RecordWell Data

March 14, 2024 BZA Packet

Anderson County · Anderson County · meeting of Mar 14, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Anderson County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEMORANDUM ANDERSON COUNTY DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS DATE: TO: FROM: SUBJECT: March 7, 2024 Land Use and Zoning Board of Appeals Members Tyanna Holmes March 14, 2024 The Anderson County Land Use and Zoning Board of Appeals is scheduled to hold its next meeting on Thursday, March 14, 2024 at 5:15 PM at the Historic Courthouse 101 South Main Street, Anderson, SC 29624. The meeting agenda and packet are attached for your review. Please email tkholmes@andersoncountysc.org or call 864-260-4719 to inform staff whether or not you will be in attendance. This ensures a quorum prior to arrival. Thank you. Tommy Dunn Chairman, District 5 Brett Sanders V. Chairman, District 4 John Wright, Jr. Council District 1 Glenn Davis Council District 2 Greg Elgin Council District 3 Jimmy Davis Council District 6 Cindy Wilson Council District 7 Renee D. Watts Clerk to Council Rusty Burns | County Administrator rburns@andersoncountysc.org PO Box 8002, Anderson, South Carolina 29622-8002 | www.andersoncountysc.org Anderson County Board of Zoning Appeals Hubert McClure, Chair, District #5 Mike Miller, Vice-Chair, District #2 John Farr, District #1 Russell Barton, District #3 Tony Cirelli, District #4 Brad Swillen, District #6 Debbie Chapman, District #7 AGENDA March 14, 2024 5:15 PM Historic Courthouse 101 South Main Street Anderson, South Carolina 1.) Call to Order: Mr. Hubert McClure, Chairman 2.) Invocation: Mr. Hubert McClure 3.) Approval of Minutes: a. December 14, 2023 minutes b. January 11, 2024 minutes 4.) Public Hearing: a. Variance request to allow one additional wall sign located at 108 Woodson Street/ TMS 236-00-14-019 (Council District 6). b. Variance request to allow additional signage located at 1913 SC-86/ TMS 216-00-13-002 (Council District 6). c. Special Exception request to allow a short-term rental located at 933 Hunter Trail/TMS 67-00-02-057 (Council District 5). d. Special Exception request to allow a short-term rental located at 1408 Cherokee Road/ TMS 17-06-01-033 (Council District 4). 5.) Old Business: 6.) New Business: 7.) Other Business: 8.) Adjournment. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) COUNTY OF ANDERSON ) ANDERSON COUNTY LAND USE AND BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DECEMBER 14, 2023 PRESENT: HUBERT MCCLURE, CHAIRMAN MIKE MILLER JOHN FARR RUSSELL BARTON TONY CIRELLI BRAD SWILLEN ALSO PRESENT: ALESIA HUNTER TIM CARTEE HENRY YOUMANS TYANNA HOLMES BRADEN BANNISTER PARKER MORRIS Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - December 14, 2023 2 1 HUBERT MCCLURE: We’ll go 2 ahead and call this meeting to order. And Ms. Chapman 3 is not going to be here, but who else is going to be 4 here? Or is this it? We’ve got four, so we can go 5 ahead and meet. 6 All right, first of all I’d like to do the 7 invocation. Let us pray. 8 INVOCATION BY HUBERT MCCLURE 9 HUBERT MCCLURE: Approval of 10 minutes for September and October. Any problems there? 11 MIKE MILLER: I make a 12 motion to approve as mailed. 13 HUBERT MCCLURE: Make a motion 14 to approve. 15 JOHN FARR: Second. 16 HUBERT MCCLURE: Second by Mr. 17 Farr. All in favor. 18 And let’s go ahead and get on the agenda. 19 Staff report on, I think, (b). I think (a) is 20 gone. (B) is a variance request, 28 Bypass, Council 21 District 2. 22 Staff report. 23 BRADEN BANNISTER: Thank you, Mr. 24 Chair. This is a request for a variance to allow 25 additional wall signs. The applicant is Kylie Fain for 26 Hilton Displays. The property location is 414 Highway 27 28, Anderson, South Carolina. As you mentioned, this 28 is in Council District 2. And the tax map number is 29 there for your reference. The current zoning is 30 unzoned. And the land use will be commercial. 31 The applicant is requesting a variance to install 32 two additional wall signs. 33 Finding of facts: Anderson County Code of 34 Ordinances Chapter 24-245 Section 2(c), number of 35 signs, specifically, permanent business identification 36 signs attached to buildings. Only one projecting sign 37 as defined in Section 24-24 is allowed per building 38 frontage, except for shopping centers, which may have 39 one projecting sign for each business use, plus one 40 aggregate freestanding business identification sign for 41 the shopping center as prescribed in 1(b) of this 42 section. 43 This is for a Starbucks on Highway 28 Bypass. 44 This is your site plan for Starbucks. And these 45 are the signs that will be requested for wall signs. 46 HUBERT MCCLURE: There’s Mr. 47 Cirelli. 48 TONY CIRELLI: Sorry. 49 HUBERT MCCLURE: That’s all 50 right. We’re on (b). (A) is thrown out. Yeah, take Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - December 14, 2023 3 1 (a) out. 2 BRADEN BANNISTER: And these are 3 surrounding properties. This is -- Papa John’s is on 4 the corner. This is your aerial showing the property 5 in question. 