RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals — Agenda Packet

Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Sep 28, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Monday, September 28, 2026, 2:30 PM 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304. 1. Call to Order 2. Welcome and Introduction to Board Procedures 3. Adoption of the Agenda 4. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of June 22, 2026 5. Unfinished Business 6. New Business a. Public Hearing VAR-000863-2026 - Request from John B. Paysinger, III for a variance from LMO Section 16-6-104.F.2, Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation: General Requirements, to remove a specimen tree that is located on a single- family lot. The property is located at 1 Arthur Hills Court, with a parcel number of R520 016 00B 0089 0000. b. Nomination and Election of Officers - July 1, 2026 - June 30, 2027 7. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items 8. Staff Reports 9. Adjournment FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island. Page 1 of 30 In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge: “I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the betterment of my city or town.” Page 2 of 30 Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Minutes 6/22/2026 Page | 1 Town of Hilton Head Island BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING Monday, June 22, 2026, 2:30 PM Minutes 1. Call to Order Vice Chair Bayless called the meeting to order at 2:30 p.m. In attendance were: Vice-Chair Bayless, Jeffery Greene, Peter Kristian, Michael Sackheim and Amy Fee. Absent were: Chairman Fingerhut and Dale Strecker. 2. Welcome and Introduction to Board Procedures Vice Chair Bayless welcomed all in attendance and introduced the Board's procedures for conducting the meeting. 3. Adoption of the Agenda Mr. Kristian moved to approve the agenda as presented. Mr. Sackheim seconded. The motion passed unanimously. 4. Approval of the Minutes a. Regular Meeting Minutes of April 27, 2026 Mr. Greene moved to approve the minutes of April 27, 2026. Mr. Kristian seconded. The motion passed unanimously. 5. Unfinished Business a. Public Hearing VAR-000251-2026 - Request from Daniel Kirchberg, owner of 14 Pelican Street, also identified as Beaufort County Tax Map Parcel R550 015 00A 0467 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-6-104.F.2.a, General Requirements, to remove a specimen tree that is located on a single-family lot. Vice Chair Bayless advised the Board that they would pick up where we left off on this item from the April 27, 2026 meeting. All members of the Board were present for the last Hearing. Brian Eber, Principal Planner, advised the Town had received an Aborist Report from Mr. Richard V. McDevitt, Certified Aborist from Abor Nature as requested. Mr. Eber responded to several questions from the Board. Vice Chair Bayless then invited comments from the applicant, Daniel Kirchberg had nothing to add to Mr. Eber's comments. Following discussion, Mr. Greene moved to grant the applicant's request to remove the specimen tree. There being no second, the motion died for lack of a second. Mr. Kristian moved to deny the applicant's request due to the following: Findings of Fact Page 3 of 30 Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Minutes 6/22/2026 Page | 2 1. The subject property contains a specimen tree which the applicant states is approximately 36" in diameter. 2. The subject property is approximately 0.27 acres in size and contains 4 specimen live oaks and one significant 28" live oak tree. 3. The subject property is a single family residential lot, located at 14 Pelican Street, within the RSF-District and subject the Forest Beach Character Overlay (FB-NC- O.) The subject parcel borders single-family residential uses to the north and south while fronting Pelican Street. 4. The property owner requests a variance to allow removal of the 36" live oak tree located immediately adjacent to the rear of the house so a new swimming pool and pool deck can be constructed. 5. The Forest Beach Owners Association Inc. has approved the construction plans but has neither approved nor disapproved the removal of the 36" live oak tree. Instead, the Association relies solely upon the provisions of the Town of Hilton Head's Land Management Ordinance for the determination of removal of significant trees. 6. The risk associated with 36" live oak has been professionally evaluated. On March 19, 2026, Arborist Clay Jones, with Jones Brothers Tree Service, called Town staff member Brian Eber. The property owner had requested that Mr. Jones give his opinion of the tree and Mr. Jones stated that the tree was healthy. 7. A second opinion was obtained by the owner by Abor Nature. By letter of May 1, 2026, Mr. Richard V. McDevitt, Certified Aborist, opined that the tree presented a "moderate risk" with a "possible" likelihood of failure. A "moderate failure" means that the tree may be mitigated and/or retained and monitored. A "possible" likelihood of failure means that failure could occur but is unlikely during normal weather conditions. 