violent crime has declined slightly (albeit from a very low starting point), while property crime overall has declined considerably over that period of time. FIGURE 3-1: Reported Bluffton Violent and Property Crime Rates, by Year 05001,0001,5002,0002,5003,0003,500 2013201420152016201720182019202020212022ViolentProperty Page 30 Section VI. Item # a. 15 The following figure compares the 10-year trend in crime rate for Bluffton versus South Carolina. Again, Bluffton has a lower rate overall and has also seen a significantly steeper crime drop during the 2013 to 2022 period. FIGURE 3-2: Reported Bluffton and South Carolina Crime Rates, by Year § § § - 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 4,000 4,500 2013201420152016201720182019202020212022BlufftonSouth Carolina Page 31 Section VI. Item # a. 16 TABLE 3-3: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Rates, by Year Year Bluffton South Carolina National Population Violent Property Total Population Violent Property Total Population Violent Property Total 2013 13,047 376 2,905 3,280 4,800,816 502 3,581 4,083 321,947,240 362 2,627 2,989 2014 13,755 240 3,352 3,591 4,856,207 489 3,415 3,904 324,699,246 357 2,464 2,821 2015 15,689 229 2,097 2,326 4,919,429 489 3,260 3,748 327,455,769 368 2,376 2,744 2016 17,498 143 1,526 1,669 4,984,808 501 3,220 3,721 329,308,297 383 2,353 2,736 2017 20,024 205 1,648 1,853 5,024,369 506 3,196 3,702 325,719,178 383 2,362 2,745 2018 22,578 221 1,116 1,337 5,084,127 488 3,018 3,506 327,167,434 369 2,200 2,568 2019 24,812 185 887 1,072 5,148,714 511 2,940 3,452 328,239,523 379 2,010 2,489 2020 27,549 91 722 813 5,118,425 556 2,842 3,398 331,449,281 399 1,958 2,357 2021 30,519 85 737 822 5,190,705 533 2,605 3,138 332,031,554 396 1,933 2,329 2022 36,064 69 613 682 5,282,634 519 2,456 2,975 332,403,650 380 1,954 2,334 § § § Page 32 Section VI. Item # a. 17 SECTION 4. ADMINISTRATION Chief Joseph Babkiewicz is the current police chief in the Town of Bluffton. He reports directly to the Town Manager. The Town has experienced significant turnover in the police chief position; it was reported to us that six different police chiefs have served in this role in the last 10 years. With that level of turnover during a time of significant department growth, the structure of the organization has evolved and changed quickly. The following figure is the current organizational chart provided to CPSM. FIGURE 4-1: Bluffton Police Department Organizational Chart (July 2024) The police department is divided into two primary divisions, each led by a police captain. The Operations Division is comprised of Patrol and Investigations. The Support Division encompasses myriad responsibilities ranging from traditional civilian employee functions (such as Records) to Special Operations. Each of these divisions and their responsibilities will be discussed in greater detail in this report. However, here we will offer some observations about the structure of this organizational chart. ■ The department's internal affairs (IA) function is under the police chief. It is normal for the IA function to answer directly to the police chief, and we will make recommendations to support that. However, no separate IA function currently exists within the agency. ■ The Patrol Division is staffed with two lieutenants, each managing two patrol teams. This chart reflects that all four teams report directly to one lieutenant. Page 33 Section VI. Item # a. 18 ■ At present, the K9 function consists of one bloodhound. That K9 is not a patrol asset and is not part of the patrol function. ■ The “Marine Patrol” is not a full-time function. It is seasonal and staffed by school resource officers (SROs) only occasionally when they are not working at the schools. Patrol reported to us that the function is not managed within the division. ■ Under Investigations, the domestic violence and victim advocate function are staffed by one sworn officer. ■ The “Crime Scene Unit” is actually a regional function that does not report to the BPD Investigations hierarchy. Some BPD officers do work on this regional team. ■ “Narcotics” does not exist. ■ The “Intel” function is an ancillary function of a lieutenant and not a unit in the department. ■ “CAT,” Traffic, and Bike Patrol do not currently exist in the department. An organizational chart should accurately reflect a visual representation of the chain of command as well as an accurate representation of department’s teams, functions, and capabilities. In defense of BPD, the department said some of these functions would exist if the department were fully staffed (Traffic and CAT), and it's not uncommon to list a function that is only staffed part-time so long as it actually falls under the correct manager/supervisor. Additionally, as staffing changes, these charts may change, and they are sometimes challenging to keep up to date unless it is a mandated expectation in the agency. It is also worth noting that the department did have another document that listed each assignment/team and the employees at each rank occupying those positions. As changes occur, it is a good practice to constantly update assignment lists and organizational charts and date them to indicate when they are “effective.” Maintaining those documents will allow the department always to look back to know who may have been responsible for a certain area of operations at a given time in history. Additionally, an up-to-date org chart allows department employees outside of management to know who may be responsible for department functions at any given time. We are confident that this occurs to some degree within the agency but clearly it is not kept current at all times. Alignment of Responsibilities and Reporting Another observation made in this area is the misalignment of responsibilities and the nexus to the job/title of individual managers. Examples include: ■ The Emergency Manager is currently managing the field training program. That is a function that normally falls directly under patrol where the activity is taking place or under training for consistency in management. ■ Community Mental Health: This position is a function that assists the Patrol Division yet is assigned to Investigations. ■ Policy, Training, and Internal Affairs often have a nexus, and in many agencies the size of BPD those functions are often consolidated in one position. In some respects, BPD appears to assign tasks and functions based on past job assignments that follow managers into new assignments or by personality. A key part of professional development within policing involves transferring managers from time to time into different positions to broaden an individual’s experience and exposure to different areas of police operations. Attaching a function to an individual stagnates the professional development of the organization. If a transfer occurs, there should be cross-training and a handoff of the Page 34 Section VI. Item # a. 19 responsibility from one person to another. The responsibility should not be moved to another area of the department because the employee has moved. We believe that BPD should reset its organizational chart and align functions where they belong within the organization. All functions that have a nexus to Patrol should belong under Patrol. For instance, if fuller staffing allows the department to staff traffic units in the future, the department needs to determine if the units will be individual traffic officers assigned to patrol teams or if they will work as part of a larger stand-alone Traffic Unit. BPD’s size would imply that they will be a single officer working with a patrol team and working under the on-duty team sergeant. As such, the function would likely belong under Patrol in the future. If the function grows into a dedicated unit of motorcycle enforcement officers, then separating them due to the additional complexity of the assignment, equipment, and training may justify moving them within the organizational chart to a specialized unit. Management Staffing We also believe that BPD is overstaffed in the management ranks. There are nine management positions in the organization. Although each of the positions has areas of responsibility, we believe that collectively the workload for managers is much lighter than we would normally see in a police organization. We have provided ideas for assignment restructuring to the Police Chief. There are different ways to restructure but we strongly believe at least one management position could be reclassified into an operational position to assist in staffing elsewhere in the organization. In an exit meeting with the Police Chief, we discussed some of the potential areas that could be restructured. The Bluffton Police Department is authorized for 66 sworn positions and 18 civilian positions. The following table depicts the authorized and current state of the department’s staffing. Page 35 Section VI. Item # a. 20 TABLE 4-1: Department Staffing Position F/T Authorized 2024 F/T Actual (July 2024) Part-Time Sworn Police Chief 1 1 Captain 2 2 Lieutenant 6 6 Sergeant 10 10 Corporal 12 12 Police Officer 29 23 Class 3 Officer (SRO) 6 6 Sworn Total 66 60 Civilian Accreditation Manager 1 1 Records - FOIA Administrator 1 1 Records - Evidence Administrator 1 1 Code Enforcement Officer 1 1 Community Services Assistant 2 2 Data Entry Clerk 1 1 1 Senior Crossing Guard 1 Crossing Guard 6 Mental Health Advocate 1 1 Quartermaster 1 1 Receptionist 1 Civilian Total 9 9 9 Grand Total 75 69 9 Note: These totals change frequently. They depict a filled position, but in some cases, the person occupying the position may not be actively working (i.e., long-term injury, administrative Reasons, etc.) Accreditation The Bluffton Police Department is accredited by the Commission on Law Enforcement Accreditation (CALEA). It was first certified as CALEA compliant on March 21, 2009. The agency was re-accredited on March 21, 2012; March 21, 2015; March 21, 2018; and most recently in 2022. As part of this assessment, we reviewed the most recent CALEA inspection report dated October 11, 2022. Although the department meets standards in a vast majority of areas, there were areas of department operations and existing policy that were cited as being an issue. Page 36 Section VI. Item # a. 21 Some of those same areas will be highlighted in this report, specifically in the area of data-driven enforcement work. Strategic Planning Strategic planning is an organizational management activity that is used to set priorities, focus energy and resources, strengthen operations, ensure that employees and other stakeholders are working toward common goals, establish agreement around intended outcomes/results, and assess and adjust the organization’s direction in response to a changing environment. It is a disciplined effort that produces fundamental decisions and actions that shape and guide what an organization is, who it serves, what it does, and why it does it, with a focus on the future. Effective strategic planning articulates not only where an organization is headed, and the actions needed to make progress, but also how it will know if it is successful. In all of our assessments we look to verify that the department is engaged in strategic planning. BPD provided to us a strategic planning document for the period of 2023 through 2026. The plan includes the following goals: ■ Building Trust and Legitimacy. ■ Policy and Oversight. ■ Technology and Social Media. ■ Community Policing and Crime Reduction. ■ Training and Education. ■ Officer Safety and Wellness. Each of the six goals has a number of objectives, with corresponding action items (“activities"). The Strategic Plan calls for the Strategic Planning Committee to meet quarterly; the Committee is to update the plan once per year in order to document progress or make adjustments as necessary. We made inquiries with the department leadership and learned that the required quarterly meetings were occurring in accordance with the plan. Succession Planning For many smaller and mid-sized police departments such as the Bluffton PD, succession planning is difficult and often informal. Oftentimes, resources can be scarce, and it can be difficult to have key management personnel away for any length of time for professional development. Additionally, many smaller agencies find it difficult to outline specific and desired training and remain on task simply due to the dynamics of a smaller agency. In discussions with BPD we learned that no document currently exists that outlines all necessary and desired training for employees who reach certain milestones in their career. Additionally, the State of South Carolina does not mandate that certified officers of a certain rank must attend and complete certain courses for professional development. BPD does list desired training for officers in select positions. For instance, for newly promoted supervisors there are courses on supervision hosted by FBI LEEDA; BPD has started sending supervisors to these courses. Similarly, for managers the desired training is the FBI Academy, SPSC (Northwestern School of Professional Studies), or SMIP (PERF). Succession planning should not be confused with developing certain individuals for future leadership roles in the agency. Rather, it should be a process that develops all personnel within Page 37 Section VI. Item # a. 22 the organization to be successful in their current role and prepare them for future leadership roles. The process should be inclusive of all employees. Many departments, either by policy or state mandate will ensure that supervisors will attend a specific police supervision course within one year of a promotion into that position. Similar mandates exists for officers in certain specialized positions, investigators as well as managers. BPD informed us that a draft document was being developed that would hopefully serve this purpose. The specific manager that had been assigned to this project recently separated from the agency, thereby creating uncertainty on the progress or timeline for completion. Department Policy Manual BPD maintains its policy manual on a platform called PowerDMS. This platform holds all policy documents, is readily available to all department personnel, and includes an attestation component so the department can verify that an officer has received the policy. In our experience, PowerDMS is a valuable platform and performs well for organizations that use it. The individual policies in place at the Bluffton Police Department are a mix of internally generated polices as well as sample policies provided by the International Association of Chiefs of Police. While reviewing many of the policies within the platform we found a mix of current policies that we would deem as adhering to current best practices and older policies that need an update. Because individual policies in the BPD are signed by the police chief when implemented and because of the frequent changeover at that position we found many of the policies to contain the signature of past chiefs and not the current chief. The department recently assembled a Policy Review Committee comprised of various members of the department. Their task is to review at least three policies per month, look for updated versions of the same policy in the industry (IACP or other departments), make updates to the specific BPD policy, and submit the revised policy for review and approval. The Police Chief is the first step in the review/approval process. The policy is then forwarded to the department’s citizens review committee, which often will offer suggestions. If suggestions are offered the policy is sent back to the department’s policy review committee for consideration. If no additional suggestions are offered the Police Chief signs the policy and implements it departmentwide. BPD officers will be directed to the PowerDMS system to receive and read the new policy. We inquired with department leadership if there were any legal reviews by the Town’s legal counsel (or other legal entity with the department’s interest in mind) and learned that no legal review takes place. We believe this is an important step in the policy review and implementation process for any police department. Any legal proceedings that involve the agency and the Town are likely to have a nexus to the department’s documented policies. Oftentimes, the nuanced nature of the English language can have an impact on those legal proceedings. Having legal counsel review a policy from both a legal standpoint as well as a wording standpoint can offer valuable protections in the future. Policy Subscription Service There are several areas of this report in which we will explore select department policies. In some cases, we will recommend changes or updates to those policies. In addition to the policies we will identify for change along with the recommended legal review, we are also advising the use of a policy subscription service to close the gap in current policy shortfalls. A policy subscription service provides an agency with a state-specific, legally reviewed policy manual tailored to the specific functions that exists within that agency. As changes take place Page 38 Section VI. Item # a. 23 at the legislative level or within industry best practices, those policies are automatically updated for the agency. The subscription platform also provides the same capability as PowerDMS with a chain of distribution, read receipts, and attestation that individual employees received the “current” version of a policy. Furthermore, portions of these platforms have a training and testing component that regularly have officers review select policies and demonstrate knowledge, proficiency, and proper application on that policy through the use of testing and scenario-based questions. This is a permanent record of an officer receiving and “understanding” the current policy. In our experience, the initial implementation process for a subscription platform can be time-consuming, since all policies are reviewed and certain updates need to be made. Additionally, there are certain policies that are agency specific (e.g., promotional process policy) and which need to be added into the subscription platform. With a current policy review committee already in place, and with what we observed as additional workload capacity for some department managers, we believe Bluffton PD is well positioned to absorb the work involved in transitioning to a policy subscription project. The future benefits are significant because all policy updates are more streamlined and attestation is included. Administrative Recommendations: ■ CPSM recommends that BPD maintain an up-to-date operational chart and department assignment list. (Recommendation No. 1.) ■ CPSM recommends that BPD reorganize the department organization chart so that functions are placed where there is a natural nexus to other department functions. (Recommendation No. 2.) ■ CPSM recommends that BPD eliminate at least one management position (captain or lieutenant) and reclassify it as an operational position (officer or corporal). (Recommendation No. 3.) ■ We recommend that BPD pursue and complete the development of a department succession plan. (Recommendation No. 4.) ■ We recommend that BPD engage its legal counsel for a review of all critical policies recently updated through the department’s current review process. (Recommendation No. 5.) ■ We recommend that BPD involve legal counsel in all policy updates going forward. (Recommendation No. 6.) ■ We recommend that BPD consider purchasing a policy subscription service to replace its current policy manual and internal policy process. (Recommendation No. 7.) PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS Ensuring the department has the public’s trust is vital to the law enforcement mission, and this trust rests on departmental responsiveness to community needs and expectations. Because the effectiveness of any police agency is dependent upon its reputation for integrity within the community, an Internal Affairs Unit for investigating serious violations of the law and violations of department policy by police officers should be established by all police departments, and Bluffton PD has done so. An Internal Affairs unit should act with integrity, be responsive to complaints from both inside and outside the agency, and keep an accurate record of its activities. The unit should strive to preserve the public's trust and confidence by conducting thorough and impartial investigations of alleged employee misconduct, providing proactive Page 39 Section VI. Item # a. 24 measures to prevent such misconduct, and by maintaining the highest standards of fairness and respect towards the citizens and employees. Citizens should not be discouraged from presenting complaints; every complaint should be recorded and the progress of any investigation monitored. PSB Staffing The department does not have a designated Professional Standards/Internal Affairs Unit. When a complaint is made, the complaint is assigned to one of several people in the department who have previously handled complaint investigations or who has attended internal affairs training. Usually, those complaints are assigned to a lieutenant within the organization, As mentioned above, the responsibility for completing all investigations usually falls upon the shoulders of a lieutenant. In most agencies studied by CPSM, sergeants will also conduct complaint investigations. In the case of BPD, CPSM recommends the department begin assigning complaints involving minor policy violations, such as rudeness, to the Patrol sergeants if the involved officer works for them. Doing this will assist in the development of supervisors in conducting personnel investigations. Due to the importance of an Internal Affairs Unit, the department should consider creating a Professional Standards/Internal Affairs Unit, staffed with either a lieutenant or sergeant who will act as the gatekeeper for all investigations to ensure they are completed in a timely manner, completed thoroughly, and that the information about the complaint and any investigations is maintained in the department’s records. This lieutenant or sergeant should report directly to the Chief of Police regarding Professional Standards/Internal Affairs issues. If the department were to move forward with the unit, CPSM recommends that the person in the assignment be rotated every three years. Since the department is fortunate and handles only a few complaint investigations each year, the position could also oversee the department’s training, policy, and personnel. Each of those are intertwined with internal affairs. Internal Affairs Training Each member of the department who is assigned to investigate complaint investigations should attend an Internal Affairs school, which will provide that knowledge necessary to complete the investigations. Currently at BPD, there are only several of the lieutenants who have received that training. CPSM would recommend that every sergeant in the organization be sent to internal affairs training. Policy All policies pertaining to the complaint process are found in the Bluffton Police Department Standard Operating Procedures, Section #032. According to the SOP, the last review of this policy was effective in 2011. CPSM recommends that all policies, especially those involving citizen and personnel complaints, be reviewed annually. Complaint Process BPD will accept and address all complaints of misconduct in accordance with its policies and applicable federal, state and local law, municipal and county rules, and the requirements of any collective bargaining agreements. Any person who witnesses or has direct knowledge of police misconduct or unlawful behavior may file a complaint, including those persons wishing to Page 40 Section VI. Item # a. 25 remain anonymous. Complaints may be filed by anyone in person, by written correspondence, via telephone, or anonymously. The complaint form can be obtained on the department’s website and is a fillable form that can then be submitted via the website. Complaints of a serious nature that are assigned to Internal Affairs (formal complaints) may include allegations of corruption, brutality, excessive use of force, breach of civil rights, criminal misconduct, or those assigned by the Chief of Police. Complaints that are considered minor in nature may include alleged rudeness on the part of the member/employee, insubordination or tardiness, etc. and may be assigned by Internal Affairs to the member's/employee’s division. Oftentimes the complaints come to a supervisor or the watch commander who may suggest appropriate remedies to resolve minor incidents; however, citizens are not discouraged from filing a complaint. The supervisor/watch commander has the authority to handle the matter with discretion and make the appropriate resolution without a formal complaint. Many citizens only want to make their issue known to the department, be listened to, and know that their incident will be handled appropriately. Although this does come with some risk that supervisors may “kiss off” complaints, if the supervisors are appropriately trained there can be an effective and efficient resolution to an incident. BPD must ensure, through ongoing discussions of personnel performance, that supervisors are making these “informal” complaint decisions utilizing a full understanding of the department’s mission. Allowing the informal resolution of complaints is a common and accepted practice in most law enforcement agencies. BPD should be commended for the trust it has in its supervisors in allowing them to resolve minor incidents without a formal complaint being filed. Oftentimes when these minor incidents are handled informally, if they are not properly documented, then a pattern of employee misconduct can be missed. It is imperative that some type of documentation occurs when incidents are informally handled. All complaints, even those handled informally, should be documented in the Shield database. The department attempts to complete investigations as quickly and carefully as possible, and for service-level complaints the department attempts to complete them within 45 calendar days. However, the Chief of Police may allow extensions in increments of no more than 45 calendar days. Complex investigations are sometimes outsourced to other agencies if they involve members of senior staff, or if there is any possibility of it involving a crime. In fact, the department has used the Beaufort County Sheriff and SLED to conduct investigations. Complaint Classifications Upon intake of a complaint by the agency, the complaint can be classified or separated into four different categories: ■ Information Report: Any allegation not resulting in a conclusion due to lack of information or evidence. ■ Personnel Complaint: The Internal Affairs section may investigate cases where allegations do not involve moral or ethical issues or refer them to the division commander of the affected member/employee. ■ Shooting Incident Complaint: Any incident where a member discharges an authorized firearm on or off duty, except for hunting or practice purposes. Internal Affairs will investigate these cases. Internal Affairs will notify SLED when appropriate. Page 