6 And staff recommendation is for denial for the 7 following reasons: Permitted freestanding and wall 8 signage allowed per current county ordinance would make 9 this property visible to all motorists traveling 10 Highway 28 and Highway 29 alike. On-site directional 11 signs included in the sign permit application will 12 serve as means of identifying means of ingress and 13 egress, therefore there is no need of additional 14 wayfinding on where to enter/exit. There is no 15 physical hardship that was presented in order to 16 approve the requested variance. And this requested -- 17 this request is not compatible with the spirit and 18 intent of the ordinance. 19 This is your staff report. 20 HUBERT MCCLURE: Okay. I have 21 a question right quick. Just so I can visualize this, 22 are they asking for a sign toward 29, a sign toward 28 23 and a sign toward Dobbins Bridge. Is that what they’re 24 asking for? I’m a little bit confused. I know they’re 25 not asking for a sign that backs up to Lowe’s. 26 BRADEN BANNISTER: No. There 27 would be one on each end and then one facing towards 28 Highway 28. 29 MIKE MILLER: So what has 30 been approved and what -- which signs, based off of 31 that. 32 HUBERT MCCLURE: Yeah, which 33 one do y’all approve? 34 MIKE MILLER: What are y’all 35 approving? 36 BRADEN BANNISTER: So by 37 ordinance we can approve one freestanding and one wall 38 sign. 39 MIKE MILLER: One wall sign. 40 HUBERT MCCLURE: Okay. So 41 they’re asking for two wall signs? 42 BRADEN BANNISTER: Two 43 additional, that’s correct. 44 MIKE MILLER: Okay. Either 45 you’re going to approve off of this page 8 and then 46 they’re requesting a (b) and a (c)? 47 BRADEN BANNISTER: Correct. 48 HUBERT MCCLURE: Okay. 49 Anybody here -- let me open the public hearing. 50 Anybody here speaking against? Nobody speaking Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - December 14, 2023 4 1 against, so I will close the public hearing and reserve 2 questions for staff. Or anybody speaking for? Then 3 questions will be reserved for staff. 4 What’s the feeling of the board? 5 MIKE MILLER: Mr. Chair, I 6 make a motion to approve. 7 HUBERT MCCLURE: You make a 8 motion to approve. Do we have a second? 9 RUSSELL BARTON: Second. 10 HUBERT MCCLURE: And all those 11 in favor show by uplifted hand. And good luck to 12 Starbucks on 28 Bypass. That’s all I’m going to say. 13 Okay. Next, RaceTrac. Staff report. 14 BRADEN BANNISTER: Mr. Chair, 15 this is a request for a variance for 4539 Highway 81 16 North. Your applicant is David J. Brousseau in 17 representation for RaceTrac. 18 Property location as was stated, is 4539 Highway 19 81 North in Anderson. Council District 4. The tax map 20 numbers are there for your reference. And it’s 21 currently unzoned and land use is commercial. 22 Applicant is requesting a variance to install two 23 additional freestanding signs, as well as two 24 additional wall signs. Anderson County Code of 25 Ordinances under Chapter 24-245, Section 1(b), number 26 of signs, specifically, permanent freestanding business 27 identification signs, only one freestanding sign is 28 allowed for each developed site, lot or parcel on which 29 a nonresidential use is constructed. Where a developed 30 site, lot, or parcel fronts on more than one publicly 31 dedicated street, one additional freestanding sign is 32 allowed for each street but shall not be located on the 33 same street frontage. Under Chapter 24-245, Section 2 34 (c), number of signs, specifically, permanent business 35 identification signs attached to buildings, only one 36 projecting sign as defined in section 24-24 is allowed 37 per building frontage, except for shopping centers, 38 which may have one projecting sign for each business 39 use, plus one aggregate freestanding business 40 identification sign for the shopping center as 41 prescribed in subsection 1(b) of this section. 42 This is for RaceTrac on Highway 81 North. 43 This is your site plan for the signs to be 44 installed. 45 HUBERT MCCLURE: Thanks for 46 the staff report. I know we have here speaking someone 47 for. Do we have anybody speaking against? 48 ALESIA HUNTER: Mr. Chairman, 49 I think he’s not completed the report. 50 HUBERT MCCLURE: Oh, I’m Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - December 14, 2023 5 1 sorry. I thought you said -- I’m sorry. I’m sorry. 2 Keep going. I’m sorry. 3 BRADEN BANNISTER: This is the 4 aerial for the property that’s in question. 5 And staff recommendation is for denial for the 6 following reasons: Adequate freestanding signage 7 allowed per current county ordinance would make this 8 property visible to all motorists traveling Highway 81. 9 Informational and directional signs provided by SCDOT 10 on I-85 will provide advertisement of filling stations 11 on the designated exit, therefore an interstate sign 12 will be unnecessary. No physical hardships were 13 presented in order to approve the requested variance. 14 And the request is not compatible with the spirit and 15 intent of the ordinance. 16 This is your staff report. 