8. The proposed accessory use of a 350 square foot swimming pool with a 417 square foot permeable paver deck is the sole reason for the proposed removal of the 36" live oak tree. 9. Both the property owner and the contractor for the owner have acknowledged that a smaller pool can be built upon the property at a different location. Conclusions of Law 1. The purpose of the Residential Single-Family (RSF-5) District is to primarily accommodate neighborhoods of single-family dwellings at densities ranging up to five units per acre. It is intended to discourage any use that would substantially interfere with the development of single-family dwellings or would be detrimental to the quiet residential nature of single-family neighborhoods. The district also accommodates agricultural uses and parks as permitted uses. 2. Section 16-6-104.F.2a of the Town's Land Management Ordinance (LMO) reads "No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with the paragraph below. In addition, all specimen trees shall have the following protections, whether located on public or private land." 3. A variance from this section of the LMO may be allowed in an individual case of Page 4 of 30 Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Minutes 6/22/2026 Page | 3 unnecessary hardship if the Board of Zoning Appeals determines that all the following four criteria are met. Those criteria are: a) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property. b) These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity, c) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict utilization of the property, d) The authorization of the variance will not be substantial detriment to adjacent property or the public good, and the character of the zoning district where the property is located will not be harmed by the granting of the variance. 4. Based upon the report of a Certified Arborist, the BZA concludes that the 36" live oak tree on this particular piece of property does not present an imminent danger requiring removal at this time. Furthermore, the tree does not "effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property." Both the owner and the contractor have acknowledged that there is an alternate location on the property on which a pool and deck can be constructed. 5. Therefore, the request for a variance is hereby denied. Mr. Sackheim seconded. The motion to deny the application passed with a vote of 4-1. Mr Greene was opposed. 6. New Business a. Public Hearing VAR-000528-2026 - Request from Judd Carstens, on behalf of MACH XVII, LLC, owners of 1010 William Hilton Parkway, also identified on Beaufort County Tax Map as parcel number R552 015 000 289A 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-4- 102.B.5.b., Use Specific Conditions, to allow an Outdoor Commercial Recreation Use Other Than a Water Park to not have the required direct vehicular access to a minor arterial street. Mr. Brian Eber presented the staff report, as included in the agenda packet, regarding a variance request submitted by Judd Carstens, on behalf of MACH XVII, LLC, owners of 1010 William Hilton Parkway, also identified on Beaufort County Tax Map as parcel number R552 015 000 289A 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-4-102.B.5.b., Use Specific Conditions, to allow an Outdoor Commercial Recreation Use Other than a Water Park to proceed without the required direct vehicular access to a minor arterial street. Staff recommends the Board of Zoning Appeals find the request to be consistent with the Town's Our Plan and serves to carry out the purposes of the LMO, based on those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law as determined by the LMO Official. Staff recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals approve the application, with the following conditions to mitigate the potential impacts on nearby residential uses: The outdoor use shall not be permitted between the hours of 10:01 pm and 6:59 am. 1. There shall not be any speakers or amplified music or sound outside of any enclosed building or directed from inside any enclosed building to the outside. Page 5 of 30 Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Minutes 6/22/2026 Page | 4 2. A landscaping plan must be approved by the Design Review Board (DRB) and must include additional landscaping and a sound dampening fence or wall generally along the Dunnagans Alley property line and/or the existing Santee Cooper powerline easement running parallel to Dunnagans Alley, at a minimum. 3. An exterior lighting plan showing all exterior buildings and site lighting must be approved by the DRB. Mr. Eber concluded his presentation and responded to questions from the Board concerning the impact of traffic on 278E and Dunnagans Alley, whether it is in the interest of Hilton Head to have an additional mini-golf course in the middle of the road, and concern about tree removal. Vice Chair Bayless then invited comments from the applicant. Mr. Judd Carstens on behalf of the applicant. Mr. Carstens stated within light commercial, you are allowed a lot of uses. Outdoor recreation just ends up having that extra level of scrutiny. What we are trying to do with our development here is to utilize the existing open lot, which was the old car wash, while trying to lightly impact the state of trees on the backside without the removal of any significant trees and, of course, providing sufficient parking per the LMO. The variance just sought in relief to the point regarding the minor arterial, the access to a light situation of roadways. The south end of 278 is a very active area. It is surrounded by light commercial properties, including the RV Resort which is designated light commercial. Mr. Carstens said he appreciates the conditions that staff has laid out. From a use standpoint, we find it appropriate being within this district surrounded by restaurants, accessible