41 Section VI. Item # a. 26 ■ Internal Affairs Complaint: Internal Affairs will investigate all cases where allegations of a serious nature might result in written reprimand, suspension, demotion, or termination. Dispositions Once an investigation is completed, a disposition is assigned to it based upon what was determined to have occurred or not have occurred during the alleged incident that was investigated. ■ UNFOUNDED: The allegation is false or not factual. ■ EXONERATED: The incident complained of occurred but was lawful and proper. ■ NOT SUSTAINED: Insufficient evidence to either prove or disprove the allegation. ■ SUSTAINED: The allegation is supported by sufficient evidence. ■ POLICY FAILURE: The allegation is true but the member/employee was acting in a manner consistent with agency policy, necessitating a review and revision of the policy as written; or no policy exists covering his/her action. All investigations are conducted consistently; interviews conducted during the investigations are recorded, and remain a part of the investigation. BPD’s method of conducting personnel investigations is consistent with best practices, and follows the way that most law enforcement organizations operate regarding personnel investigations. Complaint Investigations All complaint data in the following tables was provided by the department and reflect the total number of citizen/internal complaints for 2018 through 2022. TABLE 4-2: Citizen Complaints, 2018–2022 Year No. of Citizen Complaints Received No. of Complaints Generated Internally 2018 8 0 2019 0 1 2020 1 3 2021 3 8 2022 2 3 Source: Bluffton Police Department § § § Page 42 Section VI. Item # a. 27 TABLE 4-3: Citizen/Internal Complaint Investigation Adjudications, 2018–2022 Year Total Unfounded Exonerated Not Sustained Sustained 2018 11 1 0 6 4 2019 2 0 0 0 2 2020 4 0 0 1 3 2021 11 0 1 3 7 2022 5 2 0 0 3 Source: Bluffton Police Department TABLE 4-4: Complaints vs. Police Contacts, 2022 Year Total Police Contacts Citizen Complaints 2022 37,251 2 Source: Bluffton Police Department The complaint statistics for 2022 show that there were just two citizen complaint investigations triggered from the 23,400 police contacts for that year. Thus, out of the 23,400 police contacts, only one complaint was filed for every 11,700 police officer contacts. For an agency the size of BPD and representing a community of 35,000 people, that low number of complaints regarding employee misconduct by BPD represents a well-trained department in which employees are held accountable to their department’s policies and procedures. Discipline BPD discipline is covered in Standard Operating Procedure #043 which was reviewed and revised in 2024. Effective disciplinary processes serve a number of important functions in a law enforcement agency. They punish, change behavior, signal organizational expectations internally and externally, respond to citizen complaints, and serve as an early warning tool about potential problem behaviors and tensions in the community. BPD has two levels of discipline (1) Summary Discipline (discipline administered by first-line supervisor) and (2) Major Discipline (discipline administered by the Chief of Police that ranges from a suspension of a minimum of twenty-four hours to a maximum of thirty days, up to and including termination). Discipline at BPD can be meted out in the following ways: ■ Written reprimand. ■ Suspension. ■ Emergency suspension. ■ Dismissal. Although the discipline options at BPD are common within the law enforcement profession, CPSM would also recommend the department add both Transfer and Demotion to the ways an employee can be disciplined. Education-Based Discipline A method of discipline that is not discussed in the department’s options, is Education-Based Discipline (EBD). EBD is unique to the law enforcement community and is an alternative to punitive discipline. EBD seeks to change the interaction of employees and management, and to Page 43 Section VI. Item # a. 28 change the impact of the discipline process. The premise of EBD is that it offers an alternative to unpaid suspension days and is beneficial to both the department and employee. It provides an opportunity for employees to voluntarily participate in an individualized remedial plan that emphasizes education, training, and other creative interventions which promote a successful outcome. When the department is faced with an employee’s discipline that rises to anything that results in monetary loss, EBD should be considered. Discipline should not debilitate the affected employee, and most times the employee is less bitter regarding their discipline after EBD is utilized. It was learned that in many of its discipline cases the department has used some element of education and training as a part of the discipline along with other penalties. However, when EBD is used, it should not include the other discipline penalties. CPSM recommends the department continue to consider the use of EBD in some discipline cases where applicable. Discipline Matrix The department uses a discipline matrix for ensuring a fair and consistent implementation of discipline, and in addition to associated policies and resulting disciplinary decisions, the discipline should reflect contemporary industry standards for progressive discipline. BPD is to be commended for using a discipline matrix when disciplining its employees. § § § Page 44 Section VI. Item # a. 29 TABLE 4-5: BPD Progressive Discipline Matrix § § § Page 45 Section VI. Item # a. 30 Although BPD does use a discipline matrix, the following matrix is provided for review by the department. TABLE 4-6: Example of a Standardized Progressive Discipline Matrix Class First Offense Second Offense Third Offense Fourth Offense 1 Min: Verbal counseling Min: Documented counseling Min: Documented written reprimand Min: 1-day suspension Max: Documented oral reprimand Max: Documented written reprimand Max: 3-day suspension Max: 5-day suspension 2 Min: N/A Min: Documented written reprimand Min: 1-day suspension Min: 5-day suspension Max: Documented written reprimand Max: 5-day suspension Max: 5-day suspension Max: 10-day suspension 3 Min: Documented written reprimand Min: Documented written reprimand Min: 1-day suspension Min: 30-day suspension Max: 1-day suspension Max: 10-day suspension Max: 15-day suspension Max: Dismissal 4 Min: 1-day suspension Min: 5-day suspension Min: 10-day suspension Min: Dismissal Max: 10-day suspension Max: 15-day suspension Max: 30-day suspension Max: Dismissal 5 Min: 5-day suspension Min: 10-day suspension Min: 30-day suspension Min: Dismissal Max: Dismissal Max: Dismissal Max: Dismissal Max: Dismissal Early Warning System (EWS) An Early Warning System (EWS) is used as a resource by supervisory personnel to identify employees who may display symptoms of job stress or performance problems at early stages. The intent of an EIP is to proactively provide employees with the assistance and training necessary to perform their assigned duties in an effective and efficient manner. While individual incidents such as personnel complaints, traffic collisions, and uses of force are reviewed at the time of occurrence by a supervisor, the chain of command, and the civilian auditors, these incidents may appear acceptable in isolation, but a pattern of less-than-optimal job performance may be developing that is more difficult to identify. Tracking the indicators detailed in this program allows the department to examine the totality of an individual’s actions and make a more accurate assessment of the employee’s well-being. Performance indicators are set by department management and can be modified as desired. In the BPD, the early warning system is covered in Bluffton Police Department Standard Operating Procedure 056vwhich was last revised in 2011. CPSM recommends that the EWS policy be reviewed annually. It is important to note that the notification triggered by reaching a threshold in and of itself does not suggest a definitive problem with an employee, but rather, informs the department of a high rate of total incidents. Again, this number is determined by the department. For instance, officers working in high-crime areas are more commonly involved in arrests and uses of force, which has the potential to trigger a notification even though their actions are entirely appropriate. This applies to more proactive officers as well. Nonetheless, the department can look at the Page 46 Section VI. Item # a. 31 employee’s pattern of conduct and determine if there may be a problem. If so, it may address the problem through counselling, training, or as otherwise called for. The following table is an example of a robust EWS to cover the highest liability issues, showing the number of events and the time involved for triggering action by the department. CPSM recommends BPD consider using this as the baseline for its EWS. TABLE 4-7: EWS Matrix Example Incident Type Number of Officer Events Number of Months Threshold Bias Complaint 2 6 Citizen Complaint 2 12 Internal complaint 2 12 Use of Force 3 6 Vehicle Accident 3 12 Vehicle Pursuit 4 12 Internal Affairs Recommendations: ■ CPSM recommends consideration be given to creating a Professional Standards/Internal Affairs Unit that reports directly to the Chief of Police regarding I/A issues. (Recommendation No. 8.) ■ CPSM recommends that the person in the IA assignment be rotated every three years. (Recommendation No. 9.) ■ CPSM would recommend that every sergeant in the organization be sent to internal affairs training. (Recommendation No. 10.) ■ CPSM would recommend the department add both Transfer and Demotion to the ways an employee can be disciplined. (Recommendation No. 11.) ■ CPSM recommends that all policies, especially those involving citizen and personnel complaints, be reviewed annually. (Recommendation No. 12.) ■ When the department is faced with an employee’s discipline that rises to anything that results in monetary loss, Education-Based Discipline (EBD) should be considered. (Recommendation No. 13.) USE OF FORCE The necessary and appropriate use of force in carrying out a police officer’s duties, up to and including the taking of a human life, is among the most complex and critiqued actions of law enforcement. At no time in the past has the use of force been looked at, examined, and judged as it is today. It is essential and critical that the department have and follow a comprehensive policy on the use of force. Providing relevant training for the uses of force is vital for the department. The purpose of comprehensive training in the use of force is to ensure employees are using proper and reasonable applications of force in the performance of their duties. With respect to the use of deadly force, no other responsibility of the town or department has more importance. Police departments must engage in an in-depth review of uses of force by their officers. In President Obama’s 21st Century Policing report, it was stated that departments must have in place a review process of uses of force by their officers. Page 47 Section VI. Item # a. 32 Policy The Bluffton Police Department’s Use of Force policy is found in Standard Operating Procedure #007, which was reviewed and revised in February 2024. The Use of Force policy authorizes officers to use only the amount of force which is reasonably necessary to overcome the level of resistance to secure a subject, or to stop a direct threat of harm posed by a subject, which is clearly defined within the policy. Any use of force by a member of the department shall be documented promptly, completely, and accurately in an appropriate report, depending on the nature of the incident. The officer should articulate the factors perceived and why he/she believed the use of force was reasonable under the circumstances. The Use of Force policy should be reviewed annually for any changes in law or altering any way that force is used. The policy clearly defines the use of force responses that can be used by members of the department: ■ Level 1. Officer Presence. ■ Level 2. Verbal Directions. ■ Level 3. Empty Hand Controls/Use of Aerosol Deterrent Spray. ■ Level 4. Intermediate Weapons. ■ Level 5. Incapacitation/Use of Electronic Control Device/Use of Less Lethal Shotgun. ■ Level 6. Deadly Force. The department’s investigative authority for the use of force incidents may be limited to the Chief of Police, Internal Affairs Division, or the Training Division. Any investigation that might be considered criminal in nature may be investigated by the Beaufort County Solicitor’s Office, South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED), the South Carolina Attorney General’s Office, or the FBI. CPSM recommends the Use of Force policy be reviewed annually for any changes in law or altering any way that force is used. Policy should also be reviewed to ensure the threshold of reporting is appropriate based upon best practices. Reporting Responses/Supervisor Responsibilities Officers at BPD must notify their supervisor as soon as possible about a use of force that occurs in the following circumstances: ■ An officer discharges a firearm in a duty-related capacity. This does not include firearms practice, training, qualification, or competition unless the discharge results in property damage or personal injury. A discharge of a Bluffton Police Department issued weapon, on or off duty, will be documented with an incident report. ■ The officer takes any actions that results in, or is alleged to have resulted in, any injury or death of any officer or any other person. ■ Weaponless physical force is used by the officer on an individual that produces an actual or alleged injury. A Use of Force report is not required for the use of physical force that has little or no chance of producing injuries and is being used to gain control of the suspect or restraining a non-combative individual, such as physical touching, gripping or holding, handcuffing, escorting, searching, etc. Page 48 Section VI. Item # a. 33 CPSM recommends the department consider adding to its policy the following additional requirements for reporting uses of force: ■ When the application of force would lead a reasonable officer to conclude that the individual may have experienced more than momentary discomfort. ■ The individual subjected to the force complains of injury or continuing pain. ■ The individual indicates intent to pursue litigation. ■ Any application of a restraint device other than handcuffs, shackles, or belly chains. ■ The individual subjected to the force was rendered unconscious. ■ An individual was struck or kicked. ■ An individual alleges unreasonable force was used or that any of the above has occurred. The officer must document in their official police report a complete, accurate, and appropriate description of the use of force utilized during the incident. The supervisor then will respond to the scene to investigate any incident involving an armed person, an incident involving the use of force beyond empty hand control, or which results in injury, an assault upon the officer, and resistance to arrest. The supervisor’s review includes: ■ Conducting a thorough investigation of the incident. ■ Interviewing the subject officer and reviewing the report. ■ Reviewing the report for any discrepancies or findings and signing it.. ■ Forwarding all reports to the Chief of Police through the chain of command. The Use of force report and investigation is also forwarded to the Training Division for review for any training needs that might have been noticed in the review, and then finally to the Internal Affairs Division when the Internal Affairs Commander will annually review and analyze all uses of force. Use of Force Review Reviews begin at the supervisor’s level when they respond to the scene of an incident and conduct an investigation. That investigation involves the supervisor talking to witnesses, the person the force was used upon, and a review of the officer’s body-worn camera video. The uses of force are then reviewed by the patrol lieutenant, patrol captain, and Chief of Police. Use of Force Tracking All uses of force are maintained and tracked in the department’s Shield system. Entries into the system are made by the patrol lieutenant. Duty to Intercede and Report In recent years, law enforcement agencies nationwide have begun to include duty to intercede and report provisions in their use of force policies. Duty to intercede requires an officer to intervene if they witness a department member using force that is clearly beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances. A duty to report policy requires any officer who observes a law enforcement officer or an employee use force that potentially exceeds what the officer reasonably believes to be necessary to report such observation to a supervisor. BPD has such language in its policy (which follows). Page 49 Section VI. Item # a. 34 BPD policy clearly states: 1. Any Officer present in a situation who reasonably believes that another Officer is using force in violation of law or Department policy has a duty to intervene to stop the unlawful or inappropriate use of force as long as it is safe and reasonable to do so. 2. Any Officer, on or off duty, who witnesses or is made aware of an instance of excessive, unlawful, or inappropriate use of force by another law enforcement officer of any agency has an obligation to report the situation to a supervisor or to the Internal Affairs Office as soon as practicable. 3. Any Officer has a duty to provide medical attention as long as it is safe and reasonable to do so. De-escalation Provisions De-escalation requirements are covered in the BPD policy as follows: “An officer must attempt to control all situations in which he/she is involved and must first attempt to control them by de-escalating the need for any type of physical response to resistance if the situation is such that their safety or safety of others is not in immediate danger.” TABLE 4-8: Uses of Force, 2021–2023 Year # of Uses of Force Within Policy Out of Policy Suspect Injured 2021 6 6 0 N/A 2022 8 8 0 4 2023 4 4 0 0 In the past three years, BPD has had no uses of force that were outside of its policy. From January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2023, BSPD recorded 23,400 calls for service. With four reportable use of force incidents, BPD officers used force in 0.17 percent of the calls. This percentage is extremely low and represents a well-trained department. Use of Force Recommendations: ■ The Use of Force policy should be reviewed annually for any changes in law or altering any way that force is used. (Recommendation No. 14.) ■ CPSM recommends adding additional language to the reporting requirements. (Recommendation No. 15.) ■ Policy should also be reviewed to ensure the threshold of reporting is appropriate based upon best practices. (Recommendation No. 16.) EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT The emergency management function for the Town of Bluffton, while a shared responsibility of all, is coordinated by the Bluffton Police Department. Coordination of emergency management responsibilities is assigned to the Emergency Manager, a police lieutenant. This is a full-time assignment, though as with most police management positions, there are collateral duties. Collateral duties include management of the Field Training Officer program, as an instructor for Page 50 Section VI. Item # a. 35 various use of force methodologies, and captaining the police patrol boat (during non-business hours including weekends and holidays). Workload associated with these collateral duties is manageable and does not take away from the effectiveness of Emergency Manager duties. Nonetheless, some collateral duties including management of the department’s FTO program are not compatible with the Emergency Manager’s current role. The FTO coordinator is more appropriately a role for a Patrol Division supervisor. The following is copied from the Town’s description of its role in emergency management, and more specifically, that of the Emergency Manager in preparing for responses to disasters and/or emergencies, natural or man-made. “Town of Bluffton Emergency Management is tasked with planning, integrating and implementing all emergency management-related activities for the Town of Bluffton. The role of Emergency Management is to coordinate the community’s efforts to prepare for, respond to, and recover from large-scale emergencies and disasters. Emergency Management works to craft a harmonized community-wide effort through the joint collaboration of both public and private organizations responsible for providing services to the community. “Emergency Management maintains and coordinates the activities of the Town of Bluffton Emergency Operations Center (EOC) during a large-scale emergency or disaster. When activated, the EOC is the central location where representatives of local government and private sector agencies assemble during disaster situations to make decisions, set priorities and allocate resources for response and recovery efforts. The EOC functions as the Command Center for all communications, directions, and plans during a natural or man-made emergency.” Phases of Emergency Management ■ Prevention – Actions taken to avoid an incident or stopping an incident from occurring. Deterrence operations and surveillance. ■ Mitigation – Refers to measures that prevent an emergency, reduce the chance of an emergency happening, or reduce the damaging effects of unavoidable emergencies. The mitigation phase differs from the other phases because it focuses on long-term measures for reducing or eliminating risk. ■ Preparedness – Activities that increase a community’s ability to respond when a disaster occurs. In the preparedness phase, plans of action are developed for when disasters strike. ■ Response – Includes the mobilization of necessary emergency services and first responders in the disaster area. This would include a first wave of core emergency services, such as firefighters, police, and ambulance crews. ■ Recovery – To restore the affected area to its previous state. Actions taken to return a community to normal or near-normal conditions, including the restoration of basic services and the repair of physical, social, and economic damages. Policy / SOP SOP 010, Incident Command System, addresses response to major incidents be they disasters, civil unrest, or any other incident requiring extraordinary resource allocations. It addresses both field and EOC command responsibilities. The policy, seven pages in length, was reviewed by CPSM and found to be comprehensive. Page 51 Section VI. Item # a. 36 A complementary SOP, Natural Hazards (011), speaks to disasters, and more specifically hurricanes. Last updated in July 2013, the nine-page policy assigns detailed descriptions of responsibilities in three major categories; Planning and Preparation, Response, and Recovery. We note that SOP 011 was last updated in July 2013. That pre-dated the police department assuming the responsibility of Emergency Management Coordinator for the Town of Bluffton. When that responsibility was assumed by the police department, the department was granted an FTE police lieutenant position who assumed the responsibility of Emergency Manager, a full-time duty with limited collateral assignments. As we reviewed SOP 011, we noted several areas where duties which appropriately belong to the Emergency Manager were assigned to other positions within the police department including Patrol and Special Operations. As one example, the following is listed as a responsibility of the Special Operations Division: “Inventory available supplies and stored items (batteries, emergency lamps, water, fans, extension cords, etc.) quarterly. Emergency equipment is tested at least quarterly for operational readiness. Ensure that sufficient supplies are ordered and maintained in the event of a critical incident. [S.46.1.8].” These are tasks that would more appropriately be a responsibility of the Emergency Management Coordinator. We conclude that these responsibilities were established prior to the 2023 transfer of emergency management responsibilities to the police department, and the SOP was not updated at that time. Therefore, we recommend that a review of SOP 011 be conducted and revisions be made to more appropriately align responsibilities with the department’s current staffing model. EOC Locations, Staffing, and Working Groups The Emergency Operations Center (EOC) is located in the Bluffton Police Department training room. In the event that the Town of Bluffton EOC becomes unavailable for any reason, the back-up EOC is located at the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office on Duke St. in Beaufort. Staffing of the EOC during emergencies includes the follow positions / functions: ■ Emergency Manager – Responsible for overall EOC operations. ■ Mayor of Town of Bluffton – Responsible for policy decisions / declaration of emergency when appropriate. ■ Bluffton Town Manager – Responsible for implementation of policies and overall EM operations. ■ Bluffton Town Attorney – Responsible for legal advice / direction. The following list reflects working groups that may include representatives from multiple departments: ■ Planning. ■ Operations. ■ Logistics. ■ Technology. ■ Finance. Page 52 Section VI. Item # a. 37 There are no representatives from non-government organizations (NGOs) such as the Red Cross or Salvation Army in the EOC staffing complement. Such agencies are often called upon to provide assistance with food and shelter needs at emergency evacuation sites. If the services provided by one or more of these or other NGOs would be considered helpful during any or all emergencies, the Town should consider incorporating their role in the Logistics working group. We note here that while the Emergency Manager’s role is to ensure that the EOC is equipped and staffed to meet the needs of the Town during an emergency, he/she may not be considered the emergency or disaster manager for all types of incidents for which the EOC may be activated. For example, the disaster manager for a fire incident would be the Fire Chief, or designee; for a storm incident involving flooding or wind damage, it may be the Public Works director, or designee; and in an incident involving civil unrest, the Chief of Police, or designee would be the disaster manager. This allows for the department most impacted to have control over EOC operations. Staff reported that the EOC is well equipped and no additional equipment is required at this point. In addition to ensuring that the EOC is appropriately staffed and equipped, the Emergency Manager is charged with establishing contracts for emergency provisions. These include ensuring availability of emergency housing, food, and water for both Town staff working during the emergency and civilians who find themselves in need of such services. Training The current Emergency Manager has been in this role for approximately one year. He is in the process of undergoing training to achieve the status of Certified Emergency Manager. This is an extensive, ongoing process involving completion of 25 courses, some available only off-site and some available