17 HUBERT MCCLURE: Thank you, 18 staff. Sorry about that. 19 Okay. Now, again, I’ll open up the public 20 hearing. If anyone is here speaking against. No one 21 speaking against. So therefore, I’ll close the public 22 hearing and reserve questions for staff or Mr. 23 Brousseau. Is there any questions of the board? 24 MIKE MILLER: Mr. Chair? 25 HUBERT MCCLURE: Yes. 26 MIKE MILLER: I am part of 27 this. I will not be voting. I will sustain, and I 28 will not be voting. 29 HUBERT MCCLURE: We have one 30 abstention from Mr. Miller. What’s the feeling of the 31 board? 32 TONY CIRELLI: They’re asking 33 for four variances; four signs; right? 34 HUBERT MCCLURE: Ask staff to 35 make sure. I want staff to say that. I don’t want to 36 say it. 37 BRADEN BANNISTER: That is 38 correct. There’s two additional wall signs and two 39 additional freestanding signs in the request. 40 HUBERT MCCLURE: And one thing 41 I would like to note, there’s quite a bit of -- there 42 used to be two lots right there. Well, it used to be 43 two lots. So it’s a pretty big piece of property. 44 TONY CIRELLI: Yeah, I 45 realize that. In looking at this and the way it’s all 46 on a small sheet, it’s hard to read, but looking long 47 and hard at this, I have no problem granting approval. 48 I make a recommendation to grant approval for A3 and N3 49 variance. All the rest --- 50 HUBERT MCCLURE: You can still Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - December 14, 2023 6 1 discuss it. You just can’t vote. 2 MIKE MILLER: I can’t vote 3 on it, but it’s no different than what with Love’s 4 we’ve already done and all the others, QT, most of this 5 is the same setup. And 85 foot is against the 6 interstate so everybody can draw that into that area. 7 It’s really not much different than the Stop-a-Minute 8 that’s right up above it. And then an extra wall sign, 9 it’s giving you directions on where you (inaudible) 10 there are Love’s. And I’m doing the work here, so 11 that’s the reason why I can’t vote on it. 12 HUBERT MCCLURE: It’s set up 13 the same way. 14 TONY CIRELLI: Well, in that 15 case, I have no problem making a recommendation to 16 approve. 17 HUBERT MCCLURE: Okay. I’ll 18 second it. All those in favor, show by uplifted hand. 19 And Tony, get it up so I can -- okay, there you go. 20 All right. That’s approved. Thank you. 21 Now, I noticed on the agenda that y’all got like 22 old business, new business and other business. Are 23 y’all sure y’all got the businesses covered? 24 Is there any old business, new business or other 25 business? I think Henry did that, didn’t he? 26 ALESIA HUNTER: Mr. Chair, 27 just to remind you, January is election of officers. 28 HUBERT MCCLURE: Oh, good. 29 Then I can get fired. 30 ALESIA HUNTER: No, sir. 31 HUBERT MCCLURE: Good, you’re 32 not going to be here? Then I will nominate and vote 33 for you to be chairman. 34 ALESIA HUNTER: January 11th, 35 looks like. No, January 12th. 11th, I’m sorry. 36 January 11th. 37 HUBERT MCCLURE: Well, great, 38 we’re going to have elections. 39 ALESIA HUNTER: Yes, sir. 40 HUBERT MCCLURE: Whoever is 41 not here is who we’ll elect. I’m kidding. We’ll do 42 that next meeting. Anybody have a motion to adjourn? 43 MIKE MILLER: I make that 44 motion. 45 HUBERT MCCLURE: I second it. 46 All in favor throw your hands up. 47 Y’all have a good Christmas and a Merry Christmas. 48 ALESIA HUNTER: Thank you. 49 50 MEETING ADJOURNED AT APPROXIMATELY 5:29 P.M. STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA ) COUNTY OF ANDERSON ) ANDERSON COUNTY LAND USE AND BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS JANUARY 11, 2024 PRESENT: HUBERT MCCLURE, CHAIRMAN - VIA TEAMS MIKE MILLER JOHN FARR RUSSELL BARTON TONY CIRELLI BRAD SWILLEN DEBBIE CHAPMAN ALSO PRESENT: ALESIA HUNTER TIM CARTEE HENRY YOUMANS TYANNA HOLMES BRADEN BANNISTER Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 2 1 MIKE MILLER: Good 2 afternoon. I’m going to go ahead and open up the 3 Anderson County Land Use Zoning Board of Appeals 4 meeting. Our chair has actually wound up being held up 5 in a class, and so he’s not going to be here. Right 6 now we’ve got five, so we do have a quorum. But he is 7 on Teams with Tim, there, so if he was to have any 8 questions or whatever, I may go back to him. 9 Like I said, it is 5:15. I will go ahead and open 10 us up in prayer. 11 INVOCATION BY MIKE MILLER 12 MIKE MILLER: Our new 13 business is -- Henry will you go ahead and staff 14 report, please. 15 ALESIA HUNTER: Mr. Chair, 16 approval of minutes. 17 MIKE MILLER: Ma’am? 18 ALESIA HUNTER: Approval of 19 minutes. 20 MIKE MILLER: I ain’t got a 21 copy of the minutes. I don’t think. 22 ALESIA HUNTER: You just need 23 to announce that they’re forthcoming. 24 MIKE MILLER: Okay. On the 25 minutes, the December 14th, 2023 minutes are 26 forthcoming. Good. 27 Mr. Henry. 28 HENRY YOUMANS: Mr. Chair, 29 this is a variance request for a reduction of the side 30 setback from 15 feet to five feet. The applicant is 31 E&B Holdings, LLC. The owner of the property is Shawn 32 Bell. Property is located at 225 Major Road in 33 Piedmont. It’s Council District 6. Tax map number is 34 there for your reference. It is 3.53 acres. Currently 35 unzoned. And the land use could be residential or 36 commercial. The applicant is requesting a variance to 37 reduce the side setback from 15 feet to five feet. 38 Under Anderson County Code of Ordinance, under Chapter 39 24-117, setbacks for non-residential principal use, 40 side setbacks from 15 feet for newly created lots of 41 record. 