to both our residents and our guests. Mr. Carstens mentioned Alan Wolf of Serge Group is here, as well as Tim Probst of Architecture Group if you have any questions. Mr. Carstens answered several questions and concerns from the Board regarding whether adding another mini-golf course in that location and restaurant adds to the attractiveness of Hilton Head or does that make Hilton Head more like Myrtle Beach and making sure there is no removal of significant trees. After discussion, Mr. Kristian moved that based on the staff report and the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law that the Board of Zoning Appeals finds this consistent with the Town's Our Plan and serves to carry out the purpose of the LMO and recommends that the request for the variance should be approved based on the conditions listed above. Mr. Greene seconded. The motion to approve the application passed unanimously. 7. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items Chester Williams, Esquire introduced Ms. Lola Campbell to the Board. Ms. Campbell is a native Island Gullah, went to University of Georgia and Howard University Law School, has worked for Wells Fargo as a Senior Derivatives Counsel. Ms. Campbell is learning about zoning and land use laws and is a member of the Town's LMO Task Force. The Board welcomed Ms. Campbell. Page 6 of 30 Town of Hilton Head Island Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Minutes 6/22/2026 Page | 5 8. Staff Reports There were no staff reports. 9. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 3:24 pm Page 7 of 30 1 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 843-341-4757 FAX 843-842-8908 STAFF REPORT VARIANCE Case #: Public Hearing Date: VAR-000863-2026 September 28, 2026 Parcel or Location Data: Property Owner Applicant Address: 1 Arthur Hills Court Parcel#: R520 016 00B 0089 0000 Zoning: PD-1 John B. Paysinger III 1 Arthur Hills Court Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 John B. Paysinger III 1 Arthur Hills Court Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 Application Summary: Request from John B. Paysinger III, owner of 1 Arthur Hills Court, also identified as Beaufort County Tax Map Parcel R520 016 00B 0089 0000, for a variance from LMO Section 16-6- 104.F.2, Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation: General Requirements, to remove a specimen tree that is located on a single-family lot. Background: The subject property is a developed single-family residential lot and is located at 1 Arthur Hills Court. The property is located within the Palmetto Dunes PD-1 District within the Leamington Plantation community. The subject parcel borders the Arthur Hills Golf Course and single-family residential uses (See Exhibit B). The request for the variance is to allow removal of a 38-inch Loblolly Pine tree located adjacent to the main driveway at the front of the house to replace the driveway (See Exhibit D). According to the applicant’s narrative: • The tree is located within the landscaped area adjacent to their driveway • The driveway is concrete and original to the home constructed in 1995 Page 8 of 30 2 • The tree’s roots have uplifted the driveway concrete slabs and created possible tripping hazards for visitors and vendors, as well as an irregular driving surface • Removal of the tree is a condition for the Leamington ARB permit to replace the driveway • The Leamington ARB will require mitigation with a 60-gallon Live Oak to replace the pine tree. An ISA Certified Arborist report has been provided with a tree condition and impact analysis for the construction of a new driveway. The tree is healthy, but its location adjacent to the driveway will require removal of roots crucial to the long-term stabilization of the tree when the new driveway is constructed. The arborist recommends removal before the driveway is redone. Additionally, one of two osprey nests monitored on the golf course this year was in this tree. The homeowners contacted the Osprey Watch organization to review the requirements and honored the wait time required for osprey protection before applying for this variance. They have received approval from Osprey Watch as of August that site work could be conducted now that the birds have departed. The purpose of the Planned Development Mixed-Use District (PD-1) is to acknowledge the unique Planned Unit Developments on the Island that are greater than 250 acres in size. The intent of this district is to allow the continuation of well-planned development according to their Town- approved Master Plans. Section 16-6-104.F.2.a of the Town’s Land Management Ordinance, LMO, reads. “No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with paragraph below. In addition, all specimen trees shall have the following protections, whether located on public or private land.” Applicant’s Grounds for Variance, Summary of Facts: Grounds for Variance: • Per the application, the applicant is seeking a variance from LMO Section 16-6-104.F.2, Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation: General Requirements, to remove a specimen tree that is located on a single-family lot. Summary of Fact: • The applicant seeks a variance as set forth in LMO Section 16-6-104.F.2.a Summary of Facts: • Application was submitted on September 3, 2026, as set forth in LMO Section 16-2-102.C and Appendix D-23. • Notice of the Application was published in the Island Packet on September 11, 2026, as set forth in LMO Section 16-2-102.E.2. • Notice of the Application