online. The courses range in duration from four hours to several days. CPSM inquired regarding training provided to EOC staff. We were advised that all EOC staff are trained in Incident Command System protocols. We also inquired regarding practical exercise training for EOC operations and were advised that this has not occurred, at least in the last few years. Such training utilizes a simulated exercise with a dynamic format. A choreographed script is prepared well in advance of the exercise and is used to prompt facilitators to provide increasingly complex challenges to each of the working groups to test their readiness to address evolving issues. This type of exercise typically lasts throughout the day and includes a debriefing at the conclusion of the exercise. This training is addressed in SOP #010, Incident Command System, Section V. C., which calls for it to be conducted biennially. The South Carolina Emergency Management Association is made up of emergency managers and others involved in EOC operations. Membership provides for excellent training as well as networking opportunities. The Bluffton Emergency Manager is a member of this organization. Personnel Consideration The Emergency Manager position has been transitory over the past several years. It has been alternately assigned between the police department, fire district, and Town Hall. As well, both commissioned officers as well as civilians have served as the Emergency Manager. It is commonplace in communities across the country that civilians serve in the role of Emergency Manager. They are often assigned to the fire department or police department. Page 53 Section VI. Item # a. 38 Here, as the EOC is located at the police department, it is appropriate for the Emergency Manager to be a police department employee. However, CPSM would urge the Town to consider civilianizing this position. It is a position that is commonly held by civilians across the country. There are a multitude of reasons for this. They include the fact that, especially in police departments, personnel are subject to both promotional opportunities and lateral movement between assignments. In fact, the current Emergency Manager intends to compete for promotion at the earliest available opportunity. If promoted, or transferred laterally within the organization, then the next, newly assigned Emergency Manager would need to undergo the rigorous process of becoming a Certified Emergency Manager as well as master the duties associated with managing the EOC in terms of systems, equipment, letting contracts, etc. Stabilizing this as a career position is in the best interests of the Town. In addition, civilian personnel are often a more cost-efficient staffing option. This recommendation is not made lightly. We understand that Bluffton has had some difficulty employing a civilian in this role, and just prior to the current police employee assuming this responsibility, it was filled by a civilian who resigned from their position. However, for long-term stability, we feel that this role is best served by a career civilian manager. Police departments across the country struggle to hire and retain commissioned officers. In fact, at present, BPD has a vacancy rate of more than ten (10) percent. As civilians can and do effectively serve in the role of Emergency Managers, there is no reason that a commissioned officer (at any rank) do so. Emergency Management Recommendations: ■ Collateral duties such as FTO coordinator are incompatible with the Emergency Manager’s present role, and should be transferred to a supervisor in the Patrol Division. (Recommendation No. 17.) ■ Review and revise SOP 011, Natural Hazards, to more appropriately align responsibilities for emergency preparedness with the department’s current staffing model. (Recommendation No. 18.) ■ Consideration should be given to incorporating non-government organizations such as the Red Cross into the EOC Logistics working group to allow for a more timely response in establishing food and shelter services at disasters. (Recommendation No. 19.) ■ Consideration should be given to ensuring that biennial dynamic practical exercise training, as called for in policy, be conducted for all EOC disciplines. (Recommendation No. 20.) ■ Consideration should be given to transitioning the Emergency Manager position from a commissioned officer to that of a career civilian position. (Recommendation No. 21.) § § § Page 54 Section VI. Item # a. 39 SECTION 5. PATROL PATROL OVERVIEW, STAFFING Division Management The Patrol Division is managed by the Operations Captain, who reports directly to the Chief of Police. Two patrol lieutenants supplement the captain, each assigned two patrol teams for administrative and managerial oversight. Each of the four patrol teams are led by a patrol sergeant who supervises the police corporals and police officers. We discussed with the staff the operational direction of the patrol teams. We learned that in some cases there are directives that may come from the Chief or the Captain for patrol to address a specific issue, often in the form of “directed patrols” or extra patrols. Outside of that specific direction from the administration, we learned that the patrol teams have traditionally evolved into their own distinct operational personalities, often based on the expectations of the sergeants leading the team. Anecdotally, we were told that some teams might focus more on traffic enforcement when not on a citizen-initiated call for service, another team may focus more on community-focused activity when not on calls, and others may engage in very little officer-initiated activity. The specific managerial oversight from those holding higher ranks in the department is more focused on managing the shift staffing and general administrative responsibilities of managing people. Almost all police departments express some concern that “communication” within their department can be improved. Bluffton PD is no exception. Although communication is a broad category and any measure of success is difficult, there are some areas that BPD may want to explore. We believe that better direction on patrol activity based on community priorities and data is important. Bluffton PD takes pride in the community it is policing. Yet, any and all unstructured officer time is left to the officers’ discretion of what they believe is important, not necessarily what the community/town/department priorities are. Management should be more proactive in this area, involving open dialogue with patrol officers and an analysis of existing crime and calls for service data. Strategic decisions on deployment and what officers focus their attention on should be a priority. Beat Structure The Town of Bluffton is divided into three patrol zones for the purpose of deploying police personnel. The following figure depicts these patrol zone areas. Although it may be difficult to make sense of for someone not familiar with the Town’s geography, the zones provide a basis for individual patrol officers to maintain a presence while on duty to best be positioned to calls that may occur within their zones. In a general sense, the area in the top right section of the map depicts the “A” zone, the area to the left of that zone is the “C” Zone, and the area at the bottom of the map is primarily the “B” zone. As the reader will notice, there are large sections within those zones that are not shaded; those are primarily unincorporated areas of Beaufort County, yet which are called Bluffton for population and census purposes. The area at the bottom of the map (within the “B” zone) is a development called Palmetto Bluff. It is nearly the same size as the rest of Bluffton, has limited access points, and travel in and out of the area can be very time-consuming for patrol officers responding to the area. BPD leadership discussed with us the possible need to have an additional unit assigned to that area alone to Page 55 Section VI. Item # a. 40 reduce response times. However, the workload within that area is light and does not justify an FTE patrol officer at this time. FIGURE 5-1: Bluffton Patrol Zones Staffing Staffing within the Patrol Division is shown in the following table. TABLE 5-1: BPD Patrol Division Staffing Authorized 2024 Actual (July 2024) Vacancies Captain 1 1 Lieutenant 2 2 Sergeant 4 4 Corporal 4 4 Police Officer 16 14 2 Total 27 25 2 Scheduling All officers and supervisors working for BPD work a 12-hour schedule. Two teams work 6:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on opposing days while the other two teams work 6:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. on opposing days of one another. BPD does not use the “make-up” day model of a 12-hour shift deployment. Rather, it uses a unique rotating version of this schedule, with officers working a select number of Page 56 Section VI. Item # a. 41 days, taking a select number off while the other team works, returning for a smaller number of days, and going back off for a smaller number of days off while the other team is working. This works out in a manner that allows all employees to work 14 days in a 28-day work cycle. It also allows for rotating days off so all employees get a weekend off at some point versus only the most senior officers who can bid for the better shifts. In addition to the 28-day cycle, the teams also switch days and nights every 56 days. The following table provides a snapshot of what a 28-day work cycle looks like: TABLE 5-2: BPD 28-Day Patrol Work Cycle Example 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 x x x x x x x 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 x x x x x x x Note: “X” Denotes a work day – Empty boxes denote a day off Law enforcement agencies around the country typically work 10- or 12-hour shift deployments. In some cases, 8-hour deployments are seen but they are becoming rarer. In our experience, 10-hour shifts require more officers but can provide the benefit of shift overlap times when workload is heavier or spikes at certain times. Agencies with a flatter workload profile, such as Bluffton (i.e. smaller workload spikes), benefit more from using a 12- or 8-hour model. This allows for more consistent staffing throughout the day to meet minimum staffing and workload demands in a simpler fashion. We believe a patrol team concept is a best practice; this involves the same officers consistently working on the same team with a sergeant on most days. Bluffton PD uses this model. Additionally, we believe that BPD’s choice of using a 12-hour hour deployment serves it well. However, we will offer some concerns with the model employed by the department. The rotating days model does not allow for upstaffing a select shift if workload makes this necessary. If officers worked a set day-off schedule the department could ensure that the team consistently working the heavier workload period would be fully staffed while those teams consistently working the slower periods could absorb staffing shortages with less of an impact. Our data analysis does show that BPD is busier during the evenings on the weekends in the summer months. With BPD’s current model a shift that is fully staffed might be on rotation working during the day on weekdays during the summer while a shift that is down one or two officers might be on the weekend cycle. This system also does not allow for upstaffing select teams that would be working those times if additional staffing were added to the agency. If an additional person were added to a team, that team would cycle back to a less busy shift, and even if they were working the busier period, the days off rotate, thereby taking them away from a time they might be needed. In our assessment, this scheduling works for BPD at the moment, as all shifts are set up to fill minimum staffing requirements (noted below) and have the same number of authorized positions. However, common sense would dictate that additional personnel added to the agency will not always come in blocks of 4 officers, and some teams will always have shortages, as it is the nature of the profession. Being constantly mindful of workload demands, including seasonal spikes in calls, is the responsibility of management; making necessary adjustments should be a job requirement. A scheduling system with set days on/off would provide greater flexibility and simplicity in making these occasional adjustments. As BPD continues to grow into the future, we believe it will need to consider a different scheduling system for deployment. As Page 57 Section VI. Item # a. 42 such, regular reviews of call load data should be done to determine if a deployment change is needed. Minimum Staffing The patrol area of responsibility for the Town of Bluffton and the BPD is divided into three zones or beats. As such, the department has set minimum staffing numbers at three officers (one per beat) plus one supervisor per shift. As a general rule, a sergeant is expected to fill the supervisor role, but in some cases, the supervisor may be the assigned shift corporal. Each team consists of one sergeant, one corporal, and three or four police officers. This results in very little overage to account for minimum staffing if one employee is off work. In some cases, there is a sergeant and four patrol officers (officer or corporal) on a shift. When this occurs, the department is able to take the fourth patrol resource and have that officer/corporal serve as a “rover” unit to assist in any and all beats. The reasoning for the above minimum staffing numbers is not based on a data analysis of the actual workload within the Town and the individual beats. The staffing numbers are in place to ensure there is beat coverage on all shifts and at all times. We encourage agencies to establish minimum staffing based on workload. In the case of BPD, as outlined later in this report, the available data does not justify this level of staffing. However, due to various mitigating factors explained later, we do not recommend changing these established minimums at this time. As the Town and the department continue to grow, decisions about staffing and beat configurations will be made. Assuming the data collection issue outlined later in the report is rectified, we strongly encourage the department to assess its needs and minimum staffing based on workload data. PATROL DEPLOYMENT AND WORKLOAD Uniformed patrol is considered the “backbone” of American policing. Bureau of Justice Statistics indicates that nearly all police departments in the U.S. in the same size category as the Bluffton Police Department provide uniformed patrol. Officers assigned to this important function are the most visible members of the department and command the largest share of resources committed by the department. Proper allocation of these resources is critical in order to have officers available to respond to calls for service and provide law enforcement services to the public. Staffing decisions, particularly for patrol, must be based on actual workload. Once the actual workload is determined, the amount of discretionary time is determined, and then staffing decisions can be made consistent with the department’s policing philosophy and the community’s ability to fund it. The BPD is a police department whose philosophy is to address essentially all requests for service in a community policing style. With this in mind, it is necessary to look at workload to understand the impact of this style of policing in the context of community demand. To understand the actual workload (the time required to complete certain activities) it is critical to review the total reported events within the context of how the events originated, such as through directed patrol, administrative tasks, officer-initiated activities, and citizen-initiated activities. In this section we will offer a number of charts and tables outlining this information. Page 58 Section VI. Item # a. 43 Understanding the difference between the various types of police department events and the resulting staffing implications is critical when determining deployment needs. This portion of the study looks at the total deployed hours of the police department with a comparison to the current time spent to provide services. In general, a “Rule of 60” can be applied to evaluate patrol staffing. This rule has two parts. The first part states that 60 percent of the sworn officers in a department should be dedicated to the patrol function (patrol staffing) and the second part states that no more than 60 percent of their time should be committed to calls for service, which includes all activities that occupy an officer’s time, including calls from the public, self-initiated work, and administrative tasks. This commitment of 60 percent of their time is referred to as the Patrol Saturation Index. The Rule of 60 is not a hard-and-fast rule, but rather a starting point for discussion on patrol deployment. Resource allocation decisions must be made from a policy and/or managerial perspective through which costs and benefits of competing demands are considered. The patrol saturation index indicates the percentage of time police officers dedicate to public demands for service and administrative duties related to their jobs. Effective patrol deployment would exist at amounts where the saturation index is less than 60 percent. This Rule of 60 for patrol deployment does not mean the remaining 40 percent of time is downtime or break time. It is a reflection of the extent to which patrol officer time is saturated by calls for service. The time when police personnel are not responding to calls should be committed to management-directed operations. This is a more focused use of time and can include supervised allocation of patrol officer activities toward proactive enforcement, crime prevention, community policing, and citizen safety initiatives. It will also provide ready and available resources in the event of an emergency. From an organizational standpoint, it is important to have uniformed patrol resources available to undertake activities such as proactive enforcement, community policing, and emergency response. Patrol is generally the most visible and available resource in policing, and the ability to harness this resource is critical for successful operations. From an officer’s standpoint, once a certain level of CFS activity is reached, the officer’s focus shifts to a CFS-based reactionary mode. The patrol officer’s mindset begins to shift from one that looks for ways to deal with crime and quality-of-life conditions in the community to one that continually prepares for the next call. After saturation is reached, officers cease proactive policing and engage in a reactionary style of policing. The outlook becomes “Why act proactively when my actions are only going to be interrupted by a call?” Any uncommitted time is spent waiting for the next call. Rule of 60 – Part 1 According to the BPD’s personnel data, patrol is authorized for 27 sworn officers (1 Captain, 2 Lieutenants, 4 sergeants, 4 corporals, and 16 police officers). These 27 of the 66 sworn officers represent 41 percent of the sworn officers in the Bluffton Police Department. This is well below the recommended 60 percent allocation. BPD has a large number of school resource officers who are assigned to local schools and who are funded by those schools. In total there, 13 of the 66 sworn officers are assigned to the SRO function. Because they are separately funded it would be reasonable to remove those officers from the sworn total for the purpose of calculating this metric. That would leave 53 sworn officers and increase the patrol allocation to 51 percent. This is still below the recommended threshold, but certainly closer to it. Page 59 Section VI. Item # a. 44 We will outline some other staffing adjustments that can be made by the department based on managerial oversight, span of control and workload. If the department elects to make those adjustments, there may be additional personnel to assign to the patrol function and would likely bring the department staffing into alignment with the Rule of 60 in this area. This part of the “rule” is not hard-and-fast. Taken on its face, however, this part of the “rule” must be considered when examining the operational elements of the department when staffing recommendations are taken into consideration. The current staffing is well below the threshold established by this rule; even when adjusted the staffing is below this rule. We recommend that BPD take steps to realign its patrol workforce to bring patrol staffing closer to 60 percent of its sworn workforce. Rule of 60 – Part 2 The second part of the “Rule of 60” examines workload and discretionary time and suggests that no more than 60 percent of the time should be committed to calls for service and officer-initiated activity. In other words, CPSM suggests that no more than 60 percent of available patrol officer time be spent responding to the community's service demands. The remaining 40 percent of the time is the “discretionary time” for officers to address community problems and be available for serious emergencies. CPSM contends that patrol staffing is optimally deployed when the saturation index (SI) is just below the 60 percent range. An SI greater than 60 percent indicates that the patrol manpower is largely reactive, and thus overburdened with CFS and workload demands. An SI of slightly less than 60 percent indicates that patrol manpower is optimally staffed. However, SI levels much lower than 60 percent indicate underutilized patrol resources. Departments must be cautious in interpreting the SI too narrowly. One should not conclude that SI can never exceed 60 percent at any time during the day, or that in any given hour no more than 60 percent of any officer’s time be committed to CFS. The SI at 60 percent is intended to be a benchmark to evaluate overall service demands on patrol staffing. When SI levels exceed 60 percent for substantial periods of a given shift, or at specific times during the day, then decisions should be made to reallocate or realign personnel to reduce the SI to levels below 60 percent. Resource allocation decisions must be made from a policy and/or managerial perspective through which costs and benefits of competing demands are considered. The patrol saturation index indicates the percentage of time police officers dedicate to public demands for service and administrative duties related to their jobs. Effective patrol deployment would exist at amounts where the saturation index was less than 60. The CPSM data analysis in the second part of this report provides a rich overview of CFS and staffing demands experienced by the Bluffton Police Department. The analysis here looks specifically at patrol deployment and how to maximize the department's personnel resources to meet the demands of calls for service while also engaging in proactive policing to combat crime, disorder, and traffic issues in the community. The following sets of figures depict staffing, workload, and the “saturation” of patrol resources in the Bluffton Police Department during the two periods (seasons) on which we focused our workload analysis. The figures represent the manpower, service demands, and workload saturation during weekdays and weekends during the periods of July 7 to August 31, 2023 (Summer) and January 4 to February 28, 2024 (Winter). Examination of these figures permits exploration of the second part of the Rule of 60. Page 60 Section VI. Item # a. 45 FIGURE 5-2: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Summer 2023 FIGURE 5-3: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 Page 61 Section VI. Item # a. 46 FIGURE 5-4: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Summer 2023 Workload v. Deployment – Weekdays, Summer 2023 Avg. Deployment 5.2 officers per hour Avg. Workload: 1.5 officers per hour Avg. % Deployed (SI): 29 percent Peak SI: 47 percent Peak SI Time: 9:15–9:45 p.m., 10:00–10:15 p.m. The “Deployment and All Workload” figure shows the relationship of all on-duty police officers assigned to patrol that were factored into the workload analysis and what work is represented by those officers throughout the day. The first figure that denotes deployed officers is also the same top line as the one represented in the second figure, denoting workload. The average deployment throughout the day was 5.2 officers. The average workload of 1.5 indicates that, on average, 1.5 on-duty officers (of the 5.2 average) were occupied with work (calls for service, officer-initiated, or administrative work). The spikes observed just after 5:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. represent shift change times when there is the occasional overlap. Those spikes occurring at shift change indicate officers were assigned to the CAD system but likely in a briefing. The average saturation index (SI) is 29 percent, and the peak SI is 47 percent between 9:15 and 9:45 p.m. and again between 10:00 and 10:15 p.m. These figures would suggest that BPD had more officers deployed on the weekdays during the summer months in 2023 than what was necessary. However, there are mitigating factors to this situation that will be outlined later in this report. The orange section at the bottom of the workload chart indicates the average number of officers that were occupied with community-initiated work, an average of 0.9 officers per hour. The color that denotes police-initiated work indicates the time officers were busy with work they observed and took some type of proactive policing approach (e.g., traffic stop). Out-of-service work will be explained in further detail later but is generally defined as being administrative in nature, while the largest green section of “patrol” indicates the number of officers that were Page 62 Section VI. Item # a. 47 available for a call and potentially looking for proactive work during any given time of the day. Directed patrol is defined as officers who may have been on an assignment to extra patrol an area (for example, a park). FIGURE 5-5: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Summer 2023 § § § Page 63 Section VI. Item # a. 48 FIGURE 5-6: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 FIGURE 5-7: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Summer 2023 Page 64 Section VI. Item # a. 49 Workload v. Deployment – Weekends, Summer 2023 Avg. Deployment 5.1 officers per hour Avg. Workload: 1.6 officers per hour Avg. % Deployed (SI): 49 percent Peak SI: 58 percent Peak SI Time: 1:00-1:15 a.m. and 9:45-10:00 p.m. These metrics from 2023 summer weekends would indicate a more balanced workload and appropriate staffing level than the weekdays during the same period. FIGURE 5-8: Deployed Officers, Weekdays, Winter 2024 § § § Page 65 Section VI. Item # a. 50 FIGURE 5-9: Deployment and All Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 FIGURE 5-10: Percentage of Workload, Weekdays, Winter 2024 Page 66 Section VI. Item # a. 51 Workload v. Deployment – Weekdays, Winter 2023 Avg. Deployment 4.9 officers per hour Avg. Workload: 1.2 officers per hour Avg. % Deployed (SI): 25 percent Peak SI: 38 percent Peak SI Time: 9:45 a.m. These numbers are similar to the first workload data sets (weekdays-summer) and indicate