42 In 2007 -- this represents the compliance letter 43 for the construction of the storage building and this 44 one represents for the construction of the separate 45 storage building for personal use. 46 This is the plat that has been subdivided into two 47 tracts. Tract one which contains both buildings, which 48 is the subject of this variance; and then tract two is 49 the remainder of the property. 50 This is an aerial tax map view of the property Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 3 1 showing the buildings as they are on the certain -- on 2 the parcel. 3 Staff recommendation is for approval. In 2007, 4 the code allowed for a 10 foot side yard setback which 5 met the requirements at the time of construction. The 6 newly adopted code requires a 15 foot setback that 7 default -- placing a higher standard of the subdivided 8 lots which comes under the new requirements under the 9 Ordinance for newly created lots. Building and Codes 10 approved the location that will not meet the fire code 11 requirements under the new regulations. There will be 12 no adverse effects on adjacent properties if the 13 variance is granted. The Board has granted other 14 variances similar before and would be consistent. And 15 I approved, the new plat will reflect the side setback 16 of five feet. 17 This is your report. 18 MIKE MILLER: Thank you, 19 staff. I will go ahead and open up the public hearing. 20 Are there anyone speaking against? Are there anyone 21 speaking against? Hearing no one speaking against, I 22 will close the public hearing. I will reserve all 23 rights for the board for any questions to the staff and 24 to Mr. Bell. 25 What is the pleasure of the board? So I have a 26 motion to approve. 27 BRAD SWILLING: I’ll second. 28 MIKE MILLER: And I have a 29 second. All in favor, raise your right hand. All 30 opposed like sign. 31 Staff report. 32 BRADEN BANNISTER: This is a 33 variance to allow additional wall signs. Your 34 applicant is Patti Ridgeway, and the owner of the 35 property is Highway 24 LLC. Council District 5. And 36 the tax map number is there for your reference. The 37 land use is commercial. 38 Applicant is requesting a variance to allow two 39 additional wall signs. Anderson County Code of 40 Ordinances under Chapter 24-245, permitted signs, 41 specifically wall signs and number of signs. Only one 42 projecting sign as defined in Section 24-24 is allowed 43 per building frontage, except for shopping centers, 44 which may have one projecting sign for each business 45 use, plus one aggregate freestanding business 46 identification sign for the shopping center as 47 prescribed in subsection (l)b of this section. 48 This is the site plan for the property. The 49 Pennzoil sign that you see on the right is one of the 50 signs that is in question. And the rear south Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 4 1 elevation facing Jiffy Lube multicare sign is your 2 second sign in question. 3 MIKE MILLER: So the Hiffy 4 Lube and the yellow sign? 5 BRADEN BANNISTER: Yes, sir. 6 These are some of the adjacent commercial 7 businesses to this. These photos do show that there 8 are no signs on the rear of any of these facilities. 9 BRAD SWILLING: Was this in 10 our packet that we got. I don’t recall see that, 11 unless I missed something. 12 BRADEN BANNISTER: The pictures 13 of the adjacent businesses were added after-the-fact. 14 This is the aerial view of the property that is in 15 question. 16 Staff recommendation is for denial for the 17 following reasons: The signage allowed by Ordinance 18 will provide adequate visibility for all motorists 19 traveling Highway 24. Signage is not needed on rear 20 due to property being incorporated into an existing 21 shopping center. Surrounding properties are compliant 22 with Anderson County Code of Ordinances. And the 23 requested variance would be inconsistent with the 24 surrounding area. Applications have been denied 25 previously based on a similar variance. No physical 26 hardships were presented in order to approve requested 27 variance. And the request is not compatible with the 28 spirit and intent of this ordinance. 29 This is your staff report. 30 MIKE MILLER: Thank you, 31 staff. I will open us up to a public hearing. Are 32 there anyone speaking against? Are there anyone 33 speaking against? Hearing no one speaking against, we 34 will reserve the right for the owner and also for any 35 questions for staff. Do y’all have any questions, 36 board? 37 RUSSELL BARTON: Isn’t there a 38 building directly behind this new construction? 