was posted on September 11, 2026, as set forth in LMO Section 16-2-102.E.2. Page 9 of 30 3 • Notice of Application was mailed on September 10, 2026, as set forth in LMO Section 16-2-102.E.2. • The Board has authority to render the decision reached here under LMO Section 16-2- 102.G. • The application is in compliance with the submittal requirements established in LMO Section 16-2-102.C. • The application and notice requirements comply with the legal requirements established in LMO Section 16-2-102.E.2. As provided in LMO Section 16-2-103.S.4, Variance Review Standards, a variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board determines and expresses in writing all of the following findings of fact. Summary of Facts: Criteria 1: There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property (LMO Section 16-2-103.S.4.a.i.01): Findings of Fact: • The subject property contains a specimen tree that the arborist report stated is approximately 38 inches in diameter. • The specimen tree’s roots have caused damage to the driveway: cracking and uplifting the concrete slabs as much as four inches in some locations. • Constructing a new driveway will require cutting into about half of the tree’s root plate and create a hazardous condition. • There is concern for the safety of visitors and vendors to the property who must traverse the damaged driveway to enter the property. Summary of Facts: Criteria 2: These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity (LMO Section 16-2-103.S.4.a.i.02): Findings of Fact: • The subject tree is within approximately one foot of the existing driveway. • The driveway is original to the home and has been damaged by tree roots. • The risk associated with the tree and a proposed new driveway presents a hazardous condition created by the tree impacted in the driveway construction process. • The risk associated with the tree has been professionally evaluated. • The Leamington ARB has requested the applicant obtain Town approval for removal before issuing a new driveway permit. Page 10 of 30 4 • The Leamington ARB will require mitigation with a 60-inch Live Oak. Summary of Facts: Criteria 3: Because of these conditions, the application of this Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property (LMO Section 16-2-103.S.4.a.i.03): Findings of Fact: • A new driveway needs to be constructed due to the possible hazardous conditions created from tree root impacts to the existing concrete slabs. • Constructing a new driveway within the current driveway footprint requires a permit from the Leamington ARB. • The Leamington ARB will not grant a permit without affirmative tree removal permissions from the Town. • The driveway cannot be fixed without impacting the tree roots. • Without a new driveway or removal of the tree causing the problem, possible hazardous conditions will continue. Summary of Facts: Criteria 4: The authorization of the Variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or the public good, and the character of the zoning district where the property is located will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance (LMO Section 16-2-103.S.4.a.i.04): Findings of Facts: • The proposed variance is limited in scope to the removal of a single 38-inch diameter specimen tree and does not involve broader site alterations or changes to the overall development pattern of the property. • The Leamington ARB will approve the new driveway and require mitigation if the Town approves the tree removal. • The required mitigation satisfies the Town’s mitigation requirements for removal of this tree. • The tree removal is supported by a certified arborist report. • The osprey nest will not be impacted since the birds have now left and the character of the neighborhood maintains a tree canopy that could support new nesting areas. • The removal of the subject tree will not materially alter the established character of the neighborhood, which is defined by a mix of mature vegetation, residential structures, and maintained landscaping. Page 11 of 30 5 LMO Official Determination: Based on the above Findings of Facts, it is staff’s recommendation that the Board considers the findings of facts and circumstances of this variance request and makes a decision that is believed to be the most fair and equitable decision for all parties involved in this matter. PREPARED BY: TSL 9/15/2026 Taylor Logan, Development Review Manager DATE REVIEWED BY: TL 09/21/2026 Trey Lowe, Interim Planning Director and LMO Official DATE ATTACHMENTS: A) Application Narrative B) Location Map C) Arborist Report D) Site Photos E) LMO Ordinance No. 2025-13 Page 12 of 30 10 September 2026 1 Arthur Hills Court Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 To: The Town of Hilton Head Island Subject: Paysinger V AR-000863-2026 Narrative This Variance is in request to remove a specimen pine tree located at the above address in Leamington Plantation, Palmetto Dunes. The tree is original to the lot, with the home built in 1995. It is adjacent to the driveway and basically in front of the entrance to the home. The driveway is original to the home and the roots of the tree have now forced the existing slabs of the concrete upward in multiple places. At one spot, the lifting of the slab is approximately 4 inches in height. The driveway has become a tripping hazard when walking, and also a severe jolt to cars passing over the lifting. Some of the blocks are breaking up, in addition to the lifting. We have been advised by several