a potential over-deployment of what would be necessary. However, as will we explain, we believe there are mitigating factors to this and we do not recommend a reduction of patrol personnel. FIGURE 5-11: Deployed Officers, Weekends, Winter 2024 § § § Page 67 Section VI. Item # a. 52 FIGURE 5-12: Deployment and All Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 FIGURE 5-13: Percentage of Workload, Weekends, Winter 2024 Page 68 Section VI. Item # a. 53 Workload v. Deployment – Weekends, Winter 2024 Avg. Deployment 4.5 officers per hour Avg. Workload: 1.2 officers per hour Avg. % Deployed (SI): 27 percent Peak SI: 47 percent Peak SI Time: 8:00 p.m. As indicated earlier, the figures and data represented above are from two 8-week periods during the summer of 2023 and the winter of 2024; the data is broken down by weekdays and weekends. In evaluating the workload against the available staffing in the BPD Patrol Division, it “appears” that the division is generally overstaffed. However, there are two primary observations we made that might suggest this is not the case. We know from conducting assessments involving departments throughout the country that these workload numbers do not represent all work being done in the department. Police culture, by its very nature, does not encourage 100 percent accounting of an officer’s time. Beat integrity is a cultural element in all departments, and beat integrity encourages officers to be available to handle any service call or crime report in their area of responsibility. As a result, officers tend to remain “available” in the department’s CAD system and not record all activities, such as report writing and other administrative tasks. We observed this firsthand during our ride-along and interviews with patrol officers. Officers handled calls for service and completed some of the required paperwork (digital–computer entries) before ‘clearing’ the call and showing themselves available again. The actual report that still needed to be written was not completed until another time, and in most cases, those reports are completed while the officers are available for another call. This means they are doing an administrative task (report writing) when, in fact, they are coded in CAD as being on “patrol,” (i.e. available for calls and addressing potential community concerns). There are methods that departments have instituted that enable officers to accurately record what they are doing while simultaneously being available to handle priority needs in their beat or for their beat partners. A CAD code of “busy” (performing a necessary task such as report writing,” but still available to respond to another call if necessary could be used to satisfy an officers need to capture this time yet maintain beat integrity. Other examples of work performed that is often not captured in CAD include: ■ Performing administrative tasks. ■ Vehicle or equipment maintenance, including tasks as simple of being busy for 10 minutes while pumping fuel into the patrol car. ■ Rest or meal breaks, These are necessary activities that take away from proactive patrol time. ■ Driving across town to perform follow-up work on a previous case. The actual work once arrived may or may not be captured but the travel time often does not get logged. Accurate representation of actual workload captured within the CAD system was one of the observations made that mitigate the appearance of being overstaffed based solely on data. The second observation concerns the Town’s geography. The Town of Bluffton and the individual beats are large for a small cadre of officers. The officers are spread out across that geography and with only a few main road arteries connecting those areas, traffic can often become a concern in the ability to quickly get somewhere when Page 69 Section VI. Item # a. 54 needed. Additionally, the geography is intermixed with Beaufort County pockets of jurisdiction that often need to be traversed to get to other sections of the Town. We also observed other areas of Bluffton that are exclusive neighborhoods and somewhat remote from where officers spend most of their beat patrol time. Travel in and out of these areas can take a substantial amount of time. It is these mitigating factors that lead us to believe that that the Patrol Division is not “overstaffed.” We do, however, recommend that BPD take steps to accurately capture all work being performed by patrol officers and supervisors. This includes an accurate representation of administrative work such as meetings, briefings, officer rest time, and report writing. We caution that this might be more difficult than expected to shift the officer culture. The entire staff of the department has been trained and ingrained in its current culture of performing work as they currently do it. Many officers we spoke with could not explain why they perform certain tasks other than to say “that’s the way I was trained to do it.” Making a change of this nature will require an explanation of why current practices need to change and will require constant monitoring and follow-up to ensure compliance and that the expectation is not being abused. This recommendation can also provide additional benefits outside of capturing the real workload of the agency. Current practices and unstructured officer time allow officers tremendous autonomy throughout their shift. Unfortunately, many cases of officer misconduct seen around the country have stemmed from officers not being accountable for their time/activities and a lack of supervisory oversight. Enacting this type of practice into policy should increase accountability. It will likely require more oversight from supervisors and management to ensure that department expectations are being met, but shifting the culture now with a young workforce should yield operational benefits in the future. § § § Page 70 Section VI. Item # a. 55 CALL AND EVENT ANALYSIS In the following portion of the report, we will explore what types of calls occupy the time of BPD patrol officers and where those calls originate from. FIGURE 5-14: Percentage Events per Day, by Initiator Note: Percentages are based on a total of 37,251 events. TABLE 5-3: Events per Day, by Initiator Initiator No. of Events Events per Day Community-initiated 10,175 27.8 Police-initiated 13,169 36.0 Zero on scene 13,907 38.0 Total 37,251 101.8 From our analysis of the total events recorded in the department's CAD system in our one-year study period, we see that approximately 27 percent of those events originated from community requests for services, while 35 percent originated from police officer self-initiated or self-directed activity. We believe this is a healthy balance of community-initiated vs officer-initiated activity and it suggest that BPD is appropriately balanced in patrol. However, the zero on scene category is higher than what is normally observed in a department. For context, zero on scene time is a category of observed events or calls in the CAD system that did not have a long enough amount of officer time attached to the handling of the event to be effectively Page 71 Section VI. Item # a. 56 captured for analysis. For example, if a citizen called 911 to report a reckless driver and an officer was in the area, the officer may have taken time to look for that reckless driver but never placed themselves on the call. After checking the area the officer may advise dispatch that they checked the area, were unable to locate the reckless driver, and will clear the call. The dispatcher would make entries that the officer was “on scene” and “cleared” within seconds for CAD purposes. Another example is officers performing a “directed patrol” only to clear the event quickly after initial entry. The table and figure that follow below further break down the daily events experienced by BPD and show that directed patrols occupy the largest number of daily events handled by BPD officers. The second most common activity are traffic stops initiated by BPD officers. TABLE 5-4: Events per Day, by Category Category No. of Events Events per Day Accident 1,519 4.2 Alarm 1,730 4.7 Animal call 154 0.4 Assist citizen 659 1.8 Assist EMS 213 0.6 Assist other agency 71 0.2 Check 328 0.9 Community activity 15 0.0 Crime against persons 206 0.6 Crime against property 1,089 3.0 Crime against society 123 0.3 Directed patrol 18,717 51.1 Disturbance 1,873 5.1 Follow-up 1,294 3.5 Investigation 1,511 4.1 Juvenile 27 0.1 Mental health 101 0.3 Miscellaneous 571 1.6 Suspicious incident 1,007 2.8 Traffic enforcement 1,003 2.7 Traffic hazard 283 0.8 Traffic stop 4,490 12.3 Violation 210 0.6 Warrant 57 0.2 Total 37,251 101.8 Page 72 Section VI. Item # a. 57 FIGURE 5-15: Percentage Events per Day, by Category The following figure and table show the month-to-month relationship between officer-initiated activity and community-initiated calls for service. Bluffton officers' workload is slower from November to January, while the remainder of the year shows a slightly higher workload. It should be noted that the slowest month is January, with 38.2 calls per day, and the busiest is May, with 51.5 calls per day. As an average, only 12 additional calls per day would imply that the workload is reasonably balanced through the seasons. Based upon the number of officers deployed in a 24-hour period, this only results in each officer handling one to two additional calls per day during the busier months. The following figure and supporting table provide insight into the average number of calls per day, per month. Although the graph may visually indicate a steeper drop in calls the reality is the drop-off is only about 12 calls per month. Also worthy of note is that officer-initiated activity drops more than the community-initiated calls for service during the months with the slightly lighter workload. § § § Page 73 Section VI. Item # a. 58 FIGURE 5-16: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Month TABLE 5-5: Calls per Day, by Initiator and Month Initiator May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Community 29.9 31.1 30.9 30.5 26.8 30.0 26.0 26.4 22.7 24.4 26.8 27.9 Police 21.6 18.4 19.6 18.0 17.1 17.4 12.3 12.2 15.5 20.7 15.3 18.2 Total 51.5 49.5 50.5 48.5 44.0 47.4 38.4 38.6 38.2 45.1 42.1 46.1 The following table shows the average amount of time that BPD officers take to handle each category of calls received by the department. The average time spent on all calls was 33 minutes for community-initiated calls and 26 minutes for calls initiated by BPD officers. The most time-consuming calls involved mental health-related service needs, taking an average of 49 minutes. The officer-initiated activity in this area took much longer, but that figure is likely an outlier, with only two recorded during the year. With the position of mental health advocate in the department, we would encourage BPD to carefully track this call category to both reduce officer time and reduce the number of calls. This type of data is valuable for BPD management to best understand the impact of certain call types on officer labor time. If there are sudden surges in the average time necessary to handle a call type, then management should be exploring the reasons why in order to implement potential remedies. Page 74 Section VI. Item # a. 59 TABLE 5-6: Primary Unit’s Average Occupied Times, by Category and Initiator Category Community-Initiated Police-Initiated Minutes Calls Minutes Calls Accident 41.0 1,337 43.4 115 Alarm 12.4 1,522 6.2 3 Animal call 21.0 129 27.0 6 Assist citizen 31.7 290 17.3 281 Assist EMS 37.6 187 31.4 6 Assist other agency 32.9 64 28.7 2 Check 24.4 287 15.8 2 Community activity NA 0 35.2 13 Crime against persons 40.7 180 34.4 10 Crime against property 30.1 885 25.2 89 Crime against society 38.9 102 12.1 4 Disturbance 28.1 1,616 27.2 37 Follow up 17.6 711 17.1 393 Investigation 15.4 1,218 13.0 59 Juvenile 46.6 24 11.9 2 Mental health 48.7 91 183.2 2 Miscellaneous 21.9 285 55.2 161 Suspicious incident 26.5 519 14.1 354 Traffic enforcement 18.7 379 9.0 285 Traffic hazard 17.3 160 12.0 34 Traffic stop NA 0 16.1 4,401 Violation 15.8 162 16.3 7 Warrant 51.8 27 71.5 24 Weighted Average/Total Calls 25.1 10,175 17.8 6,290 The next table explores the average number of patrol units that are needed to successfully manage a certain call type. It is not uncommon for police departments to dispatch two police officers for many types of calls where there is a degree of danger or unknown danger. For instance, it is standard practice to send two police officers to an alarm call just in case the alarm call is “good,” and a potential suspect is still at the location. This is basic officer safety, even though a vast majority of alarm calls are false. This is also an area that management and supervision should be actively managing at all times to ensure that resources that are not needed on a call remain in service for other calls that may arise. The reader may notice that the total number of calls noted above is greatly reduced from the number of events we noted earlier. As indicated, the zero-on-scene events are incidents that take less than one minute of CAD time to handle and are therefore excluded so as not to impact actual service time unfairly. It is generally believed that events of that nature do not have a significant impact on the workload being reported here. When we evaluated the data, we suspected that the high number of directed patrols (or extra patrols) contributed to that anomaly in the data. As demonstrated below, this assumption was correct as a majority of all directed patrols took about 14 seconds to resolve. This means that officers are entering a location on their in-car computer for a directed patrol and quickly clearing the call merely to demonstrate activity. This is also consistent with what BPD patrol officers reported to us. Page 75 Section VI. Item # a. 60 Management should be carefully watching these metrics to ensure that there is value in the activity being performed and that it is both servicing the desire of the community and not creating an illusion of more work being performed than reality may suggest. TABLE 5-7: Extra Patrol Call Types and Average Time Call Type Count Average Occupied Time Extra Patrol - Business 11,806 0.23 Extra Patrol - Residence 6,910 0.25 Foot Patrol 1 8.47 Total 18,717 0.23 Note: The Average Occupied Time is a metric or percentage of 100. 23 percent of 60 seconds is 13.8 seconds TABLE 5-8: Average Number of Responding Units, by Initiator and Category Category Community-Initiated Police-Initiated No. of Units Calls No. of Units Calls Accident 2.0 1,337 1.8 115 Alarm 1.7 1,522 2.7 3 Animal call 1.6 129 2.0 6 Assist citizen 2.0 290 1.4 281 Assist EMS 2.3 187 3.0 6 Assist other agency 2.2 64 2.0 2 Check 1.9 287 2.0 2 Community activity NA 0 1.2 13 Crime against persons 1.9 180 1.3 10 Crime against property 1.6 885 1.3 89 Crime against society 2.8 102 1.2 4 Disturbance 2.1 1,616 2.0 37 Follow-up 1.2 711 1.2 393 Investigation 1.6 1,218 1.2 59 Juvenile 2.1 24 2.0 2 Mental health 2.7 91 2.0 2 Miscellaneous 1.3 285 1.3 161 Suspicious incident 2.3 519 2.1 354 Traffic enforcement 1.5 379 1.1 285 Traffic hazard 1.5 160 1.2 34 Traffic stop NA 0 1.7 4,401 Violation 1.2 162 1.0 7 Warrant 1.9 27 2.4 24 Weighted Average/Total Calls 1.8 10,175 1.6 6,290 As noted earlier, Bluffton is divided into three zones or beats for patrol operations. The following table shows the average number of calls in each zone per day and how many work hours are consumed on those calls. The “A” zone is the busiest, with a daily average of 16.2 calls, taking Page 76 Section VI. Item # a. 61 approximately 10 hours of total labor from all responding units. Zone “B” has more calls per day than Zone “C,” but the labor time is only slightly higher. TABLE 5-9: Calls and Work Hours by Beat, per Day Beat Per Day Calls Work Hours A1 6.2 4.0 A2 10.0 6.6 Subtotal A 16.2 10.6 B1 7.7 4.0 B2 6.6 3.8 Subtotal B 14.3 7.8 C1 4.5 3.1 C2 6.4 4.1 Subtotal C 10.9 7.2 HQ 1.0 0.5 Miscellaneous 2.1 1.5 Unknown 0.5 0.3 Subtotal Other 3.5 2.3 Total 45.0 27.9 Traffic Enforcement Traffic enforcement is a common activity in almost all police departments across the country. Bluffton PD has a traffic unit designated on its organizational chart but at the time of this assessment there were no officers assigned to the task. However, as observed in the data charts above, traffic stops and enforcement activity is among the largest contributors to workload in the department. It is a common activity that is typically officer-initiated in nature that occurs within the BPD patrol function. We discussed the philosophy behind the traffic enforcement efforts with BPD patrol staff. We learned that little direction is given on what to enforce, how to enforce, where to enforce, and when to enforce. There is a genuine interest on the part of officers to remain active throughout their shift and conducting traffic stops is viewed as an appreciated activity by the department. In general, we agree that traffic enforcement is a valuable and necessary activity that police departments should engage in to make the roadways in a community safer. But we strongly believe that enforcement activity should be done with a specific purpose that includes desired outcomes. Additionally, traffic enforcement should be part of a larger strategy that includes a three-pronged approach to safety improvement. The “Three E’s”—Education, Engineering, and Enforcement—is a decades-old concept that applies to a whole-community solution to traffic safety. Often, police departments assume the enforcement role with an assumption that the other concepts are handled elsewhere. While it is true that there are national programs focused on education (example, Click it or Ticket, Drive Sober, etc.) and of course new drivers are required to educate themselves before obtaining a license, there are strategies that individual communities can engage in to educate the public about traffic hazards and general safety. Traffic engineering is the focus of other departments and while there are engineering solutions to Page 77 Section VI. Item # a. 62 traffic problems occurring all of the time, the police should have a mechanism to voice their concerns and observations within the process. We asked BPD officers if there was a mechanism to forward traffic concerns that might have an engineering solution through the Town’s communication channels. None of the officers we interacted with were familiar with any such process, let alone the concept that they might be a part of that solution. We recommend that BPD and Bluffton Traffic Engineering establish a mechanism that would enable police concerns to be routed to engineering for potential solutions when appropriate. Modern police departments have easy access to data that can be used to analyze locations with a high number of crashes as well as what might be causing those collisions (primary collision factors). Armed with this information, departments can implement strategic decisions that direct resources toward a very specific problem in an attempt to reduce collisions and improve safety. Performing this analysis may also point to other solutions that may not require enforcement activity yet be positively impacted through an engineering and or education strategy. We observed firsthand that BPD has access to this data, yet there is no evidence that it is being analyzed or even accessed for strategic decision-making. In short, management is aware of the technology but is not using it, patrol officers are not receiving the data or being given direction and are therefore left to perform randomized enforcement, and there is no feedback loop to measure the effectiveness of the existing enforcement activity occurring within the Town. We recommend that BPD engage in a data-driven strategic approach to traffic enforcement. This approach should include a data analysis, a specific strategy to reduce collisions or dangerous driving, and a feedback loop to measure effectiveness. This recommendation would suggest the department pull back from existing randomized enforcement. Although we encourage a shift in philosophy and believe that random enforcement should be more the exception than the rule, nothing here is intended to discourage police officers from taking appropriate action when significant violations are observed outside of a specific focus area. Afterall, police officers are a visible presence for a reason and the public expects them to act when serious offenses occur. But, to the extent possible we believe that if enforcement is backed up with data, and randomized enforcement encounters are reduced, the department will experience better results and better community relations. Out-of-Service-Activities Workload activity is divided into three distinct categories. Community-initiated work involves calls for service that officers are dispatched to handle. For instance, when someone calls 911 to report a crime and an officer is sent to investigate, that is classified as a community-initiated call. Self-initiated or self-directed work is also self-explanatory. When an officer makes a traffic stop and takes whatever appropriate action is deemed necessary, that is classified as self-initiated. Almost all other work recorded in a department CAD system gets classified as being administrative in nature or as this category implies, an “out-of-service” activity. The following table is a breakdown of all out-of-service activity that CPSM extracted from BPD’s CAD data. Page 78 Section VI. Item # a. 63 TABLE 5-10: Activities and Occupied Times by Description Description Occupied Time Count At station 120.8 171 Busy 77.3 338 Court 88.4 100 Meeting 110.8 20 Miscellaneous 74.7 168 School 229.4 23 Training 76.3 169 Vehicle maintenance 66.7 17 Warrant 42.6 26 Weighted Average/Total Calls 88.0 1,032 In discussions with BPD officers, we found that there is activity occurring that may not be recorded in CAD. The primary example is report writing. Officers go on a call that results in having to write a report, and at some point later in the shift they will write the report while showing ‘available’ in CAD. This is normal activity that is observed in many departments and often stems from a cultural expectation that officers remain available as much as possible in case a call needs to be handled. However, what is intended to be a good work ethic does not serve the agency in capturing actual workload. In a perfect scenario, that report writing time will be attached to the original call for the purpose of capturing actual labor time on call types more accurately. However, it is also acceptable to capture it in an out-of-service category. Aside from report writing, officers also provided additional examples of administrative work, rest stops, meal breaks, etc., all occurring while being “available” in CAD. We recommend that BPD work to ensure that all legitimate patrol officer work is accurately captured in CAD in order to improve future workload assessments. RESPONSE TIMES We analyzed the response times to various types of calls, separating the duration into dispatch processing and travel time, to determine whether response times varied by call type. Response time is measured as the difference between when a call is received and when the first unit arrives on scene. This is further divided into dispatch processing and travel time. Dispatch processing is the time between when a call is received and when the first unit is dispatched. Travel time is the remaining time until the first unit arrives on scene. We begin the discussion with statistics that include all calls combined. We started with 2,751 calls in summer and 2,332 calls in winter. We limited our analysis to community-initiated calls, which amounted to 1,703 calls in the summer and 1,320 calls in the winter. In addition, we removed the calls lacking a recorded arriving unit and calls outside Bluffton patrol beats. We were left with 1,188 calls in summer and 897 calls in winter for our analysis. For the entire year, we began with 16,465 calls and limited our analysis to 10,175 community-initiated calls. With similar exclusions, we were left with 6,921 calls. The following table provides insight into BPD response times to the various call types in both the summer and the winter months. The overall average response time to calls in the summer was just under 12 minutes and in the winter was just over 12 minutes. Page 79 Section VI. Item # a. 64 TABLE 5-11: Average Response Time Components, in Minutes, by Category Category Summer Winter Dispatch Travel Response Count Dispatch Travel Response Count Accident 3.1 7.6 10.7 171 3.3 8.3 11.6 135 Alarm 3.3 7.7 10.9 229 2.5 8.8 11.3 136 Animal call 6.0 6.1 12.1 10 3.8 12.3 16.1 9 Assist citizen 5.2 8.2 13.4 43 4.8 7.9 12.7 31 Assist EMS 3.6 6.1 9.7 34 3.1 5.4 8.5 24 Assist other agency 1.9 4.7 6.6 8 1.8 6.0 7.9 5 Check 4.2 10.5 14.8 30 5.2 9.6 14.8 38 Crime against persons 5.0 11.7 16.7 16 3.4 8.4 11.8 21 Crime against property 4.5 9.3 13.7 101 3.8 11.6 15.4 61 Crime against society 2.5 7.7 10.2 15 5.4 7.0 12.4 12 Disturbance 4.6 8.1 12.7 185 4.0 8.4 12.4 177 Follow up 6.4 7.8 14.2 23 5.2 8.5 13.7 25 Investigation 2.8 8.2 11.1 163 3.0 9.8 12.7 100 Mental health 3.9 7.2 11.1 19 2.5 5.1 7.6 10 Miscellaneous 5.8 9.2 15.0 20 4.4 9.8 14.1 20 Suspicious incident 3.7 8.6 12.4 62 3.9 7.5 11.4 46 Traffic enforcement 5.0 6.4 11.4 20 3.0 11.7 14.8 20 Traffic hazard 3.6 8.6 12.1 21 3.4 12.8 16.2 13 Violation 3.6 8.7 12.3 18 3.8 11.7 15.5 14 Total Average 3.8 8.1 11.9 1,188 3.6 8.9 12.5 897 Note: The total average is weighted according to the number of calls per category. The following data sets show response times to all calls in the different zones of the Town. Note that the “C” zone takes the longest to arrive at call with officer travel time being about 90 seconds longer on average. § § § Page 80 Section VI. Item # a. 65 FIGURE 5-17: Average Response Time Components, by Beat TABLE 5-12: Average Response Time Components, by Beat Beat Minutes Calls Dispatch Travel Response A1 3.9 9.2 13.1 1,172 A2 3.7 8.5 12.2 2,003 Subtotal A 3.8 8.7 12.5 3,175 B1 4.0 7.8 11.8 985 B2 3.5 6.7 10.2 1,011 Subtotal B 3.8 7.2 11.0 1,996 C1 3.9 11.0 14.9 757 C2 4.0 9.1 13.0 993 Subtotal C 3.9 9.9 13.8 1,750 Total 3.8 8.6 12.4 6,921 Finally, we evaluate response times by priority. Most police departments have created a priority system for calls to ensure that critical calls are handled first and nonhazardous calls are handled as capacity allows. In Bluffton’s case, since call holding is rare with the existing workload, the three call priorities listed have similar response times. Page 81 Section VI. Item # a. 66 TABLE 5-13: Average and 90th Percentile Response Times, by Priority Priority Minutes Calls 90th Percentile Response Time, Minutes Dispatch Travel Response 1 3.3 8.2 11.5 3,670 20.4 3 4.1 9.1 13.2 2,036 23.2 5 4.8 9.1 13.9 1,215 26.4 Total 3.8 8.6 12.4 6,921 22.2 Injury accident 2.3 5.7 8.0 245 13.3 Note: The total average is weighted according to the number of calls within each priority level. Many agencies classify too many call types into the highest category, thereby affecting the real response time data to true emergencies. However, injury accidents are a call type for which most agencies will have an expedited emergency response. The