39 BRADEN BANNISTER: There is. 40 This is incorporated into an existing commercial 41 structure. It is --- 42 MIKE MILLER: Food Lion. 43 BRADEN BANNISTER: Old Food Lion on 44 24. I don’t believe I had -- the parking lot to the 45 lower left would have been for the Food Lion. 46 BRAD SWILLING: Are you guys 47 the owner? So what is the -- give us a little 48 background on the reason for needing signs on the back 49 if you know what the Ordinance is. 50 MIKE MILLER: State your Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 5 1 name. 2 CHAD WEISBECK: My name is 3 Chad Weisbeck. I’m the owner of the Jiffy Lube in 4 question here in Anderson. Your question was? I’m 5 sorry. Understanding a little bit why we want a sign 6 on the back? 7 BRAD SWILLING: I guess you 8 knew when you built -- well, you know what the zoning 9 -- what the rules are; right? So what’s the need for 10 the signage on the back? What is the hardship there? 11 CHAD CHAD WEISBECK:: 12 Yeah, our business being retail like it is, viewing 13 from the Whitehall side and that Moats Fowler, I think 14 that road there, for us gives us identify at the back 15 of what kind of business we are. If you’re not 16 traveling 24, if you’re coming from Whitehall, there is 17 no identifier from the rear. 18 Other businesses may be able to function as well 19 without that, we felt it necessary, especially as the 20 area builds up, that the traffic -- that’s a shopping 21 -- larger shopping center, but technically it’s 22 separated by the Moats Fowler, which I understand isn’t 23 a main thoroughfare, but it’s still a traveled road. 24 And we won’t be able to drive that road from behind us 25 and from Whitehall specifically to be able to identify 26 what we are. Because without a sign, it doesn’t 27 identify us at all. 28 BRAD SWILLING: So you do 29 have signage allowed on 24; correct? 30 CHAD WEISBECK: On 24, yes, 31 sir. 32 TIM CARTEE: Mr. Chairman, 33 that road that he’s referring to is a drive; it’s not a 34 road. 35 MIKE MILLER: Yeah, it’s a 36 drive-through. 37 TIM CARTEE: Yeah. It’s 38 not a county or private road. It’s part of the --- 39 MIKE MILLER: I mean, 40 Walgreens, you’ve got it; you’ve got Bojangles. 41 RUSSELL BARTON: Can we go 42 back and look at the site map? 43 HUBERT MCCLURE: Tim, you 44 there? 45 TIM CARTEE: Yeah. Hold 46 on, Hubert’s got a question. Go ahead, Hubert. 47 HUBERT MCCLURE: I’ve just got 48 a question about the back, because I don’t have 49 everything in front of me right now. But my question 50 is, because I’m very familiar with this area. As y’all Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 6 1 know this is my area out here, and I’m very familiar 2 with it. I know that building is between two buildings 3 and the only pretty much access you’ve got is the front 4 because you can’t see anything from Whitehall. But my 5 question is, do they have any signage in the back? 6 Because I don’t have anything with me right now. Do 7 they have any signage in the back? That’s a staff 8 question. 9 TIM CARTEE: No, they do 10 not. 11 RUSSELL BARTON: So if I’m 12 correct, there’s one freestanding sign in the front? 13 HUBERT MCCLURE: I can’t 14 understand. Are they asking for signage in the back? 15 TIM CARTEE: Correct. 16 MIKE MILLER: So, Hubert, 17 if you can hear me --- 18 HUBERT MCCLURE: Is it one of 19 those up to about the top of a car, or is it one of 20 those -- help me out with that. I can’t remember. 21 MIKE MILLER: Yeah, so he 22 can go. 23 TIM CARTEE: Hold on a 24 minute, Hubert, so I can get the drawing for you right 25 quick. 26 MIKE MILLER: Go to the 27 front one. 28 HUBERT MCCLURE: I just want 29 to make sure I understand it. 30 MIKE MILLER: It’s in the 31 back. Go to the front. Which it’ll be the one with 32 the Pennzoil that we’re talking about putting on the 33 front. So what we’re adding there is only the Pennzoil 34 on the front. 35 HUBERT MCCLURE: I thought it 36 was that sign right there. 37 BRADEN BANNISTER: That’s 38 correct. 39 BRAD SWILLING: To the staff, 40 is this an all or nothing deal, or ... 41 BRADEN BANNISTER: So two of the 42 signs have already been approved, the freestanding 43 sign, as well as the front north elevation, the Jiffy 44 Lube sign on the front has already been approved. So 45 this variance is merely for the Pennzoil on the front 46 and then the Jiffy Lube on the rear. 47 BRAD SWILLING: So what I’m 48 saying is, is this a package deal? So you either 49 approve all of it or you don’t approve any of it? 50 BRADEN BANNISTER: No, that’s not Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 7 1 the case. 2 MIKE MILLER: No. So go to 3 the rear, please. 4 HUBERT MCCLURE: I see those 5 two signs right there. What’s the height of those 6 signs, is what I was saying? 7 TIM CARTEE: Yeah, we’re 8 just looking at this Jiffy Lube sign right here. 9 HUBERT MCCLURE: Yeah, what is 10 the height of the sign? I don’t care about the signs 11 on the walls, because you can’t see them, pretty much. 12 You can’t really see them. But I am pretty open to 13 making sure they have the signage as far as the little 14 signs that go up about four foot or something like 15 that. 16 ALESIA HUNTER: The 17 freestanding sign, Mr. Chairman? 18 HUBERT MCCLURE: Yeah, I don’t 19 have a problem with that. 20 TIM CARTEE: You mean the 21 directional signs? 22 HUBERT MCCLURE: I mean, you 23 can’t see very much back there anyway. 