vendors to warn visitors and workers of the hazard before they enter the property. In addition, the past and current Presidents of the Leamington POA live on our street and have quietly advised us to take action to prevent further any further/future problems. An additional issue has been the Osprey nest that is located in the tree itself. It is one of two nests that are monitored on Authur Hills Golf Course. In planning for the replacement of the driveway, we contacted Jones Brothers Tree Surgeons to help evaluate the issue of the roots lifting the driveway slabs, and which tree may be the problem. Dylan Bakels, their arborist, has submitted his report for review. He was the one that informed us of the Variance requirement because the tree’s diameter exceeds the 35” limit – it is measured at 38”. In addition, he recommended that we contact the Osprey Watch organization to see what our options were. Joanne V oulelis was extremely helpful in her guidance and we elected to wait until the Osprey’s had left for the season. Our project started at the end of January, 2026, and Joanne gave us the go ahead for the Variance when the birds left the middle of August. The Leamington ARB will issue their permit for us to proceed when resolution of the Variance with the Town is finalized, assuming approval for the removal. Their additional requirement is that we plant a 60 gallon Live Oak to replace the pine tree. The driveway replacement will proceed after the tree removal. Thank you for your time and considerations. John B Paysinger III ATTACHMENT A Page 13 of 30 VAR-000863-2026 Location Map 1 Arthur Hills Court Subject Parcel 0 300 600150 ft ATTACHMENT B 1818 1515 3838 1212 5151 1111 3030 77 4444 2727 1717 1515 2424 99 4242 5252 2525 3434 1616 11 11 1212 55 2020 1313 77 1010 3636 2222 2828 5454 66 1414 2020 1313 4646 2233 1414 1010 4747 88 4848 99 1919 1111 44 5656 3232 99 55 88 2626 43u43u4545 66 5151 5151 5151 4949 33 18 15 38 12 51 11 30 7 44 27 17 15 24 9 42 52 25 34 16 1 1 12 5 20 13 7 10 36 22 28 54 6 14 20 13 46 23 14 10 47 8 48 9 19 11 4 56 32 9 5 8 26 43u45 6 51 51 51 49 3 Subject ParcelSubject ParcelSubject Parcel Page 14 of 30 ATTACHMENTC Page 15 of 30 ATTACHMENT D Driveway View 1.jpeg Driveway View 2.jpeg Page 16 of 30 View from Front Door Entry.jpeg , View from Street.jpeg Page 17 of 30 View of Front Door Entry.jpeg Page 18 of 30 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA ORDINANCE NO. 2025-13 AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TO AMEND CHAPTER 16 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE, THE LAND MANAGEMENT ORDINANCE, TO AMEND CURRENT REGULATIONS FOR TREE PROTECTION TO INCLUDE SECTIONS: 16-5-115, 16-6-104 AND APPENDIX C FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, has identified a continued need for the adoption ofLMO Amendments to address needs and issues in the Town as such arise; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council seeks to amend the Land Management Ordinance to increase tree protection requirements for development to enhance ecological outcomes, and promote sustainable development; and, WHEREAS, on May 21, 2025, the Planning Commission held a Public Hearing to consider the proposed amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development, and the public had an opportunity to comment on the proposed amendments, and the Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend adoption of the amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development; and, WHEREAS, on June 16, 2025, the Community Services & Public Safety Committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the proposed amendments to increase tree protection requirements for development; and, WHEREAS, the Town Council finds it is in the best interest of the Town and its citizens, residents and visitors to amend Land Management Ordinance by amending the current regulations for tree protection. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Amendment. That the Land Management Ordinance is amended as shown on Exhibit "A" to this Ordinance. Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted language is illustrated with strikethrough. Section 2. Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion 1 ATTACHMENT E Page 19 of 30 shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS 19TH DAY OFAUGUST, 2025. THE TOW N OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA 4, Alan R. e ,Ma First Reading: July 15, 2025 Second Reading: A% 19, 2025 T O Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney Page 20 of 30 Exhibit A Chapter 16-5: Development and Design Standards Sec.16-5-115. Subdivision Standards A. Purpose and Intent The purpose of subdivision layout is to create a functional and attractive development with infrastructure and lots appropriately sized and located to minimize adverse impacts. The intent of this section is to provide clear requirements and guidelines for subdivision design for both Major and Minor Subdivisions. Subdivisions should promote the health, safety, convenience, order, prosperity and welfare of the present and future residents of the Town by: a. Providing for the orderly growth and development of the Town; b. Coordinating with the existing street system, transportation plans, and public facilities; c. Providing right-of-way for street and vehicular easements; d. Avoiding congestion and overcrowding and encouraging proper arrangement of streets in relation to existing planned streets; e. Preservation of the natural tree canopy and preservation of protected tree species; e7f. Ensuring there is adequate open space and recreation facilities; and Ensuring there is proper recordation of land ownership. C. General Requirements 1. Layout of the subdivision shall be based on complete site analysis. Streets and lots shall be designed to preserve significant trees, stands of trees and understory vegetation and situated to minimize alteration of natural and historic site features to be preserved. 