BPD response time for injury accidents is several minutes less than that for regular Priority 1 calls. This indicates that BPD is capable of responding to critical emergencies faster than the Priority 1 data would imply. Police departments strive to meet a national benchmark of a total response time of 5 minutes for emergency calls. BPD is well above that number in injury accidents and regular Priority 1 response. Meeting these benchmarks is a collaborative effort managed by the department and involves dispatch and patrol availability. BPD does not have operational control over the dispatch center (managed by Beaufort County Sheriff), and the 2.3-minute processing time for injury accidents is close to the industry standard (under 2 minutes). BPD's challenge in meeting this benchmark is response time, and that is directly tied to the difficulty of getting through traffic and the spread-out nature of patrol work in Bluffton. The only solution to the travel time and geography challenge is a greater concentration of officers around the Town (increased staffing). However, that is not practical or justified by the current workload experienced and captured by BPD. Patrol Recommendations: ■ CPSM recommends that Bluffton PD management engage in strategic decision-making regarding patrol officer-initiated workload. (Recommendation No. 22.) ■ CPSM recommends periodic reviews of call load data to determine whether scheduling changes should be made. This review should be done twice per year, during summer and winter. (Recommendation No. 23.) ■ We recommend that BPD take steps to realign its patrol workforce to bring patrol staffing closer to 60 percent of its sworn workforce. (Recommendation No. 24.) ■ CPSM recommends that BPD take steps to ensure an accurate collection of data of all patrol officer and sergeant workload. (Recommendation No. 25.) ■ CPSM recommends that BPD management carefully track “directed patrol” activity to ensure it is meeting department and community objectives. (Recommendation No. 26.) ■ We recommend that BPD and Bluffton Traffic Engineering establish a mechanism that would enable police concerns to be routed to Engineering for potential solutions when appropriate. (Recommendation No. 27.) Page 82 Section VI. Item # a. 67 ■ We recommend that BPD engage in a data-driven strategic approach to traffic enforcement. (Recommendation No. 28.) ■ We recommend that BPD work to ensure that all legitimate patrol officer work is accurately captured in CAD in order to improve future workload assessments. (Recommendation No. 29.) § § § Page 83 Section VI. Item # a. 68 SECTION 6. INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION Under the direction of the Operations Division Captain, the Investigations Division is made up of the following programs: ■ Criminal Investigations Unit (CIU). ■ Crime Scene Unit (Collateral duty to CIU). ■ Domestic Violence / Victim Advocate. ■ Community Mental Health. As we examine operations of this division, we will report on each program individually. CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS UNIT (CIU) Under the direction of the Operations Division Captain, the CIU is responsible for the following functions: ■ Criminal investigations, including crimes against persons, property crimes, financial crimes, and missing persons. ■ Narcotic and vice crimes. ■ Crime scene investigation. Detectives serve as generalists, meaning that they can investigate any type of crime. This is commonplace in an agency of BPD’s size. In larger agencies with greater staffing, detectives may specialize in the investigation of a particular type of crime such as homicide, sexual assault, or auto theft, to the exclusion of other types. In that way, they develop more specialized expertise, a luxury that is not available in the BPD. Overall, BPD is a very young department in terms of tenure. And while BPD detectives are highly committed, each is relatively new in their present role. Where necessary, they may draw upon specialized expertise from larger departments such as the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office, the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED), and federal agencies such as the FBI, ATF, and DEA. Policy / Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) CID is guided by SOP 024, Criminal Investigations. The policy, twelve pages in length, was reviewed by CPSM and found to be fairly comprehensive, though in our continued reporting we will address a couple of areas that may warrant modification. The policy provides step-by-step direction to staff regarding the following: ■ Case assignment. ■ Case management. ■ Case file maintenance. ■ Procedures to follow in various investigations. ■ Procedures to follow when conducting interviews / interrogations, etc. Page 84 Section VI. Item # a. 69 While SOP 024 largely focusses on the role of CID, there are a number of other department policies that provide further direction such as Missing Persons and Juvenile. These are complementary policies that guide both CID and Patrol operations. We did note that, as is the case with many policies we reviewed, this policy was dated. It was last amended/updated in 2017 under the signature block of a former Chief. Consideration should be given to reviewing the policy to ensure that it meets contemporary needs. Staffing Under the direction of the Operations Division Captain, the Criminal Investigations Division’s authorized / actual staffing is shown in the following table. TABLE 6-1: Criminal Investigations Division Authorized Staffing Levels at Present Position Authorized Actual Vacant Sworn Personnel Lieutenant 1 1 Sergeant 1 1 Detective 3 3 Domestic Violence Detective / Victim –Witness Advocate 1 1 Total Sworn 6 6 - Civilian Personnel Community Mental Health Advocate 1 1 Civilian Total 1 1 - Total Authorized Personnel 7 7 - Detectives hold the rank of police officer, but are referred to as detective while assigned to the CID. Selection to this assignment is based upon the discretion of the department. Selection generally follows an informal interview process where the candidate’s prior work / initiative, report writing skills, and training are considered. There is no special compensation attached to this assignment with the exception of on-call status, where the detective receives one hour of compensated time off for each full day on-call. We make a couple of notes to provide some clarity to the above table. The three detectives are general crimes detectives who investigate a wide variety of offenses, with the general exception of domestic violence cases. They serve in the traditional role of criminal investigators. The domestic violence detective specializes in family or special relationship crimes, but has the additional responsibility of serving as the department’s victim / witness advocate. The community mental health advocate works with victims of incidents which may cause extraordinary trauma to victims or a victim’s loved ones. This may include homicide victim families, sexual assault victims, and survivors in cases involving suicide. We will provide information on the work of these two positions later in this reporting. We also note that in addition to the case management responsibilities, two of the CID detectives are assigned to the Beaufort County regional crime scene investigation team as a collateral duty. We will discuss the crime scene investigation function in detail later in our reporting as well. Page 85 Section VI. Item # a. 70 Work Schedule Detectives are assigned on a modified five-day work schedule, Monday through Thursday, from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., and Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. As necessary, hours may be flexed due to investigative needs and/or call-outs. It is common practice in law enforcement agencies that detective personnel must be available for after-hours call-outs for serious cases. Agency policies generally define the process to be followed. In the case of BPD, SOP 024 II. C. addresses the issue of being on-call. However, it does not reflect the circumstances in which a detective may be called-out after-hours, and the notification/approval process for that action. This can lead to inconsistency in practices between patrol supervisors. Identifying, in policy, the thresholds needed to warrant a detective call-out will provide clarity to supervisors across all shifts and help to ensure consistency. Rotation Schedule (Proposed) At present, the detective assignment is a permanent, non-rotational assignment. Once assigned, detectives, including the sergeant and lieutenant, would only leave the assignment upon promotion, retirement, personal request, or an administrative action related to a performance or discipline issue. The advantage of this practice is that personnel become highly trained and experienced. There is no question that there is value to this argument. On the other hand, this practice presents limited opportunities to other employees seeking a detective assignment. Many, if not most agencies of BPD’s size find that they are better served by implementing a rotational schedule. CPSM suggests that a rotational schedule should be considered here. There are a number of reasons for such an action. The reasons include the following: ■ Opportunities for other employees to gain valuable experience in such an assignment. ■ The potential for stagnation to occur in both the detective assignment as well as that of patrol where, outside of the SRO program, few special assignments exist. ■ New energy and ideas may be brought into the detective workforce. ■ Officers rotating out of investigations assignments bring back to patrol the valuable experience that they can share, especially relative to newer, less experienced patrol officers. ■ As personnel are promoted, they bring more diverse experience into their supervisory/leadership roles versus being largely singularly dimensional. This allows for them to be more informed decision-makers for the betterment of the entire department, not just focused on that section in which they spent the majority of their career. ■ Assignment rotations help to prevent the “Silo Effect” in organizations. The “Silo Effect” occurs when the individual divisions become too focused on their own wants and needs and the broader interests of the department may be sacrificed. This transcends through the organization as employees move into management positions and make decisions that favor the “Silo” from which they came, or current or former members of it. As previously noted, on the downside, there is a loss of experience associated with rotational schedules. To mitigate this, it is important that the assignment is of sufficient duration that expertise is developed, and that any rotation of personnel be staggered so as not to lose all experienced personnel simultaneously. For example, using the current BPD detective staffing, this would require an assignment duration of approximately six years, with rotation of one detective supervisor out of the division every three years, and one detective out of the division every two years. It is not surprising that in agencies that do not have a rotational schedule, detectives vehemently oppose such a concept. Conversely, those seeking this often coveted special Page 86 Section VI. Item # a. 71 assignment strongly support rotations. While we appreciate each perspective, CPSM believes that the value of a making detectives a rotational assignment significantly outweighs the downside. If the department chooses to retain its permanent assignment status for CID personnel, CPSM would encourage the department to, at the very least, consider a rotational assignment opportunity. Some agencies develop a two-year rotation schedule for patrol officers interested in a detective assignment. To accomplish this, one of the current detective positions could be designated as a rotational position. The duration of assignment could be two years, This minimizes the staffing disruptions while still accomplishing some of the benefits of a full rotational policy. We also note that given the limited tenure of the department as a whole, and the Investigations Division specifically, this is not an issue at present. Nonetheless, we offer this as a consideration for implementation should the department stabilize its personnel turnover. Case Intake As we begin discussion of the case intake process for the CIU, it will be helpful to the lay reader to have a basic understanding of how records are commonly generated in police agencies across the country. We strive to do this here. Generally, the first contact with BPD regarding a service request is made through the Emergency 911 call center. For Bluffton, that function is conducted by the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office (BCSO). If the BCSO call-taker determines that an officer must be dispatched, the information on the call is entered into the computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system. The CAD system for BCSO operates off of the Spillman platform, one of many CAD platforms in use by public safety agencies across the country. A dispatcher in the 911 call center then dispatches that call to the BPD handling officer. Upon completion of the call, the officer clears/closes the call. The officer may indicate that a report will be generated, or provide “CAD notes” giving a brief summary of the disposition on the call and no additional report will be generated. This closes the CAD record. Once the CAD entry closes, the call data/record is automatically transferred to a compatible Records Management System (RMS), commonly the same platform as the CAD system, as is the case at BPD (Spillman RMS). These robust RMS platforms generally have multiple compatible sub-platforms to include Detective Case Management and Property and Evidence modules, etc. This is designed to provide a seamless transfer of applicable information between these compatible platforms, including auto-populating of relevant data in these sub-platforms. In the case of a criminal offense, once the initial report is completed and approved by a Patrol supervisor, the Occurrence Report is electronically transmitted to a que pending review by the Detective Lieutenant, or his designee. The lieutenant subsequently reviews the reports and determines whether the case will be assigned to a detective, returned to the patrol officer for completion of the investigation, or suspended/closed without further investigation. Law enforcement agencies vary widely in case intake policies and practices relative to Detective Section functions. In some agencies, all cases are referred to detectives for review and follow-up investigation, where appropriate. In others, only felony cases are generally referred to detectives, while patrol officers are responsible for the investigation of most misdemeanor cases and some low-level felony cases. Decisions as to the case intake processes are often driven by workload demand and staffing levels in Detective Sections. At present, BPD Page 87 Section VI. Item # a. 72 follows the model in which patrol handles many cases to completion, and only the most serious calls are assigned to a detective. Most agencies have inadequate staffing to fully investigate all crimes, and in some cases where little investigative evidence exists, it is fruitless to assign a case for investigation. BPD recognizes this and it is addressed in SOP 024 IV. B. 3. Here, solvability factors are established to screen out cases where investigative efforts of detectives are not likely to result in the identification of a suspect and the successful prosecution of the crime. In the event that insufficient solvability factors are present to warrant additional follow-up, the case may be declared inactive and closed by a supervisor without having been assigned to a detective. Below are examples of solvability factors to be considered: ■ Suspect is known. ■ Suspect has been seen and may be identified. ■ Subject vehicle was seen and may be later identified. ■ Specific modus operandi unique to a known or unknown suspect. ■ Victim wishes to prosecute. ■ Presence of physical evidence. ■ Ability to recover stolen property that may provide further leads. ■ The presence of any other evidence which would most likely develop further investigative leads. While the descriptors vary slightly from agency to agency, these represent commonly acceptable solvability factors that help to ensure that limited investigative resources are optimally utilized. When the answer to all or most of these questions in NO, cases are generally closed without further investigation. Next, we will examine the workload associated with criminal cases to include the number of cases assigned to a detective for follow-up investigation. Workload Demand To this point, we have discussed staffing, work schedules, and case intake procedures. Here, we will examine how CID is positioned to manage workload demand. As we previously noted, not all criminal investigations are assigned to a detective. Some are handled in their entirety by a patrol officer, an SRO, or closed without further investigation following review of solvability factors. Cases reflected in the following Table are limited to those that were assigned to a detective. Page 88 Section VI. Item # a. 73 TABLE 6-2: Criminal Investigations Unit Case Assignment, 2021–2023 Cases Assigned 2021 2022 2023 Criminal Investigations Criminal Investigations Unit 185 218 284 Domestic Violence - 10 39 Criminal Investigations Total 185 228 323 Support Functions Victim / Witness Advocate 38 58 133 Community Mental Health 1 136 128 Support Function Total 39 194 261 Total 224 422 584 Source: BPD As case assignment practices vary widely from agency to agency, there are no absolute standards to determine an appropriate caseload for police investigators. One murder investigation could occupy the time of several detectives for months, and on the other hand, one detective could handle hundreds of theft cases in a similar period. Nonetheless, the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) has suggested that a detective caseload between 120 and 180 cases per year (10 to 15 per month) is manageable. As we examine the data in the table above, we note that the caseload has steadily increased year over year. Still, considering the highest yearly caseload (2023) each of the three detectives would handle a caseload of approximately 95 cases per detective per year, a figure that is somewhat lower than the IACP range. Here, we excluded the domestic violence detective and their assigned caseload as their victim advocate role provides additional responsibilities outside of traditional case management. Had that data been included, the cases per detective per year would be lower. Other sources suggest departments should staff one detective for every 300 UCR Part I Index Crimes recorded each year. Part 1 crimes generally represent the most serious offenses. Excluded are cases involving crimes such as simple assault, drug, alcohol, vandalism, etc. In the table that follows, we show reported Part 1 Crimes occurring in Bluffton during the past three calendar years. TABLE 6-3: FBI UCR Reported Part 1 Crimes in Bluffton, 2021–2023* Crime 2021 2022 2023* 2024 YTD 7/31* Murder 1 1 1 2 Rape 3 3 1 3 Robbery 4 4 4 5 Aggravated Assault 16 17 29 13 Burglary 37 30 50 14 Larceny 163 160 275 143 Vehicle Theft 23 21 45 16 Total 247 236 405* 196* Note: *2023 and 2024 YTD data is not yet available from the FBI UCR and is provided by BPD. Page 89 Section VI. Item # a. 74 As we look at the second benchmark, in dividing these total numbers by 300, one can see it would require between 0.82 (2021), 0.79 (2022), and 1.35 (2023) detectives to adequately meet workload demands. According to both benchmarks, it would appear that BPD CID has adequate resources to manage criminal investigations when considering the section’s total caseload and staffing. However, other workload handled by BPD detectives must be factored in. One duty which adds to detective workload is that of crime scene investigation (CSI). This applies both to Bluffton cases as well as outside jurisdiction cases where detectives may be called upon by the BCSO regional crime scene investigations team to work a major crime scene in a neighboring agency. While this is something that detectives in many larger agencies are not responsible for, at BPD this is a duty that falls to detectives, and or in some simple or minor cases, to patrol officers. We offer that CSI work requires substantial training and experience to develop proficiency, and is very labor intensive. We will further address crime scene investigations shortly, but submit that the workload associated with crime scene investigations can substantially increase workload of detective personnel. Unfortunately, the department does not track CSI data, neither for patrol officers nor detectives. As such, we cannot quantify, nor report on the quality of such investigations, at least from a data standpoint. Again, we will report on CSI in more detail shortly. Case Management In previous reporting on case intake, we briefly discussed the Spillman RMS. That platform has a detective case management system module. As we noted, cases are generated in the system upon transferring the CAD call data to RMS once the CAD call has been closed. That report populates the RMS case management module. Once received, the CID Lieutenant makes a determination as to which cases will be assigned to a detective for investigation, which cases will be returned to the patrol officer for additional investigation, and which cases will be closed. Detective case management modules are robust systems that include information such as: ■ Date / time / location of occurrence. ■ Case number. ■ Nature / classification of offense. ■ Assigned officer / detective. ■ Status of investigation to include notifications to supervisors of investigative actions. ■ Alerts that a status report is due. ■ Case closure status (i.e., cleared by arrest, cleared by exceptional means, closed due to lack of leads, unfounded, etc.) When properly and fully utilized, a case management system can provide a wealth of data on workload and the overall department’s effectiveness in solving crime. This would apply to individual detectives as well. It may also lead to the identification of irregularities. For instance, in one agency studied by CPSM, one of their many detectives cleared the majority of their crimes by exceptional means, a highly irregular clearance classification. The rate substantially differed from other detectives and called into question this detective’s work/reporting practices. We are not suggesting any irregularities have been discovered at BPD, but rather, pointing out the value of case management systems when fully utilized. Page 90 Section VI. Item # a. 75 Such reports can and should be made available for review by the department’s command on a quarterly basis, something that is not being done today. This would allow a more definitive and accurate assessment of the effectiveness of the detective function vs. simply anecdotal evidence that may be available in the absence of such comprehensive reports. In some departments, detective managers utilize Excel spreadsheets to track assigned cases, though in the end, must update the compatible RMS portal to officially close the case. This is done as some managers find it easier to track cases utilizing an Excel spreadsheet. That is the case here at BPD. While this appears as a duplication of effort, the relatively light caseload allows for this to be a feasible approach. We would point out that some agencies find it difficult to navigate these sometimes complex systems, especially when a primary responsibility is investigating crimes, not data system management. This is especially true where clerical support is not available, as is the case in BPD. Training CPSM requested information regarding detective personnel training. Staff indicated that detective personnel receive relevant and up-to-date courses as needed and that detectives are asked to submit a training request for courses that they wish to attend. We inquired whether a training matrix exists for the detective function and were advised that none exists. Many agencies utilize a training matrix to ensure that all new detectives are scheduled for those courses that will aid in the development of their expertise. By tracking training provided to their subordinates, supervisors can then ensure that personnel under their command are scheduled for such training, and that this assignment-specific training is prioritized over other elective training courses that provide less value to the position. CPSM recommends that the CID Lieutenant, in conjunction with the department’s training coordinator, develop a CID training matrix to identify both required and desirable training courses for these positions. The training matrix should serve as a guide to ensure that CID personnel training assignments are prioritized by this matrix. Technology We inquired of detective personnel whether available technology for investigative purposes serves them well. A number of concerns were raised. Specifically and among others, was that their existing department-provided computers do not have the capacity to download the large files that are often associated with complex investigations. This commonly leads to “freezing” of the computer and prevents detectives from continuing their work until the situation is resolved. In some cases work is lost. They also indicated that while there are numerous video cameras positioned throughout the Town that could aid in investigations, as many as one-half are not functioning. In this report, we will devote a section to Information Technology. There, we recommend the formation of an IT users group to review technology needs throughout the department. We recommend that a representative of the Investigations Division be assigned to that group, if so constituted. FBI UCR/NIBRS Crime Reporting Annually, the Federal Bureau of Investigation produces a Uniform Crime Report (UCR) / National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS) that provides comprehensive crime and other law Page 91 Section VI. Item # a. 76 enforcement data for agencies across the country. Data is supplied to the FBI by the states after each state collects and processes the data received from local agencies. BPD reports such data to the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED). As we reported on crime rates throughout this report, the data reflects what is published by the FBI UCR/NIBRS. We note here that the department crime and clearance rate records vary slightly from those published by the FBI. As well, the department indicates that its records vary slightly from those reported by SLED, which the department also indicates differ slightly from those reported by the FBI. While the variations are minor, as we examine the subject of crime and clearance rates here, we hope to identify possible reasons for such variations. While reporting of crime and clearance rates seems simple and straightforward, this is a complex process that involves “Coding” of crimes and clearances. In other