24 ALESIA HUNTER: Oh, here it 25 is. 26 HUBERT MCCLURE: That’s my 27 input. I’ll shut up. 28 BRAD SWILLING: Mr. Chairman, 29 I’m going to defer to your expertise. 30 HUBERT MCCLURE: Yeah, they 31 have one of those freestanding signs like at the 32 driveway and --- 33 TIM CARTEE: Yeah, a 34 directional sign is what you’re talking about. 35 HUBERT MCCLURE: ... having a 36 bunch of signs (inaudible) ... 37 RUSSELL BARTON: My initial 38 hang-up, just so you’re know where we’re coming from, 39 at least the potential issue I’ve got is, what happens 40 if we go against the staff recommendations and you’ve 41 got vape stores or whatever else and they’re putting a 42 thousand signs across the front of their store. 43 CHAD WEISBECK: Can I speak, 44 if you don’t mind. 45 MIKE MILLER: Yeah. 46 CHAD WEISBECK: You know, it 47 is different in our location than the surrounding 48 businesses. You know, the corner of Walgreens doesn’t 49 have one on the back because they’ve got one on -- 50 they’ve got multiple signs on the side on Whitehall and Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 8 1 in the front. Burger King has got multiple signs on 2 the side and the front. They don’t have them in the 3 back. That’s just how our business is laid out. It 4 comes in from the rear. Our customers pull in from the 5 back. We’re really wanting to direct, if you drive 6 that, coming in through the front will be really 7 difficult. Pulling through that Walgreens there 8 creates more of a problem. So most of our customers 9 will come to the back around Whitehall to Moats Fowler. 10 I’m sorry, that little cross street. But that’s how 11 most all of our customers will come in. And that’s 12 when we -- you know, we obviously spend a lot more 13 money to put a sign in the back if we -- we really 14 thought it was necessary because that’s where people 15 are going to identify us and that’s where people we 16 want to come around from the back. And that’s the only 17 sign they’ll see that they’re at a Jiffy Lube from the 18 rear, is that sign. That’s it. They don’t see the 19 front signs from the rear at all. 20 MIKE MILLER: All right. 21 I’ve got one question. Why do you need the Pennzoil 22 sign on the front? 23 CHAD WEISBECK: Well, Pennzoil 24 is our primary -- we’ve branded and Pennzoil --- 25 MIKE MILLER: So everyone 26 coming to you know that you use the Pennzoil product? 27 CHAD WEISBECK: Yes, sir, it 28 adds value. 29 MIKE MILLER: Okay. 30 RUSSELL BARTON: Is there a 31 reason to have a freestanding sign -- they have a 32 freestanding sign on the front and a wall sign on the 33 front. Is there a reason not to move the freestanding 34 sign to the rear? 35 CHAD WEISBECK: Well, no, 36 still the traffic -- the heaviest traffic amount is 37 still on 24. And without that -- that sign sits 38 perpendicular to the street where the sign on the 39 building is parallel. So you don’t get quite the same 40 viewing from a building sign as you would a monument 41 sign. 42 Again, we felt like, you know, that was going to 43 be for people to see coming from a distance up the 44 road, that we’re there. The building sign is there to 45 identify us when you get there. But it wouldn’t look 46 right without -- you know, those channel letters on the 47 front, it’s nearing a hundred foot building and one of 48 the things, it doesn’t look very good without some 49 signage on it. It’s bigger than most buildings. And 50 that’s kind of the reason we also have a secondary sign Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 9 1 in most of our sign packages, is because the building 2 is so large. So there’s just a really large swath of 3 building with no signage on it, it doesn’t look good 4 either. It’s not appealing. 5 MIKE MILLER: So normally -- 6 has anyone else on the board got any questions? 7 Normally the chair does not make motions or do it or 8 get into that. But if I made a motion then it would be 9 to remove the Pennzoil sign on the front and looking at 10 giving you the Jiffy Lube multicare to the rear. That 11 would be the way that I would look at it. And then I 12 would put that in the form of a motion. But at that 13 point in time I don’t know if I can get a second. 14 HUBERT MCCLURE: I’ll second 15 that. 16 MIKE MILLER: So I’ve got a 17 second from Hubert and Mr. Cirelli. So I could use 18 either one of them. So I’ve got a second. So what is 19 the pleasure of the board? I’ve made the motion; I got 20 a second, and that is doing away with Pennzoil on the 21 front and giving him the Jiffy Lube multicare on the 22 rear, and that’s giving you a rear sign. And like I 23 asked a while ago, I said most everybody coming to you 24 know that you’re Pennzoil. And I’m trying to take out 25 some of this on the front. Will that work? 26 CHAD WEISBECK: I wouldn’t say 27 that most people know, if I stated that. And I don’t 28 know that it makes any difference to you. It is the 29 identifier as a national --- 30 MIKE MILLER: That’s the 31 only way that I would do this. If not -- if I’ve got 32 to go back and do it as a package, then I’m going to 33 make a motion to deny. 34 CHAD WEISBECK: I mean, to be 35 clear, the more important of the two signs is the one 36 on the rear. 37 MIKE MILLER: Okay. That’s 38 what I thought. So I’ve got a motion and a second. 