Feb 19.26 New Minutes
Chester County · Chester County · meeting of Mar 27, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Chester County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Chester County Fire Service Board
624 Wilson Street Chester SC, 29706
Meeting Address | 988 McCandless Road
February 19, 2026, | 6:05pm
Minutes
Attendees: Kim Grafton 1 Sara Lee 3, Darius Murphy 4, Robert Abell 6, Ed Darby 7, Mike
Ehrmanntraut 8, Brian Beer 9,
Call to order: Fire Director McNeil called the meeting to order at 6:07pm.
Invocation: Brian Beer said the prayer.
Citizens Comments: None
Approval of Minutes: Fire Director McNeil gave the Chiefs a moment to look over the
minutes of the February 5, 2026 meeting.
Motion to approve with change in Board Comments from” by Scout Motors” to” for Scout
Motors” by Chief Ehrmanntraut. 2nd By Ed Darby.
Discussion: None
The motion passed unanimously
Old Business
1. Medical Helicopter and Privately Owned Vehicle SOGs:
Medical Helicopter SOGs:
Discussion: None
Motion was made to accept by Chief Beer seconded by Chief Ehrmantraut
Discussion: None
Motion passed unanimously.
Privately Owned Vehicles SOG:
Motion was made to accept the POV, SOG 1-9 with changes by Chief
Ehrmantraut second by Chief Murphy
Discussion: Chief Ehrmantraut asked did this come from the county
attorney or is this based on other SOG’s that are out there?
Chester County Fire Service Board
Director McNeil stated This did not come from the county
attorney. This was from the local and state laws not just other SOG’s
Chief Ehrmantraut stated, starting with 1.4 there’s nothing in
the law that states that lighting has to be permanently bound to the vehicle. The law
just states you have to have visibility in all directions. Change 1.4 from
“permanently mounted” to “visible in all directions”
Chief Beer asked was 1.4 necessary because 1.2 was already referring to 56-
5-4700 or do you want to state what that code says?
Brandon Edwards stated 1.4, then strike the first sentence and state” All
vehicles shall be inspected by the Chief of the department to ensure all said
equipment is in accordance with state law.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated” Section 1.5 members shall produce a signed
letter on a company letterhead stating that their insurance carriers is aware of that
the vehicle at times responds as an emergency vehicle. He reached out to other
chiefs notably York county, and asked them what they require. They require EVDt for
everybody coming off of probation and lights that are visible from all four sides. And
the county pulls the MVR every 10yrs. He also stated that’s a personal vehicle, and
its up to them to make sure that they maintain responsibility. “ I don’t really see the
value in me reaching out to my insurance carrier and hoping they would actually
write a letter, because its some service center in a foreign country and spend the
half hour to seven hours hunting down someone who understands what Im asking
and I get a letter. I don’t think in the time we have in this challenging time to
maintain, retain and recruit volunteer firefighters, I don’t see the value in making
them jump through hoops to try to have a light on their vehicle. More to add to that
later with some of the other ones, but I don't see the value in that. I see I can
understand provided proof of insurance if we want to go that when the chief
inspects the vehicle, you see your proof of insurance with your insurance card that
a police officer would would ask for. But even, even that's a police officers and then
asked for a signed letter from an insurance carrier, if, if someone was, let's just say
someone was using their lights, not going to call me, got pulled over by a police
officer, and they said, Yeah, I'm a volunteer firefighter in Chester County. Well, the
law states that they can use elect in responding to an emergency, and if they're not,
they can certainly say, oh, I need to see a driver's license or registration proof of
insurance. But there's nothing notifying the insurance company that that this is
something that they allow if it's something that they screw up and their insurance
company doesn't cover them. And I understand we might be looking at, well, then
Chester County Fire Service Board
they might go after the Kell but I don't think this is a road that we
should travel down. In my opinion.
Director McNeil asked was there any more discussion on what
Chief Ehrmantraut said about 1.5.