words, each crime must be analyzed to determine which “Code” is to be utilized in classifying the case. The “Codes” are defined by the FBI. This ensures that each agency’s reporting is consistent, or uniform. The instruction manual is voluminous and complex. This applies to both reporting of crime and clearance rates. It is not a simple task, and is one with which agencies often struggle to accurately report data. In many larger agencies, a lone records specialist may be trained for and assigned the responsibility for ensuring that report submissions are properly coded. Each crime report and case disposition is reviewed to allow for accurate reporting. This is often a full-time job in these larger agencies. It was reported that Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office has two such positions. At BPD, patrol officers and detectives are responsible for “Coding” of crimes and clearances. That is accomplished when they enter information into the department’s records management system (Spillman). Supervisors ultimately approve such entries. None, however, are trained in the coding process. As such, the Spillman case management record sets the default code based upon the data entered. These records may or may not be fully accurate based upon FBI UCR/NIBRS guidelines. Monthly, the department’s executive assistant is charged with reporting crime data to SLED. That reporting is based upon the entries and process described above. If the executive assistant notices glaring errors, she works with the officer / detective to correct the information. However, the assistant has limited training in FBI UCR/NIBRS reporting, and reading all police reports to ensure accuracy of reporting is not a responsibility of this position, nor should it be. If staffing permits, this duty should be transferred to the Records Division. If necessary, additional staffing should be allocated. FBI UCR/NIBRS Clearance Rates Clearance rates are an important measure of an individual detective’s performance and excessively low rates can lead to the identification of training needs, additional supervisory oversight, and in some cases, the need for reassignment from the unit. In another department assessment, CPSM discovered policy language that we believe demonstrates the value of measuring clearance rates, which CPSM wholeheartedly agrees with. It stated: “Case clearance is an indicator of individual performance and can assist in evaluating the individual detective.” CPSM maintains that while preventing a crime is of utmost importance to any law enforcement agency, solving crime should have parity. The solving of crimes which results in the prosecution of offenders not only prevents future crime, it provides much-needed closure to crime victims. Page 92 Section VI. Item # a. 77 Clearance rates, as defined and measured by the FBI Uniform Crime Report (UCR/NIBRS), are the benchmark for a department’s effectiveness in solving crimes. The following two tables provide Bluffton 2021 and 2022 UCR clearance rates compared to state and national rates. Data for 2023 will not be available until Autumn 2024. As we have noted, however, the processes in place do not appear to lend themselves to ensuring that FBI UCR/NIBRS reports are entirely accurate. Therefore, crime and clearance rates could be under- or over-represented. We would also note that we find similar issues with most agencies that do not have a single point for ensuring consistency with FBI reporting guidelines. TABLE 6-4: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Clearance Rates, 2021 Crime Bluffton South Carolina National Crimes Clearances Rate Crimes Clearances Rate Crimes Clearances Rate Murder / Manslaughter 1 1 100% 533 377 71% 22,900 11,500 50% Rape 3 0 0% 2,351 872 37% 144,300 16,500 11% Robbery 4 2 50% 2,641 917 35% 202,200 48,800 24% Aggravated Assault 16 10 63% 16,041 8,464 53% 943,800 297,500 32% Burglary 37 2 5% 19,872 3,636 18% 899,700 107,200 12% Larceny 163 8 5% 100,391 17,030 17% 4,627,000 508,900 11% Vehicle Theft 23 3 13% 14,989 2,457 16% 890,200 68,500 8% Note: Clearances were not reported for rape offenses in 2020. *We used national crime and clearance rates for 2021 as estimated in the FBI’s report The Transition to the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS): A Comparison of 2020 and 2021 NIBRS Estimates. TABLE 6-5: Reported Bluffton, South Carolina, and National Crime Clearance Rates, 2022 Crime Bluffton South Carolina National Crimes Clearances Rate Crimes Clearances Rate Crimes Clearances Rate Murder / Manslaughter 1 1 100% 497 284 57% 21,797 10,752 49% Rape 3 1 33% 2,230 860 39% 132,997 27,856 21% Robbery 4 0 0% 2,153 699 32% 215,760 51,930 24% Aggravated Assault 17 9 53% 15,850 8,237 52% 756,601 334,405 44% Burglary 30 4 13% 18,327 3,473 19% 916,970 125,838 14% Larceny 160 14 9% 93,496 16,541 18% 4,947,709 633,098 13% Vehicle Theft 21 4 19% 13,093 2,064 16% 953,827 87,140 9% The FBI establishes strict, three-prong criteria for clearing of a case. For UCR reporting purposes, a crime is considered cleared when: (1) a law enforcement agency has arrested the offender; (2) the offender has been charged with the offense; AND (3) the offender is turned over to the court for prosecution (whether following arrest, court summons, or police notice). The arrest of one person may clear several crimes or the arrest of several persons may clear only one crime. Convictions or acquittals are not factored into clearance rates. Page 93 Section VI. Item # a. 78 Here, it is important to note that nomenclature utilized in South Carolina may lead to some confusion and inaccuracies relative to reported clearance rates. In South Carolina, if an officer makes an arrest, the arrested individual is considered “charged.” However, that does not necessarily mean that the individual will be prosecuted in court. Rather, the case is submitted to the Solicitor’s office for consideration of further proceedings. The Solicitor may opt to proceed as follows: ■ Seek an indictment before a grand jury based upon charges filed by the arresting officer. ■ Seek an indictment before a grand jury after modifying charges filed by the arresting officer. ■ Decline to seek an indictment based upon the lack of probable cause or unlikelihood of successfully prosecuting the case. If the case is presented to a grand jury, and the grand jury returns an indictment, then and only then is the case prosecuted in a court of law. If the grand jury declines to indict the offender, no court prosecution occurs. Therefore, confusion regarding reporting of clearance rates may lay in the use of the term “charged.” Whereas in South Carolina, “charged” refers to a case in which an offender has been arrested (seemingly meeting prongs 1 and 2 of the clearance criteria), in other states, the term “charged” refers to the offenses for which the prosecuting agency determines that the arrested offender (prong 1) is to be prosecuted in a court of law, or charged with the offense for which they were arrested (prong 2). It is, of course, not unusual for arrested persons (prong 1) not to be prosecuted in a court of law. Thus, the clearance rate measure for South Carolina may result in above-average reporting of clearance rate numbers as compared to those of other states. That may be the cause of disparities in the clearance rates between South Carolina and the national average (see Table 6-5) where the South Carolina rates are substantially higher than the national average. There are clearances via exceptional means as well. Examples include the death of an offender, the lack of an extradition treaty with a foreign government in a nation to which the offender has fled, or the victim’s refusal to cooperate with prosecution after the suspect has been identified. Excerpt as it relates to domestic violence cases where it is not uncommon for victims to refuse to participate in prosecuting the offender, the exceptions are limited and result in numbers that are not statistically sufficient to warrant consideration. BPD Criminal Investigations SOP 024. IV. C. and D. discuss case dispositions, including clearances. Specifically, Exceptional Clearances are defined. CPSM noted one inaccuracy here. In D. 4 the policy indicates that a case may be exceptionally cleared if “Prosecution is refused by the Solicitor’s Office.” That is factually inaccurate. In this case, there would be no seeking of an indictment before a grand jury, and no court prosecution. As we noted above, in the third prong of the three prong test, “the offender is turned over to the court for prosecution” is a clearance criteria. If the prosecutor or grand jury declines to indict due to insufficient evidence presented to warrant prosecution, that does not permit the case to be cleared by exceptional means, and doing so skews clearance rate numbers. The FBI UCR/NIBRS reporting model in place at BPD lends itself to minor inaccuracies in reporting. This is evident in reports from staff that internal crime/clearance rate numbers differ from those published by the FBI. As previously mentioned, the reporting criteria is complex. Without a single point of responsibility, someone who is trained in both coding of crimes and clearance rate criteria, accuracy is likely to continue to be an issue. Page 94 Section VI. Item # a. 79 We have devoted considerable discussion to the issue of FBI UCR/NIBRS clearance rates as we believe that these serve as important measurements of the department’s effectiveness in helping provide for a safe community. Staff indicated that there is no review of individual detective or cumulative clearance rate information as recorded in the Spillman RMS, or as reported to SLED and ultimately the FBI. CPSM submits that BPD command and supervision should take an active role in reviewing and evaluating clearance rates to assess unit and staff effectiveness. Such a review should be conducted on a quarterly or semi-annual basis. CIU Recommendations: ■ A comprehensive review of SOP 024, Criminal Investigations, should be conducted to ensure that the policy meets current department practices and operating needs. (Recommendation No. 30.) ■ As part of a comprehensive review of the Criminal Investigations policy, SOP 024. II. C. should be amended to reflect after-hours call-out procedures to include the identification of the types of incidents that warrant call-outs. (Recommendation No. 31.) ■ Consideration should be given to developing a rotational schedule for the detective assignment and move away from its status as a permanent assignment, which is the case at present. (Recommendation No. 32.) ■ Consideration should be given to the development of a CID training matrix to identify both required and desirable training courses as a guide to ensure that CID personnel training opportunities are properly prioritized and met. (Recommendation No. 33.) ■ Consideration should be given to conducting a technology needs assessment and developing a priority list for acquisition as funding permits. (Recommendation No. 34.) ■ To ensure accuracy and consistency, responsibility for FBI UCR NIBRS reporting should be transferred to the Records Division. Training of personnel will be required. As well, if additional staff are required, a part-time hire may be necessary. (Recommendation No. 35.) ■ Department command should review crime and crime clearance rates on a quarterly or semi-annual basis to allow for an accurate assessment of the effectiveness of the department’s investigative efforts and practices. The review should include both individual detective as well as cumulative department data. (Recommendation No. 36.) CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATIONS / FORENSICS In today’s policing environment, forensic evidence, especially trace and biological evidence, is of critical importance in solving crime and successfully prosecuting offenders. Crime scene investigators must have a high degree of training, experience, skill, and commitment to master this art. Each is of vital importance to this effort. As we begin our discussion of this subject, we point out that small agencies such as BPD have limited staffing, training, experience, and material resources to effectively manage complex crime scenes. As we continue our discussion, we will shed light on this fact. Nonetheless, it remains a critical element for law enforcement, regardless of the size of the agency. The complexity of such work is best illustrated by a review of what is generally entailed in the collection of evidence at crime scenes. The nature/seriousness of the offense will dictate the degree to which these processes are required. The following list of duties may be performed by BPD detectives or officers, as the case dictates: Page 95 Section VI. Item # a. 80 ■ Identifies, collects, and preserves evidence at a crime scenes. ■ Searches and processes crime scenes for latent fingerprints. ■ Searches and processes crime scenes for biological and trace evidence such has hair and fibers. ■ Collects and processes DNA evidence. ■ Utilizes available technology and materials to identify and collect evidence not visible to the naked eye. ■ Creates plaster casts of shoe and/or tire impressions, etc. ■ Photographs and diagrams crime scenes. ■ Photographs and fingerprints suspects, victims, witnesses as necessary. ■ Prepares crime scene sketches suitable for court presentation from measurements and rough drafts taken and prepared at the scene. ■ Assists in the reconstruction of crimes to include determining the course of events from physical evidence obtained, bullet trajectory, analysis of blood patterns, positions of victims and/or weapons, etc. ■ Transports evidence to evidence locker and/or state/county crime lab. ■ Establishes and maintains records to ensure proper chain of custody for court presentation and compliance with state statutes and department policies. ■ Produces detailed written crime scene reports to support other investigative activities and support the identification and prosecution of offenders. ■ Testifies in court as an expert witness regarding collection, processing, testing, and preservation of evidence collected. These are laborious, time-consuming tasks that in major cases such as homicide investigations, kidnapping, sexual assaults, etc., can take many hours and in some cases days into weeks to complete. Dedicated forensic specialists, not generalists who have multiple other responsibilities (that is, patrol officers and detectives), are vital to this effort. And as mentioned, extensive training and experience is required to master each of these tasks. Many small agencies find themselves burdened by crime scene investigations and lack the resources to be proficient in this field. We often find that detectives report that physical evidence collected at crime scenes is scarce, and that the investigation is hampered by the lack thereof. To its credit, Bluffton PD recognizes that alone it is not capable of performing this work at complex crime scenes. And while patrol officers and/or detectives will process relatively simple crime scenes, the department has partnered with Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office (BCSO) and other local agencies in the development of a regional crime scene investigation team, led by BCSO. This team comes together to assist partner agencies in processing moderately complex crime scenes. This agreement is captured in a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between BCSO and BPD signed in May 2023. The six-page MOU provides general terms and conditions that apply to the agreement. When the capability of the department resources and/or the BCSO-led regional CSI team are not adequate to investigate the most complex of crime scenes, the department may call upon the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) forensics unit for assistance. Page 96 Section VI. Item # a. 81 Bluffton is well served by this, in effect, triaging of crime scene investigations. It is a fairly novel approach to have a regional CSI partnership, and Bluffton PD and the other participating agencies deserve kudos for their willingness to come together to build this resource. CSI Policy / SOP BPD does not have a specific policy pertaining to crime scene investigations. Rather, there are references to crime scene investigations in a variety of policies including SOP 014, Evidence and Property; SOP 022, Discharge of Firearm; SOP 024, Criminal Investigations; SOP 025, Public Information / Crime Prevention; SOP 027, Training; and SOP 046, Legal Process. The most detailed information regarding crime scene investigations can be found in SOP 014, Evidence and Property. There, in Section II, Evidence Gathering Procedures, detailed information is provided about roles and responsibilities of personnel at crime scenes. This includes the utilization of outside resources where necessary, such as SLED. Many of the other SOPs identified above provide only limited reference to crime scene investigations. For instance, in SOP 027, Training, the only reference to crime scene investigation is as follows; “In-service training will be designed to provide supervisory, management, or specialized training to participants, and/or items of general interest and concern. These will include refresher training for investigative and crime scene processing personnel in the areas of laboratory capabilities and new equipment and examination techniques.” CPSM would urge the department to develop a comprehensive policy specific to crime scene investigations. The information contained in SOP 014, II, Evidence Gathering Procedures, would serve as a good starting point to build such a policy. References in other noted policies could be incorporated into the CSI policy. Such a policy would provide a central reference point for these investigations rather than requiring staff to search a variety of policies to find relevant information. CSI Training Across the country, basic recruit academies provide elementary crime scene investigation training to attendees. Courses include collection of DNA evidence, basic photography, plaster casting, and the collection of fingerprint evidence, etc. While this is marginally valuable for relatively minor crime scene processing, it does not prepare personnel for processing of complex crime scenes. As we noted in earlier reporting, agencies the size of Bluffton PD are not generally well prepared to process complex crime scenes. Commonly, CSI responsibilities are shared between detectives and patrol, and such a role is a collateral duty to their primary assignment. In larger agencies, dedicated full-time CSI teams are common. Some of those teams are staffed entirely by civilian specialists. While we have previously discussed the complexity of this work, we will illustrate this in the following table. Here we include a training matrix for another agency that excels in this field. The actual training matrix has much more detailed information. We include here only the main headings relative to the types of training required/desired to reflect the volume of courses required to develop expertise in this field. Page 97 Section VI. Item # a. 82 TABLE 6-6: Sample Training Matrix for Dedicated Crime Scene Investigators Type Class Basic Crime Scene Legal Issues of Crime Scene Searches Basic Crime Scene Photography Practical Crime Scene Processing/Investigation Evidence Collection and Processing Basic Crime Scene Investigations Crime Scene for Investigators Crime Scene Investigation Adv. Crime Scene Basic Crime Scene Academy Adv. Crime Scene Investigations Latent Print Processing Print Processing, Collection & Photography Photography Crime Scene and Evidence Photography Basic/Adv. Forensic Photography Forensic Fire Inv. Photography Low Light, Night, Inclement Wx Photography Adv. Photography Firearms for the Det. And CSI Death Investigation 101 Firearms Death Investigations Death Investigations Child Death Investigations Child Death Investigation Child Death Investigations Child and Infant Death Investigations Photoshop, PowerPoint, Diagrams for CSI Forensic Science Courtroom Testimony Testimony Courtroom Testimony: Practical Approach Reporting Cellebrite Certified Operator Susteen – DataPilot CCO DEI Digital Evidence FARO - On-Scene Drone Observer IBIS – Collection Fingerprint Recognition & Comparison (AFIS) Basic Latent Print Examination AFIS (Basic) Intro to the Science of Fingerprint Class Basic/Intm. Fingerprint Comparison Fingerprint Comparison, ID, and AFIS Plotting Palm Print Techniques Adv. Latent Palm Print Comparison AFIS (Palms) Latent Palm Print Comparison Basic Latent Print Comparison Comprehensive Adv. Latent Print Page 98 Section VI. Item # a. 83 Type Class AFIS (Adv.) Shooting Incident Documentation Shooting Incident Reconstruction Basic Shooting Reconstruction Shooting Incident Reconstruction Forensic Firearm/Toolmark ID Shooting Recon Adv. Shooting Recon Adv. Shooting Reconstruction Basic Bloodstain Bloodstain Pattern Documentation Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Level I Documentation of Bloodstain Evidence Adv. Bloodstain Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Level II Adv. Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Recovery of Human Remains Workshop Buried Body and Surface Skeleton Buried Body Clandestine Grave Search & Recovery Crime Scene Reconstruction - Level I Crime Scene Reconstruction - Level II Adv. Crime Scene Processing Drone Operator DVR Examiner (VERA) Part 107 - UAS License DVR Assessment & Video Recovery DVR/Video Processing Fundamentals of Video Evidence Forensic Video Analysis Remote Online Training – ClearID Remote Online Training - Intro to Omnivore Remote Online Training - Ffmpeg Convert Remote Online Training - dTective Effects FARO - Zone Core FARO Zone Point Cloud Crime FARO FARO Zone Point Cloud Crash FARO Zone Adv. Diagramming FARO Zone 3D (Online) BCERT (Computers) MDE (Handheld Devices) Computer Forensics CCO/CCPA Mobile Device Analysis MADE CASA Adv. Mobile Device Analysis Mac Forensics Training BNIT Adv. Digital Forensics NITRO Memory Forensics & Malware Analysis Digital Currency Course Page 99 Section VI. Item # a. 84 As can be clearly seen, both the training and duties associated with crime scene investigation are exhaustive. We are not suggesting that this serve as a training matrix for BPD. The agency does not have the capacity to perform the CSI function at this level. Rather, we utilize this illustration simply to allow the reader to better comprehend both the importance of CSI work and its complexity. Staff indicated that there is no training matrix to guide the development of those responsible for CSI collection. The only reference to CSI training that we found was in SOP 027, Training, where it indicates that “In-service training will be designed to provide supervisory, management, or specialized training to participants, and/or items of general interest and concern. These will include refresher training for investigative and crime scene processing personnel in the areas of laboratory capabilities and new equipment and examination techniques.” As we recommended in reporting on the CIU, CPSM offers that the CID Lieutenant, in conjunction with the department’s training coordinator, develop a CSI training matrix to identify both required and desirable training courses for this role. That training should focus on CSI duties that the department can effectively manage. Consistent with current practices, outside resources must be utilized when the complexity of the case exceeds the capacity of the department to management the demands. In addition to CIU personnel, Patrol officers with an interest in CSI work should be included in consideration for advanced training opportunities. CSI Case Management Data BPD does not track statistical data regarding crime scene investigation efforts. It is unknown how many attempts are made to collect evidence at crime scenes, the rate at which it is collected, or the value of such evidence in identifying suspects. This is the case for both Patrol and Detective CSI efforts. The absence of a dedicated case management software program specific to crime scene investigations is problematic. There is no reasonable way to determine the volume of workload associated with total cases processed. As well, important factors such as the number of cases with workable evidence, information on the number of fingerprints submitted through the Automated Fingerprint Identification System (AFIS), the number of DNA samples submitted for match through the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), matching “hits” for both AFIS and CODIS records, and a variety of other data is not available. This is important information for managers to have as they assess the effectiveness of the department’s efforts collectively, as well as those of individual investigators. This could be important information for managers in assessing the department’s efforts in solving crimes as we previously discussed. The department should migrate toward the use of a comprehensive CSI-specific case management program. CSI / Forensics Summary As previously noted this work is often highly complex and requires extensive training and experience to develop requisite expertise. It is not work that can be mastered as a collateral duty to a primary assignment be that as a detective or patrol officer. For that reason, the department is to be commended for utilization of experienced crime scene investigators in major cases, be that BCSO or SLED. A robust case management software program is needed to track the effectiveness of CSI efforts. At present some such information is contained only in individual crime reports and does Page 100 Section VI. Item # a. 85 not allow for the reasonable evaluation of the effectiveness of the department’s CSI efforts by command-level personnel. As well, a new CSI policy outlining duties and responsibilities for this function is needed. The International Association for Identification is the largest professional crime scene investigators association and establishes standards for forensic excellence. Certification by IAI is considered the “Gold Standard.” IAI could serve as a great source to assist the department in working toward improving its crime scene processing efforts. Crime Scene Investigation Recommendations: ■ A policy focused on crime scene investigation should be developed; it should include detailed responsibilities for patrol officers and detectives, as well as factors to be considered in seeking mutual aid for the processing of complex crime scenes. (Recommendation No. 37.) ■ Develop a training matrix specific to crime scene investigations. (Recommendation No. 38.) ■ Consideration should be given to acquiring a CSI-specific software program to include tracking of future CSI efforts and rates of success of such efforts. (Recommendation No. 39.) DOMESTIC VIOLENCE DETECTIVE, VICTIM / WITNESS ADVOCATE As we noted previously, BPD has a dedicated domestic violence detective with a collateral role as the department’s Victim / Witness Coordinator. This was at one time a grant-funded position; however, at present, the position is funded through the general fund. The current detective began service with the department in 2023 as a civilian victim / witness