39 What is the pleasure of the board? All in favor raise 40 your right hand. So I’ve got one, two, three, four -- 41 Hubert’s five, so I’ve got five out of, what, seven? 42 So we’ve got two voted no? 43 DEBBIE CHAPMAN: I voted for. 44 I don’t know who else did for. 45 MIKE MILLER: So you voted 46 for, Tony voted for, Mr. Farr? He didn’t vote, I 47 voted. 48 BRAD SWILLING: I voted. 49 MIKE MILLER: So I got six. 50 ALESIA HUNTER: And one Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 10 1 abstained. 2 MIKE MILLER: One abstained. 3 So that --- 4 JOHN FARR: I’ve still 5 got a question. Not knowing the brand qualifications, 6 does it hurt his business if he does not have the 7 Pennzoil sign up there? In other words, you say 8 everybody knows it’s Pennzoil. If I was to drive up 9 there, I don’t know what the hell he’s selling. Okay? 10 So it wouldn’t make any difference to me whether it was 11 Havoline or Texaco or whatever it was; I don’t know. 12 So I would not know it was Pennzoil. 13 RUSSELL BARTON: Is there a 14 requirement from Pennzoil for you to advertise for 15 them? 16 CHAD WEISBECK: Well, they 17 require that we try to put it on the building when 18 allowed. But it’s not a hard, it’s not a hard 19 requirement for me to have to put it. We think there’s 20 value in it. We spend the money to have the signage 21 put up there for that reason. We like our customers to 22 know we’re not just pumping -- if you’re a consumer, 23 you like to know that they’re putting something that’s 24 reasonably good and not some recycled product from who 25 knows where. So that is why we do it. 26 MIKE MILLER: So everybody 27 is good the way we voted? 28 RUSSELL BARTON: I’m good. 29 JOHN FARR: Do what? 30 MIKE MILLER: I asked was 31 everyone good with the way we voted? 32 JOHN FARR: I’m not, no. 33 MIKE MILLER: So it stands 34 the way we voted. You’ll just have to remove your 35 Pennzoil. I’m sorry, but, you know, I’m just trying to 36 help you some, but ... 37 CHAD WEISBECK: Okay. Thank 38 you. 39 MIKE MILLER: Thank you. 40 Are there anymore old business from staff. 41 Are there any more new business? 42 Our other business is the election of officers. 43 And that will be the chair and vice chair. We will be 44 taking nominations from the floor. I will nominate 45 Hubert McClure as chair. We’ve got a second. We are 46 taking nominations for vice chair. 47 ALESIA HUNTER: Mr. Chair, you 48 need to vote. 49 MIKE MILLER: Oh, all in 50 favor raise your right hand for Hubert. All opposed Anderson County - Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals - January 11, 2024 11 1 like sign. 2 I will be taking nominations for vice chair. 3 RUSSELL BARTON: I make a 4 nomination for Mike Miller, vice chair. 5 MIKE MILLER: Do we have a 6 second? 7 DEBBIE CHAPMAN: Second. 8 MIKE MILLER: I have a 9 second. All in favor, raise your right hand. 10 So both of them are approved. 11 I have a motion to adjourn. 12 RUSSELL BARTON: Second. 13 DEBBIE CHAPMAN: Third. 14 MIKE MILLER: Third, 15 fourth. All in favor raise your right hand. 16 17 MEETING ADJOURNED AT APPROXIMATELY 5:38 P.M. Staff Report Application for a Variance – To allow additional wall sign Anderson County Board of Zoning Appeals- District 6 Historic Courthouse- 101 South Main Street- 2nd Floor County Council Chambers Anderson, South Carolina February 8, 2024 5:15 P.M. Applicant: Chris Berning Owner: Paul Marshall Property Location: 108 Woodson St. Greenville, SC 29611 Council District: Six (6) Tax Map Number: 236-00-14-019 Acreage of Property: .08 Current Zoning: Un-Zoned Land Use: Commercial Surrounding Zoning Districts: Un-Zoned Applicant Request: Applicant is requesting a variance to allow one (1) additional wall signs. Findings of Fact: Under Chapter 24 of the Anderson County Code, Section 24-245 (Permitted Signs), specifically wall signs: Number of signs. Only one projecting sign as defined in section 24-24 is allowed p er building frontage, except for shopping centers, which may have one projecting sign for each business use, plus one aggregate freestanding business identification sign for the shopping center as prescribed in subsection (1)b of this section. Staff Recommendation: 1. The signage allowed by ordinance will provide adequate visibility for all motorists traveling Woodson St. as that is the only road frontage to access the property. 2. Signage is not needed on rear due to property being incorporated into an existing commercial development (Woodson Exchange) in which there is no access to the property which is in question. 3. Surrounding properties that were referenced in supporting letters provided at the time of submittal, one of which has a sign that is not permitted (Edward Jones); the other was approved a variance with conditions (Silver Salon, chose to have two wall signs instead of a freestanding). 4. Applications have been denied previously based on similar variance. 5. No physical hardships were presented in order to approve requested variance. 