2. The subdivision layout shall consider the practicality and economic feasibility of development of individual lots including the environmental characteristics, size of the site, and the requirements ofthis the Ordinance. 3. The applicant is required to demonstrate that they have made all reasonable efforts to preserve unique and fragile elements on site, including but not limited to wetlands, stands of trees and individual trees of significant size, with development reserved for environmentally stable areas. (Revised - Ordinance 2020-02; revised 3-7-2023 - Ordinance 2023-04) 4. Open space and recreational areas shall be planned in accordance with Sec. Open Space Standards. 5. Lots shall be situated so that stormwater may be easily directed away from buildings in subsequent site-specific development. Lots shall be configured so that buildings and general flood sensitive site facilities can be located out of drainageways. Subdivisions shall be designed so as to comply with Sec. 16-5-109, Stormwater Management and Erosion and Sedimentation Control Standards. 6. All lots shall have the access required by Sec. Access to Streets. LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 1 of 10 Page 21 of 30 Chapter 16-6: Natural Resource Protection Tree Protection B. Applicability 2. Exemptions a. The following activities are exempt from the standards in this section and the requirement for a Natural Resources Permit: iv. vi. vii. viii. ix. Removal of damaged protected trees during an emergency such as a hurricane, tornado, ice or Wind storm, flood, wildfire or any other such act of nature; The removal of invasive species; Removal of a hazardous tree, provided such removal is reported to the Official within five days after removal. Removal of a hazardous tree may require mitigation at the discretion of Official; (Revised Ordinance The selective and limited pruning and removal of trees or vegetation within sight triangles (see Sec. Sight Triangles) as necessary to obtain clear visibility at street and driveway intersections; Necessary tree removal by a utility company consistent with plans submitted periodically to the Official for approval in accordance with Sec. Utility Standards, provided such plans include appropriate provision for removal of any felled trees; Topping of healthy trees is only permitted on land of the Hilton Head Island Airport, and only for the maintenance of the slope approaches to the airport as referenced in Sec. 106.E, Airport Overlay District; Tree removal associated with forestry activities shielded from local development regulation in accordance with S.C. Code Ann. subject to the limitations on subsequent development in Sec. Limitations on Development Applications Subsequent to Exempt Forestry Activity; and Routine or seasonal pruning (see Sec. Existing Vegetation, for restrictions on limbing trees in adjacent street and use buffers), subject to the following requirements and conditions: 01. Pruning shall be done according to the guidelines of the International Society of Arboricultu re, as published in the Arborist Certification Guide. 02. No more than ten percent of the tree's leafsurface shall be removed. 03. Climbing spikes shall not be used on trees that are not being removed. 04. Property owners bear the burden of proving that they have met requirements. Removal or pruning of trees in the zoning district under the following conditions: LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 2 of 10 Page 22 of 30 01. On the Common Property owned by a Property Owners Association, to which all landowners of property located behind the security gate must belong, that is behind any security gate or access point that is manned a minimum of eight (8) hours per day, or at any point within the Spanish Wells PD-l, where the tree or trees to be removed or pruned are: a) Damaged, dead or dying or a fall hazard; or, b) Causing an actual, imminent hazard to pedestrian, bicycle or vehicular travel because roots of any tree or trees have uplifted pavement, or because branches and foliage are impeding travel sight lines, or because branches and foliage impede travel areas for pedestrians, bicycles and vehicles, and no feasible alternative to removing or pruning the tree or trees exists. b. No Natural Resources Permit is required where the proposed tree removal or alteration is reviewed and authorized in accordance with an approved Subdivision Plan (see Sec. Development Plan (Minor or Major) (see Sec. 16-2-103.G), Small Residential Development (see Sec. or Public Project (see Sec. compliance with the standards in this section is required. C. Tree Protection Information in Applications 2. Tree Survey a. The tree survey shall be in the form of a map or a site plan prepared and sealed by a registered land surveyor within two years of the date of application. The tree survey shall be at the same scale as the required site development plan and shall include the following information: i. The location of all Category I, II and IV trees with a DBH of 6 inches or greater, Category