advocate, and was sworn in as a commissioned police officer in January 2024. As was seen in Table 6-2, the workload has steadily increased over the past three years. That increase coincides with the changes in assigned staff from a part-time civilian advocate to a full-time sworn advocate who is also responsible for the criminal investigation of domestic violence cases. Given workload reflected in Table 6-2, in reality, time spent managing victim / witness services dwarfs that spent on assigned domestic violence cases. The investigator indicated that only 25 percent of her time is spent on investigative case management, while 75 percent is spent on victim / witness services. Policy 028, Victim / Witness Assistance Procedures, guides the work of the victim / witness advocate. The policy, six pages in length, is quite detailed, with an extensive list of duties and responsibilities attached. The policy is guided by South Carolina state law. The duties are categorized as follows: ■ Victim / witness rights. ■ Procedures to be followed by the department. ■ Review of needs and services on a biennial basis. ■ Department responsibilities. Again, each of these areas have a sub-set of directives, in some cases dozens of such, that guide services. The following is a listing of prosecutorial and community-based agencies with which the detective works in providing services to those in need: Page 101 Section VI. Item # a. 86 ■ Solicitor's Office. ■ Hopeful Horizons. ■ Department of Social Services. ■ Goodwill. ■ Bluffton Self Help. ■ Deep Well. ■ Department of Crime Victim Compensation. ■ South Carolina Victim Advocacy Network. ■ South Carolina Coalition Against Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault. Staff reported that in instances where crime victims would benefit from services provided by the department’s Mental Health Advocate (see next sub-section), referrals are made and where appropriate, the Victim Advocate and Mental Health Advocate collaborate to provide more comprehensive services. In summary, the assignment of a commissioned police officer to serve as both a DV detective and a victim / witness advocate is somewhat unusual. While many agencies do not provide dedicated victim / witness service, those that do most often assign these duties to civilian personnel. However, the workload in Bluffton at this time lends itself to the model in use, and the department is to be commended for blending these functions in a way that serves both the community’s and department’s interests. As well, the current detective assigned to this role is passionate about it, and well serves both the department’s and crime victims’ interests. Should future increases in crime rates dictate the need for additional detective support, the department may wish to consider returning the Victim / Witness Advocate role to its prior civilian status in order to remove the presently occupying 75 percent of the detective’s time to allow them to assume a greater general crime caseload. COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH Increasingly, law enforcement agencies across the country find themselves engaging with those who are living without shelter and/or those suffering a mental health crisis. Many agencies find themselves ill-prepared to provide a meaningful response and resolution to those encounters. Generally, the response is limited to patrol officer(s) who have little formal training and few resources. This often results in a “kick the can down the road” outcome where the immediate call may be adequately handled, but subsequent calls are likely. Over the past few decades, an increasing number of law enforcement agencies have created specialized units to work with this population. In some instances, those specialized units include teams of specially trained police officers or teams of both police officers and civilian mental health specialists. Generally, these are larger agencies with greater resources than those available in Bluffton. In some cases, cities/counties fund community-based organizations (CBOs) that provide teams of civilian mental health specialists who provide direct services to this population through referral from the 911 call center. This may involve a co-response with law enforcement and/or fire department personnel, or the CBO may handle the incident without police/fire support. Page 102 Section VI. Item # a. 87 At Bluffton PD, the department employs a Mental Health Intervention Specialist. That position was created in 2021. At the time of the CPSM site visit, that specialist had joined the department only one month before the previous specialist separated from it. As CPSM assessed this position, we looked to the department's policy manual for information on its duties and responsibilities. That information is found in SOP 029, Mental Health. The policy was created in 2011 and last revised in March 2024. The Community Mental Health Advocate is a “civilian member of the Bluffton Police Department authorized to assist, refer, and provide resources for persons with mental illness who have encounters with law enforcement.” The advocate works a traditional day shift, Monday–Friday, and is available to respond during normal working hours to non-violent crisis situations involving a with a mental health issue. Additionally, the advocate will be available to department personnel by telephone on a 24/7 basis. The policy describes their duties as follows: ■ Review all incident reports involving the person with mental illness and contact the family and/or the person with mental illness. ■ If the initial situation is severe enough to warrant an in-person follow-up, the Community Mental Health Advocate will contact the person with mental illness and/or family to determine whether the appropriate services needed for the individual are being met. All reasonable attempts will be made to contact the person with mental illness by telephone as soon as possible after receiving the initial report. If telephone contact is unsuccessful, an in-person follow-up may be done accompanied by an officer. ■ The Community Mental Health Advocate will act as the administrator and coordinator of the mental health and crisis intervention program. ■ The Community Mental Health Advocate’s duties will include coordinating the training, along with the Training Sergeant, of all individuals, sworn and non-sworn, who are likely to encounter persons with mental illness. Training for all personnel relevant personnel is to be provided every three years. ■ The Community Mental Health Advocate will maintain updated records of available resources within the community and will provide this information to the Patrol Division. Also, per policy, the Investigations Division Commander is to perform the following duties: ■ Complete a review of available services and assistance needs of persons with mental illness within the department’s service area at least once every two years to include: □ The extent and major types of mental illness within the department’s geographic area. □ An inventory of information and services available for persons with mental illness. □ Assistance for persons with mental illness and related community services available within the service area. □ Identification of all unfulfilled needs and the selection of those that are appropriate for the department to meet. ■ Make recommendations to the Chief of Police to provide services to the public. Department-provided services best rendered by other agencies or organizations will be discontinued. Those services which are not provided will be originated, coordinated, and implemented, when possible. Page 103 Section VI. Item # a. 88 CPSM inquired of staff and was advised that these duties have been completed as dictated by policy. In summary, the Town of Bluffton and the Bluffton Police Department offer an excellent program, one that very few agencies of this size can offer. As a minor issue, we noted one apparent conflict in policy regarding the frequency of training in Section XI. Training of Personnel indicates that entry-level personnel will receive basic mental health intervention training while in the academy and that annual refresher training will be provided to all department personnel. In apparent conflict, Section XIII, Review of Needs and Services, subsection C., states that employees will be trained and updated on services and techniques every three years. It would appear that any differences in the content of such training would be minimal and that one such session would be adequate. Community Mental Health Recommendation: ■ The Community Mental Health SOP should be amended to clarify the mandatory training schedule and eliminate the existing conflict in policy. (Recommendation No. 40.) § § § Page 104 Section VI. Item # a. 89 SECTION 7. SPECIAL OPERATIONS Under the direction of the Support Division Captain, with direct oversight by a Lieutenant, the Special Operations Division is made up of the following programs: ■ School Resource Officers (SROs). ■ Crossing Guards. ■ Community Services Assistants. ■ Bike Patrol. ■ Community Action Team (CAT). SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICERS (SRO) SRO programs play an invaluable role in providing for a safe school environment, shaping young people’s relationships with police, and in establishing and maintaining productive relationships with school officials. Recognizing the importance of such, the Bluffton Police Department in conjunction with the Beaufort County School District have long maintained an SRO program. In addition, BPD has a separate agreement with Cross Schools, a private institution providing classes from pre-school through the 12th grade. Staffing South Carolina law provides for two classifications of SROs. Class 1 SROs are typically full-time peace officers that have full police powers across the state, while Class 3 SROs have police powers only on school campuses to which they are assigned, and only during regular school hours. At BPD, Class 1 officers are full-time commissioned officers, while Class 3 officers work part-time during periods in which classes are in session. Staffing consists of two full-time police sergeants and 11 SROs. Of the SROs, 5 are Class 1, and 6 are Class 3. All are employed by the Town of Bluffton / Bluffton Police Department. SROs are assigned at the following schools: ■ Bluffton High School (Class 1). ■ May River High School Class 1). ■ Bluffton Middle School (Class 1). ■ H.E. McCracken Middle School (Class 1). ■ River Ridge Academy (Class 1). ■ Bluffton Elementary School (Class 3). ■ Bluffton Early Childhood Center (Class 3). ■ Pritchardville Elementary School (Class 3). ■ Red Cedar Elementary School (Class 3). ■ McRiley Early Childhood Center (Class 3). ■ Cross Schools (Class 3). Page 105 Section VI. Item # a. 90 Operating Agreements As mentioned previously, there are two operating agreements that we will address here. The first is an annual agreement between the Beaufort County School District, the Town of Bluffton, and the Bluffton Police Department, 2023-74. This agreement pertains to both SROs and crossing guards. We will address the crossing guard program at the conclusion of our reporting on the SRO program. This agreement covers one of the two police sergeants, and all five of the Class 1 SROs. The provisions of the agreement call for the SROs, under the direction of a dedicated police sergeant, to provide on-campus services each day that school is in session. When school is not in session, the officers are assigned regular police duties at the direction of the police department. The agreement calls for the school district to reimburse the Town of Bluffton at a rate of $373,888 per year, which is approximately 75 percent of the collective annual salary and benefits of the assigned sergeant and officers. Here, as in the second operating agreement, assignment of SROs to extra-curricular activities outside of normal school hours is paid by the schools at a fixed rate that covers costs. The second operating agreement, pertaining to Cross Schools, largely mirrors that of the previously discussed agreement with the exception that this is a five-year agreement, with the contract amount being adjusted each year based upon salary changes. The 2023/24 school year was the first year of the current five-year agreement. This contract calls for one supervisor and one SRO. At present, the SRO assigned is a Class 3 SRO. You may note that these contracts cover 6 of the 11 SROs. The remaining 5 SROs, each a Class 3 SRO, are funded through a state grant program that supports the hiring of SROs on public school campuses. Though the formula for cost sharing of SRO program/personnel expenses varies from agency to agency, such decisions are economic policy decisions for the governing bodies. We submit that the spirit of these agreements are consistent with that of many other agencies across the country. CPSM reviewed both operating agreements; they were found to be highly comprehensive and largely consistent. In addition to the administrative aspects of the agreements, both spelled out in considerable detail the roles and responsibilities of the schools and the police department. Included is detailed information pertaining to the duties of the SROs. Policy / SOP There is no stand-alone policy for the SRO program. Rather, the policy and procedures guiding the SRO program are found in Policy 026, Juveniles. Specifically, the SRO program/duties are addressed in Section X, and in total, cover approximately one-half page. CPSM reviewed the information contained therein and found that it did not reflect the current status of the program in terms of schools at which SROs provide services, and only provided general guidance pertaining to the duties of the SROs and the supervisor. We believe and that the policy is inadequate and fails to provide necessary direction to department personnel. On the other hand, we found that information contained in the contractual agreements is far more detailed than that of this policy. Since contractual agreements between cities/towns and other entities are generally not readily available to line staff for policy guidance, CPSM recommends that a stand-alone SRO policy be developed. The existing contract agreements could serve as an excellent reference source to develop such a policy. Page 106 Section VI. Item # a. 91 Training Training in preparation for their duties as an SRO and continuing professional training is extensive. For a Class 1 SRO, it initially involves attendance at a two-week basic SRO course presented by either the South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy (SCCJA), or the National Association of School Resource Officers (NASRO). For Class 3 SROs, that course is shortened to one week. At present, BPD utilizes SCCJA for this training. Staff reports that all SROs are compliant with South Carolina regulations governing SRO basic training. Continuing professional training opportunities include: ■ NASRO Adolescent Mental Health Training. ■ ALICE Instructor Certification (Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter, and Evacuate). ■ DARE Instructor Certification. ■ Child Sexual Abuse Training. ■ Juvenile Detention Alternative Initiative Conference. ■ Center for the Prevention of Childhood Maltreatment Conference. ■ Childhood Maltreatment Investigations: Minimal Facts and Beyond. ■ Street Gang Awareness, Identification, and Investigation Seminar. This is clearly an extensive list of training programs. It includes a number of investigative courses. These investigative courses are relevant here in Bluffton as the SRO conducts criminal investigations of crimes occurring on school campuses. We will discuss this further in reporting on SRO workload next. At present, no training matrix for the SRO function exists. A training matrix identifies specific courses relevant to the duties of a BPD SRO such as those identified above. It can then be utilized as a management tool to ensure that these courses are prioritized over other discretionary training opportunities that offer less value to this specific positions needs. We recommend that the department develop such a matrix for this assignment. Workload As we begin our discussion on workload, it is important to point out that unlike Patrol, where the computer-aided dispatch system captures much of an officer’s time on assigned activities, this is not the case for an SRO. SROs serve as mentors for students, resources for families and school staff, provide classroom instruction, and are responsible for law enforcement-related duties at the schools. Few of these activities lend themselves to being captured by CAD, and rarely result in the initiation of a documented case file. Importantly, and as we mentioned previously, SROs are also responsible for investigations of crimes occurring on school campuses as well as cases involving children where, based upon their duties as an SRO, they are uniquely positioned to conduct a more thorough investigation. As well, the SRO may be called upon to assist CIU detectives and/or Patrol in investigations involving school-related incidents, or those not necessarily related to school, but involving a student, even where the SRO is not the primary case investigator. This is an excellent use of this resource as they are best positioned to seek cooperation from school staff as well as students involved in criminal activities, or witnesses thereto. Page 107 Section VI. Item # a. 92 As is called for in contracts with both the Beaufort County School District and Cross Schools, each SRO maintains records of activities in which they engage at their assigned school. CPSM reviewed these reports and found them to be comprehensive in capturing activities, though limited to a statistical number vs. any detailing of the activity. The reports capture the following: ■ Arrests. ■ Student contacts. ■ Parent contacts. ■ Law-related education. ■ Accidents. ■ Drug charges. ■ Assault and battery. ■ K-9 searches. ■ Weapons. ■ School disturbances. As would be expected, the overwhelming majority of incidents fall first to student contacts, then parent contacts. Even at the high schools, the annual numbers of arrests, drug charges, and school disturbances are nominal. We did note that while the BCSD contract calls for weekly reporting from each school, the reports reviewed reflect monthly activity and annual totals. This rate of reporting is more appropriate and appears to serve both the department and schools’ needs. Annual or Semi-annual Review Both contracts call for review of the status of the SRO program on either an annual basis (BCSD Section 6, Program Goals and Evaluation) or Semi-Annual Basis (Cross Schools Section 3.A.3.). CPSM requested the most recent copies of those documents for review and was advised that no such reports are generated, nor do the contracting agencies request such. Rotation Schedule The department’s SRO program is a permanent assignment. Once assigned, SROs generally only leave the assignment based upon promotion, retirement, resignation, personal request, or an administrative action related to a performance or discipline issue. The advantage of this practice is that personnel become highly trained and experienced in this role and as well as develop relationships with school administrators, instructional staff, and students. There is no question that there is value to this argument. We would point out, however, that the arguments for a rotation schedule that we put forth in our discussion of the Detective Section (Section 6) apply here as well. We need not restate that information here, but would refer the reader back to that prior discussion. We do recognize that only select officers have an interest in an SRO assignment. In an agency of this size, the number of interested officers may be limited. We also recognize that given the number of Class 1 SROs, it is likely that openings will occur with greater frequency than at agencies with only one or two SROs. As such, the non-rotational status of this assignment may be appropriate in this instance. Still, a long-term SRO may lack important experience gained in Page 108 Section VI. Item # a. 93 working other assignments should they choose to promote. Staff should consider this in situations where an employee may be a candidate for future supervisory and leadership responsibilities. Summary The SRO program at Bluffton Police Department must be considered among the most all- encompassing programs reviewed by CPSM to date. The commitment of resources is unparalleled. The program is well structured and well run. SRO programs play an invaluable role in shaping young people’s relationships with police and in establishing and maintaining productive relationships with school officials. The Town of Bluffton, the Bluffton Police Department, and the local schools are to be commended for their commitment to this program and the community’s children. SRO Recommendations: ■ Develop a training matrix that identifies SRO-related training specific to the functions of a BPD SRO, and utilize that listing to prioritize these courses over others of less importance as it relates to the specific function of this position. (Recommendation No. 41.) ■ A department policy delineating the purpose of the SRO program and the roles and responsibilities of the SROs should be developed to guide operations. Those roles and responsibilities outlined in the Town’s contractual agreement with Beaufort County School District should serve as the framework for such a policy. (Recommendation No. 42.) CROSSING GUARDS The school crossing guard program operates under the direction of the SRO sergeants. The program is governed by SOP 042, last updated in 2022. The policy provides the following objective of the program; “It is the policy of the Bluffton Police Department (BPD) to post crossing guards at selected intersections to facilitate the prevention of unsafe and unlawful acts by pedestrians and motorists.” As of May 2024, there are five crossing guards. Guards are temporary / part-time employees who serve in an exclusive role as school crossing guards. SOP 042 indicates that there are four schools at which crossing guard services are provided. At two of those schools, services are provided at two intersections for a total of six program locations. However, staff indicated that there are additional schools and locations that receive crossing guard services at present. They are as follows: ■ HE McCracken Middle School, Bluffton Elementary School, Bluffton Early Childhood Center. □ Buckwalter Pkwy./Old Bridge Dr. □ Buckwalter Pkwy./Pine Ridge Dr. □ HE McCracken Cir./Pine Ridge Dr. ■ River Ridge Academy. □ River Ridge Dr./Bluffton Pkwy. ■ MC Riley Elementary School □ Burnt Church Rd. Page 109 Section VI. Item # a. 94 ■ Bluffton Middle School) □ Mustang Dr./Simmonsville Rd. □ Mustang Dr./Buck Island Rd. ■ Pritchardville Elementary School □ Evan Way/Stardust Ln. ■ Red Cedar Elementary School □ Red Cedar/Box Elder St. As a side note, we would offer that listing locations serviced by crossing guards in an SOP is not necessary, as it would require modifications to the policy as sites change. The department may wish to reconsider including such in the SOPs. In brief, the criteria for selection of school cross guard locations is outlined in SOP 042 III C. It states “the Special Operations Division Commander and/or his designee will conduct an annual survey to identify locations requiring SCGs. The survey will be forwarded to the Chief of Police for consideration and approval.” In reviewing this program, we did note one anomaly. The SRO contract between Beaufort County and Town of Bluffton calls for a payment of $70,212 for crossing guard services. Beyond that, the contract is silent on crossing guards. If there are issues regarding funding or locations of crossing guard services, consideration may be warranted in including service locations in future contracts. In summary, the program appears well structured and managed. No recommendations are offered. POLICE EXPLORERS While not universal, many police agencies across the country offer law enforcement Explorer Programs for area youth. In some cases, police departments offer such programs in conjunction with a community-based program such as Scouting America or area Boys and Girls Clubs, etc. Such programs offer an excellent opportunity for police departments to build relationships with young people in the community. As well, these programs can serve as an employment gateway into the law enforcement profession, which benefits both the law enforcement agency and the involved youth. The Bluffton Police Department, in conjunction with the Boys and Girls Club of Bluffton, has long offered such a program. The police Explorer Program is assigned under the direction of the Special Operations Division Lieutenant. Staffing / Participants The Police Explorer program is led by a police corporal who serves in this role as a collateral duty to his full-time assignment as an SRO. Two additional SROs assist with program activities. Program participants include both males and females, and may range in age from 12 to 18. At this time there are 27 participants involved in the program. As a leadership development tool, and to assist with program management, an Explorer rank structure includes both a platoon commander and squad leaders. Page 110 Section VI. Item # a. 95 Best practices suggest that female officers should be included in program supervision where such programs are co-ed. Here in Bluffton, while a male corporal serves as the departments lead for the program, both a current and retired female officer assist with program leadership. Policy An examination of the BPD SOPs revealed that there is no written policy connected to the Explorer Program. The only SOP reference to this program was found in SOP 050, Department Organization and Command Protocol, where it is listed under the Support Division among functions that may be assigned as an additional responsibility. There is no operational guidance provided. The absence of a Police Explorer policy is problematic and should be addressed immediately. While Police Explorer posts can serve both the department and area youth well, there are significant liabilities associated with this or any similar program where officers interact with young people, both male and female. This is especially true where officers serve in a supervisory role over Explorers in a paramilitary structure. There have been many examples of situations where officers and Explorers, often mid-teen females, have engaged in inappropriate and sometimes unlawful behavior. At times, the inappropriate conduct was initiated by the officer, and at others, by the Explorer. Regardless, responsibility lays with the agency. Such interactions have tarnished law enforcement agencies and the Explorer Program, ruined the careers of involved officers, and adversely impacted the mental health of both the officer and Explorer. In the most serious of instances, officers have been imprisoned, and/or litigation has been brought against the governing agency, the department’s leadership, and the involved officers. CPSM urges the department to immediately develop a policy guiding the administration and operations of this