Director Benson stated that was a topic of discussion, and that and that
being a one, a liability issue, and two, being a more of a hot topic that's coming up
more and more. So we figured that if he's gonna bring it to our attention to say, hey,
our insurance guys just making because he stated that they're seeing claims where
departments that don't have extra coverage that they got Somebody gets into a red I
think one of the key points for us to bring awareness is, is if somebody gets into a
wreck responding to a call as a volunteer, this is one thought process on one, I'm
thankful for that. Two, that's the only Well, that's risk that they are making that like
you pointed out, is that they're taking their livelihood and wrecking their one vehicle
that my whole family lies on, and then insurance don't pay for it because they're
like, We didn't know you weren't that's basically what he's saying. Is when the
insurance, because they're going to ask questions, you know, when they said, Oh,
you you were responding with merch, lights and sirens, we didn't know that, denied,
and he said they're seeing an uptick in that.
Chief Ehrmantraut asked So is he offering a an extended coverage under
VFIS that would cover that? Is that what he's referring
Director Benson No, he wasn't offering an extended coverage.I know our policy right now.
We cover, you know, if you're responding to a call and all that, it's just flat tire, deer, all
that, we need to probably look in the final print in there to see if there's something that
we're missing.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated And well, and part of that is so let's say, and, I mean, there's
hundreds of different insurance companies out there. Let's say I call my insurance
company and say, Hey, I use my vehicle as an emergency vehicle.
Chief Beer said drive it to the station and get into apparatus and take it that way.
Director McNeil stated I think it's protecting everyone from from that, from a liable
standpoint, because if you're driving, if you're going to the station, like so I took IOW at
Hilltop in Spartanburg, their volunteers, they respond to the station, and then they get on
the truck there. That's how they run it in. In that area, Kershaw County requires a letter it
so, so trying to make it the best for all of us, right? And I think, I think we get to a point, you
Chester County Fire Service Board
know, we need to require EVDT all the way around and drive a training
and release from the Chiefs us that you're, I don't, you're not going to
get a letter from your insurance company. I don't believe at all. But
does that help you? Also, if you were to get in an accident, you know, does it? Does it?
Does it help you? If you run a Lights and Sirens, mess around and hit somebody and and it
happens then when you get on scene, if you run a Lights and Sirens and get on scene with
just yourself, and it's a fire, which we what we look for ISO, we're looking for a fire, and
what are we going to be able to do? Do a 360 and then wait on a fire truck or maybe cut a
gas off maybe, you know, some utilities. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but I have, I had
lights, and I love my lights and all that. I'm just saying, but when we look at the bigger
picture of it, is it more beneficial for us running lights and sirens to calls, or more beneficial
for us to run lights and sirens, or run our cars to our stations, which we supposed to be
within those parameters of our station, to get there, to be able to get the truck and get it
around. So that's, that's what. That's another way I was looking at it as well. So it's a tough
topic.
Chief Mike Ehrmantraut stated And again, I don't, it wouldn't be an issue for me, but I'm
more thinking about for the people who are either living a little farther away from the fire
station, or, you know, the situations where they're, do they drive past the fire to get in the
fire station, or do they stop at the fire. Since you started getting a little into 1.6 I understand
that when we talk about beneficial, the emergency response, if a member is not beneficial,
regardless of their certification, they really don't need to be a member. I would prefer to say
that every volunteer is beneficial. I've got, and we don't have fire police in the sense of
other states, but I've got one member who does want to take EVDT, but he is the perfect
traffic control person. He doesn't, he doesn't have firefighter one, he doesn't do anything
else, but he is a fantastic he knows how to direct traffic. He knows how to be a tanker
coordinator, as far as doing certain parts of incident command. And I can see that taking
unless I issue him a vehicle. I can see that taking him out of Well, I have nothing left to do if
I'm not considered beneficial. We've got other members who will do our rehab. They will do
our you know, at a fire scene, they will do things that are certainly outside fire level three
stuff, but they're still essential. I still need someone out ladder building, and I still need
someone to get air packs and fill bottles. So to start getting into the well, you're a firefighter
one, so you're essential, but you're a level three and you're not essential. I think if we start
down that road, it kind of goes back to what we're saying that we're really going to want to
make this differentiation between, well, these are paid career firefighters, and these are
our good volunteers, and here are bad volunteers. I don't I think that's a slippery slope.