6. The request is not compatible with the spirit and intent of the ordinance. Staff Report Application for a Variance – To allow additional wall sign Anderson County Board of Zoning Appeals- District 6 Historic Courthouse- 101 South Main Street- 2nd Floor County Council Chambers Anderson, South Carolina March 14, 2024 5:15 P.M. Applicant: Kylie Fain, Hilton Displays Owner: Hwy. 86 SBUX LLC- Matt McCord Property Location: 1913 Hwy. 86 Piedmont, SC 29673 Council District: Six (6) Tax Map Number: 216-00-13-002 Acreage of Property: 1.1 Current Zoning: Un-Zoned Land Use: Commercial Surrounding Zoning Districts: Un-Zoned Applicant Request: Applicant is requesting a variance to allow one (1) additional wall sign. Findings of Fact: Under Chapter 24 of the Anderson County Code, Section 24-245 (Permitted Signs), specifically wall signs: Number of signs. Only one projecting sign as defined in section 24-24 is allowed per building frontage, except for shopping centers, which may have one projecting sign for each business use, plus one aggregate freestanding business identification sign for the shopping center as prescribed in subsection (1)b of this section. Staff Recommendation: 1. Th e signage allowed by ordinance will provide adequate visibility for all motorists traveling both Hwy. 86 & Shiloh Rd. 2. The freestanding signage will serve as way of wayfinding for travelers exiting from I-85. 3. No physical hardships were presented in order to approve requested variance. 4. The request is not compatible with the spirit and intent of the ordinance. Jeffrey D. Vaughn 933 Hunters Trail, Anderson, SC A pplication for a Special Exception Anderson County Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting County Council Chambers 2nd Floor-Historic Courthouse (DISTRICT #5) Anderson, South Carolina March 14, 2024 5:15 PM Staff Report Application for a Special Exception – To allow the use of a single-family residence as a short-term rental in R- 20 Zoning. Applicant: Jeffrey D. Vaughn Owner of Property: Same as above Property Location: 933 Hunter’s Trail., Anderson, SC 29625 Council District: Five (5) Tax Map Number (TMS #): 67-00-02-057 Property Description: LT 4 HUNTERS TRL .58AC Current Zoning: R-20 Land Use: Residential Applicant Request: Applicant is requesting a Special Exception to allow the use of residence as a short- term/rental home. Findings of Fact: Anderson County Code of Ordinances, Under Chapter 70, Section 7:17, establishments are permitted uses by special exception – Bed and breakfast, homestays, host homes and guest homes………... Staff Recommendation: 1) T he use meets all of the requirements in Section 5:7.2. Uses permitted by special exception. 2) The residence meets all of the requirements for R-20 Zoning. 3) No restrictions or covenants are recorded or filed with the Register of Deeds. 4) The 1,500 sq. ft distance requirement between bed and breakfasts has been met. 5) The use is not detrimental to public health or general welfare. 6) The use will not violate neighborhood character nor adversely affect surrounding properties. 7) Applicant must meet all tax, fire and building code requirements, pertaining to the residential structure and obtain all necessary permits from Building and Codes and compliances from Development Standards 8) The Board’s granting of the approval for this Special Exception is in keeping with similar requests previously granted for zoned areas. Brian & Rebecca Gruber 1408 Cherokee Rd, Townville, SC A pplication for a Special Exception Anderson County Land Use Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting County Council Chambers 2nd Floor-Historic Courthouse (DISTRICT #4) Anderson, South Carolina March 14, 2024 5:15 PM Staff Report Application for a Special Exception – To allow the use of a single-family residence as a short-term rental in R- 20 Zoning. Applicant: Brian & Rebecca Gruber Owner of Property: Same as above Property Location: 1408 Cherokee Rd. Council District: Four (4) Tax Map Number (TMS #): 17-06-01-033 Property Description: LT 32 CHEROKEE RD 3.90 AC Current Zoning: R-20 Land Use: Residential Applicant Request: Applicant is requesting a Special Exception to allow the use of residence as a short- term/rental home. Findings of Fact: Anderson County Code of Ordinances, Under Chapter 70, Section 7:17, establishments are permitted uses by special exception – Bed and breakfast, homestays, host homes and guest homes………... Staff Recommendation: 1) T he residence meets all of the requirements for R-20 Zoning. 2) No signage is allowed in R-20 Zoning. 3) Restrictions are recorded in the deed and filed with the Register of Deeds. 4) The use is not detrimental to public health or general welfare. 5) If approved, Applicant must meet all tax, fire and building code requirements, pertaining to the residential structure and obtain all necessary permits from Building and Codes and compliances from Development Standards 6) The Board’s granting of the approval for this Special Exception is in keeping with similar requests previously granted for zoned areas.

Source: Anderson County website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.