III trees (other than cedar and palmetto trees) with a DBH of 12 inches or greater and cedar and palmetto trees with a DBH of 8 inches or greater within the areas to be developed and within areas 25 feet beyond such area in each direction, or extending to the property line, whichever is less; (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance ii. The location of any trees with a DBH less than 6 inches (Category I, II and IV), less than 8 inches (cedar and palmetto trees), and less than 12 inches (Category III other than cedar and palmetto trees) that the applicant wishes to count toward the minimum standard of tree coverage on the site; and (Revised 5-17-2016 Ordinance 2016-07) iii. The species and DBH of all trees. b. In conjunction with the tree survey, trees shall be marked with color ribbons, using blue ribbons to mark trees to be preserved, red ribbons for trees to be removed, and orange ribbons for hazardous trees that are proposed to be removed (hazardous trees will not count towards the overall required tree replacement). in heavily wooded areas, the Official may allow significant stand of trees to be preserved or removed to be marked with the appropriately colored ribbon extending around the perimeter of the group of trees. LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 3 of 10 Page 23 of 30 F. Specimen and Significant Tree Preservation 1. Specimen and Tree For purposes of this section, a specimen tree is any tree of a species designated by the State or federal government as an endangered, threatened, or rare species, or any tree of a type and with a DBH equal or greater than that indicated in Table 16-6-104.F.1, Specimen Trees, for the tree type. A tree that is within 20% of the size classified as a specimen, is considered a significant tree. (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07; revised Ordinance 2020-02) TABLE 16-6-104.F.1: SPECIMEN AND SIGNIFICANT TREES SIGNIFICANT ' DBH (INCHES) TREE TYPE SPECIMEN DBH (INCHES) Live oak 3o ofall trunks) Single trunk Multiple trunks Laureloak Water oak Red oak White oak All hickories American elm Loblolly and slash pines Longleaf and pond pines Red bay Southern magnolia Bald cypress and pond cypress Black gum and sweet gum Red maple Spruce pine Red cedar Sycamore Black Cherry Sassafras ; hid-b ny size Any sizeNWH>wwHWHNWHNNNW moo oomoommmoomo 0 U1 N N (Revised 1-7-2020 - Ordinance 2020-02) 2. General Requirements a. No specimen tree may be removed except in accordance with paragraph b below. In addition, all specimen trees Shall have the following protections, whether located on public or private land1 Illl 'f' I III (Revised 5-17-2016 - Ordinance 2016-07) i. Any activities performed within the drip line of a specimen tree shall have the prior approval of the Official. ii. Specimen trees shall not be cut, removed, pushed over, killed, or otherwise harmed. LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 4 of 10 Page 24 of 30 iii. No more than 20 percent of the total area within the drip line of any specimen tree shall be subject to paving or soil compaction, and no paving or soil compaction is allowed within 15 feet of the tree trunk. (See Figure Limits of Paving or Compaction near Specimen Trees.) The Official may allow paving or soil compaction beyond the 20 percent limit if low impact development techniques (e.g., pervious pavers, materials placed at or above grade, no use of mechanical machinery) are used as an alternative means of protecting the specimen tree. 15%.?1 525%: :3? E712; Figure Limits of Paving or Compaction near Specimen Trees b. If preservation of a specimen tree causes unnecessary hardship, the applicant may apply for a variance from this subsection (see Sec. Variance) once any required State or federal government agency approval, if applicable, to remove the tree is received in writing. (Revised - Ordinance I. Standards for Supplemental and Replacement Trees 3. Replacement Rate, Tree Categorz, Planting Size a. Trees that are removed shall be replaced at the rate of one tree for every ten tree inches removed per tree category. b. Supplemental and replacement trees shall be within the same or lower-numbered tree category (see Sec. Tree Equivalency Table) as the trees being replaced. c. At the time of planting, supplemental and replacement trees shall have the minimum height and trunk diameter shown in Table 16-6-104.|.3 for the category of the tree. TABLE 16-6-104.l.3: MINIMUM PLANTING SIZE FOR SUPPLEMENTAL AND REPLACEMENT TREES TREE CATEGORY S MINIMUM HEIGHT (FEET) MINIMUM TRUNK . DIAMETER (INCHES) ' (USING ANSI STANDARDS) Category I 2-9 Category II 214 Category III -1-; LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 5 of 10 Page 25 of 30 Category IV (Revised Ordinance Appendix C: Recommended Native Plants Upland MEDIUM AND LARGE TREES LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 6 of 10 Page 26 of 30 lllllllllliliii i; i ii Ill!!!llllllll RECOMMENDED NATIVE PLANTS FOR BUFFERS AND WETLANDS This list is meant to be used as a uide and is not all inclusive. Bu er and wetland lants are intended to su a filterin and habitat function. Therefore usin a diverse selection of flora is hi hl encoura ed. : W W E LOCATION ' ' NAT LATS R DUNES Beach evening primrose Oenothera drummondii Primar Dune|l Beach morning glory Ipomoea imperati Primary Dune (yucca) Yucca filamentosa Primary Dune Camphor weed Heterotheca subaxillaris Primar Dunl: Climbing Butterfly pea Centrosema viriginianum Primar Dun(D Devil-joint cactus quntia