Start going down to separate people into you're not beneficial and you are beneficial.
Chester County Fire Service Board
Director McNeil stated Yeah, I agree with that, but I just, I think that's
the part of the training piece that we have to work towards. But we did
look at the fire that firefighter 1 me. We made a change at the office
and put 1152 from a basic level. The other thing to kind of go back to your point of certain
people being able to get to in direct traffic, they still able to get there when they get there.
But you know, even if they don't have lights and sirens and on the back end of it is they
doing rehab, they can get there when they get there, and they shouldn't be able to get that
set up, or that sort of I think, I think it all works together. I just think, let's, let's figure out
what the best answer is.
Chief Beer stated a statement like that is going to bleed over from the person that wants
red lights on their vehicle, to the person that doesn't have any, and they're still going to see
that. And I know this is trying. This is addressing that vehicle that the person wants to have
red lights and a siren. POV, and I mean, there's what's not in here is addressing the POV
response from that vehicle that does not have any of that stuff on it, and how that, how that
should be, how they should act when they're doing that. And that's just you drive like
everybody else on the road, nothing special. And I didn't notice that in there. And I think
that's we got to differentiate between those two things, because it could be some person
could look at this and say, Well, if I don't have lights, they don't want me to go in my POV,
and we want to make sure that. I want to make sure that's not It's not interpreted that way.
Yeah, I know what you're trying to do, but somebody else might look at it as saying, Well, I
can't go.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated And I think tied to that is the stationary aspect. So in that
example, someone's moving traffic, and they're down an intersection, and they're in their
personal vehicle, and this particular person has a white bar and 1000 lights in their vehicle.
It they use that as a traffic vehicle stationary. So do we have someone who says, Well, you
can't use your lights responding to the call, but you can use lights stationary at a call. And
it's the same with people who park, you know, let's say you're at a motor vehicle accident,
or you're at a structure fire, and you park your vehicle on the street and there's no place to
really pull into a field or someone's driveway. Do I leave my vehicle out with no protection?
Just use my hazard lights, or do I have some type of protection for my vehicle to get people
to slow down, hopefully not hit it. So whether that that be a subsection of it and allowed or
so, I mean, I lived in states where state law banned any volunteer from having flight, yeah.
The state was very tiny, so the commute to the fire station was micro, micro, micro, but a
lot of volunteers had lights just on their back deck. It was perfectly legal to have. I had in my
Chester County Fire Service Board
suburban I had strobe lights and tail lights and backup lights. And
when I would go to scene, I always knew that nobody was gonna hit
the back of my truck, so that's a potential.
Director McNeil asked was there any more discussion on that.
Chief Darius murphy stated to I see both sides of that about getting a letter from the
insurance.
Has anybody heard of any part of other state where somebody going to insurance company
and say, Hey, I'm using my car red lights? And they said, No, we're dropping you.
Chief Ehrmantraut said So my company car for my company, which happens to be an
insurance company, I am prohibited by company policy from using my company vehicle to
respond to any volunteer emergency call, fire call, EMS, search, rescue. So it's not
necessarily a letter saying, you know, as a policy holder, but it's, it's a policy of our
company, but they also won't let me do door dash in my company vehicle.
Director McNeil asked what solution they had for 1.5?
Chief Ehrmantraut stated I personally would like to strike it.
Chief Murphy said have something, there's an accounting will not be liable.