program. Activities There are two primary activities that the police department sponsors. Each Wednesday from January through May the department provides training to the Explorers in various department functions. For example, a detective may provide information about the detective function, or a traffic officer may discuss traffic enforcement and/or accident investigation. These sessions last about one hour and provide basic information. Then, each summer, the department puts on a “Boot Camp.” This two-week program complements the above, and participants are tasked to engage in practical exercises. These simulation exercises include crime scene reconstruction, accident investigation, criminal investigation, first aid training and application, etc. Funding When CPSM examines funding of Police Explorer programs, our focus is on that funding which is managed by the police department or police department staff members. There are instances where funding of such programs is managed by police department employees, and thus is handled outside of the normal town/department budget processes. As such, the handling of the funds may not receive the necessary scrutiny to safeguard funds and ensure that expenditures are appropriate. Page 111 Section VI. Item # a. 96 Staff indicated that the Boys and Girls Club manages program funding, and neither the police department nor any employees are involved in this aspect of the program. CPSM did not examine this further as the Boys and Girls Club management of any funding is outside of our scope of work on this project. We offer for consideration that for specific events, such as 5K races and parades, that Explorers may be an alternative staffing source to commissioned officers or civilian employees for specific event roles such as manning barricades at traffic posts. Some agencies effectively utilize Explorers in this role, and compensate the Explorer Post, not individual Explorers, thereby supporting the post’s activities. Police Explorer Recommendations: ■ The department, without delay, should develop a SOP guiding the administration and operations of the Police Explorer Program. (Recommendation No. 43.) ■ Consideration should be given to utilizing Police Explorers as an alternative staffing source, in limited roles, at events such as 5k runs and parades. Compensation would be provided to the Explorer Post to support the post’s activities. (Recommendation No. 44.) COMMUNITY SERVICE ASSISTANTS Under the direction of the Special Operations Division Lieutenant, the Community Service Assistants are assigned to provide a Bluffton Police Department presence in the downtown area. The program, implemented in 2019, is staffed by two full-time civilian positions. Their schedule provides coverage between the hours of 8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m., seven days per week. For identification purposes, they wear a Bluffton Police Department polo shirt embossed with Bluffton CSA, and are provided with a distinctively marked vehicle, police radio, and laptop computer. Their primary function is to serve in a role similar to that of an ambassador or guide. They do not initiate or investigate criminal cases occurring in the district. Rather, if such a need arises, a patrol officer is summoned to handle that incident. The CSA enforcement responsibilities are limited to the issuance of parking violation citations. Other duties performed by the Community Service Assistants include: ■ Setting traffic / parking cones for farmers market. ■ Check parks throughout Town for safety and cleanliness issues. ■ Traffic control support for special events such as 5k runs and parades and MLK march. ■ Ensure AEDs placed throughout the town are serviceable (Parks, River Landing, Town Hall). ■ Interface with code enforcement regarding observed violations. Staff reported that there is no formal training provided to the CSAs. Rather, learning is limited to on-the-job training. CPSM was advised of a significant issue impacting efficiency, resource deployment, and resulting in unnecessary costs to the Town of Bluffton. There are three primary issues that should be examined by department management. ■ Staff indicated that the technology in use for issuing parking citations is not compatible with Municipal Court software programs, resulting in a redundancy of work effort. Page 112 Section VI. Item # a. 97 ■ Staff is required to add a vehicle’s registered ownership information to parking citations. To do so, they must contact the State Department of Transportation (vehicles registered in South Carolina) or the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office 911 Center (vehicles registered in another state) to access that information. This is a process that can take several minutes, significantly contributing to the time required to write a parking citation of up to 15 minutes. ■ CSAs are subpoenaed to attend court for the parking citations issued and are called to testify. This applies even in cases where the violator paid the fine ahead of the court hearing. This action results in CSAs being removed from service to attend court hearings, and if on their day off, attending hearings on an overtime cost basis. Clearly this is a multifaceted program that provides numerous benefits to the Town of Bluffton, the Bluffton Police Department, area merchants, residents, and Town visitors. Community Service Assistant Recommendations ■ CPSM strongly urges BPD management to examine the process by which CSAs issue parking citations to include the technology in use, the need for the address of the vehicle’s registered owner information to be added to the citation, and court appearance requirements when citations have been paid by the violator. (Recommendation No. 45.) CRITICAL INCIDENT TACTICAL RESPONSE Though infrequent in agencies the size of BPD, critical incidents can and do occur. When such an incident occurs, it may call for specially trained and equipped officers, often referred to as Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) team. To be both proficient and effective, SWAT teams require a substantial commitment of resources including personnel, training, and costly equipment. Agencies must assess whether the need for such a resource demands that they staff a SWAT team internally, or seek other options for obtaining these services. BPD has opted to utilize the services of the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office SWAT team when such a need arises and sufficient time is afforded to request their assistance. As we will discuss shortly that service is covered in a Mutual Aid Agreement with BCSO. Staff indicated that, while no statistical records of the number of responses are kept, that the need for a SWAT response is infrequent, estimated at a couple of times per year. In the past year, only one response was required. That response involved an armed individual who threatened suicide. However, incidents do arise and waiting for assistance from a SWAT team is not feasible. Such incidents may include an active shooter. We inquired regarding operational readiness for such an incident and were advised that all commissioned personnel attend active shooter training on an annual basis, and that three officers have recently been certified as trainers in this area. We noted that the department has no active shooter policy. Staff indicated that such incidents would most closely be addressed in SOP 010, Incident Command System. As we reviewed that policy, we noted that the closest possible reference to response to a critical incident such as an active shooter would be found in Section IV, Procedures. It states as follows: The Incident Commander will evaluate the situation based on three major incident priorities: a. Life Safety: The Incident Commander's first priority is always the life safety of the emergency responders and the public. Page 113 Section VI. Item # a. 98 b. Incident Stability: The Incident Commander is responsible for determining a strategy that will: 1) Minimize the effect that the incident will have on the surrounding area, and 2) Maximize the response effort while using resources efficiently. c. Property Conservation: The Incident Commander is responsible for minimizing damage to property while achieving the incident objectives. While this language provides general guidance in terms of priorities, it lacks specificity as to the roles of those who respond to such an incident. Situations such as that which occurred at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, and many others across the country, demonstrate the need for specific policies on response to a critical incident. As such, the department should develop an active shooter policy to provide step-by-step guidance for each responding officer. Critical Incident Tactical Response Recommendation: ■ Develop an active shooter policy to provide direction for all personnel responding to such an incident. (Recommendation No. 46.) MUTUAL AID The sharing of federal, state, and local government and community-based organization resources during disasters, emergencies, and major events is consistent with best practices in governance. It is more common, however, that mutual aid simply involves a patrol officer(s) assisting an adjacent agency on a call for service or high-risk traffic stop. Such responses, though commonplace, involve few resources and last a relatively short period. In either case, agencies commonly develop mutual aid agreements to guide such operations. BPD SOP 038, Mutual Aid Agreement and Liaison with other Agencies addresses this issue. The policy, six pages in length was reviewed and found to be comprehensive. It appears to be compliant with South Carolina State Statute 23-1-215 governing such agreements. As with other policies, it has been several years since the last review in 2011. Staff should review and update the policy to ensure that department practices remain compliant with the policy, and/or modifications are made to the policy as necessary. The policy does not indicate the agencies with which mutual aid agreements exist, but rather, has a listing of suggested agencies. CPSM requested copies of all mutual aid agreements in place be uploaded to a secure file sharing program for our review. These included seven agreements, each with the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office. The following agreements were submitted for our review: ■ School Resource Officer. ■ Bomb Squad. ■ Canine (K-9). ■ Crime Scene Unit. ■ Marine Patrol. ■ Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT). ■ Violent Crime Task Force. Page 114 Section VI. Item # a. 99 The department should examine this listing and determine whether agreements should be sought with other agencies such as SLED and/or adjacent counties, cities, and towns. Mutual Aid Recommendations: ■ Review the now 13-year-old mutual aid policy to ensure that it remains accurate in guiding current operations. (Recommendation No. 47.) ■ Examine whether additional mutual aid agreements are warranted for SLED and/or adjacent counties, cities, and towns. (Recommendation No. 48.) SPECIAL EVENTS Most law enforcement agencies experience special events in the jurisdictions they serve. The variety and frequency of special events where a police presence is assumed represents a challenge to police planning and a drain on police resources that is often unnoticed by the public. Some events are pre-planned while others are in reaction to emergency situations. Development of special event deployment plans for dealing with traffic conditions, crowd control, staffing needs, use of equipment, and related crime issues requires the exercise of reasonable initiative and independent judgment. At Bluffton PD, the special events are handled by the Special Operations Lieutenant; however, at times another command staff member may handle the responsibility. Special Events and Personnel The Town of Bluffton has four large special events that occur each year: ■ May Festival. ■ Arts and Sea Food Festival. ■ Fourth of July. ■ Christmas Parade. The Christmas Parade event is the only event where the department requires a mandatory deployment (every sworn employee works). According to the lieutenant, the same operational plans and orders are used each year with only minor revisions, essentially, the operational plans are “plug and play.” Any revisions to the operational plans are handled by the lieutenant in consultation with other staff. In addition to the four main special events, there are also additional events where officers are requested, for example, many of the churches in Bluffton request officers for their Sunday morning services, and sometimes during the week for other events. Five of the churches in Bluffton have signed annual contracts for the officers each Sunday, and several others are considering doing so. The lieutenant coordinates the contracts with the churches and then posts the overtime. The town also receives requests several times a year by promoters to put on a 5k run through the downtown area. The lieutenant works with the promoter to coordinate the route and the number of officers required to ensure the event is safe and orderly. Page 115 Section VI. Item # a. 100 Officer Overtime Once the lieutenant receives the dates and number of officers desired for events, he will post it in the department’s Intime system which allows officers to log in and sign up for the overtime. Over the last several years, due to staffing shortages, the department has had difficulty filling the overtime positions, When an overtime position cannot be filled, the lieutenant advises the requester that they should seek private security to meet their needs. Workload The Special Operations Lieutenant states that he believes that he spends about 40 percent of his daily shifts working on special event coordination. CPSM does not believe that the best use of the Special Operations Lieutenant’s time should be spent on work that could possibly be completed by a civilian employee. CPSM recommends the department consider creating a part-time civilian position that could handle the responsibilities of the special events. Special Event Recommendations: ■ CPSM recommends the department consider creating a part-time civilian position that could handle the responsibilities of the special events. (Recommendation No. 49.) 1033 PROGRAM The U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) Excess Property 1033 Program has assisted law enforcement agencies for nearly 25 years. It is best known for its role in providing law enforcement agencies with critical but previously unavailable equipment for little to no cost. The program is normally the responsibility of the department’s Fleet Manager/Quartermaster; however, since that position is currently vacant, it is at present the responsibility of the Administrative Lieutenant. Equipment Management Data related to the 1033 program is maintained internally within the department on an Excel spreadsheet: however, it is also maintained on the Defense Logistics Agency’s website. Each participating agency has the ability to certify their property, initiate a transfer request to move inventory to a different agency, and to initiate a turn-in request once that the controlled property has neared the end of its useful life expectancy. Over the years, the department has obtained three vehicles, two HUMVEES and one MRAP. Also obtained in the past were night vision optics that have already been returned to the program, and 16 reflex rifle optics that are currently in service. Decisions to obtain items from the program were the decisions of prior members of the command staff, and none of those who opted to accept the items are still with the agency. The current command staff was not involved in those decisions. Continued Participation Many incidents such as the George Floyd incident in Minneapolis have caused many law enforcement agencies to rethink how they police their communities and are moving away from the “Warrior Cop” narrative. That narrative was a response to police agencies becoming more and more militaristic with equipment that many times was provided through the 1033 program. Page 116 Section VI. Item # a. 101 Much of the equipment obtained through the program extended past the traditional functions of law enforcement, such as investigating and preventing crimes, and the response to calls for service. Obviously, there is much negativity regarding equipment obtained through the program. The department is currently in the process of returning equipment obtained through the 1033 Program. At this point in time, CPSM believes the Town is wise to return equipment already received if that property does not meet its needs. 10-33 Program Recommendation: ■ CPSM recommends the department continue to return existing equipment if it is not meeting its needs and at some point have discussions regarding future participation. (Recommendation No. 50.) PIO/SOCIAL MEDIA Nearly every law enforcement agency has a Public Information Officer (PIO) to ensure there is public transparency by providing to its citizens accurate and timely information about police activities and incidents. PIOs can also assist with building public trust and legitimacy. PIOs are often part of a team that also handles an agency’s social media accounts, which can be used to issue warnings, share real time information that protects the public in emergencies, solicit public support in criminal investigations, and provide educational information about the department. In the BPD the PIO responsibilities are handled by a sergeant who reports directly to the Support Services Lieutenant. The PIO position is an ancillary job in addition to the sergeant’s primary assignment. The position is appointed by the Chief of Police and there is no set term for the assignment. Since the sergeant is the department’s only PIO, he is on-call 24/7 for issues related to the media. PIO Responsibilities ■ The community affairs, public information, and media relations function. ■ Preparing and distributing BPD media releases. ■ Creating a working relationship with the media by providing formal and informal direct lines of communication. ■ Establishing an assigned area for the media at scenes of on-going major incidents. ■ Arranging for, and assisting at, media conferences involving BPD personnel and all media. ■ Assisting in the release of media information at scenes of major crimes. ■ Disseminated information will be restricted only when it could compromise an on-going investigation or when required by law. ■ Media conferences, when deemed appropriate, will be arranged through the Chief of Police and the Public Information Officer. ■ Coordinating the release of information regarding victims, witnesses, suspects, and confidential investigations and operations after receiving appropriate authorization. ■ Preparing media releases as necessitated by specific occurrences within the jurisdiction of the BPD, at the discretion of the Chief of Police or his/her designee. ■ Updating all department social media sites regularly to promote transparency. Page 117 Section VI. Item # a. 102 Training The only training the PIO has received was a one-day “Working with the Media” class in 2022 put on by FEMA. However, it was learned that the sergeant is scheduled to attend the one-week FBI LEEDA class, “Media and Public Relations,” in mid-2024. In addition to the scheduled training, CPSM recommends the PIO also attend some type of annual conference training. PIO Team Many law enforcement agencies have assembled and implemented media teams made up of officer-level personnel. After receiving training they function as a department’s PIO team and can be responsible for the department’s press releases and interactions with the press during incidents. The addition of several personnel who are trained in PIO duties could relieve the sergeant from the 24/7 responsibility, and if those personnel are working at the time of the incident, could produce faster, more effective information. CPSM recommends the department consider implementing a PIO team of approximately two to three officers who could assist with handling PIO responsibilities. Policy Policy regarding the PIO position is found in the department’s Standard Operating Procedures #25. The PIO policy states, “The Chief of Police or his/her designee must give approval prior to members/employees being interviewed by the media when the interview relates to the Bluffton Police Department or when the member will be identified as an employee of the BPD. No part of the BPD uniform is to be worn for any publication without authorization.” CPSM recommends the policy be modified to allow the PIO to conduct media interviews without the prior authorization of the Chief of Police. Social Media Presence The department is actively engaged in using Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), Instagram, Nextdoor, and You Tube. The PIO sergeant has the primary responsibility for the postings to the department’s social media sites; however, the Support Services Lieutenant and the Chief of Police can post as necessary. The department regularly posts about issues occurring in the community on its social media sites. Its Facebook site currently has more than 27,000 followers; a review of the site revealed that the department posts information approximately two to three times per week. PIO / Social Media Recommendations: ■ In addition to the scheduled training, CPSM recommends the PIO also attend some type of annual conference training. (Recommendation No. 51.) ■ CPSM recommends the department consider implementing a PIO team of approximately two to three officers who could assist with handling PIO responsibilities. (Recommendation No. 52.) ■ CPSM recommends the department policy be modified to allow the PIO to conduct media interviews without the prior authorization of the Chief of Police. (Recommendation No. 53.) § § § Page 118 Section VI. Item # a. 103 SECTION 8. SUPPORT SERVICES The Support Services section of the department is headed by a police captain. PERSONNEL / RECRUITMENT / RETENTION The law enforcement profession always faces the challenge of renewing its ranks. For nearly every agency, this is an ongoing effort. However, for some time and especially more recently, finding qualified applicants who have the desire and ability to meet the requirements of the selection process and academy training has become a more challenging proposition, adding to a growing shortage of law enforcement officers nationwide. In addition, a problem plaguing police departments is being able to retain employees once they are hired and trained. Personnel and recruitment are handled by the department’s Administrative Sergeant who reports to the Support Services Division Lieutenant. BPD has no designated personnel or recruitment unit except for the sergeant; however, he often solicits officers to accompany him to recruitment events. Hiring Process When a vacancy occurs, the department notifies the Town’s Human resources Department, which will post an opening for the position. The HR department then receives and reviews the applications, and then forwards them to the PD. The HR department will also sit in on the command staff interviews of the applicants. The following are the steps that must be completed to become an entry level Bluffton Police Officer: ■ Online application. ■ Agility test. ■ Written exam (The National Police Officer Selection Test by Standards Associates). A cumulative score of 70 percent must be achieved to move on in the process. ■ Oral panel interview. ■ Background investigation. ■ Polygraph. ■ HR file review. Once the applicant passes all phases of the process, they are placed on an eligibility list until an opening occurs. It was learned that testing is open as long as the department continues to have vacancies. For lateral entry officers, the process is the same as an entry level. Many departments studied by CPSM have begun relaxing their testing process for experienced officers by waiving the written exam portion of the testing process. In today’s world, all law enforcement agencies are competing for the same applicants, and if one agency has a testing process that is less onerous and time-consuming it may have the ability to complete the entire process and give a conditional job offer of employment sooner than the competition. CPSM would recommend the Page 119 Section VI. Item # a. 104 department consider waiving the written portion of the testing process for experienced lateral officers. When hired at Bluffton PD, the entry level candidate is sent to the South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy in Columbia, S.C., to attend the Basic Law Enforcement Academy. The Basic Law Enforcement Academy is 12 weeks in length, and upon successful completion, the candidate will be certified as a Class 1 Law Enforcement Officer. Pre-Employment Background investigations The pre-employment background investigation is one of the most important investigations a law enforcement agency will ever conduct. The investigations must be very comprehensive if they are to lead to informed hiring decisions. They must ensure compliance with all applicable minimum standards for appointment and screen out candidates who are found unsuitable for the position, based on relevant information and their past history. Background investigations are also among the most challenging investigations to conduct. The manner in which background investigations are conducted, from areas investigated to the evaluation of resulting information, must be treated consistently across all candidates. The department conducts background investigations of police recruits and police lateral officers. The background investigations are usually conducted by the Investigation Lieutenant and the Investigation Sergeant. Each department member conducting hiring background investigations has attended “Police Applicant Background Investigations.” The department strives to complete an applicant’s hiring background investigation within one month. Again, as with the testing process, the quicker the investigation can be completed, the better chance the department has of hiring that individual. A one-month completion is average for departments studied by CPSM. All hiring background investigations meet South Carolina Standards. Many police agencies studied by CPSM are now outsourcing background investigations to retired law enforcement personnel who have obtained their private investigator licenses. Some of the reasons for outsourcing of pre-employment background investigations are: personnel currently doing background investigations can be assigned to other needs in the department, the investigation can be completed in a timelier manner, extensive investigator experience, reduced costs, and sometimes even a better, more thorough investigation. CPSM recommends that consideration be given to outsourcing all background investigations to a private investigation company that specializes in conducting hiring background investigations. TABLE 8-1: Background Investigations, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 2021

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: Town of Bluffton website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.