drummondii Primar Dun Helianthus debilis Sabal minor Yucca gloriosa gpuntia compressa Dune sunflower Primar Dun Dwarf palmetto Moundlily yucca Primar Dun Primar Dun ||l||||lllllll Prickly pear cactus Primar Dun Purple passion flower_(yine) Passiflora incarnata Primary Dune Ipomea Primary Dune Salt myrtle Primary Dune Saw palm Serenoa repens Primary Dune Sea oats Uniola paniculata Primar Dunl Seaside panicum Panicum amarum Primar Dunl Yucca aloifolia Primar Dun Myrica cerifera llex vomitoria Spanish bayonet Wax myrtle Yaupon holly Primar Dun Yellow passion flower lvinel assiflora lutea Primary Dune *Dune fields can contain several dune rows that have mostly grasses and other plants in them. Look at dune areas adjacent to yours to determine which plants are best to use in similar areas. NEVER plant a non- Primar Dunl: llll l H: native plant in dune areas;_th_ey may become invasive. GRASSES VlNES AND'GROUNDCOVER LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 7 of 10 Page 27 of 30 eltandra vir inica Lower Bank Shallow Water uncus roemerianus Tidal wetland Salt marsh bu er ris vir inica Freshwater wetland Bidenss . ellow lower blooms in Lower Bank Shallow Water I 0/ Ce halanthus occidentalis Lower Bank Shallow Water 50 ittaria lati olia V Lower Bank Shallow Water I N m hoidesa uatica V Floatin Plants m haea odorata Floatin PlantsFragrant water lilg V . Golden club rontium a uaticum Lower Bank Shallow Water Hooded gitcher glant arracenia minor . ower Bank Shallow Water risaema m- h Large marsh gmk batia dodecandra V Liza rd's Tail aururus cernuus . . Maidencane anicum hemitoman Muhleg Grass uhlenbe' ia ca illaris land Passsion Flower Pickerelweed assi lora incarnata ontederia cordata . Rushes . uncus s . V Lower Bank Shallow Water Saltmeadow Cordgass Saltha Sand Cordgrass Sea ox-e e Smooth Cordgrass Soft Rush SQ ikerushes V Swamg rose malolw Watershield Wild Rice Wild Gin er .. V . Woolgrass bulrush Yellow canna YellowJassamine VYellow fringed orchid Arrow Arum Black Needle Rush Blue Flag Iris Bu ll l \- ll llButtonbush Duck gotato Floating hearts l l llllilll ll l ll llllll l Freshwater wetland ll i . atrina atens artina atens . Saltmarsh bu er V . artinabakeri orrlchia rutescens V V } Salt marsh bu e artina alterni lora Tidal wetland l l ll l l; EE l uncus e uses Tidal wetland ll Lower Bank Shaollw Water ' Lower Bank Shallow WaterIbiscus moscheutos ' V , Brasenia schreberi V Floatin Plants V V Lower Bank Shallow Wate Lower Bank Shallow Wate lleocharis s . V Il ll _ Izaniaa uatica , _ sarum canadense l ll CIr usc erinus VV Loewr Bank Shallow Wateanna laccrda _ elsemium sem ervirens U land abenaria ciliaris Lower Bank Shalolw Wate l l l lexo aca Callicar aAmericana abal almetto ' runus caroliniana runusan usti olia smunda cinnamomea Diosggros virginiana Er thrina herbacea Lonicera semgervirens Anisostichus ca reolata . Ilex cassine L onia lucida American Beautgberrg Cabbage Qalmetto Carolina cherrg laurel Chickasaw glum Cinnamon fern Common gersimmon Coral Bean Coral honeysuckle _ Cross vine Dahoon Hollx Fetterbush Club W Ln ll salt rnhars bu er I15[33a:9.9. HS3 aD. l||||||l 333333:: 9.9.9.2. ff3 aa. Freshwater wetland U land U land salt marsh bu er llllll53 H Q >< E 3 n \Q a ('3S LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 8 of 10 Page 28 of 30 Horse sugar lnkberrx Loblollv Bax Redbav ' Salt Mvrtle Sassafras Saw Palmetto Southern Red Cedar Sgarkleberrv Star Anise Sugarberrv Tough bumelia Trumget vine Wax Mvrtle Winged sumac Witch Hazel Yau on Holl A ill llllll American V Badl Cvgress V Black Gum Florida Magle V V . V_ HickoriesE various sgecies Laurel Oak Little Gem Magnlia Live Oak Loblollv gine Long leaf 9ine Rd Ma le Sbal galmetto Slash gine S_o_uthern Magnola Southern Red Cedar Southern Red Oak Sweet Gum Water Oak Ill Eb n a: W 3S Qh].c l3C E 3 Q l ll I ll lll IFl I ll \U) ll gmglocus tinctoria lex Iabra E 3 a. lFreshwater wetland U land Gordonia lasianthus ersea borbonia E 3 a. liE3a.Cl Ln 8 un l/Ii Ce re en 5 i erus silicicol Vaccinium arboreum O ccharis halimi olia assa ras albidum n533a. iE3Q nd salt marsh bu ei l l [1%33a. cium Ioridanum Itis laevi at Bumelia tenax Cam sis radican M Cl i ll Ill 5 53 33 QQ C E 3nd salt marsh bu e iE3o. Frica ceri lora Rhus c0 allin Hamamelis vi iniana Ilex vomitoria 0 DE53Q . Ilexo aca . Taxodium distichum Ian reshwater waetlnd U Ian ii N 550 s Ivatic aras . ClllFreshwater wetland U Ian E 3 a. luercus lauri o/ia a uercus vir iniana nolia randi lora "Little Gem"Eii3-3 2.9. inus taeda mus Palstris 3 5<3 3 3 3 Q Q Q l Cl a un uercus a/cat Li uidamberst raci lua cer rubmru _ bal almet inus elliottii V nolia randi lora ens Sl/iClCOIO to uercus ni ra 0 Freshwater wetland U land WiE3Q n5 A E3a. Wii33 AQQ Freshwater wetland U land V land LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 9 of 10 Page 29 of 30 RECOMMENDED INVASIVE TREES AND PLANTS FOR REMOVAL The followin- is a list of common Invasive Trees and Plants in the Lowcountr . The list contains A. lants and trees that ne ativel im act native lants and trees and are recommended for removal. Therefore usin a recommended native glant list is encouraged. o Autumn-Olive Tree o Bamboo - W 0 Bradford Pear Tree - Maggie 0 Chinese Tallow Tree 0 Cogongrass grass 0 Common Reed Phra mites rass 0 English vine 0 Japanese Honeysuckle shrub 0 Japanese Stiltgrass grass o KudzuVine - W - Non-Native Milkweed LMO Priority Amendments: Tree Protection Page 10 of 10 57.: Page 30 of 30

Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Oct 13, 2026.