Chief Beer stated There's a point that I hadn't even thought about on this, but the chief
signs off of it. The director signs off on it. Well, buddy, is the county on the hook? I'm
asking, I don't know, because responding to a call, yes. I mean, I'm thinking that we're let
us continue with the discussion, but I honestly think when we get through with the
discussion, we're gonna need to table this and have to find out some other stuff. Yeah, it's
a pretty deal. This is, this is this is it needs to be spelled out. This is probably one of the
more contentious ones we're gonna talk about so but I think, I think if the county is on the
hook, what is the county going to do? I'm asking not telling I don't know.
Director McNeil stated if the county is going to be liable, then we have to make a decision.
We are going to take it out.
Chief Beer stated If that's maybe that's where we end up, yep. But I mean, if that's where
we need to end up, then that's what you're going to get when
Chester County Fire Service Board
Chief Abel stated hadn't said anything but if the county is gonna be
liable, and you know, you got these some call kids now they're
not gonna get a letter. It's not gonna happen, because either they're
not gonna be doing the insurance, not gonna do it. If they do, they gonna cancel. I just don't
see us. I don't see that having any teeth, you have to keep guys on fireball more or less,
because they're not going bring you a letter.
Director Benson stated TJ Martin made him think about he said, the word kid. And I think
that was another reason, one that's one thing, but actually circumvent back to the letter
from the insurance company, even if we didn't do that, it's proof of insurance. But because
my daughter decides she wants to get on the fire department and her car is in my
insurance, and then they go get so they're running on likes the sirens, or whatever the
parents didn't like what that's that just in lies another just left hand, turn right. Chief
Ehrmantraut, That's, I think that's one of the biggest things. I think maybe the insurance
company would work with you on. I'm the same way. I don't run like I've never run lights
and sirens, but I've always had some kind of light for when I do get on the scene.
Director McNeil stated I agree. I'll use, I'll use this example. What if you coming from the
Baron, you know, they do the barbecue every year and you get a call in Lewis, and it's a
power line, should you be running, like, since I already or if you get a call and you are in
York County, or you're in Lancaster County, and we running code back into Chester. So
those are the things that I think we all have to really consider and take into consideration.
Chief Darby stated Yeah, I think, I think you're right. I think we get around it. I think, I think
you're right. I think we're getting around to the real nut of the deal is, you know, do we need,
do you need that? You know? I mean, hey, if one of my kids is in a wreck or my house is on
fire, I'm gonna get that. Y'all better get away. I get that normal, you know, it really causes
more issues, because people think they can certain, you know, in their mind, they think
they can circumvent their life. And really what we're saying, is you gotta follow the law,
yeah, even though you run it, but they that's a power trip when you got that light on. And
then every station presents such a different, unique situation. You know, Richburg has
their own Lando, and then you go up here, where we're at, yes, you might run a call and see
three cars.
Chief Beer asked B. Edwards if he was still and Lebanon and what is Fairfield County’s
doing.
Chester County Fire Service Board
B. Edwards stated they're allowed. Now, but I'm gonna tell you, there's
not very many. There's a couple here and there. There's still gung ho
running that I stopped because of, because of the liability. And not
only that, it's my personal truck. If I tear it up, Fairfield ain't picking up my dime I mean, I
couldn't tell you.
Chief Beer said put it in there, it don’t cost a dime to put 1.7 in.
Chief Ehrmantraut said we need to compromise, if we are going this direction, I think that
having allowing lights that are rear facing or when the vehicle is stationary, a nice
compromise that would solve some of the issues that I can see.
B. Edwards stated where would you put that in and how would you phrase it?
Chief Ehrmantraut stated, Well, you'd have to start by. You would have to start by
eliminating 1.1, because a POV in South Carolina, it can be is considered emergency
vehicle, as long as you are in accordance to 56-5-7. So if we're saying no, we don't want for
we don't want you to use forward facing lights or lights when responding to an emergency,
but we allow them, then we have to reword, starting from the beginning and not have 1.1
Director Benson stated We’re not allowing you to respond with lights and sirens but we
would need to create an entirely policy for POV lighting on the scene and in PARK.
Chief Beer asked does the Chief have to sign off on POV and if that would make him liable.
Director Benson stated he doesn’t have to do that, as the Chief he can just state that
Chief Beer said there was something in the old SOG’s that said we had to check POV’s off
but I never did.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated if this is truly a concern then, I would recommend rewriting the
whole thing.
B. Edwards stated could we just not allow POV’s to respond lights and sirens. However
once on scene. Use your lights to protect yourself.
Chester County Fire Service Board
Chief Beer ask what would VFIS do if someone was responding to the
station and something happened.
D. Trowell stated the everybody seems to agree that you can’t run lights and sirens to the
scene but once on scene you can use additional lights for identification. So the county can
state no response in POV running lights and sirens but once on scene, you can use them
for identification purposes and be done.
Chief Beer stated that seems to be the temperature.
Director McNeil stated there is a motion on the floor by Chief Ehrmantraut and second by
Robert Abel to table this discussion until we bring back the revised copy of private own
vehicle operations response 1.9
Director McNeil stated he received a few of the Emergency Contact List from Station 9,
Station 8, and Station 3, they are due today. Then turned the floor over to B. Edwards for
NERIS training.
B. Edwards explained how to do a structure fire report.
Chief Ehrmantraut mentioned that the narratives are available sometimes and at others its
not. Asked is that something that needs to be done at 911 to make that come through.
Director Benson, stated that was a known ESO glitch.
Chief Abel stated it does not like Apple pictures.
B. Edwards said that he knows a work around
Director McNeil stated that we have a quote on a door prop and a fire extinguisher solution
prop, ill let Trowell discuss that.
D. Trowell stated the that he thought that these props would be great to have in the county
for training and would like for us to consider those as a purchase.
Director McNeil ask they still would like to put in their own Capitol Items or do it as a
county.
Chester County Fire Service Board
Chief Ehrmantraut stated those props are great. The LION prop was at
NFPA last year and it worked really nicely.
D. Trowell stated they can be used to set scenarios.
Chief Beer asked if the question that was just asked is, do we have other things that we
would like to request on capital items. Is this a one way or the other thing. This concept is
100% needs to be pursued. But other departments would have some items they would like
that would fall under capital items that might need to be thrown out there as well.
Director McNeil stated that we really don’t have budget for equipment. We just pay for it
out of operation budget.
Chief Beer asked about the threshold, what needs to be capital or what needs to be regular
equipment.
Chief Ed Darby asked how they are expected to do the things they need done around the
station with what they have. He also asked about brush trucks because they have constant
problem with theirs.
Director McNeil stated that Kell and himself are trying to put something in place to take
care of those needs.
Chief Darby stated that they would be busted if chester paid the utility bills because they
don’t have a tax district like other departments do.
Director McNeil stated that they have a commitment to each department to try and get
those things that are essential to operations.
Chief Darby stated like the forestry grant, if we don’t have money to match then we cant get
anything and wanted to know what is the answer for that. How do we operate with no
money.
Director Benson stated that he appreciated everybody that was there as the board. Some
chiefs have expressed concerns about forums and attendance. That’s something that we
need to address at the next meeting. Our biggest focus outside of manpower is facilities
and apparatus.
Chester County Fire Service Board
Chief Darby stated that North Chester station was built in 1958 with
one bay and donated and was the first volunteer station here. Then
added on three bays. They had to do fund raisers and do things
themselves. We cant keep up with no money.
Director Benson stated that is why we are trying to take oof some of the weight by taking on
the utilities.
Chief Beer stated he agree that takes a lot off the departments but now we don’t have that
money, what do we do now.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated he thinks everyone needs to look at a tax district.
Chief Darby stated we cant survive be independent departments.
Director Benson stated, what he is hearing is that you as a board wants to put together
something to present to the council a tax district or fire tax. A county wide fire tax.
Chief Darby stated we are not saying that but the six departments need to be brought
together or something.
Chief Beer stated those department if not consolidated, should have a consolidated board.
Director McNeil stated, if that’s an option, everybody putting in their own board, why
wouldn’t it be a better deal for a countywide fire tax.
Chief Beer asked if we decided to go and ask for a tax district, is it best to go all at once or
one at a time.
Director Benson said all at once, if that’s the route you want to take.
Director McNeil stated that even if it’s a countywide tax district, all the money still comes
from one pot and it is just distributed to each department. We are behind the eight ball with
the way the volunteers and paid positions are going. This is eventually going to come,
countywide fire. Maybe not in my lifetime but eventually.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated that once you set the millage rate it cant be changed so you have
to take in consideration the county and what’s in each district.
Chester County Fire Service Board
Director McNeil stated we still have a few more budgets that haven’t
been turned in. So is there anything we need to add, so we can finalize
so we will know what to go to Mr. Hester about.
Assistant Chief Lee stated that Great Falls need water rescue items and Rossville. They
have things they had put together.
Chief Darby stated things are changing in the county and for every effect. Maybe Duke can
give some equipment. Its going to be a headache down there at the park.
Director McNeil stated that we will look at incentives and POV SOG’s at the next meeting.
Station 1, Chief Grafton, everything is good
Station 3, everything is good, Assistant Chief Lee
Station 4,
Station 6, waiting on delivery, they will pay for the delivery
Station 7, no comment
Station 8, need to have a discussion about response during the construction on 901
Director Benson stated if there needs to be a temporary response plan put together, that
can happen.
Station 9, stated 911 was very cooperative when the bridge was out. When you asked to
send Great Falls to that call they were responsive. That was our experience. The accident
we had on 77 last week was a very good call and they appreciated the help from Richburg,
Chief Beer stated.
D.Trowell talked about the individual and department SOP and it will be something we can
discuss at the next meeting. He asked Chief Able how many times do they train per month
and Chief stated about 4 times a month for about 2 hours. D. Trowell stated that in order to
meet ISO all firefighters need to have at least 16 hours per month. At the rate that we are
going, we wont have any firefighters. This new training, the elearning, digital training will
help us meet that number. It is not a supplement but in addition too. We need everybody to
Chester County Fire Service Board
signup with their emails in order for this to work. He asked those that
received the training how they liked it.
Chief Ehrmantraut stated he enjoyed it.
D. Trowell stated this is cost effective and we can track everybody, personally and
department wise. We are going away from the point system. We are not trying to reward
people for the amount of calls. Lets concentrate on training and this helps the
departments. Switch all your older or less experience folks over to support, that doesn’t
count against ISO, it can help.
Chief Darby stated that the point system was started by him because you couldn’t get
people to do anything. The county adopted it and it started to give people a few dollars. I
like the idea of online training.
D. Trowell stated the first countywide required trainings will be in March, 2 at Richburg and
2 and CCFS office. Three of the trainings will be at night and the Saturday training we are
considering early morning. If you miss it then you’re responsible for getting it outside of the
fire service on your own.
Director Benson stated the dates for the Bloodbourn training is March 23 and 26 at
Richburg and March 17 and 21 at CCFS office. We will be sending flyers out. Thank you’ll
for the work during the ice and snow.
Chief Darby stated they ran 4 lines as a phone bank in case 911 got overwhelmed.
Director Benson, stated they had plans to activate the new radio template on March 2 at
2pm. Ops 1-6 Tach 1and 2 will be monitored by dispatch. 1 direct line of sight channel, not
monitored. 1 training channel as always.
Director McNeil adjourned with a motion from Chief Darby and Second by Chief
Ehrmatraut at 8:29
Source: Chester County website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.